Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / From Opera to Seminary: How Music Shapes Faith and Life with Becky Robinson-Lavenberg
Transcript
- 0:00Coming up on the Together for Good podcast, I am sitting down
- 0:03and talking with Becky Robinson Lavenberg and we are discussing
- 0:07the ways that music effects our life.
- 0:09Becky is a professional musician, A mezzo soprano
- 0:12singer, also studying to be a mental health counselor.
- 0:14So she's got some great insight on how all of these pieces fit
- 0:17together. I'm looking forward to this.
- 0:19Hope you are too. Here we go.
- 0:20Welcome to the Together for Good podcast, a podcast created by
- 0:24Bethany Lutheran Church in Cherry Hills Village, Co and
- 0:27hosted by me, Pastor Nate Pricinger and Together for Good.
- 0:31Our goal is to provide practical, engaging content that
- 0:35supports you without expectations.
- 0:37Whether you're feeling disconnected from traditional
- 0:40religion or simply exploring what faith means in your life,
- 0:43we are here to walk alongside you.
- 0:46No matter where you are on your journey of faith, we're glad
- 0:49you're here. Welcome to Together for Good.
- 0:52OK, Becky, here we are. Here we are.
- 0:54We've talked about doing this for a long time, so I'm really
- 0:56glad that it finally worked out. Yeah, me too.
- 0:59And I just want to start by you sharing a little bit.
- 1:02You have such an interesting background and especially
- 1:05compared to some of the other people that I've talked with.
- 1:07Not that there's not interesting, but just growing up
- 1:10in a really musical household and having that as such an
- 1:13important piece of your character from the beginning, if
- 1:16I remembering the story correctly.
- 1:18Go ahead. Just tell us a little bit about
- 1:19your upbringing and yeah, how those pieces fit together.
- 1:22Sure. Yeah.
- 1:23So I am the daughter of two professional orchestral
- 1:27musicians. I grew up just outside New York
- 1:29City. My dad played in the New York
- 1:30Philharmonic and my mom played in the New Jersey Symphony.
- 1:34I'm the youngest of three, and I was the only one who had any
- 1:36inclination toward music. So I was their last hope to read
- 1:39the family Doors and. Your siblings aren't musicians
- 1:42at all. No, not at all.
- 1:43One's a doctor. One works in sustainable
- 1:45business. Wow, I didn't know that.
- 1:47OK, I or I didn't remember you saying.
- 1:49That my middle sister can crush a karaoke way better than I can.
- 1:52But yeah, no like formal interest in music.
- 1:55Interesting. OK, so then as the youngest, you
- 1:57were the last hope. Yeah, they're 13 and 11 years
- 2:00older than me, so I there was a. They thought all hope was lost.
- 2:03They thought all hope was lost. Exactly.
- 2:05And they were like, yes, we got one.
- 2:07I did. I did have a sort of natural
- 2:10inclination towards singing at a very young age.
- 2:12And because my parents are musicians, I think they knew
- 2:17what to look for, what to listen for.
- 2:20Where I don't think you can, I think especially with the voice,
- 2:24because it's biological, there are certain things you can't.
- 2:27I always tell people like you can't be a prodigious young
- 2:30singer. You can be a prodigious young
- 2:31piano player, but I think there's my godmother was a
- 2:35singer and she wouldn't even let me take voice lessons until I
- 2:37was 13, just because there's so much.
- 2:40Can you like mess it up? Yeah, you can just learn bad
- 2:42habits. You can learn to imitate people
- 2:46versus like actually learning your own instrument.
- 2:49I think that's what's so special about the voice, right?
- 2:51It's like I have this instrument that only I can play, but I
- 2:56can't see or touch it, which I think is such a bizarre notion.
- 3:01And you have a voice that only you can play.
- 3:04And so I think kids who have a really good ear, I think like
- 3:06the best thing you can do is put them in like a choir if they
- 3:10want to sing, just cuz I think you can learn some really
- 3:12wonderful fundamentals of music without putting the pressure on
- 3:14them. Don't sound a certain way.
- 3:16Yeah, and did you sing in choirs?
- 3:18Yeah, so I started singing in the Metropolitan Opera
- 3:20Children's Chorus when I was 7. That strikes me as something
- 3:24that you don't just walk into. There were a lot of adjectives
- 3:29describing that choir. There are a lot of adjectives.
- 3:32They were probably even more in the 90s, not also not all great.
- 3:35They actually the audition is really straightforward.
- 3:38They have you sing happy birthday in about 12 different
- 3:42keys and and that's it. I think it to this day, that's
- 3:45still the audition process. But in the same sense, they're
- 3:48not taking just anyone. You had to have some capacity or
- 3:51shows some talent at that point even though.
- 3:54They picked happy birthday because actually it's rather
- 3:56challenging to sing. So I'm sure you've heard it
- 3:59plenty of times at a restaurant where you're like, that's an
- 4:01interesting rendition. Yes, it's actually, it's got
- 4:03like some challenging intervals in it.
- 4:05And so that's why they pick it. And it's a good way to test a
- 4:08kid's range in their ear. And some of those like Innate
- 4:11musical. Abilities, yeah.
- 4:15And then I was put into the chorus and you learn a lot in
- 4:18the beginning and you never on stage.
- 4:20I wasn't on stage maybe for probably until I was about 10.
- 4:23So I spent like first couple years, maybe 9, spent a couple
- 4:27years just going to rehearsals every week, learning the
- 4:30repertoire. Then once you're on stage and
- 4:33you're like in those shows, you're expected to be at
- 4:35rehearsals in the middle of a school day and you're expected
- 4:39to, you can't miss the like school is not an excuse.
- 4:42Traffic is not an excuse. High commitment level.
