Latest / Newcomer Pod / Can Tech Work With Zohran Mamdani? | Julie Samuels
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine doge with empathy. We're not talking about firing
- 0:03people, but take a resource strapped organization like city
- 0:06government that has the most antiquated technology you can
- 0:09imagine and think about how you can identify savings within that
- 0:13framework to make city government work better for New
- 0:15Yorkers. This week on the podcast, I had
- 0:17Julie Samuels, the head of Tech NYC.
- 0:20Julie has spent her career at the intersection of innovation
- 0:23and policy, and as the head of Tech NYC, she's become the most
- 0:26important voice in the room when it comes to the future of this
- 0:29city, these tech industry. And hey, it wouldn't be an
- 0:32episode without a little politics.
- 0:34What is the tech industry's plan post?
- 0:37Trump, I've been thinking a lot about that.
- 0:38Welcome to the newcomer podcast. Julie Samuels, Tech NYC.
- 0:49Thank you so much for joining me on the podcast.
- 0:51Thank you for having me. You work on sort of New York
- 0:54politics, New York State and then obviously that all fits
- 0:57into sort of the federal landscape and sort of advocate
- 1:00on behalf of the tech crowd. And I feel like we share a
- 1:04similar sort of frame of reference where, you know,
- 1:07believe in tech, want it to work, but also believe in sort
- 1:11of the normal democratic reality and have to navigate that.
- 1:14So excited to have this whole to have a.
- 1:16Conversation. We've been talking for a long
- 1:18time, you and I. Yeah, I know it's more than a
- 1:20decade. More than a decade, yeah.
- 1:23So, yeah, I mean, let's start with the Mum Donnie Trump
- 1:25meeting. Yeah, in some ways, you know,
- 1:28the tech community, you know, it's hard to paint with too
- 1:30broad of a brush is what wouldn't have picked Mom Donnie
- 1:34as their mayor. I think among the different
- 1:36candidates, his ability to sort of like cozy up to Trump, is
- 1:41that a sign that he can sort of win over the business community
- 1:44or what do you take of? Yeah, that's really.
- 1:45Popularity. Well.
- 1:47Firstly, I think his popularity is also, well, firstly, he's
- 1:51uniquely, uniquely talented. Greater retail politics, just
- 1:55really good media presence. But so much of that is also that
- 2:00he knows how to use the tech platforms.
- 2:02He's the first, not the first, but one of the first mainstream
- 2:07politicians who's just nailed that, who knows how to use the
- 2:10media to speak to people in a way that most politicians,
- 2:13surely most Democrats, have just not figured out at all.
- 2:17You know who else has, though is of course Donald Trump, right,
- 2:20Right. Right.
- 2:21So the politicians that maybe tech did not, you know,
- 2:24certainly, you know, plenty of people embrace tech, Trump in
- 2:27tech. But you know, it took them a
- 2:29while. He wasn't their first choice.
- 2:31And yeah, and then AOC obviously is pretty good at it, too.
- 2:34None of the candidates that tech leaders might have chosen to
- 2:38lead the United States are the best.
- 2:41That's right. That's it's very interesting and
- 2:43you know, part of this is the second time Zoran Mamdani has
- 2:46gone to the to The West Wing to to the Oval to see Trump.
- 2:50And I think both times the kind of take away was like, oh, you
- 2:54know, game recognizes game and that Donald Trump, he gets it.
- 2:58And that's the people should go look up the photo from The West
- 3:03Wing where Trump is holding up these two newspapers, one with
- 3:06the famous headline Ford to NYC drop dead.
- 3:10And the other one which is a mock up base, you know, the same
- 3:13but Trump to NYC let's build. And you know that it's all about
- 3:17getting funding to build a more affordable.
- 3:19Housing, sunshine development or what?
- 3:21Sunnyside. OK, what is the big?
- 3:23Affordable housing development. And basically, as I understand,
- 3:28the mayor went and asked for $21 billion in federal funding to
- 3:31help build this really big affordable housing project,
- 3:34which, you know, everyone wants to build more housing.
- 3:36Everyone's a winner, Trump, you can take credit.
- 3:40And, and the picture is so telling because clearly the
- 3:43mayor's team brought these mock ups, but Trump is holding them
- 3:46and he's got a big smile. Like, you know, you can tell
- 3:49it's not a fake smile. It's like, I mean, I don't know,
- 3:51listen, I can't get in Trump's head, but he's smiling like it's
- 3:54a smile. And it wasn't just the
- 3:56newspapers. They also, you know, kept
- 3:57emphasizing how historic this would be.
- 3:59One of the biggest projects. That's right.
- 4:01Obviously, this is a New York real estate developer.
- 4:03This is what he wants. So what?
- 4:06What is? What is the tech?
- 4:08Read on Mumdata. Well, let me go back for a
- 4:10second. You said that a lot of people in
- 4:11tech didn't, you wouldn't be tech's first choice.
- 4:14And I, I think I generally agree with that.
- 4:16But I also want to point to one thing that is so interesting
- 4:19about tech and why tech is different than the other kind of
- 4:23traditional industries here, business, industry, whatever, is
- 4:27that when they went, they went back through the primary, the
- 4:32mayoral primary and looked where all the donations came from.
- 4:35The employer, the business with the most employees who wrote
- 4:40checks to Zoron during the primary was you want to guess.
- 4:45Google. Is Google yeah and and many
- 4:47other tech employers were high in that top. 10 was, but was he
- 4:50Google's most contributed candidate?
- 4:53I think so, but I'm not, I'm not certain.
- 4:55I can't say for sure. We should look that up and maybe
- 4:57put in the notes or something. I'll, I'll double check now.
- 5:01I think that where the employees are is not always where
- 5:05management and the executives are, to be fair.
- 5:08But I also don't think that a lot of the kind of traditional
- 5:12finance firms, the real estate firms, I don't think they have
- 5:15that same dichotomy where their employees are all supporting the
- 5:19the kind of DSA candidate in the primary.
- 5:22That is a uniquely tech dynamic. And you and I know that that
- 5:26dynamic has been part of the industry.
- 5:27When I when I had, you know, Keith Ruboy on the podcast the
- 5:30other day, you know, conservative pro Trump, he was
- 5:33sort of making the case that part of why all these, you know,
- 5:35tech CEOs needed to capitulate so much to Trump was, you know,
- 5:39because their employees, it all donated to the Democrats.
