Latest / Eye Spy: The Intelligence History Podcast / Spies in the Vatican: Part II
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Eye Spy, the Intelligence History Podcast.
- 0:08I'm your host, Krystel von Kumberg
- 0:12Every few weeks, I'm going to be interviewing historians, practitioners and scholars in
- 0:16the field of intelligence to explore some aspect of the past and what it can tell us
- 0:21about the present and future of intelligence studies.
- 0:26Welcome to part 2 of David Alvarez's talk on Vatican Intelligence.
- 0:31David Alvarez is professor at St. Mary's College of California and has taught at universities
- 0:36in France and Italy.
- 0:37A student of the Diplomatic, Intelligence and Military History of the Modern Papacy,
- 0:42his first book, with Robert Graham, Nothing Sacred, Nazi Espionage Against the Vatican,
- 0:47was translated and republished in French, Italian, Polish, Portuguese and Slovenian
- 0:52editions.
- 0:53His second book, Spies and the Vatican, Espionage and Intrigue from Napoleon to the Holocaust,
- 0:58also appeared in French, Italian and Polish editions.
- 1:01His most recent book, on the Modern Papacy, is The Pope's Soldiers, Military History
- 1:06of the Modern Vatican.
- 1:08His articles on subjects ranging from papal cryptology to the papacy and the American
- 1:12Civil War appear in several edited volumes in such professional journals as Catholic
- 1:17Historical Review, Cryptologia, Diplomatic History, Intelligence and National Security
- 1:23and Nuova Antologia Militare.
- 1:26By invitation of the editors, he contributed the entry on the Military Papacy to the Cambridge
- 1:30History of the Papacy, which came out in 2025.
- 1:34He addressed, by invitation, the intelligence working group of the Italian National Parliament
- 1:38on the topic of Vatican Intelligence capabilities and served as a consultant to the Vatican
- 1:43in the investigation into the pontificate of Pope Pius XII that is part of the inquiry
- 1:49still in process leading to Pacelli's possible canonization by the Catholic Church.
- 1:55The author's secondary research interest is the history of espionage.
- 1:59He has authored two books on American intelligence in the Second World War and Early Cold War,
- 2:04edited a special issue on the journal Intelligence and National Security and published more than
- 2:09a dozen articles in professional journals on topics in American, German and Italian
- 2:14intelligence history.
- 2:15On the strength of these publications, he was invited to spend a year as scholar in
- 2:19residence at the National Security Agency.
- 2:23There was no goldmining of information.
- 2:25It's a complete myth.
- 2:26And only gradually did countries, other powers, come to the realization that there's no there
- 2:35there.
- 2:36You know, we're working like crazy to collect information that isn't there.
- 2:43There's a wonderful OSS report, Office of Strategic Services report, OSS being the American
- 2:50and Findersen Intelligence Service during the war, major service during the war.
- 3:00And this OSS operative, who had been working in 1944 with Italian resistance groups in
- 3:13northern Italy, crossed the battle lines and went to Rome with a couple of Italian resistance
- 3:26to report to the Vatican on Catholic resistance groups, explicitly Catholic resistance groups
- 3:35working in fighting the Germans and the fascists in northern Italy.
- 3:40And he went with representatives of some of these Catholic resistance groups to report
- 3:47to the Vatican.
- 3:48And he filed a report with Washington after his encounter with Vatican officials, including
- 3:56the Pope.
- 3:58And he's completely the report is complete bewilderment.
- 4:02He said, these guys don't know anything.
- 4:05They weren't even aware that there were Catholic resistance groups operating in northern Italy.
- 4:10It was all news to them.
- 4:12They knew in the Vatican, they were completely oblivious to major operations being conducted
- 4:20200 miles from where they're sitting.
- 4:25They knew nothing about this.
- 4:27Nothing.
- 4:28So, what you've got is a situation which is entirely contrary to popular imagination or
- 4:35what our imagination would want us to believe.
- 4:38The Vatican was even in times of crisis, surprisingly uninformed or misinformed about events, not
- 4:50just on the opposite side of the globe, but events within miles of Vatican City.
- 5:01And one particularly intriguing event you describe is the April 1926 mission of a Catholic
- 5:09bishop sent by Pope Pius XV to the Church of St. Louis of the French in Moscow, the
- 5:15only Catholic church still open in the city at that time, located across from the Ljubljanka
- 5:21headquarters of the Soviet secret police, the OGPU.
