Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Palimony / Marvin Actions: What Family Law Practitioners Need to Know
Transcript
- 0:03Thanks, everybody, for joining us. We're here
- 0:05with two very special speakers, Alphonse Provenziano
- 0:11and Sarah Clark, to speak on Palimony actions,
- 0:15Marvin actions, and family law proceedings. So
- 0:19we're going to have a great program set for you
- 0:21today. Just a few introductory matters. I would
- 0:25be remiss if I did not mention that we have a
- 0:28Beverly Hills Bar happy hour going on on February
- 0:335th at 6 p .m. in Beverly Hills. And this is
- 0:37a cross practice networking night with the family
- 0:41law section, the entertainment law section, and
- 0:44the litigation sections. And that's at above
- 0:4660 in Beverly Hills. Great opportunity. It's
- 0:49something that we're trying to stress is kind
- 0:51of doing some cross pollination between the family
- 0:54law section and other adjacent sections like
- 0:57entertainment and litigation. So great networking
- 1:00opportunity. We have some additional upcoming
- 1:03CLEs on calendar for you. On the 28th tomorrow,
- 1:09we have international family law, Islamic law
- 1:12in international family law matters. On the 2nd
- 1:16of February, we have everything you need to know
- 1:18about California's new joint petition. That's
- 1:21the petition for dissolution. On February 4th,
- 1:25we have the Four Corners event, the 2025 annual
- 1:29family law case update. And last but not least,
- 1:32on March 11th, we have a CLE on bifurcation issues
- 1:36featuring Erin Gray and Judge Luna. So a lot
- 1:39of great programming coming up. Stay tuned for
- 1:42all of that. The family law section is sponsored
- 1:45by White Zuckerman, Warsowski, Hunt, Luna, LLP,
- 1:48and SoberLink. White Zuckerman provides a wide
- 1:51variety of resources to complete almost any project,
- 1:55large or small. They also provide traditional
- 1:58accounting and tax practice services. We invite
- 2:00you to contact them to discuss your specific
- 2:02accounting needs and learn how they can be of
- 2:05service to you. Learn more at WZWLH .com. SoberLink
- 2:11provides objective real -time data that can be
- 2:13used to reduce disputes over alcohol consumption,
- 2:16leading to less conflict in custody cases. To
- 2:21help ensure smoother negotiations for a more
- 2:23efficient legal process, consider using SoberLink's
- 2:26trusted alcohol monitoring system to eliminate
- 2:28hearsay and protect your client's best interests.
- 2:31With an unprecedented combination of features,
- 2:34including advanced reporting, facial recognition,
- 2:36tamper resistance, real -time results, and customized
- 2:39testing, the discrete system has been the leader
- 2:42in remote alcohol monitoring since 2011. Learn
- 2:45more at soberlink .com. Well... I am delighted
- 2:50to introduce our speakers, Sarah Clark in our
- 2:55moderator today, Al Provenziano. Sarah C. Clark
- 3:00is an attorney at Goldstein Clark, an associate
- 3:04where she has devoted the past 17 years of her
- 3:08practice exclusively to family law and specifically
- 3:11Palimony. actions. Throughout her career, Ms.
- 3:15Clark has advised and represented hundreds of
- 3:17individuals in complex Marvin claims, many of
- 3:20which involve significant crossover issues with
- 3:22traditional family law matters, including division
- 3:24of properties, spousal support, and breach of
- 3:26fiduciary duty. Her practice regularly involves
- 3:30high conflict and high asset disputes requiring
- 3:32a sophisticated understanding of both family
- 3:35law principles and the contractual and equitable
- 3:37doctrines that govern non -marital relationships.
- 3:40Ms. Clark is licensed to practice law in both
- 3:42California and New York, giving her a broader
- 3:45perspective on complex multi -jurisdictional
- 3:47matters. Al Provenziano is a prominent divorce
- 3:51and family law attorney and the founder of Provenziano
- 3:53and Associates, Beverly Hills Law Firm, focused
- 3:56exclusively on family law matters. He handles
- 3:59high stakes, high net worth matters, including
- 4:02complex divorces, international custody disputes,
- 4:04cross -border as a division, and pre -nuptial
- 4:07and post -nuptial agreements. and he's also known
- 4:11for his strategic advocacy and financial acumen.
- 4:14CFLS and former deputy district attorney, I didn't
- 4:17know that out, he's handled more than 2 ,000
- 4:21matters and over 220 trials since 2004, that's
- 4:26a lot. Provenziano is a fellow of the IAFL and
- 4:32serves as president -elect of the Beverly Hills
- 4:34Bar Association. He earned his undergraduate
- 4:36degree with honors from UC Berkeley and his JD
- 4:40from UC Law San Francisco, formerly known as
- 4:43UC Hastings. He's also a frequent speaker and
- 4:48featured as a legal media expert in national
- 4:51and international law outlets. With all of that,
- 4:55now let's take it away, Al and Sarah. Thanks
- 4:59so much, Ryan, and thanks for the intro. Wanted
- 5:04to welcome Sarah. Thank you so much for this
- 5:07class. And I know it's one of the things that
- 5:10you've done is that you've trained under Harry
- 5:13Goldstein, who was also trained by and assumed
- 5:16the caseload of Marvin Mitchelson, who is the
- 5:19counsel for the plaintiff in the landmark Marvin
- 5:21case, giving you the benefit of more than 40
- 5:25years of accumulated experience dating back to
- 5:27the very beginning of Palomoni litigation. And
- 5:30we're very excited to have this course here at
- 5:34the Beverly Hills Bar Association. And from your
- 5:39standpoint as a practical matter, Sarah, why
- 5:41is Palomoni an area that family law attorneys
- 5:44really can't afford to overlook anymore? Well,
- 5:47thank you, Al, for that intro. And good afternoon,
- 5:50everyone. I'm sure it's no surprise to anyone
- 5:53here that over the years, there has been an increase
- 5:56in long -term non -marital relationships. And
- 6:00palimony claims can often come to light during
- 6:03the pendency of a dissolution action or a parentage
- 6:06action. So as a family law practitioner, it's
- 6:10very important to be able to recognize a potential
- 6:12palimony claim so you can properly advise your
- 6:16client and ensure they don't inadvertently allow
- 6:19a statute of limitations deadline to expire.
- 6:22And it's also important to be able to recognize
- 6:25whether your client has exposure to a Palimony
- 6:28claim being filed against them and how best to
- 6:31protect their interests and prepare a solid defense.
