Latest / Common Practice Show / Ep. 1 — Jana Vanaman: What Recruiting Gets Wrong
Transcript
- speaker-0: All right, this is the common practice podcast with Justin Vosquez. I am incredibly lucky to have my first guest ever. She ran global recruiting at Gartner for a decade, left to do her own thing. She went back in house and man, she has opinions about all of it. Janna, thank you so much for being with me today. speaker-1: I'm happy to be here, Justin, and and bring my opinions front and center. speaker-0: Yes, please. That's what this show's about. So yeah, before we kinda dive too deep, just explain to people what your background is and why you are the expert and what we're gonna talk about today. speaker-1: Absolutely. So my my background is in HR and talent acquisition through and through. I started my career actually on the retail side in the retail industry at ⁓ Target and where I led human resources for multiple stores and multi-site locations. That's really where I got my taste. Of recruiting and talent acquisition because we were hiring so much all the time and building teams and started doing campus recruiting. It was so much fun. And then I had the opportunity to go into Gartner and join Gartner. I was there for, like you said, almost 11 years and led started as a recruiter, grew into leadership, ended up leading global. recruiting teams supporting various functions across finance client services, sales, which is so fun, and HR. And from there, like, you know, I I decided, all right, you know, this after a decade with Gartner and all the all these great accomplishments and and and impact I was able to have, I decided it was time to to spin off and do my own thing. So I started Vannaman Talent Solutions at the beginning of 2026. I had consulting engagements. I was helping hiring with with different clients that I and and people that I had connected with over the years. And then made an acquaintance with double talent solutions. I ran into them across the market. We had a very similar mission and and charter in terms of what we were doing. And I decided it would it's Better together. And so combined efforts essentially joined the firm. And now I lead a function of executive recruiting for W Talent Solutions, which were a national boutique executive search and ⁓ hiring placement and HR consultancy firm. speaker-0: Awesome. Yeah. I mean, you've been kind of everywhere. Started at Target. I mean, be full transparency. It's kind of how we met and know each other a little bit from the Target days when you worked with my wife and you guys were in HR together. And it's just one of those opportunities where to brag on South Florida a little bit, where I just remember your leadership you had in South Florida for the HR program was just absolutely amazing. And it's kind of where you guys have all kind of segueed through, you know, and with you The biggest thing is when you went from Target to Gartner, what was really your major catalyst of getting out of the cushy world of retail HR? I'll phrase it that way, right? Versus getting into Gartner starting from the bottom again compared to where you were, to working your way up to independent practice. So kind of walk me through what that journey was like and what you've learned through that process. speaker-1: Absolutely. I mean, retail is its own beast. I love I love retail. I'm still in a Target store probably every week. But at the time, I mean, and this was, you know, circa 2014, I had two young kids and the you know, while I was leading HR yeah at Target. It was still it was still re retail. So, you know, we were there when our guests were there. So that meant sometimes nights, weekends, holidays. And so my motivation was to be able to be present for for them. And fun fact, my husband, he worked at Target at that time as well. Our time there overlapped. And so it just wasn't going to be sustainable to have both of us kind of working these different flexible schedules, if you will. And so I had there was somebody within my network. I'm all about networking. And they mentioned Gartner. And I had heard of it, but I didn't really know what they did. And there was an opportunity to to move into recruiting there, which is something that I like I shared. I love the recruiting element. And so it was worth it to me to take a step back. And even at the time, it was, it was so, it was all about the schedule. It was all about my family first. And I wasn't thinking, I'm gonna be a leader here. I'm gonna rise to the top. I just thought of put my family first, myself second, and master the role. And so that's what I that's what I did is just focus on being the best I could possibly be. And and that ambition and opportunity, I should say, just came organically through through that drive. speaker-0: Awesome. And walk me through. I mean, I've I mean, 41 years old. I've been through multiple companies. Look at my resume. If you were to look at my resume, you would throw it right in the garbage can, right? And I and I sh and I share that just because I've never had the opportunity personally to be with a company where growth inside of it fostered the longevity that you've seen with Gartner, right? Almost 11 years and you started from the bottom, now you're her, right? That that type of phrase. But it's walk us through. You know, with Gartner, with you committing the eleven years and how that growth transition worked, was it fair growth? Are you starting to see that again in industries where you can start at the bottom and work your way up through the leadership if that is the path you want to take? speaker-1: Yes, I I would say that it ex it still exists there. So my specific experience, if you will, and I I do have to brag on Gartner, they are really big about growing from within. They really promote internal mobility and they don't just promote it. They they they follow through. It's it's part of their culture. ⁓ I would say in the 90 plus percentile of leaders at Gartner came internally versus externally. So, you know, which is for a company that's twenty thousand plus people, that's pretty impressive. Now, when I started with them again back in twenty fourteen or so timeframe, it was a different it was a different Gartner, a different size. It was a few thousand people, not nearly twenty thousand. So a lot of the opportunity that presented itself really aligned with the natural growth that we were seeing as a firm. And so I was I was the right person at the right time. When it was, hey, a selection needed to be made because from a team standpoint, our span of control under one leader was getting to be too much. All right, let's open up a team lead role. Hey, Jana, would you be interested in applying for this? You know, so I had some some taps on the shoulder to be considered for things. And I was very upfront with my leadership team as well on like. I want to grow. I want to I want to make an impact and continue to grow my sphere of influence. And they awarded me that opportunity, you know, to the point where I again got to the point of VP of a global talent acquisition. And ⁓ it was it was a great run. I'm very grateful for it. But yeah, a lot of it was I was the right person at the right time in the right place. And I mean, some of my my jumps, you know, and Titles don't, you I'm not I'm not as b big on titles, but you know, some of my jump from manager to director to VP happened over a span of a few years. I don't see that radical timeline as much on the market anymore. It's it it exists, but it it was a lot of growth in a short amount of time. And there were some learn there was some growing pains that came along with that as well, as you could imagine. But But yeah, it was it was great. And my biggest advice for my to my mentees, to anybody who asks is don't think about, don't just focus on the future and I want to be a chief people officer or a CHRO. That's the that's the wrong kind of motivation, in my opinion. It's about being the best that you can be in the role that you're in now. And how can you help then the your leader? How can you take things off their plate? What can you do to constantly be be learning and contributing? Take initiative. If