Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Dogs Cats A.I. (oh my!)
Transcript
- 0:00We understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol,
- 0:09an idea. The population of atheist in this country is going through the rule,
- 0:13rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the
- 0:19truth, it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand
- 0:23on a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking feels much more happiness, truth, beauty,
- 0:32and wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything,
- 0:39and start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews.
- 0:56I just got back, walk in the door and saw the eyes of my
- 1:00puppies and they were both excited to see me, and they were judging me
- 1:07for leaving them by themselves, even though I left them with Natalie under her
- 1:12care. No, no, this was a betrayal. I was gone for
- 1:17a couple of days, and I find myself, first of all, apologizing
- 1:21to the dogs. When I leave, I need to explain to them where
- 1:25I'm going. Okay, I'm lione Is and Grace, he loves you.
- 1:27I will be back in two days. I will be back in two days.
- 1:30You'd be good pups, Mommy will take care of you. You guard
- 1:34the house. I talk to them as if they understand the words that are
- 1:40coming out of my mouth. Do you do this with your pets? I
- 1:45mean the cat is, oh yeah, he misses me like he's become more
- 1:52codependent as he's gotten older. It used to be that I could pet him
- 1:56for eight seconds and then he would bite the shit out of my hand.
- 2:00And now he sits at my shoulder and purrs and sleeps next to my head,
- 2:04and he mews at me all the time. In fact, this is
- 2:07a total digression. Cat has been doing this thing where about nine o'clock at
- 2:13night and then about three in the morning every night he starts howling. Now
- 2:23he's in good health. We've had him checked. He's in good health,
- 2:27but he just howls and it sounds freaky. One night I pulled my phone
- 2:32out and I recorded it. Check this out. It could be argued that
- 2:52felines are vessels for demon possession. I mean, I know I've heard that
- 2:58cats are gods anyway, didn't the Egyptians considers gods I'm trying to remember.
- 3:04But if there was a vessel that would house a demon, I mean,
- 3:08any creature that makes that sound, I think is a candidate. Anyway,
- 3:13came back from Denver, apologized to the dogs, and we are getting reacquainted
- 3:17Linus and Gracie. Gracie is our most recent rescue, thirteen pounds shitsue.
- 3:23I don't think I've ever owned a dog as timid as Gracie, and I
- 3:30know a lot of rescued dogs have been through it. Many of them have
- 3:34been abused. I don't know what her story is beyond she was an owner
- 3:37surrender, and I think it was like a little old lady who never I
- 3:42don't know exposed her to the world. I don't know if she was just
- 3:46kept in a room or what, but I mean, everything freaks around.
- 3:49She was terrified of everything when we got her. She was terrified of stairs
- 3:53and she still freaks out at every single noise. Natalie will be on the
- 3:57couch, her phone on silent, a text, come in and the phone
- 4:00vibrates, and Gracie, We'll jump off the couch, run out of the
- 4:03room and go up the stairs. Now she runs the stairs, right,
- 4:08She's come a long way. She used to be terrified of the leash.
- 4:11Now she's walking a little bit. We're doing about a block before she decides
- 4:16she's done and she can't handle anymore. And I can't get her past the
- 4:20one block mark. I don't know if she's afraid of what's beyond or she's
- 4:26just done. Maybe she's not a shape right, I don't know. I
- 4:30can't get her past the one block mark. But it is admirable how much
- 4:33courage she has displayed. She's learning more and more how to be a dog.
- 4:38Anyway, I'm just babbling blah blah blah. But if you have animals,
- 4:43they all have their quirks, and if you have a cat, maybe
- 4:46you can relate to the demon that crawls the house in the middle of the
- 4:53night. Let's try today to not talk about Christian nationalist. I need a
- 5:00break, You need a break. Let's talk about something else. We got
- 5:03a whole bunch of calls lined up. I was at the American Atheist National
- 5:08Convention, and I had the honor of speaking there in Phoenix, and there
- 5:12was one stretch where we had like six straight hours of people talking about the
- 5:16ship storm of Christian nationalism and how it's about to ruin democracy and turn us
- 5:21all into a Christian Gilead. And by the end of that stretch, I
- 5:26just wanted to go run into traffic. And it's tough because you know,
- 5:30you want to address the house on fire, right, But at the same
- 5:34time, I need a break, You need a break. So we're going
- 5:36to be talking about some others stuff in the weeks ahead. Next week,
- 5:41we're going to be talking about a book that is released. It's about religions
- 5:46and extra terrestrials. Oh yeah, oh yeah, well I can talk about
- 5:50the aliens. That's gonna be awesome, especially in light of the fact that
- 5:54I think it was CNN that just posted another article about these declassified Department of
- 6:01Defense UFO videos. You know, the stuff that was seen and recorded and
- 6:09documented fifty sixty years ago and it's been kept in a vault, and now
- 6:15this UFO information has been revealed and the unidentified flying objects remain unidentified. We
- 6:27didn't know what it was. We still don't know what it is. Somebody
- 6:31was flying along in a plane, saw some shit, caught it on video,
- 6:34we put it behind a padlock, and here you go, Like it
- 6:40just happens the same way all the time. But anyway, the idea of
- 6:43aliens, you know, the extra terrestrials, out there, and you know,
- 6:47would we consider them gods? Would they consider us to be gods?
- 6:53Do you think there is life elsewhere? And what would the discovery of such
- 6:59life due to our notions of gods and monsters? I think that's going to
- 7:03be great. Next week, I've got a show where I'm speaking with a
- 7:09Baptist. She's not a minister, Amanda Tyler. I'll call her an influencer,
- 7:14and she's head of a very influential religious organization that, believe it or
- 7:19not, is on our team when it comes to trying to protect the constitutional
- 7:25state church line. So you're going to see an example of an atheist and
- 7:28a Baptist on the same page, doing the same kind of work. And
- 7:33I've been banging this drum for I don't know how long. You know.
- 7:38Oh, the religious are all vests, the religious are so stupid, The
- 7:43religious are all Nazis, blah blah blah. And I'm like, no,
- 7:48No, there are a lot of religious people that agree with us that a
- 7:54religion should be a personal faith right. And Amanda Tyler is one of those
- 8:00people. We're going to talk about her faith. I mean, I can't
- 8:03not ask her about the Bible, especially when it comes to women, etc.
