Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Stop Lying (2020 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00So, Burdo, do you ever lie? Never? Come on, you
- 0:03gotta lie sometime. I have been told that I have lied sometimes. What
- 0:09do you mean, Like, what are some of the lies you're willing to
- 0:11tell us that you've committed? All right? So, I mean, obviously
- 0:13as a kid, I did tell lies. In fact, I told there
- 0:16are three memorable lies that I told that sort of define my childhood and my
- 0:21upbringing and made me loathe to tell lies later on in life. What about
- 0:26a lie recently? Tell us about lies that you've done in the past.
- 0:30I was supposed to have a document done for work, and I knew I
- 0:36was going to be able to get it done that evening, but I hadn't
- 0:40technically finished it, and so I lied and I said, yeah, yeah,
- 0:45it's done, I'll send it in the morning. But really I knew.
- 0:48I was like, man, most of the work is ahead of me.
- 0:50But I did like the mental calculus, and so I did, in
- 0:54fact send it in the morning and it was fine. But it was a
- 0:57lie. Yeah, so you know that counts. Okay, So it's drill
- 1:00down on that one. Why did you lie? Well, because let's see,
- 1:04I didn't want I didn't want it to sound like I wasn't making it
- 1:08an important a priority or that it wasn't important to me. Why why did
- 1:14you not want it that? Because I didn't want them to feel like I
- 1:18was like I wasn't taking it seriously or I wasn't you know, like I
- 1:23had other priorities that were more important than this thing. And I know this
- 1:26sounds repetitive, but why didn't you want that? Because that would make make
- 1:30it make me look bad in their eyes as a worker, as a coworker.
- 1:34And why he didn't want that because then they wouldn't trust me as much
- 1:38next time. And ironically, I know this is, you know, stupid
- 1:44for me to keep asking, but I am genuinely curious. Why wouldn't you
- 1:48want them to not trust you? Well? Because then, well, first
- 1:52of all, this could roll. This could be a snowball, right,
- 1:55like at first they don't trust me with a small thing, but then over
- 1:59time, like, yeah, let's not work with Embarrado because like, I
- 2:02don't know, he's just it's kind of hard to rely on him. And
- 2:06then pretty soon I might be out of a job. And then if I'm
- 2:08out of a job, I might not have food, and then I might
- 2:12start I might end up on the streets begging I might die, right,
- 2:15death. I lied because I'm afraid of death. Right. I mean you
- 2:20wanted to know why that. I learned it from watching you. Is it
- 2:23accurate? Probably? I mean, if you if you follow the trail of
- 2:29thought, yes, yeah, I think we could have ended with they would
- 2:32think bad thoughts about me. Sure the tribe might kick me out. Yeah.
- 2:38Well, and you have you know, rejection traumas. Oh right,
- 2:42that's true. I mean, which could have led to you lying as a
- 2:45three year as a third grader as well because your mom literally abandoned you.
- 2:49Oh yeah, yeah. So we've talked about this before that it could have
- 2:51been because you know, like we talked about this, my dad didn't beat
- 2:54me, so I wasn't physically afraid of telling him something. Was I so
- 3:00afraid? He did raise his voice and you know what when he raised his
- 3:02voice and he made a scrunchyk scary face, it's like this kind of like
- 3:07you see it with it. That was scary. But I don't know,
- 3:10they're like, my my fear was so much greater than that. And so
- 3:15we've talked about how maybe it was in fact that I subconsciously was afraid that
- 3:19if I did something wrong, I would lose my dad as well. Yeah,
- 3:23when we're rejected or we feel rejected, you know, sometimes just divorce
- 3:28can do that because you're one of your parents becomes less involved in your life.
- 3:32We blame ourselves. We think if I was a better boy, this
- 3:37wouldn't have happened. It's you know, self centered. But that's the way
- 3:39children think. And so to be a bad boy means rejection. It's happened
- 3:46before and it could happen again. So I'm gonna head that off of the
- 3:50pass and I'm gonna lie. I'm going a trick and that will solve my
- 3:57anxiety and it will make me feel more cure. But as you said,
- 4:00it's ironic because lying actually will jeopardize your standing and your acceptance from the other
- 4:09person. Right. Yeah, And to drill down on this a little bit,
- 4:14We've talked about this before and I'm reticent to bring it up again,
- 4:16but you did this exact same lie to me a few years ago when we
- 4:21were going to a Halloween party. You remember that, Yeah, yeah,
- 4:25when I was on the way. But so that one, that one is
- 4:28uh or was? I guess? I don't know. If it's so much
- 4:30recently. But that was a very common lie that I would tell, which
- 4:34was about how close I was to leaving or being at a place right.
