Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: The trouble with transmission, new hope for Lindsey and running out of space in the North Sea.
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:04podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:08the UK energy market. Tenuous headlines.
- 0:11Sorry, Tenuous continues to make headlines.
- 0:14Lindsay gets an update as it goes off to court and we discuss
- 0:19the future of regulators in the North Sea.
- 0:21That's an awful lot to discuss if you're just me.
- 0:23Aberdeen features lead Ryan Duff, but thankfully, I'm joined
- 0:26by our crack team of experts starting us off as news editor.
- 0:31Erica Asklyn. How are you doing today, Erica?
- 0:33Hi, well I'm I'm suffering but powering through.
- 0:36But I will insist upon starting to use the word tenuous with
- 0:42whenever we're talking about, you know, that weird acronym
- 0:44that, uh, Ofgem has come up with to describe, uh, the current
- 0:48system of, uh, network charges. Just because it makes me laugh.
- 0:53Do you know what? I think there's the only person
- 0:55in the world that can tell us exactly what that acronym means.
- 0:58That's renewables reporter Michael Bear.
- 1:00How are you doing today? I'm nervous now because I think
- 1:02I've you've challenged me to do this and I genuinely feel like
- 1:05I'm going to forget it one day. Come on, we're going to put you
- 1:08on the spot. Michael, what does Tenuous stand
- 1:10for? Transmission network use of
- 1:13system, yes. There we are.
- 1:15Look at that. OK, you could.
- 1:16You could stay, Michael. You could.
- 1:17Stay. I need that on a post it note
- 1:19just overlooking me whenever I'm working.
- 1:21I think you should have a tattoo on your ass I feel.
- 1:25Like that'd be difficult to read if it's across his ass.
- 1:28Eric True. But anyway.
- 1:30So yeah, we're we are we are discussing tenuos tenuous
- 1:34transmission charging. It's a it's a it goes by many,
- 1:37many names. We got some updates this week,
- 1:40but it's been a long running issue.
- 1:41We saw W West of Orkney earlier this year.
- 1:44Scrap or quote UN quote pause investment.
- 1:47So, Erica, what's been happening this week?
- 1:49Right. So this week Scottish Renewables
- 1:52pulled out the kind of definitive report about tenuous
- 1:57transmission charges, highlighting why any energy
- 2:02production in Scotland has to pay to access the grid versus
- 2:08any energy production facilities in the England or particularly
- 2:13the South of England in some areas of Wales get paid to
- 2:17produce their energy and send it to the grid.
- 2:19Which is now going to be a huge problem for any energy developer
- 2:25in Scotland, particularly any project that is involved with
- 2:29Scotland. Maybe not in TOG so much because
- 2:32they get different off takers. However, it was actually quite
- 2:36crazy. So, you know, Scottish nubles,
- 2:41uh, have pulled together this or have found that commissioned
- 2:44this report and they reckon that so far since 2016, umm, energy
- 2:49producers in uh, Scotland have paid 2.9 billion more, uh, than
- 2:54their uh, counterparts in, uh, you know, further South, uh,
- 2:59because just of this charging regime, which of course was
- 3:03established, you know, way back in the dark ages of time and was
- 3:08basically designed in order to ensure that, you know, coal,
- 3:13coal power stations, gas station power stations and nuclear
- 3:18stations were built closer to areas of population and in order
- 3:24to kind of benefit them. So, umm, the problem this
- 3:27emerges. So I'd had been speaking to
- 3:29Ocean Winds off and on. I mean, of course they're
- 3:32Scotland's largest current, umm, offshore wind developer.
- 3:36Uh, you know, they've got two major projects in the Murray
- 3:40Firth umm, and those are producing.
- 3:43Uh, Michael's been up there a few times actually, and it's
- 3:46really kind of an interesting project.
- 3:48But of course what they're saying is since they decided to
- 3:52take a financial investment decision on Murray East and
- 3:55Murray W charges have gone up fourfold.
- 3:59And you know what? It's not even something that you
- 4:00can predict, which of course makes blows a hole in any sort
- 4:05of projections, any sort of finances, any economic.
- 4:09So, you know, as ocean winds are finding and as you know, the
- 4:14developers behind West of Orkney are finding, they're kind of
- 4:18going, you know what, Scotland, we like this.
- 4:20We put a lot of money into it and put a lot of planning and
- 4:22effort into it. But we don't think the economics
- 4:25are going to stack up unless Tenuous is reformed.
