Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Complaints and Regional Appeals of Examination Issues What You Need to Know
Transcript
- 0:00sometimes there were these personality conflicts and it would be easier for
- 0:03me as a supervisor to just assign a different examiner or a different
- 0:08specialist and make that issue go away.
- 0:13Hey everyone, this is Mark with a special Archive episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:18I hope you enjoy.
- 0:22Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:25Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:29your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:31The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:34Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:36If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:40team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:44and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:46com.
- 0:47Hello,
- 0:55I'm Mark Treichel, and you are listening to With Flying Colors, the podcast where
- 1:00I interview subject matter experts to provide credit union leaders with tips
- 1:04on how you can achieve success with NCUA and pass your exam with flying colors.
- 1:12Today, I'm joined by Todd Miller.
- 1:14Who's going to talk about examination appeals up to the regional level.
- 1:21Todd, before we jump in for folks who are just meeting you for the first time,
- 1:25could you share a little bit about who you are and your career and your experience?
- 1:31Okay.
- 1:31Thank you, Mark.
- 1:32I started with NCUA in 1987.
- 1:35I did retire here in June of 2021.
- 1:38So had almost 34 years with NCUA.
- 1:41And during that time, I was an examiner.
- 1:43a problem case officer, a regional capital market specialist.
- 1:48Last 10 years I was the director of special actions in the western region.
- 1:52I've went through this appeals process on more than number of
- 1:55occasions and even served on NCUA's supervisory review committee.
- 1:59So I had 34 years with NCUA, enjoyed all of it and enjoyed the chance
- 2:04to talk to you here today and share some of my experiences with people.
- 2:08Yeah, Todd.
- 2:09It's it's great to have you as part of my team.
- 2:12I've enjoyed.
- 2:12Obviously, I enjoyed working with you at N.
- 2:14C.
- 2:14U.
- 2:15A.
- 2:15We got to work real closely together at one of the corporate
- 2:18conservatorships, and I got to know you on my West Coast time back when
- 2:22I was director of special action.
- 2:24So we can speak to that.
- 2:25But you've you've.
- 2:26You have a lot of background in the field levels, like the capital markets,
- 2:30like you were saying, and and having been on the supervisory review panel,
- 2:35that is a very unique perspective for credit unions and also from X N.
- 2:39C.
- 2:39U.
- 2:39A.
- 2:40Or current N.
- 2:40C.
- 2:40U.
- 2:41A.
- 2:42Your resume and the background of this is going to be real helpful.
- 2:44So with that, let's talk about exam appeals at the regional level.
- 2:49But before that, why don't we talk a little bit about what happens
- 2:53between examiners coming in to start the exam and, and then how the final
- 2:59exam report actually gets issued.
- 3:02This plays a big role in appeals over.
- 3:062019 and 2020 NCUA kind of changed the whole process of how reports
- 3:11get issued to credit unions.
- 3:13It used to be the examiner could issue the report directly to the credit union
- 3:17on their own at the completion of the exam and that's no longer the case.
- 3:22Now before reports get issued, they always get reviewed by the supervisory examiner.
- 3:28Depending on the credit union and the camel rating, that review might extend
- 3:33all the way up to the division of the supervision in the regional office and
- 3:37for large credit unions and those troubled credit unions with camel fours and stuff,
- 3:42that report is going to get reviewed by an associate regional director as well before
- 3:46it's ever issued to the credit union.
- 3:48Cardinians no longer see draft reports.
- 3:50They'll see draft exam findings and doors, but now when they get a report, it's
- 3:56a final report and it's been reviewed and approved at various levels within
- 4:01the agency before they even see it.
- 4:03I was around when we made this transition and NCUA was the only banking regulator
- 4:08that, that didn't have some higher level of review, which is, which is one of
- 4:12the reasons we went in this direction.
- 4:14A lot of state, uh, supervisory authorities.
- 4:16State regulators were doing it before we started doing it.
- 4:21And so you're saying you might see a document resolution on capital
- 4:27adequacy or something, but you wouldn't see the supplementary facts.
- 4:30You wouldn't see the exam overview.
- 4:32You wouldn't maybe have discussions about the camel code until it
- 4:36had gone up to that higher level.
