Latest / Newcomer Pod / Fine-tuning of the Metaverse
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome. I used to cover Facebook like
- 0:14nominally. Like, I would get invited to the
- 0:16Facebook connect. Thank you, guys, ever go.
- 0:19We why would the FAA part? Yeah.
- 0:21Oh yeah. The what Back when Mark used to
- 0:23walk around with lick security guard, sort of off in the the
- 0:26office they had an amazing spread of like roast turkey and
- 0:30delicious food and nobody was eating it.
- 0:32I made this huge plate was so awkward because like a cocktail
- 0:36plate, too. But I piled it very high and
- 0:37went and sat all by myself and then Tom came up for her.
- 0:42I was eating alone in the corner because, yeah, I don't know.
- 0:46I just pretty quickly assess that we weren't going to get any
- 0:48real information out of the executives were there that
- 0:50night, right? But the food was good and they
- 0:52had said we also had a giant donation, a bin full, you know,
- 0:56like Facebook employees at a donated things to charity and I
- 0:59thought it was like I thought it was like, the swag that again,
- 1:02we started rummaging around it and these days, like one,
- 1:07Facebook toys, a Facebook employers, like yeah, cool.
- 1:10Like a soccer embargo and robots and, and I told one out in a
- 1:13Facebook employee was like, dude, what are you doing?
- 1:16That's the classic Tom. Yeah, that's the last days of
- 1:20partying to this amazing f8, the developer conference, right?
- 1:25Right. Yes.
- 1:25Of8, you know, ends up comes out there and he gives his speech
- 1:28and they talk about the new products.
- 1:29He's going into Instagram and Facebook, and then there's
- 1:31always like a section where they talk about the Oculus products
- 1:35and, and the all the different, you know, not augmented reality
- 1:38but like the altar, you know, whatever like like Second Life
- 1:41Products that they have, but they were all out and I would
- 1:43always tune out during that section, it was always the least
- 1:46interesting and relevant to the business and like I wouldn't
- 1:49have expected at my 2015, that that was going to be the whole
- 1:52company. Like that one section that
- 1:54everybody didn't pay attention to was secretly.
- 1:56The only thing that he cared about this whole time, Is it
- 2:00that he biggest surprise though? Yeah, a lot of watching that's
- 2:04just worst from the company's issues and problems.
- 2:07Yeah, it shouldn't have been a surprise but anywhere for tell
- 2:09me your argument, well, you know, my call my column, this
- 2:13week was basically saying that, you know, tech companies have a
- 2:16long tradition of using futuristic technology to
- 2:19distract people from their issues, you know, obviously
- 2:22alphabet, you know, literally Google changed, its name, they,
- 2:26you know, promised us life, extension and Fabulous.
- 2:29Us new cities and self-driving, cars and amazing connected
- 2:34homes, and like, very little of. It has panned out and then Uber
- 2:37basically copied the model with some of the same people and
- 2:40said, a while, flying cars. And we'll also have self-driving
- 2:43cars and they did that. And, you know, that help sort of
- 2:46juice it and lifts president promised, I think most of their
- 2:51vehicles would be self-driving cars by this year which
- 2:54unfortunately hasn't happened. So, you know, I think, you know,
- 2:57the argument is that there's an obvious Sort of distraction
- 3:01quotient to this and that the media basically can't help but
- 3:06play into it because we're addicted to these stories, no
- 3:10matter what. And it's not even that the media
- 3:11isn't sufficiently skeptical because you know, like we're
- 3:17writing the column saying this is bullshit, but it's just like,
- 3:20there's a fatalism to if this is what Facebook is talking about
- 3:25where is dragged into it. So I guess the idea that I had
- 3:28was fuck it. It like okay, everybody, you
- 3:32know, it's a second-order sort of concern.
- 3:36What if we just like argue about the actual sort of first order
- 3:40sort of meta verse plan thing and buy in to the whole conceit
- 3:44like DUI? Because I don't think there's a
- 3:45big fight over whether or not everybody agrees.
- 3:47It's a distraction a key distract from the fact that the
- 3:50companies you know, being right it's like so self-evident and
- 3:54yet we're still like it still happens is a weird like we're
- 3:58on, you know Like why can't everybody just ignore and say?
- 4:02Oh it's just like fucking face, right?
- 4:03And actually get to the essential issue of whether or
- 4:05not people would want to live in a meta verse.
- 4:07I mean I think that people like human contact.
- 4:09I think they actually enjoy things like being in rooms
- 4:12together and sharing genuine laughter.
- 4:15I think they like touching one another.
- 4:16They like having sex they like you know, emotions that only
- 4:20come from being a in groups of small, small groups, or large
- 4:24groups of people. And I just don't think that's
- 4:27all replicable in the metaverse. Outside of his surrogate outside
- 4:31of a surrogate played by actor who played it in her.
- 4:35I can't remember who played Scarlett Johansson.
- 4:38Well, that was the voice. I mean I even think like getting
- 4:41to this point of whether or not people are willing to accept the
- 4:44metaverse almost allied's past the point that like the
- 4:47technology required for this to be at anyway, close to what Zach
- 4:51was explaining in this just isn't there, but that's what I'm
- 4:53talking about, right? Like everybody knows well, never
- 4:56replicate the things that we like, about living the things.
- 4:59Like about living with other human being.
- 5:01I disagree with that suck about being around other human beings,
- 5:05but the things that are really great about are pretty special
- 5:07and they're not, there's no technology that replicates the
- 5:10feeling of being at a party and having a really good time.
- 5:15I don't know. I'm bullish on the metaverse.
- 5:17There's an interesting way to explain to me like what jurors
- 5:20what variable actually had did. What part of will be fun?
- 5:23Like I'm willing to accept it. Incomplete theory that.
