Latest / No Way Out / Understanding the Intricacies of Middle Market Businesses with Doug Farren | Ep 43
Transcript
- 0:21Mark McGrath: So, Doug, when we're talking about the middle market, we're talking about 200,000 plus or minus businesses in the United States.
- 0:28Mark McGrath: Paint that picture.
- 0:29Mark McGrath: What is exactly the middle market?
- 0:33Doug Farren: So it's a great question and it's one that causes a lot of confusion, because a lot of organizations whether they be financial services institutions or government organizations or economic development groups kind of everyone has their own definition of what that means.
- 0:51Doug Farren: But when our center launched in 2011, we tried to take a practical look and say what is the middle third of the US economy?
- 1:01Doug Farren: In other words, tell us the parameters that create one third of private sector GEP and one third of private sector employment, and so that landed us on a definition that we still use today, which is annual revenue of $10 million to $1 billion.
- 1:20Doug Farren: It's a huge range.
- 1:21Doug Farren: We understand that, but in a lot of our research, we're able to cut that into different segments.
- 1:27Doug Farren: So, for instance, because again, people will reach out to us and say, how can you compare a $30 million company with an $800 million company Well, you can't.
- 1:37Doug Farren: They're completely different.
- 1:40Doug Farren: But when we sub-segment, we can look at what we call the lower middle market.
- 1:44Doug Farren: So these are the $10 million to $50 million companies.
- 1:46Doug Farren: They tend to be more family-run businesses.
- 1:51Doug Farren: They kind of operate like small businesses as you start to grow into the middle segment, which we call core middle market.
- 1:59Doug Farren: These are $50 million to $100 million businesses.
- 2:02Doug Farren: They start to have characteristics like multi-location.
- 2:07Doug Farren: They probably have a fully developed C-suite leadership team.
- 2:12Doug Farren: For instance, they may have an outside board of advisors.
- 2:15Doug Farren: That's another common thing we see as companies hit that $50 million threshold.
- 2:21Doug Farren: And then the last group is the upper middle market $100 million and above, and these are businesses that truly start to resemble enterprises.
- 2:28Doug Farren: They're more likely to be publicly traded, although 90% of the middle market is actually privately held, which is what has made it so difficult to find information and data and any type of insights and thought leadership, and it's actually why the National Center for the Middle Market was founded.
- 2:48Doug Farren: So, yeah, that's kind of a picture of what the middle market looks like.
- 2:51Doug Farren: I'll just add as well they're in literally every city.
- 2:55Doug Farren: They're across every industry.
- 2:57Doug Farren: There's one of the hypothesis we wanted to test was like Silicon Valley are these companies congregated in certain parts of the country or in certain industries?
- 3:08Doug Farren: And, as it turns out, they're pretty much all over the place.
- 3:11Mark McGrath: They're everywhere.
- 3:12Doug Farren: Yeah, everywhere.
- 3:12Mark McGrath: Yeah, so nobody's living in an area in the United States anyway, where there's no middle market companies.
- 3:19Mark McGrath: They're there.
- 3:19Mark McGrath: No they're everywhere.
- 3:22Mark McGrath: Okay, and that's about a third of all private sector jobs we would find in the middle market.
- 3:27Mark McGrath: Correct, correct, yep, and then we slice out of our GDP, it would be about a third of our GDP, correct?
- 3:35Mark McGrath: And then 3% of all US companies.
- 3:38Mark McGrath: So I mean we're calling anything a company that has, like an LLC or anything, a sole proprietor and everything all the way up to like Walmart and everything in between, correct?
- 3:46Mark McGrath: Yep, that's right.
- 3:47Mark McGrath: Yep, got it Now.
- 3:49Mark McGrath: You and I have talked about these things a lot over the many years we've known each other, and middle market companies are primed for what we talk about with UDA and understanding.
- 4:02Mark McGrath: How do they shape observations, how do they make better decisions?
- 4:06Mark McGrath: How do they have agility and resiliency in light of an ever changing VUCA marketplace?
- 4:13Mark McGrath: You and I have talked a lot about volatility, uncertainty, complexity, ambiguity.
- 4:16Mark McGrath: Sure, I would imagine in that space that third, that middle market VUCA.
- 4:21Mark McGrath: They're certainly not strangers to that.
- 4:24Doug Farren: No, no.
- 4:25Doug Farren: So let me go a little bit further into the demographics and kind of what we've learned over the years.
- 4:33Doug Farren: So again, 90% privately held.
- 4:36Doug Farren: They do that for a reason right.
- 4:37Doug Farren: So these companies tend to take longer term views of not only challenges but opportunities.
- 4:45Doug Farren: They're not looking to satisfy a quarterly earnings report or impact a stock price by making short term decisions.
- 4:53Doug Farren: They're making decisions for the long run.
- 4:55Doug Farren: I think the pandemic was a great example of that.
- 4:58Doug Farren: We didn't see many of these businesses close, go out of business.
- 5:01Doug Farren: That didn't panic.
- 5:02Doug Farren: They were making longer term decisions out of that.
- 5:06Doug Farren: They've also been in business on average about 39 years.
- 5:10Doug Farren: So if you think about that, they have seen various economic cycles.
- 5:15Doug Farren: They have seen lots of challenges, whether it be global competition, things that are happening domestically, things that are happening from a government, regulations and policy standpoint.
- 5:29Doug Farren: These companies have been through quite a bit of different challenges.
- 5:33Doug Farren: So they have experience.
- 5:34Doug Farren: And then we like to say that, because of their lean nature in terms of how they run, they often are tackling big company challenges with small company resources.
