Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Mentalizing vs. Emotional Regulation
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information.
- 0:06Please visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:11That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:21This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:23It is Thursday, April 2nd, 2020, sixth at 7:36 PM specific
- 0:28Daylight Time. And tonight I thought I would
- 0:30talk about mentalizing versus emotional regulation and how the
- 0:35meditation approach differs with attachment repair.
- 0:39I think this is really one of the fundamental differences in
- 0:43the Medi group approach with the the more psychotherapy based
- 0:48approach approaches. And I think that that is also
- 0:52true because of the way that Buddhist philosophy understands
- 0:57the construction of self in Western psychology.
- 1:04If I can make these, you know, sweeping general statements with
- 1:09no citations to back anything up.
- 1:16The, the main activity is the deconstruction of self and how
- 1:21the self experiences the world and how the self relates to
- 1:25other people in the world. In, in the, in Buddhist
- 1:31philosophy, the world is other people, not this other, this
- 1:35place that's around us. And so if you look at the Sati
- 1:41Pattana suit to the refrain that repeats 17 times, a mindfulness
- 1:46of inside, mindfulness of outside, mindfulness of inside
- 1:49and outside, what we're looking at is this structure of self
- 1:54that we create and the structure of other people.
- 1:58And then can we in real time monitor the the interaction, the
- 2:04reaction to the other person and how that affects the self and
- 2:09how we monitor the other person's reaction to our sense
- 2:13of self? And can we really understand
- 2:16that? That would be mentalizing,
- 2:19right? To be able to understand that
- 2:21you represent your yourself as a working model.
- 2:26This is how it ties in so seamlessly to attachment theory
- 2:31and attachment thought. Balby's understanding that we
- 2:35create a working model of self, we create a working model of
- 2:39other people and we we attempt to understand the interactions
- 2:43between these two working models in, you know, classical Freudian
- 2:52theory, it's instincts. You get into the Klein and
- 2:56stuff, it's object relations and projection.
- 3:03In Buddhist philosophy, of course, the self is
- 3:08insubstantial and is created in the moment based on conditions,
- 3:14which is very different than a western concept of a a self that
- 3:19that's consistent and actionable over time.
- 3:24Really the sense of self arise is based on the conditions of
- 3:27the present moment in a relationship to the conditions
- 3:32of the present moment. When you say a working model,
- 3:35what that really means is these gists, these little capsules of
- 3:39memory that are associated to one working model or another.
- 3:44And then when something happens in the present moment that
- 3:47activates that patterning of self, we recognize, oh, this is
- 3:52me. And when it activates a
- 3:54representation of someone else, we think, oh, that's you.
- 4:00A gist, if I can use the metaphor of a recording studio.
- 4:04Have you ever been in a recording studio when when
- 4:07they're mixing down a track and you have in front of you this
- 4:10large mixing board that has all of these different tracks on it
- 4:15and the the recordings are separated.
- 4:17Say let's say 8 tracks or 16 tracks something.
- 4:21And as you go through the song, you set all of these levels.
- 4:25Then you get into the next part of the song, you set all of
- 4:28these levels, and then when you get all the way through the song
- 4:32setting all of the different levels, you run the song through
- 4:36and shift all of the different levels.
- 4:38And so a lot of these boards are completely automatic and you
- 4:44have this, well, mixed track where everything is balanced at
- 4:47the end. So you might say that it just is
- 4:50one of the particular settings of the board and the board is
- 4:54the body, let's say. So you remember something that
- 4:57just goes off and it changes the settings and the board, the
- 5:00sensitivities between the sense gates as you've gathered the
- 5:04material and it recreates in the present moment in memory.
- 5:09That is to say, the recreation in the present moment of the
- 5:12setup of the experience and what the experience meant to you.
- 5:17We don't really operate on what happens.
- 5:21We don't have the capacity to record what happens and then
- 5:25play it back and reflect in the present moment on something that
- 5:30was representative of what happened.
- 5:35What we have is the capacity to reset the body into a similar
- 5:39state and then play the meaning that we made out of the
- 5:43encounter that we had. And so we're in each moment
- 5:46creating the meaning of the experience that we had
- 5:49activating these working models. You know, you're thinking a
- 5:55thought and the thought plays and in the thought you're
- 6:00speaking to someone or you're watching two people speak and
- 6:03you have the sense, because of the physical sense of the body
- 6:06and the emotional component of the body, that the memory is an
- 6:11accurate representation of what happened.
- 6:15But actually it's a it's a replay or a recreation of what
- 6:20it meant to you. And depending on what state you
- 6:24were in, it could be accurate or not accurate.
- 6:27And whether you understood properly what was actually
- 6:30happening or your version of it is quite different than what
- 6:35other people's perceptions of what happened are.
- 6:38You're still in the meaning that you make out of it.
- 6:43If you remember something from childhood when you were five
- 6:46years old, you no longer have a 5 year old body to remember it
- 6:49in. You have a whole different
- 6:51cognitive capacity to reflect on it.
- 6:54All you have are the the rudimentary settings of the
- 6:59experience that you had that changes or adapts to the body
- 7:03that you have now and the meaning of it.
- 7:05And it plays. And then you create in the
- 7:08present moment the version that you're experiencing now, Right?
- 7:14Is that making sense? So in order to mentalize that
- 7:24well, you have to be able to track all of that and all of the
- 7:26the different sense gates to see what the settings are, to
- 7:29understand the auditory visual felt sense of the body, taste
- 7:37and smell, all of those plus mind, what was mind doing, what
- 7:41was mind focusing on? And then there's the physical
- 7:45quality of the body and then the the emotional quality of the
- 7:50body. All of those things create the
- 7:54sense of meaning that we have. One of the things that's also
- 7:58important about meaning is the relationship, right?
