Latest / Pedagogically Speaking / The Students We Call “Lazy” Are Actually Overwhelmed
Transcript
- Ilana: What if the biggest lie tell struggling students is that they just aren't trying hard enough? Because single day, students are being labeled lazy, ⁓ unmotivated, disorganized, defiant, or careless. when many of these students are actually just drowning cognitively. It's not that they're unwilling, they're overwhelmed, They're overwhelmed by executive dysfunction. They're overwhelmed by chronic stress. They're overwhelmed by the anxiety they have. They're overwhelmed by what feels to them like repeated failure. They're overwhelmed by impossible workloads. They're overwhelmed by nervous systems. that have been stuck in survival mode for far too long. And we know these students. These are the students that we have extra snacks for in our classroom, These are the students, we have spots in the room where they can go and they can rest. We make sure all students can access a reading nook, right? We have students go to the water fountain just to try and take a break. And I think the real tragedy is that once students internalize this idea that they're lazy, many of students stop seeing themselves as capable learners altogether. When students come to work with me and I tell them that, hey, you're smart and look at this, what you did, how smart are you? And I give them praise. It takes them so long to even believe me. I'm not talking like, ⁓ by the end of lesson, I'm talking, I will be doing this for weeks and maybe if I'm lucky by the end of term two, they'll be like, ⁓ my gosh, I did that. And I'll be like, I know you're so smart. And they're like, I'm smart. Again, that is heartbreaking. is heartbreaking because these students are smart. All of your students are smart. So today we are talking about why the students that are deemed as lazy are actually just ⁓ overwhelmed. we're talk about how schools, confuse with apathy. And going to discuss what happens when these educational systems were in mistake exhaustion for ⁓ lack of Okay. I think it's also really important, like I'm sure as you were listening to that, you were like, that's me as well, right? And I think that's really important to so we're going to be talking about the students, but you could probably take in some of that and be like, I'm overwhelmed, I'm overworked. ⁓ Yeah. What this education system that we're all a part of? welcome, welcome, welcome, welcome. ⁓ back to the podcast. My name is Alana I have been a teacher for 16 years now, first kindergarten and the primary grades. Now I'm in inclusive and learning support. And I created this podcast so that we as teachers would have to go ⁓ to feel heard, to feel seen. ⁓ to get together and collaborate. you all ⁓ much for your I know I say that every episode, but really I am grateful for all of the emails. And especially after last week's episode, ⁓ you all seemed to really that episode and a lot of you, it resonated with you. So I really appreciated ⁓ you reaching out. ⁓ Remember, can email me pedagogicallyspeakingpod gmail.org. Keep them coming. yeah, last week's episode definitely ⁓ big responses, which I am so glad that you liked it. ⁓ this is kind of like a part two for that episode. If you're listening on Spotify or Apple, please feel free to leave me a five star review. And today's episode is one that think educators, parents, and ⁓ possibly students going to feel very deeply inside of themselves because we are definitely talking about the word lazy. And I want to start by saying this clearly. I think lazy is one of the most damaging terms or labels that we use in education because once a student starts believing that they are lazy, it changes the way they see themselves. permanently, you know, they go from saying things like I'm struggling or I need support or even I mean, which would be amazing. This environment isn't working for me. And said they go to I'm the problem. ⁓ I learn. This is, you know, like that's it. I'm down. I'm all of these things. Right. And, you that's not what we want. ⁓ But it the reality that many students who appear disengaged, it's not that they're lacking intelligence, capability, or even desire or drive to succeed. They're cognitively overwhelmed, right? They have not figured out the path. in order to get to the end of the assignment. They have not figured out the systems that they need to put in place in order to access the learning on whatever level it is in the classroom that's going on there, right? And that's a massive difference. There's a massive difference between refusal being overloaded and overwhelmed. ⁓ schools often treat that the same way. ⁓ actually had a teacher actually email me ⁓ Friday last week. She was talking about how she has a student that she's been thinking was lazy. And I felt bad. She was like, I don't want to think about teacher. You're not a bad teacher. This is just what happens. Like we talk about all the time, we are overwhelmed. And