Latest / Success Story with Scott Clary / Renée Mauborgne - Co-Director of the INSEAD Blue Ocean Strategy Institute | The Blue Ocean Strategy
Transcript
- 0:00Today, my guest is Renee Mulborn, a prominent figure in the world of business and strategy.
- 0:05She is an NCAD Distinguished Fellow and a Professor of Strategy at NCAD,
- 0:09one of the world's leading business schools. She is also the co-director of the NCAD
- 0:14Blue Ocean Strategy Institute, a center dedicated to exploring and promoting innovative strategies
- 0:20that create uncontested market spaces. Her collaboration with W. Chan Kim has resulted in numerous
- 0:26best-selling articles and publications like The Harvard Business Review, The Wall Street Journal,
- 0:30and The Financial Times. Their most notable work, The Blue Ocean Strategy, published in 2005,
- 0:36has become an international sensation, selling over two million copies and being translated
- 0:42into 42 languages. Her influence and expertise have earned her accolades, including being recognized
- 0:48as one of the world's top management gurus and winning prestigious awards for contributions
- 0:53to the fields of international business and strategic thinking. Welcome to Success Story.
- 0:59I'm your host, Scott Clary. The Success Story podcast is part of the HubSpot podcast network.
- 1:05For everyone listening, I just have to ask you a question. Do you want to know what separates
- 1:09the contenders from the pretenders, the A list from the C list, world champions from the world,
- 1:15not champions? It's pretty simple. The fourth quarter in sports, more importantly for a lot of
- 1:21the people listening here in business, finishing strong is key. Now HubSpots, New Sales Hub is the
- 1:27software that you need for your sales and your sales team to win Q4. You could be a solo printer,
- 1:35you could own and run a larger business, regardless if you're selling anything to anyone,
- 1:40which I think a lot of the people who are listening to this are, you need to check out Sales Hub.
- 1:44So there is a new prospecting workspace, there's revamped deal management tools,
- 1:49there's smart sequencing, Sales Hub is loaded with everything you need to turn leads into prospects
- 1:55and then convert those prospects into customers. With Sales Hub, you have the right information
- 2:00at the right time to build better relationships, which means closing deals has never been easier.
- 2:06So this Q4 give yourself and your team the tools to win big with HubSpot Sales Hub. Learn more at
- 2:14HubSpot.com slash sales.
- 2:25So I remember my father when I was very little talking and he just looked at me and he said,
- 2:33Renee, no matter what, but never, but never, but never give up. Even when you face struggles or
- 2:41difficulties, you keep on going. And I think that has really made me never want to give up because
- 2:49in any journey in life, there are difficulties, there are challenges. And when I face them,
- 2:54yes, you take a punch, you might shed a tear, but I was remember, but never give up. There's always
- 3:01a way forward. Start looking for that now. That would be it. Why was that such an important lesson
- 3:07for him? I think he was in the Marines and that was drilled down into him in the Marines. The Marines,
- 3:14you never give up. That's it. You marched forward. I love that. And like growing up, so let's talk
- 3:21about, you know, your early career and what because a lot of the work that you do has focused on
- 3:29researching things that no one has, it's almost like a contrarian view on a topic. So the way
- 3:36that you first researched the blue ocean, I find it to be very contrarian, even now it's very
- 3:41normalized. And even what you're working with now, how we relook and reinterpret disruption,
- 3:49again, a very contrarian view on what disruption is and what it isn't. So how does one's career allow
- 3:55them to, without sounding too cliche, go into a blue ocean in terms of a thought that has never existed
- 4:02before. Research that thought, think through the implications on an industry and then properly
- 4:09formulate something that resonates so deeply with somebody where before your research, there wasn't
- 4:15a concept like that. So you know, I don't think I have, or we have a really neat, tidy answer for
- 4:24you on that. But you know, like when we were in Michigan in the 1980s, myself and my colleague,
- 4:32Chan Kim, everyone in business school was teaching about how to compete. And that was the time in
- 4:40America where, you know, for the first time in our history, industry after industry was getting
- 4:46devastated by a new set of global challenges. And at the time, it was the Japanese. It was
- 4:51Earth moving, equipment was devastated, consumer electronics, electronics, tech styles.
- 4:57And in being in Michigan and in Arbor, we saw the auto-capital America absolutely devastated.
- 5:03I mean, just right was a, was a ghost town when we went in there. And so we thought, you know,
- 5:09what's the cause of all these problems? And it was too much competition. And yet that was exactly
- 5:16what we were teaching was how to compete. So we said, is that the best way? And if you read
- 5:23the journals at the time, everyone was talking about how we need to learn to compete in order to
- 5:29survive. And we were young and we thought, we don't want to survive. We want to thrive. And are
- 5:34there other organizations that in spite of the competition are finding an alternative path
- 5:41to grow, to create new opportunities and to thrive. And we started to search them out.
- 5:47And we found out, yeah, there were. And they were not stuck in what we call these existing
- 5:52industries, which were labeled the red oceans at the time because there were bloody red with a lot
- 5:56of competition, more competition, more supply than demand. And so it was tough. And we saw people
- 6:04being led out of work. That was when the rust belt of America was being built. And then we saw
- 6:08all the other companies creating that we call those blue oceans because you could unlock them.
- 6:13So I guess if I think about, you know, we just became observers of life. And instead of only
- 6:19listening to what the media told us, we have to compete. This is the way. We looked at what are
- 6:25the implications and what do we see? And we asked ourselves, oh, is was there another way? We don't
- 6:32want to start with what is, but what should be? And then how do we construct that? And I think
- 6:38Scott, to our second book, it's a very similar mindset. And that is that, you know, when blue ocean
- 6:45took off, of course, and it did what it did. And thank you for acknowledging that. You know,
- 6:50people said, well, if you're creating, you said there's competing and creating. It's counterintuitive,
- 6:56but it is also complementary. One does not just place the other. You need both in life. Like,
- 7:00you have to know how to compete. You have to know how to create. Every company does. But at the same
- 7:05time, you know, we started looking at people in innovation space and said, well, is it blue ocean
- 7:10is creating? So is it innovating? And we looked at our data and we said, no, it's not.
- 7:14Disruption is when you create an industry that completely displaces and takes down another.
- 7:18So Netflix comes along and blockbuster and any video rental store finished.
- 7:24Yeah. On the other hand, blue ocean is about looking across industry. So Cirque du Soleil,
- 7:29I take a little a circus, I take a little a theater, I have a disruption at the margin,
- 7:34but I never displaced an industry, create new growth. But we started looking. We said, wow,
- 7:39isn't that interesting? As our database had grown because we're perpetual researchers every day,
- 7:44you know, we saw all these examples of companies that were actually creating outside of existing
- 7:50industries where they had no displacement at all. And so we thought that is interesting.
