Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Cumulative Trauma Claims in Workers’ Compensation: What is happening, and where are things going?
Transcript
- 0:03Hello everyone and welcome to cumulative trauma
- 0:06claims in workers compensation. What is happening
- 0:09and where are things going? My name is Michael
- 0:12Falati and I'm the chair of the workers compensation
- 0:15law section. I'm an attorney at Greyward Kaplan,
- 0:18Wernick and Evans and a certified specialist
- 0:20in workers compensation law. Before I introduce
- 0:23today's speaker, I'd like to take a moment to
- 0:25plug the workers compensation section. The work
- 0:28comp section is a new and fast growing section
- 0:30of the Beverly Hills Bar Association. I obviously
- 0:33encourage all work comp practitioners to join,
- 0:36but I also highly recommend that practitioners
- 0:38in overlapping practice areas like personal injury
- 0:41and labor and employment also join. And for those
- 0:44interested in becoming more involved with the
- 0:46work comp section, as a section leader perhaps,
- 0:49I encourage you to reach out to me or contact
- 0:50the Beverly Hills Bar Association help desk.
- 0:53We'll throw my email and the help desk's email
- 0:55in the chat. All right, and now I'd like to introduce
- 0:59our speaker for today, Randy Pollack. For those
- 1:02of us who have been practicing long enough, Randy
- 1:04really needs no introduction. And no introduction
- 1:07could ever fully capture the breadth of Randy's
- 1:09contributions to the field, but I'll give it
- 1:11a try nonetheless. Randy Pollack is a director
- 1:14and California attorney at WCF National Insurance,
- 1:18where they focus on workers' compensation law.
- 1:21Over the course of his career, Randy has built
- 1:23deep expertise in claims administration, litigation
- 1:26management, and insurance law. Earlier at Pacific
- 1:30Compensation Insurance, he rose from attorney
- 1:32to supervising attorney to managing attorney,
- 1:35handling legal representation, research, and
- 1:38the mentoring of legal staff. Randy has also
- 1:41served as a managing partner and practice leader
- 1:43at Winterstein and an associate at Tobin Lux,
- 1:47where he worked with the insurance and employer
- 1:49communities. He has also served as editor of
- 1:51the Workers' Compensation Quarterly for the California
- 1:54Lawyers' Association. And now let's get started.
- 2:01Thank you, Michael, for that very generous introduction.
- 2:03I appreciate it. Well, welcome, everyone. I'm
- 2:07very happy to join you today for this presentation
- 2:11on cumulative trauma CT claims. I hope that you're
- 2:16all familiar with this as a legal point. What
- 2:21I will introduce to you today, in addition to
- 2:23the legal points that are very important, is
- 2:25the evolving policy and political landscape that
- 2:30cannot be ignored of what's taking place right
- 2:33now, given some developments in the last five
- 2:36years approximately coming out of the pandemic.
- 2:40So what you'll see, though, from today's discussion
- 2:42is that the law really has not changed for decades.
- 2:48But what's happened is the tools of the attorneys,
- 2:51the practice tools of the attorneys to work in
- 2:55this space have changed. And what you've seen
- 2:58is an evolution of where these types of claims
- 3:02had historically only existed in Southern California
- 3:06and really very minimally existed in Northern
- 3:10California, that's changed. Where the Southern
- 3:14California firms have been able to file these
- 3:17types of claims throughout the state. And that
- 3:19has now put pressure on the system and put more
- 3:26attention on these claims. And as a defense attorney,
- 3:31I'll say the weaknesses of these claims in terms
- 3:34of defenses that has really brought it to the
- 3:38highest levels on the radar of the highest levels
- 3:42in the state, including the insurance commissioner,
- 3:46the Commission on Health and Safety and Workers'
- 3:49Comp, WCIRB, CWCI, and other organizations that
- 3:55recognize that this is something that may need
- 3:59to be dealt with to create sustainability in
- 4:01the system. And so I'm going to go through the
- 4:04law and then I'm going to go through the realities
- 4:06of those changes the last couple of years, including
- 4:08some data, and bring us to the present, which
- 4:12Sets up some of this discussion, which is likely
- 4:14going to take place over the next couple of years.
- 4:16And I think what many of us just saw with the
- 4:22passage of the reform how that came about through
- 4:26the budget trailer process, which was very controversial.
- 4:30I think that adds an element to this policy discussion
- 4:33that. Be careful out there. things could change
- 4:38quickly. And I think that's a live example of
- 4:40that. All right. So with that backdrop in mind,
- 4:43I'm going to go through the law and explain how
- 4:48these CT claims work, what is controversial about
- 4:53them, and where I think things are going to go.
- 4:57My disclaimer. Can you re -share the PowerPoint,
- 5:00Brandon? Sorry to interrupt. Oh, did I not share
- 5:03it? Yeah. So yeah. Oh, apologize. But I already
- 5:07put that on. OK, let me. All right, are you able
- 5:14to see now? No, we can see it. Thank you, Randy.
- 5:17I had it set up for them and then moved off of
- 5:19it. OK, so my disclaimer is these are my views
- 5:23and my views only. They're intended to be educational,
- 5:27informational, hopefully entertaining at times.
- 5:31They're not intended to be legal advice. Please
- 5:33do your own legal research. if you have a specific
- 5:38issue in front of you. All right. So this is
- 5:44what we're going to talk about today. We're going
- 5:46to talk about specific injuries versus CTs. What's
- 5:48differences? Why does it matter? The main thing
- 5:51being the date of injury for a CT injury and
- 5:55how that's determined with the disability knowledge
- 5:58nexus. Then we'll go into why these are controversial,
- 6:01which is dealing with things like statuallitation
- 6:03defenses. post -termination defense and then
- 6:06how this has been historically Southern California
- 6:09practice moved into a statewide practice. I'll
- 6:12talk about the reality of the electronic remote
- 6:15appearances that really changed the game. That's
- 6:18what I mentioned, these practice tools that are
- 6:20available and then the data trends and then looking
- 6:23at the hard practical sort of policy realities
- 6:27of people are starting to look at this and it's
- 6:30getting a lot of attention and things that are
- 6:32talked about right now. about how to address
- 6:36these concerns. So, of course, we start our discussion
- 6:41on CT claims with the discussion on specific
- 6:44injury claims, right? It makes total sense, right?
- 6:46It's funny is if you look at like any kind of
- 6:51organization that always talks about the problem
- 6:53of CT claims, they always start with a discussion
- 6:55about specific injuries because I think it's
- 6:58absolutely necessary as a preamble to be able
- 7:00to like distinguish how different an unusual
- 7:05CT injury is. Not every state has a CT injury.
- 7:09Many states do not. And so it's bringing people
- 7:12up to speed of like, hey, just, you know, this
- 7:15is different. And so let's start here with that
- 7:18reality that there's a very big difference between
- 7:21a specific injury and a CT injury. And that really
- 7:25is in the form of the date of injury determination,
- 7:27which I'll explain in a few minutes. So let's
- 7:29start there. A specific injury is an incident
- 7:34that leads to need for medical treatment or disability.
- 7:38I always use this classic example every time
- 7:40I've presented anything on CTs is you need two
- 7:44things. You need an incident at work plus a need
- 7:48for medical treatment or disability. Two things.