- 5:45Doug Farren: They kind of are at the intersection of resilience and runway, and by that I mean they've got enough resource where they can actually do things and make impacts, but they're also quick to make decisions and reorient when a lot of this chaos and uncertainty tends to pop up.
- 6:04Doug Farren: We're right now in the process of wrapping up our semi-annual survey called the middle market indicator, and one of the things we're seeing out there there's a lot of uncertainty.
- 6:13Doug Farren: You've got inflation that now is starting to maybe come down a little bit.
- 6:18Doug Farren: You've got everyone that keeps talking about is there a recession?
- 6:21Doug Farren: Are we in one?
- 6:22Doug Farren: Is one coming?
- 6:23Doug Farren: How long?
- 6:24Doug Farren: You've got geopolitical issues going on all over the world.
- 6:28Doug Farren: You've got talent challenges confronting these companies.
- 6:30Doug Farren: Bottom line.
- 6:32Doug Farren: They just kind of keep doing business Like they deal with it and move on, because most of these companies have the unique ability to follow the OODA process.
- 6:42Doug Farren: They basically see what's going on in their industry or their environment, they make decisions and then they act.
- 6:49Doug Farren: They don't wait.
- 6:50Doug Farren: They don't need approval Again, they're not going to.
- 6:53Doug Farren: They're shareholders.
- 6:55Doug Farren: They're not looking for outside influences to make decisions for them.
- 6:58Doug Farren: They just act when needed, and I think that's what makes this segment really interesting.
- 7:06Mark McGrath: So, in a sense, they're obviously trying to continue to improve and build.
- 7:10Mark McGrath: What do you see from a?
- 7:13Mark McGrath: You're a former collegiate athlete.
- 7:15Mark McGrath: What do you see from a team standpoint, from a mission standpoint?
- 7:18Mark McGrath: When you look at many middle market companies, what are some of the characteristics that you're observing that make the good ones really stand out and as examples for others to emulate?
- 7:29Mark McGrath: What do you see?
- 7:30Doug Farren: Yeah, I think you know it's kind of easy to talk about culture, but it really is a real thing in the middle market.
- 7:37Doug Farren: I've been teaching a class here at Fisher College of Business for our undergraduates and I have the ability and have had the opportunity to take a lot of our students on site visits.
- 7:49Doug Farren: We go and visit, you know, local companies here around central Ohio.
- 7:54Doug Farren: We do projects with a lot of middle market businesses, not only in Ohio but around the country, and part of the reason we do that is we want to expose these young, you know, students that are going to be entering the workforce.
- 8:06Doug Farren: We want them to see what it's like to actually be around and be inside working in a middle market company.
- 8:12Doug Farren: To your point about teams, I think because they are run typically in a very lean fashion.
- 8:21Doug Farren: Everyone knows each other right, so it doesn't matter if I'm an intern or a new hire, like my ability to maybe sit and work with the senior leadership team, maybe the founder or CEO he or she may have.
- 8:34Doug Farren: You know, direct interaction with every single person in that company is a experience that I know I didn't have when I worked at a Fortune 500 company.
- 8:43Doug Farren: I was in a cube and I felt like more like a number right.
- 8:48Doug Farren: I think these businesses do a really, really good job of getting everybody on board with kind of their mission, what they're there to do.
- 8:58Doug Farren: A lot of them are kind of world-class in what they do.
- 9:00Doug Farren: They have a very unique niche, you know, in terms of the product or service that they produce, and the employee teams typically buy into that.
- 9:10Doug Farren: It's part of the reason why they stick around.
- 9:12Doug Farren: Now, on the flip side, we do see that they oftentimes have challenges attracting people and then ultimately retaining people, because where they have weaknesses are on defining exactly what their employee value propositions are, like having a talk track, so to speak, where they can go out and tell people like, hey, this is what we're all about Middle market companies.
- 9:36Doug Farren: Inherently, I think they feel that, but they can't really verbalize it, so that makes recruiting difficult.
- 9:42Doug Farren: And then, from a retention standpoint, we see that a lot of them struggle with kind of like the blocking and tackling of what I would call basic human resource processes, like having a succession plan, like identifying your high performers and making sure that they're getting unique development opportunities.
- 10:00Doug Farren: So it's just like any team.
- 10:02Doug Farren: I mean, you wanna identify who your star talent is, and make sure that that talent is continuing to be engaged and developed.
- 10:11Doug Farren: That's where we see some challenges.
- 10:13Mark McGrath: So it sounds like there's a lot of opportunity for learning in order to adapt, yeah, which is what we do and we work with.
- 10:22Mark McGrath: We have clients in that space as well.
- 10:24Mark McGrath: I find that the ones that are doing well are the ones that want to learn more, and they're the ones that have a strong appetite for learning in order to adapt even better and to build a culture of continuous improvement.
- 10:41Mark McGrath: Yeah, Directly at providing value for the customer.
- 10:45Doug Farren: Yeah, I can give you an example.
- 10:47Doug Farren: We used to run executive education when GE Capital was our partner.
- 10:52Doug Farren: In the early days of the center, we brought in like waves of their customers.
- 10:58Doug Farren: Typically 10 or 12 of their clients at a time would come to Ohio State.
- 11:02Doug Farren: They would bring the whole leadership team, so it's the CEO and his or her three or four top people and they would spend four days here just really stepping away from the tactical running and the day to day and spending more time stepping back and thinking strategically about things that their company is struggling with.
- 11:26Doug Farren: And to your point, the feedback that we heard was this is the best use of time that we could have ever, even though we, like we're kicking and screaming to give up the four days.
