Latest / Crypto Coin Show / How Fireblocks provides Blockchain for Banks, Institutions, CBDC’s and DID | Blockchain Interviews
Transcript
- 0:00I'm Ashton Addison from the Crypto Coin Show and today i'm Blockchain Interviews with Francois
- 0:04Skonkin, tokenization business lead at Fireblocks. Francois, welcome to the show and
- 0:10thank you for taking the time. Thank you for having me. I would
- 0:16love to you before we start. I would love to just sort of get
- 0:20a refresher for those people who have been in crypto for a while or they're
- 0:24just starting and they haven't heard of Fireblocks. You know, I've personally seen
- 0:28the name quite a bit around, but I think you guys have a specific
- 0:31client tele that sort of very specialized and a lot of people don't really know
- 0:36the full scope of Fireblocks. I think guys do a lot of stuff and
- 0:40then would love to dive into the tokenization focus with you and your specialties after
- 0:45absolutely happy, happy to touch on that. So Fireblocks is a custody and
- 0:53tokenization infrastructure company. We started back in twenty eighteen. If I'm not mistaken,
- 1:03we honed and refined MPC based key custody control. We have a derivation
- 1:12there are NBCCNP that we had open source. We have very very deep technical
- 1:19expertise around the securitization of the securing and management of custody in the back end.
- 1:26Talking to our client tele well, it's a pretty broad gambit. We
- 1:30very much take a infrastructure perspective, so we have in our eight hundred plus
- 1:38clients many many of the largest exchanges, many large banks, many large fmis
- 1:48and asset managers. So we really we really span the gambit from from crypto
- 1:56to defy to more sea fight and we pride ourselves on that and the fact
- 2:01that we have the flexibility to interact on those various dimensions. People much more
- 2:08eloquent than myself could probably make a better case for exactly what the nuances on
- 2:13the crypto side is, but on the cassidy side is that in my technical
- 2:19assessment, it's a very strong platform to bold tooling upon m HM. Great,
- 2:24thank you for the intro Francois. And on the business side and just
- 2:31what we're seeing with the landscape so far in twenty twenty four, I think
- 2:36bitcoin is now making its way into the news. With the ETF approvals,
- 2:40more businesses are going to be saying, hey, you know, we want
- 2:44to get involved in crupercurrency but also blockchain, and hey, how can we
- 2:46also use it in our business? I think tokenization use cases are going to
- 2:51come from all industries, public, private, every direction. Would love to
- 2:54hear a little bit on what your focus is with relating to that, then
- 3:00we can dive into those details. Absolutely So. I heard a wise man
- 3:07use the quote people say bitcoin is the tide that lifts all boats. I
- 3:13think his name was Ashton. Yes, I have said that our expectation is
- 3:21that as engagement in this environment takes up, we will probably see a correlated
- 3:30uptick end organization. Now I say correlated, I'm not thinking one on one.
- 3:37There's there is a lag because what we find is large institutions have such
- 3:43a large or large budgeting and planning window that it takes them a long time
- 3:49to direct. It's the old adage around a oil tanker. I mean it's
- 3:53it's bigger. I'll get there, but it takes a while to get turned
- 3:54and go into the direction. But what we do see is we see a
- 3:59whole lot of renewed energy around corporate addictioniences. There's a lot of energy around
- 4:08unit of account. So when I say unit of account, I mean stable
- 4:11coins and depositokens. Interestingly enough, over the last six months or so,
- 4:16we have seen a lot of renewed energy in joint ventures between marquee banks wanting
- 4:25to create currencies within local domains and surface those on exchanges so that they can
- 4:30create a set of collateral that folks can easily interact with. And we see
- 4:34this in Europe, South America and in other places. And then something that
- 4:42given the higher interest rate environment we're seeing a lot of is people showing interest
- 4:47in yield bearing assets. So in low interest environments, people just hold on
- 4:53to their stable coins as a means of getting ready for speculation on other instruments.
- 4:59Given that you're in a high interest environment, are you going to keep
- 5:00it there? You're going to just put in the bank and get your five
- 5:02percent to that end, yield bearing instruments and even things like money market funds
- 5:09where there's interest in using that as a unit of account or unit of trade.
- 5:14We see a lot of arptic there. The usual entrance s in there
- 5:19as well. Bank guarantees supply train for finance, but the energy around them
- 5:25tends to be the same. These are the ones I mentioned with the ones
- 5:30that kind of pick up. It's a good insight, and I know that
- 5:34there are many banks, central banks, private banks, governments, probably all
- 5:40working on some kind of unit of account based on the blockchain CBDC of sorts.
