Latest / Horror Movie Maniacs / Return to Silent Hill with Sam Lee (Celebro)
Transcript
- 0:12Horror Movie Maniacs Horror movie maniacs will make you
- 0:19scream and alive. Horror movie.
- 0:21Maniacs. Straight forward, she will get
- 0:26you a texting fence. Graham.
- 0:31What Louise, you'll say from those twinkles, take deep in the
- 0:39horrorscore moving maniacs.
- 1:06Hello everyone, and welcome to the Horror Movie Maniacs
- 1:09podcast. I am one of your hosts, Ben, and
- 1:11I'm here as always with my Co host grant.
- 1:13Good day. That's very somber.
- 1:16Are you all right, I? Don't know what you expect from
- 1:18me, Ben. I expect for this film, Grant, I
- 1:21expect you to be absolutely buzzing.
- 1:23Yeah, but I'm not happy though, am I?
- 1:25Never. You're never happy.
- 1:27I'm especially not happy today. I'm really surprised to be
- 1:30honest. Anyway, yes, so before we get
- 1:34into a return to Silent Hill, I'd like to introduce a very
- 1:38special guest. We have Sam who you might know
- 1:42as the Libro. Hello.
- 1:44Hello. Hello, how are you doing?
- 1:47I'm all right, gentlemen. How are you?
- 1:48Well. I'm How about bridge?
- 1:53Is that because you just watched this film?
- 1:55I'm just kidding. We'll do that later.
- 1:59I'm happy. No, I'm unhappy because I
- 2:00haven't been able to watch it again, that's how.
- 2:03Wow. OK, interesting.
- 2:05Yeah, that is an interesting style actually.
- 2:07John, Ben. Right, so before we dig into
- 2:11Return to Silent Hill, which won't take long today, let's
- 2:14have a synopsis. Then please Grant Oh.
- 2:16You want a synopsis, dear? I do.
- 2:19OK, it's very short. When a man receives A mysterious
- 2:23letter from his lost love, he is drawn to Silent Hill, a once
- 2:25familiar town now consumed by darkness.
- 2:28It's pretty terrible. It's pretty terrible.
- 2:31That's an awful synopsis. Yeah, but most of them are.
- 2:35Yeah, fair. That's fair.
- 2:36I appreciate you saying that. Right, let's roll the trailer
- 2:40for everyone's enjoyment. James.
- 2:51So much time has passed, but I'm asking to please come back to
- 2:58our special place. Something's happened, Love,
- 3:04Mary. Hello, can anyone hear me?
- 3:11Everyone got sick in Silent Hill.
- 3:14Something's happened here. Something really, really bad.
- 3:38What you're doing? It won't be enough to save.
- 3:41Her. You did it, didn't you, Jimmy?
- 3:46You woke up. No one said it would be easy.
- 4:03I'm here. I'll always be here.
- 4:13OK, There you go. So what a trailer.
- 4:17What a film. So much to say, right?
- 4:22Let's start then with a few few details about who made this film
- 4:28and all that stuff. Like normal.
- 4:29Yeah. So we've got returning director
- 4:32Christoph Ganz. I think Gong, that's how you say
- 4:36it, Gong, because he's French, isn't he?
- 4:37So he comes back after 20 years to direct this new instalment.
- 4:43This time though, he has part wrote it with Sandra Voan and
- 4:47William Joseph Schneider. Oh yes, Sam.
- 4:51Any idea who any of those writers?
- 4:53Yeah, those people, yeah, No idea.
- 4:55Look. At those people.
- 4:58Same. No idea at all, but no idea
- 5:00could be where some of the issues start to come in already
- 5:03because obviously on the original film we had, we had
- 5:06Roger Avery, didn't we? So well, he Co wrote Pulp
- 5:10Fiction. So you know, yeah, bit of
- 5:14caliber there. The cast, I'm not going to go
- 5:17through all the cast, OK? Just the main ones, yeah.
- 5:19James. James Sunderland is played by
- 5:22Jeremy Vine. A whole War Horse over there.
- 5:26I've not seen it of. Course you haven't.
- 5:29You don't see a great deal of the guy, do you?
- 5:31Jeremy Irvine? But he got cast in this role and
- 5:33I was like, OK, that guy that it's been a while.
- 5:36It took me a minute. It took me like until about an
- 5:38hour after. I was like, Oh yeah.
- 5:40Yeah, I didn't. Even recognize him.
- 5:43Because you don't watch anything, Ben, no.
- 5:45No. Fair enough, Grant.
- 5:48No. Need for that.
- 5:50Anyway, I'm moving on. So Hannah, Emily Anderson plays
- 5:55now hold on. She plays Mary Crane, yes, but
- 5:58she also plays Angela Maria and Moth Mary as well.
- 6:02There's a hell moth Mary. Yeah, yeah.
- 6:05I don't know why I know her. I don't know her obviously, but
- 6:08I recognize her. No idea.
- 6:11I don't. I haven't seen her in anything
- 6:12before, I don't think. She's definitely doing this
- 6:14stuff. Jigsaw and X-Men dot yeah, X-Men
- 6:18dot Phoenix as well. Oh, OK.
- 6:21Again, it will come as no surprise to everybody that
- 6:23haven't seen that of. Course you haven't.
- 6:25I haven't seen Dark Phoenix. To be fair.
- 6:26No, I haven't seen Dark. Phoenix.
- 6:27I've heard it's terrible. Yeah, that's what I did.
- 6:30Yeah, yeah. I wonder.
- 6:31It's bad. It's in the Purge.
- 6:34OK, nice TV series not. The right purge, right?
- 6:37Fair enough. We've also got see, I know the
- 6:39next one. I know the next one.
- 6:40We've got Evie Templeton playing Laura.
- 6:42OK, now she was in Wednesday. Oh, and watch that crap.
- 6:51I kind of watch most of it, you know, I've got no excuse.
- 6:55I'm not really into like the Addams family to be honest.
- 6:59No, it's a bit of a strange one to spin off, but anyways.
- 7:03She also voices Laura in the Silent Hill Two remake.
- 7:05Oh. That's cool.
- 7:07Yeah, yeah, that's, that's a little bit of homework done,
- 7:10isn't it? You sort of, I think that gets
- 7:12your hopes up a little bit. This guy's taking it seriously
- 7:14and then, well, we'll come on to that.
- 7:18We will, indeed. Apparently, though, he didn't
- 7:19know that she was the voice of Laura in the game.
- 7:25Wow. Yeah, I find that a bit hard to
- 7:27believe because apparently he's an avid video game player and he
- 7:30likes playing a lot of Silent Hill so.
- 7:33You'd never know. You'd never know.
- 7:38Anyway, hold that thought, OK? A.
- 7:41Couple Bull. We've got Pierce Eagan who plays
- 7:43Eddie for a minute and then Eddie, and then we've got Robert
- 7:48Strange who plays Red Pyramid. Oh mate, Rob.
- 7:51I mate Rob. Soon to be you are mate.
- 7:54Your mate. My mate.
- 7:56Soon to be your mate. You're you're going to get a
- 7:59picture with him and you're horrified too.
- 8:02There you go. I'm not going to go through the
- 8:03rest really because they're very bit part characters.
- 8:06Don't. Really have, Yeah.
- 8:08No one cares. No one even cares about this
- 8:10film or probably what we're doing here.
- 8:12So you know, what'd you say? The budget.
- 8:16The budget. Again.
- 8:18No, no, Grant. You know, I do have some
- 8:20positive things to say. About Oh, I'm so glad you got
- 8:22some positives to say, Ben. Which, Sam, this might surprise
- 8:24you, but I don't fully hate this film, so yeah.
- 8:28I don't need the charity, Ben, I'm perfectly capable on my own.
- 8:31All right, fair enough. This film has a budget of $23
- 8:36million. Yeah.
- 8:38Somewhere in there. And most of the money came back
- 8:41from China, I read. Oh, really?
- 8:43Yeah, it's a bit of a flop in North America, but China came in
- 8:46with like 10 mil. I mean it's just come out as it
- 8:49took it hasn't took 10 mil already.
- 8:51No, it's taken. It's taken more than that.
- 8:53It took like 9 and a half million in China.
- 8:55Second day 15.3 at the minute apparently.
- 8:57There, there, there you go. Yeah.
- 8:59OK, he'll probably make his budget back then, so.
- 9:01Yeah, Europe made a bit and then try and do the bulk of it and
- 9:04then obviously when it comes to streaming platforms and stuff,
- 9:07it'll clear its budget. Yeah, Europe's always the worst.
- 9:10Isn't it though? Smallest so well Europe.
- 9:12Is doing better than North America, apparently.
- 9:14Right, Sam, I'm going to give you a chance to have a little
- 9:17guess at some of the scores that people have gave it online.
- 9:20All right, We normally do as a grant.
- 9:22They're all wrong. But Grant, I'm not giving you
- 9:24the opportunity today. Actually, no, I don't.
- 9:26OK, best Sam, this is all about you.
- 9:28So IMDb, what do you think they gave it out of 10?
- 9:333.4 That's pretty close. Coach right the wrong way round.
- 9:37Yeah, I was going to say 4.3. OK, all right.
- 9:41Wasn't 1,000,000 miles away then?
- 9:43No, no, which for them is all right, Rotten Tomatoes.
- 9:46Now, I think we're all aware this started on about 6%.
- 9:49Yes, yes. What do you think it's on
- 9:54currently 13, very close again 18 Ah, OK.
- 9:59It's on the rise. So I mean it couldn't get much
- 10:04lever and then finally letterboxed out of five.
- 10:11Are we talking maybe an average? Yeah, yeah.
- 10:14Like 1.8. Very close 1.7.
- 10:19God. What?
- 10:22One point, do you know for letterbox?
- 10:23That's all right. Do.
- 10:26You have a real problem with the letterbox average scores that
- 10:30you usually grant. Because it's just fucking wrong.
- 10:34Always wrong. Do you know I've got a letterbox
- 10:37to count? Yeah, and you're wrong as well.
- 10:40I have. I have two.
- 10:41Yeah, I like letterbox. There you go.
- 10:42Yeah, popular platform Grant. No, don't.
- 10:46Care. Let's move on to talk about the
- 10:49story elements then of return the two Silent Hills.
- 10:52So this is a I'm going to say reimagining.
- 10:57I was going to say adaptation, but yeah, I can see by your
- 11:02face, Sam. So let's maybe say reimagining
- 11:04Silent Hill too. The main story beats are kind of
- 11:09similar. We have our characters from the
- 11:11video game, but Christoph Ganz has chosen to implement some of
- 11:17his own ideas, let's say, and remove some of the original
- 11:22ideas. It's a bit of an odd mix here,
- 11:24isn't it really? So, Sam, do you want to start us
- 11:27off with your thoughts about the story in general?
- 11:30Yeah, sure. I think there are sort of
- 11:36potential liberties taken here with the story.
- 11:39I think it's for me opens up on the wrong note completely.
- 11:43While we are following the basic premise of the second game, I
- 11:46think that this film opens up quite strangely and on sort of a
- 11:51really positive upbeat note. And I think that that while, you
- 11:54know, to potentially could be you to disarm the viewer, I
- 11:57think for me just felt wrong instantly.
- 12:00And that's that it left an immediate impression sort of
- 12:02like, oh, OK. And it surprised me a little bit
- 12:06as well. And I think story wise, you
- 12:09know, I think, I mean, so many of us know the the story to
- 12:13Silent Hill too. But I think that a lot of people
- 12:14that will be watching this that haven't played the video game
- 12:16are going to sort of think what's going on here.
- 12:20And I'm not sure that they're going to be able to sort of
- 12:22piece the parts together, especially when it comes to sort
- 12:25of and what, you know, we'll probably dive into this later.
