Latest / Word Balloon Comics Podcast / Robin Lives With Jim Starlin Denny O'Neil Mike Barr and more
Transcript
- 0:03Hi, everybody, welcome back. It's word Balloon the Comic Book Conversation Show
- 0:07John Cuntriss here you know. DC made an announcement regarding the infamous story Death
- 0:14in the Family that was written by Jim Starlin and drawn by Jim Aparo.
- 0:19Great Mike Mignola covers this was the death of Jason Todd. You'll remember.
- 0:24It involved the nine hundred number that you could call and say kill Robin or
- 0:29save Robin. I called, I said kill Robin. Well, regardless,
- 0:35it happened, and for a long time Jason Todd was dead or believed to
- 0:39be dead, as they say in the Incredible Hope beginning, But I guess.
- 0:44Over the weekend at New York Comic Con, DC made the announcement that
- 0:48they are going to reprint Death in the Family with the Robin lived scenes.
- 0:52We've seen that panel of Batman carrying Jason and saying he's alive. They used
- 0:59to put that in all the trades of Death in the Family. Well,
- 1:02now a new edition coming out with the alternate scene of Jason living. I
- 1:07had the pleasure of hosting a terrificon panel years ago with a lot of the
- 1:12men who wrote Robin including Jim Starlin who wrote the infamous Death in the Family
- 1:18story, including Denny O'Neill, who was the editor at the time. And
- 1:25it wasn't an easy decision for the men, and it had consequences. Jim
- 1:30Starlin lost his Batman writing job because of that. Good news. He got
- 1:34with Marvel and immediately proceeded to write the Infinity goallet. So everything was fine
- 1:40with Jim ultimately. But what can you say. I mean, I want
- 1:45to let the men tell their story. They did on this great Terrificon panel
- 1:49from a couple of years back, also Mike Barr on the panel, Pete
- 1:53Tomassi and Tim Seeley who were doing some great Robin writing, and Dick Grayson
- 1:57writing. So it's fun to present this Robin panel from terrific On a few
- 2:05years ago, given the context of now we're finally going to see the full
- 2:09Death in the Family scene where there was no death. Robin lives. So
- 2:14all that to present to you on today's word Bloon. This episode of word
- 2:19Balloon is brought to you by the League of Word Balloon Listeners. Thank you
- 2:22very much, League for your support. Truly, your contributions via Patreon are
- 2:25greatly appreciated. It helps me keep the equipment up to date and helps me
- 2:30get to cons making the connections for more great programming here on word Balloon.
- 2:36I hope you'll continue to subscribe to Patreon, and if you haven't yet,
- 2:39maybe you'll consider it if you can afford it. Word balloon is free,
- 2:44It'll always be free, and I'm happy to provide this free content. But
- 2:46if you'd like to help the cause, the best way to do it is
- 2:50subscribing via Patreon. You can go to Patreon dot com slash word balloon,
- 2:53or you can go to word balloon dot com click on the Patreon ad.
- 2:58Is word balloon worth a dollar a mone? There's a worth the price of
- 3:00a comic book a month. I hope so, and I hope that these
- 3:04hours of comic book conversation are adding to your enjoyment of the culture. This
- 3:08is what I'm trying to do here Every week with new episodes of word Balloon.
- 3:12You can go to Patreon dot com slash word balloon or click on the
- 3:15Patreon ad at word balloon dot com. Thank you as always, League of
- 3:20word Balloon listeners. Word Balloon is brought to you by Alex Rossart dot com.
- 3:27Alex has been a long time sponsor of Word Balloon. I greatly appreciate
- 3:30it. You got to go to his website. You will find tremendous art
- 3:34from original work, covers, pages, fantastic lithographs, amazing posters. Every
- 3:42price point is covered and every subject is covered. At Alex rossart dot com.
- 3:46You've enjoyed his iconic looks at DC and Marvel, but also great stuff
- 3:51like his wonderful work on the Monkeys, Monty Python, so many other great
- 3:54pop culture things that Alex has put his fingerprints on. His wonderful Flash Gordon
- 4:00poster that evokes the fantastic Tino Dala reddest Sam Jones movie. Recently, Alex
- 4:05did things like the timeless Marvel covers featuring great solo shots of all your favorite
- 4:12Marvel heroes, and of course is fantastic four Full Circle graphic novel still available
- 4:17all waiting for you now at Alex rossart dot com. I mentioned Lollipop Kids
- 4:26because on the next Word Balloon you'll be hearing from Adam and Aiden about their
- 4:29book. Also what Adam is doing with the Teen Titans these days. But
- 4:32now it's time to talk about Robin with the men who know him best.
- 4:36I mentioned that incredible illustrative cast of writers we got together. It was one
- 4:42of the last panels at Terrificon and I was pleased to be able to moderate
- 4:46it and have this hilarious conversation with these wonderful creators whose work we've enjoyed literally
- 4:51from the sixties to today. So let's join our August panel with a discussion
- 4:58of Dick Grays and Jason Todd, Damian Wayne Tim Drake, the men who
- 5:02became Robin on word Balloon. Welcome to the Robin Palell. Everybody. I'm
- 5:08thrilled to be moderator is now. My name is John Sundris. I host
- 5:11a podcast called word Balloon, said worblon dot com, and I have one
- 5:15on one conversations with creators. Why do we have on our palel, But
- 5:18what a great opportunity to really look in the history of Robin with the men
- 5:24behind the creation the evolution of not just Jake Ray said, I got Jason
- 5:30Todd, Tim Drake, and of course Danian as well. So I'm going
- 5:32to start at the very end with one of the killers of Robin, the
- 5:36man who killed Jason Todd Ray jem start Lace, John n when he didn't
- 5:46do anything creative with the character. I just tried to give rooms. That's
- 5:53kind of one of the dynamics of the Robins storytelling. Do we need Robin
- 5:56or not? Other stories? But then, of course Dave Rayce had a
- 5:59great evolution under this man's work in the book rayson as a super spot tim
- 6:03Celia, you know, thank you. Then a wonderful Batman writer and editor.
- 6:13So I'm quart aboue or truly, and I'm really excited to talk about
- 6:16various points, including the death of Jason Todd, but even an earlier point
- 6:20as well. But the great Daniel Hill is another incredible Batman writer. He's
- 6:30run on the attective comments with down dais c's for itself, as I told
- 6:33I believe, I told Mike this and also alum what I loved him out.
