Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / When Life Gives You Lemon...Law Reform
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to today's program, When Life Gives You
- 0:06Lemon Law Reform. I'm Alla Policastro, Director
- 0:10of Education and Professional Development at
- 0:12Beverly Hills Bar Association. And today I'm
- 0:14delighted to introduce our speakers, Erica Kavicki
- 0:17and Michelle Fonseca Kamana. Michelle is the
- 0:21founder and principal attorney at West Coast
- 0:23Lemons APC, a law firm specializing in California
- 0:27lemon law. Having personally negotiated over
- 0:30$14 million worth of settlements from auto and
- 0:33RV manufacturers throughout her career, she is
- 0:36most proud of coupling incredible results with
- 0:39an unparalleled client experience. Her article,
- 0:42When Life Gives You Lemons, Law Reform, in an
- 0:45advocate magazine has been one of the leading
- 0:47publications on the recent changes from AB 1755.
- 0:52Michelle serves on the board of consumer attorneys
- 0:54of California and dedicates significant time
- 0:56to mentoring other attorneys on how to start
- 1:00their own law practice. Erica is the founder
- 1:03of Lemon Law Lawyers Group, Inc. She has over
- 1:0620 years of legal experience with the last 14
- 1:09years dedicated exclusively to lemon law litigation.
- 1:13She has successfully settled hundreds of cases
- 1:15for consumer clients against big car manufacturers
- 1:18while obtaining results beyond expectation for
- 1:21those clients pushed to trial. Erica has tried
- 1:23over 30 bench and jury trials throughout her
- 1:26career, conducted hundreds of administrative
- 1:28hearings, and has successfully argued in front
- 1:30of the San Diego Court of appeals. We can't wait
- 1:33to hear what they have to share with us today.
- 1:34So I'm going to turn it over to them. All right,
- 1:38welcome, everyone. So we're going to get our
- 1:42slides going here. All right, next slide, please.
- 1:50All right, so if you've been practicing lemon
- 1:53law over the last year, you know, it has been
- 1:56absolute chaos So we had Rodriguez come down
- 2:00last October We've had this AV 1755 get passed
- 2:04and then we had SB 26 get passed So we have a
- 2:09lot to talk about here today next slide All right,
- 2:18so I don't want to spend a lot of time on Rodriguez,
- 2:20but most of us are well aware Rodriguez basically
- 2:23tanks used car cases against the manufacturer
- 2:26So we've got our carve out if they're certified
- 2:30pre -owned these cases still live on But something
- 2:34that I just wanted to note here during today's
- 2:36presentation because I see a lot of misunderstanding
- 2:40of Rodriguez used car cases under song Beverly
- 2:45are not completely gone. You can still have a
- 2:48song Beverly case against a dealership. So same
- 2:52type of analysis, you look at who's the warrant
- 2:54or were the defects covered under that warranty?
- 2:58Have there been enough presentations? So take
- 3:01a look at your cases. If you're getting used
- 3:03car leads, don't just automatically reject them.
- 3:07Take a look at the facts. Also take a look at
- 3:10civil code section 1795 .5. We still have a duty
- 3:15to to these used car customers. So take a look
- 3:18at the law on this. Don't completely assume that
- 3:20because Rodriguez came down used car cases across
- 3:23the border out. look at cases against the dealerships
- 3:27based off of their warranties, look at the buyer's
- 3:30guide, look at CLRA. There are a lot of different
- 3:33ways we can still take on these types of cases.
- 3:37Next slide. Just briefly on the Rodriguez, if
- 3:41you have current cases with used vehicles, expect
- 3:46the manufacturers to most likely file a motion
- 3:48for summary judgment. Be creative when you amend
- 3:51your complaint. Add in additional claims to keep
- 3:55your case alive. Definitely good advice there.
- 4:00And then AB 1755. So this has been absolute chaos
- 4:06over the last year. So we really want to get
- 4:09into this. So AB 1755, formally approved by Governor
- 4:13Gavin Newsom back in September of 2024. This
- 4:19has been probably the biggest reform to lemon
- 4:21law since it started. So major, major changes
- 4:24came through statute of limitations, damages
- 4:27and procedure. Next slide. Key dates for this
- 4:35statute. Original AB 1755 implementation date.
- 4:40It went into effect across the board for every
- 4:43single defendant essentially January 1st, 2025.
- 4:48We then saw some issues with SB 26 come through,
- 4:52but from January 1st, 2025 to about April 1st,
- 4:562025, this was the new law that applied to everyone.
- 5:01Next slide. And then came SB 26, probably the
- 5:07worst thing that's ever happened to lemon law.
- 5:10Proved by Gavin or Newsom, April 2nd, 2025, it
- 5:14allowed the defendants to choose which law applies
- 5:17to them via some changes to the Code of Civil
- 5:21Procedure. The worst part of it was it was retroactive
- 5:26as well. So from January to April, We really
- 5:30didn't know what law was going to apply since
- 5:32this code section ended up being retroactive.
- 5:36Next slide. So key dates on SB 26, it passed
- 5:42April 2nd, 2025. It created a 30 -day opt -in
- 5:46for defendants to take a look at the new law,
- 5:48decide whether they wanted to opt into it or
- 5:51just stay out of it. Once that deadline hit,
- 5:54the Department of Consumer Affairs then had another
- 5:57month to make sure everything was posted on their
- 5:59website. However, as we saw, Department of Consumer
- 6:03Affairs was pretty quick with it. We had a pretty
- 6:07stable list well before June 1st, 2025, but at
- 6:11this point, that list is pretty locked in at
- 6:14least as two cases filed in 2025. Next slide.
- 6:20Someone's asking a question about the materials.
- 6:24They're unable to get the materials I think?
- 6:26You should have gotten an email with the materials
- 6:28I believe, but we can circle back with the Beverly
- 6:31Hills Bar Association folks and give you a little
- 6:34bit more information at the end, but you will
- 6:37be provided with the materials and it should
- 6:41be in the chat. All right, so the initial opt
- 6:46-in There's the code section just for reference.
- 6:49So 30 days, 60 days. And then the important one,
- 6:54I think, is subdivision C, where it made this
- 6:57statute retroactive. So definitely, if you have
- 7:01cases filed between January 1st, 2025 and April
- 7:051st, 2025, take a look at this statute. It's
- 7:09going to be very, very helpful for you to determine
- 7:11what law actually applies to those cases and
- 7:14what can you enforce. Next slide. So this is
- 7:22going to be something ongoing, unfortunately.
- 7:26So these opt -ins aren't forever. defendants
- 7:31opt -in. they are opting in for a period of five
- 7:33consecutive calendar years and they can't withdraw
- 7:37the election. so right now based off of the people
- 7:40that are on the list on the initial opt -in,
- 7:43they're going to be locked in for the next five
- 7:45years. so you know come 2020 what 2029 we're
- 7:51going to want to start taking a look at who's
- 7:53going to remain on this opt -in list and who
- 7:56may have basically revoked their opt -in then.
- 8:01However, I imagine there's going to be a few
- 8:05manufacturers that have kind of seen how things
- 8:08have played out with the new law and may decide
- 8:10to opt in. So their opt -in deadline for 2026
- 8:14and the next five years is actually coming up
- 8:17at the end of this month. They have to opt in
- 8:19by October 31st of this year to be able to have
- 8:24the new law applied to them in 2026 and beyond.