- 7:51One is, you know, just being an incident is not
- 7:54enough. It needs to actually cause something.
- 7:57So for me, sitting right here and I slap my hand
- 7:59on this desk while in the course of work, I've
- 8:03had an incident. Now, if I do that too hard,
- 8:07trying to be too cute, and then it actually causes
- 8:10a need for medical treatment or disability, then
- 8:12I may have now had an injury. So two parts, an
- 8:15incident plus a need for medical treatment or
- 8:17disability. Now, there's no mention of date of
- 8:20injury in the specific injury statute. It's addressed
- 8:25in a separate statute, labor code 5411, which
- 8:28is the easiest version of the law possible. and
- 8:31I'll just translate it here. It happens on the
- 8:34day it happens. So if you fall down a set of
- 8:38stairs on January 1st, 2026, your date of injury
- 8:41for a specific injury is January 1st, 2026. Nothing
- 8:45creative or interesting there. But now we've
- 8:50set that sort of baseline, foundation understanding,
- 8:52and we'll distinguish it from what a CT injury
- 8:55is. And you'll see the cascading impact of that.
- 9:00What is a CT injury? Now, it shares a similar
- 9:04concept to the specific injury in the sense that
- 9:06you need something plus something. In the specific
- 9:10injury context, there was an incident plus a
- 9:12need for medical treatment. What you have with
- 9:15the CT injury is repetitive physical traumas
- 9:18or mental traumas plus a need for medical treatment.
- 9:22So the fact that I am at work and I'm having
- 9:25to bend repeatedly daily and lift things repeatedly
- 9:30daily, that's not an injury of itself. It's just
- 9:35working and experiencing these repetitive traumas
- 9:38or exertions. But it's when it needs, it results
- 9:43in a need for medical treatment or disability.
- 9:45So the repetitive nature plus a need for medical
- 9:49treatment or disability is what creates that
- 9:51concept of the CT injury. But there's more. The
- 9:57date of injury for the CT is not defined by the
- 10:02specific labor code section it's in. It's deferred
- 10:05to another section, which it says very specifically,
- 10:09go to labor code 5412 to figure out the date
- 10:11of injury. And I'm going to translate this slide.
- 10:17Everybody knows these. points of law, but I'm
- 10:19going to really sort of break it down into a
- 10:21translation. It's the idea that you need disability
- 10:23and knowledge of the CT. Those intersecting creates
- 10:28a date of injury. So you have disability from
- 10:30this repetitive injury and knowledge that it
- 10:34is a cumulative trauma injury. That intersection
- 10:37creates a CT injury. Do you have one without
- 10:40the other? You have nothing. Do you have the
- 10:41other without the other? You have nothing. So
- 10:43if you have knowledge without disability, you
- 10:44have nothing. If you have disability without
- 10:46knowledge, you have nothing. It's only when the
- 10:48two intersect. So let me do the translation here.
- 10:51It's an intersection in time when the worker
- 10:54has a compensable disability from the cumulative
- 10:57injury and knows their work is the cause of that
- 11:00cumulative injury. So compensable disability
- 11:03plus knowledge of a cumulative work as the cause
- 11:06equals a date of injury for the CT. Here's an
- 11:11interesting point of law. So with the specific
- 11:15injury, If you fall down a set of stairs on January
- 11:171st, it's not a separate analysis of what the
- 11:20date of injury, it's the date that it happened.
- 11:22You fell down a set of stairs, the end. With
- 11:25a CT injury, there's danger here for the statute
- 11:30of limitations for the worker. The idea is you
- 11:32could now have met the definition of an injury.
- 11:36Remember I said you could have a physical repetitive
- 11:39thing and then plus a need for medical treatment,
- 11:42now you've had an injury? So for example, let's
- 11:44say a worker is working as a typist and is typing
- 11:49all day and repetitive trauma from the typing,
- 11:52and then they start treating a Kaiser and they're
- 11:55getting treatment for their carpal tunnel at
- 11:57Kaiser. Okay, well, that meets the definition
- 11:59of the CT injury. Problem is, do they know they
- 12:03have the injury yet? And so the risk is they've
- 12:06actually met the definition of the injury, but
- 12:10now they don't know that they've had the injury
- 12:12yet. And what if there's a statute of limitations
- 12:14problem with them bringing that client? So the
- 12:17law actually allows for this situation with the
- 12:22concept that you could have a finding of injury.
- 12:26You can go to trial and have a finding of injury.
- 12:29And if the intersection of disability knowledge
- 12:33has not taken place yet, that's fine. That could
- 12:35be a deferred determination. And the reason is,
- 12:39is that it's to prevent the premature commencement
- 12:42of the statute of limitations so that it would
- 12:44not expire before the employee was reasonably
- 12:47aware of his or her injury. So you can have,
- 12:51in fact, an injury, a CT injury, the worker's
- 12:55not aware of it. You can even have a CT injury
- 12:57where the worker is aware of it and brings the
- 13:00claim. And you can have a finding that there
- 13:03is a CT injury but no finding of date of injury
- 13:05yet and it's deferred. But this is a protection,
- 13:08a backstop protection this concept of the date
- 13:11of injury to prevent a worker from having an
- 13:16injury, not realizing it, and then later on someone
- 13:20saying that their claim is barred by the statute
- 13:21of limitations. I'll show you in a few minutes
- 13:25the flexibility of that concept with a couple
- 13:29of examples where it's very, very, very flexible
- 13:33and protective to the worker. That gets into
- 13:36the controversy discussion that we'll see. why
- 13:39it's controversial, this reality of it, and then
- 13:44the fact that some of these practices were historically
- 13:46in certain regions, and now they're everywhere,
- 13:48and that causes a lot of attention. All right,
- 13:53so let's now dive into these component parts
- 13:55for the date of injury for the CT. And that is
- 13:59the disability, compensable disability, and then
- 14:02the knowledge piece, and the need for those to
- 14:04intersect, and that creates the date of injury.
- 14:08And so the first concept is Compensable Disability.
- 14:10As I mentioned when I first started in this presentation
- 14:13is that it's been decades since there's been
- 14:16any kind of law change, either through legislature
- 14:20or case law with significant developments, fundamental
- 14:24significant developments on CT counts. And so
- 14:312004, Rodarte, the Court of Appeals published
- 14:33a decision is 22 years ago. But this gives you
- 14:37an idea that there's nothing necessarily new
- 14:40here, but you'll see the practice environment
- 14:43has changed. So I'm going to try to keep this
- 14:46as short as possible, this discussion. It can
- 14:48go deep, but I want to keep it just so you have
- 14:50the little nuggets, little point pieces, line
- 14:53item, pieces of law so you can work through this.
- 14:57Labor Code 5412 requires compensable, temporary,
- 15:00or permanent disability. See the money sign there?
- 15:02that's on purpose and I'll show you in a minute.
- 15:06Compensable, temporary disability or permanent
- 15:08disability. Modified work alone is not sufficient
- 15:11for compensable disability, but may indicate
- 15:13permanent impairment of earning capacity. Medical
- 15:15treatment alone is not disability, but may be
- 15:17evidence of compensable permanent disability.
