Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Mentalizing From an Applied Perspective
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I love you.
- 0:02Keep going podcast with George Hoss.
- 0:05For more information, please visit our website at
- 0:07www.medicare.gov org, that's www.a.
- 0:12Me TT a gr, oup dot-org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:21This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:23It is December 1st 2022, it 7:35 p.m.
- 0:27Pacific time. And I was thinking that we would
- 0:32that it might be useful to talk about mentalizing from an
- 0:36implied point of view. I was talking to somebody this
- 0:41this morning about it trying to understand how active
- 0:48mentalizing and non mentalizing interface with the different
- 0:54attachments strategies and And how in the pattern of
- 1:02mentalizing in organizing secure and disorganized people, even
- 1:07though you could call it, active mentalizing is still in some
- 1:11sense, limited by the attachment conditioning.
- 1:16And then have that manifest in the way, that we form, Ultimate
- 1:23Reality into conceptual reality, or the experience that we have
- 1:28of the world. In talking about this, we use
- 1:34the anti Bateman Peter Van icky approach that they developed at
- 1:41what is now the Anna Freud Center to treat personality
- 1:47disorders. We don't really use the
- 1:52personality disorder frame and in the work that we do.
- 1:59It's a little bit different. I did pick up a book from
- 2:05Masterson's Group, which is explaining their approach to
- 2:13personality disorders, using the attachment lens.
- 2:18But I haven't digested the material enough to be able to
- 2:22relate it to you. Masterson is a psychologist who
- 2:30came up with the the frame of narcissism at the one end of the
- 2:36narcissistic spectrum is antisocial personality disorder.
- 2:40And at the other end of the narcissism spectrum is
- 2:44borderline personality disorder lately.
- 2:50Borderline personality disorder is been getting A lot of bad
- 2:54press. And so they're, they're
- 2:57advocating a different couple of names for it.
- 3:02So you may notice that happening in the future, And when you map
- 3:13that Loosely on to the attachment, the antisocial
- 3:17personality disorder is the extreme of dismissing and
- 3:22borderline personality disorder is the extreme of preoccupation
- 3:27but it doesn't map exactly. And actually most people that
- 3:33have what we would call a personality disorder has
- 3:40components from the whole range of Narcissism so it's not just
- 3:45one thing. We might from the Buddhist lens
- 3:50call that fixed views, which is the less.
- 3:56I'm sorry. That in our culture, mental
- 3:59illness. It is often such a pejorative,
- 4:02it's very painful. I think to think of it in that
- 4:05way. Most of the people who come
- 4:09through their Early, Childhood experiences have responded in a
- 4:16very predictable and ordinary way to the conditions that they
- 4:21faced as children. You know, extremely difficult to
- 4:25conditions are necessary for somebody to develop the very
- 4:33rigid views, the very fixed views that they They have
- 4:38particularly in the US where there's really very little
- 4:42treatment even available for people.
- 4:45I don't know if you saw on. New York, they've decided that
- 4:51it's acceptable to. Hospitalized people without
- 4:59their permission. They just need to be deemed
- 5:05unfit to take care of themselves and now they can be
- 5:07hospitalized. This is a throwback to prior to
- 5:14the Kennedy administration in the early 60s, you met Remember
- 5:21that before the Kennedy administration, we had these big
- 5:27state-run hospitals for mentally ill people, which were quite
- 5:31horrific, and the response to the, to the seeing the
- 5:36conditions. There resulted in this duel
- 5:41phased legislation, that passed during the Kennedy
- 5:46administration, one was to close the state hospitals and the
- 5:50second was to fund small community-based centers.
- 5:57So that rather than being removed from their communities.
- 6:01There would be Treatment available within the community
- 6:03that people who had mental illness.
- 6:05Could go to. You may also remember that one
- 6:10Reagan came into office, that he continued to fund the closing of
- 6:18all of the hospitals and canceled the funding for the
- 6:22Community Mental Health Centers, which is the thing that
- 6:26precipitated the homeless problem that we have now, So the
- 6:34gradual dismantling of the public mental health system,
- 6:39which was then supposed to be replaced by a community-based
- 6:43system, resulted in the Statewide and countywide
- 6:49Facilities, being closed, and nothing replacing them.
- 6:58Anyway, I'll get off my soapbox about that.
- 7:06When you look at a rigid or fixed views, what that really
- 7:10means is that when you take conceptual reality, it's
- 7:15filtered through these rigid views and it creates a very
- 7:18distorted perception of what's actually happening.
- 7:22So you have in the Buddhist concept Ultimate Reality,
- 7:26Ultimate Reality is the sensing data.
- 7:29So you have the capacity to send something the object that can be
- 7:33sensed when there's contact consciousness of At sensing
- 7:36experience arises, it's then evaluated for what I would say
- 7:41urgency Baden is the poly work. It's often translated as
- 7:46pleasant unpleasant or neutral, but one of the things about this
- 7:51process is that urgent material always goes to the front of the
- 7:54line and requires much less input to form.
- 7:58A neutron material almost never makes it into Consciousness
- 8:01because the bandwidth of Consciousness is so narrow.
- 8:05And Then Pleasant. If there's time, the brain
- 8:07science on this is pretty good, something that's Pleasant
- 8:11requires, double the intensity of Sensation that something
- 8:16that's urgent requires and it requires a duration of about a
- 8:21half a second in order for it to get into the queue for
- 8:24consciousness. We queue for consciousness.