- 4:45High commitment level, yeah. Which is how musicians always
- 4:47are. Let's just.
- 4:48We're like, it's high. Very.
- 4:51Pedantic bunch, yes. No, it's true.
- 4:54And I think my parents, I've been thinking about this a lot
- 4:56lately. They, I think, really saw the
- 4:59value in that as an educational experience versus a classroom
- 5:03experience in terms of, and my dad always used to say that I
- 5:06have all my dad's isms in my head, but one of the ones that
- 5:08sticks with me most is never trade an extraordinary
- 5:12experience for an ordinary 1. And so I think from his
- 5:14perspective, like this is something extraordinary that I
- 5:16got to do. So I missed 52 days of 7th grade
- 5:20because at that point I was in basically any show that had a
- 5:23child in it, I was in it. They kick you out once you hit
- 5:26puberty because you don't fit the costumes anymore and you
- 5:28don't look like a kid on stage. And for the boys, their voice
- 5:31starts to change and there is a cap on how long you can do that
- 5:35for. But you clearly kept singing and
- 5:40so you didn't because that level of intensity also seems like it
- 5:45can often make or break an individual.
- 5:48And so we're like getting to this point with my son right now
- 5:50where he he's playing in more and more competitive soccer
- 5:52situations and soccer, youth soccer is crazy because I feel
- 5:58like what he's doing for an 11 year old is so much.
- 6:01And he is honestly like the bottom tier of what this could
- 6:05be at his age. He was telling me too, there's
- 6:08this kid in my school plays on Platinum.
- 6:10I'm like, where is platinum? And he like lists all the things
- 6:13like, Oh my gosh. And I'm wondering he just has,
- 6:18he has three practices a week and a game on the weekends or a
- 6:20tournament. And I'm like, this is going to
- 6:22break him. Like he's just going to quit
- 6:24because he's going to be so sick of it.
- 6:26I mean, I actually think that analogs between a really sort of
- 6:28serious music study and sports are very apartment.
- 6:31It's a very apartment to comparison, not only because of
- 6:34the expected commitment that you're talking about, but also
- 6:36what it does for your brain and that sort of thing, like what it
- 6:39teaches you fundamentally. Say a bit about that.
- 6:41What does it teach you? Fundamentally, I.
- 6:42Think like a team sport and singing in a kids choir for
- 6:46example. I think they teach you a lot
- 6:48about collaboration, teach you a lot about paying attention to
- 6:51your peers, not just focusing on yourself.
- 6:54Again, is part of why I think like choir is a great
- 6:56environment for a kid for a lot of reasons, but I think it
- 6:59teaches some of those sort of soft skills and I think that it
- 7:05develops. You learn tenacity.
- 7:06You learn this sort of. Grit.
- 7:08Focus, grit, and I think the they both accomplish it by
- 7:13different means, but I think they serve the same purpose in
- 7:16teaching those skills. So I I played trumpet all
- 7:19through high school and college and had the private teacher.
- 7:22My mom really wanted all of her children to be musicians and so
- 7:26worked with the trumpet professor at one of the small
- 7:29local colleges from 8th grade through high school.
- 7:33And what he always said is he said he's like the best trumpet
- 7:37players are swimmers or the best musicians, he said, are swimmers
- 7:41because a swimmer goes down and comes back and goes down and
- 7:46comes back. And he's, that's what it takes
- 7:48to be a good musician is he's you need to do your scales, you
- 7:51need to do your lip slurs. You need to do your low
- 7:54register. You need right.
- 7:55Like he had this whole rant that I heard so many times the course
- 7:58of my study with him. But I there's something to that.
- 8:02And more to the point, too, this is a life skill, which is where
- 8:06I think you were going with all this too, right?
- 8:07Like, it really is a life skill to learn that grit and that
- 8:10tenacity. And yeah, I tell my kids all the
- 8:12time, like, life is boring. You need to learn how to be
- 8:14bored. I was just actually about to
- 8:15say, didn't you tell me earlier this summer that like, a lot of
- 8:18life is learning how to manage your boredom?
- 8:20Yeah. And I thought about this a lot
- 8:22since you mentioned it because I was like, that is so true.
- 8:25And I do think that stuff is boring.
- 8:27That stuff is like mind numbingly boring.
- 8:29Yeah. And in order to build up that
- 8:32base so that you can do the fun stuff, because the artists I'm
- 8:35not, I still, I don't do it. I don't sing opera
- 8:37professionally anymore because the time commitment is just.
- 8:40Immense. It's immense and I made a
- 8:43difficult decision around the time I was 30 ish to no longer
- 8:47sing full time. And but the thing I miss is the
- 8:50fun stuff, right? I miss playing dress up for a
- 8:52living. I don't get to do that anymore.
- 8:54But the leg work is really it's work.
- 8:58And I think you only see the tip of the iceberg.
- 9:00You only get to we don't watch the team practices.
- 9:03Maybe as a parent you do, right. For the most part.
- 9:05You see the games like we watch the game on TV.
- 9:08We don't see the quarter. Hours and hours. 18,000 passes.
- 9:13I've thought about that boredom quote a lot and I was like.
- 9:16And I think when we were talking earlier this summer too, I also
- 9:19mentioned I have the aha moment watching the Olympics last
- 9:21summer too, where I'm like, oh, in another life, I was an
- 9:24Olympian. And then I thought more about
- 9:26like, that would be miserable because of the repetitions, just
- 9:29the sheer amount of work that has to go into that.
- 9:32But so you did this. I did do this.
- 9:34You really did not. Always so diligently.
- 9:37I will admit that I think certain things came easily to
- 9:39me, so I didn't have to learn the hard work.