- 15:20And these are questions for the triad back to
- 15:22determine. and may require medical expert medical
- 15:25opinion. What I mean by those pieces is you got
- 15:27to look at the historical context of when Rodarte
- 15:30came out. It was hot off of changes in the law
- 15:34moving where there was work restrictions and
- 15:38that was the framework of permanent disability
- 15:41and that was still relevant and this became a
- 15:47piece that had to be grappled with. of the concept
- 15:50of people saying, well, you use a modified work
- 15:53and that's obviously going to be a disability
- 15:58coming off of that background picture of the
- 16:01prior framework. And so even to this day, people
- 16:06latch onto that concept of saying, well, someone
- 16:08was a modified work and that's evidence of compensability
- 16:12disability. And the answer to that is no. But
- 16:16it is possible you can make that argument if
- 16:19you take that information and go to a medical
- 16:21doctor and make that case that those. The fact
- 16:25the worker was on modified duty and needed a
- 16:27bunch of medical treatment that was evidence.
- 16:30A permanent disability, not that that was permanent
- 16:32disability, but those factors are evidence of
- 16:35permanent disability. I won't go down the path
- 16:38of. whether that's possible to make a substantial
- 16:41medical evidence opinion, there is some case
- 16:43law that says it is possible to kind of latch
- 16:46onto that and cobble together a medical opinion
- 16:48that wasn't the existence of permadisability
- 16:51at the time. But fundamentally, as a practitioner,
- 16:55you should be looking at compensable temporary
- 16:58disability and permadisability. And I'll show
- 17:01you some cases right now which really drive home
- 17:04that need, because the operative term is compensable.
- 17:09Do you get paid for it? Compensable equals you
- 17:13get paid for it. Do you get paid for modified
- 17:16duties? No. You get paid for modified duties
- 17:20if the employer can't accommodate them and it
- 17:21translates into total temporary disability. Yes,
- 17:24then you get paid for that. So the fact that
- 17:26someone's modified duties alone is not enough.
- 17:29It's when you cannot accommodate it as the employer,
- 17:33which translates into total temporary disability,
- 17:35then you get paid, then it's compensable. See
- 17:37how the logic train works on that? So compensable
- 17:40in this framework of law equals you get paid
- 17:42for it. And so there's a couple of panel decisions
- 17:45I'd like to point out that really drive this
- 17:48point home on the money piece. And I'm just going
- 17:52to say the points of law. I don't want to go
- 17:54through the whole cases. But this Trujillo case,
- 17:57a finding of 0 % PD in an MMI report is not compensable
- 18:03disability. That's the point of law from that
- 18:05panel decision. And I want to jump to this one,
- 18:09this Espinoza. This is a very unique situation.
- 18:13But again, it drives home the point about the
- 18:14compensability piece. Sorry, the compensable
- 18:17piece that you actually get paid for. If you
- 18:19are a defense attorney, for example, and you're
- 18:22trying to push back a CT date of injury, and
- 18:24you're like, I'll say I got these subpoenaed
- 18:27records from Kaiser, and it looks like the applicant
- 18:29missed one to two days while he was working.
- 18:32And I'm going to say that that's compensable
- 18:34disability. Look at this Espinoza case. It said
- 18:38lost time within the three -day waiting period
- 18:40for TD. Remember, there's a three -day waiting
- 18:42period for TD. If you miss less than that amount
- 18:45of time, then you don't get compensated for those
- 18:47lost days. You're not compensated for it. It's
- 18:51not compensable disability. That's the way the
- 18:54panel decision came out. So you see the point
- 18:57here that it must be paid and if you're not getting
- 19:02paid for lost time, it's not compensable. If
- 19:05a 0 % report comes out, it's not compensable
- 19:07disability. Now, there may be facts in each case
- 19:11that you have which you could otherwise move,
- 19:14say that that is compensability or otherwise,
- 19:16but I'm just pointing out the concept, compensable
- 19:20equals you get paid for. Now, I just threw in
- 19:23this mind's case as well, just to point out this
- 19:25case just flat out rejected the concept of a
- 19:29defendant in a contribution proceeding, just
- 19:31going in and arguing to the arbitrator, hey,
- 19:34this guy had significant need for medical treatment,
- 19:37and that is evidence of compensable disability.
- 19:40But they did it without a medical report saying
- 19:42that. They did it without a QME or AME, anybody
- 19:45saying that evidence of medical treatment was
- 19:49evidence of compensable disability at the time
- 19:51that you're claiming it was. You can't just go
- 19:53in with your own allegations. So even hoping
- 19:57to attempt to do that with just evidence of medical
- 19:59treatment, you need a medical opinion that goes
- 20:02back, again, using Rodarte and saying that that
- 20:05was evidence of compensable disability at that
- 20:07time. But look at the trend, look at the trend
- 20:10of the board here, that it's heavily, heavily
- 20:13pointing to the idea that you need to be paid
- 20:15for whatever it is, temporary disability or permanent
- 20:17disability. Now, let's move to So we've established
- 20:23some parameters for the compensable disability
- 20:26piece. Now let's deal with the knowledge piece.
- 20:29Because again, we have to have the intersection
- 20:30of the two. So this is the other fundamental
- 20:34piece, which is the knowledge piece of the CT.
- 20:37And the seminal case on this is the city of Fresno,
- 20:39the Johnson case. Again, decades, decades and
- 20:44decades. No big change here. This has been the
- 20:46law for a long time, this and Rodarte, and people
- 20:49have been working with it. But then we'll see
- 20:51later on some functional changes in the practice.
- 20:55So this deals again with the concept of knowledge.
- 20:57The worker needs to know or should have known
- 21:00that their disability was caused by a CT injury.
- 21:03It's a question of fact. Now if the worker comes
- 21:06in and says they didn't know until they filed
- 21:08the application, then the burden is on the employer
- 21:14to say that they knew earlier on than what they're
- 21:18claiming. So that's the employer's burden. it
- 21:21switches the employer's burden. So if the worker
- 21:22comes in and says, I had no idea I had a CT injury
- 21:26until I met with my attorney on January 1st,
- 21:292026, and they told me I had a CT injury and
- 21:32we filed the application. That's my first state
- 21:34of knowledge. That's my first knowledge of this
- 21:36is a CT injury. So comes in, the application
- 21:38comes in like that. Now, if the employer wants
- 21:40to say, the defendant wants to say that it was
- 21:43earlier than that, that's their burden approved
- 21:46to show it. And the fact that they had, this
- 21:49is in important piece that I'm going to tie with
- 21:52something else in a minute. Just mere showing
- 21:55an applicant knew they had symptoms is not enough.
- 21:58You're going to subpoena records and you're going
- 22:00to have the worker in the records being told
- 22:03or telling the employer that they have symptoms
- 22:05from their back and there's going to be loose
- 22:08statements here and there and you're going to
- 22:10have that and it's not going to be enough. The
- 22:12fact that they knew they had symptoms two, three
- 22:14years ago before they filed the application.
- 22:16You're going to need a heck of a lot more than
- 22:17that. I'm going to show you in a minute. So fundamentally,
- 22:26this should come in the form of a medical advisement
- 22:31to the worker that you have a CT injury, a cumulative
- 22:37trauma injury, a medical doctor telling the worker
- 22:40that. That's just the best evidence. Remember
- 22:43law school, best evidence? I'm just gonna use
- 22:47that phrase to connote this. It's the best version
- 22:50of evidence that you could possibly have as a
- 22:52doctor telling the worker they have a cumulative
- 22:54trauma injury. Now, can you have something less
- 22:57than that or something different than that to
- 22:59establish the knowledge? Yes, but it's hard.