sometimes our brains want the easiest thing. And so we reach for that easy thing. Especially if maybe you've heard maybe their parents labeled them lazy or last year's teacher. You know what I mean? Anyways, so she emailed me she had been thinking that this student was just lazy ⁓ just didn't want to be in the classroom at ⁓ because they're always, you know, going to the bathroom, missing a whole entire lesson. I would come back and be like, ⁓ guess we're not doing that anymore, right? But then after that episode, she thought, you know, I wonder if he's just not understanding. I wonder if he doesn't know, ⁓ what's happening. ⁓ And it was cool because I got the email back and forth. And so she started talking to the students she's starting to use non-verbal cues like they're like a thumb ⁓ one down and middle and they're doing a post-it notes. on the desk and I just think that's so fantastic, right? Because we really want to see our students for who they are then once we know who they are, lower that barrier of learning ⁓ them. So just thought that was super important and that was super great to hear. So well done Ashley, that's wonderful. Yeah, so ⁓ how schools define motivation? know, like the modern systems, you know, they're operating on a very simplistic assumption like student capable produced work consistently, right? Not student not producing work consistently, you know, must not care. And you know, that's I him. dichotomy really creates an incredibly harmful narrative around motivation. don't even believe in motivation. Like, I, ⁓ gosh, I don't believe in motivation. And maybe that's a bit simplistic, but like, so for instance, my husband would be like, I'm not going to gym. I'm not motivated. It's like, ⁓ like, are you just going to wait till you feel this thing called motivation to do things? No, like, of course not. And but my husband absolutely hates it when I say that. which is fine, but it is true or it's a simplified version of the truth because if you believe in motivation, what motivation is then is a friend that doesn't come around often. can't just call ⁓ this friend. We can't call on motivation. It shows up or doesn't. It shows up sometimes and we feel motivated and it doesn't show up and we don't feel motivated, but we still need to show up. We still to do the work. not a big fan of motivation. Let me know how you feel about it the comments or in the emails. be that'll be a really interesting one, I think. Anyways, We tend to interpret visible productivity as evidence of kind of like character, right? The organized student is responsible. The compliant student is hardworking. Whereas the struggling student is lazy. But human cognition is more complicated than that. And we know that, you know, a student can care absolutely deeply and still be unable to initiate tasks, right? A student can want success desperately and still shut down completely, right? A lot of these students that are potentially deemed as lazy, they're students that want to be at school. you know, they want to understand. They want to know what's going on, right? But then the flip is true, too, right? Like a student can appear apathetic really like inside they're experiencing enormous anxiety or stress or they're not sleeping and we can definitely see that when we tailor our lessons to some of our struggling students. You know, like for me, there's nothing more like, like I just love tailoring lessons and projects and things for students and like their individual like loves and like the things that they're super passionate about. And yeah, I just, I love it. But you know, you can do that for a student who's maybe struggling. and think, okay, so I'm gonna do my homework. I'm gonna learn about the students. What are they interested in? And then do this project based on their interest, put all this work into it, and then that student is still unable to initiate or start the assignments. And you're like, I so much work into this. It's so frustrating. I think this is really where schools fail to distinguish between can't ⁓ and. won't. So even if you're putting if you're doing something that should motivate the student right the students passion about this they want to learn about this you get you're gonna give them a project where they're doing and they still kind of initiate a task ⁓ that should tell you something right like so there's there's something there they need you know they need the steps they you need to start like curious ⁓ and thinking about is the student showing up. And I think also really ⁓ what does being cognitively overwhelmed actually like? Because ⁓ cognitive is not always dramatic. Sometimes it like ⁓ procrastination, task ⁓ incomplete work, emotional shutdown, That's a big one. Constant fatigue, disorganization, irritability, distraction, simply staring at a page unable to begin, right? And because schools are so output driven, these behaviors often get interpreted instead of neurologically. And ⁓ looks