- 5:46And you're right about that tanker analogy that, yeah, this is something
- 5:49big, you know, if it's going to affect the whole country or the
- 5:51whole banking system. It's not something that they can just do in a week,
- 5:56you know it sort of taking cautious steps towards it and transitions towards it.
- 6:01What are some of the things that you and the team at Fireblocks are
- 6:05doing to help lower those barriers to entry or to lower those barricades to help
- 6:11get them over the finish line. I'll address that in two aspects. First,
- 6:24I'd like to call out a project that we had the privilege of working
- 6:26on, So for your audience, I'll take a moment and go through what
- 6:31BIS is. So BIS is the Bank of International Settlements, so we tradify
- 6:36absolutely, and they have a division called the Innovation Hub. The Innovation Hub
- 6:44is a spin off where they engage with new frontiers and tech. Their mandate
- 6:49is to create patterns, not really develop products. So the BIAS Innovation Hub.
- 6:59Recently, this is in last year, we helped them on a project
- 7:01called Project Mariana project, Mariana for a techie like me, very very interesting.
- 7:08Uh. The tagline for the project was deep liquidity. And basically what
- 7:12you had is you had three central banks. They had their own independent private
- 7:18networks to hyperlajure beezoo one quorum. These banks were above to France representing euro
- 7:27SOURSS National Bank representing the Swiss frank and then maa is representing the Singaporean dollar.
- 7:32We helped implement a CBDC. That CBDC we bridged onto a prior onto
- 7:39a public network. Then inside the public network we used an AMM to do
- 7:46exchanges between the currencies. So obviously this is not targeting myself of yourself.
- 7:51This is large financial institutions moving billions of dollars around and wanting to do that
- 7:57level of exchange. Was interesting in that was that we were afforded the option
- 8:03of working with Michael Igoroff. He is the original author of the curve producol
- 8:09And because you've got curve, you get to have three currencies instead of just
- 8:13pair currencies with routing, which yields a bit of a bodies. So to
- 8:18your question where are we focused, we have a division that's focused on that
- 8:24side of the market and engaging with central banks in everything up to the hypothetical
- 8:31research down to implementations of something called uniformity of money. Now, when we
- 8:35think about uniformity of money in the I think in the early night's mid twenty
- 8:43twenty one in Europe they released a paper talking about the notion of uniformity of
- 8:48money, and one of the pieces of data in there was this idea of
- 8:52the money flower, which basically says that you need to think about your unit
- 8:58of accounts in a way where it's interchangeable, the same way a dollar is
- 9:01that you would hand from your wallet to me. Now, if you have
- 9:05a plurality of stable coins, which seems inevitable, you need a mechanism whereby
- 9:11you can enact that. We're working with folk in South America and some folk
- 9:18in Europe where we've implemented a CBDC backed unit of account that does that exchange
- 9:24in a real time basis or on transaction basis for folk that have a better
- 9:30central banking knowledge. Basically we execute in time exchange settlement accounty. So that's
- 9:37the hyper theoretical perspective. Then on the more tools and offering to get companies
- 9:43up and running, we have a set of opinionated reference smart contracts. That
- 9:50is the product of the last two and a half years of our consultation distilled
- 9:56into what makes sense in a higher legoratic environment, and we have a set
- 10:01of reference architectures. How you can bring that to bear. So we can
- 10:05now in a pretty short term, take a customer that is commercially ready from
- 10:11zero toganization into having their own unit account, having their own money market fund,
- 10:15and their own bond issuance with what we believe to be a very healthy
- 10:20balance of the on and off chain expression. When we think about toganization,
- 10:26we've joked we're going to get the tattooed on ourselves, but express on chain
- 10:31only that which adds value on chain. We find that when people are new
- 10:35in this environment, they tend to want to express the full workflow the same
- 10:41that they would in traditional banking systems. And that's not where you garner your
- 10:46benefit out of this environment. Whilst technically possible, it doesn't get you to
- 10:50a positive space. Now if you focus on the byzantine, full tolerant nature,
- 10:56so the lack of double spending risk you have in these assets, and
- 11:01you focus on the elements that have value, not to yourself, but to
- 11:03your customer, then your your projects and our experience tends to take up and
- 11:09tend to run pretty well. Hm hmmm. Very interesting. Uh. And