- 6:37And why is it important for practitioners to
- 6:40remember that Marvin claims are grounded in contract
- 6:43rather than family law, Sarah? Yeah, so at its
- 6:47core a Marvin action is a civil breach of contract
- 6:51claim filed in civil court and is not a family
- 6:54law proceeding so they're treated very differently
- 6:57and I know that's a bit perplexing since the
- 7:00discussion regarding Palimony claims is contained
- 7:04in the family law guide of the rudder group But
- 7:07under no circumstances will a Marvin claim be
- 7:10subject to the family code They are governed
- 7:13entirely by statutory law and case law regarding
- 7:17contracts. And for all intents and purposes,
- 7:21though, they do involve very similar issues as
- 7:25dissolution actions in that you're essentially
- 7:28untangling the finances in real property holdings
- 7:31between two parties. Those parties just happen
- 7:34to be unmarried. So let's start by discussing
- 7:38the case that really put Palamoni on the map
- 7:41in California, which was the Marvin versus Marvin
- 7:44case. And that was a case from 1976, which addressed
- 7:50whether an unmarried cohabitant could enforce
- 7:54financial and property rights against a former
- 7:57partner after the relationship ended. And the
- 8:01Marvin case involved the plaintiff Michelle Triola
- 8:04and the defendant Lee Marvin, who was an actor.
- 8:08and not to be confused with Michelle's attorney
- 8:11in the case, Marvin Mitchelson. So there are
- 8:14a few few Marvins involved in this one. So the
- 8:18plaintiff Michelle Triola alleged that she and
- 8:21her former partner Lee Marvin entered into an
- 8:25oral agreement whereby they agreed they would
- 8:28hold themselves out to the general public as
- 8:30husband and wife. Lee Marvin would provide support
- 8:34to Michelle for the remainder of her life, and
- 8:36they would essentially share equally in all property
- 8:40accumulated during the relationship. And in exchange,
- 8:46Michelle agreed that she would give up her career
- 8:48and perform domestic services for Lee Marvin
- 8:51as a companion, homemaker, housekeeper, and cook.
- 8:58The parties did live together for seven years,
- 9:02and during that time, Michelle used the last
- 9:05name Marvin. They did hold themselves out as
- 9:08a married couple. Michelle also gave up her lucrative
- 9:12career as an entertainer and a singer in order
- 9:16to devote her time to rendering these domestic
- 9:19services to Lee Marvin. And during their relationship,
- 9:25substantial real and personal property was acquired,
- 9:29including fairly significant motion picture rights.
- 9:33All property was acquired solely in Lee Marvin's
- 9:36name, however. So when the relationship ended,
- 9:40Lee Marvin supported Michelle for about another
- 9:43year until he refused to provide her with any
- 9:47additional support. At which point, Michelle
- 9:49then filed a civil lawsuit against Lee Marvin,
- 9:53alleging breach of their express contract. And
- 9:57so when the Marvin court considered Michelle's
- 10:01claim, it had to kind of strike a balance between
- 10:05case law that treated contracts between unmarried
- 10:08partners as unenforceable if they were based
- 10:12on an illicit relationship and the existing line
- 10:15of cases recognizing that non -marital partners
- 10:19could still bring claims against each other concerning
- 10:22property rights. And they looked at cases, the
- 10:26Marvin case looked at other cases like Trutalli
- 10:29versus Meroviglia. And in that case, the parties
- 10:32have lived together for 11 years. They had two
- 10:37children. They agreed to pool their earnings
- 10:40and hold property jointly. That court found that
- 10:45living together in a, quote, unlawful relation
- 10:48didn't disqualify the parties from entering into
- 10:52a lawful agreement with one another regarding
- 10:55ownership of property that was acquired during
- 10:57their relationship. Similar to the Trutali case,
- 11:05the Marvin Court essentially rejected this notion
- 11:09that public policy automatically barred the enforcement
- 11:14of agreements between unmarried partners. And
- 11:18the Marvin Court found that adults who voluntarily
- 11:22live together and engage in sexual relations
- 11:25are nonetheless as competent as any other persons
- 11:29to contract, respecting their earnings and property.
- 11:33They may agree to pool their earnings and to
- 11:35hold all property acquired during the relationship
- 11:38in accord with the law governing community property.
- 11:42Conversely, they may agree that each partner's
- 11:44earnings and the property acquired from those
- 11:47earnings remain the separate property of the
- 11:50earning partner. So long as the agreement does
- 11:53not rest upon illicit, meretricious consideration,
- 11:56the parties may order their economic affairs
- 11:58as they choose, and no policy precludes the course
- 12:03from enforcing such agreements. Even though Michelle
- 12:07Triola ultimately did not win her case against
- 12:11Lee Marvin, the decision did have a lasting impact
- 12:15and it opened the door for future Palomoni claims
- 12:19and is now widely recognized as the foundational
- 12:22case for all Palomoni actions, hence the term
- 12:25Marvin actions. Sarah, can you speak to the evidentiary
- 12:31challenges that may arise when an agreement is
- 12:33implied rather than expressed? Sure. Let's talk
- 12:42about... Oh, Al, can we go back? Oh, yes. Perfect.
- 12:49Yeah. So let's talk a little bit about... the
- 12:58elements of a breach of contract claim. So now
- 13:02that we know Marvin actions are civil breach
- 13:04of contract claims and are enforceable between
- 13:09non -married cohabitants, there are some key
- 13:11elements that must be present in any contract
- 13:15claim and some elements that are unique to Palimony
- 13:18claims. So let's take a look at those. The first
- 13:22element in any breach of contract claim is the
- 13:26existence of the agreement. And basic contract
- 13:29law tells us that there are three types of agreements,
- 13:34the first being a written agreement. And while
- 13:37it's always amazing when two unmarried cohabitants
- 13:40have a written agreement memorializing their
- 13:43understanding regarding support and property,
- 13:46it's rarely the case that you actually see a
- 13:49written agreement in a palimony type situation.
- 13:52And the most common type of palimony claims are
- 13:56based on express oral agreements. And as you
- 14:00can imagine, those can be difficult to prove
- 14:02because it often comes down to one person's word
- 14:06against the other. And the third type of agreement
- 14:09that is quite common in the Marvin context is
- 14:13an implied agreement. And as the Marvin court
- 14:16stated, the courts may inquire into the conduct
- 14:20of the parties to determine whether that conduct
- 14:23demonstrates an implied contract or implied agreement
- 14:27of partnership or joint venture or some other
- 14:30tacit understanding between the parties. So what
- 14:33this essentially means is that an agreement to
- 14:36provide ongoing support or to share an all property
- 14:40equally can arise based on how the parties have
- 14:44conducted themselves and their financial affairs
- 14:47during the relationship, even in the absence
- 14:50of any express representations. So now, to answer
- 14:55your question about evidentiary challenges in
- 15:00these implied agreements, they can be difficult
- 15:04to prove. And a Palomoni plaintiff is typically
- 15:08relying on third -party testimony. Many times,
- 15:12one partner has repeated these promises of financial
- 15:15support or property sharing to friends and family
- 15:19members. You also want to look closely at the
- 15:23party's communications, such as emails, text
- 15:26messages, greeting cards, even social media posts,
- 15:30to see whether those promises show up in writing
- 15:33anywhere. So in terms of evidence and an implied
- 15:39Marvin agreement, it typically involves the parties
- 15:43having a quote marriage type relationship. And
- 15:47maybe one party is using the other's last name.