like us saying, well, they just need to apply themselves more. They need more discipline. They need They're capable of so much more than they're doing. Or they're just choosing not to do the work. If you're already overwhelmed, can you start something? Like think about it, think about your worst day, you're overwhelmed and everything, you get home. Can you cook a meal that takes 45 minutes? Or do you reach for something easy? Or do you get the phone and get like takeout? Right? Like, and we're adults. these students, they're ⁓ They're overwhelmed. Their brains are so ⁓ and noisy and there's so much going on, you know, and they're using so much of their brain space just to function, right? Just trying to sit on a chair and not be noticed and like fit in. especially this time of year when everyone's so tired there's so much going on you know and I know I know you can imagine like carrying anxiety ⁓ overload and sleep deprivation and social stress stress and academic pressure ⁓ emotional dysregulation and a feel of feeling of failure or fear of failure and fear of failure while also trying to perform cognitively six hours a day. I mean... six hours a day, five days a week. And that's like when I listed off all of those things, that's not even talking about did they eat breakfast, did they eat dinner, do take care of the younger siblings, do they take care of, you know, members of the family, right? Like there's so much going on in these students' lives. And there's so to really take into consideration. There's so much to for these students. And that's why getting to know them really helps. And sometimes you can get to know students and sometimes you can't. But then that's why this episode is so important because it really just, I think, makes us reflect and makes us think, you're right. The student's not lazy. The student's overwhelmed. How can I lower that barrier for them to be able to access their learning? Right? showing up. ⁓ Oh my good golly gosh, they've got so much going on in their brains and they're still showing up. They're not lazy. You know what I mean? At some point, the nervous system, it starts protecting itself. And sometimes protection looks like shutdown. And we need to remember that executive dysfunction is not laziness. This is one of the most, I think, misunderstood things in education. Executive functioning involves being able to start a task, planning, organizing. man, does it involve working memory. It's like your ability to hold things in your head while you're continuing to learn things. Do you know what I mean? I had a student last week. Last week? Yeah. We were It social studies. We were reading something. ⁓ the questions were based exactly on the text. So you read a paragraph, you answer one question from that paragraph, you read the next thing. And they're like, it's not a paragraph, it's not, you know, like one's about food, one's about culture, different things. And the student's like, so smart, I mean all students are so smart, so smart, he's like, I cannot hold this in my head. can't read it, hold it in my head, and then turn the page and write it down. And already, wow. ⁓ already highlighted what he needed to do. I hadn't even taught highlighting. So good. And I said, you've done great. You've highlighted it. And you realize that you can't keep it in your head. What can we do more? You know what I mean? Do you need another copy? Do you want to rip that page out so you can write it down? What's going to be better for you? And that takes a lot to understand who you are and what you need help with. Not a lot of kids will understand that. And we read it out loud too, right? So we read it out loud, read it to ourselves, did it to all these things, and they highlighted it. He did. But what do you do if you don't have all that knowledge about yourself? You haven't been given that language to help yourself with, right? So then you just think, I'm stupid. Or if you've been told that you're lazy, then you're like, this is proof that I'm lazy, right? And so, yeah, man. executive functioning skills are just interesting. So ⁓ ⁓ digress. working memory, ⁓ emotional regulation, attention, and cognitive flexibility. Right, so that's, all of those things executive functioning and it needing to, you know, be working at. capacity, shall we say. However, when executive functioning becomes overloaded, simple tasks can feel ⁓ ⁓ And is students will sometimes avoid starting assignments or forget their materials or miss their deadlines or completely freeze when asked to begin independent work. ⁓ not because they don't care, right? It's because their brain's management system is overwhelmed. It cannot do the thing. what makes this worse ⁓ that ⁓ further reduces executive functioning capacity. So the more students hear you're lazy, ⁓ need to try harder. you're wasting my time, you're wasting potential, then the harder it is, like the harder it becomes to access the skills they're being criticized for