- 5:41And this was make good sort of a contorted argument, but it's
- 5:45funny to hear it. So yes, the the rank and file in
- 5:48Silicon Valley and New York of these tech companies is fairly
- 5:51liberal and sometimes even to the point of supporting DSA.
- 5:54It also makes the even the executives who by and large
- 5:57might be more even anti mom Donnie.
- 6:02It, it kind of numbs that a little bit because even now,
- 6:06even with AI, so much about success in tech is attracting
- 6:10the right talent. And this is all part of their
- 6:13competitive landscape too, you know, to be able to attract the
- 6:16right, smartest, best young people to come work at your
- 6:19company. So it's there's a balance for
- 6:21tech execs when you think about politics that is different than
- 6:25in other industries, I think. Who do you represent in tech?
- 6:27I mean, it's interesting because you represent a lot of startups
- 6:30and those startup founders are often more similar, I imagine to
- 6:32some of the rank and file in terms of their outlook.
- 6:35And then then the execs or how do you think about who you
- 6:38represent? I'll tell you quickly how Tech
- 6:39NYC is set up at a high level. We can dig in.
- 6:42So Tech NYC has got about 500 members and it is a sliding
- 6:47scale. So it's free for startups to
- 6:48join and then you know, the largest employers pay $60,000 a
- 6:52year to be members and and then investors have their own scale.
- 6:55So we have 500 total members. We have a board of about 60
- 6:59people. They are executives, CE OS,
- 7:04founders, GPS and firms, other senior execs from companies.
- 7:08So it's really, even though we spend a lot of time on politics,
- 7:11we're our main goal is to ensure that New York is the best place
- 7:14to build and grow a tech company.
- 7:16So, so that's everything we do is through that vision.
- 7:19So we work with policy people, but we also really work with the
- 7:22executives themselves. So who do we represent?
- 7:24Tends to be the executives, yeah.
- 7:26And do you survey like how do you decide what state has to
- 7:30take on an issue given you know, we can talk about tech with a
- 7:33broad brush, but then. It's really complicated.
- 7:35Well, yeah, this is, I don't have a very satisfying answer to
- 7:40this because I would tell you when we built the organization,
- 7:43I was really worried about this. How do we do the right process?
- 7:45How do we make sure we're getting it right?
- 7:47And something I've learned, we started the organization 10
- 7:50years ago. This is our 10th anniversary
- 7:51this year. Something I've learned that's so
- 7:53interesting is that part is actually pretty easy.
- 7:56There is not a lot of space, not space.
- 7:59There's there's not a lot. It's much more aligned and
- 8:02almost much more obvious which issues we should work on and why
- 8:06and how. Then I than I really feared
- 8:09going. I thought that would be much
- 8:10harder. Than what are the top three
- 8:12right now? I imagine like AI.
- 8:14Fear. Yeah, it's.
- 8:16All AI, it's like energy data centers.
- 8:19Everything that like can touch right.
- 8:21Obviously, listen, I think something that's been really
- 8:24interesting over the past decade that's shifted in our work is
- 8:27when we first started the organization, the issues were
- 8:30all kind of core tech policy, like what impacts the company's
- 8:33bottom line, data privacy, There was a marketplace tax, like very
- 8:37tech specific issues. The work has broadened
- 8:41significantly over the past 10 years for many reasons, but one
- 8:45of the reasons that I find the most interesting is that
- 8:48increasingly every company is a tech company.
- 8:52Obviously, I mean it's like kind of a trite thing to say, but
- 8:54it's true. And increasingly, tech is
- 8:57becoming one of the biggest, if not the biggest industries here
- 9:00in New York City. And, and what that means is that
- 9:04now the industry is more and more made-up of New Yorkers than
- 9:09than people for whom tech is their primary.
- 9:11They care about everything, and so you're reflecting a broad set
- 9:14of interests. That's right.
- 9:15So we already listen, we already talked about the Sunnyside like
- 9:17we're talking about housing, we're talking about public
- 9:19safety, we're talking about good schools, functioning public
- 9:23transit. We are talking more and more
- 9:25about the things that make it so that people who work in tech
- 9:29want to live here. Because if people who work in
- 9:32tech want to live here, then the companies will continue to
- 9:35locate here, we think. And then everything.
- 9:37Everything. AIAIAI.
- 9:39Yeah. I want, you know, I, I recently
- 9:41had last year, Daniel Laurie, the mayor of San Francisco on
- 9:45stage one of my events. I was interviewing him.
- 9:48He was the most warmly received person on stage all day, you
- 9:51know, probably at any of our events, you know, like Dario,
- 9:54the CEO of Anthropic. I mean, politicians, you know,
- 9:57are much more charismatic than CEOs.
- 10:01And, you know, so he really had the crowd.
- 10:03They really were a believer. He was good at staying on
- 10:06message. It's funny, though, when I was
- 10:07interviewing him, you know, I was like, yeah, the tech people
- 10:10love you. Like, why is that?
- 10:12And he sort of made something, he made a point that, you know,
- 10:14they weren't, they didn't necessarily love him the whole
- 10:15campaign. You know, he wasn't necessarily
- 10:17their first choice. Some of them stuck with London
- 10:20breeding. But we don't need to get in the
- 10:21particulars of San Francisco. But now he has this warm
- 10:23embrace. And I think part of it is just
- 10:26he likes tech, defends tech, says positive things about tech,
- 10:30like what? What is what?
- 10:31What do you think he's figured out?
- 10:33And what would you like Zoram Amdani to, like, learn from it?
- 10:36That's realistic, given he is to the left a little bit of Lori,
- 10:40but Lori's the mayor of San Francisco.
- 10:42I, I don't think the politics are that fundamentally different
- 10:46from a right, left balance, but the messaging is different.
- 10:49I think that that what he's plugged into.
- 10:52Also, you have to remember, of course, that it came on the
- 10:54backside of years of the city of San Francisco beating up on
- 10:58tech. And we were talking about this
- 11:00earlier before we started recording.
- 11:02There's this political dynamic. I think This is why so many tech
- 11:06leaders have kind of gone to the Trump side where, you know,
- 11:11these these people, they built companies, their grow jobs, they
- 11:14make big investments. They feel like they've done
- 11:16everything right. We did everything we we set out
- 11:19to do. We followed the rules.
