Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Why Buffett Sold $130 Billion of Apple
Transcript
- 0:00Picture this scene. It is May 4, 2025.
- 0:06Yeah, we are in Omaha, NE and there are like 40,000 people
- 0:10packed into an arena. They've flown in from literally
- 0:13every corner of the globe. Just a massive crowd.
- 0:16Exactly. The room is buzzing, but then it
- 0:19goes dead silent because on stage is a 95 year old Warren
- 0:23Buffett, and he leans into the microphone to admit something.
- 0:26Well, genuinely shocking. Yeah, it really was.
- 0:28He looks out at the crowd and says essentially, I have to be
- 0:32honest, Apple's Tim Cook has made Berkshire Hathaway far more
- 0:35money than I ever did. Which, I mean, that is a
- 0:38stunning admission from a guy who is widely considered the
- 0:41greatest investor of the modern era.
- 0:42Right, but that wasn't even the climax.
- 0:44Not at all. Just minutes before this massive
- 0:47annual meeting ends, Buffett drops the real bombshell.
- 0:50He announces his retirement. He tells the world he is handing
- 0:53the reins of his entire empire over to Greg Abel at the end of
- 0:57the year. Which, you know, that's an
- 0:59absolute shock waves through the financial world.
- 1:01Everyone was stunned. But what is truly fascinating, I
- 1:04think, is what he was doing in the background while everyone
- 1:08was just waiting for that eventual retirement
- 1:10announcement. Yeah, because before he
- 1:13officially walked away on January 1st, 2026, Buffett spent
- 1:17two years quietly orchestrating one of the most massive
- 1:20financial retreats in history, right?
- 1:22He sold off 75% of his most profitable investment ever.
- 1:26We are talking about dumping Apple stock, like dropping from
- 1:31over 915,000,000 shares down to roughly 228 million.
- 1:36That's crazy. He pulled $130 billion out of
- 1:40the company he had just praised. Yeah, well, sitting here in
- 1:43April 2026, the parallels are just undeniable.
- 1:47Oh, for sure, because just days ago the Wall Street Journal
- 1:50reported that Tim Cook is also stepping down, right?
- 1:52Yeah, he is handing Apple over to a 50 year old hardware
- 1:55engineer named John Turnus on September 1st of this year.
- 1:59So you have two absolute Titans, 2 distinct global empires
- 2:03undergoing these massive historic handovers at the exact
- 2:06same time. It's wild timing, so we are
- 2:08going to figure out exactly why Buffett walked away from his
- 2:11crown jewel right before handing over the keys to his Kingdom.
- 2:15Unpack all three theories behind that decision in this deep dive.
- 2:19Sounds good. But first, I want to quickly
- 2:21speak to you listening right now to access more advanced
- 2:23researches, applications and our latest published personal
- 2:26intelligent multi agent Deep value intelligent Welcome to
- 2:30explore and join deep values dot AI community track total market
- 2:34temperature. Welcome to search and download
- 2:36iOS app Buffett indicator from Apple App Store.
- 2:39Disclaimer All analysis is based on publicly available sources
- 2:43and may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 2:46All contents from this channel is for educational and research
- 2:48purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 2:52Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 2:54decisions. If you like to access wider
- 2:56topics, including life and investing philosophy, please
- 2:59subscribe to our sister channel Deep Values.
- 3:01Don't forget to like this video. Much appreciated.
- 3:04Nice. So to understand $130 billion
- 3:07exit, we really have to start with the only explanation Warren
- 3:11Buffett ever gave the public. OK, let's unpack this, because
- 3:15he only ever gave one official reason.
- 3:17Right. Exactly.
- 3:18And it happened back at the May 2024 annual general meeting.
- 3:22Buffett was addressing a, well, a slightly anxious crowd.
- 3:27Yeah, because they had already noticed Berkshire trimming its
- 3:29Apple position, right? Right.
- 3:31They saw the filings, so he calmly brought up the history of
- 3:34the US tax code. Which is not exactly what you
- 3:38expect to hear when asking about a massive tech stock.
- 3:40No, not at all. It was a very macroeconomic
- 3:42pivot for him. You reminded the shareholders
- 3:45that the federal corporate tax rate on their capital gains
- 3:48currently sits at 21%. But he pointed out that it used
- 3:51to be 35%. And he even noted that way back
- 3:54when he started in business in the post war era, it was as high
- 3:58as 52%. Wow. 52%.
- 4:00Yeah. So looking at the rising US
- 4:03fiscal pressures and, you know, the growing national deficit, he
- 4:07basically deduced that taxes are almost certainly going back up.