- 5:25Yeah it would be fun to be able to in a limited sense.
- 5:30Feel like you're next to someone that you couldn't be for one
- 5:32reason or another. But first of all, the standard
- 5:35the kitties setting that until it's as good as sex.
- 5:38It's not going to work. I mean, first thing that, I
- 5:40mean, I think that we even found you to be better than work
- 5:43together was satisfactory. It's not satisfactory, but we're
- 5:46still doing it. I think there are a lot of weird
- 5:51but we're recording this on Zoom, right?
- 5:53People are not attending well because we physically can't
- 5:58cities, right? But we're prioritizing That over
- 6:00finding real people. You know, like in everything
- 6:03there are trade-offs but that's different from wanting to live
- 6:06in the metaverse. It's different from saying I
- 6:09voluntarily, I'm going to spend my leisure time there.
- 6:12I don't voluntarily, spend my leisure time with you guys on.
- 6:14Well, it could be where I think work is a big use potential, use
- 6:18case and video games. Like people play video games
- 6:21there in sqd, right screen digital spaces.
- 6:24Like people spend a lot of time. I spend a lot of my time in
- 6:28front of a computer. If I got to keep the the clothes
- 6:32that I bought in fucking Fortnight in the costumes and
- 6:35what so that the gaming everywhere else.
- 6:37So I look you like that, that that seems good.
- 6:40Like if I were in here with a bunch of shiny things mean, you
- 6:43guys, you know, jealous and laughing.
- 6:47That's like the Stepping Stones of it.
- 6:49I know that's, it's like the Katie's like, this is most
- 6:51pathetic like thing in the world.
- 6:53But I do think it's incremental. No, I don't think it's pathetic.
- 6:57I agree that it's incremental, I just don't think that A world in
- 7:00which people given the choice between spending a lot of their
- 7:05time in the meadow verse and spending a lot of their time
- 7:07with other people would choose the metaverse.
- 7:10Now, I think you're right applicate, there's probably work
- 7:12application business application.
- 7:14But again, like, we're working business application.
- 7:19I mean, if that was a goal, we already have zoom with that but
- 7:23that's always been the cop-out. For all of this technology is
- 7:26like, well let's just make it work for business.
- 7:27I mean like if you follow the river like with second, Life.
- 7:30There were like, well people will start setting up stores in
- 7:32Second Life, buddy. Merchants in Second Life.
- 7:34Oh, like the economy within it. I mean that's a whole other
- 7:36thing that's like people. Apply the economy.
- 7:39I think we're pretty close. I mean, entities are already
- 7:41getting us? There were already we have
- 7:43people playing nft games in the Philippines where they're making
- 7:46money playing those games. Like just just the fact that if
- 7:50even if it's just delusional money provided by tech companies
- 7:53that there are going to be people, you know, not just like
- 7:56World of Warcraft, weird sort of like but like people who are
- 7:59doing Jobs in a fully digital space to make, you know, like
- 8:04that's amazing. Like and I feel like that
- 8:06transition is that is closed and I think that is a pretty
- 8:10radical. I mean, economies are powerful
- 8:12and once people can make money in a digital space because
- 8:15they're producing things or holding things that people want.
- 8:18But this is the cart before the horse, right?
- 8:20Like you have to have a critical mass of people who are actively
- 8:24choosing to participate in this reality for the economy to be
- 8:27me. That's why infps are amazing.
- 8:29They're like, If initially the cart, before the horse right
- 8:31there, literally buying the objects when they're just text
- 8:35or for. There's some standard broker who
- 8:37accepts them. Also, yes, I agree with you.
- 8:39It's insane but like part of the effort to get around, this is
- 8:42literally, we're going to sink money into it before it even
- 8:46exists. Basically to do what you're
- 8:48saying to put the cart. Before the horse.
- 8:49I mean, that's like, that's like the completely logical and like,
- 8:53a pragmatic explanation for nftl.
- 8:55I think the one that I buy into more is that people just have a
- 8:58lot of money and like, Hang on shit and feel like they can have
- 9:02it for a lot of money but like it seems to me that there are
- 9:05two kind of sides of the spectrum here that they're
- 9:08trying to make meat in the middle of like regular people.
- 9:12That that's like, where I don't get it.
- 9:13Because in one sense, we have business, right?
- 9:15Like a, you have people that are like, oh we can do more
- 9:17efficient meetings with people all over the world by
- 9:19pretending, they're next to us, rather than doing shitty
- 9:21conference calls resumes. And then you have like the
- 9:24gaming World, which is like hyper connected people that have
- 9:27already sold into a world where their friends ends are people
- 9:30that they communicate with playing, whatever, Fortnight or
- 9:34OverWatch. And then like not that gaming is
- 9:37small and not the business is small, but the world that sock
- 9:39is explaining here is one in which were like, we've bought
- 9:42into it. Like there's the efficiency of
- 9:45connecting people over the world, and there's the social
- 9:47aspect of gaming. And I just think there's a huge
- 9:50hurdle to get to that point where people in the middle are
- 9:54going to be that interested in either either use case and with
- 9:58the technology, not even being close to good.
- 10:00It almost makes me wonder aside from the distraction element
- 10:03that Facebook is, you know, also pushing for here why anyone
- 10:06cares like, why are we talking about this so much right now,
- 10:09this reminds me so much of the flying cars and like, please, I
- 10:12could not give any fucks about the flying cars.
- 10:14Call me, call me, call me when they're in the air.
- 10:16Well, the reason is because people like to fantasize, I do
- 10:20think it's dilute it doesn't make sense, especially for the
- 10:22media and like professional media.
- 10:25People are worried about business to think about these
- 10:27Technologies so far. Our out.
- 10:30Like I do think that's that's irrational and the fact that we
- 10:33just like, we are trying to think of there were like uber
- 10:38obsessed with seasteading for a while.
