Latest / No Way Out / The Grey Zone: Influence Without Attribution and the Real OODA Loop | Oriane Cohen
Transcript
- 0:00Oriane Cohen: Conspiracy theories give you know it's a story, it's a it's a narrative, it's storytelling, it gives a villain, it gives a final answer, a closure to the brain.
- 0:12Oriane Cohen: Like, okay, we are being controlled by they.
- 0:15Oriane Cohen: I I like this, you know, when they say they.
- 0:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yep.
- 0:18Oriane Cohen: Who is they?
- 0:18Oriane Cohen: Uh and what about if there is no day?
- 0:21Oriane Cohen: And that's something that we cannot deal with.
- 0:24Oriane Cohen: It's extremely difficult, you know, to handle this contradiction of like there is no day.
- 0:29Oriane Cohen: There are tons of actors with different incentives.
- 0:32Oriane Cohen: Sometimes they are coordinated, sometimes not, sometimes they are even enemies.
- 0:37Oriane Cohen: Like ideologically, you know, they hate themselves like each other, but still are converging on uh their effect.
- 0:46John R. Boyd: What am I getting at?
- 0:47John R. Boyd: The underlying message is very simple, then there is no layout.
- 0:57John R. Boyd: Well, problem though, we don't know how to do this.
- 1:04John R. Boyd: There is no way out.
- 1:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think we want to start there, and it goes like this.
- 1:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, Orion, can you walk us through this uh post that you put up on LinkedIn?
- 1:19Oriane Cohen: Yeah, I think it's first of all, thanks for having me.
- 1:22Oriane Cohen: Uh glad to be here.
- 1:24Oriane Cohen: And yeah, so uh I talked about this this story because it's quite an old story, and you know, Elon Musk is a very polarizing, I would say, uh character nowadays.
- 1:34Oriane Cohen: And I think it's a very interesting example that both connect, you know, my my my field, which is basically uh espionage and intelligence, and all of the topics that I'm studying are in depth.
- 1:46Oriane Cohen: It's the story that basically how Elon Musk you know made a leaker reveal himself in his own company.
- 1:55Oriane Cohen: Uh quite simple, he used uh quite a basic technique that is called the canary trap, and there are different ways to call this technique.
- 2:02Oriane Cohen: But I wanted to emphasize this story because uh at the end of the day, what he did is instead of trying to track you know where who is the leaker and ask questions and investigate, as you know, people usually do, what he did was most much simpler.
- 2:20Oriane Cohen: Uh he created a fingerprint, and basically what he did, he knew it there was a leak, and he sent the same piece of information to different people with a slightly little difference, and that would be what reveal uh you know the leaker at the end of the day, and it worked.
- 2:36Oriane Cohen: And again, my point here is not just about the technique itself that is quite interesting, but really about the logic behind it.
- 2:43Oriane Cohen: Because you know, Elon Musk thinks in first principles, and I think the logic behind is very interesting because his goal was to not go and look for the information, but alter the environment so the information re- will reveal itself.
- 2:59Oriane Cohen: And I think at the end of the day, that's very close to the topic that I'm studying, and I'm sure we are going to talk about this now more in depth.
- 3:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, I thank you for that story.
- 3:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I just saw that uh this morning, and I want to make sure we share that out.
- 3:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm gonna just uh start off here that uh Ariana is uh joining us from Portugal today.
- 3:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um I'm putting up an image of her at the moment.
- 3:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: She's been writing quite a bit.
- 3:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And one of the things that attracted me to what you've been writing is you've been talking about the environment.
- 3:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think this is absolutely critical because most people who explore what we should we talk about here on our show, which is John Boyd's Observer Weight Decide to Act Loop, they they always exclude the environment.
- 3:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They don't have that in in there.
- 3:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's uh we're trying to correct that.
- 3:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But more importantly, as we explore these, you know, have conversations with great coaches, great leaders, they all talk about the environment.
- 3:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we're looking back into cognitive warfare at the moment because I I see we need to revisit that as people like yourself are looking at the environment and talking about it.
- 4:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh Ariane, can you give us a little bit more background on on uh how you got involved with all this uh we'll call it cognitive warfare for now, but how did what's your background and how did you come uh into this space?
- 4:13Oriane Cohen: Yeah, so a little bit about me, as you can hear, first of all, from my my accent, I'm French and quite uh difficult to hide.
- 4:20Oriane Cohen: And I arrived to this field uh by operations, and that's your point.
- 4:26Oriane Cohen: And that's quite funny because I I like to say, you know, that back in operations, you don't call it this way.
- 4:34Oriane Cohen: While you operate and you influence people, you don't actually say, Oh yeah, what do you do?
- 4:39Oriane Cohen: I am in cognitive warfare.
- 4:40Oriane Cohen: There is no such thing as being in cognitive warfare, you're just an operator.
- 4:46Oriane Cohen: So my background to to make you understand as well, you know, why it's quite unique even in the world of intelligence.
- 4:52Oriane Cohen: I started, so I studied political sciences and international relations, transport in France.
- 4:57Oriane Cohen: From there, I became a journalist.
- 4:59Oriane Cohen: I covered Israel and mostly the West Bank, Palestinian territories, uh, and so on.
- 5:05Oriane Cohen: So I conf I covered a conflict area, uh so really about you know perception and mass influence.
- 5:13Oriane Cohen: Because at the end of the day, you know, I I was working on TV and reporting on what is going on in a place that you know people get killed just for being, you know, on both sides.
- 5:24Oriane Cohen: So, you know, you have a huge impact as a journalist.
- 5:27Oriane Cohen: Maybe we'll get back to this.
- 5:28Oriane Cohen: And then I left journalism exactly for these reasons.
- 5:32Oriane Cohen: Actually, I felt like, you know, we like to say, you know, in particular in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, there are two parties, there are much more than two parties, and I think that journalists, the observers of the conflict, take a direct role now, have a a role and a responsibility in the lives of this conflict, but they don't want to share the responsibility.
- 5:54Oriane Cohen: Uh, so that's one thing.
- 5:55Oriane Cohen: So I left uh this uh this job, and you know, I was quite young, I was still uh single lady, and uh, you know, I just received uh this proposition, you know, I speak a few languages, I was young again.
- 6:08Oriane Cohen: Uh and I remember, you know, the announcement was just saying we are looking for a woman speaking this and these languages, ready to travel, and it was, you know, like intelligence work, but no details about what it was gonna be.
- 6:23Oriane Cohen: Like, oh wow, how fun! Sounds like me, you know.
- 6:26Oriane Cohen: Uh so that's how I got there, and I entered the world of uh so private intelligence, humint operation, so human intelligence, which is basically the jargon to say spying.
- 6:39Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 6:40Oriane Cohen: Is basically really the art of gathering intelligence from human sources.
- 6:45Oriane Cohen: And I was, you know, again, I was young and I guess quite young, quite quite good at it, but it was mostly um intuitive.
- 6:54Oriane Cohen: You know, when they recruited me, I didn't understand, you know, why I was good.
- 6:58Oriane Cohen: It's now with a bit more maturity and having left this job that I understand, you know, what was the process of being recruited by myself, because that's also the paradox, you know.
- 7:09Speaker 5: Right.
- 7:10Oriane Cohen: You are being paid to recruit people, but you were recruited in the first place somehow, you know.
- 7:16Oriane Cohen: Uh so anyway, so then I left after a few years.
- 7:19Oriane Cohen: Uh, I left as well this job for a simple reason.
- 7:22Oriane Cohen: I met uh my husband, uh, and I understood that this was not the life I wanted to offer my kids uh for the future.
- 7:30Oriane Cohen: So I started my own advisory firm.
- 7:33Oriane Cohen: And somehow, you know, so yeah, of course, I came back to all of these topics.
- 7:37Oriane Cohen: So now I help leaders work really like businesses or individuals directly, advise them in strategic intelligence, perception, strategic communications, and so on.
- 7:48Oriane Cohen: But my approach is very field-oriented, practical.
- 7:52Oriane Cohen: Yes, and I do as well the research part, but this is more as a even a I would say a hobby.