- 23:06The easiest substitute for a medical doctor telling
- 23:09the worker they have a CT injury is the attorney
- 23:12telling them they have it. The attorney telling
- 23:15them to file a CT claim. is going to be a good
- 23:18substitute for medical knowledge. So that's gonna
- 23:22work. There's case law that's gonna say that's
- 23:24gonna work. But what about something less than
- 23:28that? And that's where you get into this question
- 23:31of, fine, it's gonna be a question of fact. You
- 23:34don't have the doctor saying it. You don't have
- 23:37the attorney saying it. But what do you have
- 23:40that you as the employer can point to and say
- 23:42this applicant either knew or should have known?
- 23:45And the framework of factors that the courts
- 23:49will look at is the nature of the disability,
- 23:51the applicant's training, intelligence, qualifications,
- 23:54that they should have recognized the relationship
- 23:56between the known and adverse factors involved
- 23:58in the employment of the disability. That sounds,
- 24:02on its face, sort of reasonable as a defendant.
- 24:04You could say, oh, I could work with that. In
- 24:06practice, it's very difficult. I've seen cases
- 24:09with doctors as the claimant being found to not
- 24:13have the qualifications and sufficient. uh training
- 24:16to the to roll this way to find what they knew
- 24:19nurses let that sink in for a second there we're
- 24:23talking medical professionals that have brought
- 24:25their own ct injuries and it's found that they
- 24:27don't have enough uh knowledge to connect it
- 24:30so pretty hard stuff right um and so when you
- 24:36start thinking about your case with maybe it's
- 24:38an uneducated worker um and or it's a more unusual
- 24:43type of injury or took many medical evaluations
- 24:45to find compensability for the injury, you got
- 24:48to start asking yourself, really, do you have
- 24:51enough under this framework of law? And I'm going
- 24:53to show you a case in a few minutes that is going
- 24:55to make you a little uncomfortable, especially
- 24:59if you're a defense attorney. All right, and
- 25:02that's it. Oh, sorry, right away. I was thinking
- 25:04I was a few minutes off, but here we go, right
- 25:05on time. This case came to me in my knowledge,
- 25:11again, it's not saying any new point of law,
- 25:14but it's showing how the board's applying these
- 25:17points of law and really giving guidance to the
- 25:22parties of the high standard here. And I came
- 25:27across this, I serve as an arbitrator in Southern
- 25:29California, the whole state, but I serve a lot
- 25:32in Southern California as an arbitrator. I was
- 25:35dealing with a particularly interesting case
- 25:37and I came across this decision to help guide
- 25:40me in my decision of how to write it. I viewed
- 25:45this decision as very instructive from the board
- 25:47of how to think about this part of knowledge,
- 25:52this requirement of knowledge and what's really
- 25:53required there. Again, in a situation where you
- 25:57don't have the attorney telling them what the
- 26:00date is, you don't have the applicant outright
- 26:03admitting, They knew that could be a different
- 26:07scenario altogether where the applicant admits.
- 26:09We're not saying they knew they admit that I
- 26:12had a CT injury. That could be a different case.
- 26:14That's the Nielsen case, where they absolutely
- 26:17testify that they knew they had a CT injury.
- 26:19That's a very unusual circumstance. Not many
- 26:21applicants attorneys would want to see that from
- 26:24their applicants testifying that. So really,
- 26:28this is a good example of a case in those more
- 26:31ambiguous situations. case is very instructive
- 26:36to a judge. In my case, acting as an arbitrator
- 26:39was instructive. And then as a defense attorney,
- 26:42you can look at this case and say, oh dear, this
- 26:44is what's necessary. And as an applicant attorney,
- 26:46you can feel a lot of confidence from looking
- 26:47at this case and saying, oh yeah, this is pretty
- 26:49significant. But in terms of what, in those ambiguous
- 26:53situations where there's maybe some medical evidence
- 26:56in the record that kind of talks about the worker's
- 26:58work and you want to say, that's it, that's it.
- 27:00They knew, because the doctor mentioned that
- 27:02they work. And then they're also having back
- 27:05pain. This gives some kind of cold water to that
- 27:10idea. And so I'm gonna go a little bit in detail
- 27:12in these slides. I don't wanna go typically this
- 27:15detail, but I wanna go a little more detail in
- 27:17the slides so you can really get it into your
- 27:19bones, the level of knowledge that's necessary
- 27:21here. And then you can go forward and realize
- 27:23what you're working with. Okay, so applicant
- 27:27originally brought a 1999 specific injury claim.
- 27:30The carrier that was administering that claim
- 27:32for a while became insolvent and went to Ciga.
- 27:35Later, Ciga filed a CT claim. Ciga's filing a
- 27:39CT claim through 2006, and they wanted to use
- 27:44that, and they filed it in 2011. They wanted
- 27:47to use that as a vehicle to get reimbursements
- 27:50from other carriers. In that case, it was Zenith
- 27:52and Skip. And Zenith argued in that case that
- 27:57the filing in 2011 was late under the statute
- 28:01of limitations of labor code 5405. So you see
- 28:04what's happening here. Applicant has a regular
- 28:06specific injury. SEGA has been administering
- 28:10it. They get to a point where they believe that
- 28:12they have enough evidence to file a CT claim
- 28:14and say that there's been a CT involved here
- 28:17and we want to get some of our money back or
- 28:20all of our money back from another carrier and
- 28:23use the CT claim as a vehicle for that. They
- 28:26filed in 2011. And so problem here becomes, or
- 28:32at least the dispute here becomes, that Zenith
- 28:34argues that that filing in 2011 is late because
- 28:38of the fact that there had been an AME report
- 28:41in the case that came out that said, that commented
- 28:46on the idea that there was a cumulative trauma
- 28:48injury. In 2009, December 15, 2009, AME saying
- 28:54that there's a CT injury and they're saying,
- 28:59that that was evidence of knowledge in the parties,
- 29:04including CIGA, that there's a CT injury and
- 29:08that established the date of injury for the CT.
- 29:11And now the filing in 2011, April 27, 2011 is
- 29:16late under the one -year statute of limitations.
- 29:19So does everybody see that lay of the land in
- 29:21terms of the dispute? CIGA wants to use this
- 29:24application, CT application to get their money
- 29:26back. Zena is arguing that it's late because
- 29:28there have been an AME report saying this is
- 29:30CT. But let's dive into the language of that
- 29:33AME report, which becomes very influential here.
- 29:37But this points to the difficulty of not having
- 29:41a really tied up medical point about a CT. So
- 29:46this is the AME report. And you judge it. You're
- 29:49practitioners. You judge this language right
- 29:51now. As for apportionment, it is clear that she
- 29:54had a specific injury. Remember the original
- 29:56filing? There have been clear periods of trauma
- 29:59after that. Periods of trauma. Sounds like a
- 30:01cumulative trauma, right? This includes a period
- 30:04where her symptoms were significantly absent
- 30:06after her first operation. In the joint letter,
- 30:09a deposition has been alluded to and realized
- 30:11that it has not been forwarded to me. I believe
- 30:14at this time I will defer her apportionment discussion
- 30:16until I receive her deposition and I am able
- 30:18to compare her thoughts on her injuries and trauma.