- 7:55So I can create, not touch even the margins of an industry and create economic and social
- 8:01good. What is that? Why does the field of innovation assume we need to disrupt and every venture
- 8:06capitalist will tell you every startup comes to them. We've plans to take on an existing industry
- 8:12when there's all this opportunity space where I can also make impact and billion dollar businesses
- 8:18where I can pursue what we call non-destructive creation when you create without destroying.
- 8:23And so we said, no, that is really interesting. No one's talking about it and we want to start
- 8:29exploring it. So I think in both cases, it's about, you know, we talk about your agency versus
- 8:37structure in the book. And we say many people lead with structure, meaning we accept the world
- 8:43as it is. And we build from that what should be. And really, it's about using the power of your
- 8:50own thinking to observe the world and see what it is and determine does what you're hearing make
- 8:55sense and what could do better. So I love the view. I love the lens I wish you look to the world.
- 9:04And I think the world would candidly across every school of thought, every argument, every debate
- 9:10would be a better place if everybody approached them with that mindset. I absolutely love that.
- 9:18So that would be my beginning thought, you know, on how we kind of think as researchers and how we
- 9:25observe. Why do you think that you just mentioned a very good point that I have an opinion and I'm
- 9:32curious as to whether or not you think this opinion is valid, valid, excuse me. Why do you think
- 9:36that venture capitalists always say we have to disrupt? It's because, and in my opinion,
- 9:42it's because the playbook is there and it's it's de-risked to some degree. It's still risk.
- 9:48But it's so I would say that if you're looking at the levels of risk, we have building a product in,
- 9:54say, a red ocean and doing it slightly better, cheaper, that's like the most de-risked opportunity.
- 10:00Then disruption is at least there's a playbook for disruption because we can look to other
- 10:05people that have done it. But no one's codified the playbook for disruption without displacement.
- 10:12Yeah, and so we would actually say it's not a sky destruction. We, you know, we call it non-destructive
- 10:17opportunities and we call it non-destructive creation because you create without destroying. So we would
- 10:23no flip that lens. So we put a new, just a blue ocean, put a new lens to look at the world and see
- 10:29things. When we start thinking non-destructive, it just changes where our orientation is and what comes
- 10:34to the foreground of our observation and thought. But to go back to that, I mean,
- 10:42it's got, so your question is, why do we default to this? Why do we default to the we have to disrupt?
- 10:52Thank you so much. So I think there's, you know, a few issues there. One is I think it's really
- 10:58start up to go to venture capitalists with destructive ideas because they've seen unicorns that
- 11:04have succeeded based on that in the theory of innovation for what we learn in the top MBA schools.
- 11:10It starts out with creative destruction from this gentleman or economist called Shimpeter. Then
- 11:15there was disruption. We saw disruption with the internet and it became a whole way of looking
- 11:19at the world. So that frames us just the way competing framed everyone before blue ocean came out.
- 11:24We got pushed back in the beginning and now it's completely accepted. So I think that's one
- 11:30thing, but I think also when I agree to your point, it looks like, well, when I disrupt, I know there's
- 11:35an established industry and I can take it on. But in some ways, I would argue, you know, the venture
- 11:40capital odds of being successful are not that high when they bet on, you know, many of their investments
- 11:46fail. And think about that because when you set out to disrupt an existing industry, that existing
- 11:51industry is not going to just sit there and say, welcome to my industry, please take the bone
- 11:56of Bologna off my bread and enjoy the results. They are going to sit there and fight you, right?
- 12:02So it's very interesting. Yes, at the start point, we know the existing industry, that looks
- 12:07easier. But then I'm saying, but I'm going to take on all the biggest bullies and the biggest
- 12:11strength there is and watch me knock it down as a startup. That's a lot of bravado actually in that.
- 12:17And no doubt some succeed, but not nearly to the extent that we would think that they do.
- 12:23And I would condition that to say that, you know, if to give, you know, a tip to your
- 12:28reviewers who are probably thinking some of them thinking about creating a business,
- 12:32if I see an industry that's really asleep at the wheel, players in that industry really have
- 12:38an innovating the long time, they seem to have poor service, cost structures are high,
- 12:44that might be an industry. I'm going to think that there's some disruptive opportunity,
- 12:48because obviously they're leaving a lot of good things on the table for someone to take.
- 12:53But if I'm looking at an industry that's got, you know, top players in it that have deep pockets,
- 12:58deep resources, people really love them. They're getting good ratings. Am I going to sit out
- 13:04to disrupt that industry? Well, let me tell you, you can't just be a magnitude of 10% better
- 13:11to displace that industry. You've got to be 50, 60, 70 percent better.
- 13:16And there's another factor we don't take into account. Forget
- 13:20in disruption, which no one talks about. All the big guys and big players are going to go out
- 13:25that are out to smack you down. Understandably, as you would smack someone down, but there's another
- 13:30thing, there's sunk costs involved for buyers. So, you know, solar roofs have been trying desperately
- 13:37to displace traditional roofs on houses for the longest time. And think about it, they promise you
- 13:42to almost reduce your electricity or energy cost is your big plus, right? They allow you to know
- 13:49you're contributing to the environment, big plus. And in truth, there's some emotional status. Yeah,
- 13:55one of those people that care, I take action. Yet, the penetration is very small and why? Because
- 14:02the investment in a roof is 20,000, depending on where you are, 20 to 30,000 to read your roof,
- 14:07depending on the size of your home. It lasts for 20 years. And so once somebody has done that,
- 14:13there's huge sunk costs to change. So, there's also the buyer sunk costs. And for me to move from
- 14:19what is to what could be your new disruptive offering, your magnitude of difference has to be
- 14:26fundamental for me to shift. And I think that a lot of startups aren't calculating that correctly.
- 14:32So what looks like it's de-risk to your point, because I can see it, is actually when you deeply
- 14:39think through it, a lot more risky than we know. So then you say, well, non-destructive has a
- 14:44different set. We don't have to take on the big players. We don't have to, on the other hand,
- 14:50overcome some costs. But we have a different set of challenges, because we need to be able to
- 14:56establish that demand could be there, that isn't there yet, and the size of that potential market.
- 15:02And so they have different pros and cons to them. But I would say the ease of disruption
- 15:08has been greatly oversold to people. That's practically from a practical standpoint.
