Latest / The Redshirt Seniors / Recap of Week 5: Jeremiah's Heisman Case, Florida Might Be Done, Bama is Back?
Transcript
- The Great Debater: It feels like it shouldn't be halfway through the season, but here we are. Like it's it's too early to already be talking about near the end of college football, but here we are. Welcome to another episode of Redshirt Seniors. I am Alex Jones, the great debater, whatever you want to call it. You know, Book is already doing the go-gators chomp, even though his boys got smoked on the barbecue in Missouri. Like Kansas City barbecue this week. But Book, how you doing? Booker T: Just wait. Hey man. Win, lose, draw, man. It's always great to be a gator, man. I'm doing fine, man. The Great Debater: Tyler's team had a scare against Washington. Tyler, you good this week? Ty: Man, I'm I'm phenomenal. you know, they say a ugly win is better than a beautiful loss. So would you let's just keep it rolling. The Great Debater: It's true. Colin, I don't think the Ducks did anything this week. How you doing? Kylen: No, definite by week. Them boys getting well rested. They got a big challenge coming up for The Great Debater: yeah, they do. They do have a little challenge. So we're gonna talk about that at the end of the show, actually. welcome to another episode of the Red Shirt Seniors. But today is a little bit different from what we've been doing. Usually we start off with topics and we start off to talk about this is what happened last week and all this. Today is the great debate day. Today is the day that all of us are going to debate on certain topics around college football. Before the show, what we did was we got our topics together and we each flipped a coin. About whether we wanted to take one side or the other. So we are prepared to argue both sides, but we flip the coin beforehand to talk about which sides that we want to argue in each debate. So we're gonna get started. first off is me and Tyler. Today we are starting with the topic about Jeremia Smith. Jeremiah Smith is, I mean, he's amazing, obviously. He's got 800-something receiving yards to start the year already after 200 yards against Iowa and a big win for Ohio State. He is leading the country in receptions, receiving yards, and touchdowns, and is really not even close right now as to who's the best receiver in college football. Today, me and Tyler are going to argue about if Jeremiah Smith will or will not win the highs. Tyler is taking Jeremiah Smith's case for the Heisman. I am arguing why Jeremiah Smith will not win the Heisman. Tyler, you wanna go first? Cause you've been wanting to talk about Jeremiah Smith for a long time, brother. Ty: I have been wanting to talk about Jeremiah Smith for a long time, brother. this isn't a great receiver having a great year, right? this is the best player in the country having a historic season. I think we just talked about the Miami Dolphins saying they want Jeremiah Smith one-one. The last time a wide receiver went first overall in the NFL draft was Keyshawn Johnson back in, I think, 1996. So we are on a level that has not been matched in in about 30 years. I think that it would be it would be a shame. Kylen: Yeah. Ty: It would be it would be a smudge Kylen: Yeah. Ty: on the history of this great sport that we all love if Jeremiah Smith. Kylen: Yeah. Ty: plays three years of historic football and does not win the Heisman Trophy. And I don't think that the voters will allow that to happen this year. The Great Debater: Okay, so that's that's that's your that's your case for Jeremiah Smith winning the winning the highs. Ty: I mean that's just my opening. Like, you know, like I I think Jeremy Whitesmith's a great player, you know. I mean I'm just stating my case. State in my case. The Great Debater: So I gotta I Kylen: He said it's all you got. The Great Debater: gotta statement. Okay. I mean if this is opening that's cool. Ty: I mean I th that's just I that's my opening, man. I mean, who do you think it should be? I don't know. Let's we The Great Debater: I Ty: can go from there. The Great Debater: remember I'm prepared to argue either. So, like, I mean, we're both prepared to argue either. So, and I kind of hated that I had I took the negative on this one. I hate that the coins flipped in my favor. But why Jeremiah Smith will not win the Heisman. the Heisman has had how many winners since what the 1930s, and only two receivers, full time receivers, have won the award Desmond Howard and Devontae Smith. Now, mind you, I will say this. Jeremiah Smith is on pace to have better statistics than both of those seasons, but at the same time, his the competition was also weaker for Devontae Smith and Desmond Howard, if I'm not mistaken. Devontae Smith's own teammate finished in the top three of the Heisman voting. So, like, I mean, that was the COVID year and everything. Devontae Smith had a phenomenal season. It's really, really hard for a wide receiver to win the war. Do we count Travis Hunter as the other full time like wide receiver to win it? Or are we considering that defensive player? I don't know. That's up to you guys to decide. Ty: Just to your point, you know, we we say in the last thirty years only two have one wide receiver two wide receivers have won it, but in the last in the last six years, two wide receivers have won it. So I would count Travis Hunter. So it's not unprecedented for a wide receiver to win the Hausman trophy. The Great Debater: It is not unprecedented, Booker T: I've like The Great Debater: but when is l but Travis Hunter didn't win it just being a wide receiver only, correct? Ty: Yeah. The Great Debater: Okay. It's hard for it. I th I it's hard for a wide receiver to win it because they're so dependent on other offensive offensive positions to do their job well in order for them to look the greatest. and I would I would be remiss to say that it is hard for a wide receiver to be the best player in college football. I think he's a phenomenal Ty: All right, wait, so let me get this straight, man. Let me get this straight. Is your argument that Jeremiah Smith should not win the Hosman Trophy because he's a wide receiver? So like The Great Debater: Yes. Ty: y you don't even have another player. You don't even have another player it should be. It just can't Jeremiah Smith because he plays wide receiver is what we're saying. The Great Debater: You didn't let me finish, dude. Like but Ty: Well, I mean I'm just thinking I'm speaking talking about you. The Great Debater: but what we're doing here is that the competition level is pretty great this year. He's got a face-off against I know he didn't have the greatest game, but Kamario Taylor is still on the board as far as Heisman odds go. Ty: Yeah, he's out. The Great Debater: he's not out. He is not out after one bad game against Ty: Yeah, exactly. The Great Debater: against B Alabama. Jaden Baugh is not out. Keelan Russell is still up there. CJ Carr is still up there. Trinidad Chambliss is still up there. He's got a lot of guys that he has to fend off in order for him to be a Heisman can Heisman winner. He is a Heisman candidate. He he will win the Bolitnikov Award. But to win the Heisman, you have to be insane. Like I think he needs 2,500 receiving yards like 20 touchdowns in order to win a Heisman. At this stage of college football. Ty: Well, I I don't I don't think he needs twenty-five. I don't think he needs twenty five. I I don't think he needs twenty five hundred. I will say through five games this year, Jeremia Smith leads the nation in receptions with forty-four receiving yards with eight hundred and twenty-three and touchdowns with nine. Through this point, through the first five year five games of Devontae Smith's historic cosmic season, he had forty-five catches, five hundred and fifty-six yards, and five touchdowns. So Jeremia Smith is already outpacing him. to the tune of four touchdowns and about 300 yards. Jeremiah Smith is also averaging over 18 yards a carry. Now, just how absurd that is that while getting nine balls a game, he's averaging 18 yards a pop. The Great Debater: Yes. Ty: And I I would just say to the point of the the competition being stiff, Kamario Taylor, he's he's not going to win the Osman Jaden Ball, Jaden Ball gave you a whopping like 40 yards last week. No disrespect, book. He didn't show up. That was a big game, big spotlight game, big opportunity. Jeremiah Smith is gonna be on the national stage almost every week this season. He's got the big game at the end of the season against Michigan. He's got national television spot against USC coming up on Halloween. And he's also got a big game, I think they play Indiana here shortly. So Jeremiah Smith is gonna be all TV. Every single week. Indiana on the 17th, USC on the 31st, and then Oregon and Michigan to follow. So I think the stage is going to be there for Jeremiah. not to mention, did you watch the game last week? Have 200 yards against The Great Debater: He's phenomenal. Ty: Iowa, 200 yards against Iowa, 180 The Great Debater: You spent life. Ty: against Texas. I mean, if you want to say Julian Saiyan could take away votes from him, I no, he's not. You can ask, you can ask his teammates to one of his teammates, the running back. was just on with nightcap which unkin ocho he said jj's got his vote i think the the nation has been captivated by jeremiah smith i watched the game so i watched every game actually i'm captivated i can't turn him off against illinois 200 yards i i don't understand how you could be the best player on the field that fast that big and they they how are you guarding this guy one on one he's he's wide open on every play So then I go back, I watch Iowa this week. Another 200 yards. All right. Some places he's wide open, some places got three guys on him. He catches it, breaks the tackle, 50 yards up the sideline. They they're grabbing him, passing the fence. He's still catching the ball. Four touchdowns, three touchdowns, man. This man is just it's raining touchdowns. Like, and then if you want to say, all right, Julian Satan is you know, he's the driving force behind the production. All right, fine. Yeah, Julian Satan is great player. Julian Satan's best game of the season 300 yards against Iowa, 200, go to JJ. All right. no other Ohio State receiver is coming close. And I think Ohio State and Ryan Day have made it a point that they want Jeremiah Smith to win the Heisman Trophy in New York at the