Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Costco (COST) Q2 2025 Deep Value Analysis
Transcript
- 0:00OK, let's unpack this. Have you ever walked into a
- 0:02Costco, maybe for those legendary hot dogs, you know, or
- 0:06bulk paper towels, and just stopped and wondered about the
- 0:09the massive machine behind it all?
- 0:11Yeah, it's pretty impressive when you think about it.
- 0:13Well, today we're taking a deep dive into the business model of
- 0:161 of retails true Giants, Costco Wholesale Corporation and our
- 0:21source material for this is a really comprehensive financial
- 0:26research report. It pulls back the curtain on,
- 0:29well, everything from their latest earnings to their long
- 0:31term financial health and crucially, how they measure up
- 0:35against some pretty rigorous investment criteria.
- 0:38Right. And what's fascinating here I
- 0:40think is how Costco's unique approach creates this remarkably
- 0:43stable growth, strong returns year after year, but at the same
- 0:46time it presents this valuation puzzle for a certain kind of
- 0:50investor. So our mission today is really
- 0:52to extract those core insights, understand its strengths, its
- 0:55risks, and then, you know, evaluate it through the lens of
- 0:57value investing principles. It's exactly, this is just about
- 1:00crunching numbers. It's about understanding the
- 1:02inner workings of a highly effective business, maybe one
- 1:05that's often misunderstood, but one that touches millions of
- 1:08lives every single day. So let's start by looking at
- 1:13their recent performance. OK.
- 1:14So Costco's latest quarter, the one that wrapped up May 11th,
- 1:172025, it delivered a pretty clear message.
- 1:21Robust growth, excellent operations.
- 1:23Their total revenue surged to over $63 billion.
- 1:27That's an impressive, what, 8% increase from the year before?
- 1:29Solid. Growth there.
- 1:31And what really stands out, I think beyond just the strong net
- 1:33sales is the continued growth in their membership fee revenue
- 1:37that climbed up to $1.24 billion.
- 1:41These figures aren't just big numbers, right?
- 1:43They signal a business that's really firing on all cylinders,
- 1:46it seems, driven by increase customer traffic and just a
- 1:50steadfastly growing membership base.
- 1:52And if we connect those numbers, those impressive numbers, to the
- 1:55bigger picture, it really all boils down to their core model,
- 1:59the membership warehouse club. It's actually elegantly simple.
- 2:03They move massive volumes of goods, everything from fresh
- 2:06produce to electronics and incredibly low markups, right?
- 2:09The key, of course, is you need that membership to get in the
- 2:12door and access those prices. Their revenue streams are like
- 2:15almost entirely from merchandise sales, about 98% and then the
- 2:19remaining 2% comes from those annual membership fees.
- 2:22OK, that 2% from membership fees really caught my eye.
- 2:24I mean, it seems like such a tiny piece of the overall pie,
- 2:28yet we always hear how crucial it is.
- 2:30How is it that vital to their success?
- 2:32What's the the genius behind that small percentage?
- 2:36That's a great question and it really highlights the the
- 2:38brilliance of their model actually, because despite being
- 2:41a small percentage of their total revenue, you said it
- 2:43around $4.58 billion out of over $242 billion in fiscal 23.
- 2:49Those fees are absolutely vital to their profitability.
- 2:52OK, profitability. Yeah.
- 2:53Think of them as high margin, predictable recurring revenue.
- 2:56It just keeps coming in. And that allows Costco to
- 2:59maintain incredibly low markups on their merchandise.
- 3:02They can sell stuff at or sometimes maybe even below cost
- 3:05in certain cases. And that perceived value that
- 3:08drives membership retention attracts new signups.
- 3:11It creates this really powerful self reinforcing cycle.
- 3:14So they. Pass the savings on, which makes
- 3:16people loyal, which lets them keep prices low.
- 3:19Exactly. It fuels that loyalty directly.
- 3:21And Speaking of loyalty, I mean, their customer base is just
- 3:24huge, nearly 128 million card holders back in 2023.
- 3:29But what's truly astonishing, I think, are those renewal rates,
- 3:3292.7% in the US and Canada and 90.4% worldwide.
