Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Absolute Threshold & Psychophysics: How We Detect Sensation
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the psychology undergrad. So you think
- 0:04you are hearing my voice right now, but you are
- 0:06not really. Right. It's an illusion. Exactly.
- 0:09What you're actually experiencing is like a highly
- 0:11synthesized hallucination. It's built by electrical
- 0:14spikes and a dark silent vault inside your skull.
- 0:18It is pretty wild to think of. Yeah. Every sight,
- 0:20every sound, even every deeply held moral belief
- 0:25you have is ultimately just constructed from
- 0:28this chaotic storm of physical cells and psychological
- 0:31interpretation. That realization is a heavy one,
- 0:34especially for you, our third study buddy listening
- 0:36in. as we prep for this exam. Seriously, it completely
- 0:39hijacked my brain when I was doing the reading
- 0:41for this week's sensation and perception module.
- 0:44Our mission today is to figure out exactly where
- 0:46the physical hardware of the nervous system basically
- 0:49collides with the software of the conscious mind.
- 0:52And to frame this deep dive into our textbook
- 0:54reading today, we're really bridging two distinct
- 0:56worlds. Right, psychophysics and neuroscience.
- 0:59Exactly. We have psychophysical methods, which
- 1:01are the mathematical tools researchers use to
- 1:04quantify subjective human perception. And then
- 1:07we have neuroscience, which reveals the actual
- 1:10cellular mechanics generating that perception.
- 1:13You really can't understand human reality without
- 1:16layering those two fields together. OK, let's
- 1:18unpack this. So if we are basically hallucinating
- 1:22our reality, how do we get the data to build
- 1:26that hallucination in the first place? Well,
- 1:28the text draws a massive heavy line between sensation
- 1:32and perception. They're definitely not synonyms.
- 1:34Right, like sensation is purely a mechanical
- 1:37physical event. It's transduction. Yes. Taking
- 1:40physical energy from the environment, like a
- 1:42photon of light or the compression wave of a
- 1:44sound, and translating it into the electrochemical
- 1:47language of action potentials. Because that translation
- 1:49is like the only way the brain can interact with
- 1:52the outside world, right? Precisely. The brain
- 1:54doesn't know what light is. It only knows electrical
- 1:56impulses. That is so weird to think about. It
- 1:59is. But what I find most compelling in the reading
- 2:01is how limited our conscious awareness of that
- 2:05transduction really is. I mean, we're taught
- 2:08the five senses as children, but the reality
- 2:10is just so much more complex. Oh, totally. The
- 2:12five senses thing is a total lie. It really is.
- 2:15We have specialized receptors for proprioception
- 2:17and kinesthesia, which are constantly monitoring
- 2:20the stretch of our muscles and the angles of
- 2:22our joints. So we don't just, you know, collapse
- 2:24when we walk down the street. Right. And we have
- 2:27the vestibular sense where fluid moving over
- 2:29these tiny hair cells in our inner ear tells
- 2:32us our orientation relative to gravity, plus
- 2:35nonsusception for pain, thermoception for temperature.
- 2:38We're basically walking sensor arrays just soaking
- 2:40up massive amounts of raw data. We are. But sensation
- 2:44is really just the raw data entry. And perception
- 2:47is the psychological organization. It's the meaning
- 2:49we assign to the data, which requires top -down
- 2:52processing, right? Exactly. Our memories, our
- 2:54expectations, our beliefs, they all filter the
- 2:57raw input. When I was trying to memorize this
- 2:59for the exam, I thought about reading a holy
- 3:01text. Sensation is just the physical mechanics
- 3:05of recognizing the contrast of dark ink on light
- 3:09paper. That's a great analogy. Right, because
- 3:11you could be reading a sacred scripture or a
- 3:13grocery list and the sensation is identical.
- 3:16But perception is that top -down spiritual knowledge,
- 3:19the history and the faith that gives those specific
- 3:23shapes of ink profound meaning to the reader.
- 3:26That illustrates the distinction perfectly. The
- 3:28raw input doesn't change, but the internal interpretation
- 3:31does. And importantly, Our neurobiology actively
- 3:35filters out sensations before they ever reach
- 3:38the level of perception. Sensory adaptation is
- 3:41a prime example of this. Oh, like tuning out
- 3:43an old analog clock ticking in a room. Exactly.