- 4:11So you wanted to lock in their astronomical profits at that
- 4:14historically low 21% rate? I want to breakdown what those
- 4:18profits actually look like because honestly the numbers are
- 4:21hard to wrap your head around. How much money was he actually
- 4:23sitting on? Well, we can look at it
- 4:25conceptually first. Imagine you bought a house for
- 4:28$40,000. OK, and years later it is
- 4:32suddenly worth 175,000. A great flip.
- 4:35Right. Now multiply that dynamic by
- 4:37hundreds of millions of shares. Berkshire's original cost basis
- 4:41for Apple was about $39.62 a share.
- 4:44OK, by 2024 they were selling at around $175.00.
- 4:48So Buffett was sitting on roughly $83 billion of pure,
- 4:53untapped, unrealized profit. Wait. 83 billion.
- 4:56Yeah, and that's just from the shares he sold in 2024 alone.
- 4:59That is insane. So, OK, if you tax that 83
- 5:03billion at the current 21% rate, Berkshire pays about 17.4
- 5:09billion in taxes, right? But if he waits and the
- 5:12government bumps that rate up to, say, 28%, that tax bill
- 5:17swells 23.2 billion. Exactly.
- 5:20So by acting when he did, he locked in a tax saving of nearly
- 5:25$6 billion. OK, saving 5.8 billion purely by
- 5:29anticipating a shift in the tax code is, I mean, that's a
- 5:33masterstroke in capital preservation.
- 5:35Oh, absolutely. But I have to push back on this.
- 5:37OK, go for it. Because this sounds a lot like
- 5:39letting the tax tail wag the investment dog, right?
- 5:42Yeah. I mean, if you truly believe a
- 5:44stock is going to keep soaring, you don't sell it just to save a
- 5:47few billion in taxes. The future gains would just
- 5:50dwarf that 5.8 billion penalty. That's a fairpoint.
- 5:54It feels like, you know, being offered a massive pay raise at
- 5:57your job, but turning it down because it puts you on a
- 5:59slightly higher tax bracket. You still take home more money
- 6:02at the end of the day. And that right there, is the
- 6:04critical flaw in taking the tax argument at absolute face value,
- 6:09right? Any investor of Buffett's
- 6:11caliber knows you don't interrupt compounding
- 6:14unnecessarily, which leads to a very logical, unavoidable
- 6:18conclusion. Which is.
- 6:19To sell that much stock, Buffett must have fundamentally believed
- 6:23that Apple's future growth would not be strong enough to cover
- 6:27that impending tax penalty. He looked at the road ahead and
- 6:30simply didn't see enough upside. Right.
- 6:32So if the tax argument doesn't fully explain $130 billion exit,
- 6:37we have to look at what Buffett actually saw when he looked at
- 6:39Apple's books. Here's where it gets really
- 6:42interesting. We have to talk about the
- 6:44valuation and, more importantly, the deterioration of the Moat.
- 6:48We really need to remember how unprecedented it was when he
- 6:51bought Apple in the first place. Yeah, because for decades,
- 6:53Buffett notoriously avoided technology stocks.
- 6:56Completely. He openly admitted he didn't
- 6:58understand the space. He passed on Google early on.
- 7:01He passed on Amazon. He tried investing in IBM in
- 7:05what, 2011? Yeah, 2011 and he got burned
- 7:08eventually selling it off at a massive loss.
- 7:10She actually had a strict 30 year rule against tech.
- 7:14And then, at age 86, he breaks his own rule.
- 7:17He starts buying Apple in 2016 and eventually pours $36 billion
- 7:21into it. Like what changed his mind?
- 7:24Well, in 2016, Buffett wasn't really looking at Apple as a
- 7:27tech company. He was looking at it as an
- 7:28incredibly dominant consumer goods brand.
- 7:32It had a competitive advantage, a Moat as deep and wide as
- 7:35Coca-Cola or Gillette. People were fiercely loyal to
- 7:39their iPhones. It was practically a utility.
- 7:42And, crucially, it was a bargain.
- 7:44Right, because the rice to earnings ratio at the time was
- 7:46just. 12X exactly, which means based on the company's earnings,
- 7:50it would only take 12 years to earn back the investment.
- 7:53It was actually cheaper than the broader S&P 500 average.
- 7:56It was a classic value play. But Fast forward to 2024, that
- 8:00PE ratio had swelled from 12X up to 35 X.
- 8:04That's A. Huge jump.
- 8:05Yeah, suddenly Apple was 50% more expensive than the broader
- 8:09market. It was priced for absolute
- 8:10perfection. And perfection requires growth.
- 8:14But the engine was stalling, right?