- 6:38It was Batman smile when he was writing about and he was surely moren't
- 6:42human might bar everybody. That's a type of thing the father were taking it.
- 6:47Yeah, yeah, that's right. So and then forgive it because he's
- 6:50wearing over my shoulder. But another another rocket killer there. I brought that
- 6:57you didn't write it up. I brought him back okay, all right,
- 7:00excuse made the residation of the day again. But also the great run of
- 7:03Batman and Robin that was detechnically was Batman and Robin, right, yeah,
- 7:06Batman and Robin of course, a wonderful Batman, Rian, wonderful Superman and
- 7:10Waterworld writers, well, Petamassi, everybody. So I want to start because
- 7:18it wasn't I believe Frank Robins wrote the story. But you know, we
- 7:21had about thirty years of Batman and Robin once he finally debuted a couple of
- 7:28issues later in Detective Comics and that great Batman issue number one with a swinging
- 7:31back of Rooks. But it seemed by the late sixties, early seventies,
- 7:36and I can't remember the name of the of the story. Maybe somebody in
- 7:40the audience remembers. But when Robin went to Hudson University, and I wonder
- 7:43if you were part of that conversation of maybe it's time for Robin to grow
- 7:47up a bit and leave the nest if you will. Yeah, I don't
- 7:51know, or wayl right a lot. Yes, I don't know who thought
- 7:59what back then. I mean it was a very casual business and we I
- 8:05mean I didn't think the stuff would be remembered a year later or so.
- 8:11Yeah, I mean, the conventional wisdom was a comic book's life was a
- 8:16month, and I thought some of the stuff we were doing I was aware
- 8:20was pushing the envelope. So I thought, three months. Okay, they've
- 8:24just reprinted Green Lantern, Green Arrow for like the tenth time in hardcover,
- 8:31and it's it is good that I'm not a financial advisor. This prophecy thing
- 8:41is beyond me. But yeah, I mean, I think about then,
- 8:50the business as an entity was beginning to realize these characters should evolve. They
- 8:56are becoming dated, and besides, it's no phone writing on the same kind
- 9:01of story month after month. So it might have been Julie's idea to send
- 9:09Dick to Hudson. I was mostly just a hired hand. Then, of
- 9:16course, I was a hired hand who was working for arguably the best editor
- 9:22in comics, and certainly a very easy guy to get along with, and
- 9:26a very very good editor in that his ego never got between him and the
- 9:35work. It was always about the story and never about Julie. Hasn't always
- 9:43been the case, but that's the way to be an editor. Be invisible,
- 9:50but help your creative people. And that's exactly what he did during the
- 9:54rise at Willstart'm trying to remember how many did racist stories he did because of
- 9:58course what you and your as kind of separated Batman from the sixty six series
- 10:05and Batman became more serious, was Robin, you know, part of the
- 10:09story and it was fine, easy to work with as a character. Or
- 10:13did you want to want to get away from Robin as a character? Well,
- 10:16I think Mike bar might hit me with a microphone for what I'm about
- 10:22to say. But don't get me started. I never believed that Robin made
- 10:33any sense in terms of narrative because, first of all, you take when
- 10:41they started back in nineteen forty an eight year old kid, and you're going
- 10:46to put him against a bunch of heavily armed homicidal mania not good parenting.
- 10:54There colors where you were high in the shadow, the dark. Absolutely,
- 11:05yeah, I mean it's too Realistically, if there was any logic to Batman's
- 11:09costume, it was a ninja logic. It was dark, he could hide
- 11:13in shadows. So along comes an eight year old with bare legs and a
- 11:20dry tunic. In the same way that I think Batman and Superman don't really
- 11:30ever belong in the same story because you got one guy who can probably bench
- 11:35press four hundred and fifty pounds, and then you've got another guy who juggles
- 11:41planets and stars. So when I heard they were making that movie, I
- 11:46thought, dude, they have any idea what they're letting themselves in for how
- 11:52difficult it is to put these characters co starring in something and still maintained story
- 12:01integrity, narrative integrity. The way they solved it was they didn't solve it
- 12:09well. Now, I feel like I'm in a high school to make.
- 12:11So for a counter argument, Mike Barr, you know the usefulness of Robin,
- 12:18Well, this can't be proven until we discovered that parallel world where has
- 12:20never happened. But I've always felt that Robin was one of the basic ingredients
- 12:28to Batman's longevity. I think if you didn't have Robin in there, then
- 12:31Batman's constant quest for vengeance would have gotten would have gotten a little tiresome after
- 12:37a while, and the readers simply would have stopped reading. The interesting contrast
- 12:41about Batman is that he's not really He's not really a comic book character,
- 12:48and that he's very dark and very vengeance bound, as opposed to say Superman,
- 12:52who's more optimistic character. Superman is really a comic book character, as
- 12:56they conceived the comics back in the nineteen forties as a kids medium, and
- 13:01Batman is a little tougher to pull off for kids because he's so because he's
- 13:05so grim, And I think that's I think the addition of Robin basically helped
- 13:07that. It's funny because Frank Miller and I used to have a joke about
- 13:13about Robin back in the eighties, when you know, from Batman would say,
- 13:16we'd get a call from Commission. He used to believe that Robin was
- 13:22basically rob The Robins got killed almost every case, and Batman would simply recruit
- 13:26more Robins. And so so Batman would get a call from Commission a board
- 13:31that says, you know, the Jokers taking over the water supply of got
- 13:33Fam City, and Betman would say, that's probably a five Robin job.
- 13:37I'm gonna need five rob and you go on and you go on from there.
- 13:43That's excellent. Yeah. My favorite mind from the Justice League movie who
- 13:48was when someone asks Batman what his powers are and he says I'm rich.
- 13:56Absolutely, So Rob goes off to college. Eventually, you know, abandons
- 14:03the Robin identity, did Races, becomes Nightwing. There's a new Robin and
- 14:09Daddy before I get to gym knocking him off. Tell us about the beginnings
- 14:15of Jason Todd because there was an origin and then in my right, Max
- 14:18Collins then wrote a second origin where he became more of a street kid.
- 14:24I remember he stole the batmobile tires and that obviously caught that that's attention.