- 10:40There were like there were all these weird debates.
- 10:43We would like fall in the actually I I'm still really
- 10:47interested in see static. You want to live on an oil rig,
- 10:51didn't you see the Saudis? We're trying to think of like an
- 10:53amusement park in oil rig? Just I mean I just I think the
- 10:56idea of living sort of in this like extra territorial space,
- 10:59it's like not Country. I mean, that was a part of think
- 11:02Scientology had going for. Yeah, I think that is actually
- 11:04an interesting idea. Hey, everyone to feel like
- 11:07they're out on the Seas. Should we should we turn towards
- 11:10the, the media asked? I guess we sort of already did,
- 11:13but there seemed to have been like, a couple of specific
- 11:15controversies that have come up in the post metaverse discourse.
- 11:20Like you got interviews was shocked or what?
- 11:23Yeah, basically that. And, and if and when they did
- 11:25it, did they ask the right questions that they should have
- 11:27give. Oh yeah, the Ben Thompson one's
- 11:29And I started tweaked him in my newsletter today.
- 11:31Yeah. Yeah.
- 11:32So basically, you know, there was sort of like two big,
- 11:35Facebook news dumps that happened this week one was the,
- 11:39you know, the Consortium, right? That was this week, right?
- 11:41That's Monday. When like, oh my God, wait, was
- 11:44it really your right time? Well, it sort of broke over the
- 11:49weekend, right? And the whole Friday, it's crazy
- 11:51that just happened, right? But right, so on Monday, they
- 11:54started having like the drip drip of stories coming out from
- 11:57what I really liked from Ben Smith.
- 11:59All of that. Casey Newton suggested they call
- 12:02it the leftovers because it's basically what it was right.
- 12:05It was like the stuff that the journalists like deemed not
- 12:07worthy of part of their series like got collected in the papers
- 12:10and then Francis Haugen's extremely skilled and Savvy.
- 12:13PR team, you know brought together a bunch of news
- 12:16organizations to analyze it and kind of incoordination put it
- 12:21out. And so there was all kinds of a
- 12:23can ringing about like who is included and you know what, the
- 12:27value of these kind of second, you know.
- 12:29Sloppy second stories were and then there was the duck
- 12:33interviews in which he spoke to see if I can get off.
- 12:36The top of my head here, he did interviews with the information,
- 12:38The Verge start a curry and Thompson, what else?
- 12:42Hey Casey, you got one, I wasn't sure.
- 12:44I think he got Andrew Bosworth and then was there anyone else?
- 12:48I think there may be one or two more but it wasn't the New York
- 12:51Times. It wasn't the Wall Street
- 12:52Journal was in The Washington Post.
- 12:53So now because the times the journal and the post were going
- 12:56through the leech company document, right?
- 12:59Virgil was the only one in the Consortium, right?
- 13:02That also got an interview. I think somebody said that.
- 13:05Yeah, yeah, that's that's right. So, that's you know, it wasn't
- 13:08like, I don't know if it was specific penalization.
- 13:11It fits into our theme of whether the Big Beat reporter
- 13:14should get interviews as we've argued about before.
- 13:17I think that there was probably a higher chance that they would
- 13:19have done interviews if they hadn't been writing stories
- 13:21saying that the company was evil and destroying democracy, I just
- 13:24seemed like it feels that way to me.
- 13:26It feels like that. Yeah, yeah.
- 13:28I mean, I think, just on the, the first, on the Consortium
- 13:32reading been story and having spoken to people at the journal
- 13:36about it before. Been story came out, I think I
- 13:38would be extremely distressed if I saw one of my sources say,
- 13:44it's been great working with you.
- 13:46But now I'm going to take this and kind of just work with a lot
- 13:49of other people because I didn't think you did exactly what I
- 13:53wanted. He did.
- 13:53Maybe that would that would be really like that kind of source
- 13:56management would be tough. Yeah, you know, like I don't
- 13:59know. The Wall Street Journal got such
- 14:01a big story out of the, they got a great story but I think that
- 14:04when you're working with a source who is really forthcoming
- 14:09with information, your hope is it that's not the end of your
- 14:12relationship with them. I think he wanted to write for a
- 14:15book. It seemed like their series was
- 14:17over. They continue to give
- 14:20information because I think that I would just say for me if I
- 14:25were to write a series of Stories on the topic that I
- 14:27thought was important about say the His Department.
- 14:30I don't think of it as, okay. Well, I've packaged up for great
- 14:34stories and that's it. I actually want to continue to
- 14:36get information right about the department.
- 14:39Hopefully, from the person who was helpful to me, right?
- 14:43I mean, part of it, not to flatter you too much, but you
- 14:46seem like the dominant justice department of where I feel like
- 14:50in tech there. Just like so many.
- 14:53It feels like they can get other good stuff whereas staying with
- 14:56like the top reporter on the beat He's in like the sources
- 15:00interests in some ways. I mean, there's like a tactic
- 15:03there's tactics but that but that's what was so interesting
- 15:06about this is that you could argue that because say in an in
- 15:10hypothetically, because I don't know, Jeff and I don't know what
- 15:13their relationship was like, but hypothetically, if she had a
- 15:15good relationship with him, people read The Wall Street
- 15:19Journal, incredibly widely, particularly the kinds of people
- 15:22who you want as a reader who will have that, you know, the
- 15:26particularly the people who can force some sort of Impact around
- 15:30the company Regulators. People in business investors,
- 15:34they are reading the Wall Street Journal.
- 15:36So, in a hypothetical world where the two of them have a
- 15:38really good relationship. You could imagine a world where
- 15:42the jury would be at least in the journals interest to keep
- 15:44this Source happy. Right.