- 8:17Like looking at the data, the revenue trend is really
- 8:19alarming. In 2021, Apple's revenue grew by
- 8:23a massive 33%. But then the deceleration
- 8:26begins, right? In 2022, growth dropped to 8%.
- 8:31By 2023 it was actually negative, shrinking by 2.8%, and
- 8:35in 2024 they barely scratched out 2% growth.
- 8:39So you have a stock that is 3 times more expensive than it
- 8:42used to be, attached to a company that has essentially
- 8:44stopped growing. Exactly.
- 8:46And this completely breaks the primary rule of Buffett's
- 8:48mentor, Benjamin Graham. The margin of safety.
- 8:50Right, the margin of safety. Graham originally borrowed this
- 8:53concept from engineering. When you build a bridge and you
- 8:57expect £10,000 trucks to drive over it, you build the bridge to
- 9:00withstand 30,000 lbs. You have a massive margin for
- 9:03error. Precisely applied to investing,
- 9:05you buy a stock so cheap that even if your projections are
- 9:08wrong, or management makes a mistake, or you know the economy
- 9:12tanks, you don't lose your shirt.
- 9:14At A35X multiple with flatlining growth, Apple's margin of safety
- 9:18had completely evaporated. And while the financial engine
- 9:21was stalling, a massive external threat arrived artificial
- 9:26intelligence. Boo.
- 9:27Yeah, the AI wave. There's this brutal quote from a
- 9:30Wall Street Journal source that perfectly captures the market
- 9:33sentiment at the time. It says if modern chat bots were
- 9:36humans, Siri would be a Neanderthal.
- 9:39I mean, it is a harsh assessment, but it reflects A
- 9:42deeper structural issue. What's fascinating here is the
- 9:45sheer difference in capital expenditures over the last two
- 9:48years. OK, let's hear the numbers.
- 9:50Google, Microsoft, Meta and Amazon have collectively spent
- 9:54nearly $700 billion on AI. Infrastructure.
- 9:59They are fighting a full scale existential war to build the
- 10:01future of computing. Apple spent less than 80 billion
- 10:05in that same time frame. Wow, it feels like Apple has
- 10:08been buying really nice luxury train cars using stock buybacks
- 10:13while Google and Meta are out there spending hundreds of
- 10:15billions laying entirely new tracks.
- 10:17Eventually, Apple's luxury trains just won't have anywhere
- 10:20to go. That is a fantastic way to
- 10:22visualize it. Tim Cook's philosophy has always
- 10:26heavily favored stock buybacks and squeezing out profit margins
- 10:30to reward shareholders. He avoids massive risky bets on
- 10:34unproven tech, and that strategy earned shareholders 8X returns
- 10:39over the last decade. But in doing so, they arrived
- 10:42late to the most important technological shift of our time.
- 10:45But how does that specifically threaten Apple's Moat?
- 10:49Because, you know, people still need phones.
- 10:51They still love their iPhones. Well, it threatens the
- 10:53fundamental nature of the hardware.
- 10:55Apple's mode relies on a walled garden.
- 10:57You buy the iPhone, you use the App Store.
- 10:59You buy the Apple Watch. You get locked into the
- 11:01ecosystem. Right, it's sticky.
- 11:03Very sticky. Yeah, but if the future of
- 11:05computing is an omnipresent AI assistant, an intelligence layer
- 11:09that can act across any device, booking your flights, managing
- 11:12your calendar, writing your emails, then the hardware
- 11:14becomes irrelevant. Oh, I see.
- 11:15The iPhone just becomes a commoditized piece of glass, a
- 11:19dumb terminal for a smart cloud. Buffett understands competitive
- 11:23moats better than anyone alive. He likely saw the floodwaters of
- 11:27AI threatening to commoditize Apple's most profitable asset.
- 11:31OK, so we have a stock that is too expensive, growth that has
- 11:34stalled, and an AI sweat that could break the walled garden.
- 11:37It makes perfect logical sense, right?
- 11:40But there is a glaring contradiction in this evaluation
- 11:43theory too. Really.
- 11:44Where do you see the contradiction?
- 11:46The timeline. I mean if Buffett genuinely
- 11:48thought Apple was too expensive and the Moat was dying, why
- 11:51didn't he sell at the absolute peak in mid 2024?
- 11:55Apple stock has $237. That was the high watermark.
- 11:59But he didn't wait for that. He actually started selling way
- 12:02back in late 2023 and he kept systematically dumping shares as
- 12:07the price dropped down to $190.00.
- 12:09Right? If it is purely A ruthless
- 12:11valuation play, why start selling them?