- 5:25And his mission was to establish an underground church hierarchy and administration to replace
- 5:30the bishops and priests exiled or imprisoned by the Bolsheviks.
- 5:34Could you elaborate on this mission and its significance within the broader context of
- 5:39Vatican-Soviet relations?
- 5:43When the Bolsheviks took power in Russia, the Vatican's initial response was optimism.
- 5:54The Vatican was not reflexively anti-Bolshevik, at least at the beginning, because under the
- 6:00Tsar, the Catholic Church had been disapproved at the say the least, but at times was disapproved
- 6:12of so much that the official response could be characterized as persecution, that the
- 6:22Russian Orthodox Church was a state religion, other churches, especially the Catholic Church
- 6:29was viewed with disapproval to say the least under the Tsar.
- 6:34So when the Tsar is overthrown, the Vatican is hoping that what we're going to see is
- 6:40a new regime, first the Republican Democratic regime, and then when it's overthrown by
- 6:47the Bolsheviks, the second replacement regime, that the attitude of Vatican is, well, things
- 6:54could actually get better, right?
- 6:56That this could be an improvement because at least the replacement regimes after the
- 7:03initial removal of the Tsar, at least rhetorically, are not anti-religion in general or anti-Catholic
- 7:14in specific.
- 7:15So the initial reaction was, hey, things could improve for the church in Russia, but obviously
- 7:22they didn't.
- 7:24And although in the first decade of Bolshevik rule or the first half decade of Bolshevik
- 7:32rule, the attitude of Bolshevik authorities in Moscow towards the Catholic Church varied
- 7:42depending upon the foreign policy requirements of that regime.
- 7:48Sometimes they were more open, sometimes they were more restrictive, but the general course
- 7:55of papal Russian relations was towards increasing persecution of the church, increasing suppression
- 8:03of the church, increasing suspicion on the part of both parties towards each other.
- 8:09So that by the mid-1920s, the Catholic Church in Russia was a persecuted church.
- 8:18Priests were hunted down, they were brought before courts on trumped up charges, they
- 8:26were sent to camps or they were executed, bishops were imprisoned or executed.
- 8:33Only a handful of churches remained open, usually serving Catholics in the diplomatic
- 8:40community.
- 8:41So the church you referred to in Moscow, the only Catholic Church in Moscow, its congregation
- 8:46was entirely non-Russian.
- 8:49They were Spaniards or Portuguese or French diplomats who practiced Catholicism in the
- 8:56one Catholic Church that was open in Moscow.
- 8:59No Russian would step foot in such a church for fear of immediate reprisals by the secret
- 9:05police because the church was under constant surveillance.
- 9:08So from the Vatican's perspective, the problem is how do we save the church in Russia and
- 9:19how do we go into this survival mode?
- 9:24And the solution that they proposed that they came up with in the Vatican was to conduct
- 9:36what for the Vatican was something they hadn't done in a long time and they hadn't done this
- 9:41in anybody's living memory and that is to organize what we today would call a clandestine
- 9:47operation, a cross-border clandestine operation.
- 9:51And the operation involved introducing into Russia this individual, Michel de Ebrigny,
- 10:00French Jesuit who was made a bishop before his trip.
- 10:09He was sent into Russia on more than one occasion into Russia with the job of secretly creating
- 10:21Russian bishops to locate the few surviving Catholic priests that are still at liberty
- 10:30inside Russia and to create among them some bishops, make some of them bishops.
- 10:40Bishops are a necessary part in the survival of a church because only bishops can ordain
- 10:46priests.
- 10:48And you can't ordain a priest from a distance.
- 10:50It has to be a hands-on face-to-face event.
- 10:54So if you're going to try and create a church that effectively has to be an underground
- 11:03church because of persecution, you have to first have not priests but bishops, first
- 11:11bishops and then bishops can create priests.
- 11:15And so the Ebrigny is sent into Russia to secretly create bishops.
- 11:21And that event that you referred to in the church in Moscow was a secret clandestine
- 11:28meeting between this French Jesuit and this priest who was still at liberty, who was just
- 11:41given an instruction, a letter to go to this church.
- 11:45He didn't know what was going to happen.
- 11:47He didn't know any of it.
- 11:48This was all going to be news to him.
- 11:50He just went to this church.
- 11:52He was dressed as a peasant, right?
- 11:56You didn't walk around Russia dressed in clerical garb and expect to survive the week.
- 12:03So he walks into this church where he meets this Jesuit bishop who he's never seen before
- 12:11who says, hey, I've got some news.