- 4:28And now of course, you know, Tenuous, of course, is managed
- 4:32by Ofgem and it's also, you know, safeguarded by Nisa, which
- 4:37should know better. You know, they are the state
- 4:39owned, uh, network operator and they're like going, ah, you know
- 4:43what? We're not going to bother to fix
- 4:45it until 2029, which is far too late for any offshore wind farm
- 4:49that wants to maybe submit to AR-8, maybe even AR 9 because,
- 4:55umm, you know, it's impossible. It makes it impossible and very,
- 4:59very difficult to figure out how much it's going to work.
- 5:01Well, I mean, it's, it's, it's like, you know, sort of setting
- 5:03up any business in your, your supply chain costs go through
- 5:06the roof. It's kind of like that.
- 5:07And and that's in a time where offshore wind is already having
- 5:11it's literal supply chain costs go through the roof, it's
- 5:14operating costs to increase. Although these are not supply
- 5:16chain. Costs supply.
- 5:18Chain costs are the function of the market.
- 5:20This is a function of a supine regulator that just can't be
- 5:23asked to fix things, in my opinion.
- 5:26You know, it's very, you know, I don't know, OK.
- 5:28So I'm going to put it on, put the cards on the table.
- 5:31You know, policy, you know, is often drafted up by, you know,
- 5:35kind of wine bars in London. You know, by people who've come
- 5:40out of university and have absolutely no real life
- 5:44experience and have no cognizance of what, you know,
- 5:47investors, employers, engineers really want or what actually
- 5:51really works. Sorry, I'm going to stop.
- 5:53That tell us what you really think, Erica.
- 5:55But no, I think it is, it is an interesting point, right?
- 5:58Because yeah, the whole idea of Scotland was it was meant to
- 6:01help us deliver our 2030 win targets.
- 6:03And if we're not reforming until 29, that's never going to
- 6:06happen. You don't, you don't put up a
- 6:08wind farm in a year, that's not not going to happen at all.
- 6:11And when you're looking at what developers say in, in the UK,
- 6:16when wind resource in Scotland is very strong, got a strong
- 6:21capability for generation, but if the numbers don't add up, you
- 6:25just don't do it. Michael, you were looking at a
- 6:28slightly broader stroke report this week as well.
- 6:32Michael's got a much more measured approach I.
- 6:34Think, yeah, you're not going to tell tell us that, that Chris
- 6:37Stark should know better, as Erica said, are you?
- 6:40I mean, go for it if you think that's right.
- 6:43From what I've heard, it's not even a case that anyone should
- 6:46know better. From what I've understood,
- 6:47there's I think someone gave me a quote that might be about 20
- 6:50people in the entire UK who actually understand how tenuous
- 6:55charges work. Like what?
- 6:56Whatever algorithm is used, but you know, it is, you know, to
- 7:01provide a slightly more concrete example, because we've always
- 7:03been hearing Erica from ocean winds West of Orkney, you know,
- 7:08being developed by Corio. They, you know, recently said
- 7:11like we can't go ahead with this project until these charges are
- 7:14dealt with. We know that they're increasing,
- 7:16but Inchcape produced a report recently that was looking at
- 7:21basic the investment of the project, but topped away in
- 7:25their, in their stats of like, oh, we're going to invest, you
- 7:28know, £8 billion over the, the course of the lifetime of the
- 7:32project. It's gave a concrete example of
- 7:35how much tenuous charges are affecting it.
- 7:38I think the example they gave was that they're going to spend
- 7:41about £130 million a year operating the the project and
- 7:46about 40% of those costs are going to be just in servicing
- 7:52tenuous charges, so about £55,000,000 a year.
- 7:55And when you think about the economics of it, you know, the
- 7:58whole point of an offshore wind farm relative to say another
- 8:02form of, of power is that, you know, they are relatively cheap
- 8:06to run. You don't have to worry about
- 8:07gas prices or uranium. You don't have to bring in quite
- 8:10as many people to run it. They are theoretically going to
- 8:14be cheaper to run. So if that is now half more or
- 8:17less of the the cost of running it, it really does start to eat
- 8:21into the economics. Especially when you consider the
- 8:23fact that offshore wind farms are funded through the the
- 8:26contract for difference mechanism, the CFD, which I
- 8:29believe was pushed up to 20 years in AR 7.