- 30:22to the current records. At that time I will issue
- 30:24a supplemental on the apportionment status between
- 30:26continuous traumas and specific injury. So you
- 30:30have the doctor in there saying there's some
- 30:34evidence of a trauma and saying there's evidence
- 30:38of potentially apportionment to a continuous
- 30:41trauma but then goes on to say they need to get
- 30:44some more records so they can make a final determination.
- 30:46So on the one hand you can look at this as saying
- 30:48oh this is clear. saying that there's a cumulative
- 30:52trauma. This is enough knowledge to say it. And
- 30:56then the other hand is, well, it's saying there's
- 30:59a cumulative trauma, but at the same time it
- 31:00says it needs more records. And it's not definitive
- 31:03on the periods of the cumulative trauma and so
- 31:05on and so forth. So the trial judge says that
- 31:09this was not enough knowledge. This is not enough
- 31:13for knowledge, this medical statement. And again,
- 31:15I'm gonna read it in a little more detail because
- 31:17I want you to kind of feel it. This is precisely
- 31:20why the court found, this court, the judge, found
- 31:22that this report was not sufficient to provide
- 31:245412 knowledge of the defined cumulative trauma
- 31:29injury. Although the doctor references periods
- 31:31of trauma, he does not elaborate further as to
- 31:35what periods means, what trauma means, what dates
- 31:38are in question, and what the causes or potential
- 31:41industrial etiology of that trauma. In fact,
- 31:46the doctor defers further discussion on this
- 31:48point pending review of the Alpkins deposition
- 31:51testimony, where he will then be able to compare
- 31:54her thoughts on her injuries and trauma to the
- 31:56current records. This passage is meaningless.
- 32:00In isolation, it does not provide sufficient
- 32:02information to place any party on notice of the
- 32:05particular existence of a bounded industrial
- 32:09cumulative trauma claim. Although one could certainly
- 32:13draw an inference, It cannot be said that this
- 32:16passage provides the requisite knowledge to fix
- 32:20the date of injury for purposes of Labor Code
- 32:225412 and statute notations. So it's saying, this
- 32:26medical opinion's saying there's possible trauma
- 32:30and periods of trauma and a cumulative injury,
- 32:33but it's not definitive. It's not definitive
- 32:36on the periods, and it's not even definitive
- 32:38on the idea that there is one. It says it needs
- 32:41to look into it further. And so this judge says
- 32:43this is not enough. It's not enough. You can
- 32:48make the inference, but it's loose. It's too
- 32:51loose. Whereas the first instance in this case
- 32:57came a little bit later, where the judge says
- 32:59it's unequivocal. Think of that word, clearly
- 33:02unequivocal. As an applicant's attorney, you
- 33:06might want to use those words. in a case where
- 33:08someone's arguing with you as a defense attorney
- 33:10in a contribution proceeding, and if someone's
- 33:13trying to move back the CT on you, you might
- 33:15want to use these words, or move it further out,
- 33:19clearly and unequivocally. But these are pretty
- 33:21powerful and useful words. In this instant case,
- 33:25the first medical report which clearly and unequivocally
- 33:27set forth the existence of a separate cumulative
- 33:29trauma injury was the later Nelson report of
- 33:32November 17, 2010. This is the first and only
- 33:35report that describes a defined period of industrial
- 33:38cumulative trauma and applicant returns to work
- 33:40from her operation. Thus, the parties cannot
- 33:42be charged with knowledge of the cumulative trauma
- 33:44until the issuance of Dr. Nelson's November 17,
- 33:472010 report. So, Zena filed for reconsideration
- 33:52and the board adopted and incorporated the judge's
- 33:55decision, which talked about clearly and unequivocally
- 33:59established knowledge with that later report.
- 34:02So you see the high, high expectation for knowledge
- 34:07here. Yes, it comes out of the controlling authority
- 34:10is the City of Fresno case, which allows for
- 34:16an investigation in terms of, you know, if you
- 34:19don't have medical knowledge, you can look at
- 34:21the worker's intelligence and all that, which
- 34:24could factor in here. But in terms of that level
- 34:28of advisement, doctor telling the worker you
- 34:32have a CT injury and this is the level that they're
- 34:36talking about. There were work comp attorneys
- 34:38in this case. Think about how to compare that
- 34:41versus an uneducated worker. There are work comp
- 34:44attorneys in this case seeing that AME report
- 34:46saying there's trauma, periods of trauma, et
- 34:49cetera, and that's not enough with work comp
- 34:52attorneys involved in the case. Think about an
- 34:55uneducated worker that's gonna be having a doctor
- 34:58saying in a medical report at Kaiser or elsewhere,
- 35:03you know, oh, you're working and your work involves
- 35:05lifting. Oh, okay. What does that say? Does that
- 35:09tell you anything in terms of CT injury or periods
- 35:12of CT injury? This guidance from this case is
- 35:16very significant. Anyways, all right, so I've
- 35:22laid out. the definition of a CT injury as opposed
- 35:25to a specific injury. I've laid out the concept
- 35:27of the CT date of injury and how it's to be determined
- 35:33under labor code 5412, which is intended to protect
- 35:37the worker from the premature lapsing of the
- 35:40statute of limitations. And that now transitions
- 35:44us. And I've shown you the flexibility of these
- 35:46concepts with the need for that intersection
- 35:48of disability and knowledge. And that if you
- 35:51don't have Oh, if you have nothing. So if you
- 35:53only have a conventional disability, no knowledge,
- 35:55that's not enough. If you only have knowledge
- 35:57but no compensable disability, that's not enough.
- 35:59And so how flexible this point is. Now, as I
- 36:05said, this has been the law for decades. Nothing
- 36:08unusual here. I show that case to really ratchet
- 36:11up that refinement of the knowledge piece to
- 36:14show the level of evidence that's needed. But
- 36:18that's not really a change. That's just a nice
- 36:19refinement of the statement. This has been going
- 36:22on for the past few years. And what's been happening
- 36:26is, as we'll see, is the transition of the Southern
- 36:29California practice, which has been historically
- 36:32where it's been, and the spread to other areas.
- 36:35But what is so bothersome? What is so bothersome
- 36:39to the defense community about this? I showed
- 36:42you the statute of limitations issue. I'm actually
- 36:45going to show you a good case right now in terms
- 36:47of how flexible it is. But the statute of limitations
- 36:50thing is frustrating to the defendants, sure.
- 36:53Post -termination defense, that's where it really
- 36:56gets agitating to the defense, is that you have
- 36:59a worker that brings a claim after they're terminated.
- 37:04The whole concept of the post -termination defense
- 37:06is to avoid retaliatory claims. It's a public
- 37:09policy thing. The idea being, you had an injury?
- 37:13Cool. but you brought it after your termination.
- 37:16Therefore, as a matter of public policy, you
- 37:17lose, injured worker. Do you see how that works
- 37:20as a policy matter? It's an overriding of the
- 37:23injury. It says that's fine that you had an injury,
- 37:26but the fact you reported it after your termination
- 37:28as a matter of public policy, you lose, worker.