- 12:27But when it comes to Abstract Daddy and it comes to Angela,
- 12:29and you know, the significance of Angela's character and the
- 12:32fact that so many people resonate with Angela's character
- 12:36as well, they're not going to be able to do that with this film.
- 12:38And I think that that's a huge part of why it falls down for
- 12:41me. Yeah, yeah, that's kind of Fair.
- 12:44It is a bit of a strange opening.
- 12:47I was surprised with how they portrayed James at the start.
- 12:51Me too. Me too, to be honest.
- 12:52Grant what? What about you?
- 12:55Yeah, I'd say that's fair. I'd say that the the opening is
- 12:58a little bit not what I was expecting, but I think I got
- 13:01carried away with the excitement of it all when I was just like
- 13:03finally silent here. I don't even think I was paying
- 13:05attention for the 1st 15 minutes because I was just like Silent
- 13:07Hill. Silent Hill.
- 13:08Yeah, I just, for me, obviously in the game, James seems very
- 13:12somber. He's a very sort of he seems
- 13:15quite guarded, soft spoken. And then the film, he was kind
- 13:19of like bombing down the highway listening to some loud music,
- 13:22smoking a joint. Yeah, seemed an odd, an odd
- 13:25character choice to make. But then I was thinking, did
- 13:28they just basically have him smoke in the joint so it
- 13:30distracted him so he then swerved to Mr. Lorry to then
- 13:34knock Mary's cases over? I mean, they could have done
- 13:39that in any manner really, couldn't they?
- 13:41Could have had a phone call, could have, I don't know, just
- 13:43seen some. Because on the the flashback or
- 13:46whatever, right at the very end, he's not.
- 13:48I don't believe he's smoking a joint then.
- 13:51No, we'll come on to that later. I've got a couple of interesting
- 13:54theories about the ending. So so.
- 13:58But yeah, the story overall. I see.
- 14:01I would say I'm quite a big Silent Hill fan.
- 14:04I'm currently playing second, the remake of the second one.
- 14:07I'm near the end, so I'm nearly there.
- 14:08I was trying to rush through it for this.
- 14:09I was trying to get there, you know, Rush.
- 14:11Yeah, No, I know. Like 6 months.
- 14:15Fuck off. I might, I might have stopped
- 14:17for a bit and then realised it's a better hurry up.
- 14:20So I've rushed through it in the last few days.
- 14:22Let's say I'm I'm near the bit where you've got the 2 pyramid
- 14:25heads. So I'm I'm nearly there.
- 14:27Yeah. Yeah, yeah, Completely forgot
- 14:31where I'm going with this. I don't know.
- 14:34No, but the story does differ. He takes liberties with it.
- 14:38He he squishes characters together.
- 14:41He completely changes character arcs of Mary, Angela, even Laura
- 14:47to some degree I think as well. And Eddie?
- 14:49What? Why Why?
- 14:51Let's should we talk about Eddie briefly?
- 14:53Yeah, definitely. Because there's a, there's a
- 14:55huge impact on this and I think it had a lot of people upset,
- 14:57didn't it? Yeah, I mean, the film version,
- 15:00there's no relevance to Eddie. Am I, am I right?
- 15:03He. He he, he doesn't feel like
- 15:05Eddie. He doesn't remotely resemble
- 15:07him. And while he meets him in sort
- 15:09of a similar scenario, there's one huge error here, and I'm
- 15:13more than happy for you guys to announce it, But something that
- 15:16Eddie does that he just shouldn't be able to do in this
- 15:18film, something he sees. Yeah, yeah, of course.
- 15:22Yeah, yeah. He shouldn't be able.
- 15:24He shouldn't be able to see Pyramid Head.
- 15:26Right. Not at all.
- 15:27Pyramid Head is a manifestation of James's guilt and that need
- 15:31for punishment. So why can Eddie see it?
- 15:35Yeah, and, and I think that that immediately and the fact that we
- 15:38don't even see him again, and he's such a significant part of
- 15:42the game as well, the fact that we don't see him again and and
- 15:45we almost break that wall instantly that Oh no, he's
- 15:49priming heads just there. Well, that's the whole point is
- 15:52the fact that only James can see him because like you say, he's a
- 15:54manifestation of James's psyche. So instantly you're sort of
- 15:58like, oh God, not only for me, respectfully to the actor.
- 16:01Is that a little bit of bad casting?
- 16:04But we've instantly just not understood the story of Eddie
- 16:06and and not understood the story of Pyramid Head, which in my
- 16:09opinion is one of the most significant elements of Silent
- 16:11Hill too. Yeah, I I don't disagree.
- 16:15Yeah, obviously they used Pyramid Head, didn't they, in
- 16:18Silent Hill One which obviously in a in a fan's eyes is a
- 16:23mistake. But I think in a casual film
- 16:25kind of viewing the the fans would need like a, they'd need
- 16:30like a big bad, like not not just Christabella, but they need
- 16:35like a a monster, a big bad monster, you know?
- 16:37Something to be scared. Of so obviously they they put
- 16:40him in there and then they kind of have got themselves trapped
- 16:43in this place of shit. We've kind of got to carry that
- 16:46on. And I think that's partly where
- 16:49Christoph goes wrong here. He tries his he sorry, he tries
- 16:53to please both sets of fans. So he's trying to put stuff in
- 16:56there from the game. So the game fans go, oh look,
- 16:59that's in the game. And then he's trying to put
- 17:02things in there that a casual film fan, I think this is cool
- 17:05and they'll understand the story, but he's kind of missed
- 17:09the mark on both sides because of that.
- 17:12Yeah, yeah, it's hard. It's really hard.
- 17:15Yeah. I, I believe that he does have a
- 17:17passion for the project. I think so do I Yeah, I I think
- 17:21you can see that with the first one especially and some of the
- 17:26elements of this one, like he wanted to use a lot of practical
- 17:28effects. He wanted it to feel real.
- 17:31And one of the interviews I saw, he said 70 to 75% of this film
- 17:36is is practical, which I applaud, I think.
- 17:39Yeah. Great.
- 17:40Brilliant. Definitely me too.
- 17:41Yeah, me too. I think that the monsters look
- 17:43good. Yeah, yeah.
- 17:45I don't think they were the issue, really.
- 17:48Yeah. Neither do I.
- 17:50What did we get early on? We get what?
- 17:51What's the grant? What's the harmless one called
- 17:54where it's all tied up beyond his back?
- 17:55Just called the harmless. Man, fair enough.
- 17:59All right, difficult about it, no.
- 18:01No. Fair.
- 18:02OK. The lion figure.
- 18:04There you go. That's it.
- 18:05That's it. Yeah.
- 18:06You think I'd know that, but yeah, I'm pretty sure it is.
- 18:10Yeah. The Lion, the.
- 18:10Lion figures, yeah. Because in the game they they
- 18:13scurry about on the floor, don't they before?
- 18:15Oh, sorry. Yeah, I know what you mean.
- 18:17Yeah, they're in in the first one.
- 18:18They're called the Armless, Armless Man.
- 18:20All right. So I mean I thought that looked
- 18:22great. You could see, you could see
- 18:25that was practical. Obviously they have CG to the
- 18:27the arms off and the lighting and everything else.
- 18:29But I did have the arms attached to the back under like a layer
- 18:32layer of skin. Especially when I liked that,
- 18:34yeah. Yeah, when James is hiding
- 18:35behind the car with the radio, I thought that was a nice touch
- 18:37because I did always wonder where are their arms?
- 18:38And I know. In the yeah, yeah.
- 18:40In the in the first one with the making of documentary, we learn
- 18:42it's like a cage around the actor's arms and he's kind of
- 18:45like that. But I like this one that they
- 18:47took the time to sort of put that sort of faint see through
- 18:51skin on the monster. And so yeah, you can see it's
- 18:54arms for that was unique. Yeah, yeah, definitely.
- 18:57I like that that was it was a good future design.
- 19:00And I quite like the scene that involved as well, where it kind
- 19:02of spews everything out of his chest area and it melts the IT
- 19:05melts the homeless guy, didn't it?
- 19:07Yeah, yeah. So he's short lived, isn't he?
- 19:09But yeah, really, really well done scene.
- 19:12You know, I, I, I, I haven't got anything to say about that
- 19:14scene. Really well done.
- 19:15And I do like that they because I know there's some things that
- 19:18differ from the game, but I do also like a lot of things where
- 19:21they pay respect to the game. So before we get to that scene,
- 19:24the the scene where James parks up, I remember nudging you, Ben,
- 19:28and saying that's like exactly from the game, like where the
- 19:30toilet's placed down the steps down into the graveyard, like it
- 19:33was exact. And then when we get to the
- 19:36armless man scene, even where James is running through the
- 19:39streets and the whole thing is fenced off, I remember that
- 19:41being unbelievably irritating in the game because you just
- 19:43obviously want to get get by, don't you?
- 19:45And they've done the same thing in the film and and the radio
- 19:49crackling especially even though Ben, you did point out a plot
- 19:52there, a plot hole there that why did it stop crackling?
- 19:55I did, yeah. A little bit later on when when
- 19:57he's with Maria, it crackles because obviously, you know,
- 20:01they're in danger. He's like, oh, no, you know,
- 20:02that means something's nearby. And they hide behind the car and
- 20:06the lion figure is right close to them, but the radio stopped
- 20:09crackling so. Just so close it couldn't
- 20:12crackle. Yeah, it broke.
- 20:15It broke the radio. We'll go with that.
- 20:17I mean, it's just a small thing I would say, but I don't know,
- 20:20it takes you out of that immersion a little bit because
- 20:22obviously in the game the louder the crackle, the closer the
- 20:25monster is. But is it the?
- 20:27Point where you get so scared that you can't hear anything
- 20:29around you. Do you reckon it's part of that?
- 20:32Maybe I'm going to go with that because it makes, maybe it makes
- 20:36it. Sound loud it.
- 20:37Sounds. That's my head cannon, yeah.
- 20:39Yeah, we'll go with that. I personally think they just
- 20:43didn't think about it. Didn't need your extra input
- 20:46there, Ben. They're all worried about that.
- 20:48Sentence finished. I'm sorry, Grant.
- 20:51OK. I also quite liked that when
- 20:55James is running about through the streets and stuff, he looks
- 20:59at the street signs, doesn't he? So all three of those streets
- 21:04are actually in the game and it's.
- 21:07Almost in in a bit of homage to the first one where Radha uses
- 21:10all the bus stop signs. Yeah, yeah.
- 21:12But like I say, they're actually the streets.
- 21:14He's he's took the time to find out the street names and add
- 21:17them in. That shows a nice bit of detail,
- 21:20I think the little bug creature that's in the toilet near the
- 21:23start, I quite liked that because it foreshadows later on
- 21:27where all the bugs come out. And again, obviously in the game
- 21:30you have to smack them with a pole, don't you?
- 21:32Now and again. Yeah, they're annoying.
- 21:34They. Always follow.
- 21:35They are annoying around the first one, don't you?
- 21:36Yeah, because again, your radio will go off and you're looking
- 21:38at everyone like what the fuck's that?
- 21:39What the fuck's that? And it's a tiny little bug on
- 21:41the floor. Yeah, yeah.
- 21:42It's a good way of trickling. Yeah, yeah.
- 21:44I remember that because you just want the peace and quiet, don't
- 21:46you? Yeah, or you're you're ready for
- 21:49something massive in front of you, not a.
- 21:50Stupid little mannequin arm leg fuckers hiding up.
- 21:53Oh don't, don't. Those fucking yeah the double
- 21:56legged mannequin things in the game are the scariest sucky
- 21:59things ever to me. Agree.