- 14:28Yeah, that was for me as an editor of Learning Experience, because yeah,
- 14:35we screwed, we made mistakes. Now, nobody had ever done what
- 14:39we were doing before, so I don't think we ought to wear hair shirts
- 14:43about this. But yeah, I mean I I carry around a lot of
- 14:50regret for the things that I did wrong when I was professionally involved. And
- 14:58we could have done with that story. But Jim is the Jason TODDD expert
- 15:05up there, I would say, yeah, talk about it. I find
- 15:09that amusing because I said, my entire run out of Batman tried to avoid
- 15:13Jason Cott. There you go. You kept forcing me to do stories involving
- 15:18him. You know, we do three or four Batman and no Jason and
- 15:22no Robbin, and Denny said, you gotta put Robin in your eventually.
- 15:26And I mean he worked well inside the cold with that we did with Bertie,
- 15:33but I always found him. That's a great story. Kind of a
- 15:35strange you know what we talked about earlier about fighting crime with a teenager and
- 15:39the dangerment and all that. So basically what I was trying to do is
- 15:46avoid him, and Denny was pushing him on me and we Denny eventually came
- 15:50up with the idea, well, we had to remember the Aids book they
- 15:54were going to do up at DC, and they were voting on who was
- 15:58going to do it, and I was trying to get Robert I would think
- 16:02wanted to give Robin HIV. Oh yeah, wow wow after doing interesting and
- 16:07eventually what edited up is that Jimmy Olsen was voted to have it. Oh
- 16:12my god. But then Dasey found out that the actor who played Jimmy Olsen
- 16:17in the Christopher Reeves movie was gay, and so they abandoned whole pride.
- 16:21Oh wow. Okay. Mike Mark Mark Cannon, I forget what his mark
- 16:26was? His first in Mark what clutter think? Mike absolutely, and then
- 16:30great Any came up with the I came upon the idea of the call of
- 16:33the Thing, and I had almost given up on the lobby and on getting
- 16:37rid of it Robin at this point, but Denny gave it a new light
- 16:42and we went from there. I voted because it was so shocking I vote.
- 16:49I voted on the nine hundred number or eight hundred number to kill Robin
- 16:52because you know, reading these books, just like when Jerry Connway killed Gwen
- 16:57Stacy, my nine year old one, and I went to read it,
- 17:02I'm not that but still, and it's like these characters never did really die
- 17:07in comics. I mean this was before Mary Allen died, So I mean
- 17:11yet, I mean was that upstairs? Was this a big problem for parately?
- 17:15Given Robins waits on birthdaycaches, he became green cards in the life.
- 17:19Are there any time Warner executives in the room. Hey, I don't care,
- 17:30I get my pension, you guys can I'm retiring? No, we
- 17:36went. My best editorial tool was getting people together to talk. I believe
- 17:44that that it should be about the story and not about the egos. So
- 17:49if you have a dozen people working, we would try to do six months
- 17:55two years continuity. One of the disagreements are Darren, are you here over
- 18:00here, over there, over there? Yeah. I disagreed with my merry
- 18:06men because they wanted it all tightly plotted, and I wanted to know what
- 18:11the important story you beats were, and to leave some room for the the
- 18:15individual creative people to come up with a better idea. And occasionally they did
- 18:22a much better idea than mine. Uh so, even even back in the
- 18:27day than he when, for instance, oh I'm I'm Darren Vincenzo, I
- 18:34was so, what did Dennis Drew with fesc comics back in the nineties.
- 18:42Yeah, I edited, uh Vienio. I was the editor protected for a
- 18:47while. I had hoped introduced to the back girl the uh stuff at the
- 18:51deal. Yes, y wow, that's entertain Yes, that was. Yeah.
- 18:57Those guys were so good that I went to lunch with Paul Levits after
- 19:03both of us retired, I Darren and Jordan and Scott, and I told
- 19:11Paul a year at a time exactly when we were quitting, to give him
- 19:18all the time he needed to know, hire new people to do whatever sect
- 19:26here Jim. That was. That was the crew. After the nineties back
- 19:30up the DC books. But I think, as what Denny brought up when
- 19:33he was talking about Jason Todd, Denny as an editor has always returned to
- 19:40his entire game team, always writers, all his editorial set out. You
- 19:42know, anybody that would get Tom put in on stories on characters, on
- 19:48things that were results. And I'm sure it's no different when you were Jason
- 19:52Todd situation, Jim, he probably could could have attest to this, uh,
- 19:56you know, when it was time to do something with Jason Todd or
- 20:00possibly do something with Jason Todd. You know, Daddy would bring in people.
- 20:03He'd talk to the writers and talk to the editors and make some decisions
- 20:07about what he felt, you know, was best for the character. And
- 20:10I guess you came up with this idea to have this nine hundred number,
- 20:14have people vote, have the fans vote. So yeah, can we circle
- 20:18back to the question that I I was just killing Robin. I was gonna
- 20:22give the corporate people killing kid good background. The story did not play as
- 20:33we originally plotted it because at one of those things at Terry Towns or we
- 20:40used to meet, we had killed Robin or the fans that actually killed Robin.
- 20:51So I thought, they will believe that I'm capable of killing Madman,
- 20:55or we are collectively, because there's a precedent for it. And so therefore,
- 21:02when he comes back after a year, they're going to sell it ninety
- 21:06jillion copies and we will get a challenging story out of it. That was
- 21:12always part of ourgin. I don't know that it still is always, but
- 21:18for us, it was always at some level about the story. So we
- 21:25knew we were taking a chance. And so at one of these retreats at
- 21:30Terrytown, about every ninety minutes, somebody in the room would call New York
- 21:37and say, you understand what we're telling you. It's going to look like
- 21:45we've killed Batman. And it's not too late for us to change our mind.
- 21:51We've got all afternoon. We could plot a whole new continuity. But
- 21:53are you sure you understand what I'm telling you. Yeah, So we went
- 22:03ahead with the thing. And then three months later, I am walking through
- 22:10the lobby where DC's headquartered headquarters were, and an executive stopped me, and
- 22:21the executive kind of said, you've killed Batman. You can't do that.
- 22:26I said, well, we told you, And in a year from now.