- 8:01So mindfulness inside, mindfulness of outside,
- 8:04mindfulness of inside and outside is really about the
- 8:08expression of our experience to someone else.
- 8:11Why is that important in generating meaning?
- 8:18It's important because the process of making the meeting is
- 8:21often the same process of figuring out what it is that we
- 8:25want to communicate to someone, right?
- 8:28And without the, the, the need to communicate to someone,
- 8:32without anyone being available to us to communicate it, we
- 8:38don't necessarily go through a process of assigning meaning to
- 8:41anything. And also we don't have a good
- 8:44means of testing the accuracy of what it is that we've created in
- 8:49the present moment. It's not that we're relying on
- 8:54the other person to define the meaning of the experience that
- 8:57we have, but you know, whether they receive it and it seems
- 9:02likely or they receive it and it seems unlikely gives us an
- 9:05indication about whether we should review the, the, the
- 9:09structure and meaning of what it, what we're experiencing.
- 9:14Is that making sense? So the mentalizing frame that I
- 9:26like to talk about is we are able to understand in the
- 9:30present moment, the experience that we're having.
- 9:35That is to say, we're able to touch into the felt sense of it
- 9:38in the body, the visual aspect that we pick out of the
- 9:42environment. In the West, we often think that
- 9:46the the body mind experiences in a neutral way everything that's
- 9:50happening around us, and that we create a version of that that's
- 9:54largely accurate. That's the Aristotelian view.
- 9:59In the Buddhist view, we highly curate a selection of mind
- 10:04moments that we select, grabbing the things that we prefer and
- 10:09leaving out the things that don't matter to us and avoiding
- 10:13the thing that we don't like. So that we really pick a very
- 10:19curated misrepresentation of the general in the way that we
- 10:25experience what's happening in the present moment.
- 10:32So the capacity descends. Touch, sight, sound, taste,
- 10:37smell, mind. Mind is what directs your
- 10:40attention. The object has contact with the
- 10:45sensing experience. Consciousness of the sensing
- 10:47experience arises. That makes sense capacity to
- 10:50sense the object that can be sensed by that sense gate.
- 10:54When there's contact, consciousness arises.
- 10:59It's then really evaluated by the body for urgency.
- 11:02This is the Buddhist model, right?
- 11:05If it needs urgent, it needs urgent attention.
- 11:08It skips the line and goes to the top of the queue.
- 11:11If it doesn't matter, if there's no need to ever pay attention to
- 11:16the the the gathering of a particular sense data, nothing
- 11:22ever happens with it. And if there's time for a
- 11:24pleasant experience, then we have in a pleasant experience.
- 11:27The brain science is pretty good on this. 3/8 of a second to
- 11:31process something that's urgent to half a second to process
- 11:35something that's pleasant, a shorter duration, a shorter
- 11:40pressure for urgent, a longer duration, and a higher pressure
- 11:47of sensation in order to posit process something positive.
- 11:52It then forms this cue, which is compared to the perceptual
- 11:56database. And if there's a meaning in the
- 11:59perceptual database that's close enough to the undifferentiated,
- 12:03unfixated, unformed sensing moment that the whole thread of
- 12:08meaning comes down and attaches and it rolls into conceptual
- 12:13reality. That is to say, we make a
- 12:15tableau of the world around us that feels solid and compelling.
- 12:23If you're a sighted person, one way that you can figure that out
- 12:26is if you look around the room and everything looks in focus
- 12:29and everything has detail in it. You're in the construction of
- 12:33the mind and not in the sensing experience.
- 12:37Have you ever looked for your keys for and not found them and
- 12:42not found them and not found them and found them in the place
- 12:45you looked three times already? That's this.
- 12:52You created a picture of where the keys were without the keys
- 12:56in them because it didn't make sense to you in some level that
- 12:59they would be there. So you looked and you looked and
- 13:01you looked. And then finally, when you put
- 13:03the effort into recreating every single place that you looked,
- 13:08you created the place more like it was and the keys were there.
- 13:14The mind is very, the brain is very economical in the way that
- 13:17it processes things. And if it can get away with
- 13:20using an old image over having to recreate the image new, it
- 13:24will use the old image. I I last December, I changed all
- 13:33of the pictures in my living room to different pictures.
- 13:37And I have a friend who comes over for dinner once a week.
- 13:42And, and in June, no, in March, last month or no, in February,
- 13:55in February, he said, oh, you put new pictures on the wall.
- 14:02I said, yeah, I put new pictures on the wall three months ago.
- 14:04And you've been here five times and you didn't notice them,
- 14:09right? Because the mind recreates the
- 14:12environment using the old imagery.
- 14:16So you can't even be sure that the this creation that you're
- 14:20currently inhabiting is actually what's happening now, right?
- 14:25And the insurance industry says that motorcycle with one
- 14:29headlight is 9 times more likely to be in an accident with a car
- 14:34than a motorcycle with two headlights.
- 14:37The most common excuse of a driver who runs a motorcycle off
- 14:40the road is it wasn't there. And this is particularly true on
- 14:46commuter routes where you're driving back and forth on the
- 14:50same road. Do you ever leave work and get
- 14:55home and not really remember the space between?
- 14:59The mind is just driving on automatic.
- 15:05So the mentalizing is to push the mind into every time making
- 15:10a new representation rather than allowing it to rely on the old
- 15:16to examine as you make meaning. Taja padadi is the word for
- 15:22this, that you're reflecting backward on to what you make.