- 3:38Yeah, staggering numbers. When you see renewal rates
- 3:40consistently above 90%, what does that fundamentally tell you
- 3:43about Costco's, you know, customer value proposition?
- 3:46Well, it tells you they're not just providing a service,
- 3:48they're delivering immense sort of undeniable value that really
- 3:53resonates deeply with their members.
- 3:55You don't buy that kind of loyalty with advertising.
- 3:57You earn it by consistently exceeding meeting expectations,
- 4:00price, quality, the whole shopping experience.
- 4:04It's proof really that their members genuinely believe
- 4:07they're getting a fantastic deal year after year.
- 4:10And operationally, by the end of fiscal 23, they were running 861
- 4:14warehouses worldwide, most in the US, obviously implying
- 4:18around 316,000 people and about 95% of those folks work right in
- 4:23the warehouses and distribution centers.
- 4:25And they have that reputation for paying well right above
- 4:27average for retail. They do, yeah, which helps keep
- 4:30turnover low, definitely supports the model, but it
- 4:32certainly adds to their overall cost, particularly compensation
- 4:35and benefits. That's a big chunk after the
- 4:37merchandise itself. OK, so even a company as strong,
- 4:41as seemingly invincible as Costco isn't immune to external
- 4:44pressures, right? What are some of the challenges
- 4:46they face, maybe short term and long term that could impact
- 4:50their operations or you know, the bottom line?
- 4:52That's right. No business operates in a
- 4:54vacuum. Short term, well, you've got the
- 4:57usual suspects. Inflation, the specter of
- 4:59recession, rising commodity costs, wage costs, those can
- 5:04squeeze their already thin merchandise margins and an
- 5:09economic slowdown, well that could dampen spending on non
- 5:12essential items. Supply chain disruptions are
- 5:14always a risk, as we've all seen.
- 5:15That impacts inventory costs and foreign exchange.
- 5:19You know a strong dollar can hurt their international revenue
- 5:22when translated back. And competition always a factor
- 5:25I. Oh, absolutely.
- 5:26It's relentless. Not just from the discounters
- 5:28like Walmart and Sam's Club, but increasingly from e-commerce
- 5:31giants like Amazon that could challenge their pricing.
- 5:34Maybe even membership retention over time.
- 5:36Looking further out, long term risks.
- 5:38Well, some analysts point to their maybe slower digital
- 5:41transformation compared to some rivals, e-commerce delivery that
- 5:46could erode market share if they don't keep pace effectively.
- 5:49Labor and regulatory pressures are ongoing concerns, rising
- 5:52minimum wages, unionization efforts, those could increase
- 5:55operating costs, changes in trade policies, tariffs that
- 5:58could impact their cost of goods.
- 6:00And increasingly, you know, ESG, environmental, social
- 6:04governance, expectations from consumers, regulators that might
- 6:08require significant investments down the line, sustainability,
- 6:10packaging, supply chain changes. OK.
- 6:12So given those pressures and their commitment to paying
- 6:15employees well, how do they manage to keep prices so
- 6:18incredibly low? How do they maintain that
- 6:20competitive edge? What's the secret in their cost
- 6:23structure? Yeah, their lean cost structure
- 6:25is really the backbone of that value proposition.
- 6:27Their single biggest expense by far is just the cost of the
- 6:30merchandise itself. That was a staggering what,
- 6:33212.586 billion of their total revenue in fiscal 20?
- 6:39Beyond that, you have SGNA selling general administrative
- 6:41expenses. That was about $21.6 billion in
- 6:44FY23, mostly payroll and benefits.
- 6:46But get this that's only roughly 9% of their total sales, which
- 6:50is remarkably low for a retail operation of this massive scale.
- 6:539%, OK. And it's fascinating how little
- 6:56they spend on traditional advertising compared to other
- 6:58big retailers. So how do they keep growing that
- 7:01membership base, attracting new customers without these huge
- 7:04marketing campaigns? What's their secret sauce there?
- 7:07It is quite remarkable, isn't it?
- 7:09Their mentorship growth is overwhelmingly driven by just
- 7:12powerful word of mouth and the sheer perceived value they
- 7:16offer. So people just tell their
- 7:17friends. Pretty much customers are so
- 7:19satisfied they become organic marketers for the brand, sharing
- 7:23positive experiences. It's a highly effective, super
- 7:27low cost marketing strategy. Very few companies can really
- 7:30replicate that. That makes sense.