- 3:45If you walk into a room with a ticking clock,
- 3:47your auditory receptors transduce every single
- 3:50tick. But after 10 minutes, you stop perceiving
- 3:52it. Because your brain is just like, this is
- 3:54boring, I don't care anymore. Basically. The
- 3:56physical sensation hasn't stopped, but your brain
- 3:59deemed it irrelevant, so it drops it from your
- 4:01conscious reality. And it's the same with selective
- 4:03attention, like you can tune out a crowded, loud
- 4:06party just to perceive the voice of the person
- 4:09right in front of you. Yes, our attention is
- 4:11highly selective. But there's this philosophical
- 4:14edge to this that I found really unsettling in
- 4:16the reading. Oh, how so? Well, if our neurobiology
- 4:20is fundamentally designed to adapt to constant
- 4:23stimuli and tune out background noise, That mechanism
- 4:26applies to our moral environment, too. Ah, I
- 4:29see where you're going with this. Yeah, it's
- 4:30like a biological spiritual blindness. If we
- 4:34are constantly surrounded by background injustices
- 4:36or ethical compromises, our brains are literally
- 4:39wired to adapt. That is a sobering thought. Right.
- 4:42If we don't actively force our attention onto
- 4:44them, we literally stop perceiving them, even
- 4:47though the signals are right in front of us.
- 4:49It's terrifying that our neurobiology naturally
- 4:52trends toward apathy. It really is. conscious,
- 4:56top -down effort to maintain awareness of things
- 4:59our biology wants to classify as just background
- 5:02noise. Yeah, we have to actively fight it. But
- 5:05moving from philosophy to the laboratory, how
- 5:08do psychologists actually measure these subjective
- 5:10internal filters? Right, because we have to quantify
- 5:13the invisible. Which brings us to psychophysics
- 5:15and thresholds. Yes, starting with the absolute
- 5:18threshold. OK, let's unpack this. This is defined
- 5:21as the minimum amount of stimulus energy required
- 5:24to be detected exactly 50 % of the time. And
- 5:28the text lists some wild statistics for this.
- 5:31They are quite impressive. Like under optimal
- 5:34conditions, the sensory cells in our retinas
- 5:36can detect a single candle flame 30 miles away
- 5:40on a clear night. 30 miles. And the hair cells
- 5:43in the cochlea can pick up the ticking of a watch
- 5:4520 feet away. It's crazy. But what if a stimulus
- 5:49falls below that absolute threshold? Well, meaning
- 5:51it doesn't possess enough energy. to reliably
- 5:54trigger conscious perception, we call it a subliminal
- 5:57message. Which immediately makes me think of
- 5:59like all the paranoia about advertisers flashing
- 6:02hidden images or rock bands putting backward
- 6:04messages in their tracks to brainwash us. Pop
- 6:06culture definitely loves that narrative, but
- 6:09the laboratory data actually provides a lot of
- 6:11reassurance here. Oh good, I need some reassurance.
- 6:14It is true that our brains can process information
- 6:17just below the threshold of conscious awareness.
- 6:21However, the text makes it very clear that these
- 6:24subliminal messages have practically zero measurable
- 6:26effect on our actual behavior outside of highly
- 6:29controlled lab settings. So I can't be hypnotized
- 6:32into buying a car by a hidden flash on a screen?
- 6:35No. From a moral standpoint, we maintain our
- 6:38agency. We aren't mindless biological automatons
- 6:41who can be corrupted by a hidden track on a record.
- 6:43Well, good to know my free will is intact, but
- 6:46it's not just about detecting a stimulus from
- 6:49nothing, right? detecting a change. Exactly.
- 6:51That's the difference threshold, or the just
- 6:53noticeable difference, the JND. Right. And reading
- 6:55through this, I hit a snag with Weber's law.