- 8:28So Their opt -in date is October 31st, then we
- 8:32go through the whole process of them putting
- 8:34it on their website through Department of Consumer
- 8:36Affairs. So by December 15th, we should have
- 8:40a new list of all the car manufacturers, RV manufacturers
- 8:46that are opting into the AB1755. Put a little
- 8:51tickler on your calendar for December 15th because
- 8:54you're going to want to take a look at who's
- 8:57opting in for 2026 and adjust your processes
- 9:00that way. Next slide. And they usually pretty
- 9:04good about, I think we provided a link on one
- 9:07of these slides for the web page that shows which
- 9:11ones have opted in, which ones are not in, and
- 9:14where to send your demand letters to. Exactly,
- 9:18exactly. Department of Consumer Affairs, to their
- 9:20credit, they've made it pretty simple for us
- 9:23to check out, you know, all of the contact info,
- 9:26which is good. So, damages. AB 1755 changed a
- 9:31lot when it comes to damages, but it's important
- 9:34to kind of see where we started, what our original
- 9:37law was. So, Civil Code Section 1794, that's
- 9:41our main statute for damages in song Beverly
- 9:43cases, as many of you know. the words that i
- 9:47really want you to focus on is it's not just
- 9:51repurchases or replacements which is our standard
- 9:54settlements in these lemon law cases under 1794
- 9:58you may bring an action for the recovery of damages
- 10:01and other legal and equitable relief so it's
- 10:05not just your repurchase it's not just your replacement
- 10:08you've got those very open -ended damages statute.
- 10:12You also have UCC damages in addition to your
- 10:16repurchase or replacement. So this is going to
- 10:19be important to note when you're analyzing what
- 10:21the new law takes on and what it takes off. So
- 10:25next slide. So what is not included? So this
- 10:32is the new kind of main start of this new AB
- 10:351755 statute. Code of Civil Procedure, Section
- 10:39871 .20. So I've highlighted some of these keywords
- 10:44I want you to really hone in on. So notwithstanding
- 10:48any other law, this chapter applies to an action
- 10:51brought against a manufacturer. So notably, This
- 10:55doesn't apply to dealership defendants. And as
- 10:57we talked about with Rodriguez 1795 .5, used
- 11:01car cases still can live on under Song Beverly
- 11:05against the dealerships. As long as the stars
- 11:08align, I mean, it is kind of tough, but those
- 11:10cases can still live on there. So this is just
- 11:14against manufacturers. The second part to note
- 11:18is seeking restitution or replacement of a motor
- 11:21vehicle pursuant to those code sections. So we're
- 11:25looking at buybacks, we're looking at replacements.
- 11:28As we just saw in 1794, you can ask for a lot
- 11:32of different types of damages that aren't necessarily
- 11:35restitution or replacement. So keep that in mind
- 11:38if you have a case where you might have statute
- 11:42of limitations issues, where maybe you can try
- 11:45to get a repair covered under this as the damages.
- 11:50Get creative, especially on cases where they
- 11:53might be... otherwise left without any remedies
- 11:56because of these new statutes. The last thing
- 12:00to note is the where the request for restitution
- 12:04or replacement is based on non -compliance with
- 12:06the applicable express warranty. So what does
- 12:09that leave out? Leaves out the implied warranty,
- 12:11right? So keep that in mind when you're looking
- 12:14at this code. It's not just this all -inclusive
- 12:17where it's every song Beverly case is now covered
- 12:20under AB1755. There are some carve -outs so make
- 12:25sure you understand where you might be able to
- 12:27take advantage of these carve -outs. And the
- 12:30last section chapter does not apply to service
- 12:33contract claims or anything like that. So that's
- 12:36just kind of another carve out. So be thinking
- 12:38about these other different types of claims that
- 12:41might not be your usual restitution replacement
- 12:44based off of violation of the or breach of the
- 12:47express warranty. Next slide. So if you've been
- 12:54practicing you probably heard the term legacy
- 12:57cases especially from you know, some of these
- 13:00manufacturers like General Motors, so defense
- 13:04position they are very gung -ho on drawing a
- 13:09line in the sand of January 1st 2025 and on and
- 13:13anything that was filed before that so they've
- 13:15been calling anything before that these legacy
- 13:18cases And so depending on the facts of your case,
- 13:23there might be certain things in the new law
- 13:25that might benefit your clients. So if you're
- 13:28in that situation where you do wanna pull from
- 13:30some of the new law, there are arguments you
- 13:33can make. However, quick little disclaimer, as
- 13:37we all know, arguing with these manufacturers
- 13:40is sometimes like talking to a brick wall. So
- 13:43if you can even get to talk to them, that's the
- 13:45biggest problem too that we're facing here is
- 13:48that a lot of the manufacturers, you cannot,
- 13:50it's not like the olden days, which is like last
- 13:52year, where you could get them on the phone or
- 13:55you can get them via text message or email and
- 13:58actually have a communication with them about
- 14:00a case. They are so overwhelmed over there. They
- 14:04don't know who's handling what. And the legacy
- 14:06cases are the ones that are falling through.
- 14:08through the cracks. Those are the ones where
- 14:09I think as consumer attorneys, we have the biggest
- 14:12advantage on because we can keep progressing
- 14:15those cases while they're so worried about the
- 14:18new ones, we can progress the legacy ones and
- 14:21push them towards trial and get some resolution
- 14:25that's more favorable to our consumer. Absolutely,
- 14:29absolutely. We wanted to throw out the law in
- 14:33there. So it's good to know what the law is on
- 14:34this, whether you're going to be able to speak
- 14:36logic to some of these, you know, people on the
- 14:39defense side is a whole different thing that
- 14:41we cannot promise or guarantee or warrant. But
- 14:44at least here's something, some tools that you
- 14:47can use in your tool belt. So a lot of the things
- 14:49that they've been pushing back on is, you know,
- 14:52there should be implementation dates. If the
- 14:54whole AB 1755 were to apply to these legacy cases,
- 14:58the legislature would have said so. And so you
- 15:01can point out there are actually very specific
- 15:04implementation dates for different provisions.
- 15:06So we've listed some of those out. So if their
- 15:11argument made sense, there is a provision that
- 15:15says it only applies to civil actions filed on
- 15:17or after January 1st, 2025. That would have been
- 15:20listed at the very beginning to apply to the
- 15:22whole law. It only applies to certain provisions
- 15:25of it. And so that's part A of your argument,
- 15:28part B of your argument. case laws on our side
- 15:31so as long as it's something that affects things
- 15:35that haven't happened yet so for example your
- 15:37settlement procedures damages something like
- 15:39that where that has not yet concluded you can
- 15:43actually pull from the new statute so there's
- 15:45two cases that talk about this so definitely
- 15:48look into these cases look at the brief briefing
- 15:51on this You can shoot your shot with the manufacturer,
- 15:56see if you can get a couple wins for your clients,
- 15:58if there are provisions in the new law that could
- 16:00help your current clients on these legacy cases.
- 16:04Next slide. I have a question here. It says,
- 16:07manufacturers are overwhelmed and hard to get
- 16:10a hold of. If they don't respond to our demand
- 16:12letter within 30 days, is this enough for civil
- 16:14penalties? We will get to the civil penalty section
- 16:17in a little bit, but that is a very good question.