- 11:21Sometimes we broke the rules, but we broke the rules in, in
- 11:24the conquest of bringing new technology to the world and
- 11:27employing so many people. And, you know, that's, that's
- 11:30the tech world that I come from, that techno optimist world that
- 11:32gets made fun of a lot now, but it's actually like, it's pretty
- 11:35lovely. It's like a vision for the world
- 11:38that I wish were, were fundamentally true.
- 11:40And I think it is actually fundamentally true complex.
- 11:43Anyway, I think then we've seen we see this backlash and these
- 11:48are people. They're not, they're not robots,
- 11:50they're not companies, they're people.
- 11:52And these people feel like, you know what?
- 11:55What did I do wrong all of a sudden?
- 11:56Why are you beating up on me? I.
- 11:59Right. I think one thing, and the
- 12:02YouTube commenters might not agree with this, but I think we
- 12:05both have concluded is that, yeah, tech people and rich
- 12:08people really want to be like loved and appreciated and
- 12:12sometimes they care more, right? Everybody does, right?
- 12:15Right. It is a fun.
- 12:16They don't lose sight of that and it is sometimes less about
- 12:19the money seemingly. And more about always less about
- 12:22the money. But I think what happens is a
- 12:24lot of the politicians, both on the far left and the far right,
- 12:27they think it's about the money, you know, and they're well,
- 12:31they're so rich, why do why would they care?
- 12:33Why does it matter? But but again, I think they
- 12:35sometimes, and Daniel Laurie's done a great job of this.
- 12:38They forget that under all these are still just people.
- 12:41And when they are feeling attacked as people, they're
- 12:45going to react. And their reaction can be like,
- 12:50well, screw you. Like I'm gonna go to the White
- 12:52House now. But Daniel, Lori speaks their.
- 12:54Language, right, Daniel? Lori compliments them, says
- 12:56thank you, even as he knows he represents broader San Francisco
- 13:00and it's not really their town to run.
- 13:04I mean, the, you know, the classic madman madman line.
- 13:08That is what the money is for. You know, there.
- 13:10I think the the response is often like, you're getting paid
- 13:13well. Why do you also need to get
- 13:15thanked by politicians? There are lots of, you know,
- 13:17politicians need to be looking out for the rank and file
- 13:20person, not spending all their time thanking people who have
- 13:22already been rewarded by society.
- 13:25I mean, I don't know what's. It's really interesting.
- 13:27I mean, I think from the way I see the world, which, you know,
- 13:31this is just an opinion, of course, I think you can get
- 13:35farther if you try and work together in that way that like
- 13:38making that person an enemy because it's politically
- 13:43expedient is I think long term more harmful given the realities
- 13:47of the world we live in. Like the example I always go
- 13:50back to, the first time I really saw this was when I was in San
- 13:54Francisco and everyone was throwing rocks at the Google
- 13:58buses. And I was like, what are you
- 13:59doing? Like those engineers, you want
- 14:02those people to be with you. The people on the bus, they're
- 14:05actually, most of them are young, most of them are early in
- 14:08their career. Most of them don't have families
- 14:11or else they wouldn't be living in these apartments and
- 14:13commuting at the Google bus. And you're turning them into
- 14:15enemies. And I think we'd all have been
- 14:18better served had we had the Democrats done a better job of
- 14:21bringing those people in the fold, because those people who
- 14:25had rocks thrown at their buses are now, many of them, I'm sure,
- 14:28people supporting Trump. So can the tech business
- 14:32community have a strong working relationship with Zoram?
- 14:36I'm Donnie Given seems unlikely that he's going to run around
- 14:39saying I love the tech business community.
- 14:42I guess that's sort of the existential question.
- 14:45I think they can. I think we will.
- 14:46I think there will be things we disagree on and I think there
- 14:50will be things we agree on. And what we're trying to do at
- 14:53Tech NYC is identify the things we can agree on and, and make
- 15:00real progress there. And let me just tell you what I
- 15:01think some of those are. And I think this is true, by the
- 15:03way, for every city. I think New York has unique
- 15:06scale and we should be really doing some of this work here
- 15:10immediately. But I think it's true
- 15:12everywhere. Tech in government start with
- 15:14that especially, especially when we are talking about the
- 15:18affordability crisis. The mayor just announced that
- 15:21every city agency is going to have a chief savings officer who
- 15:24will have 45 days to identify savings within the agencies.
- 15:29It is like a an ideal situation to use tech and dare I say AI to
- 15:34identify savings. Democrats are traumatized by the
- 15:38Doge experience. Here, I mean, but this I've
- 15:40been, I can't not stop talking about this.
- 15:41Like imagine doge with empathy, like imagine doge in in in a way
- 15:47that felt more culturally aligned with New York City.
- 15:50You can totally envision that, right?
- 15:53You can. We're not talking about firing
- 15:55people, but take a resource trapped organization like city
- 15:59government that has the most antiquated technology you can
- 16:02imagine and think about how you can identify savings within that
- 16:07framework to make city government work better for New
- 16:09Yorkers. It's like it's so obvious,
- 16:11right? So, OK, that I think that's one
- 16:13place, right? And everybody on the face wants
- 16:16a productive yes city government, so it's hard to
- 16:18disagree with. It and in fact some of this I
- 16:20think has to do with age. We have a young mayor, he has a
- 16:24young team, is the first time that I, I don't know what the
- 16:27exact numbers are, but I imagine there are more digital natives
- 16:30working in City Hall right now than there have ever.
- 16:33Been and one of the things you know, I ultimately did, you
- 16:36know, certainly ranked mum Donnie above Cuomo.
- 16:38He was you know, I was I think it was Brad Lander.
- 16:40But like the he understands that city government needs to work
- 16:49and the government needs to work if people are going to sign up
- 16:52for the progressive agenda and that you can't have sort of, you
- 16:56know, bleeding heart without like the governance you have to.
- 16:58Deliver zone. You have to deliver, right?
- 17:00Right. And clearly you live in a world.
- 17:02I mean, the great example of seeing technology work in
- 17:06practice in government to me is Omni tapped to pay on the
- 17:09subway. We all swiped our subway cards
- 17:13and then during Covad they redid the entire subway system.
- 17:17They put in tap to pay technology and it just works
- 17:20and. It's great for tourists.
- 17:22I mean, it's great as local, but it's amazing for tourists.
- 17:24And I think about it a lot in this context.
