Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Fain Files Against Trump-Musk, Auto Credit Tightens, AI Becoming A Turn-Off
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning. It is Wednesday, August 14th. We're talking about fun stuff today: Fain, Trump, Musk, auto credit tightening, and AI becoming a consumer turnoff.
- 0:13Everywhere I go, the people really wanna know. What could possibly go wrong? Wow. They stop and stare when they see me roll by. What could possibly go wrong this morning in the news? I know. You can't avoid the politics.
- 0:21[laughs] It's not really- I mean, it's political- Ah... but it's auto. You know. We were just having a blast talking about this live feed from a Waymo lot in San Francisco.
- 0:30[laughs] We're gonna talk about it on tomorrow's show, I think. We're just gonna- It didn't make it today's show, but- Oh... I think it's just because we didn't all watch it together. [laughs] Right. Tomorrow.
- 0:38Once- and once we started watching it, we were like, "We could just talk about this for 20 minutes." Tomorrow. [laughs] Tomorrow. Tune in tomorrow for- for the hot takes on the- I'll start placing bets...
- 0:46Waymo whole, all right. [gasps] Oh, my gosh. Which one gets out first? Oh. Oh, my goodness. That's good. All the people are still all... Now everyone's like, "When are they talking about?"
- 0:55We're gonna gamify- we're gonna gamify this at ASOTU CON. If you didn't know, uh, the- you can go to asotucon.com right now, and you can see a little bit of a taste of the new aesthetic that's coming in 2025 in May.
- 1:07You can actually put your name on the first to know list. Uh, names every day.
- 1:10We're watching the ticker every day, names coming in, people saying, "I wanna be first to know what's going on at ASOTU CON," so, uh, never too early, right? It's May. Summer's over. Let's go. Summer's over.
- 1:20Is ASOTU CON- I'm telling you what-... officially in the spring? It is officially in the spring. Or the fall, one of the two. Uh- No, ASOTU CON's in the spring. Oh, it's- ASOTU CON's in the spring.
- 1:29[laughs] I'll tell you what, there's like... I was actually talking to a buddy last night, and I started just thinking through all of the things that happened toward the fall.
- 1:37I mean, we've got this thing in our daily email that's saying where we're gonna be, and it only has four. I think we're gonna be at, like, eight different places this fall. Yeah.
- 1:44But you start to line that up, and everybody else is, like, jockeying for where you're gonna be, what you're gonna be doing- Yeah... how you're gonna prep for the new year.
- 1:52Like, dealers are trying to figure out training protocols because of new... Yeah, I mean, it's- Yeah... like, the moving parts st- get going midway through August because- It's a thing...
- 2:01you get through that selling season, and it's like, all right, what's next? You know? It- it- it's go- I don't even know what to expect, but it's gonna be cool.
- 2:07Also, um, we're get- we're gearing up for season two of, uh, the More Than Cars docuseries. We have an episode- Oh, yeah... to release tail end of season one. Season two, uh, dealers are starting to line up.
- 2:18Uh, hand- if you are interested in bringing the show to your store, just reach out, crew@asotu.com. Uh, we have some stuff. We packaged together some new things. It's a lot of fun.
- 2:28Uh, and we may have a couple of announcements, uh, as season two- Hey... starts to shape up. And, uh, yeah, I think that's enough for the morning. People need- That's enough... people need the news.
- 2:38Air quotes, people need the news. All right, let's do it. Need the news. Need the news this morning. Yeah, yeah. [laughs] Uh, well, let's talk about it.
- 2:45The UAW has filed federal labor charges against former President Donald Trump and Tesla CEO Elon Musk, incue- accusing them of imp...
- 2:55Okay, I'm gonna accuse you of implied threatening actions [laughs] against striking workers on, uh, basically, Elon Musk had Donald Trump on a, uh, Spaces, a s- space, an X Space. Is that what we call it?
- 3:08It used to be called Twitter Spaces, which is a live- Yeah... conversation. Over a million people were a part of this live conversation.
- 3:14Trump suggested that employers could handle striking workers simply by firing them all. He described the scenario where, in response to a strike, an employer would tell workers, "That's okay.
- 3:23You're all gone," implying that all strike- striking workers would be dismissed.
- 3:27Uh, Musk, while not directly quoted in the charges, has a history of anti-union statements and sentiments, further fueling the union's concern.
- 3:35Under federal law, as a reminder, employees conduct, can conduct lawful strikes for economic reasons, such as higher wages.
- 3:41They can't be discharged for that action by their employers, but in certain instances can be replaced.
- 3:47Um, the charges aim to highlight the UAW stance that Musk and Trump oppose workers' rights and are unlikely to have any practical impact. Like, they don't, these things don't have a lot of teeth.