- 16:21All right, so Statute of Limitation. Wait, go
- 16:25back, I think. There we go. All right, Statute
- 16:28of Limitation. So now we have been blessed with
- 16:30two Statutes of Limitation to worry about instead
- 16:33of just one. So Statute of Limitation number
- 16:37one. It's one year after the expiration of the
- 16:41applicable express warranty. The second one is
- 16:45six years from the date of original delivery
- 16:47of the vehicle. So we've got the code sections
- 16:50there. Take a look at it. But generally speaking,
- 16:52you've got your one year and you've got your
- 16:54six year. Next slide. Here's where these things
- 17:00can get very, very tricky and dangerous. So on
- 17:05the one year statute, if you're dealing with
- 17:07just your run of the mill, normal lemon law case
- 17:10on a car truck, even a car that's over three
- 17:14years is now gonna be considered kind of an older
- 17:16car because of these warranties and because of
- 17:20these statute of limitations. So if you've got
- 17:23a car that is, for example, four years old, your
- 17:28spiny census should be taking a look at that
- 17:30because if the problem is covered under the basic
- 17:34warranty, and for example, if they have a three
- 17:35or 36 ,000 mile basic warranty, That means your
- 17:39statute assuming it's a lower mileage vehicle
- 17:42that runs at year four if the problems You're
- 17:45suing for are covered under that basic warranty.
- 17:49So if you've got infotainment issues air conditioning
- 17:52stuff like that Be very aware. This statute is
- 17:56going to sneak up on a lot of people The other
- 18:00problem, RVs. I'm already seeing a lot of issues
- 18:04with statute of limitations on RVs. A lot of
- 18:07RVs only have a one to two year warranty. Being
- 18:10a recreational vehicle people aren't just it's
- 18:13not their daily driver. They're going on camping
- 18:15trips a few times a year So that time period
- 18:19goes by very very quickly and the RV manufacturers
- 18:22especially are very good at kind of drawing things
- 18:25out when they're talking to customers about Oh,
- 18:28let us make it right. We'll give you an extended
- 18:30warranty. We'll give you You know a little cash
- 18:32settlement before you know it on a one -year
- 18:37Warranty on an RV by year two, statute of limitations
- 18:41is run and you're done. So be very, very careful
- 18:45when you're looking at these types of vehicles,
- 18:48RVs especially, or normal vehicles where the
- 18:51defect is something covered under the basic warranty
- 18:54or one of the shorter warranties. Next slide.
- 19:01So the six -year statute also something we're
- 19:04gonna see a lot of lot of problems with so certified
- 19:07pre -owned vehicles especially so most of them
- 19:10are six years old or less at the time of sale,
- 19:13but For example, if you've got a certified pre
- 19:17-owned car that was five years old at the time
- 19:19of sale, that means you only have about a year
- 19:22for the client to drive the car around, see what
- 19:24the problems are, take it in for all the repairs,
- 19:26and really build the case in a very short amount
- 19:29of time compared to what normal, you know, a
- 19:32brand new vehicle is. So if you're dealing with
- 19:34certified pre -owned vehicles, You may want to
- 19:37move quickly once they get to be leads for you
- 19:40because these stochitive limitations are going
- 19:42to run out very very quickly. Next slide. So
- 19:51not everything was bad. Some positive news, at
- 19:55least. We have a few positive changes when it
- 19:58comes to damages. So the best one for us and
- 20:02for a lot of our clients is this code section
- 20:04871 .27B. So as we know, when a lot of our clients
- 20:09go into the dealership, they're sold, take it
- 20:12or leave it. You have to add on $6 ,000 worth
- 20:16of aftermarket accessories, theft deterrent devices,
- 20:20extended warranties, gap insurance, you name
- 20:22it, they're gonna add it to the contract. And
- 20:24then a lot of the manufacturers will try to nickel
- 20:26and dime our clients on that. This new code section
- 20:30helps us out a lot because as long as these basically
- 20:34aftermarket additions are supplied by the selling
- 20:37or leasing dealership, They can be recoverable
- 20:41as damages, which means they can't be deducted
- 20:44So take a look at your purchase contracts. Take
- 20:47a look at your lease agreements Generally speaking
- 20:49if these additions are listed on that original
- 20:52document They can be recoverable as damages and
- 20:56you can also cancel them for pro rated refunds,
- 20:59especially when it comes to those Contract type
- 21:02things extend warranty service contracts and
- 21:04gap insurance And we are seeing this applied
- 21:07to legacy cases. So I never gave them these deductions
- 21:11to begin with, but now it's not a fight. They're
- 21:14just including it and not trying to subtract
- 21:17it anymore. Yeah. Yeah. So for the most part,
- 21:20we're not seeing too much pushback. I did see
- 21:22a little bit of a pushback on one case recently.
- 21:25So just something to be aware of. If they're
- 21:28trying to take these deductions, have this code
- 21:30section in your back pocket, cite it. This is
- 21:34the new way. But also keep in mind if your clients
- 21:39are getting their cars, you know wrapped window
- 21:42tinted stuff after purchase after lease You can
- 21:46still argue to have those expenses reimbursed
- 21:48But your your this isn't really going to benefit
- 21:51you for things that happen after the sale or
- 21:53after the original lease next slide So another
- 22:00positive change is in 871 .27 G that really talks
- 22:06about the processing of these cases. So before
- 22:09it was kind of the wild, wild west when it came
- 22:12to how everyone was processing these cases. So
- 22:15now we have it in statute, settlement processing
- 22:19within 30 days from receipt of assigned release
- 22:22from plaintiffs council. You get the buyback
- 22:25check provided to client at the time of surrender,
- 22:27so it's not checks in the mail kind of thing
- 22:29anymore. And there's also a mandatory $50 a day
- 22:33penalty until the settlement is completed if
- 22:37they go over that 30 day mark. However, there
- 22:41is that little asterisk at the end subject to
- 22:44good faith responding to reasonable documentation
- 22:46required to process settlement. So just make
- 22:50sure you have your ducks in a row. Make sure
- 22:52you have your financial documents, payment history,
- 22:54payoff quote, any incidental damages. Just have
- 22:57that ready to go so you're not looking at delays
- 22:59caused by you and that way you can maximize your
- 23:02client's recovery and you can make sure these
- 23:04things are actually taking place in a timely
- 23:07fashion. Next slide. So we had a good break on
- 23:14good news. Back to the bad news. CCP section
- 23:20871 .27c, negative equity is now a statutory
- 23:25deduction. Negative equity. Historically, the
- 23:29manufacturers have tried to deduct it. There
- 23:31are some good arguments or were some good arguments
- 23:34prior to this being codified, but just something
- 23:37to be aware of. If your clients are rolling debt
- 23:41into their new car purchase, that's a lemon,
- 23:44the manufacturers kind of have this in their
- 23:46back pocket now. The other thing that has happened
- 23:52is Creighton versus FCA seems to have been in
- 23:56a way codified now in this new law. Quick refresher,
- 24:00if you're not familiar with Creighton, it basically
- 24:03talks about whether residual value on a lease
- 24:06can be included in the consumer's actual damages.
- 24:09And if so, how do they play into civil penalty
- 24:12damages? So unfortunately, Creighton didn't exactly
- 24:16go our way. Residual value on a lease did not
- 24:20fall under actual price paid or payable. So they
- 24:23wanted to see actual payments toward it. So next
- 24:27slide. This is what AB 1755 essentially did to
- 24:34these types of damages. So if you have a lease
- 24:38when it comes to just your normal damages, amounts
- 24:41paid or payable under the original lease terms
- 24:44are still reimbursable. So nothing is changing
- 24:46there. If your clients are making payments towards
- 24:49the lease, they get that back. It's included
- 24:51in actual damages. It's included in civil penalty
- 24:54damages. The thing to note too is it's also included
- 24:58if you purchase the car out of the lease and
- 25:01the residual is financed. So if your clients,
- 25:04a lot of clients are buying cars out of leases
- 25:08pretty quickly to take advantage of tax deductions.
