Latest / The Film Hobbyist / Rachel Getting Married (2008): Obscured in Naturalism
Transcript
- 0:12in and spend some time with the film hobbyist.
- 0:15My name is Lydia, and I love movies. We're here
- 0:32in my attic room. You're sitting on a forest
- 0:36green Walmart futon with a black metal frame.
- 0:40I'm in an old desk chair with cracks in the pleather
- 0:43lining. On the floor next to us are piles of
- 0:48fabric scraps and various sewing accoutrements.
- 0:51I apologize for the mess. My daughter just started
- 0:55sewing lessons, and she's been inspired. Sewing
- 0:59and clothing design have been hobbies of hers
- 1:01for years, and I've taught her about everything
- 1:04I know. It was time to get a professional involved.
- 1:08We've actually been planning this for months,
- 1:11but we had to wait for several factors to align.
- 1:14On our part, we had to wait for the end of school
- 1:17year activities to make sure we had the time
- 1:20to devote to this. On her teacher's part, we
- 1:24had to wait for wedding season. At first that
- 1:28might seem counterintuitive, for wedding season
- 1:31to be a break for a seamstress who makes wedding
- 1:34dresses. But it makes more sense when you sit
- 1:38with it. The work needs to be done before the
- 1:41travelling and the set -up and the wedding day.
- 1:45So she's only now free for lessons. Weddings
- 1:50are fairly unique events in the broader American
- 1:53culture. We don't have many universal celebrations
- 1:56of milestones outside of smaller religious or
- 2:01cultural distinctions. We don't have an American
- 2:04celebration of births or age milestones. There's
- 2:09kind of a thing around sweet 16, but not really.
- 2:13There's a little bit of fuss around high school
- 2:16graduations, but only grandparents would travel
- 2:19across country for that. As far as events where
- 2:23a whole family or community gather for ritual,
- 2:27again, outside of particular smaller religious
- 2:30or cultural distinctions, It's weddings and funerals.
- 2:36I'm not even talking about the actual events
- 2:39themselves, not the wedding ceremony and reception,
- 2:43not the funeral service, but the gathering before
- 2:46that, the family and friends packed into several
- 2:50houses or a hotel, running errands, filling time,
- 2:55working together to make centerpieces or table
- 2:58cards, decorating the event space. There are
- 3:02formal meals and speeches, and informal ones
- 3:06on the floor or packed in a corner. In a funeral,
- 3:11there's a shroud of sadness that comes in waves,
- 3:15and joy bursts through anyway in the pockets,
- 3:18in the time together. With a wedding, it's the
- 3:22opposite. There's a fervent atmosphere of desired
- 3:26happiness and excitement, an expectation of positivity.
- 3:32And if you are the person carrying pain or anger
- 3:35or tension or frustration, which is always there
- 3:38at the corner of a stressful emotional event,
- 3:41the amount of repression that is expected of
- 3:45you can be quite high. In most films, this is
- 3:50the source of high melodrama or absurd comedy,
- 3:54perhaps some sweet sentimentalism. Father of
- 3:58the Bride All versions center this in the comedic
- 4:02expense of everything, a father watching his
- 4:05money walk out the door. Steel Magnolias focuses
- 4:10some on the wedding's setup, but mostly on the
- 4:13single piece of getting hair done before the
- 4:16ceremony, spending time with the mother of the
- 4:19bride's friends. Romantic comedies tend to focus
- 4:24on relationships between the members of the wedding
- 4:27parties, frequently who the best man or maid
- 4:30of honor sleeps with. But there aren't many films
- 4:34that capture the long trajectory of the days
- 4:37before, of the boredom and the final plans and
- 4:42the errands and the rising tension quite like
- 4:452008's Rachel Getting Married, directed by Jonathan
- 4:49Demme. You probably haven't heard of this movie.
- 4:54That's okay. It's a small independent film that
- 4:58made an awards splash, mostly in nominations
- 5:01for the movie, but especially for lead actress
- 5:05Anne Hathaway. Up until this point, she was mostly
- 5:09known for being a pretty face in chick flicks.