- 7:32And beyond those core operating costs, Costco is definitely
- 7:35investing in the future. They spent about $4.3 billion on
- 7:38capital expenditures and FY23, and they're planning even more,
- 7:42like 4.4 to $4.6 billion in FY24 for new rare houses, expanding
- 7:47logistics. They're not standing still.
- 7:49Right. And who's steering this enormous
- 7:51ship through all these market dynamics, all the operational
- 7:53complexities? What does the leadership look
- 7:55like? Well, Costco's management team
- 7:57is really characterized by incredible longevity and deep
- 8:01operational experience. W Craig Jelinek's been CEO since
- 8:042012. Many executives, like Ron
- 8:07Vakris, the president and COO, and Richard Galanti, the
- 8:10longtime CFO, they've worked their way up through the ranks,
- 8:14often started right in warehouse operations.
- 8:18So they know the business from the ground up.
- 8:19Exactly. It fosters this strong culture
- 8:22of operational discipline, that unwavering commitment to low
- 8:25prices. They understand the nuts and
- 8:27bolts plus management owned shares, which naturally aligns
- 8:30their interest with the broader shareholder base.
- 8:33And the major owners? Looking at the top shareholders,
- 8:35it's mostly the big institutional investors,
- 8:38Vanguard, BlackRock, State Street, Geo Capital, FMR, you
- 8:43know, Fidelity, the usual suspects for a company this
- 8:46size. OK.
- 8:47And beyond just running the business day-to-day, their
- 8:49financial discipline seems to extend to how they treat
- 8:51shareholders too. We've seen things like that big
- 8:54$4 billion share repurchase program authorized through
- 8:57January 2027 that shows confidence in their own stock,
- 9:00right? Definitely.
- 9:01And they've been actively buying back shares.
- 9:03For example, they bought back about 1.3 million shares for
- 9:07$677 million just in FY20 23. And then there are the
- 9:12dividends, consistent quarterly ones, plus those famous special
- 9:16dividends, like wasn't there a $15 per share one back in
- 9:19December 2020? That's right.
- 9:22Those special payouts really speak volumes about their cash
- 9:25generating power. Yeah.
- 9:27It's interesting too. I remember Berkshire Hathaway
- 9:29was a longtime holder, but they sold their Costco stake a few
- 9:32years back. Maybe that hints at the
- 9:34valuation discussion we're about to get into.
- 9:36It certainly adds another layer to the puzzle.
- 9:37Yeah, valuation is key here. OK, perfect segue.
- 9:40Now we get to the core numbers. For those of you who really love
- 9:43to dig in, let's look at their 10 year financial performance.
- 9:46How have they actually grown and managed their finances over the
- 9:49past decade? Absolutely.
- 9:50So looking from fiscal year 2014 through 2024, Costco has shown
- 9:54just remarkable consistency and growth.
- 9:56Revenue more than doubled, grew at a solid 8% compound annual
- 10:00rate hitting $254.5 billion in 2024.
- 10:04Eight. Percent Cher.
- 10:05OK. Net income nearly quadrupled,
- 10:08climbing up to $7.37 billion. And what's striking is how
- 10:12stable their Net margin has been, consistently hovering
- 10:15right around 2.9 percent. Consistent, but maybe not super
- 10:18high. Right.
- 10:19That's part of the model. Operating income also grew
- 10:22steadily to $9.29 billion, keeping that operating margin
- 10:25around 3.6%. Now free cash flow or FCF,
- 10:29that's the cash left after paying for operations and
- 10:31investments. It's been positive every single
- 10:33year, which is great, though it's margin is relatively modest
- 10:36around 3%. OK. 3% FCF margin and returns.
- 10:41Returns look outstanding. Return on equity ROV average
- 10:44about 24%, return on investment capital ROIC around 18%.
- 10:48Both indicate really efficient use of capital, strong returns
- 10:51for shareholders over time. And the balance sheets debt.