- 7:58Oriane Cohen: That's really because it passionates me and I arrive at cognitive warfare by you know this experience of the field, and because I'm pissed off, you know, by and I think that's gonna be about, you know, this conversation is gonna going to be about like the way we talk about cognitive warfare, it is being debated and talked about by people that sit in offices, read a lot of books, but what do you know?
- 8:29Oriane Cohen: What did you do?
- 8:32unknown: Yeah.
- 8:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, you're spot on there.
- 8:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The academics that are out there writing about this, and they they do show up on the show, and we do enjoy the conversations with them.
- 8:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's the practitioners, though, that really help us understand how to how do you apply this and what you're doing your day-to-day.
- 8:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So going back to the Elon Musk story, that is a great way uh to understand what we're what we're looking at here.
- 8:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And to me, leadership, manipulation, cognitive warfare, the constraints-led approach and sports, uh, intent-based leadership, mission command, they're all pointing to the same thing.
- 9:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that is shaping the conditions on the outside of the agent, the performer, the target, uh, the person, the peer, the employee, whatever you want to call them, if you set those conditions, you set those constraints, you can get inside of their orientation, their OODA loop, and you can adjust their behavior.
- 9:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So to me, when this cognitive warfare thing starts popping up all over the place over the last few years, and I live here next to Norfolk, so which it's uh NATO Allied Command Transformation, where they do a lot of this thinking.
- 9:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, I'm like, this isn't anything new.
- 9:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And again, that's my perspective.
- 9:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I want to ask you this why is there so much interest in cognitive warfare right now?
- 9:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What's happening?
- 9:40Oriane Cohen: Yeah, so that's a good question.
- 9:42Oriane Cohen: And I asked myself the same question actually, not a long time ago, and I wrote about this.
- 9:47Oriane Cohen: I was like, why did we need suddenly the concept?
- 9:51Oriane Cohen: Because again, it's a matter of language here.
- 9:54Oriane Cohen: The the practice of what they call today cognitive warfare is not new.
- 9:59Oriane Cohen: And what I found out, I tried to make it short, but what I found out is basically that cognitive warfare is a concept that was assembled.
- 10:07Oriane Cohen: Okay, it has not been invented, it is nothing new.
- 10:10Oriane Cohen: It is assembled.
- 10:12Oriane Cohen: Okay, let's take it this way.
- 10:14Oriane Cohen: You have in cognitive warfare a mix of a lot of things.
- 10:18Oriane Cohen: There is a lot of psychology, cybernetics, neurosciences, and you know what, you name it, influence, cognition as well, and so many other things, propaganda, mass influence, and and so on.
- 10:30Oriane Cohen: The problem is I mean, it's not a problem.
- 10:33Oriane Cohen: Each field is fascinating and has its own lexicon, its own vocabulary, its own expertise, its own methods as well.
- 10:41Oriane Cohen: But cognitive warfare, or the way we define it today, is somewhere in between all of this.
- 10:48Oriane Cohen: Uh it's a bit of this, a bit of this, a bit of this.
- 10:51Oriane Cohen: And I think that first of all, we named uh we coined cognitive warfare with the word cognition because it sounds more scientific and more neutral, you know.
- 11:02Oriane Cohen: Calling it, you know, the propaganda warfare, the influence warfare is too oriented towards one of the fields that I just mentioned.
- 11:12Oriane Cohen: But saying cognitive, oh, it makes it scientific.
- 11:16Oriane Cohen: Okay, and when when it sounds scientific as well, so the the fact that it has been institutionalized, we needed to institutionalize the topic.
- 11:25Oriane Cohen: Because once you institutionalize a topic, so you can actually deploy, allocate resources, budgets, organize around it.
- 11:35Oriane Cohen: It's not just, oh, it's all about the money, it's really about organize, create departments.
- 11:40Oriane Cohen: When you create departments, so you create careers, you create experts.
- 11:44Oriane Cohen: And when you create experts, a whole field is going to develop, and now we see it, you know, like there is a legend of new experts on like pretendously cognitive warfare.
- 11:56Oriane Cohen: Uh and the thing is, once we created it, we cannot stop it because you know it's kind of self you know fulfillment.
- 12:04Oriane Cohen: Now that we deployed already so much energy and people and and money around the topic, we need to make it real.
- 12:11Oriane Cohen: We need this fucking cognitive warfare, you know.
- 12:14Oriane Cohen: We need it to exist.
- 12:15Oriane Cohen: And uh and there is other stuff, you know, there is uh you know AI today as well, and it's quite easy to do uh uh I mean to to to write about the topic uh and uh and and to research the topic uh just with AI.
- 12:29Oriane Cohen: So uh yeah, so that's one part.
- 12:32Oriane Cohen: The second part is the why is also there is a timing, okay.
- 12:36Oriane Cohen: And what I identified to try and make it short, I I did in a in an article, if you want, I will send it to you later on.
- 12:42Oriane Cohen: Sure.
- 12:43Oriane Cohen: A chronology really of when the word the con yeah appeared actually, the cognitive warfare was coined.
- 12:49Oriane Cohen: It started in 1996, but again, the concept itself, I I traced it back as precisely as possible from basically Soviet Union's reflexive control, yeah, um, and so on.
- 13:03Oriane Cohen: And then you know, it was just like reused by by NATO and institutionalized around 2020.
- 13:11Oriane Cohen: And here it's quite interesting because I think 2020 we will not forget this time you know of our lives.
- 13:18Oriane Cohen: Uh, it was you know globally a very revealing time.
- 13:23Oriane Cohen: The environment was changing.
- 13:25Oriane Cohen: We was just we were just in between like you know, COVID pandemic, a global pandemic, a different relationship to trust, to institutions, to mobility, uh, and therefore to influence.
- 13:36Oriane Cohen: Like suddenly, you know, power and influence uh mechanism, I guess, somehow were not exposed in the sense like revealed, just like they were out.
- 13:46Oriane Cohen: So, yeah, I think the environment again here uh played a huge role in needing this concept.
- 13:53Oriane Cohen: Okay.
- 13:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you you brought up uh reflexive control, and and before that you brought up uh uh different disciplines.
- 13:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you brought up neuroscience, cybernetics, uh psychology, uh you have cognitive science, you have all these different disciplines that uh I guess you're looking at as well.
- 14:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then uh you you brought up 1996, I believe is reflexive control.
- 14:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that when uh that first popped up?
- 14:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that correct?
- 14:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Did I get that right?
- 14:15Oriane Cohen: No, 1996 it was an American thesis, uh DAL thesis.
- 14:20Oriane Cohen: Uh no, reflexive control is the the the 60s, 67, if I'm correct.
- 14:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, so this is and that's from the the Soviet Union, is that correct?
- 14:30Oriane Cohen: Yeah.
- 14:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 14:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and can you go a little bit into reflexive control, what what that what that means?
- 14:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh just because I have an idea, but I want to make sure um my our listeners understand what that is, or what you think, what we can talk about.
- 14:43Oriane Cohen: Yeah, I I mean I I don't I don't want to pretend I I am an expert, but what is interesting, first of all, with reflexive control, is that it was introduced by a mathematician, which I I I I I think is fantastic.
- 14:56Oriane Cohen: And so it was you know very like modelizing uh you know realities, and basically what it's saying I I will try to make it short and please don't quote don't quote me if I if I make a mistake on this, but it's basically the idea that uh you the you can shape the environment and the condition that will make the other party uh make his decision.
- 15:21Oriane Cohen: But what I find interesting in this is that and and then Lefebvre only started to talk to about to talk about this, and maybe I didn't read enough because it's also all in Russian, so I I had a huge work of research and translation here.
- 15:37Oriane Cohen: But what his uh assumption is that is never stated as such, is to have reflexive control, you need to have kind of a strategist, you need to have a controller.
- 15:50Oriane Cohen: Okay, it means you need to have someone that is upstream trying to influence your decision.
- 15:57Oriane Cohen: Okay, but my whole point, and that's what I'm trying, I'm I'm writing about constantly, is that there is reflexive control, so there is uh woo, people, whatever, you know, that are willing, you know, actors, sometimes it's states, sometimes it's companies, sometimes it's individuals for different reasons, is incentives and so on that are directly trying to influence us and modify, alter, let's say the our environment and the way at least we perceive our own reality.
- 16:30Oriane Cohen: But what very few people talk about is what about when there is no actor?