- 12:13Perhaps you should sit down before I give you this news because here I have a letter
- 12:18from the pope authorizing me to create you as a bishop and I'm going to do it right now,
- 12:27right here.
- 12:28And he did.
- 12:30And then bishops through these clandestine missions, the Vatican hoped to create a clandestine
- 12:38infrastructure that would allow the church to continue to survive underground in the
- 12:44face of persecution.
- 12:47It didn't work out.
- 12:48It didn't work out because the Russians were onto him from the get go and followed him,
- 12:56maintained surveillance over him, noticed, recorded the various people with whom he was
- 13:03meeting, including the new bishops that he's creating, and then once he, the Jesuit bishop
- 13:10had returned to Rome, the Russians at their leisure and as they felt necessary, rounded
- 13:18up all these bishops and either executed them or sent them to labor camps so that this clandestine
- 13:28effort to maintain a church hierarchy within the Soviet Union was a complete failure.
- 13:35What it did was only confirm the suspicions in the Russian security services that the
- 13:43Vatican was an enemy of the Soviet regime and that this enemy was actively conducting
- 13:53clandestine operations to undermine the Soviet regime.
- 13:56It was a self-fulfilling prophecy, right?
- 13:59That it wasn't an effort on the part of the Vatican to undermine the regime, but they
- 14:08acted in such a way as to confirm suspicions on the Russian side that there was such a
- 14:16goal in mind.
- 14:19Not only was it a disaster and a debacle on the purely organizational and structural level,
- 14:25there was no way that the church was going to be able to survive in the Soviet Union
- 14:30in the 1930s, but it also worsened the situation for the Vatican because it confirmed in the
- 14:39eyes of Soviets in Moscow that the Vatican was in fact an existential threat to the survival
- 14:49of the regime.
- 14:50It wasn't, but they were able to convince themselves of such.
- 14:56Yeah, really interesting.
- 14:59Going to a very different case study, in your book, Nothing Sacred, Nazi Espionage Against
- 15:07the Vatican, you reflect alongside Father Robert Graham how German cryptanalysts broke
- 15:13some of the Vatican's codes and ciphers, but unlike during World War I where Germans
- 15:18managed to plant an agent who actually served as Pope Benedict XV's private chamberlain
- 15:24and confidential aide, how successful were they during World War II?
- 15:29As you pointed out during the brief period in the First World War, the German government
- 15:36had an agent at the side of the pope.
- 15:41They had this German priest, Monsignor Rudolf Gerlach, a confidant of the pope, Pope Benedict
- 15:51XV, but he was exposed by Italian counterintelligence and was expelled from Italy.
- 16:04During the Second World War, the Germans never even came close to having an iteration as
- 16:14they had with Gerlach in the First World War.
- 16:17I have to emphasize, even in the First World War, Gerlach, who is almost certainly, it's
- 16:25almost beyond doubt that he was an active German espionage agent.
- 16:31He was only such for a relatively short period of time before he was exposed by the Italian
- 16:39police who informed the Vatican and his utility ended when he was expelled from the country.
- 16:48So in the Second World War, there were no even middle level German informants operating
- 16:58inside the Vatican.
- 17:01The German intelligence coverage of the Vatican was very weak, but it wasn't for lack of
- 17:08trying.
- 17:09They tried, but they never were successful in recruiting anything but the most marginal
- 17:14informants, by marginal I mean informants operating on the margins of the Vatican.
- 17:22Like one of their agents, German agents during the Second World War, was merely a researcher
- 17:29in the Vatican Library.
- 17:31Wasn't even employed by the Vatican, but was an independent researcher who sometimes
- 17:38visited the Vatican Library and would pass on whatever gossip she might pick up among
- 17:50the other researchers in the library.
- 17:53Well, I mean, we're both academics.
- 17:57We know what kind of gossip that's going to look like.
- 17:59It's hardly the kind of information that the Germans are hoping to get out of Vatican City.
- 18:05And even that source dried up when the Germans occupied Rome in September of 1943, the Vatican
- 18:12Archive and the Vatican Library were closed.
- 18:17And so that source, as modest as it was, was shut down and could no longer provide information.
- 18:27So that the Germans were certainly trying to penetrate the Vatican during the war with
- 18:35human agents, but they were unsuccessful, largely unsuccessful.
- 18:42They were so desperate that they came up with the idea of creating a phony seminary in Rome
- 18:57that they would staff with seminarians in quotation marks who were actually German intelligence
- 19:07operatives.