you see something and you know, this is broken, I'm gonna fix it. That's what I did. You know, there was there was opportunity. So I'll give you a ⁓ example. When I was at Gartner, we were hiring like crazy, we were growing like crazy, but a lot of our processes were, you know, the way we had already always done things. And it just didn't scale with the speed, with the volume. And I needed to get ahead of anticipate hiring needs instead of waiting for requisitions or roles to open. Otherwise, we were literally leaving revenue on the table. And so I took initiative to look at the data, to look at the trends, historic, current, and put together a model in place. And I'm not an overly analytical person. ⁓ I'm not a data analyst or a data scientist. Put together a simple model of okay, this is what, you know, we need to be anticipating and then building those candidate pipelines and strategy to support that. So that was just something that hadn't been done. And I took initiative to do it. And we got to a point where our staffing levels were consistently in the 95 percentile percent range. And, you know, for revenue generating streams, that is so critical. speaker-0: Yeah, I think, you know, that's a great initiative is a big piece. I think we're missing a lot, right? Because very little initiation gets rewarded. And we live in a incredibly I coach youth sports, so I I will call myself a Dean Pro at this, where we are looking for the quick satisfaction whether we win or lose. And It's hard for people to take initiative, I think, on the background because they don't know whether it's going to be accepted or frowned upon. And I think that's where you you kinda said you're in the right place at the right time, but those opportunities wouldn't have been there if you didn't kick butt at what you did. Right. Like you you can start with a new company and grow. And I've been a part of that multiple times where initiative kind of hurt people. Because they were showing up the leaders above them and it kind of gets squashed down a little bit. So what advice would you have knowing the success that you've had by being the best Janna you can be in every role that you've had, where it might be more intimidating for people to go out of their comfort zone and fear the rejection versus just doing it, whether it's going to be rejected or accepted? How would you teach your mentees the opportunity to go through that brick wall regardless of the outcome? speaker-1: So it starts with being incredibly self-aware and proving proving your worth first. So if you look at my career as an individual contributor when I was a recruiter, I was a recruiter for a few years. I mean, it took me a while to master it, to be to be a proven performer year over year and a top performer, and to essentially make my leadership team confident. That I could handle initiatives and taking things on. So, you know, I would say for my mentees, take a take a real look at yourself and your performance. Look at the feedback that you're receiving and the con, especially the constructive feedback, and make sure to master those areas before you start thinking about. something more. The other real thing to look at is your leadership team. I was very fortunate to work with some amazing leaders over my over my tenure, not just at Gartner, but over the course of my career. And and I've worked with ones that aren't as empowering as well. That could be its own podcast. But ⁓ you know, so I would look at that, take a real look at yourself and then take a real good look at your leadership support. And to your point, Justin, I mean, if you're getting if you're seeing kind of that intimidation from your leader of, you know, ⁓ they're gonna make me look look bad or or they're going to outshine me, then you know, maybe that's not the right environment to the right timing. Or, you know, I've I've coached some mentees through this very, very thing where it's like, let's f how about let's to look at the conversation. How do you tee this up? How do you frame it to where maybe it's their idea and then you get kind of selected to take on a a project or initiative? So there's a couple of different ways to go about it, but it does start with with role mastery and like you said, kind of kicking butt in your role that you're in before really trying to elevate further. speaker-0: Awesome. And when you we're the recruiter, let's kind of segue over to some pipelines and building, right, throughout your what almost twenty years plus of HR, right, man. We're we're old. We're old, Channa. We're old. Things I never thought I'd say twenty years ago when I was an ad adult. Wait a second. I know. But yeah, so Walk us through how do you build pipeline? What are you looking for? You know, from when you were in time with Gartner to when you were independent and now you're with your current role. What what are you doing to still succeed and meet and exceed expectations versus just meet expectations that anybody can pretty much implement? speaker-1: Yeah. So I mean, it's really about embracing it's it's really important where that I wherever I work that I align with the vision, with the mission of the organization and really embody that. So when I think about pipelines, when I think about, you know, anything, I'm considering not just myself, I'm considering the overall organization and why we do what we do. So even ⁓ with Gartner, we really focused on, you know, quality candidates, quality over quantity. And, you know, I didn't always have the the the quantif from a quanti quantifiable standpoint, the deepest pop pipeline, but I had the best quality, where, you know, from a conversion standpoint, I understood what my stakeholders were looking for and presented that quality to them. And that rings true even now. My pipelines today look a little bit different because, you know, when I was at Gartner, I'm an in-house recruiter. I I'm, you know, my my ⁓ pipelines are very candidate focused. Now being on the other side of recruiting, I have clients, not just internal external clients, and I have candidates. So I need pipelines of both, and me and my team need pipelines of both. So that, you know, we're meeting our overall revenue goals. And that comes with relentless prioritization and relentless execution and consistency, that extreme ownership. Jocko Willock is a is a you know somebody that I absolutely admire and his extreme ownership, and that's something that I really aspire to live by and teach others. speaker-0: So how do you handle a how do you handle someone that's under you? So you're you're the VP and obviously you have recruiters under you that you're fostering and growing and holding accountable. So in our world, I can speak directly to KPIs. KPI word is the bane of my existence. Is you better make your 70 phone calls, you better have your 22 meetings, you and in my my opinion, we feel like we basically force numbers upon people, but I can have 70 phone calls. But if only two of them are quality, what was the point of the other sixty? But when you look at phone records, that's what you see. Right. Right. When you get into a pipeline, I can have a hundred companies in the pipeline, but if only one of them are ever realistically gonna close, what's the point of the other ninety nine? So where Where do you find the balance through all your roles of KPIs? Are you a left to right? Are you right to left? Are you production quality based? Walk us through how you handle as a great leader through your companies to keep pressure, because we're there to do a job, but do it sustainably to where they're not coming from a scarcity mindset where they know they can still have an abundant mindset and quality mindset. How do you balance those two worlds in leadership slash production? speaker-1: Yeah. So as a VP I I lead a little bit differently than I was when than I did when I was a manager, ⁓ for instance. And, you know, I've I've learned a lot of learned a lot of things dur along the way. Earlier in my career, I did. I really focused on the KPIs. I focused on those those leading indicators of, you know, how you know, what's the how many, you know, just quantity, how many calls are you