- 15:13I think that's actually very fair. And I think that, I think that if I was a founder trying to
- 15:18build something, and I, and I, by the way, I love your mod. I'll tell you why I love your model,
- 15:23because this is the second book and, and person that is thought through this problem. If you
- 15:27actually look behind me, Play Bigger is about Benioff with Salesforce.com and Ikea,
- 15:35very similar mindset. They didn't really disrupt. I mean, they did to a point, but it wasn't
- 15:39displacing. It was creating a category and then selling into that category. And that's,
- 15:45I mean, look, look at these companies now, right? That's why they're killing me. So I think that's,
- 15:49is that, but to, to, to really draw a vivid picture for people, is that the, the type of company
- 15:57that has done it? Well, you said Cirque du Soleil, what a Salesforce.com would? Cirque du Soleil
- 16:03and Salesforce. Those are two companies that are both in what we would call blue ocean. So,
- 16:08so let me say there's three paths to creating new markets. Okay, I want to, I want to be for
- 16:12the understanding example of each type of company. Yeah, that's great. I think so there's three
- 16:17different paths to creating a new market. So one is disruption and that is when I offer a breakthrough
- 16:23solution to existing market. So I set out to displace and replace it. So Netflix comes, they
- 16:29displace and replace blockbuster videos, right? So that's what I am doing there. Apple comes with
- 16:34the iPhone. They displace all the existing mobile phones. Nokia goes out of business. Sony Ericsson
- 16:40out of business, right? So you have Motorola out of business, Blackberry out of business,
- 16:44and they come in that area. That's disruption. Then blue ocean is when I create a new market,
- 16:50not within an existing industry, but across industries. So in the case of Cirque du Soleil,
- 16:57I look across theatre, I look across circus, take a little of both, recombine it in a,
- 17:04in a new way, take a margin of disruption. So not disruptive growth and a margin of disruption.
- 17:10So it's a balance. And now the third path is non-destructive creation. And that's when you create
- 17:15a new market outside of industry boundaries. So actually, there's no displacement at all. So
- 17:21if you look at Jim McKelvie and Jack Dorsey, who created the square reader,
- 17:26you know, Jim McKelvie himself has an article that came out in Harvard Business Group,
- 17:30said great companies don't set out to disrupt. And so what he is looking at is how come
- 17:36micro businesses that need credit cards, most popular form of payment in America,
- 17:41and individuals like a babysitter who wants to get payments or an ice cream, you know,
- 17:46truck that's going around and people don't have cash, but their kid is crying. They want to give
- 17:50them a nice, or they want it for themselves. They can use that credit card. And so they created
- 17:54the square reader by using the mobile phone. And now suddenly they opened up this whole new market,
- 18:00industry outside of credit cards and payment didn't infringe on either. By the way,
- 18:05did not have any NCR payment industry going out to attack it. Everyone just let it go because
- 18:12it didn't try to take my bread or butter at all. And it created all new growth. So I guess the
- 18:18three differences. One is disruption is within an existing industry. Blue ocean is across
- 18:24existing industries and non-destructive creation, which is really the opposite end of the
- 18:30innovation spectrum. And that is creating outside of industries. And no one has been talking about
- 18:36that. And we believe it's important because there's no displacement at all, no shuttered companies,
- 18:42lost jobs, hurt communities, a main street that has every single store empty because Amazon has
- 18:49given us break products, but led to retail being closed everywhere. So the follow up to that is
- 18:55as a founder, say, say I would love to build that. I would love to build a product in that category.
- 19:00But then I run into the issues that I'm talking to a venture capitalist. I'm talking to an angel
- 19:05and they're like, what's the tan? And I'm like, oh, I don't know. Well, I don't know what the
- 19:07tan is. So how does somebody think the total addressable market, what's the market that you're
- 19:14going to sell into when you're trying to raise money from an investor? So how do you think through
- 19:20getting a company in this third lane off the ground? So I think the first thing, we give the
- 19:28three building blocks to do it. The first is you have to identify. There's two ways to identify
- 19:32these non-destructive opportunities. So one is an existing problem we've all taken for granted.
- 19:39So you know, small companies and individuals like a babysitter prior to square reader,
- 19:44we just took for granted that when you're an individual, you can't accept credit card payments
- 19:48as small business. That's kind of what stinks about being a small business. You don't get to enjoy
- 19:53those bets. That's a struggle of a small business until you're a big guy. You don't get to enjoy
- 19:58those benefits. So we just simply accept it until someone says, well, why not? Right? So the
- 20:03square comes out. That's one path. And the other path is an emerging issue or problem in the
- 20:12world due to demographics, environment, social chains, new technology. So like esports, how did that
- 20:21grow? They had all these video games, kids and young people and older people are playing all over
- 20:27the world. And they started to observe in the video game industry how many people, especially in
- 20:32Korea where it's really part of their culture, would not play the video games, but sat and started
- 20:38watching them always online and they had these video game cafes where somebody would be playing
- 20:43and they'd have a crowd around them. And they started to realize, wait a minute, young people
- 20:49don't only want to play the game. So there's a whole group of people that want to watch just
- 20:54the way people love watching tennis, even if they don't play or they love watching football,
- 20:58even if they don't play. And then they started saying, could we not create an opportunity to
- 21:04create esports, live event, 50,000 people and bring it together? Net to your point. How do you start
- 21:10to assess the size of that market? Now the next question becomes, well, who cares? The most important
- 21:16question is, so I need to understand the two paths, but then question, who cares besides me?
- 21:21Who? Am I the only one or not? So in the case of, if I go back to square reader, they said,
- 21:28okay, how many small and mid-sized businesses, what is the size of their transaction volume?
- 21:34They make much smaller transactions, but what is the quantity of them? And then, you know,
- 21:39can we find out how many would find it in annoyance or would be better served if they had credit cards?
- 21:44And then they look for studies that found as well, most people prefer to be able to have the ease
- 21:49of a credit card if they don't have cash. That allowed them to see that on the bottom of the pyramid,
- 21:54well, companies were all focused on the big and large companies on the pyramid, which have huge
- 21:58volumes. They found out that all these little tiny volumes could add up to a lot. So the question
- 22:04becomes that, but you can also, and is very important, is find out how can, so we say, who cares
- 22:10besides you? But then the second thing is, dream big, but start small. So can I then,
- 22:18for esports, start to bring people together and start to have one event and see what kind of
- 22:24response that I'm getting, so that I can have some level of proof for the effectiveness of what
- 22:29I'm doing to establish that. So I guess if I were to go to a VC, I'm going to go to a VC and say,
- 22:36you know, you hear about destruction. I know it sounds good, but let me, but how many of your venture
- 22:41capital projects succeed or fail? They know so many fail. From the significant amount.