- 15:29So that that would suggest that your orientation is in the
- 15:33sensing experience, not in the fabrication, right?
- 15:41But how easily can you discern the sensing experience, the pure
- 15:46sensing experience from what you made it into?
- 15:50And one of the, the reasons for that, of course, is that it
- 15:53enters consciousness most of the time already defined, already
- 15:59solidified into these representations.
- 16:03And it's very easy if you don't begin to mentalize it to, to
- 16:06just accept the version that the mind has landed on.
- 16:12So one of these mentalizing skills, of course, is to be able
- 16:15to reflect backwards from the sensing experience on to what
- 16:21you created to see whether it's actually represent
- 16:25representative of that. So that when we talk about
- 16:30recognizing the experience of the creation of self and others
- 16:35through the attachment frame, through this Buddhist meditation
- 16:38frame, what we're really talking about is this moment by moment
- 16:43manufacturing of self and world, rather than reifying, which is
- 16:51often what happens in Western psychology, reifying the self
- 16:56experience as being something that's fixed.
- 17:00I think that's particularly true of people who do parts work
- 17:04because they talk about parts of themselves in a reified ways, as
- 17:08if they actually exist as a separate part from the whole.
- 17:13And that it's an interaction of parts that are stable and fixed
- 17:18rather than a moment by moment creation of the experience of
- 17:24self and world, which is more on the the Buddhist side of things.
- 17:27So they're working with attachment conditioning and
- 17:31attachment repair on the meditation side means that we
- 17:36are experiencing over and over again these creations of self
- 17:41and world, mainly by reflecting back on them and comparing them
- 17:46to the sensing experience to see how well they match, rather than
- 17:51reifying the sense of self into something stable, solid in the
- 18:00meditation frame there arising based on conditions.
- 18:05And there is no solid, retrievable, consistent self
- 18:11response. It's always made-up based on
- 18:13conditions of the present moment.
- 18:17There aren't fixed parts. There isn't an ongoing self
- 18:21experience that existed from the beginning of your life to now
- 18:26that will exist into the future. It's momentary, it's
- 18:29instantaneous, and it comes and goes.
- 18:34I guess you'd have to. You'd have to imagine the
- 18:38experience of your life to see whether that that would be true
- 18:42or not. Is the self this constant thing
- 18:44or not? When the self experience arises
- 18:51in consciousness, Which is not to say that it doesn't.
- 18:55Of course it does. It's an organizing principle
- 18:58that we use in a way of relating to other people.
- 19:04You're understanding that I'm speaking English and you're
- 19:07making meaning out of the words that I'm saying.
- 19:11But we would have to have a conversation about meaning to
- 19:14understand that your definitions of the words I'm using match the
- 19:19definitions that I use in the creation of the sentences,
- 19:24right? You could understand something
- 19:26quite different than what I'm intending you to understand
- 19:30because you are defining all the words differently.
- 19:33And so part of what this process is, so that first level of
- 19:37mentalizing is where you understand that you have just
- 19:41created the experience of the present moment that you're
- 19:45having based on your conditioning and you understand
- 19:49what conditioning you're using to define the present moment.
- 19:53That's the that piece of deconstructing self as it
- 19:59arises. Once you understand all of that,
- 20:02the second part of it is. What about that?
- 20:06Do you want to communicate to someone else?
- 20:09That's this process of meaning making in relationship to
- 20:13someone else. Have you ever noticed that
- 20:17you're thinking can get wildly off if you don't ever express
- 20:20anything to anyone else? Your perception of self and
- 20:25world can get quite distorted in a way that might not be so
- 20:30useful because you never actually define what actually
- 20:37you mean. You never define how you've made
- 20:41the experience of reality. If you don't like the
- 20:46experiences of reality, you could split them off and project
- 20:49them on someone else and think that they're expressing that to
- 20:52you, which is a a way in which the the experiences of Western
- 20:58psychology and the information that's been gathered in that the
- 21:01process can be very useful in illuminating the sense of the
- 21:07activity of self. But we're really organized
- 21:13around this momentary creation of self enrolled and not so much
- 21:18on these chunks or pieces or parts of self, not in, in the
- 21:28sense that you're in this way or or or that way.
- 21:31You're responding to the conditions of the present
- 21:34moment. And depending on the conditions,
- 21:36you can be wildly disparate in, in how you respond in
- 21:42communicating to someone else. There's a transliteration often
- 21:45where you understand the definitions that they use and so
- 21:50that you explain to them what you mean in a way that they're
- 21:53likely to understand what you mean.
- 21:56But then you check, you validate that they've understood actually
- 22:00what you mean. You, you probably have heard me
- 22:02use the metaphor of chairs, cherries and raspberries.
- 22:09I love cherries. This is not a good time of year
- 22:13for cherries, although there's still some from Chile that are
- 22:17available if you don't mind the astronomical carbon use
- 22:23associated flying them here from there.
- 22:28And cherries are one of those fruits that don't ripen after
- 22:32you pick them. So you have to pick them ripe
- 22:35and and they don't last very long.
- 22:39Stone fruit typically doesn't last long, although some stone
- 22:43fruit you can pick green it, it will ripen.
- 22:45This is not true of cherries, but if you get a fresh ripe
- 22:52cherry, there is a a complexity to the taste of it, at least in
- 22:58reaction to my tongue, that I find astonishing.
- 23:03And every now and then you just get a a magnificent cherry out
- 23:07of the bunch and the taste experiences mind blowing.
- 23:15But let's say you think cherries are rather ho hum.