- 6:59Because Ernst Weber proposed that this difference
- 7:01threshold is a constant fraction of the original
- 7:03stimulus. Yes. The classic example is the dark
- 7:05movie theater. Yeah. If someone checks their
- 7:08phone in a dark theater, the whole room perceives
- 7:11the change in light. But if someone checks their
- 7:14phone in a brightly lit sports arena, no one
- 7:17notices. The stimulus is the same, but the background
- 7:21weight is heavier, so our sensitivity compresses.
- 7:24That is a perfect summary of Weber's Law. Wait,
- 7:27so Weber's Law means our sensitivity is entirely
- 7:30relative. Because if our nervous system always
- 7:32compresses data like that, how does pain work?
- 7:35What do you mean? Like if I touch a hot stove
- 7:38and it gets just a tiny bit hotter, my perception
- 7:40of that pain doesn't compress. It screams. You've
- 7:43just outlined the exact limitation of Weber's
- 7:45law. It applies to compressive or sublinear functions
- 7:49like brightness or loudness, where the nervous
- 7:51system needs to handle a massive range of inputs
- 7:53without getting overwhelmed. OK, so I came up
- 7:55with a memory trick for this. Weber's is about
- 7:57the weight of the background, the theater versus
- 7:59the arena. But Stevens is about shocking expansion.
- 8:03I like that. Yes, Stanley Smith Stevens provided
- 8:06a different mathematical model. Stevens power
- 8:09law maps expansive or super linear functions.
- 8:13For something like an electric shock, your sensitivity
- 8:16actually increases exponentially as the stimulus
- 8:19gets stronger. Right, because the biological
- 8:21motivation there is survival. We compress things
- 8:24like light so we don't go blind, but we expand
- 8:27things like pain so we immediately drop whatever
- 8:30is hurting us before it melts our skin off. Exactly.
- 8:33But regardless of whether the function is compressive
- 8:35or expansive, measuring these thresholds in a
- 8:38human subject is messy. Oh, totally. When we
- 8:40plot a person's ability to detect a stimulus
- 8:42on a graph, we create a psychometric function.
- 8:46And it almost never looks like a sharp staircase.
- 8:48Right. It doesn't just instantly flip from 0
- 8:50% detection to 100%. It's always an S -shaped
- 8:53curve. Yes. And that gradual S -curve exists
- 8:57because human neural responses have inherent
- 9:00variability. There is literal physical noise
- 9:03in the system. Exactly. The curve has a floor
- 9:06representing the worst possible performance.
- 9:10For a simple yes or no task, the floor is zero.
- 9:13But for a too alternative forced -choice task
- 9:16-like guessing, if a faint sound came from the
- 9:19left or right speaker, the floor is 50%. Because
- 9:22you can just guess and be right half the time.
- 9:24Precisely. And the ceiling is rarely 100 % because,
- 9:28well, humans are clumsy. The reading calls them
- 9:30finger errors, where you perceive the stimulus
- 9:32perfectly but accidentally hit the wrong button
- 9:34on the keyboard. Yes, finger errors account for
- 9:36that. But the most crucial part of that S -curve
- 9:39for our exam is the slope in the middle. The
- 9:42steepness of that slope actually quantifies the
- 9:44internal noise in a person's head. So if two
- 9:46people have the same threshold, but one has a
- 9:48flatter slope, that just means their brain is
- 9:50dealing with more internal static. Exactly. A
- 9:53very steep slope indicates low variability and
- 9:56low perceptual noise. But a flatter slope indicates
- 9:59highly variable responses. The signal is struggling
- 10:02to cut through the internal static. And the text
- 10:05mentioned this applies to autism, right? It does.
- 10:07Researchers found that perception and autism
- 10:10spectrum disorder is often characterized by unusually
- 10:13high internal neural noise and an impaired ability
- 10:16to filter out external noise. Wow. So if researchers
- 10:19can measure the static on a graph, what is physically
- 10:22vibrating in our heads to create that noise in
- 10:25the first place? To understand the software glitch,
- 10:28we have to look at the cellular hardware. Right.
- 10:31We need to transition from psychophysics to neuroscience.