lacking. They have the skills, but now all of a sudden they're stressed out. They can't access it, right? And so like, yeah, okay, chronic stress. Here we go. Let's dive into it. I think schools underestimate how many students are functioning under chronic stress. There. I said it. We know that stress fundamentally changes our cognition. When students are chronically stressed, working memory decreases, attention becomes fragmented. You can tell I'm super passionate about this. If you're watching me on the screen, I'm like, gotten really close to it. Their ability to regulate themselves emotionally weakens. cognitive flexibility drops those ⁓ that may with motivation are disrupted. we talked about this already. Some ⁓ students carrying family instability, poverty, ⁓ food trauma. anxiety disorders, perfectionism, which I don't think we talk enough about, social isolation, or relentless pressure to perform. And then we ask them, why aren't you motivated? Why aren't you doing this? the nervous system is simply trying to survive, ⁓ ⁓ just trying to get through the day. I want, I'm happy to be here. I want to be here. It's safe. The routines are Simple. The toilets work. The water fountain has clean water. Right? Like all of these things. There's Kleenex on the desk. I've got everything I need. There's food. There are snacks. And we have to stop just piling it on these students. We have to stop freaking ourselves out over how much of the curriculum we've covered, how much more we need to cover. And we need to understand that if learning isn't full of for and for the students, if ⁓ If every day feels like a struggle and a slog, something's got to change. Because these students cannot take that on. And I know it's hard because we're getting it, but we cannot pass that on to our students. All right, I don't think we talked about perfectionism and avoidance. One of the biggest misconceptions in education is that think we think of these perfectionist students ⁓ like always high achieving students and not, right? Because know that students and adults, we know students who ⁓ experience perfectionism are to start a lot of tasks. They're unable to start tasks that they don't feel like they will be perfect in. ⁓ So I have a student that I work with. art is hard. Art ⁓ hard this student because it's never going to turn out like they want it to before they start. Right? And it becomes a struggle. And so we're on coping strategies. ⁓ And we're working on going through things where we have a lot of social stories and dialogue around how art is expressive and it doesn't look a certain way and different things like that. And I think that's a low stakes example, but also it's very, those, it's very real for that student as well, right? overwhelmed students tend avoid work because the ⁓ fear failing is intolerable. So instead of risking imperfection, they disengage completely. ⁓ often interpret that disengagement as laziness rather than ⁓ And think this is especially common in students who were previously tied their self-worth their achievements, or their parents did that, or experienced repeated academic pressure because eventually some students decide, I can't do it perfectly, ⁓ rather not do it at ⁓ And avoidance can look identical to apathy from the outside, especially if we're not looking for it because we're like, well, the student did this before. Why aren't they doing it now? They're clearly capable. ⁓ You're of doing this. You need to do it. You need to start. And then I think also the thing that really stresses ⁓ me out, probably the students too, is that like because there's this history, there's like a record of the student being able to do things, you don't think to chunk the work. You don't think to just give them the first step. You don't think to give them a checklist. You don't think to give them any of the supports that other students get because well this student doesn't need those supports. Now they do. You have found something that they are terrified to do. You now need to chunk their work and put in all those things in place that you've done for other students, right? Because, avoidance absolutely can look like apathy. However, ⁓ those students ⁓ experiencing enormous emotional distress. We can't see it. We might not understand it. but that's what they're experiencing. They cannot start because they're so scared. this also a bit heartbreaking too. When students repeatedly experience failure, criticism, overwhelm, or the that the effort that they're putting in doesn't seem to ever change the outcome, many of those students stop trying altogether, right? And once again, it's that hopelessness. And hopelessness can be adaptive, right? And so then what ends up happening? ⁓ we jump in. ⁓ let me help you with that. me start that with you. Let's start this together. Let's work on this. Or EA or TA, the adult in the room, if you're lucky enough to have one, works with them. And what that create? It creates learned ⁓ Because