doing? What is that, how is that you know, how many hiring manager interviews and just really focused on that that funnel. And that's fine, but you're not necessarily to your point encouraging the right behaviors or awarding success. So when I was a VP, I I didn't focus as much on those like, I don't care if you had 10 phone call, 10 interviews in a week or 30 interviews in a week. Your goal is To average three hires a month. And, you know, we have a proven framework of what that needs to look like. A best practice isn't standard operating procedure. So the best practice might mean 20 calls a week. This is going to yield the, you know, that sort of thing, kind of standard conversion. But if you can do that with less, do it with less. If it needs to be done with more, put in the work to do it with, to do it with more. But You know, I I really focused on coaching for at it the right attitude. And, you know, some people give up. You know, I'm not trending the right direction. It's gonna be too much. Instead of solving the problem, what okay, you're convert you're doing these things. You're con you're not converting. Candidates aren't converting at the next stage. There's a disconnect. Connect with your hiring team. Figure out where there's misalignment. Is there you know, sometimes it's something that is simple or obvious that people just overlook, but you know, there's there's kind of a different style depending on on the level on the organization. And as a VP, I'm not gonna be micromanaging people's phone call you accounts. No, I I need to focus on the overall business impact. Are we trending to our overarching goals? Are we not? And leverage my leadership team to to help, you know, problem solve those specifics. And when I talk to my recruiters, it's it's all about the attitude, the skill versus will, right? So they need to have that will they gotta do it. But, you know, if there's a skill misalignment where, you know, they're just not the right person on the team, that's gonna that's gonna be obvious too. speaker-0: And when you so I guess with you being in the VP roles, how do you go about the application process to figure out whether you need to you can bring up from within or if you need to go outside? What are you looking for for resumes? That's we're gonna segue there in a second. Resumes is a beast in its own, right? Yes. But it's one of those pieces of how do you with the success that you've had across multiple companies and industries, what are you looking for in that key leadership quality to say, hey, you may be maybe weren't the best at the recruiter, but I see the intangibles that can make you a phenomenal leader, right? Because just because you're the best at sales doesn't make you a best leader at sales. Sometimes it's the middle of the road sales guys who leads the team to greatness. So walk us through kind of how you handle that on a daily basis. speaker-1: Yes. And and actually sometimes your best salesperson who tends to be the ones tapped to take on more responsibility are absolutely the worst managers because they're so they're so focused on themselves or the bottom line and they're not focused on others. And so that's really what I always looked for is that the impact Across the team, not just your individual goals. What do you how are you teaching others? How are you sharing back lessons learned? So internally, whenever I promoted people, yes, they absolutely needed to be hitting their goals. They didn't have to be the best of the best. That was a standard that I set for myself, but they did need to be meeting goals. And most importantly, from a leadership lens, how are they impacting those around them? So I would gather feedback. ⁓ from other members of the team, leadership team, stakeholders, and you know, just candid i feedback on individuals to understand, are they actually leadership ready or am I going to promote the top performer and then create a toxic work environment because all they're going to care about is looking the best. speaker-0: So reverse question, what if your top performer could be a great manager, but you're self you you're coming from a selfish mindset and you don't want to lose your top performer to management and try to backfill? How do you overcome those? Cause we're all human, right? We want to make sure we're always looking good. Sure. So how how do you attack that when it's like, man, this person's my A plus player, but he could be, he or she could be a phenomenal leader, but I really hate to lose him in this role. and they don't get the promotion maybe they should because they're too good at what they're doing. speaker-1: I I've seen this quite a bit over the course of my career. I've even struggled with that in the past. I had an individual on my Europe team and he was phenomenal. I mean, just from a producer standpoint, hit all of our goals, carried the team. And but they the aspiration was leadership. And they had that too. They were impacting the team. They were teaching others. They were encouraging Others, they were having difficult conversations again, taking that initiative. And so, you know, I had to the the right thing to do was to promote the the person that earned it and then encourage them and and trust that they are going to coach and teach and continue to do that, their team to to cover those gaps. Unfortunately, that that worked, but I saw some of my peers resist. That and then then you lose really talented people to other opportunities because they're ready to grow, but they're being held back. Even if there's opportunity to grow and they're held back because selfishly we're gonna lose 30% productivity. So I've seen that, and then well, now you're gonna lose even more than that because now they're gone and there's a huge gap ⁓ on the team. Everyone's upset and so I've I've experienced that and I've seen that over the course of my career for sure. speaker-0: And then when you're trying to backfill, walk us through kind of resume. We'll we'll go ahead and just jump into that because I know that's going to be quite a bit of topic for us. But resume. Obviously, hundreds and thousands of people are applying to random jobs. We have different sites, indeed, LinkedIn. I don't is Monster still around? I know it was when I was younger, but I don't know if it is. But it's just all these different sites. And now it's all these AI sites, job right, where you can. Put a little ⁓ bookmark or ⁓ extension into your browser and it will apply and it will take your resume and make it ATS certified because we know the ATS when you have high volumes, you gotta simplify the process somehow. So walk us through what are you doing through when you are with Gartner Private with your own company and current company and just in general? How are you? How are you not filtering out the top candidates because they have they're they're aware of the ATS, so they try to make their resume ATS perfect? Or we'll take it back a little bit step further, because I know you do a lot of resume consulting where I get at least three solicitations a week, like, hey, your resume's so close to being perfect. For $400, I will make sure you hit all your ATS recommendations to guarantee you hire. So how do we combat that in twenty twenty six where AI seems to be taking over the world, specifically in the upfront hiring, to be able to get that face to face where it we're kind of in that new paradigm where I think everyone's trying to adapt yet satisfy. So what are you doing to combat that? speaker-1: Yeah. So when I was hiring for my for my team, I mean, we weren't really leveraging AI very much. This was in my Gartner days, we weren't we weren't leveraging AI much at all, actually. And so yeah, we would get flooded with all of these resumes and you know, they all look the same, especially in the age of AI. I mean, you could prompt with the right things and wow, Justin can be ⁓ next CEO. with with all the buzzwords and it's not a complete lie, but there's some stretching and and so that's it's really, it's really tough. So I get it. I get why companies kind of use some kind of some screeners at W Talent, we are, we are big and very passionate on additional assessments. So we