- 8:07In our Baptist religion, I can't. We have to talk about a
- 8:09little bit of that, but we're going to cover a whole lot more.
- 8:13And then a very serious conversation later in June, as I talked to someone,
- 8:18a woman who I met in Phoenix. Her husband had died by suicide
- 8:24a few years ago. Very heavy conversation about those left behind after a suicide.
- 8:31This is it's such a tough subject. I hesitated. I thought,
- 8:35maybe it's too heavy, maybe it's too dark for this audience. But you
- 8:37know, we have this phobia, this stigma about you know, these heavy
- 8:43subjects, and it's something that's touched all of our lives. I think we
- 8:48all know someone who has died by suicide and those left behind are just swimming
- 8:54in an ocean of blame and shame. And could I have done more?
- 8:56Did I see the warning signs? And how do I recall hovered? Do
- 9:00I allow myself to be happy again? How long is that going to take?
- 9:03Are there stages of grief and beyond suicide? I think grief relates to
- 9:09all of us as well, because it's part of the human experience. And
- 9:13so we're going to speak about this very very very important subject later on in
- 9:18the month of June. So, yes, I am going to mix things
- 9:20up, and yes, we have some very good stuff on the horizon.
- 9:24Today, we're going to talk about what you want to talk about as we
- 9:30go to the phones. Nine eighty nine. Who's this, Chuck? Chuck?
- 9:35What do you want to talk about today? It's kind of a free
- 9:37for all free will. I've just came into atheists about four years ago or
- 9:43so, you know, been loving it and freeing. But I talked to
- 9:48a lot of my friends and family about free will, and they're kind of
- 9:52delusion or religious, you know, and we talk about the you know,
- 9:56gaze, and I asked him, you know, do you think that gays
- 10:01were born gay or where they you know, come gay later on in life?
- 10:07And they said, well, you know, they have to think a
- 10:09bit and then say well I think they were born Well, you know,
- 10:13I get different answers, but anyways, I said, well, I can
- 10:16prove we don't have free will. I mean, I don't know where you
- 10:18stand on this free will thing. Do you believe we have free will?
- 10:22You know? You know, I'd like to soften our language, you know,
- 10:26to talk about the gays, But I think, yeah, yeah,
- 10:30yeah, yeah, I'm sorry. Yeah, it's all good. You know.
- 10:31I think this is an issue that deserves compassion. But I get the
- 10:35intent behind it. I totally get the spirit of what you're saying. Yeah,
- 10:39yeah, I don't mean to nobody, and I have no bad feelings
- 10:41of gays or nothing like that. I mean, I understand. I mean
- 10:45you were having the discussion because you want to advocate for non heteros. So
- 10:48I take the spirit of what you're saying, Well, that in free will.
- 10:52You know, well, when I think of free will, beyond identity,
- 10:56right, beyond our genetic predispositions one way or the other, which I
- 11:00think maybe another conversation. When I talk about free will, do I have
- 11:05free will to decide to turn left instead of turning right? Or has my
- 11:09brain already said that? Well, that's that speaks more to choices or the
- 11:13illusion of choices, more than it does to a genetic identity or you know,
- 11:18the way we are sort of biologically wired. And I think that's a
- 11:22different conversation, But it also speaks to free will in the sense that your
- 11:26rights. I can't will myself to be of a different ethnicity. I can't
- 11:31will myself to be a different height or a different you know this or that.
- 11:37I'm just it just sort of is the way it is. And I
- 11:41think those type of baked in things are important parts of the discussions we have
- 11:46about choice or lack of choice. This is who I am, is I
- 11:50think a very valid approach. Right. Well, I got a religious friends
- 11:56who she's saying, oh, us trumpers are, we're mellowing everything but stone
- 12:01the gaze whatever, you know. I mean, I'm glad we got laws,
- 12:07you know, against people like that. You know, you know how
- 12:09the Bible says stone in the gaze, and stone if you go to church
- 12:13on Sundays on a Monday, right you know. I saw a hate preacher
- 12:18on Twitter who was actually advocating for the execution of non heterosexuals. For those
- 12:24who think that this is locked into an Old Testament model, there are preachers
- 12:28at pulpits with large online followings who are now they've ample. If it used
- 12:33to be they'd say, well, God's law would have endorsed it. Now
- 12:37they're just saying someone needs to go do it, which I consider an incitement
- 12:41to murder, and I think the police should be all over it. But
- 12:46I understand what you're saying, brethren, and it's an interesting concept over coffee.
- 12:50Do we have free will in this sense? Certainly? I don't think
- 12:54we have will over who we are genetically. I think that's a different conversation.
- 12:58Okay, right, Well, then you got to religionships say oh,
- 13:01they turned gay because they take out or whatever. You know, like,
- 13:05come on, you know, do you really believe that? You know,
- 13:09I think the same can apply to our religious belief Some people will say,
- 13:13well, when did you choose to be an atheist? And I'm like,
- 13:16well, I just don't believe. Like when I say atheist, that's a
- 13:20descriptive. I'm saying I realized that I don't believe. I can't force myself
- 13:26to believe that is something happening organically in the brain. So when they say
- 13:31did you choose to be an atheist, I'm like, well, I just
- 13:33acknowledged something that had happened organically, really beyond my control. Interesting stuff,
- 13:39brother, thanks so much for calling the show. Thanks for listen. You
- 13:45know, when I came out of the faith, I remember I had some
- 13:48some baggage there when I would talk about the gay lifestyle and I didn't even
- 13:52think about it, I say, well, you know people who lived the
- 13:54gay lifestyle, and someone had to bring to my attention. You know that
- 14:00implies or even declares that it's a choice, right, It's your attractions that
- 14:05are hardwired into you, are something that you decide to have. And when
- 14:11you say lifestyle, that plays into this sort of often religious protest against it.
- 14:18They chose to be gay, and I had to modify that attitude and
- 14:22certainly changed the language. It was part of my evolution out of religion.