- 25:11So if you have clients in that situation, if
- 25:15they're financing the car, those payments still
- 25:17count just as much as if they were under the
- 25:20original lease and then that residual value as
- 25:23well. Next slide When it comes to civil penalties,
- 25:30they do make a few different distinctions. So
- 25:33the first one is based off of a lease extension
- 25:36so They put a little bit of a leash on when you
- 25:40can do these lease extensions So keep in mind
- 25:44if you have a legacy case and you're like deep
- 25:46into it The timing of the lease extension could
- 25:50be a problem for you. So take a look at this
- 25:52code section, but For most cases, especially
- 25:55if they're early on, if you haven't sent a demand
- 25:57yet, if you haven't filed a lawsuit yet, the
- 26:01payments under the lease extension can be included
- 26:04in both damages and civil penalties. Just make
- 26:07sure the lease extension is triggered no later
- 26:10than 30 days after the pre -suit notice, so like
- 26:13your pre -lit demand or 30 days after filing
- 26:15a lawsuit, whichever is earlier. Next slide.
- 26:22When it comes to residual value, really take
- 26:26a look or think of this as the lease buyout.
- 26:30When your clients are buying the car out of the
- 26:32lease, basically they're financing the residual
- 26:35value more times than not. If they are doing
- 26:38that, suddenly it turns into a purchase type
- 26:42of evaluation. These payments are included and
- 26:46the residual value can be included, but There's
- 26:49also that timing element. You have to buy it
- 26:52out of the lease no later than 30 days after
- 26:55your pre -let demand or 30 days after filing
- 26:58a lawsuit. So that is kind of the hack, I guess,
- 27:03to including all of that residual value into
- 27:07both your damages and your civil penalties, but
- 27:10you have to act quickly. Next slide. procedural
- 27:17changes. So we've got some some new timelines.
- 27:23They equally hit us as much as it hits the manufacturers.
- 27:27So when you're filing these lawsuits, you want
- 27:30to just make sure to calendar these dates from
- 27:33the beginning. You do not want to miss these
- 27:35deadlines. So the key deadlines to be aware of,
- 27:3960 days from the filing of an answer or other
- 27:41responsive pleading, initial disclosures are
- 27:44due from both sides. And I think they've been
- 27:47kind of aggressive on the initial disclosures.
- 27:49Yeah, I've had the experience of them being quite
- 27:51aggressive on that. First off, Biggest tip I
- 27:53can give you when you're doing intake on these
- 27:57cases and it's a case that's going to fall under
- 27:59the new procedures, make sure you talk to the
- 28:02client, get the financials, get the documents
- 28:05you need for those initial disclosures right
- 28:07away because otherwise you're chasing them for
- 28:09them and if you don't get them in time and you
- 28:12don't serve them in time then now you're looking
- 28:14at sanctions and sanctions are pretty much automatic.
- 28:17They're not something that, you know, courts
- 28:19are not unwilling to sanctioned for. So definitely
- 28:23do that. I think you asked me a question about
- 28:32that. Oh, yeah, the initial disclosures because
- 28:34they're they're even filing sanctions. Yeah,
- 28:36so I did get one. I actually got a motion for
- 28:41sanctions with a General Motors case because
- 28:44I didn't provide current registration. However,
- 28:47my client did not have current registration.
- 28:50He had expired registration, which we provided
- 28:52and I provided a note and over there, their discovery
- 28:57team, their litigation team, nobody talks to
- 28:59each other. So while I gave this information
- 29:02over to the litigation team, the discovery team
- 29:05apparently did not get that information. So I
- 29:08received a motion for sanctions for not providing
- 29:11current registration in violation of the initial
- 29:15disclosures. And I served them with a 128 .7
- 29:20motion, which you have to serve, I think it's
- 29:2321 days in advance and let them know that their
- 29:26sanction motion was frivolous. They called me
- 29:29the... But the lesson from that is that they
- 29:33are going to be, and they intend to be aggressive
- 29:35on failure to provide everything that is listed
- 29:39in the initial disclosures if your client has
- 29:41it. Yeah, that is a very good lesson and story
- 29:48for us. So initial disclosures, be ready so you
- 29:53don't have to get ready. 120 days out you have
- 29:57the right to take the deposition of their PMK
- 29:59So as we all know it takes forever to get PMK
- 30:02depot date So be aggressive with this notice
- 30:05those depositions early on Set a date unilaterally,
- 30:09but let them know like look if this doesn't work
- 30:11Please provide me with a couple different dates
- 30:12that way you're building your paper trail from
- 30:14the beginning and making a point I'm not trying
- 30:17to waive any of these procedural deadlines. We
- 30:19are going to meet every single deadline, but
- 30:22just be aware you need to be ready to comply
- 30:24with your own deadlines as well. Also, with regard
- 30:27to the plaintiff's deposition, they will initially
- 30:30when they send the answer, they will send you
- 30:32a notice for plaintiff's deposition. If that
- 30:34date doesn't work, object to it, but I would
- 30:37suggest that you put in two to three dates that
- 30:40work for your client for that deposition. in
- 30:43your objection. Chances are they're not going
- 30:45to read it, and they're going to blow over those
- 30:47dates anyway. But if they go after you for a
- 30:49motion to compel that deposition, now you've
- 30:51got this exhibit to show the judge, hey, we're
- 30:54trying to cooperate here. We're trying to be
- 30:59in compliance. And then I just got a question
- 31:01on what's a PMK. That's the person most knowledgeable
- 31:04at the manufacturer. So that's someone who, and
- 31:06I think we'll get to it later in the slides,
- 31:08has to be able to testify competently under for
- 31:12the manufacturer regarding certain topics. Exactly,
- 31:16exactly. And if you take a look at this code
- 31:18section, the 871 .26, it goes into a lot more
- 31:23detail about these things. So definitely check
- 31:25that out because it says exactly what the initial
- 31:28disclosures have to be for plaintiff, what they
- 31:30have to be for defendant. It talks about plaintiff's
- 31:33deposition. timeframes, PMK deposition, I believe
- 31:38categories are listed out on there as well, mediation,
- 31:43they're also saying on the mediation, I believe.
- 31:45They have to have someone with authority at these
- 31:47mediations under these AB 1755 cases. And some
- 31:51of these manufacturers love to go to mediation
- 31:54without someone with authority. Right. And kind
- 31:56of waste people's time. So just be aware that
- 31:59there are a lot of little nuggets in there in
- 32:01this code section that you can use to your advantage
- 32:04to hold them accountable, especially since violations
- 32:07of these things carry mandatory sanctions and
- 32:11it's sanctions against the defense attorney that
- 32:13can be reportable to the state bar so if they
- 32:16keep messing up we all know the defense firms
- 32:19and defense attorneys that tend to not respond
- 32:21not do their jobs this could be a powerful way
- 32:25for us to try to get things moving hopefully
- 32:27get them better staffing I don't know we need
- 32:31some changes on the on their staffing for sure
- 32:33but take a look at this so mediation must be
- 32:36scheduled 90 days out The biggest thing I think
- 32:39I've seen through AB1755 is mediation dates are
- 32:43nearly impossible. Yeah, we have a question here.
- 32:46It says, who is responsible for coordinating
- 32:47slash scheduling the mediation? Is this private?
- 32:50And if so, who pays? OK, great question. It's
- 32:55supposed to be a mutual agreed upon mediator.
- 32:58And the mediators that are typically being used
- 33:00in consumer litigation seem to be jam packed
- 33:03until January, February, March right now. And
- 33:07so don't delay. As soon as you file a case, I
- 33:10would start contacting the mediators, finding
- 33:12out what dates they have available, maybe even
- 33:14holding a date because the mediators will allow
- 33:16you to hold a date and then you can cancel it.