- 4:39So that was if it makes you feel any better, It wasn't just you,
- 4:42No, no, I know, it's not me. I knew Burto
- 4:45was like that. I knew that Berto has a complex around disappointing people,
- 4:51such that he will lie to avoid disappointing people and thus disappoint people with his
- 4:58lies. And barn to meet this Halloween party and it was like it was
- 5:01like an hour drive away. It was pretty far up north and it was
- 5:05an amazing Halloween party in the end, but I did not want to arrive
- 5:10at the Halloween party before you because I don't know these people. I don't
- 5:13know anyone at this party. And I was like, no, Rush,
- 5:17I'm not me and my friends. We're at you know, we're having fun
- 5:20at my house, no big deal, But can you let me know when
- 5:25you're when you're there or almost there? And I don't mind. I don't
- 5:29mind getting there at eleven pm, like it's no big deal, because I
- 5:32knew if I put pressure on you, you would interpret it as I was
- 5:36getting increasingly disappointed that you weren't leaving right You're like, oh, yeah,
- 5:42you know. And we went back and forth a few times, and then
- 5:44you texted me, I'm on my way. We're rolling up on the house
- 5:48and we don't know which house it is. We have an address, but
- 5:51and I start to text you and I'm like, I'm like, so you're
- 5:55there, right, because you left an hour and forty five minutes ago and
- 6:00it only takes you forty five minutes ago. And you're like, oh,
- 6:01yeah, yah, yeah, yeah. Well we're parking. We're parking,
- 6:04and I'm like, you're parking, and because because we were parking, and
- 6:09I was like, I don't see you. So we park and we get
- 6:13out and I'm texting you and I'm like, so, where are I don't
- 6:16see you. And you're like, oh, you know, we're there.
- 6:19You know we're there. We're totally we're parking, and I'm like, well
- 6:25where just was so confused, And then after I don't know, half an
- 6:31hour standing on the curb, I just said, oh, he did it.
- 6:38He lied to me. You are exaggerating, by the way, that's
- 6:42a huge exaggeration. I never ever ever say I'm parking if I'm not like
- 6:49mentally like I'm almost about to be parking. I would never say I'm parking
- 6:55and like be like half an hour away, Like I would never do that.
- 6:58So like, for example, I've done this, because I've done this
- 7:00like countless times going to Seattle, which by the way, is the worst,
- 7:03and a lot of times I'm actually seriously parking and it takes me half
- 7:08an hour to part. Yeah, but regardless, you admit it. And
- 7:11the point is is that because I know you, it's not a malicious lie.
- 7:15It is a lie of desperation and has nothing to do with me and
- 7:20has everything to do with your something in your history. You know. Well,
- 7:25so I should have told you up front because what was happening, And
- 7:28you're absolutely right about the psychology, because what was happening is Eric was late,
- 7:31and when they got there, we were still not ready to go,
- 7:33and so like and I'm trying, and I'm trying to play both sides,
- 7:38like because i don't want you not to show up, So I'm like,
- 7:41if I tell it, like, he might not go, and then I
- 7:43don't want him to not go. And so you're absolutely right about that.
- 7:45But I should have just been like, hey, man, we're running late.
- 7:47Eric just got here. It's got it, and I would have been
- 7:49like, no effing problem, man, we're having fun here. I don't
- 7:54have to go to this party, you know. But part of actually what
- 7:57I do professionally is I have to ride a fine line between what might be
- 8:03possible and what people say is possible, because in my line of work,
- 8:09it's like if you just go by what is on paper, like what we
- 8:15can maybe do, like, you're just never gonna accomplish anything big because people
- 8:20tend to be either way too conservative or way too over us like fairhose,
- 8:26Yeah exactly. So part of part of yeah, sure, but like so
- 8:31part of what what you have to do is like you have to basically draw
- 8:33a mythical line in the middle live. You could call it lie, but
- 8:37it's really likes to not tell the truth. I have a bone to pick
- 8:41with society, not you burto, but with society drifting away from the virtue
- 8:46that we all learned when we were five years old in kindergarten that you do
- 8:50not lie. Conspiracy theories are based on this assumption that people are lying and
- 8:54they're not wrong. People are lying. The government is lying, just not
- 9:01about that, but they are lying, and they are liars. And if
- 9:05we're going to have a society one on one, you and me, Burdo,
- 9:09if I'm going to trust you, you know, if I'm going to
- 9:11say, well, he says he's doing this and I trust him, it's
- 9:18got to stop. People try to gravitate towards the truth, and in business
- 9:22because our capitalistic society rewards Enron Darnos all these other people. The liars get
- 9:30the money, the liar gets elected. Then society looks up to these people
- 9:33and says, well, that's just what you do, and if you're going
- 9:37to get ahead, you have to lie. Why because we do not punish
- 9:41people for lying. We only punish very few individuals. People who lie need
- 9:46to have Now I don't know what sort of consequences, but the very least
- 9:50we should like say, oh, that person lies. I can never trust
- 9:54anything they say as a person who considers the truth be very important. And
- 10:00I from the day that I was I I lied. When one of the
- 10:03very first lies I can remember saying was I was four years old and I
- 10:07stole my friend's matchbox car, which was totally stupid because I had the exact
- 10:11same one in fact mine was newherre and it looked better. And I'm sitting
- 10:16in my hallway staring at this matchbox car and I feel so guilty and I
- 10:20don't know what to do. I'm sort of stuck, you know. I'm
- 10:22like, I stole it. I don't know what to do. My mom
- 10:24walks by and she just asks. She just sees me kind of staring at
- 10:28this matchbox car, and she's like, Kurt, what's going on? And
- 10:33I burst out crying. I'm like, I stole this matchbox car. And
- 10:37I'm thinking I'm going to be strung up because you know, lying is bad,
- 10:39it's wrong. And my mom says, we'll just give it back,
- 10:43and I was like, okay. So I gave it back to my friend
- 10:46and my friend was like, oh thanks, and like nothing ever happened.
- 10:48But the point was was I learned that the guilt of lying is not worth
- 10:54the lie. Whatever consequenced the truth has, it's lesser, it's not as
- 11:01painful as the pain one can have from having a gray zone of lies in
- 11:11your life. We have to as a society return to revirtue of truthfulness.