- 9:41Until a little later on when all of a sudden my pond got a lot
- 9:44bigger and I was like, oh, now I have to learn the hard work.
- 9:47That came a little later for me because I was able to coast on
- 9:51being the little bit of an anomaly and in the form of a
- 9:54child who was like opera. And especially because I grew up
- 9:58outside New York, so many kids wanted to be on Broadway.
- 10:01And I was like, I could literally couldn't care less
- 10:04about this. So I think I got to ride my
- 10:07little bit of a weirdo wave in my love of classical music, but
- 10:12then I got increasingly bigger pawns and then all.
- 10:14Of a sudden, which I'm sure was because of your parents.
- 10:18I gotta think in a household with two professional
- 10:21instrumental musicians that like my parents, played The Beatles,
- 10:24sometimes the oldie stations, whereas I'm guessing they put on
- 10:28like Brahms in your household. We played guess the composer.
- 10:32I did not do that, yeah. I know.
- 10:34I don't think many people did that.
- 10:36Yeah, we did a lot of that. And my, my dad, especially my
- 10:40dad, my mom, she branched out a little, but she fell asleep at a
- 10:43Jimi Hendrix concert. So that gives you an idea of fur
- 10:46level commitment to anything other than her craft.
- 10:49My dad wouldn't even go. He didn't know my mom at the
- 10:51time. But had she said, hey, I have
- 10:53two tickets to see Jimi Hendrix, he'd be like, why would I want
- 10:57to do that? It doesn't.
- 10:58He can't even. Where is the chamber music?
- 11:00Yeah. So very much.
- 11:03And then I had a godmother who we met at our church growing up
- 11:07and it was like fluke thing. But anyway, she had a
- 11:10professional career as a singer and she's like a dead ringer for
- 11:14Doris Day. She really lived in the heyday
- 11:16of opera when you travelled with hat boxes and things like that.
- 11:19And she just had everything about her world was like,
- 11:23glamorous. And she had been diagnosed with
- 11:27breast cancer in her early 40s anyway, but it stopped her
- 11:32career pretty abruptly. And so by the time I knew her,
- 11:35she hadn't been singing for decades that she still had.
- 11:38She had all these posters of her productions and La Scala and she
- 11:43just at the Med and. They were these.
- 11:45Big black and white posters that lined her home and somebody had
- 11:48made a of doll replica her in one of her costumes.
- 11:52Everything was so glamorous, so I had her as a role model too.
- 11:55Absolutely. Which definitely I think
- 11:57informed my it was. Especially because it, yeah,
- 12:00because it was not one of your parents.
- 12:03So you could look up to her and see this person as a role model
- 12:07because we would never do that for our parents.
- 12:08I don't think it's just not. It's just not how it works.
- 12:11But you mentioned there you met her because of a church
- 12:15connection. And that's also like a big part
- 12:17of this whole story, I think especially because of the type
- 12:20of music that you sing and the type of music that the classical
- 12:25music, that type of work, a lot of it is church music or
- 12:29originally was. You could probably say more
- 12:31about this than I can, but one of my favorite things, Bach is
- 12:35renowned as such an accomplished musician and he wrote church
- 12:40music. And I don't think people realize
- 12:42that all the time, like almost everything was for this Sunday,
- 12:46right? Like the 11th Sunday, the 12th
- 12:47Sunday and the way that like, and I'm sure he's just one
- 12:52example of many, but people tended to write this music for
- 12:55the church fair. Oh yeah, Actually one of the
- 12:58most like profound moments I had in a voice lesson was with my
- 13:03grad school teacher. He was like a very pre eminent
- 13:07performer of Bach. And that's where a lot of, like,
- 13:09my love of Bach's music comes from, was just learning it
- 13:12through him. There's a lot of pressure in
- 13:15opera to like, put your stamp on something, right, to your
- 13:20interpretation. And I was working on something
- 13:22and he stopped me and said, listen, Bach wasn't trying to
- 13:26convert anyone. He like, stop proselytizing and
- 13:31sing the music. And I was, it was such a
- 13:33liberating notion to me. It sounds harsh or something.
- 13:36And he didn't mean it like that at all.
- 13:37He was just saying you don't need to.
- 13:41You don't need to do the interpreting.
- 13:42It's all in the music here. And his point was like, Bach
- 13:45wasn't trying to. As far as Bach was concerned,
- 13:48everyone in the room was a believer.
- 13:50He didn't need to convert them. They were there.
- 13:53And so I think it just, it alleviated me from this burden
- 13:57that I think I always felt with more traditional opera, which is
- 14:00I have to make this mine. And he was like, no, make it
- 14:04boss and be really good at it. And that is a real mindset shift
- 14:08is what I'm hearing you say is that opera is about the
- 14:11performer in so many ways of give us your interpretation of
- 14:14this using your as using your phrase, right?
- 14:16Like your instrument, your unique voice.
- 14:19But this is more that there's something deeper going on, but
- 14:25that with the church music, there's something more that you
- 14:28just need to trust in and allow it to be.
- 14:31His point was like, it's all in there and you don't need to
- 14:34reinvent the wheel with it. Be really good at doing it, but
- 14:38you don't. And I think that was one of my
- 14:42strengths when I was singing more full time was like, I was
- 14:44good at doing. I wasn't always great at this
- 14:47creative interpretation. So actually when people say you
- 14:50must be so creative, I'm like, no, I don't think of myself as a
- 14:54terribly creative person. I think I was like a really good
- 14:57sort of doer of the thing. I was like a good, I don't know,
- 15:01that's a clunky way to say it, but I think that's why I don't
- 15:04think of myself as super creative because they're not my
- 15:07ideas. I'm just a channel for somebody
- 15:10else's ideas. And I think his point about
- 15:12Bach's music is like everything. He put everything you need in
- 15:17the music, and the music was for the church.