- 12:13Because investing at this scale is rarely just about
- 12:16spreadsheets, we have to look at the silent, deeply emotional
- 12:20factor behind this time, the loss of Charlie Munger.
- 12:24Yeah. On November 28th, 2023, Charlie
- 12:28Munger passed away. He was 99 years old, just weeks
- 12:31away from his 100th birthday. He had been buff his partner for
- 12:3464 years, and Munger had championed the Apple investment
- 12:38more than anyone. He once publicly called it one
- 12:40of the best decisions he ever made in his entire life.
- 12:43And Munger rarely spoke with that kind of unbridled
- 12:46enthusiasm. Yeah, he was usually pretty
- 12:47grumpy. Exactly.
- 12:49Yeah, Even for core foundational holdings like Coca-Cola or the
- 12:52Burlington Northern Railroad business, he was always
- 12:55measured. Apple was his crown jewel,
- 12:57right? If you look at the timeline,
- 12:59just months prior to his death in May 2023, Buffett was asked
- 13:03about Apple's high valuation. He defended it vigorously.
- 13:07He called it a Better Business than any they fully owned.
- 13:09And Munger was sitting right beside him, nodding in
- 13:12agreement. And then, one month after Munger
- 13:14dies, the massive Apple sell off begins.
- 13:17Yeah. It is a sequence of events that
- 13:19cannot be written off as a coincidence.
- 13:21For over 6 decades, Munger was the ultimate filter.
- 13:25Buffett himself has said that Munger was the abominable no
- 13:28man. Yep, the fondle.
- 13:29No, man, I love that. Right.
- 13:31If Charlie said no, the deal simply didn't happen.
- 13:34It reminds me of someone quietly packing up their hotel room.
- 13:37You know when you know your trip is over, you don't care what
- 13:40time it is, You don't care what is on the television.
- 13:42You just methodically take your things, fold them and put them
- 13:46in the suitcase you were preparing to check out.
- 13:50Buffett wasn't trying to time the market to squeeze out an
- 13:52extra $20 a share. He was just packing the bags.
- 13:56How does a lone decision maker operate when the person who
- 13:59spent 64 years telling them no is suddenly gone?
- 14:03This raises an important question because the psychology
- 14:06of losing your anchor fundamentally alters your
- 14:09strategy. You stop playing to win the next
- 14:12quarter. You stop trying to maximize the
- 14:15peak valuation of a specific stock, you start playing to
- 14:18secure the legacy, right? Buffett was the last man
- 14:20standing in an empire that they had built together, an empire
- 14:23that transitioned from a failing textile mill into a trillion
- 14:27dollar behemoth. Facing his own mortality, the
- 14:31mission changed entirely. So what does this all mean?
- 14:35The tax math? The decaying AI Moat?
- 14:38The emotional fallout of Monger's death?
- 14:40They aren't mutually exclusive, are they?
- 14:42No, not at. All they all point toward one
- 14:44singular ultimate objective succession.
- 14:47Yes. If we connect this to the bigger
- 14:50picture, Buffett wasn't just managing A portfolio anymore.
- 14:53He was meticulously turning his empire into Greg Abel's empire,
- 14:57Right. Look at his other moves during
- 14:58this exact same window. He didn't just sell Apple, he
- 15:02chopped his massive Bank of America position in ass.
- 15:05He demoted Chevron from being a core holding.
- 15:08He was deliberately, methodically cashing out his
- 15:10paper wealth. And what did he leave behind?
- 15:13A staggering, unprecedented 373.1 billion dollar mountain of
- 15:18pure cash. Exactly.
- 15:19He was giving Greg Abel a clean slate.
- 15:21When a new CEO takes over legendary Founders company, the
- 15:24heaviest burden is the Founders leftover baggage.
- 15:27Oh yeah. If Buffett had left that massive
- 15:29Apple position untouched and the stock subsequently tanked, Abel
- 15:33would be paralyzed. Does he dare sell the stock the
- 15:36Legend bought? Right.
- 15:38The optics of that would be terrible.
- 15:40Horrible. Would the market panic if the
- 15:42new guy dumped Buffett's favorite company by liquidating
- 15:46it himself? Buffett took on the burden of
- 15:48selling. He took the PR hit.
- 15:51He paid the taxes. He handed Able ultimate
- 15:54flexibility. But I want to look at the final
- 15:56accounting on this. OK, Did Buffett actually leave
- 15:59money on the table by selling when he did?
- 16:01Because looking at the market data, Apple eventually hit an
- 16:04all time high of $288.62 on December 3, 2025, right?