- 8:33So basically you have a fixed income for 20 years against this
- 8:39massive volatile cost. The, as you know, as I pointed
- 8:42out, we're not even completely sure how it's calculated and
- 8:46it's incredibly hard to predict. You know, it's basically the
- 8:49idea of like you renting or getting a mortgage, but the bank
- 8:52or the landlord is just rolling dice every every month to see
- 8:55what you're you have to pay. You can.
- 8:58Excellent metaphor. Yeah.
- 8:59You can't budget on that, which is why the, you know, so many of
- 9:04these developers are saying, look, we need to, we need to
- 9:08bring forward reform. And, you know, I think we, we
- 9:11were at the offshore wind conference in Glasgow last month
- 9:14and, you know, I think we had Chris Stark up on stage with a
- 9:18couple of developers and he's a politician.
- 9:22He has to be careful with his words.
- 9:23We're journalists, we, we don't have to be careful with our
- 9:25words. I think he told them to, to kick
- 9:28rocks. I think he said that no, we are
- 9:30going to focus on getting it right and not including quick
- 9:33fixes this year or the next. It does look like they are going
- 9:37to have to wait to get these reforms in.
- 9:39But then, but then as I said, you know, the, the started the
- 9:42whole idea of Scotland. Yeah, I mean it was the leases
- 9:44were handed out in 2022 and Erica mentioned in Target how
- 9:48that's not as affected the majority of the resources and
- 9:51because that was targeted oil and gas.
- 9:53But then even even with that, we're seeing the Target oil and
- 9:57gas projects like Greenville looking to actually just on
- 10:00shore. It's it's when generation power
- 10:03because it's not finding oil and gas assets to decarbonize.
- 10:08And then we've got the innovation projects, which we're
- 10:10always going to bring power to shore.
- 10:12It does see what there's an awful lot of resource that's
- 10:15that's being told to as you put kick rocks.
- 10:18And so if these projects are delayed, is it about time to
- 10:22start thinking, well, those wind targets, people have been saying
- 10:25that ambitious for a long time. We need to either push them back
- 10:29or reduce them to a scale that we've already had.
- 10:33Who knows? Or build nuclear plants instead,
- 10:36because, you know, that's what I think they're trying to do.
- 10:38But anyway, you know, that's a different thing all together.
- 10:40I think that's about it. We can probably talk about, you
- 10:43know, we have to move on to the next exciting subject.
- 10:45What's that? Well, so Floyd March, our NW
- 10:48correspondent, has been looking into Lindsay.
- 10:50So I'm going to be catching up with him just after this break
- 10:53on exactly that. Hello, I'm Edrey, the editor of
- 10:57E Forward. E Forward is a membership
- 11:00community that brings together the entire UK energy supply
- 11:03chain, every hub, every sector, every stage.
- 11:06Our aim is to deliver growth to the energy sector, working with
- 11:09industry and policymakers to unlock the UKF opportunities and
- 11:13advantages. This is the movement to secure
- 11:16increased investment, improved policy making and better
- 11:20collaboration by providing our members with visibility,
- 11:23influence and access. Join me forward today.
- 11:28So Floyd, you were a bit late to the introduction Chitty chatty
- 11:32bit at the start of the show, but NW correspondent Floyd March
- 11:35is joining me. How you doing today mate?
- 11:37Yeah, I'm more good. I'm good.
- 11:38I didn't miss the the chin that I missed the chin wag this
- 11:41morning because there's there's always some good stuff.
- 11:43But yeah, I'm glad to be on partially late post edit.
- 11:46No one will know. So, so we're all good.
- 11:49Yeah, exactly. The the important thing is we
- 11:51didn't tell them that we're recording this after the rest of
- 11:53the interview, the rest of the podcast, we're all good.
- 11:57You know, I did. I did sorry, throw ahead to you
- 12:01just before the break about about Lindsay court case.
- 12:06There's a you know, it feels like this.
- 12:08It felt like this saga was coming to an end, the takeover
- 12:11tribulations and now it's back. What's actually happened?