- 15:22And so you would just stop trying to convert people?
- 15:26Like just let it be what it'll be.
- 15:28What it is, because it's all in there, and I found that
- 15:31personally liberating. And it's also like particularly
- 15:35on point with Bach because it really is all in there.
- 15:38It's so complicated. More to the point on all this
- 15:40too, is that because of singing, you found yourself in church a
- 15:46lot. I did, yeah.
- 15:47And what was your kind of experience of that growing up,
- 15:52especially because people, there's a typical kind of life
- 15:57cycle as it comes to involvement and participation in communities
- 16:01of faith where it's like you go as a kid because you're dragged
- 16:04there. And then as soon as you have the
- 16:05option to not go, you decide to duck out most of the time unless
- 16:09you've really found connection. And then maybe you cycle back
- 16:12later on in life or maybe not. But.
- 16:15That was like, that was like mostly my trajectory.
- 16:19So my parents, they were all, they grew up church going.
- 16:23They were, but they were never committed to any like specific,
- 16:28not even a specific denomination because they picked their music
- 16:33or they picked their churches based off of the music program
- 16:35and who had the music, who had the music where they wanted to
- 16:38go and listen every week. Yeah.
- 16:40And who actually had professional behind the wheel,
- 16:43so to speak, when it came to the Oregon in the choir and all
- 16:46that? I want to talk about that.
- 16:47Yeah, Because. And you were saying before we
- 16:51hit record that that was always your mindset too, because that's
- 16:53what you've been told. Like, no, you pick it for the
- 16:55music program. What do you mean people pick it
- 16:56for something else? How do you differentiate that?
- 16:59What is it about a church offering a great music program
- 17:04that's different than if that's really your priority?
- 17:07Like just go to the Symphony because the Symphony is going to
- 17:09be better anyways, probably. True.
- 17:12So I imagine though in your mindset and your family's
- 17:15mindset, there is a distinction here in.
- 17:18Their case they'd be like go to both, we have your solution.
- 17:24There's not a Symphony performing at 10 AM on a Sunday.
- 17:27No, I was going to say like we were talking about before we hit
- 17:30record, they had their order of priority.
- 17:31So it wasn't just the music that was not that was the first
- 17:36litmus test that a church had a path.
- 17:37Then they really they preferred at least this is how I
- 17:40understand it. They've never said in so many
- 17:42words, but they preferred churches where the sort of
- 17:46pastoral and preaching staff were really well educated in not
- 17:52just their lane. They like the sort of diversity
- 17:55of thought, and I think that found they found that more
- 18:00spiritually engaging to be able to look at Christianity in the
- 18:04context of the broader world. A number of different yeah
- 18:09areas, OK. And not just I think, because I
- 18:13say so. Theology just never flu for
- 18:17them. And I think so.
- 18:18And then I would say like other things trickled down from there.
- 18:22They wanted a sense of community.
- 18:24So why not just go to the Symphony?
- 18:26I think for me, it's the church serves a different function in
- 18:29my life. It's not there to entertain me.
- 18:32Where is the symphonies there to entertain me?
- 18:34But so for them it was like in what order do they have to pass
- 18:37the bar? Yeah, no.
- 18:39So that's a really good point. And I think when some people
- 18:43hear you say, oh, you just picked the church based on the
- 18:45music program and who knows what they're doing, that where a lot
- 18:48of people's mind goes is, oh, then it's all just about
- 18:50entertainment. Yeah, I also think though the
- 18:53the music program for, at least for my parents, was indicative
- 18:57of those other things too. Fair.
- 18:59Because certain church traditions that have maybe a
- 19:03music program that was less appealing to them are also then
- 19:06not going to have XY and Z thing like they they're
- 19:10traditionalists, right? So they were only going to go to
- 19:13church and denominations that are like following a pretty
- 19:17traditional liturgy. So while we weren't faithful to
- 19:21one specific church, I think that the music program and the
- 19:27pastoral staff it were indicative of the type of church
- 19:30they were getting, broadly speaking.
- 19:32Right. Kind of looking for a place
- 19:34that's more thoughtful. Maybe that's just like what I
- 19:37hear, because what I also hear you saying is it can't be just
- 19:40do what it's I said It's so trust me.
- 19:43And yeah, like in order to pull off excellent music program,
- 19:48there's a lot of thought, care, expertise that needs to go into.
- 19:53I love my parents very much. They're snobs too.
- 19:55So there is a degree of like intellectual snobbery that I
- 19:58think goes along with the kind of highfalutin music.
- 20:01And I don't mean to denigrate other types of.
- 20:04Churches by any means, it's just that's not what was for them.
- 20:07And so I do think that the common link between the music
- 20:11program that they liked and then again that sort of curious and
- 20:16slightly more not open mind, maybe open minded pastoral staff
- 20:21is intellectual curiosity. No.
- 20:23And maybe that's the best way to determine.
- 20:25Yeah, OK, but enough about your parents.
- 20:26Like what about you? I think I very much took up the
- 20:29mantle there. That's a short answer.
- 20:31The long answer is I've sung in many different types of churches
- 20:35because for a long time I had to go where the work was and I
- 20:39simply couldn't afford to turn down a decent church job because
- 20:44I didn't align with the church. That being said, I had a few
- 20:48experiences where I was like it's hard to believe that we
- 20:50both operate under the banner of Christian because I feel like
- 20:53our values are so polar opposite.
- 20:57Similar to my parents. Like I'm not very interested in
- 21:01because I said so theology. Like that's not how my wheels
- 21:04turn and I find that. You also want the intellectual
- 21:07curiosity. Yeah, I find that dissatisfying.