end of the season. The Great Debater: Okay. All right. So presenting my counter argument, right? The Heisman has historically been a quarterback's award, right? But I think in order for Jeremiah Smith to I Ty: Well, let's talk quarterbacks. The Great Debater: mean, he ha he is, like, and he's he's got a lot of good quarterbacks that he has to fend off in order to win the award. Keelan Russell, CJ Carr, Kamario Taylor, Trinidad Chamblers. Like these are all guys that he has to push away in a award that historically has gone to them, right? But another thing about Jeremiah Smith is Like he's gonna face better defenses this year. And I think because it is a historically quarterback award, off game for him, which might be a good game for every other wide receiver, might take him out of the res the Heisman vote. When they play Indiana and when they play USC and when they play Michigan even, When he plays those games and they're gonna like focus specifically on him. If he has a game where he has 80 yards and a touchdown, that's gonna lower his odds real quick. I think it's gonna be hard for him to bounce back. I think obviously that he should have like forgiveness in that because 80 yards and a touchdown is a good game. But in order for a wide receiver Ty: Now we heard it. The Great Debater: to win the Heisman, I think it's it's going to be something where he has to do something astronomical every week. Not to mention Ohio State has an abundance of riches as far as talent goes. So as the The season continues and they play tougher teams because they're gonna play tougher teams throughout the season. Like I just mentioned with Indiana and USC and Oregon, the focus is going to be on him. So they're gonna try to get other guys involved. I think this second half of the year for Ohio State is gonna be a breakout for Chris Henry. And the reason why is because they're gonna be focused on Jeremiah Smith so much. So if you're focused on Jeremia Smith so much and other guys are getting the ball, that doesn't mean he's a bad player, but it does diminish his odds. And it does diminish his statistics, which is what you need in order to win the Heisman Trophy. Once again, this is not me saying that Jeremiah Smith is a bad player. Jeremiah Smith is phenomenal. I would draft Jeremiah Smith today if I could, one-one. But this is about who can win the Heisman Trophy. And I think the odds are stacked against him to win in New York at the very end of the year. Ty: Just to your point about better defenses, they just played a top ten defense in the country in the number fourteen Iowa Hawkeyes, who were The Great Debater: Yes. Ty: coming in averaging one hundred and fifty two passing yards a game and eight points a game and Jeremy Smith just lit up to the tune of two hundred and two touchdowns. and yeah. The Great Debater: The Iowa Hawkeyes do have a phenomenal defense. The Iowa Hawkeyes games before Ohio State, let me read off. Michigan, Northern Iowa, Iowa State, and Northern Illinois. Ty: But wait, d de but hold on. Do you think do you think Texas has a good defense? The Great Debater: I think Texas has a very good defense. I think Texas has a very good defense and I watched what happened in that fourth quarter. Ty: eight catches, hundred sixty four yards and a touchdown against Texas. I that's that's pretty good, right? Yeah, that's pretty good. It's pretty good. Yeah. The Great Debater: Yeah. I mean, it's pretty good. He did it pretty early though. You know what mean? So his quarterback wouldn't they couldn't they couldn't get on the rhythm when the game mattered. And another thing about that is to bring bring up another point with Ohio State is we also have to admit that when it comes to the Heisman Trophy, how your team does matters. Ohio State already has one loss on the season. I don't I think they're one of the best teams in college football, obviously. But if they slip up once or twice, that diminishes his. his odds too as well because it's like he's a great player on this team that is good, but not like national championship level great, right? Does it make sense? So now his team success also i is important for how he does as far as winning the Heisman trophy. Ty: Yeah, and I I have complete confidence in Ohio State that one, they're gonna keep keep winning and two, they're gonna continue to get Jeremia Smith the ball. and I bro you still haven't told me, you know, who who can compete. You said the quarterback. So the field just being the quarterbacks. So The Great Debater: Yes. Yeah. Ty: if let's let's talk about okay. The Great Debater: Okay. Ty: right now, Jeremia Smith is currently the overwhelming favorite to win the Heisman. according to Calci, he's got forty eight percent. talking about these brands, but according to Calci, he's got forty eight percent odds to win. Booker T: I was like a calci drop. What? The Great Debater: Ha ha ha. Ty: my bad. Kylen: Okay. Ty: and the the next the next highest odds is your boy Darien Minsa. Now I will say Darien Minsa, good player, great player. The Great Debater: Mm-hmm. Ty: he's averaging eighty four percent completion percentage. He's got fifteen touchdowns and zero interceptions, and I mean that's that's really good. But they have played absolutely nobody. The Great Debater: Okay. Ty: absolutely nobody, and they're not gonna play anybody. The Great Debater: In the eyes of the Heisman voters, how much does that really matter if your team success is good? Ashton Genty was the runner up two years ago. Ty: Yeah, the runner up. that that'll get a runner up. So I think it matters. The Great Debater: A lot of people argued he should have won it. Ty: Okay. But I mean he didn't. And I I think a lot of people you know Jeremiah Smith was a finalist last year too. I think he was he finished sixth in the ballot. So now I will say Minsa's Minsa's pretty good, but I don't really think Minsa has a shot. I think he'll make it to New York. But I think the the best threat to Jeremiah Smith's Heisman candidacy or his ability to win Heisman is gonna be that quarterback in Tuscaloosa, Keelan Russell. The Great Debater: Maybe. Ty: So I I think that he he's gonna be on the stage and have the chance to prove himself to the voters. with a big one coming up this week against Georgia. We'll see, we'll see what he does. I mean, if he likes them up for 400 yards, three touchdowns, he might shoot to the top of the odds, but that's to be determined. And he'll also have games against Tennessee. That'll be a big one. Of course the Iron Bowl, and then a couple more shots. But like I said, Jeremiah Smith. Already has captured the nation with his his big plays thus far and the stages are only gonna get bigger with matchups against defending national champion, Indiana, national championship favorites, Oregon, and then the big matchup with USC and the Coliseum. So I The Great Debater: Yeah. I I Ty: th I think it this is about a big a slam dunk for a Heisman trophy as we've seen in a long time. The Great Debater: If if you're arguing the field versus Jeremiah Smith, I have to take the field just based off of history and just based off of how hard it is for a wide receiver to win the award. Honestly, I think with when you brought up Darien Mincy, you kind of proved my point a little bit, is at the beginning of the year, everybody was like, Malachi Tony's gonna be in New York, and nobody talks about Malachi Tony being a Heisman candidate anymore. Right? Is I feel like this is Ty: It's so hard for a wide receiver to win the Hosman. Why have we had two wide receivers win the Hosman in last six years? The Great Debater: One of them didn't play wide receiver fully and one of them was in a covet year. Ty: I mean, that's two wires. You it it's not like it can't be done. Two two out of the last six and neither one of those guys can hold a candlestick to Jeremiah Smith. The Great Debater: That's two wide receivers, yes, but the circumstances were extenuating. I have like eighty five more years of evidence that show you why a wide receiver won't win the Ty: Hey, it's the modern era. It's a different game. You're talking about the old days. In the old days, brother. It wasn't it wasn't no it wasn't no Jeremiah Smith back then, man. The Great Debater: I got you. Book Colin, bringing y'all in on this. How do y'all feel about it? Do you think Jeremiah Smith wins or does not win the Heisman Trophy? Booker T: I think he has a good shot. I like both of y'all points. I do think if we're discounting certain Geisman and Heisman already for one loss, then which was Tyler's point, you know, some guys already dropped off by not showing up, then it will just take one game for Ohio State just not a D there Jeremiah Smith to I ain't gonna say be shut down 'cause it's g it's impossible to see. But he has a good shot. but I will be on the side of for safety reasons. If I'm being safe about it, yeah, I'm going. The Jeremiah Smith will not win the Heisman. But he has a great shot. The Great Debater: Okay. Colin, what about you? Kylen: I d I think that he is the front runner right now. I think that he is showing up every week, which is as you can see, hard to do. We have some guys who come out and they have amazing weeks and they come out and they lay stinkers. And you got this guy who's just consistently being great, consistently breaking records. I think he has outplayed the quarterback wide receiver bias on his own team. Because I mean, we were talking like Julian Saiyan may knock out his numbers, but to me, it looks like Julian Saiyan needs Jeremiah Smith for his numbers. I mean, it's clear and obvious he's the best player on that team. he goes out week in, week out. I'm sitting here making these graphics and reading these stats. I mean, like he's like Tyler said, he's averaging what every every time I look at it, it's like 18 yards a 18 yards a catch, Guy's getting like 20 yards every time he touches the rock. He's getting like 200 yards a game. It's always two or three touchdowns. Now it's getting to the point where every week it's like, well, this record's broken. This record's broken. All right. Now The Great Debater: Yeah. Kylen: he's the leader in this category. It's it's it's it's getting kinda out of hand. The Great Debater: For the record, man, I like I love this debate thing, but I also hate it because I had to argue why Jeremia Smith should win the Heisman. Kylen: Yeah. The Great Debater: And y'all know I absolutely think Jeremiah