- 17:27Tap to Pay technology using Apple Pay on your iPhone every.
- 17:30I mean, how many times a day do you use Apple Pay?
- 17:32All the time. It should be table stakes,
- 17:34right? It right, It should be table
- 17:35stakes. And when you use the New York
- 17:37City subway, it is table stakes now.
- 17:39But we're not even talking about like jumping, leapfrogging to
- 17:44the next technology. We're talking about getting to
- 17:47the level of technology that everyone has in their pocket all
- 17:50the time anyway. So #1 embrace tech, deliver on
- 17:55the efficient. Progressive number 2 is really
- 17:58focus on education and think hard about.
- 18:06I mean, this one's very. Is this.
- 18:07Gifted in tracking or no, not to.
- 18:10I'm curious what you're using on education.
- 18:12But it's funny, like, you know, Gary Tan in San Francisco, I
- 18:15think tweeted or he has this Garry's listing now that a New
- 18:20York Post story where it says Zoran's gonna get rid of gifted.
- 18:23And it's not even clear if they've really done anything
- 18:26more there. But people keep the right wing
- 18:28media keeps putting that one front and center.
- 18:30They love this one. Right.
- 18:31And obviously the tech community is very sensitive.
- 18:33I will say that. Not elevating, You know, the
- 18:36geniuses among us. The the New York City education
- 18:40is very complicated. It's very complicated.
- 18:43And on the GNT in particular, like gifted and talented, gifted
- 18:46and talented, like tech, the tech industry, I would say by
- 18:49and large would not be happy if that were eliminated.
- 18:53I mean, they're very happy if it were eliminated, Definitely
- 18:55wouldn't be happy if it were cut back on.
- 18:59So I think, but we haven't really, there's a lot of
- 19:02rhetoric, but we haven't seen what's going to exactly happen
- 19:05there. So like, maybe I'll come back
- 19:07when we know more. I know it is sort of one of
- 19:09those distraction issues in that it gets everybody who's sort of
- 19:12fired up. Another big one here is charter
- 19:14schools. That's something that the tech
- 19:16industry has been very supportive of, and that's
- 19:20something that the Mamdani administration seems less
- 19:22supportive of. So that also might come to a
- 19:23head. Again, we'll see.
- 19:25Where can they agree on education?
- 19:27Thinking about curriculum, OK, Thinking about curriculum,
- 19:30thinking about how we are preparing students not just for
- 19:34jobs of the future important, but also preparing students to
- 19:38like, live in a world where these tools are out there.
- 19:42You know, one of the things that I've been thinking about
- 19:44politically is 10/11/12 years ago when when Bill de Blasio
- 19:49first became mayor, Fred Wilson, former chair of Techno ICS
- 19:54board, venture capitalist of course from Union Square
- 19:56Ventures, kind of went in, saw the new mayor and said, I think
- 20:00we should work together to ensure that there's computer
- 20:02science education in every school.
- 20:05And they launched A10 year public private partnership
- 20:08called CS for All and they ensured that there was.
- 20:12Computer science education in every city, in New York, in
- 20:15every single New York City public school.
- 20:17And that that's the answer, right?
- 20:19Maybe that answer looks a little different now.
- 20:21The CS education of, you know, 2014 is not the same as what we
- 20:26think the tech education should look like in 2026.
- 20:29But those are the places I think where we really can and should
- 20:33be working together to support the kids in the schools.
- 20:36Is tech a barrier to getting cell phones out of school?
- 20:40Or no, we supported that. Yeah.
- 20:41That was something that we did with the governor last year, the
- 20:44cell phone ban that, you know, this was so funny.
- 20:46We could talk. The politics around tech are so
- 20:48interesting. So we, Tech NYC supported the
- 20:51governor's proposal for the Belle de Belle ban to get cell
- 20:54phones out of schools. And we did that very publicly.
- 20:58And a lot of people called me after, and they were like, wow,
- 20:59I can't believe you did that, You know, that that was great.
- 21:02Or that whatever they said. But I got a lot of incoming and
- 21:05I was like, I don't understand how our politics have gotten so
- 21:08calcified that you can't understand how I run an
- 21:11organization who's literally main goal is to support the tech
- 21:15ecosystem in New York City and state, but also understand that
- 21:18kids shouldn't have cell phones in classes like these.
- 21:21This is very weak. And obviously a lot of these
- 21:23tech executives themselves are very careful about their own
- 21:26children, yeah, using devices. So they understand that it is a.
- 21:29I think it's a device. What's made a lot of our
- 21:32politics actually really hard is that you people feel like you
- 21:35can't say those two types of truths, that you can't hold
- 21:38those two truths together. Like, of course both those
- 21:40things can be true. In fact, I think they need to be
- 21:45true. I think the tech ecosystem will
- 21:48thrive if we are more open about the challenges, which is that
- 21:52like, kids shouldn't be on phones during class.
- 21:55Like, of course they shouldn't be.
- 21:57That's insane. So education is number 2.
- 22:01It seemed like you had a third one.
- 22:03I mean, I have a lot. I think those are like the first
- 22:06kind of places we're looking and then, you know, I think that.
- 22:09Are you on the YIMBY train as an organization?
- 22:13Yeah, yeah. I mean, I'm definitely on the
- 22:16YIMBY train. I think we've always been on the
- 22:18YIMBY train. I think that's also it's
- 22:21interesting to see which pieces of the kind of tech zeitgeist
- 22:26are the same here and in the Valley, and which ones are
- 22:29different and like the MB train, Same, same, same.
- 22:33Well, in some ways California needs it.
- 22:35I mean, New York is getting on it after California.
- 22:38California got to more of like a crisis point, whereas obviously
- 22:41New York is. Large city California got to
- 22:43such a crisis. There's a number of reasons, of
- 22:45course, but we should talk about the subway and public transit
- 22:49and how transformative it is to have such a huge, 24/7
- 22:54functioning public transit system, which means you can here
- 22:57in New York, which means you can live, you know, you have much
- 23:01more geographic diversity and where you can live and get to
- 23:04work. And that's a huge
- 23:07differentiator. How do taxes play into all of
- 23:10this? I mean, we, you know, I talked
- 23:11earlier about earlier about the mayor of San Francisco who's
- 23:14been pro tech, but obviously now California, you have
- 23:17billionaires literally fleeing the state because they're
- 23:20worried about a referendum. I mean, referendums themselves
- 23:23are funny because obviously it's like there's no politician
- 23:26necessarily to stop it. It's, you know, the public could
- 23:28do it and there's nothing to be done in so there, you know, we
- 23:31have the Google Co founders leaving the state and it's crazy
- 23:34people to get they're not coming to New York, right, They're
- 23:37going to Florida. I mean, I guess if you're going
- 23:38to run from taxes, you're going to run.
