Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Health Literacy & Aging: Spotting Health Fraud & Fake Cures
Transcript
- 0:00In 1900, if you made it to your 48th birthday,
- 0:04you were officially beating the odds. You know,
- 0:05you would actually outlive the average human
- 0:08life expectancy. Which is just wild to think
- 0:10about. Right. Fast forward just one century and,
- 0:14like, 47 is barely a midlife crisis. Welcome
- 0:18to the psychology undergrad. We are putting on
- 0:21our psychology student hats today to look at
- 0:23a massive paradigm shift because, well, we aren't
- 0:26just fighting off sudden infections anymore.
- 0:29We're living long enough to deal with the long
- 0:31-term consequences of our own behaviors. Yeah,
- 0:33it is arguably the most profound demographic
- 0:36shift in human history. I mean, that jumped from
- 0:39a life expectancy of 47 .3 years in 1900 to 76
- 0:44.8 years by the year 2000. That is entirely thanks
- 0:47to public health measures and modern allopathic
- 0:49medicine. Exactly. But it completely changed
- 0:51the leading causes of death. We went from acute
- 0:53infectious diseases to basically chronic lifestyle
- 0:57choices. Which means we need a totally different
- 1:00framework for how we think about aging. If you
- 1:03are listening to this right now, I want you to
- 1:05think about your chronological age as a car's
- 1:08model year. Oh, I like that. Yeah, it's just
- 1:11the year you rolled off the assembly line. You
- 1:13can't change it. Yeah. But your biological age,
- 1:16that is the actual mileage on the odometer. Yeah.
- 1:19So the question becomes, are you a 30 -year -old
- 1:21with a biological mileage of a 20 -year -old
- 1:24because you've been doing the maintenance? Right.
- 1:27Or are you a 30 -year -old with the biological
- 1:29mileage of a 40 -year -old because you've been
- 1:31redlining the engine? every single day. And doing
- 1:34that maintenance, keeping that biological mileage
- 1:37low, it requires an incredibly complex set of
- 1:41skills today. It's not just about eating your
- 1:43vegetables. No, definitely not. It's about how
- 1:45you process information, how you navigate the
- 1:47health care system, and how you mentally approach
- 1:51the aging process itself. Exactly. So the mission
- 1:54for today's deep dive is to map out that exact
- 1:57terrain. We're going to explore how our psychological
- 2:01biases make us vulnerable to health fraud, the
- 2:04morality of how we care for an aging society,
- 2:07and the specific biological mechanisms behind
- 2:11the habits that keep our mileage low. Yeah, it's
- 2:13a lot of ground to cover. It is. But let's start
- 2:16with the immediate threat, which is the psychology
- 2:18of believing completely bogus health information.
- 2:21Like, if I get sick today, my very first instinct
- 2:25isn't to call a doctor. It's to Google my symptoms.
- 2:28Oh, absolutely. Which is why health literacy
- 2:30is the foundational skill of modern aging. The
- 2:33CDC defines health literacy as your ability to
- 2:36find, understand, and use information to make
- 2:38health -related decisions. Right. The problem
- 2:40is that the internet is an entirely unregulated
- 2:42landscape. You have life -saving clinical data
- 2:44sitting right next to dangerous predatory misinformation.
- 2:47Yeah, but why do we fall for the misinformation?
- 2:49I mean, I like to think of myself as a rational
- 2:51person. But if someone I love gets diagnosed
- 2:54with a terrifying illness, rationality just goes
- 2:56out the window. Desperation kicks in. We are
- 3:00psychologically wired to latch on to hope, and
- 3:03scammers know exactly how to weaponize that against
- 3:05us. They absolutely do, and they exploit that
- 3:09desperation using very predictable patterns.
- 3:12The FDA actually highlights six common tip -offs
- 3:15to rip -offs that these fraudsters use. Let's
- 3:18look at the first two. Okay, lay mine. So claiming
- 3:21one product cures a wildly diverse range of diseases
- 3:26and relying heavily on personal testimonials.
- 3:29instead of clinical data. I want to pause on
- 3:31the testimonials for a second because the mechanism
- 3:33behind that is pure psychology. Our brains are
- 3:36narrative -driven machines, not statistical ones.
- 3:39Like if you show me a double -blind placebo study
- 3:41with a thousand participants, my eyes glaze over.
- 3:44But if you show me a video of a crying mother
- 3:46saying, you know, a specific root powder cured
- 3:49her son's illness, my brain lights up. I trust
- 3:52the story over the spreadsheet. You're on the
- 3:54right track, but it's even more insidious than
- 3:55that. Scammers use testimonials because they
- 3:57completely bypass our critical thinking filters.