- 22:01Yeah, well, they, they, they hide, don't they?
- 22:03They hide and they're also. What do you mean this?
- 22:08Yeah, they're not. That is one creature that they
- 22:11don't put. In Isn't that what Pyramid has
- 22:13in the game? Gets a bit naughty with?
- 22:15Doesn't he get naughty with one of them?
- 22:16Yeah. Yeah, absolutely.
- 22:18It's like a manifestation of like James's like desire, isn't
- 22:22it? As well as the nurses serve that
- 22:24as well, like his. I think it's like sexual
- 22:25frustration almost, isn't it? Yeah, no, you're right.
- 22:29It's it's similar with the Maria character, isn't it?
- 22:31He's seeing her as the kind of woman he wants married to be
- 22:34again and all that. Unfortunately they, well, I say,
- 22:38unfortunately I don't know. The creature that they chose to
- 22:40implement instead of the double legged mannequin thing was some
- 22:43kind of, it was, I am right in thinking, well, it was Mary on
- 22:47the floor wasn't it? Naked with a bald head.
- 22:50I didn't. Pick that up.
- 22:52Oh. That yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 22:53Yeah, OK. Yeah, yeah.
- 22:55And I didn't, I think, did I pick you up that it was Mary?
- 22:58At this point I was probably just frustrated.
- 23:00But yeah, that makes sense, I suppose, doesn't it?
- 23:02And then, you know, considering what we've spoken about, that
- 23:05would be like his repressed desire, etcetera.
- 23:07Yeah, I suppose, yeah. But it was nothing like the
- 23:10things in the game, did it? No, this, this was a made-up one
- 23:13for the movie but I didn't mind it.
- 23:16The head rolls off and then he turns into some strange spider
- 23:19creature, doesn't it really? I did find it funny what they
- 23:22did though, because he puts the monster on the table.
- 23:26He was like, is he? Isn't he?
- 23:28Yeah. Is he going to do it?
- 23:30Yeah. No, he just.
- 23:31He just beats him up. Yeah, I guess it's.
- 23:34Probably the right choice to be better for cinema.
- 23:36Yeah, it was a bit of an odd scene though, because he's just
- 23:38like, punching it in the belly. Yeah, but I think it's like, I
- 23:42think, again, just what you've touched on though, it's a bit of
- 23:44Christopher trying to do things for everyone.
- 23:46He's because I was like, I just said, I was like, oh God, is he
- 23:49actually going to put that in it?
- 23:51Because he puts him in the position on the table, so he's
- 23:54got all the games going. But then for everyone else that
- 23:56doesn't get it, they're just like, oh, he's just going to
- 23:58kill him. That's true.
- 24:00That's. True, and as I said, you can't
- 24:02really. In this day and age, there's no
- 24:04way you get away with putting that in.
- 24:05It'll do even worse at the box office than it already has.
- 24:08Yeah, yeah. It could have been hinted
- 24:10though, couldn't it? Like, it was it like in the
- 24:11remake, it's hinted that that sort of happened and you can
- 24:15just sort of piece it together in in this.
- 24:17It's just it's not really done that way.
- 24:20Yeah, they do. I do a lot to say sorry.
- 24:22Go on. No.
- 24:23No, I was going to say what I really do like about this scene,
- 24:25and it's because when we were watching it, I knew obviously he
- 24:28was in the apartment block and I was like, if he goes and hides
- 24:30in the cupboard, then this is unbelievable because just from
- 24:33the game, remember that from the original and the remake, and
- 24:35then what does he do? Goes hides in the cupboard.
- 24:37So that's little things like me. Does that make it an automatic
- 24:4110 out of 10 for you? Yeah.
- 24:42Yeah, yeah, no, no, no. Like it's my overall theme with
- 24:47it. Like, I know it's far from
- 24:48perfect, but I love it when a film respects the source
- 24:51material. Whether or not Christopher's hit
- 24:54the mark with it, he you can tell he's respected the game.
- 24:58But in my opinion, So that's why it kind of gets a pass with me
- 25:02and that's why it gets a bit higher than it probably should
- 25:04be if it was something else. Like if I had a real love for
- 25:08monkeys, Primate would have got a three out of 10 and not a 2
- 25:10out of 10. Oh, God, don't.
- 25:13I don't. What about sinners, by the way?
- 25:15Fuck sinners. No, I'm kidding.
- 25:18Stop bringing sinners up angry to raging.
- 25:23Anyway, so let's talk about Pyramid Head or Red Red Pyramid
- 25:28as is actually. Is his technical term yes.
- 25:30Yeah, I've. I've always known him as Pyramid
- 25:32Head until no. Me too.
- 25:34Yeah, me too. OK, it's not just me.
- 25:36That's good to know. I mean, even in this book, would
- 25:39you believe it? I'll just flicked on a page and
- 25:40it right there it says Pyramid Head.
- 25:43Oh. So even in this book it says
- 25:44Pyramid, but he is he is red Pyramid.
- 25:47How did we feel about him in general in this not, not the
- 25:52story connotation of him, we'll come on to that, but just his,
- 25:55his look, his, his stature, his presence.
- 25:59How do we feel about that after you?
- 26:01Thank you, I I thought he looked absolutely spot on.
- 26:05I thought the size made sense. The helmet looks right.
- 26:08I think in the first one you've got him as like this big Hulk in
- 26:10Behemoth. And while it's cool and it makes
- 26:12for some great scenes, it isn't Pyramid Head the same as sort of
- 26:17he was introduced in Silent Hill too.
- 26:19You know, it's many be it's always eluded.
- 26:21I mean, this is right on the nose with it, but it's always
- 26:23eluded that it's Jane's under that mask and that's why they're
- 26:25the same size. And he's a little bit sort of
- 26:27almost a little bit pathetic, isn't he?
- 26:29And he sort of walks with a hunch, etcetera.
- 26:31And I like the fact that we brought that Pyramid Head here.
- 26:34I thought that the helmet was really good.
- 26:37I thought the look was really good.
- 26:38The the groaning, the moaning, you know, I was excited when I
- 26:40was sat in the cinema and I realised that he was on his way
- 26:43because I was just sort of like here we go.
- 26:58So overall I thought the look was perfect.
- 27:01I wish we'd have got a bit more. Oh, got you couldn't.
- 27:05Agree more with that. Grant, do you want to go into
- 27:08your thoughts about him? I'm kind of much the same and I
- 27:11definitely would have loved to have seen him a hell of a lot
- 27:14more. I will say that what threw me
- 27:18off, to be fair, was that he was quite vocal that he was
- 27:21shouting. Like I know Silent Hill, to just
- 27:23be this silent mask wearing monster and then to hear him
- 27:28sort of groaning and shouting and stuff threw me off.
- 27:32But I will say when he comes back for his little return near
- 27:36the end with Maria, that was an incredible scene, an incredible
- 27:39kill scene and I wasn't expecting it at all.
- 27:42And I know that it ties in with the game, but I I often forget
- 27:46all about you don't like I don't I'm not watching that film going
- 27:49on. It's this point in the game,
- 27:50like I just don't. I don't always remember things
- 27:53Dog and. Yeah, yeah, that's my dog again.
- 27:56Yeah, yeah, I was. Surprised and I thought it was
- 27:59done well. Yeah, I'm in agreement.
- 28:01Yeah, the the scaled down sort of this made more sense.
- 28:05Like you say. The one thing I was a little not
- 28:11taken aback by, but I didn't think like, you know, in the old
- 28:14one, like they make the sword look really heavy and stuff.
- 28:17I thought that just lacked a little bit in this one.
- 28:19But then again, then again, we didn't really see enough of him
- 28:22to make a sort of a full judgement on all his movements.
- 28:25More doesn't. He tries to smash his head
- 28:27through the gate. Yeah, he does.
- 28:29He does didn't like that. I just I really like the idea of
- 28:36when you put when he first enters those apartments, he's
- 28:38just sort of looking at him and you know, the gamer and James
- 28:41probably think what is that? You know, and it sort of just
- 28:44doesn't move and it adds a little bit of a weird tension in
- 28:46the air. And I think, you know, I mean,
- 28:48Christophe Dan's, he's got a, he has got a short of screen time
- 28:50to work with, so things have to probably move along a little bit
- 28:53quicker. But yeah, I think him just
- 28:56bashing you through, I know it sort of provides more of a
- 28:58threat and stuff, but I liked that ominous feel that you sort
- 29:01of think, well, what's that thing's intention if it's just
- 29:03going to look at me through that fence.
- 29:05And I think we almost lost that a little bit, if that makes
- 29:07sense. Yeah, I agree.
- 29:09It doesn't. It doesn't.
- 29:11It doesn't linger on the look of Pyramid Head.
- 29:14You know, there's a bit I've just done in the game actually,
- 29:17that I'm going down a ladder. There's a sort of a bit of a red
- 29:20background behind. And Pyramid Head is just
- 29:23standing there. He's he's been chasing you and
- 29:25he's just standing there. And I was like, what the fuck?
- 29:28But is he going to come after me?
- 29:29Is he just, what's he doing? And it adds, like you say, Sam,
- 29:32it adds that sense of tension and fear.
- 29:35Yeah, it does, yeah. Completely.
- 29:37Whereas the head butting thing, yeah, it didn't overly do it for
- 29:39me. I understand why they put it in,
- 29:41you know again. I do casually, I understand.
- 29:43Yeah, that's it. They need a they need a big
- 29:45monster, don't they like, And then how do we feel about the
- 29:49the very on the nose point that they made that you see twice if
- 29:52it's zooming through the helmet and you see it's James,
- 29:55obviously it's just hinted at in in the games and stuff, isn't
- 29:58it? You slowly put the pieces
- 29:59together, whereas in the film they make it abundantly clear
- 30:04this is this is the other side of James kind.
- 30:07Of thing, I think like I mean as much as I probably would say
- 30:09it's better in the game, they kind of have to like it's an
- 30:11hour and a half an hour 45 movie.
- 30:13Like they can't hint too much and they can't take their time
- 30:16too much. They've just got to go for it on
- 30:17the no sometimes. And I whether or not it was
- 30:20great or not, I feel like it was necessary.
- 30:23I can completely understand that viewpoint, you know, I think.
- 30:27But sometimes, you know, I think some questions are best left
- 30:30unanswered. I like the fact that Silent Hill
- 30:322, the game has never fully gave given us that answer, even
- 30:35though we kind of already know. I think I would have preferred
- 30:38it that way just to sort of make a maybe a slight hint, something
- 30:44to give us away. But yeah, I feel for me a little
- 30:48bit on the nose. Yeah, I, I think it was on the
- 30:52nose. And to do it twice.
- 30:54I didn't mind the fact that when the siren went off, you had
- 30:57Pyramid Head to mimic James's movement.
- 31:00I thought that maybe, yeah, I thought maybe that would have
- 31:03been enough. But no, they do give you the
- 31:05full through the helmet shot so. Absolutely.
- 31:09I don't know. It's kind of tricky, isn't it?
- 31:10Because obviously I have all the game stuff in my head.
- 31:12I can't Unsee that. Yeah.
- 31:15So I would quite like to hear an opinion from someone who has no
- 31:18clue about the games, You know, if they like that, if it helped
- 31:21them understand the story. Yeah, it'd be good to know.
- 31:25Yeah, yeah. I mean, one of my biggest
- 31:27critiques with this film is that I feel that people are going to
- 31:30go into this film that haven't played the game and then just
- 31:33they're just not going to understand what was going on.