- 4:37Am I interpreting that right?
- 4:39That is correct.
- 4:41In fact, examiners are told not to discuss camel codes during the
- 4:44exams any longer because those camel codes have to get approved by at the
- 4:48supervisory level or the final reason review level, whichever that might be
- 4:53and overviews, you're not going to see drafts of those supplementary facts.
- 4:58The EIC may or may not let you see a draft of that because those are just
- 5:02kind of additional information to study.
- 5:05Enhance what they've given you is draft exam findings and draft doors and need
- 5:11to understand the doors and findings.
- 5:12You see, they are drafts.
- 5:14They might get changed from your exit conference to, um,
- 5:18when the final report shows up.
- 5:20Got it.
- 5:20And so you used to see a draft report and now you don't see a draft report.
- 5:26How does, how does that relate to, I'm sure we're going to get into how
- 5:30that relates to the appeal process.
- 5:33How does that relate to there?
- 5:34There used to be a requirement where there was a certain number of days
- 5:38before a joint conference or an exit interview that you would have to give.
- 5:42A draft report.
- 5:44It was seven days under the old rule.
- 5:46If you had doors that you needed to let the party review the report
- 5:50before you held that joint conference.
- 5:52And you know, now it kind of depends, you know, camel ones and camel twos, they
- 5:57might not even have a joint conference.
- 5:58They might just get that final report and it's all done.
- 6:02If you are going to have a door, you'll get a final report.
- 6:05Hopefully that examiner does give you a few days to.
- 6:08Dissect that before you have that joint conference.
- 6:11A lot of times the joint conference dates are set and they try and
- 6:16fit that review process into it.
- 6:18So your exams over will set our joint conference out here a month.
- 6:21And, you know, typically, it just kind of depends on what level that review is.
- 6:28If it's just going to a supervisory examiner.
- 6:31Are the division, the supervision or ARD, there's different timeframes
- 6:34for getting those reviews completed, but usually everyone will try
- 6:38and get that process completed in time for that joint conference.
- 6:42That is tentatively set at the end of the exit.
- 6:45In most cases, got it.
- 6:47Got it.
- 6:48All right.
- 6:48So.
- 6:50A credit union gets that final report and it contains its camel ratings.
- 6:55It's document of resolution or door items, examiner findings or EFs or comments that
- 7:02the credit union might disagree with.
- 7:04So they might disagree with the camel.
- 7:05They might disagree with.
- 7:07The door, uh, they might disagree with a sentence in supplementary
- 7:11facts or in the overview.
- 7:14A lot of times what they disagree with would be things
- 7:19that NCUA expects action on.
- 7:22So that happens, a credit union finds itself at this fork in the road.
- 7:27What do they do?
- 7:28So what would the next steps be?
- 7:30Relative to an appeal.
- 7:33Well, I'm going to back up and just give some hints to let's
- 7:36try and avoid appeals to be.
- 7:37I love it.
- 7:38Yeah, absolutely.
- 7:39I think there's some things credit unions can do, and this is the
- 7:41way it works most of the time.
- 7:43I mean, appeals are not all that common.
- 7:45They're fairly rare, but they do happen with some frequency, but I
- 7:50think there's a lot of things that a credit union management team can do to.
- 7:54Avoid us ever having surprises in that final exam report.
- 7:59And that goes to just managing that whole exam process and communicating effectively
- 8:05to make sure you don't get surprises.
- 8:08So, you know, when your exams in process, make sure you're commuting
- 8:12openly with that exam staff that includes the EIC and team members.
- 8:18This becomes a challenge in NCUA's virtual world over the last couple years.
- 8:22And, you know, those examiners are not sitting there and you're
- 8:25building the EIC and that exam team, they're all in different locations.
- 8:30So, you know, there's challenges for them to get on the same page.
- 8:34Sometimes they're not always on the same page when you have a larger
- 8:37credit union, a larger exam team, make sure you have frequent check
- 8:42ins during that exam with both.
- 8:44If you're a CEO, make sure you're talking to your staff.
- 8:47What are the examiners saying to you?
- 8:49And then check in with that exam staff, you know, several times during the exam.