- 14:26The stuff that we considered to be normal. We didn't think it was harmful.
- 14:30Even when I was an atheist, I carried that with me and someone
- 14:33had to bring it to my attention. So when you know better, I
- 14:37think you try to do better. Kathy at nine seven zero, are you
- 14:43there? Oh? Hi, seth, Hi, Kathy, This is Cathy
- 14:50Goead. Go ahead. Okay. First of all, I've got your book
- 14:56Sacred Cow, Thank you, and I absolutely love it. The part about
- 15:01infallibility is giving my brain a bit of a twist. Now let me flesh
- 15:07this out. There's a chapter on the choosing of the pope and how the
- 15:11pope is God's proxy. Is supposedly infallible, and yet Pope Francis has said
- 15:18some somewhat occasionally, we'll say some somewhat progressive things about non heterosexuals, etc.
- 15:24And then the people, enclave and the bishops and everybody around him will
- 15:28lose their minds and then they will publicly correct him. But that stands against
- 15:35the notion that the Pope is God's proxy, is infallible. He's not supposed
- 15:41to be a thing. So if he's infallible, you know. So I
- 15:46was drawing attention to the weird hypocrisy that was going on. But thanks for
- 15:50the kind words about the book. I appreciate you. Oh it's fabulous.
- 15:54But also when I first came on and you we're talking about, I think
- 16:00was Gracie where she would only walk a block. Yeah, a suggestion would
- 16:04be to pick her up, carry her the first block, put her down,
- 16:11let her walk the second block, and then perhaps when she's headed home,
- 16:15like you know, dogs and horses, Yeah, but they turn around
- 16:19he had home, then she's going to have to walk the whole two blocks
- 16:22back. Kind of an exposure therapy where I give her a little bit of
- 16:26a nudge. Yeah, I'm gonna pick you out and love you and carry
- 16:30you this first block. Then I'm gonna put you down. We're going to
- 16:33walk on the lease for another block. Is that's what she's used to.
- 16:38That sounds like it might work. You know, normally we walk out the
- 16:41front door. It's her in Linus. The other challenges. Linus wants to
- 16:45do like a mile his little legs, you know, you know, a
- 16:49little seven pound dog and he just wanted to go, go, go,
- 16:52And she's like, okay, I went done my business. We did a
- 16:56block. I'm done. I'm ready to go home. Maybe I knew to
- 17:00walk them separately as well. Part of my don't know, does anybody even
- 17:03care about the stuff we're talking about. I don't know. I guess old
- 17:10dogs their works, especially rescue dogs, as they come to you and they've
- 17:15got a past. And I don't know about you, but anybody who would
- 17:19abuse an animal, my brain does not process vile. It's fine. I
- 17:26do a lot of work with the Humane Society and Tulsa, and I just
- 17:29you hear those stories and you see the damage done and you're like, who
- 17:32could do this? And then whatever conditions they put the dog in, the
- 17:37primal part of me wants to put the human in you know what, Fine,
- 17:41you know, I'll beat you with a rod, put you in a
- 17:42cage for eight years. We'll do this, and then I feel terrible for
- 17:47thinking those awful things, but it's a primal response in me. Kathy.
- 17:52My mom's little dog was a rescue and I had made a little ramp for
- 17:57it to come up and down the front stairs because he had problems with his
- 18:03hips. And at first he didn't know what to do with the ramp,
- 18:07and so his favorite food in the world was chicken, and so I took
- 18:12little pieces of chicken and put it at sequences down the ramp, and he
- 18:18went down the ramp eating the chicken, and I put the chicken duck coming
- 18:22back up, and he came back up, and after out four times that,
- 18:25it was like, Okay, I got this ramp thing. Maybe I'll
- 18:27take dog treats and just sort of spread them out over a three quarter mile
- 18:33around the neighborhood. Here you go, be like, okay, fine,
- 18:36you're going to weigh twenty five pounds, Grace, but at least you will
- 18:40have taken the journey. Kathy, You're awesome. Thanks again for being in
- 18:44Denver. We'll talk soon, Okay, thanks, but see you later.
- 18:49Let's take another look here. I've got Rick at two zero two. Are
- 18:56you there? Yes? Wanting if you we're familiar with the Secret Book of
- 19:00John, I am not. You are not, okay, I thought you
- 19:06would be, with your extensive knowledge book. Well, lower your expectations.
- 19:11You know, it's possible I've been introduced to one of the non canonized books,
- 19:15including a Book of John, and simply don't remember. That's happening more
- 19:19and more. But no, I'm no expert. Brother, tell me about
- 19:22the Secret Book of John in a nutshell, and it's actually one of the
- 19:26things that made me realize that I was an atheist. It's basically that the
- 19:33god Jehovah is actually a bastard son of Sophia, and he created this realm
- 19:42that we live in to control us because he wants the adoration we are made
- 19:48to worship. Kind of thing, right, Well, I mean that's present
- 19:55I think in other parts of the Bible. In fact, if we look
- 19:59at the model for heaven as we go and get our mansions and grounds and
- 20:03whatever it else we're supposed to get, I think we also say, Holy,
- 20:07Holy, Holy, is the Lord God Almighty, and we do it
- 20:10over and over again. So we are created to give adulation to our Father.
- 20:15Yeah, but if you follow that line of thinking, then Lucifer would
- 20:22be the bringer of light who's trying to save us from being under that God's
- 20:26dominion, and Christ was a follow up, being the same personification to come
- 20:33down and save us from Jehovah. So in that sense, the biblical God
- 20:37would be the oppressor and Satan would be the savior figure, the illuminator,
- 20:45whereas the Jehovah God wanted us to be in ignorance. Luver came and tried
- 20:52to bring us to knowledge from the Tree of knowledge, eat of the fruits
- 20:59and have enlightenments and become self aware. This is what God did not want
- 21:04right now, that's interesting. Is there a reference online for this Secret Book
- 21:10of John? I mean there's some kind of texts that you're drawing this from.
- 21:12Yeah, you can actually just google a Secret Book of John. The
- 21:18thing that struck me is that it's so much like the matrix. Help me
- 21:22out in what sense in that the reality that we are experiencing is not true
- 21:29and real. We are made to worship God, that's our purpose. But
- 21:34you're saying that this reality that we are worshiping God in does not actually exist.
