Latest / The Sticky From The Inside Podcast / Self-Empathy. The Leadership Keystone
Transcript
- 0:10Hello and welcome to Sticky from the Inside, the employee engagement podcast that looks at how to build stickier, competition smashing, consistently successful organisations from the inside out.
- 0:22I'm your host Andy Goram and I'm on a mission to help more businesses turn the lights on behind the eyes of their employees, light the fires within them and create tonnes more success for everyone.
- 0:39This podcast is for all those who believe that's something worth going after and would like a little help and guidance in achieving that.
- 0:46Each episode we dive into the topics that can help create what I call stickier businesses, the sort of businesses where people thrive and love to work and where more customers stay with you and recommend you to others because they love what you do and why you do it.
- 1:03So if you want to take the tricky out of being sticky, listen on.
- 1:10Okay then, if empathy is such a vital leadership skill, why do some of us skip the most important step in looking at ourselves?
- 1:20Is it because it's harder for some than others?
- 1:24Because we're all too busy to think about it?
- 1:26Or maybe it's because a fair few don't really see the value in it at all.
- 1:31We often talk about empathy in terms of understanding and connecting with other people.
- 1:37But my guest today, Dr. Melissa Robinson-Winemiller, believes we've got to start somewhere else, closer to home.
- 1:45And she calls it self-empathy.
- 1:48It's about understanding and connecting with yourself first, so you can show up more clearly, confidently, and consistently for others.
- 1:56Now Melissa is a TEDx speaker, exec coach, host of the Empathic Leader podcast, and author of the Empathic Leader, how EQ via Empathy transforms leadership for better profit, productivity, and innovation.
- 2:11In her work, she focuses on something she calls practical empathy, turning empathy from a nice notion into a skill you can actively develop and apply every day.
- 2:26So in this episode, we're going to dig into the steps to building self-empathy, explore why it matters more than you might think, and see what the latest research reveals about empathy's impact on performance, innovation, and retention, when it's done well.
- 2:43Welcome to the show, Melissa.
- 2:45Thank you so much for having me, and I don't want to get off track, but I've got to say you have some of the best bumper music in the business.
- 2:51I love it.
- 2:53It's amazing what you can find in the YouTube studios.
- 2:56It really is.
- 2:57It's fabulous.
- 2:58I'd love to think that I had some sort of rock band set up in the corner just recording for me, but maybe in a few years' time, maybe.
- 3:04We'll see how we go.
- 3:05But bless you.
- 3:06What a lovely way to start.
- 3:08Well, I was listening to your podcast, I'm just like, yeah, that's like that guitar sound.
- 3:13And oh, yeah, let's talk.
- 3:14This sounds fantastic.
- 3:16Tom Clougherty It's very upbeat indeed, which I'm sure this conversation is going to be too.
- 3:21Now, I've given a very small little introduction to you, Melissa, but do me a favour.
- 3:28Before we get into the topic, which I'm desperate to do, please just give us a better introduction to you, who you are, and what you're focused on today.
- 3:36So I am currently very focused on empathy, and it's because of some stuff that happened in my past life.
- 3:45And I'm sure a lot of people can relate to it, being in a job or in a career where there is no empathy within an organization.
- 3:53There is no ability for people to understand and connect.
- 3:57For me, it came out of an assault.
- 3:59I was a musician.
- 4:00I loved what I was doing.
- 4:02I mean, I loved everything about it.
- 4:04But I also loved food, shelter and clothing.
- 4:07And being a performing musician, sometimes those things can be a little difficult.
- 4:11So I went and I got my doctorate and I went to be a professor.
- 4:14And within my first term, I was assaulted by one of my colleagues.
- 4:18And then over the next seven years, my career, which I mean, I'd worked on for decades, just unraveled, because no matter who I talked to or where I went or what I tried to do, there was zero empathy.
- 4:29And it wasn't because people were evil.
- 4:32It isn't because people were bad.
- 4:34It's because the organization and the system had them so beaten down that they just couldn't hear it.
- 4:39And I eventually had to leave, which was hard.
- 4:42I'd been a musician my whole life.
- 4:43But after that, I kind of spun for a while, and I kept trying to figure out what had happened.
- 4:49What was the thing?
- 4:50And at this point, my husband and I were doing some consulting, and I had been doing some other work.
- 4:55And I just kept seeing these behavioral patterns repeated in these organizations.
- 4:59And I kept kind of coming back to this idea of empathy.
- 5:02That's supposed to be something that's so integral to us as humans.
- 5:07And yet within these organizations, somehow we couldn't be human enough to have empathy.
- 5:11So I started researching it.
- 5:13And long story short, now I'm into my second doctorate, which is a little insane, but it's in empathy and leadership.
- 5:20My dissertation is empathy and leadership, and I'm that serious about it because I believe in it that strongly.
- 5:27Wow.
- 5:27Well, I can feel the passion already emanating from you on this topic.
- 5:32But that's a horrible experience to have.
- 5:35I know I'm nothing to do with it, but I'm sorry you had to go through something like that.
- 5:40But it looks like you're really turning that horrible negative experience into something good and something practical.
- 5:47Yeah, trying to.
- 5:48I call it trying to turn garbage into gold.
- 5:51Because if I can help other people, if I can keep anybody from having to deal with what I dealt with, even on a small level, then I figure I've succeeded.