- 10:54Rock solid. Their balance sheet is
- 10:55incredibly strong. Long term debt was a manageable
- 10:58$5.79 billion at the end of fiscal 24 and that's comfortably
- 11:02offset by cash on hand, which was over $11 billion.
- 11:06Wow, more cash than long term debt.
- 11:07Exactly. So that gives them a very low
- 11:09debt to equity ratio about .14, current ratio over 1.5, interest
- 11:15coverage over 30 times. So by all those traditional
- 11:18measures of financial health, operational efficiency, Costco
- 11:22looks like an absolute powerhouse.
- 11:23OK, this all sounds incredibly strong, right?
- 11:26Every number seems to point to a powerhouse.
- 11:29But here's where that puzzle really emerges.
- 11:31How does Costco with all these impressive underlying numbers
- 11:35fair when you put it to the test against those strict value
- 11:39oriented criteria? You know the kind champion by
- 11:42investors like Warren Buffett does a great business always
- 11:45make a great stock buy at any given time.
- 11:47And that is indeed the crux of the puzzle, because despite its
- 11:50operational excellence, Costco's stock often trades at a
- 11:53significant premium. And that premium causes it to
- 11:56fall short on several of those traditional evaluation
- 11:58discipline criteria that strict value investors prioritize.
- 12:01Like what for example? OK.
- 12:02We'll take the PE ratio price to earnings in 2024 it was around
- 12:0655. The typical value investing
- 12:08standard is often, you know, less than or equal to 15, so way
- 12:11above. Yeah, big difference.
- 12:12Same with price to book ratio around 12 for Costco versus a
- 12:16standard of maybe 1.5 or less. And the concept of a margin of
- 12:19safety, you know, buying significantly below what you
- 12:22think the intrinsic value is, say 25% below.
- 12:25That's challenged here. The current price, around
- 12:27$916.00, often exceeds the more conservative discounted cash
- 12:31flow evaluations. OK.
- 12:33Any other metrics where it falls short for value value investors?
- 12:36Well, yes, while the free cash flow is consistently positive,
- 12:38that margin we mentioned around 3%, it's below the desired 5% or
- 12:43higher that many value investors look for in highly cash
- 12:45generative businesses. Their estimated return on
- 12:48retained earnings maybe three, 5% also fall short of the
- 12:51typical 12% benchmark some use. And critically, those margins we
- 12:55talked about gross margin around 13%, Net margin around 2.9%.
- 13:00Those are significantly lower than the 40% gross or 20% Net
- 13:03margin standards often sought by value investors looking for
- 13:06businesses with really wide moats and high pricing power.
- 13:08Right. Those high margins often signal
- 13:10a stronger competitive advantage, theoretically.
- 13:12Exactly. Now, where Costco does truly
- 13:15shine, even by Buffett criteria are in areas reflecting its
- 13:18underlying quality and financial health.
- 13:21Its EPS record consistently rising for 10 straight years.
- 13:25Strong track record. That's passed.
- 13:27Book value per share grew around 9% CAGR, which marginally passes
- 13:31the 10% standard. Some look for debt to equity at
- 13:340.14, excellent way below the .5 standard.
- 13:37Interest coverage over 30X interest expense only about 2%
- 13:41of operating income, both exceptionally strong, shows real
- 13:44financial discipline. Current ratio over 1.5, good
- 13:47liquidity and those profitability metrics we liked
- 13:50earlier are OE around 24%, Ric 18%, ROA 11%.
- 13:55They all comfortably exceed their respective standards.
- 13:57Even things like depreciation as a percentage of gross profit
- 14:01around 10%, that passes the test too.
- 14:03So it's this weird mix then. It excels in profitability,
- 14:06balance sheet, strength, consistency, yet it kind of
- 14:09fails on many of the valuation discipline metrics.
- 14:11What's the fundamental reason for that split?
- 14:13Why the dichotomy? It's simply because the stock
- 14:16consistently trades at premium multiples.
- 14:18The market seems really optimistic about its future
- 14:21growth, its stability, the durability of its business
- 14:23model. Investors are clearly willing to
- 14:26pay a high price for that quality and consistency.
- 14:28It's a quality premium, essentially.