- 22:47Significant amount. And number two is, you know, we think destruction is easy, but let's talk about
- 22:52what really destruction means. I'm going against big guys. I'm going against sun cost. There's
- 22:55another path, right? So let me talk a name, and I'm now going to name five, six, seven big players
- 23:01that have pursued this, right? They're in our book, but you can just find them. These are all
- 23:05non-destructive opportunities. Do I take on big players? No, that don't I? Then I'm going to say,
- 23:10what is the problem I'm doing? It should be palpable. Who cares besides me? I'm going to start
- 23:15articulating that. And then what I'd love to have, I say, dream big, but start small is proof
- 23:22of where I have, if possible, and usually is possible, one experiment. So if I go back to even
- 23:303M when they came out with Post-it notes, the first thing they did before they could start to
- 23:36scale that, because when 3M starts to really move big, you're talking a lot of money. That means
- 23:41a lot of Siri to system more money than more people way. So they start giving this Post-it note
- 23:46to every single secretary and they find out no matter who they give it to, they call and they want
- 23:50more, right? So they start testing. They then interestingly did a first market research study with
- 23:57it, and they didn't get good results. So it goes back to what I said initially and never give up.
- 24:02And they realized was they explained the product, but they didn't let people try the product.
- 24:08So then they went back and they said, let's do a sampling blitz. Let people put it in their hands
- 24:12and see how it works. And it starts to take off there, right? So I guess my point is that we're
- 24:19looking for, you have to look for proof of how something works or doesn't work in order to be
- 24:25able to show what it is. In the case of Viagra, you know, that drug was initially meant for high blood
- 24:32pressure. And when they talk with the people that were testing the drug, this unfortunately didn't
- 24:38look like high blood pressure, but they noticed it had this side effect, which we understand what
- 24:44it was. And a man were smiling, they didn't want to give these pills back. And they said, wow,
- 24:52I think we're on to something. And so these are the types of social push that when you're saying,
- 24:57so in Viagra, in Viara's case in Pfizer, the case didn't have to meet to VC. It has made
- 25:02an upper management to start having money being it. So then they said, okay, let's put a different
- 25:06study behind it, you know, because whether it's internal or external before people put money down,
- 25:11they really want to start to understand the size of the market. So you want to try to de-risk it,
- 25:15but also as much as possible, minimize the resources I put behind before I have that proof.
- 25:22So, you know, you still have that MVP framework, that minimum viable product framework that
- 25:27transcends all startups, no difference there, and that actually allows you to test.
- 25:33Yes, so you can, that is right, but you can also, minimum viable, you can scope it down. So like
- 25:37microfinance, if we look, that's a, you know, a multi-billion dollar industry helped over 140
- 25:44million people. Well, when Mohammed Yunus had the idea to start doing that, he saw all the poor
- 25:50people in India, in Bangladesh and all, but what he really did initially was he said, no,
- 25:56if I was ever to talk to people about starting this industry and getting financing for this industry,
- 26:02and I said, I want to tackle poverty, which is widespread in all of the people that are living
- 26:08under today, the banking industry, and my own team will laugh at me. What I'm going to do is scope
- 26:14it down to one town, one village, and I'm going to make these tiny loans, and I'm going to see the
- 26:19pay-back rates. I'm going to see the way it impacts our lives. When I have that, I have something
- 26:25that I can bring of credibility in my team to believe I'm onto something, because you want to
- 26:31convince your team, they need confidence to move forward, but also when I go to bankers and
- 26:36outsiders with what I have. And so, you know, we try to go into how, you know, to answer the two
- 26:43questions. Once you've identified the problem, so it's an existing problem that's overlooked,
- 26:49long taken for granted, like if I go back to microfinance, whoever, this didn't pop problems
- 26:55in pop-up. It's been here since eternity. You ever thought that people, many of whom were
- 27:01other earning less than two dollars a day, many of whom are illiterate, can't read a bank document
- 27:05to begin with. They won't walk into a bank out of fist because they feel intimidated. They have no
- 27:11steady income, if they have income, and on the other hand, they have no collateral, and they've
- 27:17nobody that can co-sign for them. Of course, how could banking be for them? Maybe take for granted,
- 27:22but he said, no, no, no, no. These people have skills. They know how to survive in poverty,
- 27:28and these people have the same aspiration we have. They want to better their lives, and guess what?
- 27:34They don't need tens of thousands of dollars the way people in the wealthy cities do. They need
- 27:38matter a few dollars. And so, he started to look and reframe that thinking there is existing problem
- 27:46had long been taken for granted. And to be truthful with you, Scott, they're everywhere.
- 27:51It's like, when you don't have the lens to think that way, you don't realize how many problems
- 27:57are often right in front of us. We just don't see. We start the book off with the case of music,
- 28:03not impossible, and the death and hearing. We all assume what a tragedy. And I say that from a
- 28:11hearing perspective, so maybe that's wrong perspective to say, but I say most people would
- 28:16commonly say it's unfortunate to be born without hearing. And we just say, forget that as a result of
- 28:22that, you cannot experience music. It's just part of life. But they said, why is that? Because we don't
- 28:30actually hear with our ears. It's just where vibration enters our human existence, our body.
- 28:37We actually hear with our brain. And if you fall on the street and you hurt your head in a certain
- 28:43way, without even touching your ear, you can lose your hearing. So he said, it can we not find another
- 28:49receptive mechanism to allow vibration to enter our brain. So we begin to get the sensational
- 28:56music. And they found it could be your skin. Were these audiologists or doctors? No. These are
- 29:02just this company called music. It's called Not Impossible Labs. Actually, that's the name of the
- 29:07company. It's called music, not impossible. Because I said, how could we bring music? And so they
- 29:13used existing technologies found how through vibration and the skin, they could let that
- 29:20enter our body with different frequencies. And so it's like a vest you wear if you were surfing.
- 29:26And it was it's a beautiful, but we took for granted that problem and they said out to solve it.
- 29:31Is it just one or like in the case of, you know, esports, what are newly emerging aspirations of
- 29:39people, right? Or newly emerging problems? It didn't exist two years ago even. And then how do we
- 29:44create these new opportunities? So it's absolutely fascinating. What when you look at this lens,
- 29:52this is a lens in which you view the world. Now, I hope that people can understand how impactful
- 29:57this is, but speak to me about why this is important for our future. Why is it important for us to
- 30:01look in this way outside of maybe having a slightly easier go at building a company? That's
- 30:08that's fun. That's nice. That's very that's not that important at the end. It's important,
- 30:13but it's not as important as where does this take humanity in the future?
- 30:17So I, you know, I think there are several reasons, which is why we're so passionate about and we've
- 30:24worked a lot of years on this. You know, so one is, of course, that it allows me to achieve,
- 30:33often we think, you know, in business, you're either a corporate reader, I'm being simplistic,
- 30:37you're a corporate reader, you're a tree hugger. You know, you either pursue profiting growth,
- 30:42or you know, you're very committed to helping the world. And non-destructive creation
- 30:49allows us to pursue profit, but achieve social good in the very way we earn money, not spend money.
- 30:55So, you know, traditionally corporate social responsibility in companies is a cost factor.
