Latest / American Combat Files / Episode 9 Companion Video: Steel vs. Steel: M4 Sherman vs. German Tiger I
Transcript
- 0:15In 1944, the standard American M4 Sherman tank went to war
- 0:22armed with a 75mm main gun. History often critiques the
- 0:29Sherman tanks armor and firepower as weak, but the
- 0:33Sherman tank was built for an extraordinary primary purpose,
- 0:38primary mission, and that was to provide infantry support.
- 0:43So somewhere along the way, the Army decided that the primary
- 0:47mission was to provide infantry support and that was slightly
- 0:53more important than tank on tank or tank on tank capabilities.
- 0:59That should provide us here on this podcast or on this episode
- 1:04with the perspective needed before we dig into those details
- 1:08of the Sherman tank. The M4 Sherman tank.
- 1:12This tank was a fantastic tank historically, and it could
- 1:17systematically dismantle enemy bunker networks and German anti
- 1:23tank gun nest with high explosive rounds which were
- 1:27badly needed for American infantry to advance on the
- 1:31battlefield in Europe. But when a Sherman tank found
- 1:35itself face to face with the thick frontal armor of a German
- 1:40Tiger one, yeah, the map changed entirely.
- 1:45At any range over 500 yards, the Sherman's 75mm main gun shooting
- 1:52an armor piercing round simply wasn't a match against Army
- 1:59Tiger tanks. Also, pop culture and films and
- 2:05video games paints the M4 Sherman as fragile undergun or
- 2:10under undergunned death trap. However, this reputation, this
- 2:14reputation does not match the truth in the tanks crucial
- 2:21historical contacts. And that's why we're having this
- 2:25companion video. Welcome back to American Combat
- 2:29Files today. It's the match up everyone asked
- 2:33about the American M4 Sherman tank versus the German Tiger 1.
- 2:39Sure, the German or the Sherman tank tangled with Panzers and
- 2:45German Panther tanks across every theater in Europe.
- 2:48But in this episode, we're going to lock in on the deadly
- 2:52mismatches, the tactical realities, and the raw,
- 2:57unvarnished stats of the Sherman taking on the feared German
- 3:02heavy armor or armored Tiger tank.
- 3:06Before we dig in, I'd like to cover today's relevant verse.
- 3:12Is Ephesians 611 Put on the whole armor of God that you may
- 3:17be able to stand against the Wiles of the devil?
- 3:22Now on to episode 9 companion video.
- 3:25Steel versus steel M4 Sherman versus the Sherman versus the
- 3:30German Tiger 1. So let's talk about the armor
- 3:35and the reality. As we touched on earlier, the
- 3:38standard M4 Sherman mounted a 75mm main gun, but when
- 3:44examining its combat performance, the real story lies
- 3:48in the protection of the tank crew inside the tank.
- 3:53With all tanks for that matter. The Sherman featured a 5050mm
- 3:59thick frontal armor plate, and that was at a 56° slope, which
- 4:06seemed sufficient. But that slope was designed, and
- 4:10that slope was designed to divert AP rounds or for future
- 4:14reference, AP armor piercing to protect the crew inside.
- 4:19While that might sound sufficient on paper, against a
- 4:23high velocity German anti tank gun, it simply wasn't enough,
- 4:28and tragically we lost far too many brave American tank crews
- 4:34because of that statistic. That's a harsh reality, and
- 4:40that's where many of the historical critiques and
- 4:43complaints originate from. In contrast, though, the Sherman
- 4:48was an incredible workhorse of logistics.
- 4:51American America really at this time needed a mass produce or
- 4:58needed to mass produce as many tanks as possible to overwhelm
- 5:03the German army. But improvements were
- 5:06desperately needed. Before we look at how those
- 5:11upgrades were made, let's breakdown the core
- 5:15specifications of the Sherman tank.