- 11:38Doug Farren: At the end of it, what we found was that by stepping out of the day to day fires, we actually gave ourselves a chance to learn, not about textbook things or classroom things, but we learned from each other about what's going on in the business.
- 11:53Doug Farren: We learned from our peers who were in the class with us a lot of networking, a lot of discussion about common problem solving.
- 12:01Doug Farren: But I couldn't agree more that the companies that do the best are the ones that are always out there challenging themselves to try to learn, whether it be from peers from educational institutions.
- 12:13Doug Farren: They soak in knowledge and kind of thought leadership material as much as they can, because they're just looking for an edge to get better.
- 12:22Mark McGrath: So I love it when we work with a company and we just see the lightning bolt hit them and they go.
- 12:29Mark McGrath: Oh, we should be learning.
- 12:31Mark McGrath: We should be taking a step back and making time to learn and learn with each other To your point.
- 12:37Mark McGrath: There's so many things that in team exercises and team learning and even learning effective things like value mapping we use wardly mapping, even effective red teaming, just being a healthy devil's advocate to attack the plan and learn how to become more cohesive by not attacking the person.
- 12:56Mark McGrath: Isn't it amazing?
- 12:58Mark McGrath: It's always the top companies that are doing that, that are looking to build that edge, I mean from an opportunity standpoint.
- 13:08Mark McGrath: I would think that there are a lot of companies out there that find themselves in some kind of a stuck state and they just really need to take that step.
- 13:15Mark McGrath: They really need to take that step to do the extra work, to do the extra sort of.
- 13:19Mark McGrath: Stop talking about where you wanna go.
- 13:22Mark McGrath: Let's take a breather and let's figure out exactly where we're at now, right, in order to get where we want to go.
- 13:31Doug Farren: Yeah, I think you're hitting it right on the head is that they oftentimes reach a stalling point.
- 13:37Doug Farren: We've talked to some other researchers at other universities who have done this kind of work on a qualitative basis.
- 13:44Doug Farren: They haven't necessarily gone out and collected a bunch of data, but we talked to some researchers I believe they were from Michigan State University who were interviewing a lot of basically middle market owners and they were asking them about where did you stall?
- 14:00Doug Farren: They were calling it the growth wall because basically every company could, oh, we're growing, growing, growing, and then they would hit this wall.
- 14:08Doug Farren: It was essentially when they reached the end of the capabilities of that founder or that leadership team and they didn't necessarily have the knowledge or the I wouldn't say the capability, but they didn't know the tools to basically do that type of planning to get to the next level.
- 14:29Doug Farren: That's where we see a lot of times we work with companies on doing research projects and whatnot.
- 14:34Doug Farren: They're the advisors, they're the trusted advisors that have to work with these leadership teams to say we'll show you how it's done.
- 14:41Doug Farren: We've done this a hundred times.
- 14:42Doug Farren: You may be only doing this once or twice.
- 14:45Doug Farren: A great example is when a company goes through an M&A transaction.
- 14:49Doug Farren: Mm-hmm, they're selling a home.
- 14:51Doug Farren: How many times do you do that in your life?
- 14:53Doug Farren: Maybe two or three times, if you're lucky.
- 14:55Doug Farren: They don't have the knowledge or the experience having gone through that process.
- 15:00Doug Farren: That's why they need trusted advisors.
- 15:03Doug Farren: It doesn't really matter what it is Putting in a technology platform, going through a transaction doing something but doing your HR talent planning, All those things.
- 15:13Doug Farren: There are tools and they don't have to be super formal too.
- 15:17Doug Farren: I think that's where it scares away a lot of people.
- 15:19Doug Farren: I don't have the time to do big process maps and all that.
- 15:23Doug Farren: Okay, then just start somewhere.
- 15:25Doug Farren: Start with a basic approach, Think of a plan and then be willing to adapt that plan as you encounter challenges and uncertainties along the way.
- 15:37Mark McGrath: We all say we followed John Boyd.
- 15:39Mark McGrath: People ideas things in that order always.
- 15:42Mark McGrath: Anytime that order is violated, you're going to have problems at some point, you're going to have a rough time.
- 15:49Mark McGrath: Because it's people that make a company, it's people that operate a company.
- 15:52Mark McGrath: It's people that buy whatever a company is offering.
- 15:56Mark McGrath: It's people that align with a company to work with them in any capacity, whether they're customers, whether they're partners.
- 16:03Mark McGrath: Sure, it seemed to me that in those types of environments, especially when there are so many that are privately held and, as you say, teams that obviously you would hope anyway, there's a pretty big emphasis on people versus, or do you find more companies seeking technological or capital solutions versus human-centric solutions?
- 16:24Mark McGrath: Yeah, that's our business.
- 16:26Mark McGrath: Our business is to help people with the human-centric side we can fit into any technology.
- 16:32Mark McGrath: But do you see more people just seeking technology for technology's sake or money for money's sake, or are they actually trying to address things with the people that they have and that they?
- 16:43Doug Farren: work with.
- 16:43Doug Farren: Well, we're seeing some interesting things.
- 16:46Doug Farren: We started looking at digital transformation in the middle market around 2019.
- 16:52Doug Farren: About four years ago, we noticed that there was an uptick in companies that were seeking out some of the, I would say, the headline technology platforms CRM systems, erp systems.
- 17:10Doug Farren: I think now the last six months all I keep hearing about if I'm out on the road or at a conference or at an event everybody wants to talk about generative AI.
- 17:20Doug Farren: That's the biggest thing out there now.