- 16:36Oriane Cohen: What about you know there is no one is actually there is no intention?
- 16:42Oriane Cohen: That's the point.
- 16:43Oriane Cohen: That's that's the key word I would say.
- 16:45Speaker 4: Okay.
- 16:46Oriane Cohen: What when you remove the intention?
- 16:49Oriane Cohen: And I believe that we today live in an environment and we could develop that, you know, like with AI and algorithm, recommendation, personalization, and so on.
- 16:58Oriane Cohen: That you cannot now, you know, trace back the exact origin, like the exact intention.
- 17:04Oriane Cohen: There is not one person that is doing this to your mind.
- 17:08Oriane Cohen: It doesn't work this way, it is a convergence, and there is no coordination.
- 17:13Oriane Cohen: And I think that's also why we see today, you know, uh, it's not the rise, it's like the explosion of conspiracy theories and so on, because conspiracy theories give you know it's a story, it's a it's a narrative, it's storytelling, it gives a villain, it gives a final answer, a closure to the brain.
- 17:35Oriane Cohen: Like, okay, we are being controlled by they.
- 17:38Oriane Cohen: I I like this, you know, when they say they.
- 17:41Speaker 4: Yep.
- 17:41Oriane Cohen: Who is they?
- 17:42Oriane Cohen: Uh and what about if there is no day?
- 17:45Oriane Cohen: And that's something that we cannot deal with.
- 17:47Oriane Cohen: It's extremely difficult, you know, to handle this contradiction of like there is no day.
- 17:53Oriane Cohen: There are tons of actors with different incentives, sometimes they are coordinated, sometimes not, sometimes they are even enemies, like ideologically, you know, they hate themselves like each other, but still are converging on uh their effect on us.
- 18:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, absolutely.
- 18:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You got a couple things that uh are popping up in my mind.
- 18:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And they one of the ideas is in a in a complex system there is no centralized control, right?
- 18:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then that's hard for people to understand, and that's what you just talked about.
- 18:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and you we talk about the deep state over here, these these this group of people, and they may or may not exist, we don't know, but the it's not like there's a private meeting happening, as far as I know.
- 18:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Based on my experience in the military and my my my time in the uh in the government, is it's hard for people to keep secrets, right?
- 18:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They they always let there's always a leaker or something.
- 18:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So when people think that there's this villain or this central group controlling everything, and I think you just made that very clear, that that may not be true, right?
- 18:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That it's it's it's it's emerging within the system.
- 18:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And with the the idea of complex adaptive systems is you want to amplify the messages that you prefer and dampen the ones you don't.
- 19:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So as a as an individual agent in this system, uh, with access to things like YouTube and X and Instagram and TikTok, I can put a message out there that I want to amplify because my orientation, and I'll get back to that here in a second, is that uh that's that's the way I want you to view the world.
- 19:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's that connection to complex adaptive systems.
- 19:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I gotta ask you a question, we can come back to complex adaptive systems.
- 19:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Reflexive control, I have to ask you this.
- 19:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You brought up cybernetics earlier.
- 19:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is there any known connection to you between reflexive control and and cybernetics that you know of?
- 19:39Oriane Cohen: I don't know.
- 19:40Oriane Cohen: But again, here I don't want to uh I I cannot develop that much.
- 19:44Oriane Cohen: I just know, you know, it's a concept from mathematics that has been, you know, later on used in you know Russian doctrine, uh like intelligence doctrine.
- 19:55Oriane Cohen: And I I believe, you know, and again I come I I come to this world from the world of intelligence and from the world of you know spy craft or whatever.
- 20:04Oriane Cohen: And I I have and it's difficult you know for an American audience in most of the time or Western audience to hear, but I have a deep respect for the Russian doctrine and know how uh consistently close to the truth or to the reality of the ground, you know, they are uh somehow uh in their doctrine.
- 20:27Oriane Cohen: Because I think, you know, at the end of the day, reflexive control is much closer to what I experience in the field than all of the bullshit that I can read online that makes no sense and that is actually applicable.
- 20:40unknown: Yeah.
- 20:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I I'll I'll I'll agree with you on this, and that is well, let me rephrase that.
- 20:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: My understanding of uh cybernetics is it was suppressed here in the US and amplified in the former Soviet Union years ago.
- 20:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't know why that is, but we've had guests come on to talk about that, and I can I can uh I'll find I think Sean Mannion might be one of the people that we want to bring up in this, uh, and I'll look into that after we record or after in post-production.
- 21:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So um there might there might be a connection, I'll look into that.
- 21:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh the other thing is the um uh in in Spycraft, I want to kind of leverage that a little bit.
- 21:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You have independent agents working, right?
- 21:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, that's kind of how it works.
- 21:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um you're given an intent, and then you figure out how to execute on that.
- 21:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that correct?
- 21:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Am I getting that right?
- 21:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the same thing is true in like leadership, is we want to set intent, we want to create the conditions at the end of the day, and then wait, this may not resonate with all of our listeners, but leadership is manipulating the environment to get what you want out of your people, right?
- 21:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's still some type of reflexive control, is it not?
- 21:47Oriane Cohen: Yes, it is.
- 21:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 21:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So again, we're not talking about anything unique here.
- 21:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what I think we're you and I agree with that, that cognitive warfare.
- 21:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and again, this is my perspective looking at John Boyd's work uh over years, which he was looking at a Of these things, cybernetics included, and I'm I'm not sure about reflexive control.
- 22:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I can look into that.
- 22:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But he identified that you know there's three types of uh themes on war, and that's moral, mental, and physical, right?
- 22:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So cognitive warfare, what we're talking about here is not and I'm gonna ask you this, is is it a an attack on the physical space or is it on the moral and mental?
- 22:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And can you talk a little bit about that?
- 22:20Oriane Cohen: So look, I think I understand why the distinction exists, like you know, the mental and the moral and and the physical, but I also think again it's it's it's a mistake uh to treat them separately.
- 22:33Oriane Cohen: Because precisely, we know we we talked earlier, if we start, you know, again from the principle that all of this you know warfare is happening at the end of the day on the environment that is producing your cognition, so you know you cannot separate the physical.
- 22:51Oriane Cohen: If you know if you've been in the military, so if you live some through some war, and you know, just even like just a civilian going through a war, if you deprive a population from of electricity or you know, connectivity to the or of internet, so you remove physical access to something that they need, it will be a kind of intervention that will have a direct cognitive consequence.
- 23:16Oriane Cohen: I mean, it can even kill some people, you know, from the inside.
- 23:19Oriane Cohen: It makes people crazy.
- 23:20Oriane Cohen: Think about corona, you know, think about the pandemic.
- 23:23Oriane Cohen: Physically, they asked us to stay in our houses.
- 23:28Oriane Cohen: People started to get crazy.
- 23:30Oriane Cohen: It had like tremendous and long-term cognitive consequences.
- 23:34Oriane Cohen: So, so you see, that's exactly where for for me, like there is already like a problem, like to separate all of these things because physical, mental, moral are all yeah, related.
- 23:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 23:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, they're interdependent.
- 23:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I agree with you on that.
- 23:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: A great analogy there, you know, the standing six feet apart and wearing masks, putting physical things on our body, unbelievable time.
- 23:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think a lot of folks get upset when you look back at that time, because I th I, you know, I would you know, anytime we talk about COVID on here or or the pandemic, uh, YouTube likes to suppress that.
- 24:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that that to me is some type of cognitive warfare or you know, an attack on our our reality.
- 24:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Speaking of that, uh we we you you and I are kind of kicking around the idea of open and closed systems.
- 24:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, we've been talking about that quite a bit on uh on the show, open systems, uh meaning we're interacting with the environment.
- 24:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's that's you know, nothing is in isolation, that's natural.
- 24:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So all living systems are pretty much engaging with an environment.
- 24:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's an open system.
- 24:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The problem with that, in my mind, is in that open system, I can attack another system, another agent, if you will.
- 24:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you have any thoughts on uh open and closed systems in your work or how that how that uh relates to cognitive warfare?
- 24:44Oriane Cohen: I uh I did study and I still do study complex systems in general.
- 24:49Speaker 4: Yes.
- 24:50Oriane Cohen: And it's fundamental as well, I think, to understand uh my work.