- 22:30If if you don't read a Batman comic this year and you pick one
- 22:34up in a year, you won't know that anything has changed. We're going
- 22:38to put all the two pieces back in place. But uh, sometimes anybody
- 22:48who's worked in the media, TV, particularly but anywhere knows that sometimes executives
- 22:56don't quite understand what the ft you're talking about and playing with sentences. So
- 23:07we came up with that I thought reasonably lame storyline wherein Bruce Wayne disguises himself
- 23:17as a body British detective. That's knife fault. Okay, so that was
- 23:22killing knife fault. Yeah, that took the edge off of the Batman story.
- 23:27If we had actually convinced the readership that yeah, he's dead, it
- 23:33would have been a very profitable thing to do. Also, it would have
- 23:37been interesting for us as storytellers. But that was one of three times in
- 23:42seventeen years I was overruled. And my guess is this, it's only a
- 23:49guess. All those telephone calls we made from Terrytown, I have a pretty
- 23:57good idea of which executive took to them, and I don't think she undered,
- 24:02she paid any attention to what I was saying no, no, you
- 24:07mentioned last night and a different panel. It just kind of came out,
- 24:11you know, casually that unfortunately for Death and the Family, an epic battan
- 24:17story that we all remember in the Death of Robin. I've seen that Jim
- 24:19and Parrel panel where oh he's alive. They alternate in the Red Hood,
- 24:25right, Yeah, but yeah, talk I mean talk about your experience writ
- 24:29and Sert, but also post story where as opposed to killing Batman, which
- 24:33you were talking about killing Robin. Obviously, the executives and licensing never found
- 24:40out about it until after the fact because I remember them exploding at us because
- 24:47they had all these dampajamas and lunge of boxes and stuff like that, right,
- 24:51and the better shakeout of it at the end. You know, they
- 24:56were pretty pissed off at us as Era Ball and you were left hold of
- 24:59the back. Unfortunately, I sort of came change came down to that.
- 25:03But you know, but it worked out okay for me because I went over
- 25:06to the Infinity. God let it happy any at least Jason. I didn't
- 25:11have a happy an yeah, and I voted for the kid to live.
- 25:18Uh. Dick Geordonald was my boss. Uh, no. I voted thumbs
- 25:25down and Dick voted thumbs up. My logic was this, they won't,
- 25:32they will dare they will see if we're going to go through with this,
- 25:37and Dick thought no, it would be too ugly. So it was a
- 25:42basic disagreement. So Mary Frian and I were in my office at ten after
- 25:49seven one Friday night, and I made the last phone call to the phone
- 25:56company and got the final count and went down and put the correct panel where
- 26:03it had to be, and we thought, it's been an interesting experiment.
- 26:07It's over. Wow. The rest of my logic was, I thought,
- 26:14if its thumbs down, I've got a hell of an editorial problem to solve
- 26:21beginning Monday, because yeah, we're we're going to put the pieces back in
- 26:26place. Sure, And I didn't exactly know what that story could possibly be,
- 26:36but the problem got solved for me. My son once directed the movie
- 26:44for HBO, and one of the executives came in and said, don't like
- 26:51shwimmers pants. That doesn't work for me. Like that had nothing at all
- 26:56to do with the movie or anything about it, but this guy felt he
- 27:02had to make a decision and he didn't have any idea what a story,
- 27:07so it stupends there's I mean, there have been times in comic books where
- 27:15you couldn't have green on a cover, or you couldn't have spaceships or ray
- 27:19guns because the guys in the big office I feel they have to make a
- 27:27contribution. The problem with that is they are not capable of making a question
- 27:34that absolutely McKee's Robert McKee's storytelling course. Any of you that have taken it
- 27:45are probably aware that a lot of critical type people disagreed with the fact that
- 27:56he was doing that because they said, it's going to make everything the same
- 28:00story. It's just just going to be the same stuff repeated over and over,
- 28:04which is not even remotely true. But it's that kind of thinking that
- 28:12very often dominates television. And well, what I'm talking about is now ten
- 28:21years on a date, because television is our best source of drama. Correct
- 28:26movies are about explosions, iron man, it's going to blow up another factory.
- 28:33Those kids in here. Mike, I think you had a point to
- 28:37think about the death of Jason Talker. Well, I wanted to ask in
- 28:42terms of uh, well, I think the way you asked bobab the one
- 28:47of executives. We added to the death of Robin. Yeah, and I
- 28:51wasn't. Well. One of the ways that you would do, I think,
- 28:53adjust to that possibly, And I'm asking here, is if you realize
- 28:57that if you're talking about the merchandising of rob it's it's that you would simply
- 29:02say, well, there will always be a Robin that is just not that
- 29:06same. So there's a guy who can be there's a kid who can be
- 29:08on the pajamas, in the lunch boxes and the candies and all that.
- 29:11It's just not the same guy, and we'll get some stories out of that.
- 29:15Is that how that worked? Yeah? I knew they weren't gonna let
- 29:21me eliminate Robin for exactly the reason you just said that. Sure it was
- 29:26worth millions merchandising less certainly, but they I don't know how they could not
- 29:33understand, Look, we're gonna have Robin. He's gonna look exactly like Robin.
- 29:38It's not gonna get in the way of your merchant. You're not gonna
- 29:41get in the way of anything. It's just gonna give us a story to
- 29:45tell. And you have to be pretty dense not to understand that. But
- 29:52somehow they didn't, and Marv wrote the Tim Drake story that introduced Tim,
- 29:57and suddenly Tim, Tim almost became your guy's point of view of course Batman
- 30:03needs and he was a very much improved version of Robin, I thought.
- 30:10And I give complete credit to Jim Starlin and Marvin Wolfman because that was not
- 30:18an easy editorial problem to solve, and they solved it beautifully. They they
- 30:25we ended up with a better character than what we started to doing. Anything.