- 31:00It's how we spend money, not how we make money, but with non-destructive creation, I am able to
- 31:06pursue economic growth without causing social harm to the organizations, which I think speaks very
- 31:14much to what the younger generations really care about, but also it speaks very much to this new
- 31:21movement about how we need to consider not only shareholders, but our broader stakeholders in
- 31:27society. And this is very important. And, you know, recently there's been some pushback where
- 31:34people say, you know, you're pushing too hard for stakeholders, and that's because companies
- 31:39are feeling that they have to truncate their profits too much to do this, and they're hurting
- 31:44themselves in the process. But, you know, non-destructive creation, it's a positive some approach,
- 31:51not zero sum. So, that's at one level, and I do believe it's important. If I'm an executive
- 31:56as a company, do, if I had two alternatives, one is I can disrupt and displace and destroy
- 32:02an industry, which is macho and good and I make money. On the other hand, I can create a billion
- 32:07dollar business where I don't destroy and take down others, and I care about communities that are
- 32:14around and those employees, because when I disrupt, when you're on the opposite end of disruption,
- 32:19someone's really getting hurt. Of course. The whole word source is wiped out, right? Yeah,
- 32:24just walk down Madison Avenue, New York, and you watch every other store, every three or four
- 32:28stores, they're closed, right? And so, it has a tremendous impact on the real estate industry,
- 32:34all the retail employees, but also on our minds, right? It just creates a sense of a lack of hope
- 32:44when you see everything getting closed down, right? You need, you need vibrancy and vibrancy
- 32:49in a neighborhood in the community, inspires us to think, feel with hope, imagination for the future.
- 32:55So, as a CEO, if I have two opportunities before me, I'm not going to disparage disruption,
- 33:00but I'm going to seriously weigh non-destruction because those ideas and those issues matter,
- 33:06but the second issue very much is what we're talking about every day, and this is an emerging
- 33:11challenge, and that is a fourth industrial revolution. So, you know, every day with this chat,
- 33:18GBT that came out, everyone's playing with it, trying it, and you know, every day you'll read
- 33:24articles estimated 100 million people might lose jobs or whatever, it's always in large numbers,
- 33:30often in the hundreds of millions, that we hope that's not the case, and no be countervailing people,
- 33:35which will say, well, in most industrial revolutions, there is displacement, but eventually new jobs,
- 33:41and we hope so, you know, we hope that'll be the case, but we believe we should always prepare
- 33:49for the worst and plan for and hope for the best. We need to be preparing for the worst, hoping for
- 33:54the best, and what does that mean is that when this AI, and if by the way, it's not coming as much
- 34:00for blue collar jobs, smart machines are coming from blue collar jobs, but AI is coming for white collar
- 34:06jobs, they're coming for creative jobs, they're coming for writing jobs, legal jobs, medical jobs,
- 34:13all these industries that have seen themselves as safe. And so, the real question is, you know,
- 34:19people say, well, the result in lower price, better quality products and services, sure,
- 34:24if people have a job and income to buy those, but if 100 million people get crushed and lose
- 34:30their jobs and they have no income, where's the money to buy that? And what's going to be the
- 34:34implication, if we are within the space of a few years, all these people out of work for society,
- 34:40that's not a productive society, it actually creates a lot of social problems when people don't
- 34:45have work. So where are the new jobs going to come from? That's what I ask. And non-destructive
- 34:51creation by creating without destroying, without displacing jobs allows me to create new jobs
- 34:57without taking away further. If I disrupt that, also create growth, but in the short and medium
- 35:04term, by releasing even more labor. So, you know, please, but if you look at even self-driving
- 35:11cars, big disruption, but let me tell you, I think it's the 3% of the American workforce,
- 35:19it's one of the highest occupations in America in many states are drivers of one sort,
- 35:24bus driver, tractor, taxi driver, truck driver. So it comes and disrupts, eventually creates new
- 35:32jobs. But what about in the interim of all those jobs displaced, where are they going to get absorbed
- 35:38to? So, you know, we see that I think it'll be really important at the level of community,
- 35:44at the level of government to start trying to think about and inspiring people to think not
- 35:49only disruption and not only aiming AI at efficiency and productivity, because technology is a means
- 35:58to an end, but can I aim it and start thinking about the value space of non-destructive,
- 36:03so I'm also creating new jobs with it. And that I think is going to be a big challenge
- 36:10and why it's important for the future. And just one thought on that, because even in a non-destructive
- 36:18creation of a new industry, some of the jobs, just to make sure I understand some of the jobs in
- 36:24that new industry will still be displaced, but ultimately at least the entire industry is not
- 36:29displacing jobs in another industry. So there will be, it'll be mitigate some of the effects of
- 36:36emerging AI technology replacing white collar and whatnot. Yeah, so what it'll allow us to do,
- 36:44Scott, is to hopefully create new industries, new markets, new products and services that require
- 36:51new people to come on board and you're right. Some of those jobs that come on board will be able
- 36:57to be used by AI to be efficient, but also creating all these new jobs. But what it's not going to do,
- 37:03though, is start to displace people in existing jobs and existing industries. So it allows us,
- 37:09as human resources and human beings are released from some jobs, it creates new opportunities
- 37:15to absorb new jobs. So that's what we see. Yeah. I just want to take a second and thank the sponsor
- 37:21of today's episode, HubSpot. Now, as you all know, the success story podcast is part of the HubSpot
- 37:27podcast network. There are incredible podcasts in this network. One of my favorites that you have
- 37:32to check out. If you don't know this podcast, you're kind of sleeping on it. The Gold Digger podcast
- 37:38hosted by Jenna Kutcher. This podcast has been around for a minute. Jenna is an OG in the podcast
- 37:44game. The Gold Digger podcast helps you discover your dream career with productivity tips, social
- 37:49strategies, business hacks, inspirational stories, interviews, and so much more. Please go check out
- 37:56the Gold Digger podcast hosted by Jenna Kutcher wherever you get your podcasts.
- 38:02Okay. So a lot of this conversation has spoken about an entrepreneur that's thinking about
- 38:08building something from scratch, but there's also the opportunity for people within organizations
- 38:14to adopt a more non-disruptive mindset. So how do we foster that culture of non-disruption
- 38:23because I don't think that even in a legacy organization, I mean, even getting a legacy
- 38:29organization to disrupt, it is like a hard enough thing to do. So how do we get them over that
- 38:35hump all the way through to, okay, just be forward thinking, be non-disruptive, create in this lens.
- 38:42How does a company do that? Somebody's listening to this, VP, C-suite, and a fortune 1,000.