- 21:09And then it and if anything actually repelling.
- 21:12Whereas if somebody invites me into in a conversation where
- 21:15it's like, hey, I don't have all the answers and this thing is
- 21:17complicated and messy and let's dig in.
- 21:21And here's what other traditions say about this.
- 21:23And like I, I find that so much more engaging and frankly
- 21:27welcoming as like a stance because it's not predicated on
- 21:32the belief that there is AI have the right answer, the end
- 21:36period. And I think that there's
- 21:39something, and maybe I'm just trying to fit these two
- 21:42together, but I do think there's some interesting connection
- 21:45between music and what you're describing, because music has
- 21:50this artistic element to it always.
- 21:53Even if you're singing Bach and you just need to let Bach do the
- 21:56work. But there is a piece to it.
- 21:58There's an intellectual curiosity to music, wouldn't you
- 22:00say? You could probably speak better
- 22:02about this than I can. In fact, I know I what I said
- 22:04about Bach. This will sound contrary to it.
- 22:07I actually think that one of the things that drew me to Bach a
- 22:12lot was the sort of intellectualism in it.
- 22:15It's not as, and actually maybe this isn't contradictory at all.
- 22:19It's not as performative. It's not as emotive.
- 22:23And so for people who are really drawn to like the kind of high
- 22:26drama of Puccini, like they might find Bach to feel a little
- 22:30stilted or restrained in a way that they find unrewarding.
- 22:34I find I think of Bach like a crossword puzzle or something,
- 22:39which I also love. Me too.
- 22:43So I yeah, back to me is like a musical crossword.
- 22:46And the more you dig, the deeper the well gets.
- 22:50I don't know if that's the case with every composer that ever
- 22:53existed. I think some of it can really
- 22:55appeal to base emotional instinct.
- 22:59I don't necessarily know that it rewards the same degree of
- 23:03scrutiny. Maybe that's my shortcoming.
- 23:05And. I haven't.
- 23:06I think we know like what Nickelback was trying to say.
- 23:11There certainly is a lot of music out there that is an inch
- 23:15deep. That's funny, one of my one of
- 23:17my friends has like a campfire question.
- 23:19It's what's an unpopular opinion.
- 23:21And my husband's answer is always, I really like
- 23:23Nickelback, alright. We did.
- 23:27I didn't know this. I think that's a fair, that's a
- 23:29fair analogy to make. I think even within the realm of
- 23:32classical music, there's certain types of composers and music
- 23:36that attract a certain type of singer.
- 23:38And then Bach and certain types of early music.
- 23:42But I think Bach, especially, because he was so prolific,
- 23:45there's just so much to work with.
- 23:46Do you think that the fact that he was constantly writing church
- 23:52music plays into the depth. I wonder about that because if
- 23:56you're trying to give expression to the divine, like you're now
- 24:03you're dealing with something that is by definition infinite.
- 24:05And so like, how can you not create something that is just,
- 24:10yeah, expansive? Yeah, yeah.
- 24:13And I think you have to be a genius to do.
- 24:14And I think he probably was. And he was also deeply devout
- 24:19himself, so that he wasn't. It wasn't performative for him.
- 24:23It was very much personal. But I think there's absolutely
- 24:27truth to that. And if you, and I'm not a
- 24:30scholar by any means, like there are people who I'm not writing
- 24:32dissertations on Bach, but I do know that like he works in
- 24:36motifs and things like that, that do actually represent sort
- 24:39of the symbolism of or various symbology of the church.
- 24:42And like it's all very layered in that way.
- 24:44And that's 100% in touch. But so where would you say,
- 24:50where do you fall on all of this, especially given the
- 24:53course of your life? I'm sure it's been different at
- 24:56different times. You speak about how Bach himself
- 24:58was so devout and that gives expression to the artistry that
- 25:03he brings out for you. I'm sure at sometimes, like you
- 25:06even said, it was a job more than it was anything else.
- 25:09Where do you feel like you are at today?
- 25:11I actually think that my sort of cyclical life within the church,
- 25:17it mirrors a lot of my cyclical life and music in that.
- 25:22So I grew up going to church. Then I took time off and was
- 25:26like, yeah, I'm a teenager, not interested.
- 25:28And then but then I because I was singing, the music is what
- 25:32kept me in the church and kept me returning in various
- 25:36iterations. And then I got to see, OK, this
- 25:38is a church community that I really like and this is a church
- 25:43community that does not speak to me at whatsoever or I feel like
- 25:46an outsider. I don't feel welcome, whatever
- 25:48it might have been. But it was really the job that
- 25:52kind of kept me there. And then when I decided to leave
- 25:56the full time career of singing, I found myself coming back to
- 26:02music because I wanted it in my life, not because I needed it in
- 26:06my life. And I think similarly, I found
- 26:09myself, I landed at Bethany by accident thanks to Bach and
- 26:13James Kim. But I, I then decided to stay
- 26:17even though I didn't need it in terms of, to pay my bills.
- 26:22And I found community and I found a place that I think
- 26:26represents my values and a place where, you know, if we have a
- 26:30kid, I would want to raise them with exposure to those values.
- 26:34And so I think then it became much more a choice in the same
- 26:39way that in keeping music in my life became a choice.
- 26:44So I think they parallel each other in terms of this sort of
- 26:46cycle back. And I think with each of those
- 26:50things, too came time to grow up a little bit, think about my own
- 26:54values and engage in some introspection.
- 26:57It's not necessarily something I was all that concerned about
- 27:00when I was 22. Yeah.
- 27:03As is the case for most of most 22 year olds out there.