- 10:34The nervous tissue generating all of this is
- 10:36composed of glial cells which provide support
- 10:38and neurons which perform the actual electrical
- 10:41computation. And looking at the diagrams in the
- 10:44text, I was struck by how wildly different these
- 10:47neurons look like. We talk about a neuron like
- 10:49it's a standard Lego brick, but they are incredibly
- 10:51specialized. Very much so. We have unipolar cells,
- 10:54which are exclusively sensory neurons acting
- 10:57as single continuous wires. We have bipolar cells
- 11:00in the retina and then multipolar cells. The
- 11:03text highlights Purkinje cells in the cerebellum,
- 11:05and they have this massive, complex, tree -like
- 11:08structure of dendrites. The shape is entirely
- 11:10dictated by the function. A Purkinje cell looks
- 11:14like a dense thicket of branches because its
- 11:17job is to integrate thousands of incoming signals
- 11:20simultaneously. Oh, because the cerebellum coordinates
- 11:22balance? Exactly. It needs to synthesize a massive
- 11:25amount of proprioceptive and vestibular data
- 11:28all at once to keep you upright. Form following
- 11:31function at a microscopic level. It's so cool.
- 11:34And these neurons are organized into our two
- 11:36primary divisions. The central nervous system,
- 11:39the CNS, which is the brain and spinal cord,
- 11:41and the peripheral nervous system, the PNS, which
- 11:44is the nerves reaching out to our limbs. And
- 11:46do you have a memory trick for those? I do. I
- 11:48just picture the CNS as the corporate headquarters
- 11:50locked away in an armored bone vault, the skull
- 11:53and the vertebrae and the PNS or the field agents
- 11:56out in the vulnerable tissues taking the hits.
- 11:58That works perfectly. but there is a vital consequence
- 12:01to where those cells are located. Peripheral
- 12:04neurons generally have the capacity to regenerate.
- 12:06If you suffer a deep cut on your arm and sever
- 12:09a nerve, you lose sensation. But over months,
- 12:13the Schwann cells in the periphery can guide
- 12:15the regrowth of the axon, and feeling slowly
- 12:18returns. Central nervous system neurons, however,
- 12:22typically do not regenerate. And that is why
- 12:24spinal cord injuries are so devastating. The
- 12:27field agents can heal, but if the communication
- 12:29lines in the bone vault get severed, the damage
- 12:31is usually permanent. It's a tragic reality.
- 12:34It really is. Reading about the research into
- 12:36why the CNS inhibits its own repair while the
- 12:39PNS promotes it, it really acts as a moral call
- 12:42for empathy. It strips away all our top -down
- 12:44biases and reminds you of the profound shared
- 12:47biological fragility we all live with. It certainly
- 12:49does. It's a powerful reminder. But assuming
- 12:52this delicate architecture is intact, we arise
- 12:54at the core question. How does a physical cell
- 12:57generate an electrical thought? Right, the membrane
- 13:00potential. A resting neuron maintains a charge
- 13:02of negative 70 millivolts. To transmit information,
- 13:05that electrical state must change. And it does
- 13:07that in two completely different ways, graded
- 13:09potentials and action potentials. Yes. Graded
- 13:13potentials happen in the dendrites and the cell
- 13:15body. They are analog. A weak stimulus causes
- 13:18a tiny shift in voltage, and a strong stimulus
- 13:21causes a large shift. My initial thought was
- 13:24to compare them to a dimmer switch on a light,
- 13:26but even that feels a bit too rigid. A dimmer
- 13:29switch is okay, but a graded potential is actually
- 13:31more like tossing a stone into a puddle. The
- 13:34voltage change creates a ripple that travels
- 13:36across the cell membrane, but that ripple degrades
- 13:39and loses strength as it spreads out. Ah, so
- 13:41if it's a tiny stone, the ripple might just vanish
- 13:43before it reaches the edge. Exactly. And in a
- 13:46neuron, that edge is the axon hillock. Okay.