- 3:59It just feels like peer -to -peer advice, which
- 4:02leads into the next two FDA tip -offs. Promising
- 4:05quick fixes, like losing 30 pounds in a week
- 4:08and marketing the product as all -natural. Oh
- 4:10man, the all -natural fallacy drives me crazy.
- 4:13Poisonous mushrooms are all -natural. Arsenic
- 4:15is natural. As psychology students, we literally
- 4:20study the appeal to nature fallacy. Right, exactly.
- 4:23It's this cognitive bias where we just assume
- 4:25anything from the Earth is inherently safe and
- 4:28anything synthesized in the lab is toxic. It's
- 4:31logically bankrupt. It is. wildly profitable.
- 4:35Which brings us to the final two red flags from
- 4:37the FDA, using the phrase miracle cure and pushing
- 4:41conspiracy theories. Like the government is hiding
- 4:43the cure from us. Exactly. Or claiming pharmaceutical
- 4:46companies are suppressing this secret knowledge.
- 4:49Let me theorize on the conspiracy angle for a
- 4:51second. If I'm feeling helpless because of a
- 4:53diagnosis, a conspiracy theory actually gives
- 4:55me a bizarre sense of control, right? That makes
- 4:58sense. Yeah, it gives me an enemy to fight. I
- 5:00get a dopamine hit from feeling like I possess
- 5:03insider knowledge that the sheep don't have.
- 5:06So let's turn these six FDA warnings into a memory
- 5:09trick for you listening. Think of the three false
- 5:12promises of health scams. I like where this is
- 5:15going. Number one is speed. That covers the quick
- 5:17fixes. Number two is secrets. That covers the
- 5:20miracles and the conspiracies. And number three
- 5:23is supplements. That covers the all -natural
- 5:25cure -alls and the emotional testimonials selling
- 5:28snake oil. That's a highly effective way to categorize
- 5:31them. And avoiding those false promises requires
- 5:34actively checking your sources. When you land
- 5:37on a health website, you need to check the About
- 5:39Us page. Right, look for actual credentials.
- 5:41Yes, look for a medical editorial board. But
- 5:44most importantly, follow the money. If a pharmaceutical
- 5:47company is funding an article that suddenly concludes
- 5:49their new drug is the only solution, your alarm
- 5:52bells should be ringing. loudly. And what about
- 5:54the sites that demand your mother's maiden name
- 5:57or like your zip code just to read an article
- 5:59on heart health? Oh, that is a blatant privacy
- 6:02breach. If a site requires excessive personal
- 6:05data before offering general health info, they
- 6:08aren't trying to educate you. You are the product.
- 6:11They are harvesting your data to sell to advertisers.
- 6:14The catch here is that scammers often market
- 6:17their fake snake oils under the guise of alternative
- 6:19medicine. They spook you away from standard doctors
- 6:22and offer a secret natural cure. But that taints
- 6:26the concept of legitimate nontraditional care.
- 6:29It really does. Like if I'm rejecting standard
- 6:32medicine because a scammer spooked me, what am
- 6:34I actually turning to? I hear alternative medicine,
- 6:37and my mind immediately goes to healing crystals
- 6:39and herbal teas, but is there actual validity
- 6:42there? Well, to untangle that, we really have
- 6:44to define our terms carefully. Standard care
- 6:46is conventional or Western medicine. It's allopathic.
- 6:49It relies on a systemic approach, you know, physical
- 6:52exams, clinical trials, and treating diseases
- 6:55with drugs, radiation, or surgery. So the classic
- 6:57hospital experience. Exactly. Then you have complementary
- 7:00and alternative medicine, or CAM for short. The
- 7:05distinction is crucial here. If a non -mainstream
- 7:07practice is used alongside Western medicine,
- 7:10like doing acupuncture to manage nausea from
- 7:12chemotherapy... That would be complementary.
- 7:14Right. It is considered complementary. If it
- 7:16is used instead of conventional medicine, it
- 7:18is alternative. And when a physician intentionally
- 7:21coordinates both conventional and CAM treatments
- 7:23together, we call that an integrative approach.
- 7:26So what are the actual mechanisms of CAM? Like,
- 7:29what categories are we talking about here? There
- 7:31are four primary classifications. First, mind
- 7:34-body therapies. This includes meditation, biofeedback,
- 7:37hypnosis, yoga, and Tai Chi. Okay, got it. Second,
- 7:41biologically -based practices. This relies on
- 7:44substances found in nature, like dietary supplements,
- 7:47botanicals such as cannabis, or spices like turmeric.