- 19:09And the idea would be that these so-called seminarians would, because of their status,
- 19:16have better access to the ecclesiastical world of the Vatican than historian researchers
- 19:26in the Vatican Library or the equivalent of whatever they had working for them at the
- 19:33time.
- 19:34So they literally created a seminary.
- 19:39They recruited half dozen agents who would pretend to be seminarians and then attempt
- 19:47to penetrate the ecclesiastical society of the Vatican and then report back to Berlin
- 19:54through a clandestine radio which was hidden away in this seminary.
- 19:58Well, this whole thing was a complete disaster because the agents who they recruited as seminarians
- 20:07had no intention of living in Rome under the discipline and rule of a seminary, right?
- 20:19They didn't want to be walking around Rome in ecclesiastical dress and they wanted to
- 20:24go out at night.
- 20:25They wanted to go out to bars, they wanted to go out and meet women, they wanted to do
- 20:29all the things that 25-year-olds would want to do in Rome even during the war, right?
- 20:35And so, they proved completely unacceptable for the purposes of the operation and they
- 20:45all had to be sent home before they could collect any intelligence.
- 20:48And by the time they got around to trying to find replacements, the allies had liberated
- 20:57Rome, the German security and intelligence services had fled to the north and this whole
- 21:03idea of a seminary as an intelligence base collapsed.
- 21:11Nothing came of it.
- 21:12Not a single intelligence report was even filed.
- 21:17And also, because of radio intercept and communications intelligence, Allied communications intelligence
- 21:25was aware of what was going on as German intelligence operatives and supervisors in Rome were communists.
- 21:33Communicating developments and progress to Berlin, these messages were all being intercepted
- 21:39by Allied radio intelligence programs.
- 21:46And when the allies marched in the Rome, liberated Rome in June of 1944, one of the first things
- 21:53American counterintelligence did literally on the first or second day they were in Rome
- 21:59is they went to the seminary.
- 22:01They knew exactly where it was.
- 22:02They knew exactly who was in charge of it.
- 22:05They knew exactly where to find a radio.
- 22:07So the whole thing was blown.
- 22:11It was a complete disaster.
- 22:15And see, that's what German intelligence against the Vatican looked like during the Second
- 22:20World War.
- 22:21Now, to be sure, German intelligence against the German Catholic Church inside the borders
- 22:27of the Reich, that was much more effective.
- 22:32They were much more successful in operations against the German Catholics and the German
- 22:39bishops and the German archbishops.
- 22:41But in terms of their operations directly against Vatican City, they were minimal.
- 22:48Well, they were minimal in terms of success.
- 22:52They were not minimal in terms of effort, but they were minimal in terms of success.
- 22:56And I guess the Catholic Church's ability to protect Catholics in Germany, for instance,
- 23:04or as we saw in Russia, that also isn't as effective, right?
- 23:10Yes.
- 23:11Well, certainly in Russia.
- 23:16In a sense, the Vatican just gave up on Catholics in Russia.
- 23:23They had so little information coming out of Russia or what had been the Baltic states,
- 23:31Russian occupied territories in Eastern Europe.
- 23:35They didn't even know if there were any bishops were still alive.
- 23:39They didn't know how many priests were still operating.
- 23:43Russia was a blank slate to the Vatican and would remain so throughout the war, through
- 23:51the 30s and then through the Second World War and into the early Cold War period.
- 23:59With regard to Nazi Germany, the Vatican was better informed, but then so were the Germans.
- 24:15The Vatican kept up communications with the German church.
- 24:20I mean, there were what?
- 24:21I don't know, tens of millions of German Catholics, right?
- 24:25And there were German Cardinals and whatever there were, 15 German bishops.
- 24:31I mean, there was a well-established church structure even in Nazi Germany.
- 24:40Such a structure didn't even exist in Russia, but at least in Germany, the structure remained.
- 24:45And it was a structure that was able to be monitored from the Vatican.
- 24:50There were still communication channels that were open.
- 24:54These channels were penetrated by the German intelligence to be sure, but at least information
- 25:07was coming out of Germany and information was going from the Vatican into Germany.
- 25:13But the Vatican, the German security services and intelligence services were much more successful
- 25:20in monitoring the activities of German Catholics and the German church within the traditional
- 25:26borders of Germany.
- 25:29Through communication surveillance, telephone taps, mail intercept, the German security
- 25:40intelligence services broke several of the Vatican ciphers, which the Vatican hoped would
- 25:47protect its more confidential communications.