- 38:49What do they take away? I think the first thing I want to take away is to start a discussion
- 38:54on it, to ask people to think about this idea and whether it makes sense to their organization,
- 39:01the one thing that you find is that when you ask, and this is where the theory of disruption
- 39:06has been, you're asking an established company to disrupt themselves. First of all, if you ask
- 39:10them to disrupt an existing industry, they understand that they're going up against big
- 39:16piers with big resources. They know it's not an easy win, but the alternative is they often say,
- 39:21you know, disrupt your own industry before someone else does, but no one wants to disrupt their
- 39:27own industry. Because the second I tell myself, disrupt myself, what happens to me as an organization?
- 39:33Actually, I fill myself with fear because what I'm saying is make myself irrelevant in a sense.
- 39:38So first thing is that you have to understand within an established organization,
- 39:44disruption is harder to, in many respects, from our perspective, it's harder to absorb because
- 39:52I think it's politically and emotionally difficult for organizations to overcome that.
- 40:00And so there's often a lot of pushback. We have a quote in our book from an oil executive,
- 40:05that saying that when you have three quarters of your organization focused on fossil fuels,
- 40:11and you have these existing new industries that are green energy trying to displace and destroy
- 40:19this, we're not too excited about putting out our livelihoods here. So we find ways to slap overhead
- 40:26on the new businesses and you know, make it difficult. And so people want to jump shit from there.
- 40:34And so let me just say that, but I think very importantly, we say to organizations, you know,
- 40:39we all need to innovate. No one is going to deny that. Innovation, if there's one constant
- 40:45in the future is we need to innovate to stay ahead, especially with global competition and tense.
- 40:51And especially today with people being concerned with the recession on the horizon,
- 40:57or maybe being felt now everyone has different perspectives, but it's difficult right now.
- 41:01No doubt it's difficult. I can be difficult for the next few years, especially if we have
- 41:06de-globalization and cost structures rise because of that. And so the question is people are going to
- 41:13be tight with their money. So it's less you're innovating in the marketplace and doing something
- 41:17special, you can expect your demand to shrink. So we need innovation. Now there's two different
- 41:22types of innovation. I can disrupt in this place, or I can also pursue these non-destructive
- 41:29opportunities where I look for growth and innovation outside of my industry, but it doesn't have to
- 41:35be far outside, right? So when video game makers created esports and jumped on to and created their
- 41:42own teams and and their own adapted to multi-game players, they created a non-destructive industry,
- 41:49but it was right next to their industry. So to simplify Scott, you can have both
- 41:57destruction isn't that easy for a lot of established companies, but we found non-destructive
- 42:01is a bit more because I'm not displacing myself. I'm looking for new opportunities. And the first step
- 42:07is I need to have a discussion. What is this? Does it make sense? Do we need to innovate and should
- 42:13we pursue disruption or maybe some of our unit should because those industries are asleep at the
- 42:18wheel? And maybe there are these industries where we see we really can see existing problems that
- 42:25have been unaddressed that we can or newly emerging ones, we can do some non-destructive. And I'd
- 42:30want to have that discussion. And I think that's the first thing I'd really want to do. And then
- 42:36you know, if I want to take it further, I'd start to ask my team, all right, these are the two
- 42:41paths, you know, an existing problem we've taken for granted that people are really struggling with.
- 42:48I want you to go give me two weeks go think about that one team of my people and another team
- 42:54newly emerging problem or opportunity we could create. And let's come back in three weeks
- 43:00knowing these two and let's brainstorm what ideas we have and how can we start thinking about that.
- 43:07And that would be the way I would start a conversation. So I start to open people's mental space
- 43:12to that. You know, when I was doing research for this, I saw a paper that you would put out for
- 43:19the Harvard Business Review about value innovation. Was this was value innovation the first iteration
- 43:28of this concept that just evolved? So evaluations are a research is a 30 year journey. I realized
- 43:35that 2004 I was I was surprised it wasn't something 2014. It seems like this has been an emerging
- 43:41concept for a while. Well, value innovation was actually became a classic. So it was republished.
- 43:46Innovation was actually first published in 1997. Oh my goodness. Yes. So we have and we had a series
- 43:54of best selling Harvard Business Review articles and then they asked Harvard and a few publishers
- 44:00asked us for about five years to write a book. We said no, we have nothing really simple and
- 44:07important. We believe to say that can make a real difference to business. And then we took five
- 44:12more years and then we eventually came out with our first book, Blue Ocean Strategy. And we got
- 44:17pushed back because competing is everything. And we said, we're not we're not challenging competing.
- 44:22We're just saying there's competing and there's this non-destructive opportunity called creating.
- 44:26Let's look at it. And then, you know, we did that. It grew and then we started to see all this
- 44:32disruption. And we say, why did we why are we always playing a zero-sum game? I mean, do you know
- 44:37where the zero-sum game comes from? I don't actually know. What's I know the I know what it is,
- 44:42but I don't know where the. And business fundamentally comes from war. It comes from military strategy.
- 44:50Interesting. And the key defining a factor of military strategy, there's only so much land.
- 44:57So for me to advance and gain more territory, I have to do it at your expense.
- 45:02Because there's the amount of land that exists on this beautiful earth is limited.
- 45:08So my win must come at your loss. But when we took so that's why we used Chief Executive Officers
- 45:15frontline staff, right? We use all these still military terminology in companies without
- 45:19understanding realizing it. And when military strategy moved into business strategy, innovation,
- 45:26infiltrated all of business, we took with it the key limiting factor, which is that limited land
- 45:33that you have to have zero-sum game. When in business, the only limitation is our imagination.
- 45:39The amount of industries have exploded over time. And so he said, why do we accept that key
- 45:44limiting factor of war in a space that has no such limitation? We can our limitations are
- 45:51imagination. All these industries, if you look at the industry classification systems done by
- 45:56governments, they have exploded over time in the next financial way. And so he said, why should we
- 46:03play that zero-sum game when we can play a positive sum game and keep growing that pie for all of us
- 46:09and make it better as opposed to only fighting? And so it seems to keep going back. I was going to
- 46:16say we keep defaulting to this, though, because even though blue ocean is a very widely recognized
- 46:22concept, then disruption, again, turns into a zero-sum game. So it seems to be the comfortable place
- 46:28that humans always go back to. Well, that is true. I think to a lot of extent is, what was
- 46:36so I would say, yeah, I was going to say a certain type, but I would say, yes, I think a lot of people
- 46:41find that they're looking for that growth and comfort don't really coexist. You want to get more
- 46:48muscles. You have to strain yourself. You have to hurt, right? Every time we grow, we have to step
- 46:53into a discomfort to expand that. So there is some of that. There's also just histories far
- 46:59far longer, right? Going all the way back. Sun Zhu and an interesting way, he always taught the
- 47:06best way to win a war is not to enter the war. But you're right about that. It is a high default,
- 47:16but you know, we will start keep charging forward in our way because we see that it is possible.