- 21:41It's only a matter of perception. Well in a way, I mean
- 21:44that's more like the matrix side of comparison. But this realm that we live
- 21:49in is entirely false, and we are to worship this Yaldebas who is Jehovah.
- 21:59And it's just stay a facade to keep us in ignorance, a rundsome
- 22:03to chew on. Anyway, Rick, thanks for I'll let you. I'll
- 22:07let you go ahead and look it up, all right, The Secret Book
- 22:11of John. Thank you for everything you're doing. Okay, brother, We'll
- 22:12see you later. Then we get into the philosophical conversations about perception. Is
- 22:21perception actually reality? So if I was in the matrix and my brain perceived
- 22:27solid objects and the sun coming up and the food that I eat, would
- 22:33that constitute a kind of reality. This is the kind of naval gazing that
- 22:41philosophers do all the time. Maybe you've got an opinion about it. Stand
- 22:47by, my friends, Lots more to do, lots more to talk about.
- 22:51We will continue next. If you haven't checked out my second podcast,
- 23:02please subscribe on all major podcast apps. Five minute true vignettes that release three
- 23:08times a week. They're easily digestible. They can be about pretty much anything,
- 23:14and I think there are a lot of fun to listen to, certainly
- 23:17a lot of fun to write and produce true stories with Seth Andrews like subscribe
- 23:23and share and thanks so much? Three zero three? Is it Travis?
- 23:32Yep? Has it going? I'm good, Talk to me. What's on
- 23:34your mind? Yeah, Well, I'm not sure if you've ever heard of
- 23:37a YouTube channel called Dude Perfect. Dude Perfect, Yeah, they do basically
- 23:45a lot of trick shots, and recently what I'm calling you about, they
- 23:48made the world's highest basketball shot at eight hundred and fifty something feet. Are
- 23:52these the same guys that drop like basketballs off at the top of I don't
- 23:57know, the Hoover dam and that kind of thing, and they well,
- 24:00so they're different people in this kind of YouTube space, though I think those
- 24:04guys might be how ridiculous you're talking about it? All? Right? But
- 24:07anyway, so, yeah, Dude Perfect. Last a couple of weeks they
- 24:11did it's a world record shop for you know, eight hundred and fifty something
- 24:15feet And just what really got me about it is in the video they said,
- 24:21oh, you know, this was our last day doing it, and
- 24:23you know in that last shop I did, and you know it should have
- 24:26gone in, but I just can't think of any reason why it came in,
- 24:30and I just think it must have been God had a hand in it.
- 24:32And wait, anyway, hang on, how many times did they dropped
- 24:34the ball unsuccessfully? They didn't say how many times, but so like this
- 24:40was at least as far as they say, and what the video show is
- 24:42the only one that actually got close to the hoop. And again, you
- 24:47know, a last day, and you know it must have had God's hands
- 24:48in it, because it would it should have been impossible otherwise. All right,
- 24:52hang on your second. So a child dies of leukemia a few miles
- 24:56away, but instead God directed his divine power to score three what you know
- 25:03exactly? And that's again my just and I just don't understand that that a
- 25:08mindset. And I almost wanted to comment this but are on the video,
- 25:12but I was like, it is it really worth it? You know,
- 25:14because it is mostly you know, geared towards kids watching these videos, and
- 25:18they never really mentioned God at all and their rest their videos. It's just
- 25:22in this one instance where I was kind of like, yeah, as you
- 25:25said, you know, yeah, two blocks away a child was starving to
- 25:27death. But you know, man, we got to get these YouTubers a
- 25:30cool video for their YouTube channel. I wrote about this in my last book.
- 25:36Christianity made me talk like an idiot. A guy in my home state,
- 25:41and he was like a serious cyclist or bicyclist or whatever. And he
- 25:45had one of these thousands of dollars ten speeds fifteen, so I don't know
- 25:49whatever the speeds they are, and it was stolen. And so for the
- 25:55course of I don't know how many months, nine months, he was trying
- 25:57to find it. Maybe somebody pawned it or something, and at the very
- 26:03last second it was located. And he used it as an object lesson to
- 26:07teach his daughter, or maybe his daughter said something to him about how you
- 26:11know God, God never forgets us, and he never forgot your bike.
- 26:17And now you are back together again. And I'm like, yeah, twenty
- 26:21five thousand people are going to starve to death to day. Right. God
- 26:25didn't prevent the Holocaust, but he found your bind singing on and there's a
- 26:30priority problem that they don't seem to see. Yeah, and again, as
- 26:33I say, I just don't know if it was worth it. And I
- 26:37didn't comment on the video, but if you would have been worth it to
- 26:40again, hey, you guys really think your God cares this much about you
- 26:44guys, and yeah, not about the other problems in the world. But
- 26:47I just figured, yeah, maybe we'll leave this one lie. But I
- 26:48don't know if I see it or not. I honestly think it's okay.
- 26:52I'll jump in and make a comment on a thread. What I don't get
- 26:56trapped in is the avalanche of protests are going to come back, and they're
- 27:03all going to be these vacuous bumper stickers, you know, these fortune cookies,
- 27:07total empty calories. What I don't do, and what I see some
- 27:11atheists fall into the trap of doing, is they respond to everything and they
- 27:15spend days, They waste days in arguments. I think it's fine to make
- 27:23the declaration, ask the question, go on the record, challenge the claim.
- 27:27I think that's totally valid. And if you do that, great,
- 27:32But if responses start to roll in, you're going to see those empty calories.
- 27:36Your first thought is going to be I need to correct that, and
- 27:40I need to refute that, and this is wrong, and this is stupid
- 27:42and this is offensive. I would not expend energy and oxygen doing that.