- 5:18The Sherman tank was around weighed about 33 tons and it had
- 5:22a capability of going 30 mph, which is pretty fast for a tank
- 5:26in these days. The M4 Sherman tank could move
- 5:30rapidly over roads and trails, it could keep pace with
- 5:33advancing infantry, and just as importantly, it would fit on
- 5:38standard US transport ships and rail cars.
- 5:44That way they could be transported all over Europe.
- 5:48Another key factor is because of the weight it could cross most
- 5:53European bridges that would not collapse.
- 5:58In comparison to the German Tiger which was 60 tons that
- 6:04would not hold most bridges. Yes, 60 tons, double the weight
- 6:08of the Sherman. Remember that before the war,
- 6:13America did not have a modern concept of a of a main tank.
- 6:18The only tank the Army produced was a light tank called the M2
- 6:21light tank with a 37mm main gun that was basically obsolete by
- 6:281939. And certainly we could not fight
- 6:30the German Army and the the German armored Calvary regiments
- 6:36they had with this tank, with this light tank.
- 6:39So American. The American Army faced an
- 6:43eternal balancing act in tank design.
- 6:46Really. We needed a tank with firepower,
- 6:49protection and mobility. Get that firepower, protection
- 6:55and mobility In tank design, at least of this era, you can
- 7:01almost never have all three of those at maximum level.
- 7:06If you add weight to armor to protect the crew from high
- 7:09velocity anti tank rounds, you got to add tons more.
- 7:13Weight demands a larger engine. It stresses the transmission,
- 7:17tears up the tracks, and limits the bridges you can cross.
- 7:22If you listen to episode 9 Battle of the Bulge, which is a
- 7:26companion video of Battle of the Bulge, Thunderbolt 6, and the
- 7:31Cobra King, I recommend you go do that.
- 7:34You know that speed and mechanical reliability were
- 7:37often worth far more than raw armor thickness.
- 7:41The 4th Armored Division could move fast, exploit enemy gaps,
- 7:45and outmaneuver the German army because the American Sherman
- 7:48tank didn't constantly break down under its own weight.
- 7:53At the same time, that weight and armor compromise came at a
- 7:58devastating cost to the crews when facing heavy German armor
- 8:03head on. It's a vital lesson in military
- 8:06history. Warfare isn't just about who has
- 8:09the biggest guns, but it's about logistics, mobility, and the
- 8:13brutal trade-offs forced upon the men that operate these tanks
- 8:18and the men that built them. So let's go back a little bit.
- 8:22In the beginning of World War 2, the M4 Sherman's 75mm gun was a
- 8:27short barrel gun, and it was a good gun at that moment could
- 8:31easily knockout a German Panzer 3 or Panzer 4 tank.
- 8:37And the Sherman's sloped frontal armor proved exceptionally adept
- 8:42adapt to deflecting incoming fire from standard German anti
- 8:47tank weapons at that time. But that all changed.
- 8:52That changed as the battle evolved in heavier German armor,
- 8:57specifically the Panther and the Tiger began to appear.
- 9:02The Sherman's, The Sherman tank struggled in direct tank on tank
- 9:05on tank duels. To close that gap, the US
- 9:09military upgraded the platform with thicker frontal armor and a
- 9:14vastly superior weapon. But unfortunately designed to
- 9:18production time or what we call flash to bank time, meant the
- 9:22American tank crews had to continue fighting with what they
- 9:26had during this gap, during this gap of time.
- 9:30This the mismatch caused American lives.
- 9:34This should be a lesson to all of us today.
- 9:37Having a strong American military with the best of
- 9:40equipment saves lives and deters our enemies from attacking us.
- 9:47That was not the case before World War 2 at the the American
- 9:51military had been stripped down to a meager Defence Force after
- 9:56World War One, which was called the Last War or the War of All
- 10:01Wars. How neat naive we were.
- 10:04Maybe we still are. So now the German tank shows up
- 10:09on the battlefield and honestly, we're getting our pants whipped.
- 10:16Let's do a quick comparison to the to the German Tiger One.