- 15:51They could be wearing wedding rings. Perhaps
- 15:54they had a religious marriage ceremony or they're
- 15:57simply holding one another out as spouses. And
- 16:01that marriage type relationship is usually coupled
- 16:05with other conduct relating to their finances
- 16:08and property. And so some conduct which can be
- 16:13demonstrative of an implied agreement is where
- 16:16the parties have joint financial accounts, joint
- 16:20credit cards, they might hold joint title to
- 16:24property, they may have filed their tax returns
- 16:28as married. They may have signed a declaration
- 16:32of domestic partnership, and that's not necessarily
- 16:36the declaration of domestic partnership that's
- 16:39filed with the Secretary of State. Many parties
- 16:43will complete these forms for their employers
- 16:46in order to obtain health insurance benefits
- 16:50for their partner. And those declarations can
- 16:54be quite informative because they very often
- 16:58can contain express representations confirming
- 17:01cohabitation, joint ownership of property, and
- 17:06responsibility for support and living expenses.
- 17:10If you're trying to prove a Palamoni claim, that
- 17:13can be a great piece of evidence. You might also
- 17:17see a party identifying their partner as... as
- 17:23a spouse in order to obtain other benefits. For
- 17:25example, maybe listing them as a beneficiary
- 17:28on their life insurance or their retirement accounts.
- 17:32You might also see a will or trust that has been
- 17:35drafted or executed where the other party is
- 17:39named as a beneficiary to memorialize the promises
- 17:43of support and property division in the event
- 17:46of death. And you've listed several indicators
- 17:50that the courts look at, Sarah. How much weight
- 17:52does any single factor usually carry with the
- 17:55court? And are there particular facts that you
- 17:58find courts find especially persuasive when looking
- 18:02at an implied agreement? So it's important to
- 18:06keep in mind that none of these actions or behaviors
- 18:10are strictly required. And there isn't one that
- 18:14necessarily carries more substantial weight.
- 18:17If they didn't have joint accounts, for example,
- 18:21that alone is not going to be fatal to a polymony
- 18:25case because sometimes even legally married parties
- 18:29have separate accounts. If the parties were married
- 18:33before to other people, you may want to inquire
- 18:37as to how they handled their financial affairs
- 18:40during their marriage to see how similar or different
- 18:43that is to the palimony relationship. And you
- 18:47really just have to look at the totality of the
- 18:50party's relationship and whether their conduct
- 18:53demonstrated some type of implied agreement.
- 19:02So let's talk about lawful consideration, which
- 19:07is the second key element for a breach of contract
- 19:10claim. And in the Marvin context, you usually
- 19:15see two very common types of agreements. One
- 19:18is a pooling agreement where the parties pool
- 19:22their income and earnings to acquire property
- 19:25together. And the second very... common type
- 19:28of palimony agreement is one where one party
- 19:32essentially promises to be the breadwinner for
- 19:35the relationship and promises to render the other
- 19:39party financially secure by providing lifetime
- 19:43support and equally sharing all property that's
- 19:47acquired during the relationship. And in exchange,
- 19:50the other party agrees to provide homemaking
- 19:53or domestic services. And these domestic services
- 19:57can be anything from cooking the meals, doing
- 20:00the laundry, doing the dishes, caring for children,
- 20:05caring for pets, or assisting the other party
- 20:08in their business. And as the Marvin case told
- 20:11us, a promise to perform homemaking services
- 20:15is lawful and adequate consideration for a contract.
- 20:19Otherwise, those engaged in domestic employment
- 20:22could not sue for their wages. But how does this
- 20:27consideration, how does it differ from a more
- 20:30traditional contract dispute? So in many ways,
- 20:35it really doesn't differ that much at all. As
- 20:38long as the consideration is lawful, a Marvin
- 20:41claim is analyzed just like any other contract
- 20:45dispute. And the court is going to look at the
- 20:48same basic principles of contract law. The cohabitation
- 20:55requirement is very unique to Marvin actions.
- 21:01And as the Bergen versus Wood case stated, cohabitation
- 21:07is necessary not in and of itself, but rather
- 21:11because from cohabitation flows the rendition
- 21:15of domestic services, which services amount to
- 21:18lawful consideration for a contract between the
- 21:21parties. And the rationale there is that a party
- 21:26would not be able to perform these domestic services
- 21:30for the other party on any consistent basis if
- 21:34they did not live together. There is one caveat
- 21:39here though that I do want to make clear, which
- 21:42is that the cohabitation requirement in Marvin's
- 21:45situations only applies to the scenario where
- 21:48domestic services are being formed at performed
- 21:53as consideration for the agreement. If it's purely
- 21:56a pooling agreement of money to acquire property,
- 21:59then the lawful consideration for the agreement
- 22:02is the contribution of those funds. So cohabitation
- 22:05wouldn't necessarily come into play. And is there
- 22:09any practical issues that arise when cohabitation
- 22:12is disputed? Well, I will say that Cohabitation
- 22:18is not an issue that is frequently disputed and
- 22:23it's usually fairly easy to prove whether the
- 22:26parties were living together on whether that's
- 22:29by third party testimony or other documents reflecting
- 22:34joint residency. Okay, so if you have a Marvin
- 22:45situation where domestic services are the consideration
- 22:49for the agreement. Although cohabitation is required,
- 22:54full -time cohabitation is not. Part -time cohabitation
- 22:58can be enough. And the case that best illustrates
- 23:02that is the Cochrane versus Cochrane case. And
- 23:06in that case, the parties were in a long -term
- 23:08relationship that lasted 17 years. They lived
- 23:12together about two to three days per week, and
- 23:15they held themselves out as husband and wife,
- 23:18they raised a child together, and they owned
- 23:20a joint home. And the court held that that level
- 23:24of cohabitation, just two to three days per week,
- 23:28was sufficient to support a Marvin -type agreement.
- 23:32And the Cochrane court specifically stated that
- 23:36the purpose of Marvin was to permit parties to
- 23:39a significant and stable relationship to contract
- 23:43concerning their earnings and property rights.