- 47:21We can, you know, decodify that. And I think organizations can get a lot better. And just because
- 47:27something is doesn't mean I fully agree. And this should be and we're going to keep marching
- 47:33forward. Jessica, I hope you'll march forward with this. I will definitely end you right.
- 47:37History is long. History is very long. And there's a lot to learn from it. And, you know,
- 47:43let me say another thing, it's got to clarify, you know, competing has a troll as it's creating.
- 47:49They both do. Unfortunately, business is no longer monotone. We have to manage paradoxes. We have
- 47:54to be good short term and we have to think long term. We have to understand how to disrupt as well,
- 48:00disruption matters, but also we have to understand non-destructive opportunities. So
- 48:05it's more challenging in that sense, but to not accept that reality is to sort of bury our head
- 48:13in the sand and hope that our body doesn't get hit. And I just think that we need to be open to it.
- 48:19And, you know, we've saw when we started looking at non-destructive, we started just thinking
- 48:24about it. And, you know, we start really around. Think about it. Business books are our own
- 48:29category. It was a non-destructive opportunity in the whole book industry. Didn't
- 48:34displace any other category when it was born. It really started with insertive excellence,
- 48:39really. That was first real big business book. Before that, there really weren't business books.
- 48:43And, wow, but didn't displace, and no one stuck reading literature, more whatever, just a lot of
- 48:48still learning about business. Then I look at teens, you know, they have a lot whole new category
- 48:52of teen books. Never existed before. Didn't displace. Just engaged teens by talking books that talk
- 48:59about their issues. Wow, home category, you know, and then I have dogs and my little daughter would
- 49:05say, mom, can we get this pet Halloween costume when we're supposed to look at this model? Wow,
- 49:10pet Halloween costumes never existed before. Didn't displace. That's a $500 million
- 49:14industry. And the war we started thinking about it, and look at these industry after industry,
- 49:22when you have that lens and you start to see it, you start to pay attention to it, and we start
- 49:28to realize how much more prevalent and how much money and opportunity and impact we can have in that
- 49:34space. If we bring it to our consciousness, you know, it's just like the first time you hear a new
- 49:40word, you never heard that word, and then suddenly you're at a party and you hear it. And then you
- 49:44go, and then you read an article, oh my god, there's that word. And you thought no one ever uses
- 49:48archaic word and you start popping up, because now your mind is attuned to it. And I think
- 49:54that's what we're hoping the book will help to do. Get us attuned to non-destructive opportunities
- 49:58and thinking more positive, son, as opposed to, and by the way, it creates a lot more hope than
- 50:05just, uh, destruction is also, um, and it's not an attack, but it's a fear-based way. If I tell you,
- 50:11I'm going to just drop you, Scott, oh, believe me, you don't like me right away. Yeah.
- 50:15I'm your, you're in an anxiety mode, and an attack mode. And if I, if you say to yourself,
- 50:21to your team, we're going to disrupt ourselves. Oh boy, they're going to go home and say to their
- 50:24wife or to their husband, Scott wants to disrupt his honey. I'm not sure. And six months, who
- 50:29is that mean to my job? Yeah. Yeah. What's going to happen to me now, right? You know,
- 50:34I'm the other thing I want to say, um, Scott is this AI thing. I think that a lot of people today,
- 50:40whether companies are talking about it with their staff or not, people are reading
- 50:44AI is everywhere. They're, or their kids are trying it, or they're trying it night, and they're
- 50:48saying, oh my god, with two prompts, like, it can write an article for me. Somebody did a test,
- 50:56and they said, it was amazing. They said, write a story about a piece, I don't have it exact,
- 51:03so please forgive me, I'm an aggregate. Write a story about a piece of celery who falls in
- 51:08main Marty, who falls in love with a peanut, they move to France, they start a bakery, and then
- 51:16they have an almond, I don't know, an almond for a house or whatever. And they said, just write
- 51:23this story, chat GBT goes, right? Little Marty, Miss Sally, Liz Green, and Sweet, and he meant this
- 51:30cute little guy. And it was so sweet, and I thought, my god, this could be a best-selling book. My
- 51:34daughter would think it's adorable, you know? So people at my point is, people see this and what
- 51:39it can do. And they're, whether they're having that conversation or not, they're starting to think
- 51:45about their own job. Like, wow, what does that mean? And we all know companies are under stress,
- 51:50we see today, people getting lay off again, and again, just for the economy, right, in the lot
- 51:56and the IT and other sectors. So people are wondering, and so I think a really worthwhile conversation
- 52:03in a company is to realize technology is a means to an end. What do I do that technology?
- 52:08Do I aim it at efficiency and productivity? I'm going to lose employees, but I have another
- 52:14opportunity if we start thinking together in our company. Can we think about how could we leverage
- 52:20that to create non-destructive opportunities where we can create growth and hopefully new jobs
- 52:26for ways we can transition in so that we can keep our value boom for ease and grow? And I believe
- 52:32that's an important discussion to have. And it's also an inspiring one as a lot of people,
- 52:39I think, are starting to wonder. And even if they're not wondering today, believe me, at the rate,
- 52:44if we project out where it's going, they're going to be worrying, thinking about it in six months or
- 52:48eight months or a year, what can we do event? I think it's better to think in advance and try to
- 52:53get ahead of the curve if we can, then to get hit by it and kind of be in the valley of death.
- 53:00And one more thing with fear, trying to figure this out. So I would think like that, you know?
- 53:05What's the next book you hope you'll be able to write?
- 53:11Spot, you're killing me now, you're killing me now, you know?
- 53:14That is a very conflict for a researcher. You're like growing gray hairs as I ask that question
- 53:19because it's so so stressful. It's asking a woman, you know, just had a child,
- 53:25when's the next one she's like, oh, believe me, I'm just really surviving, getting out.
- 53:31You know, we're going to listen really carefully as we talk to people, we find out
- 53:37what are their challenges, right? So we had, and where do they need more understanding? So you
- 53:44I'll go back after our discussion, right? So, you know, our books are a way to try to
- 53:50share what we learned and what we've studied. But in a way like when I'm interviewing you, you're my
- 53:54educator. I'm learning from you. I hear what your concerns are, what your questions are.