leverage predictive index. So all of our jobs as I hire for my team, I benchmark that. From a behavioral standpoint, from a cognitive standpoint. And so we we can get a lot of resumes of talent acquisition or HR professionals, but you know, there's another additional step to completing an assessment. And, you know, a lot of times candidates don't take that extra step because, to your point, they're mass applying. It's it's the market that we're in. AI is automatically applying for for them. And so that those additional Additional steps just help companies. And I know it's annoying from a candidate perspective to apply and have all these questions that they need to answer, but it's the only way to differentiate yourself. The other piece is is referrals. So a lot of times, you know, when I was hiring at scale and building my recruiting team, it was a lot of who do you know? Do I have endorsements and references or referrals from people? That say, talk to Justin. He's excellent. I worked with them in the past. And so I had a lot of success leveraging other people's network. And that's one of the reasons, one of the many, many reasons that I could that I say your network is so important. Or what's that cliche? Your network is your net worth. Yeah. Is so true because again, anybody's resume. can look absolutely perfect in the age of AI. And then you get them on an interview and it's a total dud. So so yeah. So with W Talent, we use the asset the predictive index assessment tools a lot of companies and and countries do. And it really helps weed out or vet out ⁓ those that could be a good culture fit, cognitive fit. Cause not everybody can do recruiting and HR. It's not for the it's not for the weak at heart, that's for sure. speaker-0: So what you said it was the predictive index? speaker-1: Predicted index. Yep. speaker-0: So so it's essentially a test that f so I apply and then it auto populates this test like, Hey, please fill out this assessment. Yes. And there's like ten or fifteen questions. speaker-1: It's so there's ⁓ there's it's two parts to it. One's a yes, one is a behavior test, so or assessment. It's not a test, ⁓ Justin. No testing happening here, but it's an assessment where you're basically you're just you're selecting, you know, the descriptions of who you are, how you see yourself, how you show up at work, and it synthesizes that data. And comes up with, all right, Justin, you're a maverick. And this is and it shares your your results with you. And and then there's another part of it that is a cognitive test ⁓ assessment. Look, I said it myself. It's an assessment. And it's it's not an IQ test. It's not, it's not testing that you're good at math. It's more that processing speed. So it's timed, it's 50 questions. ⁓ it takes like twelve minutes. It's fast. And where it's pattern recognition and back of the napkin math and those sorts of things that you gotta be able to move through quickly. and it just helps with, you know, and there's various roles out there. We we bet you could benchmark them and tailor, you know, what the results kind of need to look like or what that kind of range needs to look like, depending on your team dynamics, your your culture at work, your the job itself. So all of that can be tailored and And the insights are spot on. speaker-0: Hmm. That's interesting. I know my mentors when I had my clinics, we I guess I didn't realize it was named anything. It was just like, hey, do this. So we would for front desk receptionist type stuff. We would have a bunch of people come in and do like a big group interview because it was the best use of time. And then we would give everybody a test and probably fifth sorry, assessment. And probably 50% of the people wouldn't take the assessment. They go, Well, I'm not here to take a test. And it's like, well, no, it's an assessment. No, I'm kidding. But it's Right. Yeah, exactly. But they would walk out and it was simple. You know, you go to the store, candy bar costs fifty-two cents, you give the cashier a dollar. How much do you get back? Right? And people would shut down during the test because we're we're trained now with just everything's calculated for us. Right? You punch numbers in your cash register and it tells you negative forty-two. Right. So you know exactly what to give back. And I won't even get into some of the change the change that I get back for 42 cents, right? Sometimes it's a quarter, a dime, a nickel. Sometimes it's four dimes. They're like, well, it's 42 cents. I'm like, I can I have a quarter, please. But yeah, it's one of those things that we used to do to try to a put you under a little bit of stress, right? Because when you have patients yelling at you, someone owes you money, someone else is checking in, you got to get a patient out of the x ray room and into the adjusting room. It was one of those pieces where can you handle that stress? And if you can't do a simple question without having that bombardment of anxiety come over you. It's like maybe this wasn't the right role for you. And other things we used to do, you trip feel free to steal this one. And our job posting, we would highlight our email, but in different sections. So we might go Justin Voskis at gmail dot com. And then on the bottom of our job posting we would put Follow the highlights, put those together, and that would be that's the email to email your resume to. And it was just something simple where A, did you read our job posting? Do you really know what you're applying for? And did you follow the instructions at the bottom? Or did you just hit quick, you know, easy apply on the top right corner, expecting to get your resume in front of that? And that was always interesting too, because people, they would call the offices, be like, Hey, I applied, I never heard anything. And it's like, well, you didn't follow the protocol. process you didn't follow the steps. So that was an easy way to eliminate people too. But yeah, so speaker-1: Yeah. speaker-0: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And now you said n what what what did you say? Your network is your net worth. So walk us through that. LinkedIn, phenomenal, right? Social networking outside of politics stuff, right? Like you can share surveys and data and whatever you want to share through LinkedIn. Great connections, usually across the US and the world sometimes, depending on what your profession is. But they have the job section where you click easy to apply. This job has been seen by over a hundred applicants in the last 32 seconds, right? Those type of postings. How do you combat that? And what is your recommendation to people who are going through, right? The world's getting tight and it's getting tough and it's getting harder and harder to land jobs because the competition is getting so immense. What are you doing about that? What are your thoughts on that back end process? How are you guys attacking that for high level jobs all the way down to entry level, what are you guys doing to make sure it's fair and equitable to really represent your brand? speaker-1: Yeah. So one I I will say we we at W Talent Solutions, we use job postings very sparingly. We are a headhunting firm. So most of the time our candidates are coming from direct outreach from me, from my team, seeking somebody, you know, with your experience. So there's there's a lot of that. However, I have a lot of experience with with LinkedIn job postings. There's a couple things to know. The easy apply, I would, you know, it's it's easy, right? For a reason. So as a job seeker, it's like, ⁓ I could do these all day. But they don't always cleanly link to an ATS. Sometimes they're being managed just within LinkedIn. Recruiters or hiring managers can just Post a job, easy apply. And then maybe they don't have the discipline to go through everything. Or it's all going into their email and maybe it's getting flagged as spam. So I would be careful with the easy applies. The ones that take a little more time when you have to click on them, when you have to go to their website, and it takes you to greenhouse and it takes you to Ashby or Workday or wherever. Those are, it takes more time, but At least you