- 12:16Yeah, so, so like you mentioned, everyone thought that the the
- 12:19saga was over. Phillips 66 agreeing to to buy
- 12:22the the Lindsay refinery with the deal expected to go through
- 12:26kind of halfway through 2026. Everyone kind of thought, well,
- 12:30this is that the mothball in the site, they're going to use it
- 12:32for extra storage. You know, jobs are going to get
- 12:35lost. It's just like, you know, not
- 12:37great, but that's just what we've got to deal with type
- 12:39thing. But but yeah, the Mark Hamrun
- 12:41Consortium, who we probably bullied too much on this
- 12:44podcast, sent me through some documents to, to to show that
- 12:50they're taking an issue with the process in which Philips 66 was
- 12:53awarded the the keys to the refinery, if you like.
- 12:56But they've also raised an urgent matter to try and protect
- 13:02jobs for a little bit longer. So when the sale was announced
- 13:06and Philips 66 said that the the refinery won't be operational
- 13:10anymore, the government said until March the 250 remaining
- 13:15jobs will be safe. Obviously, you know, we're in
- 13:18March next week. So who knows when when that's
- 13:20all going to kick off and the job losses are going to be
- 13:23announced. So they've kind of filed A
- 13:26complaint to the High Court to try and force the government to
- 13:30extend the period of time where the job would be saved for.
- 13:33Obviously, you know, that's what everyone's going to want.
- 13:36But if Philip 66 on mothball in the site, then, you know, the
- 13:40jobs aren't really going to be safe past March.
- 13:42You know, if the deal goes through in June or July, you
- 13:45know, another month isn't really going to do much for for the
- 13:48workers. So yeah, that, that was the the
- 13:53top line really of the documents that got sent through.
- 13:55And it yeah, it got sent through when I was watching the Man
- 13:58United Everton game, which was absolute dross.
- 13:59So yeah, it kept me entertained through the 90 minutes reading
- 14:02through what they sent over. Obviously you weren't there at
- 14:06the end of the top segment, but we were speaking about football
- 14:09at the end of that as well. And, you know, so I know.
- 14:11Sorry, it isn't. It's it's going to happen.
- 14:14Spoilers listener. We already recorded the end,
- 14:17too. I'm really bad at keeping the
- 14:19curtain. So, yeah, when it comes to
- 14:23Phillips, Phillips 66 and his takeover, like you say, there's
- 14:27a mothball in the site. Jobs are going to be lost.
- 14:31Is, is this court case specifically just about delaying
- 14:34the inevitable or is there a campaign to do something like
- 14:39we've seen in Grangemouth with the sort of funding that the
- 14:43Scottish and UK governments have put forward to try and create
- 14:47jobs in the region or support people?
- 14:48That the Scottish Government launched a, an initiative worth
- 14:51about 20 odd £1,000,000 to try and make sure that companies
- 14:56that are hiring within the area are essentially going to
- 15:00prioritize the people who have lost their jobs at Grangemouth
- 15:04and sort of guarantee job interviews and that type of
- 15:06thing. Is that part of their plea or is
- 15:09it just push back the inevitable?
- 15:11Yeah, just just just that simply there was, there was nothing to
- 15:14suggest that like, oh, we need to like have a wider plan.
- 15:17And I know that there are a couple of sites and and one in
- 15:21Scunthorpe, I believe, but the the place eludes me right now
- 15:25that are taking on some of the people that have lost their jobs
- 15:28at the Lindsay or refinery. But yeah, this specific case has
- 15:32got kind of nothing to do with that.
- 15:34And it is obviously worth noting that the Mark Cameron Consortium
- 15:38did attempt to buy the refinery and they've been snubbed.
- 15:41So, you know, there there is that to consider and the fact
- 15:44that they're like, you know, filing a complaint against the
- 15:46decision to to award Phillips 66 the keys.
- 15:50But another caveat in this long, long saga is, is the fact that
- 15:55Wood Mackenzie said that and basically anyone that I've
- 15:58spoken to about the Lindsay or refinery, it was profitable.
- 16:02It was a profitable site. So that's where a lot of key
- 16:07decisions from the government and from the official receiver
- 16:11to award Philips 66 when there was always clear that it
- 16:15wouldn't be operational. That's where this dramas kind of
- 16:18come in because there were bids maybe not as expensive, not as
- 16:23big as the Phillips 66 big bid to keep the refinery
- 16:27operational. So that that's the core issue in
- 16:29this whole argument and and drama around the Lindsay or
- 16:32refinery. It wasn't some big failed
- 16:34refinery that needs to shut, essentially.
- 16:38Yes, See, this is the thing that I think is, is very different to
- 16:41the situation that, you know, we saw up in Scotland with
- 16:45Grangewith, because I didn't see anything on that at the time
- 16:48about, Oh yeah, this could keep going.