- 24:54Oriane Cohen: But I try not to use the the the jargon, I would say, the scientific, because at the end of the day, it's also like very it's kind of analogies or metaphors, you know, from physics and you know, from from world of science that is not my field, so I don't feel necessarily legitimate sometimes, you know, to use the analogy for everything and the metaphor, but I still find it extremely useful to understand uh the world we live in, these ideas indeed of closed and open systems, but again, from my experience also, and because I have an experience very you know human-oriented with humans, uh when you put a human into the systems, they have you know, we we we we mastered the art of transforming, you know, I don't know, the the systems uh profoundly.
- 25:42Oriane Cohen: Right.
- 25:43Oriane Cohen: So I do connect with this, of course, intellectual intellectually speaking, I would say that it helps me a lot.
- 25:49Oriane Cohen: Operationally, using you know these concepts too much, I think it complicates things.
- 25:54Oriane Cohen: Yeah.
- 25:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, we uh you know we get into a lot of uh conversations with academics and they push back at some of the things that we say.
- 26:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: To me, I I like being an operator, I like being a generalist and trying to understand how these things all interrelate and how they connect.
- 26:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But but at the end of the day, when you're working with an executive, uh it sounds to me like you're not using the you said the jargon of uh of uh these uh concepts like complex adaptive systems and maybe in cybernetics and maybe even concepts out of neuroscience.
- 26:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So can you tell me uh how is how is it you take these lessons and help uh organizational leaders improve their decision making, understand perception?
- 26:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you can you talk a little bit about that?
- 26:33Oriane Cohen: First of all, I think you know uh my audience, so uh, you know, I have quite a big audience today today uh following uh my work and my briefs.
- 26:43Oriane Cohen: Uh I write every week about these topics, and to an audience of people that are not like you know intelligence operatives, but you know, operators of what I like to call the grays on operators, you know, people doing the real job, you know, in critical industries, leaders making decisions in a world that is clearly uncertain and unstable or volatile, whatever.
- 27:05Oriane Cohen: And of course, they are uh I think I'm very lucky, you know, to be followed by by an audience of uh very sharp, truly, that I respect in different fields, uh different countries as well.
- 27:18Oriane Cohen: I have a very uh international audience, and of course, you know, when you have this kind of responsibilities, both over, you know, their teams, their people, because they believe in what they do, you know, and they do something most of the time, you know, critical, related to health, finance, critical minerals or whatever.
- 27:37Oriane Cohen: Uh, and also, again, because they need to understand geopolitics.
- 27:40Oriane Cohen: And in my work, I I don't put boundaries.
- 27:43Oriane Cohen: I I myself don't like to call myself an expert in cognitive something, you know.
- 27:48Oriane Cohen: It puts me into a box.
- 27:50Oriane Cohen: I don't like boxes, you know.
- 27:52Oriane Cohen: I I prefer to have the flexibility to talk about all of these things because they are all interrelated.
- 27:58Oriane Cohen: So, back to your question.
- 28:01Oriane Cohen: So, I I think, of course, that it helps people making real decisions uh in the real world to understand um all of this topic, you know, that our fellows academicians are researching about.
- 28:14Oriane Cohen: And that's why also I'm trying not to make it simpler, because I believe my audience is smart enough to understand even some jargon sometimes, but I think that the overuse of you know concept, scientific concept doesn't serve my goal.
- 28:30Oriane Cohen: And if you read you know all of my work, so there is a paywall, I know, but you know, it's for my clients.
- 28:36Oriane Cohen: But if you pass the paywall, basically after you know a brief, so what you will see is that I always give something applicable, okay, uh, to the to my audience and to my to my readers.
- 28:51Oriane Cohen: You know, after I explain the concept, I I just explain how they can you know use it in their decision-making process in their life and so on.
- 29:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, I'm actually sharing your uh your website at the moment and showing folks uh some of your recent articles.
- 29:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So on that, you know, I've read a few of these over the last several weeks.
- 29:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you're talking about your audience.
- 29:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You you brought up the idea that this is you you don't want to box yourself into one domain like cognitive warfare.
- 29:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I have to agree with you on this.
- 29:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What what I've noticed is that academics are in these silos, and then people like you are are cutting across them and allowing leaders to see that mental health is no different than understanding strategy, right?
- 29:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I know that might be a far stretch for some folks, or understanding how we perceive reality has a direct connection to leading um and and leading change in an organization and dealing with the changing environment.
- 29:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh would you agree with that assessment?
- 29:45Oriane Cohen: Yes.
- 29:46Oriane Cohen: Uh yeah, yeah, I would agree.
- 29:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 29:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, this is great.
- 29:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh a couple of things that popped up over the last few weeks on your uh on your blog here.
- 29:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's see.
- 29:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh any any of these that you want to talk about that we can we can bring up?
- 29:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um I mean you have the blind spot of cognitive warfare.
- 30:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Any of them that uh you want to just uh you know address?
- 30:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And before we do that, I actually I think we need to address one big thing: gray zone.
- 30:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We talk about liminal warfare before on the podcast.
- 30:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We do talk about gray zone.
- 30:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh give our listeners uh uh what that actually means to you and how you help folks with that area.
- 30:21Oriane Cohen: Yeah, so that's a good question, actually.
- 30:23Oriane Cohen: I'm I'm glad you asked.
- 30:24Oriane Cohen: Because, you know, so my goal when I created uh the gray zone and all of this work, first of all, I think it was extremely selfish.
- 30:32Oriane Cohen: It was for me, you know, when I left operations, you know, and really gray, dark, yeah, darkish operations.
- 30:40Oriane Cohen: I I think I needed, you know, uh personally to understand who I was, what did I do truly, what did it mean.
- 30:48Oriane Cohen: Because again, I think at the end of the day, and as I I started with this in the beginning of this conversation, I was recruited, you know, I was young, it was a great incentive, you know.
- 30:59Oriane Cohen: It's wow, it's so sexy, you know.
- 31:01Oriane Cohen: Everyone would dream of having a job like I had, you know.
- 31:04Oriane Cohen: So, and you feel special, you feel different, you feel like they've seen in you something that is, you know, not better, but you know, yeah, different than others.
- 31:15Oriane Cohen: You are able to manipulate people, that's why they want you.
- 31:18Oriane Cohen: But to have this ability to manipulate people, you need to be as well extremely um manipulable and flexible, let's say.
- 31:26Oriane Cohen: So, anyways, you know, when I left this environment, I think I needed to understand what was it.
- 31:31Oriane Cohen: And it's important for me as well to specify because people get this confused, even if I'm not hiding it.
- 31:38Oriane Cohen: I was in private intelligence uh organization.
- 31:43Oriane Cohen: The problem is that, and that's exactly the topic of the gray zone, you know, in the private industry, there is, you know, operations that states for plausible deniability reason outsource.
- 31:58Oriane Cohen: And this is where people like me, and I like to call us, you know, the bastards of the systems, bastards, you know, for the actual reason.
- 32:06Oriane Cohen: You know, a bastard is someone that is not being recognized by his own parents, you know.
- 32:10Oriane Cohen: So, yeah, this is what you know, people of the gray zones and you know, mercenaries are in intelligence or you know, in war.
- 32:18Oriane Cohen: They are not being recognized by the by the people sending them, you know, like they need the plausible deniability, but they are basically doing uh the same job, if if not even worse, uh with less capabilities, you know, because state comes with huge capabilities and so on.
- 32:36Oriane Cohen: So the gray zone comes with more responsibility somehow, you know, it's everything in your shoulder, your skin in the game.
- 32:42Oriane Cohen: No one is coming to save you or to recognize you if you fail, you know.
- 32:46Oriane Cohen: You know what I mean?
- 32:48Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 32:49Oriane Cohen: And that's the same, you know, with mercenaries, you know, like uh you get killed in the fields, uh, you were sent, you know, it you was outsourced, you know, and today we see a lot, you know, of private military companies.
- 32:59Oriane Cohen: No one recognized, like, yeah, we sent them, you know.
- 33:02Oriane Cohen: That's it.
- 33:03Oriane Cohen: You are not a soldier, you're just dead.
- 33:05Oriane Cohen: You know?