- 3:56It's more of a political statement. UAW president, you know him, you love him, Shawn Fain. He stated, "When we say Trump stands against everything our union stands for, this is what we mean."
- 4:09Bring back the Eat the Rich T-shirts. [laughs] Wow. It- it- it- He- he didn't say that last part. That was mine. Bring back the Eat the Rich T-shirts. That was- that was added for impact, right? Yeah, yeah.
- 4:17A- added emphasis. For impact. [laughs] Yeah, whatever it is. So what's so interesting about this one to me is, like, the positioning of implication, right? Yes. Yeah. Nothing's actually been done here.
- 4:28There's no legal paperwork. There's no, like, this is what we feel or say. And I think honestly- No, they did file a thing. They did file a thing. Well, they filed a thing. Yeah. But on, like, the Elon- Oh...
- 4:42Trump- Yeah, yeah, yeah... side, it's just, like, words said at a rally basically, right? Tru- And- and Musk never even said anything in that interaction. Exactly. They said he left.
- 4:50Yeah, I- I think what this points to is that there is this growing sentiment where kind of, like, the net new EV manufacturers and the legacy manufacturers and even some of their subsidiaries have this, like, battle and jockeying for position, and it- and it goes all the way into the political spectrum.
- 5:08Yeah. I would, uh, you know, I, like, I think the- the- the turn here is, at a localized level, recognize that I don't think consumers are caught up in that battle as much. Not at all. I don't think they are at all.
- 5:23And- and they are just looking for their next best vehicle. That's it. And they're considering both almost at equal weights. You run into so many consumers where they're like, "You know the Ford dealership."
- 5:36"Well, which Ford dealership?" "No, no, no, the- the Ford dealership." Ford, you know, owned by Ford- Right... the company with the F-O-R-D blue oval. Exactly. Yeah.
- 5:42And- and they- they see, like, the majority of consumers, now some or some brands that- that lean in really, really well, but the majority of consumers just see a Ford dealership like a McDonald's outlet, right? Mm-hmm.
- 5:53Like a McDonald's franchise.
- 5:55And- and so, like, this type of political or relational positioning between legacy manufacturers and- and EVs and how even their unions are structured and how their workers are structured does not really seep into the consumer matrix.
- 6:11Mm-hmm. And so as-... dealership employees. We should not be considering that in, like, how we go to market or how we kind of, like, position ourselves. It's really just, you know- Mm-hmm...
- 6:22it's always competitive conquest. That's true. You know, I don't know if there's anything else to add. I think this has a l- just a lot to do with the state of Michigan, honestly. [laughs] Like, r- really.
- 6:34I mean, it, it's a, it's a battleground state. Like, if, if you- And so, like, OEMs get looped into it. You know, workers get you- looped into it. People get leveraged. And Sean Fain's on the cover- Look-...
- 6:45of Automotive News today. So, like- I'm-... he's happy... I'm from, I'm from Ohio. And so if you want, if you wanna throw stones at Michigan, you feel free. Yeah. [laughs] Speaking of feeling free- Stop.
- 6:56Or not free- Segway. Less than free. [upbeat music] Uh, we love our daily email. Uh, if you don't get it, asotu.com. You should. Today, it highlighted some recent Cox Automotive data.
- 7:08Auto credit availability has been tightening for now for four consecutive months, creating challenges for dealers as customers find it increasingly difficult to secure loans, especially for used vehicles.
- 7:19Dealertrack Credit Avail- Availability Index dropped to 92.9% in July, which is down a full percentage point from June, and a point and a half down year over year.
- 7:29So, continuing trend is used car loans, um, through franchise dealers are seeing the most significant tightening. Banks are leading the way in tightening credit, marking the fifth consecutive month in stricter lending.
- 7:41Mm. The spread between the auto loan interest rates and other investments has also widened, making loans less appealing for consumers especially.
- 7:48Or additionally, more buyers are dealing with negative equity, asking for, you know, further risk from lenders, tighter restrictions, higher interest rates.
- 7:57Consumer sentiment sees some optimism about the future, but concerns over the current economic situation at large, including high vehicle prices, interest rates in general, could potentially dampen the sideline buyer's willingness to make a purchase.
- 8:11Yeah. If you're in a store, you're probably experiencing this already, so it's not new news.
- 8:15But, um, the, the way to look at this is most likely, uh, mid-prime and subprime lending is getting restricted at this point, right?
- 8:23Prime lending is not as restrictive, except for there is restriction happening on the loan-to-value rate.