it's not that that student is incapable, can't do it, isn't smart enough. But when you jump in or when someone jumps in ⁓ just does it for them or helps them like, you know, whatever, that student then thinks, I'm stupid. I do this. The only way for me to be able to do this properly is with an adult. And then they're done. They stop trying. And that is the learning to helplessness. And it happens all the time. It happens with students all the time. It absolutely happened with my child. My child is absolutely capable, can do the things, all the stuff. You know, does get overwhelmed, doesn't understand things, but does not need someone to do the task for them or start the task for them. They need someone to check in, maybe give them a sentence starter. and leave and let the student it. Let them show you what they can do because I promise you they can do that. Okay. Once students reach this learned helplessness stage, those traditional motivation strategies often fail completely. then more pressure doesn't help. And more consequences don't help. Neither lectures about responsibility. ⁓ None that stuff helps. I always think when I'm listening to teachers do this, think, what are they? It just popped out my head. What's your goal? ⁓ What is your goal with saying that to a student? What is your goal with applying more pressure onto a student? What is your goal, you know, ⁓ them, talking to them about like responsibility? Like, is your goal, what is the goal? Because it really just kind of sounds like you're shaming the kid, right? Because you're turning it into like the issue is no longer motivation. ⁓ issue is the students belief in themselves, you know. If the student no longer believes that their effort leads to success, well, they're not gonna strive for success. You you need to make sure that these students know that they're smart or that you're telling them that they're smart. You're telling them they can do it and then you're giving them the tools to succeed. Okay, we're lowering the barrier to learning. And I think, know, schools really, ⁓ my good golly gosh, schools, and I know that it's like accidental. But it's creating this disengagement. ⁓ is the uncomfortable part of the conversation right ⁓ where these schools are unintentionally the very disengagement that they later punish, that they later shame students for. And they're doing this through excessive ⁓ workload rapid pacing. and fear-based grading and constant comparison. And I know you say, well, I'm not comparing these students. No, but these students are getting compared to each other in public in the classroom. are very aware of what's going on. And they're very aware of how you are interpreting all of the different things that are coming around in your classroom. And that really does create this public performance pressure. Students also experience a lack of autonomy, limited movement, and These are ⁓ that are prioritizing productivity over and being able to self-regulate. ⁓ ⁓ I really care so deeply about this. I really do. And I know that I get a bit scary when I care about things this much. But I just think, good golly gosh, how can students not be disengaged? How can students not be overwhelmed? Do you know? Like, there's just so much to do in school and in classes. And then we just, we absolutely wonder why students seem disconnected emotionally from learning. You know, human beings are not machines. know, motivation cannot thrive indefinitely under chronic stress and constant evaluation. ⁓ do students actually need? ⁓ know, these overwhelmed students, well, ⁓ know they don't need lower expectations. What they do need is emotional safety and you saying you're safe. They need to have felt safety. That's something new I learned this year because I work with amazing, and we all do work with amazingly smart people. And I know, like I've been saying for years, I'm sure you all have, we've all learned like when students don't feel safe, they're not gonna take risks. So you create safe environments. And I always stopped it at that, like create the safe environment, create the community, you know, like. student voice and choice and all of these things and I firmly believe that and I teach like that too but I never understood that students had to have felt safety and it just blew my mind and it might seem simple to you but it was just like you can have the best conditions and maybe a student will feel safe one day and they won't have that felt safety the next day or how quickly felt safety can go away. so what do students need? Students need safety, co-regulation, ⁓ pathways to learning, explicit instruction for executive and explicit support with executive functioning. Students need opportunities for success and leadership. They need the shame, right? Like reduce the shame that students ⁓ Students also need their nervous system regulation and that separate worth from productivity. Okay. Let's go back and talk about executive functioning support. You