- 5:12I think her comedy skills in The Princess Diaries
- 5:15are underrated, but you have to admit that she's
- 5:19the least showy performer of the Devil Wears
- 5:22Prada cast. She had a well -buzzed -about supporting
- 5:25role in Brokeback Mountain, but it was an outlier
- 5:29definitely overshadowed by the rest of the conversation
- 5:32about that film. Rachel Getting Married is the
- 5:37movie where the film criticism community realized
- 5:40that Anne Hathaway really could act by playing
- 5:44a character who is spiny and prickly and a mess
- 5:49rather than the polished, charming brunettes
- 5:52she usually played. Her protagonist Kim is no
- 5:57princess. Physically, Yeah, she's Anne Hathaway
- 6:01in a messy haircut and smeared makeup, but character
- 6:05-wise, she is a deeply complex individual, responding
- 6:09to real past traumas with an abrasive, hot mess,
- 6:14always -say -the -wrong -thing chattiness, and
- 6:17her performance completely deserves all the attention
- 6:20it got. There's a version of this story that
- 6:24is an intense wedding -themed melodrama, all
- 6:28of the deep secrets in clear exposition, plot
- 6:32twists revealed on a dime, with a swell of music
- 6:35and dramatic camera moves. But this movie is
- 6:39something else, an incredibly grounded, complex
- 6:43portrait of family dysfunction, where the ones
- 6:47we love and enjoy time with have caused the most
- 6:50pain. What really struck me the first time I
- 6:54watched it is how the film reveals the layers
- 6:58of trauma naturally, as we just experience each
- 7:02day leading up to the wedding. Plot twists only
- 7:05because of reverse dramatic irony, where we are
- 7:09learning what the characters already know as
- 7:12they navigate the complicated steps of wedding
- 7:14ritual. Gathering, rehearsal dinner, wedding
- 7:18setup, wedding day. The second time I watched
- 7:23it, the real surprise was how the plot twists,
- 7:26how these reveals, all sat out in plain sight,
- 7:31discussed far before the audience even knows
- 7:34what is being talked about, hidden in all the
- 7:37ordinary. Rachel Getting Married tells the story
- 7:42of Kim, a young woman in recovery from many years
- 7:46of abusing drugs and alcohol. She's been sober
- 7:49for nine months, largely because she's been in
- 7:53rehab. We meet her just as she is released temporarily
- 7:56for her sister Rachel's wedding. Kim has a history.
- 8:02With something like a decade of struggle with
- 8:04addiction, it would be hard for that not to be
- 8:08the case. And that history is complicated. There's
- 8:13deep tragedy here. And there's also the fallout
- 8:16from a collection of bad decisions. Kim is very
- 8:21unlikable. She's full of insults and justifications
- 8:25and is a bit attention -seeking. But she also
- 8:29earns our pity. She's frequently putting her
- 8:32foot in her mouth, saying the wrong thing at
- 8:35the wrong time, trying to be familiar in situations
- 8:39where she ought to be formal, abrasive when she
- 8:43ought to be soft. There aren't easy explanations
- 8:47here either. We never learn when or why she started
- 8:51using. We don't learn the veracity or timeline
- 8:55of other events in the family. But what makes
- 9:00this story so amazing is that open -endedness
- 9:03that lets the audience fill in the blanks, a
- 9:08lot of which comes from the style of filmmaking.
- 9:11This film feels like a fictional documentary.
- 9:16Director Jonathan Demme had a fairly good documentarian
- 9:20filmography, especially music and concert documentaries,
- 9:25and all of that style of filming and editing
- 9:28really plays a huge role in what makes this film
- 9:32special. A good deal of the camera work is handheld
- 9:36digital photography, which now leaves many sequences
- 9:41with slight pixelation, really locking it in
- 9:45time and place. Demi didn't set up shots beforehand,
- 9:49really trusting his camera operators to find
- 9:53interesting angles in each scene to communicate
- 9:56the story. In the story, Kim's father and Rachel's
- 10:01fiancé are in the music business, so there are
- 10:04just musicians everywhere, playing music. It's
- 10:09always in the next room over, or just outside.
- 10:13All of the music was improvised. It's the only
- 10:16soundtrack of the film. Music downstairs while
- 10:20we talk in bedrooms. Music outside while we're
- 10:23in the kitchen. Music performances at the rehearsal
- 10:27dinner and wedding itself. The sound production
- 10:31of this film is amazing, capturing all the music
- 10:34live, which contributes to the naturalistic atmosphere.