- 30:30Yeah, fortunately Tim Drake. Okay, yeah, unfortunately, as as
- 30:37Jim said earlier, you know, someone had to take the blame for killing
- 30:41Robin. Denny was one of the big editors and stuff. But I think
- 30:44that poor Jim had was left holding the bag. So but again it worked
- 30:47out good because went to Marvel Infinity Gauntlet, and I think that's worked out
- 30:51nicely for Jim. If we've watched movies recently, so that's okay. But
- 30:56yeah, Tim Drake, obviously it has become an interesting and is still now
- 31:02in the in the books and everything. But we also, Mike, you
- 31:06come up with the son of the Demon at the Birth of Damien, and
- 31:08that had to be a controversial please yeah, you know, yeah, you
- 31:14really have no idea what it was like, but because because I had said
- 31:18to to DC, well, actually the story itself, you know, the
- 31:22idea was that the Batman and Talia would would would would would have this have
- 31:26this child. And then during the course of the of the story, after
- 31:30some action where where will Talia is actually slapped around some she would still tell
- 31:36Batman and she had lost the baby. And at that point you think,
- 31:38okay, fine, then yeah, we just go back to business as usual,
- 31:41right, But then you realize at the end of the story then Talia
- 31:44is actually lying because she's afraid that having this knowing having this child around,
- 31:48is going to take the edge off of Batman. He's gonna get killed.
- 31:51So I'll tell him that there is no child and that will be fine,
- 31:55and you know, and I uh, and I figured, you know,
- 31:59they they would do with it what they would but they but again, people
- 32:02didn't seem to realize that we had done something that could be undone. It
- 32:07was sort of like, what had you done? What have you done?
- 32:09And I said, well, basically, you know, you forget that it
- 32:13wasn't my I mean, I mean, I wrote the story, but I
- 32:15didn't do it on my own. I didn't throw the story. I didn't
- 32:17love this story. I didn't sneak the art work into the printing planet and
- 32:22put it on my own and distribute. Everybody knew what I was doing.
- 32:25Everyone knew what was what we were doing. Actually, so I was a
- 32:29little surprised that the hear of the the story had created. And this was
- 32:34after Dark Knight returns Frank Miller's story had come out. Correct. Yes,
- 32:38yeah, so a more adult telling of Batman's stories had already been established.
- 32:45And I don't know if initially was it supposed to be incontinuity or was it
- 32:51supposed I mean this was a pre l sport as well with the Son of
- 32:53the Demon? Oh so how did how did detail? Was what was supposed
- 32:58to be? Kind of was the Son of It? Was your story about
- 33:00Damien and Batman'll Talia getting down? Was that? If you will? Uh?
- 33:06You know? Was that was that? Okay? Because again they they
- 33:09you know, wasn't going to be an inconnuit because I remember reading in fan
- 33:13magazines that it's like, oh no, no, no worry, this is
- 33:15this is out of continuity. Well that's what I thought too, But I
- 33:17I basically said to dig Jar Donna. Who's the man editor at that time.
- 33:21It was the editor of the of that graphic novel. You know,
- 33:24did he realized what we're doing in her? They said, yes, sure,
- 33:28there's no problem. And maybe there was. Oh was it? Well
- 33:34let's see, I thought it was, Well, maybe it was? What
- 33:37was was? Okay, okay, all right. I came in when the
- 33:43editorial work was all done on that. I didn't touch. No, that's
- 33:49true, Yeah, that's true. But I think you were the editor when
- 33:51the book was published. Yeah, yeah, because that was after album I
- 33:54had done Detective, so sure, so yeah, So I didn't really know
- 34:00whether they were going to incorporate the story into the bigger Cuntuwi or not.
- 34:05And I and and first for years it was it was absolutely Forbuden to even
- 34:10speak of it. And now all of a sudden, you know, Damian
- 34:14Wayne's everywhere. Well, yeah, Pete, this is a good opportunity to
- 34:16talk a bit about Damian Wayne. My problem was it was doctor that meant
- 34:22that neither Batman or Talia were virgins. And listen, I'm a Catholic,
- 34:27I mean, I am my standard. Well there's the thing. And it
- 34:32really was this great and standalone story. Son of the Demon that we all
- 34:37loved as Batman fans, and then Pete what happened in terms of bringing him
- 34:42forward and really deciding, hey, well I was editorial at that time.
- 34:45It was well Grant brought him back Grant Morris, and I hired Grant to
- 34:49write Batman. So Grant, obviously, you know, one of the first
- 34:52things he said was, let me check out the Son of the Demon,
- 34:55and because he wanted to bring a kid into this from Robins, so which
- 34:59he did. And uh then just over time, he he always initially he
- 35:02was gonna kill Robin right off the bat is just a question, uh not
- 35:07hit but when so he just kind of kept it going and going for a
- 35:10while, and then I actually ended up going freelance at that point. And
- 35:15uh then he was like, yeah, I want to go and I got
- 35:17the book with Batman and Robin, and then he goes, I wanna kill
- 35:21Robin. I'm like, oh good, I got to book Batman and Robin.
- 35:22I don't know they're gonna kill him. But but I was able to
- 35:27really play with dating and really add a lot of layers to him as I
- 35:30as I went on and uh and then explore I think for the first time
- 35:35when really, I mean, even though there's some really great stories in the
- 35:37past, took take a lot of time to explore the grief of it,
- 35:42the real you know what it, what had caused him emotionally and psychologically losing
- 35:45Damien, losing Damien as his son, and especially you know, you know,
- 35:50born of his Truman's blood, et cetera, et cetera. So uh
- 35:52so that hadn't been done, and a lot of some people were like,
- 35:54well, I mean it should be there month later. Wow, why isn't
- 35:57he over it already? And I was like, you know, let's let's
- 35:59silly, let's let's dig into it. And so I went into the five
- 36:01stages of grief and obviously used other DCU heroes, you know, to U
- 36:06to explore it with Batman and such, and you know, went from the
- 36:09streets of Godham, you know, to the depths of it, you know,
- 36:14everywhere in the dc that I could go, and then of course went
- 36:16to you know, streets of goth into the streets of Armaghetto and not Apocalyan.