- 6:00And we see this lack of human-to-human empathy in these organizations so often that it's a place where people can make a massive impact.
- 6:12And it does well for the business besides because the data is there to show it does increase profit, productivity, and innovation.
- 6:20So it's a win-win situation.
- 6:21So why not?
- 6:23Which I am fascinated to get into.
- 6:25I would like to, if I may, just ask you at the very start of this so we can get everyone on the same page.
- 6:32There's two phrases that I think we have looked at.
- 6:34I'm going to get to self-empathy in a sec, but practical empathy.
- 6:40Because let's define what practical empathy means from your perspective, Melissa, before we move on.
- 6:47Because I reckon, even based on my own research for this particular episode, I could have gone down all sorts of different alleyways in my own interpretation of that.
- 6:56And I don't want to start the whole show off in the wrong direction.
- 6:59So when you talk about practical empathy, what are you really saying?
- 7:03How do you define that?
- 7:05So practical empathy for me is something that is skills-based, it is data-driven, and it is outcomes-oriented.
- 7:11It isn't this soft, fluffy feeling thing, which that's how most people know empathy.
- 7:17And that's part of empathy, but it's not all of it.
- 7:20Empathy, it's this incredibly complex thing.
- 7:24It spans a bunch of different subjects from psychology and neurobiology to philosophy.
- 7:31One researcher actually pinned it down to 43 different kinds of empathy that fall into eight broad categories.
- 7:37Yeah, it's a massive, massive subject.
- 7:39And researchers don't agree on it necessarily.
- 7:43So we're kind of in that kind of water where, of course, society isn't necessarily going to understand it because the researchers aren't necessarily pinning it down.
- 7:53But for me, I think the easiest way to actually describe practical empathy is that we're out of this fuzzy feeling kind of thing, and it is skills-based.
- 8:02The way I like to describe it is it's like having a treadmill.
- 8:05You get the treadmill after Christmas, and then by New Year's, it sits in the corner, and you hang clothes on it, and the cat slips on it kind of thing.
- 8:13It's great to have, but you're not going to get results if you don't use it.
- 8:19Empathy is the same way.
- 8:20It's great to have, but you have to actually use it in interpersonal interaction in a practical way for it to really, really have value.
- 8:29Yeah, I think, I mean, blimey, 43 types of empathy.
- 8:33I mean, that's a start of a conversation right there because I think, I mean, maybe that's part of why some people will describe this as pink and fluffy and, you know, intangible.
- 8:45And if the researchers can't nail it down, well, is it really a thing?
- 8:50But I think we've all probably experienced those situations where someone does connect with you and see something from your perspective and has a line of curiosity and support that is in line with your stance at that point or the position that you are in, and they act accordingly.
- 9:09So this is going to be a fascinating conversation, I'm sure.
- 9:12Another thing I just want to touch on, you've already used words like neurobiology, which is, I'm in now, okay, I love these things.
- 9:20But I wonder when we talk about empathy, we almost fall into two buckets, right?
- 9:25Those guys who get it, understand it, and do let you see it as a skill.
- 9:29And others perhaps with a bit more of a fixed mindset about it are of the opinion that, well, it's just a personality trait.
- 9:36You either have empathy or you don't.
- 9:38What do you say to those folks, Melissa?
- 9:42So again, this is another myth that's out there because there is some biological basis, there is some empathy that you are born with or you're not, and there are certain people that are born without it completely.
- 9:56I mean, luckily, they're a very small percentage of the population, but we're talking dark triad, which is psychopaths, sociopaths, Machiavellians, and narcissists.
- 10:04They have little or no empathy by definition.
- 10:07So that's part of what they are.
- 10:10So those people aside.
- 10:13I think I've definitely worked with a couple of those in my career, Melissa, but yeah.
- 10:18Yeah.
- 10:19I think we all have, sadly.
- 10:21But that part that you are born with or not, there's other kinds.
- 10:27Like you talk about cognitive empathy, and that means I logically understand what you feel or I logically understand what you're at.
- 10:34I just don't feel it.
- 10:35And in business and leadership, I actually find this to be one of the biggest tools that we can use because if you're in charge of a company, right, and you're having to make big decisions, and they're not all going to be popular decisions, but you have to because the business has to run first, then you can fall into this cognitive empathy and actually being able to logic through it.
- 10:57It's actually a very important part of it.
- 10:59I believe that the three go together.
- 11:01And this is what I talk about in my book, affective or emotional empathy, which is the one that I feel, what you feel, cognitive empathy or logical empathy, which is I logically get it.
- 11:10I just don't necessarily feel it.
- 11:11And then self-empathy, which is a whole different thing that there isn't a lot of research, like hardcore research on, which is why it fascinates me all the more.
- 11:20Well, it fascinates me too.
- 11:22And we're going to introduce people to this topic today, but I'm, my head's already spinning.
- 11:25This is wonderful.
- 11:27Even the three, the three types, just the way that you described the cognitive empathy, because I would, I would consider myself more of the emotional empath, if you like, you know, I'm, I guess I'm pretty well wired for that, but the way you've just described cognitive empathy, I can see examples of that with people that I've worked with, but perhaps I didn't connect with there.
- 11:51I'm pretty sure I used that process myself at times too, without giving it a label or understanding it.
- 11:56So I'm in Melissa, this is going to be fab.