- 13:49Let's unpack this. These graded potentials can
- 13:51be excitatory postsynaptic potentials, EPSPs,
- 13:54which push the voltage closer to the threshold,
- 13:56or they can be inhibitory IPSPs, which push it
- 13:59away from the threshold. I like to think of this
- 14:02as a chaotic congressional floor vote. The dendrites
- 14:04are receiving thousands of EPSP yes votes and
- 14:07IPSP no votes simultaneously. They all summate
- 14:10or tally up at the axon hillock. If the yes votes
- 14:13outweigh the no votes and hit the threshold,
- 14:15the neuron fires an action potential. The bill
- 14:18is passed. That is a brilliant way to remember
- 14:20it. And unlike the analog ripple of the graded
- 14:23potential, the action potential is digital. It
- 14:26is an all or nothing event traveling down the
- 14:28axon. So it doesn't degrade? No. It is a self
- 14:31-regenerating electrical spike that instantly
- 14:34reverses the membrane voltage up to positive
- 14:3630 millivolts. And it looks exactly the same
- 14:39every single time it fires. Wait. So if the spike
- 14:42is always the same size, how does it communicate
- 14:44a stronger stimulus? By the rate. The intensity
- 14:47isn't coded by size, it's coded by frequency.
- 14:50A stronger stimulus just means the neuron fires
- 14:52more spikes per second. Wow, okay. But an electrical
- 14:55spike traveling down a wire is only half the
- 14:57story. The brain isn't just one long wire, it's
- 15:00a network of billions of disconnected cells.
- 15:03The space between them, the synapse, is where
- 15:06the real magic happens. How does the electrical
- 15:08signal cross the physical gap? It requires a
- 15:10chemical translation. When the action potential
- 15:13reaches the terminal button at the end of the
- 15:14axon, the electrical spike opens voltage -gated
- 15:17calcium channels. Calcium ions, Ca2+. Yes. Calcium
- 15:22rushes into the cell, and this is the crucial
- 15:24trigger for exocytosis. Exocytosis. That's where
- 15:28the little vesicles, which are basically biological
- 15:31shipping containers full of neurotransmitters,
- 15:33fuse with the cell membrane and dump their cargo
- 15:36out into the synaptic cleft. Correct. Those neurotransmitters
- 15:40drift across the gap and bind to specific receptor
- 15:44proteins on the next cell. It operates exactly
- 15:47like a lock and key. And the text outlines two
- 15:50major types of these receptors. We have ionotropic
- 15:53receptors, which are built for speed. The neurotransmitter
- 15:56binds, and the receptor immediately snaps open
- 15:58a channel, letting ions flow in to create that
- 16:01analog -graded potential. Yes. But then we have
- 16:04metabotropic receptors, which are much slower
- 16:06but way more powerful. Because metabotropic receptors
- 16:09don't have a channel. When the neurotransmitter
- 16:11binds, it activates a G protein inside the cell.
- 16:14kicking off a complex cascade of chemical reactions.
- 16:17And these can literally alter gene transcription,
- 16:20right? Like rewrite the cell's DNA over time.
- 16:22They can change the physical structure of the
- 16:23neuron over time, yes. It's incredible. The electrical
- 16:27spike triggers calcium, calcium dumps chemicals,
- 16:30and those chemicals either trigger a fast spark
- 16:32or alter DNA. And the two main neurotransmitters
- 16:36pulling the levers here are glutamate and GABA.
- 16:39Glutamate is the primary excitatory neurotransmitter.
- 16:42It's the accelerator, creating an EPSP. While
- 16:45GABA and glycine in the spinal cord act as the
- 16:48brakes, they are the primary inhibitory neurotransmitters,
- 16:52creating an IPSP, making it harder for the neuron
- 16:55to fire. But here's where we tie this all back
- 16:57to the psychometric functions we graphed earlier.
- 16:59The release of those neurotransmitters isn't
- 17:01perfectly synchronized. No, it is not. The timing
- 17:04of the action potential, the rush of calcium,
- 17:07the drifting molecules, it all contains a tiny
- 17:09inherent amount of physical randomness. Yes.
- 17:12Noise in the system. A sensory neuron will not
- 17:14fire the exact same microsecond every time it
- 17:17detects a stimulus. And that variance is where
- 17:19the philosophical theories get really wild. Or
- 17:21the free will argument. Yeah, if there is literal,
- 17:25fundamental unpredictability at the cellular
- 17:27level, some neuroscientists and philosophers
- 17:30argue that this physical noise is the only place
- 17:32where human free will or even the concept of
- 17:35a soul could interact with the biological machine.