- 36:21So it was a real cool way to just blow out Batman because what
- 36:24I love about Batman, which you know a lot of guys have said,
- 36:27of course who've written him, is that you know, he fits every genre
- 36:30in my head, so you know, even though you know you can sometimes
- 36:32say I know then he was like, you know, and know Danny hated
- 36:35him in space and all that, but I but I thought that emotional,
- 36:39that emotional through line for him, you know, worked when he went to
- 36:43get his son to the ends of the earth and beyond. You know,
- 36:45what you see up here going on now in real time is the editorial process
- 36:52because while we're all being polite, we obviously disagree absolutely, And what Levitt
- 37:01said was it's their turn out. Sure it may be heresy, but I'm
- 37:12saying that there is no right or wrong. Absolutely. Black and I have
- 37:15some fundamental disagreements about this stuff, and we work together fine. I have
- 37:22fairly radical disagreements with Frank Miller, but I wouldn't have any problem working with
- 37:29him tomorrow. It's the stuff has to evolve, and the mistake that the
- 37:37executives made for years and years is not believing that well. And that's the
- 37:43beauty of the indestructibility of the character, because, as Pete says, he
- 37:46can fit in various genres, but also the very things that you felt was
- 37:51wrong with having an eight year old fighting crime. Here comes Damien, eight
- 37:55year old ninja. Yeah that knows how to kill you twenty five different ways
- 38:00with a paper clip, you know, I mean, and that's and again
- 38:02it's extreme, but it's interesting. It builds new story and new story opportunities,
- 38:08and Tim, I want to get you in there, because as the
- 38:12Batman universe evolved, we also reached another point where it's time to kill a
- 38:15Robin again. Man, David Deal must hate it, I mean, the
- 38:20thing over the years. Really efore you know, uh for I forgetting me
- 38:23witch crisis. Wasn't that killed him? He just hates Dick Grace. Well
- 38:28there, I don't care. I don't understand, all right, But of
- 38:30course all of us are like Dick Grayson was our Robin, you know,
- 38:35Dick Grayson really a lot of us, you know, he was the witch
- 38:37fulfilment. Even as he got older, it was allowed to get older and
- 38:40stuff, and so he is presumed at final crisis. No, I don't
- 38:45even remember. I don't remember whither I had every oil painting by Dick Sprang
- 38:52hanging, and my off I said, home and listen, that's that was
- 38:58published when I was that's the real Batman. I agree, Fix Frank is
- 39:04an amazing Batman artist, but Grayson, so we get the evolutions. It's
- 39:08just like the opening of The Incredible Halt, Dick Grayson's presumed of the day.
- 39:13He must the world we want, believing that he is dead so he
- 39:15could pick up supers fining Grayson. I mean, to me, that was
- 39:19interesting to talk about the Robin stuff and not point out the most important thing
- 39:22about Robin is that it's hard for older people to understand the appeal because they
- 39:27see a bright color and a kid, and it's actually Robin. Is you,
- 39:30as a reader coming in to get to hang out with Batman. So
- 39:35Robin is more important than Batman actually, because he's the entry point, the
- 39:38kid who comes in and says, man, if I could just hang out
- 39:42with Batman, that'd be so cool, And you get Robin, and that's
- 39:44why Robin. I mean, I'm sure the majority of the people in these
- 39:46room one of the first characters they ever, you know, gravitated toward was
- 39:51Robin, whether he was ineing Teen Titans Go or the Batman animated series,
- 39:54or in the comic or maybe in the Joel Schumacher movies. I doubt it,
- 39:58but maybe the character is so fundamentally important to the mithos and the longevity
- 40:06of Batman, and I think there's a cynicism that comes with us when we
- 40:08get a little bit along in the career and we were like, oh,
- 40:12I just want to get rid of Robin, and you're wrong. You shouldn't
- 40:15get rid of Robin. And he's really important to the character. So you
- 40:21know, for me going to work on DECRESI, it's like, Okay,
- 40:23have to figure out why this character sticks around. And it's the thing is
- 40:28he has the opposite attitude of Batman. Right, he had a terrible thing
- 40:32happened to him and he had someone there to catch it, and Batman did
- 40:37it. So Batman became his way and Robin became night a cool guy who
- 40:42just wants to help you and have fun doing it. And speaking to Jeff
- 40:45Johns in his con argument to Dan Die when he said this on the podcast,
- 40:50it's like everybody loves Dack Grayson, the guy. The rest of the
- 40:53DC universe loves Data Race. He's like the best friend to ever want to
- 40:58typhus the Justice League because he's happy. Well, he's also the guy they
- 41:01hung out with when he was a cool kid. So they've seen him grow
- 41:05up. You know, they're just like you as a reader, you watched
- 41:08it grow up no matter which version you saw. He started out as a
- 41:13kid and he became a teenager in your lifetime, so that the DC EU
- 41:16Earth was character the same way. It's like your buddy's kid. Hey man,
- 41:19it's good to see you like you're happy to see your buddy's kid,
- 41:22you know. But the medium has evolved in such way that one of your
- 41:27questions gets answered. Yeah, we bring back Robin, but we don't have
- 41:36Rob, and let's make him an eight year old Robin. But let's give
- 41:40a story reason why that is the baddest ass eight year old kids absolutely on
- 41:49the East Coach. In the early comics, nobody was really thinking about characters.
- 41:54Most of those guys were refugees from the Pulps. And then Paul Plot
- 42:00was king uh Stan may have been the first two a comic book guy to
- 42:10really see the the entertainment value in logical plots, and his weren't terribly logical
- 42:21always. But he brought him back, but you didn't bring him back because
- 42:27his naive little right he was, Yeah, he was well versed in the
- 42:31artists and death and he was a well rounded individual. Like then we sort
- 42:36of a double based spread and talias on him the ninja arts, but then
- 42:40he was also learning from top teachers and music and he was a pure renaissance
- 42:45kid in a way. But he was as deadly as we could go.
- 42:49And you believe him as he was out there on the streets that Batman for
- 42:52the first time could have a kid at that age with him, and of
- 42:55course we tore him down. There were no more shorts that, yeah,
- 43:00thank god you have. But no, the character like they were getting into
- 43:04it was key understand well, I mean there was. I mean really the
- 43:07first death for me when I was reading, the first time that shocked me
- 43:09as a kid was when Captain Stacey died and of course the inspirement when that
- 43:14happened, that was like, wow, okay, this stuff is really you
- 43:16know, you could grab me at any time, you can get something taken
- 43:20away from you. So it was that was for me. And then of
- 43:22course Leadings did Gwen but and then the Million Robins, but I know it
- 43:27was the character is king for res I know when I write, and especially
- 43:30Rockland, well, I want to forgive me, but I know I really
- 43:34wanted to hear everyone's perceptions of the various Robins that they were with. So
- 43:37if people do have questions, I'd love to open the floor so speak.