- 8:28Of course, - experience or urgent experience, can jump the
- 8:33queue. So you may never get to the
- 8:34pleasant stuff because the queue is always been jumped.
- 8:38If you Then that that information when it comes to the
- 8:46top of the queue is compared to the perceptual database.
- 8:50And if there's a meaning that's in the perceptual database,
- 8:54that's close enough to the pattern of sensing experience.
- 8:57It is attached and it rolls into conceptual reality and the views
- 9:05of slip in between, we could call the mine States.
- 9:10And distort the perception. And so, when you have these
- 9:14rigid or fixed views that come out of adverse conditioning
- 9:20experiences, it's easy to create these experiences of conceptual
- 9:27reality, which don't actually match what's happening in the
- 9:31present moment that, well, that all making sense in that
- 9:35description. The other piece to understand is
- 9:39that we do not take a complete survey of everything that's in
- 9:42front of us. And then create a version of
- 9:45reality based on that we cherry pick things based on our
- 9:48preferences for what's in front of us.
- 9:53So, each of us because our conditioning is different, is
- 9:56cherry picking a different set of data points with which to
- 10:00create the experiences that were having If you are very present
- 10:05and very open, there's not a lot of rigidity in the way that you
- 10:10form experiences. You end up, creating a
- 10:14perception of the present moment, which is closed in the
- 10:20way that we can understand the present moment to what's
- 10:23actually happening. And if you have a lot of rigid
- 10:26views who create quite a different experience of the
- 10:30present moment that other people would have, A hard time really
- 10:35understanding because they don't have the same conditioning as
- 10:39you and they don't distort in the same way that you do.
- 10:45That all makes sense. So when you talk about the frame
- 10:50of, for the finally Bateman mentalizing, we're really
- 10:55talking about the mentalizing capacities that are developed in
- 10:58the very early experience. With the caregiver, the primary
- 11:04caregiver, we don't see ourselves accurately by
- 11:09ourselves. We are see ourselves in the
- 11:12reflection of other people. And one we're born.
- 11:17We really rely very heavily on the reflection of our
- 11:22caregivers, to understand our nature.
- 11:26And we begin to develop a working model of who we are.
- 11:30But our capacities are what our desirability is based on the
- 11:35experience of our caregiver reflecting back to us their
- 11:39experience of being with us, in those early days, and Months and
- 11:45years of our life. We begin to develop the capacity
- 11:53to mentalize work or to understand what's happening in
- 11:57that dyadic relationship. And so the deficits of the
- 12:01advantages of our caregiver are part of what's reflected back
- 12:06into us and we begin to develop ourselves in relationship to
- 12:11them. And that's one of the reasons
- 12:16why the attachment conditioning is so stable generation to
- 12:20generation because we come in largely as a blank slate and
- 12:24then absorb through the interaction with our caregivers,
- 12:30how they do it might be a way to put it.
- 12:34So if you have a skillful caregiver you learn a lot of
- 12:37good skills and if you have an unskilful caregiver you learn a
- 12:41lot of unskillful. The cheese for being the world.
- 12:54So, an example of that might be, lets say you're a colicky, baby.
- 12:57You can't sleep. When you're irritated all the
- 12:59time when you cry a lot and you have a caregiver who's quite
- 13:03resilient and actually Delights and taking care of you even
- 13:06though you're extremely fussy. And so your experience of
- 13:10yourself as being really fussy, is that it creates the
- 13:13experience of delight and, and heightened interest in you and
- 13:18your well-being. And so you develop a working
- 13:22model of yourself. That even when I'm having
- 13:24difficulty, even when I'm fussy, even when I'm hard to settle,
- 13:31what can't sleep, the people that are around me.
- 13:35Not only will be delighted by me and that safe, but they'll also
- 13:39want to take care of me and that and state, then you don't have a
- 13:45problem with being in that state because that your expectation
- 13:49then, is that you Well, taken care of them but let's say
- 13:53you're a colicky baby and you wear your caregiver out and
- 13:56they're angry at you and they're irritated at you and they they
- 14:00don't want to do it anymore. Then, what you learn is that in
- 14:06those States, they have to be hidden because if they're not
- 14:08hidden, you're going to be abandoned and if you're going to
- 14:11be abandoned, you're not going to be able to survive.
- 14:15And so you learn to suppress those expressions in one case.
- 14:20Case. The authentic expression of what
- 14:23your experience is is not being inhibited.
- 14:26It's being rewarded. And in the other case you
- 14:29learned that authentic expression is not tolerable
- 14:32here. It's dangerous to do that.
- 14:34So I have to learn to suppress it and this is all an
- 14:39unconscious and we're that did say pre verbal.
- 14:42We haven't developed the capacity for Autobiographical
- 14:49reference had because our brain hasn't developed enough.
- 14:51This is all procedural, that's at the level we're talking about
- 14:55the the fearfulness to be authentic.
- 14:59In people who had those early experiences of rejection is
- 15:05unconscious and very Primal, because it's in the survival
- 15:12frame, the the intensity of it. so, depending on the pattern of
- 15:21mentalizing skills that are offered, you, you take them up,
- 15:25we talked about it in four, domains of active mentalizing in
- 15:30three, domains of non mentalizing, Non mentalizing is
- 15:37psychic, equivalence mode teleological mode and pretend
- 15:41mode, psychic. Equivalence mode means that you
- 15:44think that your understanding of what's happening is actually,
- 15:48what's happening. And that everybody is having the
- 15:51same experience of it as you are.