- 17:22Doug Farren: I think there are a couple of different ways to look at that.
- 17:27Doug Farren: On one hand, certainly there are ways as companies struggle with finding people that have the right skills and are a good fit for their company.
- 17:37Doug Farren: There's a talent issue out there.
- 17:40Doug Farren: There's a war for talent out there Using technology to maybe replace some of the functions that are easily repeatable, and we see that all the time.
- 17:50Doug Farren: On the flip side, we're also seeing as companies implement some of these technologies.
- 17:56Doug Farren: They actually need more people.
- 17:59Doug Farren: We did a study on advanced manufacturing a couple of years ago.
- 18:03Doug Farren: Our assumption was that manufacturers who use a lot of robotics and AI and things in their factories have less people.
- 18:13Doug Farren: It was actually the opposite.
- 18:15Doug Farren: Those companies were hiring more people.
- 18:17Doug Farren: They were just different types of jobs, instead of a bunch of blue collar people out there putting nuts and bolts and things.
- 18:25Doug Farren: The machines are doing that, but now they're hiring engineers who have to run and maintain and monitor all the equipment.
- 18:33Doug Farren: I think what technology is doing is it's certainly replacing some of the maybe lower skilled or easily repeatable jobs, but it's also creating opportunities for maybe higher skilled, digitally savvy jobs that are just going to change the nature of the workforce.
- 19:49Doug Farren: The new market is being forced to respond to that aspect of technology.
- 19:55Mark McGrath: Yeah, you see, a lot of technology for technology's sake.
- 19:58Mark McGrath: Then you also have, as you've alluded to, the fear that technology is going to replace us all.
- 20:04Mark McGrath: I always like to think that people aren't going to be replaced by technology.
- 20:08Mark McGrath: People are going to be replaced by people who understand how to work with technology more effectively than they do.
- 20:15Doug Farren: Yeah, I think it's absolutely right.
- 20:18Doug Farren: We're seeing a lot of the big vendors are now taking a look at their platforms and saying, wow, these aren't appropriate for mid-sized companies.
- 20:32Doug Farren: I'm going to pick on SAP here for a second, but it's like in my prior life.
- 20:37Doug Farren: I was at a retailer here in Columbus that implemented SAP.
- 20:41Doug Farren: It was hundreds of millions of dollars and it took multiple years.
- 20:45Doug Farren: It was very, very painful.
- 20:48Doug Farren: A middle market company just isn't going to be able to do that.
- 20:51Doug Farren: So I think we're seeing more and more providers start to say you know what?
- 20:56Doug Farren: I need to scale this down.
- 20:57Doug Farren: Maybe we don't need all the bells and whistles.
- 21:00Doug Farren: We need to start with something pretty basic that these companies can implement easily, and then they can support internally and we'll help them along the way.
- 21:09Doug Farren: But then, as they get better, we can start bolting on new things to it, which I think is smart.
- 21:15Doug Farren: It makes a lot of sense.
- 21:17Doug Farren: I mean another one of our partners, google Cloud.
- 21:19Doug Farren: We did some work with them to look at cloud technology and it's like OK, how much of the middle market is using the cloud?
- 21:25Doug Farren: Well, most of them are in some way shape or form, but that could mean anything from email to really basic stuff, and what we found in our research is that the fastest growing middle market companies are more integrated across more areas of their business in the cloud Finance, hr, operations.
- 21:46Doug Farren: More of it was being used in that way because they were able to figure out the privacy, security, all those aspects that may be of concern.
- 21:56Doug Farren: But yeah, yeah, it's really interesting stuff.
- 22:00Doug Farren: I think there's a lot of exciting opportunity out there, but I think there's also a lot of things where companies need to take a step back and say I need to understand what I'm getting myself involved in here.
- 22:13Doug Farren: Because, you can also open yourself up to some risks when it comes to security, for example.
- 22:19Mark McGrath: Yeah, we see.
- 22:19Mark McGrath: You see a lot of companies.
- 22:21Mark McGrath: They take on things, initiatives, technology, whatever, because everybody else, they're conforming to a standard that they perceive is real.
- 22:29Mark McGrath: We like to say that when we work with companies, we're trying to help them on the vital few.
- 22:37Mark McGrath: The vital few human-centric ideas around complexity thinking, distributed leadership and effective, high-performing teams versus the trivial many which everybody's doing.
- 22:48Mark McGrath: It doesn't differentiate, it doesn't really make any difference to the customer, it doesn't make any difference to the stakeholders or to the people that are there on the team.
- 22:58Mark McGrath: In that value is subjective, it's not bringing any value, it's not creating value.
- 23:04Mark McGrath: Do you see a lot of that, the copycatting or is there opportunity for people to start focusing on those types of things to improve the you used the word quality earlier Improve the quality of their leadership skills, their leadership, the leadership even has a quality right, because leadership oftentimes is just like oh, they're in charge.
- 23:26Mark McGrath: No, leadership is a quality that we all inherently have that could be developed and nurtured.
- 23:29Mark McGrath: Do you see the best companies focusing on those few things or do you see a lot of others just going?
- 23:35Mark McGrath: Well, everybody else is doing this, so I shouldn't we?
- 23:39Doug Farren: Yeah, yeah, I mean that's a challenge for the middle market in particular, because a lot of times they don't know where to go to look to get it's like peer benchmarking right.
- 23:51Doug Farren: I want to know what my closest peers are doing, but I can't find that A lot of times what they rely on actually is if I'm a manufacturer or I'm a healthcare company or I'm a retailer, I'm going to look to my industry organization probably first, and probably my suite of advisors, banker, lawyer, account, as crazy as it sounds.