- 16:50It was very much, well, it's not working anymore.
- 16:54So now we need to look at sustainable aviation fuel or
- 16:57hydrogen or whatever else. And there's been a lot of
- 16:59different discussions about what we're doing at Grangemouth, you
- 17:04know, for, for context for the listeners.
- 17:06It's worth is worth mentioning, like you say that that Mark
- 17:10Hammer and sort of put in this bed, it's a really strange bed
- 17:14that was kind of like opera. It was a private public
- 17:18partnership with government that essentially outlined, we'll, you
- 17:24know, we can take the profits, but you'll take the operating
- 17:26costs, which didn't sound like a good deal at all at the time.
- 17:31And they've lost out on that. Have you have you spoken to
- 17:35anyone obviously in your capacity in the northwest of
- 17:38user looked looked into this and gone, you know, was there was
- 17:43the writing always on the wall for Phillips 66.
- 17:46They always felt at the front runner in this sort of sales
- 17:49process. But if Mark Cameron or any
- 17:53similar sort of body put, put forward a deal to take on the
- 17:58refinery and you know, run it as is or expand it or whatever it
- 18:03has to do to sort of make the profit margins that would
- 18:07continue operations. Was that would that have been
- 18:12preferential or have you you heard anything on that?
- 18:15Well, well, I mean straight straight off the bat Philips 66
- 18:18makes sense. They've got a the Humber
- 18:20refinery basically next door that is profitable that is run
- 18:23well. If you look from the government
- 18:25perspective and the official receiver perspective, you've got
- 18:28Prax that was running a supposed profitable site that just you
- 18:33know vanish off to Dubai. I think that is where they fled
- 18:35to like, you know, they're going to want a safe pair of hands and
- 18:39not going to want some kind of like secretive consortium who
- 18:43want to kind of like socialise, cost, privatise profits.
- 18:48You know, that isn't going to really be where you lean.
- 18:51If you try and look at it from the government and official
- 18:53receiver perspective, Philips 66 makes sense.
- 18:57They've invested in the UK for a while.
- 18:59But then, you know, if you consider the flip side of like,
- 19:02you know, just taking a bid that will keep the refinery
- 19:05operational, you know, that doesn't go alongside necessarily
- 19:092050 net zero targets where refineries are going to be
- 19:13closing anyway, like you would have thought, unless it's like
- 19:15some mental CCS refinery improvement.
- 19:20So, you know, if you just Ed Miliband and you heard about
- 19:23this refinery that's shutting down and one company wants to
- 19:26just turn it into storage, you think, oh, that's like 1 less
- 19:28thing for me to deal with between now and 2050.
- 19:32So, So yeah, maybe, maybe I'm rambling on there, but but yeah.
- 19:36No, I mean, it's certainly a point worth mentioning.
- 19:39The sort of net 0 targets point, but like you say CCS is an
- 19:44option and that was something that Grange mouth before it
- 19:48announced that we'd shut its doors, it was set to to work
- 19:52alongside the Acorn project. And since it's since Grange
- 19:55mouth and the most more on ethylene plant have shut their
- 19:58doors, now there's questions about Acorn.
- 20:01So you know, I guess, I guess this does have wider knock on
- 20:05effects on cluster models which we we do have in the region.
- 20:10For, you know, for that is a case of, you know, could, could
- 20:15that was that ever being discussed for Lindsay to to sort
- 20:18of hop on board with the with the track 1 winners in the in
- 20:21the area. Yeah, I'm not too sure to be
- 20:23honest with like the Northern Endurance Partnership, you know,
- 20:26I think there was focusing on like other parts of the cluster
- 20:29because like the Lindsay or refineries, you know, just kind
- 20:31of just S below all of that stuff.
- 20:33So I'm not sure how much they were involved in talks,
- 20:38Obviously the Humber refinery as well.
- 20:40So I assume if like you know, they want to get on board with
- 20:43the track cluster, that's still an option.
- 20:46And, you know, Phillips 66 have always said as well that with
- 20:50extra storage capacity, they'll be able to refine more at the
- 20:55Humber Refinery. So it's basically like having 1
- 20:581/2 refineries. They see it rather than two
- 21:00refineries that are right next to each other just, you know,
- 21:03mothball one into storage and then you'll be able to refine
- 21:05more at that Humber refinery. But yeah, As for jobs as well,
- 21:10I'm not too sure if like people move over to the Humber Refinery
- 21:14from. But I think all of that will be
- 21:16announced, you know, as more of the sale processes is discussed
- 21:20between government and Phillips 66, which is why the government
- 21:23like promised to save jobs until March.