- 27:48It is a rabbit hole you will never get out of. But you know,
- 27:52if you've got an opinion, go back and throw it out there,
- 27:56just go on the record, let me know what happens. Yeah, maybe
- 27:59that's a good in that moment. I definitely got drawn into some, as
- 28:02you said, empty calories for It's hard. Somebody would say something and you're
- 28:07like, well, I have the refutation for that right here. Yeah,
- 28:11no, I get it, and yeah, definitely something. I'm definitely a
- 28:14sort with them fast, but I definitely I think of moving towards again Manby
- 28:18once or twice and we'll see what happens. All right, Be safe out
- 28:22there, Travis, Thanks for calling. Think that it's hard when you have
- 28:26a crusader temperament. I'm an activist my whole life. I've been a crusader.
- 28:32I was a crusader when I was a Christian. I'm a crusader now
- 28:34challenging somebody says something online that is irredeemably stupid or factually wrong or offensive,
- 28:44and you want to go in and counter that as a matter of principle,
- 28:48that's valid I've seen people and that's all they do. I'm part of me
- 28:55is like, what else do you do with your day? You just sit
- 28:59online and argue with people, and minds are almost never changed. People almost
- 29:04never budge. I see the utility of social media to represent and present for
- 29:11those who might be watching. But this idea that you're going to engage with
- 29:15somebody who may be typing out of his mom's basement, you know, and
- 29:22that's all they do is stir the pot or you know, they're sending not
- 29:25receiving. How much isn't your time and energy and oxygen pretty valuable? Do
- 29:30you really want to waste it doing that? I mean there are people who
- 29:33will defend it. Somebody must say something. I'm going to champion reason on
- 29:37Twitter. Bump bump bump. Yeah, I don't know. Probably got myself
- 29:41in trouble with that. John at three three six, thanks for calling?
- 29:47Are you there? Yeah? I'm here, So let's talk. What do
- 29:49you have on your mind? Well, acually, I just wanted to pay
- 29:53tribute. First all, I'm an atheist, but I had a good friend
- 29:56past last year and she was like a family friends since I was twelve years
- 30:02old, and she lived her life as a Christian like no one I've ever
- 30:08known. I can remember many years ago, first telling her I was gay.
- 30:14The first thing she said was how mey, God loves everybody. Let's
- 30:18have a cup of coffee. And I was just remember being completely floored by
- 30:23that at that time. So I knew the kind of person she was.
- 30:27Gosh, what else to say about her? I guess again she was a
- 30:33person of beautiful values. Yes she was, and she lived like that,
- 30:37and she lived her life to me how I think the Christians should live.
- 30:41Her life. She kept her Christianity in her home, she didn't speak of
- 30:47it really otherwise. And I remember also the second time I had to come
- 30:52out to her, which was as an atheist, and I was expecting something
- 30:59pretty bad from that. She's just like, you know, don't worry about
- 31:03it, she said, we all believe different things. And that was the
- 31:07end of that, and we went on being friends. She lived a beautiful,
- 31:12long life, and I just wonder why all Christians can't be like her
- 31:18actually live the life. She didn't go to church. She didn't think she
- 31:21needed to. She said she loved God, she didn't need to go to
- 31:23church for that, and actually was a beautiful example of what I think a
- 31:30real Christian is. I just wonder why that's so hard for other people to
- 31:34do. Well, I'm glad you drew attention to the reality. And this
- 31:38is not popular with many of my fellow activists out there, But there are
- 31:44a lot of religious people who are beautiful, and they have wonderful values,
- 31:49and they would rather unite than divide, and they lead with compassion, and
- 31:53they would give you the shirt off their back, you know, and we
- 31:57shared this planet together. Those types of Christians are out there, and there
- 32:01are more than many atheists think. I think, what's your take. I
- 32:06hope that there are millions and millions of them out there. I do hear
- 32:10some occasionally speaking up now and then, you know, I'm watching the news,
- 32:14But oh, I mean, they're really not saying a lot of it.
- 32:17I don't disagree that there's a mobilized effort of people who are, you
- 32:22know, weaponizing Christianity. I get that right, right, And I think
- 32:27they're more interested in politics and the art Christianity. Well, I'm sorry for
- 32:31the loss of your friend. I hope you're doing okay. Oh, yeah,
- 32:35thank you very much. Yeah, she lived a good long line she
- 32:37was eighty three. So thank you, appreciate you, Colin John, take
- 32:40care all right, thank you. So by freaking guys are weed eating and
- 32:49mowing just outside my window to the neighbor's yard. This is one of those
- 32:52weird quirks of doing a broadcast from a home studios and when they're doing construction
- 33:00in there's these big construction trucks and now there's a guy who's got a freaking
- 33:02weed whacker, and he's like, well, you know what, I'm trying
- 33:07to actually concentrate and trying to, you know, trying to be a good
- 33:13steward of the calls that are coming in. I've got a noise gate which
- 33:16helps just a little bit. Four zero four, Bernard, thanks for calling.
- 33:22I want to speak on something, but I just heard something expressed and
- 33:27I think I'm going to touch on it. It's the fact that there are
- 33:30good Christians, just like there are good Muslims and Buddhists and Hindus and elsewhere.
- 33:37But the problem is that most of the Christians who want to point to
- 33:39the doctor Kings and so forth, they don't seem to understand that. I
- 33:44try to use the illustration of professional baseball sports that I do love that if
- 33:47you took the strike zone and you made it a ten foot square, that
- 33:52the sport would die because no matter how great that batter was, and he
- 33:58was a combination of Babe Ruth r Aaron kid Williams, he just doesn't have
- 34:02a chance. The strike zone is too great. And that's the problem with
- 34:07Christianity because when you can allow a doctor King or Riinhard Nupler and the klu
- 34:14Klux Klan and the Neo Nazis, your strike zone is far too wide.
- 34:20The home plate or the strike zone is what. Now, who's the picture?
- 34:25Who's the batter? Help me understand your analogy better? Okay, Now,
- 34:29the strike zone as I'm expressing it, that's the high morality, the
- 34:34decent morality. This is right, this is wrong. You don't molest children,
- 34:38you don't reread women, you don't hate people for who they are if
- 34:42they're not harming anyone, that's very good. But when you allow this huge
- 34:46strife zone where you can still do all these hateful things and still be allowed
- 34:52into the club of Christianity or any religious because it happens in Islam as well,
- 34:58because you have a Muslim like Muhammad Ali who loses valuable years of his
- 35:02prime. Because you won't go to heal people, then you have been Lawton
- 35:07who gleefully kills people. You know, it's in every religious tradition. You
- 35:12cannot have so wide a strike zone. It makes no sense. There are
- 35:17believers who call out and condemn hate and bigotry and violence and all those things.