- 43:42Did you ever get any feedback from Jerry Robinson about the different evolutions of Robin
- 43:46over the years, Jerry Robinson feedback from the various evolutions? Had you ever
- 43:51heard Jerry's opinion? No, I got to be pretty close to Jerry toward
- 43:55the end of his life. We were uh, always friendly acquaintances, we
- 44:04became friends at the end, and we never talked shop. Jerry was a
- 44:09renaissance man in his own way, and so yeah, we talked politics and
- 44:16current events and things like that. I don't think those early guys, with
- 44:25the exception of people like Eisner, would not have cop to it being an
- 44:30art farm, and they really didn't see any need to think about it too
- 44:36much, and even had a separate word for it. The science fiction writers,
- 44:39I don't remember what it is. It's in one of Alfred Bester's essay
- 44:45collections. Oh well, so, I mean it was their way of saying,
- 44:49well, this isn't really science fiction. They're just grinding it out.
- 44:53They were a basically yeah. We once asked the guy who ghost didn't the
- 45:01stuff like that's upped signed Bob Kane Chilly mayor uh us, Yeah, and
- 45:12he said Bob I had a family. Bob's checks didn't bounce. End of
- 45:19the story understood. Absolutely, yeah, man, I mean that's that is
- 45:22kind of the reality strontling. So the mots come in and the fan bo
- 45:29to g Jason Todd a line how the starry afterwards the alternate Yeah, and
- 45:37if Jason hide things, and they said we like about him is keep him
- 45:39around and hopefully was done. I would have gone back to trying to figure
- 45:44out stories later I collect him. I'll be honest about it. That's great
- 45:51though, Jim, honestly, and it's a it's a legitimate again, this
- 45:52is the bad Debby would have kept pushing me into doing. But again they
- 45:57brought that. They brought that into the comic Send does Batman Eater? And
- 46:00then again that became the reason for for Tim Draken's the guys say absolutely it
- 46:04does. Didn't get back with Batman and it's like, Joe, I've got
- 46:07my own life now. And of course that gave Denbi entree to the confident
- 46:10job. Sure, Robins has been killed in pretty violent graphic manners for years.
- 46:16It's so weird that this panel the generally just murder talk. It's so
- 46:20weird. It's like the happy, bright colored character of DC and all you
- 46:23guys want to talking about murder. So screwed up? Well yeah, I
- 46:29mean there's where you discussed and fled out where the more r than gen lesson
- 46:37beful manners never that side and said no, we're going the stream. No,
- 46:44it was a meaning with with Grandman. It was always go to be
- 46:46a pretty brutal death for Danien. But we knew were I mean, you
- 46:52know, we knew we were going to bring it back, and they was
- 46:54they wanted to Grant wanted to weigh properly closer than five years. I would
- 46:58I puote more for the year in a few months. I thought it was
- 47:00you know, it'd be too long await for Damien to be gone. Well,
- 47:05and it was great. I remember Rant saying and that great Scottish I
- 47:07say, can you go to the loo? And then you gotta cry as
- 47:09soon as I killed? So you know, who's who's that sort? I
- 47:15not? Only so Robin has been through quite a few stories told with Batman
- 47:21on his own as night Wing and Tim Drake you racing with the Teen Titans.
- 47:27I just want to wonder which version, which story do you think Robin
- 47:31had a chance to best shine on his own outside of Batman's shadow. Probably
- 47:38what Pete's been doing, are those guys. Yeah, I think we really
- 47:45led Damie Eden. I mean it it was It's called Battan and Robin,
- 47:47But I do think I let Robin sort of take center stage to a degree
- 47:52in that book and really wanted to, you know, layer it out of
- 47:54that. It was perfect timing for me because my son was at that age
- 47:58wan't want the new good started with it. So I was pulling a lot
- 48:01from our relationship is is a is a Angel and Devil's side in corporating you
- 48:07know, incorporating into uh the book like even a small I mean that's the
- 48:10best thing about Once for me and being a writer, is you know,
- 48:14you look at the garage when you see your son, you know, hold
- 48:16your h my mood against his boot, and in my head you never you
- 48:20never stop rioting. I'm like, oh, he could do that, and
- 48:22he need to do that in the Bad Gay with Badman's Boot and you know,
- 48:24just moall moments like that and informed the character. So it was really
- 48:28key for me. Didn't make Robin after everything he'd be done but done to
- 48:32him to really feel like a pleasure blood three dimensional character. Very cool,
- 48:37greater the whole table. Your favorite problem story? Okay? All right?
- 48:45Yet dot hold with Tom Rope your favorite Robins story, and I'll be interestingre
- 48:50like in uh Gyp's a ship's reaction that could We'll start with me start that,
- 48:54okay, him? Do you have the favorite Robins or was there ever,
- 48:58as a reader even or writer, a favorite Rocklin story? I do
- 49:05remember one that really stood out for me. Okay, I mean I might.
- 49:08I felt like a lot of Batman Ammon story, but I can't and
- 49:15just quiet bringing something to find well, I like yours fingall ibout to exalt
- 49:20Joker as well. I mean your your own story of killing him was a
- 49:22great Jason story of revenge and that really informs the characters subsequently, even I
- 49:30was a good about to find Batman, so I would you know when I
- 49:34haven't? Kind of curious is after you've killed so many Robins, where are
- 49:37you finding anybody who's willing? Did become a really the most managists and person
- 49:45I hate that definitely. I mean, there's lots off with Robert. I
- 49:54think the first tim drank stories when he was first introduced, was it the
- 49:59perfect time for me? I was a teenager, and you know this character
- 50:02who comes into and approaches it with how vengeance or angers is someone who's inherently
- 50:08good. I love that stuff. A lot of the Dick Grayson t type
- 50:13stuff is fantastic. I think some of the stuff we pulled off and Grayson,
- 50:17he's pretty good for meat, is pretty good for Robin. I think
- 50:22there's a good rock staff. Do you have a favorite Robin story? Was
- 50:30two ways to look at this. Mike mentioned one of them Robin has provided
- 50:38an effect comic relief. He lines things up a little bit. The other
- 50:44side is it's not logical to have him in the story. And I could
- 50:51argue either side. As a writer, I kind of found him to be
- 50:59a pain in the butt because when I started, there was understood there had
- 51:07to be a Robin in a Batman story. Sometimes he didn't belong there.