- 11:13with some parts that you mentioned there with the author of the Curve paper and
- 11:20talking about the AMM sort of makes me look into, you know, from
- 11:24a crypto perspective DeFi and how it is. Now. Is there a major
- 11:30difference in how these banks and the digital dollars that you're working to build with
- 11:35them are integrating into a sort of hybrid tratified banking of DeFi or is it
- 11:41very similar to what you would experience on Curve for transferring, lending, borrowing,
- 11:48that kind of stuff. I'd say there's there's material differences, uh,
- 11:54and the material differences tend to inform be informed by the operating pet and of
- 12:00the respective entities. So if we and don't write this in any former thesis,
- 12:07but if we think about what a bank does. Typically they take deposits,
- 12:13They hold a deposit, and then they make loans on the back of
- 12:15it. And assuming they're regulated, there's a ratio, a reserve ratio call
- 12:20a ten percent that needs to be held at central. Now, if you
- 12:24reason about that, the incentive for a bank is to interact with capital off
- 12:30their balance sheet, not lock capital into pools. So the likes of an
- 12:35AMM for your average bank isn't very opinion because it's a capital inefficiency. This
- 12:43is why you will find that whenever you do significant FX transactions, you always
- 12:50tend to get a spot price because the spot price is related to what they
- 12:54can achieve and what is happening on their balance sheet at the time. Now,
- 12:58if you take that little bit, the notion of holding light reserves and
- 13:03taking yield on the back of that isn't very appealing to acts. There's mechanisms
- 13:07around that in ways you can work with that, but it does get very
- 13:11very complex and you blink and then all of a sudden you need a super
- 13:16complicated oracle set of infrastructure to hopefully make that interlink possible. Now, that's
- 13:24on the FX side, but when you think about the settlement and the settlement
- 13:30efficiency side, on that side, there is enormous excitement from a bank's perspective.
- 13:37Using traditional railers. If you're a bank and you're a premier bank and
- 13:41you do a inter country settlement that, if it goes well, takes three
- 13:48and a half hours now there's a bit of fees associated with it and a
- 13:52fair bit of admin. If you look at the option of having units of
- 13:58account as your sub ledger, doing these large settlements and then sublagering them out,
- 14:03this now takes the amount of time it takes for your selected blockchain to
- 14:07mine a transaction. I have had the great fortune of sitting in a room
- 14:13with people that run treasury at pretty large banks and just seeing that are hormone
- 14:20when they for the first time see a transaction execute it and they realize and
- 14:26this is one of the pieces of beauty of large at scale. Let's say
- 14:31attack resistant public blockchains. You can have a large entity, let's call it
- 14:39the acmebank, and the aquibank has branches and I'll go my majioestiction will go
- 14:43Australia and Singapore, and then you can do a transfer between those two the
- 14:50different legal entities. But the confidence in the expression of the asset on something
- 14:56like etheroem main it is such that you can run the sub ledger and then
- 15:01type that back into your own accounting and then do larger netting of This is
- 15:05just one example where some of that DeFi power is very, very appealing to
- 15:11traditional markets. That's incredible. And you mentioned their Ethereum the main net and
- 15:18we've been talking about private networks public networks as well. I'm guessing that a
- 15:24lot of these banks, at least with the testing, probably in the production
- 15:26as well, they're using some kind of private networks or private blockchains. Is
- 15:31that based off of Ethereum language, and then if they're moving into public networks,
- 15:37is that also on Ethereum or is it layer twos on Ethereum or other
- 15:41blockchains. I'm going to respond from an energy and market participation perspective, because
- 15:48obviously there's exceptions, but the bulk of what we see is that customers are
- 15:56gravitating towards EVM and it doesn't have to be etherorum, but just EVM.
- 16:00And if it's EVM one dot zero, you're probably okay. It's it's more
- 16:03than stable enough. We had a example where mid of last year we worked
- 16:10with tel Aviv Stock Exchange. Now tel Aviv Stock Exchange is partnered with the
- 16:17Ministry of Finance Israel and contained within the Ministry of Finance is the is the
- 16:23account General and the account General is responsible for all debt issuances. So that's
- 16:27that's government bods. Now, tel Aviv Stock Exchange has a very very interesting
- 16:32relationship with the account General where bond issuances are enacted using a maker checker process.