- 27:06Yeah. But in the same sense, thinking
- 27:09about values, one of the things I did want to talk with you
- 27:11about, I know you're working on this project or your friends
- 27:14working on this project and consulting with you about about
- 27:16the ways that musicians develop certain values so far beyond the
- 27:22scope of what like we normally Revere them for.
- 27:27Is that an OK way to put it? Explain a little bit more about
- 27:29it? I.
- 27:30Think that's actually a good way to put it.
- 27:31It's so the project is trying to both quantify and share and
- 27:36qualify the inherent value that musicians bring.
- 27:40We're focusing specifically on professional space.
- 27:42So like for people like me or my friend who they were at one
- 27:48point full time artists and now no longer for one of those
- 27:53things, I that was a difficult transition for me to make.
- 27:55There was like a huge identity crisis.
- 27:57I'm sure. Came hand in hand with that was
- 27:59like if I'm not a singer, who am I and then also learning to
- 28:04articulate like what is it that I bring to employment situation
- 28:11that is unique to the fact that I have this arts training and
- 28:14that and frankly that my training wasn't for naughty
- 28:17because I think I did have a moment of where it's like I just
- 28:20wasted X many years of my life and I have these music degrees
- 28:25like who cares about that? And so this is the project is
- 28:29really it's partly to help broaden the cultural
- 28:32conversation around what artists can bring in this sort of
- 28:35inherent way of seeing the world that might be a little different
- 28:39than somebody without the arts. And so it's valuable for
- 28:42employers, but it's also teaching the artists themselves
- 28:45that they are more than just their art.
- 28:47They're more than just what they do.
- 28:49That's simply a kind of bow that gets put on it, and it really
- 28:54what they bring and stand to offer as like a value
- 28:59proposition to society is deeper than that.
- 29:02So how would you articulate that for yourself?
- 29:05You, you were a musician, like a professional singer, but you
- 29:09like because of that. Because of that, I think singing
- 29:13taught me an inherent ability to communicate with people.
- 29:16That to me feels like a big bridge now with going into
- 29:20counseling is the ability to communicate, say what I mean,
- 29:25what I say. Hopefully at least on the
- 29:28ladder. Podcast listeners, you be the
- 29:29judge. Yeah, I.
- 29:30Really backed myself in another corner with that one.
- 29:32And no. And then also there's a degree
- 29:34of there's a lot of listening that's involved in music too.
- 29:37Absolutely. That's sort of responsive.
- 29:39They say it's not acting, it's reacting.
- 29:41They put a sensitivity, yeah. Kind of responsive sensitivity
- 29:44that in order to be a good colleague on the stage, I think
- 29:47that that communicates. I think storytelling is an
- 29:50inherent trait that I have cultivated.
- 29:54And that fits so well with the opera piece.
- 29:56Oh yeah. Totally, obviously, like that's
- 29:58telling a whole story, but even the subtleties that you were
- 30:00saying of how you opera singers have to bring.
- 30:04Their own story. Into it, yeah.
- 30:06Exactly. Like, I can't just tell the
- 30:08story that's in the book, I have to bring my version of the story
- 30:11that's in the book. And so you mentioned that you're
- 30:13being trained as a mental health counselor.
- 30:15That's the trajectory that you hope to end up on.
- 30:17Yep. And yeah.
- 30:18What is it about that's compelling or interesting to
- 30:21you? I actually, I think it is a lot
- 30:23about story. Again, I think a lot of things
- 30:25probably boil down to that for me.
- 30:27Yeah, I love hearing other people's stories and I think
- 30:31helping people tell their stories.
- 30:33So I think a lot of times people come to counseling, telling
- 30:36themselves one version of the story, not realizing that
- 30:38there's alternatives available to them.
- 30:40And I think that I'm particularly interested, at
- 30:42least at this point in my training and I reserve the right
- 30:45to change my mind, but I'm interested in working with an
- 30:48older population. So it's like post retirement age
- 30:51and I think part of that is because a lot of times when
- 30:54people go through retirement, they have an identity crisis and
- 30:57that's something that I can relate to.
- 30:58Yeah. I do like to tell people and
- 31:00they say, oh, you used to sing. And I say, no, I retired young.
- 31:04That's something that though I haven't, though I may not be
- 31:08able to understand the sort of full scope of what somebody's
- 31:13going through, I can appreciate that piece of the experience.
- 31:17And I think also just, yeah, helping people figure out what
- 31:20story do you want to tell? Yeah.
- 31:21If you feel like you're running your head against this brick
- 31:24wall over and over again, maybe we need to revise the narrative
- 31:27a little. And I feel like especially given
- 31:31amount of musical work that you've done in faith setting,
- 31:36those two factors just strike me as leading really well into that
- 31:41space. Yeah.
- 31:43Of like listening and understanding other stories like
- 31:48that's what music is in so many ways is trying to tell a story,
- 31:51but then you as a musician using your instrument, trying to find
- 31:54ways to express that that's compelling, that's emotionally
- 31:59sensitive to the audience. There's so much there that just
- 32:02strikes me as fitting into a counseling space.
- 32:05And in particular, and then I'm really biased too, if like when
- 32:08we're talking about mental health, I do think that the even
- 32:12if you can't bring in, they're like cold hard themes of faith
- 32:16in a very as a like a Christian counselor there, there's still
- 32:21so much there that that's what faith is trying to talk about
- 32:23and help with. You know, like you, you're cared
- 32:25for, you have value, you have purpose, you have identity, you
- 32:28are worthy of love. Like all of that is what people
- 32:33in mental health crisis are often lacking.
- 32:35Yeah, totally isn't understanding that.
- 32:37Obviously, you know this because you had to write my reference,
- 32:39but I am at Denver Seminary doing this degree.