- 10:22But don't forget, I'm going to show us how the American
- 10:24Engineering Department answered the call and upgraded the
- 10:27Sherman. On paper, the Tiger One tank was
- 10:33a monster. Crew protection was at its
- 10:36maximum at 100mm thick armor plates and the frontal plates.
- 10:42But remember when I said earlier, adding weight adds
- 10:46problems? The Tiger was also, well, let's
- 10:49go back to this. The Tiger also had a lethal 88mm
- 10:53KWK 36 gun. That main gun could knockout a
- 10:57Sherman long before the American tank got close enough to scratch
- 11:02it. This is called range standoff.
- 11:07What does that mean? Well, it's simply the difference
- 11:11of distance between the maximum effective range of your enemy
- 11:15opponent's main gun to your gun. So the maximum effective range
- 11:20of the Tigers 88mm main gun was 1200 to 2000 meters.
- 11:27We don't use meters much here, so to bring that into
- 11:30perspective, 1000 meters is 9/10 of a mile.
- 11:34So the German Tiger tank could shoot and destroy an enemy tank,
- 11:38an American tank more than a mile away.
- 11:41More almost 2 miles away. Most people can't see that far
- 11:45to shoot. So that's where the tanks gun
- 11:49gutters optics come into play. The optics magnify just like a
- 11:53rifle scope but stronger. Let's drill down on the range
- 11:57standoff of the Sherman Tiger and the standard M4 Sherman
- 12:02tank. In comparison, the M4 Sherman
- 12:0675mm manga and had a maximum effective range of 500 to 1000
- 12:13meters, far shorter than the Tigers 1200 to 2000.
- 12:19So as you can determine, the range standoff at the maximum
- 12:24was of both tanks was about 1000 meters.
- 12:28Meaning if a German tank crew operating a Tiger one tank could
- 12:34observe you at their maximum effective range of 1200 to 2000
- 12:39meters, we'll say 2000 meters here, they could destroy you
- 12:43with their 88mm gun, but you could not turn around and shoot
- 12:47back and destroy them because you're 75mm guns maximum
- 12:51effective range was only 1000 meters.
- 12:55That is 1000m range standoff. That is what range standoff
- 13:01means and it's not a good feature for the Sherman tank in
- 13:04this matchup. But the Sherman or Greg
- 13:07correction. But the German Tiger tank was
- 13:12also an over engineered nightmare.
- 13:17As we mentioned earlier, at nearly 60 tons, it routinely
- 13:22tore up its own transmissions and Dr. shafts.
- 13:26To distribute this heavyweight, the Germans had to design A
- 13:30complex overlapping Rd. wheel design.
- 13:35Rd. wheels are the spoke steel wheels that are connected to the
- 13:39tracks and propel the tank forward or backwards.
- 13:46The Tiger tank overlapping Rd. wheels system provided the crew
- 13:50with a remarkable smooth rod, but required higher level
- 13:55maintenance. So if you don't know tanks in
- 13:59most armies, including the American Army, the tank crew
- 14:04must be able to repair, replace, and maintain tension on the
- 14:09tracked systems without mechanical experience.
- 14:12And they're trying to do that. This is called crew.
- 14:16This is called crew maintenance. Any maintenance above that is
- 14:22meant for a specialized mechanical team that knows how
- 14:25to work on that specific tank, but that also means that that
- 14:30tank is out of Commission. Usually when a Tiger tank broke
- 14:33down, recovering it often required two other heavy
- 14:38recovery vehicles, or worse, they would have to abandon it
- 14:42and blow it up so it wouldn't fall into allied hands.