Smith should win the Heisman Kylen: Hehehehehe The Great Debater: trophy. But that's the reason we do this. Booker T: Content baby. Kylen: Yeah. The Great Debater: my gosh. All right. Ty: Thing is, man, if there was if there was a a quarterback that has separated himself from the other quarterbacks the way Jeremiah Smith has separated himself from the other wide receivers, we wouldn't even be having this heisman talk. Like they would be The Great Debater: Mm-hmm. I know. Ty: far and away the number one. But I mean nobody has. I and that's that's the big thing. I think Jeremiah's separation is like he's in a different stratosphere than everybody else right now. The Great Debater: Yeah. All right. Moving on to topic number two. book, sorry, man. The Gators, bruh. Huge fall off after a huge win over Ole Miss, the Gators get smacked in the mouth by Missouri. Man, Tyler, I remember you saying that Missouri had no shot at this. And look what happened. Demolished them boys 45-17. Do you want Eli Drinkwitz to be the coach at USC now? Ty: No. The Great Debater: Okay. All right. Forty-five seventeen. Missouri moving up from twenty-five to fourteen in the AP poll. Florida dropping very, very much so. Maybe we we crowned the Gators too early, but this debate is between Colin and Booker. Colin, you gotta tell me why Florida's chances are dead for the college football playoff after this loss. And Book, you gotta tell me why the Gators still have a shot to possibly go dancing in December. Colin, I'm gonna start with you first. Why are the gators dead in the water, literally? Kylen: I think they had a good run. I think they showed a lot of grit. I think they showed a lot of fight. And I think that they went and they played a very good game against Old Miss and they have been winning in their s their schedule. But I think that they got a little overhyped. You know, jumping from twenty-one to eight is a astronomical jump when you have had some teams within that gap that have played some tougher schedules, that twenty-one to jump to eight jump, which is kind of absurd. I think that's gonna hurt them more in the long run, especially with a loss like this. It's one thing to come in and you have a close loss, you have a hard fought game. Like like Mizzou was firing off all cylinders, but to come in and it's like because even my brother Book was like, man, our secondaries are very questionable. And it's like Austin Simmons is a very good player. He's been a very good player for a long time. had that unfortunate injury and then unfortunately Trinidad comes up and he's behind you and he's the one that takes your spy. But that's how the game goes. And so he's a good quarterback. How many good quarterbacks are you going to face going through the SEC? How many good quarterbacks are you going to face in the postseason? If that's the case, then how many times is your secondary is going to get picked apart like that to the point where it's like, who do you who's out there? It's me, Jones, Simmons, and Taylor out there. Out there Ty: But Kylen: at DV. And it's like it's if that's your secondary I don't wanna see you go against Jeremiah Smith. I don't wanna see you go against DeCorium Moore. I don't wanna see you go against Cam. I don't wanna see you go against Ryan Williams. I it's it's gonna get dirty. It's gonna get nasty. I think that that really hurt their chances, just showing how weak their defense can be. one more game, and I think that they are completely just out of the talks. Just you gotta get up out of there. Booker T: I have my notes for this. so let me read them off to you. You are wrong. my bad. Hold up. I shouldn't have said that. Ty: Ha Booker T: I was just playing. Let me just say that I'm just gonna go ahead and just stick to the prompt. Is the playoff hopes dead? No, they're not dead. One loss does not get you out. Let me purpose this whole conversation too, because y'all, of course, we're talking about the gators. You see me in the gator jersey. I'm glad we're having this conversation. If you were to ask me where we were having this conversation a few months ago, I'd be like, man, let's go. I'll take it. So the fact I thought we'd be like three losses in right now. Can't lie to you, told y'all at the beginning of the year. So the fact that we have the conversation, fantastic. it's not dead. This SEC What we said last week and the week before, it's a bloodbath. Like everybody has like some certain games where it's like, hold up. We have to pay attention to this. You know what I'm saying? And I understand that rankings, you know, we have to follow them. We have to follow the polls. We have to kind of like keep up with that, man. But we still, bruh. Alex, we're halfway through the season, man. We still kind of don't know things. Like, we don't know who's best. Because at the end of day, we beat Ole Miss. The Great Debater: Why you say me like I'm arguing it? Booker T: Well, cause you had mentioned well, you had mentioned the whole rankings thing. And I'm like, even with rankings, like we still don't know. So at the end of day, just last week, we was the ones to be the top ten team. But now and we blew them out. Now we got blown out. You know what I'm saying? people just last week, a big topic of discussion, I don't know if y'all covered it, was the simple fact that Missouri was twenty five. Everybody was like, SEC bias, what is doing on? Like, Houston looks better than Missouri, Missouri said, okay, bet we're gonna take y'all darlings and we're gonna spank So like what do we know? Kylen: Yeah. Booker T: You know what I'm saying? What do we know? So at a certain point, man, I don't think the playoff hopes are dead. I just think that's just at a certain point, let's just say, for example, if we get a win, because I'm looking at two games. If we beat a Georgia, if we beat a Texas, and let and let the other one fall. And we win out the rest. you starting to look at the schedule, you start Kylen: Yeah. Booker T: to look at the you know what I'm saying, the repertoire. So I don't think it's dead. It's dead when them losses start stacking up. That's when it's gonna be dead. But at a certain point, there's still hope. You know what I'm saying? There's still a chance to rebound. I'm about to say if you beat Texas, who at a certain point, some games they start off too slow. If you catch them on a great I understand that they have weapons, they have guys that can kill the secondary. Secondary look terrible. I've been saying that all year. But at a certain point, you catch them on the right day. And you can just get up and let the, up big. And now you kinda have to kind of catch up. Let the game script go to there. Then you get a win right there. You get that one win, then hey man, you just looking. So I'm not and then at a certain point too, let's look at the Missouri side of things. They got 10 them. If they get a big win against Ole Miss. Now, granted, their schedule is looking, like I said, bloodbath. You got Ole Miss. You got Missouri. You got Georgia. You got Texas at home, though. What if Missouri gets that win against Texas? How are we looking at that Florida loss? Now, granted, yes, the score looks terrible. Final score looks terrible, but it was a game in the first half. So it's just one of them things where when it's all then done, man. You just gotta look, bro. You just gotta look. I don't think it's dead, though. Still hope. Kylen: I think you may be looking a little too far ahead when you just jump to Texas and Georgia. But you know, this South Carolina team, they have been very underwhelming, but at the same time, they're getting to a point to where we talking about some families not eating at this point. We're talking about somebody losing their job. Eventually they gonna start scratching and clawing for anything. And, you know, that's you're coming off that loss, they're coming off of this, you know, hey We may lose our coach before Halloween. This that's a game that you gotta look at because now they they fighting a little different at the same time. Sellers, he's he's still good. And he plays that position that's been eating Florida up all season. He plays that quarterback position, he's very mobile, he's big, he's a strong guy. and then like you said, then you have to go from him into Arch in Texas. Then you have to go from them into Georgia. And then from them into Oklahoma. And granted, Oklahoma has not been the biggest threat all year, but going to Oklahoma after a South Carolina game, after a Texas game, after a Georgia game, those are the type of games to where you have to go in and fight. And then not to mention, later on down at the end of the season, you got Kentucky down there. Kentucky has been playing some good ball all year. They're not ranked at this time, but Kentucky is no longer just that's just a game down the stretch that we're gonna play before Vandervelt. No, you gotta you're gonna have to prepare for Kentucky. That's no longer Caitwalk. And then you you have Vandervelt, Vanderbilt, they've been fighting. And then you got you got the little bros. To be honest, I don't know what that last game is gonna look like. I don't even know if Mike is gonna be at that game. He may have to buy tickets to that game, depending on how the rest of their season goes. We don't know. But Florida, but just like how you said, depending on how Missouri goes out, it's some teams on here. It's like, hey, they didn't change the objective of everybody else's schedule. And with Florida having these big that that that secondary was just egregious, man. It you got some Booker T: No, I agree, at the end of the day, game script. At the end of the day, at a certain point, what's the best way to stop a quarterback? Keep on the sideline. This was a Missouri team that has a great front seven. Now granted, I know Texas probably were gonna have a better run game, and so is Georgia. So it's like I'm not gonna everybody's like, we they figured Jordan Ball out and stuff like that. At a certain point, the game plan always been from day one is to control the ground. Control the control the time of possession. So I understand, yeah, secondary week, like I said, at a certain point the game can go one way. If one strip sack, one fumble. I'm about to say they was getting to Simmons, but at a certain point, once you have the game set up to a certain way, it would just got out of the hand. You know? And so that's to the quarterback