- 23:21And so I say to you that this experience is so fascinating.
- 23:26It's so interesting and so amazing.
- 23:29It's just like cherries. And you think that's ho hum,
- 23:32I'll skip it. Now.
- 23:35Had I said to you it's just like raspberries, you would have
- 23:38said, oh, that's intriguing. I love raspberries.
- 23:40There's complexity there. So that's what I mean by
- 23:46transliteration. You explain things to people in
- 23:49a way that they understand what you mean, not what they would
- 23:53mean if they were using the the way that they described.
- 23:58If they used your words to describe something, they would
- 24:02mean something else. Then what you have to do is
- 24:05listen to their response, right? They expressed to you their
- 24:09response to what you communicated to them.
- 24:11And then you have to understand that you've understood them
- 24:15because then you can modify your understanding of the
- 24:17relationship that you're having. And if those pieces aren't in
- 24:22there, they could be having a completely different
- 24:24relationship than you're having. You ever noticed that one, one
- 24:30or both people are in a fantasy of what the relationship is
- 24:33rather than in a communicated, shared experience of what it is?
- 24:42The mentalizing capacity is linked to the emotional
- 24:46regulation capacity. If you get really emotionally
- 24:49regulated it, it diminishes or collapses the capacity to
- 24:54mentalize. And then you're simply in in
- 24:57these constructions of the body mind where the meaning that
- 25:04you're making, the reaction that you're having is related to the
- 25:08memory, the gists that you set up and are often related to a
- 25:12time different than the time you're in, often different time.
- 25:18Of course, we could say is a construct that have you noticed
- 25:25that you, you, you only exist, that you've never existed
- 25:29outside of the present moment. It's always only ever been the
- 25:33present moment. So in that sense, time is
- 25:37irrelevant, right? There's no escaping the
- 25:41experience of the present moment.
- 25:43And in fact, because we define the experience of the present
- 25:46moment on what has already happened, the the past and the
- 25:53present moment are in somewhat the same.
- 25:55And because we expect things to happen, we anticipate things
- 25:59happening based on the meaning that we give them.
- 26:01The future is also all compressed in this sliver of
- 26:07experience. Is that making sense?
- 26:09Does that match what your experiences?
- 26:12The eternity, the unending present moment?
- 26:17And yet we seem to be older, David.
- 26:25Do you have a suggestion on what to do when somebody is
- 26:30constantly dwelling on the past and saying, oh, you always do
- 26:34this, it always turns out that way.
- 26:37Is there a way to flip that into the present?
- 26:44You always do. This means that they're
- 26:46interpreting or are eliciting from you a a different kind of
- 26:51care. Is that what they're doing?
- 26:53Yeah, well, like you never listen.
- 26:55You always leave the toilet seat down.
- 26:59You you know that there's some people that that that I think
- 27:04there's some people that live their whole lives as if it's
- 27:09always going to be the same way it's always been and not relish
- 27:14the present or think that things can change for the better is.
- 27:19The so the non mentalizing frame is where we're at a non
- 27:28mentalizing frame. If you would say it's always the
- 27:34same and it always turns out the same, that would mean that you
- 27:39are not actually in the experience of the present
- 27:42moment, which is never the same, right?
- 27:44So you're not not mentalizing at that that level.
- 27:48You always do the same thing, which means they're assigning
- 27:51meaning to something. Is it a request for something?
- 27:59Right? When you say that it's always
- 28:01the same, what is it that you're actually asking of me?
- 28:06How would you like? I mean, you would like it to be
- 28:09different, You would like me to be different, or you would like
- 28:11me to to respond to in a different way.
- 28:13What is it that we're actually talking about?
- 28:15Because it's always the same and it always turns out the same.
- 28:19Doesn't actually provide much in the way of information, but
- 28:23sounds like a request for closeness, a request for
- 28:29response. Could you say instead that you
- 28:34want closeness? Could you say instead that
- 28:36you're looking for a particular response?
- 28:40Because that's all being pushed on me, right?
- 28:44Or maybe it's you who keep having the same experience and
- 28:48that you don't want to hold on to that, so you're splitting it
- 28:50off onto me, and I'm the one who's suddenly responsible for
- 28:53all of that. Am I really the one who's
- 28:57responsible for how your perception of the present moment
- 29:01is? I don't even have capacity to do
- 29:03much about that, really. Thank you.
- 29:07What do you want? All you have to do is ask.
- 29:11I'll give it to you. What do you want?
- 29:18That would mean they would have to.
- 29:19They would have to begin a mentalizing process of what is
- 29:22it that was absent for them in that creation of it's always the
- 29:29same and the outcome is always going to be lacking, right?
- 29:33What is the big lack, to use a Leukanian term, what is the big
- 29:40lack that you're describing in saying it's always the same?
- 29:43What's missing? So that you you push it back
- 29:48onto them. You know, you throw the ball
- 29:49back on that side of the court and let them fumble.
- 30:01PJ. It feels to me sometimes like it
- 30:06just feels like time travel. It can, certainly.
- 30:11Yeah, I mean, you are here now, but you're not.
- 30:16I I get this feeling sometimes, not so often anymore, but I used
- 30:21to get really triggered and it felt like I flew back to some
- 30:24time in the past, right? So that's the collapse of
- 30:29mentalizing and the overtaking of emotion.
- 30:31Yeah. Grounding here we are.
- 30:37Grounding in the past. Yeah.
- 30:38Look around. Look at Here we are.
- 30:40Feel my body, look for colors, Yeah.
- 30:44And then understand what is it that?