- 12:00So let's look at self-empathy then, the third place in your list of three.
- 12:05There's a couple of things I'd like to ask.
- 12:08You've just started on a sort of a mild definition.
- 12:10I'd like, if you could just to explain that definition a little more deeply, the self-empathy, what that really is, what it shows up like, how do we, should we think about it?
- 12:22And then why you think this is particularly a really interesting foundation stone for leading other people?
- 12:30Sure.
- 12:31Cause I think, I think it is the keystone.
- 12:33I mean, I think that's, that's where you have to begin.
- 12:36So we get, if we get away from this idea that empathy is feeling right, really what empathy is, is understanding and connecting.
- 12:45And there's different ways to do that, which is why there's so many different kinds, right?
- 12:49So when you think about self-empathy, really what it is, is being able to understand and connect with yourself.
- 12:56Cause if you think about these people in these leadership positions, right, usually they're very driven.
- 13:00They're very ambitious.
- 13:02They're very high self-actualized, right?
- 13:04If you think of Maslow's pyramid and the little piece at the top, you know, these are people that, that really strive.
- 13:10And because of that, they don't necessarily take the time to understand and connect with themselves first, which means that number one, that's why you end up with higher rates of burnout.
- 13:20You end up with different substance problems.
- 13:23You can end up with family problems.
- 13:24You end up with all sorts of issues in leadership, right?
- 13:28But number two, how can you expect to be able to show this for somebody else if you don't know how to show it for yourself?
- 13:34Charity starts at home.
- 13:37It's interesting, isn't it?
- 13:39The, the, the people can become, I guess, so fixated with the goal, the target, the result, everything else sort of pales in into insignificance in the background until it becomes too late and something happens as a result of those things, right?
- 13:53You're talking about taking a more present attitude to understanding where you are at any given moment in time, I guess, and what's, what's driving that.
- 14:03Okay, great.
- 14:04Fabulous.
- 14:05How do you think that actually shows up though in daily behavior?
- 14:09What, what's, what sort of behaviors are you advocating?
- 14:13So here's, here's an example, right?
- 14:16A lot of times we get people in these leadership positions that get there not because they're the best leaders, because they're the best technicians, because they're the best politicians, because they've, they've done all the right steps, but it's not necessarily because they know how to lead.
- 14:31And a lot of times, if these people actually take the time to think about it, they know this, but instead of taking the time to think about it, they'll just rush in, they'll make snap judgments, both against themselves and other people.
- 14:45It'll be that this is how we do things, because this is how we've always done things without actually taking a moment to go, okay, so why are we doing this?
- 14:53Could I lead this better?
- 14:55Am I able to create a better synthesis between what I'm doing with my leadership and my people to create an environment where everybody can grow?
- 15:05And what I'm finding, and you know, some of my other stuff is on, is that a lot of this comes back to judgment.
- 15:12When we judge, we immediately place judgment on, you know, this is good, this is bad, this is the right way to do it, this is the wrong way to do it.
- 15:20And under this judgment, you know, we kind of tend to suffer, honestly.
- 15:26And without adding that judgment to what you're doing, self-empathy allows you to look at these behaviors and say, yeah, maybe this wasn't the best way for me to lead.
- 15:38Maybe I could have done better in that meeting without yelling at people.
- 15:42Maybe taking that heavy-handed approach when I was doing my employee reviews wasn't the best way to go.
- 15:48But you're doing it without judgment, right?
- 15:51Empathy and judgment cannot exist in the same space, period, whether it's judgment of yourself or judgment of another person.
- 16:00So the second you know judgment is going on, it's not empathy.
- 16:03And that's usually a big cue that now I need to step back, be critical, not caring of whatever it is that I feel I'm judging myself for as a leader.
- 16:12You know, think about it.
- 16:13Critique is good.
- 16:14It helps us to grow.
- 16:15It helps us to learn.
- 16:16But there's a difference between critiquing and judging, where we're actually putting a value on it and saying, I'm a bad person because I did this like this, you know?
- 16:27Okay.
- 16:29That's actually quite a lot to take in, you know, especially if you come pre-wired with the notion of what empathy is and you think you understand empathy.
- 16:41Because I'm not the cleverest man in the world.
- 16:44We know that.
- 16:45Let's get that out in the open.
- 16:47Not that it needs any flagging.
- 16:49But I'm coming to this conversation open, trying to understand, looking to understand more stuff, right?
- 16:58But I'm also coming to the conversation with my own bias of what empathy means and what it feels like.
- 17:05And I've already sort of said I'm definitely on the more emotional side of understanding what empathy is, seeing something from somebody else's perspective and not making, like you say, a judgment, but just trying to see something from somebody else's perspective to connect with them in that sense and understand what's going on.
- 17:23I have just found that last bit really hard to put myself in a place where I'm properly understanding self-empathy in the way that you describe it, which is fascinating because I get what you're saying.
- 17:39It's just, I've never attached empathy to that, if you like, critique or assessment or whatever that process label has.
- 17:50I've never used the word empathy alongside it.
- 17:52But it's beginning to make a bit of sense for me in that it's about an understanding and connecting to what's just happened or the thought process that's gone.
- 18:00I just would never have used the word empathy.
- 18:03And most people wouldn't.
- 18:04Yeah.
- 18:05You're not the only one.