- 33:19two weeks in advance or something like that depends
- 33:21on the mediator but yes it is uh it's your responsibility
- 33:25as well as the defense's responsibility to get
- 33:27together and coordinate that mediation date so
- 33:30you have to just really keep trying with them
- 33:33because you need a paper trail absolute paper
- 33:35trail with them because if this goes in front
- 33:37of the judge and and um i've had several judges
- 33:40actually now who are asking about the mediation
- 33:43date and when it was completed or when it will
- 33:45be completed and if you don't have that paper
- 33:48troll you're both going to get sanctioned. Yeah,
- 33:51take a look at the code section because I believe
- 33:53it talks about also like who has to pay I believe
- 33:55it's half and half But obviously we get our costs
- 33:57back so you would get that back once you're successful
- 34:00or the prevailing party But take a look at that
- 34:03code section But pro tip that 90 days out to
- 34:06schedule mediation if you're waiting till 90
- 34:08days out It's too late. You like you need to
- 34:10start, you know when you when they file the answer
- 34:13like hit them with your PMK depot dates, get
- 34:16mediation dates going. That way you're building
- 34:18your paper trail and you're setting yourself
- 34:21up for success. Because if you're being proactive,
- 34:24you're going to get those dates. You're probably
- 34:25going to get mediators that you actually want
- 34:27to work with. And that just puts pressure on
- 34:29them because they know you're not letting anything
- 34:31slip through the cracks. Squeaky Wheel gets the
- 34:35grease if you know on a lot of these cases. So
- 34:38make sure you are very, very prepared when it
- 34:40comes to these different timelines. Next slide.
- 34:48So the bad thing is discovery has stayed during
- 34:50this period. So we're very limited on what we
- 34:53can do. But we still have usually enough to be
- 34:57able to go through the PMK depot and get a pretty
- 35:00effective mediation done and get these cases
- 35:03done. But just also be aware, sanctions are mandatory
- 35:06for non -compliance. There's monetary sanctions.
- 35:09And the good thing for us For repeat violations
- 35:13by the other side, there can be evidentiary sanctions
- 35:16where basically your underlying lemon law case
- 35:19is proven for you. So keep an eye out for that.
- 35:22And it's just another reason why you want to
- 35:24be proactive with pushing these different deadlines.
- 35:27So you show the court, look, I'm just following
- 35:29the law here. They don't respect the law. We
- 35:32are entitled to evidentiary sanctions in this
- 35:34case. And just a quick note with regards back
- 35:37to the person most knowledgeable deposition.
- 35:40Just know that most likely they're going to offer
- 35:43up to somebody that knows nothing about the case
- 35:47and most likely nothing about Lenin Law. So it's
- 35:50also important when you are deposing these people
- 35:52to get the information that they don't know.
- 35:54Because that's going to help in your mediation,
- 35:57that's going to help in litigation, that's going
- 35:58to help if you're going in front of a jury, you
- 36:00know, and you can talk about, you can cross -examine
- 36:03them all the stuff that he didn't know at that
- 36:06deposition that he was supposed to know. I have
- 36:09been finding, at least in my experience, that
- 36:11the discovery that we've been receiving post
- 36:13-871 .25 is actually more extensive than we were
- 36:17getting before. Go through everything. I mean,
- 36:20I'm getting thousands of pages per case, phone
- 36:23calls, recordings. Go through it. There's little
- 36:26nuggets of gold hidden in there that you can
- 36:28talk to the person with most knowledge about.
- 36:30But also, you can use that at mediation to potentially
- 36:33get a civil penalty or extra incidental damages
- 36:37if you don't want to call it a civil penalty.
- 36:40But there are some things that you can find within
- 36:44the discovery they're giving now that was different
- 36:46and more extensive than prior. prior to 871 .25
- 36:49or 26. Absolutely, absolutely. Yeah, because
- 36:53on the PMK depot thing, I've gotten so many recently
- 36:56where their only skill is they can read documents.
- 37:00Their responses are, well, that's what the document
- 37:02says. That's what the document says. If they
- 37:03receive the document. Because sometimes they
- 37:05don't even receive the documents. And they're
- 37:07just kind of flying blind and basically saying
- 37:10or admitting they're saying what the attorneys
- 37:12told them to say. Exactly. So build your paper
- 37:15trail because once again, if they're not actually
- 37:17producing a true PMK as to the categories listed
- 37:20in this code section, guess what sanctions and
- 37:24if they do keep doing it evidentiary sanctions.
- 37:28Next slide. So civil penalty procedure going
- 37:33back to one of the previous questions I believe
- 37:36so. Keep this in mind. So on cases that you're
- 37:41filing after July 1st, 2025, you need to go through
- 37:45this procedure. There's contact information for
- 37:48the defendants that have opted in. On some of
- 37:52these earlier cases a lot of the manufacturers
- 37:54especially on some older cars You know their
- 37:56owners manual the warranty booklets not gonna
- 37:58have this info on it because it was printed pre
- 38:01this law So you can always check the Department
- 38:04of Consumer Affairs website. We put the link
- 38:06in here Just so you have it but you're gonna
- 38:10want to honestly I have that link bookmarked
- 38:12on my desktop because I'm constantly looking
- 38:15at it and especially as these new opt -in deadlines
- 38:17come through and on December 15th you're going
- 38:21to want to refresh that. So make sure you, attorneys,
- 38:24paralegal staff, everyone has access to this.
- 38:27Do you want me to reread the questions so you
- 38:29can answer it now? Oh, sure. Manufacturers are
- 38:32overwhelmed and hard to get a hold of. If they
- 38:34don't respond to our demand letter within 30
- 38:36days, is this enough for civil penalties? Yes,
- 38:40especially if you're doing this now. So make
- 38:43sure your demand letter complies with this procedure.
- 38:47So this procedure is pretty simple to follow.
- 38:50Go to the next slide. I might have more information
- 38:53on this on the next one. Here we go. So you send
- 38:57your initial demand letter. So you can send it
- 38:59via mail or you can do it via email. So you brought
- 39:04up a good point of sending it via mail because
- 39:06that kind of buys you a little bit of time, right?
- 39:08And then also they will respond to you within
- 39:11a day or two and then you'll get or what I've
- 39:15seen and I haven't been doing a lot of these
- 39:16for reasons we'll talk about later, but my initial
- 39:20ones I would get a response that says, okay,
- 39:23we're gonna buy back the car. Please send the
- 39:25fine in. financials. At that point the consumer's
- 39:28responsibility triggers and you have to send
- 39:30the financials payoff, loan payment history,
- 39:34registration, incidentals, anything. You have
- 39:37to send all that as you know as efficiently as
- 39:39possible to assist in the process. I have also
- 39:43been receiving from, should I name the manufacturer?
- 39:46General Motors. They sent me an email saying
- 39:51we would like to evaluate your case for or a
- 39:55buyback. So it's not even an offer for a repurchase.
- 39:59It's send us the documents to evaluate your case.
- 40:02No, that's not what A71 .24 says. The consumer's
- 40:07responsibility only triggers once there's an
- 40:09offer on the table. So I ignore those. And it's
- 40:12been going pretty well. Yeah, so when in doubt,
- 40:17just go back and read the code section. You'll
- 40:19find a lot of nice little loopholes there. So
- 40:22on that one, there's a good faith requirement
- 40:24for documentation required to complete restitution
- 40:28or replacement. So those repair orders are not
- 40:30required to complete anything. It's the financials.
- 40:34So keep that in mind when you're dealing with
- 40:36the manufacturers on these kind of pre -lit cases
- 40:39where you're trying to build that civil penalty
- 40:41case. But if you do it right, You send your notice,
- 40:45it's basically got, you know, the consumer's
- 40:48information, the VIN number, brief summary, like,
- 40:50oh, I'm having check engine light problems. It's
- 40:53been in four times. And then that specific request,
- 40:56I'm looking for a repurchase. I'm looking for
- 40:59replacement. You don't need to send this whole
- 41:02long thing. You don't need to send docs with
- 41:04that pre -lit request. It's really just look
- 41:06at the code and just send what is required. Then
- 41:09they have 30 days to make a yes or no decision.