- 15:48And but it seemed like a heat and keep her feeling like she
- 15:51will get as much out of simply just working with the journal as
- 15:54she will creating an enormous Consortium of like doesn't
- 15:58Publications. Whoo-hoo.
- 16:00All right, completely unoriginal stories because they're all
- 16:02amplifying the same five thing. For one of her issues I thought
- 16:05was Facebook's failure to moderate in developing countries
- 16:10to the same degree that it was and the US.
- 16:13And then that wasn't one of the major hits in the journal story
- 16:17and knowing the journal. It does seem like a place that
- 16:20isn't I mean to their credit. Almost like that isn't willing
- 16:23to do like fan service to their source as much.
- 16:26So I do wonder if there's a degree to which they sort of Did
- 16:29their series they didn't hit what she wanted with.
- 16:32That story have been with that story of been a bad story for
- 16:35the journal to do. First of all, you should have
- 16:37done it in the main series if that was their Source has also
- 16:40issued. Every I don't I think it's weird
- 16:43to think about investigative journalism is a series, I think
- 16:47of it. That's how they bought.
- 16:49They packaged it. Everyone, its packaging.
- 16:52Stories is one thing. People package stories for all
- 16:55sorts of reasons, but I think the mentality of okay, we wrote
- 16:58Our Force Stories. And now we can just move on.
- 17:02If you really believe that you want to interrogate our, why
- 17:07would you think of it that way, that that made no sense to me?
- 17:11That would be like me saying, well, I wrote a few stories
- 17:13about January 6 and, you know, March and April.
- 17:16So I think I did it, I'm done. That was very well would be
- 17:19very, which is she's laughed. She left, she's not a bell and I
- 17:23bear. It's hard to know.
- 17:26I mean, I guess we don't know if the journal initially when they
- 17:29got the It's they thought we should be the ones to own it or
- 17:32they just sort of said, you know, we're going to take what
- 17:34we can get from this person who clearly had a motive not motile
- 17:37to your motives, but she had a plan on what she wanted to do.
- 17:39I mean, we kind of could tell several days into the series
- 17:43that oh, she was going to testify cancer is dumb question.
- 17:46I should know the answer to, like, was it obvious in the
- 17:49journal story? That it was like a key
- 17:52whistleblower like they didn't presented that.
- 17:53Yeah. Because they said in their
- 17:55stories in the sourcing of their stories they said according to
- 17:58documents, From a whistleblower that have been given to the
- 18:01hill, like, that was often the execution right.
- 18:04Felt like they didn't present it as like, I don't know.
- 18:06I wasn't as personally obsessed about The Whistleblower reading,
- 18:09their series, as I was just about, like, the claims,
- 18:12whereas, if she wants to be a celebrity that's successful for
- 18:16them to say, in an ideal world is about the claims and not
- 18:21about Devin the personality, but there we go.
- 18:23But you think that was a mismanagement on the part of the
- 18:25journal? It just seemed that Francis.
- 18:27How good was it thing? I'm not saying even that it's a
- 18:29myth. On the part of the journal I'm
- 18:30saying that if I were the reporter I would be a little
- 18:35distressed. Yeah.
- 18:37To see because I wouldn't think she just gave this package of
- 18:40papers to Congress. She gave me a sneak preview so I
- 18:45could break them and package an interesting series.
- 18:49I would think this is a person with whom I'd want to have an
- 18:51ongoing relationship for a variety of reasons.
- 18:54Because sources are not only people who bring us information
- 18:58sources of people who helped us vet information.
- 19:01There are people with whom we discussed story ideas but
- 19:04fundamentally a great source is more powerful than a good
- 19:07reporter at this point and the trusting relationship goes to
- 19:10way. So the source trusts us to keep
- 19:12their identities, secret to the extent, they want to be secret
- 19:15and we also trust them to not tell other reporters when we are
- 19:20working on a story and we call them and say I want to work on a
- 19:24story right now about Margot over at Andreessen Horowitz and
- 19:27you trust that source that you speak with Eric tonight.
- 19:29Get on the fucking phone and then call Casey and say, Eric,
- 19:34just called me and said that he was working on a story.
- 19:36Well there are also people you do think are you doing that?
- 19:39And yeah and yeah, I don't consider them my sources but
- 19:43what do you do in those? So fine so she's not really
- 19:45their Source. I mean she effectively used the
- 19:47journal as a way to get her message out in the way that
- 19:50benefit me. The journal did independent
- 19:51reporting to kind of back it up and, you know, fill it out in a
- 19:56way that would give it more credibility than just a document
- 19:58dump. But what do you do in the case
- 20:00of a reporter where you've come across a source?
- 20:02Who's got an axe to grind, which he does.
- 20:04I mean, it's for the public good, but this is fundamentally
- 20:07her campaign and you're like, okay, I'm going to get these
- 20:11documents but it's only going to be exclusive for certain amount
- 20:14of time, but it also didn't seem from Ben Smith story that they
- 20:17were aware. That it was only going to be an
- 20:19exclusive for a certain amount of time.
- 20:21They were in shock on the phone call and like Jason Dean their
- 20:24editors had. This is very awkward, I just
- 20:26think it's hubris they had a huge crack at it like And I
- 20:30don't agree with you, I get what you're saying.
- 20:32I think you have a bunch of better pitch to a source, whose
- 20:34soda justice department are still in the loop of the justice
- 20:37department. What do you because?
- 20:39It's like the all of my sources are at the justice of sure.
- 20:41It makes zero sense. Okay.
- 20:42Okay. Wherever that wherever they're
- 20:44like just that you're the think the capital right story for
- 20:47example, just feels more ongoing like allies Facebook Stories are
- 20:52like, looking back at past practices, whereas an
- 20:54investigation is on going? Well, that's the interesting
- 20:57thing to do. You think that Facebook has
- 20:58changed their Practices. Do you think that anything these
- 21:01stories are framed as like this is what happened at this date,
- 21:05whereas like an investigation this Source has a clear reason
- 21:08to know why they would have more stuff.