- 51:12Now, as the medium and my relationship with Julie Schwartz evolved, I didn't
- 51:19have to do that anymore, and I think as bits of narrative, the
- 51:24stories were improved. I mean, Robin wasn't necessary evil for me. But
- 51:30I never believed that I was the boss of DC Comics. I basically did
- 51:37what they told me to do unless it crossed some kind of private manerl line.
- 51:44I would not write a story glorifying war, though there were plenty of
- 51:49them written. I had some problem with romance stories, not from any sense
- 51:59of more outrage, but because they were kind of lame stories. Okay,
- 52:07if it was a given that there was gonna be Robin, if there was
- 52:10a Batman, and okay, we can make a work. You're all with
- 52:14an Mike favorite Robin stories. There's a story from nineteen sixty three or maybe
- 52:22early sixty four, the very end of Jack Shifts from on Batman called Robin
- 52:28giz a Dawn. That's good one one which is one of the more which
- 52:32is one of the more famite stories from that era, in which deals although
- 52:36it looks like a science it looks like one of the whacky science fiction stories.
- 52:38Originally, it actually resolves itself into a more or less naturalistic of situations,
- 52:45and it's explodes the relationship between Batman and Robin very well. I've read
- 52:50it absolutely. You know, I can't think of the story or say but
- 52:53acting with Mike, with Mike sitting next to me, I think, I
- 52:57like, really just the exuberance and the dynamic duel as big likes Batman or
- 53:02robis or there's just so much life and them together. But that was working.
- 53:07That's awesome. And Allen dream one of the best Robin's ever shown,
- 53:10and he was like a teenager, was always moving and he was you know,
- 53:14he's really entertaining. That's great. Well, that's again there was this
- 53:16positivity about your run on Batman always. Yeah, well that was that basically.
- 53:22I don't know if I can take any credit for that, per se.
- 53:25I was just trying to do, in more or less terms of modern
- 53:30comics in those days, what Bill Fender and Bob Kane and Dick Sprang and
- 53:34Jim Mooney and all those guys had done back then was just to explore the
- 53:37relationship with Batman and Robin, which was Batman and Robin. Is this either
- 53:43either are they a good brother or little brother? Are they father and son?
- 53:45Are they uncle and nephew? Well they're they're maybe all those, And
- 53:49that one of them has to be in that uh you know, one of
- 53:52them is in charge in one of them and one of whom follows the orders,
- 53:54and but but but but Robin is able to take initiative on his own
- 53:59when he has to, and a two percent initiative, I'm just gotta throwing
- 54:02mine at the US. But the Ulsi Robbin team that used to show up
- 54:07in the World smiles back in the Silver Age again as a kid. And
- 54:09I love those stories because it was the two side case getting together and doing
- 54:14their own thing. So we've got to try one pitches sequel to that in
- 54:16Grace where he has a team up and spy and reporter. I thought that,
- 54:20but again she got a shot down to too happy finish. Yeah.
- 54:23Hi, And I'm hoping Venus will put Jimmy back where he belongs as far
- 54:28as providence. But we got about five minutes left. And the other are
- 54:31questions like n sure answer for my daughter. She likes to keep tankans go
- 54:36absolutely and I'm a therapist and like Keith hangtans go Robins so erotic kind of
- 54:40treating. What story have you guys ever written that would show the very home
- 54:45of melody of a Robin The anxiety where he's not sobering poems where he's not
- 54:52so together. That's why star all the characters on teen Tanks got erotic,
- 55:00not just fight is revitally. Would you said that's one of Damian's weaknesses,
- 55:04that is that he doesn't really as evolved as he is. You know,
- 55:07obviously he's still a ten year old kid. Yeah, that's de mentioning about
- 55:10Damiens. You can write him has killed a ninja. At the same time,
- 55:15you know, he's still just a kid. And I think, I
- 55:16mean I A heard that Van and Robin Aroun we do that. I never
- 55:21just let that takes enter stage. I always go in to show that he's
- 55:24a kid and you know, dealing with a lot of stuff. So most
- 55:29of that one has a lot of that in there, about just self doubt
- 55:31and also just the status of his mother treating him the way she does and
- 55:37stuff like that. So that's that's all in there, Mike uh. I
- 55:43suppose my favorite story imagine category is the as an issue with the tenant comments
- 55:47and Alan Davis and I did where they fuck the Scarecrow and and and it's
- 55:52a reveal band basically Robin in this case, Jason one of his biggest fears
- 55:58is family Ma's He's to terrify that he's not gonna be able, that he's
- 56:04never going to be good enough to to to and to accept the role.
- 56:07And that's some crucial appointment Ben and his life is a stake. Jason will
- 56:10fail him actually, kind of the way I feel about Nail Latins. I
- 56:15will never be good enough to ye that my story is the one I would
- 56:22recommend. That's that's a great story. And again all Davis, so it
- 56:25looks beautiful, and that was when Scarecrow is really creepy and he doesn't look
- 56:30like he should be able to it's like a you know, with twigs holding
- 56:32up the sack. It's great. It's a really good story. Again,
- 56:36you just once, I haven't made my own personal thing. I didn't really
- 56:43do a story where we left it where Robin may or may not have murdered
- 56:46some guy at the end of the story. Yes, and then right before
- 56:51t in the family. Absolutely, Jim, I remember that story very well,
- 56:53and it was that kind of smug satisfied again playing right too, Jason
- 56:59Todd. Is that everything that I know what I'm doing, but obviously showing
- 57:01us frailty and I think that's great call. Yeah, I remember that story
- 57:05very well. Yeah, let's good. Great run man. Absolutely, I'm
- 57:07glad that things might have created stuff in terms of going back to Marvel Cosmick
- 57:12for you. But yeah, it's it's a shame because Julie Janet to help
- 57:15her run out bad. So yeah, I was I was wanted to be
- 57:17like, let's starting a thought happen you said, I'll go to the table.
- 57:23Probably time for one fast question. It's got to be a lightning question.
- 57:27So anybody that will rob nobody? All right? You know seriously,
- 57:31an excellent conversation about the evolution of Robin by the men that don't ends.
- 57:37So thank you for your attention. Thank you, Connel for a frank conversation.