- 32:42And part of why I picked seminary is because even though
- 32:45the school is oriented to a different faiths tradition than
- 32:49what I'm used to. And so I'm a bit of a black
- 32:52sheep at times. Yeah, I, I wanted to feel well
- 32:56versed in how to make those connections and how to speak
- 32:59about them a little more fluently because I think I grew
- 33:02up doing an awful lot of listening in church, but I
- 33:05didn't ever talk about my faith until, I don't know, two years
- 33:09ago. Actually, this even just being
- 33:12able to like speak about it out loud, that's been something that
- 33:15seminary has really helped me do because I just haven't always
- 33:18been around peers who are going to engage in those types of
- 33:20conversations with me or in spaces where I can wade into
- 33:24that and feel comfortable going there.
- 33:25But I know that there may be clients walk in the door
- 33:28regardless of what their faith is, they want to talk about
- 33:32faith. And I didn't want to feel scared
- 33:34to engage in those conversations or feel like I lacked the
- 33:37vocabulary and hadn't done the work for myself.
- 33:39And so I think that's this layer that the program stands to offer
- 33:44that I'm finding really valuable and sometimes challenging.
- 33:48Like it's definitely stretching me in a lot of ways, But that
- 33:51was that was a point and that's why I picked it.
- 33:54Yeah, and I think too, I know the last time that you and I
- 33:57chatted, you were struggling through some Bible classes and
- 34:01but you weren't, I shouldn't say struggling is the right.
- 34:03Word, but I just took the final today so.
- 34:06No way. So here's hoping I cast.
- 34:08Yeah, but what's interesting, and there's certain people who
- 34:12if they hear just this, this snippet of what I'm about to
- 34:15say, all the alarm bells will go off and they'll yell at me.
- 34:18And so I'll preface it by saying for Christians, the Bible means
- 34:21so much more. And it's wisdom literature and
- 34:27it has brought value and direction and purpose to
- 34:32people's lives for thousands of years.
- 34:34And I think there's a certain population of people who, if you
- 34:37said, hey, I came across this really incredible ancient Near
- 34:41East wisdom literature from 6000 years ago that's been passed on.
- 34:46They're like, oh, what is it? That sounds really compelling,
- 34:53but I think there is as a counselor too, like just knowing
- 34:56these stories, even if you never directly like chapter and verse,
- 35:01but it's just like, no, have you ever thought about there's so
- 35:04much in there and there's a reason that it's been valuable
- 35:07for generation after generation of people in terms of helping
- 35:12guide direct. One of my essays was about
- 35:14wisdom literature today, so how about that?
- 35:18No, I completely agree. I know some of my classmates
- 35:21intend to work in a Christian setting, like at a Christian
- 35:25School or church or whatever, and they, I think, want to be
- 35:28fully prepared to engage in a much more sort of obvious way
- 35:35with it. But I think for me, it's like it
- 35:37was being able to leave those pieces together.
- 35:39It's the crossword puzzle again for me.
- 35:41It's like, how do these things all intersect and connect
- 35:44together to create a whole? And it's an important part of my
- 35:49life. So I also, but it's an important
- 35:53part of my life that I didn't pay a lot of attention to.
- 35:56Sure. And yeah, I think the biggest
- 35:58first step in this process for me has been also being able to
- 36:02then articulate what matters to me.
- 36:05How am I different than some of the things that I hear in the
- 36:07classroom? And is that OK?
- 36:11Yeah. And then I call Nate and I say,
- 36:14is this OK? There are those moments, but no,
- 36:17it's more it's really, it's doing the introspective work
- 36:19around it. And then having a place like
- 36:21Bethany where I do feel like, OK, this is a space where I can
- 36:25like chew on some of those sticking points for me, trying
- 36:28to make sense of them. And I that it feels like a safe
- 36:31environment for me to do that. And I admired that in the
- 36:36sermons that that I've heard you guys don't really shy away from.
- 36:41Oh, we got a really gnarly Old Testament reading this week.
- 36:44So let's unpack that one. And I appreciate that because I
- 36:47think there's there are other they'd be easy to be like, OK,
- 36:52anyway, let's get to the gospel. And but I think that's going
- 36:56back to what were those benchmarks for picking a church
- 37:00for me, it was like, you got to be able to look the hard stuff
- 37:03in the face. And frankly, I think that is a
- 37:05counseling too, which is you can't from it, you can't hide.
- 37:09From it, it's still. There some, really, the class I
- 37:11took this summer was Old Testament.
- 37:13So there's some stuff that a lot of people really like to sweep
- 37:17under the rug and be like, we didn't see that.
- 37:20And so there's some tough, there's some tough stuff in
- 37:23there. How do you make sense of it And
- 37:26what I love about what you're describing though?
- 37:29In terms of the story of your life is how you're now piercing
- 37:34together the bread crumbs. And I just, I don't think I
- 37:40don't believe that God just has a set plan for each of us and
- 37:44oh, like they're going to do this, that we're just following
- 37:46some sort of linear direction. That's a mystery to us.
- 37:50But I do think that when we look back in retrospect, you can
- 37:55connect to the dots. It's funny you say that, because
- 37:57that is. Literally, the imagery that I
- 38:01used in my essay, application essay for Denver Seminary.
- 38:06Yeah, I used it. I called it a mosaic.
- 38:08But I was like, you pick up these pieces, these tiles, and
- 38:10you're like, no, it is. But similarly, I don't believe
- 38:13I'm like walking some path that's been perfectly laid out.
- 38:18Like, I believe human beings have the free will to choose.
- 38:22But then when you do, you get nudged where you are meant to.
- 38:26You know, I have. No.