- 21:26Well, at the end of the day, I mean, you know, I feel like to
- 21:28be a bit of a downer, you know, consolidation and you know, sort
- 21:32of merger is always result in job losses.
- 21:35Even if company companies don't like to admit it at the time,
- 21:37they can sometimes eke out a better time with it.
- 21:40But eventually you have two marketing teams, 2 IT teams, 2
- 21:46legal teams and companies that eventually sort of consolidate
- 21:51that. So as soon as they've got the
- 21:52workforce for like you say that 1 1/2 refineries, if that's the
- 21:55metric, yeah, they will, they will look to shelf people.
- 21:59And that's just it's, it's a sad state of affairs, but that's the
- 22:02way, the way of things. It sounds a little bit like the
- 22:06region needs a good referee to sort it out.
- 22:09And do you know what? So does the North Sea We I've
- 22:12been speaking to former former Scottish football referee John
- 22:17Underhill from Aberdeen University.
- 22:19And if you want to hear what he's saying about the state of
- 22:21play North Sea, well stick around for after this break.
- 22:24You're going to hear all about that.
- 22:27Be a part of the conversation shaping Scotland's investment
- 22:31future. The Scottish National Investment
- 22:33Bank Conference 2026, in association with Energy Voice
- 22:37and the Press and Journal, brings together investors,
- 22:41business leaders and policy makers who are driving
- 22:44economics, social and environmental impact across
- 22:48Scotland. This is your opportunity to hear
- 22:51directly from those deploying mission LED capital.
- 22:55If you're serious about investing with purpose, whether
- 22:58you're raising capital, allocating it, or shaping
- 23:00policy, this is the room you need to be in.
- 23:04Get your tickets online. Today.
- 23:08So to wrap us up this week, I've been speaking to a friend of the
- 23:11show, John Underhill from Aberdeen University at the HSE
- 23:15conference run by Offshore Energies UK and Aberdeen this
- 23:19week and he was presenting some really interesting information.
- 23:23He'd sort of touched on this OUKS November decommissioning
- 23:28conference, but he's really cheered the opening session this
- 23:32week and essentially stood up and said, well, he presented
- 23:37some really interesting maps. He showed, you know, Sir,
- 23:40offshore wind usage, oil and gas, subsurface work, shipping
- 23:46lanes, fishing activity in in the southern North Sea just off
- 23:50East Anglia. And he essentially said, you
- 23:54know, these maps in in isolation, which is how they're
- 23:57generated and how like how you gathered the information Look.
- 24:01OK, looks like, oh, yeah, there's bags of room.
- 24:03But then when you stack all these maps on top of each other,
- 24:06we're starting to see overlap and we're starting to see, you
- 24:09know, the North Sea isn't that great expanse that, you know,
- 24:12people standing on the beach in Aberdeen looking out to the sea
- 24:16think it is. And so that creates that creates
- 24:19an issue. And then that sparked A wider
- 24:21debate around, well, how do we regulate this?
- 24:24Because we've got, like I say, shipping, fishing, oil and gas
- 24:28activity, CCS, CCS, wind, potentially tidal coming into,
- 24:33we've got, you know, a lot of resource going into the North
- 24:37Sea at the moment. And then, you know,
- 24:39interestingly, he also pointed to aviation.
- 24:43You know, we've got helicopter activities in the North Sea.
- 24:46Well, they obviously can't fly straight through wind turbines.
- 24:50So you've also got that and military uses for an aviation
- 24:53and commercial a lot going on, a lot happening.
- 24:56So essentially he was saying do we need a new regulator or he
- 25:02kind of flippantly said benevolent dictator energies are
- 25:07now. Yeah, bring on the dictators.
- 25:11Energy Voice official statement We support dictators.
- 25:14Is that what you're standing by, Erica?