point of view, yes, that can happen. But also too, you name a lot of teams, guess who else has to play them? And you have a good argument for a lot of these teams. And dudes go back to my whole point about the SEC fighting each other. Georgia has to play these teams. Georgia has to play South Carolina. Georgia has to play Ole Miss. Georgia has to play Missouri. Texas have to play these teams as well. So it's like what if they get a loss? You know what I'm saying? That's why I'm like that's why I'm saying this is not dead, 'cause if one of them get a loss messing around. I'm about to say Georgia about to play Bama. And when the way Keelan Russell playing, this ain't even a guarantee. So Those are our favorites. Remember, those are our SEC favorites. All the teams you just named, they gotta play them too. What Kylen: I'll say the difference between like for instance the Georgia and Obama game for years, especially within this playoff setting, those two teams have gone head to head plenty of times. And there have been times to where they have gone head to head and their spot has not moved, even though one team lost and one team won. They just have to make sure that the winner was above the loser. depend Booker T: Mm-hmm. Kylen: on how these teams look because of so how how how highly decorated they are and How much everybody has believed in them and what they have already shown, a loss to them may not cost as much as a loss to Florida. If we're talking about, even if we are talking about a two-loss Bama team or a two-lost Georgia team, I think that they would be put above a two-loss Florida team. If we're talking about Booker T: But what if the d but what if the Florida team is one of the losses for Georgia? 'Cause again, Florida was poo poo trash last year and it still was a good game to the fourth quarter. What what we do Kylen: Alright, we'll say Booker T: what we gonna do then? Kylen: Well well let's say that they got the SEC championship. Is Florida gonna get in over Georgia in the SEC championship? Booker T: depends on the result of the Florida Kylen: got the same record. Booker T: Who wins who wins the game Kylen: I think. Booker T: on October thirty first? I feel like it depends on it. Kylen: I don't know book as a sh I think it this setting, 'cause Booker T: I I think George's his favorite. Yeah. Kylen: 'Cause I think with this setting, especially with the playoffs, that unfortunately, you know, the aura of your team does matter. if your team goes out there and they look a little slow, they look a little boo boo, they gonna remember that. They're gonna be like, Y'all remember that day that Florida look look boo boo out there and then they not they gonna they gonna throw all the analytics stuff out of out of the window and then they gonna remember like, Hey y'all remember that classic, another classic from from Georgia and Bama and they both put up Ford it points on each other and they're gonna be like, Yeah, that that game made us feel good. And then you also gotta remember they're gonna put in the teams that get the most views as well. Who if we're talking about Georgia or Bama or Texas and then we're talking about Florida, out of those four teams, who's gonna get the least amount of views when it comes to television? And I'm not saying that Florida's just s some dog water team that nobody watches on T V. Florida Florida has a large fan base. The swamp is crazy. But if we're talking about in 2026, Roll Tide is insane. Texas and crazy fan base. Then you got Georgia. Again, another dog fan base. At this time, they just they would get put in above Florida to the point where Florida just can't make as many mistakes as what these other teams can't afford to make. And plus you got Keelan Russell out here balling at a Heisman level. Booker T: I think it's hard for me to go with that. It's hard for me to go with that The Great Debater: I'm watching Book cook up like right now. I'm like I'm watching Book's wheels turn. Booker T: because all we had to do was be Ole Miss, the same old Miss that struggled with Louisville, to go up to number eight. So to say that we ain't gonna have the same backend is kind of crazy to me. All it was for Kylen: And DNA. Booker T: us to be media darlings was to be old miss. So that's the thing. I'm like, I hear you. Yes, history and rep reputation, you want to go ahead and throw Texas, though Georgia, though Bama above us, but it took us a few good games and a non-emotional, which I said last week, a non-emotional Arbor win to get to get a to get us number eight. So I Kylen: Well, it was it was a little more than that. It was a little more than that. 'cause remember that old Miss team had to go have that crazy win against that LSU team, which everybody Booker T: Yeah. Kylen: was is now saying, like, well, that LSU team is definitely a postseason team that you're gonna see in the playoffs. And Old Miss beat them. So then y'all beat them. Then y'all beat Old Miss. And so they're like, okay, well. They're competing with the playoff teams, but then you go in, and Missouri, who hasn't really shown that playoff potential on either side of the ball, comes in it's one thing to lose, and it's another thing to lose in dominance. Because there's four quarters that you have to play. If you compete in all four quarters, then hey, hats off to the better man. But at a certain point, that game started getting out of hand, and one team started looking better than the other one. Not saying that it was, but from the looks of that game, that's how it ended. The Great Debater: in on this real quick. Ty, like you got you you were impartial on this when like I said, we we argued for and against Tyler. Honestly, what are your honest thoughts about if Florida is out of the college football playoff race? Ty: So obviously Florida is not mathematically eliminated from the playoffs on October 5th, 2026. But they owe life support. I tell you that. Kylen: That's Ty: They owe life support. So I would just say what are the chances of a three loss Florida getting into the playoffs, right? so are we making that argument that a The Great Debater: Sl none actually. Ty: so does a A three loss Florida probably not making the playoffs, right? The Great Debater: Unless they that third loss is SCC championship, I don't see how it happens. Ty: So just the way I have things, you know, hashing out. You got Alabama probably eleven to one, Georgia probably eleven to one, Texas probably eleven and one, LSU probably eleven and one. if you get five teams of the SEC into the playoffs, Florida could very well be that unless Missouri, you know, wins out or finishes with two losses or three losses. A three loss Missouri is getting in over a a three loss Florida, right? Just because of the hit to hit. a three loss O miss is probably out of the question, right? Any three loss team. But I will say three loss Florida is not getting into the playoffs. That's pretty safe to say it's possible, but not likely. And I would just please make the argument that Florida can beat either Georgia or Texas. Because I mean I just don't see it happening. They just they just lost about The Great Debater: Can't. I I can't. Ty: four touchdowns to Missouri. So how you gonna go into Austin? How are you gonna go into Austin in two Booker T: So so we so we know that what Georgia Ty: weeks and beat them? Booker T: so we know what Georgia look like. Ty: They look good. Number two team in the country. Yeah, it looked pretty The Great Debater: We're about to get into that in a minute. Kylen: Yeah they Yeah they Booker T: Okay, Ty: good. Booker T: all right. Okay. The Great Debater: I Kylen: well The Great Debater: here's the thing. Kylen: oiled machine over there. The Great Debater: I don't know book, like, and I'm not this is Ty: They w George was George Booker T: We know what you're gonna look like. No, Georgia dominant. Yeah, Georgia amazing. Yeah, Ty: was doing D logic. Yeah. Booker T: they gon they gonna kill everybody. Yeah. To the top. To the movie. Got it. Ty: I mean if you hey, go The Great Debater: They very well could. Ty: beat J that's that's why you roll the ball out there. That's why you play the game. Kylen: That's why you play the game. Ty: Go yeah, go beat Booker T: That's my whole argument. If it's dead. It's not dead. The life support, chances, and then again, the teams you named, Tyler, like, they don't have to play each other. miss, miss. But you saying again, your scenario was like... Ty: So who y'all gonna beat? Y'all gonna beat are y'all gonna beat Georgia or Texas? But are you are you gonna beat Georgia or Texas? Kylen: And Kentucky. Booker T: It's a possibility. Ty: But who you gonna be? Just who are you gonna be? You gotta one of them. Who you gonna be? Who? Booker T: It's a possibility. I say Georg Geor I say Georgia is the most likely, but I'm not sleeping on the Texas. I'm not changing the argument. Let's let's keep the Ty: You just lost about twenty eight to Missouri and now you're gonna go beat the number two team in the country. Booker T: We just be Ole Miss. But you just said Ole Miss, though, is got a chance and we just dog walked them. So what what we the the conversation is too imbalanced. Because we just dog walked Ole Miss. Ole Miss still has to play Georgia. They still gotta play Missouri themselves. But but you was like, if we got them, them and Ole Miss, like, wait a minute, hold up. Too much imbalance. That's what I'm saying. They gotta play each other. Ty: I was just naming teams, but I I was just to say that a three loss SEC team probably doesn't it I wouldn't put an Ole Miss in the upper echelon. They're probably you know, their own life support Kylen: They're too banged up. Ty: too, honestly. Yeah. Booker T: Which is which is very fair. Keep on. The Great Debater: Biggest concern of my biggest concern about Florida is that they're a one trick pony. That's that's and I feel like it kind of got not shown this week, but it's just like, all right, if you stop this, it's over, period. Like Jaden Ball had what, twelve carries for thirteen yards and they couldn't do anything else, like on offense. Aaron Falo like had a very, you know, meager game, I guess. Like they don't Florida hasn't had to rely on a passing offense to win them games yet. And so it's like the week that you needed a passing offense to be kind of not explosive, but at least a little bit more dynamic, Kylen: Open the field. The Great Debater: it