- 24:17Doug Farren: A lot of times they're going to those folks and saying, hey, what are your other clients doing when it comes to technology?
- 24:22Doug Farren: They're getting tips from that group who's giving them information, because they don't have a direct source to go to.
- 24:31Doug Farren: We work with a lot of chambers of commerce around the United States.
- 24:34Doug Farren: The light bulb's starting to come on, I'd say there are a few cities that have really latched onto this idea of hey, we need to support our local middle market because they are such a big source of jobs and economic contribution.
- 24:50Doug Farren: For the most part, middle market companies don't have any reason to join their local chamber because 95% or so of the programming that a lot of chambers offer are for small business.
- 25:03Doug Farren: They need it.
- 25:04Doug Farren: That makes total sense.
- 25:06Doug Farren: Those businesses need that help.
- 25:07Doug Farren: Then, on the other end, if you are in a city that has Fortune 500 or large public companies, they're probably supporting those chambers out of a civic sense of duty, which is also very noble and the right thing to do.
- 25:22Doug Farren: But they don't necessarily need a chamber.
- 25:24Doug Farren: It's like I'm huge, I've got all the resources I need, I've got everything I need.
- 25:28Doug Farren: The middle market gets caught in there.
- 25:31Doug Farren: Because then they're like well, why would I join a place that doesn't have programming that fits me or they don't necessarily understand me.
- 25:38Doug Farren: What we've been seeing over the last five or six years, as chambers reach out to us, they're like hey, can you help us identify the middle market in our city?
- 25:47Doug Farren: We don't know them.
- 25:50Doug Farren: We just don't know who they are.
- 25:51Doug Farren: We don't have many members.
- 25:52Doug Farren: Like I said, there are some exceptions to that.
- 25:57Doug Farren: We've seen some cities that have really been active in building up their middle market.
- 26:01Doug Farren: But yeah, back to your question.
- 26:02Doug Farren: We hope that a place like the NCMM is a resource where companies can go and look up what other companies are doing.
- 26:14Doug Farren: I mean that's why we publish A lot of our reports are publicly available.
- 26:18Doug Farren: We put as much data out there as possible, because we're not going to solve challenges necessarily.
- 26:24Doug Farren: We're not designed for that.
- 26:26Doug Farren: My vision is that businesses that consume our material will say, hey, this raises some good questions.
- 26:32Doug Farren: I just read this report that came out of Fisher College of Business.
- 26:35Doug Farren: It says that the best middle market companies in the world do X, y and Z.
- 26:40Doug Farren: Like I said, we don't offer up solutions because every company is different and everybody has their own way of approaching things, but hopefully they would read these white papers that we put out and this data that we publish and they would say, all right, let's talk about that.
- 26:56Doug Farren: That is a team.
- 26:57Doug Farren: What are we doing?
- 26:58Doug Farren: Right, yeah, now I've got some academically based, non-biased data that's telling me that the best, the fastest growing or the best performing mid-sized companies in maybe certain industries, what are they doing?
- 27:14Doug Farren: And then, what are we doing?
- 27:15Doug Farren: So those are the questions that we hope to raise, to really challenge these leadership teams to say, yeah, are we thinking about this the wrong way?
- 27:23Doug Farren: Is there another way that we should be approaching these opportunities and ultimately helping making them better?
- 27:31Mark McGrath: So you're alluding to something that in the aspect of teaming science, where there's a psychologically safe company where anybody can bring up ideas and ideas can be discussed and we talk about these things to the idea and to the relative importance to the business not against people we can bring constructive feedback.
- 27:53Mark McGrath: What do you see when you look out in middle market companies?
- 27:56Mark McGrath: What do you see from that cultural aspect?
- 27:59Mark McGrath: Do you see a lot of internal learning capabilities?
- 28:02Mark McGrath: Do you see a lot of efforts in that respect that are going to create more self-awareness in the company, to improve their situational awareness in their market space?
- 28:13Mark McGrath: Are you observing things like that?
- 28:18Doug Farren: So just so I understand.
- 28:19Doug Farren: So are you asking if they are trying to drive a lot of that internal self-awareness?
- 28:29Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 28:29Mark McGrath: So we challenge all assumptions.
- 28:31Mark McGrath: We're helping people challenge all assumptions.
- 28:33Mark McGrath: Like John Hoy told us, if we don't challenge assumptions today and continuously, whatever works will soon become obsolete and whatever we don't challenge will become.
- 28:43Mark McGrath: Today's doctorate will be tomorrow's dogma, and then it's inflexible and it never changes.
- 28:48Mark McGrath: And then we're just vulnerable, we're just going to degrade because our orientation is never going to be able to realign to the market.
- 28:55Mark McGrath: As VUCA unfolds, as complexity unfolds, we're going to be stuck with linear solutions because we didn't challenge that.
- 29:04Mark McGrath: So do you see things in an organization in the middle market where companies are actually doing that and creating environments where there are healthy challenging of assumptions, where people could say hey, I read a white paper at the National Center for the Middle Market.
- 29:17Mark McGrath: I think we should consider that.
- 29:19Mark McGrath: But I don't get persecuted for bringing that in.
- 29:22Mark McGrath: I don't get whacked over the head because I don't outrank somebody or that kind of a thing.
- 29:28Doug Farren: Yeah, we were talking about this at the very beginning of our conversation.
- 29:32Doug Farren: I think the cultural dimensions of most middle market companies.