- 41:12So even on some of those where they're harassing
- 41:14us for the purchase contract. Right before it's
- 41:1930 days, they're magically like, oh, we're going
- 41:20to buy it back. So just keep that in mind. And
- 41:25then from that time, then they have 60 days from
- 41:29the original notice date to process the settlement.
- 41:32So you want to be ready with financials the day
- 41:35that you get that, hey, we're going to buy it
- 41:37back. Send. the financials over, you want to
- 41:40be ready with those financials so that you can
- 41:42actually hold them to the 60 -day mark. And sometimes
- 41:45it takes 10 business days to get payment histories
- 41:49from credit unions from some banks. So just put
- 41:52your client on notice that you'll need that and
- 41:55that way you'll have it so you're not burning
- 41:59some of the days. You want them to burn the days.
- 42:01You don't want to be the one burning the days
- 42:02because you want to be able to qualify for you
- 42:04to file the lawsuit if they can't make it. Exactly,
- 42:08exactly. Yeah, I'm asking for financials like
- 42:10right when I'm signing these clients out because
- 42:12I know this is coming in 30 days. Next slide.
- 42:24For the first time really I believe gives Plaintiffs'
- 42:27Council the right to pre -lit fees. However,
- 42:30the manufacturers are kind of going rogue and
- 42:33their standard offer pretty much across the board
- 42:36is $1 ,500, which is insane. I have not. If anyone
- 42:41has seen more than 1 ,500 being offered, please
- 42:44chime in because that is every manufacturer.
- 42:48That is the standard offer they are making. There
- 42:50is no negotiation. Even when you try to counter
- 42:53that, they would rather send you to fee arbitration
- 42:56for the dispute. And so that's where many of
- 42:59these are heading. And that is, again, why these
- 43:02demand letters aren't exactly the greatest thing
- 43:05on earth. Yeah. Yeah. And you brought up a good
- 43:07point about the fee arbitration too. Where it
- 43:11just needs to be somewhere neutral. It doesn't
- 43:13need to be mutually agreeable So I believe like
- 43:16GM is very particular about saying no, we're
- 43:19not gonna use jams I think it is they want to
- 43:21use BBB or in CDS But we reviewed the code. There
- 43:26isn't anything in there that says you cannot
- 43:28elect the arbitrator. So why let them pick somebody
- 43:32that they know in their experience has been more
- 43:36favorable to the manufacturer? I would say pick
- 43:39Jams. Jams has been more consumer friendly in
- 43:42my experience. So I say, you take the initiative.
- 43:45You file the claim in Jams and see what happens.
- 43:49Yeah, put the burden on them because then they're
- 43:51the ones that need to prove that jams is not
- 43:53a neutral forum And that's more of a fight and
- 43:56that's going to help you on your little 15 You
- 43:59know hundred dollar fee thing. These cases are
- 44:01going to get a lot more expensive for them So
- 44:03it's kind of a way to hopefully shift the power
- 44:06a little bit because they're they're holding
- 44:09firm on this 1500 and Quite frankly, it's ridiculous
- 44:14next slide So the new settlement procedure, we
- 44:20already touched on this a little bit, but you've
- 44:22got the 30 day processing, you've got $50 a day
- 44:25penalties for any time over that as long as it's
- 44:28not your fault. plaintiff receives a repurchase
- 44:31check at time of surrender appointment, and then
- 44:33you're looking at getting your payoff, civil
- 44:35penalty, and attorney's fees check sent within
- 44:37one business day. So this should expedite processing
- 44:41quite a bit. So this is good. Keep this in mind
- 44:44that you can hold them to these types of timeframes
- 44:47now on the back end of these cases. Next slide.
- 44:54So we now have a standardized release the way
- 44:57it's written is kind of written for Prelit it
- 45:02seems like with the prelet demands for the civil
- 45:05penalty because it talks about I believe like
- 45:07within 60 days of receiving notice Obviously
- 45:10on a litigation case that that doesn't make sense.
- 45:13So if you have a prelet case just know that's
- 45:16the release that that we're working with here.
- 45:19If you have a litigation case where you're trying
- 45:21to use the standardized release, it's going to
- 45:24need to be tweaked a little bit, but a lot of
- 45:26the manufacturers are still using it. It's just
- 45:29slightly different. But also keep in mind, 998
- 45:32offers are still fine. So what this does is the
- 45:37manufacturers can't force you to sign their,
- 45:39you know, six to 10 page Settlement agreement
- 45:42that you know sells your clients, you know second
- 45:44-born child, you know, it's a lot more streamlined
- 45:46now But even if you don't like some of the release
- 45:49terms in the standardized release You still have
- 45:52the option of settling a case via 998 offer Well
- 45:55also the advantage of the 998 also is the fee
- 45:58motion because it kind of triggers the timeline
- 46:01for the fee motions Yeah, so definitely you can
- 46:05get creative to maximize your recovery here because
- 46:08we're in We're in interesting times right now.
- 46:12Next slide. So you want to talk about this one?
- 46:17Yeah, so some tips for the old way. So these
- 46:21are the legacy cases we're talking about, any
- 46:23cases prior to January 1st. You're going to want
- 46:27to You take use to your advantage the fact that
- 46:31these manufacturers are kind of just neglecting
- 46:34these cases So make sure your discovery is out
- 46:37on those cases continue to send out discovery
- 46:39continue to Work those cases up even though the
- 46:43manufacturers ignoring them schedule your depositions,
- 46:46you know depose the person most knowledgeable
- 46:48They're gonna most likely start objecting because
- 46:51they're trying to get their person most knowledgeable
- 46:52Scheduled for the newer cases. So do your motions
- 46:56to compel get those depositions on calendar.
- 47:00And knowing that we know now that all these manufacturers
- 47:04are offering some arbitrary $5 ,000 in fees,
- 47:10sometimes a little more than that, but $5 ,000
- 47:12in fees or fee motion. Keep that in mind so that
- 47:15when you start doing significant work in the
- 47:17case and your billing slips are getting higher
- 47:20and higher, send out Send out fee motion or send
- 47:24out demands for settlement, including your attorney's
- 47:28fees in there so that you have the ability to
- 47:30show the court as exhibits in your fee motion
- 47:32that at every step of the way during significant
- 47:35intervals in that case, you tried to settle.
- 47:38You were trying to be the reasonable one. This
- 47:40is going to help us when the judges are getting
- 47:41pissed off that they're going to have a bunch
- 47:43of fee motions in front of them that they're
- 47:45going to have to deal with. And by the way, this
- 47:47also could potentially settle your case early
- 47:49on. You know, last I heard, is taking eight months
- 47:53to give you a fee motion date. So that's eight
- 47:55months where you have to wait to get paid on
- 47:57a case that you worked up. Yeah, I had an LA
- 48:00case. I had to wait a year to be heard on a fee
- 48:03motion, which was crazy. So depending on what
- 48:05venue you're practicing in, you're looking at
- 48:09delays, that's cash flow issues. That's going
- 48:11to hit a lot of, you know, solo small firms.
- 48:13So keep this in mind. It is kind of these fee
- 48:17motions are more and more prevalent. So make
- 48:21sure you're setting up your cases where you are
- 48:23protecting your interests here. Next slide. Yeah,
- 48:33so the new way so the the pre litigation demand
- 48:38letters that we're sending out to the manufacturers
- 48:40that have opted in are Resulting in quick buybacks
- 48:44for the clients and often with I mean the numbers
- 48:47are correct There's little to no deductions oftentimes.