- 38:26I have no regrets about my experience in music, even though
- 38:30sometimes it feels, Oh well, what really set me back 10
- 38:33years, 15 years in my career. That's one way to look.
- 38:37That's one story I could tell myself.
- 38:39The other way to look at it is that was like really essential
- 38:42character development that got me to where I'm at.
- 38:47And then I, I worked, there's an interim where I worked in
- 38:50advertising for eight years between leaving singing and
- 38:54starting my degree at seminary. And I could have, I know I
- 38:59always knew this is not my, this is not where I'm intended to end
- 39:02up, but this is where I'm intended to be now.
- 39:06And frankly, I think I got that job because the CEO who hired me
- 39:10has a background in music. And so for the first interview
- 39:13of however many I do, I didn't actually have to sell her on
- 39:17those sort of core attributes. She knew them inherently.
- 39:20She said, if you are a musician, you're XY and Z, you're good at
- 39:23this, you're good at that. And I was like, oh, that's what
- 39:26I was going to say The thing too though, about.
- 39:29What you're describing is it's also like we have such a mindset
- 39:33in the West. I think in particular of always
- 39:36thinking that we need to be headed somewhere.
- 39:38And you're saying like, oh, I was set back professionally 10
- 39:40years. Like, no, like, you had 10 years
- 39:42of incredible experiences. Even more than that, I'm sure as
- 39:46a professional musician and a lot of hard work, but a lot of
- 39:49character development. And also, what are you in such a
- 39:51hurry to get to? We talked about that too, I
- 39:55think this summer of just the ways of that, that we have this
- 40:00mindset so often of, oh, I need to get there.
- 40:03I need to arrive there. And there's not a lot of
- 40:05contentment. I feel like that was the word
- 40:07that was thrown around. It's like, no, there's something
- 40:09really important about learning to just appreciate where things
- 40:12are and to recognize that you, you don't need to be in such a
- 40:14hurry to get somewhere else. Yeah, Yeah.
- 40:16And then I think you. Describe it at some point to me
- 40:20as Christianity is not a destination.
- 40:22And I think that applies here too.
- 40:24It's happiness is not a destination.
- 40:27Being a Christian is not a destination.
- 40:29And yeah, when it comes to your profession, there might be
- 40:32milestones you have to reach. I have to get accredited.
- 40:35That's a destination. But the that is not why I want
- 40:38to be a counselor. I'm not doing it so I can be
- 40:40like I'm accredited. I'm doing it so I can be a
- 40:42counselor, which hopefully is a dynamic thing that changed over
- 40:47the course of the time that I do it Exactly and.
- 40:51Yeah. And I I just I never.
- 40:52Thought of tying Christianity into that too.
- 40:54Which is no, being a Christian is just being.
- 40:58Yeah, and it doesn't. Have to be represent.
- 41:02This end state that you don't belong into.
- 41:06I have arrived. Yeah, exactly.
- 41:07Yeah, exactly. So.
- 41:10You know this this question is coming and everything, right?
- 41:13Like with all of this, I'm always interested in asking
- 41:15people why they still choose to be involved in the community of
- 41:19faith. And so that's my last question
- 41:21for you. Why do you think you're still
- 41:23here? You literally said it.
- 41:25Community I think the church offers a unique proposition to
- 41:33people which is the opportunity to engage in a community where
- 41:38you can You can relate to each other based on your values not
- 41:43it's not based on your hobbies it's not based on your you find
- 41:46people who I love racquetball you love racquetball but it it's
- 41:49not about that nobody plays racquetball it's all pickleball
- 41:51keep. Going.
- 41:52I know that's what I meant. But but yeah, you know what I
- 41:57mean? It's like it's not based off of,
- 41:58it's not conditional around a hobby, It's not conditional
- 42:01around a political belief. It's not conditional really.
- 42:04It's like saying that, OK, if I'm walking through these doors
- 42:07and I want to be here, I can guess that the other people here
- 42:12aligned to these certain values and that offers a unique
- 42:15structure for building a community that I don't know that
- 42:19another space in my life offers, that it is a place where like.
- 42:23I can wrestle with. My hard questions with faith and
- 42:26feel like I'm not going to get punted out the door.
- 42:28There are churches where I do feel that way.
- 42:30So that's why I'm not there and I'm here.
- 42:32And I think, I think that's really truly what it boils down
- 42:37to for me, which is that it's an hour or two of my week where I
- 42:43am a part of something bigger than myself.
- 42:46I am not the center of that universe.
- 42:49I don't think we have that many spaces in our lives anymore
- 42:53where we're not the center of our own universe.
- 42:55And I like that I can set my life aside and be a part of
- 42:59something bigger. So it's why I've been trying to
- 43:01like get more involved. And I'm always like, I'm a
- 43:05little bit of a slow mover in that department, but I, that's
- 43:08part of why I've wanted to get more involved and like really
- 43:12actually take advantage and tap into the community that the
- 43:16church stands down for. I'm super glad you are a part of
- 43:19this community. It's been really fun getting to
- 43:20know you over the last several years as you call me with
- 43:23questions about seminary and everything else.
- 43:25I love those types of conversations.
- 43:27I appreciate it. I always appreciate you taking.
- 43:29The e-mail or the text or whatever cuz it may helps me
- 43:32level set when I'm like oh what am I doing?
- 43:35You're doing great and yeah, thanks for sharing.
- 43:37All of your heart and your story with us in this way.
- 43:40And you do listener. Thanks for listening.
- 43:42As always, stay in peace. Thank you for listening to the
- 43:45Together for Good podcast. If you'd like more resources for
- 43:48your walk of faith, please visit our website bethany-denver.org
- 43:53or download our mobile app by searching Bethany Connect in
- 43:57your phone's App Store.