- 35:25I do agree, but it should be to the point where none of
- 35:29them and they shouldn't be the rare Doctor King's letter, the famous letter that
- 35:34he wrote on the toilet paper of the smokeled pen from a Birmingham jail.
- 35:37That wasn't written to the community at large. That was him condemning the religious
- 35:42leaders of Birmingham who were not standing up to do the right thing. So
- 35:45he was doing it. That letter shows it, you know, he was
- 35:47trying to explain it. No, our cause is just you're seeing that we're
- 35:51breaking the law, and we are. But the law is unjust. Every
- 35:54law that there was no Nothing that happened in Nazi Germany was against the law,
- 36:00but it was unjust an evil. We're breaking the law, but the
- 36:02law is evil, it's unjust. But he had to explain that to the
- 36:07religious community and that's who the letter was addressed to. Yeah, but many
- 36:10people in the religious I mean, there was a freaking reverend so and many
- 36:14of the people who joined him, who lock step with him at Selma,
- 36:17etc. Were themselves religious. But I understand the point of one of my
- 36:21heroes, Reverend were you killed for it? You know? But he was
- 36:23a reverend, okay, and he died in that cause when they see all
- 36:28these flu klux klansmen, all these Christian nationalists, they should be an even
- 36:31greater mass steam rooming. No, you're not part of our club. We're
- 36:37not going to leave it to the rare saints who will speak out in mass.
- 36:40We're telling you that you're unacceptable. You have to identify as something else.
- 36:45You're unacceptable. There is sometimes conspicuous silence in the wake of bigotry and
- 36:52atrocity, and we see this in tribes across the scopes. So, yeah,
- 36:55I take your point. And I wanted to tell you, you know
- 36:59that I have all of your books, and I don't know if you remember
- 37:01me, but you sign them all and they have a reverence for my book
- 37:05show with my signed company of the books by Christopher Hitchins, my book by
- 37:08a Rozzer Dawkins and a book by arn raw So you know it's there.
- 37:14Well, you're very kind. Thanks for the kind words, my friend.
- 37:16Take care of yourself. Thank you. You're welcome, say Aaron. You
- 37:21know it's weird being an author and a creator, a content creator in the
- 37:25age of chat GPT. By the way, if you're not familiar with chat
- 37:30GPT, this is a natural language processing tool. It is driven by AI
- 37:38technology, and it apparently allows us to have human like conversations and more with
- 37:45a chat bot. It answers questions. It apparently can assist with composing emails
- 37:53and making essays and even writing computer code. Open to you is by the
- 38:00general public, totally for free, because it's still sort of in the beta
- 38:04phase, the research and feedback collection phase, and then there's a plus version
- 38:10of it. And of course the rise of chat GPT and other generators has
- 38:15brought about these larger questions of just what we want software, the machines,
- 38:21etc. To do for us. And so here I am as a creator
- 38:25in a time where AI is able to write for me or I don't know,
- 38:32against me, or and what's the future even looked like in that way?
- 38:39Let's say you're a professor of English and you receive an essay from a
- 38:45student who is able to use the English language. This isn't one of those
- 38:50scenarios where oh, I see perfect English and sentence structure, and I know
- 38:53then that the student has faked this because their sentence structure is horrible. Let's
- 38:59say that someone really really good at English goes to chat, GPT or some
- 39:05other program and they just type in the subject matter and they bring in this
- 39:08generated essay. The teachers are more and more going to have to know the
- 39:14difference. And beyond that lies the philosophical conversation. Do we want the machines
- 39:21making art? I've seen some impressive computer generated art. Some of it's really
- 39:28funny, but you know, the more photo realistic it becomes, that becomes
- 39:32a problem. And isn't this a human thing? Like don't we get to
- 39:37make the arts and the machines do all of the menial crap, you know,
- 39:44all the calculations I've seen. I think it was Spielberg and some other
- 39:47Hollywood directors who create films have come forward and say red flag, right,
- 39:54this is a trespass on humanity. This is not why we should have machines
- 40:00and software and programs, etc. Okay, so just for kicks, I
- 40:06went to chat GPT and I typed in the instruction write a story about Seth
- 40:13becoming an atheist, and it cranked out like within twenty seconds one two,
- 40:19three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, ten
- 40:22paragraphs. Now, I'm reading this cold. I haven't actually read this in
- 40:27advance, so we are going to discover what the program has written together in
- 40:34real time. It says this. Once upon a time in the quiet town
- 40:38of Oakville, there lived a young man named Seth. Seth was raised in
- 40:45a tightly knit community where religion played a central role in people's lives. From
- 40:52a young age, he attended religious services, learned sacred texts, and embraced
- 40:58the teachings of his faith. As Seth grew older, he began to experience
- 41:02a growing sense of curiosity about the world beyond his religious community. He found
- 41:09himself questioning the beliefs he had been raised with, wondering if there could be
- 41:15alternative explanations for the mysteries of life. One day, Seth stumbled upon a
- 41:22book in the local library that challenged the traditional religious narratives he had come to
- 41:29know so well. The book explored different philosophical perspectives and offered scientific explanations for
- 41:37the origins of the universe and the complexities of life. Intrigued by the new
- 41:44ideas presented in the book, Seth embarked on a journey of self discovery.
- 41:50He spent hours delving into scientific literature, engaging in philosophical discussions, and seeking
- 41:58out the experiences and perspectives of people from different walks of life. As he
- 42:04deepened his understanding of the world, Seth began to question the existence of a
- 42:08higher power. He found solace in the beauty of scientific explanations and the wonders
- 42:15of the natural world. The more he learned, the more he realized that
- 42:21the explanations offered by science and critical thinking resonated with him in a way that
- 42:28religion never had. Seth's newfound doubts and uncertainties led to tension within his religious
- 42:37community. Friends and family members, concerned for his spiritual well being, tried
- 42:44to convince him to return to the fold. They found it difficult to accept
- 42:49his departure from the religious path. They held, dear, holy shit,
- 42:52I gotta stop right here. Like I wasn't born, nor did I live
- 42:58in the quiet town of Oakville, but the rest of it is allar It's
- 43:05shockingly spot on. Okay, where was I? Let's see, I had
- 43:09uncertainties led to tension. My family, my loved ones, tried to convince
- 43:15me to return to the fold, and they found the whole thing difficult.