- 48:50They're waiving the mileage offset for the client
- 48:52as well. So With that keep in mind those cases
- 48:57there's a conversation that needs to be had with
- 48:59the client before you decide which strategy to
- 49:02take. Oftentimes I'll present the pros and the
- 49:05cons to the consumer and let them know, okay,
- 49:07if we go this way, more than likely you'll get
- 49:10your car bought back in the next 30 and surrendered
- 49:12in the next 60. But then there's this other way
- 49:17you can go instead. And we have been having conversations,
- 49:22open and honest conversations with the clients
- 49:24about that. I can tell you that the pre -litigation
- 49:28procedures are great for the consumer. However,
- 49:31be advised and be aware that you are going to
- 49:34get those lowball fee offers of $1 ,500. You
- 49:37are going to end up potentially in fee arbitration
- 49:39because they're not negotiating at this point.
- 49:42And you're not going to get anything extra. for
- 49:45your client if there's anything extra that they
- 49:48need. So definitely have that conversation with
- 49:52the client. Make sure when you do get that buyback
- 49:54figure from the manufacturer that it's correct
- 49:57and it's accurate. It includes all their incidentals.
- 49:59It includes the correct mileage offset. And if
- 50:03it doesn't, you know, have that conversation
- 50:05with the client again and file a lawsuit. Next
- 50:09slide. Oh, OK. So the new way, straight to litigation.
- 50:21So there are some manufacturers where I won't
- 50:24do the demand letters with anymore. It's a waste
- 50:26of time. And make sure that you know when you
- 50:30file that lawsuit that you calendar all those
- 50:32dates coming up, get those documents during intake
- 50:35that you need from your client, all the financials,
- 50:38especially the payment history, the loan payoff.
- 50:40I don't think the code says current. payment
- 50:43history or current loan payoff. It just requires
- 50:46it that your client obtain it. So if you get
- 50:49it 90 days before you have to turn it over, you
- 50:52know, it still qualifies under the law. Get that
- 50:57registration, get everything. That way you have
- 51:01it and even you know serve it as quickly as possible
- 51:03I don't even wait till the the 90th day to serve
- 51:06it. I just serve it Yeah, you know because then
- 51:08they go into a panic because they think they've
- 51:10missed a date and they start panicking And I
- 51:12look and lo and behold I get to discover a little
- 51:14bit sooner. Yeah but just know that you will
- 51:19most likely be resolving these cases. You know,
- 51:23you'll resolve them favorably for your client
- 51:25if the claim is there, but you'll be most likely
- 51:27resolving the attorney's fees and cost portion
- 51:31by fee motion. I have seen some attorneys being
- 51:37able to resolve their matters by turning over
- 51:40their fee slips prior to any fee motion. Personally,
- 51:46I find that a little problematic because I think
- 51:48that all the manufacturers across the board are
- 51:51actually starting to do this fee motion thing.
- 51:54And I think a lot of it has to do with that Rico
- 51:56case, which, you know, we'll we'll get into just
- 51:59a little bit towards the end. But they I don't
- 52:04think it's about seeing that substantiating the
- 52:07fees that you did on that particular case. I
- 52:09think they're gathering this data, all of them
- 52:12to sort of do something with it universally,
- 52:17whether it be try to find some way to fee cap
- 52:20plaintiff's fees in consumer litigation or to
- 52:25figure out strategy on these cases with the consumer
- 52:28lawyers. And so my way of thinking has been now,
- 52:32I'm not turning those over without a protective
- 52:34order. So I have pitched out to the manufacturer,
- 52:38sign a protective order and I'll give them to
- 52:40you because that... will limit the purpose of
- 52:43them. That will not allow them to distribute
- 52:46it to the other manufacturers. It won't let them
- 52:48put it into some AI tool so that they can have
- 52:51all this information gathered and cumulative
- 52:53with all the other manufacturers. So that's just
- 52:56a food for thought there. Something to think
- 52:58about. Hopefully they're going to get tired of
- 53:02these fee motions. I think I've got about 12
- 53:04to do in the next month or so. So hopefully they
- 53:07get tired of it and they'll start really trying
- 53:11to negotiate. these fees without this added need
- 53:15for a fee motion. Yeah I think it was a knee
- 53:18-jerk reaction I think to the Rico case where
- 53:20some of the manufacturers were like oh no we're
- 53:22overpaying and then they drew this insane line
- 53:26in the sand that's basically forcing most of
- 53:29us to go to a fee motion just to be paid a fair
- 53:32fee award. Which is crazy. So just be aware of
- 53:38that I think the data point is really really
- 53:41smart because obviously there's a lot of things
- 53:43going on legislatively politically like this
- 53:47all these reforms have just happened in the last
- 53:49year on personal injury side, you know ubers
- 53:52coming up to the personal injury attorneys like
- 53:54there These big companies are trying to shut
- 53:57us down and take away our clients rights to have
- 54:00reasonable, affordable legal counsel. So we need
- 54:04to think 10 steps ahead and I think Erica is
- 54:08really smart in not wanting to give them that
- 54:10data because if we're just willy -nilly filing
- 54:13fee motions, not doing protective orders on our
- 54:16slips, We don't really have control over what
- 54:19happens with that and it can be used against
- 54:23us and we need to protect our industry because
- 54:26it's under attack. Next slide. So in case you
- 54:36missed the news, especially when it was back
- 54:39in May, uh for to file a RICO case against one
- 54:45of the bigger lemon law firms in LA uh night
- 54:49law group so take a look at this uh if you are
- 54:53so interested it is you know pretty juicy reading
- 54:56uh but essentially They took the fee motions
- 55:01that they have written They basically compiled
- 55:05all that data cross referenced it and found a
- 55:08lot of things that didn't add up So this is kind
- 55:10of an example of how fee motions and all of that
- 55:13data can be used against us. So For all of us,
- 55:17of course, we're all ethical attorneys. We bill
- 55:20correctly all that. But just be aware this is
- 55:25happening. This is an example of how this data
- 55:27is being collected and being used against different
- 55:30firms. So be aware that this is. something we're
- 55:34going to be dealing with for the foreseeable
- 55:36future. And it also gives perspective on why
- 55:40out of nowhere, a lot of these manufacturers
- 55:43are low buying us on pre -lit fees. It didn't
- 55:46used to be that low even last year. And even
- 55:50on litigation cases, they're drawing these insane
- 55:52lines in the sand to try to force fee motions.
- 55:55And why else would they force fee motions but
- 55:57for to collect this type of data? to use against
- 56:00us. So just something to take a look at that's
- 56:04a little bit outside of your day -to -day practice
- 56:06area. But it's something we need to pay attention
- 56:09to if we want to preserve our right to continue
- 56:12doing our jobs and representing our clients.
- 56:15And just so you know, I believe the defendants
- 56:17filed a motion to dismiss. And I don't think
- 56:20there's an outcome on that yet. Yeah. So stay
- 56:23tuned. Get your popcorn. Buckle up. It's getting
- 56:27crazy. Does anyone have any questions for us?