- 15:55And that gives you a lot of latitude to assign meaning to
- 15:58other people's reactions. Other people's internal
- 16:02experience in teleological. Vehicle mode, you assign meaning
- 16:07to the external appearance of things without investigating,
- 16:10whether your assignment of meaning is accurate or not.
- 16:15So when you present yourself teleologically, you expect
- 16:21people to understand you in the way that you intend the meaning
- 16:25to be. So you buy a Rolex watch and you
- 16:29expect people to think that, whatever it is that you think
- 16:32about somebody who wears a Rolex watch that I'm successful.
- 16:35I've made. But I should be treated with a
- 16:37certain amount of respect because I'm wearing this.
- 16:40Watch somebody else might not necessarily have that view of
- 16:44that watch and might think something entirely differently
- 16:47about it. But in a teleological mode you
- 16:50think because you're wearing that watch that people will
- 16:52treat you in the way that you expect them to and if they don't
- 16:56as usually angering When you look at somebody else in a
- 17:01teleological mode, you assign meaning to the way that they
- 17:04present themselves, don't really investigate whether your
- 17:08assignment of meaning to them is accurate or not.
- 17:12It's not making sense. Christian.
- 17:20So I can think of examples of like where the teleological mode
- 17:23would seem to overlap with. A realistic expectation of
- 17:28someone's really like a CEO and you know, surrounded by Yes, Men
- 17:32or something like that. We're in Rolex watches.
- 17:35And, you know, if you, you can have your entire life, you know,
- 17:38given the society that you keep, where that's just getting
- 17:43confirmed, right? Is that I guess.
- 17:47My question is, is that I think that would be more associated
- 17:52with an avoidant avoidant attachment Style.
- 17:59Well, this is an interesting aspect in really what I'm
- 18:06talking about tonight, the aspect of the, the teleological
- 18:11down mentalizing mode, depending on what your native attachment
- 18:15strategy is, our current attachment strategy is has
- 18:18different aspects to it. So for instance, in a dismissing
- 18:25person, when you look at the dimensions of active until
- 18:28mentalizing, spontaneity versus monitoring, self versus other
- 18:35internal versus external and cognitive versus effective,
- 18:41Dismissing, people tend to be very self oriented.
- 18:47They tend to be very internally oriented, and they tend to be
- 18:50over monitoring, they tend to be cognitive.
- 18:56So, in the teleological mode of a dismissing person, they read
- 19:01the external experience of something and they understand it
- 19:04to be what they understand it to be.
- 19:10And because of the way that they're active active
- 19:12mentalizing, is they don't pick up contrary information readily.
- 19:20And so that would be active mentalizing in a non active mode
- 19:23and just teleological mode, which is not active, it might
- 19:27appear similarly to that. The difference would be that
- 19:32they don't really pick up on any contradiction to it.
- 19:39In an active mentalizing mode. A dismissing person, might pick
- 19:44up that somebody doesn't agree with their interpretation.
- 19:50Is that helping at all? In non mentalizing mode, there
- 19:58really is no alternative to the understanding of it as in a
- 20:06contrast in teleological mode. When it's a preoccupied person,
- 20:10primarily what they're trying to do is present themselves in a
- 20:14way that will provide meaning to the other person.
- 20:21So that what they try to do is into it, what it is that you
- 20:24want them to be and then they try to become that so that their
- 20:28teleological presentation is often pretending to be who it
- 20:33is. They think you want Not because
- 20:37they want you to want them in that sense, but because they
- 20:41want you to take care of them in the way that they want to be.
- 20:44So they're often taking care of you, not, so that you'll be
- 20:47taken care of. But so that the that you'll,
- 20:50then take care of them. Do complicated.
- 20:59I guess I'm not exactly seeing the preoccupied teleological
- 21:05mode like I would have thought that maybe an example, I think
- 21:09of borderline being more on the preoccupied end.
- 21:13Yeah, that's true. But I would think of like, you
- 21:17know, if someone is born, you know, has a really They've been
- 21:22hurt by their partner or something, then internally, they
- 21:25are saying I'm hurt. So, this person intended is
- 21:29trying to hurt me. This person's against me like,
- 21:32kind of splitting or whatever. Would that be an example of the
- 21:35teleological mode for preoccupied, because it I guess
- 21:41I wasn't quite getting how your example was.
- 21:46Someone seeing the world in a particular way and kind of
- 21:51fixated on this missing person tends to review the world and
- 21:55assign meaning to it. They don't use an empathetic
- 22:00experience of the other person, as a way of checking it.
- 22:04So, if you look at a dynamic mentalizing, presentation of a
- 22:10secure person, for instance, they understand what they think
- 22:14is going. Going on, but they have the
- 22:16capacity of empathy to check it. And if they, if it's confusing
- 22:21to them, they also have the capacity to ask what's actually
- 22:25happening. So the stands would be, this is
- 22:28what I think is going on. What do you think is going on?
- 22:31This is my experience of this is, what was your intention or
- 22:35what was your meaning to the experience of this rather than
- 22:39assuming that their interpretation of it is actually
- 22:43accurate. There's a flexibility.