- 7:49Makes sense. Third, manipulative and body -based
- 7:52practices which physically manipulate the body.
- 7:55Think massage therapy, chiropractic care, and
- 7:57reflexology. And fourth, energy healing like
- 8:00Reiki or therapeutic touch, which supposedly
- 8:03manipulates a vital energy field flowing through
- 8:05the body. Okay, I have to jump in on the mind
- 8:08-body and energy healing. categories, because
- 8:10the overlap with theology and morality is just
- 8:13undeniable. Oh really? How so? Look closely at
- 8:16these practices. Meditation is functionally identical
- 8:19to silent prayer. Energy healing, where a practitioner
- 8:22holds their hands over your body to transfer
- 8:24energy, that looks exactly like the religious
- 8:26tradition of the laying on of hands. That's a
- 8:29fair comparison though. A clinical researcher
- 8:32might argue the intent is different. Perhaps,
- 8:35but the psychological mechanism is the same.
- 8:38Science might not be able to build a machine
- 8:40that measures a mystical energy field, but we
- 8:42can measure the psychological and physiological
- 8:45impact of the placebo effect. Oh, definitely.
- 8:47We can measure psychoneuroimmunology. You know,
- 8:50how your psychological state affects your immune
- 8:52system. The spiritual peace, the reduction in
- 8:55anxiety, the comfort of having someone just care
- 8:57for you. Those things actively lower cortisol
- 9:00levels. Right, the stress hormone. Yes. And lowering
- 9:03stress gives the body's immune system the bandwidth
- 9:07it needs to heal. It's incredibly powerful. You're
- 9:10highlighting the exact reason integrative medicine
- 9:12is gaining so much traction. The relaxation response
- 9:15is a measurable physiological mechanism that
- 9:18aids healing. But here's the harsh reality that
- 9:22bridges both Western hospitals and Eastern practices.
- 9:25Let me guess. It all costs money. It all costs
- 9:29money. And the financial stress of getting sick
- 9:31is arguably one of the heaviest psychological
- 9:33burdens a human being can carry. Like, dealing
- 9:36with insurance companies makes my biological
- 9:39mileage go up just thinking about it. Yeah. It
- 9:41is intensely stressful because the mechanics
- 9:44are complicated. Unlike nations with universal
- 9:46health care coverage, the United States uses
- 9:48a fragmented system of risk pooling. Let's break
- 9:52down the two main safety nets the government
- 9:54provides first. Okay. You have Medicare, which
- 9:56is a federal program primarily for people 65
- 9:59and older, or those with severe disabilities
- 10:01like end -stage renal disease or ALS. Then you
- 10:04have Medicaid, which is jointly funded by the
- 10:06federal and state governments to assist eligible
- 10:08low -income individuals. Okay, but what if I
- 10:11don't qualify for either of those? How does the
- 10:13private insurance sector actually structure the
- 10:15math so they don't just go bankrupt? Well, they
- 10:18structure it by controlling your choices to mitigate
- 10:21their financial risk. In the private sector,
- 10:24you generally choose between three models. First
- 10:26are HMOs or Health Maintenance Organizations.
- 10:29Those are the strict ones, right? Very restrictive,
- 10:32but cheaper. You are confined to a specific network
- 10:35of doctors and you absolutely must get a referral
- 10:38from a primary care physician before you can
- 10:40see a specialist. So the HMO acts as a gatekeeper.
- 10:43They keep costs down by making sure you actually
- 10:45need that expensive MRI before they let you get
- 10:48it. Precisely. On the other end, you have PPO's,
- 10:51Preferred Provider Organizations. These offer
- 10:54maximum flexibility. You don't need referrals
- 10:56and you can see out of network doctors. But I'm
- 10:59guessing that flexibility costs you. It does.
- 11:02The trade off is much higher out of pocket costs
- 11:04and higher monthly premiums. Finally, POS or
- 11:07point of service plans are a hybrid. You have
- 11:10a primary care gatekeeper like an HMO, but you
- 11:12retain some out of network flexibility like a
- 11:15PPO. And for those who fall through the cracks,
- 11:17like if you're unemployed or lacking employer
- 11:19coverage, the Affordable Care Act or the marketplace
- 11:23was established to provide subsidized accessible
- 11:26options. Stepping back from the acronyms for
- 11:29a second, if you look at how a society handles
- 11:31insurance, it feels like a profound moral test.