- 11:16And in the past religion, you know, God would punish you if you
- 11:20sinned, right, And so as a society, we're moving away from those
- 11:24kinds of thoughts, which is, you know, fine, but we haven't
- 11:26replaced it with another constitution, if you will, of human behavior. And
- 11:33I feel like lies have become so normalized that it's like, well, you
- 11:39know, it's not that big of a deal, Like they won't find out
- 11:45it's you know, it's for their own good that I'm lying to them,
- 11:48and I just don't think that's a good way to live. There are lies
- 11:52that are consequential, and I think because of my own childhood trauma, like
- 11:58I can't lie about consequential stuff. So like that's why I am such an
- 12:03open book when it comes to like stuff, because I'm like, I'm just
- 12:05going to tell you. But at the same time, like the human brain
- 12:11operates way too fast and randomly for us to constantly be saying everything that's in
- 12:16our brain, right, So like the extreme would be like you're fat,
- 12:20you're ugly. I don't think you're you're good. I think you're Like if
- 12:24we actually operated this way, because we felt that if we don't express everything
- 12:26in our head, it would be a lie, like that would dissolve society.
- 12:30We can't handle the truth, so to speak, well, there is
- 12:33a thing called radical honesty, and if you live in those circles, you
- 12:37learn to deal with the truth because someone says like, no, I don't
- 12:43want to hang out with you because you've been annoying me lately. The truth
- 12:46is relative sometimes right, like meaning how you feel in your head about something
- 12:50isn't actually always finite or constant. Right, we have a device that measures
- 12:56these things in your blood versus where it's trying to develop it. One is
- 13:01a lie, absolutely, and one is the truth, and that's consequential.
- 13:07There are examples where you could make an argument the fact that you don't tell
- 13:11your wife that her butt looks big in those genes well, or even something
- 13:15bigger, like let's say you're being interviewed about how you feel about a senator
- 13:18who just died. Do you say, well, I still think you as
- 13:20a coward. Do you have to say that? Yeah? So there,
- 13:26But most of us can agree on certain things like saying that you have a
- 13:31device that can measure things in blood when you don't have a device that can
- 13:33measure things in blood. That most of us, if not all of us,
- 13:37can agree though that's just a flat out lie. But we have normalized
- 13:41those lies among many others in our society that it distresses me. Again.
- 13:46You see the consequences in our society. There are so many people who don't
- 13:50even believe scientists when they say that the Earth is a sphere. And that's
- 13:54consequential. Though. You know, scientists lied to me before, and they
- 13:58have. Scientists have lied to them before. Cigarettes don't cause cancer. They
- 14:03have lied in the past. It's wrong. It's wrong, and it destroys
- 14:09democracy. If we want to have a democracy, we have to work together,
- 14:13and we have to trust institutions like science, like journalism, like politicians,
- 14:22like your neighbor. We have to be able to trust each other.
- 14:26There has to be an assumption of truth. It's not okay now if you
- 14:31end up lying on accident in the moment, as Berto was kind of alluding
- 14:35to, Fine followed up with the fact, I'm sorry, I just lied.
- 14:39It's a knee jerk reaction. It's a problem of mine. Here's the
- 14:43truth. Da da da da da. You can always say that, and
- 14:48if someone did that to me, my trust points in them would skyrocket.
- 14:50I'd be like, oh my god, that person just admitted they lied to
- 14:54me without me catching them. I now trust them a lot more. It's
- 14:56okay, you know we make mistakes sometimes, so anyway, I'm just ranting.
- 15:01But let's take a break, get back, Let's go into this research
- 15:05that I want to go over with you. Berto, what do you say?
- 15:07Let's do it? All right, we're back from the break. I'm
- 15:15trying to figure out what I would have you do, Berto in this situation
- 15:20to convince people to become a pod What if a radically honest person were to
- 15:26try to get the listeners to become a patient of the podcast? What would
- 15:30that sound like? Listen, we have this thing that we are just now
- 15:35after twelve years, sort of comfortable doing, where one of us is an
- 15:43expert in one field and has sort of crammed themselves into this other field to
- 15:48talk on a microphone, and the other one of us doesn't know almost anything
- 15:52about this field. But we are here to tell you our random thoughts about
- 15:58stuff that sort of has something to do with your mental health. Maybe.
- 16:02But the great news is if you support us via Patreon, all of this
- 16:08is a lie and we're actually the best thing ever and we're true experts in
- 16:11all fields. We're gonna get emails about me yelling at Huberto. You know
- 16:19I love you. Wait you yelled at me? Well, I mean when
- 16:25version of yelling when daddy and daddy fight. Listeners get uncomfortable, but we're
- 16:34cool with each other. People out there, there's there's there's nothing. There's
- 16:38nothing at steak. Well, there's a lot at steak, but there's nothing
- 16:45in jeopardy. There's a vegan steak. So experiments done in a team of
- 16:52researchers in Spain. They did two experiments. Okay, so this first experiment,
- 16:57this is all online. They told participants to flip a coin of virtual
- 17:02coin and then report what happened. If it was heads, they got five
- 17:06dollars and you can only flip the coin once. If it was tails,
- 17:10they got nothing. So you're on your computer and you click this this virtual
- 17:17coin. If you get heads, you get five bucks. If you get
- 17:18tails, you you get nothing, and you can only flip it once.
- 17:22And but you reported what you got. So there's a little field that said
- 17:30which one did you get? Did you get heads or did you get tails?