- 18:07And that's part of why we have so much, like when you said in the beginning, what do you do when people push back against this?
- 18:14Well, they push back against this idea that empathy is all feeling and that feeling doesn't belong in organizations.
- 18:18Yeah.
- 18:19But empathy is so much bigger than that.
- 18:22That's the thing.
- 18:24It really, I mean, I understand.
- 18:27I just, I said a lot in a very...
- 18:29No, no, no, no, no.
- 18:30It wasn't anything to do with the volume of things that you were putting across.
- 18:35It was me being able to detach from my own personal understanding, let's put it that way, of what I believe empathy is to somebody who's studying this topic, right?
- 18:51In far more detail, from far many more different perspectives than I have.
- 18:57And I would never have attached the word empathy to that thought process.
- 19:02I just think that's really, really interesting.
- 19:04Really interesting.
- 19:05I don't know.
- 19:05There could be people listening here going, oh, get on, Andy.
- 19:09Come on.
- 19:09We're all there.
- 19:10We've already got it.
- 19:11And I'm like, hey, listen, I'm just being honest.
- 19:13I'm just trying to connect to it.
- 19:15No, there's a reason why people study this the way they do, because it really is.
- 19:20We didn't even really study empathy as a topic until like 1910 or so.
- 19:25Before that, it meant pity.
- 19:27So, you know, this whole thing has gone through this massive evolution.
- 19:31I think that's really interesting, because maybe some of the people who believe this stuff is a little bit woo-woo and doesn't have a place in business is that we've still got conflation with terms or feelings around sympathy or being self-indulgent or pity.
- 19:50I mean, in the research that you have done clearly to write one book and continue on your second doctorate, which is crazy with the amount of work that must take, do you see that...
- 20:04Not anymore.
- 20:05But that's why we love you, Melissa, and that's why we're having a lovely chat.
- 20:10I think, do you come across this sort of conflation in other people, still using those old definitions, beliefs that that's what it's all about?
- 20:20Oh, definitely.
- 20:21Yeah, totally.
- 20:23And I mean, even within the research, you can look and see this evolution of the topic.
- 20:27So even if the researchers who are supposed to be cutting edge are moving along this line, then the lay people who are following what they're saying, of course, they're going to be confused, because it is such a massive subject.
- 20:39And there's been such a huge thing in the last 10 years or so, but especially since COVID, where a lot of big thinkers are like, use empathy, use empathy, use empathy, use empathy.
- 20:52Okay, that's great.
- 20:52How do I use empathy?
- 20:53Well, I don't know, just go out and use it.
- 20:55It's natural.
- 20:57Okay, well, can you lead me in the right direction?
- 20:59No, just go use it.
- 21:01That doesn't help, because it makes it sound like it's something we're either born with or we're not, which again, I mean, goes back to what we were saying.
- 21:07I mean, in other countries, they actually teach empathy in schools.
- 21:11Really?
- 21:12Wow.
- 21:13Yeah.
- 21:13Under like social emotional learning models.
- 21:15That's cool.
- 21:16I think that is fascinating.
- 21:18Really fascinating.
- 21:20I'm sitting here, the old brains whirring.
- 21:22I want to go back to this thing you were talking about, where empathy and judgment can't sit in the same room.
- 21:29I love that.
- 21:29That's a lovely, lovely notion.
- 21:31Has that got something to do with, you think, this group of leaders who perhaps might turn their back on this or pay no attention to this topic, and by then not looking inward, what do you think it is that they're missing from not putting this stuff into practice?
- 21:53What are the gulfs that you see in all of the research and the people that you work with, Melissa?
- 21:58I'm fascinated.
- 22:00I see a real gulf in the steps that lead up to having self-empathy.
- 22:06Okay.
- 22:08This is just from what I've seen and what I've put together and that sort of thing.
- 22:13It starts with being able to self-reflect.
- 22:17A lot of times, these people are very busy, and I'm not negating that.
- 22:21I mean, it's hard to be a leader.
- 22:24It's like the end of the Conan movie, where they say, heavy is the head that wears the crown.
- 22:29It is.
- 22:30It's a lot of responsibility.
- 22:32But because of that, they either can't or won't take that time to self-reflect.
- 22:37It's hard, because you're looking at stuff you may not want to see.
- 22:41But if you think of self-reflection as turning it in, how am I doing with this?
- 22:45How did I end up with this situation?
- 22:48How did I make people feel when I blew up in that meeting?
- 22:52How did I react to that?
- 22:54That self-reflection, ideally, then can turn to self-awareness, where you turn this outward.
- 23:00How did this make everybody else feel?
- 23:01What is this doing to my company?
- 23:03Now, I've got two more employees leaving.
- 23:05We have this attrition, which, according to the Society of Human Resource Management, takes 90% to 200% of the employees' wages to replace these people.
- 23:14How have my actions affected my environment around me?
- 23:19Then you can get to self-empathy and the critical not caring.
- 23:22Okay, I see what I did.
- 23:24This didn't work.
- 23:26This did work.
- 23:27I'm not going to put judgment on myself and call myself a horrible person, even if, in the moment, that's definitely how it was perceived, but I'm going to fix it.
- 23:35I'm going to move this forward.
- 23:36I'm going to show myself kindness and understanding and mercy that this maybe shouldn't have happened, but it did, and now we have to move forward.