couldn't happen and you lost by twenty eight points. Booker T: I say our best playmaker was out this game. Just had to mention that. To be fair. Mm-hmm. He was out. The Great Debater: You talking about VB three? But like I guess my concern is that like even even when VB three has played, right? Book all year it has been Florida is gonna ride the Jaden Bartrain to victory literally every week, right? They did it against Auburn, they did it against Ole Miss. Now, can you do it again? But like the week you really, really needed it in Missouri, like it just didn't show up. So My concern is I don't think you can beat a Texas or a Georgia with that, if that makes any sense. But I digress. We'll get off Ty: Looks a do they now look like a completely different team on the road? Or am I just hallucinating? The Great Debater: I don't know, man. They scored seventeen this week and they l scored Booker T: You're elusating because The Great Debater: forty four against Auburn and Jordan Hare, so Booker T: Nah about say Ty: Yeah, that was a nail biter against Auburn on the road, Booker T: it became a nail biter because they were playing from behind again the second year was getting torched from some light last Last Man Last Man Heroics the game. Ty: Okay. Yeah. I mean you got f what? One, two, and three, four. Your four Booker T: we'll Ty: of your hardest games are on the road and you gotta win same Booker T: Georgia's neutral. Georgia's neutral. The Great Debater: But it's in Atlanta. Kylen: Up it. Ty: I mean, that's in Atlanta. Kylen: I'd say Texas and Georgia are away. Booker T: So we always play Georgia The Great Debater: Neutral. Booker T: That's all neutral. Huh? What'd you say, bro? Kylen: I was saying Texas and Georgia are away? Booker T: Texas is a way, Georgia is neutral. The Great Debater: Georgia, like I said, is neutral but Geor Ty: That's yeah. The Great Debater: Georgia is Nino. Kylen: Neutral in Atlanta. The Great Debater: Georgia's a Nino, neutral in name only. Like it's it's a Georgia ro it's a Georgia. Kylen: I would say if it's in Atlanta, that's a Red Stadium. The Great Debater: That is that's for sure. Ty: I like Florida in Gainesville though. I like Florida a lot in Gainesville. The Great Debater: I do too. I do too. but anyway, moving on part three of the debates. I like this little debate thing, man. It's fun. Alabama looking honestly pretty dynamic against Mississippi State. The Heisman fight that we all kind of were watching goes to Keelan Russell after he balls out against the Bulldogs. Alabama wins 56 to 23. Over the Bulldogs in Starkville. now might be game of the year is coming up next between Alabama and Georgia in Bryant Denny Stadium in Tuscaloosa. It's the 6 30 game. It is the college football playoff game. So the next argument is does this last Alabama win basically show that Alabama is going to beat Georgia this weekend? This is between what, Colin and me? man. Okay. Colin, you're taking the negative on this one. I'm taking the positive on this one. Colleen, you want to start first? Kylen: I'm a firm believer that each Saturday has its own date for a reason. Any given Sunday, any given Saturday, that Mississippi game will have absolutely nothing to do with the game that's coming up this coming Saturday. Yes, you know, Keelan got off. Yes, it was a good quarterback battle. Yes, you know, we got to see two Heisman level competitors go at it. Unfortunately, we have one that showed up kind of late to the party and ended up walking away a little early due to an injury. Yes, Bama looked good. Yes, Bama looked like a solid team. They look like they're playoff ready. But at the same time, from looking at this Georgia team, it's another Kirby Smart team. We all know how Kirby Smart does. It's a well oiled machine. They come in, they replace, they are a high energy team. They don't play with a lot of emotion. They come in, they play the game the right way. there's not a lot of teams that play like Georgia in general. So there's not gonna be a lot of teams that you are gonna have on your schedule that either that can even replicate the type of game that Georgia plays. They play that down south, dirty, hard football. They don't pass a lot, they keep it on the ground, and they try to punch you in your mouth every play. It's not anything that you can prepare for without physically just going through it. That's why normally when Bama does play a Georgia, they may lose to him the first time and then beat the second time. Or vice versa. They it's just not something that that physicality is something different when it comes to the Bulldogs. You see, they put a lot of guys within the trenches into the NFL, into the next level, and they just keep reloading I don't think that you will have Another game outside of a Georgia game that can prepare you for Georgia. So did I think that was a statement game for Belma? I think it was a, you know, another statement game for Keelan Russell, but I think this is a whole nother beast that you have to prepare for. I think that mentally Belma has to just completely wipe the board when it comes to everything that they've done now and say, let's lock in and let's focus on this week because nothing that we have nothing that we have seen is even gonna replicate what we're about to see, Saturday. So no, I don't think that that last week's game will have anything to do with this game coming up. The Great Debater: Do y'all remember like the discourse for Nick Saban while he was at Alabama was that he was not good against a dual threat quarterback? Booker T: Yes. The Great Debater: Yeah, like that that used to be like his that was kind of his thing. Like, okay. And I think it was an unfair narrative, but that was a narrative against Nick Saban was. Like he can't when when he faces a dual threat quarterback, it's trouble for him, right? Kirby Smart's narrative is that when he faces a dynamic offense that it's it's pretty it's pretty troubling for him. He is 122 and 21 in his tenure at Georgia, which is phenomenal, obviously, right? But at the same time, the things that usually give Kirby smart problems, the only anomaly being Notre Dame in the playoff, what, two years ago, is that when he faces a dynamic offense, like it kind of spells trouble for him. And Alabama's offense is picking up at the perfect time. They looked they looked like they were firing on all cylinders since the Fans decided to bully Ryan Grubb into calling good plays. Keelan Russell is finally hitting his stride as a quarterback. actually earlier than I thought he would, because I kind of I mean, it's the SEC and he's this is his first year starting as QB, but he's been amazing for the last few weeks of college football. Alabama has is averaging the second most points overall in college football. They're averaging 49.6 points a game. The only team that is above Alabama is actually Georgia. Georgia is averaging 50 points a game. However, let me read off the schedule to you. So far, Georgia has played Tennessee State, Western Kentucky, Arkansas, Oklahoma, Vanderbilt. Not anywhere near eat not great teams by any stretch, but definitely not great offenses at all, right? So it's kinda easy to run up the score against all of those teams, right? But when you look at a team like Alabama, who genuinely has turned it on this year as far as getting their running game better and getting their wide receiver core better, they have a more dynamic quarterback and everything. Kirby Smart's Georgia teams usually have a hard time keeping up in like races as far as offenses go. And I'm concerned that I don't know if he's going to be able to do it again this week. Because if you look at A couple years ago, the last time Georgia came to Tuscaloosa, Alabama was putting up twenty eight to nothing on before Georgia came back. And then Alabama, you know, edged out the game at the end, but they already had what felt like a head start. You can score, but can you score enough is the question. And I think that's going to be the biggest question for Georgia this weekend against Alabama. But I think Alabama has shown you they can they can score extremely easily. They scored 56 and it felt like they should have scored 70 against Mississippi State. I don't know if a Georgia can put up a 70 on Alabama. I don't think that Alabama can put up seventy on Georgia, but at the same time, if it's a race to thirty five or thirty eight points, I do kind of like the crimson tide in that in that little race right there. And I think that that's gonna spell trouble for Kirby Smart's Bulldogs in Tuscaloosa. Kylen: So here's one thing from watching the game, especially this Bama game this past Saturday. So coming to the game, you know, all hype, you know, get to see this Mississippi State quarterback come in and do his thing. Comario Taylor comes out and drops the ball between his legs, turns the ball over, Bamba gets a ball. Bama gets it. They go down the field, what, about three, four plays later? Then they The Great Debater: Mm-hmm. Kylen: turn the ball over. Mississippi gets the ball. it was a sequence like that to where every time, like Bama would turn it over, Mississippi State would turn it over. Camario would throw a pick, Bama could score off of it, then they come Bamba fumble, you know. How many are how many mistakes are you gonna rely on in that Georgia game to happen like that? How many times do you think Gunnar Stockton's gonna go out there and he's gonna drop back for a pass and just drop the ball completely and then Or how many times do you think Bama's gonna be able to make a turnover and Georgia just not capitalize off of it? I don't think Bama has played too many teams that really punish them for making mistakes. They played a lot of high emotion games that like the Florida State game. Florida State came in, punishment and off. That's a high emotion game because The Great Debater: Mm-hmm. Kylen: every time Bama and Florida State play each other, it's just this thing to where it's like we're not scared of them and we're gonna show you guys that we're not scared of our big brother. And we're gonna go in and we're gonna fight. Even the Kentucky game, high emotion game. It's like, hey, we're Kentucky and we're here to show you guys that we're here to play football this year. I don't think, in the sense of Bama, because I know you're saying that with Georgia, you know, they had a kind of weaker schedule. But the thing with Georgia is Georgia