- 25:51There was physical surveillance of the German bishops.
- 25:55So in terms of internal affairs, the German intelligence services were much better informed
- 26:04than they were about what was going on in the Vatican.
- 26:06And in part, the German services within Germany were assisted by the fact that there were
- 26:14an alarming number of renegade monks and priests who gave up, abandoned the ecclesiastical
- 26:22life and signed up to work for German intelligence, for the Gestapo or for the RSHA.
- 26:31So these renegade priests, these renegade monks, and we're talking not about one or
- 26:37two, but more, a lot more, were able to provide kind of an insight into the ecclesiastical
- 26:46world of Germany that really assisted German efforts to understand that world in general,
- 26:55but also focus upon particular aspects of that world.
- 27:00These renegade priests and monks spoke the ecclesiastical language.
- 27:06They understood the ecclesiastical culture.
- 27:08They could identify potential pressure points or access points for German intelligence and
- 27:14security services.
- 27:16None of that was available to the Germans operating in Rome trying to penetrate the Vatican.
- 27:22The Vatican was a complete mystery to them, as it was a complete mystery to American intelligence
- 27:29or French intelligence.
- 27:33It was a world that secular intelligence services found a great deal of difficulty in understanding.
- 27:41It was a world, somebody once asked me, what was the most effective security device that
- 27:48the Vatican implemented during the war?
- 27:50Was it, did they have a counterintelligence service?
- 27:53No.
- 27:54Did they have close physical security of facilities?
- 27:59And no, they didn't have any of that.
- 28:01What was the greatest, the most effective security program the Vatican had?
- 28:08Just being priest by itself.
- 28:14That was a whole different world.
- 28:17And today where the priestly life or the ecclesiastical world is so much different in positive ways
- 28:27than it was even in the 1940s, it's hard for us to understand how much that ecclesiastical
- 28:34world of the Vatican was a closed society.
- 28:39Not just physically closed by gates, for instance, and locks, although that certainly was present.
- 28:48It was closed on a cultural level.
- 28:52And I'm tempted to say on an emotional level.
- 28:56That was very hard for non-ecclesiastics, non-Italians to penetrate, to get their arms
- 29:05around.
- 29:06I mean, when you read intelligence reports, American intelligence reports or British intelligence
- 29:15reports, German intelligence reports, you see this kind of basic ignorance about the
- 29:24Vatican and how it operated that seriously compromised the ability of the secular intelligence
- 29:34services to make any sense out of what's happening.
- 29:37And because they were so basically ignorant, ignorant on a fundamental level, they were
- 29:43easily fooled and misled by intelligence fabricators who claim to have access to the Vatican and
- 29:54then would for money flood the intelligence marketplace with completely spurious intelligence
- 30:02reports.
- 30:03I mean, made up out of whole cloth.
- 30:08American intelligence towards the end of the war was completely bamboozled by this remarkable
- 30:15character whose name was Virgilio Scattellini.
- 30:20He was an intelligence fabricator on a level beyond any fabricator of the war.
- 30:26He was, I think, probably the most notorious fabricator of intelligence during the Second
- 30:32World War.
- 30:33He sold his product to anybody who would buy it.
- 30:36And one of his best customers was OSS, where he not only sold his information once, but
- 30:44sold the information, the same information twice to American intelligence.
- 30:50He operated under two different code names for American intelligence because American
- 30:58intelligence thought they were dealing with two different people, two different sources,
- 31:02when in fact it was only one.
- 31:04He just made stuff up.
- 31:05I mean, literally just made stuff up.
- 31:09Everything was completely fabricated.
- 31:10And well into 1945, he was considered by OSS its absolute best source on the Vatican.
- 31:19His code name, the one by which he's known to any historians who care about this, is
- 31:25Vessel, V-E-S-S-E-L.
- 31:27And he was the Vessel Project.
- 31:30He fooled almost everybody.
- 31:33And the few people who weren't fooled were hushed up because, well, for one thing, no
- 31:39intelligence service wants to admit that it has been seriously fooled by anybody.
- 31:46But also because there was no alternative.
- 31:49There was no alternative source.
- 31:53Even when analysts in OSS started raising questions about him, effectively saying, well,
- 31:59this can't be true.
- 32:01I mean, what he's saying this month is exactly the opposite of what this guy is saying two
- 32:06months ago.
- 32:08People just refused to accept it.