- 8:53It's probably a good idea just to have briefings like every week on a two
- 8:56or three week exam, or even a couple times a week when the examiners do
- 9:01give you draft items during that exam.
- 9:04Take the time to understand any risk ratings they provide you during the exam.
- 9:09The credit examiners use those risk ratings to set that camel code.
- 9:12You should see proposed doors or exam findings during the exam,
- 9:17especially with document resolutions.
- 9:19Those corrective actions are negotiable.
- 9:22And do sit down, negotiate with them, make sure it's a legitimate problem and
- 9:27make sure you understand the findings.
- 9:29It's much easier to get all this stuff resolved during the exam, rather than
- 9:33get surprised with the final exam report.
- 9:36So the first step is in the appeal process is.
- 9:40Try and make sure we don't have to use the appeal process.
- 9:42Let's try and get everything squared away during the exam to
- 9:45the greatest extent possible.
- 9:47And like I said, you have to be very intentional about that, especially now
- 9:51in the COVID world where you're not all in the same room and you have to use
- 9:56these virtual forms of communications and you lose that face to face contact.
- 10:02All great points, Todd.
- 10:03I'll hit the nail with the hammer on the try and resolve it during the exam.
- 10:08That front level contact between the district examiner and any
- 10:12specialists that might be there.
- 10:14If you can resolve it with good communication is communications, the
- 10:17key to life and everything, whether you're whether you're dealing with
- 10:22negotiating with somebody on a contract, whether you're dealing with being a
- 10:27parent to your children, if there's good communication on both sides, things.
- 10:32Go better.
- 10:33And that starts first and foremost with the examination.
- 10:37Now, if you, I will say, as an aside, and maybe we can talk about this a little
- 10:43later, you know, since since I left N.
- 10:45C.
- 10:46U.
- 10:46A.
- 10:46And I'm now consulting and have had some clients that have
- 10:50been at that fork in the road.
- 10:51And I think, you know, we're going to talk about what your options are.
- 10:54If you feel you do want to appeal.
- 10:56I used to.
- 10:58Get approached by credit unions, like at the governmental affairs
- 11:01conference, where there might've been a complaint and they would want to
- 11:05talk through what their steps would be.
- 11:06And I would explain that, but oftentimes the trade associations or the leagues
- 11:10would come to come to the NCUA board, or they would come to me as a regional
- 11:14director and they'd say, Hey, we have someone who says there's an
- 11:18examiner in this part of the country.
- 11:20That's being a little heavy handed and they're afraid, uh,
- 11:24for retaliation relative to that.
- 11:26And the, the policy at NCA is there is no retaliation.
- 11:30The policy is that if somebody appeals it, they have all these
- 11:34rights that they can pursue.
- 11:36But the reality is.
- 11:38Without specifics, it's hard for NC, NCA to deal with it.
- 11:41And so that would be typically the response.
- 11:44Well, if you don't give me specifics, there's nothing
- 11:46that I can really do with it.
- 11:47Now that I'm on the other side, assisting credit unions, I, I
- 11:53realized the weight of that.
- 11:55What that means to the credit unions more than I ever did in
- 11:58my, you know, 34 years at NCOA.
- 12:00And I've had a couple of clients, I actually use the phrase go along to
- 12:04get along and they hit, you know, so you hit this fork in the road.
- 12:06The examination says we need to do X.
- 12:10I don't really think we do because that's going to create a cost of Y.
- 12:14And is the risk that they're saying is it to a certain level really at that level?
- 12:18But do I go along to get along?
- 12:21Is this the issue that I do want to appeal?
- 12:23Or do I try and improve those communications at the field level
- 12:27and have a discussion with the examiner to try and explain my side,
- 12:31which is, you know, again, like you said, do it during the exam.
- 12:35It's just that the magnitude.
- 12:37I never realized that almost every discussion that NCUA has with the credit
- 12:42union, they have to weigh in that manner.
- 12:45Is this something that I agree with?
- 12:48Is this something that I disagree with 10%?
- 12:51Or is this something I just disagree with 80 percent that
- 12:54I really want to push back?
- 12:56And that takes a lot of time and energy in the credit unions.
- 12:58And quite frankly, until I was helping credit unions understand the exam
- 13:02process and helping them through their examinations, I didn't fully realize.