- 29:38Doug Farren: Now again, they're bound to be exceptions, but I think in general, the de-layering of that type of bureaucracy is very, very common.
- 29:47Doug Farren: It's almost a necessity when you've got maybe three or four senior leaders and then everybody else is empowered to run the rest of the organization.
- 29:58Doug Farren: You actually have to have that in order to be successfully functioning.
- 30:02Doug Farren: I'll share an example.
- 30:04Doug Farren: This goes back to the start of the pandemic.
- 30:08Doug Farren: It's for a local restaurant business here called Cameron Mitchell's.
- 30:11Doug Farren: I'm sure people if they haven't been to one of the restaurants, they've got seven or eight different restaurant brands across the country, maybe 50 or 60 different locations, very high-end restaurants.
- 30:26Doug Farren: Everything got shut down in the spring of 2020.
- 30:31Doug Farren: Basically, this restaurant organization went from an upper middle market revenue company over 300 million a year in revenue went to zero literally overnight.
- 30:42Doug Farren: Another their issue was that they were never designed to be a carry out or, like it's high-end dining.
- 30:56Doug Farren: It's part of the reason of going to these restaurants is for the experience of the dining this team for going about six weeks with zero revenue.
- 31:07Doug Farren: Basically, the team came to the table and said we have to change immediately.
- 31:13Doug Farren: This wasn't necessarily something that came from the top.
- 31:16Doug Farren: I think it was a team approach.
- 31:19Doug Farren: They said we have to rethink this and we have to do it very quickly or we're going to be out of business.
- 31:26Doug Farren: Before they laid off a single employee, they were paying their staff, their wait staff, their cook staff.
- 31:33Doug Farren: Everyone maintained their jobs.
- 31:35Doug Farren: They were able to quickly pivot and develop carry out functionality, online payment, like everything that's associated.
- 31:44Doug Farren: Now that all seems pretty straightforward, because I think everybody does that.
- 31:49Doug Farren: For them, that was a radical change and it happened within a matter of eight weeks.
- 31:53Doug Farren: They were open to it.
- 31:55Doug Farren: They were open to it because that one was done almost out of necessity.
- 32:00Doug Farren: But that just proves that when you're backs against the wall and you have to do these things, everybody was all in.
- 32:07Doug Farren: They made it happen very quickly and they launched carry out.
- 32:11Doug Farren: They were able to not only survive, but now they're back to a growth organization where they're opening new locations.
- 32:20Doug Farren: They're opening new restaurant concepts.
- 32:24Doug Farren: This company they just figured it out.
- 32:26Doug Farren: That's what I would compare and contrast to.
- 32:29Doug Farren: A big organization maybe like, well, we got to think about it and we got to go through RFP.
- 32:33Doug Farren: What vendor are we going to use?
- 32:36Mark McGrath: What did so, and so do yes.
- 32:38Doug Farren: Let's do our research.
- 32:39Doug Farren: Let's do benchmarking.
- 32:41Doug Farren: Let's hire consultants.
- 32:42Mark McGrath: Let's get a survey.
- 32:45Doug Farren: This was a fairly large middle market company who just said all that's out the window.
- 32:50Doug Farren: Here's what we're going to do.
- 32:51Doug Farren: We're going to make a decision and we're going to launch.
- 32:53Doug Farren: They did it and they were successful.
- 32:57Mark McGrath: We should talk more about that because that is a tremendous example of how disruption is met with design.
- 33:03Mark McGrath: In orientation in UDA it shifts through drift like the passing of time, like our late 40s selves see the world different than our early 20 cells just by aging and passing of time.
- 33:14Mark McGrath: Then the other two ways, both again with D.
- 33:16Mark McGrath: There's disruption, like you described.
- 33:18Mark McGrath: They wake up one day and they're zero revenue.
- 33:21Mark McGrath: And then there's design.
- 33:22Mark McGrath: They meet it with design so that the way that company was set up to function as a team, to function as an organism that delivers a phenomenal experience.
- 33:30Mark McGrath: I know them very well in that we both live here in Columbus, but they're also in Florida and other places they're able to meet that with design rapidly.
- 33:39Mark McGrath: That did not have a playbook, did not have a precedent, so to speak, where everything was just shut down like that.
- 33:48Mark McGrath: By having those things like facing complexity and pushing decisions and working together, they're able to reorient and adapt really quick.
- 33:59Mark McGrath: It's not surprised you and I have been going to those restaurants as long as we've lived in this area.
- 34:03Mark McGrath: Every time I've been there it's a phenomenal experience.
- 34:07Mark McGrath: I've never not had a feedback card that I've sent into that company.
- 34:11Mark McGrath: I've never not gotten a reply, positive or negative.
- 34:15Mark McGrath: If I had a negative experience, I send in.
- 34:18Mark McGrath: I have a positive experience 100% of the time.
- 34:20Mark McGrath: I've gotten a feedback from them when you tell me that it's no shock because they do deliver an experience that seems to their medium is yeah, it's restaurant, but they're onto something bigger.
- 34:33Mark McGrath: They have a much bigger thing that I think they're oriented on.
- 34:38Doug Farren: None of that happens without an ingrained culture where it's like this is just how we do things.
- 34:44Doug Farren: We're going to respond to every customer.
- 34:46Doug Farren: It's important to them.
- 34:49Mark McGrath: You would know better than I but my observation of the years of interacting with them.
- 34:52Mark McGrath: I would imagine that they have a phenomenal training program, that they do a lot of different procedural things as teams and as locations so that when things happen they're able to pivot and adapt really quickly.