- 31:35They're not going to, I don't think they're going to
- 31:37understand who Maria was, just some random chick that showed
- 31:39up. I don't think they're going to
- 31:41understand that she's a manifestation of what James
- 31:44wants Mary to be. I don't think that that rings
- 31:46clear whatsoever. I, I think, you know, they've
- 31:49obviously made Angela and they've combined those
- 31:51characters and I can see what he did there with the father and
- 31:54the cult stuff. I think that we've got to, we're
- 31:56going to touch on that, aren't we?
- 31:57I can see what he did there, but there was just things that I
- 32:01think were sort of, I, I think people that are going into this
- 32:04film that just don't have a clue.
- 32:05But like that first film, I, I, me personally, I think they're
- 32:09going to walk away disappointedly thinking, I, I
- 32:11just don't understand. Yeah, I think that's a fairpoint
- 32:14as well, actually. Like I said, I can't see it from
- 32:16someone who hasn't played the game.
- 32:17So I I know what's going on, but it could be very confusing for
- 32:21somebody. The Pyramid Head stuff, yeah,
- 32:24All the different characters that just come and go for no
- 32:27reason half the time, and then some pretty cool set pieces and
- 32:31some good sets. Yeah, some really good set
- 32:34pieces. There's a beautiful imagery as
- 32:36well at times. There is, there is.
- 32:39Yeah. What what was your favorite
- 32:40parts of the imagery would you say for out here?
- 32:43Even though it didn't really, it didn't really strike a call with
- 32:47me at the time. I do think the the scene of him
- 32:49sort of towards her and her arms outstretched in the sort of moth
- 32:52form and you know, the sort of the background, the orange sort
- 32:56of like template if you like, with all the Moss flying around.
- 33:00I thought it looked beautiful. I did think that that looked
- 33:02cool and I thought the nurses were doing really well.
- 33:05I actually really liked the nurses in this film.
- 33:08Fine for. Me.
- 33:10That's that's yeah, I'm surprising to touch on that
- 33:12because the nurses were something I was surprised about.
- 33:14I think you were a little bit as well, weren't you?
- 33:16Oh, good. Yeah, yeah, I wasn't expecting
- 33:17that. And I would say first, first
- 33:19scene, I wasn't sure. I think I was like, what have
- 33:23they done here? Why has he gone with this route?
- 33:24But then when, when we sort of read up on it and the the theme
- 33:30that the, I don't know what you call them, but the guy that had
- 33:32put all the monsters together, he that he went for, kind of
- 33:35made it really cool sounding. Yeah, yeah, I got.
- 33:38To word it in a better way. But then I was like, Oh yeah, I
- 33:40get it now, actually, that's really good.
- 33:42Yeah, I did that. I came out after the film
- 33:44thinking, well, what the fuck? Why have they done that to the
- 33:46nurses? So I don't like that, especially
- 33:49when they're all walking together at once and it looks
- 33:51really odd. And they made them like
- 33:53porcelain. I was like, what?
- 33:54What is this? Why?
- 33:55That was the one issue I had, the porcelain stuff.
- 33:57So I I think you guys are about to drop something on me.
- 34:01But it makes sense when you're in it.
- 34:02But then in France, to people watching the movie, like you
- 34:05wouldn't know any of this. No, but they the the creature
- 34:09creator can't think of his name. He he decided that he was going
- 34:13to make their faces like part like Beehive and then their
- 34:18bodies. He based it on Japanese pottery.
- 34:21Right. I mean, it explains why they
- 34:24sort of crashed apart when James hit them.
- 34:27There's no real reasoning other than the fact that I think he
- 34:30just wanted to do something that wasn't seen before.
- 34:34OK, so I kind of get it. But when there's something so
- 34:37iconic as the nurses, the bubble head nurses and all that from
- 34:40Silent Hill, you're kind of expecting the nurses that we've
- 34:43had previously. Yeah, it gradually got worse, if
- 34:46I'm honest. The the one, the nurses in the
- 34:49first one were just, you know, terrifying to me, seeing that
- 34:53for the first time and Rose standing there and being frozen,
- 34:55having to weave herself through. Yeah, I'm really scary.
- 34:58Yeah, and then Revelation. They were just fucking stupid.
- 35:02Still haven't seen that. Yeah.
- 35:04Don't, don't worry about it. They were, they were.
- 35:09No, to be fair, the nurses were fine in the second one.
- 35:11It was the, the, the cultists were the idiots.
- 35:14They just come into this room full of nurses, like, oh, all
- 35:16right, guys, like, oh, no, now they're killing me.
- 35:19Like, come on. That's it.
- 35:20It's the idiot human characters. Yeah, but in in this one, in
- 35:23Return of Silent Hill, they almost seem like an
- 35:25afterthought. Yeah, I would agree with that.
- 35:28The guy that made the monsters, that was where he started.
- 35:30He started with the nurse design.
- 35:33But I'm again, again, you just don't see it for long enough.
- 35:35It's way too quick. Way too.
- 35:37I agree. They're so significant.
- 35:39Aren't the, you know, the hospital section, etcetera.
- 35:40And how many cosplayers do you see at these horror events that
- 35:43are doing the nurses because they're so iconic?
- 35:45You know, a lot of people set see that, you know, as part of
- 35:48Silent Hill too. The nurses stand at the side of
- 35:50Pyramid Head. I think an argument can be made
- 35:52that Pyramid Heads probably the mascot for Silent Hill at this
- 35:55point, but that's why he's in those sorts 1st 2 films.
- 35:58But I I do think that the nurses, although I really liked
- 36:01the scene, I completely agree with the fact that they just
- 36:03weren't in it for very long. Yeah, they they.
- 36:08Revelation, though in it they they weren't in Revelation long
- 36:10enough. No, they needed a slower build
- 36:12up. You know, a glimpse of them here
- 36:14or there when you've suddenly got 30 of them in a hallway and
- 36:18they will come rushing forwards. You you don't have a minute to
- 36:21take it in. Yeah, I get that.
- 36:23Yeah. There's no build up, no tension
- 36:25building, etcetera. Yeah.
- 36:26I I wouldn't feel mad if they did the same as the first one
- 36:29though, you know, even if they just copied it, like I wouldn't
- 36:31have cared because it's so, it's so such a tense scene.
- 36:35I think it could have worked. It is a really tense scene in
- 36:37that first film. I, I, I on the record, by the
- 36:40way, I, I really liked that first film.
- 36:42I think it's great. Like I really do, you know, I, I
- 36:45think it's solid. Yeah, I'm slightly obsessed with
- 36:47it. Yeah, it's great.
- 36:48And I think that's why this one cut cut deep for me because I, I
- 36:52mean, I, I did a video sort of saying, you know, I think I feel
- 36:56like nobody's given giving return to Silent Hill the
- 36:59attention that it deserves. Then I watched it.
- 37:04Yeah, I'm not going to lie, Edwell, Sam, as you know, I did
- 37:07get a little worried that you and Grant were just going to end
- 37:09up in a massive verbal argument. You know, I was like, oh,
- 37:13fucking hell, this could go so wrong here.
- 37:15What have I done? That's all.
- 37:16Good. It's all subjective, isn't it?
- 37:19That's all. Opinion based.
- 37:20Absolutely. And I think that's the joy.
- 37:22That's the joy. I love the fact I'm seeing
- 37:25people because I, I mean, I put out a review for this film and I
- 37:27blasted it and I always will. If, you know, if I feel that
- 37:30way, the fact that people are watching this film and they're
- 37:33enjoying this film, I think it's fantastic.
- 37:35I, I'm jealous. I wish that I could have that
- 37:37feeling. And you're not wrong for
- 37:38enjoying that film because if you genuinely go into this film
- 37:41and you enjoy the imagery, you love the game, and you're happy
- 37:44with the direction that the film took, good for you, more power
- 37:48to you. And I said the same with the
- 37:49Star Wars sequels as well. You know, I think if you're
- 37:52finding enjoyment in those films where, you know, where I can't,
- 37:56as someone that's a huge fan of the franchise and a new fan of
- 37:58the franchise in Silent Hill, good for you.
- 38:01I'm never going to knock you if you're doing that.
- 38:02I think that's fantastic. And and I want to know why you
- 38:04looked it. Tell me why you liked it so
- 38:06much. I'm interested.
- 38:08I'd like to know why people like sinners.
- 38:10Oh. God.
- 38:11Wow, many reasons. I mean, I'd love sinners.
- 38:14That's. Gonna say.
- 38:16I can't think of 1. OK.
- 38:20No, Sam, I'm I'm glad. I'm glad you touched on though.
- 38:23If people do get enjoyment from this, obviously I got a bit from
- 38:26it. Grant got everything you wanted
- 38:28from it. But.
- 38:31I, I can understand, you know, both sides of the argument where
- 38:35fans get fans of the games are like, you've changed too much of
- 38:37the story, ETC. I'm a I'm a big fan of the
- 38:40games, as as I keep saying, and I was OK with some of the the
- 38:44story changes because I think they make sense for a film kind
- 38:48of reason. So let me give you an example.
- 38:51The the whole adding the cult stuff back in from the first
- 38:55one. It's it's not ideal, but when
- 38:58you then look at the later change of Angela's character,
- 39:02it's kind of like it's something needed to be in there about the
- 39:07sort of abuse that Mary had suffered.
- 39:10And if you know Angela's story, then making it Mary's father
- 39:13makes sense. Obviously it's a bit out of
- 39:17place. It's a bit odd because I don't
- 39:18even really know what they were doing to her, to be honest.
- 39:20I don't think anyone knows. A bit like Eddie as well,
- 39:22doesn't it? I, I think it's hard with Angela
- 39:25though, isn't it? Angela is a very significant
- 39:27character to a lot of the fandom, especially I think the
- 39:30female fandom in Silent Hill, which is huge, by the way, as
- 39:32I've found. And I think Angela's so
- 39:34significant because she's purely A victim and she's looking for a
- 39:37mother. She's going through this
- 39:38traumatic time. And personally, to me, I think
- 39:40stripping that and, and just shoving that into Mary's, you
- 39:44know, Mary's arc, I think it hurt.
- 39:47It hurt the film for me because I think the whole point of
- 39:49Angela walking towards her purgatory in the game and Angela
- 39:53sort of being, you know, abstract daddy, which is a
- 39:56significant sort of, you know, villain in this Silent Hill sort
- 39:59of thing. And I completely understand why
- 40:01they, like you said, the interweb, you know, with the
- 40:03cult, etcetera. But for me, I would have left
- 40:06that out and I would have kept things out.
- 40:07They were, I would have had the character Angela searching for a
- 40:10mother at the same time, still reeling from the fact that she
- 40:12was abused by her father. Because like, I think it's such,
- 40:16like some people that I've spoken to, and especially since
- 40:19I did my video, they've said that Angela's story is the most
- 40:21significant part of the story for them because they've been
- 40:24able to be unfortunately relate or they've been able to sort of,
- 40:28you know, sort of I, I think really feel for Angela.
- 40:30And I don't think people are going to have that same punch
- 40:32with the film. Yeah.
- 40:34I mean, I'm not. No, it's all good.
- 40:35I'm not. I'm not enamoured with the
- 40:37changes he made. I'm just saying I can kind of
- 40:39see why he's got 130 minutes to get a 20 hour game, you know?
- 40:46Yeah, and he's going to take it into that first film, isn't he?
- 40:48That's it. That's it.
- 40:49I mean, I don't know if that was his decision, a studio decision
- 40:53or what, but yeah, for some reason somebody along the line
- 40:56decided this has to tie into the first one.
- 40:59You know, they made they made a big thing about, oh, this is the
- 41:02original director, so. Yes, they did.
- 41:05It makes sense to connect it back to the Weld he partially
- 41:08created. I just, yeah.