- 17:33And so if you got it self reporting right. So if you got
- 17:36tails, you could say head heads and you would get five dollars unknownst to
- 17:41the participants, the researchers were keeping track of the actual coin flip that you
- 17:45did. They made it seem like, look, it's an honor system.
- 17:49You know, you tell us what you got. Okay, So for those
- 17:55people, so half the people got heads, and so we're not going to
- 17:59talk about that because you know, they all told the truth. But of
- 18:03those who didn't, of those who got tails, what percentage flipped tails?
- 18:11And we're honest about it. They got tails, and they're like, oh,
- 18:15I got tails, I get zero dollars. What percentage of the people
- 18:19who flip tails, we're honest about it, We're honest sixty percent lower forty
- 18:29Yeah, about thirty seven percent, yea, so surprising. Just so,
- 18:33by the way, about a third of people. So that's an example of
- 18:36a lie. I would never tell, Like I would never cheat at anything
- 18:40like that, Like I don't cheat at games, Like if we're playing Monopoly
- 18:44and I see like an extra five hundred, I'm not grabbing that bill.
- 18:47I don't cheat like at anything. That's like the same reason I don't like
- 18:51spoilers, Like I like thinks, like we have rules we've agreed on,
- 18:53we're gonna play by the freaking rules. Yeah, I can. I can
- 18:56absolutely relate to that, right, But there is a person, you know,
- 19:00and I wouldn't fault like someone who's starving their kid is starving and then
- 19:04they took the bread. Like that's a thing that's existing sadly in our world.
- 19:07But there is, there are sadly a lot of people clearly by this
- 19:11percentages that they don't care, like if it's yeah, so even though no
- 19:17one would know if you're being honest about the five hundred dollars playing monopoly or
- 19:22not, why do you care about telling the truth. That's a good question.
- 19:27I mean, I actually I know one of the reasons for me.
- 19:33When I was little, like I constantly heard from my dad about all these
- 19:37examples about how the world was unfair and about how you know, certain groups
- 19:41were being treated unfairly, and I saw it in the news constantly. I
- 19:47also saw it around my family and stuff, and so I developed this like
- 19:52hyperbolic notion of like the need for fairness like that to me is very important.
- 19:59We need to be And so I think that when you have an agreed
- 20:02upon set of rules and you're like lying, you know you're breaking those rules
- 20:07without agreeing that to me is unfair for the other people and for everyone involved.
- 20:12Yeah, so thirty some percent were honest. About a third of people
- 20:18flipped tails, knew they weren't going to get any money and said, you
- 20:22know what, I got tails, I get nothing. So there are four
- 20:25different categories. Let me tell you all four. So it's people that flip
- 20:27tails and were honest. Then there's the people that flipped tails and just said
- 20:30they got heads. Then there were people who flipped until they got heads.
- 20:36So because you could keep flipping technically, but the instructions were the instructions were
- 20:41clearly like flip it once and tell us what you got. But there were
- 20:45people who flipped it until they got heads and then they said I got heads.
- 20:49And then there were people that didn't even flip it at all and just
- 20:55said they got heads. Wow. Okay, So there's the people that flipped
- 20:59it once, didn't get heads and lied about it, right, There's the
- 21:03people that flipped it multiple times until they were not lying about getting heads even
- 21:07though they lied about only flipping once, right, And then there were the
- 21:10people that didn't even bother flipping. They're just they just lied, right,
- 21:14So what percentage flipped tails and just flat out lied. Flipped tails and flat
- 21:19out lied. Let's go with fifteen percent percent. Okay, so what percentage
- 21:27of people flipped until they got heads and reported they had heads? Twenty five
- 21:33seven percent. So I'm surprised I would have thought that that was the the
- 21:37rationalization that won the day. Yeah, for the liars, right, like,
- 21:41well I technically got heads, right, yeah, exactly, because that's
- 21:45kind of yeah, they call those the cheating non liars, so they're not
- 21:49lying, but they cheated. The people that flipped tails and lie, they're
- 21:53just called bers. And then we have the radical liars. What percent,
- 21:57it's like fifty percent or something. For god, they didn't even bother Yeah.
- 22:04Okay, see this is the other thing. I would never feel good
- 22:07about winning at anything where I had cheated. Yeah, unless it's like a
- 22:12completely like if we're literally just goofing around, like let's say we're you know
- 22:18what I'm saying, Like, if it's totally like we are cheating on purpose
- 22:21kind of thing, like because to me, it's like when I'm playing a
- 22:23video game, if I turn on the cheats, I only do it for
- 22:27fun and it quickly gets old. So I never like that yeah, so,
- 22:32but we all know people that love the cheats and will even go online
- 22:37and do PvP and cheat and cheat, you know, And there's a whole
- 22:41it's a it's a rampant problem. There's servers that have to spend a lot
- 22:45of time booting people who are using exploits, right, Okay, And so
- 22:52I'm I know I'm not gonna win the day with you on this, but
- 22:55there is a there is a fundamental difference where I believe this and I'm not
- 23:00trying to justify myself because I still agree with you ultimately, It's just what
- 23:06is the purpose of the lie? If the purpose of the lie it misguided?
- 23:11So is to try to help someone other than yourself, like we can
- 23:15maybe have a conversation about how to deal with it better. When the purpose
- 23:18of the lie is to just help yourself, Now we have to like understand,
- 23:21well, is this person in dire straits or is this person literally just
- 23:26cheat trying to cheat life? Well, give me an example. Well,
- 23:29so for example, like the lie where you're like, so, what did
- 23:32you think of my play? Oh? It was good? Yeah, I
- 23:34lied to you, But I'm not hurting you. I mean, I'm trying
- 23:38not to hurt you. Now, someone might say that that actually hurts you.