has always played with this mentality that has not changed over the years. And each The Great Debater: Mm-hmm. Kylen: year that mentality has dragged them. deep into the playoffs, not just a first round exit. I'm talking about sometimes all the way to the championship, talking about semifinals. It has always carried them that way and they have always played the year and it has always competed at the hot level. I think because The Great Debater: Yes. Kylen: they have consistently stayed at that level over the years, that there's gonna be times to where some things are going to happen and I don't know if Bama at this point in the schedule will be prepared for or if They will be prepared for a team to capitalize on a mistake they make. Because this isn't a The Great Debater: Yeah. But what Kylen: game to where you can come in and you can afford three Ryan Williams drops. Ryan Williams needs to catch everything. You can't afford The Great Debater: Me Kylen: an interception, a deep ball interception from Keelan Russell because they might take that all the way to the house and then now they're up 14 and they should just be up seven. The Great Debater: Correct. But I mean, Ryan Williams had a a 60 yard touchdown for a drop last year and they still won the game. So, I mean, we've seen evidence to where like that's gonna be fine. I'm not saying he I he needs to do that in this game, obviously. But once again, going back to the original point, is like so far, Georgia has played against quarterbacks. They haven't seen a Keelan Russell yet. They they have seen KJ Jackson, and they have seen, which Arkansas is terrible. They saw John Mateer, who book called the tight end in the in the next level. they haven't seen a Keelan Russell yet. They they just haven't. And I'm just saying, I think they'll prepare as best as they can for it, but that's like a a septic shock to the system when you've been playing probably three of the worst offenses in the SEC and you go to what? Is right now the best offense in the SEC. I'm not saying that the the system doesn't work and that the format doesn't work, but at the same time, what I am saying is that I mean, it it it could very well be like a race to 35, and I'm going to count on Alabama to get there before Georgia does. And I'm not saying and this Alabama offense is very opportunistic. I mean, Alabama defense is very opportunistic as well. They are very leaky. That's a good word to use, but they don't break a ton. They did break a lot against Florida State, but against South Carolina and Mississippi State, which everybody thought Mississippi State was going to score a lot, they didn't break that much. they bent, but they did not break. And they're opportunistic. I'm not saying that I think they're gonna force a lot of turn turnovers because Georgia is very methodical on offense and they like to grind it out and they like to move slow. But at the same time, I definitely could see a play where Georgia looks off for a minute and Keelon throws a 60-yard at a Lottie Brooks. Or there's a Trey Sean Brown and EJ Crowell run that was supposed to be five yards that goes for 35. In a especially in a loud environment where it's going to be late night in Tuscaloosa. Yeah, I mean, I absolutely do think that the script that we saw against Mississippi State could very well be what we see against. Georgia this week. Not saying that it's going to be exactly that way 'cause it could very it should be a close game. These are the two to me, these are the two best teams in the SEC right now. But I mean it just I don't know if this necessarily spells great for for for Georgia this weekend. Tyler Book, I'll bring y'all in on it. What are your thoughts? Ty: I'll I'll say this. this is gonna be obviously the best team that either one of these guys has faced. And I I like Alabama a lot. Georgia is a different animal. I mean Georgia is the team where like on Saturdays, if I'm watching football and I'm flipping through the channels and it it stops. And I see those Bulldogs, man. And them big old red jerseys. Them some big old boys, man. Like Georgia, they got some size on them, man. I'm talking about, you know, shout out Tony, man. That's what they got. They got that Tony Hampton, man. And they got it in spades. So we gon we gonna see what Alabama does. Obviously the game is in Tuscaloosa, but I don't think beating Mississippi State proved anything. I think that was the original question. Them beating Mississippi State proved absolutely nothing. That was just the next game on the schedule. First real session Saturday. line it up and see what you're gonna do. I got Georgia though, but yeah, that's for later. Booker T: I don't think it's the fact that they beat Mississippi. I think it's the fact of how they beat Mississippi and how after it kinda they kinda got the lumps out of the way on the road, like how the offense had almost had a proof of concept. It's like Debore, you finally see it after all these games, especially this game. It's like, okay, this is what Debore wanted to bring. This is the type of quarterback, the type of offense. the type of offense Grubb wanted to have. Like at a certain point, they didn't have a quarterback to this magnitude. I hate to throw all this on them early, but they didn't have this talented of a guy, you know, when it comes to throwing and running. And Pennyx wasn't even a runner, but since Pennyx. You know what I'm saying? So it was like because of how the offense looks I'm with you, Jones. I can see how this offense gives Georgia problems, especially since this is Georgia's first real test. I I'm definitely way more interested after last week with this game. The Great Debater: I mean, I think I think this week it'll be a goody, of course. But like like I said, the debate thing is awesome, man. Let's get into the last one of the week. one team that struggled in the top ten this week that has kind of looked stellar so far, but had some real concerns this weekend. Notre Dame. Notre Dame getting a struggle win against Bill Belichick's North Carolina squad. Kylen: They struggle to get that picture. The Great Debater: Tyler, book, I'm coming to you. is this cause for concern? Is Notre Dame fraudulent? Tyler, I'll start with you. You're arguing that Notre Dame is not fraudulent, correct? Ty: yeah, that's that's correct. so I would just say that untested and fraudulent are not synonyms, right? I believe that Notre Dame is a team that is, you know, you can only play who you who you line up to play against, right? And I I think they have played down to their competition. and I think we all had this idea that Notre Dame was gonna come in and they were gonna steamroll guys. They're gonna look like Georgia. They're gonna look like Ohio State. They're gonna look like Alabama. But I mean, honestly, that's not who Notre Dame is. That's not who they've been under Marcus Freeman. Notre Dame is a team that kind of puts me in the mind or is reminiscent of those early days of, you know, the Nick Saban Alabama teams where just just grind you down. or like the the Georgia teams. of of recent dominance where they just it's almost like a bold constrictor they just wrap around you and just suck the life out of you that's the type of team that Notre Dame is and unfortunately they they're not gonna be tested they're not gonna be tested and they're gonna make the playoffs and you're gonna like it. And then we're gonna see we're gonna see what happens in December. Booker T: So use my old notes. I got my new notes right here. you Kylen: Yeah. Booker T: are a foo. I was playing my bad. I shouldn't have read that either. Kylen: Yeah. Booker T: I was playing. Nah, I think these boys and frogs, man. I think these boys and frogs, man. North Carolina's not good. Not good, not good. They're doing better. but at a certain point. Defense. The defense is my only question. The offense looks cool. Office looks cool. but the defense is not playing up to the same level. yards allowed, they ranked 16th. So if I'm talking about like the big which is great, by the way. Great. If we're talking just about, you know, the whole country, yeah, this is fantastic. But if you wanted them if you're playing I need your defense, yards allowed. Kylen: Yeah. Booker T: I need that to be top 10 if you're gonna play Wisconsin, Rice, Michigan State. I need I need that top ten, man. Off the gr off the rip. I need that top ten. kinda like George, like we said. Ty: Yes. They got they got the number one defense in the country, right? Booker T: Not in yards allowed, unless my sources are trash. Ty: I thought I thought The Great Debater: Let's let's look up the stats. Ty: I I wanna s yeah, can you can you can you check that check that zones? I think their two hundred sixteen yards per game is number one in the country. The Great Debater: You're talking about by yards. Ty: Yeah. Yours. The Great Debater: yes, it is. It is just above LSU. Booker T: But what the heck I'm seeing? The Great Debater: I don't know, book. Booker T: What's my yards allowed? The Great Debater: They yeah. Yards allowed a game. Yeah, Notre Dame is number one with two sixteen. LSU is right behind them at two twenty. Booker T: Well, throw this all out. I think they gon' I think they alright. Kylen: Ha ha ha! The Great Debater: Yeah. Booker T: I think these boys gonna Ty: man. I mean like it I don't really know. Booker T: be alright, man. Hey, you just gotta play no you just gotta play Miami and we good. Ty: Yes. The Great Debater: That was the perfect way. Booker T: I just kidding. The Great Debater: That was the perfect way to to continue a debate right there. That was awesome. Ty: Yeah. I know the reason that we're having this discussion is because it was a close game last week against no North Carolina. Shout out to Bill Belche, man, he kept it close for a while. You know, North Carolina, they returned open and kickoff for a touchdown. So that's how it was twenty one twenty. And then the final score ended up being thirty seven twenty six. So aside from that, I mean it was an ugly game. It was all muddy and rainy and crazy, but Notre Dame, they they steadfast. Booker T: And in it in all actuality, like that's one of Bill Belichick's specialties, man. He's gonna make sure that the team is up the par on all three levels. Some people may, Ty: Slash teams. Booker T: you know, forget about the special team. So again, that's what Bill Belichick. And like I said, again, North