might think, what is executive functioning support? Executive functioning support is the things you're probably already doing, right? It's the visual schedule. It's the timeline. Students know what's happening. They understand what the transition is. It's using the same It's the same rules, the same breakdowns, everything ⁓ you do every day. It's the, okay, you know, ⁓ ⁓ It's math time. Put your language arts books away. Get your math to a tings. Everyone start on their daily math and then we'll get into the lesson. know, whatever it is, all that stuff is executive functioning support. I still firmly believe in having a poster on your door. So when you open the door, it says you need water bottle, book, pencil to be ready so that they see it. It's there all the time. Anything that's constantly reminding them so they have less. They need to use their working memory less for those things so they can more cognitive for when they're doing their learning. ⁓ That's super important. And I think opportunities for success. What does look like? It could be as simple as taking the late slips to the office, whatever it is that your students can access success for, because that's the motivation, right? Like the feeling of success, the feeling feeling good, right? And it can be very small, the thing that can make you feel good, but then you're gonna feel that elusive motivation. students need help breaking tasks down. They need movement breaks. They to see the sunshine. They need rest. They need that nook. And ⁓ they accommodations. That's why we have Universal Sports. Students need genuine emotional connection before they can engage academically, okay? Before success academically can be possible. I think really important, support is not the same thing as enabling. We really need to stop saying we're enabling students. Helping students access learning is not lowering standards. Lowering the bar to access learning is not lowering your standards. It's everyone ⁓ Everyone deserves to learn. so here we are. Here is, you know, ⁓ the things that you need to access learning. We're not going to like, it's this idea that like, ⁓ well, I'm not going to buy a high chair for a baby. They can sit on a regular chair. No, can't. ⁓ But still need to eat. Right. Whatever need to do to lower the ⁓ barrier for so that they the students can still learn. That's ⁓ What needs to happen? the barrier. Don't remove the expectation. Okay, so let's talk about what teachers are up against. again, I really just want to say this clearly. ⁓ are not causing this, right? We are all operating inside of this system that is built around output, not just for students, but for us to compliance, pacing guys, standardized assessments, ⁓ shortages. and impossible workload demands. We're working against chronic underfunding. We're working for people that understand that every classroom needs an EA but won't give it to us. We're working in a system that understands that every school should have a full-time counselor but they don't give it to us. It's so interesting, isn't it? And yet we put all this pressure on students, they do, right? So many teachers, I know you all deeply understand that what overwhelmed students are going through because you're going through it. We're all overwhelmed. I think that's part of why I'm so passionate about this conversation and why this conversation feels so emotionally charged right now with where we are in education. ⁓ is not only happening to the students, it's happening to us. And it's happening on a huge ⁓ scale. And how we leverage that to understand about how we can support our students, one of the most dangerous things we can do to children is to confuse struggle with character failure. because once students believe that they are lazy, they stop what did I wrong here? And those are really questions, right? Because feeling like you're lazy, it create shame. Whereas feeling like, I just missed a step, you know, that just feels like, oh, okay, I just need to like go back or ask for some help. I think as part of that we need to understand that students aren't refusing to learn. actually, ⁓ exhausted and overloaded ⁓ that's creating this regulation and that is creating them bothering students ⁓ and a These students are discouraged. They're terrified of failing or failing again. And if the that are in place right now continue to ⁓ interpret nervous system overload as some sort of moral weakness, going to keep losing students who were incapable of learning in the first place. They were just overwhelmed. And I think that's really, that's a problem. So thank you so much for listening today. And if you like this episode, please subscribe so you don't miss the next one. And if you were a student who spent years believing you were lazy when you were actually overwhelmed, I hope this conversation has helped put language to something that you felt but never fully understood. You deserve support and not shame. I will see you next time.