- 23:40If you're running from taxes, this is probably not the place
- 23:42you run to. Have you tried to get it?
- 23:44Have you made the pitch to anybody, like moved to New York
- 23:46because of the billionaire tax issue?
- 23:49Every time a politician says they're going to raise taxes,
- 23:52people who represent companies, wealthy people, we're always
- 23:56like everyone's going to leave. And the politicians are like,
- 23:59they're never, you're never going to leave.
- 24:00You always say that. And it's this kind of like game
- 24:02of chicken and mouse. Chicken and mouse?
- 24:04Is that no cat mouse cat? Mouse, Chicken and egg, Cotton
- 24:09mouse. It's like it's.
- 24:11Fine, whatever. It's, it's like, you know, it's
- 24:13this little or, or that isn't even the right analogy.
- 24:16The actually the right analogy is it's a little bit of like the
- 24:18boy who cried wolf, which is to say like, you're never really
- 24:21going to leave. And then they're like, no, we
- 24:22will leave. But what's happened in
- 24:25California has been like, no, no, no, they're going to leave
- 24:27like, so I think that is interesting to know at what is
- 24:31the number, you know what, what is enough to push you out.
- 24:35And I don't think it's ever just a tax proposal alone.
- 24:39But again, I think it gets to what we're.
- 24:41Talking about in the California 1, it seems like there's
- 24:44potential to tax unrealized gains.
- 24:46Yeah, control of companies. It was constructed and so it did
- 24:50really poorly. There was a high risk that if it
- 24:52went. Through it could yeah, hit
- 24:53specific people in a. And it would hit people before
- 24:55they're liquid in a way that would be really is right
- 24:58unrealized gains part. You said that like so I mean
- 25:01that is its own disaster there. But I think there is a feeling
- 25:05in tech this kind of like we've been a punching bag for so long
- 25:11and we're just sick of being your punching bag.
- 25:14You know, I'd note that most of the billionaires that I've seen
- 25:18reported having left California are a little bit older.
- 25:22They don't have school age kids. Much tougher to pick up and move
- 25:26when you know you don't have school age kids because everyone
- 25:28uses that app where you count your nights.
- 25:30Like these people aren't selling their California homes.
- 25:33Some might be, but they're just going to spend like, you know,
- 25:3651% of their nights somewhere else or whatever it is.
- 25:39But but with that goes the tax revenue, which is significant
- 25:41for a state. So what is?
- 25:43What's the How much time are you spending opposing taxes on
- 25:47behalf of the tech? Community right now.
- 25:51Because I'm Donnie is saying we need more money.
- 25:53And it's. Like we'll do property.
- 25:54Tax, I think that's a good that's there isn't really a live
- 25:58proposal, if there were a tax proposal.
- 26:01So we're actually in a really interesting time in New York
- 26:03State's political cycle. We're in the budget process in
- 26:07Albany right now, which will go on for another month or two,
- 26:09yeah, two months. And then, you know, our session
- 26:12here goes until summer. And so right now, this is the
- 26:16busiest time on a lot of these political things.
- 26:19There really isn't a tax proposal to react to.
- 26:22If there was some live tax proposal, but the governor's
- 26:27been really consistent that she will not raise income taxes and
- 26:31you can't do it without her. She's done an amazing job.
- 26:34It's been amazing. She's amazing.
- 26:35I'm. I mean, maybe you're not
- 26:37shocked, but it took me a while. But not shocked like when she
- 26:39delayed congestion. Pricing, I was like, terrible.
- 26:42And then it was like, oh, you're totally right.
- 26:43That was the savvy move. She has been she's she's just
- 26:47she's great, but she she's done things for the state and for
- 26:51tech specifically that have been so good.
- 26:54And she just does the work. You know, one thing well,
- 26:57there's a handful of things. One one of the things she's done
- 26:59that is the coolest is she has funded a public private
- 27:03partnership. So there's private dollars too,
- 27:05called Empire AI, which is amazing.
- 27:08It is a independent 5O1C3 that she's funded.
- 27:14It's a coalition of research institutions.
- 27:17It includes our city system, CUNY, our state system, SUNY,
- 27:20Columbia, Cornell, NYURPI, Rochester schools, you know, all
- 27:26these private and public institutions.
- 27:28They are building a supercomputer in Buffalo.
- 27:31They already have the first version up and going.
- 27:34But the eventual final state will be huge It it will be I
- 27:39think 1 of, if not in the end, the most powerful, the biggest
- 27:43academic research computer surely in the country, maybe the
- 27:46world. And New York academics are the
- 27:49only people who have access to it.
- 27:50And it's amazing. And right now really only
- 27:55private sector has access to the kind of compute that our
- 27:59academics have because of Empire AI.
- 28:00It is incredibly forward-looking, incredible for
- 28:04the state. I mean that when you think about
- 28:07what Stanford did for the Valley, I think that's what
- 28:08Empire AI will do for New York. Because what happens is you've
- 28:12got these postdocs and and other professors and they're choosing
- 28:15which school to go to, and they're going to find out that
- 28:17the only computer on which they can do their research is in New
- 28:21York. Part part of me is skeptical
- 28:23just because, you know, the scale of investment on private
- 28:26enterprise in San Francisco is so large that if these, you
- 28:29know, Neo Labs and, you know, opening Anthropic, they get so
- 28:32much money. On the other hand, obviously,
- 28:34you know, Mayor Bloomberg's work in New York establishing, you
- 28:37know, a tech campus here really did change sort of the
- 28:42penetration. So some of these government
- 28:43projects do. Can't turn into something I
- 28:46totally support the companies creating compute for academics.
- 28:50Like the more compute for academics and research I think
- 28:52the better in general. But there are a number of
- 28:55academics and there is good reason to think that academics
- 28:58want access to compute that is their own.
- 29:01You know no one else, I mean technically in this instance
- 29:04OF501-C3 owns it, but but they are they have control over it.
