Latest / Retail Fast Five / Amazon To Meta’s Muse: Not In My Store | Fast Five Shorts
Transcript
- 0:00Headline number one, Amazon has cut off Meta's new Muse personal AI agent from shopping on Amazon.com, citing data security concerns after Meta declined to voluntarily exclude the site from the experience.
- 0:14According to Geekwire, Amazon says Meta never told it Muse would access its store, that the agent doesn't identify itself when it browses, and that it appears to capture and store customer credentials.
- 0:25Meta has said Muse has no visibility into people's passwords or payment methods.
- 0:30Shoppers trying to use Muse on Amazon now see a pop up warning that access by an unauthorized AI agent violates Amazon's conditions of use.
- 0:39Amazon says third party shopping apps should, quote, operate openly and respect service provider decisions.
- 0:45End quote.
- 0:46Now, for those loyal listeners, you all will remember that Amazon has spent the better part of the past year keeping outside agents off its site, suing Perplexity and moving to block shopping agents from Google and OpenAI.
- 0:58The stakes here are high.
- 1:00Amazon generated more than $68 billion in ad revenue last year, a business that depends partially on people browsing its pages.
- 1:09The legal backdrop here is also fascinating because the 9th Circuit overturned Amazon's injunction against perplexity on August 4, ruling the user, not the AI company, was accessing Amazon's computers, leaving Amazon to lean on its terms of service rather
- 1:25than its anti hacking law.
- 1:26All right, producer Ella.
- 1:28Producer Ella is going to step in for our friends at the A and M and she's going to ask me.
- 1:32I'll put you on the spot question for every one of today's headlines.
- 1:35So, producer Ella, how am I going to be put on the spot for headline number one?
- 1:40All right, Chris.
- 1:41A and M wants to know who ultimately has more power as this agentic commerce battle rages on the AI super app or the Megalith E commerce marketplace like Amazon.
- 1:52Ooh, the Megalith.
- 1:53That's a big word, Ella.
- 1:54I like that.
- 1:55I like that.
- 1:56Oh, man, that's a tough question.
- 1:58But I think it's a really, really important question to start out the show.
- 2:02I think it's going to be a grounding point for this entire show when we look at the headlines in front of us too, Ella.
- 2:07But sadly, sadly, I think this might surprise some people.
- 2:11I'm not sure this is a battle Amazon can win.
- 2:14I think there's going to be a struggle here for Amazon, Ella, and it could be also why they took the defensive position, allowing prime purchases on other retailers websites, which we're going to cover in a few headlines.
- 2:26And the reason I say that it's going to be a struggle for them is that the AI engines, the LLMs, they are coming.
- 2:32Agentix storefronts are coming.
- 2:34And if Amazon doesn't provide that marketplace to connect with those LLMs, somebody else is going to do it.
- 2:41Is it Walmart?
- 2:42Is it TikTok?
- 2:43I don't know.
- 2:44But the consumer love potential is so great that no one's going to avoid it.
- 2:50Somebody's going to step into the void and fill the need that the customers want.
- 2:55So I don't think the answer, I don't think the answer is shutting down the bots to keep a hold of advertising income in the long run for Amazon, short term.
- 3:02Short term, however, I do think it's the right move.
- 3:04But longer term, if the demand is what everyone thinks thinks it will be.
- 3:09Shutting off the LLM bots, in my opinion, is going to hurt in two ways.
- 3:13One, it's going to hurt your advertising revenue, but two, in the long run, it's going to hurt your overall retail sales.
- 3:18Amazon can figure out its way around the loss of the first one, particularly if Alexa for shopping can also take hold.
- 3:25But the second one, the second one is a lot harder to overcome.
- 3:30I'm reminded of the famous quote from Jeff Bezos.
- 3:33Bezos my margin is your opportunity.
- 3:35Mr.
- 3:36Jeff used to say, or like to say, and that is exactly how the LLMs are thinking about things.
- 3:42Ella, the LLMs are going after Amazon's margin with this strategy.
- 3:46And Amazon, I don't necessarily like the position that they are in.