- 23:41So we could have that conversation and say, maybe I can give you
- 23:44a different kind of feedback. I get it, but I'm not malicious.
- 23:47I'm trying to trying to like not bring you down or something. So it
- 23:51depends on some level. So I'll just think for myself, if someone's play
- 23:56sucked and I've been there before and they asked me how things went, and
- 24:00I would not say wow, that's if I thought that they thought it went
- 24:03well or they were hoping it went well. I would say like, wow,
- 24:07you know went Wow, it's cool. Yeah, but I'll tell you
- 24:11this would be that perhaps the cheating non liar part is I would find something
- 24:17that was true and I would say that I would say, that's actually what
- 24:21I usually do too when these situations arise is I'm like, I just couldn't
- 24:25believe how much effort was spent on the lighting. Really amazing light. Yeah,
- 24:30your costume was amazing, amazing, that's just my clothing. Oh well,
- 24:36geez, it's amazing. You have a great sense of stuff. Yeah.
- 24:38No, I would find something like like, wow, you know it
- 24:44was the it was very believable or I don't know, I would find something
- 24:48that I could say that was true. You know, you could say that
- 24:52that's not being honest honest, but I guess my point with it was,
- 24:57Look, there are times where you you might fudge the truth or maybe even
- 25:02flat out lie, but your intention wasn't for you to get away with something
- 25:06and like cheat, Like, well, but you kind of are so,
- 25:08so say Berto, you're well, let's make it real personal. You have
- 25:15a performance with your band, and I would go to your shows a lot
- 25:19of the times and you come out off the stage and you come up to
- 25:23me and you're like, You're like, how do you think it went?
- 25:26And I'm like, there are all sorts of problems that I could observe.
- 25:32The sound was off, couldn't hear your voice. It seemed like you're you
- 25:37didn't warm up your voice enough. You seem nervous. There were some parts
- 25:42where you and Eric weren't really in sync. You know, I don't know,
- 25:48I'm just sort of, you know, making stuff up. But would
- 25:52you want me to say that or yeah, I mean and I know that
- 25:56you'd couch it a little bit, but that would be super useful. That's
- 26:00my personality. So so if I said something like, oh my god,
- 26:03it was it was amazing, You guys are great. Would which one would
- 26:07you rather? I say, well the first one? Right? So what
- 26:11are we trying to avoid? Are we trying to avoid someone else's feelings being
- 26:15hurt? Or am I trying to avoid my own anxiety about someone else disapproving
- 26:22me for what I really believe and think? Absolutely? But you know this
- 26:26isn't This is the thing. I know you're not trying to make it black
- 26:29and white because I can envision a billion hypothetical questions, and I think a
- 26:33lot of times we make excuses for white lies. That's not for the other
- 26:37person, but for our set. We're lying for our sake, not for
- 26:41their sake. But you could imagine, like, you know, a relative
- 26:45passes away and then like, tell us a memory you had. So I
- 26:49have no good memories with this relative. They were really not an important person
- 26:53in my life. So I've been here before, so I had So this
- 26:57is actually you know, this is just one of your examples. But I
- 27:00actually hate it at funerals when everyone talks one hundred percent positive about the person
- 27:07who died. I mean, everyone is free to grieve in the way that
- 27:11they went to. But for me, I'm like, so the funerals that
- 27:12I go to, the memorials I go to where people will give some of
- 27:17those nuanced stories, maybe even a negative one, and then they will say
- 27:21something nice. I trust those people so much greater than the person who just
- 27:26gets up there and says all nice things. Now, maybe a man and
- 27:29you can make that argument, and we can debate that, and we could
- 27:32see which one is actually ultimately better for which I love it. But you
- 27:36have to you have to come with me on the realization that the person that
- 27:42flat out constantly cheats at their taxes goes and steals whatever they can, like,
- 27:52you know, like the actual, truly like malicious liar. Like there's
- 27:56gotta be a difference. Yeah, well yeah, right, well there's a
- 28:00difference. But they're the cult called a culture of lying, that we've created.
- 28:06I'm not saying we're supposed to be radically honest. When we do lie,
- 28:11we have to have a critical analysis of what is happening in that moment,
- 28:17and you have to acknowledge right now I am lying, and there is
- 28:22a potential consequence to that. It is an untruth. It is a flat
- 28:26out lie, I am deceiving this other person? Is it worth it?
- 28:30Am I doing it for the right reasons? Instead and instead of well everyone
- 28:37lies, you know, white lies. It just happens, you know,
- 28:40as if it's just commonplace to just flat out lie to someone's face. I'm
- 28:45not saying you don't do it sometimes for legitimate reasons, but we frame it
- 28:52as it's part of life. And when you talk to a five year old,
- 28:56they're like, but it's a lie. So when I have something in
- 29:00my head about someone, like some value judgment, that may or may not
- 29:03be a lie, like or me saying it may or because there are so
- 29:07many gray areas with what we think about our own cognition and what we think
- 29:11is true or not. As an example, it's like, you have always
- 29:15told me that you would never like drink at a party, and here you
- 29:18are drinking at a party. Were you lying to me all those years?