- 23:45To require nothing short of full -time cohabitation
- 23:49before enforcing an agreement would defeat the
- 23:52reasonable expectations of persons who may clearly
- 23:55enjoy a significant and stable relationship arising
- 23:59from cohabitation, albeit less than full -time
- 24:02living arrangement. For instance, it would exclude
- 24:05otherwise valid support agreements made by parties
- 24:08who, perhaps because their jobs are geographically
- 24:11far apart, maintain a part -time residence for
- 24:14one party and also a second residence where at
- 24:18times they live jointly. Certainly the rationale
- 24:20of Marvin does not support such a result. And
- 24:26how does the holding of Cochrane affect clients
- 24:28whose relationships don't fit a traditional mold?
- 24:32the ruling in Cochrane really acknowledged that
- 24:35relationships don't always fit a traditional
- 24:38mold and that cohabitation can take many different
- 24:44forms. So whether the parties to a Marvin agreement
- 24:48have satisfied the cohabitation requirement is
- 24:53really going to be fact specific to their particular
- 24:56situation. And obviously there's a part about
- 25:01breach turning to that, when does a Marvin agreement
- 25:05typically fail from a legal standpoint? Yeah,
- 25:09so let's talk about that third key element of
- 25:13a Marvin claim, which is the breach. So in general,
- 25:17And in terms of general contract law, the breach
- 25:20of an agreement occurs when the party charged
- 25:23with the duty to perform under the contract ceases
- 25:27to perform. And typically, a Marvin -type contract
- 25:30is breached when one party terminates the relationship.
- 25:35And this is usually because non -performance
- 25:39under the agreement typically coincides with
- 25:42the end of the relationship. In practical terms,
- 25:46non -performance will often manifest when one
- 25:50party ceases providing financial support or cancels
- 25:55credit cards, terminates health or automobile
- 25:58insurance, or takes any other action that effectively
- 26:03withholds promised financial support to the other
- 26:07party. And is there situations that you could
- 26:11elaborate on how continued performance affects
- 26:14the accrual of a claim? Yeah. So while Marvin
- 26:19claims are often breached at the termination
- 26:22of the relationship, that breach does not always
- 26:26happen at that time. Since a Marvin cause of
- 26:30action does not accrue until the agreed upon
- 26:33performance stops, if the parties are separated
- 26:37in the obligor continued to perform as required
- 26:41by the contract, then there's been no breach.
- 26:45And this is a concept that was once again reflected
- 26:49in the Cochrane case. And remember, in that case,
- 26:53the plaintiff and defendant had a child live
- 26:55together as if they were husband and wife. The
- 26:59plaintiff in that case had alleged that the defendant
- 27:02promised her that all property acquired during
- 27:05their relationship would be joint and that he
- 27:08would provide her with lifetime support. So fast
- 27:13forward 20 years when the defendant married another
- 27:17woman and the party ceased living together, that
- 27:23he can actually continue to financially support
- 27:27the plaintiff for another nine years after the
- 27:30relationship ended. When the financial support
- 27:35eventually stopped, the plaintiff then filed
- 27:38a Marvin action alleging breach of contract for
- 27:41lifetime support. And so the Cochrane court held
- 27:45that the statute of limitations for a breach
- 27:48of a Marvin agreement to provide support does
- 27:51not commence to run until the support payments
- 27:54cease, notwithstanding that the parties may have
- 27:58separated years earlier. So once again, that
- 28:01date of breach is going to be very fact -specific
- 28:05in a Marvin claim and does not always coincide
- 28:09with the termination of the relationship. And
- 28:13continued support in a Marvin situation will
- 28:16prevent the statute of limitations from running.
- 28:20And what kind of common claims do you see played
- 28:23alongside Marvin actions and how does that shape
- 28:26overall strategy? Yeah, so once you've been able
- 28:30to analyze the core Marvin agreement in any given
- 28:34case, you'll want to determine what additional
- 28:38claims and remedies might be available to a Marvin
- 28:41plaintiff. And there are some that can be quite
- 28:44common. the first being a breach of partnership
- 28:49or joint venture. And this can be common when
- 28:53parties are operating a business together. Many
- 28:56times you'll see a business that's placed in
- 29:00only one party's name, but both parties are holding
- 29:04themselves out as founders of the company and
- 29:07devoting their time to working for the business.
- 29:11Fraud claims are also quite common, where one
- 29:15party has made representations of property sharing
- 29:19or financial support, which are later discovered
- 29:23to be false. And this can happen in situations
- 29:27where the parties have made express representations.
- 29:31about sharing property together even if property
- 29:35is only titled in one of their names and later
- 29:39the non -title holder discovers that the other
- 29:43party never intended to equally share that property
- 29:47and that's usually discovered when you review
- 29:50communications with third parties during the
- 29:53relationship or if the title holder had drafted
- 29:57a will or a trust during the relationship that
- 30:00contradicted the terms of the party's relationship.
- 30:05Specific performance is also available to a Marvin
- 30:09plaintiff. In situations where damages are inadequate,
- 30:13a party can elect to pursue specific performance
- 30:17of a property agreement with respect to either
- 30:21real property or property with sentimental value.
- 30:25Now, there's such a thing as a resulting trust
- 30:28and a constructive trust. Sarah, can you distinguish
- 30:31those for us and how they apply in a Marvin claim
- 30:34case? Sure. Both resulting trusts and constructive
- 30:38trusts are remedies that are available to Marvin
- 30:41plaintiffs. A resulting trust is usually implemented
- 30:46when property is transferred to one party and
- 30:51the consideration is paid, whether that's either
- 30:53in whole or in part by another party. So for
- 30:58a resulting trust, the consideration does not
- 31:01have to be money. A party's rendition of domestic
- 31:06services that allows the other party to save
- 31:09on costs and increase their own financial base
- 31:12and ability to purchase property can give rise
- 31:16to a resulting trust. In the context of a constructive
- 31:21trust, that is typically implemented when property
- 31:25has been wrongfully obtained or retained, whether
- 31:28that's by fraud, accident, or mistake, and prevents
- 31:33unjust enrichment. And you might see that in
- 31:36a scenario where there is a piece of property
- 31:40owned by one party prior to the relationship,
- 31:43and for one reason or another, that property
- 31:46is temporarily transferred to the other party
- 31:49with the intent that it would be transferred
- 31:51back but it never is. Or you could see a situation
- 31:54where during the relationship one party inadvertently
- 31:59signs a document that they later discover was
- 32:03a quitclaim deed where they have transferred
- 32:06their property to their former partner without
- 32:09ever knowing. An equitable lien is also available
- 32:17to Marvin plaintiffs and that is a court recognized
- 32:22security interest imposed on specific property
- 32:26to secure performance of an obligation without
- 32:29actually transferring ownership. And this is
- 32:32a remedy that prevents unjust enrichment where
- 32:37property is not acquired, but maybe the value
- 32:40of the property is increased. And this type of
- 32:44remedy can be appropriate in situations where
- 32:48maybe there's a property once again that was
- 32:51acquired by one of the parties previous to the
- 32:54relationship, but the parties reside there during
- 32:59during the relationship and the non -title holder
- 33:02contributes a significant amount of money towards
- 33:06improvements and repairs. And in that situation,
- 33:10a party may be able to pursue an equitable lien
- 33:14against the property for reimbursement. Declaratory
- 33:19relief is also available to Marvin plaintiffs,
- 33:23which is a judicial determination establishing
- 33:26rights of the parties that are in dispute. Again,
- 33:30exactly what type of declaratory relief any given
- 33:36Marvin plaintiff is pursuing will really be specific
- 33:40to their situation. What situations do the court
- 33:44seem most receptive to these other forms of relief?