- 33:05Oriane Cohen: Um and that was the world I needed to understand.
- 33:09Oriane Cohen: Uh, you know, there is the guys from CIA A6 and blah blah blah.
- 33:14Oriane Cohen: So they get the recognition, but they have no clue of what it is to actually live in the gray, in the place where no one will recognize you, and you cannot even yourself recognize what you've done.
- 33:26Oriane Cohen: You know, that's the whole point of using the gray zone.
- 33:30Oriane Cohen: So, anyways, all of this story to explain that yeah, I created the gray zone.
- 33:34Oriane Cohen: I think, first of all, it was a selfish need to understand what was this environment.
- 33:40Oriane Cohen: And when I started to, you know, to research it again, I fell on these articles, you know, a gray zone, whatever, you know, from academicians, hybrid warfare, and blah blah blah.
- 33:52Oriane Cohen: And I was like, yeah, it doesn't tell me anything, you know.
- 33:55Oriane Cohen: It's like it's not using the right words, it's not close to the reality, it's a lot of you know, words, but empty of actual meaning.
- 34:04Oriane Cohen: They don't know what they're talking about.
- 34:05Oriane Cohen: The people talking about gray zone don't know the gray zone.
- 34:09Oriane Cohen: So I decided, okay, I will talk about the gray zone from the actual fucking gray zone, you know?
- 34:15Oriane Cohen: Yeah, and and that's what I did.
- 34:17Oriane Cohen: So I I I I tried to redefine it and its founding principles and and uh uh and one of them is that of course, so yeah, the cognitive uh terrain is the terrain, the gray zone is fundamentally a cognitive uh operating in a cognitive terrain, and the the principle of influence without attribution that is fundamental as well to the gray zone.
- 34:44Oriane Cohen: And again, there are a lot of words to describe the same thing, you know, plausible deniability and so on.
- 34:50Oriane Cohen: But I think this concept makes it even larger.
- 34:54Oriane Cohen: Uh influence without attribution can also mean um let me give you an example.
- 35:01Oriane Cohen: So, yeah, it's the idea is as I told you, you you you make a war, but you don't want your name, you know, as a state on it, or you want to spy on a friend of yours, you know.
- 35:10Oriane Cohen: In Twin States, we don't do that.
- 35:12Oriane Cohen: You know, if you're a friend, we don't spy on friends.
- 35:14Oriane Cohen: But they do.
- 35:16Oriane Cohen: I mean, of course they do, right?
- 35:18Oriane Cohen: But they just cannot do it officially with their own spies.
- 35:21Oriane Cohen: So they would use, you know, people like me.
- 35:23Oriane Cohen: Okay?
- 35:24Oriane Cohen: Uh so this is influence without attribution.
- 35:26Oriane Cohen: And in another way, influence without attribution is also something sometimes much simpler.
- 35:32Oriane Cohen: Today I influence people in the sense that I write online on LinkedIn, I'm visible, I am being amplified by shares, by algorithms, and so on.
- 35:42Oriane Cohen: And I talk about topics, I define the gray zone, I repeat every day the same concept so people get it about the gray zone.
- 35:51Oriane Cohen: And at some point, people start using the gray zone, but they don't attribute it to me because, hey, well, you didn't invent nothing.
- 35:59Oriane Cohen: I mean, the gray zone is is a well-known word, but they start using it, for instance, with my my meaning and with my definitions and so on.
- 36:09Oriane Cohen: And and I think that's fantastic.
- 36:11Oriane Cohen: In the beginning, it's of course a little bit frustrating, you know, because we live in a world of ego and we want the credit and so on.
- 36:18Oriane Cohen: But I think at the end of the day, influence without attribution, particularly in the world of grey influence operations, you don't you don't want your name attached to your ideas and concepts.
- 36:31Oriane Cohen: What is more important is the impact of your ideas or what you want, you know, like convey anyway, the message, without the messenger.
- 36:40Oriane Cohen: Yeah.
- 36:40Oriane Cohen: So that is influence without attribution, yeah.
- 36:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I I'm a parent of two teenage girls, and I will say this uh seeing how they interact and their friends interact, uh what you're talking about is no different than, and this is my opinion, than what they go through at school and and they're clear, you know, just growing up and and things like that.
- 36:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So all of this to me is in my view, is not new.
- 37:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is part of human nature, right?
- 37:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is what humans do.
- 37:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Any thoughts on on that point about the teenage kids acting in in this way that uh uh whether they're influencing each other through media and or their actions?
- 37:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is is isn't that some type of influence operation they're doing day to day?
- 37:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 37:21Oriane Cohen: Yeah, look, it's interesting that you're mentioning this because when I defined the gray zone, so I had to define as well, you know, domains of applications, and there are different scales.
- 37:31Oriane Cohen: Uh the gray zone, because that's the thing, when we talk about the gray zone, we use it mostly to talk about you know international relations, geopolitics, warfare, you know, and all of this field.
- 37:40Oriane Cohen: But I do believe that it has actually four different scales of application.
- 37:46unknown: Okay.
- 37:46Oriane Cohen: And I like to say that the gray zone starts in childhood.
- 37:49Oriane Cohen: You know, the first gray zones that I faced is my own family.
- 37:54Oriane Cohen: You know, the family is a place where you discover the first interactions, the first secrets, the first manipulation.
- 38:01Oriane Cohen: And I'm not talking about this, you know, in a in a bad way, in a dark way.
- 38:05Oriane Cohen: I mean, some families are darks and some kids are going through some real shit.
- 38:10Oriane Cohen: Okay.
- 38:10Oriane Cohen: But in general, you know, like the first, you know, uh you understand quite intuitively as a kid that okay, when you do this, your parent is reacting like that, or when they come back from work, they start to drink something, and then they get a bit more aggressive or less passionate.
- 38:29Oriane Cohen: I don't know.
- 38:29Oriane Cohen: So the kid is already learning, you know, how to interact with the world.
- 38:33Oriane Cohen: And this is the first gray zone.
- 38:35Oriane Cohen: And what I noticed as well later on in operation is that the greatest gray zone operators are the ones that encountered their first gray zones early.
- 38:48Oriane Cohen: So yeah, I like to say it starts in the family.
- 38:51Oriane Cohen: So the the first gray zones are very intimate, interpersonal in family.
- 38:55Oriane Cohen: Then you have the same gray zones in you know, love relationships.
- 38:59Oriane Cohen: Then you have organizational gray zones in a company.
- 39:03Oriane Cohen: The power dynamics are you know, understanding that okay, in this company, when you raise up a problem, even if it's important, you are here because you love the company, you want to help the company.
- 39:15Oriane Cohen: When you raise a problem, the CEO gets mad and is punishing somehow the messenger.
- 39:22Oriane Cohen: So basically, you understand that if you want to grow up in this company, you don't bring up the problems, you just hide them.
- 39:28Oriane Cohen: Again, I'm not here to say it's right, it's wrong.
- 39:30Oriane Cohen: It's a gray zone.
- 39:31Oriane Cohen: You know, it's just about understanding this mechanics.
- 39:33Oriane Cohen: And some people are frustrated and they're like, Yeah, but I'm the best employee and I'm so competent like compared to my colleagues, and and yet, you know, they are the ones being promoted.
- 39:43Oriane Cohen: Yeah, but because they understand the power dynamics and the incentives and and so on.
- 39:48Oriane Cohen: So, yeah, I think there is different, you know, scales of gray zones, and it starts uh these these are great examples.
- 39:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so in organizations, we know that the uh constraints of the system, the environment, the promotion models, the incentive models, uh, the goals, they all influence the behavior in the organization, right?
- 40:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's what you just described.
- 40:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So there's a you know big movement right now, and and and this has been known for a while, but psychological safety is creating the conditions so everybody can bring their full self to work, so they can actually speak up and share these weak signals uh that uh they may they may not share.
- 40:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, in my view, psychological safety is a type of gray zone or cognitive warfare.
- 40:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's I'm going to set the conditions as a leader, I'm gonna um uh show humility, I'm gonna show some vulnerability, I'm gonna do things, take actions that give you, as employees or members of my team, the the conditions to speak up, right?
- 40:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So to me, that's no different than what you you've been talking about, other than intent and then I guess plausible deniability, right?