- 21:10I'm mix on, I don't know because like the January 6 attack is
- 21:13literally looking back. A lot of the Scoops are about
- 21:15the nature of the investigation. Had there been subsequent
- 21:18attacks on the capital that I didn't hear about Eric.
- 21:20Holy shit, I should get off the phone, I should get on the
- 21:23phone. But what do you do?
- 21:24If you, you know, even into it at this point that you have a
- 21:27source that is going to go wide? In some way or start talking,
- 21:30other reporters. No idea.
- 21:32All I can drop that would be really distressing.
- 21:35Oh sure. It's incredibly stressful.
- 21:36That happened to have the the experience of talking to a
- 21:40source and you have this feeling in the back of your head, I
- 21:42think they may be talking to someone else and you kind of
- 21:45have to say. All right, let me be strategic
- 21:47here by what I tell this person. Like maybe I'm better than other
- 21:50reporters so I can use them in a more effective way.
- 21:52But fundamentally this changes the relationship and it's not
- 21:55like we wouldn't or haven't gone to other people's sources.
- 21:59And said, oh, I think I could tell this story.
- 22:02Well, you should talk to me to the, I mean, I know they're
- 22:05reporters who tell source of specifically do not tucked.
- 22:08Other reporters, do not do that. I think that sucks.
- 22:10I think that's weird. Okay, I don't do that.
- 22:12I think that's weird II. Don't tell them not to because
- 22:15you can't control them. I think it's bad that it's all
- 22:20so pathetic. Like it just kind of reveals the
- 22:23grade, right? Exactly a purpose behind
- 22:25scoopage and wanting to own a story.
- 22:27We really want to talk about. I feel like We if you got to do
- 22:30this job for like decades, you know, you're not going to scoop
- 22:33every story. Like you got some things are
- 22:35just maybe, maybe that's not the winning attitude.
- 22:38I'm supposed to bring to my job but it's like this is a long too
- 22:41long too long race. You know, right what is it
- 22:43projecting? That is a good strategy but I
- 22:45mean looking at the whistleblowers I mean have you
- 22:48seen some of these Tech whistleblowers on Twitter who
- 22:50are very angry that that they didn't get like worshipped like
- 22:54she did and it it's not a good look for them.
- 22:57It looks very like they. Want it to be about them.
- 23:01It is part of some larger cultural shift where we are.
- 23:04Just so all influencers. If yes, get me.
- 23:08Everything is so self-centered just in culture in general.
- 23:12And how much of that is Instagrams fault.
- 23:15Well, that's the only frame that I can understand the current
- 23:18whistleblower, boom, but this is like, you know, it's just it's
- 23:21just a different niche of influencer.
- 23:23I mean, my mind is literally worked right now because I just
- 23:26finished. The Susan Sontag biography the
- 23:28eighth good. You In Page biography of Susan,
- 23:31Sontag by Benjamin Missouri. But I mean you can't read that
- 23:36thing and not you can't read that thing in the 21st century
- 23:39especially when so much of it is about you know like note on Camp
- 23:43and on photography and not think about her writing in the context
- 23:49of something like Instagram, you know.
- 23:51Basically her making this like huge cultural argument that
- 23:54people are still arguing about. You cannot study photography
- 23:56without thinking about Sontag still arguing about.
- 23:59Whether or not the camera is a weapon and whether or not, it's
- 24:03like a form of like there is a theft there, and there is a way
- 24:07in which people lose control of themselves through image, and
- 24:10then to turn that camera on ourselves again.
- 24:12And again, every single day willingly, I mean it is very
- 24:17difficult to think about her cultural critique of Photography
- 24:21and not wonder how it has played out in this like exponential.
- 24:26I say, thanks to Instagram. Anyways, I totally total
- 24:31digression. But no, no, but not really
- 24:33though because it is any wonder that you have whistleblowers on
- 24:36writer being like, but I wanted to be the 60 Minutes
- 24:38whistleblower, right? And then to frame our jar,
- 24:42frustration with the Whistleblower sort of turning on
- 24:44the Wall Street Journal. It's just the Classic reporters,
- 24:47being mad. That influencers are like
- 24:49fucking everything up tweeting. I threw it.
- 24:52Like it's like why isn't it more controlled?
- 24:54Why isn't there just sort of like it's the same Dynamic
- 24:57outside of whistleblowers? Why was I don't think it's that
- 25:01simple. I don't think it's just like
- 25:02being upset because you don't get your way.
- 25:05I think it's saying if this means there's a fundamental
- 25:08shift in the way that sources see themselves, vis-à-vis.
- 25:12The media does that mean that the media has to make some sort
- 25:15of fundamental shift in the way that it sees how it deals with
- 25:18sourcing right at me like you don't you don't honor your
- 25:21agreements, you always honor your agreements.
- 25:22But does that mean, for example, the you that the best way to do,
- 25:26you know, investigative work is in the She model, which, which
- 25:30definitely predates these Facebook Stories, right?
- 25:33You had the Panama papers, that was a Consortium model you've
- 25:36had mean. Like this has happened before.
- 25:38You've seen Publications, like propublica consistently Tina,
- 25:41team up with other papers, like the guardian, like, the New York
- 25:44Times Like NPR. So I so it's not new.
- 25:46It's just like, okay, well, if this is the shift that's
- 25:48happening on the sourcing side, does that mean on the media
- 25:51side? There needs to be a shift.
- 25:52Yeah, that's the right way. I agree with that framing
- 25:55totally. And also I think like the
- 25:57framing of Answers as, you know, the base, superstructure of how
- 26:02these people, you know, view their role is incredibly
- 26:06relevant because they are talking to us.