- 11:35How do you mean? Well, insurance at its core
- 11:38is just a community pooling its resources to
- 11:42protect the unlucky few from financial ruin.
- 11:45So how we structure access to health care, how
- 11:47we treat the sick, the uninsured and the elderly.
- 11:50That is a direct reflection of our collective
- 11:53values. It's a statement about what we believe
- 11:55human life is actually worth. That's a heavy
- 11:57thought. And that moral infrastructure is about
- 11:59to be tested on a scale we have never seen before.
- 12:02We are facing a demographic reality known as
- 12:04the silver tsunami. The silver tsunami. I've
- 12:06heard that phrase. Yeah. Remember the jump in
- 12:08life expectancy we talked about at the top of
- 12:10the show? Well, in the United States right now,
- 12:1210 ,000 people turn 65 every single day. 10 ,000
- 12:16people today? Every day. Globally, there were
- 12:201 billion people over the age of 60 in 2019.
- 12:24By 2050, that number is expected to hit 2 .1
- 12:28billion. That is staggering. And the strain isn't
- 12:30just the sheer volume of people. It's the fact
- 12:33that roughly 80 % of older adults are living
- 12:36with at least one chronic health condition. And
- 12:39while the elderly population is exploding, birth
- 12:42rates in the developed world are plummeting.
- 12:44The math is brutal. We are facing a catastrophic
- 12:47shortage of caregivers. Let me speak directly
- 12:50to you listening. The structural reality is that
- 12:52when you reach your 80s, there simply may not
- 12:55be enough nurses or facilities to take care of
- 12:57you. The burden of keeping your biological mileage
- 13:00low falls entirely on the daily habits you are
- 13:02building right now. It really does. So how do
- 13:04we actually protect our brains as we age? First,
- 13:07we have to distinguish between overall brain
- 13:09health and cognitive health. Brain health is
- 13:11the broad umbrella. It controls your motor functions,
- 13:14emotional regulation, and how you process tactile
- 13:17sensations like touch and pain. And cognitive
- 13:20is just thinking. Right. Cognitive health is
- 13:22a very specific subset of that. It is your ability
- 13:25to think, learn, and remember. And a crucial
- 13:29misconception we need to clear up right now,
- 13:31Alzheimer's disease, which physically destroys
- 13:34the brain's memory networks, is a specific disease.
- 13:37It is not a normal or inevitable part of aging.
- 13:40So what are the mechanisms we can actually control?
- 13:42What does the data say about keeping our cognitive
- 13:45health intact? Physically, the data points to
- 13:49vascular health and cellular clearance. Let's
- 13:51look at movement. Research shows that taking
- 13:548 ,000 steps a day compared to just 4 ,000 lowers
- 13:57your risk of all -cause mortality by 51%. Wow.
- 14:01Over 50%, just for walking a bit more. Yes, because
- 14:04cardiovascular exercise keeps the blood vessels
- 14:06in your brain flexible, preventing micro -strokes.
- 14:09Diet plays into this directly, too. The Mediterranean
- 14:11diet has been shown to lower sudden cardiac death.
- 14:14And the DAA's diet specifically targets and lowers
- 14:17hypertension by reducing salt intake. What about
- 14:20sleep? I feel like we constantly glorify running
- 14:23on fumes in our culture. It's a badge of honor
- 14:25to sleep four hours. It's incredibly destructive.
- 14:28A study tracking 8 ,000 people found that getting
- 14:31six hours or less of sleep in your 50s and 60s
- 14:34significantly raises your risk of developing
- 14:36dementia. Oh, wow. The mechanism here is fascinating.
- 14:40During deep sleep, your brain activates the glymphatic
- 14:43system. Think of it as a biological dishwasher.
- 14:46It literally flushes out the toxic amyloid plaques
- 14:49that build up during waking hours. If you don't
- 14:52sleep seven to nine hours, those Alzheimer's
- 14:55linked proteins accumulate. That is terrifying,
- 14:57but it makes so much sense. Right. And similarly,
- 15:00quitting smoking at any age immediately improves
- 15:02circulation and stops the restriction of oxygen
- 15:05to your brain tissue. Those physical hacks make
- 15:07perfect sense. But as a psychology student, the
- 15:10mental and social data is what really blows my
- 15:13mind. Oh, the social aspect is huge. Yeah, we
- 15:15are fundamentally social creatures. The data
- 15:17shows that chronic loneliness and social isolation
- 15:20are linked to a significantly higher risk of
- 15:22heart disease. And the mechanism there is inflammation.