- 41:11I mean, if they added the true Angela storyline, the arc in
- 41:15there, which obviously is very dark, it's very emotional, very
- 41:18upsetting. And and you do feel absolutely
- 41:22terrible for her. You really do.
- 41:24How would they have woven that in there amongst, you know,
- 41:27James and Mary? They might have then thought,
- 41:30there's the runtime's going to be too long.
- 41:32You know, I think they just wanted the focus to be on James
- 41:35and Mary's love story. That's why I made that decision.
- 41:39But maybe it would have been better if they just didn't put
- 41:42the Angela storyline in there. Yeah, maybe I again, it's one of
- 41:46those, isn't it? He sort of tried considering
- 41:49what we said about Angela and, and the fact that it is so
- 41:52significant. You know, I think he tried,
- 41:54didn't he? He tried to sort of bring in the
- 41:56abstract daddy stuff. And he even said I, I remember
- 41:59sort of reading that abstract daddy was absolutely his
- 42:01favorite monster to to portray in this film.
- 42:03Even though it's for a split second, I still think that the
- 42:07the average view is just going to I think you can piece
- 42:10together that that's, you know, abstract daddy and that, you
- 42:14know, that's going to be her father and what happened and
- 42:16stuff. But I almost feel that if we
- 42:19could have brought Angela in as the side counsel like she is and
- 42:21maybe she assists James etcetera and and contributes to the plot
- 42:25in that way, then I think that could have that that could have
- 42:28helped. It's it, like you say, it's hard
- 42:31with the runtime, isn't it? But how do you feel about the
- 42:33Maria stuff? Because I honestly feel that
- 42:36people are going to be so confused by Maria.
- 42:38Yeah, I agree, especially because they they just sort of,
- 42:43well, they kill her often and then forget about her.
- 42:46She she appears out of nowhere, just wandering aimlessly around
- 42:49Silent Hill, and then she just agrees to help James and then
- 42:52she flirts with him a little bit.
- 42:55I'm pretty they do actually kiss in the film didn't they as well?
- 42:58I think we do, yeah. Yeah, because they don't they
- 43:01don't in the game, do they? As far as I know, they get they
- 43:03get close. And she's more flirtatious,
- 43:05isn't she? And more like that.
- 43:07Yeah. I I'm a bit confused by it.
- 43:10Yeah. Why they didn't do more.
- 43:11How about you, Grant? I don't have to word this
- 43:14properly, but I think that's the gamers sort of understanding of
- 43:19it is, you know, you're expecting it.
- 43:23Are we wondering whether people are going to get it or not?
- 43:25And I'm and I don't think they would they do touch it a little
- 43:28bit because she does sort of say I look just like her, don't I?
- 43:31You know she she hints at it, but.
- 43:33Yeah, that's a good point. I don't know how to word it.
- 43:35So yeah, I don't think people would get that at all.
- 43:38But I don't know if for me watching it, I don't know if I
- 43:40cared if it's basically what I'm trying to say.
- 43:42I don't. Care people.
- 43:44Got it. Selfishly, I I kind of knew.
- 43:46I knew she was and I knew what she was doing and all and all
- 43:49suddenly. Yeah.
- 43:51Completely. But that's just my naivety.
- 43:52That's my like, stupid caveman approach to things.
- 43:55I'm a bit like fucking. I know she is.
- 43:58I do. I do think a casual movie gamer
- 44:00that hasn't played the games would be generally confused by
- 44:02the Maria character. Yeah, and well, I feel like you
- 44:05could explain it though, couldn't you?
- 44:07Because I remember playing the game.
- 44:08I was so confused by Maria. I was like, who is this woman
- 44:11and why is she in Silent Hill and why is she being so friendly
- 44:13towards me when we're in a state of panic because shit's trying
- 44:16to kill us, you know? And then and then when she does
- 44:20die a few times in the game and she's back, you're sort of like,
- 44:23oh, OK, this is obviously something to do with Silent
- 44:26Hill. You know, it's something to do
- 44:27with Jane, etcetera. Maybe like because I, I actually
- 44:31agree with Grant, the the scene where the killer off in the
- 44:34film's perfectly done. I love it.
- 44:35I think it's great. I don't like the fact he sort of
- 44:37tapped into his powers or whatever, whatever, and then
- 44:39suddenly she's gone. I thought that was a bit, you
- 44:41know, Avengers team up. But I did like, I did like the
- 44:44actual scene. I've been getting her and stuff.
- 44:46Bringing her back then would have provided a lot of context,
- 44:49I think a lot of new context to sort of say, I'm going to say
- 44:52she's obviously part, she's part of this.
- 44:54She's part of this weird sort of circle that's going on.
- 44:57Yeah, pretty. Good point, yeah.
- 44:59I think that's I'm, I'm in agreement with you guys.
- 45:01The scene, it's probably one of my favorite scenes in the film.
- 45:03You know, it looked incredible. It was tense.
- 45:06It was scary to a degree. But if if they did follow the
- 45:09game though and they did keep bringing Maria back, would that
- 45:11confuse non fans of the game more do you think?
- 45:15Probably, yeah. Or it gets.
- 45:17I mean, I don't know. I mean in general, right?
- 45:20The game is fairly. The game is confusing at times.
- 45:23It is. It is.
- 45:23Oh yeah, definitely. It's a mind bend, isn't it?
- 45:25That's the idea. That's it.
- 45:26That's it. You have to figure it out.
- 45:28You have to proper lock in and focus and you know I.
- 45:30Know this is off tangible. Sun Hill is very similar in that
- 45:33way. It hints a lot of themes and
- 45:34stories so. Is it?
- 45:36Yeah. I haven't played it.
- 45:37I'd love to. Yeah, it's very, very good.
- 45:38Yeah. But there's there's certain
- 45:40scenes in the game in there, there's certain puzzles to do,
- 45:42scarecrows and stuff. I won't bore you all, but it's
- 45:44very suggestive in that way as well.
- 45:46So I think in a way the film doesn't, it nails that
- 45:48confusion, whether it's on purpose or not.
- 45:52Yeah. Yeah, OK.
- 45:53I can see that. I don't know.
- 45:54It's, it's a mishmash, messy film.
- 45:57It plays around, yeah. It plays around with James.
- 45:59Is, is he mad? What is going on?
- 46:02You see him in the in the hospital like in, in normal
- 46:06time, and then you see him in Silent Hill.
- 46:09You're not quite sure whether he's gone insane.
- 46:12There's a lot going on in this hour and a half, I think.
- 46:14I I would say that the film not at any point would I have picked
- 46:19up that these are all representations of his of, you
- 46:22know, of his mindset and his guilt and whatnot.
- 46:24I wouldn't have said that at all.
- 46:25The only point where it becomes the only point where it becomes
- 46:29like, oh, what is this is where he goes back and he can re loop
- 46:32it with Mary. But above than that I wouldn't
- 46:35have ever. The reason?
- 46:37The idea the Pyramid Head was, you know, a reflection of him,
- 46:40etcetera. There is a scene that does
- 46:41explain it a little bit. So when you see James and Mary
- 46:44back in the apartment and he's trying to convince her to leave
- 46:48with him, he's like, I'm going, you come with me or you don't,
- 46:51you know, with this cult stuff, all your friends are weird.
- 46:53What I saw is too weird. I'm off.
- 46:55Come on, let's go. He does say about how some of
- 47:00the feelings are manifesting in that scene.
- 47:03Yeah. Yeah, OK.
- 47:04Yeah, that's a good point actually.
- 47:06But it is a little bit of a kind of he blurts it out so you could
- 47:09kind of miss. Some I don't remember.
- 47:11That I missed it. Yeah, I missed it.
- 47:13Yeah. And then?
- 47:14I missed that. I, I've, I've had the pleasure
- 47:16of seeing this twice. So yucky bastard, don't ask, I
- 47:23say. I say pleasure.
- 47:24You went back to the one more, Ben, one more.
- 47:28One, no, I I don't mind it, granted.
- 47:32But when you when you see a second time, you know, you can
- 47:36start putting more little bits and pieces together because you
- 47:38know what to expect. You've seen it already.
- 47:39So I was looking out for these little bits and pieces that
- 47:43indicate that these characters are part of James Psyche, that
- 47:46they're in his mind. And there are a few in there.
- 47:49They're just like a lot of stuff in here.
- 47:51They're not very well explained. You know we could do, Ben.
- 47:54What's that? By the book.
- 47:57Wait, what is it? Let's see the book.
- 47:59I, I What's the book? It's just a novelisation of it.
- 48:04Very cool. I won't mind a copy of that
- 48:05myself. Actually, I didn't realize
- 48:07because it's such a good story. It really is.
- 48:10And I'm such a new fan. Do you know what I mean?
- 48:12Like so I'm consuming all Silent Hill related media.
- 48:15I'm trying to get a Pyramid Head for the back but it's it's not.
- 48:18Proving easy. They've got a new pop Funko out,
- 48:21so you know. HMV exclusive.
- 48:22Go nuts. Yeah, the, the actual Pyramid
- 48:26Head, the Pyramid Head statues and stuff are really expensive.
- 48:30They're very popular, so. Yeah, they are.
- 48:31Yeah, huge market, huge market. So they did a six scale figure
- 48:35of the nursing the and Pyramid Head it's all about.
- 48:38Not surprised. Yeah.
- 48:40I mean, we were for the love of horror back in October.
- 48:43Was it October? Yeah.
- 48:44For the first time someone had 3D printed one.
- 48:48What was it? About 810 inches, would you say?
- 48:50Yeah, it. Wasn't wasn't much.
- 48:51They didn't even paint it or anything.
- 48:52And how much did they want from you for it?
- 48:54Like 120 I think it was. Yeah.
- 48:58Just on another. Stand, they had the nurses and
- 49:00Pyramid Head painted and they were about 200, which is like
- 49:03I'm like, yeah, OK. I was trying to pick up the
- 49:05soundtrack from the remake recently because I saw there was
- 49:08a special edition on that sold out everywhere just like yeah,
- 49:12it's it's amazing artwork. It's incredible.
- 49:14But it goes for like 200 and 5300 lbs, right?
- 49:17I'm not paying that. I don't know Mrs. would string
- 49:19me up I'm. One game away from completing
- 49:22everything so aren't here. I literally need one game and
- 49:25the cheapest I can find it is £200.
- 49:27That's not going to do. That No, that's the book of
- 49:30Memories on the Vita. I've got everything else.
- 49:32I've got 1234 Downpour, Homecoming, Shattered Memories.
- 49:39Origins. I've got Origins, Yeah, I've
- 49:41just bought Origins, actually. This is what I'm doing.
- 49:43I I'm going to make my way through them.
- 49:45Yeah, and one away. But I can't spend £200 in a Vita
- 49:48game, especially when I had it. I have it years and when it came
- 49:51out I bought it. And I thought it was more.
- 49:53I know I was like, I'll just sell it.
- 49:55I. Was going to say I got rid of
- 49:57all mine years ago. I've got, I've got Silent Hill
- 49:59one on disc for PS1 and I've got the instruction book and I
- 50:02haven't got the case. I don't.
- 50:04I don't know where that's going. I had that special edition
- 50:07Silent Hill Two that you've got. Grant sold it years and years.
- 50:10Ago. That is devastating, that one.
- 50:12Yeah, I know. I had Silent Hill three.
- 50:14I think I had the room as well. I was lucky though, I really, I
- 50:18messaged my dad and he's got all my stuff in the attic and So
- 50:21what does he call out? Silent Hill Four.
- 50:23He pulled out, which I couldn't believe.
- 50:24It's in really good condition as well.
- 50:27Silent Hill One? Yeah.
- 50:29Oh, it's brand new. Wow, you an idiot, Sam, don't
- 50:31do. It you're going down.