- 30:46What is it about this moment that had the body mind grab that
- 30:52set of gists to attach to it? What is it about this present
- 30:56moment? It took me a long time to figure
- 30:58out that it was being triggered by something.
- 31:02I just thought I was nuts, right?
- 31:03It was like it was a bit. Right.
- 31:09Well, that, yeah, that the use of fantasy, right.
- 31:17If we can use the term fantasy, the use of the soothing
- 31:23narratives, remember we're always generating these
- 31:27narratives to correspond to what our experiences, which tend to
- 31:33have a soothing quality to them. Well, I'm thinking of like more
- 31:37stressful things though, like the wrong look from somebody and
- 31:41suddenly I'm not here. I'm.
- 31:44Right. Somewhere a long time ago where
- 31:46I'm afraid, even though there's nothing actually to be afraid
- 31:49of, but it's just the look in somebody's eye or something.
- 31:52So you've understood when I said fantasy that I meant something
- 31:56pleasant? Yeah.
- 31:59I didn't necessarily mean that. Yeah, OK.
- 32:02Yeah, but it is. Like a fantasy of rejection and
- 32:05condemnation is also a fantasy if it's not happening.
- 32:10Yeah. So why did we, why did we create
- 32:13that fantasy in, in the experience of the present
- 32:16moment? And what is it distracting us
- 32:19from so that we don't actually know?
- 32:22You know, in that scenario, if it was something like me, it
- 32:25would be longing for connection to them and then being
- 32:31frightened to actually express it and then relieving myself of
- 32:36the of the need to express it by creating the fantasy of
- 32:39rejection so that I don't even have to venture forward and see
- 32:44whether I'll actually be rejected.
- 32:46I just self reject. That saves time, but it's too
- 32:59much energy. What I like to say is just let
- 33:01them reject you. It's easier or not no one of the
- 33:09things what do you what do you finally figure out that yes is
- 33:13way harder than no That makes the yeses more more interesting.
- 33:21Somebody says no and then off you go, right?
- 33:24Somebody says yes, and then all of a sudden you're, you, you
- 33:27have to engage, right? The, and this really ties into
- 33:34the, the way that you know, when you work with attachment
- 33:37conditioning or actually any conditioning really, in this
- 33:41model of how we create the experience of the present
- 33:44moment, the capacity to sense means the object can be sensed.
- 33:48The body evaluates the urgency, the vedna, and then your
- 33:53undifferentiated sensing experiences compared to the
- 33:57database, the conditioned database of meanings, not of
- 34:01what happens of meanings. And then you attach a meaning to
- 34:04the present moment, and it creates A conceptual reality
- 34:08that is defined by that meaning. And the process is automatic and
- 34:15usually fast enough that it precedes consciousness.
- 34:18So it just comes into the self experience already formulated.
- 34:22And if you're not used to really getting into it and you don't
- 34:25have the mentalizing capacity to do it fast enough, you just
- 34:29react to the creation as if that's what's happening.
- 34:34Which then of course creates karma, right?
- 34:38You make an intention, you take an action, the action then has
- 34:42consequences and you gather the the outcome, not what happens,
- 34:49but what it meant, what happened, what what happened
- 34:52meant to you. And then that that gets thrown
- 34:55into the the database. So the way to change that
- 34:59mechanism is in these this visualization process of
- 35:06layering into the database these visualized experiences that
- 35:11contradict the conditioning. The way to change conditioning
- 35:15is to reimagine it in a way that's optimal because the body
- 35:21mind can use whatever is in the database to define reality.
- 35:25Since it's not about what happens, it's about meaning.
- 35:28You can have a visualization that creates meaning that's
- 35:31different and use that in the construction of the present
- 35:36moment. And of course, you're gathering
- 35:38something that did happen and associating it so that the the
- 35:43imaginings, the visualizations that are, you know, indeed
- 35:48rickety in the beginning, develop heft because you use
- 35:52them to define the present moment and then gather something
- 35:57that did actually happen. I'm not quite understanding your
- 36:06question, David, sorry. I.
- 36:10You the way I understand the ideal parenting is you take what
- 36:17was a bad parenting situation that you were in.
- 36:20You create an ideal parent and replace what happened with the
- 36:26ideal and kind of create a new set of, of synapses or and, and
- 36:33so you, you then have a much more comfortable way of thinking
- 36:36about how you were brought up because you've now replaced the
- 36:40bad parenting with ideal parenting.
- 36:43Did I just hear you say you take a situation and you reimagine it
- 36:48in more of an ideal setting so that way you can come from a
- 36:52better place in that situation? Because instead of basing it on
- 36:57past memories that went bad, you're now imagining a good
- 37:02outcome and therefore it it's. Right.
- 37:06You're reimagining the meaning of the situation so that it has.
- 37:12So then you have an alternative definition to use when something
- 37:15like it happens in the present moment and it's been identified
- 37:19as that pattern, that gist is then, then you have alternative,
- 37:24you have alternative meanings associated with that kind of
- 37:27experience and the body mind will typically go to the low
- 37:31calorie choice is really what's happening.
- 37:33Positive experience is less intense than negative
- 37:36experience. So positive out, so positive
- 37:39point of view helps in more ways than just faking it till you
- 37:44make it. It actually reconditions your
- 37:47brain into something that's more pleasant.
- 37:49Right, it creates a a a different way of understanding
- 37:56the meaning of what's happening in the.
- 38:12You know, PJ was talking about this, the, the, the link to the
- 38:16present moment experience or losing touch with with that.