- 10:39I don't know to what extent the dialogue was
- 10:43improvised. It's possible most of it wasn't,
- 10:48but... It wouldn't surprise me if the majority
- 10:50of the scenes had a loose outline and the actors
- 10:54were just allowed to riff. At least, that's how
- 10:57this movie feels. Which is, again, it's genius.
- 11:01The ambience hides the very clear plot twists
- 11:05and reveals. I don't want to spoil too much,
- 11:10because that journey of discovery really is the
- 11:13engine of this piece. Yeah, the atmosphere is
- 11:17cool. And yeah, Anne Hathaway's performance is
- 11:21completely transformative. And yeah, there might
- 11:26be some cultural commentary and satire. But the
- 11:30fact that this wedding is South Asian themed,
- 11:33when the bride's family is white, possibly ethnically
- 11:38Jewish, judged by how often they toast L 'chaim,
- 11:41and the groom's family is African American. I
- 11:45guess. But the real fuel here is these character
- 11:50reveals. I will illustrate just a small twist
- 11:55to prove my point. Pretty soon after arriving
- 12:00at their rural Connecticut house, Kim needs to
- 12:05go somewhere for a mandatory drug test and a
- 12:0812 -step meeting. Her dad won't lend her the
- 12:11car, so she ends up riding a bicycle. She bursts
- 12:15into the office, running late, and we watch her
- 12:18pee in a cup, turn it in, and then race over
- 12:22to the complex's other building to try and catch
- 12:25the meeting. She bursts in awkwardly as the guy
- 12:28talking mentions he lives in Hawaii, knocking
- 12:31over a pile of chairs. He finishes his introduction,
- 12:35and the meeting goes on to the next one. we get
- 12:39a montage of the meeting. Introductions, testimonies,
- 12:43encouragements, a piece of a story here, a piece
- 12:47of another there, a collage of the consequences
- 12:51of addiction and the long journey of recovery.
- 12:55The purpose of this sequence is for the viewer
- 12:59to see Kim in an authentic environment with people
- 13:03who have no history with her. She might say to
- 13:07her family that she's in recovery and she's improving,
- 13:10but they've shown skepticism and doubt. And even
- 13:15at this early point in the movie, we don't know
- 13:18who to believe. But she's genuinely listening
- 13:21to the stories here and caring about the circumstances.
- 13:26And when she recites the serenity prayer, we
- 13:29can tell she says it with sincerity. As an audience,
- 13:35This purpose is satisfying from a storytelling,
- 13:40character study point of view. What we don't
- 13:44know, because Kim already knows, so there's no
- 13:47reason to say it out loud, is that Rachel's fiancé
- 13:50lives in Hawaii. So when Kim walks her bicycle
- 13:54back up the driveway toward her family's house
- 13:56and sees the first speaker at the 12 -step meeting,
- 14:00it's a surprise that he's the best man. Kim didn't
- 14:05know. And so both of them get this special connection
- 14:09with being addicts in recovery. And he, as someone
- 14:15who understands, can speak up for her later in
- 14:18the film, an outsider to the family who understands
- 14:22the difficulty of returning home with substantial
- 14:25baggage. And again, this reveal is right out
- 14:30in the open. He's the first guy we see at the
- 14:33meeting, but we're busy following Kim as she
- 14:37crashes into a pile of chairs, so the details
- 14:40of him being from out of town don't really stand
- 14:43out. His important plot point introduction is
- 14:47lost in the shuffle of other people's shared
- 14:49experiences. Because of how ordinary it all is,
- 14:53how documentarian and naturalistic the storytelling,
- 14:57we don't clock this as important. So when it
- 15:01is, the surprise is that much greater. The more
- 15:05I've thought about this film, the more I've realized
- 15:08that the manner of the storytelling really does
- 15:11change the experience of the story. This plot
- 15:16could have been filmed as an incredibly melodramatic
- 15:20family drama, or maybe a dramedy. Like, I can
- 15:25imagine Kim stumbling into the chairs with a
- 15:28bunch of reaction shots from the rest of the
- 15:3012 -step meeting, making it as awkward as possible,
- 15:33drawing attention to the man speaking as he says
- 15:36something like, I've just come in from out of
- 15:39town, where this scene almost becomes a meet
- 15:43-cute. And in that case, you wouldn't need to
- 15:46hear much from the meeting, because the scene
