Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When You Were Hired During a Talent War
Transcript
- Lucas: So you got hired two years ago, during the peak of the talent war, when companies were throwing money at anyone with a pulse. You negotiated hard, got a great base salary, and maybe a sign-on bonus. Fast forward to August 2026, the market's cooled, your company's hiring freeze is real, and you're pretty sure you're now making more than most of your peers. How on earth do you ask for a raise without sounding like you've lost the plot? Luna: That's such a good question. I feel like everyone's been in that position where you're like, 'I know I'm paid well, but I still want more.' It feels greedy. Lucas: Exactly. And the standard advice — 'just go get a competing offer' — doesn't really work when the market has softened. You can't exactly walk into your manager's office and say, 'Hey, I've got another offer for 20 percent more.' Because in this climate, that offer might not exist. Luna: So what do you do? Do you just accept that you're topped out? Lucas: No, not at all. You shift the conversation. Instead of anchoring on market data, you anchor on the value you're creating and the scope you're carrying. Here's the thing: your manager knows you're paid above market. They approved that package. But what they don't want to hear is that you're looking around. They want to hear that you're delivering. Luna: Right, so it's more about the deliverables than the comp. Lucas: Precisely. Let me give you a concrete example. I spoke with a product manager at a mid-sized tech company a few months back. She was hired in early 2024, right when AI talent was at a premium. She got a base salary that was probably 15 percent above the band for her level, plus a $30,000 sign-on bonus paid over two years. Now the bonus has run out, and the market has cooled. Luna: So she's essentially taking a pay cut if you count the bonus. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a legitimate opening. She went to her manager and said, 'Look, my sign-on bonus is gone, and my responsibilities have grown significantly since I joined. I'm now leading a team of three, and I own the roadmap for a product line that's generating 12 million in annual revenue.' Luna: That's a solid case. But how did she handle the 'but you're already paid well' pushback? Lucas: She didn't wait for pushback. She proactively said, 'I know my base is above market for my level, but I'm not asking for a market adjustment. I'm asking for a recognition of scope. My role has changed since I was hired.' And that's the key move — you redefine the job, not the salary. Luna: So instead of saying 'I'm underpaid,' you say 'I'm doing more than what I was hired for.' Lucas: Exactly. And that reframing makes it much harder for the company to say no, because if they refuse to adjust your comp, they're implicitly saying 'your expanded responsibilities aren't worth anything.' Which is a pretty bad look. Luna: So what did she end up getting? A raise? Lucas: She got a title change — from product manager to senior product manager — and a 10 percent base salary increase. Not as much as the 15 percent she wanted, but she also negotiated a one-time retention bonus of $15,000 to cover the gap from her expired sign-on. That's another strategy: if the base salary budget is tight, ask for a bonus. Companies often have more flexibility with one-time payments than with permanent salary bumps. Luna: That's smart. And I guess the timing matters too. You don't want to ask right when the company is announcing layoffs or budget cuts. Lucas: Right. Timing is huge. If you're in a company that just announced a hiring freeze, that might actually be a good time, because they're trying to retain the people they have. But if they just went through a round of layoffs, you probably want to wait a quarter. You don't want to look tone-deaf. Luna: And what about when you're going into the annual review cycle? Is that the best time to bring it up? Lucas: Actually, I'd say no. Annual reviews are often tied to a budget that's already been set. If you come in with a 'hey, I want a raise' expectation, you might get a 'we've already allocated the pool.' Better to start the conversation three to four months before the review cycle, so your manager has time to advocate for you. That way, when the budget is being planned, you're already on the radar. Luna: But what if your manager is the type who says 'I can't do anything until the annual review'? Then what? Lucas: You say, 'I appreciate that, and I'm not asking you to break policy. But I want to work with you on building a case for the next cycle. What would you need to see from me between now and then to make that happen?' That turns your manager into an advocate instead of a gatekeeper. And it gives you a clear list of goals to hit. Luna: That's a great approach. I also think there's something to be said about the psychology of being the 'expensive hire.' Like, do you worry that your manager might think 'well, we're already paying you a lot, so you should be grateful'? Lucas: Absolutely, and that's a real risk. That's why you need to be even more on your game in terms of documenting your wins. Keep a brag list — a running log of projects you've led, metrics you've moved, and feedback you've received. When you go into that conversation, you're not just saying 'I think I deserve a raise,' you're showing evidence. And if you sense that 'grateful' attitude, you can gently push back by saying, 'I am grateful for the opportunity, and I want to keep delivering at this level. But I also want to make sure my compensation reflects the value I'm bringing, so I can keep doing this work without distraction.' Luna: That's a nice way to frame it. But let's be real — what if the company just says 'no'? Do you have any leverage at all in this market? Lucas: You do, but it's not the same leverage as before. It's not 'I have a competing offer.' It's 'I have deep knowledge of this business, and if I leave, it's going to cost you time and money to replace me.' That's still a form of leverage, but you have to be subtle about it. You don't want to threaten to leave unless you're actually prepared to leave. And in this market, the safer play is to focus on what you can control — your performance, your visibility, and your relationship with your manager. Luna: So what's the takeaway for someone listening who's in this exact situation? Lucas: The takeaway is this: don't assume that being above market means you have no case. It just means you have to make a different case. Lead with your contributions, redefine your role, and think beyond base salary — bonuses, title, flexibility, even a pledge to revisit in six months. The worst thing you can do is stay silent and let your comp stagnate while your responsibilities grow. Luna: And if you're a manager listening, what should you do when someone brings you this kind of request? Lucas: Listen with an open mind. Don't default to 'you're already paid well.' Ask yourself if their scope really has changed. And if you can't do a base salary increase, offer a bonus or a title change. Don't let a good employee walk because you couldn't find a creative solution. And remember, if you're in a talent war, retention is just as important as acquisition.