- 22:46It died a dynamic to secure. People aren't worried about the
- 22:51relationship collapsing because they tend to rely on
- 22:54relationships and they tend to be stable.
- 22:56So it doesn't come into their mind so much.
- 22:59But this missing person is extremely sensitive to
- 23:03abandonment fear, which they mostly experience as rejecting.
- 23:09And so, for teleological response to something, for
- 23:11dismissing person is to interpret what's happening as a
- 23:15rejecting gesture, which they then don't check because they
- 23:21don't have the capacity really to check in that same way.
- 23:28So if you remember empathy, the first level of empathy is that
- 23:31visceral response to the witnessing of somebody else's
- 23:35physical or emotional pain. The second level is where You
- 23:38can read the external presentation of facial
- 23:41expressions and body language and assign meaning to it.
- 23:45And the third is the compassion and empathy, where you actually
- 23:49feel the experience of the person in your body emotionally.
- 23:55We tend to compare the second and third to see whether we
- 23:58think somebody's lying in insecure and disorganized
- 24:02attachment. Dismissing people because they
- 24:06suppress awareness of their emotions don't have the capacity
- 24:09of empathy so they don't actually gather that
- 24:12information. It doesn't occur to them.
- 24:15To check the presentation of the person with the empathetic
- 24:19experience of the person or what the person does.
- 24:24They really just look at the external presentation or if
- 24:28they're really not even able to do that rely on what somebody
- 24:32tells them is happening. So preoccupied person in pretend
- 24:46mode, what that means is that they need to present themselves
- 24:50in the way that they think you want them to be so that you'll
- 24:54take care of them. So in the teleological approach
- 24:59to a preoccupied person is to pretend to be something to
- 25:04present something to get the other person to respond in the
- 25:08way that they want to without ever asking directly for what it
- 25:12is that they want. Then, of course.
- 25:21It's often as pseudo empathetic experience that a preoccupied
- 25:24person has they met? Experience emotion.
- 25:36And they may be able to touch into the empathetic experience
- 25:40of someone else, but because they can't separate it from
- 25:42their own emotions and see the two as distinct.
- 25:50Don't really have a sense of the the effect that the empathetic
- 25:55experience have the other person is having on them.
- 26:01Not helping. And I think this is why it's
- 26:09useful to talk about mentalizing too, because of the way that it
- 26:13might manifest. So, the dismissing person is
- 26:16very self oriented, very internally oriented very
- 26:21cognitively oriented, and over monitors.
- 26:24But over monitoring really means, is that the dismissing
- 26:29person previews, everything that they're going to express in
- 26:35through the self experience, which is delayed.
- 26:38About half a second, they're not spontaneous.
- 26:41Everything is previewed. Everything is calculated for a
- 26:44fact. So you notice that they're not
- 26:47spontaneous, it's not quick, their responses, there's always
- 26:50a sense of calculation in that I'm preoccupied person is the
- 26:55opposite of that, they're very spontaneous.
- 26:58They're very other oriented, they're very externally oriented
- 27:01in their very emotionally oriented.
- 27:03And so, they're constantly just banging off react Expressions,
- 27:11without much monitoring on them. They lose track of themselves.
- 27:16They Don't Really differentiate themselves from the experience
- 27:19of the other person. They're very externally focused
- 27:23their reading the signs, the teleological experience of a
- 27:29preoccupied person is reading this, the signs of the other
- 27:32person and then pretending to be responding in a way that they
- 27:38think will get them taken care of The reason it's pretending is
- 27:44because if you made a gesture to take care of somebody in the
- 27:47intention was to actually take care of them, that would be one
- 27:50thing. But if you make the gesture to
- 27:53take care of somebody, because you have an implicit
- 27:57understanding with them that that if you do that for them,
- 28:00they'll do something for you. It's quite different, right?
- 28:03Does it matter to you? Whether you succeed in taking
- 28:06care of them, because the intention of that was for them
- 28:09to take care of you. Joan.
- 28:20How does dissociation interplay with a non mentalizing modes or
- 28:27we just dissociating from evidence?
- 28:31That would contradict what what we normally see dissociation is
- 28:38a in adults is primarily an emotional regulation strategy.
- 28:43So we really talk about mentalization and emotional
- 28:49regulation as working together to create resilient capacity for
- 28:58emotional regulation. In people who dissociate?
- 29:02It's adults. What ends up happening is
- 29:06dissociation becomes the main strategy for emotionally
- 29:09regulating. So if something is difficult
- 29:12that it exceeds the window of Tolerance, the Dan Siegel term
- 29:16for the intensity of emotion that you can just process.
- 29:21Then you'd associate the experience that exceeds the
- 29:24window of Tolerance Association is kind of a spectrum and one
- 29:29end your thinking becomes very rigid, very black-and-white
- 29:33friend and foe good bad and on the other end it's a trance-like
- 29:38state in the extreme end. Of course, it's a loss of
- 29:41conscious awareness. If you don't mentalize very
- 29:49well, then it's hard for you to mentalize that you're
- 29:51dissociating so that you don't include that in the way that you
- 29:56assemble experienced a dissociative person comes and
- 30:02goes from the experience of the present moment.
