Latest / Entangled Reality / Why Can’t We Simply Choose the Good?
Transcript
- 0:03SPEAKER_00: Welcome to Entangled Reality,
- 0:05SPEAKER_00: exploring the hidden relationships,
- 0:07SPEAKER_00: constraints, and forms of trust that shape our world.
- 0:11SPEAKER_00: I'm Kerry Southworth.
- 0:13SPEAKER_00: When we have a choice before us, why can't we simply and consistently choose the good?
- 0:18SPEAKER_00: That may sound like an odd question.
- 0:20SPEAKER_00: We make thousands of choices every day.
- 0:23SPEAKER_00: We decide what to eat, where to go, what to buy, whom to call, what item to click on.
- 0:31SPEAKER_00: If we recognize that one course of action is better than another,
- 0:36SPEAKER_00: why not always just choose it?
- 0:39SPEAKER_00: I'm pretty sure that most of us know that it isn't usually that simple.
- 0:44SPEAKER_00: We can know that we should forgive someone,
- 0:46SPEAKER_00: but sometimes we can't stop playing back their betrayal and disregard for the truth
- 0:51SPEAKER_00: and their disregard for our feelings and their lifetime pattern of weakness.
- 0:57SPEAKER_00: Other times we intend to tell the truth but then exaggerate some aspects of
- 1:01SPEAKER_00: the story to get a laugh.
- 1:04SPEAKER_00: Or we leave out the parts that might cast us in a bad light.
- 1:09SPEAKER_00: We can decide that a habit is damaging us,
- 1:12SPEAKER_00: make a perfectly sincere resolution to stop and then discover that the person
- 1:17SPEAKER_00: who made the resolution is also the person who wants the habit to continue.
- 1:23SPEAKER_00: More information does not always solve the problem.
- 1:27SPEAKER_00: Often, because maybe most of the time, we already know what we ought to do.
- 1:33SPEAKER_00: So do those who are trying to straighten out.
- 1:36SPEAKER_00: Imposing more rules on ourselves,
- 1:38SPEAKER_00: on our loved ones, and society in general, does not necessarily solve it either.
- 1:45SPEAKER_00: Rules can identify boundaries,
- 1:47SPEAKER_00: but they aren't so good at making us love what lies on the other side of virtue.
- 1:52SPEAKER_00: Augustine of Hippo made this problem central to Western Christianity.
- 1:58SPEAKER_00: His answer was both illuminating and unsettling.
- 2:02SPEAKER_00: He believed that the human will is real, but it is not sovereign.
- 2:08SPEAKER_00: We choose,
- 2:08SPEAKER_00: but we choose as people who have already been formed
- 2:12SPEAKER_00: by what we have repeatedly loved, feared, practiced, and avoided.
- 2:18SPEAKER_00: We lose some measure of sovereignty in the process,
- 2:21SPEAKER_00: and that means that grace had to do more than forgive us after a bad choice.
- 2:26SPEAKER_00: Grace had to reach the place from which choices arise.
- 2:31SPEAKER_00: Augustine was born in Roman North Africa in the year 354.
- 2:36SPEAKER_00: He came of age while Christianity was moving from a persecuted religion toward
- 2:40SPEAKER_00: the authorized faith of the Roman Empire.
- 2:44SPEAKER_00: The church had spent decades arguing about the identity of Christ.
- 2:49SPEAKER_00: Emperors could convene councils.
- 2:52SPEAKER_00: Bishops could formulate creeds.
- 2:54SPEAKER_00: Imperial patronage could build churches,
- 2:57SPEAKER_00: support clergy, and fund institutions that cared for the poor and sick.
- 3:03SPEAKER_00: Those things certainly mattered, but they also revealed a limit.
- 3:06SPEAKER_00: An empire could enforce a creed, to a great extent, but it couldn't make an individual faithful.
- 3:13SPEAKER_00: Similarly, a law could restrain conduct.
- 3:16SPEAKER_00: It just couldn't produce love.
- 3:19SPEAKER_00: A society could become officially Christian while remaining full of baptized people
- 3:24SPEAKER_00: whose desires, ambitions, and loyalties were deeply divided.
- 3:29SPEAKER_00: Augustine turned the question inward.
- 3:32SPEAKER_00: What happens between hearing a true teaching and becoming a different kind of person?
- 3:38SPEAKER_00: His own life gave him no easy answer.
- 3:41SPEAKER_00: His mother Monica was a Christian and prayed for his conversion.
- 3:46SPEAKER_00: Augustine became a gifted teacher of rhetoric.
- 3:48SPEAKER_00: Otherwise known as the art of persuasion.
- 3:51SPEAKER_00: He pursued professional distinction.