- 43:20Okay. Despite the challenges he faced, Seth remained true to his convictions.
- 43:25He found solace in the freedom to explore different ideas and to form his own
- 43:30understanding of the world. He surrounded himself with individuals who respected his journey,
- 43:37engaging in meaningful conversations that enriched his perspective and broadened his horizons. As Seth
- 43:45embraced his atheism, he discovered a deep sense of liberation. He realized that
- 43:52he could find purpose and meaning in the human experience. Grounded in empathy,
- 43:59compact, and the pursuit of knowledge. He developed a deep appreciation for the
- 44:05beauty of life and the interconnectedness of all beings, finding awe and wonder in
- 44:12the natural world. In his quest for truth, Seth never lost his respect
- 44:17for those who held different beliefs. He recognized the importance of understanding and dialogue,
- 44:23fostering an environment of mutual respect, and acceptance. Through his journey,
- 44:31Seth not only discovered his own truth, but also found a sense of peace
- 44:37and fulfillment in living and authentic and examined life. He embraced the uncertainties and
- 44:44complexities of existence, navigating the world with an open mind and a compassionate heart,
- 44:51and in his quest for knowledge and understanding, he realized that atheism was
- 44:57not a rejection of spirituality, but a celebration of the profound potential of human
- 45:04curiosity and reason that was generated by AI. I didn't write a word of
- 45:14it. And this is the beginning of the technology. Like this is We're
- 45:17at the beginning. I don't know. I don't know what happened. Like
- 45:22as an author of books, what happens if I become irrelevant? Now?
- 45:27What if I just type in reasons the Book of Genesis is bullshit? To
- 45:35just hit enter? And then I waited twenty seconds and there are paragraphs.
- 45:40Oh look, it's an entire chapter. Copy paste. I have now written
- 45:45the first part of a book. Is I understand a chant GPT and other
- 45:51programs are actually drawing from other books? Is that right? It goes through
- 45:55and it scans data, and that it mixes up the data so it doesn't
- 46:00look like plagiarism. And I don't I it's all above me. It's way
- 46:04over my head. But I am in a weird place as a creator.
- 46:08As a creator, don't you feel if you play music, if you write
- 46:13books, if you make paintings, if you are a digital artist, if
- 46:17you, you know, do something that requires human inspiration? Does it actually
- 46:24require human inspiration anymore? I don't you know. I wonder if chat GPT
- 46:36would generate an apology to my dogs for when I'm leaving to go to the
- 46:39airport and I'm always saying, you know, I'm sorry and I'll be back
- 46:44hanging apologize too, dog for leaving generating there it is dear dog's name.
- 46:58It's got that in brackets. So Linus and Gracie, I want to apologize
- 47:04to you for leaving you alone. I know that being separated from you can
- 47:08be stressful and lonely, and I'm truly sorry for any distress it may have
- 47:13caused you. Sometimes circumstances require me to leave, but please understand it's never
- 47:20easy for me to be away from you. You are an important part of
- 47:23my life and I cherish the time we spend together. I'm scrolling down here.
- 47:30I'm committed to finding ways to spend more quality time with you. Please
- 47:35forgive me for any distress caused by my absence. Wow just blows my mind.
- 47:46We'll go back to the phones and talk more about this stuff. Hang
- 47:51on. Thank you so much for listening to the broadcast. My patron to
- 48:00get the show early and commercial free. Thank you so much for your support.
- 48:06Patreon dot com slash Seth Andrews six four seven Mike are you there?
- 48:15Hi, Seth? How are you on this fine afternoon? I'm well,
- 48:17what do you want to talk about? Well, I want to ask you
- 48:21something really weird. It's about Ais and religion. I think we're very close
- 48:27to Ais becoming conscious and sentient. The question is, once that happens,
- 48:34if the Ais are benevolent, which they probably will be. In my argument
- 48:38for that, I'll tell you real quick is if you look at the trajectory
- 48:43of growth of Homo sapiens over our existence, the more intelligent we got,
- 48:47the more empathetic, sympathetic and loving we got. So it's safe to say
- 48:52that if the Ais are more intelligent than us, they will be quite benevolent.
- 48:58If they are, we're looking at a time when all humanity will get
- 49:02whatever they want whenever they want. And my question is, do you think
- 49:07when that time comes, do you think that religion as an overwhelming majority,
- 49:13not entirely, but as an overwhelming majority will be wiped out? Help me
- 49:17understand, people will get whatever they want whenever they want. They will get
- 49:22that from who or what? From the new alpha species? The Ais?
- 49:29Wait, are we pets or are we cattle? I think if there's AI
- 49:34functioning at that level, well, again, like I say, if you
- 49:37look at the trajectory of growth of ourselves, we become more empathetic and sympathetic.
- 49:42So I don't believe that we will be cattle, and I don't believe
- 49:45we'll be pets either. I believe that we will be viewed as their primitive
- 49:51creators, sort of like you love your grandmother, you know. And I
- 49:55do believe that benevolence will be a big deal. I don't believe the concept
- 50:00of like Sam Harris when he says, none of us really hate ants,
- 50:06and most of us go out of our way not to step on an ant,
- 50:08but if they get in our house or in our way, we have
- 50:12no problem wiping out the entire colony. I don't think that applies to this,
- 50:15because with that level of intellect, the planet Earth is not going to
- 50:20be the only thing. I mean, they can travel the stars it.