- 14:30OK. So given all these factors, the
- 14:32strong business, the premium valuation, what does this all
- 14:36mean for its actual value per share, especially when we use
- 14:39something like a discounted cash flow or DCF analysis, what does
- 14:43that tell us about the current price?
- 14:44Right. The DCF analysis tries to put a
- 14:46number on that intrinsic value based on different assumptions
- 14:49about future free cash flow growth.
- 14:51So using their fiscal year 2024 free cash flow, about $7.88
- 14:55billion as the base and standard assumptions like a 9% discount
- 14:59rate, 2% terminal growth, we modeled 3 scenarios based on the
- 15:03recent price around $916.00. This is as of August 2025.
- 15:07OK. What do they show?
- 15:08Well, in a conservative scenario, assuming basically 0%
- 15:11FCF growth going forward, the intrinsic value comes out to
- 15:14about $222.71 per share, a 25% margin of safety buy price would
- 15:19be way down at $167.03. OK.
- 15:22Very far from the current price. Very far now under a nominal
- 15:26scenario, using their actual 13.8% average FCF growth rate,
- 15:31the intrinsic value rises to $623.58.
- 15:35The margin of safety buy price there is $467.69, still well
- 15:40below 916 dollars. Getting closer, but still a big
- 15:43gap, right? And finally, in a really
- 15:46optimistic scenario, assuming a very high FCF growth rate of
- 15:4925.1% continues for years, then the intrinsic value jumps to
- 15:54$1433.06 and the margin of safety by price would be a
- 15:58$1074.80. So only in the really optimistic
- 16:02case does the current price look potentially reasonable or even
- 16:05cheap with margin of safety. Exactly what's vaccinating here
- 16:09is that the current market price, around 916 dollars, is
- 16:12well above both the conservative and the nominal intrinsic
- 16:14values. It only falls below that highly
- 16:17optimistic valuation scenario. So this means investors who are
- 16:19really seeking a large margin of safety, which is typical of a
- 16:22strict value investing approach, might find the shares quite
- 16:25expensive at their current trading levels.
- 16:26So we've taken this deep dive into Costco and what a
- 16:30fascinating journey, really. On one hand, you have this
- 16:33incredibly robust membership driven model, stable growth,
- 16:37consistent returns, fiercely loyal customers.
- 16:40It's a business known not just for value but also, you know,
- 16:42for treating its employees well, which is great.
- 16:45Right. But on the other hand, the stock
- 16:47trades at these premium valuation multiples that as we
- 16:50just saw caused to fail many of those strict value oriented
- 16:54criteria, particularly around margin of safety.
- 16:57The business is phenomenal, no doubt, but those free cash flow
- 17:00margins are modest compared to some benchmarks and the stock's
- 17:03implied margin of safety looks narrow unless you assume pretty
- 17:06aggressive future growth. So what's the take away for an
- 17:09investor looking at this? Well, ultimately it seems like
- 17:12long term, maybe growth oriented investors who really believe
- 17:16Costco can sustain that double digit free cash flow growth for
- 17:20a long time, they might justify paying the current price they're
- 17:24paying for quality and expected future growth.
- 17:27However, more conservative investors, the ones who really
- 17:30prioritize a significant margin of safety and strict adherence
- 17:33to valuation discipline, they might prefer to wait for a
- 17:37substantial pullback in the price before considering an
- 17:39investment. It depends on your philosophy,
- 17:42yeah. And what does this alltel you,
- 17:44the listener about that fundamental tension in
- 17:46investing, the tension between a fantastic business and a
- 17:48potentially challenging stock valuation?
- 17:51Do you prioritize owning a great company, maybe at almost any
- 17:54price? Or do you wait for a great
- 17:56price, even if it means missing out on some great companies
- 17:58sometimes? It's a core question every
- 17:59investor has to grapple with, right?
- 18:01Yeah, it absolutely is, and just a reminder for everyone
- 18:04listening. As always, all analysis is based
- 18:06on publicly available sources and maybe subject to revisions
- 18:10or differing interpretations. This content is for educational
- 18:14purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 18:17Please conduct your own due diligence before making any
- 18:20investment decisions. Great points.
- 18:22Thank you for joining us on this deep dive into Costco.
- 18:24Until next time, keep learning and exploring.