- 37:31But there's an exception to that defense if the
- 37:36date of injury is after the termination. How
- 37:39is that possible that your date of injury can
- 37:41be after the termination, you ask? why it's through
- 37:44the fact of the CT, if you have a CT injury,
- 37:47the date of injury being established after the
- 37:49germination, which I've just established is done
- 37:51with that intersection of disability and knowledge.
- 37:54So these have been irritating to the defense
- 37:58and insurance committee for some time. But it
- 38:03kind of reached, I'll admit, I've been around
- 38:05for a while in those circles. It was irritating
- 38:08and annoying, but it was at a point of plateau,
- 38:11if you will. No one was really pushing for anything
- 38:14in terms of reform or making a big stink out
- 38:17of it. Every now and then when people would say,
- 38:19let's make an adjustment here or there, really
- 38:21it's annoying to see these claims, no major push.
- 38:25But what changed though, like I said, it becomes
- 38:28controversial, is the explosion of filings of
- 38:32CT claims throughout the state, originating out
- 38:34of Southern California with Southern California
- 38:35output attorneys filing throughout the state.
- 38:39I'm going to work through each of these examples.
- 38:41I just want to show you a couple of flavor pieces
- 38:43for the stash imitations in the post -term to
- 38:45show you how flexible these concepts are and
- 38:48how it has irritated the defense community. And
- 38:51then we'll move through the dynamics and the
- 38:54policy discussion. This is a legal discussion
- 38:58in case you want to see some good examples as
- 39:00an alphabets attorney of how powerful these concepts
- 39:03are. And also, these are. illustrations for the
- 39:07defense, anyone that's the defense that's watching
- 39:09to see how powerful these concepts are. So when
- 39:11you're arguing about statute of limitations or
- 39:14post -termination defense, know where you stand
- 39:16in terms of the viability of those arguments.
- 39:20The case I love to present always is showing
- 39:23the most extreme version. And this is a sports
- 39:26case, I know, but the logic is applicable and
- 39:30the law is applicable. I've seen it applicable
- 39:32in other instances, but I just think this is
- 39:34a great example of how flexible these concepts
- 39:38are for the knowledge piece. Again, I'm just
- 39:41showing you an example of the statute of limitations
- 39:43defense and how it fails on a CT claim because
- 39:46of the data knowledge issue and why this is something
- 39:50that bothers the defense side. And then this
- 39:53post -termination example, and then you're going
- 39:55to see how an explosion of those throughout the
- 39:58state would start causing people to get a little
- 40:00bit concerned. So this applicant was a football
- 40:04player. They brought a CT claim filed in 2015
- 40:10for a CT period running through 1997, June 1997.
- 40:16The defendant argued, denied the claim, and argued
- 40:18it was barred by the statute of limitations.
- 40:20It's filed over 18 years later. Statute of limitations
- 40:24per labor code 5405 is one year when no benefits
- 40:27have been paid. Well, no benefits have been paid
- 40:29here. The argument that 18 years later is late.
- 40:32Everybody see that? Okay. Applicant claimed,
- 40:36had knowledge. So this is the applicant's support
- 40:38for their filing in 2015. They said they did
- 40:41not know they had a CT, they said that their
- 40:45date of injury was 2015 because they did not
- 40:47have knowledge of the CT until they filed it
- 40:50in 2015. So they're saying when they filed it
- 40:53with their attorney, that's when they had the
- 40:55knowledge. Remember I said earlier that yes,
- 40:58you need, it's best evidence is to have the medical
- 41:00evidence saying you have a CT. But a substitute
- 41:02for that can be your attorney telling you you
- 41:05have a CT and you filing a CT claim. That's an
- 41:07acceptable substitute. All right. The judge said
- 41:11the laborer 5412 required medical evidence. This
- 41:15is wrong. So I just want to point this out. Some
- 41:17things will come out that's just straight up
- 41:19wrong. And therefore, the CT date of injury was
- 41:23actually later. That the applicant, you filed
- 41:26an applicant. Your attorney told you had a CT.
- 41:27You filed a CT injury. but you did not know you
- 41:30had a CT injury until you had a medical doctor
- 41:32seven months later tell you how to CT. Okay,
- 41:36so we'll see what the board does at that point
- 41:38in a minute, but I just wanted to point it out
- 41:39that you'll see some things like that. The application
- 41:42filing of the CT is enough and it could substitute
- 41:46for the need for medical knowledge. So you don't
- 41:48need to like continue pushing it out to a later
- 41:50date. Defendant recondit claiming that the applicant
- 41:55should have known earlier. They had pointed to
- 41:57treatment records showing that the applicant
- 41:58got treatment for the knee getting surgery in
- 42:021998. So that's what the defense is going in
- 42:04on, saying the records show that he was getting
- 42:06treatment for the knee and that he should have
- 42:07known his playing as a football player had caused
- 42:10that. All right, from work. So the board denied
- 42:15recon and said the defendant was wrong, that
- 42:18those records in 1988 showed knowledge. But the
- 42:21judge was also wrong. because they said that
- 42:24you absolutely need a doctor report to find knowledge.
- 42:27That's not true. You could have something else
- 42:30establish knowledge. Remember I said with, you
- 42:33know, again, I'm saying it's a substitute, but
- 42:35the logic of it is the applicant's training,
- 42:38intelligence, and all of that. Well, when you
- 42:40have an attorney telling you you have a CT and
- 42:42file a CT, that's going to be sufficient to satisfy
- 42:45that. So that's it. So the CT knowledge date
- 42:49was 12 -17. 2015 with the filing of the CT. And
- 42:54the disability was actually already present in
- 42:561998. So remember, you need disability knowledge.
- 42:59You need the intersection. If you have one without
- 43:00the other, you have nothing. So here, the disability
- 43:03was established in 1998 when he had the surgery.
- 43:06But the intersection with knowledge did not come
- 43:08until 2015 when he filed the CT claim. So therefore,
- 43:12that was the date of injury. And it was filed
- 43:16within one year. the application was filed within
- 43:21one year, because it was filed on 12 -17 -2015,
- 43:24and that's when the applicant knew that's within
- 43:26one year, and it's not late under the statute
- 43:27of limitations. You see how that works? It's
- 43:29filed within one year. So the defendant loses
- 43:33on that argument. And then the other instance
- 43:36I want to use is a really simple example of the
- 43:40post -termination defense failing, but I just
- 43:43want to show you how just... plenty of examples
- 43:46of this. Better just throw this in there because
- 43:48it's just such a common example that, you know,
- 43:51as an applicant's attorney you can see it, and
- 43:53then as a defense attorney you should know what
- 43:55you're dealing with if you're telling your client
- 43:57that you're going to win a trial and you're running
- 44:00the woodchippers right in front of you, you're
- 44:02jumping right into the woodchipper. So this is
- 44:05a good guidance on that, or a good example of
- 44:07that. So this applicant was a housekeeper that
- 44:12brought a CT claim after they were terminated.
- 44:15Defendant argued that the post -termination defense
- 44:17applied and is barred by it. Applicant argued
- 44:19an exception to the post -termination defense
- 44:21is the 3600A10D because the termination was before
- 44:26the date of injury. So the date of injury was
- 44:28after the termination. So that's the exception.
- 44:30If the date of injury is after the termination,
- 44:33it's viewed as an exception. It's viewed as not
- 44:35retaliatory because you didn't know you had an
- 44:37injury until after you were terminated. That's
- 44:39the legal fiction. Therefore, this was not a
- 44:43pre -termination injury. This injury was after
- 44:47the date of injury is after the termination.