- 38:21That also can be part of it. The, the, the, the lack of
- 38:26resolution, the lack of integrated meaning or even a
- 38:30dissociative experience which is not tethered to a particular
- 38:35timeline or a particular reference to the past and the
- 38:39present can easily create in the present moment what what
- 38:44actually is an experience from the past.
- 38:46Because it's not anchored in that way.
- 38:50We have astonishing flexibility in how we define what's
- 38:56happening. It's really easy to understand
- 39:04someone's intentions differently than they understand, and if you
- 39:09are, aren't free to engage in a dialogue about that.
- 39:14That is to say, you become too frightened to express
- 39:18authentically what your experiences were, to inquire
- 39:22authentically what their meaning was, what the meaning was in
- 39:27their action. Then it's very easy to get
- 39:34skewed in a way. You're, you're, you're having
- 39:36one experience of what's happening and they're having
- 39:39another experience of what's happening.
- 39:41We would call that, I think in Western psychology, a fantasy
- 39:45relationship rather than one that's tethered in a
- 39:49collaborative exchange with the other person.
- 39:55How easy as it is for you? How easy it is it for you to
- 39:59express yourself authentically? How easy is it for you to
- 40:03regulate the level of vulnerability that you express
- 40:08to someone? Is it based on their
- 40:12demonstrations of trustworthiness or is it based
- 40:15on a wish that they would be trustworthy?
- 40:19Right. Those are the the those bases if
- 40:28you. Like somebody you, you, you like
- 40:32them because you're recognize if you meet somebody and you like
- 40:35them, you're recognizing a working model of somebody that
- 40:38you like, right? Because you don't know them that
- 40:41well, don't know what their actual, you haven't really
- 40:45created a model for them. You're, you're borrowing working
- 40:50model of someone else and then as you get to know them, you're
- 40:54actually engaged in the process of constructing a working model
- 40:57of them. So that that's going to take
- 40:59time, right? It's going to take encountering
- 41:02them in a lot of different situations so that you can get a
- 41:05very response to the the the situations and you can witness
- 41:11the the way that they make meaning out of that so that you
- 41:14can understand who they are. And then you begin to build a
- 41:18robust modeling of them. But what can also happen is you
- 41:22simply decide that they're the the working model that you've
- 41:25already constructed of someone else, and they become the avatar
- 41:30that you're that you're using Christian I.
- 41:35Don't know if this sounds this formulation sounds perverse, but
- 41:38it. You've worked out it and it
- 41:41should I. Mean I'm like, I'm coming
- 41:47through this like the the kind of Lacanian or the Zojekian
- 41:51lens, like you're kind of constructing a maybe more
- 41:54workable, flexible fantasy that the other person fits into.
- 42:00Yeah, if you don't check, sure. If you do check, then you have
- 42:07to adapt your working model to match what their their meaning
- 42:14is so that it's accurate, right, that it actually represents
- 42:19them. The I, I, I was reading and I
- 42:30can't tell whether it's flip a flip.
- 42:33This is a king comment and that he said that we don't want to
- 42:38get rid of the fantasy. We don't want to get rid of the
- 42:40big other because we all depend on the big other for all the
- 42:44things that we don't do. And if we were to get rid of the
- 42:48big other, then we would have to blame ourselves for everything
- 42:51that we don't do. And none of us are willing to do
- 42:54that, that it would be a disaster to live an authentic
- 42:59life in that way. Yeah, my my understanding of
- 43:03that kind of lenses that we can only love people through
- 43:07fantasy. Right.
- 43:09That there is no, there's no like other.
- 43:11That's like the form of mediation, right?
- 43:13And it, it sounds really like, it sounds really traumatic until
- 43:17you kind of accept it and then it's like, all right, that's all
- 43:19right. Well, another way to say that
- 43:25might be that we we don't know what's happening.
- 43:28We know what meaning we make, right?
- 43:32So we're making a meaning of somebody, and is that meaning
- 43:37representative of them or not? And then how do we respond when
- 43:41there's an indication that the meaning that we've given doesn't
- 43:45actually correspond to who's there?
- 43:47Do we take the dismissing approach and bully them into
- 43:50being who it is that we want? Do we take the the preoccupied
- 43:55approach and just pretend that they're that way or pretend to
- 44:00be who who they want? Do we manipulate them into the
- 44:08position that we want them into, to go so deeply into the the
- 44:16whole sense of justice, right? Is it true?
- 44:21Are we both agreeing that it's true?
- 44:23And are we both authentic in our agreement?
- 44:27Or are we both pretending that it's true because we perceive
- 44:31that we, the other of us needs that?
- 44:38And then when the rug comes out, of course, you know the emperor
- 44:43has no clothes. And then how does that, How
- 44:49devastating is that for your sense of well-being?
- 44:53That could actually be really hot.
- 44:58Well, it is one of those things, you know, in the attachment
- 45:01world, what makes attachment work.
- 45:03It's predictable, it's reliable, it's steady.
- 45:07What makes Eroticism work? Unpredictableness, difference,
- 45:12all of that stuff. And so in in an an attachment
- 45:16relationship that has that erotic quality to it, they're in
- 45:22some sense working against each other.
- 45:26How do you balance the dependency of an attachment
- 45:29relationship with a relationship long erotic life?
- 45:37And then that might be the place where fantasy comes in, that you
- 45:42can step out of the reliability, the ordinariness of the
- 45:49attachment relationship into something exotic role-playing.
- 45:57You know, lots of people engage in theatrical sex.
- 46:02It always makes me laugh and it's not really erotic.
- 46:05But some of the outfits are great.
- 46:15Kindness is the great aphrodisiac and bye bye.
- 46:18But that isn't really true. A lot a lot of people.