- 13:07The magnitude of that you haven't any thoughts or comments on that statement.
- 13:11I do I have a couple 1st, like, when you get an exam report, and
- 13:15I'll do this myself, someone will send me an email or I'll get an
- 13:18appraisal and there's something in it.
- 13:20I don't like, I think the 1st thing you do is just kind of set that
- 13:23down and digest it for a night and then kind of reread it the next day.
- 13:28When I was a supervisor, I would always.
- 13:31Have my staff give doors to me, and one of the things I would look at is
- 13:35this going to cost more money than it's worth, and I think have to weigh that
- 13:40cost benefit of appealing things appeals take a lot of time and time costs, a
- 13:47lot of money and is it worth appealing.
- 13:51Or is it just easier to spend a little bit of money and and
- 13:54do what the examiner says?
- 13:55Sometimes it's worth it to address something in an inexpensive
- 14:00way rather than appeal it.
- 14:03I do think it's always worth a conversation with the examiner, even if
- 14:06you're not going to file a formal appeal.
- 14:09And kind of let them know your thought process and make sure
- 14:12you understand what they wrote.
- 14:14But yes, I mean, sometimes you may think that examiner's wrong and they
- 14:18may have an exam finding, which is correctable in normal course of business.
- 14:23You don't think you need to do anything.
- 14:24Sometimes if it's just a small policy or procedural change, it's easier just to.
- 14:30Write that into a policy or procedure rather than appeal
- 14:33that examiner's determination.
- 14:35At the end of the day, the examiners are trying to help you.
- 14:38It's not malicious on their part or anything.
- 14:42But yeah, sometimes it's better to not appeal if it's Not going to cost you a
- 14:46lot to address the issue or, you know, if you don't agree necessarily with a
- 14:52CAMEL rating, but that doesn't affect your employee performance goals, or
- 14:57it doesn't affect your credit rating with the FHLB or any external parties.
- 15:03Sometimes it might not be worth appealing that item in a formal process all
- 15:07the way up to the regional director.
- 15:09I do think it's worth.
- 15:10I do think it's worth a conversation with the examiner though, and
- 15:16you may just stop at that point.
- 15:19Got it.
- 15:19Yeah.
- 15:20So indeed, we both agree that sometimes it makes sense to go along to get along and
- 15:24you said they're there with good intent.
- 15:26The credit union is there with good intent.
- 15:28So try and resolve it is always step one.
- 15:31So there are going to be some situation where the credit union does do its
- 15:35best to manage the examination process.
- 15:37And they've negotiated, they've used all their meet and deal skills with
- 15:43the examiner, and the report still contains a surprise or something
- 15:48that they materially disagree with.
- 15:51What would they do next?
- 15:53Well, when a cardian gets this exam, that first 2 pages, there's a whole 6 point
- 15:59bullet section that says levels of appeal.
- 16:03Well, 1st thing is read through that and understand those levels of appeal.
- 16:08There's timeframes in there for formal appeals to the regional director.
- 16:12Make sure you adhere to those timeframes, the appeal process.
- 16:16It always starts with the examiner, then the supervisory examiner,
- 16:20then the regional director.
- 16:22I think, depending on the item, you know, sometimes you might want to actually bring
- 16:26in the supervisory examiner right away.
- 16:29Do.
- 16:34Consider how much documentation you need.
- 16:36If you're going to choose to appeal, it's going to take some documentation
- 16:40because you're going to have to prove your point that the examiner made a mistake.
- 16:43They missed something.
- 16:44And let's just be honest.
- 16:46The examiners do make mistakes and, you know, they send you an
- 16:49exam request list and you give them 10, 000 pages or whatever.
- 16:53Two thousand pages of documents, sometimes the piece of it isn't read by a team
- 16:58member and it just gets overlooked and it results in a finding or door
- 17:01that is not necessary, but you're going to have to gather up all that
- 17:06information to prove your point and.
- 17:09You do need to consider that with the appeals is how much documentation do you
- 17:13need to prevail and you're going to have to prove your point and it can be done.
- 17:18Nowadays, it's hard with this whole report approval process
- 17:23for an examiner or supervisor to.