- 3:54SPEAKER_00: He lived for years with a woman whose name history is not preserved,
- 3:58SPEAKER_00: and they had a son together.
- 4:00SPEAKER_00: He searched for an explanation of evil among the Manuchians.
- 4:05SPEAKER_00: Later, Platonist philosophy helped him take immaterial reality seriously.
- 4:11SPEAKER_00: And Ambrose of Milan showed him that Christian scripture was more intellectually substantial.
- 4:18SPEAKER_00: Then he previously assumed.
- 4:20SPEAKER_00: By the time of the crisis he later described in the Confessions,
- 4:24SPEAKER_00: Augustine's difficulty was no longer a lack of evidence.
- 4:28SPEAKER_00: He had become convinced that Christianity was true.
- 4:32SPEAKER_00: He believed that he should reorder his life,
- 4:34SPEAKER_00: but he simply couldn't bring himself to actually do it.
- 4:38SPEAKER_00: He wanted a new life and wanted the old one to continue a little longer.
- 4:44SPEAKER_00: His famous prayer for chastity, but not yet.
- 4:48SPEAKER_00: It's memorable because the contradiction is so familiar.
- 4:52SPEAKER_00: This was not a contest between knowledge and ignorance.
- 4:55SPEAKER_00: It was a division within desire itself.
- 4:59SPEAKER_00: Augustine described the mind commanding the body and often being obeyed.
- 5:04SPEAKER_00: You decide to move your hand and your hand moves.
- 5:07SPEAKER_00: But when the mind commands itself to will something wholeheartedly, it may encounter resistance.
- 5:14SPEAKER_00: One part of the person says, this is the life I want.
- 5:17SPEAKER_00: Another says, yes, but not if I have to give up this and that.
- 5:22SPEAKER_00: Maybe tomorrow.
- 5:24SPEAKER_00: Augustine did not think that made him a passive object.
- 5:28SPEAKER_00: He deliberated, he resisted, he consented, and finally acted.
- 5:33SPEAKER_00: His agency was real,
- 5:35SPEAKER_00: but he had discovered that the self does not stand above its history as
- 5:39SPEAKER_00: a completely unconditioned chooser.
- 5:43SPEAKER_00: This becomes clear when we think about habit.
- 5:46SPEAKER_00: A choice does more than produce an immediate result.
- 5:50SPEAKER_00: It also changes the chooser.
- 5:53SPEAKER_00: The first evasion may feel difficult.
- 5:56SPEAKER_00: The fifth is easier.
- 5:58SPEAKER_00: Resentment repeatedly rehearsed becomes readily available.
- 6:03SPEAKER_00: A desire repeatedly indulged begins to present itself as a need.
- 6:07SPEAKER_00: What began as a voluntary act can become a disposition and the disposition can begin
- 6:13SPEAKER_00: to feel like a necessity.
- 6:16SPEAKER_00: Past agency becomes a present constraint.
- 6:19SPEAKER_00: The reverse can happen as well.
- 6:22SPEAKER_00: Truthfulness,
- 6:23SPEAKER_00: patience,
- 6:23SPEAKER_00: courage, and generosity can be practiced until they become more available to us.
- 6:29SPEAKER_00: But none of us begins with a blank history.
- 6:32SPEAKER_00: We inherit bodies,
- 6:34SPEAKER_00: families, institutions, expectations, injuries, and examples we did not choose.
- 6:43SPEAKER_00: In other words,
- 6:47SPEAKER_00: the will is neither a machine nor a tiny command center floating above the rest of
- 6:52SPEAKER_00: the person.
- 6:53SPEAKER_00: It acts within a self formed through time and relationships.
- 6:59SPEAKER_00: Augustine often described the moral problem as a disorder of love.
- 7:03SPEAKER_00: That does not mean everything we love is evil.
- 7:07SPEAKER_00: In fact, the difficulty just might be that we love genuine goods badly.
- 7:12SPEAKER_00: Food, family,
- 7:13SPEAKER_00: friendship,
- 7:14SPEAKER_00: intimacy,
- 7:16SPEAKER_00: beauty, reputation, achievement, security, and political peace can all be good.
- 7:22SPEAKER_00: The disorder comes when a limited good becomes ultimate or when
- 7:27SPEAKER_00: a lesser attachment is allowed to displace a greater obligation.
- 7:31SPEAKER_00: Someone may betray a serious responsibility not because he loves nothing but
- 7:36SPEAKER_00: because he loves comfort, approval.
- 7:39SPEAKER_00: This brings us to grace.
- 7:40SPEAKER_00: The biblical and early Christian background is richer than the modern idea
- 7:43SPEAKER_00: of receiving an obligation-free benefit.