- 44:49Okay. The judge showed that the facts, the applicant
- 44:52was an uneducated worker, did not know her injuries
- 44:55were from work before her termination. The first
- 44:57date of disability is when she saw a PTP after
- 45:00termination and that doctor said you had a CT
- 45:03injury. The date of injury per 5412 was then.
- 45:06Therefore, the date of injury is after the termination
- 45:09and the exception is met. The defendant filed
- 45:11for reconsideration and the board adopted and
- 45:13incorporated the judge's decision. Nothing interesting
- 45:15there. But that's the reason why there's plenty
- 45:18of examples of these cases. I just wanted to
- 45:20show an easy, breezy example so you could just
- 45:23know that's how the board disposes of something
- 45:24like that. So these dynamics have existed for
- 45:29a long time. The agitation of the CT injuries
- 45:32being brought way late in terms of the defendant's
- 45:35perspective and that being a statute of limitations
- 45:38problem. the perspective of the defense attorneys
- 45:40and the insurance side, that these are post -termination
- 45:43filings and it's public policy says not that
- 45:49they shouldn't collect on them, but the weakness
- 45:52of that post -termination defense with the exception
- 45:55because of the date of injury after the termination.
- 45:59So like I said, there was kind of like a plateau
- 46:01or a stalemate for years here until some dynamics
- 46:05changed the last few years, which has put a lot
- 46:07of pressure on. And one of those things I want
- 46:11to point out, particularly, is this recent practice
- 46:15in the last one to two years of applicant attorneys
- 46:17filing two CT claims, one for the ortho and one
- 46:21for the psych. And so this has been a bit of
- 46:25the cherry on top of the last couple of years
- 46:28of the explosion of CT claims and the issues
- 46:31of the post -ternation defense and the statute
- 46:33of limitations and the Southern California attorneys
- 46:35bringing their practice throughout the state.
- 46:37The cherry on top has been this new practice
- 46:39of filing two CT claims. And I'm just going to
- 46:42say this for the benefit of everybody. This really
- 46:46was the accelerator of making the insurance side
- 46:49angry the last couple of years. So this practice,
- 46:53I get where it originated from. I get the idea
- 46:56that you're frustrated with the defense attorney's
- 46:59not agreeing to additional panels when you file
- 47:00a CT, which includes ortho and psych. And so
- 47:03there is some culpability on the part of the
- 47:05defense community and not operating in good faith
- 47:08on those cases and agreeing to additional panel
- 47:11when it's pled and clearly going to be needed.
- 47:14And so what happened was that if the applicant's
- 47:16attorneys, what is obvious is that they resorted
- 47:19to filing a second CT claim with a slight differential
- 47:23on the date, usually ending or starting one day
- 47:25early. And that way they can use that as a vehicle
- 47:28to straight away get the psych panel, get your
- 47:31one panel for the ortho claim. bodily injury
- 47:35claim, I know you're trying to get through Kairos,
- 47:36and then get your psych claim so you don't have
- 47:38to deal with a defense attorney being obstinate
- 47:41and fighting you over the additional panel. I
- 47:43get it. And so the defense community does have
- 47:45some culpability there. But this practice has
- 47:51agitated the carrier side tremendously because
- 47:54what it does is it creates a claims frequency
- 47:56issue on these accounts. It's very angering to
- 48:00the employer. And it creates an issue internally
- 48:02for insurance companies from the actuarial perspective
- 48:05that they're seeing many, many claims being brought
- 48:09and requiring tremendous amounts of reserves
- 48:13being considered for these claims when there's
- 48:17multiple spot. So it may look like from the applicant
- 48:20perspective on the outside that you're just filing
- 48:22this as a vehicle to get an additional panel.
- 48:25The chaos you're causing behind the scenes in
- 48:27terms of the employer's ex -mod and And the actuarial
- 48:33aspect on the insurance side is bad. And so this
- 48:37gets a lot of attention in the insurance industry.
- 48:40And so this, like I said, has kind of become
- 48:41the cherry on top of the attitude of, OK, you
- 48:45got our attention now. And so I'm just telling
- 48:48you what's being talked about. And I'll give
- 48:51you those examples in a minute. But here's how
- 48:54it comes in. I did a side by side. I removed
- 48:59all basic information just to show you how it
- 49:02comes in. The highlighted portions show how the
- 49:05CTs pled. So on the left is an ortho, I think
- 49:07it was, yeah, left is the, oh shoot, yeah, left
- 49:11is the site one, no, sorry, left is the ortho
- 49:14claim, pled through 1 -1, sorry, 1 -5 -2015,
- 49:18and the right one is the site claim, pled through
- 49:201 -4 -2025. So one day apart. And then so, The
- 49:26left -hand one was the ortho that was filed with
- 49:27that, and then the right -hand side is the cyclone
- 49:30that was filed with that. And that causes those
- 49:33issues that I just described internally in the
- 49:36carrier side and then with the employer and gets
- 49:38the attention of what I'll show you in a few
- 49:40minutes from the Department of Insurance and
- 49:43all these organizations that are now looking
- 49:45at this. But I mentioned a few minutes ago that
- 49:47this has been an explosion, and I'll give you
- 49:49the data that comes straight from the WCRDMs.
- 49:52That pre -pandemic there were 16 % of all indemnity
- 49:58claims were CT claims. In 2024, the number is
- 50:02up to 26%, and the estimate for 2025 is 30%.
- 50:07We don't have final numbers for 2025, but it's
- 50:09estimated at 30%. So a doubling, a doubling of
- 50:13the CT claims brought in the state. They're across
- 50:17all industry groups. So if not like, you know,
- 50:20people are having more injury, cumulative trauma
- 50:23injuries in one sector versus another. It's across,
- 50:25it's everybody's having more CT injuries. How
- 50:27is that, right? That's a strange dynamic. It's
- 50:30across all industries. It's across all regions.
- 50:33You had Central Valley, 7 % CTs before, and then
- 50:39up to 12 % in 2024. So that number is probably
- 50:41about 15 % with the adjustments for 2025. Northern
- 50:44California, 6 % pre -pandemic. and then up to
- 50:4711%, again, in 2025, those numbers are gonna
- 50:49be at least 14 % or something like that. And
- 50:54the reality is, it's come about from our colleagues
- 50:57in Southern California. LA area firms filing
- 51:00CT claims, 80 % of all CT claims, let the statistics
- 51:06sit with you for a moment, 80 % of all CT claims
- 51:11in Northern California, meaning workers from
- 51:14Northern California. 80%, regardless of being
- 51:18filed in Southern California, I get that. But
- 51:2180 % of all CT claims in Northern California,
- 51:25workers living in Northern California, bringing
- 51:27CT claims, are being brought by LA area firms.
- 51:32So domestically, organically, in Northern California,
- 51:3720 % of the CT claims that exist are from Northern
- 51:40California firms, 80 % are from Southern California
- 51:42firms. How is that possible? I'll show you in
- 51:46a minute. 58 % of these CT claims are filed post
- 51:49-termination, and 99 % of the post -termination
- 51:52CT claims are litigated. You're probably wondering,
- 51:54how is it only 99 %? I would expect it to be
- 51:57100%, but it's as close to 100 % as you could
- 52:00possibly get. These are some big numbers, and
- 52:04they're very dramatic numbers. There's no escaping
- 52:06them or hiding from them. It's clear the increase
- 52:11in CT filings that for these Northern California
- 52:14populations are coming from Southern California.