can be confident that they're being received. And we can talk about delay and timelines later. But so and then on LinkedIn, you could also sort by postings within the last week, 24 hours. And I would encourage that as well. Also don't be too discouraged by by the number of people that have clicked apply within the last 20 seconds because those numbers can be inflated a bit, because you can click it and then not. not submit. Candidates do that all the time where they just don't finish their application. So, you know, I one of the things that I that I've done and that I would encourage is, you know, we have to differentiate ourselves. Like I said, all of resumes tailored to through AI, they could all look exactly the same. So do a bit of research on the company. You can look at, you don't have to have a special LinkedIn license. Premium's great. But, you know, and I have it all, but you don't you don't have to. You can literally go and and look at W Talent Solutions. I'll use our firm as an example. Go to people and in their on their company page, you can find people within their organization. And, you know, where they probab might have hiring influence, you could reach out to them or try to connect with them. When you connect with them, you could send a note in your connection request. That says, I'm I saw that this job is posted. You know, something that that, you know, start with pleasantries. That helps, but ⁓ you know, show your politeness. But and you've got a 300 character limit in that connection message to to put yourself out there. Once they connect with you, you get an alert that they connected with you. Now you have ⁓ free reign to keep messaging them. Some people never check their messages, but I've gotten many hits that way. ⁓ when I was when I was an app active job applicant, for example, I reached out to chief people officers and and it led to sometimes just networking calls. Because the other thing I would say is there is a lot more jobs out there than what are posted on LinkedIn. And I worked with, I've talked to different career coaches, I've coached as well. And we always say the same thing. Come up with your target company list where you want, where you really you admire them, where you see yourself and connect with HR professionals, to connect with people that would be relevant potential decision makers. If you're looking for a sales role, connect with sales managers and then just ask them to connect, maybe over a networking call, over coffee if they're local. And build that that networking relationship. That for me, that's led to interviews. That's led to long lasting relationships. And sometimes those companies might not have an active job posting, but there's things happening behind the scenes and you know, where they are looking, or maybe they're working with a headhunting firm like mine and there's confidential roles that are that they're working on. And it's ⁓ it's just sometimes just the right connection or message at the right time and just be really consistent about that is what is what I would advise and and you know how I've understood the the market to to again to differentiate yourself from millions and millions of people. speaker-0: So people actually read the invite connect message? speaker-1: I do. speaker-0: Huh. I guess I guess well I mean I have thousands of followers on there and I guess I've never I've never submitted one. I'm like, you know what, I'm not gonna write a message 'cause they're probably gonna be annoyed that I wrote a message. It gives them it something to read just to instead of just click accept. So yeah, I'll have to start doing that. I I've I've never written one of the messages on there. So see, you just taught me something today. I didn't think I didn't think people actually read it. It was like do I do I know this person or not? Can this person add value or not? Click but speaker-1: I I would say I would I mean, we can't control if people are annoyed or not, right? I mean, I I live in and out of LinkedIn recruiter. It's part of my part of my job. I've been doing it a long time. So, you know, it doesn't bother me when I get unsolicited in mails about things. What's the worst that I can ha that can happen? I ignore it. You know? What's the worst that can happen if I reach out to somebody and and they and they see my note and they ignore it or they delete it? Who cares? I I I put myself out there. You know, you have to it's it's a it's a long game. Sometimes it's a numbers game, hate to say it, but sometimes it's like you get forwarded to the right people. Hey, I'm not the right person, but reach out to Justin and then I'm gonna reach out to Justin and say, Hey, Janice recommended I connect with you. Well, now Justin has a higher likelihood of responding because now I just, you know, I was recommended an introduction. So or sometimes in a the the beautiful thing will happen where you know let me introduce you to this person or you could ask for it would you mind introducing me so you know I have quite a few people in my network I tell people all the time hey if there's a mutual connect or is there somebody that you you want to be introduced to that I'm connected to on LinkedIn I'm like you justin I've ti I have thousands of of ⁓ connections and followers and I'm happy to make an introduction that's what it's for It's a networking a social media networking platform. speaker-0: Yeah. And are you more apt to get a response through ⁓ I'm assuming you use sales navigator? Is that what your side's called? speaker-1: We use we have it all. We have sales navigator, we have LinkedIn recruiter. That's primarily what we use for for our headrunting purposes. speaker-0: Does LinkedIn Recruiter do the direct mails, but kind of it flags it on the back end? Yeah. So for people listening, do you recommend the two-prong attach where you try to connect and you send a direct in mail? I guess that's what's this called in mail. Or do you try to connect first, see if the connection's accepted, and then send a direct message through that connection? Where on the recruiter side, where have you had success? Connecting with people through the in mails versus just a direct message 'cause you guys are quote unquote friends. speaker-1: Right. So the most successful is being connected with them first. And then a you know, if if they don't respond or you can see if they don't accept within a certain amount of time, you know, give it a day or so, then go in with a with an in mail. Organizations, recruiters have have only so many in mail credits. So for any of the you candidates out there listening, when you get a when you get a message ⁓ unsolicited and that falls into your other ⁓ mailbox. They they pay they wanted so bad to talk to you or get a hold of you that they're willing to pay for it. But, you know, so you know, and it's and it's not cheap. Don't even get me started on ⁓ the LinkedIn paywall. But but I mean, so yeah, I would take a serious look because we don't just send those out a willy nilly, if you will, because there is there is a cost, but to answer your question directly, it is most successful from what my experience to connect with them first. Try to make that kind of a little more personable, personal touch and then, you know, follow up with an in mail. Now, if they accept your connection message, in mails are f it's free, it's free reign. You don't have to once you're connected, you can message back and forth and and there's there's no additional in mail kind of credit loss, if you will. speaker-0: And what are you looking for on profiles? Right? Cause you see a lot of people that will message you that don't have a profile photo or they're trying to be an influencer and start posting in our world at Becker's. Becker's is like if we can put something Becker's related to what we're working on for that opportunity, what are you looking for in candidates who maybe let's say current and past day? Where they applied quick applied, you pulled up their LinkedIn profile. What are you looking at within their profile to be like, ⁓ this is an actual human and not somebody with a fake profile just spamming a job site over and over again? How are you look what