- 25:16Is that what we're going? Through I will, I mean, someone
- 25:19needs to take control of this and Aberdeen University and
- 25:25Professor Undertale have been doing really awesome work on,
- 25:29you know, this spatial challenge that, you know, we're now facing
- 25:32on the seabed. And umm, you know, once again
- 25:35I'm hoping that, like umm, his new licensing regime, which has
- 25:40been adapted by the UK government to spare their
- 25:44blushes and maybe even support an industry that they're
- 25:47otherwise looking to kill. But it is an interesting point
- 25:51around, especially floating, you know, when it comes to trawler
- 25:54shapes, you know, yes, you've got cables, but then you also
- 25:57have, you know, mooring systems which then, you know, create
- 26:01massive expanses. Where trawling fishermen get a
- 26:03little bit. Upset.
- 26:04So it's an interesting point and it's something that Underhill
- 26:07and. His colleague doesn't take much
- 26:10upset. At Aberdeen University have been
- 26:12looking on. I believe Ruth is actually the
- 26:14person that's fronting this research after speaking to the
- 26:18two of them yesterday. That's the sense that I got.
- 26:20John definitely wants to big up her involvement and that that
- 26:24report set to come out in the next couple of months and it
- 26:28will show exactly their findings and recommendations.
- 26:32I did try to push them for. So is a new regulator what what
- 26:37Aberdeen University is going to call for and as academics have
- 26:42to do, everything goes through peer review.
- 26:44It's done that now. It's now just needing sign off
- 26:47and publishing times and that sort of thing.
- 26:49So it is on the horizon. A very interesting piece of work
- 26:54that'll raise some questions about both Crown Estates, the
- 26:57Crown Estate and Crown Estate Scotland.
- 26:59The NSTA obviously to a certain extent operate, you know,
- 27:03operator that that governs some, some modicum of North Sea
- 27:09activity. So we have an awful lot to
- 27:12discuss there. And he pointed to whether or not
- 27:15the, you know, this new regulator, if it were to be
- 27:18established, should be part of the latest talking shop from
- 27:23Westminster in the form of the North Sea Future Board, which
- 27:27was fronted by Minister Michael Shanks.
- 27:30Save us from talking shops. I mean honestly, like how many
- 27:33of these have we seen? Come on.
- 27:34It's very true. You know, they're all the same
- 27:36people and, you know, what are they actually achieve is what I
- 27:41wonder. So I mean, hopefully maybe they
- 27:43will start being a regulator, but you know, does that mean
- 27:46that Michael Shanks is going to be the the.
- 27:48New, you know. Father of this new regulatory
- 27:50body and how do we all feel about.
- 27:52It Michael Shanks, they've become the new Stuart Payne plus
- 27:56everyone else in the North Sea. Yeah, it's it's an interesting
- 27:591. So essentially John said whether
- 28:01or not we need a regulator that all other bodies feed into or
- 28:05sort of like I say that flippant remark about dictators, but I
- 28:08thought what was most interesting about this, and we
- 28:11are saving the most spicy bit for last, was Katie Heidenreich
- 28:15of OEUKI was wondering what? OEUK was saying about that.
- 28:19So OEUKS supply chain and Operations Director Katie was
- 28:23essentially saying I agree. She provided a much more nuanced
- 28:28discussion, which, you know, I, I thought was really interesting
- 28:33chat actually, where essentially she was like, yeah, the
- 28:35regulator, the regulatory system in the UK, North Sea currently
- 28:39doesn't work very well. And if we lived in, as she said,
- 28:44quote, a perfect world, we could just establish a new regulator.
- 28:49However, how long would that take?
- 28:51How much resources are going to take to pull that together?
- 28:54Is it going to stall investment? Is it going to stall projects
- 28:57while we like, while we try to fix this?
- 29:00So she essentially spoke more about sort of massaging the
- 29:04system we have for now while keeping an eye on this idea of
- 29:09maybe a an all powerful regulator that would govern
- 29:13everything. I mean, it seems to me, I mean,
- 29:15if we're just kind of speculating that the NSTA would
- 29:21probably be, you know, the body that would make most sense to,
- 29:27you know, because they have, you know, the, they have a great
- 29:29deal of data on the geology and, you know, they're really across,
- 29:34you know, all of the subsea imaging and, you know,
- 29:41exploration that has gone on. I mean, you know, they have more
- 29:44data than anyone knows what to do with.
- 29:46Now it is, though, then I know how would the North Sea
- 29:51Transition Authority, which is interesting because of course it
- 29:53has changed its name and it may. Have used to be the OGA.