- 33:49Well, usually courts are going to be more receptive
- 33:53to implementing this form of relief when there's
- 33:56fairly egregious inequity and unjust enrichment,
- 34:00because again, these Marvin claims are mostly
- 34:03equitable in nature. And is there situations
- 34:07when quantum marijuana becomes a viable alternative
- 34:10to a contract based claim? Yes, so a quantum
- 34:16Marrowit can always be pled in the alternative
- 34:19to relief as part of a breach of contract claim.
- 34:24And as the Marvin Court stated, a non -marital
- 34:28partner may recover in quantum Marrowit for the
- 34:31reasonable value of household services rendered
- 34:34less the reasonable value of support received
- 34:37if he can show that he rendered services with
- 34:40the expectation of monetary reward. And it's
- 34:45important to know that the law does not presume
- 34:48that compensable services are rendered between
- 34:51non -marital partners with donative intent. So
- 34:55if a party is alleging a defense to a quantum
- 34:59Marowit claim that the services were rendered
- 35:02as a gift, they will need to demonstrate specific
- 35:06proof that it was actually intended to be a gift.
- 35:10And it's also important to understand the correct
- 35:14measure of quantum Marowit recovery is the value
- 35:20of the beneficial services, not the value by
- 35:23which someone benefits from those services. So
- 35:28the most notable case involving a quantum Marowit
- 35:32claim in the Marvin context is the Maglika case.
- 35:37In that case, Anthony Maglica was involved in
- 35:41a romantic relationship with the plaintiff. They
- 35:45began living together, holding themselves out
- 35:48as husband and wife, and plaintiff began using
- 35:51the last name of Maglica. The parties worked
- 35:55together at Anthony Maglica's business, which
- 35:58was always in his name. And during the relationship,
- 36:01the business began manufacturing flashlights,
- 36:05which Some of you may be familiar with the Maglite
- 36:08flashlight. And the plaintiff in this situation
- 36:13did contribute some great ideas for the business,
- 36:16including a little purse -sized flashlight. And
- 36:19the business was very successful and lucrative
- 36:22during their relationship. So when plaintiff
- 36:25later pursued a quantum Marowit claim against
- 36:28Maglika, she was initially awarded $84 million
- 36:32as the reasonable value of her services. But
- 36:37the appellate court reversed that, saying that
- 36:40the $84 million award was based on the resulting
- 36:44benefit to Maglica and the success of the business,
- 36:48rather than the proper measure of recovery, which
- 36:51was simply the reasonable value of the services
- 36:55that were performed by the plaintiff. As a practical
- 37:00matter though, it's always a good idea to plead
- 37:03quantum merit any time compensable services have
- 37:08been performed during a Marvin type relationship.
- 37:13And what does this tell us about the importance
- 37:14of tailoring the remedies to the facts and whether
- 37:18or not this is an exhaustive list of remedies?
- 37:22Yeah, so It is important to understand that these
- 37:25claims and remedies are not exhaustive, and most
- 37:29Marvin claims are equitable in nature, and the
- 37:33Marvin Court stated that where existing traditional
- 37:36remedies prove inadequate, Trial courts may fashion
- 37:40additional equitable remedies to protect the
- 37:43party's reasonable expectations, and the suitability
- 37:47of such remedies may be determined in later cases
- 37:50in light of the factual setting in which they
- 37:53arise. So whether someone has a palimony claim
- 37:57and what specific claims they might bring really
- 38:00depends on the unique facts of their situation.
- 38:03as well as the agreements made during the party's
- 38:07relationship and how they conducted themselves.
- 38:10It's also very common to see additional claims
- 38:14alongside a core Marvin breach of contract claim.
- 38:18For example, A Marvin plaintiff might also bring
- 38:22real property claims like quiet title or partition.
- 38:27And if the parties run a business together, you
- 38:28might also see claims for accounting conversion
- 38:32or breach of fiduciary duty. And depending on
- 38:36a person's age, financial elder abuse claims
- 38:39can sometimes be a part of these cases as well.
- 38:43And so the takeaway here is that spotting and
- 38:48evaluating all potential claims very early is
- 38:51going to be critical in a Marvin case. Just talking
- 38:58a little bit about statute of limitations for
- 38:59us. Yeah. So now that we've covered what a Marvin
- 39:03claim is, let's shift to some of the defenses.
- 39:07Like any contract case, Marvin claims are subject
- 39:11to the usual affirmative defenses, but there
- 39:14are a few defenses that tend to come up quite
- 39:16frequently in these cases, the first being the
- 39:19statute of limitations. And if you have a Marvin
- 39:22claim for breach of written, agreement, the applicable
- 39:26statute of limitations is going to be four years
- 39:29from the date of breach. If you have an oral
- 39:32or implied agreement, that statute of limitations
- 39:36deadline is going to be two years from the date
- 39:39of breach. And the same with a quantum Marowit
- 39:43claim, two years from the date of breach. All
- 39:47other equitable claims like for example constructive
- 39:51trust or resulting trust, those are going to
- 39:53have a four -year statute of limitations. Are
- 39:57there any pitfalls that it pitfalls that attorneys
- 39:59should be aware of when they're calculating the
- 40:01accrual of dates for the statute of limitations?
- 40:06Yes, so parties need to be very careful about
- 40:08pursuing a Marvin claim promptly so it doesn't
- 40:11expire, and it's especially important for the
- 40:15plaintiff to be transparent with their attorney
- 40:18and for the plaintiff's attorney to do their
- 40:22due due due diligence and review all communications
- 40:26between the parties. Sometimes there are emails,
- 40:30text messages, or statements where the other
- 40:33party has clearly indicated that all property
- 40:36belongs solely to them. And when that happens,
- 40:39the statute of limitations can start running
- 40:41even before the relationship officially ends.