- 17:26Getting a report changed.
- 17:28So sometimes you're often going to end up at that supervisor or D levels, which
- 17:32is a more formal appeal in writing.
- 17:34And like I said, you do have to make sure you file those within 30 days
- 17:39and provide enough documentation to demonstrate that report was an error or
- 17:44the examiner's conclusions were incorrect.
- 17:48Sometimes you're going to have to provide more information than you even
- 17:50gave the examiner during the exam.
- 17:53But you have to prove somewhere that the examiners made an error and conclude
- 17:57and their conclusions are an error.
- 17:59In fact, that said, it can be done.
- 18:02Um, I spent a lot of time as a supervisor.
- 18:06I had a few exams appealed.
- 18:07And of course, I talked to a lot of other supervisors.
- 18:10It's not uncommon when it's writing appeals at the regional director
- 18:14level that they will prevail.
- 18:16In part with changes to CAMEL ratings or they'll see corrective actions
- 18:20softened or removed from the report.
- 18:23So don't be scared to do it.
- 18:25You know, I was with NCA in 31 for 31 years and I'm going to be honest.
- 18:30I didn't really see any instances where examiners retaliated against credit
- 18:34unions because of an exam appeal.
- 18:37I'm not going to deny sometimes there's just personality conflicts.
- 18:40One examiner and one specific person in a credit union just don't get along.
- 18:44And that leads to issues, but I wouldn't be scared to appeal.
- 18:48If this is the material thing, that's going to cost you money.
- 18:51And the examiners have it, don't be scared to appeal.
- 18:54Cardians have pretty good success at the regional director level of proving
- 18:58their case, and it's just because honest mistakes throughout the exam process.
- 19:04We're all human and examiners sometimes make mistakes and miss things.
- 19:10All great points.
- 19:11So you talked about supervisory examiner right away.
- 19:16I'm assuming So once it's finalized, you end up getting where the examiner
- 19:21has less control about doing something.
- 19:23But let's say it was, we think you need to add these 10 things
- 19:29tied to your investment policy.
- 19:32You disagree with the examiner, and then the examiner doesn't change or they change
- 19:40a little bit, but you're still unhappy.
- 19:41You're saying Get that supervisory examiner involved before it
- 19:46goes on up to the higher levels.
- 19:48Let's deal with that one first.
- 19:50Yes, always start with the supervisory examiner for the smaller cardians.
- 19:55A lot of times they can alter report just on their own.
- 19:58If you go above the supervisory examiner.
- 20:01Well, the regions process is they're going to go back to the supervisory
- 20:04examiner and start there anyway.
- 20:06So it's always best to start with that supervisory examiner.
- 20:10You know, while they may have read the report and okayed it, a lot of times
- 20:15they're minimally involved in the exam, so they might not know all the
- 20:19background to the exam and everything.
- 20:22So it's always a good place to start with that supervisory examiner.
- 20:26The appeal levels, that's kind of way it lays it out.
- 20:29That's the agency's expectation is you will start with that supervisory examiner.
- 20:33And it's always the best place to start.
- 20:36And just in a general view, we always talk about cardigans having
- 20:40relationships with their examiners.
- 20:42Well, it's good for them to have working relationships with those
- 20:45supervisory examiners as well.
- 20:47Absolutely.
- 20:49Excellent.
- 20:50Excellent point.
- 20:51So I'm curious.
- 20:53I'm interested to hear your thought on this next question, which is
- 20:56similar, but slightly different.
- 20:58And so you were a capital market specialist.
- 21:00You're also a supervisor.
- 21:02The exam happens.
- 21:05You've got the principal examiner who's in charge of issuing the report.
- 21:09You've got a capital markets specialist.
- 21:10And you got a commercial loan specialist that come in the
- 21:14exam goes on the teams there.
- 21:17And well, this is I'm almost saying this in a, in a forum where we're into
- 21:21a used to be on site, but let's say it's virtual or, you know, whichever.
- 21:25And.
- 21:26You're interacting with the capital market specialist.
- 21:28They do their work.
- 21:29They come up with something that's a proposed document resolution.