- 16:41So what I mean by that is that the account General will put forth
- 16:45their proposal for a bond, tele Aviv Stock Exchange will approve that proposal,
- 16:48and then upon receipt of approval, the Auditor General will issue the bond out
- 16:52into market. So Project Eden was about running that process on a blockchain and
- 17:00then having twelve primary dealers. So these are wholesale banks, five domestic,
- 17:04seven international I think Golden really really large banks participated in this and they would
- 17:14they would run their bids. Because you would do this authoring a collaborative authoring
- 17:17cycle. We would pipe it out to a Bloomberg test asset. We would
- 17:21do auctioning on Bloomberg and then pipe the results back and then we'd execute on
- 17:23the on the atomic settlement. Now to your question, what they did in
- 17:30that instance is they started out with a VMware EVM engine. Just under a
- 17:37week prior to the live date, VMware announced that they would deprecate their engine
- 17:44on the back of their acquisition, and we converted the entire solution from EVM
- 17:51to BIPE ledger basin in sub forty eight hours, because it's really a deployment
- 17:56action, it's not a redevelopment. We use the same as now. To
- 18:00that end, their vision was that they could start out with private and then
- 18:06go public, and if they've got assets that could go public, assets that
- 18:10are EVM compatible, that makes life a lot easier. Now that being said,
- 18:15over the last I want to say, eighteen months, I've seen a
- 18:19shift in our larger let's called FMI assa management banking customers where you would almost
- 18:27have people in the R three very very constricted has to be private. I'll
- 18:33concede maybe hyper ledgere based an EVM camp all the way over to now they
- 18:38realize, well, public infrastructure is where the power is at and the benefit
- 18:45they're hoping to clean will be capitalizing on secondary markets when they come into play.
- 18:51So I also feel that oil tanker is slowly turning towards understanding these public
- 18:56ledgers have value. Now. The moment you go there, the entire question
- 19:00of PII. So personally, idea to have all information becomes central to your
- 19:07challenges. But I mean that's just a technical challenge. You take it on
- 19:11the chin around with it. Yeah, no great insights to Francois, and
- 19:15I've heard many enterprises before working on R three or hyper Ledger, but it's
- 19:22great to hear that they're sort of EVM focused. And from what I'm seeing
- 19:25on the crypto side, the amount of large players that have raised hundreds of
- 19:29millions, multiple hundreds of millions, these layer twos that are coming out,
- 19:33it sounds like EVM is here to stay, and they're making it faster and
- 19:37cheaper than ever on the public network side, so I'm looking forward to seeing
- 19:41where they go and what networks they choose. Now you mentioned at the end
- 19:45there about the PII, I'm guessing that it's important for these institutions you're working
- 19:49with, especially banks, to have some kind of identity attached to it,
- 19:52whether it's on the blockchain or attached to that. I know that fireblocks as
- 19:59well. They also recent only got a top former top regulator that's helping with
- 20:03the identity side of it. Maybe you can talk a little bit about how
- 20:07that fits into the scene with these banks or with all of the companies that
- 20:12you're working on organization with. Absolutely, and it's a year uniform consideration So
- 20:23I'll use a very simple example. Let's assume in your average common law jurisdiction
- 20:30that you have a debt issues if the parcel size is above a certain size,
- 20:36let's call it one hundred thousand dollars. The typical structure in most common
- 20:41law jurisdictions is that you need some mechanism of having the investor be a qualified
- 20:47investor. Now it's not a very high bar, but it just means that
- 20:51the investor has to sign an attestation. I understand this is a speculative instrument.
- 20:55I understand I'm incurring some type of risk. This is not not a
- 20:59kin to a bank deposit, where I know that a federal entity would cover
- 21:03me if the bank goes under. And then there's usually a small component of
- 21:07just a means validation, but that's continued upon the jurisdiction. Now, that
- 21:15is just commonplace and has been commonplace for decades in these types of issuances.
- 21:19When you go to on chain, you now have a problem. You have
- 21:22no privacy in terms of what's expressed on chain. Now, what you could
- 21:27do is you could just say I've done all this off chain, and I
- 21:32take Ashton's address and we say Ashton's address is contained in the set of or
- 21:37proofs, and that's pretty good. But it only holds true for binary evaluations,
- 21:45things like is ashen in this list or not. Once we start extending
- 21:49that too, let's call it multivariate considerations, is ashen and this jurisdiction is
- 21:56there any of these claims, And it's just once it becomes a little bit
- 22:00more of a constellation of consideration, that strategy tends to fall over a little
- 22:03bit. Now, what you'd like to do is you would like to express
- 22:08the same type of data points that banks and asset managers and as traditionally hold
- 22:14onto about their customers. You would like to express that on chain. But
- 22:18that riches expressed on chain is there forever. I mean, that's the beauty
- 22:22and the scary thing about blockchains. Now, if you think about something like
- 22:27the GDPR regulation of Europe, and we've got similar regulations all over the world,
- 22:33a large component of that is the requirement that I have the option of
- 22:38bowing out of my information being used. That's a very hard proposition in this
- 22:45context, and this is where the idea of privacy preserving a digital identity comes
- 22:52into play. And simply put, what you do is you build a set
- 22:57of proofs off chain and then you lodge the proof and then you can use
- 23:03on chain mechanism to confirm that that proof folds true. So that proof could
- 23:07be Are we confident that France was older than twenty one years so France was
- 23:11allowed to buy THEA or whatever our consideration is there. Now. Our approach
- 23:17to this is that then that research and that environment in terms of executing it
- 23:22at a scalable manner. And that's important because just expressing a proof on chain
- 23:29you can do it today, but it tends to be very, very costly,
- 23:32so we are investing a lot of energy in terms of building things that
- 23:36are market and scale ready. We have, however, in a set of
- 23:41opinionated reference contracts, brought to bear a pattern which we call access registry,
- 23:48and it's a generalized pattern around allowing for the holding and participation on assets.