- 46:31In the development of mentalizing using meditation,
- 46:33meditation develops mentalizing really well, particularly
- 46:36Viposinum. But to go that insight practices
- 46:40and emotional regulation, you can explore using Viposina, but
- 46:44what it really is about is developing an equanimity with
- 46:50the intensity of sensation, the emotional sensation, neither
- 46:55grabbing on to it, neither resisting it, neither denying
- 46:59that it's there. And then the intentional
- 47:04development of positivity is the other aspect of it in attachment
- 47:10conditioning. Because the circumstances of
- 47:13children who grow up to be insecure, disorganized adults
- 47:17are so extreme, what you tend to find is that their internal
- 47:23working model of emotion is decidedly lopsided on negative
- 47:28emotional states. You know you have the reaction
- 47:33to the present moment. You have the thought processes
- 47:36that you used to regulate it. If you grow up in the the
- 47:40harshness of a family system that would produce insecure
- 47:44disorganized attachment. Likely those regulating thought
- 47:49processes are also going to be pretty harsh and generate strong
- 47:54negative emotions. If the body mind system is
- 47:58overwhelmed emotionally in childhood, it stores the
- 48:02emotion. Somatic sized emotion is the
- 48:04word for it, which then contributes to the perception of
- 48:09the emotional experience, the emotional reaction to the
- 48:13present moment. If we can say that an emotion is
- 48:16the preparation for the response, the pattern of
- 48:20experience in the body as the body prepares to take the action
- 48:26is what we identify as an emotional pattern.
- 48:30And in in difficult environments where we're constantly needing
- 48:35to be vigilant, we're constantly needing to provide some kind of
- 48:41protection or some kind of flight creates a strong negative
- 48:47valence for emotion and, and maybe not so much capacity for
- 48:52positive emotions. So we have to intentionally
- 48:55develop the capacity for positivity.
- 48:58And in fact, we want to do it so well that we lopsided the system
- 49:02on the side of positives that the default becomes these
- 49:06positive responses rather than these negative responses.
- 49:09That's also something that meditation is really good at.
- 49:13And then we need to explicitly talk about the quality of the
- 49:19relationships that we have with other people.
- 49:22It's funny. I've been teaching these
- 49:24workshops and I had somebody say to me on Saturday, which I
- 49:31thought was pretty funny. She said people don't do that.
- 49:35And I said, what do you mean? She said they don't talk about
- 49:38relationships. And I said, you sure about that?
- 49:43Some people talk about relationships.
- 49:44It's just maybe here in meta group, in this little group of
- 49:48eight people, we talk about emotions.
- 49:50But out there, out there in the world, nobody talks about
- 49:54emotions. We just try and get along.
- 50:00And I said, well, you could, if there's a problem with the
- 50:03ration, bring it up and see whether you could negotiate.
- 50:09And then she said, oh, I get you.
- 50:10You mean implicitly You could suggest I said no explicitly and
- 50:18she said nobody does that. I don't know anyone who does
- 50:22that. I've never heard of anyone doing
- 50:25that. That would be role based
- 50:32relationships. All right.
- 50:33You just step into the role and you enact the role as best you
- 50:37can without so much guidance in it.
- 50:42So one of the aspects of course, learning secure functioning
- 50:46relationships is to discuss relationships and discuss
- 50:49relational dynamics and to come into a place of authentically
- 50:54expressing what your relational needs are and negotiating with
- 50:57someone else to get taken care of in the in the way that you
- 51:01need. And in understanding the frame
- 51:04of secure functioning relationships, the idea is that
- 51:06I take care of you in the way that you need to be taken care
- 51:10of so that you feel taken care of.
- 51:13And I'm willing to do that for you if you take care of me in
- 51:17the way that I need to feel taken care of.
- 51:20And we collaborate with each other on how we should do that
- 51:24for each other so that each of us feels taken care of.
- 51:29And this is the whole picture, the whole of the care, not
- 51:33individual aspects of the care and trade for some other aspect
- 51:38of care. But if you don't do that, then
- 51:43of course you're just relying on your conditioning, meshing their
- 51:47conditioning in a way that doesn't produce homicides or
- 51:56whatever. It might produce a long lasting
- 52:00stable relationship. And why would you even want a
- 52:03long lasting stable relationship?
- 52:06This is the other aspect of it because it supports your
- 52:11exploration and supports your a possibility of going into the
- 52:16world and exploring it and in such a way that you derive
- 52:20meaning from this life that you have.
- 52:25That's what it's for. That makes sense.
- 52:29And without that safety net of relationships to catch you, what
- 52:33typically happens is we begin to limit the risk.
- 52:38We're willing to take the authentic risk.
- 52:44And I think that actually that's what most people do.
- 52:50They don't explore so much. They gather the time, energy and
- 52:54resources that they need, and then they hide out.
- 52:56And I think our culture is really good at offering forms of
- 53:01distraction that you can hide out and you can justify not
- 53:07doing it, but it doesn't believe the despair.
- 53:13You can distract yourself from despair, but as soon as the
- 53:16episode ends, it immediately appears to get it so that you
- 53:20have to watch another episode. Do you ever find yourself
- 53:24surfing through shows and thinking, Oh my God, there's
- 53:28only one season? I can't possibly watch that
- 53:30show. I'll get to the end of it, and
- 53:33then I have to wait for Season 2.
- 53:35I can't bear that there's only one episode a week.
- 53:40I'll wait until they're all out and I can just game.
- 53:43What all of those strategies for distraction?