- 21:33They give it to the principal examiner and the capital market specialist
- 21:37has a lot of other responsibilities out of the other exams and they go on
- 21:41their way to their next assignment.
- 21:43And I have given the advice to some of my clients that.
- 21:48You want to have a really good communication with those specialists
- 21:51are there and you want to be able to talk to them while they're there
- 21:55while they're assigned to you.
- 21:56Because what I've seen happen in some instances is that higher ranking,
- 22:02higher graded, higher paid specialist.
- 22:04does work, gives it to the principal examiner who's responsible, and
- 22:08then the principal examiner has to carry the water, if you will,
- 22:12of the other experts, and then you start asking questions about that.
- 22:17Yet, it's not the expertise that they particularly have.
- 22:20While they might have capital markets background, they relied
- 22:23on this other specialist.
- 22:24So, Annie, you agree, you agree with my, my, my precept that Talk to the
- 22:29people while they're there, because if the specialists move on, it can
- 22:32get a little bit harder to negotiate.
- 22:35Yes, I do agree with that.
- 22:37And if you get involved with an appeal and it involves like a regional lending
- 22:42specialist that was on the exam or a capital market specialist, I don't think
- 22:46it's out of bounds to, as you're talking to the supervisory examiner, say, Hey, can
- 22:51we get the specialists on the phone too?
- 22:54Um, Sometimes what happens, this happens infrequently, but it does happen where
- 23:00a specialist, whether it's a information systems officer, security officer, or
- 23:06a capital market specialist or regional lending specialist, they'll do an
- 23:10extensive write up and they will write findings that are detailed and Through
- 23:15the editing process, the EIC edits them, you know, thinking that they're making it
- 23:19easier to read, but it tends to sometimes change the context of what they wrote.
- 23:25So you do see issues like that come up occasionally where as reports
- 23:30get edited, what the specialists.
- 23:33Man is not what ends up in that report.
- 23:37So sometimes that does occur.
- 23:40Uh, but when you have complex questions about something a specialist did,
- 23:45I think it's fine to ask the EIC supervisory examiner, Hey, can we get
- 23:49the specialist on the phone after the exam and talk through this, certainly
- 23:53talk to them extensively during the exam.
- 23:56But if there's something you're unclear about when you get that final report,
- 24:00don't be scared to ask them to get on a phone call and say, explain this to me.
- 24:04Great advice.
- 24:05Great advice.
- 24:06The third item that you referenced that I want to highlight a little bit
- 24:10is the fact that sometimes they're just our personality conflicts, right?
- 24:14Everybody doesn't get along with everybody.
- 24:17And I have my thoughts on kind of what I had seen as during my arc of
- 24:22my career relative to that, but there are times when someone's appeal.
- 24:28Might include, you know, I think our camel rating was wrong.
- 24:32I think this document resolution was unfair.
- 24:35Here's the a hundred pages that support why I think that document resolution.
- 24:39And Oh, by the way, this personality conflict is such that we would
- 24:44like a different examiner.
- 24:47What had you seen that?
- 24:49It's come up a few times in my career.
- 24:52So yeah, give me your thoughts on that.
- 24:54I'm going to give you my own personal opinion and the way I dealt with that as
- 24:57a supervisor, this might not specifically be official agency policy, but it's
- 25:02the way I would choose to deal with it.
- 25:04And I don't think it's dissimilar to.
- 25:07What other supervisors may do as well.
- 25:11First, we're going to look at the factual situations regarding the report.
- 25:15If you're a Camel 1 credit union with no troubles, you're going
- 25:18to, as a supervisor, look at that differently than if this is a Camel
- 25:224 credit union, close to failing.
- 25:24But I'll look at that whole background situation.
- 25:26And, and I was.
- 25:28Typically involved in joint conferences and exit meetings.
- 25:31So I had a feel and I will just say that, Hey, sometimes as a supervisor, I'm just
- 25:36going to say, Hey, the grading was wrong.
- 25:37This was they're, they're, they're raising a complaint about an examiner because
- 25:41they don't want to deal with their issue.
- 25:42And then I might not have changed.
- 25:44That person.
- 25:45But those get very, very case specific.
- 25:48I think it does happen.