- 30:06And what you'll notice if you if you know dissociative people, is
- 30:10that each time they come back, if you're accepting of the fact
- 30:14that they spaced out and fill in the blank for them, they can
- 30:18keep up with the conversation and be in line with what your
- 30:22experience is. but if you don't if you express irritation or
- 30:28difficulty with the fact that they can't stay in the
- 30:31conversation, Then they'll stop telling you that they're not in
- 30:36the conversation continuously and that the that is really
- 30:40where the problem is. They will create a bridge that
- 30:46links where they remember, they were and where they are now so
- 30:51that it makes sense to them. Internally, what the experience
- 30:55was But there's a very low degree of accuracy.
- 31:00And in the bridges that they make So if the conversation
- 31:05ended in, there's two minutes of conversation that followed and
- 31:09then you come back in and you have to fill in two minutes of
- 31:12conversation or 10 seconds of conversation, whatever it is.
- 31:17And you make up the bridge, it may not at all wrote resemble,
- 31:21what happened. And then what begins to happen
- 31:24is the dissociative person is having one experience of the
- 31:27conversation and the other person has having a different
- 31:31experience of the conversation. And you know, you could even
- 31:36make agreements in the in the Gap.
- 31:38And not remember that you'd made agreement or talked about
- 31:41something made a dinner appointment.
- 31:45You know, not remember it because you were to dissociate
- 31:49and then when you don't show up or you don't keep the agreement
- 31:52and you earnestly say, I don't remember making that agreement.
- 31:56I don't remember making that plan.
- 32:00The other person is thinking you're lying, right?
- 32:02Because they didn't associate the conversation, we're
- 32:06manipulating or doing something dissociation.
- 32:10Nobody think. So they didn't show up because
- 32:13they dissociate So the the way to come out of dissociation, is
- 32:25to work with the emotional regulation strategies that are
- 32:28not dissociative so that you can strengthen them, and use them
- 32:30instead and also develop the capacity to mentalize, the
- 32:36coming and going. And then actually to insist that
- 32:41people fill you in. In the gaps so that you don't
- 32:46get you don't get too far away. From what the conversation.
- 32:51Was that making sense? You still there.
- 33:04Joan. Your image seems to have Frozen.
- 33:15Well, maybe she's Frozen. so, these active mentalizing modes,
- 33:24I use spontaneity and monitoring Bateman and fauna GE use
- 33:31automatic versus controlled. Self versus other.
- 33:47Internal versus external cognitive versus effective.
- 33:50What you'll notice in different attachment outcomes is these
- 33:57different patterns of functioning and so when you
- 34:00begin to use your meditation, practice to build up the
- 34:05mentalizing skills, it's useful to understand what your native
- 34:09attachment strategy is, so that you can recognize the skill set
- 34:13that you already have and the deficits that you need to
- 34:16develop. That you can spend your time,
- 34:19developing the deficits what often happens.
- 34:23In meditation practice, like many things is that the, to
- 34:27develop the skill set of, the deficits is awkward and clumsy
- 34:32and unpleasant, and you don't really like it that much.
- 34:36But to reinforce the skill set that you already have feels
- 34:39pretty good. And so you could organize your
- 34:42practice in such a way that you're reinforcing the skill set
- 34:45that you already have. But and not addressing the skill
- 34:49set that you don't have to. Don't really improve in terms of
- 34:53your capacity to mentalize. So that's one of the reasons why
- 34:57understanding what your attachment strategy is.
- 35:02If you are rigidly controlled or monitoring Then you have to
- 35:11lighten up and allow spontaneity except for loosen up the mind if
- 35:15you're completely spontaneous completely automatic, you never
- 35:19really check what what you're doing.
- 35:22Then you need to begin to develop the monitoring and you
- 35:25need to begin to develop intervention.
- 35:27So that you that that stays in Balance, if you're really self
- 35:33oriented, like the dismissing person is and understand the
- 35:38dismissing person is self oriented because Nobody came to
- 35:41help them and they don't feel empathy so they don't pick up
- 35:45information from other people. It's not they didn't learn to do
- 35:50it and they don't have the skill to do it, so there's no
- 35:52information for them to gather, so it's natural that they would
- 35:56be so self-oriented, because that's where the information for
- 36:00them. To manage being in the world is
- 36:03you have to develop the capacity to recognize emotions in the
- 36:07body. So you have to develop the
- 36:09capacity of Conscious experience of emotions, embodied,
- 36:15experience of emotion. And then have to learn how to
- 36:21regulate them in a conscious experience and then also to read
- 36:27the empathetic experience of somebody else which comes back
- 36:31online. As soon as you're able to
- 36:33consciously experience emotion So the question in the chat is
- 36:41is the disorganized person already a master by practicing
- 36:45both approaches were at. So The.
- 36:58The what makes the disorganized person to experience so chaotic
- 37:04is that the different patterns of preoccupied or dismissing, or
- 37:12even secure can Flash at different moments.
- 37:17And so one moment you could be completely preoccupied on
- 37:20moment, you could be completely dismissive.
- 37:22One moment you could have responded in a secure way so
- 37:26that you can't predict really What your response is going to
- 37:29be and also other people can't predict what your response is
- 37:32going to be and that puts you in the unreliable category.
- 37:37The unreliable category also puts you at an arm's length from
- 37:42most organized people because they don't like to deal with
- 37:46that. So much.
- 37:48Certainly secure people won't Cindy.