- 8:06SPEAKER_00: The Hebrew word chesed can refer to enacted kindness,
- 8:10SPEAKER_00: loyalty, mercy, and care within a relationship.
- 8:14SPEAKER_00: It is not merely a warm feeling.
- 8:17SPEAKER_00: It is visible fidelity in action.
- 8:20SPEAKER_00: The Greek word charis can refer to favor,
- 8:23SPEAKER_00: graciousness, a gift, and even the gratitude awakened by a gift.
- 8:28SPEAKER_00: We should not pretend that chesed simply became charis through translations.
- 8:33SPEAKER_00: The relationship is conceptual, not a straight lexical line.
- 8:38SPEAKER_00: But both words help us recover something important.
- 8:41SPEAKER_00: A gift may be freely initiated without being relationally empty.
- 8:47SPEAKER_00: The response does not purchase the gift.
- 8:50SPEAKER_00: Gratitude is not a delayed invoice.
- 8:53SPEAKER_00: But a gift can create or renew a relationship.
- 8:56SPEAKER_00: And that relationship becomes visible in trust.
- 9:00SPEAKER_00: Loyalty, generosity, or mercy extended to someone else.
- 9:05SPEAKER_00: Paul's language of grace has this shape.
- 9:07SPEAKER_00: God acts first and cannot be placed in anyone's debt.
- 9:11SPEAKER_00: Yet, grace does not simply stop at the recipient.
- 9:15SPEAKER_00: Because you have received mercy, you have an obligation to become merciful.
- 9:21SPEAKER_00: Because you have been forgiven, forgive.
- 9:24SPEAKER_00: Because Christ has given himself, you should bear one another's burdens.
- 9:29SPEAKER_00: Grace is free because it cannot be earned, but it is not aimless.
- 9:34SPEAKER_00: Grace calls forth an answering life.
- 9:37SPEAKER_00: Augustine's question was, where does our capacity to answer come from?
- 9:42SPEAKER_00: Is grace placed before a will that is already fully capable of choosing it?
- 9:48SPEAKER_00: Or must grace also heal the will that receives the gift?
- 9:53SPEAKER_00: Augustine came increasingly to believe the second.
- 9:56SPEAKER_00: If our problem were ignorance alone, teaching might be enough.
- 10:01SPEAKER_00: If it were outward misconduct alone, law might be enough.
- 10:05SPEAKER_00: Teaching and law can both be valuable.
- 10:08SPEAKER_00: One identifies the good, the other can restrain harm.
- 10:11SPEAKER_00: But neither necessarily gives us the love by which the good becomes desirable.
- 10:17SPEAKER_00: For Augustine, grace therefore means more than pardon.
- 10:21SPEAKER_00: It is healing as well as liberation.
- 10:24SPEAKER_00: God does not merely issue a command to a neutral will and wait for the result.
- 10:29SPEAKER_00: Grace reaches the person at the level from which willing arises.
- 10:34SPEAKER_00: This does not make the response less human.
- 10:37SPEAKER_00: Augustine's claim is that grace makes a fully good human response possible.
- 10:43SPEAKER_00: The person really chooses.
- 10:44SPEAKER_00: The person really loves.
- 10:47SPEAKER_00: But the healed capacity to answer is itself a gift.
- 10:51SPEAKER_00: So there is no ground for boasting as though the recipient had made God a debtor.
- 10:56SPEAKER_00: That is a profound insight.
- 10:58SPEAKER_00: It also creates a serious problem.
- 11:01SPEAKER_00: If even the beginning of a good response depends upon grace, what becomes of responsibility?
- 11:07SPEAKER_00: Why command, teach, exhort, correct, or praise someone for a response that only God can enable?
- 11:16SPEAKER_00: This is where Pelagius enters the story.
- 11:19SPEAKER_00: Pelagius is often reduced to the role of Augustine's defeated opponent.
- 11:24SPEAKER_00: That is too simple.
- 11:26SPEAKER_00: His writings survive incompletely, frequently through people arguing against him.
- 11:31SPEAKER_00: And not every idea later called Pelagian came directly from Pelagius.
- 11:36SPEAKER_00: That being said, his central concern deserves to be taken seriously.
- 11:41SPEAKER_00: If God commands justice,
- 11:42SPEAKER_00: chastity,
- 11:43SPEAKER_00: generosity, and love, Those commands must address people as responsible agents.
- 11:50SPEAKER_00: Moral exhortation assumes that hearing the command can matter.
- 11:55SPEAKER_00: Pelagius feared that constant appeals to weakness
- 11:58SPEAKER_00: and inherited sin could become excuses for Christians who were unwilling
- 12:02SPEAKER_00: to take discipleship seriously.