Carolina, they're doing pretty solid. Especially with all the distraction, the noise and stuff like that. They actually play pretty well. So for them to play in North Carolina for the game to go w the way it did, I think that's that's pretty impressive. Like I said, Notre Dame's offense looked really good. Defense number one in the nation. Ty: Mm-hmm. Booker T: They just gotta they just better not slip up man. They just better not slip up. The Great Debater: All right, man. I love debate day. We might need to do this again this season, honestly. it's pretty solid. But with that being said, let's actually get into the predictions at the end of the the end of the show. So we got four games to bring up. First one is the game day game. Let's let's talk about Georgia and Bama. Georgia, obviously, Bama have has become a big robber in the last few years. They played twice last year. Alabama won the regular season. Georgia dominated the SEC championship game. Both of these teams are five and and three and in the SEC play. Book, I'll start with you who you got, Georgia, Obama, and why? Booker T: I got Bama. like I said before with our previous discussion, I think again Georgia hasn't been tested. This is gonna be a big test to have, especially on the road. I think the way how Kino Russell is dynamic, he's one of the quarterbacks that at a certain point I think it's a I think it's a cliche almost. Like he's one of the quarterbacks where everything can be right and he'll still make you wrong. and I think his ability to run does that. so I'll I'm give me Bama, man. The Great Debater: Okay. Tyler, how about you? Georgia or Obama. Ty: So obviously biggest game of the year so far for both of these teams. I I'm gonna go out on the limb and say both of these teams are untested. I know Alabama does have the one ranked win against Mississippi State on the road. That was a that was an impressive win. They blew them out. Very impressive win in Oklahoma, their opponents have not exactly matched up. I just it's hard for me to pick against Alabama at home. So I'm not gonna do it. I'm gonna say I'm gonna take Alabama. Kylen: Hehehehe. Ty: I'm gonna take Alabama. I think Alabama wins. I think Keelon Russell has his Heisman moment and gives Jeremiah Smith just a little bit of push. So give me Alabama to win at home. what's the spread on this? 28 35. The Great Debater: It's a funny enough, is it opened as a three and Georgia opened as a three and a half point favorite and Alabama is now a one and a half point favorite. so that Ty: Probably went by le a late touchdown, I think. The Great Debater: Okay. Colin, what you thinking? Kylen: I was like, Simmons took the words out of my mouth. I was like, I don't see how one team is just more tested than the other. I mean, if you go look at their schedules, I mean, nobody's really played anybody spectacular. even with that Mississippi State team, from the very beginning, everybody has always said that they were probably going to be a bottom-tier SEC team, but they did. They just didn't expect Comario Taylor to jump out and have a Heisman level year or an elite level year at that. And when you just have somebody playing at that level, it's just gonna bring the whole team up. But when it comes to picking between these two teams, I think it's gonna come to who's just more disciplined at the end of the day, who's gonna make the least amount of mistakes. of course time of position. I think that Georgia out of both of these teams has just been shown that they are just a military force at this point. I need to go ahead and get him a little slot in the Pentagon, go ahead and make it a what's it? What's six sides simmons? Ty: More again. Kylen: What's what's a six sided sh six sides. Can't think of it right now. Ty: a hexagon. Kylen: Yeah, let's go ahead and make it a hexagon and put Georgia right next to the army and the air force. And then let's go ahead. I got them giving Belmont their tests and then taking a roll win now and then having those two guys rematch later on the SEC championship. I think it's gonna be lower score game. Well not low score. 'Cause I think it's I think like Jones said it's gonna be that race too, that thirty. I think Georgia will get that thirty one, thirty two point range and Bamma have like twenty seven. The Great Debater: Yeah, I I mean, once again, I had to make that argument for debate's sake. I do think that Alabama is hitting its stride at the perfect time. I think that's trying to finally get over these slow starts that they had to start the year that were just annoying. but I do think Georgia brings something different out of each team. And like I said, sometimes the boring answer is still the right answer. I do think Kirby had a Alabama problem and then kind of figured it out in the SEC championship last year. Give me Georgia in this one. gimme Georgia thirty one to twenty seven and I'm doing my reverse psychology. So either way I win. If I, you know, if I lose, I win. If I if I win, I lose, if that makes any sense. So yeah. going in going in Ty: Mm-hmm. Booker T: If you if you're in Tusaloosa this weekend, go ahead and holl Skinner's Transportation Kylen: Yeah. Booker T: for all your transportation needs for the game. Don't need to pay all that extreme prices for parking. Just call for transportation. We'll pick you up from your hotel. Take it back. Shout to Skinner's. The Great Debater: Book what we playing in the car, man. Booker T: Shout out to Skinner's Transportation. We're playing nine nine nine one three point two the Eagle. Kylen: Ha ha ha. The Great Debater: Okay. That's too many numbers. Kylen: Can we listen to the Mac album Booker T: What was it called? Kylen: book, if I request it? By Willy by Willie Hutch? Booker T: Yes. Our score is wrong. The R score is yours. The Great Debater: Okay. All right. My next game on the schedule. Red River is this weekend, man. And people aren't really talking about it as much as they should. Red River is this weekend. Texas, Oklahoma. His I mean, obviously a historically good Kylen: Think 'cause they John Matir's playing. The Great Debater: matchup. Texas is the number one team in the country. Oklahoma has looked this this week, but it's always a fun game in Dallas, Texas. I would I would bend to say that like you can throw records out when it comes to this game. This kind of feels like the iron ball. You know, if Oklahoma is is historically good, that means Texas will win it. If Texas is historically good, then that means Oklahoma's gonna win it. so Texas won the last two of them and they've won both of them by double digits. Texas beating a top ten Oklahoma last year. who you got in this game? Book, I'll start with you. Booker T: man, I think because of the rivalry, because at a certain point this is still college football at the end of the day. all roles are leading to Texas, blowing them boys out. I think at a certain point Oklahoma's gonna have a lot of pride about themselves, so I think that the first half we're kinda gonna see w kind of what we saw against Texas and Tennessee, unless Sarkeese made some adjustments. But then after that I do think Texas is going to run away with this at the half. I think Texas defense is going to just suffocate John Mathir. You already said how I feel about him. No need to be the dead horse. but get your gloves ready, Matthir. Ty: Yeah. I mean you said it, Jones. This is a game where you kind of gotta throw the records out of the window and, you know, expect the unexpected. anything can happen. I will say this is these are gonna be two fantastic defenses playing today and two quarterbacks that are prone to making mistakes. So I think whichever defense is able to capitalize on those mistakes, is probably gonna get it done. And I don't think John Material can capitalize on anything. So give me Texas to pull off a close one. Probably something like seventeen eleven or something crazy like that, man. I think it's something ugly. Booker T: Goodness, this is that's The Great Debater: my gosh. Booker T: crazy. The Great Debater: Ew. This is disgusting. Colin, what you think is gonna happen? Ty: It's gonna be a rock fight, man. Kylen: man, I think y'all are I think y'all are underestimating John, man. I think every week he surprises me on just how musty you can be in the game. You know, this is come he come up with something new every week, man. I I I I kind of hate what it had I don't want to know what he got first on Saturday, man. Ty: Ex Kylen: He might tell he might tell the defensive lineman to go long and just throw it to him in end zone. Man. As a matter of fact, I know exactly what he's gonna do. he went and he watched that Colorado and that Texas Tech film. He said, hey, when we get bagged up to the one, let's call a let's call a rollout pass. And when the linebacker gets in the end zone, I'm gonna throw it right to him for a zero-yard touchdown interception. I think John got something new for us that we just don't want to see. Definitely got Texas. If if he playing in that game, and it and from what I heard Coach said, that's the guy, sound like they tanking. Sounds, yeah, I got Texas. To whatever they want. The Great Debater: be real with you i d I also have texas in this game but i still have real concerns about texas' offense as of as of late didn't look the Kylen: John gonna make sure they score. The Great Debater: that's the defense that's what i'm saying like but ha i mean i guess i have real concerns Kylen: John's gonna help the offense too. He's gonna say where y'all wanna have the ball at. I'm gonna make sure y'all get it. The Great Debater: my cons I have i have real concerns i'm gonna be honest with you so i just Last year was what, twenty-three to six? It'll probably be somewhere around the same same thing. Give me Texas twenty four to like nine. Honestly. I think it's gonna be just as gross. Booker T: And make sure off all my fans out there make sure don't eat anything before the game. The Great Debater: You gotta use some interfere, bruh. Booker T: no no no no no what you gonna witness on the field, they're gonna serve y'all up some some some hoagies, some shrimp hoboys, Ty: That's Booker T: some The Great Debater: Some good meatball subs. Booker T: meat some meatball meat meatball marineras. Yeah, Kylen: definitely gonna be some John, I might throw you a tuna sub, man. Booker T: yeah. They they they don't have a wide Ty: Well Booker T: variety on that