- 15:49would be about a possible romance, not about
- 15:52Kim's sincerity. And then when she came home,
- 15:55maybe he would open the door, and they would
- 15:58be like, oh, it's you! And someone would notice
- 16:02and say, oh, you two know each other? And then
- 16:05they would laugh, which would make the next scene
- 16:08of them having sex in the basement much more
- 16:11flirty and fun, rather than a further example
- 16:15of how, for all her sincerity, Kim really is
- 16:19unreliable and full of poor judgment. In this
- 16:23other hypothetical film, Kim would be more edgy
- 16:27and less awkward, kind of like a Diablo Cody
- 16:32protagonist, rather than the spiny, volatile,
- 16:36impulsive force she actually is. But this isn't
- 16:40a glossy, melodramatic piece. It's echoey and
- 16:45inefficient. Scenes go on for way longer than
- 16:49they would in other films. There's a long rehearsal
- 16:53dinner sequence where there's a concert with
- 16:56multiple acts we see throughout the film, and
- 17:00a number of speeches from various family members
- 17:02and attendees. It drags. And so we learn not
- 17:08to get in a fuss over whether this enhances the
- 17:11plot, but realize the story it is telling, the
- 17:15way it shows this collection of family and friends,
- 17:18the cultural mix of backgrounds and histories,
- 17:22the moments that most move Kim, and the ones
- 17:25that make Rachel sparkle. Jonathan Demme and
- 17:29cinematographer Declan Quinn told an interviewer
- 17:32that they wanted this to feel like the most beautiful
- 17:35home movie ever made, and I really think they
- 17:39captured that atmosphere. What makes this film
- 17:42different from other artsy, naturalistic kinds
- 17:46of pieces is that there really are genuine plot
- 17:50points here, where the story as you initially
- 17:54assume, is pulled away layer by layer until you
- 17:59actually understand these people, what happened
- 18:03to them, and how they got here. There is genuine
- 18:07catharsis and hope at the end of this film, all
- 18:10with the open -ended ambiguity promised by its
- 18:14storytelling style and main character. Why tell
- 18:18the story this way, though? Why turn this into
- 18:22a faux home movie? What does filming a wedding
- 18:25scene in real time really accomplish in the end?
- 18:30An American wedding comes with a particular kind
- 18:34of cultural expectation. Weddings carry with
- 18:38them an atmosphere of desired happiness and excitement,
- 18:42an expectation of positivity. If you have any
- 18:47pain or anger or tension or frustration, always
- 18:51there at the corner of a stressful emotional
- 18:53event, you're expected to repress it, to shove
- 18:58it down and keep everything happy. But what if
- 19:02you can't repress it? What if you are a walking,
- 19:07ragged figure of anger and tension and impulsive
- 19:11negativity? What if you have a history of bad
- 19:16choices with horrible consequences that everyone
- 19:19in the room knows about? How can you be filled
- 19:24with positivity? In a sleek melodrama, by virtue
- 19:30of the filmmaking style, there's already a lot
- 19:34we can tell about the characters and the story
- 19:37they're living in. The film tells us where there's
- 19:41a good guy and a bad one. Who's the romantic
- 19:44interest and who's the enemy? Who was in the
- 19:47right and who was in the wrong? Normal exposition
- 19:51means we can pick up pretty quickly how awful
- 19:54the backstory is, often because it's just told
- 19:58to us. Because of how the naturalistic filmmaking
- 20:02obscures all these details, Kim is actually given
- 20:07the opportunity of a clean slate. The audience
- 20:11doesn't know who she is or her bad choices or
- 20:14their consequences. It's pretty clear pretty
- 20:18quickly that she's not a good person, but we
- 20:21are given the opportunity to see a person who
- 20:24might actually be trying to be a better person.
- 20:30In naturalism, we are able to see her attempt
- 20:34to fit in and begin to pity her for her flaws
- 20:37and pain. We can root for her to not make bad
- 20:41choices. We can have the space to examine our
- 20:46own feelings toward her as the story unfolds.
- 20:49We can notice her there in the background at
- 20:53the wedding, really trying hard to let the story
- 20:56be about Rachel getting married rather than her
- 20:59own baggage. And in that grace, we can quietly
- 21:04reflect on our own pains. and rifts, and what
- 21:10it might take to find joy again. Thanks for coming.