- 26:09They like everyone, so media-savvy, like, that was sort
- 26:11of like, the big revelation of influencer culture.
- 26:14Was that people understand the concept of audience of fandom of
- 26:19distribution and I think because everyone that's on social media.
- 26:22Understands these things whistleblower is included or
- 26:25whatever employees that become whistleblowers included.
- 26:27They know when spots talking to her Order.
- 26:29They need to frame it in a certain way.
- 26:31That gets Maximum Impact. Yes.
- 26:33And like, so I'm talking to, you know, a lot of people I read
- 26:36about this company, go puff, which is this like delivery
- 26:39service. Oh my God, we obsessed with her
- 26:41go puff stories. Yeah, so, I mean, one of the
- 26:44people that was talking to me recently, like, giving me all
- 26:47this inside information about like the complaints that
- 26:49warehouse workers have and bicycle, you know, sorry that
- 26:52and drivers have, is she saw that?
- 26:54I was verified on Twitter and she was like, she's like, oh
- 26:57you're famous. Oh my God.
- 26:59Which is like, I didn't really want to push back on her that
- 27:02like, you know, a lot of reporters get verified, a lot of
- 27:04X reporters remain verified. It's a pretty useless reckon,
- 27:08but because I had that, I'm sure that's one of the reasons she
- 27:11was willing to talk to me so much because she saw it as like,
- 27:13oh, I'm I'm reaching big distribution here and it's, that
- 27:17kind of savviness that runs through all people these days
- 27:21that is, like, I think absolutely responsible for like,
- 27:24you know, whistleblower culture and like, you know, Wars among
- 27:27whistleblowers and people wanting to Fashion themselves in
- 27:30that way. It's crazy.
- 27:31It's totally crazy. I wanted to touch on Katie's
- 27:33question about like, how the media reacts.
- 27:36I mean, I would say to me like the most high-minded solution
- 27:40would be if we could be less obsessed with who published like
- 27:46the initial fact, it was gonna say like, the culture of like
- 27:48credit. For Scoops is very, very, very
- 27:51intense and the tech right reporting World in a way that
- 27:55it's less. So, I mean, in other player, I'm
- 27:58not saying that reporter. Everywhere don't do it but like
- 28:00really pretty, like a whole investigative project can be for
- 28:04investigative project to go viral.
- 28:05It's still very helpful to have new facts that aren't known to
- 28:09the public. Well, of course, that's
- 28:11reporting and but there's a degree to, which if it's like,
- 28:13you put all the pieces together and have the narrative and have
- 28:18obviously, you have new facts but they're the sort of B and C
- 28:21plot facts. Not like the, I don't know.
- 28:24The like I mean the Instagram case with the teen girls, right?
- 28:27Like you have this study out. Like say that study comes out in
- 28:32some like, quick piece at Forbes or something.
- 28:36Like, if the journal turns around and writes the story
- 28:39thoughtfully like they did. It just has less impact because
- 28:42we're sort of addicted to who got the detail out.
- 28:46And I mean, that's why Outlets front run and Sarah stories in
- 28:49the past that social media made women feel bad and there was the
- 28:54empirical evidence of women talking about it online that it
- 28:57made them feel bad. So, I mean, it's It wasn't a new
- 29:00condom me, this was powerful because Facebook knew it was
- 29:02powerful because Facebook what the story was saying.
- 29:05The Facebook knew this internally based on their own
- 29:08research and lied about it. Yeah, I'm still iffy on what you
- 29:12know about that story, but that's a whole different can of
- 29:16worms but the metaverse nobody owned that story.
- 29:20Although, although there were the Scoops about the fact that
- 29:22Mark was going to be announcing it in.
- 29:25Oh yeah. I mean what?
- 29:27Which that is going to eat. Alex, he's breaking the Change.
- 29:29I mean, terms of like single fact, scoop that's it's big and
- 29:34it's not culturally, but it's just like, it's certainly one of
- 29:37the new cycle that evening and then right was 00 pop if your
- 29:40job is to get a bunch of people to think your name and their
- 29:42brains, it was a very successful scoop I don't know if that's
- 29:46really the job but yeah, succeeded on that metric.
- 29:49I'm very skeptical of the I mean I think that it is good to be
- 29:53competitive and important to get Scoops and it is essential in
- 29:57our jobs. And but I Terms of like what we
- 30:00do for a living. I think what we do for a living,
- 30:03it's such a cliche but we write the first page of history and
- 30:05then we are forgotten like we're not we're not a thing anymore.
- 30:09Like we're not going to be a thing.
- 30:10We're just, we're delivering like the raw material that like
- 30:14a historian, who is a thing is going to use.
- 30:17So that's, that's why you gotta gotta get the opinion game here,
- 30:20you know? Yeah.
- 30:21I don't think I don't think that's any more last.
- 30:23I'm trying to move away from the the Raw Deal scoop and more.
- 30:27And I mean, framing things up. I mean I want least arity be one
- 30:31of the nine hundred million different.
- 30:37I think it's becoming its commoditized.
- 30:39I think it's more like time and thoughtfulness are what will be
- 30:44the most important things? And like those are those and I'm
- 30:49actually just totally fine with it like like named me the person
- 30:53who got us all the Iran-Contra Affair Scoops.
- 30:56He got none of us person, right? But those were Really, really,
- 30:59really fucking important stories.
- 31:01And it doesn't make it less important just because
- 31:03literally, no one can remember the name of the person who broke
- 31:05the stories, right? See where you really need.