- 23:45Then, once you have those things in place, self-reflection, self-awareness, self-empathy, now you can start to turn that empathy outward and start to understand your people and the organization and how this all synergistically flows as a huge organism.
- 24:00I'm just reflecting on something a previous guest said on a show we were talking about, psychological safety.
- 24:07I think he gave a great example of what you've just talked about here in this reflection piece.
- 24:12There was an example he gave of going through a psychological safety test with some employees, and on the results, somebody said to the boss, well, I could have told you that before.
- 24:25The boss immediately reacted and said, well, why didn't you tell me?
- 24:30The reflection on that afterwards was, hey, actually, it's not why do you tell me, it is what sort of environment have I created that means you couldn't tell me.
- 24:40I think that's my interpretation of what you've just said in a practical sense, right?
- 24:46Yes, exactly.
- 24:47That's exactly how it plays out in the real world.
- 24:50Yeah.
- 24:50Okay.
- 24:52You've now started to talk about this path to building self-empathy.
- 24:57I think we're now beginning to understand that this self-empathy thing is about connection, understanding, this judgment-caring piece.
- 25:05You talk about a path towards building self-empathy.
- 25:09Can you walk us through that path, just picking up the various stages and just explaining how they link together and the importance of that process?
- 25:22Yeah.
- 25:23It is a process.
- 25:25I tell my clients that this is, I mean, back to being a musician, that it's a practice, not a performance, because in practice, you're doing it every day.
- 25:34You are working on it every day.
- 25:35A performance happens one time and you're done, finished, perfect, in the can.
- 25:40Practice happens every single day, all the time.
- 25:43This is definitely a practice.
- 25:46It follows those steps of starting with self-reflection, so taking the time to really stop and think about that day.
- 25:55It doesn't have to be hours and hours of meditating.
- 25:58It can be 30-second journal entries.
- 26:01It can be what I call micro-meditations, where you stop and you stop the world for just a second.
- 26:07You go, how did that actually go?
- 26:09Did this actually go like I think it did or did it not?
- 26:12This is where having someone outside of you that will tell you the truth is good.
- 26:17That doesn't mean someone that's going to answer to you and tell you what you want to hear.
- 26:20This means someone who's going to tell you the truth, whether it's a coach or a mentor or something like that, but having that piece in place so that you actually have a clear view of how this is happening and how it relates to you on the inside.
- 26:35It's that adage of the pickle jar.
- 26:38If you're in the pickle jar, you can't read the label on the outside of the pickle jar, so you have to have someone out there who can help you read it.
- 26:45That's precisely what the self-reflection piece is.
- 26:48That's the dirty work.
- 26:50Moving from that to the self-awareness, now you're asking these same people, can you show me how this affected other people?
- 26:57I saw this, this, and this.
- 27:00Is that what actually happened?
- 27:02I think this affected other people.
- 27:06These layoffs, they had to happen for the good of the company, but maybe I could have handled the way I did it better in that meeting when I blew up.
- 27:16What I wanted to do was light a fire, but I think all I did was scare everybody.
- 27:21Am I aware of my place in this universe, or do I think maybe I'm creating this microcosm that isn't quite real?
- 27:31Now that you've reflected and you're aware of how this is affecting everybody else, you can start to instill the actual self-empathy.
- 27:38I now understand what happened.
- 27:40I can connect to that part of myself that was judging myself for being a bad leader, so I was trying to lead other people the way I thought I should by yelling at them, by being hardcore, by pushing them just as hard as I push myself.
- 27:55We see that a lot.
- 27:57Well, that's how I was trained.
- 27:59Well, that's what my leaders did.
- 28:00Well, this is what I do to myself.
- 28:02Well, no.
- 28:03Now that I've reflected on it and I'm aware of what that is actually doing to me and why I now have a substance abuse problem, then I have the empathy to be able to start to address this to myself and the empathy for my people to say, I don't want to drive them like that.
- 28:19This is not helping me.
- 28:20This is not helping them.
- 28:22This is not helping our organization.
- 28:25Okay.
- 28:26I am getting clearer.
- 28:31Honestly, I love what you're taking me through today, so let me just try and see if I can connect to you, see if I've properly understood this, because I'm sitting here going, yeah, yeah, yeah, I get it now, but I really want to make sure, because this is such a departure and actually not really what I expected I was going to take from today's conversation so far, which is brilliant.
- 28:53So, I get the self-reflection thing.
- 28:55I think the thing that sort of prompted me to think about stuff when you were talking about that is when you mention words like meditation to people, I mean, that can lose an audience immediately, right?
- 29:08That's when people start going, oh God, where is it?
- 29:10But again, that's another word I think just gets misinterpreted.
- 29:14I think this is just about being alone with your thoughts for a bit and seeing some things clearly.
- 29:20So, I get the self-reflection thing.
- 29:22And actually, when we think about this whole self-empathy thing and me not being able to connect to it initially, I think it's all been wrapped up in reflection previously in my own head.
- 29:33The process that I've gone through has been wrapped up in reflection.
- 29:35I think the self-awareness after reflection, that's great.
- 29:40The clarity of what was the impact of what just happened.
- 29:44For me, I've taken the impact assessment of that in that sense.
- 29:48There's a real purpose to it.
- 29:50And then now I kind of see the self-empathy thing around, in that instance, you talked about connecting to what I was trying to achieve, but understanding what was going on because of the impact that may have taken place instead.