- 40:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that okay to say that?
- 40:54Oriane Cohen: Yeah, I mean, of course it's okay to say that.
- 40:56Oriane Cohen: And I think it would depend also, you know, on the context and which company.
- 41:00Oriane Cohen: That's also the thing, you know, there is not one rule that works well.
- 41:04Oriane Cohen: In some contexts, I think, you know, for instance, implementing this kind of mechanism could help a lot.
- 41:10Oriane Cohen: It depends on the ability as well of the CEO or the receiver to actually receive, you know, uh the critics or the problems and so on.
- 41:19Oriane Cohen: But it can also create uh a vibe of a paranoid environment.
- 41:25Oriane Cohen: You know, if you know that anyone can suddenly anonymously denounce, blame you for something that happened, so you know everything is open.
- 41:35Oriane Cohen: So at the end of the day, you don't do anything anymore, you can even think uh upfront, you know, about inventing something because anyway it's anonymous.
- 41:46Oriane Cohen: If you just want to hurt someone that you hate, uh you know, your boss within your company, and and this gives a lot of space to a lot of uh abuse, you know.
- 41:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 41:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So let me ask you this.
- 41:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If we can go back to your time uh in the field, I'll call it that for now, and you're working with sources.
- 42:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And again, if we could talk about this, were you designing the constraints for them to do things for you, or are you telling them how to do things?
- 42:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you give me some background on what what you would do back then that translate to what business leaders do today or need to do today?
- 42:18Oriane Cohen: Mm-hmm.
- 42:19Oriane Cohen: It was there is not there was not one rule, you know.
- 42:23Oriane Cohen: That that's the thing, and that's something you know that is difficult for people to hear.
- 42:27Oriane Cohen: You know, they would like me to give, you know, like the CIA spies on YouTube today, you know, the the checklist of you do one, two, three, four, that's it, you're a spy.
- 42:37Oriane Cohen: It doesn't work this way.
- 42:39Oriane Cohen: You know, that that's the problem.
- 42:40Oriane Cohen: Um, I didn't have real techniques.
- 42:43Oriane Cohen: First of all, I think I'm a woman that has to count for something.
- 42:47Oriane Cohen: So, you know, I was mostly uh handling male sources, uh the ability to listen a lot, much more that than you talk, and it was really about building trust, uh, long-term, you know, rapport.
- 43:00Oriane Cohen: I operated five years, you know, and I was also in a what we call you know a deep cover.
- 43:05Oriane Cohen: So it means it was not, you know, like a punctual mission or where you change cover every two days, you know, or every mission.
- 43:13Oriane Cohen: It was long term.
- 43:14Oriane Cohen: And you know, four years undercover is particularly long.
- 43:17Oriane Cohen: The first year was mostly about building it, you know.
- 43:21Oriane Cohen: Four years undercover, it's very long.
- 43:23Oriane Cohen: It's even not really recommended in the field because you may you you may lose uh a bit some parts of your identity in the process.
- 43:31Oriane Cohen: But, anyways, my point is so it my goal was to build long-term relationships, and even more than that, actually, my goal was to attract my sources to me.
- 43:41Oriane Cohen: Okay, so before I even manipulated any sources, I create it, I created, and I I will send you maybe also a piece I wrote about this.
- 43:52Oriane Cohen: I created an environment, so I I knew my target, okay?
- 43:55Oriane Cohen: When I started the job, I knew my goal is to get to X.
- 43:59Oriane Cohen: People, you know, a group of people, an environment.
- 44:02Oriane Cohen: And I was like, okay, but I'm not going to see them, you know, because then if my it doesn't work, so I we need to reinvent again and to create a new strategy and so on.
- 44:13Oriane Cohen: So I will circumvent all of this and make them need me.
- 44:18Oriane Cohen: So I needed to study the environment.
- 44:21Oriane Cohen: What do they need?
- 44:22Oriane Cohen: How can I be useful to them so that at some point they will call me?
- 44:26Oriane Cohen: So then you know, you proceed basically, it's reverse engineering.
- 44:30Oriane Cohen: You proceed by okay, who is in their third circle, second circle that can at some point recommend me, or first circle that can directly recommend me.
- 44:42Oriane Cohen: Okay.
- 44:42Oriane Cohen: So during the first two years, actually, I was, you know, and for some people it would be considered like a boring job, but I was working on relationships, on making the cover extremely real, not just credible.
- 44:57Oriane Cohen: It was extremely real.
- 44:59Oriane Cohen: Everything we were doing, the company's job was happening, you know, was real work.
- 45:05Oriane Cohen: And you know, it's not it's not Hollywood, but this is this is a real story of yeah, of deep cover spies, anyway.
- 45:11Oriane Cohen: So so so that at some point, you know, they would ask for me.
- 45:18Oriane Cohen: And when this day arrived, wow, this was already, you know, half of the job being done, you know, they arrive to you, they don't know you, they don't know that you've been trying to get to them for the last three years, that you know everything about them, or everything that there is to know.
- 45:36Oriane Cohen: And from there already, you know, you start from a basis of an asymmetry of information, okay, which is key in you know, in handling sources and and this kind of relationships.
- 45:47Oriane Cohen: You know, it's like the information that I have, that I retain, that I can use, that I can leverage when, why, and so on.
- 45:55Oriane Cohen: That's the first.
- 45:57Oriane Cohen: And the second thing that I would like to say is that then, you know, it's about maintaining the trust.
- 46:04Oriane Cohen: It's it's very easy to break the trust.
- 46:07Oriane Cohen: And and the long-term work, you know, it's not even to really create the condition.
- 46:11Oriane Cohen: I mean, yeah, of course, I created the conditions of trust, and also I I have to say that to some extent it was extremely sincere.
- 46:19Oriane Cohen: Until today, I still think about some of you know these guys that I I really like.
- 46:25Oriane Cohen: We were real friends, and somehow, you know, they knew me, they knew a part of me, just under a different name and identity.
- 46:32Oriane Cohen: But I mean, I wasn't faking it.
- 46:34Oriane Cohen: I I was not an actor, you know.
- 46:36Oriane Cohen: To to trust me, they needed, you know, to feel like the genuine care and curiosity, and it was real.
- 46:43Oriane Cohen: I was paid for that as well.
- 46:45Oriane Cohen: And you know, that this here come all of the contradictions and the paradoxes that I find, you know, fascinating to study and even to analyze within me.
- 46:55Oriane Cohen: But I I really like them and they really liked me.
- 46:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the couple things come to mind here.
- 47:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: One, it sounds like this is messy, meaning there is no script, there's no checklist, and you brought that up.
- 47:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's the same thing we want that that's leadership, is we they have to probe.
- 47:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh anytime we're in a complex environment, there is no one way to do things.
- 47:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We we have to make that up.
- 47:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I also wrote in here as you were ta speaking, I wrote, uh, and I tell my kids this and and all this time all the time, and it's when the student is ready, the teacher will appear, right?
- 47:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you're trying to, you know, even though they are we're trying to get them to do things, they won't do it until they're ready, right?
- 47:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They'll they'll find the teacher uh when they're ready.
- 47:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's kind of what's going on there.
- 47:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And another thing that popped in my mind, it sounds like dating.
- 47:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, everything you just described, I'm like, yeah, it sounds like we all what we all went through at some point in our life trying to get near somebody, uh influencing a friend to get closer to somebody.
- 47:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Come on, I'm I'm saying I I'm calling myself out here.
- 47:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I've done that in the past, right?
- 47:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You you do that, and uh um and maybe I might be alone on that, but uh that sounds like what everybody goes through when they're dating somebody.
- 48:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Like, how do how do I get access to that person?
- 48:03Oriane Cohen: Because this is real life at the end of the day, you know, like it's just like the intentions and the goal are uh are are broader, but the leverages are are the same.
- 48:12Oriane Cohen: And that's why I think you you have to be a very fine psychologist.
- 48:17Oriane Cohen: You really need to understand deeply human psychology and before anything to understand yourself without that and without this humility, and that's always you know what I start with with my client, the one that I help individually.
- 48:30Oriane Cohen: It's like don't ask me for hacks and tricks and techniques to understand, you know, what people are hiding around you when you are not even ready to face, you know, your darkest parts, or just not even darkest, you know.