- 50:32A very dark. Path with friends, if you go on
- 50:35the beta one just get 2 of them. I.
- 50:40I've heard you know. You know what I've heard?
- 50:42Phenomenal things about them and I think for me, I'm going
- 50:46through the original now. I am I'm documenting my journey
- 50:48as well. I'm sort of making videos on
- 50:50them because it's been really interesting for me because I've
- 50:52always been a big resi guy, a huge resi guy.
- 50:55Like I'm playing spare the new resi next month, but you know,
- 51:00finish the majority of Reza games and Silent Hill's always
- 51:03been that sort of franchise that I've ignored.
- 51:05And I realise that there's such a fandom around Silent Hill.
- 51:07People love this franchise. And you know, I think Silent
- 51:10Hill too has always sort of spoke to me because I've even
- 51:13going to like horror con and for the love of horror, there's
- 51:15always a pyramid head and there's always a nurse and you
- 51:18sort of think what what is this? You know, I I need to know.
- 51:21It's that FOMO, isn't it? And God, I'm glad I got
- 51:25involved. That's all I'm going to say.
- 51:27You're in. Yeah.
- 51:27You're in for a treat going through all.
- 51:29Of those, they're very. That was a long time though,
- 51:31weren't they? It was the fixed camera I'm
- 51:33playing. Through three again and I'm
- 51:35like, it's just like Rezi, just less guns.
- 51:38Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's a lot more psychological.
- 51:40It's a lot more. Draining and dark, isn't it?
- 51:43So yeah, I love both. Rezi's great.
- 51:46Simon Hill. Yeah, I love all that.
- 51:47Yeah. Except for five.
- 51:48Didn't like. 5 or 6/5 right? 7.
- 51:51Done at six. Right.
- 51:52What should we touch? On, I was going to say favorite
- 51:54scenes. Maybe we've touched on a couple.
- 51:57Have you got any others you want to Chuck out there?
- 51:58Anyone or my favorite scene is what we mentioned earlier and
- 52:01it. Wouldn't be what people think it
- 52:02is, but it's the scene with the armless man where they where
- 52:05they where you first see. Well, it's kind of a couple of
- 52:08scenes, I guess, when you first see the armless man and he kills
- 52:12the homeless guy and then when they're hiding behind the car.
- 52:15And while I'm thinking of that, I remember another scene I
- 52:17really, really love. And this is a real nod to the
- 52:19game. It's where James is running
- 52:20through the streets, and you get that camera angle from inside
- 52:23the flower shop of James looking in, and that's a direct grab
- 52:27from the game. And it's little things like that
- 52:29that I really appreciate. So that whole before it goes
- 52:32fully nuts where James is running around the streets and
- 52:34investigating and seeing the alms.
- 52:35And that's my favorite sequence of events.
- 52:37It's good. Yeah.
- 52:38Very nice, Yeah. That's it's a really well done
- 52:41scene. I haven't, I haven't got a
- 52:43critique about it, you know, when it comes to the, but when
- 52:47it comes to the lion figure, I think for me, my favorite scene
- 52:50is probably the scenes with Pyramid Head.
- 52:52Just because even though, even though I've got something to say
- 52:54about him bashing his head with the, the, the defences, it's,
- 52:57it's completely forgivable. I get it.
- 52:59We've got a runtime. We've got to go through it.
- 53:00He's a threat, isn't he in the game, He still tries to kill
- 53:04James in the game. So he's, he's a threat, you
- 53:06know, that can definitely be ignored.
- 53:08So I'm going to go for the scenes where Pyramid Head first
- 53:10appears. I'm also going to go for the
- 53:12scene where Pyramid Head impales Maria.
- 53:15I thought that was very cool. And yeah, again, I'm going to, I
- 53:20am going to say with Grant as well.
- 53:22I do think when you when you first see the lion figure, you
- 53:25sort of think, hang on, this guy's done his homework, you
- 53:27know, that looks like the lion figure.
- 53:29And I thought the nurses were cool as well.
- 53:31If all be a little bit short. Yeah, definitely right.
- 53:34Yeah. Nice, nice.
- 53:36You've got the bench for. Me for me, I said.
- 53:38I've said already, but the the Pyramid Head Maria scene, he
- 53:42impales her. I think he's really good, really
- 53:44well done. And I I quite like the the scene
- 53:48right near the start where James, he goes into the toilet
- 53:50and it's all grim and dirty and you get the little bug and stuff
- 53:52because Grant a bit like for you, it instantly puts me in
- 53:56that world, you know? Yeah, I recognized it.
- 53:59I was like, oh wow, that looks exactly how it's really done
- 54:01when it seems like it Exactly, yeah.
- 54:04Yeah. So yeah, there you go.
- 54:07OK, on to some things that maybe we didn't like so much.
- 54:12Now, Grant, do you want to go full on What did you hate or
- 54:16with with your Jingle what did you hate?
- 54:27What did you hate then Grant, you can start with this as it's
- 54:29your. Little segment.
- 54:31It's not easy for me because I generally enjoyed this.
- 54:33Thing did you hate it wasn't longer.
- 54:38Yeah, I did. No, I mean we touched it, but I,
- 54:40I. Hated that the nurses came and
- 54:42went so quickly. I've got no complaints with the
- 54:45design of them. I thought that was really cool
- 54:47reading up on them. I love how James sort of fights
- 54:50them off and you know, 1 gets into the lift and gets his hand
- 54:52on Maria and then he Yanks her off.
- 54:54I really like that because they are historically they're kind of
- 54:57seen as untouchable in the old films.
- 54:58You can't go near them because it's insta kill.
- 55:01So I quite like that. I just wish it was longer.
- 55:04It was like suggestive towards the first one, but then it was
- 55:08just really quickly I was done. He's gone.
- 55:11So that's what I hate. I would have loved a bit more of
- 55:13that. Yeah.
- 55:15Yeah, that's fair enough. Sam, what about you?
- 55:16How? Long have you got?
- 55:18Yeah, I was going to say we'll have a plan too.
- 55:22I hate the opening. I hate the opening.
- 55:25To the film, I, I, I really thought it set the wrong
- 55:28president. I, I would have started him up
- 55:30in the bathroom, in the toilet. I really would, and I would have
- 55:33set it from there And, and, you know, with potential flashbacks
- 55:36of him having a good time. I thought the opening just set
- 55:38the wrong kind of scene and set us for the wrong James, the
- 55:41stuff in the bar, etcetera, just didn't need it.
- 55:43I also don't think we needed the social worker.
- 55:45I think it was a social worker. Sorry, that's the wrong term.
- 55:48But I, I don't think that we needed, yeah, that we didn't
- 55:51need the therapist for me at all.
- 55:52Completely. Yeah, we we didn't need that.
- 55:56I don't. I think, like I say, I would
- 55:59have explained Maria a lot more in the respect that I would have
- 56:02just shown her coming back so that people could be like,
- 56:04Silent Hill's created this, you know, this is getting on.
- 56:07This is weird. I would have definitely there's
- 56:10there's absolutely no way that I would not have left out the
- 56:14scenes of the two Pyramid Heads at the end with Maria sort of
- 56:18upside down. I think that's so significant.
- 56:20And when he says I don't need you anymore and they impale, I
- 56:23just would not have left that out.
- 56:25I would have spent more time in the hospital, maybe the
- 56:28labyrinth. I wouldn't have done the whole
- 56:29moth thing. And even the sort of creature
- 56:31that sort of jumped James in the game with the sort of mouth
- 56:34changing that into changing that into in, you know, into narrate
- 56:37again. He just he didn't fly with me.
- 56:40I might have even recast James. To be honest.
- 56:42I didn't think it was a great casting.
- 56:44Sorry, Jeremy, you ever see this?
- 56:46I said what I said. I mean, look, there's a guy up
- 56:49there that looks a bit like. James, if he grows his hair a
- 56:51bit, you know. Yeah, Grant, give it a go.
- 56:55Grant looks more like him than than the guy they cast, and for
- 56:58me that's an issue, you know, there you go.
- 57:02Brilliant. Perfect.
- 57:05How about yourself? Yeah, no, they're all valid
- 57:07points in a. Way.
- 57:09Yeah, so I've got a couple of surface level ones like, and
- 57:14this is a bit silly, I know, but why?
- 57:16Why has James got dark, curly, like WAVY hair?
- 57:19You know, he's wearing like a cool leather jacket and stuff.
- 57:23He's not in his normal military. He's not in the little.
- 57:25Military jacket and stuff. Maria's wig.
- 57:28I know everyone has said this, OK, but Maria's wig.
- 57:32What the hell, right? Yeah, Maria's wig.
- 57:35It just it just didn't fit properly.
- 57:37Did it on a red. I never heard it just didn't it
- 57:41looked. I'll fitting it didn't.
- 57:42Look right, I you're paying too much attention, man, I wasn't
- 57:47even looking at that. I, I, I, you know what people
- 57:49have sort of. Said it as well.
- 57:51I didn't notice it and I want to make it clear I really lied to
- 57:53Maria. I thought that the actress who
- 57:55played Mary played Maria even better.
- 57:57I thought she was really good. It just it's not her fault that
- 58:01it wasn't explained. I I thought Maria was great in
- 58:04this film. One of my favorite parts I don't
- 58:07I don't disagree with any of. That I'm fine with the actress.
- 58:09I thought she did a good job. Just don't like her hair.
- 58:12Bloody wig in it. Yeah.
- 58:15Yeah. And you know what, I'll see it
- 58:16now because you're not the only ones who've said that.
- 58:19I'll see it now. But if I if I want if you want a
- 58:23bit more. Filmic kind of criticisms, shall
- 58:27we say? I'm in agreement.
- 58:28The opening. The opening with James smoking a
- 58:30joy and speeding down the thing. I was like, hang on, that's
- 58:33James. What?
- 58:34What? Hang on.
- 58:36So that was a bit off. And yeah, the the James
- 58:39character in general at the start, I think he got better as
- 58:42it went on, yes. But to start with, us like this.
- 58:45Doesn't feel like the. James, I've been playing as in
- 58:47the video game, yeah. So that.
- 58:51That's my main hate, you know, won't go into every single
- 58:56dislike, but of course, yeah, they're the worst offenders for
- 58:59me, right. So we touch on the acting a
- 59:02little bit before we. You heard.
- 59:05It's been nattering for a while, weren't we?
- 59:07Actually, it's been good. We have.
- 59:08We have, Yeah. When you're talking about great
- 59:10things, you see. Well, anyway, that's from you
- 59:15moving on. Sam, you said about Jeremy
- 59:19Irvine being cast as James Sunderland, you feel wasn't the
- 59:21right option. Have you got anyone else in
- 59:25mind? No, not at all.
- 59:29Not. At all.
- 59:30I don't have anyone else in mind, maybe Granny, but I think,
- 59:34I think for me, I just it just didn't quite fit and maybe maybe
- 59:39it was just the look, but I think a lot of it comes down to
- 59:43direction. I don't have anyone anybody else
- 59:45in mind to play James. I'm just not sure that Jeremy
- 59:49was right. I thought Mary was fine in terms
- 59:52of casting. Laura was cast well, obviously.
- 59:54I think that makes sense, even if her storyline went a bit
- 59:57sphere way. I do think Eddie looked right.
- 1:00:00OK, I don't think Eddie looked right.
- 1:00:04He had a full on beard, didn't he?
- 1:00:06Actually, he was thinking. About it, yeah, he did.
- 1:00:08Aside from that, you know. I'm, I'm fine with it, but I
- 1:00:12think yeah, yeah, that's fine. Yeah.