- 31:08You need an infrastructure to self, mythologize the scoop you
- 31:11break is soon as you break it so that it gets into the history
- 31:15ography right away. You and Francis Haugen come back
- 31:20together. Yeah, well, I will say, my first
- 31:22reaction to the 60 Minutes interview that she gave and she
- 31:25started tweeting, she made a Twitter account and she was
- 31:27like, you know, I released that whatever it was.
- 31:29Like announcement of herself as part of 60 Minutes thing.
- 31:31I looked at her follower count, it was like, 4,000, I'm like,
- 31:34ooh, Francis not good enough, you're not what she?
- 31:38I know. It's not great, honestly,
- 31:41really? You know, I don't know how much
- 31:42he's paying her PR team but it's not the kind of work she'd be,
- 31:45you know, she looks kind of a CPR team.
- 31:48Yeah, she clearly does. I think these Scoops are over?
- 31:50I like I think in six months we're not going to be talking
- 31:53about her. I mean, 82,000 I don't know, I
- 31:56know sometimes journalists Dancing with the Stars.
- 31:59Next right. Right.
- 32:00I would assume you know, assuming you know that they
- 32:03bring production of Puerto Rico. She should, she should
- 32:05definitely be considered mean the journal had high impact
- 32:08stories and I agree with Casey. The rest have been left over as
- 32:12right. Does it me disagree with that?
- 32:14Yeah, I honestly haven't read them.
- 32:15So I'm going to, I don't know, she's eighty two thousand five
- 32:19hundred followers. That's okay.
- 32:21That's okay. I'm going, I'm going to follow
- 32:24her now. Click there, 80 2501, there's an
- 32:28mft. Account.
- 32:29I follow that has way way above that.
- 32:33Like, what? She tweeting about now like
- 32:34succession or like, what's, like, what's next?
- 32:37That's always a funny thing about these people to me like, I
- 32:39followed it, you know, Snowden. And you know, that guy's, he's
- 32:42pretty committed to the bit, you know.
- 32:43He's still living in Russia and, you know, so only because you
- 32:46can't come back, right? Yeah.
- 32:48That's probably, I think he's committed to the bit.
- 32:50I think he's just in. Exile.
- 32:52Yeah, but that's the thing about a whistleblowers.
- 32:54You got to think. Like, all right, I'm past this
- 32:56point, you know, Chelsea Manning for example, I mean that's been
- 32:59a Pretty difficult transition from being whistleblower to go
- 33:02into jail to coming out. Yeah, because when you're, when
- 33:05you're disclosing classified information, it's a little bit
- 33:08different than taking a bunch of documents from Facebook, right?
- 33:10Fortunately for us corporations, don't yet have statutes
- 33:15dedicated to Prosecuting people who take information out of
- 33:18their corporations, I don't want our conversation to be read is
- 33:21talking about jealousy manicure Snowden.
- 33:24I feel like they're in. Yeah, and it's very separate,
- 33:26that's sort of a different kind of case.
- 33:27The Lange she has Nine tweets. I mean it's just you're not
- 33:32going to get a lot of engagement at that level.
- 33:33They got to be really good tweets.
- 33:34Each time you just gotta eat one has five to each one, seems have
- 33:40five to ten thousand retweets. She's tuned.
- 33:42Okay Twenty-One thousand retweets.
- 33:44That's a high hit rate, it's a good rate.
- 33:46I just I just kind of in 80,000 followers with just nine tweets,
- 33:53that's pretty good. Have you like our citizens
- 33:55beside Eric, you can't tell me you were not even mildly
- 33:58entertained by the fact that Is she like is a crypto
- 34:00millionaire. Well, yeah, he lives is a great
- 34:02been. Smin is the best, probably the
- 34:05best journalists out there right now.
- 34:07I mean, he's killing it, at least on topics.
- 34:09I'm interested in that's gonna say, what part of it is just
- 34:12that the journals boring, you know.
- 34:14It's just not their sensibility, like you wouldn't they do, they
- 34:18have anyone who's writing that type of story there?
- 34:20I'm sure they, well, they don't, but they don't have that.
- 34:23I mean, like basically Margaret Sullivan, I'm Ben Smith are very
- 34:27different in the way that they approach, like, being a medium.
- 34:29Media columnists, and like pretty much anyone else friends,
- 34:31having a good time. And he's also asking the
- 34:33questions, you know, specifically about Francis that
- 34:35I was amazed. No one really asked before that,
- 34:37which is like, What's your deal? Where is she right now?
- 34:40How does she have the money to make this work?
- 34:41Well, people are starting to wonder, I do think there is a
- 34:44motivate these people, the omidyar thing at already come
- 34:47out. So then there were real
- 34:48questions about she was making her money.
- 34:51And I do think she's like, oh, I have my Bitcoin money, but then,
- 34:55I mean, they're paying for, like her lawyers.
- 34:57Still, I you think there was a little bit of Downplaying, how
- 35:00much immediate arrow is a big player in her apparatus, which,
- 35:05even if it doesn't affect her sort of personal wealth, the
- 35:08fact that she's not having to spend her personal.
- 35:10Wealth is a Big Boon. I mean, I'm not that cynical of
- 35:14her, but I do think they were, like, messaging games going
- 35:17around that whole circumstance. Exactly.
- 35:21All right, how do we wrap this one up?
- 35:22Eric are you think the media has has so much ketchup to play on
- 35:27influencer culture? I like Was why I think the media
- 35:31should stay away from influencer culture.
- 35:32We should not. I'm cheerleading for them to
- 35:35collide. I don't want, I'm not an
- 35:36influencer. I'm just I'm like I'm mining.