field, man, throwing out there. So make sure don't don't eat before the game. Kylen: you gonna slowly see Subway spill itself out by the first quarter. Booker T: Yeah. The Great Debater: That's so gross. Booker T: Yeah man. Jersey mice can't compete with that. The Great Debater: All right. next, I'm gonna let's go here, Ty. USC at Penn State. Penn State got demolished by Northwestern last week. They are now three and two, but at the same time, we are now looking at USC like, huh? no matter how Ty: Mm-hmm. The Great Debater: much USC's defense wanted them to get back into the game, Washington just could not do it. real concerns for USC in this one, actually. Does Penn State bounce back? With a win at Happy Valley over the Trojans or does USC continue on and does Lincoln Riley's seat get cooler? Tyler, I'm actually start you on this one. Ty: Okay. I'll be honest, man. I I liked how USC fought back and got the win over Washington. That was a ugly game. and if it was for Penn State looking absolutely terrible on Friday against Northwestern, I would probably pick them to win this game on the road. But I don't think that is a very good football team right now. I don't think USC's a great football team, but I think they're a a a good football team. I think they're a better football team than Penn State. Whiteout, not worried about it, man. If you think Alabama, if you think USC is concerned about a whiteout, tell them about the time they flew down to Alabama in 1970, play Bear Bryant and them boys. Tell them about The Great Debater: Brother Ty: Sam Bam Cut Sam Bam Cunningham. All right. The Great Debater: Okay, hold on. You said nineteen seventy, I don't think we could play college football back then, bruh. Booker T: That was the game that ended racist on That was the game That was the game Bear Bryant said I told y'all we need them Ty: And y y y yeah. Exactly. Yeah, we we couldn't we Yeah, yeah. Tell by yeah. Kylen: That was the game that we did. That was the game that we did. I need some of them. Booker T: Bear Bryant said I told y'all we needed them Ty: Yeah. So The Great Debater: my god. Kylen: He said he said if we just had two or three. Ty: So, in other words, man. Booker T: He said, ya he said y'all don't want it. We gonna so I'm gonna show y'all. I'm gonna show ya. Ty: I don't think USC is concerned about a whiteout, is I say all that to say. So yeah, I think I think USC continues to to play well. It continues to get off the skid. it's gonna I'm gonna need Jaden Mallow to step it up, man. He's been missing a lot of throws. I think he's a little banged up. I think there's something they're not telling us, but they they should have enough to beat Penn State. Give me US C thirty to twenty seven. The Great Debater: Okay. Book, what you got? Booker T: Honestly, with that being said, with J. My Alba being banged up, with Penn State not being able to control the ground. Shout out to Northwestern, man. Shout out to Chip Kelly, bro. Bro broke out the wing T on them fools, man. So with that being said, just I think I'm about to say USC got some solid running backs. They got a solid run game. They was averaging four yards a carry the last game. Give me USC, man. I think this might be the slump buster right here, man. And the fact that it's gonna be in a controlled environment Kylen: Whoa. Booker T: might bring them some hope, man. So I'm about to say, give me USC give me 2114. The Great Debater: Okay, ga. Kylen: What would you describe that? Booker T: the slump busting, you know what I'm saying? sometimes you need to break the slump, man. Ty: Mm-hmm. Booker T: So you can know you gotta you know. Right now that that's Arkansas. Arkansas the slump buster team right now in the SEC. Kylen: yeah, it's for sure. I just don't believe in Penn State. I think that they have I think that they tang it for the draft next year. And I don't think anybody told them that they don't get a draft. I think The Great Debater: Ha ha ha ha. Kylen: Think it's looking kind of bad out there. I don't really believe too much pen tape. As long as 14 don't throw no more meatball subs out there. I I turned to the channel real quick. I saw him throw a fadeaway six foot-long meatball marinara, extra cheese, not toasted, straight to the DB. I was like, hey man, that that that was just terrible. But I got I got USC over there. I don't think USC's a bad team. I just think it's that time of year where it starts getting a little cold in LA and USC's like, Yeah. I think we just gone I think we won enough games for the year. And but I think that they'll get them another win. I don't know what the score is gonna be don't ask, man. I just depend on how many subs gonna be out there for the day. The Great Debater: Okay. Yeah, I think USC's gonna get the dub in this one as well. I think USC probably bouncing back. Th the schedule's about to get much harder. I d I do think that USC gets the win over Penn State. Unfortunately they fall to three and three, but I don't I don't think it's gonna be particularly close. I'm going USC thirty four to seventeen in this one. Last game of the week. Two five Kylen: A shout out to Brayden Turner, man. Two five one from Northwestern. The Great Debater: one, man. Last game of the week, man. what wasn't a game that I had marked off as something to circle, but now I do. UCLA in Oregon. UCLA as back in the top twenty five. and trying to show that they are legitimate Big Ten contenders. Oregon, of course, coming off that big win against USC. is Dante Moore playing in this game? Kylen: they haven't updated on if he is cleared or not. They said that he's doing good, but I think we just I think we should just roll with eight for now and give Dante a little more time. The Great Debater: Okay. Well let's start with let's start with you, who wins? Oregon or UCLA? Kylen: Working of course. The Great Debater: Okay. Kylen: Gosh, we're gonna win like eight three to two. The Great Debater: Ew no you're not Kylen: I mean you wanna get your realistic score, it's gonna be like what, fifty three to twelve? The Great Debater: Okay, all right. You say so. Tal, what what you thinking? Ty: I like I like what I like what Bob Chesney's doing. in Westwood over there. he's got a good team. amazing turnaround they've got. but it's still UCLA, right? I think that the talent disparity is gonna be too much for Oregon. I I do like that running back they got Wayne Knight. He's got a nose for the end zone. The Great Debater: Mm-hmm. Ty: I think I think Oregon keeps it close. Into the third quarter, but then the talent for the Ducks just starts to show itself and it doesn't matter who the quarterback is, Dante Moore or Dylan Raoula. I think either one, they just got too many weapons. So they probably pull away and they probably end up covering the spread. It's probably gonna be something like forty two, twenty eight, The Great Debater: Yeah. Ty: in favor of Oregon. The Great Debater: Okay. Book, what you thinking? Booker T: Yeah, I I agree, man. I ain't gonna count, man. I real deal fool with UCLA. Now I might be a little biased because I have him in my dynasty, man, but them boys get some real deal ballers, man. Bob Chesney, man, I fool with his get down. I like to cut his jib. Wayne Knight is a problem. Try to aim my former gator, bro. I think that we might have a mini shootout on our hands, because at a certain point, seems like Oregon has a click in UCLA. getting people fired. so I think we're looking at like a thirty five, twenty eight, give it I give it to Oregon. But man, I fuck with UC LA man. I like what they're doing. The Great Debater: Yeah. This is a Oregon win for sure. Kylen: I think we run LA this year. Y'all gonna respect I get out. The Great Debater: We'll see. Ty: Mm. The Great Debater: This is a Oregon dub for Kylen: this. The Great Debater: for Shurski, I think. I I honestly don't think it's gonna be close. Bob Chesney is doing really, really good stuff, but they're not there yet. Give me Oregon forty nine to like twenty one in this one, honestly, I think it's Ty: I will say I do just love the identity of that team though. Like they they run the ball, they're physical, just hard nosed. Man, I wish we could get some of that down the street. Booker T: They run the ball. Like they like they like four they're they're like four deep at running back. The Great Debater: Yeah. They run the ball. Booker T: Like Wayne Knight is a problem, Woods a problem. Ty: Lake and Riley, take notes. Booker T: Like they they they have some problems, man. Ty: Yeah. The Great Debater: Yeah. Well, fellas, this was a great episode, man. This was this is awesome. I enjoyed this very much. I can't wait to see we're gonna get fed this week of college football. I'm not gonna lie. this is awesome. Of course, follow the brand, Redshirt Seniors Podcast on Instagram, Redshirt Seniors Pod on TikTok. Check out our website, red shirt seniors dot com. But Booker T: Like our post, man. Reposted if you see us, man. For real, man. Like I'm about to say. Smash that like button. Comment. I was say and The Great Debater: Yeah, man. Yeah. Like, yeah, smash that like button, man. Share it with your friends. Put it on your story, bruh. Kylen: Yeah. Ty: Smash that like button. Kylen: Don't don't worry don't worry y'all. Booker T: mess I'm about to say mess with us, man. If you feel like some of us is a fool, type it in the comment. Be boy, you a fool. Yeah. The Great Debater: Literally, yes. We'll talk about your comments on the air, man. But send send these reels that we we give y'all gold in these reels, man. Send these reels to your girl. Send them to your boss. Send them to that person you met at the coffee shop. Send it to your situationship. I don't care. Send it to whoever, bruh. Like send these reels to Booker T: Send it to your fellow college football fan that also likes watching football with you. How about that? The Great Debater: Well, I mean, yeah, but what I'm saying is like make them college football Kylen: Books books are not just a hole. The Great Debater: fans by listening to us. So but yeah, Booker T: Yeah, yeah, yeah. The Great Debater: check us out. Also check out, like I said, the website and everything. But this has been a phenomenal episode. We will see y'all, of course, next week. Same time, same place. Kylen: Don't worry, hot seats coming back soon. Soon as more of y'all get fired. The Great Debater: yeah, them hot seats coming back for sure. but yeah. Well yeah.