- 8:29So, you know, the important takeaway from this is that when you are looking at putting the customer on the right vehicle, or structuring the right loan, or understanding the negative equity going into a deal, it's important to understand the entire deal structure- Mm-hmm...
- 8:44so that you have the best possible of opportunity of going into the negotiation or financing or, or, you know, the acquisition of credit, you know, with the best foot forward.
- 8:54Because you recognize, like, hey, loan-to-values are, you know, uh, shrinking. Banks aren't as willy-nilly with their 130s, 135, 140%, uh, you know, carries.
- 9:06And also, when you look at sub and midprime, you've gotta be on the right vehicle with the right equity position- Oh... to be able to acquire that loan. So it's really, like, a strategic thing from hello- Mm...
- 9:18on understanding the customer, understanding their needs and wants, and understanding the potential deal structure so that you can head into the finance office appropriately.
- 9:26And they're not sponsoring the show, but our good friend Matt Lasher over at West Herr and the team there do have a product called Streamline that helps with this exact issue, and I'm sure they're seeing an uptick, that helps, like, show customers vehicles based on what will actually get bought because no two $20,000 cars are the same.
- 9:45Not at all. Yep. That's for sure. Speaking of not at all- Stop Or not a lot- Segway. Time. [upbeat music] Contrary to the NADA show floor, a recently study reveals- [laughs]...
- 9:58that the term artificial intelligence or AI in marketing is increasingly a red flag for consumers, suggesting a growing skepticism toward AI-powered products.
- 10:07Uh, the study surveyed 1,000 adults, which is kind of the, the, uh, Gallup results and, and the way the actuaries love it, um, that AI mentions lowered product appeal.
- 10:17Emotional trust drops significantly when AI is referenced, reducing purchase intentions. Uh, AI in high-risk purchases, like electronics or medical devices, exacerbates safety s- concerns right now.
- 10:30Uh, Forrester's December 2023 survey, so a bit ago, shows a split in consumer sentiment with only 29% trusting Gen AI and 73% demanding transparency when companies use AI.
- 10:43Um, a lead author and clinical of- assistant professor of marketing at Washington State University, Mesa Cekic, uh, said, "When AI is mentioned, it tends to lower emotional trust, which in turn decreases purchase intentions."
- 10:55How about that? Really interesting in c- in comparison to maybe the B2B results of something like this. Absolutely. And so, like, I think everyone's very anxious to use the, the, the letters AI in- Mm-hmm...
- 11:08in, like, hey, to show... I mean, obviously, the stock market momentum behind it, to show that we're forward-thinking, we're thinking of the customer, we're thinking of you.
- 11:16But this saying, when consumers hear it, they don't hear the same thing the business managers hear, right? They hear- Isn't that wild? They, they're like, "Eh,
- 11:24eh," because I think everyone's had that experience with some AI bot, right, where it's delivered some weird thing, or it's janky, or it's slow. And, like, the question, like, "Am I talking to a human?"
- 11:35comes up probably more- Yes... in the chats. And especially, it makes sense. The more, the more expensive a purchase or technical a purchase, you might start to question.
- 11:43Because anyone who's used, like, ChatGPT understands that, you know, quote-unquote, "hallucinations" are a real thing, where all of a sudden it starts feeding you information- I'm telling you...
- 11:52and you're like, "Is that real? Is it not real?" You're like, "Huh?"
- 11:55You know, the, the thing that frustrates me, honest- like, you, you see, like, Meta AI, and you see some of these, like, public, public-facing consumer brands, Gemini coming into Google search, right- Mm...
- 12:06becoming a little bit more widespread. Um, you know, and then, like, in the Olympics, I was watching Salesforce, you know, promote their AI because so many users out there are on Salesforce- Yeah...
- 12:17for their business interactions. But, um, the interesting thing to me here is, uh, that so much of AI is baked into chat products. Oh, yeah.
- 12:28And I'm telling you what, that is the place where I get most frustrated not talking to a human.
- 12:33And I understand the, the g- the gap between, like, human payment for things that can possibly be automated, like the, the, you know, the skills matrix- Yep... of needing to train and hire humans versus allowing an AI.
- 12:47But, uh, Josh Orr just, uh, i- in the LinkedIn comments said, "Human empathy and genuine connection will forever be the driving factor of sales, period" And I completely agree.
- 12:57Like, if you can figure out the human capital equation of leveraging AI in a B2B scenario to have your B2C scenario be humanly empathetic- Ooh... that's the win. There you go. I agree.
- 13:11[upbeat music] But look, we can guarantee one thing. There is zero AI in this show, where you and I- That's right... and Kyle are talking. Zero. We are real people. You are real people. This is us.
- 13:21Go out there, serve some real people. See how that works? [upbeat music]