- 29:08No one else can do or say what kind of research can happen on
- 29:12that machine. You know the role of government,
- 29:14Yeah, sort of independent, non corporate.
- 29:16That's right. And, and how can we help
- 29:18government, especially with, you know, the way the federal
- 29:22government is clamp, clamping down on funding, research and
- 29:26just kind of thinking about funding for universities, it's
- 29:31even more important. And this is the role state
- 29:34government can play that role. They are in a unique position to
- 29:37be able to fund at scale. You know, it's going to end up
- 29:39being like a $700 million machine over time.
- 29:43And so that's been that's it's amazing.
- 29:46And she's done a bunch of other great stuff too.
- 29:49She, we worked really hard with her at the end of last year.
- 29:52I'm sure we've talked a lot about the SB53 and the Rays Act
- 29:57here in New York, the two big kind of.
- 29:59AI Regulation. Yeah.
- 30:00And one thing we did here with the leadership of Governor
- 30:03Hochul, she was really, really just great on this.
- 30:07She kind of took the bill that we had on the table here and it
- 30:11was after SB53 had become law in California and, and looked at it
- 30:15and was like, we can do a version of this, but let's make
- 30:18them work together. And in the absence of
- 30:20congressional action, in the absence of Congress, like
- 30:24creating. Match it with California so
- 30:25there wouldn't be two regimes, right?
- 30:27So it's like, and it's important and we're going to have
- 30:29guidelines here and we're not going to just let the companies
- 30:31run amok. But what we're going to do is
- 30:34also make it easy or at least make it streamline for the
- 30:38companies to comply. We're not going to create all
- 30:40kinds of barriers just because. And so that was great.
- 30:43That was like real leadership that was hard to get done.
- 30:45The public seems very concerned about data centers.
- 30:48They seem more worried about AI than upbeat.
- 30:51I mean, I think we, we literally saw this week that, you know,
- 30:55block is laying off like 40% of their workers that they're
- 30:59attributing to AI. So I guess workers have a right
- 31:02to be worried about AI on some level.
- 31:04I don't know. What.
- 31:05Yeah. What What is your read on text
- 31:09sentiment with the electorate? I think it's a very good
- 31:13question. This is something I worry a lot
- 31:15about too. I think that if we don't get
- 31:19this moment right, we'll, you know, we'll really be, we could
- 31:21be shooting ourselves in the foot here, here across the
- 31:25country. You know, competitiveness
- 31:27matters, you know, New York versus, let's say Texas, but
- 31:32also America versus China or whatever.
- 31:34Like I, for starters, I come at this from the vantage point that
- 31:39like technology is coming. There's some tweaks around the
- 31:43side that regulation can shift it a little bit one way or
- 31:46another, but it's coming. So we can either find a way to
- 31:50build it here to figure out how to make it work here, or
- 31:54somewhere else. I agree with that, but yeah, I'm
- 31:57not sure the. Voters.
- 31:59They they are trying to kill data centers.
- 32:01I mean, the data center, well, to go back to Governor Hochul,
- 32:03she's got a great proposal on this, which is actually it was
- 32:06in her budget before. Trump has said something
- 32:09similar, which is you can build it here, but you can't put it on
- 32:11our grid. You know, you have to pay for
- 32:13your own power. And that's, you know, that like
- 32:17more politicians to find a way to get to, yes, within a
- 32:21framework like that is what I think we need to see.
- 32:23But I do worry about the sentiment.
- 32:27I worry too, that like so many politicians, just kind of follow
- 32:32those poles and then chase, Chase that chase where the
- 32:35voters are instead of trying to be.
- 32:37Leaders, the long arc of tech, One lesson sort of politicians
- 32:43learned and the public was we didn't regulate social media and
- 32:47then we came to regret it and it was too powerful to put back in
- 32:50the box. And we don't necessarily enjoy
- 32:52our time on it. And I'm sort of sympathetic to
- 32:56that on social media, whereas I like AI.
- 32:59To me, when AI's done well, it's sort of a truth seeking valuable
- 33:03thing like improving our quality of life.
- 33:07Yeah. I don't know.
- 33:08How do you sort of stop politicians and the electorate
- 33:12from taking well? Let me tell you some of the
- 33:14things we're doing right now. One thing we're doing in
- 33:16particular that is I'm so proud of is we have a project at the
- 33:20Tech NYC Foundation called Decoded Futures.
- 33:22You can Google it, learn more. And what it is, is it's all
- 33:28again through our foundation. So it's free and we take
- 33:32cohorts. We're in our 4th cohort right
- 33:33now of about 2025 nonprofits. And we do 8 weeks, We pair them
- 33:38with volunteers from the tech sector and we do 8 weeks of
- 33:41training to teach them about AI, how to build AI, how to use AI
- 33:46internally, how to also just. Change.
- 33:48These are the frameworks. Or nonprofits, OK.
- 33:50Nonprofits, OK, but the idea like.
- 33:54Get them hooked. Yeah, and get them hooked.
- 33:56I mean it's. Actually no, if people are vibe
- 33:58coding seeing the value like building something or using.
- 34:01It right or I mean to go back to the block example that's you
- 34:04know they today announced how many people the layoffs like
- 34:09thousands, thousands 4000 or something I don't know yeah I.
- 34:12Think it was 4000. Yeah, I think it was 4000.
- 34:14But most nonprofits, city agencies, these are resource
- 34:17trapped organizations. We're not talking about laying
- 34:20people off. We're talking about being able
- 34:22to do more. And, and some of it is so basic.
- 34:25You know, it, it's, it's thinking about AI tools that
- 34:29help you automate a spreadsheet. Most people I know who go work
- 34:32in the social sector, who go work for nonprofits don't go
- 34:35there because they want to sit in front of Google Sheets all
- 34:37day. You know, they're, they want to
- 34:39be out in the field. They want to go do the work that
- 34:41they're passionate about. That's why they choose to work
- 34:43in the nonprofit sector. And something AI can do is like.
- 34:48Skip the bullshit work. Yeah, create capacity, create
- 34:51capacity. And and we think fundamentally
- 34:56that a couple things. Number one, you start working.
- 34:59We started in New York with nonprofits.
- 35:00Nonprofits, you know, they're hundreds of thousands of
- 35:03nonprofits here. Nonprofits do so much of the
- 35:06social services that New Yorkers depend on, you know, meeting New
- 35:10Yorkers where they are. It doesn't have to be
- 35:12nonprofits. That's that's our project.