- 37:53Yeah I have a question. I think relates all this as
- 37:58you've been talking about the spectrum between dismissive and
- 38:03anti-social borderline preoccupied.
- 38:05I realized that I have a brother who is three years older than me
- 38:11and he seems to me extremely dismissive and all the things
- 38:17that you Lister like this is his Mo and I I'm on the other
- 38:22Spectrum. I'm preoccupied borderline and I
- 38:27threw my entire life and you know, he's what 71 through my
- 38:33entire life. I'm like, how do I ever Bridge a
- 38:38way to communicate with this person?
- 38:40It's always like Earth to Rich even as a child ever.
- 38:45Are you there? And he's just somewhere else and
- 38:48it's very painful for me. Me in that position to have
- 38:53somebody who's so out of tune with my, you know, emotional
- 38:58body. My, you know, everything that I
- 39:01express. He's just, where is he?
- 39:04But it can be very painful and I'm wondering what I just in
- 39:09that situation. Somebody who's preoccupied
- 39:12trying to just even have a brother-sister relationship?
- 39:16How would you do? I just work on myself and then
- 39:20all of a sudden I, it's Easier to tolerate his dismissiveness
- 39:24or do. I try to work with him and say
- 39:28you know Richard I've been telling you for 20 years, I
- 39:32don't drink alcohol. So why is it every time I come
- 39:35there you hand me y'all call and he's just like, won't get it and
- 39:40just tune into. I don't drink alcohol.
- 39:42He can do what he wants. That's just a basic example.
- 39:46Yeah. Well.
- 39:54One of the things particularly with relationships with siblings
- 40:01and family members is the, it's a long relationship and it's
- 40:08quite complex and the the working models began with a
- 40:17whole different set of experiences saying parents
- 40:23capacity, right? Right?
- 40:25But you were a child. You were younger than he.
- 40:28Yeah, three years younger. So he had a whole different
- 40:32range of experience. If you're so different in terms
- 40:35of your attachment, then the condition that he grew up in
- 40:39we're quite different than the conditions, you grew up in, I
- 40:42don't know why but we had the same parents same parent teen.
- 40:46Yeah. Well what are the things that
- 40:47can happen is that the demands that you come into the world
- 40:52with in terms of how you need to be?
- 40:54In care of, in the body that you are, sometimes fit into the
- 40:58capacities, of the parent sometimes, exceed the capacity
- 41:02of the parent. So the child whose needs fell
- 41:06within the range of what the parents could do, has a very
- 41:10different experience of their needs being met, most of the
- 41:13time for, as a child, whose needs exceeds what the parents
- 41:16could do, had the experience of their needs not being met very
- 41:20much of the time, which Great Lakes very different attachment.
- 41:24Outcome. Same household. you as a younger
- 41:30sibling had needs from an older sibling for care and from, for
- 41:37the mirroring and all sorts of other different things that may
- 41:41not have been satisfied at the very beginning and so it sets up
- 41:45an expectation with them that their relationship is going to
- 41:48be dissatisfying and it's very hard to let go of that early
- 41:54desire for a particular type of Experience with another family
- 42:00member. So part of it is to see them the
- 42:03way that they are, the way that you described him, doesn't sound
- 42:07like he's able to respond to you in the way that you need him to
- 42:12number. So part of that is to accept
- 42:14that. Not that you should have banned
- 42:18and getting those needs. Then, you know, Jon Bovi
- 42:22famously said. You're only as needy as your
- 42:25unmet needs of people think that you're needy.
- 42:29It's because you have a lot of unmet needs.
- 42:31And the idea is not to, to squash the neediness.
- 42:35The idea is to get somebody else to meet their needs because the
- 42:40person that you're asking to meet them because they have the
- 42:43capacity to meet them. And it is to really see the them
- 42:46clearly and to see what possibilities exist in the
- 42:51relationship with them and then take those possibilities and
- 42:55enjoy them and take the needs that they're incapable of
- 43:00meeting and get somebody else to meet them.
- 43:03So that you're not needy in the sense that you have a lot of
- 43:06unmet needs now, when the ideal. Yeah, so the situation is often
- 43:12that we, this is the rigidity of this.
- 43:17We want the person that we wanted to meet our needs to meet
- 43:22them even if we we can see fairly clearly, they can't do
- 43:26it. Yeah, I see that.
- 43:28There's no way you can do it and I'm still wanting it after all
- 43:33these years. So you have to give up on them.
- 43:37That's what I like to say. Let's turn on offense.
- 43:39It's just emotionally. I feel so connected and I want
- 43:43to love him and I do love him, but I feel no connection.
- 43:46Action with him. So it's like, how do you love
- 43:49your brother? When your needs aren't being met
- 43:52even at a basic level? Well you take the need those
- 43:56needs and give them to other people to meet as it is.
- 44:02No I don't mean that. I mean love him.
- 44:05The way that he is with what he has to offer so that when you go
- 44:11and you walk in the door and he offers you a drink you put your
- 44:15arm around him and say oh but I've been telling you for 20
- 44:18years, I don't drink. If you're someone else again
- 44:25it's only his world. Whatever works in his role he
- 44:28thinks is what he has to offer me, right?
- 44:31Because he doesn't have any way out of that.
- 44:34It's not he's not what where we really get into trouble is when
- 44:40we think that they have the capacity to do what we want, and
- 44:45they're withholding it from us, for some reason, right.