- 17:37Because if the brain were perfectly deterministic,
- 17:39we'd just be biological clocks. Exactly. But
- 17:42because the synapses are noisy and unpredictable,
- 17:46there is room for the ghost in the machine to
- 17:48influence the vote. It is a profound intersection
- 17:51of neuroscience and philosophy. But getting back
- 17:54to the mechanics for our exam, the action potential
- 17:57cannot just fire. It must travel rapidly. If
- 17:59you step on a piece of glass, you need that non
- 18:02-susceptive signal to reach your brain instantly.
- 18:04Which brings us to conduction velocity. And myelin.
- 18:07Myelin is that livid -rich insulation created
- 18:10by oligodendrocytes in the CNS and Schwann cells
- 18:12in the PNS. Yes. And the speed differences blew
- 18:15my mind. Our skinny staxons, the C fibers that
- 18:18carry pain and temperature, are unmyelinated.
- 18:20Because they lack insulation, they conduct at
- 18:22about one meter per second. That is literally
- 18:24walking speed. Contrast that with wide myelinated
- 18:27A fibers, which carry signals for touch and pressure.
- 18:31Because the myelin insulates the axon, the signal
- 18:34jumps from one tiny gap in the myelin to the
- 18:37next, the nodes of Ranvier. Saltatory conduction.
- 18:40Exactly. This allows the signal to travel at
- 18:43over 100 meters per second. Race car speeds.
- 18:46Which completely explains why if you stub your
- 18:48toe, you feel the immediate pressure of the impact
- 18:51instantly, but the throbbing ache of the pain
- 18:54takes a second or two to arrive. Because the
- 18:56pressure signal drove a race car to your brain,
- 18:58but the pain signal had to walk. That is so cool.
- 19:02But it also highlights why demyelinating diseases
- 19:04are so catastrophic. If the myelin is damaged,
- 19:07that high -speed saltatory conduction fails.
- 19:10Yes. Multiple sclerosis is an autoimmune disease
- 19:13where the body mistakenly attacks the myelin
- 19:15in the central nervous system, leaving scars
- 19:18and causing massive deficits. And Guillain -Barre
- 19:20syndrome is similar, but it targets the peripheral
- 19:23myelin, which can lead to autonomic failures
- 19:26like a sudden drop in heart rhythm. When the
- 19:28hardware loses its insulation, the software crashes.
- 19:32It's a delicate chaotic system. Wow. Okay, looking
- 19:34over our notes, I think we've covered the entire
- 19:36journey for the textbook reading. We take physical
- 19:39energy from the universe, our receptors transduce
- 19:42it into graded potentials. If the yes votes win,
- 19:45it triggers an action potential, a digital spike
- 19:47that races down the myelinated axon. It hits
- 19:50the terminal, calcium rushes in, exocytosis dumps
- 19:54neurotransmitters to vote on the next cell. A
- 19:56perfect summary. And all of that messy, noisy
- 19:59data ultimately arrives in the brain, where our
- 20:02top -down process organizes it into the conscious
- 20:04hallucination we call perception. You've synthesized
- 20:07the source material perfectly. Yeah. But before
- 20:09we finish our study session, I want to leave
- 20:11you and our listener with a final thought to
- 20:14chew on. Oh, wait me. We've established that
- 20:16our perception relies on psychophysical thresholds
- 20:18that differ from person to person. Our neurobiology
- 20:21dictates how much data we compress or expand.
- 20:24Our synapses operate with random noise. And ultimately,
- 20:27every sensation is filtered through our highly
- 20:30individualized top -down biases. Given all of
- 20:33those variable layers of biological and psychological
- 20:35translation, is it possible that no two humans
- 20:39have ever experienced the exact same reality?
- 20:42Are we all just sitting in our own isolated psychophysical
- 20:44universes doing our absolute best to translate
- 20:47each other's hallucinations? Well, that's a suitably
- 20:50existential note to end on. Good luck sleeping
- 20:52after contemplating your isolated psychophysical
- 20:55universe. And more importantly, good luck on
- 20:57the upcoming exam. Thanks for joining our study
- 21:00group. Keep questioning your reality, and we
- 21:02will catch you next time on The Psychology Undergrad.