are you looking for as a recruiter for even your exec searches, right? If you when you guys are actively headhunting, you know, do you go to their profile? Do you look through it to see if this is a viable candidate, or do you just look for a couple touch points? Walk walk me through what that looks like. speaker-1: Yeah, so a couple things. So I I do look at a profile picture and you know, it could be a flag if it's an AI generated one. I've seen that more and more. You know, changing your background is one thing, but a full full you know, AI photo is is sometimes, you know, is this is this l legit. You can verify your profile. So I look we look for verified LinkedIn profiles so that ⁓ That just kind of again adds some legitimacy. Are they active? Do they have multiple connections? I wouldn't reach out to somebody that has, you know, especially a lot of the recruiting I do is at the leadership level, sales professionals. And I mean, if they don't have 500 plus connections, then they're not really utilizing the platform, especially if they're in sales, then they're not very good at that if they're if they don't have very many connections. So I look at that. ⁓ I look at the just the overall professionalism of their of their LinkedIn. I mean, I talk to candidates all the time that say, you know, I'm not because again, I'm a headhunter. So, you know, they're like, I haven't been on updated my profile in years. Okay, but does it still look good? Like, does it, does it have details around their roles, what they've been doing over the years? It might not be the most updated, but is it professional? Because When as a recruiter and when I go to a hiring manager and I say, I want you to talk to Justin, what's the first thing that they're gonna do? They're gonna pull up your your LinkedIn and and they're going to see that, you know, he doesn't have, you know, he's gonna they're gonna see all of those things. ⁓ they could also see all of your activity. ⁓ wow, he has come some controversial comments on people's profiles or on different postings. I had this kind of raised not too long ago where You know, candidates are posting about like in in just desperation wanting a job. And that can be seen as unprofessional. So I do I do look at all of those things of just, you know, how are they, how are they putting themselves out there for the world in a public forum? And, you know, is there does it have a clean, crisp LinkedIn profile because it's the first thing outside of the resume that the hiring managers are looking at? speaker-0: All right, so now move it to the next step. We have our resume fine-tuned. Our LinkedIn profile is attractive to everybody. They get to call from Jana. Hey, I would love to have an opportunity with you. I will tell you, you I got the one interview with ⁓ Gartner and it was it the star method. My gosh. I bombed. I was so so freaked out. speaker-1: Yeah. speaker-0: over hitting the S and the T and the A and the R and the follow up questions that I was getting from the recruiter at the time. You know they were just looking at S T A R. Did I hit all of ⁓ and all my prep work was S T A R and I told my wife, I go, I've never been nervous for an interview because I'm I can I enjoy meeting people and talking to people. I can sell myself on what I did and how I can help companies grow, et cetera. But that one interview I had with Gartner, it was the most torturous interview only because I had so much stress onto the star side. Right. Versus having a conversation. And I get and I get that point. So now resume's good. Jana, I'm on the phone with you. Wednesday, two o'clock. This is my dream job. I'm really excited to hear more about it. As an interviewee, what can I do to put my best foot forward to not be able to lean on my resume? But maybe that's what you're looking for as well. What advice would you have for that candidate to put themselves in the best light? Because it's so hard to even get the opportunity to talk with you. Right now they have the opportunity to talk with you and now they clam up and they're shy because they're scared to screw something up. And then you go, nope, this person's not who we're looking for. So what advice do you have for that? speaker-1: I know. And it's such a shame when that's that happens because an interview is a point in time, right? You could have it's just like anything. You could have a great day and you could have a not so great day. And you know, it and they could they could be back to back. Yeah, at Gartner, that happened a lot. They were really big on the star format, just I'm so sorry. Yeah, that was her experience. Basically, what the advice probably should have been was keep it keep it short and sweet. Right. Like hit the main points, tell a story and move on. ⁓ they'll probe if they want additional information. But you know, we're working within a time window. Interviews with me could be 30 minutes, can be an hour. We have a lot to cover in that time. We gotta be efficient. So if I'm already on if I'm our if you're already getting a call from a recruiter, you already have an interview set up, like You know, open the bottle of champagne because that's a cell that's that's a celebratory event. They want it to go well. So be yourself is would be the advice that I give now is be yourself. Because when you get off of that interview and you're reflecting on it, it's like, okay, was I myself and they just they aren't into this? Okay, that's one thing. I could I could sleep at night. But if I was someone else. And maybe they would have liked me better, then they have then that's a little bit more of a harder pill to swallow. But as I yammer on more, as I as I don't follow my own advice, basically a recruiter has objectives that they're needing to get through. Same with the hiring manager. There's probably going to be a couple areas that they're going to hit on. The the recruiter's going to qualify a candidate. So they're going to confirm some things on their resume. Have your pitch ready to go. So Justin, tell me about yourself, right? Have your pitch ready to go of, hey, this is what I do. This is why I'm interested in the role. Do your homework on who you're not just who you're interviewing with, but the company. Have a have ⁓ again, you don't have to be an expert. You don't work there. If the company expects you to be an expert, then that's silly. But, you know, have have do some due diligence, have an understanding of the role. And when you talk about this is who I am and this is what I do and this is what You know, tie it back to the job of this is why I'm interested in the role. This is what I understood it to be, and then stop talking and let the recruiter ask their questions, confirm some things, build rapport. We're likely gonna talk about what's motivating you to even consider talking to me. Talk to give me an overview of your of your background. Again, 30,000 foot view. Doesn't have to be in 1999, I did this or that, you know. Focus on the last 10 years or if there's an overarching story that that can be summed up in a couple of minutes. So those are the things that I would encourage candidates to to practice because that would apply to various interviews that they're a part of. Now, when it comes to the hiring manager interview or next rounds, then they're a little more in depth. Maybe they want more information. And it's good to pulse check. When you answer their question, do you want more information? Did that ans adequately answer what you were looking for? Ask those questions naturally and you know, give them a chance to be like, ⁓ I was hoping you'd go into a little bit more depth here. All right. That's your green light to expand. But yeah, so it's just you've got this, you've got this small window. The best advice is just be yourself, be as excited as possible. Show you want the job. By doing your homework, doing your due diligence on the company, on the job, and send a follow up. I feel like that is a a lost art. I always impressed when candidates send even a LinkedIn message, an email. You know, we've coordinated this. They're gonna have my contact information. Send me a follow up, even if it's just a sentence or two just