- 12:05SPEAKER_00: He did not simply deny grace, but disputed what grace does.
- 12:10SPEAKER_00: Does grace give creation,
- 12:12SPEAKER_00: free choice, law, teaching, Christ's example, forgiveness and assistance?
- 12:18SPEAKER_00: Or must it also transform the will's capacity to want the good?
- 12:23SPEAKER_00: Pelagius protects a necessary truth.
- 12:26SPEAKER_00: Human response must be real, and responsibility must remain intelligible.
- 12:32SPEAKER_00: Augustine protects another.
- 12:35SPEAKER_00: The person responding is not neutral.
- 12:38SPEAKER_00: We arrive with habits, wounds, histories, and attachments already in place.
- 12:44SPEAKER_00: Emphasize capacity without those constraints.
- 12:47SPEAKER_00: And grace can become little more than instruction offered to a self-sufficient chooser.
- 12:53SPEAKER_00: Emphasize incapacity without meaningful agency and responsibility begins to lose its meaning.
- 12:59SPEAKER_00: Augustine's strongest answer was not that grace replaces the will.
- 13:04SPEAKER_00: It simply frees the will to delight in the good.
- 13:08SPEAKER_00: Freedom on this account is not about having the largest possible menu of choices.
- 13:14SPEAKER_00: A person becomes free when love is sufficiently healed that the good can be chosen
- 13:18SPEAKER_00: as good, not merely obeyed under pressure.
- 13:22SPEAKER_00: This returns us to the opening question.
- 13:25SPEAKER_00: Why don't we simply choose the good?
- 13:28SPEAKER_00: Because the person making the choice has a history.
- 13:31SPEAKER_00: Our earlier choices,
- 13:33SPEAKER_00: relationships,
- 13:34SPEAKER_00: injuries, habits, and loves shapes what we can see and what we find desirable.
- 13:41SPEAKER_00: We remain agents, but we do not choose detached from our past.
- 13:46SPEAKER_00: Augustine's answer is that transformation requires more than a correct rule,
- 13:50SPEAKER_00: a convincing argument, or the removal of a penalty.
- 13:54SPEAKER_00: It requires the reconstitution of the person who receives all those other provisions.
- 14:00SPEAKER_00: That insight remains difficult to dismiss even for people
- 14:04SPEAKER_00: who do not accept Augustine's entire theology of grace.
- 14:08SPEAKER_00: We know that telling someone what is right does not necessarily make that person want it.
- 14:14SPEAKER_00: We know that forgiveness can remove guilt without repairing the desires that caused the injury.
- 14:20SPEAKER_00: We know that damaged relationships may require truth.
- 14:23SPEAKER_00: Restitution, time, practice, and a different pattern of life.
- 14:28SPEAKER_00: Augustine adds that at the deepest level,
- 14:30SPEAKER_00: the injured will needs a gift it cannot manufacture for itself.
- 14:35SPEAKER_00: But then his own life presents us with a troubling paradox.
- 14:39SPEAKER_00: If love must be healed inwardly, what can outward pressure accomplish?
- 14:44SPEAKER_00: Augustine eventually defended coercive measures against the Donatists,
- 14:49SPEAKER_00: a divided Christian community in North Africa.
- 14:52SPEAKER_00: He argued that pressure might interrupt error and return people to a setting in
- 14:57SPEAKER_00: which truth can be recognized.
- 14:59SPEAKER_00: But force cannot make someone experience pressure as grace,
- 15:03SPEAKER_00: and it cannot manufacture gratitude, faith, or love.
- 15:08SPEAKER_00: In short,
- 15:08SPEAKER_00: the thinker who understood that we cannot simply command ourselves
- 15:11SPEAKER_00: into wholeness also became one of Christianity's most consequential defenders
- 15:16SPEAKER_00: of coercion for another person's supposed good.
- 15:21SPEAKER_00: That is where we will turn next.
- 15:23SPEAKER_00: Can pressure ever prepare the will to receive grace?
- 15:27SPEAKER_00: Or does coercion corrupt the very relationship that grace is meant to create?
- 15:33SPEAKER_00: The essay on which this podcast was based develops the argument in greater detail,
- 15:38SPEAKER_00: including the relationship among chesed,
- 15:41SPEAKER_00: charas, habit, ordered love, and Augustine's understanding of grace.
- 15:47SPEAKER_00: You can also find glossary entries for chesed and charas at entangledreality.org.
- 15:54SPEAKER_00: Thank you for listening to Entangled Reality.
- 15:56SPEAKER_00: I'm Kerry Southworth.