- 29:22Probably not, maybe not, but now they're drinking, Like why? Like
- 29:25in the psychology is crazy, right, But there is definitely a difference when
- 29:30you are maliciously constantly lying, right, So like it's a matter of degrees,
- 29:33it's not a slippery slope. I think it is a slippery slope.
- 29:37I mean, I have no data, but I as I don't know if
- 29:40this is just me getting old. That's my argument is that it is a
- 29:44slippery slope, and that we have as a society slipped so far normalizing little
- 29:51lies and bigger lies, excusing lies so much so that we have now just
- 29:57accepted that from you. You just can't trust people now. I don't know
- 30:02if the past you think. Are you trying to make the world great again?
- 30:06No? But and again, like I said, it could just be
- 30:08just because I'm old now and I wasn't aware of things when I was.
- 30:12It's not like politicians still the truth necessarily. Yeah, I don't think humans
- 30:17have ever operated from one hundred percent honesty. But and who knows. There's
- 30:22no way to measure this, But I would suspect that in the seventies,
- 30:26the common person in Seattle, because that's all I know about on the daily
- 30:34count of deceptions that they have committed, were less. Jimmy Carter when the
- 30:42country was experiencing troubles. If you don't know, he was a president of
- 30:47the United States and such. The United States was going through an economic crisis
- 30:51and experts were saying that they didn't know if we were going to get out
- 30:56of it, and they didn't know how long it was going to take,
- 30:59and if if we were going to get out of it, sacrifices are going
- 31:02to have to be made. People were going to have to lose jobs,
- 31:04you know, like to get out of the deficit, to get the economy
- 31:08back in line. We are going to have to cut programs. Bad things
- 31:12are going to have to happen. Jimmy Carter because he was so religious and
- 31:18this sort of guy, and is still that guy. He's still alive,
- 31:21right, I think so? Yeah. He gave a speech the American public
- 31:25and said, here's the deal. We are in a crisis right now,
- 31:27and if we're going to get out of it, here's what we have to
- 31:30do. And there's no easy way to say that. There's going to be
- 31:34problems. People hated him for that. They thought he was a joke that
- 31:40he would And then who did we elect after that? An actor Ronald Reagan,
- 31:45who frequently lied to us about the state of things, so much so
- 31:49that Iran Contra affair, and most people conclude he was absolutely a part of
- 31:56that lie and knew absolutely what was going on. And Olie North absolutely took
- 32:00the bullet for that. Was that progress? Was that a good thing?
- 32:06I argue no. And so as a society, we would rather have Ronald
- 32:10Reagan than Jimmy Carter. We would rather be lied to than being told the
- 32:15hard truth. And where are we today? Now? There's been another experiment
- 32:24that just popped into my head. Mark Rob Mark Rober you know anyway,
- 32:28I don't know, he's big. Oh, I know the one about stealing
- 32:31boxes though, I remember seeing that video. Yeah, that guy. So
- 32:36he did an experiment where he planted across the United States a bunch of wallets,
- 32:44just left them in public places, and in the wallet was an instruction
- 32:49of like, if you find this wallet, please mail it back to me,
- 32:52you know, at this address. And so not only did they mail
- 32:57it back, but people had to get an envelope and pay for shipping themselves.
- 33:01And I can't remember the exact stat but like the majority were sent back
- 33:06to them, even though it was just a wallet sitting there, And maybe
- 33:10that was more personalized, personified, because there's a human being on the other
- 33:15side of that wallet, you know. So what does this all mean?
- 33:19You know, this coin flip thing, it's easy, and what it's being
- 33:22reported in the news is that you know, people are liars, But it's
- 33:27context dependent, of course, to this experiment. Yeah, for this particular
- 33:31action, apparently most people are totally okay lying, but in other contexts they're
- 33:40almost it's a pain in the butt to be truthful and to do it's a
- 33:45pain in the butt to do the right thing, and yet most people will
- 33:49actually do the right thing. So we want to be careful about how we
- 33:53read these research projects and what point they're probably trying to get across. Because
- 34:00to the researchers, what they would love is that people get up at arms,
- 34:05and they did. There's a New York Times article about this. As
- 34:08a researcher, you become in research circles, you become famous, you get
- 34:13better, you know, professor jobs, you get accepted into journals. More
- 34:17like it's a real thing to get into the news. So the scandal helps
- 34:22them. Yeah, the scandalized point, which is that humans are liars,
- 34:27and so we just have to read these things with some but clearly some people
- 34:31lie. Other reasons are psychopathy, they have any social personage sort it,
- 34:36They don't care about other people's feelings, and they lie Another reason is pathological
- 34:40lying out of either psychopathy or because they learned if they didn't lie knee jerk
- 34:45reaction, they something really bad is going to happen to it. I mean,
- 34:50you abuse someone or you abandon them when they're growing up, and they
- 34:54learn early in life that they need to lie to get out of it.
- 34:57You will find people will have pathological whole lying behaviors. And you can listen
- 35:00to other podcasts where we talk about that. Another reason is we've been talking
- 35:06about this in the past, is to lie about the coin flip is poverty.