- 54:00We will go back and we'll really start thinking about what really matters, where are areas
- 54:05that we could fill in to help organizations move? What are some of the hurdles or stumbling
- 54:14blocks they have in embracing this idea? And so we really interact with the market and with people
- 54:19and with businesses. And we listen very carefully. So, you know, in our book we talk about one thing is
- 54:27that, you know, what can trip you up on this path? And we say, you know, be ready for discouragement
- 54:34from the pundits. Which you think we have a few, but one of them is, be, don't take others'
- 54:44assumptions as your own. It's very important. You know, people will tell you it's not the way it's
- 54:50done, but don't take that other's assumptions because, you know, when we're setting Sesame Street,
- 54:57you know, all the people in the education industry said, little children cannot learn by watching
- 55:02and have to learn by doing. You cannot have a silly puppet teach education. No kid will take it
- 55:08seriously. And also, you cannot miss fantasy and song with serious education. Kids need to be
- 55:15sitting down and be serious to learn. And she said, if we had ever listened, Joan Genskuni,
- 55:20to what the educator said about how education should be, Sesame Street would never be born, right?
- 55:26So one, you know, one problem is don't take others' assumptions as your own think for yourself.
- 55:32That goes back to my first point. You say, how did we create these ideas? You saw them as counter
- 55:37intuitive. We think for ourselves and we observe for ourselves, right? That's very important.
- 55:42A lot of people out others to think for them. That's number one. The second thing is,
- 55:47though, don't get ready for discouragement from the pundits. And when you're ready to be
- 55:53discouraged from the pundits, you actually get hit less when it happens because you're expecting it.
- 55:59But at the same time, you don't want to poo poo it because you want to say, well, why did they
- 56:05have that? And if you have a good reputation for why it's irrelevant, you get strengthened your
- 56:10ideas. But if you can't say, wow, we couldn't really speak to that. We don't really have a good
- 56:15answer for that. We don't know why our product won't work in that situation. It teaches you where
- 56:19you need to strengthen where your idea and where you're not as good. And so I say to you, that is what,
- 56:25when you say, what will our next book be, we are going to be passionate about we do in marching
- 56:31forward. We're not discouraged by the pundits because we've seen what it is. But we're also going
- 56:35to learn from the pundits. And we're going to make sure when I say, wow, what couldn't we have
- 56:40answered? What should we answer? How can we help people more? Because our idea isn't just to put
- 56:46a book out there. It's to try in a small way, a big way, maybe even a tiny way, to try to make
- 56:54some difference. You know, my grandfather, he lived to over 100. And he gave me his most beautiful
- 57:01gap at the very end. And he said, Renee, I want to talk to you for a minute. And I said, yeah,
- 57:05I've been thinking about it because he was bad-ridden, but he never lost his mind. And he said,
- 57:11if I had to think about, you know, what makes a good life, for me, it only comes down to two
- 57:18activities. And he said, that is to strive and to give. And he said, never stop striving to try
- 57:24to make a difference in this world, whether big or small, so it's better than when you came.
- 57:29Don't give up on that. And then he said, never stop giving to those who love. And I remember I walked
- 57:37out of that room and I thought, I'm just chained up and I said, thank you. You have given me the best
- 57:43gift in my life. That was of all the gifts that gave me growing up, those two were striving and
- 57:48giving. And so, good advice. It's very good advice. What would you, what would be one final lesson,
- 57:57or one final question that I should have asked you that I didn't, that you think would be useful
- 58:02for somebody listening? I think that if you're fortunate enough, you know, I went on this journey with
- 58:11my colleague, Chan Kim, for over 30 years. And I think that we both, it's been really rewarding and
- 58:23powerful for both of us along the journey, hence 30 years. And I think that we always look for
- 58:30and value and try to understand the value each of us brings to the table and respect that.
- 58:38And I think doing that with your, in an organization, with your employees, and if you can have a
- 58:45really great, to build a really strong team like that, I think that's indispensable. Because
- 58:51sometimes you have blind spots you don't see, and they see them for you. They're active as your
- 58:55eyes. When you get, when you know, you get hit by something, they can provide a different way to
- 59:05think about it. So I think building a strong team is very, very critical. And I know it's certainly
- 59:11benefit us in our journey. And I think building strong teams in our companies and with those we work
- 59:19and that are based on really a lot of mutual respect and alignment of values. So we're both very hard
- 59:24working. We're both very, you know, perfectionists in our own way. We align in our viewpoint of what
- 59:35we're trying to achieve. We, you know, when we achieve setbacks, we keep marching forward. And
- 59:43that's very powerful, I think. So I would say I'm building a team to maybe take some actions
- 59:48like that. But other than that's got to love to your questions. And I love your manner, your,
- 59:54yeah, I love telling people because I just feel that. Thank you. We often think things you don't
- 59:59articulate them. But you have such a winning way. I appreciate that. Very kind. I try to ask
- 1:00:05more questions that I think your audience cares about. And I really respect that.
- 1:00:11And so I thank you. I appreciate you a lot. And I actually really enjoyed the conversation a lot.
- 1:00:16This is right up my alley. And I could probably do a much longer podcast than anyone else would listen to
- 1:00:23just about all the topics we just went into. But before we close it out, I want to give you the
- 1:00:29opportunity. Where should people go to connect with you? So the socials, the website, a little bit
- 1:00:36more, but where they can get the book, of course, all the regular spots, the Amazon's and whatnot.
- 1:00:39But any links or anything else you want to drop? You know, whatever just says our main link,
- 1:00:46which is www.bluetianstrategy.com and from there, you know, our socials are there for our work.
- 1:00:54And you know, they can also go to www.INSEAD, which is our school, our university.edu
- 1:01:05and they can find, you know, we have an institute there and they can find us there as well.
- 1:01:10But I would really say www.Bluetianstrategy.com can one stop shopping, can direct them everywhere.
- 1:01:16And yes, of course, you know, Amazon as well and the other usual suspects for the books.
- 1:01:23Perfect. Okay. And then the last question that I ask everyone, before we close this out,
- 1:01:27you've had an incredible career at this point in your life. What does success mean to you?
- 1:01:35Okay. So Scott, I didn't know you're going to ask that question.
- 1:01:38No, that's fine. That's fine. You can take time to it. You can take time to think about it.
- 1:01:43It's not a trick. It's just because you've achieved a lot. And I think that people's definition
- 1:01:47of success changes over time and I'm curious what yours is now.
- 1:01:54Well, it's against different spheres, but one is for us success in the way we
- 1:02:01took our whole career was simply doing our best every day.
- 1:02:08That was what we were always trying to achieve. It was just, did we do our best today?
- 1:02:13That would be in work. And I think success in life is just knowing whether
- 1:02:22have I been a good partner to my researcher,
- 1:02:27which and Kim, have I been a good daughter to my parents?
- 1:02:31Have I been a good sister to my brother? And have I been a good mother to my daughter
- 1:02:37where I put things down when she comes in the room and I spend really valuable time with her?
- 1:02:45Have I been a good friend to my friends? And I ask myself those questions,
- 1:02:50often every morning over a coffee, you know, before the day starts and the house is awake
- 1:02:55in the dark. I sit there and I'm not that I achieve it, but I try to think consciously about that.