- 40:45So any time one party takes a position that directly
- 40:49conflicts with the Marvin plaintiff's understanding
- 40:52of the agreement, the clock starts ticking. And
- 40:55if that plaintiff doesn't act quickly, They risk
- 40:58waiving the claim and giving the defendant a
- 41:01strong statute of limitations defense. And no
- 41:05plaintiff's attorney wants to find out in the
- 41:07middle of litigating a Marvin case the evidence
- 41:09like this exists. And yes, it does happen. I
- 41:13have seen situations. where in Marvin claims
- 41:16that predate a legal marriage, you're six months
- 41:20into litigating the Marvin case and the other
- 41:24side produces a premarital agreement that the
- 41:27parties sign to memorialize all of their separate
- 41:29property and that is essentially fatal to a palimony
- 41:33claim. So it's very important to have transparency
- 41:37with your client and to do your own investigation.
- 41:42And can you explain why the statute of frauds
- 41:44is less effective as a defense to a Marvin claim?
- 41:48Sure. So the statute of frauds is another common
- 41:51defense when real property is involved because
- 41:54the statute of frauds requires agreements relating
- 41:57to the sale or ownership of real property to
- 42:00be in writing. And since Marvin agreements are
- 42:03typically expressed oral agreements, the statute
- 42:07of frauds can bar enforcement of the agreement.
- 42:10But one way for a Marvin plaintiff to try to
- 42:14overcome a statute of fraud's defense is by alleging
- 42:17detrimental reliance. these Marvin plaintiffs
- 42:23have relied on the other party's promises to
- 42:26their detriment. And this can be a very significant
- 42:29part of any Marvin claim. You will often see
- 42:33this in long -term relationships where one party
- 42:37has given up their career, stayed home to raise
- 42:40the children, supported... the other partner
- 42:44in their professional life, and 20, 30 years
- 42:48down the line, the relationship ends and the
- 42:51Marvin plaintiff might find themselves in a position
- 42:53where they have no property in their name, no
- 42:56retirement, no employment history, no established
- 43:00credit, and they've made no contributions to
- 43:02social security for many years. So in situations
- 43:06like that, the consequences can be truly devastating.
- 43:10So that's why courts will allow plaintiffs to
- 43:15rely on equitable estoppel to prevent the other
- 43:18party from using the statute of frauds as a defense
- 43:21when the plaintiff clearly relied on promises
- 43:24to their detriment. And as the Marvin case noted,
- 43:29most cohabitation agreements are expressed oral
- 43:32agreements. So many other cases have expressly
- 43:38rejected defenses to such agreements that are
- 43:42grounded on the statute of frauds. And the Byrne
- 43:46versus Laura case also addressed this issue and
- 43:49said that in light of Marvin's endorsement of
- 43:52equitable remedies to protect the expectations
- 43:55of the parties to a non -marital agreement, The
- 43:58court's observations on the enforcement of oral
- 44:02cohabitation agreements can only be interpreted
- 44:05as an approval of the use of equitable estoppel
- 44:09by cohabitants in appropriate cases. And there's
- 44:13a particular case, the case of Taylor versus
- 44:16Fields. Can you tell us what lessons that practitioners
- 44:19should take regarding consideration from that
- 44:22case? Absolutely. Another common defense to Marvin's
- 44:27actions is a lack of lawful consideration. And
- 44:30this can be a very successful defense if a contract
- 44:35is expressly in and inseparably founded upon
- 44:39a meretricious relationship. And in those circumstances,
- 44:43the contract will be invalid and unenforceable.
- 44:48And Taylor versus Fields is one case that really
- 44:50highlights this situation where a Marvin agreement
- 44:54will not be enforced. case, the plaintiff, who
- 44:57was the longtime mistress of a man who had passed
- 45:00away, brought a Marvin action against the widow,
- 45:03alleging that the deceased husband had promised
- 45:06her lifetime financial support in exchange for
- 45:09plaintiff acting as defendant's confidant, friend,
- 45:13travel companion, and lover. And the court ultimately
- 45:16found that the role as lover was an inseparable
- 45:19part of the consideration for the agreement,
- 45:22rendering it unenforceable in its entirety. So
- 45:26the important lesson from Taylor is that it matters
- 45:28how you plead your claim, and you don't want
- 45:31to include any language in a complaint that could
- 45:35be perceived as sexual services being part of
- 45:38the consideration for the Marvin agreement. So
- 45:41when drafting a complaint, you might even want
- 45:44to include a specific line that sexual services
- 45:47were not part of any agreement. And how do later
- 45:51cases define the analysis from Taylor? Yeah,
- 45:55so the Taylor case made it clear that sexual
- 45:57services, agreements where sexual services were
- 46:01inseparable from the consideration would be invalid.
- 46:05But in a typical Marvin situation, The parties
- 46:08most likely have a sexual relationship, so that
- 46:11raises questions of how does the existence of
- 46:14that sexual relationship impact the enforceability
- 46:17of a Marvin agreement? And the Alderson case
- 46:21addressed that issue and said that the existence
- 46:23of a sexual relationship, even where both parties
- 46:26considered their sexual relations to be part
- 46:29of the role each assumed in the relationship,
- 46:32is not a sufficient sufficient basis to find
- 46:35the contract was rooted in providing meretricious
- 46:38sexual services. And the De La Zopa case also
- 46:42examined this issue and found that a Marvin agreement
- 46:45will not be invalidated as a meretricious sexual
- 46:49relationship if the parties agree to have children
- 46:51together as part of the agreement. So the cases
- 46:55after Taylor made it pretty clear that in a Marvin
- 46:58agreement, in Marvin agreements, the existence
- 47:01of a sexual relationship alone is not going to
- 47:04invalidate the agreement. Now, lots of us watching
- 47:08primarily focus on family law without maybe having
- 47:13the benefit of working on a Palimony case. Can
- 47:17you talk with us about how a Marvin claim will
- 47:19coexist procedurally with the dissolution action?
- 47:23Yeah, so it's. It's not uncommon for Marvin actions
- 47:26to have crossover claims. And it's important
- 47:29to understand that a Marvin claim survives marriage.
- 47:33It's not extinguished simply because the parties
- 47:35marry. The Marvin agreement just applies to the
- 47:38period of time that predates the marriage. And
- 47:42we've talked a little bit about the date of breach,
- 47:45which is often at the termination of the relationship
- 47:49when one party ceases providing support. But
- 47:52When there's a dissolution case pending, the
- 47:55date of breach is often not the date of separation
- 47:58because one party is usually continuing to pay
- 48:01support during the pendency of the case. And
- 48:05in these situations, you might need to look at
- 48:07the declaration of disclosure or the schedule
- 48:09of assets and debts to see if one party is claiming
- 48:13that property acquired during the relationship
- 48:15prior to marriage is their separate property.