- 53:51There used to be like before the streaming era, you used to like
- 53:56get together with people and and talk about stuff, the water
- 53:59cooler and like there's a whole social component to watching TV,
- 54:04all the social component of it. Yeah, totally.
- 54:08Oh, you get to post 3 emojis. Poster is run by bots.
- 54:18Now you don't even have to post. There's AI for posting.
- 54:31I think that one of the reasons why the meditation approach to
- 54:34attachment repair is so useful is because it really is very
- 54:38targeted on these things that have to happen.
- 54:41And in in the general therapeutic approach,
- 54:43particularly if it's reliant on the relationship, it's the main
- 54:47agent for change doesn't tend to work so well.
- 54:50The line up between your attachment conditioning and
- 54:54somebody else's attachment conditioning has to be so you
- 54:59know, in line with what needs to happen.
- 55:05And then it requires the interpretations to be actually
- 55:10accurate, which would require you to be able to actually be
- 55:14authentic in the relationship rather than representing
- 55:18yourself in a way. It's particularly challenging
- 55:22for preoccupied people to represent, represent themselves
- 55:26accurately, to represent themselves authentically.
- 55:31And if you're skillful at pretend, if you're skillful at
- 55:35misrepresentation, it's very hard for people to tell,
- 55:40particularly in a therapeutic setting where you really the
- 55:44your obligation is only to present, right?
- 55:50What else is necessary in that follow through?
- 55:54So if you can't figure out as the clinician whether they're
- 55:59accurately representing what's happening there, there are these
- 56:04long stretches of the engagement that don't really lead to much
- 56:08in the way of change except for elaboration.
- 56:13And when it's when it's focused more on these, the ideal parent
- 56:21figure protocol, the meditation and the development of
- 56:27positivity, so the emotional regulation and the mentalizing
- 56:31capacities that come from meditation.
- 56:33And then also the education around what collaborative
- 56:38relationships are supposed to be like.
- 56:41That is a tendency to speed it up.
- 56:44Anyway, what do you say we do a little bit of practice?
- 56:49What would you like to do? The pasta.
- 56:56OK. Whatever's good for.
- 57:00PJ. Developing a sense of
- 57:02positivity. That would be meta Christian.
- 57:10You're the tiebreaker. He's going to say IPM.
- 57:17Sorry David, I like the pasta tonight.
- 57:23All right, so go ahead and settle in, closing your eyes.
- 57:27OK, let go of the meditation. How's that good Christian?
- 57:46George, what do you? I guess this can happen in any
- 57:49of the domains, but what do you make of the kind of pre verbal
- 57:52verbals and gurgles? Do you like sometimes practice,
- 57:57Do you sometimes put the boundary of noting on one side
- 58:00or the other of those or do you always kind of exclude those?
- 58:05I I think it doesn't matter what whether you exclude them or you
- 58:08just give them whatever it seems like the appropriate label is.
- 58:13The the categories of the labels are pretty broad anyway and
- 58:18overlapping. OK.
- 58:21I guess I was, I guess I was, I was kind of wondering if there's
- 58:24like if there would be a logic or kind of an outcome of
- 58:28including or excluding those from like regular practice.
- 58:33In in a see here feel focus in, focus out at.
- 58:36Any sensation that you can detect is included, and then
- 58:43clarity of course, will develop over time.
- 58:47Discernment will develop over time.
- 58:50The rumblings in auditory space are the ones that usually there
- 58:57and then the cognition of what the thought would be arises and
- 59:00then then the clear talk of the thought arises.
- 59:05So the focus in focus out of that part of it is, is that that
- 59:11area of it doesn't matter where you put it.
- 59:15You could say, oh, it's a, it's a feel in.
- 59:19No, it's a feel out. It's a feel out.
- 59:21It's a physical sensation of vibration.
- 59:24Then the cognition of what would say arises, and then the clear
- 59:29talk arises. So then is that feel out or is
- 59:33it an aspect of? Herein is an example of the
- 59:38fuzzy quality of it. In some sense, we might then be
- 59:45talking about the addition of rest space.
- 59:47So for instance, in visual thinking, you're looking, your
- 59:50attention is drawn to the screen, but the screen is just
- 59:53swirling. What is that?
- 59:56Is that flow? Is that CN?
- 1:00:00Is that C rest? So.
- 1:00:05OK, lot fun, lots of options. Yeah, good.
- 1:00:11Someone else here in New York next week from Saturday, I'll be
- 1:00:20doing a day long on meditation and addiction there at inside
- 1:00:23New York. We have a level 2 starting this
- 1:00:28month. We're going to do it on
- 1:00:29Wednesday morning so that if that's a good time for you.
- 1:00:33If if you've done level 2 before and you were thinking of
- 1:00:36repeating it, we've, we've also created an option where you can,
- 1:00:41we'll offer you the course at half off for people that have
- 1:00:46already done it if they want to repeat it sometimes.
- 1:00:49Because each time the class is taught in the Socratic method,
- 1:00:53the the they're quite different or can be quite different from
- 1:00:56each other. What information is offered?
- 1:00:59What is in plus, hopefully I'm always learning something or
- 1:01:04other which will change by perspective so that I see it
- 1:01:10differently. What else?
- 1:01:14I think Kaleidoscope is this month, we have not coming up.
- 1:01:20So anyway it's on the calendar. Take a look.
- 1:01:22Appreciate your practice. I appreciate you being here.
- 1:01:26I enjoy your company. Ioffer the teaching freely.
- 1:01:30But I do hope if that you're able to make a donation, you
- 1:01:33will because it supports me and also the work Medical Group is
- 1:01:36doing. And I hope to see you again
- 1:01:39soon. Bye.