- 32:11So he was operating, he was functioning as an intelligence source well into 1945.
- 32:18And he only got away with it because the United States was so ignorant of what was really
- 32:23going on inside the Vatican.
- 32:24If they actually had good sources, he would have been exposed in a flash as a fabricator.
- 32:33But they had nothing to compare his reports to.
- 32:35They had nobody in an American intelligence who knew anything about the Vatican and could
- 32:41say that's impossible.
- 32:42The Pope would never have an audience with such a person.
- 32:46Or that can't be the case.
- 32:47This guy isn't even in China.
- 32:51He's in Argentina, right?
- 32:53I mean, he would get away with stuff like that.
- 32:56He would report that Monsignor so-and-so had a conversation with the Pope and they talked
- 33:01about this when in fact Monsignor so-and-so was actually in Argentina at the time.
- 33:07American intelligence and any of the other intelligence services that Virgilio Scatellini
- 33:13peddled his information to had no other information to compare his reports to.
- 33:20And so they just took them at face value.
- 33:23The Italian security services exposed him as a fabricator already in 1942, right?
- 33:31And he was actually put on trial and convicted of peddling this information and punished.
- 33:39He got a short prison sentence.
- 33:46When he came out of jail, he just reopened his shop and started doing it all over again
- 33:52and was exposed once again at the end of the war, mainly by, again, by the Italians.
- 34:02And then, so now he's been exposed twice, put out a business twice.
- 34:08But you know, he's got a good thing going.
- 34:11He just for the third time reopens his shop and starts peddling information, this time
- 34:20including the Italian Communist Party as one of his clients, customers if you will.
- 34:26And he worked for some time peddling information which appeared in books published by communist
- 34:32presses that denigrated the Vatican, accused the Vatican of all kinds of things, being
- 34:40a puppet of the United States.
- 34:41Anyway, he was working well into the end of the 1940s.
- 34:47The fact that he had been exposed didn't seem to matter.
- 34:53He sold his information not just to foreign governments, he sold his information to newspapers,
- 34:59magazines, banks, had him on the payroll.
- 35:03He would peddle information about Vatican investments and Vatican finances.
- 35:08None of this had the slightest connection with reality.
- 35:13It was completely fanciful.
- 35:14It was all fairy tales and people bought it because they were ignorant.
- 35:23I mean, they were prepared to believe anything because they had no information about no understanding
- 35:27of the Vatican at all, right?
- 35:30One guy was prepared, did one OSS report, bought as to truth a report that the Vatican
- 35:37was building an airport inside Vatican City.
- 35:41Anybody with the slightest knowledge about the geography of Vatican City could never
- 35:47swallow such a report.
- 35:51You're building an airport inside Vatican City, the size of Vatican City is 108 acres.
- 35:59It's built on the side of a hill, okay?
- 36:02When you're walking in the Vatican Garden, you're either walking uphill or downhill,
- 36:07the Vatican is full of tall buildings, St. Peter's Basilica being the tallest building
- 36:13in Rome, at least central Rome, right?
- 36:17And still you're trying to convince me that they're going to build an airport inside Vatican
- 36:22City?
- 36:24I don't think so.
- 36:25But OSS was prepared to believe it.
- 36:29That's a really, really interesting case study.
- 36:33Yeah, thanks for sharing that.
- 36:36So just to wrap up, I guess, everything.
- 36:38It's interesting, historian Christopher Andrew reflects how God was the first major figure
- 36:44in world literature to highlight the importance of intelligence.
- 36:47And so I was wondering, and you've mentioned a little bit, how, you know, the Vatican is
- 36:53very different to secular states, right?
- 36:56So and we can see that in how it conducts intelligence activities.
- 37:02So in what ways do you think it was, it is different or it was different as well in the
- 37:09past 20th century, but also in its activities today?
- 37:16We can only speculate about what the Vatican is doing today.
- 37:23I mean, literally in contemporary moments, right?
- 37:25We can speculate on the basis of some glimpses that we get inside the Vatican.
- 37:32We can speculate on the basis of the recent history that we are better informed about.
- 37:38And those glimpses and that recent history, to my mind, at least, is the Vatican remains
- 37:49what it has been for the last century.
- 37:55An organization that has very weak intelligence capabilities.
- 38:07What information goes into the Vatican today is basically what we would characterize as
- 38:13open source information gathered from social media, from news sites, from the press and
- 38:26global media, broadly understood.