- 35:08Mark McGrath: It also seems to me too, and maybe this would be a question about.
- 35:12Mark McGrath: One of the things that we talk about is distributed leadership.
- 35:15Mark McGrath: It also seems to me at that example that there's a lot of decisions that are pushed down to the lowest level so that the person immediately dealing with the customer can handle it, rather than have to ask a manager, who has to ask a branch manager or a regional manager and all the way back that they can pivot really fast under the regular operations.
- 35:33Mark McGrath: Do you see a lot of that?
- 35:36Doug Farren: It's funny because I just had this experience.
- 35:38Doug Farren: Last night I was at one of their restaurants and it wasn't our server, but one of the staff came by and just said, oh, we were finishing up our salads or bread or whatever Mistakenly took my salad.
- 35:53Doug Farren: I wasn't done.
- 35:54Doug Farren: He's like, oh, I'm going to take this.
- 35:56Doug Farren: Everything was taken away, including all my silverware.
- 35:59Doug Farren: The server came out and I was like, oh, can I get a new set of silverware, because it was taken with my salad.
- 36:05Doug Farren: She's like, oh, my gosh, Come back, new set of silverware.
- 36:09Doug Farren: And then, as I left, gave me a full salad to go.
- 36:12Doug Farren: I said this is for the mistake that we made.
- 36:16Doug Farren: And she did it.
- 36:17Doug Farren: She didn't get it, she just did it.
- 36:18Doug Farren: I was like, wow, I didn't even make an issue of it.
- 36:22Doug Farren: My family was embarrassed because they were like hey, why did you make such a big deal?
- 36:26Doug Farren: I said I didn't make a big deal, I just said I needed new silverware.
- 36:29Doug Farren: She went above and beyond by bringing me a full salad to take home with me.
- 36:33Doug Farren: So that's just yeah to your point.
- 36:35Doug Farren: That's a fully empowered employee.
- 36:38Doug Farren: She made that decision and make it operate faster.
- 36:42Doug Farren: Very, yes, exactly, yeah, exactly.
- 36:44Doug Farren: And I left going.
- 36:46Doug Farren: That made such a huge impression on me because so many of my restaurant experiences in the last couple of years have been poor, right, and now I'm like, oh my gosh, this place is amazing, yeah, and now you're telling the world on no way out.
- 36:58Mark McGrath: So that one decision, that one decision that was pushed down and that person was able to take care of you then and there.
- 37:03Mark McGrath: Now the world knows about it.
- 37:05Mark McGrath: And that's how companies.
- 37:06Mark McGrath: That's great, that's how it happens, yeah.
- 37:10Doug Farren: And that's part of what we call the.
- 37:12Doug Farren: So we say employee value proposition was something I talked about, like why you want to work at a middle market company Employer brand.
- 37:19Doug Farren: It's like that's what we call what people say about the company, right?
- 37:23Doug Farren: If you're talking to your neighbor hey, what's it like to work at Cameron Mitchell?
- 37:27Doug Farren: What's it like to work at Fisher College of Business?
- 37:29Doug Farren: What you tell the community about your business?
- 37:32Doug Farren: Yeah, and that's an area of opportunity as well.
- 37:35Doug Farren: I mean, middle market companies can do a lot better job kind of communicating that and espousing that and getting people to talk about that, Because so many of these companies are.
- 37:46Doug Farren: I shared an example of a more well-known one, because it's a consumer restaurant brand.
- 37:51Doug Farren: But there are so many of these businesses that are B2B that most consumers you and I would never even know who they are.
- 38:01Mark McGrath: How pervasive in the middle market is that where a culture would push decisions down to the lowest level to take care of the customer or the partner right away, without delay?
- 38:10Mark McGrath: I mean, do you see decision rights or do you see distributed leadership as something that there's opportunity for companies to learn, or is that common?
- 38:20Mark McGrath: I think ultimately it centers around trust, and the trust that you build with the team and the trust that you build inside of a culture.
- 38:27Mark McGrath: When you say Cameron Mitchell, that's another thing.
- 38:30Mark McGrath: That's obvious.
- 38:31Mark McGrath: As someone that goes there myself, it seems that they do trust and empower their people to do exactly that.
- 38:36Mark McGrath: I mean, how much learning is left on that?
- 38:40Doug Farren: Yeah, I think there's a ton to look at there.
- 38:42Doug Farren: I mean I couldn't speak effectively on how much we see that because we haven't really looked closely at that issue, but my presumption is that there's a lot of opportunity for businesses to learn about the power of that capability, about really not only just walking the talk when you say, oh yeah, we fully empower our employees.
- 39:05Doug Farren: But what does that really mean?
- 39:06Doug Farren: What does that really mean to do that and define that for your team and make it.
- 39:13Doug Farren: Because, again, it's one thing when you're serving a customer, like the example I just shared.
- 39:17Doug Farren: It's another thing when you're in a factory floor and there's nobody looking.
- 39:21Doug Farren: Right, you see a problem, do you fix it immediately?
- 39:25Doug Farren: Do you have the ability to do that?
- 39:26Doug Farren: Do you know how much leeway you have when you know something's wrong to just fix it on the spot?
- 39:34Doug Farren: I mean, that's something that we haven't looked a ton at, but I'm sure there's a lot of opportunity around that for these businesses.
- 39:41Mark McGrath: Let's continue that conversation at some point, because there's a lot of things we could discuss.
- 39:46Mark McGrath: The big industries with middle market are going to be consumer services, construction insurance healthcare hospital systems.
- 39:56Doug Farren: Yeah, the four biggest, as we look at them in terms of the number of companies, would be business services.