- 48:18And if they are, that's typically a good indication
- 48:21that that party's reaching the Marvin Agreement.
- 48:24Another important point to keep in mind for dissolution
- 48:27actions is that you will likely be required to
- 48:31file a notice of related case if the actions
- 48:34involve the same parties and the same property.
- 48:38And the court also has discretion to consolidate
- 48:41the cases so that they can be heard together.
- 48:44And most times when a notice of related case
- 48:49is filed, the Marvin action will be transferred
- 48:52to the family law department. How does the breach
- 48:56analysis differ in a parentage case? So, unlike
- 49:00dissolution matters where the timelines can be
- 49:03a little more complicated, in parentage cases,
- 49:06the date of breaches is usually the end of the
- 49:08relationship. with some exceptions. So if you're
- 49:12representing a client in a parentage action and
- 49:15you realize that they may have a Marvin claim,
- 49:18they need to move quickly to preserve it while
- 49:22the parentage case is still pending. And on the
- 49:25flip side of that, if you have a client in parentage
- 49:27action and you recognize they have exposure to
- 49:30a Marvin claim being filed against them, if you're
- 49:33engaging in any type of settlement discussions
- 49:35in the parentage action, it's going to be critical
- 49:39to make sure that you include a Civil Code 1542
- 49:42waiver in any settlement agreement. So the takeaway
- 49:47here is that whenever you're handling a parentage
- 49:49matter, it's wise to do some early due diligence
- 49:53to determine if any significant property was
- 49:56acquired during the party's relationship so that
- 49:59you can assess the likelihood of a Marvin claim.
- 50:02Now, unlawful detainer actions probably arise,
- 50:05but why are those a poor fit for a Marvin dispute?
- 50:09So these are quite common. with Marvin claims.
- 50:16So when you have a party who's a title holder
- 50:18to real property, an unlawful detainer action
- 50:22can be used as a means to evict the non -title
- 50:24holder from the property. And these actions move
- 50:27very quickly. So if you have a non -title holder
- 50:30as a client, it's going to be crucial to act
- 50:33fast because there are things a Marvin plaintiff
- 50:35can do to delay the unlawful detainer action
- 50:38by either staying it or consolidating it with
- 50:41the Marvin action if real property is at issue.
- 50:46And it's generally recognized that the summary
- 50:49unlawful detainer action is not a suitable vehicle
- 50:52to try complicated ownership issues. And this
- 50:55is usually because it's a practical matter, the
- 50:58likelihood of someone being able to litigate
- 51:02issues of ownership to property within the constraints
- 51:05of an unlawful detainer case, it's not going
- 51:08to be great. And how should counsel approach
- 51:12those? How should counsel approach those types
- 51:15of consolidation or stays in unlawful detainer
- 51:18cases? So again, it needs to be done quickly.
- 51:23And there are procedural steps that need to be
- 51:26taken in order for a court to stay or consolidate
- 51:29these matters. And before that request can even
- 51:32be made, the cases usually need to be related.
- 51:35Otherwise, you can risk the court denying a stay
- 51:39or consolidation based on procedural grounds.
- 51:43And if you look at the Martin Bragg versus Moore
- 51:46case, that is clearly on point, which involved
- 51:51two long -term domestic partners who were involved
- 51:54in a dispute regarding real property. And in
- 51:57that situation, the court did determined that
- 52:02consolidation was appropriate. How often do you
- 52:08see the unlawful detainer issue come up in practice?
- 52:12Often. So anytime there's a real property dispute
- 52:17and the non -title holder is still in the property,
- 52:20I would say about 75 % of the time an unlawful
- 52:24detainer action is filed and this can really
- 52:26put a Marvin plaintiff in a tough position because
- 52:30most of the time they are the de facto outspouse
- 52:33and don't even have the ability to move out.
- 52:36I think it's also important to just add that
- 52:39requests for domestic violence restraining orders
- 52:42can also be quite common in these situations,
- 52:45especially when one party doesn't have the ability
- 52:48to move out of the shared residence. And while
- 52:51we all know no one would ever file a request
- 52:53for a domestic violence restraining order to
- 52:56gain an advantage in a civil litigation, I have
- 52:59seen situations where where a party is unsuccessful
- 53:05in evicting a Marvin plaintiff and almost immediately
- 53:08thereafter files a request for a DVRO, and they're
- 53:12able to get a move -out order through that mechanism.
- 53:18Now, let's talk about probate. What's the most
- 53:21important procedural step in preserving a Marvin
- 53:25claim in a probate action? Yeah, so Marvin agreements
- 53:29are enforceable against an estate when one party
- 53:32to the agreement dies, but unlike the standard
- 53:36statute of limitations that would apply to written
- 53:40oral or implied agreements, a Marvin plaintiff
- 53:43is subject to the strict one -year deadline to
- 53:46file a lawsuit for a Marvin claim against the
- 53:48estate in order In order to preserve that claim,
- 53:52a Marvin plaintiff needs to go through the proper
- 53:55procedural steps of filing a creditor's claim
- 53:58and having it rejected prior to filing the lawsuit.
- 54:01And sometimes there's no probate case open, so
- 54:04a Marvin plaintiff might need to open that probate
- 54:07case in order to file a creditor's claim. A lot
- 54:12of us see putative spouse litigation in our practice.
- 54:15Can you tell us what's why is the intent to marry
- 54:18a critical distinction between Marvin and putative
- 54:21spouse claims? Yeah, so a Marvin claim differs
- 54:25from a putative spouse claim because a putative
- 54:28spouse has to have a good faith. belief that
- 54:31a valid legal marriage existed, meaning they
- 54:34had to have taken some affirmative steps to legalize
- 54:36the marriage. But in a Marvin claim, there's
- 54:39no requirement to create a legal marriage, and
- 54:42the claim is based solely off of agreement, whether
- 54:45that was a written, oral, or implied agreement.
- 54:50And obviously, there's atros in divorce cases.
- 54:53It's not necessarily the case in Marvin's cases.
- 54:56But can you talk to us about how a list pendants
- 54:58may function as a partial safeguard when atro
- 55:03protections are not available to Marvin litigants?
- 55:06Yeah, so. Anytime there's a real property claim,
- 55:10a Marvin plaintiff can file a lease, a lease
- 55:13pendants, which functions to alert potential
- 55:16buyers that the property is subject to ongoing
- 55:18litigation, which will essentially dissuade buyers
- 55:21from wanting to buy the property given the risk.