- 30:05Now, if I bring together the time I've taken to think about it, understanding the impact of what I did, and then having the self-empathy to understand what I was trying to do or why perhaps I did the thing I did, I can now take a corrective action on the back of that because I've joined all the dots, if you like.
- 30:24Am I anywhere closer to understanding this stuff better now?
- 30:29Yeah, absolutely.
- 30:31The big thing is just that, as you said, it comes back to that understanding and connection.
- 30:37Whether it's an understanding
- 30:39and connecting of events or an understanding of yourself about why you do things the way you do
- 30:44and connecting to that so you don't do it anymore, an understanding of your people and connecting so
- 30:50that you can actually create a better organization instead of just doing the same things because this
- 30:57is how we've always done them and not stopping to actually think about it, not understanding why you
- 31:01do it and not connecting to the fact that this may not actually be the best course of action.
- 31:06Yeah, and this really does link quite strongly to the whole development of emotional intelligence, right?
- 31:12Moving from react to respond, I guess, making the connections between the two parts, would you say?
- 31:20Yeah, totally.
- 31:21In fact, in the beginning, empathy was put into the emotional intelligence basket.
- 31:27This goes back to Daniel Goleman's book in 1995, and it was part of it.
- 31:33I actually think you have to have empathy first because if you think of emotional intelligence as a basket of tools, right?
- 31:40You've got chisels and saws and hammers and screwdrivers and whatever.
- 31:44If you use empathy first to connect and understand, then you know when you reach into that basket if you're reaching in for a saw or a left-handed screwdriver.
- 31:54Whereas if you don't employ empathy first, how do you know what's going to be the most effective tool to grab?
- 32:01And when you talk about tools, I mean, you mentioned things like journaling, meditation, micro-meditation.
- 32:11Are there other specific tools that you recommend to help try and strengthen, build this sort of self-empathy muscle that we have but perhaps don't use as often as we should?
- 32:25I actually think the best thing you can do is have someone that you can talk to about this that will give you the straight answers.
- 32:33And it doesn't matter if it's a spouse or a colleague or a coach or whatever, as long as this person understands, I've been looking at this path to be able to instill self-empathy so that I can actually employ empathy within my organization.
- 32:50I'm building this skill.
- 32:52It isn't just a fluffy woo, we're going to journal and feel better kind of thing, which has its place too, just this isn't it.
- 33:01I'm sure you have client confidentiality and all that kind of stuff.
- 33:05But are there any specific stories that spring to mind of people you've taken through this process who have really understood and got to grits with the self-empathy thing and seen some major changes in behavior or attitude as a result?
- 33:22Yeah.
- 33:24So I'll keep it kind of vague.
- 33:26There's one in particular.
- 33:29Always useful.
- 33:31Yeah.
- 33:32I can actually think of a couple, but I can think of one in particular because as he himself has said, he doesn't really feel he has emotional empathy.
- 33:45He doesn't necessarily have that deep feeling, but he was really able to get a hold of the cognitive empathy side of things and start to be able to use this with his people.
- 33:57But in the process, we were working him into self-empathy through the self-reflection, self-awareness, self-empathy.
- 34:04In doing this, what he figured out was that he wasn't really using self-empathy or whatever, because there was too much going on with his leadership that he didn't want to see.
- 34:15He knew that he had been damaged, I guess is maybe a good way to put it, by some of his leaders and the way that they had taught him, and he had compartmentalized this.
- 34:27So of course he wasn't necessarily feeling it because it was painful.
- 34:31He didn't want to think about some of the ways that he had been brought into the industry.
- 34:37Once he was able to connect with that, then he was able to get away from the, this is how we do it because this is how I was trained, and now I'm going to train others, and now I'm going to do this to my people.
- 34:49He saw results in terms of innovation right away because he was able to build that trust with his people.
- 34:54They started coming to him with ideas to be more efficient right from the front lines.
- 34:59They understood that he was listening, actually tapping into some of those emotional intelligence skills.
- 35:04It's created a really good system.
- 35:09He's working well with his people, and he's come a long way.
- 35:14I think the people reference here is fascinating because I think I think we genuinely have a good sense of when people are being genuinely empathetic towards us and when they're being performative or pretending, and I think this is a bit of a worrying trend.
- 35:31I tried to be a good boy, I tried to do some research, and I had a quick look at the Ernst and Young, well they have a repeated report, right, between 21 and 24, I think, where they've started to look at some of these things.
- 35:43I thought there were a couple of things that were really interesting.
- 35:46You will know these, but I'd love to get your view on this and how you see this playing out, but I think the two pieces that stuck out for me were 90% of workers link empathic, or sorry, empathetic leadership to higher job satisfaction, and there were clearly reported boosts in innovation, efficiency, and most importantly for me and the topic of this podcast, particularly retention.
- 36:13However, the report, especially of late, is also citing growing concerns over this performative empathy, pretending or masking, and a complete lack of follow-through, like we'll say we're being empathetic and then nothing ever happens.
- 36:34Do you see these things playing out, those stats living large for you?
- 36:37Yes, yes, very much so, and I think that is a result of so many high-profile people talking about it, is now it's a very buzzy word, right, and people want that in their mission, vision, and values that we show empathy and, you know, that kind of thing, but people aren't stupid.