- 15:25Yes, exactly. When you are isolated, your body
- 15:28perceives it as an evolutionary threat. Your
- 15:31sympathetic nervous system goes into overdrive,
- 15:34pumping out stress hormones like cortisol. Over
- 15:36time, that chronic stress physically shrinks
- 15:39the hippocampus, which is the memory center of
- 15:42your brain. Yes. Chronic cortisol toxicity is
- 15:45devastating to cognitive health. But the reverse
- 15:48is also profoundly true. Positive psychological
- 15:51engagement builds what we call cognitive reserve.
- 15:55Cognitive reserve. Yeah. Studies show that simply
- 15:57spending an hour a day reading, playing a game,
- 15:59or participating in a hobby decreases your risk
- 16:02of dementia compared to those who spend less
- 16:04than 30 minutes a day on hobbies. You're literally
- 16:07building new neural pathways that can compensate
- 16:10for age -related decline. I love that. Let's
- 16:12use an analogy to lock this in. Think of these
- 16:14habits as compound interest for your biology.
- 16:17Ooh, nice. The Department of Labor always tells
- 16:19us to start saving for retirement early because
- 16:22of the power of compounding financial interest.
- 16:24Your biology works the exact same way. Reading
- 16:28a chapter of a book, walking those 8 ,000 steps,
- 16:31calling a friend to combat loneliness. These
- 16:33aren't just nice little self -care activities.
- 16:35No, they're critical. They are daily deposits
- 16:37into a biological 401k. You are building up cognitive
- 16:41and physical wealth that will pay dividends three
- 16:44decades from now. It is the ultimate long -term
- 16:47investment. But we also have to face the final
- 16:50reality of this process. No matter how much biological
- 16:53wealth we accumulate, no matter how impeccably
- 16:55we maintain our mental and physical engines,
- 16:58our bodies will eventually fail. Yeah. Which
- 17:00brings us to the final and perhaps most profound
- 17:03moral choice we can make in healthcare, which
- 17:06is organ and brain donation. It's something people
- 17:08avoid thinking about, but it's so important.
- 17:11The statistics highlight a massive gap between
- 17:13our intentions and our actions. About 90 % of
- 17:16adults say they support organ donation, but only
- 17:1960 % are actually signed up on the registry.
- 17:21Why is there such a huge gap? Part of it is driven
- 17:24by a psychological misconception. People assume
- 17:26their biological mileage is too high, they think
- 17:29they are too old to donate. The truth is, there
- 17:32is absolutely no age limit. In 2021, one out
- 17:36of every three organ donors in the US was over
- 17:39the age of 50. Wait, I read the stat on this.
- 17:41The oldest organ donor in the United States that
- 17:43year was 92 years old, right? 92 years old, that
- 17:46is correct. That is staggering. And honestly,
- 17:49it ties everything we've discussed today together
- 17:51perfectly. Organ donation is the ultimate act
- 17:54of human altruism. It's a profound legacy that
- 17:58completely transcends your chronological age.
- 18:01Even when your own biological engine has reached
- 18:03its absolute limit, you have the power to give
- 18:05someone else a brand new model year. It is the
- 18:08ultimate expression of community. So to synthesize
- 18:11the terrain we've covered today, the demographics
- 18:14of our species have permanently shifted. We are
- 18:16living longer than ever before, but the quality
- 18:19of those extra decades isn't guaranteed. It depends
- 18:22heavily on our personal health literacy, our
- 18:25ability to understand the psychological tricks
- 18:27scammers use, our navigation of the insurance
- 18:30safety nets, and the compounding daily habits
- 18:33we cultivate for our brains and bodies. Which
- 18:36leaves us with a final provocative thought for
- 18:38you to chew on before we go. Based on everything
- 18:42we just broke down about how lifestyle, stress,
- 18:45and habits physically rewire the cellular structure
- 18:48of your brain over time, I want you to ask yourself,
- 18:51are you morally obligated to your future self?
- 18:54That is a great question. Think about it. The
- 18:5780 year old version of you is essentially a completely
- 18:59different person. Their cognitive ability, their
- 19:02physical pain, their joy, and their independence
- 19:05depend entirely on the choices you are making
- 19:07today. So what is one thing you can do right
- 19:10now today to show a little compassion to that
- 19:13future version of you? That is an excellent thought
- 19:15to leave on. Keep your mileage low, stay critical
- 19:18of the miracles, and we'll catch you next time.