- 35:10There were times in my life where five dollars would have got gone a
- 35:15long way for me. I mean, I mean no joke. When I
- 35:19was in my early twenties, pretty much until it was probably like twenty six
- 35:23or seven, five dollars was no joke. I mean there there was a
- 35:28point in my life where I literally had five dollars in my wallet and I
- 35:32didn't have a job, and I had like a gallon of gas in my
- 35:38in my car, and I didn't know what to do, you know,
- 35:44I was I was, and I just started driving around Ballard looking in despair
- 35:50for just to find a job. And I drove by Godfather's Pizza and they
- 35:54said hiring drivers. And even though I had a bachelor degree from the from
- 36:01the Foster School of Business at the University of Washington, you know, one
- 36:06of the most prestigious universities in the world and business and business universities at that
- 36:14I am driving into a Godfather's Pizza and applying for a driver's job, which
- 36:19was really applying to be a dishwasher in the You know, they lie and
- 36:23they say hiring drivers, but what they're really doing is they're hiring dishwashers and
- 36:30people to make the pizzas. And maybe every once in a while you can
- 36:32drive. And so five dollars what there were times when life would have gone
- 36:38a long way. And if if I was given this test, I'd be
- 36:42like, I better get heads because I need that. I need that five
- 36:46dolls doubling my wealth. Yeah, like that'll last me. I don't have
- 36:52to find a job another day. Anyway, that literally happened to be.
- 36:55So I graduated, you know, and with the business degree, and had
- 37:00a really hard time getting a job. I was stupid. No one mentored
- 37:04me, like, no one told me, like, here's how you get
- 37:05a job. You get an internship. I just thought, like, you
- 37:08get a degree and you get a job. Job. Also destructive entitlement.
- 37:12We talk without going in. You can listen to my full deep dive on
- 37:15nauge and contextual family therapy. But there's this notion that when you get ripped
- 37:20off in life, you're abandoned, you're abused, you are fired from a
- 37:27job that you didn't deserve to be fired from. You develop what we call
- 37:30destructive entitlement, meaning you feel entitled because you didn't get what you deserved in
- 37:36the past, but it means that you will take from in the future.
- 37:40Your ledger is off balance and you feel like you're owed things. And so
- 37:47some of you out there might know people in your family that are like this.
- 37:51They seem to never give as much as they get, and they seem
- 37:55to be very expected that they're going to get things. And I imagine I'd
- 38:00speculate that would lead to more lying on this thing. Okay, the next
- 38:05experiment and then we'll end with this, is they instead of a coin flip,
- 38:09it was a die, you know, a six sided die, and
- 38:14it was virtual and you would roll it. If you rolled a one,
- 38:16you got one dollar. And although we up to five, you would get
- 38:19five dollars, but if you roll a six, you got nothing. Okay,
- 38:23so this is different. It's not binary, it's not you know,
- 38:27one or zero. It's like there's a gradient, so there's a little more
- 38:30like for you to claim. Like for example, if it was hey,
- 38:35if you get a five hundred thousand out of a million, you win five
- 38:39bucks, Like you really got five hundred thousand. Really, So what do
- 38:45you think happened? I'm I'm betting that there was a small change in the
- 38:51percentages. Maybe it was not that small, but there was a change in
- 38:53the percentages because more people feared being called out being in a lie because the
- 39:00odds are not quite as easy. So you think, like meaning mean like,
- 39:05it's probably a little less likely they actually are telling the truth. Interesting,
- 39:07so I would say that like, if if it was thirty eight percent,
- 39:13we're the only ones that told the truth, Maybe that went up to
- 39:15like forty five percent or something. Nope, the percentages were pretty much the
- 39:22same. The only the only difference was for those that lied. Many people
- 39:28lied, not that they got a five, but they got a three.
- 39:31So if they rolled up six or a one, they would say, I
- 39:37got a three, so they would lie, but not all the way to
- 39:40five. They would average out the lie. So why would they do that?
- 39:45I mean, if you're gonna lie, why not just go for five?
- 39:47Wait did they get sorry, did they get any money? Partially?
- 39:51Yeah? So so if if you roll a one you get one dollar,
- 39:53up to five you get five dollars. Yeah, it's the whole. Like
- 39:57my it's the line from Tombstone. Doc Hollywood says, Doc Hollywood, Yeah,
- 40:04Holliday. What's his name? Holiday Holiday, not Hollywood Hollywood. Doc
- 40:07Holliday says, My hypocrisy goes only so far because like, you know,
- 40:14okay, I'm lying, but I'm not going to lie that much. It's
- 40:19you know, I got a three, right, Apparently, if we're going
- 40:24to lie, somehow, it feels like less of a lie if we don't
- 40:31lie as much, right, It's like there's a guilt there. It's like,
- 40:36well, I want to lie because I feel like I deserve it,
- 40:38but I feel like I shouldn't go full lie. You know. It's like
- 40:44did you finish all your beans? Yeah? Now there were three beans left,
- 40:50but I eat most of them, you know, where instead of like
- 40:52did you finish your beans? And you haven't touched them, yeah, exactly,
- 40:55or or or I guess an analogy would be, did you finish your
- 41:00beans and then you haven't touched the beans, but you quickly scoop some beans
- 41:05into your mouth and yeah, like yeah, I finished st Okay, so
- 41:08that's an interesting one. In high school and not high school. In junior
- 41:12high we had to do an assignment that was you have to keep a journal
- 41:15for six months. So it was six months worth of journaling. So this
- 41:21amounted to I don't know how many pages, but like it was not a
- 41:24little bit like you have to do it, Okay, I didn't do it.
- 41:28I didn't do it because I was terrible at homework and I didn't know
- 41:31that oh yeah, yeah. I could never do homework well, like I
- 41:35was so good at classes, like I could, I could pass the tests.