- 14:46The Tiger tank was a fantastic tank as long as it was running,
- 14:51but another flaw was it burned through fuel at an unsustainable
- 14:55rate and required a specialized maintenance crew for every minor
- 14:59mechanical failure. That was a hindrance to the
- 15:03German armor corps. So to bridge that gap and outmut
- 15:09outmatched German armor units, the American Ordinance
- 15:13Department in the Pentagon or Department of War at that time
- 15:16introduced the 76 millimeter cannon on late model Sherman's
- 15:22like the M4A3 Sherman Jumbo Assault Tank, which we spoke
- 15:26about in our last episode. It fired a high velocity armor
- 15:32piercing round AP round. The 76 millimeter gave American
- 15:37Gunners like John Gatowski in Thunderbolt 6 and Milton
- 15:42Dickerson and Cobra King from episode 9 the teeth to fight
- 15:46back from a distance closing in that rain standoff we spoke
- 15:51about earlier and when they need to pure ammo like survivability.
- 15:57America's the new America's M4A3 Sherman Jumbo Assault tank.
- 16:03That was the answer. By doubling the frontal hole
- 16:07armor to over 4 inches and packing a massive 7 inch turret
- 16:13shield, the Jumbo can absorb direct hits from the German 88
- 16:18millimetre gun at point blank range.
- 16:21Where the Sherman tank truly dominated was in logistics,
- 16:25mechanical reliability, and operational speed.
- 16:29Consider these critical advantages.
- 16:33The power plants. Whether powered by the legendary
- 16:364G8 AAV 8, the engine inside Colonel Abrams Thunderbolt 6 and
- 16:44the Cobra King, or the Massive 30 cylinder Chrysler A57
- 16:49multibank Sherman engines ran for hundreds of hours without
- 16:54breaking down. That was key.
- 16:57Turret traverse here is a massive tactical advantage that
- 17:02people rarely talk about except in the tank circles.
- 17:06As a former Calvary scout on AM 2 Bradley Fighting vehicle, I
- 17:10can tell you first hand turret traversing speed is everything
- 17:15in a firefight. So a Sherman gunner in a Sherman
- 17:19tank could spend his turn a full 360° powered by a electronic
- 17:27hydraulics in about 15 seconds. A German gunner relying on hand
- 17:32cranks or engine dependent rotation could take up to a full
- 17:37minute, especially if the tank was parked on a slope which out
- 17:41even the hydraulic fluids. Mass production.
- 17:46Chrysler Chrysler's Detroit arsenal alone turned out nearly
- 17:5118,000 Sherman's. In total, over 49,000 Sherman
- 17:56tanks were built during the war. By contrast, Germany produced
- 18:00fewer than 6000 Panthers and only about 1350 Tiger tanks
- 18:06combined. So on paper, a Tiger had a
- 18:10thicker steel and a longer gun. But battles aren't fought on
- 18:14paper. When Lieutenant Colonel Abrams
- 18:17ordered the 37th Tank Battalion to charge into the into a Sainos
- 18:22to break the siege of a stone, they won because the Sherman was
- 18:26fast and it was mechanically unstoppable and backed by a five
- 18:32man crew who could load, lay down, fire and fire faster than
- 18:37anything the German tank crews can ever seen before.
- 18:40The Sherman didn't win, but win the war because of sheer
- 18:45numbers. It won because of the men who
- 18:48sat inside that cramped steel box and made it perform when
- 18:51history was on the line. So if you haven't heard the full
- 18:57dramatic audio story of episode 9, Battle of the Bulge,
- 19:02Thunderbolt 6 and The Cobra King, I'm telling you now.
- 19:05Go over to Spotify or Apple and do it now.
- 19:10Check it out on or even YouTube or wherever you get your your
- 19:16podcast. Don't forget to like subscribe
- 19:19and drop your thoughts in the comments below.
- 19:22How about this 75mm versus the 76 millimeter?
- 19:27Which Sherman variant would you want to command?
- 19:30Until next time, keep your eyes on the cross.
- 19:33Be a soldier for Christ. And remember, if you don't know
- 19:36him as your Lord and Savior, drop us a note in the comments.
- 19:40We would be honored to pray with you.
- 19:43Until next time, God bless you.