- 35:39Little pieces of information, and putting them in the public
- 35:42and then someday, I'll retire. That's Eric, is I want, I want
- 35:45them to be the same like, but think about it, from the
- 35:48journalistic perspective. If influencers and journalists
- 35:51are held to the same standards that puts him, I mean, you know,
- 35:55to Circle back on something and we were talking about Ben
- 35:59Thompson. As trajectory interviewing Mark
- 36:01Zuckerberg and Tom and I were having this argument about
- 36:04whether he should be held to the same standard as journalists or
- 36:08not. And I think he's playing the
- 36:10role of a journalist. He's interviewing Mark
- 36:12Zuckerberg! Hold him to the same standard.
- 36:14When is that Galifianakis interviewed Barack Obama on
- 36:17Between Two Ferns, was he supposed to be held to the same
- 36:20standards of journals? Just who's interviewing
- 36:21somebody, when Oprah Winfrey interview, somebody should she
- 36:24be held to the same standard as a reporter Because She
- 36:27interviewed them, this is absurd.
- 36:29Word. No, that's why you take your ass
- 36:31to those people to be interviewed.
- 36:33And you don't take your ass over to the Washington.
- 36:35Post in Marty Baron, who will Grill, you like journalists?
- 36:38There's a reason for this? No I don't think that Mark.
- 36:41What's his face? Should be held to the same
- 36:44standard for the only standard is that you maintain your
- 36:46shtick. So Dylan Byers is like I'm
- 36:49sucking up to you because I always suck up to everybody
- 36:52that's not that's not criticize about and that's why that's why
- 36:55somebody that's why somebody would go to Dylan Byers, hoping
- 36:57to get that treatment. Ali, but it's not criticize a
- 37:00bowl because that's his stick. Yeah.
- 37:02I don't think it's, I don't think you should be held to the
- 37:04same standard as Marty Baron. No, no.
- 37:07I don't think Oprah should be held to the same standard as
- 37:09Marty Baron when she's interviewing Megan.
- 37:10What's her name, Markle? I don't like it.
- 37:13There's clearly a threshold say there was like, a key fact, we
- 37:15needed to know from like, Mark Zuckerberg they could be asking
- 37:18the question and the only thing he goes to his Between Two
- 37:21Ferns, you don't think it's like, criticize the Wolves a
- 37:24cough and a kiss. Doesn't try.
- 37:26Try to get an answer. I think the choice is more
- 37:28criticize. More than the actual I think
- 37:30that. Yeah.
- 37:30I think the choice is criticized Apple.
- 37:32I think what Zuckerberg trying to do by making the choice is
- 37:35criticized Apple. But I don't think that everybody
- 37:38should be held to the standard of a beat reporter at a major
- 37:43publication or an editor like a Marty Baron ordained by K.
- 37:46That's fucking crazy. The whole reason you're going to
- 37:49Oprah is because you don't want Oprah to ask the question that
- 37:52Marty would ask. Well, I guess what what that
- 37:55requires is that we the audience still has the ability to tell
- 37:58the difference I guess. Is between sort of money here
- 38:01audio. I mean, I hope that the audience
- 38:02could tell the difference between Marty Baron that
- 38:04Galifianakis and Oprah Winfrey. That's my propun prayer.
- 38:07And then we have people like Dylan Byers, who try to pass as
- 38:11one thing will be another. I don't know you guys you guys
- 38:16don't watch reality television but I mean you know I've never
- 38:18said I didn't hear you know, after having a podcast you have
- 38:21to have a second podcast about your like little hobby.
- 38:23You know I want a Survivor podcast or you need to start
- 38:26thinking now about what the it like this.
- 38:29Second one, this sort of lighter and just expanding our brand
- 38:32personalities. Is because because that's
- 38:34coming, Eric unit charges money working with your friends video.
- 38:41Listen we need to build out. Kitty, you have your fast, it's
- 38:44that you're not mining for content right now that that are
- 38:47appealing to an audience. And oh my God, I have like a
- 38:50normal person's job dude, I'm just like a little you're
- 38:55letting in my living charm. Go to waste only way your
- 38:58friends. Enjoy it.
- 38:59Not not monetizing. I just think it's sad.
- 39:03I know sometimes I just like having friends.
- 39:06This is a generational issue. I think it is because I'm
- 39:09fucking old. Yeah, yeah.
- 39:10I think the fact that Katie doesn't believe in like mining
- 39:13all aspects of her personality till she's just an empty husk
- 39:17willing to be filled by whatever PR person for the fans.
- 39:20Mining her personality, till she's an empty husk for the fans
- 39:24can't because it seems to be working out so well for other
- 39:26people who've done that. Yeah, the point is that we want
- 39:29the Answer take equity in us personally.
- 39:31And so I do. So, can we do an mft?
- 39:33Yeah, that's that's I think we're all ultimately headed
- 39:35isn't once? Yeah, I would do that.
- 39:37You have a little kitty cat as our image if you don't think,
- 39:40and if T is no, we own that too. Listen, I'm not.
- 39:44I don't decide that I don't, I don't objected digitizing
- 39:50something about the podcast and having Eric salad,
- 39:53unfortunately, per our contract, all the proceeds accrue to him.
- 39:57No, not that podcast know that I didn't specify.
- 40:01Yeah, this podcast is mutually the audience that gets driven to
- 40:04the newsletter. That's Eric's, but the people
- 40:06that love us for us, those are, those are legitimate.
- 40:09Those are people that we have equity and, or they have equity
- 40:11in us actually. And once, once the true nft
- 40:14crypto Market takes hold, and people can start trading their
- 40:17ownership of Eric. Katie, and me, I think that's
- 40:20when they're the true large as happens.
- 40:22And that's when we finally transition from journalists to
- 40:24influencers and and the cycle is complete and we're probably more
- 40:27powerful is because of it. And people Don't hold us to
- 40:29journalistic standards that we've already established think.
- 40:32Yeah, I feel that's a good, a place as any to end Silicon
- 40:43Valley. So work on Sally, goodbye.
- 40:56Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 40:58Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 40:59Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 40:59Goodbye.