- 48:48Oriane Cohen: Understand your own mechanism.
- 48:50Oriane Cohen: We talked earlier about you know physical conditions without talking about wars and depriving someone of electricity and so on.
- 48:57Oriane Cohen: I am a woman, I don't operate the same when I have my periods than when I don't have my periods.
- 49:04Oriane Cohen: That is something that I know about myself and I manage my whole life around this.
- 49:10Oriane Cohen: I know that I will not take make important decisions during a certain period of the month.
- 49:15Oriane Cohen: And I'm telling this, okay, it applies for women, but you know, for men, I guess it's something else.
- 49:20Oriane Cohen: When you know you're tired, maybe it's not the time to make uh tough decisions.
- 49:24Oriane Cohen: I'm talking really about simple examples, but some people, you know, believe they are machine, and the problem is also our society, you know.
- 49:33Oriane Cohen: We live in a society of productivity and so on, like we don't make the differences, but and that's what I love about being, by the way, an entrepreneur and being completely independent and free uh to schedule my my days.
- 49:47Oriane Cohen: I don't work a nine, five, like I have to be efficient from nine to twelve, then lunch, and then no, if I have now a four hours or six hours sometimes of deep focus with just you know my coffee and cigarettes, I will do it, you know.
- 50:05Oriane Cohen: You know, and as well, if I need a few days of creativity and just walking around because you know, this is the moment I can solve problems in my head, I I can as well do it.
- 50:17Oriane Cohen: And this is because I I learned to actually know myself deeply and my own mechanisms, my own cognitive mechanisms as well.
- 50:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh that's a fantastic connection.
- 50:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, I have uh two daughters in the house and and a wife in the house, and the connection to the uh the cycle is is important for sports, and we we talk about that because there are some things that uh women get injured during that period of the month, more likely in knee injuries and things like that.
- 50:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Nobody wants to talk about that, but that's that's a fact of nature.
- 50:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, that's one thing we monitor in the house is to monitor their health uh in sports and and and manage that a little bit more.
- 50:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I wanna I want to bring up something else.
- 50:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you brought up that in I can't remember which article it is, but you talk about uh actors do not begin from a shared reality.
- 50:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh is can you elaborate on that?
- 51:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: On reality and and how people uh view it?
- 51:05Oriane Cohen: Yeah, so I I I think I remember which piece it was and and the specific example.
- 51:12Oriane Cohen: And here again I will talk about Israel and Palestine and my experience as as a journalist.
- 51:17Oriane Cohen: It is yeah, the idea that you know there is there is a common reality, an objective, you know, reality.
- 51:24Oriane Cohen: This one is not like subject to discussion, it exists.
- 51:29Oriane Cohen: But my point is that for instance, if we take you know Israel and Palestine, when I was a journalist and it was extremely like for me in the beginning, and I was young, it was so weird, you know, like I was living a scene, I was observing the scene, and I would talk to both sides, you know, like the intelligence officers, the the military guy, and then you know, the Palestinian.
- 51:51Oriane Cohen: And we were all here at the same scene.
- 51:55Oriane Cohen: But it's like we experience and we've seen and we felt all different stuff, different stuff.
- 52:01Oriane Cohen: And and I think you know, when we talk about a polarized environment, it is super obvious, you know, that you know, this idea of like we can live you know the same in the same field, literally, you know, geographically being at the same place and yet not experience reality in the same way.
- 52:20Oriane Cohen: And it comes from you know the what I call the frames of references, includes you know, the languages, the experience, the family, the traumas, the religions, genetic I mean, so many stuff.
- 52:34Oriane Cohen: And what I noted today is that today, and I think also because you know of you know the new technologies and AI and social medias and so on, and the the current informational environment we live in, you can literally have, and I I hear so many sad stories, you know, of people you can live in the same building, you can live in the same house.
- 52:58Oriane Cohen: Today I hear horrible stories about parents with their kids, with their teenage kids or even you know older kids that don't talk anymore because they live literally in two different environmental uh informational uh environments.
- 53:16Oriane Cohen: They and they live again in the same house and under the same you know conditions and reality, you know, money and so on.
- 53:24Oriane Cohen: Yet, you know, when they open their phones, their algorithm is taking their in different bubbles, in different echo chambers, and you know, they disagree on topics, you know, fundamental topics as you know what is gender, what is society, uh, you know, politics, capitalism versus communism, all of these things extremely polarized.
- 53:45Oriane Cohen: And I think that unfortunately, AI and you know the personalization and recommendation of contents is making us more and more living literally close to one another, but really it is separating our realities more and more.
- 54:04Oriane Cohen: It becomes harder and harder to recognize connect, we don't share the same ground, you know.
- 54:10Oriane Cohen: And I think that also, you know, for a society and a civilization, now I'm even taking this further to survive, is it's okay to disagree.
- 54:18Oriane Cohen: It's very healthy to disagree.
- 54:20Oriane Cohen: I love contradiction, it's so important.
- 54:22Oriane Cohen: But contradiction and disagreement to exist need you know a same basis.
- 54:29Oriane Cohen: We need something to disagree about that is common, but that's even the thing, you know.
- 54:34Oriane Cohen: There is no common ground anymore.
- 54:36Oriane Cohen: You know, you know what I mean?
- 54:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 54:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you described the uh the frames and then the frames that uh I I didn't catch all of them, but you had trauma in there, you had experience, religion, language.
- 54:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So when we talk about orientation from the lens of the oodaloop or a world model that that may or may not determine how we sense reality, how we decide how we act, um sometimes that's built off of genetics, culture, and previous experience.
- 55:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And what I just heard from you is that experience that we are living through when you come home, and we could talk about my household, we try to avoid social media as much as possible, except that's my nature, my job is to be engaged as much as possible.
- 55:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The kids, uh I I do my best to keep them off of that.
- 55:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And uh you're right, we do see we do have differences on the in the household about things that are going on in uh in the news, uh, and we have discussions about them.
- 55:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and that's that's uh one thing I I hope more people would do is have a discussion about those disagreements and go, okay, what what is the foundation of this argument?
- 55:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it's hard to do even in your house.
- 55:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's much harder to do when you walk outside, right?
- 55:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and in fact, I would say we're losing our our ability to be interconnected.
- 55:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um we don't, you know, in my view, this is my view again.
- 55:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Going out to dinner, going out to the store, uh, interaction amongst people is down.
- 55:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We don't talk to each other as much, right?
- 55:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, it's weird.
- 55:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that the same that you've you've experienced, or or can you talk about your view on that?
- 56:04Oriane Cohen: Yeah, but definitely.
- 56:05Oriane Cohen: And again, I think that uh the the 2020 uh approximately has been uh a turning point.
- 56:12Oriane Cohen: Coupled this with you know you know the emergence of something, you know, like all these chat GPTs and AI that are amazing tools, again, don't get me wrong, but it has completely transformed the way we we communicate.
- 56:26Oriane Cohen: It has actually completely transformed even language.
- 56:29Oriane Cohen: And language I love, I study language a lot, not languages, how to speak languages, but really like the the fundamental uh feature, like why do we need languages as humans?
- 56:43Oriane Cohen: And we use language to to define what we observe, to put the world into categories.
- 56:52Oriane Cohen: And today we have a machine which is uh LLM, uh large language model that is using language, and now everyone is using different words to say the same shit.
- 57:04Oriane Cohen: Uh most of people, you know, don't understand what they talk about, and you can particularly see it on LinkedIn, you know, it's quite well known everyone is using AI, and it's kind of a big, you know, puree of jargon and the same words, and and you're really wondering do people understand what they talk about?
- 57:24Oriane Cohen: They use language so much but do they understand the meaning of it?
- 57:32Oriane Cohen: And I actually I have been you know preparing something and I make this metaphor of not this metaphor but this analogy to to Babel, you know, the the the Tower of Babel in Yeah, yeah.
- 57:44Oriane Cohen: Yeah that I find I find it uh interesting uh parallel uh to do that you know according to the tradition, believe it or not, it's not interesting, but I think it's an interesting story.
- 57:57Oriane Cohen: The the the humans were trying to to they were all speaking the same language, so and they were organizing and coordinating to get to God.