- 25:50I would look at them as impartially as I could, knowing that, hey,
- 25:54occasionally there are personality conflicts and to the extent resources
- 25:58are available, you reassign someone.
- 26:00But I also would look at it on a rare occasion that.
- 26:05Maybe you're complaining about the examiner, but you're going to get
- 26:08the same outcome with another 1.
- 26:09and I'm not going to reassign that person because they already have
- 26:12extensive knowledge about your organization and what's occurring.
- 26:15And that more happened more often in troubled credit unions,
- 26:20typically well run credit union.
- 26:22There was personality conflicts.
- 26:25I would quite often just assign someone else.
- 26:28And make that issue go away.
- 26:31That's how I dealt with it personally.
- 26:33I don't necessarily know that that's agency policy, but I think
- 26:36a lot of other supervisors would look at it in the same framework.
- 26:40Let's go look at this fact pattern here.
- 26:43And if it truly is just a conflict in personalities, well,
- 26:47NCVA has got lots of employees.
- 26:48They can assign someone else.
- 26:50Great, great answer.
- 26:52I agree with 100 percent of what you said.
- 26:54There were times when I was a regional director where those requests
- 26:58were made that I would actually have to make a decision on it.
- 27:01And there were other times, like you said, where it was mitigated
- 27:04along the way, where it never even got to me as a regional director.
- 27:07But the supervisory examiner, the director of special action
- 27:11said, let's just change this up.
- 27:12Let's get a different set of eyes.
- 27:14It's NCUA rotates examiners after a certain amount of time.
- 27:19There is a good, there's value in having them there more than one year, but there's
- 27:24also the complacency and the challenges that you can get if they stay there too
- 27:27long, and then when you weave in the potential of the personality challenges,
- 27:31they're not common, but they, when you're doing, when you have 5, 000 credit unions
- 27:36and you're doing exams in two thirds of them every year, they're going to happen.
- 27:40So great advice, Todd.
- 27:43Now, so we've talked about appeals.
- 27:48Up to the regional director level, there'll be future podcasts where we'll
- 27:52talk about what can happen beyond that.
- 27:54You've been involved in that.
- 27:56I've got another person joining my team.
- 27:58That's going to talk on a future podcast relative to that whole topic.
- 28:02So Todd, those appeals get a lot more costly too.
- 28:06Yeah.
- 28:06A lot more costly.
- 28:07Yes, indeed.
- 28:09So any last thoughts from you before I wrap?
- 28:13No, I don't think so.
- 28:14I, I, I am going to reiterate, you know, the best way to deal with an appeal is
- 28:19to avoid it during the exam process.
- 28:22Communication.
- 28:23You mentioned it earlier is kind of at the heart of this.
- 28:26If you're communicating openly, honestly, with your examiners during
- 28:30that exam process, we shouldn't have surprises and things shouldn't
- 28:34go to the appeal process at all.
- 28:37Unfortunately, we're all human mistakes get made and appeals do occur, but.
- 28:43If you feel strongly about it, that the examiner is wrong,
- 28:46don't be scared to appeal.
- 28:48If it's a material issue, it's fine.
- 28:51Very good.
- 28:52Yep.
- 28:52Great.
- 28:52Todd, this was great.
- 28:53I want to thank you for being my guest today.
- 28:56In closing now, something Todd said, or something I said may have triggered
- 29:02a question or a specific example that.
- 29:05As you're listening to this relative to your credit union, you
- 29:08might have a follow up question.
- 29:10If you have a follow up question, send it to me and I'll, I'll tell
- 29:13you how you can get that to me.
- 29:15But one of the features I want to do with this podcast is allow for follow
- 29:19up questions that can be dealt with in future editions of a podcast.
- 29:25Also, If you'd like to talk to me about how Todd and I could assist
- 29:30you in your credit union, you can reach me at my email, which is
- 29:36cuexamsolutionsatmarktreichel.
- 29:40com or via my website, which is wwwmarktreichel.
- 29:47com.
- 29:48Okay, folks, that's it for today.
- 29:50I'm Mark Treichel, and I hope you join me again next time for With Flying Colors.
- 30:06Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 30:10your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 30:14of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 30:18If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 30:21out our services at mark trickle.
- 30:23com.