- 52:18But how is that possible? It didn't exist before
- 52:20the pandemic. It's possible with the advent of
- 52:23remote appearances. Recall, pandemic happened.
- 52:26We switched to remote appearances, life size,
- 52:30and well, AT &T line, life size, and then switched
- 52:32over to core call. It was baked into the rules
- 52:35in 2022 that any type of hearing could be covered
- 52:39remotely. There's a process if you want to object,
- 52:46which is almost impossible. But the idea is it's
- 52:50presumed. It's presumed that any appearance other
- 52:53than trial will be covered electronically, remotely.
- 52:57So what does that do in terms of a practice group?
- 53:00You, as an athletics attorney looking at it,
- 53:03or a defense attorney looking at it, that I'm
- 53:05sitting here in Southern California. Can I take
- 53:08a case for a worker that's in Northern California?
- 53:11And what would it look like? And so that is the
- 53:17logic train of how that looks. And going, OK,
- 53:19well, they're telling me it's presumed these
- 53:22will be electronic appearances. Got it. And you're
- 53:25telling me, and I know most people want to settle
- 53:28with me, so I will settle before trial, which
- 53:31could be in person. It's possible. And there's
- 53:35some things that are. Anyways, I'll get a separate
- 53:38point. Fundamentally, there's a confidence that
- 53:43you can file these claims and handle these claims.
- 53:46Either you get them venued in Southern California,
- 53:49where you want them to be, or if venue is moved
- 53:51to Northern California, you could still manage
- 53:54them because you'll be able to settle them without
- 53:56the ever need for a physical appearance. This
- 53:58becomes the infrastructure to support that practice.
- 54:03And as I showed you a few minutes ago, 80 % of
- 54:09the CT claims filed for Northern California applicants
- 54:11are filed in Southern California. So this becomes
- 54:15the infrastructure to make that possible. Before
- 54:18the pandemic, 17 % of appearances were handled
- 54:21remotely. After the pandemic in 2024, and again,
- 54:24probably adjust upwards, there's a few reasons
- 54:27for that. About 83 % were done remotely. Obviously,
- 54:30it's including the trials that are in person,
- 54:32but I think that numbers ticked up a little bit.
- 54:37And so where has this become controversial? As
- 54:41I talked about before, it's getting the attention
- 54:43of significant players in the state, policymakers.
- 54:50In 2025, the insurance commissioner, Laura, had
- 54:58specifically cited this increase in CT claims
- 55:03and justifying the first increase in the peer
- 55:07premium for insurance, for workers' comp insurance
- 55:11in over a decade. And this is a letter to the
- 55:16governor and the legislature saying that I'm
- 55:20increasing, I've highlighted the relevant sections,
- 55:23I'm increasing the insurance rates in part because
- 55:28of these CT coins. So where does that go downstream?
- 55:32The employers? The employers are getting hit
- 55:34with higher insurance. And they are important
- 55:40stakeholders in our system. And so if they get
- 55:44agitated about that, and no one wants the political
- 55:47backlash of workers' comp. Workers' comp is not
- 55:50never, ever, ever, as a policy point and a political
- 55:54point, a net gain. You just don't, as politicians
- 55:57go, historically, they just don't want anything
- 56:00negative. They don't believe it's a vehicle.
- 56:02I don't think there's any historical evidence
- 56:04of using it as a vehicle for improving their
- 56:05popularity. They use it as they just don't want
- 56:08to have it pull them, drag them down. No one
- 56:10wants to have workers' comp drag down your popularity
- 56:13as governor. It's a distraction. You have an
- 56:15insurance commissioner to deal with it. You have
- 56:17experts in the system to deal with it. But if
- 56:19it becomes an albatross around the neck in the
- 56:21economy, nobody wants to deal with that. And
- 56:25that's the story of SIPTF as an emergency issue.
- 56:28and then just straight up pushing through a reform
- 56:33come hell or high water, regardless of many stakeholders'
- 56:37interests, because that was hitting the employers
- 56:38very hard, as an administrative piece as well
- 56:42for the state to have to pay that and administer
- 56:44that giant beast of SIBTF. And then, sure enough,
- 56:49in 2026, just had another rate increase from
- 56:52the insurance commissioner, and citing once again
- 56:55that the increase in CT claims and the litigation
- 57:00has accompanied it. And so this is on the radar.
- 57:05It's an insurance commissioner talking about
- 57:06it, and then WCRB talking about it, CWCI talking
- 57:12about it, the California Health and Safety Workers
- 57:14Commission talking about it. It's there. So what
- 57:18are some of the things that have been talked
- 57:19about in terms of dealing with them? Again, remember,
- 57:24I mentioned these are pie. I've heard about people
- 57:27talking about CT performed for decades. This
- 57:30was pie in the sky stuff, historically talking
- 57:33about it. Eliminating that exception to the post
- 57:36-termination defense with the CTs. Raising the
- 57:40causation standard for CT injuries to make it
- 57:44like a site claim, making it 50 % plus. Those
- 57:48types of things. Those are pie in the sky ideas.
- 57:50When people bring them up in discussions, you
- 57:52literally roll your eyes and be like, yeah, yeah.
- 57:54Now these are literally things that people are
- 57:56talking about as actual reforms. And this trend
- 58:01has produced that, has brought it up to the,
- 58:03has bubbled it up to the top. And so, but my
- 58:06prognostication, well, my feeling, I mean, if
- 58:10you've got me, if you want my cold hearted belief
- 58:14is that if you removed, again, many of you in
- 58:16this call are probably going to hate me for saying
- 58:17this, but, and I like remote appearances too.
- 58:19But if you killed remote appearances, I'd have
- 58:21to imagine that would make it harder to operate
- 58:24this way. But assuming you don't do that, then
- 58:28you didn't change any venue rules or anything
- 58:31like that. But the major ones that are being
- 58:33discussed right now and will be in the mix in
- 58:36the next couple of years are raising the causation
- 58:39standard for CT claims, like what was done with
- 58:42site claims 30 -something years ago, and or eliminating
- 58:49the CT exception to post -harmonization offenses
- 58:51or things that are actively being talked about.
- 58:53Question is whether it's going to come in the
- 58:54context of a grand bargain or not. Obviously,
- 58:58I could acknowledge that there needs to be a
- 59:00PD increase. There hasn't been one for many years,
- 59:0412 years, 13 years. I could see over the next
- 59:09one to two years, horse trading happening and
- 59:11the grand bargain happening with the PD increase
- 59:13in exchange for reform to the CT claims in some
- 59:17form. don't think it's possible, that was a radical
- 59:22change to SIBTF that went through with very little
- 59:27interest in what people had to say about it.
- 59:29And just saying things hit the fan hard enough.
- 59:34Politically, there's no interest in having bad
- 59:36stuff. Just delivering news from the field. All
- 59:41right. That's all I have. Thank you, everyone,
- 59:43for attending. Thank you. Pleasure to be here.
- 59:45Take care. Bye -bye.