- 40:04Doug Farren: That's a broad definition.
- 40:05Doug Farren: Think about a lot of law firms are actually middle market because those are regional in nature.
- 40:12Doug Farren: You've got firms that serve, like, maybe, several states or an area of the country, young firms, places like that.
- 40:22Doug Farren: Manufacturing is another large segment in the middle market.
- 40:27Doug Farren: You've got 14% or so of mid-sized companies following the manufacturing sector.
- 40:33Doug Farren: Then retail is the number three.
- 40:35Doug Farren: Retail would include restaurants, e-commerce, places like that.
- 40:42Doug Farren: Those are generally the top three.
- 40:44Doug Farren: Then, beyond that, you've got construction, healthcare, financial services.
- 40:51Doug Farren: We all attract technology companies.
- 40:54Mark McGrath: In about 90 private, 10 public percentage-wise.
- 40:58Doug Farren: Yeah, okay, thanks for taking your time.
- 41:02Mark McGrath: What do you think the current landscape looks like over the next couple of years for middle market companies and what are the opportunities for them to adapt as we drive on?
- 41:12Doug Farren: Yeah, I mean I mentioned our mid-year study.
- 41:17Doug Farren: We've got an ongoing study called the middle market indicator.
- 41:20Doug Farren: We survey a thousand financial decision makers in the middle market every six months.
- 41:26Doug Farren: Our mid-year 2023 reports getting ready to come out and give a sneak preview of that.
- 41:31Doug Farren: I mean what we're seeing is overall very strong top-line performance, very strong hiring, very strong confidence in the economy.
- 41:41Doug Farren: Also, the positive thing we're seeing there's an uptick in capital investment planning for these firms.
- 41:50Doug Farren: So it's been lagging for the last couple of years as a result of the pandemic and some other stuff, but we're starting to see that open up a bit.
- 41:57Doug Farren: About 60% of these companies have introduced their new product or service in the last 12 months.
- 42:03Doug Farren: So that is a signal of expansionary activity.
- 42:08Doug Farren: About another 40% have entered a new domestic market in the last 12 months.
- 42:12Doug Farren: So yeah, I mean what we see is kind of continued strong performance.
- 42:18Doug Farren: There are some headwinds out there, obviously.
- 42:20Doug Farren: I mean it's becoming much more pricey to borrow money, so that may constrain a little bit of the expansion.
- 42:29Doug Farren: We think about physical assets like plant equipment, facilities, things of that nature.
- 42:36Doug Farren: It and technology seems to be a big target again.
- 42:41Doug Farren: Like we talked about earlier, a lot of these companies are thinking about whether it's following the crowd or thinking about something that's a right fit for them.
- 42:52Doug Farren: That seems to be a big target.
- 42:55Doug Farren: So we're going to be monitoring a few things.
- 42:58Doug Farren: I mean one is the continued use of technology.
- 43:03Doug Farren: We're going to be monitoring kind of skills development and workforce.
- 43:07Doug Farren: We've got a partnership that's developing with the Ohio Chamber to build some training.
- 43:12Doug Farren: So it's not going to look exactly like that GE experience that I described.
- 43:17Doug Farren: It's going to be actually more of a mix of some online and some in-person.
- 43:22Doug Farren: So we hope to roll that out, hopefully early next year, where we're going to bring in again middle market leaders across the state of Ohio and then the goal would be to eventually roll that out across the country, giving them new skill sets and views and the things.
- 43:38Doug Farren: So if I look back at the last 11 years, I mean I think the middle market is a rock solid part of the economy and they continue to do well in the face of a lot of adversity and they've got a lot of characteristics that position them well for continued growth.
- 43:55Doug Farren: So everything from our end looks extremely positive.
- 43:59Mark McGrath: That's good.
- 44:01Mark McGrath: Lots of applications for the theory of John Boyd Boyd, for business, for sure.
- 44:07Mark McGrath: Where could people, where would you direct people to go and learn more?
- 44:13Mark McGrath: And we'll close with that before we go over to the extended version that we'll put up on YouTube In the closing moments of the podcast.
- 44:21Mark McGrath: Where would you send folks to go check out more about the middle market and learn more about these things?
- 44:27Doug Farren: Yeah, so our website is middlemarketcenterorg.
- 44:31Doug Farren: It's a tremendous resource for all things about the middle market.
- 44:37Doug Farren: We have a large content library, so about 65 research studies over the 11 years we've been in existence.
- 44:45Doug Farren: I mentioned data, so there's areas that you can go in there and look at benchmarking data my industry by size.
- 44:53Doug Farren: We've got video content on there.
- 44:56Doug Farren: We've got a knowledge center that has lots of different things for people to kind of poke around and consume and that's where we also put out a lot of you know, all of our latest information.
- 45:06Doug Farren: So I would advise that as a starting point.
- 45:10Doug Farren: Okay, lots of things to look at there and you know, certainly follow along.
- 45:15Doug Farren: And, yeah, that's where I would go.
- 45:19Mark McGrath: So if you're at a company, one of 200,000 United States, which has an annual revenue of 10 million to a billion that's who we're speaking to right, correct Go on middlemarketcenterorg and learn more Cool, hey, doug.
- 45:34Mark McGrath: We'll close out the podcast and we'll head over to the extended version over on YouTube, but thanks for coming on no Way Out and thanks for sharing the story of the middle market and some of the success stories that hopefully others will take an interest and learn from.
- 45:48Doug Farren: Yeah, sounds great.
- 45:49Doug Farren: Glad to be here.