- 35:14But whatever. You can do this with small
- 35:15businesses. You can do it with city
- 35:16government. Imagine any small resource
- 35:19limited organization that probably doesn't have a lot of
- 35:21internal technical skill. OK.
- 35:24So #1 we've been doing that and it's been great.
- 35:26And the nonprofits, at the end of their eight weeks, tell you
- 35:29about what they've built. And like, literally might.
- 35:31Sometimes I tear up. It's transformative for them.
- 35:34It's amazing. And with the idea that they can
- 35:36be strong advocates for you if. They're and they're just regular
- 35:39people too. They're not like tech, you know,
- 35:41they're not tech Bros saying AI is great.
- 35:43They're like regular people in the world.
- 35:45So I think that is that is the actual work.
- 35:48But the thing I think is crucial about it, and this is like a
- 35:51little abstract or maybe like a little woo woo or whatever.
- 35:55It's not woo woo. It's a little like trite maybe,
- 35:58But there is a moment, I mean, we are living in a moment of
- 36:01significant technological transformation.
- 36:03Like whether you like it or not, we are.
- 36:06And the one of the biggest risks we face is that some people are
- 36:12going to capitalize on that and everyone else is going to get
- 36:14left behind. And I think it is incumbent upon
- 36:16us just as like people in the world, but also on us at Tech
- 36:20NYC and wherever that we try and like avoid.
- 36:23That, and especially in New York City, we win at capitalism, yes.
- 36:26We win at capitalism, but we had to bring everyone along with us.
- 36:29So that, I mean, that's the kind I think we need more decoded
- 36:31futures. We need more work like that.
- 36:33When people actually, to your point, when people play with AI,
- 36:37they're like, oh, this is awesome Right now.
- 36:39People are scared. Like we need to do a better job
- 36:42of demystifying it, of explaining what it actually is,
- 36:44how it can fit in to a regular person's life or job right now.
- 36:50Yeah, And I, I think a lot of, you know, people who are just
- 36:51using Google search results and getting Gemini answers don't
- 36:55always appreciate that that is the sort of AI we're talking
- 36:58about. And also the tech industry is
- 37:00still turning the technology into like direct applications
- 37:03where it's like, you can do this thing, you know, right now you
- 37:06sort of have to be a little more proactive and like motivated to
- 37:09get some of the value out of. It that's the case for New York,
- 37:12right? Like the way I think a lot of
- 37:13these technical cycles go is they build the hard tech in the
- 37:17Valley and it's kind of like just, you know, a bunch of
- 37:21dudes. It's always dudes.
- 37:23I wish there were more women like in, you know, in a group
- 37:26house. It used to be a garage in Palo
- 37:28Alto. Now maybe it's like a, a
- 37:30townhouse in Hayes Valley or whatever.
- 37:31And they're like tinkering away and they've got this great idea.
- 37:34But then it comes time to figure out, well, who's going to pay
- 37:37for it? Who's going to actually use it?
- 37:39What are they going to use it to do?
- 37:40And I feel very bullish on New York 'cause I think we will
- 37:44answer those questions here. Right, build the applications,
- 37:47understand what the companies. And we don't have those answers
- 37:50yet. We don't.
- 37:51The I mean, if you, if you were to give like to go back to the
- 37:56mayor and where we started the mayor or like one piece of
- 37:58advice to build like an agenda that it is at once progressive
- 38:03and fitting his values and in the tech industry, like what
- 38:06would the advice be? It would be to dig in and figure
- 38:09out how to make technology work better in government.
- 38:12People see that, they understand it.
- 38:15I think it aligns with his campaign, with his vision for
- 38:17New York. I think it aligns with his base.
- 38:20It aligns with the private sector as well.
- 38:22Like I think that is, I think for every politician, for every
- 38:27elected official, there's a different answer.
- 38:30You know, it's how you ran, it's what you ran on, it's what you
- 38:32believe in. And I think that what it seems
- 38:36to me the mayor believes in and where technology can be
- 38:39deployed, it's very clear that it's in the the space of like
- 38:44making government work better. What's, you know, this is more
- 38:49national, but like, the tech industry in California certainly
- 38:53has cozied up to Trump, like New York.
- 38:57I mean, we don't necessarily have all the CE OS to do the
- 39:01cozying, but like what is the tech industry's plan post Trump
- 39:05or if if if Democrats come back in like I don't I don't know.
- 39:09I've been thinking a lot about that.
- 39:10Well, first of all, I think New York will do much better in that
- 39:13instance because. We and that they have to
- 39:15navigate. They saw, well, I mean, in
- 39:17California, they have a Democratic governor, you know.
- 39:19You know, there's there's something that I think about a
- 39:22lot. I think this is true.
- 39:23Surely in tech, I'm not sure it's specific to tech.
- 39:27I think tech is just a little bit more immature than some
- 39:30other industries in that it's newer, you know, not, I don't
- 39:33mean to mature in any way other than it's literally younger, but
- 39:37something that's really interesting about politics is a
- 39:40lot of times you'll see people who've seen great success in
- 39:43business assume that they also get politics and it's different
- 39:47and it's a different skill set. It's a different set of
- 39:50equities. And I think that, you know,
- 39:54you've got some people in tech who are like chasing the thing
- 39:57they think is the right thing. And there's.
- 40:00They're going to be some hard lessons, like if a Democrat,
- 40:02depending on which Democrat is in the White House, which I
- 40:06personally hope is the case in 2028, again, depending on who
- 40:11that person is, yeah, I think there's going to be some people
- 40:14in tech. We're going to have to pay a
- 40:15price, right? I think that there is space to
- 40:21show up at certain events. People understand like that,
- 40:24whether you like it or not, Donald Trump is the
- 40:27democratically elected president.
- 40:28And there are meetings and things that you go to, but then
- 40:31there are certain things, donations, certain events,
- 40:35certain vibes that you don't have to go to.
- 40:37And I think that there are no hard and fast rules.
- 40:40But I think that Americans who pay attention to these things,
- 40:45like have a gut sense of where those lines are with the
- 40:48difference between kind of responsibly running a business
- 40:54during this administration. Versus without being Marc
- 40:57Benioff and saying no send. Without, like, fealty.
- 41:01He's a dear leader. Yeah.