- 1:00:16Grant what? About you acting in general, it
- 1:00:19was all fine to me, but I. Really didn't like the cultists
- 1:00:22the the sort of lady with the the really short hair.
- 1:00:26OK, yeah, I know the one that was like suspiciously.
- 1:00:29Really. Like close to Mary.
- 1:00:32I, I, I just found it really fake.
- 1:00:34They were almost like wannabe cultists from the first film
- 1:00:37with Christabella as the as the leader.
- 1:00:39They in the first one, they are believable when they bend to
- 1:00:43every word that Christabella says.
- 1:00:44And this one don't know. It all just felt a bit, they
- 1:00:48felt a bit half assed, if I, if I'm honest.
- 1:00:50It didn't portray the importance of the world to me.
- 1:00:54Yeah, yeah, very fair. Yeah, then.
- 1:00:56Yeah, I'd agree. I, I was alright with most of
- 1:01:00the acting, to be honest. I've, I've seen a little bit
- 1:01:02online about a lot of people are shitting on the acting, but I
- 1:01:04don't really think it's that. I think it's more more the
- 1:01:08script, the dialogue. I think actually like I say I.
- 1:01:12Think. Jeremy Vine whatever started off
- 1:01:15a little wonky, but again, that might be more to do with how
- 1:01:18they portrayed his character. But then I thought he got better
- 1:01:21as it went on. Yeah.
- 1:01:23Best actress, I think was the was the lady playing Mary Maria.
- 1:01:28All of those. I thought she was great,
- 1:01:29actually. Really enjoyed her performance.
- 1:01:31I agree. Yeah, Eddie was slightly off,
- 1:01:34but. It doesn't really matter because
- 1:01:35he was in it for about a minute. I can always say, yeah, Marley
- 1:01:39was there. Laura was good, Robert.
- 1:01:41Strange did a fine job. As Pyramid Head for the 2
- 1:01:44minutes or the two scenes he had, Yeah.
- 1:01:47So in general, I didn't really have a major issue with any of
- 1:01:50the acting. Like I say, I think it was the
- 1:01:52the way the dialogue was the storytelling.
- 1:01:54Yeah, sure. I was going to say a little bit
- 1:01:58about wet gooeys. So wet gooeys, if you're not
- 1:02:08aware is. Where we chat about the blood,
- 1:02:11guts, gore, innards, liquids, bodily fluids, etcetera.
- 1:02:15I see. I see anything wet.
- 1:02:17Anything wet? Anything.
- 1:02:19Moist and slippy? Gooey.
- 1:02:21Yes, there you go. We didn't get too many here, did
- 1:02:25we? No.
- 1:02:26The squirty boy from the beginning.
- 1:02:28The. Squirty boy can't stand by.
- 1:02:31Was that you in the cinema? The squirty boy?
- 1:02:35Yeah. No, no, the armless man.
- 1:02:38Or whatever we're. Calling them the lying, lying
- 1:02:39figure. Is it lying figure?
- 1:02:41Yeah. Well, again, yeah, he was a bit
- 1:02:42of a bit of. Gooey's there.
- 1:02:44Yeah, we had the Maria impalement.
- 1:02:47Yes, yes, yes. Apart from that, I'm trying to.
- 1:02:50Think. Oh, we had.
- 1:02:51The cultists where they're doing whatever they're doing to Mary.
- 1:02:55Oh, yeah. Oh yeah, yeah.
- 1:02:57Yeah, yeah, they're all at their hands in pulling the blood.
- 1:03:00Out and putting it all over them, yeah.
- 1:03:02Weird finger pain, yeah. Finger pain in yeah.
- 1:03:07Good one. Any other gooeys?
- 1:03:09I can't really think of any other gooeys.
- 1:03:10Nothing. Nothing obvious.
- 1:03:12I mean, you've got no. It's more cycle as well, which
- 1:03:15is which is. Audibly quite graphic.
- 1:03:17Yeah, that's true. Yeah.
- 1:03:20Apart from that, no, not, not too not.
- 1:03:22Too much distinct lack of. Gooeys, yes.
- 1:03:26Very light on the goo, but like I say.
- 1:03:28Silent Hill is more. Psychological though, isn't it?
- 1:03:31Yeah, it's not. It is.
- 1:03:32Yeah. It's no psychological goo.
- 1:03:34No. Right.
- 1:03:36Anything else? Anyone would like to add Yes.
- 1:03:41OK, now then, I know this film is far from.
- 1:03:46Brilliant. Like, if I'm going to be honest,
- 1:03:48I know it is for me, I take it at face value.
- 1:03:51It's a, it's a, it's just something Silent Hill.
- 1:03:55It scratches that itch for. Me, you know, it's something to
- 1:03:57be talking about, it's something to go to cinema to see.
- 1:04:00It's got some of the Silent Hill monsters in there, silent
- 1:04:02characters. And I think on a very basic
- 1:04:06level, I, I loved it and had a really good time.
- 1:04:07And I can't wait for it to come out on, you know, Blu-ray and
- 1:04:09whatnot so I can add it to my collection.
- 1:04:12There's always one. Yeah.
- 1:04:13Well, yeah. I feel like I am alone.
- 1:04:16On it. But no, I get, I get, I get the
- 1:04:20hate. I really do get the hate.
- 1:04:22I just don't. I just didn't.
- 1:04:24I didn't, I didn't get, I didn't take that from it myself.
- 1:04:26So I said that in 12 million ways.
- 1:04:29But yeah, I didn't hate it, but I get why people do.
- 1:04:33I think that's a great thing, though.
- 1:04:34You're a huge Silent Hill fan. Like, you've just, you've
- 1:04:37explicitly said today that you've played through nearly
- 1:04:39every single game except one, VA 1.
- 1:04:42You know, I think you're more than qualified to talk on the
- 1:04:45subject of Silent Hill overall. And the fact that you liked the
- 1:04:47new film is a joyous thing. That's that's an amazing thing.
- 1:04:51The fact that you've gone in as an Uber fan that knows the law,
- 1:04:54that knows these creatures, and you've gone.
- 1:04:56I liked it for what it was. That should be celebrated, in my
- 1:04:59opinion. What a guy.
- 1:05:01Yeah. It's.
- 1:05:04Unbelievable. I was going to say, I bet you
- 1:05:06weren't. Expecting that grand were you?
- 1:05:07I had a little. Tim, I just, I just.
- 1:05:10Think it's one of the don't ever.
- 1:05:11Knock anyone that's a huge fan of a franchise and just because
- 1:05:14I because I, I, I'm a huge Star Wars guy, massive and I hated
- 1:05:18the sequels, but the people that like the sequel, good for them,
- 1:05:21you know, good for them. I like the fact that they like
- 1:05:24them. There's certain bits I like and
- 1:05:26I think that there's too much, especially in in the community
- 1:05:28and I think it seems to be making content.
- 1:05:30I'm sick of seeing sort of people say you're objectively
- 1:05:33wrong. Well, no, you're not objectively
- 1:05:34wrong. We've got a guy here that's, you
- 1:05:36know, a semi expert on Silent Hill and likes the new film.
- 1:05:39Good for him. One of my friends has been
- 1:05:41through it. He's been through every game as
- 1:05:42well, and he didn't like the film.
- 1:05:44And I think that that's what's interesting.
- 1:05:45I think, you know, he's played for every single game and you
- 1:05:48know, we I took him to go and see it.
- 1:05:50He's not he doesn't usually go to the cinema.
- 1:05:52I said come on taking you to see Silent Hill and I took Luke and
- 1:05:55and you know, he was excited etcetera and he turned to me and
- 1:05:58he sort of said I just didn't love that.
- 1:06:00And I was like, you know what, fine, but you've seen it and the
- 1:06:03fact that people are enjoying it is good and you know, more power
- 1:06:07to you. I mean a 4.3 and IDB says I'm
- 1:06:10not the. Only one that liked.
- 1:06:12It exactly. I've seen other people say they
- 1:06:13enjoyed it as well. Yeah.
- 1:06:15So it started out with a load a load of negative reviews.
- 1:06:18That's all I was seeing, negative, negative.
- 1:06:20I do get it, but the last couple of days I have.
- 1:06:22Seen one or two positive reviews creeping?
- 1:06:24In there. So, you know, I don't think it
- 1:06:27will go full turn around. The first one kind of did got
- 1:06:30panned by the critics. Fans mostly enjoy it.
- 1:06:35I I kind of sit somewhere in the middle.
- 1:06:36I don't I don't see the hate for it.
- 1:06:39I really don't. It's not the worst film in the
- 1:06:41world. You know, it's probably better
- 1:06:45than Revelation, to be honest. Oh God, yeah.
- 1:06:47It's a low bar. I need to I need to watch that.
- 1:06:49I need to watch that. Like I say, yes.
- 1:06:51It muddles. It muddles some things.
- 1:06:53It changes some. Things, but he did have a fairly
- 1:06:57good attempt at it. Some, like I say, creative
- 1:06:59decisions were interesting to say the least.
- 1:07:03But in a way, I suppose at least he's not doing a straight one
- 1:07:06for one remake because you've seen that and you've got that
- 1:07:09with the game. So if you want that, you can
- 1:07:12play the video game. I think you touched a little bit
- 1:07:14earlier, Ben. I think once people get to see
- 1:07:16this. A second time, maybe a third
- 1:07:17time if you want to. I think it will grow a bit more
- 1:07:21on people. Yeah, just my opinion.
- 1:07:23I could be wrong on that, but you know, whatever.
- 1:07:25Yeah. I hope so.
- 1:07:26I hope so so. Right just before we do.
- 1:07:30Our final. Scores then shall we just have a
- 1:07:31brief chat about the ending of the movie yes so in Silent Hill
- 1:07:362 the video game there is what 6 I think there's now 8 different
- 1:07:41endings including the two new ones in the remake and obviously
- 1:07:45one of the big conversations around this film was what ending
- 1:07:47would it go for you know so and it kind of went for about 3 and
- 1:07:53mixed them together I think in my eyes so now Sam you've
- 1:07:59recently finished Silent Hill two haven't you I have what
- 1:08:02happened in your ending I. Got the leave.
- 1:08:05Ending OK, is that where? James leaves with Laura.
- 1:08:09That's right. Yeah.
- 1:08:10OK. Yeah, so.
- 1:08:12Return to Silent Hill. What happens?
- 1:08:13To Laura. I'm trying to think she's part
- 1:08:15of Mary, isn't she? She's kind of there, and then
- 1:08:17she's not. Yeah, OK.
- 1:08:20Just just like every other character.
- 1:08:21Yes, she's there. Yeah.
- 1:08:23But yeah, I think she's part of Mary, isn't she?
- 1:08:25Because we get that actual terrible bit which kind of made
- 1:08:28me snigger, where it says Mary Angela.
- 1:08:31Laura Crane. Oh, yeah, that was great.
- 1:08:34That actually is 1 of what I hate.
- 1:08:36Remove that completely. From it, but awful.
- 1:08:39Yeah. So.
- 1:08:40So leave. I don't think we touched on
- 1:08:42leave in the film, but we did get in water, basically.
- 1:08:47Sam, have you seen any of the other endings online or
- 1:08:49anything? I've seen, I've seen them all.
- 1:08:50Yeah. Like I said, you know the
- 1:08:52obsession is real. Gentlemen, I, you know, I, I
- 1:08:55read them all up. Yeah, yeah, OK.
- 1:08:57I just didn't want to spoil it by then blurting them up.
- 1:09:00So, I mean, if you're listening and you haven't, I'm going.