- 58:06Oriane Cohen: So God divided them by you know like having them speak different languages, and now it's like we are circumventing this actual condition.
- 58:19Oriane Cohen: We still don't speak the same language, but we created an intermediary that somehow allow us to connect between us without understanding each other truly, you know.
- 58:29Oriane Cohen: You still don't understand Chinese and you don't want to understand a Chinese guy and his own culture, but you can still somehow coordinate because you have the same interests again to you know to to this fundamental thing to kind of reach God, you know.
- 58:45Oriane Cohen: And we talk also about this a lot about AI and you know, in the Silicon Valley environments that that you know, some people and again in Silicon Valley environments, so don't like intelligent people, you know, some of the sharpest people in the world today uh strongly believe that AI has some kind of um divine whatever you know feature in in the world.
- 59:12Oriane Cohen: That that raises some very interesting philosophical questions, you know.
- 59:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Absolutely.
- 59:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm kind of curious, you brought up Silicon Valley here, uh the use of technology.
- 59:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are they have you seen how how does technology play into uh the the gray zone and cognitive warfare?
- 59:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you know, what is it accelerating it?
- 59:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It sounds like it is.
- 59:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Anything else you want to add to it?
- 59:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are there are these are there bad actors in Silicon Valley?
- 59:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What what what's what's actually going on?
- 59:39Oriane Cohen: I don't want to say there are bad actors, you know, there are good and bads everywhere, and it sounds a bit generic to say.
- 59:45Oriane Cohen: I mean, it is definitely, you know, like everything, it's a tool.
- 59:49Oriane Cohen: I like to say, take a knife, you can use a knife, you know, to spread some very tender and good butter into your baguette, or you can kill a man with it.
- 59:59Oriane Cohen: At the end of the day, this is the tool.
- 1:00:02Oriane Cohen: And this is the same with AI and all of these things.
- 1:00:04Oriane Cohen: I think it's a way for like it's it's a tool for so much progress and and knowledge and and sharing and connection, that again, this is the way we use it.
- 1:00:14Oriane Cohen: We humans that make it complex and and problematic.
- 1:00:18Oriane Cohen: So, in you know, in in influence operations and so on, of course, using AI is is useful uh because you can basically amplify your messages without attribution.
- 1:00:32Oriane Cohen: Uh, I received this morning, you know, in my in my email uh uh chat GPT um email saying like, hey, we are starting the chat GPT ads if you want to you know listen to our webinar.
- 1:00:45Oriane Cohen: That's it.
- 1:00:46Oriane Cohen: We are there, you know, this is the world we are going to live in now.
- 1:00:49Oriane Cohen: The place where you get your information is also the place that is trying to influence you.
- 1:00:55Oriane Cohen: So it is fascinating and it is interesting.
- 1:00:58Oriane Cohen: And I think at the end of the day, it's really about you know learning the fundamental of reasoning.
- 1:01:05Oriane Cohen: And that's the problem.
- 1:01:06Oriane Cohen: You know, we teach people now to gather more and more and more information, even though we are saturated by information, but people can't reason.
- 1:01:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um I tell you what, uh I I've kept you on for over an hour.
- 1:01:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I really appreciate your time.
- 1:01:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I do want to wrap it up here in a few moments.
- 1:01:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I do want to say this one of the things I've discovered with podcasting, and this was never the intent, is uh this has allowed me, in my opinion, to uh test ideas, challenge other folks, and uh learn, right?
- 1:01:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and what I've noticed about it is as more people gravitate towards using AI, um we're starting to find people that when we ask them to come on the podcast don't know what they're talking about.
- 1:01:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you're not one of them, by the way.
- 1:01:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's just uh we're we're starting to find out you know how prevalent AI is in um writing.
- 1:01:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and and we do use it here.
- 1:01:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Clearly, we use AI from time to time to help us accelerate the production of things.
- 1:02:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But any thoughts on the growth of a medium such as this to communicate ideas?
- 1:02:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is this is this a good thing or uh w you know you see previously?
- 1:02:13Oriane Cohen: It's scary.
- 1:02:14Oriane Cohen: I I I do see uh I do see uh observe the same problem as you.
- 1:02:18Oriane Cohen: Uh, I don't have a podcast, but me, I have this newsletter that I started a few years ago.
- 1:02:22Oriane Cohen: When I was doing this, there was not a lot of people doing it.
- 1:02:25Oriane Cohen: Now I can see like everyone is on Substack and so on.
- 1:02:29Oriane Cohen: And again, why I'm so pissed off and I started by this is really because you know I put so much time and energy and all of my hurt because you know this is these topics are just important, and I love you know the intellectual stimulus about thinking about these topics, debating them, you know, and so on.
- 1:02:49Oriane Cohen: And today, you know, I see that almost anyone can write about this very complex topic without understanding nothing about it, but you know, it sounds just so smart because AI, and they are using like some ridiculous words, and and that bothers me because really this is you know, like we call this in French, nivellement vers le bas, you know, it means taking down the the level of the game, you know, they are just taking down the level of the game, and these guys are impacting the whole field and the credibility of the field at the end of the day.
- 1:03:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, great point.
- 1:03:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Last thing for me, what if you could share your your main intent behind doing what you do now?
- 1:03:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What is it you're trying to do?
- 1:03:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, what is you are you trying to generate revenue?
- 1:03:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are you trying to inform people, goodwill?
- 1:03:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What what is it you you want out of sharing your background and insights with folks?
- 1:03:46Oriane Cohen: First of all, it depends on what what you're truly asking.
- 1:03:49Oriane Cohen: What I do, I do different stuff, you know.
- 1:03:51Oriane Cohen: So I do I do advisory uh because I love the the relationship that I have, you know, with direct client and the impact, and also it generates, of course, revenue and and that's important uh nowadays.
- 1:04:04Oriane Cohen: You know, I I think I'm very self-aware and aware of the world that we live in, and I know that money is giving me leverage and freedom as well.
- 1:04:13Oriane Cohen: Uh, that's the thing.
- 1:04:14Oriane Cohen: You know, when you leave, you know, all of these researchers, they need the funds, the institutional funds to write, but they need to write in a certain you know context.
- 1:04:24Oriane Cohen: Me, this freedom that I'm not offering myself.
- 1:04:28Oriane Cohen: I mean, I'm working really hard to get there.
- 1:04:31Oriane Cohen: It offers me, you know, having money and making a business, a consultancy business, giving me is giving me the freedom to talk in my terms, in my conditions, without any uh, you know, censorship and you know, in a different tone, not academically speaking.
- 1:04:48Oriane Cohen: So, yeah, of course, it's uh to my goal is to just spread the the word, you know, and help people think differently.
- 1:04:56Oriane Cohen: And my dream on the long term, I would I would be honest, is at some point, you know, disappear, retire, but still write and completely for free and just continue doing this because I love it.
- 1:05:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's is it sounds like a passion, not a job, right?
- 1:05:11Oriane Cohen: So yeah, yeah, definitely love it.
- 1:05:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I tell you what, uh, tell our listeners where they can find you, social media, uh, your website, I have it up right now.
- 1:05:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But where can our listeners find it you find your work?
- 1:05:23Oriane Cohen: So, yeah, directly on my website, and I think you know, just adding me on LinkedIn, I'm super active there.
- 1:05:28Oriane Cohen: It's a way for me, you know, to connect directly to you know to the world.
- 1:05:32Oriane Cohen: So interacting, you know, with uh my content and private messages.
- 1:05:36Oriane Cohen: But if not directly to my website, this is where they will find my uh my writings, my brief, everything I do.
- 1:05:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, fantastic.
- 1:05:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm gonna keep you on here for a moment, but we're gonna say goodbye to our uh our listeners at this point.
- 1:05:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh thank you so much for being being here.
- 1:05:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This has been an amazing conversation.
- 1:05:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Some things I wasn't expecting out of you.
- 1:05:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'll keep you on here for a moment.
- 1:05:57John R. Boyd: Okay, thank you.
- 1:05:58John R. Boyd: What am I getting at?
- 1:06:00John R. Boyd: The underlying message is very simple, then there is no layout.
- 1:06:07John R. Boyd: Unless we can eliminate the feature just cited.
- 1:06:09John R. Boyd: Well, problem though, we don't know how to do this.