- 55:25And unfortunately, this is really one of the
- 55:29only safeguards available to a Marvin plaintiff
- 55:32during the pendency of the case. And does the
- 55:36court have the authority to award temporary spousal
- 55:39support in a Marvin claim on its own? So the
- 55:43court lacks inherent equity power to award temporary
- 55:47spousal support. And what it comes down to is
- 55:51there's just no statutory authority providing
- 55:54Marvin litigants with the right to temporary
- 55:56support. And while there's injunctive relief,
- 56:00which is available to all civil litigants, a
- 56:03Marvin plaintiff would have to demonstrate all
- 56:05of the elements required for a preliminary injunction.
- 56:09And the need and ability to pay standard available
- 56:12to spouses in a family law situation is simply
- 56:16not going to satisfy the requirements for injunctive
- 56:20relief to provide temporary support to a party
- 56:23in a Marvin claim. And how can practitioners
- 56:28navigate the limited rate of recovery for attorney's
- 56:32fees in a Marvin case? Yeah, so unlike dissolution
- 56:35actions, there's no statutory right to recovery
- 56:38of attorney's fees for a Marvin litigate. litigation.
- 56:41And because of this, it can be really cost prohibitive
- 56:44for a Marvin plaintiff to pursue a claim when
- 56:47they are typically the party with no money and
- 56:50no property. One way around this would be to
- 56:54modify the fee structure. Because Marvin claims
- 56:57are civil actions, an attorney can represent
- 56:59a client on a contingency fee basis, but unfortunately,
- 57:03not many attorneys do. And even if attorney An
- 57:07attorney is willing to handle a Marvin action
- 57:09on a contingency. There are still other significant
- 57:13costs, like expert fees. Many times, Marvin litigants
- 57:17still have the need for a forensic accountant
- 57:20to determine standard of living, or appraisers,
- 57:23or economists to testify regarding quantum merit
- 57:25claims. And can there be situations when financial
- 57:29discovery is restricted, and what can attorneys
- 57:32do about that in a Marvin case? Yeah, so Marvin
- 57:36litigants are not spouses. So the ability of
- 57:39a Marvin plaintiff to obtain financial documents
- 57:42can be limited because the Marvin defendant can
- 57:45invoke their constitutional right to financial
- 57:47privacy. And the tax return privilege does apply
- 57:50to Marvin cases. So a few things that can be
- 57:55done here is maybe the parties can agree to a
- 57:59stipulated protective order. That's one way that
- 58:03you can get a Marvin defendant to produce some
- 58:06financial documents. Also, if the Marvin plaintiff
- 58:09can demonstrate that there was some type of waiver
- 58:12of expectation of privacy during the relationship,
- 58:16maybe they were conducting their financial affairs
- 58:18together, allowing access to all of their accounts.
- 58:22That might give rise to a waiver. And lastly,
- 58:26if there is an ongoing dissolution action or
- 58:28parentage action, you'll be able to obtain some
- 58:32financial documents in those cases. Now this
- 58:36is exciting. When might a jury trial be advantageous
- 58:39in a Marvin case? So in Marvin actions, it's
- 58:44no secret that jury trials can be risky because
- 58:47most people on that jury have likely been through
- 58:50a divorce or a bad breakup. and will be judging
- 58:52the case through their own experience. So whether
- 58:55Marvin litigants ought to have a jury trial is
- 58:59going to be very case -specific. And for a plaintiff,
- 59:03they might want a jury trial if maybe their story
- 59:06is particularly compelling or if damages are
- 59:10likely to be substantial. And how do you navigate
- 59:13confidentiality in a Marvin case? So because
- 59:18parties to Marvin agreements are not married,
- 59:20the marital communication and testimonial privileges
- 59:23do not apply, which is one reason why when you
- 59:27see settlement agreements in Palimony Matters,
- 59:31you often see confidentiality clauses to address
- 59:35the lack of the marital privileges. And what
- 59:39is a way that a cohabitation agreement can either
- 59:43provide clarity or ease the way when a Marvin
- 59:46claim arises? Yeah, so one way a party can avoid
- 59:50a Marvin claim is by having a cohabitation agreement.
- 59:54And when that's drafted properly, the cohabitation
- 59:57agreement functions the same way as a premarital
- 1:00:00agreement does in memorializing the party's understanding
- 1:00:04regarding property and support and how those
- 1:00:07items are treated in the event the term the relationship
- 1:00:09terminates. So the parties can avoid a Marvin
- 1:00:12claim altogether. And Sarah, what are the high
- 1:00:16level takeaways that people should take from
- 1:00:18our discussion today about Marvin actions? Well,
- 1:00:22if there's one takeaway from today's discussion,
- 1:00:25it's that Marvin claims are incredibly fact specific
- 1:00:29and timing matters. So if you think your client
- 1:00:33might have a potential Marvin claim, it's critical
- 1:00:36that they get legal advice early because the
- 1:00:39clock on the statute of limitations may already
- 1:00:41be running even if they don't realize it yet.
- 1:00:46And we have time for maybe one question. One
- 1:00:49person asks, what would you agree that the best
- 1:00:54outcome for a Marvin case is to ask for a jury
- 1:00:57trial? I guess the idea is, should you always
- 1:00:59ask for a jury trial at the onset of a Marvin
- 1:01:02case? Well, it's always a good idea to ask for
- 1:01:05a jury trial at the onset so you have. the option.
- 1:01:10If you don't do that and you don't post your
- 1:01:12jury fees, there's always the possibility the
- 1:01:14court could deny a litigant a jury trial. So
- 1:01:17you always want to make sure you are preserving
- 1:01:19that right. The parties can always agree later
- 1:01:23whether or not they'd like to have a bench trial.
- 1:01:27And a follow -up question to that is, if it's
- 1:01:28part dissolution, part Marvin, is the disso tried
- 1:01:32to the bench and the Marvin case is tried to
- 1:01:34the jury? So the simple answer there is it can
- 1:01:38get complicated. And it all depends on how the
- 1:01:43court is willing to accommodate the parties.
- 1:01:46If both cases are within the family law department
- 1:01:49and the family law department can accommodate
- 1:01:51a jury trial, that's always one way that the
- 1:01:55cases can proceed. But if that family law department
- 1:01:59is not able to accommodate it, sometimes the
- 1:02:01Marvin action will be transferred back to civil
- 1:02:04court for adjudication by a jury. Thank you so
- 1:02:09much, Sarah, for this enriching discussion. I
- 1:02:12know it's going to enhance every practitioner's
- 1:02:15toolbox and toolkit in approaching these cases.
- 1:02:20And we at the Beverly Hills Bar Association really
- 1:02:22appreciate all the time and effort that you put
- 1:02:24into this. Thank you so much. Thank you.