- 44:49But he doesn't have the capacity.
- 44:51So I'm looking for teaching moments, like, he doesn't have
- 44:55it, he can't give it to you. Is that withholding it from you?
- 44:58He doesn't have it to give. So I shouldn't even try and
- 45:01teach him and write him an email and say in the future, when I
- 45:04come to visit, could you remember that?
- 45:07I don't drink. Angkor.
- 45:09No. Yeah, that wouldn't work.
- 45:13Well that would be the set up for disappointment when he
- 45:17doesn't remember when you come. So it's just in the moment and
- 45:22that's as far as it'll go. Yeah.
- 45:25So You know, one of the things about the remarkable thing about
- 45:34seeing people, the way that they are it off that it's, you do
- 45:40take it personally. Yeah.
- 45:43And I take a lot, firstly. I'm so, and put the liquid all
- 45:46those things about preoccupies. I've got, I'm totally that, I
- 45:50guess, I'm borderline, Maybe. As constructs go.
- 45:59But, you know there's also a way out of it mentalizing is one of
- 46:02the pieces learning to emotionally, regulate developing
- 46:06the skill set that you need. So spontaneous very spontaneous
- 46:11but not too much not enough monitoring.
- 46:13So you're tightening up the mind, so you're continuously
- 46:16monitoring. Each time you notice that you
- 46:18get preoccupied and locked into the experience, over the person
- 46:22you bring your attention. Turn back to your own emotions
- 46:25and experience them private as the primary place.
- 46:34The, you can't that the same with the internal external.
- 46:38You constantly bring yourself back into your own experience,
- 46:42and anchor in your own experience.
- 46:45You don't anchor in the experience of the other person
- 46:50and you begin to, to monitor your thinking, We do that, we do
- 46:55that through the investigating self-generated emotion, stopping
- 46:58afflictive, self-generated emotion, and economizing, the
- 47:03pool poison in pain. So with that be when they're
- 47:06self-generated emotions that are overwhelming.
- 47:08Uncomfortable unwanted extremely fearful, then I would go to
- 47:12mentalizing and recognize that that's what's happening.
- 47:17Then suppress those thoughts and replace them with something
- 47:21beneficial because the the emotions Are coming from the
- 47:25mental mentalizing, right? The emotions are coming from the
- 47:29self-generated emotion. And so you want to monitor
- 47:32whether it's a useful strategy or not.
- 47:34It's not useful. You want to suppress it and
- 47:37replace it. You can't just stop.
- 47:39That's one of the things. I'm just going to stop using
- 47:42these bad habits. You can't do that at they're
- 47:44regulating habits. You have to offer a different
- 47:48strategy for regulation, or the body mind will regulate itself,
- 47:52using the tools that are installed.
- 47:53That's one of the Why all this stuff is so resilient, you're
- 47:56getting something out of it. That's vital.
- 48:00It may be unskillful but you're still getting something vital
- 48:04out of it. So you have to suppress the
- 48:08afflictive strategy and replace it with a beneficial strategy,
- 48:12you have to develop the capacity for beneficial strategies so
- 48:16that they're effective because if are not, the mind will toss
- 48:20them and go back to the old habit because you cannot not you
- 48:24late, you only have some agency and how you do it.
- 48:28Okay, that makes sense. And that's why we do ipf.
- 48:31Right ipf is really about embedding the database with
- 48:36different choices. It turns out that the body-mind
- 48:39does not care, whether you can imagine it or whether it's
- 48:43actually based on experience, right?
- 48:45In order to form a response now. You may think that these
- 48:51visualized ideal situations that we work at developing our
- 48:55rickety structure to hang a life on and you would be right about
- 49:01that but that's not really understanding.
- 49:07What happens over time you develop these imagined responses
- 49:13that were not what actually happened but when the body mind
- 49:17uses those as the basis of Linked to the situation in the
- 49:21present moment and it unfolds in a more secure way than what
- 49:24you're remembering is something actual that happened and as time
- 49:29goes on and you do that more and more often the database of
- 49:33actually experienced secure responses to situations gets
- 49:38richer and richer to the point that you're no longer relying.
- 49:41On the visualize scaffolding, you're relying on this very
- 49:46robust database of since that actually did happen, not making
- 49:52sense. So you move from the visualized
- 49:57experience to something. That's really robust and dynamic
- 50:02that that was possible because of that initial framework, Like
- 50:11a Seed, Pearl and an oyster. Yeah, that's helpful.
- 50:20Why don't we do is add a little bit of practice some metaphor
- 50:24self and then we should continue talking about metalloids and I
- 50:30think some of it really becomes clear that what mentalizing
- 50:34idolizing and its relationship to emotional regulation, will
- 50:37continue to talk about this, so it really makes sense.
- 50:43But go ahead and take your meditation posture.
- 50:51How that go? Good enough.
- 50:58As usual, my mind got distracted a lot.
- 51:01And I just came back to the feels like a mantra to me.
- 51:07Yeah, be peaceful good and I don't know if I'm looking for
- 51:13feeling tones, you know, noting is that part of what we're doing
- 51:18when we're just repeating? This may I be peaceful.
- 51:22No, not really in the body at all really up sort of in visual
- 51:26experience. Looking for the view.
- 51:30So we're actually looking for a review of peaceful mind
- 51:34loving-kindness, okay? Yeah, I felt kind of neutral.