- 38:30The Vatican today, if the recent past is any indication, does not have any clandestine
- 38:38intelligence capabilities and doesn't particularly care that it doesn't have any clandestine
- 38:43intelligence capabilities.
- 38:46I think the Vatican is aware of the fact that its role on the international stage as an
- 38:54employer in world diplomacy is now a very modest role.
- 39:02The Vatican doesn't fool itself into thinking that it is somehow an important player in
- 39:09international political affairs.
- 39:11It's not, and it knows it's not.
- 39:14And so the kinds of imperatives that would drive other powers, other international actors,
- 39:23both governmental and non-governmental, to aggressively seek out information, those imperatives
- 39:32aren't part of the Vatican posture.
- 39:38The Vatican is reactive rather than active on the international stage.
- 39:49It's not anymore and hasn't been for over a century a self-conscious, deliberate player
- 39:57in the world of intelligence.
- 40:01And I don't think that's likely to change.
- 40:03Well, for one thing, it doesn't have the resources and never has had the resources to be an important
- 40:10player in the intelligence world.
- 40:12It is like not even close to being able to summon the resources to engage the technology
- 40:21that is commonplace now in the intelligence world.
- 40:25There was just actually an article in the Italian press just a couple of weeks ago about
- 40:32Pope Francis and where he gets information.
- 40:38And this article in the Italian press said that basically he reads the Pope, Pope Francis,
- 40:47Pope reads one newspaper a day, but the Pope himself admits that he reads it in five minutes.
- 40:57And then he gets a digest of world news from the Department of the Vatican that's concerned
- 41:05with communicable communications.
- 41:07It's kind of the Vatican PR service, news service.
- 41:15They provide him a daily digest of a world press.
- 41:19Whether he pays much attention to it or not, we don't know.
- 41:25But people might say, well, they're not going to reveal any secret sources of information
- 41:32he has.
- 41:33And if they had any, I'm sure they wouldn't reveal it.
- 41:35But I think what you see is what you get.
- 41:39That's where he gets his information.
- 41:42When given access to open sources, that doesn't mean he's poorly informed.
- 41:47You can become very well informed from open sources.
- 41:54But I think there's no evidence at all that he has any secret sources of information other
- 42:04than that provided by the liaison, the papal security services, in particular the Vatican
- 42:16gendarmerie, the Vatican police force, the liaison connections it has with foreign police
- 42:25agencies.
- 42:27They do get information when the pope is traveling.
- 42:36The immediate responsibility for the pope's safety is with the Swiss Guard and with papal
- 42:44gendarmes who travel with the pope for close in personal security purposes.
- 42:51We know for sure that in preparing papal trips that the papal police liaise with friendly
- 43:02police services and the police services of the host countries that will be receiving
- 43:07the pope.
- 43:08And so through that liaison relationship, they may have access to confidential information
- 43:15or secret information that would not appear in say open sources.
- 43:25And we know that for sure because you probably have noticed that just within the last couple
- 43:29of weeks, it was revealed in the press that during the pope's recent visit to Iraq, he
- 43:40was the target of two assassination attempts which were foiled by Iraqi security services
- 43:51on the basis of information that seems to have come from British intelligence sources.
- 43:57And that British intelligence sources shared that information with their Iraqi counterparts
- 44:03and with the pope's security service or pope's police service.
- 44:10On that level, protecting the pope on foreign visits, you would probably see the Vatican,
- 44:17not the pope personally, but the Vatican Protective Services receiving secret information.
- 44:24But they have not collected that information.
- 44:27Once again, they are the passive recipients of such information from other sources who
- 44:34have collected that information.
- 44:37And my last question for you is, what would you advise scholars in the field of intelligence
- 44:44history to learn from all of your important work?
- 44:48Oh, geez.
- 44:51I'm not very good at giving advice.
- 44:54What I have learned and about this bigger question of the Vatican's place in the world
- 45:00of espionage and intelligence, what I have learned and what I would hope my colleagues
- 45:07would learn is that it is important to separate myth from reality, myth from fact.
- 45:18And that to do so, you actually have to do the hard work of testing the myth.
- 45:29My experience has been that it is easy to embrace the myth of the intelligence of the
- 45:37Vatican as a historical intelligence superpower, a posture that continues to the present day.
- 45:47But only by testing that myth, by actually looking into Vatican information sources at
- 45:58particular periods of time, can you confirm or not confirm the reality of that myth.
- 46:06I think that's true not just about the myth of the Vatican intelligence, but the world
- 46:10of espionage is full of myths.