- 36:56They can see it.
- 36:57You know, if you talk one thing and walk another, they're going to know, and yet these employers wonder why they have the employee attrition they have, or why they have the generational friction, or why there's all these other problems coming up, and they never stop to reflect on the fact that, well, I'm the one talking this game, and because I'm the leader, I'm always on stage.
- 37:20Somebody is watching.
- 37:21Somebody sees what I'm doing, and when they see this difference between what I'm saying and what I'm doing, that makes me look like a hypocrite.
- 37:29They can't trust me.
- 37:31Trust is when words and actions align over time, and if they see my words and actions do not align over time, how are they going to trust me, but yet they don't understand why everyone's leaving.
- 37:42That connection and awareness thing crops up again, right?
- 37:45That's why I think that authentic empathy, self-empathy, to understand the impact of your actions on others, I think is fascinating because that's where I think the formative stuff falls flat, is that there's some almost ridiculous view that if I say this stuff loudly enough and with confidence and with some mouse mats and some posters, people are going to say, yeah, that's him.
- 38:14That's what we're doing.
- 38:15We're all with it, but if my actions don't kind of follow that up, then we know, but I don't understand how people fool themselves to think that they can get away with it because the employee population know it.
- 38:28I mean, you mentioned values and behaviors.
- 38:31I mean, this is a massive soapbox for me because I'd rather organizations didn't even talk about these things if they're not going to live and die by them because they become more divisive, right?
- 38:44And this is the same stuff.
- 38:45This is just, this is more action-based though.
- 38:48This is saying, I think, and I feel, and I connect, and I understand, and I see your perspective.
- 38:54Yeah, but screw that.
- 38:55I'm still going to do this, this, this, this, this.
- 38:58It just doesn't match up, right?
- 38:59It just doesn't match up.
- 39:01Are you, are you seeing, I mean, it's such a new, it's such a, well, to me at least, it's such a new concept, this self-empathy thing.
- 39:09Are you seeing more and more leaders become aware of this, this stuff and wanting to do something about it?
- 39:17And, and I don't even know if this is a self-fulfilling question or not.
- 39:20The people that come to you, what end of the scale are they on?
- 39:24Are they on the, I love this, I know this, I'd like to get better at it, or are they like, I am a psycho, I need, I need help?
- 39:33I mean, what goes on?
- 39:36You know, it's, they kind of fall into two groups.
- 39:39Either there's the ones that are in so much trouble, the psychos, that they're like, I got to do something or my board's kicking me out.
- 39:47I need you to implement this.
- 39:49And it's like, no, no, no, no, no.
- 39:51That's not how this works.
- 39:52You know, I'm happy to help you with this.
- 39:54I'm happy to help you learn it, but I can't do this for you.
- 39:57You have to do it.
- 39:59And then there's the other ones that are more like, you know, I kind of have a hold on this.
- 40:03I kind of have an idea what this is.
- 40:05And I understand that this could help, but I don't understand exactly how.
- 40:09Can you help me get a hold of this so that I can actually implement it?
- 40:13And they tend to be a little bit younger.
- 40:15Sometimes I, I, you know, I'll have people come in at the director level or something like that, which I love because those are the people that ideally are someday going to be in the C-suite, which means they can start practicing early.
- 40:27And because they're leading both down and up, you know, they, they contact the most people so they can actually, you know, spread it through action.
- 40:37So is the age thing, an openness thing, do you think that they haven't had too, too many previous lived experiences or been led down the wrong path by previous leaders?
- 40:46They're just a little bit more open, perhaps some of these things.
- 40:49I think that, and that they've just been more exposed to it.
- 40:54You know, I think people that are a little bit older, like in leadership motions, don't belong in leadership.
- 40:59You leave their feelings at the door, you know, put on your brave face and it's, it's just the way it was, you know, where some of these younger generations are a little more open to the fact that, yeah, we're human beings and we bring our humanness to work.
- 41:12You know, that's definitely some of the pushback you do.
- 41:15Yeah, I agree.
- 41:16I mean, that's definitely the same, the same thing I have in the soap books.
- 41:19I stand on a lot.
- 41:21I think to try and woo the naysayers and the park your emotion, tough brigade, this stuff though, has real commercial benefit, right?
- 41:32I mean, the words used in your subtitle of the book, better profit, productivity, innovation, those are three of the Holy grail.
- 41:42I think that most business leaders are crying out for today, especially today.
- 41:48So how do you tangibly attach those outcomes to the work of self-empathy, Melissa?
- 41:56Well, going back to that Ernst and Young article, because that's really where it began.
- 42:00The very first one, which was done as a reaction to the pandemic, they actually felt that being in an empathic environment, you know, in a workplace that actually did value this and instill it, that you increased productivity by 87%.
- 42:16I'm trying to make sure I get my numbers right.
- 42:18Innovation by 86% and profit by 84%.
- 42:23Wow.
- 42:24And this is from Ernst and Young.
- 42:25This is not me, you know, just throwing my opinion out there.
- 42:29This is, you know, a big four consultancy.
- 42:32So when you see stuff like that, it should make you go, oh, well, yeah.
- 42:36And the interesting thing is a lot of the ways in which this affects profit and productivity and innovation is above the bottom line.
- 42:44You're not losing people.
- 42:46You'll be able to bring in innovation and efficiencies that are going to make things better before they hit your bottom line.