- 51:43The said, you know, we all use these hybrids to try and
- 51:49describe what meta mind is because we don't have a word for
- 51:51it. We that means any means to
- 51:54thing. Kindness.
- 51:59And then loving is usually meaning the inclining toward But
- 52:08then, a lot of people have a lot of heat associated with love.
- 52:11A lot of craving associated with it and so, that would not be it.
- 52:15It's without, it's cool. That's what he always cool.
- 52:21Always kind, but inclining towards something.
- 52:25It's not balanced. It's not equanimous.
- 52:30And then noticing how the world appears to you, how you appear
- 52:34in the world when you hold that view as opposed to a different
- 52:37View. So I didn't really The View that
- 52:44I understood views through was the view of anger.
- 52:49As I was angry, a lot of the time and I could see how
- 52:52distorting it was and I could recognize the pattern of
- 52:55distortion and once I figured out, oh, the mind is distorted
- 53:00because this view is there. I could then look for other
- 53:03views. And that's what actually begin
- 53:09to happen. And then recognizing that
- 53:13particular View. And causing it to rise and being
- 53:18able to sustain it, that's the idea.
- 53:19So that you have the begin to develop the agency.
- 53:23To control the view that your mind is holding.
- 53:27Which is extremely useful. So good.
- 53:36Christian. I was, I guess bringing my body
- 53:42into the practice in the sense that like I have a lot of back
- 53:47pain and I would, I had the meta mind and then I would kind of
- 53:52bring up the I would allow the pain into awareness.
- 53:57So I think having them out of mind seemed to allow more
- 54:01sensation into awareness and it kind of had a more none.
- 54:04It had a more allowing or non-judgmental quality to it
- 54:07where I could good. So it seemed effective in that
- 54:11way. Yeah, I would agree.
- 54:13It is Jake. so, In this tomorrow, they represent thing
- 54:24with you say that the method of agency that you're putting forth
- 54:29is thick like you said that capacity to control and regulate
- 54:34your view in that some kind of subject you're using principal
- 54:38agency? Yeah.
- 54:45Okay, just checking you lost your view here.
- 54:50There it is. I was looking for.
- 54:56I wasn't sure of myself. I was looking for.
- 55:06Oh good, thank you. I think this is like the best
- 55:10class. Okay.
- 55:18Flattery will get you everywhere.
- 55:27All right. So we have some stuff coming up.
- 55:32It's getting toward the end of the year.
- 55:35I'm going to take the week off between Christmas and New Year's
- 55:38so there won't be this class then.
- 55:45And really, we're not going to start anything else for the rest
- 55:47of the year. So, but next year, see here.
- 55:59On the 7th of January we're starting know.
- 56:02Is that right? Yeah that's right.
- 56:04A level one and we've changed the format of level 1 to 4 half
- 56:11days rather than three day Long's.
- 56:13So for Saturday's 9 a.m. until 1:15 of.
- 56:18We're going to present the level one in a slightly more compact
- 56:26format. and then, Starting on February, 4th.
- 56:39We're going to do a level one class.
- 56:44Set right for EU. All this.
- 57:04I don't know, they're not labeled quite right.
- 57:06We're going to do a level one. U.s. that a level one for Europe
- 57:10and then another level one, we're going to start a level 2.
- 57:20Sorry, I'm a little discombobulated. if you are a 9
- 57:25on February 9th, Then we're going to I'm we're thinking
- 57:36about doing a retreat as you might have heard earlier in the
- 57:39spring in June I'm doing a retreat in Utrecht which is in
- 57:44the Netherlands and then that's the basically the first half of
- 57:51the year. So that's the stuff that's
- 57:53coming up. Take a look at it, it's on the
- 57:55website. Iowa for the teaching freely but
- 58:00it is offered at a databases' down as the Pali word for
- 58:03generosity. So we do hope that you'll make a
- 58:05donation. If you can, any amount is
- 58:08appreciated and help support me. And also the work that met a
- 58:11group is doing. We really appreciate it.
- 58:14Thank you for coming. I hope to see you soon somewhere
- 58:18on the path. Bye.
- 58:22I've questioned February 9th. The one is that just evenings
- 58:29the level two. I think it's 4:30 to 6:30 for
- 58:363634 ongoing for six months or something every other week for 6
- 58:40months. Yeah.
- 58:43Every other week for six months, okay, and I went on your website
- 58:49to look for a PDF practitioner. You said to look there, Martin's
- 58:57not available. All right, so I tried to
- 59:02contact, I think the third one down, he lives in Santa Cruz.
- 59:05He's from Europe stas. Yeah, and he didn't email me
- 59:10back and so I wondered is Still active or he is I might email
- 59:16them again. Let him know that I was looking
- 59:20because, okay, I thought it gave me his email and I just emailed
- 59:26him, right? Yeah I think so.
- 59:29Okay well and since he's in Santa Cruz, I'm right nearby.
- 59:32So that would be a nice connection.
- 59:34Yeah. That would be easy.
- 59:36Okay. All right.
- 59:37I'll also email him again. All right.
- 59:40Yeah. And hash soccer, like a bird up
- 59:46in a wildfire It's not there anymore.
- 59:51That's that I have good memories of definitely.
- 59:53Yeah me too. Thank you.
- 59:59Bye.