- 23:53And our first examples that allowed list, which is as a white list and
- 23:57a denialist which is the blackest, is a ready in play. But the
- 24:00architecture is both sections that that is consumed as a service on chain, and
- 24:04then when you're privacy preserving d id coms into effect, you can just swap
- 24:10that service out and it seems like a minor consideration, but once you have
- 24:15a plurality it's got two dozen assets, you don't want to be managing access
- 24:22on a per asset basis. And that's something that we do find people sometimes
- 24:25get tripped up on great insights, and yeah, I'm glad that there is
- 24:30a focus on privacy as well, especially when you have these public blockchains and
- 24:34for people that are using you know, just the main net ethereum. It's
- 24:37like, once you have an address, then you're looking into your account and
- 24:42if you there's no sort of standard for giving your identity to prove something,
- 24:48and if the security around that is not secure, then you know, you
- 24:52don't really know what you're getting into. I feel like there needs to be
- 24:56some more strength to the security levels. So I'm glad that Fireblocks is helping
- 25:00with that. Now. That's why we don't have a lot of time left,
- 25:03but I want to look forward towards the future twenty twenty four, I'm
- 25:07optimistic and five and six and what you and your team, the vision that
- 25:11you have for the future of tokenization, it's impact on the financial services industry,
- 25:17and how you see Fireblocks playing a continued role in that. So I
- 25:26I think summing that up in a single sentence, I would say that we
- 25:30are very excited about making available pieces of infrastructure and building blocks and then seeing
- 25:38how our customers get to delight their customers. Now you pick up that's just
- 25:44us borrowing a page out of the AWA strategy. But obviously that's where you
- 25:47would borrow it. It's the right place. Now if you think in terms
- 25:51of asset classes, we are very encouraged in terms of the width of assets
- 26:00that are now being explored and expressed on chain. We are really really excited
- 26:07by the development of secondary markets. Now, when we think about this in
- 26:14house, and I'm borrowing this phrase for the longest time, people would argue
- 26:21focus on minimum viable product. To us, this is a minimum viable ecosystem
- 26:26play, so we do not go in and just sell you on the idea
- 26:33of using our piece of infrastructure. You've got the wallet or you've got the
- 26:37token. A dedicated division within Fireblos is the Fireblox Network. It provides a
- 26:45set of technical tooling that makes it possible to transfer and have confidence of your
- 26:51counterparty, so it mitigates almost all of your counterparty risk in terms of understanding
- 26:55who your counterparty is. But built on top of that, from an organization
- 27:00respective, we lean into working with our customers and finding counterparties that could help
- 27:04them execute on their larger vision, because if you're going to tokenize, you're
- 27:11probably going to tokenize because you want access to a new market or you want
- 27:15a greater level of retention. Just leaning into their cheaper bit of faster commonalities.
- 27:21And I'd say the thing that excites us most is the energy we're seeing
- 27:26around the network and around businesses having the option of engaging and the creative ways
- 27:33in which they engage to bring new financial offerings to market. Very exciting.
- 27:38Thank you so much, Francois and I completely agree on the expansion of tokenization.
- 27:44I see that you have a big, big picture of it that what
- 27:48I think twenty twenty four may be part of the year of more real world
- 27:52assets in new industries becoming tokenized as well, and more markets to trade them
- 27:56with lower friction through the blockchain technology. So it's a very exciting time.
- 28:02I really thank you so much for all the insights into this part of the
- 28:07industry that I'm not as familiar with. Looks like Fireblocks is doing an incredible
- 28:11job. Keep up the great work and I would love to follow up in
- 28:14the near future. Absolutely, and thanks for having me. Really appreciate