- 1:09:02To spoil it. So hey ho, now obviously we
- 1:09:06weren't going to get the dog with the UFO ending or the happy
- 1:09:10birthday one. The happy birthday we're not
- 1:09:12getting we're. Definitely not getting the Maria
- 1:09:14ending either. So that only really left in
- 1:09:17water or leave. We've already said we haven't
- 1:09:20got leave So but the way the in water ending happened here, I
- 1:09:25quite liked. So just quickly to touch back on
- 1:09:29the whole of the Toluca. Lake thing.
- 1:09:30It's not ever named. As Toluca Lake in the film, they
- 1:09:33never actually call it that in the game, you have to row across
- 1:09:36it for about 5 minutes wondering if you're going in the right
- 1:09:39direction. So they skipped that completely.
- 1:09:42But I did quite like what they did here.
- 1:09:44So this is is this the scene where moth Mary puts her hand
- 1:09:49down James's throat and he ends up in the water and then he
- 1:09:52wakes back up, wakes up on the shoreline.
- 1:09:54He wakes back up on the shoreline.
- 1:09:56So I thought that was quite a good way of doing it in the
- 1:09:59movie. And then when he actually has
- 1:10:04Mary's body at the end of the film, he puts her in the car,
- 1:10:07drives into Toluca Lake because he actually admits that he
- 1:10:13deserves to die as well. He is riddled with guilt, isn't
- 1:10:15he? He is riddled with guilt.
- 1:10:17Yes, so I was. Actually hoping for the in water
- 1:10:21ending because I think it makes the most sense logically.
- 1:10:24Yeah, OK. If you follow the story of
- 1:10:25James's guilt, his need for punishing himself because of all
- 1:10:29the lustful thoughts he has. And, you know, obviously the the
- 1:10:32main kicker, which we haven't even touched on is, and this is
- 1:10:36a massive spoiler, everybody OK, So stop now if you don't want to
- 1:10:40know. But the the massive thing of why
- 1:10:43he's so guilty is that he kills Mary, which was mishandled in
- 1:10:48the film. Yeah, they don't really put it
- 1:10:51because to me it seemed like he. Was doing the right thing,
- 1:10:53killing her, not killing her, but like, if that was your
- 1:10:57partner and you're obsessed to her and they were dying in their
- 1:10:59own agony, there's a whole argument, isn't there?
- 1:11:00Assisted dying. We're going to go into Exit Too
- 1:11:02deep. But he doesn't seem like an evil
- 1:11:05bastard and I don't. That's one thing I definitely
- 1:11:07say they miss in the film is that I was a little bit like, if
- 1:11:10I didn't know what was going on, why is he so guilty?
- 1:11:13Why is he riddled with, like, why is he so upset?
- 1:11:16Yeah, but it's in the game, though.
- 1:11:18Mary doesn't ask. To be killed.
- 1:11:21No, no, I know, I know. That's what I mean.
- 1:11:22He's pissed off, he's frustrated.
- 1:11:25He's all the things that we see manifested in the other
- 1:11:27characters. He's got rage in him, he's got
- 1:11:29lust in him. He's, you know, all of that.
- 1:11:32So he decides that he's going to end her life, doesn't he?
- 1:11:35Yeah, yeah, for sure. Whereas in the film, she
- 1:11:37basically says, can you please kill me?
- 1:11:39I don't want to be like this anymore.
- 1:11:40It seems like he's being massiful in a way.
- 1:11:42Yes, Yes, 100. Percent and I feel like that
- 1:11:45that's cat. Hello.
- 1:11:47Yes, this is it. This is Lemmy, who sometimes
- 1:11:49makes appearance on social media.
- 1:11:51He is a big boy. But yeah, you know, And I think
- 1:11:55that's the whole point though. It creates that argument, you
- 1:11:58know, is this merciful, etcetera.
- 1:12:01But for me, the whole point is, is that so many people, and
- 1:12:04rightly so, they see games as a criminal.
- 1:12:05He took matters into his own hands in Silent Hill too, and he
- 1:12:09killed her. And that's, and that's the way
- 1:12:10it is. And that's the whole reason why
- 1:12:12he dragged himself to Silent Hill out of sheer guilt.
- 1:12:15Yes I agree they fumble the ending in the movie.
- 1:12:18They made you sympathise with him instead of realising it
- 1:12:22didn't have that gut punch of Oh my God, I've been playing as a
- 1:12:25murderer. Yeah, which is exactly what
- 1:12:27you're doing. Yeah, I remember.
- 1:12:29My favorite critic. Review for Silent Hill, as I've
- 1:12:31got into more reading is James had me completely fooled yeah
- 1:12:36yeah. And it makes you feel
- 1:12:37absolutely. Devastated at the end of the
- 1:12:40game? Yeah, well, I don't know.
- 1:12:41Because you're a fan of murdering.
- 1:12:44Yeah, there is that, but. Yeah, so the the film.
- 1:12:49Softens that, doesn't it? And it makes you.
- 1:12:51Compassionate towards James. It makes you on his side
- 1:12:54basically. So which which isn't what I
- 1:12:58want. But then, but then after that,
- 1:13:02we get. We don't want that.
- 1:13:05No, Yeah. That's it.
- 1:13:07I want AI want a re edited. Version on the bloody Blu-ray.
- 1:13:10OK. But no, we then get that sort of
- 1:13:15we're back to the start, basically the loop, yeah, yes,
- 1:13:18the loop and it plays out different.
- 1:13:20James knows. Exactly what to?
- 1:13:21Do. And then, yeah, he drives out on
- 1:13:23Silent Hill with Mary. I mean, you'd be well happy if
- 1:13:27that was you though, wouldn't you?
- 1:13:29Yeah, but there's a theory going around.
- 1:13:33And this has come from the games again as well.
- 1:13:35So, you know, you find the photos in the games.
- 1:13:37Yeah, there's 26 of them, I believe.
- 1:13:40And when you get all the letters, like you figure out all
- 1:13:42the puzzle, what they'll mean, it spells out you've been here
- 1:13:46for two decades. So they're they're just
- 1:13:49basically saying that you've been stuck in Silent Hill.
- 1:13:51You keep doing the same thing until you just off yourself, a
- 1:13:54good kind of thing and, you know, get what you deserve,
- 1:13:57basically. Yeah.
- 1:13:59You actually see dead bodies. You actually see dead bodies
- 1:14:03throughout your play through a silent.
- 1:14:04Hill, too, that some of them. Look like James.
- 1:14:06Yeah, I I fully subscribe to the period.
- 1:14:09This is an infinite. Look, yeah.
- 1:14:11And I think some people, interestingly, in the PS2 game
- 1:14:14were like, no, it's not, it's not like that.
- 1:14:16They were just using that because they didn't have the
- 1:14:18hard drive space to betray other bodies.
- 1:14:20But for me, you know, so they had to use James for sort of
- 1:14:23gain limitations. But for me, I subscribe to the
- 1:14:26idea that he's in an infinite loop.
- 1:14:27And I think the remake concerns that.
- 1:14:30I I, I think there's just, there's too many parallels.
- 1:14:32I, I think the idea of all these endings and the fact that Konami
- 1:14:35just will not comment on which ending is Canon as opposed,
- 1:14:39points to the direction, aside from the dogging UFO ending,
- 1:14:42that all endings are Canon and that James is stuck in this loop
- 1:14:46that he can't seem to get out of.
- 1:14:48Yeah, I'm fully on board with that 100%.
- 1:14:52Sounds good. I think that's a good place to
- 1:14:53leave it then, gentlemen. Absolutely yes.
- 1:14:55Do you want to give our ratings? Yeah.
- 1:14:58Grant. Yeah, would you?
- 1:15:00Like to enlighten us First off with your score out of 10, then
- 1:15:03please. Yeah, I'm going to go over an 8
- 1:15:06out of 10. So I've dropped it down from a
- 1:15:09nine because I I was just going to say some criticisms from it.
- 1:15:11That was just me getting excited now, of course.
- 1:15:14Yeah, look, I as I touched on, I'm not going to go into it too
- 1:15:16much, but. I get it.
- 1:15:17I get the hate for it, I just think without going too deeply
- 1:15:21into it, it's a Silent Hill. Film anything.
- 1:15:23'S good for me at this point because it's been too long
- 1:15:25without something. I'd watch it again.
- 1:15:28I'd watch it many times again. It's probably going to be in my
- 1:15:30top 10 for the year. Let's just be honest.
- 1:15:33Are you going back tomorrow to see it again on your day off?
- 1:15:35Yeah. I love that.
- 1:15:38Yeah. I don't know.
- 1:15:38I had. A really good time with it.
- 1:15:39Just as I said, anything's on hill.
- 1:15:41I just love it. Yeah.
- 1:15:42Could have definitely done a lot better, but for me, I'd give it.
- 1:15:44I'd give it a nice eight. Yeah, no worries.
- 1:15:47Good stuff, Sam. What about you?
- 1:15:48Don't know if I'm. Ready.
- 1:15:49I'm going to give it a three. OK, really.
- 1:15:54Really tough going. Yeah, it's a.
- 1:15:55Three from me I'm. OK, with that, you know, are
- 1:15:59you? Yeah, I'm yeah, OK.
- 1:16:01I think this has. Been a very.
- 1:16:03Yeah, yeah. I totally get it.
- 1:16:05I can get the hate I. Said I get the hate.
- 1:16:07Except for you, very. You are a different catalyst.
- 1:16:10You have to like it. Well, I.
- 1:16:13So like I say. I you know what, I scored it
- 1:16:16originally when we went to a cinema grant.
- 1:16:17Yes, yes, yes. And I think I'm around the same
- 1:16:20little. Place after watching it a
- 1:16:22second. Time.
- 1:16:23I don't understand the complete hate for it.
- 1:16:26I can see the faults in the film, like I said, but there are
- 1:16:29some positives as well and there are bits I like.
- 1:16:30So originally I was thinking of going as low as 5, but I think
- 1:16:35I'm going to go for about 6. Nice.
- 1:16:38You know, I'm very happy with that.
- 1:16:39So it might. Be a touch high, it might be a.
- 1:16:41Little generous, but for me it feels right to sit around that
- 1:16:44area, so I'm happy with that. There we go, everybody.
- 1:16:49All right, listeners, thank you for putting up with.
- 1:16:51Us for however long that has been.
- 1:16:53I don't know. We've lost track of time.
- 1:16:54It's been a great chat, Sam. Thank you very much, gentlemen.
- 1:16:57Thank you. It's been a pleasure.
- 1:16:58Yeah. Thanks so much.
- 1:16:59It was. Great having you on.
- 1:17:00And then finally, Sam, do you want?
- 1:17:02To tell everyone where they can find you.
- 1:17:04Yeah, absolutely. So you can find me on TikTok
- 1:17:07and. Instagram and I'm a little bit
- 1:17:09on YouTube and you'll just find me at Solibro, which is
- 1:17:12CLCELEBRO. That's quite simple.
- 1:17:17But yeah, I just essentially talk about films.
- 1:17:20I'm I'm a very new Silent Hill fan, so it's been nice to be
- 1:17:23surrounded by people that are experts tonight.
- 1:17:25And thank you for having me on Gentlemen.
- 1:17:27It's been a pleasure. Well, you're more than welcome
- 1:17:29anytime. It's been a great chat.
- 1:17:32Thanks to you Ben, I've had a terrible time talking to you as.
- 1:17:35Always. It's all right.
- 1:17:37I'll try to ignore you for the next.
- 1:17:38Two weeks, yeah. Thank God.
- 1:17:39Yeah, right. Thank you very much for.
- 1:17:42Listening, everyone. We will catch you soon.
- 1:17:44Bye bye. What the week you'll say From
- 1:18:09those twinkles to eerie scores, Don't take deep in the horrors.
- 1:18:14Core Moving Maniacs Core moving maniacs will make you scream and
- 1:18:30will make you scream.