saying, thank you so much for your time. I enjoyed this. For hiring managers, it's especially important to send them a follow-up recap, maybe clarify if you got some constructive feedback, clarify or give them another example. So, you know, there's there's some there's some ⁓ advice and kind of tricks to to differentiating yourself. If you do those things, chances are you're gonna land the next interview and maybe even the job. Just taking those, those, ⁓ those little steps. speaker-0: That's good advice because I know as a sales guy, follow up is our job, right? Like I wish I could jump on a call, sell something in 30 minutes, and never talk. No, I obviously I won't want to talk to you because the relationship's established, but there's just so much follow-up and then there's ghosting and you gotta get past the ghosting phase. So that was that was my struggle with my the current job that I have now is I was talking to my wife who's HR as well, and she I'm like, Do I send an email? She's like, Well, what do you mean? And I go, Well, it's a sales job. So I want to show examples of how I would follow up with potential clients that I'm bringing into the company, but I also know it's an interview slash follow up email from the interview. So I was I tried to be really creative with how I followed up. And I also didn't want to follow up with, hey Jan, I'm just following up. Thank you so much for the interview. Right. Cause that's you don't follow up that way in sales. If you do, you're just going to get ignored. So I was trying to be creative and I think that was a big piece for me is And a lot of salespeople is we're so used to setting up time stamps. So great, when do you think I can hear something back? And you say, I hopefully we'll have an answer to you over by Monday. Well then Tuesday morning, that gives me permission, virtual permission, to say, Hey, Jana, I didn't hear anything from you yesterday. Hope all was going well. Let me know what a better time is where I can get some feedback. You know, something like that where if you have those deadlines set into place, I think it's easier for follow-up. But like you kind of mentioned right after the interview, I think it goes a long way. I know it makes me feel warm and cushy inside when they're like, that was a great interview, really excited about the company. And it's like, okay, maybe the interview wasn't great. Maybe you got nervous and shut down a little bit and it wasn't what I was anticipating. But you were the only one that sent a follow-up email. So that tells me, like, like you said, that's the blip in time that maybe you didn't necessarily succeed at. But you're the only one showing initiative though, too. Yeah. You know, it was so yeah, that that was a great piece of advice. Now let's get to these auto auto-rejection emails, pre-interview, post-interview, appropriate timelines. I've been a victim to it all. And on LinkedIn, I love following people who have been as well with major companies where they've applied and then the auto rejection email comes 27 seconds later. It's like thank you, but we extensively look through your background and you don't quite meet the qualifications that we're looking for. It's like I j I just applied. Like how do you know? ⁓ speaker-1: Thirty seconds is extensive? speaker-0: Yeah. Or you have that great interview and then you know they're interviewing multiple people, which is fair, but then instead of just giving you some sort of personalized email back, like, hey Justin, really thank you so much for your time, whatever that is, then it's the auto-rejection email. Thank you so much for your interview. But we continue to move forward with other candidates. Please don't reply back to this email thread as this email thread is not monitored. So I don't know if you've seen those or not, but I've so walk What do you think of that? What are you doing different? What do you recommend to leaders listening to this? Cause it might not be a fit now, but it doesn't mean it won't be a fit later. So what are you doing to combat that? And what advice do you have for applicants who get that? Right? Cause it's easy to say, ⁓ just move on to another job when man, that might have been an essence, quote unquote, on paper, your dream job to not even have an opportunity to get your resume looked at. So what what advice do you have on that? speaker-1: Yeah, I mean, so I can I can I can share some reasons why that's happening. So I've I'm ⁓ I've worked on the in-house recruiting side. Now I'm on the the external recruiting side. And a lot of times, and you this is why I I don't love the easy apply buttons and some of those LinkedIn job postings, because you know, maybe they posted it because ⁓ there's a compliance. element. They have to post all of their jobs because the internal precedent is they they have to post things for five days. Gartner, we kind of followed a a posting process and there was a timeline that you have to post it externally and internally for a certain amount of time. But they have an idea of who they're already going to hire. There's internal candidates in play. There's referrals in play. Those are going to get the first look before somebody somebody off the street essentially. So You know, sometimes that's that's what's happening. On the auto rejection, and that's I believe where the auto rejections are coming because they already kind of have this slate, but they're working within a time frame of they have to have these roles posted. And so they click on everybody and it auto they have their ATS set up to where when they move them to a certain stage, everyone gets an automated automated email. of sorts. And so I'm not saying it's right. I'm just saying that it's that this is what this is what happens. And I've I've been there and I've had to course correct internally, like, darn, I didn't realize that everybody got this. Or, you know, sometimes you just don't know. So I would say what's different with with our firm at W Talent is we don't we don't do that. So again, this is the beauty of working with an external recruitment firm. Is we have a very much more tailored and candidate friendly approach. That'll I mean, time things take time in any kind of an interview process. A ⁓ week to a candidate could be a day in the court in corporate America, you know, in terms of how it feels, because so much is happening. A hiring manager isn't just hiring for their team. They have their whole job to do, plus the job that they're closing the gap of of this ⁓ for this opening on their team. So they're they're interviewing, they're doing all these things. So sometimes there can be delays. But from an ATS standpoint, you know, it leaders ⁓ that that are listening, TA leaders and HR leaders, it all comes down to configuration of your ATS. I would be very careful with mass actions. And ideally, communication comes from a person and not a system, because it just doesn't. feel good, like you said, Justin. That being said, candidates that are out there, if you get a rejection from a recruiter, they are the middleman. They are the bearer of the bad news. It's nothing personal. And yeah, so don't blast the recruiter. That's how you get on the do not ever talk to this person again list. speaker-0: Yeah, yeah. I'm yeah, I can only imagine some of the stuff that you've you've seen through the pipeline. So here's a funny here's a fun question. What has been the worst interview? Don't name company, obviously keep all that, but what is the worst interview where you turn the camera on, they turn the camera on, we'll say virtual, because that tends to be probably where the crazy ones happen. So virtual interview, walk me through what you opened up camera. It's like, ⁓ my gosh, what am I about to enter into? speaker-1: Yeah. So I had I have plenty of horror stories. More good ones, I will say. But I had one one time where the individual they it talk about not professional. You know, I don't know what they were wearing, their hair was crazy, their background looked like literally a bomb went off in their apartment. There was no blur or anything like that. And, you know, you could literally You could see questionable materials