- 42:51Yeah.
- 42:52You know, your people are going to be more productive because they actually want to be there.
- 42:56And was that the aim behind the book, Melissa?
- 43:00Was it to try and make something that some will feel is an intangible and an innate behavior?
- 43:09Was it an attempt to qualify it as a skill, show that it can be developed, learnt, built, but it also had, you know, tangible commercial benefits as well as human benefits to implementing it?
- 43:23Yes.
- 43:24That's precisely what I wanted to do.
- 43:26Take it out of the and into those skills based.
- 43:31I mean, I mean, half the stuff I talk about, I'd love to people stop thinking it's woo woo and think it and get into the practical.
- 43:38I think that the interesting thing about these things, these topics, these human leadership topics, these these culture related topics is everyone's a finite time scale as to what's going to happen and when.
- 43:50And the reality is that's the thing I can't give you.
- 43:54That's the thing I can't nail on because it's often about where the organization is, where the individual is, where all the individuals in the organization are, who's waiting for who, how long things take to kind of, uh, macerate in, in, in an organization before they start.
- 44:10But we know you and I know other people know the guests on this podcast knows that if you commit to these things and you're in, you're clear in your intentions and you're genuine with your intentions.
- 44:23With all of these things that we talk about here, these have a positive effect on the people that you work with who hold the keys to performance for your organization.
- 44:32It's, it's no more difficult than that, right?
- 44:35Yes, absolutely.
- 44:37And I mean, if you think of empathy at its best, it works in both directions.
- 44:42So if you're showing this to your employees, they're going to be more apt to show you the empathy as you're trying to instill this new thing, as you're trying to create this new microcosm.
- 44:53It is a lagging indicator.
- 44:56Yeah.
- 44:56I think that's why I talk about trying to connect what drives the business to what drives the people within it.
- 45:01To me, that, that connection thing is, is universal here.
- 45:05Oh, blimey, uh, Melissa, I have had my head exploded today.
- 45:10I, I've really loved this.
- 45:12Genuinely love this.
- 45:14Uh, I do enjoy having my perspective changed and having my horizons broadened.
- 45:20And you've definitely done that for me today.
- 45:22That has been fantastic.
- 45:24Um, I've come to the bit in the show I call sticky notes, Melissa, which is where I'm going to try and ask you to summarize, I guess, three key takeouts for people listening that they can take something tangible and practical from this self-empathy thing.
- 45:42And we started the day talking about practical empathy.
- 45:44So if you were to give three bits of advice you could fit on three little sticky notes, what would they be my friend?
- 45:51So the first would be that it, you know, it takes all three kinds of empathy.
- 45:56So you always want to approach this with a cool head and a warm heart, cognitive empathy, emotional empathy, self-empathy, it all goes together.
- 46:07You know, the second thing I would say to remember is to always be critical, but not caring, right?
- 46:15We're back to the cognitive empathy thing again, judgment, the second it's in there and you, and you bring in those kind of hard, hard feelings, it's not going to go well.
- 46:24So you want to be critical.
- 46:25You want to be able to critique, but you don't want to do it with a bunch of self-flagellation.
- 46:31And the third one that I think is the most important is just to remember that empathy and judgment cannot exist in the same space.
- 46:39I love that.
- 46:40Those are the words that are going to stick with me at the end of this episode.
- 46:44Melissa, I have absolutely loved having you on.
- 46:46Before I let you go, where can people find out more about you and where can they get hold of the book?
- 46:51Tell us.
- 46:53So you can go to my website, which is EQVIA, that's V as in Victor, IA, Empathy, and that'll have a lot of my links and that sort of thing.
- 47:03You can always catch me on social media, LinkedIn, Instagram, and my book is at Amazon.
- 47:09You can get it at Barnes and Noble.
- 47:11You can get it at most online retailers.
- 47:14And then there's my podcast too, which is the Empathic Leader.
- 47:18Which we will put links to in the show notes for sure.
- 47:23You've got a new listener out of me.
- 47:24That's going to be amazing.
- 47:25I'm going to look forward to that.
- 47:27Melissa, thank you so much for coming on.
- 47:28I have thoroughly, thoroughly enjoyed meeting you and I've loved chatting with you today.
- 47:32Thank you.
- 47:34Thank you for having me.
- 47:35And this was fantastic, Andy.
- 47:37Thank you.
- 47:38I'm happy to talk to anybody who's on the empathy path.
- 47:42I'm with you.
- 47:43I'm so with you.
- 47:44It's great.
- 47:45Well, you take care.
- 47:46I look forward to our next conversation.
- 47:49Thank you.
- 47:49Me as well.
- 47:50And many thanks to your audience.
- 47:52Bless you.
- 47:53Okay, everyone.
- 47:54Well, that was Dr. Melissa Robinson-Winemiller.
- 47:57And if you'd like to find out a little bit more about her or any of the topics that we've talked about in today's show, please check out the show notes.
- 48:07So that concludes today's episode.
- 48:10I hope you've enjoyed it, found it interesting, and heard something maybe that will help you become a stickier, more successful business from the inside going forward.
- 48:21If you have, please like, comment, and subscribe.
- 48:25It really helps.
- 48:27I'm Andy Gorham, and you've been listening to the Sticky from the Inside podcast.
- 48:32Until next time, thanks for listening.