- 46:15Good stories perhaps, but stories that have no basis effect.
- 46:20It's full of conspiracy theories and conspiracy stories.
- 46:24I mean, in particular, the world of the Vatican is full of conspiracy theories.
- 46:30I am often approached by people who want me to confirm or deny or guide them or turn them
- 46:39towards sources to prove that various outrageous things about the Vatican.
- 46:46The Vatican is the richest country in the world.
- 46:51It's not the Vatican is secretly hiding various religious artifacts and relics which have
- 46:59supernatural powers.
- 47:01The Vatican in particular, but the espionage world in general is full of myths and those
- 47:09myths should be tested.
- 47:14The opportunity to investigate those myths and test them is a research opportunity for
- 47:20young historians perhaps who are looking for career paths or productive sources of long-term
- 47:28research projects.
- 47:31That would be my first bit of advice.
- 47:33Believe everything that you hear or read, but test those myths.
- 47:41The other thing I have learned and would advise colleagues to or at least remind colleagues
- 47:53to learn because we already know this is that even intelligence documents can be misleading,
- 48:07can be wrong.
- 48:09In the case of the Vatican, multiple foreign intelligence services, most prominently the
- 48:16American, the German, the British were terribly misinformed by their own operations, misinformed
- 48:26about the reality of the Vatican during the First World War, during the interwar period,
- 48:32during the Second World War and for all we know during the Cold War period also.
- 48:41Just because something appears in an intelligence file marked top secret doesn't mean it's true.
- 48:51More often than not, a lot of what passes for intelligence on the Vatican is only partially
- 48:59true or completely untrue.
- 49:04And we all, all of us working in intelligence history on one level know that's the case
- 49:10about any intelligence document, whether we're talking about Italian documents or German
- 49:15or Russian or Swedish or whatever, we know that on one level.
- 49:20But oftentimes we don't internalize it because we've all had this experience working in intelligence
- 49:27documents.
- 49:28You see a document and you say, oh my God, I can't believe this.
- 49:31This is so cool.
- 49:32Oh, this is great.
- 49:33I'm going to write an article about this.
- 49:36Right?
- 49:37We want it to be true, you know, we want it to be true because it's such a good story.
- 49:45And you know, my very narrow experience with intelligence documents relating to the Vatican
- 49:51is that they're full of really, really good stories.
- 49:56But most of those stories are just that, stories.
- 50:00And we have to remind ourselves to accept that fact, to not accept the story just because
- 50:09it's, you want it to be true because it's such a good story or such a revealing story
- 50:15or such a scandalous story.
- 50:19We need to bring a strong sense of skepticism to these documents.
- 50:29And sometimes, you know, it results in conclusions that people aren't happy to accept because
- 50:37they prefer the good story.
- 50:40That's a lesson that took me a while to kind of embrace.
- 50:44And I'm not, I can't brag that I'm, you know, now immune to the good story theory because
- 50:53I'm just as susceptible to good stories as anybody else.
- 50:58Just literally last week, I was looking at some summaries of Vatican documents from the
- 51:04Second World War and I caught myself saying, oh my God, that's good.
- 51:09This is going to be really, really good.
- 51:11And I had to remind myself, I had to listen to that little voice that says, yeah, wait
- 51:15a minute, you've been there before, right?
- 51:18It looks good, but how do you know it's true?
- 51:21Right?
- 51:22And then when you deal with intelligence documents, it's oftentimes difficult to determine whether
- 51:28it's true or not because the material by its very nature is susceptible to manipulation,
- 51:36it's susceptible to isolation.
- 51:41One document can't be demonstrated to be true or false because all the other relevant documents
- 51:47are neither available or if they're because they're still classified or because they're
- 51:54lost or burnt.
- 51:56You got to listen to that little voice warning you.
- 52:04Be careful.
- 52:06The truth isn't always stranger than fiction.
- 52:08Right.
- 52:09Yeah, right.
- 52:11It's the problem is determining what's the truth and what's not.
- 52:16Truth as much as we can understand it to be true.
- 52:19As I say, sometimes it's difficult to determine the so-called truth of a particular process
- 52:29or a particular event, but we need to make the effort to discover that truth as much
- 52:35as we are able to.
- 52:38But then also to understand that maybe despite our best efforts, we're only seeing part of
- 52:45the story.
- 52:46Yeah, definitely.
- 52:49Thank you so much for all of your insights and for joining me today.
- 52:55It's been fun on my end.
- 52:57Thank you.