behind them. And so that was very distracting. And they were clearly not prepared and then very nervous because they weren't prepared. And I was, you know, I always try to make people feel comfortable because if you're nervous and you're you're not gonna perform your best, you know, and again, I want it to go well because I'm spending time on this. So, you know, I, you know, I've try to Try to, you know, how are you doing? How are things going? And they got so nervous. There, I could see them visibly shaking. And at one point, I asked them like a simple question, like, you know, what has you interested in this opportunity? And so pretty early on in the call, and they completely drew a blank and couldn't like they, you know, it's like that ⁓ flight, fight, or freeze. They completely froze and and started crying and said, I'm so sorry. I'm really nervous. And you know, I I can't do this and literally hung up on me. speaker-0: All right. Well, I can honestly, I can kind of get where she's coming from. And I say that because obviously background and stuff, but there's sometimes where when you're in the throes of applying and the delay and responses, I go, you go, I don't even remember what company this was. And now you can't find the job posting, right? So you're it's like, all right, Jana, all right, who was Jana on? What's this job? Right. So it it's just one of those things where it Almost kind of sounds like my biggest fear because I've had people reach out three months after my application. They're like, Hey, we're really excited. I'm like, Well, you obviously weren't too excited if it took three months to get back to me. But then I don't even remember what I applied for. They're like, Yeah, you applied. It was the vice president role of blah, blah, blah, blah. My I I don't even know if I've ever applied to that. Probably also 'cause it was a LinkedIn easy apply, right? Right. Where I met the requirements and clicked and didn't read too much into it, but Yeah, that that's interesting because that I mean, I think that's everyone's biggest fear is just who knows, maybe the she having four kids, having kids yourself, where it's like maybe it was a he hectic drop off at the school drop that morning and now they're unprepared. My co football coach used to say, You're only nervous because you're unprepared. If you're prepared, preparedness always trumps nervousness, right? Nerves are good because it gives you a visceral reaction. speaker-1: Yeah. speaker-0: to something you're about to embark in, that tells you that you are genuinely excited for it, right? Versus the nerves that you feel when you're totally unprepared for something. I'm sure you've had it where you maybe had a rough day and you couldn't get your PowerPoint ready for leadership. And it's like I got I just threw this together 30 minutes ago because I totally ran out of time dealing with fire after fire. And I guess one last question that I have is length of time at job. We're gonna kind of go back to the resume track a little bit. So in a perfect world, multiple years, our parents generation, the boomer generation, work at the same job 45 years, retire, collect your pension, collect your social security, live a good retirement. Now it's more in that conversation of how do we make sure that we are progressing through channels when not possible? So obviously ⁓ my background is I pretty much change jobs every week. Every week. No, not that much. Yeah, red flag there. speaker-1: Well rev speaker-0: But every year and I'm able to explain it to potential employers because each role that I've taken has been a promotion. But let's say maybe I'll use this term and I don't really like it. It's the company culture because culture can be sold through the phone different than the culture in the office, if that makes sense. Yeah. So how do you recommend candidates? To that maybe have that more, like every year, every 18 months, maybe two year transition to different companies. They walk us through what you look for on the resume, but then also walk us through how can they combat that. So let's say they have the opportunity, they connected with Jana on LinkedIn. Should they just be forthright? Like, hey, my background might be different than what you're customary to looking at, but I would enjoy the opportunity to have a conversation with you to explain. why my resume looks the way it was. What what do you how do you handle that? speaker-1: Yeah. I mean, Justin, you're the perfect example like you're the perfect use case of explain the context. So for example, you know, when you and I you and I kinda talked about this and yeah, I mean, looking at the resume without the story there can be problematic if it's every year or two years, especially a sales professional, because that can be seen as like, ⁓ they know maybe they weren't performing and then, you know, that it wasn't working out. You know, they they weren't making money. So they needed to move on. And there's legitimate reasons for for all of these things. But it's all about the story. So for example, I talked to a candidate just the other day and they had this kind of, you know, a non-traditional background where You know, they've been in a role one to two years over the last ten years, but they told me, you know, this is what I'm working towards. And these moves have been very in very intentional because at this company I learned this. At this company, I did this. At this company, I did this. And now I'm working to be the and I need to have all of those different elements in order to be qualified for this dream that I have, which was a job that I'm looking to fill. So, you know, there was this whole story around it. It made Perfect sense. There wasn't anything that flagged in terms of, you know, I didn't see eye to eye with my leadership. And, you know, there wasn't a trend there over and over again, which again, that's a legitimate reason too. It just really comes down to the story behind it, the why. And I would always recommend leading with that and just being outright. Again, be yourself. be forthcoming. And there's ways that you can organize a resume to tell that story as well. Sometimes people's job history looks a little hoppy just because companies get merged or acquired or or that sort of thing. You could indicate that formerly this, formerly that. Okay, well it's not a change in jobs. It's just the company was bought out or You know, or they were dissolved or what you can tell a story that way through a resume as well. And using, you know, even some paragraph forms, you know, to to do that. Or, you know, I say cover letter, but I'm not no nobody's reading cover letters really. So you're gonna have to keep you're gonna have to keep it on the resume somehow, or the or LinkedIn or whatever. So anyway, hopefully that's helpful. But yeah, I mean, your story is intentional. There's a lot of candidates out there that are intentional. But yeah, I mean, sometimes, you know, I look at a at a background and I'm like, every year they're moving around, every two years, you know, you know, what what's their what's their end game? And, you know, is this a high probability candidate that they're going to to last and do well or or a low probability? And, you know, a lot of times hiring managers are are very ⁓ leery of Of that happiness again without a compelling reasoning behind it. speaker-0: All right, we're almost out of time, so this is gonna be the one question that I ask all of my guests at the very end. So what is the one thing everybody, an all-inclusive word, I've been taught by my wife that that's not necessarily the best way to phrase it, but I'm going to anyhow. What is the one thing everybody in our business, your business does that is flat out wrong? speaker-1: Hm, everybody's doing it? Okay. I would say I would say they're not advocating enough for the either their company or their candidates. I think that oftentimes we take too much of a back seat instead of really leading the process and setting the standard of what a good candidate experience, hiring manager experience really looks like. speaker-0: There you go. Jana, this has been a pleasure and thanks so much. That's the pod.