- 16:10That was just weeks before Buffett officially retired, and
- 16:13today in April 2026, it is hovering around 270 dollars.
- 16:18We have to analyze both scenarios to see the real cost
- 16:21of this move. Let's do it Scenario A.
- 16:23Let's assume Buffett let it ride.
- 16:25He held all of his original roughly 915,000,000 shares.
- 16:29At today's price of $270, that position would be worth about
- 16:32$243 billion. Wow, That means purely on paper.
- 16:37By selling early, he missed out on roughly $75 billion in
- 16:41unrealized gains. 75 billion. That is an astronomical amount
- 16:46of money to just walk away from. It is, but we have to look at
- 16:49scenario B. That 130 billion he pulled out
- 16:52of Apple didn't just sit in a vault gathering dust, right?
- 16:56Berkshire immediately deployed that cash into short term U.S.
- 17:01Treasury bills, which were yielding around 4.5% over those
- 17:06two years. That generated roughly $12
- 17:08billion in pure risk free interest income.
- 17:12OK. But even factoring in the 12
- 17:14billion in interest, you are still looking a massive gap
- 17:18compared to the 75 billion in missed stock gains.
- 17:21True, but you have to understand the fundamental difference in
- 17:23how Berkshire Hathaway views cash.
- 17:26For the average retail investor, you know cash is a defensive
- 17:29play. It is a safety net against
- 17:30inflation or a market crash. For Berkshire, cash is an
- 17:33offensive weapon. It is pure opportunity.
- 17:36Buffett has always maintained that cash is what you use when
- 17:38the world goes on sale. Right.
- 17:40This goes back to how he operated during the 2008
- 17:42financial crisis. Exactly.
- 17:45Let's look at the mechanics of what he did in 2008.
- 17:49While every other financial institution was drowning and
- 17:52desperately seeking liquidity, Buffett used his massive cash
- 17:56hoard to step in as the lender of last resort.
- 17:59He bailed out Goldman Sachs, right?
- 18:01Goldman Sachs, General Electric and later Bank of America.
- 18:04But he didn't just buy regular stock.
- 18:06He dictated brutal, highly lucrative terms.
- 18:09Because he could. Because he could.
- 18:11With Goldman Sachs, he bought $5 billion in preferred shares that
- 18:15paid a guaranteed 10% dividend. Plus, he demanded warrants that
- 18:19allowed him to buy regular stock at a fixed price later on.
- 18:22He squeezed them because he was literally the only one with
- 18:24cash. He was the only one providing a
- 18:26fire hose to a burning building. Those crisis loans eventually
- 18:30made Berkshire around $10 billion in profit.
- 18:33By taking that $75 billion, quote UN quote loss on paper
- 18:36with Apple, he wasn't making a mistake.
- 18:38He was preparing for the next fire.
- 18:40I see. So whenever the next 2008 style
- 18:43crisis happens, Greg Abel doesn't have to worry about
- 18:46liquidating a crashing Apple stock to scrape together cash.
- 18:50He has a $373 billion war chest sitting right there, ready to
- 18:56buy up the world at bargain basement prices.
- 18:58It is the ultimate strategic advantage.
- 19:00We have tracked this from locking in historic tax rates
- 19:03and navigating away from a stalling hardware mode to the
- 19:06quiet, methodical packing up of a 64 year legacy after losing
- 19:10his closest partner. It completely recontextualizes
- 19:14this massive $130 billion retreat.
- 19:17It really does. It wasn't a panic sell off, it
- 19:19was an act of profound tenderness from a retiring
- 19:21legend. He took the heat, he paid the
- 19:24taxes, and he gave his successor an entirely clean slate.
- 19:28I think there is a thought here that extends far beyond Wall
- 19:31Street or, you know, massive corporate handovers.
- 19:34Think about your own life's work, your own projects, your
- 19:36business, or your investments. We spend so much time optimizing
- 19:40for our own maximum returns, we constantly try to squeeze every
- 19:44last drop of value out of what we do in the present moment.
- 19:46Yeah, that's human nature. But the ultimate value of what
- 19:50you build might not be what it yields for you.
- 19:53It might be the absolute freedom and optionality it provides to
- 19:56the person you hand it off to. It forces you to look in the
- 19:59mirror and ask. Are you building to hold on, or
- 20:02are you building to pass it on? When that 95 year old man stood
- 20:05on stage in Omaha, he wasn't looking at the past, he was
- 20:08entirely focused on a future he wouldn't be running.
- 20:11Thank you for joining us on this deep dive into the source
- 20:14material. The true legacy of a leader
- 20:16isn't just what they build, it is what they leave behind.
- 20:19Until next time.