- 56:33Pop it in the Q &A. Non -lemon law lawyer here,
- 56:41handling case for existing client. Can you recommend
- 56:43a good resource for analyzing damages in an all
- 56:46cash purchase case for purposes of framing a
- 56:49settlement demand? Like a cash in keep? No, it's
- 56:54a purchase. It sounds like a buyback. It sounds
- 56:58like a buyback, but an all cash buy. So no financing
- 57:02or anything. So just the risk. Oh, yeah. They're
- 57:06just a standard buyback. A good resource for
- 57:09analyzing damages. I mean, the statute's usually
- 57:12good place to start. Right. The statute is actually
- 57:14now with the new amendment and everything, the
- 57:17statute is very clear on what you can and cannot
- 57:19get. Yeah, so generally, you know your down payment
- 57:22the payments that were made If it was paid all
- 57:25cash, there's no payoff. So essentially they're
- 57:27getting their money back. Take a look at the
- 57:30deductions Incidental damages you're going to
- 57:32want to take a look at registration possible
- 57:35insurance There is case lot as to when those
- 57:40incidental damages are triggered based off of
- 57:42when your client qualifies for the lemon loss.
- 57:44So take a look at those types of cases. Rental
- 57:47car expenses, towing expenses, Uber expenses.
- 57:52So take a look at all that. And then when it
- 57:54comes to any deductions, definitely take a look
- 57:56at the code because there are some good things
- 57:59for you in trying to fight some of those deductions.
- 58:02OK, next question. If you settle pre -litigation,
- 58:06can attorney's fees be collected with a motion?
- 58:09Can civil penalties be sought separately via
- 58:11litigation? No. So pre -lit, you don't have the
- 58:16benefit of a fee motion. You don't have a court
- 58:18case. That's why you end up in fee arbitration.
- 58:22OK. And then the next question, how are modern
- 58:25firms keeping track of the time spent on a case
- 58:27for the purpose of bringing these fee motions?
- 58:30That's a great question. There's a lot of legal
- 58:32management software out there. I personally have
- 58:35experience with MyCase and Clio. Both are great
- 58:39softwares. I'm sure there's others to use, but
- 58:42that's how we've been keeping time, at least
- 58:44at my office. Yeah, I use Clio Manage for the
- 58:48litigation cases. I use Clio Grow for the pre
- 58:51-lit or on intake side. Super super easy. It'll
- 58:55you can keep track of your expenses You can keep
- 58:58track of your fees and then it'll pop out this
- 59:00report. That's very easy to provide in a fee
- 59:02motion Okay. What is a reasonable amount to charge
- 59:06per hour? That's like the million dollar question.
- 59:09You know, honestly, I think it depends on experience
- 59:12and years of litigation, years of experience
- 59:15in the lemon law. I think that's all. It's all
- 59:18very personal to the attorney handling the case.
- 59:22There are some fee surveys out there by Ron Burge.
- 59:26You can take a look at that. I'll show you what
- 59:28consumer attorneys are charging within California
- 59:31and other states. you an average that's somewhere
- 59:35where I would start see where you know see where
- 59:38someone in your experience is charging hourly
- 59:42and go from there. Yeah and some of the defensive
- 59:45firms like on a recent fee motion they'll provide
- 59:48their own kind of list or survey of what partners
- 59:53should be charging, what associates should be
- 59:55charging. So take a look at some of those, maybe
- 59:57even pull other fee motions or talk to other
- 59:59practitioners to see if they have those types
- 1:00:02of resources so you can ballpark. All right.
- 1:00:04You mentioned fee motions are way more common.
- 1:00:06Are you finding that the attorney's fees awarded
- 1:00:08after filing via the fee motion hearing on average
- 1:00:11are lower than the pre -ABE 1755 days? If so,
- 1:00:15any sense on how much percentage lower? So I
- 1:00:20personally have not had to file a fee motion
- 1:00:22in the last seven years. Most of the attorney's
- 1:00:26fees have been resolved pre -fee motion. So now
- 1:00:31I have a billion into file, so I'm probably not
- 1:00:35the best person to ask. Michelle, have you had
- 1:00:37to file any fee motions? So pre -AB 1755, yes,
- 1:00:42but I haven't had any since then, since the courts
- 1:00:45are so backlogged. I'm still TBD on what the
- 1:00:48response is going to be. But you're also still
- 1:00:51dealing with a lot of judges just really not
- 1:00:55liking lemon law attorneys. Like if you've been
- 1:00:57with CMC, you've probably had a judge that just
- 1:00:59goes on a rant about, you know, how these cases
- 1:01:02are silly and should be resolved and they blame
- 1:01:04us for everything and for inconveniencing them.
- 1:01:07Just be aware that's likely on the other side
- 1:01:11of your fee motion. So from the very beginning
- 1:01:14you want to make sure you set up your case and
- 1:01:16set up your case for a fee motion so that you
- 1:01:19can show look we did everything possible and
- 1:01:23this is why my hourly rate should be awarded
- 1:01:25and this is why all the work that we've done
- 1:01:27was because of the other side and it should be
- 1:01:30awarded. Yeah and just keep in mind this litigation
- 1:01:33is so very new that I'm not sure there's many
- 1:01:37attorneys out there that have filed a fee motion
- 1:01:39post AB1755 right now. So this is all still developing
- 1:01:44and we can continue to update you guys as this
- 1:01:48keeps going and progressing but all of it is
- 1:01:51a work in progress. I've got another question
- 1:01:53here. How long does litigation take? I want to
- 1:01:56weigh the options for my client. It's a broad
- 1:02:02spectrum for how long litigation will take to
- 1:02:05be honest with you before you could say on Average
- 1:02:08cases would take you know three to six months
- 1:02:11six to eight months now I mean, there's no way
- 1:02:14of knowing especially if it's a case that it's
- 1:02:15a legacy case Yeah, may end up going till the
- 1:02:18first day of trial You know it all depends. I
- 1:02:22just I you can't really give your client any
- 1:02:25kind of It would all be guesstimates. It is,
- 1:02:29yeah. It is. Depending on the facts of your case,
- 1:02:33what damages you're trying to get. Obviously,
- 1:02:34if you're fighting for a civil penalty, that
- 1:02:37tends to take a little bit longer. So just take
- 1:02:39a look at the factors of your case and just tell
- 1:02:42your client what the options are in different
- 1:02:45ranges. The best you can do is just advise them.
- 1:02:47It's going to be their decision in the end, whether
- 1:02:49they want to go pre -lit, do the letter thing,
- 1:02:51or whether they want to go straight to litigation
- 1:02:53and buckle up for something that could take several
- 1:02:56months. Four years. More and more years, unfortunately.
- 1:03:04Let's see. I know you focus on California cases.
- 1:03:07Curious if you have any sense on which other
- 1:03:09jurisdictions might have favorable lemon laws
- 1:03:11that would make it attractive for a law lawyer
- 1:03:17from a business standpoint. Honestly, we're so
- 1:03:27specialized in California's lemon law that we
- 1:03:30just wouldn't, I wouldn't even be able to comment.
- 1:03:34Non -lawyer, I don't, yeah, this is for lawyers.
- 1:03:37Lemon lawyer, for a lemon lawyer. Okay, good,
- 1:03:39good. So I just, I wouldn't, I know we got it,
- 1:03:42we got the type of thing. We got it. Yeah, no,
- 1:03:45I just, I wouldn't even be able to comment on
- 1:03:47that because we just really exclusively focus
- 1:03:50on California. We have a strong line, yeah. We
- 1:03:54can't know about the other ones. Yeah, no. We've
- 1:03:57got a pretty stable, as long as nothing happens
- 1:03:59with the law itself, we've got a pretty stable
- 1:04:02industry with all the new technology in the car.
- 1:04:04So California, very, very strong lemon law despite
- 1:04:08some of these changes. So definitely a good place
- 1:04:10to practice if you're a lemon law attorney. Yeah.
- 1:04:12And I don't see any other questions. So I guess
- 1:04:15we're done here. Thank you guys for listening.
- 1:04:20Till next time.