- 41:38No pro homework, I think it was. I don't. I wouldn't
- 41:43call it officially add but I I couldn't sit down and concentrate like I would
- 41:50just you know, could Yeah you could? I mean with your with your
- 41:53computer, with your yeah no, No, with stuff I cared about,
- 41:55for sure, the school stuff I didn't care about, like math absolutely,
- 42:00computers absolutely geography. What I gotta sit down and memorize these so you'dn't want
- 42:06to do it, probably, but I try. I mean I did try.
- 42:09Like my dad's like, go upstairs, you gotta do a thing before
- 42:12you can't watch TV. And I would sit there at my desk, and
- 42:15I have these painful memories of just sitting there and just like staring at the
- 42:20book and like I don't want to do this. I don't want to do
- 42:23this. I don't want to do this, and then I should probably go
- 42:27get a glass of water first, you know, like that would happen a
- 42:30lot. But anyway, so let alone keeping a journal for like, forget
- 42:34about it. But I wasn't the only one. A couple of my friends
- 42:37didn't do it either. Here's the difference. The night before, the two
- 42:43of them crammed to put together some half ass pretend journal. Yeah. I
- 42:49don't even know what they did. I think I've done that specifically. I
- 42:52remember having an assignment maybe even in graduate school, or you have to do
- 42:57I couldn't do it. I couldn't not get myself. My hypocrisy goes only
- 43:02so far. So I didn't turn in anything, and I got the failing
- 43:06rate my hypocrisy goes only well, it's not hypocritical. You just you just
- 43:10didn't want to do it, so you didn't, right. But I but
- 43:13like, I bet you if I had started a week earlier and I had
- 43:15crammed, I might have lied and said, yeah, I kept the journal.
- 43:20Oh so so if you say, in one night did and then but
- 43:28still I'd rather live with you than your friends. Honestly, yes, Well,
- 43:36because when he told me, I was like, what now, I'm
- 43:38impressed that he was able to cram that much. In of course he got
- 43:42a super bad grade. I'm sure the teacher could tell like, come on,
- 43:45these are not dumb people. Yeah. Well, I don't know how
- 43:51to conclude this other than to say that for me, I value telling the
- 43:55truth. I like to live that way. I find tremendous gratification in having
- 44:02a virtue, literal virtue of telling the truth. Am I have I lied?
- 44:09Yeah? Do I say white lies? Yes? But I try to
- 44:15in my head acknowledge what are you doing right now and why? And I'm
- 44:20not perfect. I make mistakes and you know, and I have do a
- 44:24full inventory of what I can remember. I get the cold sweats just thinking
- 44:29about like, oh, there was that one that was pretty bad. You
- 44:32know, I'm not proud of it. It's not good, and I am
- 44:39hurt by the lies that have been told to me. It hurt, It
- 44:44deeply hurts me, you know, it hurts me emotionally. Like saying that
- 44:50essentially is a message of like, I don't matter. I don't matter enough
- 44:53for me to be truthful with you. I don't matter and I matter as
- 44:58much as the way a politician feels about their constituents. To be lied to
- 45:06is just so hurtful. I guess is the conclusion that I have for this
- 45:08episode is that I don't think I've ever really framed it this way, but
- 45:14lies traumatize. What do you think about that? It rhymes? Yeah,
- 45:21I think there is a sad reality which is like what I was saying,
- 45:28which is that the world is sort of full of lies. I don't know
- 45:30if it's gotten worse. Certainly feels like right now politically things have gone worse,
- 45:34but maybe it was always like this or worse. Who knows. I
- 45:38am one thousand percent with you on the big stuff. I have certainly been
- 45:44guilty of what I consider the non I don't know lethal lies anyways, but
- 45:52I do believe that you're onto something when I do. Let me put it
- 45:57this way, I do think, although I don't agree that everything's a slippery
- 46:01slope, I do think that the more we practice lying, the more comfortable
- 46:07we get with lies, the more we will not have a functioning society.
- 46:12So or relationships, Yeah, I mean, the distance that we feel from
- 46:16each other. I wonder if it has at least in part. One of
- 46:21the factors is that we don't trust each other. And part of the reason
- 46:24why we don't trust each other is because we've all been lied to so frickin'
- 46:28much. So many times we've just been lied to and or we haven't been
- 46:34told the flat out truth. I mean, one of the when I think
- 46:38back to the people that I really like and really respect, and you're one
- 46:44of these people burto because you'll tell the truth under circumstances that you know,
- 46:49you're not afraid to tell the truth under circumstances where other people would shy away
- 46:54from those difficulties. And I think about those people and I think, you
- 47:00know what, I think, one of the things I really like about those
- 47:01people I feel good around them is that they tell it like it is.
- 47:07They tell the truth. They will even if it hurts, you know,
- 47:13they'll say, Kirk, I need to tell you some I didn't like that,
- 47:19or you look stupid in that thing, or you know, whatever it
- 47:22is. Whatever sort of negative feeling I get from the insults or whatever is
- 47:30far offset by like, oh my god, I can trust this person.
- 47:36They're telling the truth. They're likely to tell me the truth in the future.
- 47:40How wonderful is that? So people out there, like, think about
- 47:45that in your own life. You know, what gift can you give to
- 47:49people by insulting them honestly? You know you give people a gift of truthfulness.
- 47:57Well that does it for that episode of Psychology and Seattle. Thanks for
- 47:59joining us there, truly because you enjoy it, because you deserve it,
- 48:05and you enjoy it, you better enjoy it. Wait, what in the
- 48:09world how do we end these podcasts? Everyone out there, please take care
- 48:14of so because you deserve it.