- 29:58Absolutely. And then, you know, what they
- 30:01need to do is they just need to expand their agreement and they
- 30:03need to probably carve a little bit out of current, you know,
- 30:08regulation overseen by the Crown Estate and the Crown Estate
- 30:12Scotland, which, you know, is supposedly, you know, the
- 30:16mileage off the coast that is owned by the king, but which of
- 30:21course, is managed by government.
- 30:24And then, you know, kind of regulated as such Scottish
- 30:27Government for, you know, the Crown Estate Scotland and blah,
- 30:31blah, blah. So I mean, you know, it would be
- 30:34an interesting 1:00. And then of course, you know,
- 30:35what actually we've forgot to mention, you know, in this
- 30:38crowded landscape of people who are interested in taking up
- 30:43operations in the North Sea, can't forget the Royal Society
- 30:47for the Protection of Birds. They're probably one of the most
- 30:51powerful nature lobbying groups that we have in the Uki don't
- 30:55know if you've met, you know, crazy bird ladies who love like,
- 30:58watching birds and all that sort of stuff.
- 31:00Twitchers. They are a powerful group.
- 31:03And of course, they have a lot to say about, you know, offshore
- 31:07wind farms, you know, their impact on wildlife.
- 31:10I'm sure they'd love you for calling them crazy bird ladies.
- 31:13But I think, yeah, no, I mean, there was a there was an
- 31:16interesting conversation as well that I think would need to be
- 31:18set by government, which, you know, getting government to make
- 31:22a firm decision on anything is always a difficult thing to do.
- 31:25But essentially, Underhill also pointed to, well, a new
- 31:28regulator could deliver what we want from the North Sea.
- 31:32So if the, if the UK wanted to be say an offshore wind
- 31:37powerhouse or a leading body, a leading country in CCS or
- 31:42whatever it might be, you could then start saying, well, we
- 31:45could, this new regulator could set preferential areas and say
- 31:49no, this is for wind or for CCS or for oil and gas or whatever
- 31:54it might be. And that will not, you know,
- 31:56that will not be able to be taken by other areas, right.
- 32:00So you couldn't slap a wind farm on top of a, a reservoir that's
- 32:04ideally placed for CCS or whatever it might be.
- 32:07And you could then deliver ambitions which we were speaking
- 32:10about at the top of the show as being something we are not doing
- 32:13right now on wind. Well, I mean, the whole thing, I
- 32:17think what we're what, what this unveils and what John Underhill
- 32:21is discovered is that it's, it's a bloody Wild West under the
- 32:26coast. And you know, anyone with any
- 32:29idea, you know, whether they want to put a wind farm or where
- 32:32they want to put dig into a reservoir and stick a pipeline
- 32:35to it and pipe CCS into it. And all of that is, you know,
- 32:39just about taking it on a case by case basis.
- 32:42And there's not a holistic approach, which I think maybe is
- 32:46probably what we start the need to do.
- 32:49I mean, Michael has done a lot of interesting stories about
- 32:51wind theft, you know, which is a different thing.
- 32:54It's above, you know, the waves rather than below the waves.
- 32:57But again, you know, it is a, a spatial issue and effects
- 33:02projects. And there should probably be a
- 33:04regulator for that as well. Yeah.
- 33:05A. 100. Percent, but they should
- 33:06probably be the same one. It would really help.
- 33:08So no, that's, it's an interesting debate and I, I find
- 33:11myself siding with John. But then he is a very persuasive
- 33:14man. So maybe it's that he wasn't he
- 33:16was a Scottish referee for a reason.
- 33:18You know, there was a reason he was, you know, sort of wrangling
- 33:22the the Dons and the Huns and everyone else.
- 33:25I said Huns on the air. I'm sure that's going to go down
- 33:27really well for the Rangers fans watching.
- 33:30Anyway, that's a little insight into my football, my football
- 33:33takes. But anyway, that's that does it
- 33:35for this week's episode. If you are interested in this,
- 33:38this report that's coming out, I'm going to, you know, I'm
- 33:41going to stake a claim that I'm going to get both Ruth and John
- 33:44from Aberdeen University on this very show, the week that it
- 33:48comes out, so I can ask them all the burning questions about
- 33:52regulators. So until then, if you want to
- 33:55stay up to date with all the news in the North Sea and just
- 33:58the wider UK energy market, well, you know where to find us.
- 34:01We'll be in the same place, same time next week.
- 34:04Thanks for listening.