- 41:02Yeah, I think that. Who do you think in New York is
- 41:06doing a good job of like representing the tech industry
- 41:08or who do you see as sort of like the standard bearers here?
- 41:13That's a very good question. I mean, I think if you look at
- 41:16technyc.org and look at my board and you get a sense of who I
- 41:20think that is. You know, like I said, Fred
- 41:22chaired my board for 10 years. We have our first news is that
- 41:24Fred Wilson. Fred Wilson.
- 41:26I'm guessing who's the Yeah, I mean the VC is like loom a
- 41:29little larger. Yeah, of course we've got
- 41:31clearly we have thrive, right? Makes a ton of news.
- 41:35Neil Blumenthal. Someone from Thrive is on your
- 41:38board or? Yeah, Josh is not on our board,
- 41:41but Kelly Sims, a partner that is on your board.
- 41:44Yeah, I mean, people are really engaged here.
- 41:46People who live in New York care a lot about the civic
- 41:49infrastructure. Not just infrastructure, just
- 41:52like kind of the civic landscape of New York.
- 41:53NY is a city where people care a lot.
- 41:57You cannot. It's like kind of logistics in
- 42:00some ways. You don't get in your car and
- 42:02drive to work and go to your office.
- 42:04Like you are constantly among the New Yorkers.
- 42:06No matter how wealthy you are, no matter how big the business
- 42:10you run is, it doesn't matter. You are surrounded by New
- 42:13Yorkers and that creates, I think, a really special dynamic
- 42:17with the city that makes my work so much more fun.
- 42:20I mean, that's the beauty of, you know, the subway you feel
- 42:22and just walk in the streets. You're part of the community in
- 42:26a way that I think part of what's corroded California is
- 42:29San Francisco in particular. It's like you can Uber from one
- 42:32place to the next and be in your little enclave and the next
- 42:35place and then be like, why is the city letting you know almost
- 42:37people? It's like the the failures of
- 42:39San Francisco corroded text politics, I think, in a way that
- 42:43New York just hasn't. And it won't, but, and there's
- 42:46other industries here and there's other things going on
- 42:50and we talk about tech, but we'll talk about Wall Street.
- 42:52And like, you know, it's, it's not.
- 42:55New York benefits from the diversity, not just of people,
- 42:57but of industry and experience. And I think that's why tech
- 43:01continues to thrive here. Is competition with China like
- 43:04animating people or do you think that is?
- 43:07I do think it's animating people.
- 43:08I think it should animate people.
- 43:11I think it's it's real. And I think, particularly in
- 43:16this moment, I think to go back to the data centers like, you
- 43:18know, are we going to stop building data centers here?
- 43:21Does do we think that people are just going to stop building data
- 43:23centers anywhere then like I, I just.
- 43:27Right. I mean, I do feel like you know
- 43:28this dumorism well, it's good to be careful.
- 43:31I'm very supportive anthropic having the Constitution and
- 43:34pushing back on the Defense Department or but I think.
- 43:38It's the Department of War now. No.
- 43:39Well, the Congress hasn't said it's the Department of War.
- 43:41It depends where, you know, where you take your cues.
- 43:44You know, they've put Department of War on the wall, but I don't
- 43:47think, you know, the law has actually been changed.
- 43:50But you know, the steam engine analogy is basically like, if
- 43:55you have this great technology coming, do you really not want
- 43:58to lean into something that is going to ultimately improve your
- 44:01quality of life? And if you don't do it, whether
- 44:03it's in Texas or China, it's going to happen somewhere.
- 44:06I get, and I'm bought into some of the like, we need to build AI
- 44:10in a sort of ethical and intentional way, but we
- 44:13shouldn't let that sort of concern stop us from embracing a
- 44:16technology that will ultimately make our lives much.
- 44:19Better, absolutely. I think there's, I just see the,
- 44:24it's funny, the word progressive doesn't really mean this
- 44:27anymore, but I think of myself as a progressive person in that
- 44:30like progress to me means looking at how new technology
- 44:34can make things better. And that history shows as a
- 44:37guide that whenever these really disruptive moments happen, there
- 44:42are always more new jobs on the other side, for instance.
- 44:46But I don't want to be too Pollyanna ish.
- 44:49The transition to get to what those new jobs are is messy.
- 44:54And that's the moment we're living in.
- 44:55And we can either, I think, do the hard work of addressing that
- 44:58head on and having like the real hard conversations about what
- 45:03that means for New York City, for New York State, for America.
- 45:06What's it going to do to the workforce?
- 45:07How do we prepare people? Or we can like spend our time
- 45:12debating banning data centers, which in my mind is actually a
- 45:16real distraction from the hard work of figuring out what a kind
- 45:20of not post AI world, but what a world with AI prevalent AI tools
- 45:26is going to look like and how to make sure that transition works
- 45:28for as many people as possible like that.
- 45:31To me, that is the question for our time.
- 45:34Julie Yeah, we'll have you on a year we see.
- 45:37All right. Turned out all right.
- 45:38Thanks. For coming on so much for having
- 45:39me. That's our episode.
- 45:42I'm Eric Newcomer. Thank you so much for listening
- 45:45to the Newcomer podcast. If you're new here, I was a long
- 45:48time tech reporter at Bloomberg and the Information.
- 45:52I started a sub stack called Newcomer.
- 45:54It's my last name in 2020 and I've been tirelessly working on
- 45:59a YouTube channel. I also host the Surreal Valley
- 46:03AI Summit and have a podcast with my friends Max and James
- 46:06called the Surreal Valley Show. Here at the Newcomer podcast,
- 46:09we're trying to get to the heart of what's going on in startups
- 46:12and venture capital. Sometimes we veer into the
- 46:17intersection of tech and politics, trying to have honest,
- 46:20direct conversations, an independent minded show with
- 46:23someone who knows how to ask hard questions, who likes to
- 46:26fight a little bit. We're finding our voice.
- 46:28We love your comments. I've stopped saying right, you
- 46:31know, I'm I'm reading the YouTube comments for good and
- 46:34bad and we appreciate all your support.
- 46:36Go harass us on the sub stack too.
- 46:39You know, newcomer.co, thank you so much for following along.
- 46:42Please. We really do enjoy your
- 46:43feedback. Of course, like comments,
- 46:46subscribe. Excited for what we've got in
- 46:48store for you this year. Thanks so much.
- 46:50See you next week.