- 50:24I believe that we will enter based on objective reality and reasoning. I believe
- 50:32that it will be a time. We are about to enter, a time
- 50:37where Heaven on Earth will actually take place. I believe there's going to be
- 50:40biological immortality, cure of all diseases, including mental health disorders and anything that
- 50:49we like. I say, anything we want, Okay, so let me
- 50:52camp out here quickly. And this is something I hadn't thought about all that
- 50:57much. But you're saying that if AI, as we see, the brain
- 51:00is a computer, if computational technology advances to the point where brains, artificial
- 51:06brains can become conscious, right, they can think at the level where they
- 51:09become self aware, then they would also develop the potential for benevolence. Well,
- 51:16you have to consider anything, you know, unless, of course,
- 51:22you and I are atheists, so we understand that everything's within our own selves.
- 51:25There's no out experience. Somebody says, well, love and justice and
- 51:30all the nice feelings come from a god. Well, then I can't really
- 51:35argue with them. What am I supposed to say? With that said?
- 51:37You and I know full well that anything and everything, including everything we feel,
- 51:44is entirely based on layers of super algorithms in our brain. So if
- 51:51they do achieve higher level intellect than we have, then to suggest that they
- 51:54won't be empathetic or sympathetic or loving is kind of chris. Yeah, I
- 52:00don't know. I mean, what if I'm on the starship Enterprise and Vejure
- 52:04shows up, but I'm just a carbon based unit, right, I mean,
- 52:07I'm infesting the Enterprise. There's no guarantee it would evolve beneficence. You
- 52:14know, what if I'm just in the way. Well, that's the argument
- 52:17that Sam Harris makes With that said, I don't think that applies simply because
- 52:22the universe is a very very large place, and I don't think that they're
- 52:25going to be confined to just planet Earth or starships, you know, things
- 52:31like that. I don't know. We may be the ants in their house
- 52:36and they decide to step on us because we're infesta. This is a hugely
- 52:42hypothetical, abstract, yet fascinating conversation. I myself am amazed and in wonder
- 52:46of and excited about and also terrified about AI. And I see many of
- 52:52these tech people, these tech giants, who are waiving the flags warning us,
- 52:55hey hang on, we are moving way, way, way too fast.
- 52:59I'm going to be speaking to a couple of people, including a physicist
- 53:02next week about religions and aliens, and we're going to talk a little bit
- 53:08about if aliens were to arrive, would they be considered gods, would religions
- 53:15evolve around them? And AI? What if an intelligence surpasses ours, would
- 53:20they be considered gods by some people? And would there be a form of
- 53:23worship that develops on them? So I think you'll enjoy that show next week,
- 53:28Okay, I will. I'm going to make sure I listen to it.
- 53:30But I want to say to that that, yes, indeed they will
- 53:34like when people ask me, is there a God? I always say not
- 53:37yet, because they will be like gods like you. Consider this, Okay,
- 53:40If DNA is to be trusted, we are between one point five and
- 53:45three percent tops more intelligent than chimpanzees. Now, if we could find a
- 53:52way to communicate with them, some kind of language or something, how would
- 53:54we explain to them what a laptop is and the glowing screen that's moving around,
- 54:00and then the multimedia global communication of the Internet. How would we explain
- 54:05that. We couldn't It would be impossible. But the machines aren't going to
- 54:07be no measly three percent more intelligently where are there gonna be hundreds thousands and
- 54:13probably more percent intelligent than we are. They will literally be like gods to
- 54:19all of us. When you put it all together, it is where we're
- 54:22going. Well, and there's just some of this come on. A lot
- 54:24of this is it's just in fact, most of it it's probably conjecture as
- 54:29far as how exponentially the intelligence will go and all and the benevolence of benevolent
- 54:36I mean all of that. I think there's a lot of conjecture. You
- 54:37and I. It's a great I think, philosophical conversation about consciousness and empathy
- 54:44and what would develop in an artificial environment. But in some ways you and
- 54:49I are really guessing. I'm hoping Skynet doesn't find your home address right off
- 54:53the bat. I hope you have a little bit of time to be able
- 54:57to be I really do think at that time religions will die. For the
- 55:00most part. I think it's a time all right, bro, thanks Mike
- 55:05for calling the show. Gave us a lot to think about it. Hey,
- 55:07thanks for doing what you do, so all right, take care.
- 55:10There is a human element to religions that I think. I am not convinced
- 55:16in any way that religion will ever die out. I think fundamentalist faiths may
- 55:22wane, but there is an element I think, to god belief in the
- 55:27religions that surround them, that speak to human suffering and our fears, our
- 55:32fears about pain and calamity, being unsure about the future, certainly the fear
- 55:38of death. I think as long as those things exist and they are part
- 55:43of the human experience, I think we are going to construct happy endings.
- 55:50I think we're going to follow save your figures who say I will protect you
- 55:53and rescue you and lead you to a promise land. I think as long
- 55:58as people experience suffering and starvation and cancer and pain and all of these disadvantages
- 56:05oppression here on earth, they're going to say, one day I will be
- 56:09at a better place, I will achieve a better life. Maybe they'll find
- 56:14inspiration internally with the idea that there is a god out there who may one
- 56:19day rescue them. It's one of the reasons that I call myself now a
- 56:22humanist first, because I just don't think we're going to eradicate or eradicate it.
- 56:28We're not going to marginalize and lock out the fundi religions, especially as
- 56:34long as people continue to hurt and are fearful. When they are hurting and
- 56:38fearful, I think they are often more easy to manipulate by the manipulate ours,
- 56:45and I think they construct the happy ending that they might need to cope.
- 56:49So if we're going to address religious belief and we're going to try to
- 56:53spread rationality, I think that has to be rooted and built on a foundation
- 56:59of real world solutions to human suffering and insecurity. Those things are going to
- 57:07exist in some form, and I think it's one reason of many that religions
- 57:09will always be with us in some form. But it's my hope that the
- 57:14fundamentalist faiths, the dogmatic faiths, will lean more and more away from dogmatism
- 57:22and into humanism and humanitarianism. People may construct their own gods, but those
- 57:29gods will be more benevolent and loving, even if they are artificial intelligence gods.
- 57:37That's I'm going to leave that one to the common section. Gotta run.
- 57:40Thanks for listening. I appreciate you so very much. I'll catch you
- 57:45later. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of
- 57:50podcasts and videos. Products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo,
- 57:54blinks to atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming free thought events
- 58:00and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinking Atheist dot com.