Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / ALCO In Practice: Essential Reports Analysis & Risk Management
Transcript
- 0:02Treichel: Hey everyone.
- 0:03This is Mark with a special archive episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:08I hope you enjoy.
- 0:09Today I'm going to chat with Todd Miller of my team, and this
- 0:14episode is called Alco in Practice.
- 0:17Essential reports, analysis and a risk management.
- 0:21Todd has tremendous, uh, background in this, including being a director
- 0:25of special actions and examiner a capital market specialist
- 0:30and supervising the entire West coast's one third of the country's
- 0:34capital market specialist at NCUA.
- 0:38So, Todd, last week we discussed Alco governance essentials and building an
- 0:41effective committee structure, who should be on the committee, et cetera, et cetera.
- 0:46Now we're gonna pivot to a LM or ALCO reporting and, you
- 0:50know, policies, et cetera.
- 0:51So with that, I'm gonna give you free reign to share your wisdom.
- 0:55So this should be all laid out in policies.
- 0:58I'm gonna go through some general things and, um, that I think should be part
- 1:02of most ALCO report packages and part of most al alcohol's functionings.
- 1:07This shouldn't be intended to be an inclusive list, that this
- 1:10are the only things you need.
- 1:12If you wanna add other reports, feel free to do that.
- 1:14Some of this is how do you lay out your business plan and how does the board
- 1:18lay out performance, key performance indicators and key risk indicators.
- 1:23So this can change it a little bit, but I'm gonna lay out what I think is.
- 1:27Should be in a typical Elco package, and some of what I lay out here might
- 1:32not be in the package every month.
- 1:34It might be in once a quarter.
- 1:36We'll even talk about model validation is that might only have to occur a
- 1:40couple times a year, but we'll go through just some general things
- 1:44that I think should be in most Elco packages out there, even though it's
- 1:49not in an exhaustible inclusive list.
- 1:52First one, credit unions operate in an environment out there.
- 1:56So somewhere within our Elco and our organization, we should have
- 2:00some basic economic data that we're keeping track of what's going on
- 2:04nationally and more important what's going on locally when, especially
- 2:09with managing credit risk, what's happening in our local housing market?
- 2:13If you're a business lender, what's happening in our local
- 2:15commercial real estate market?
- 2:17What are employment trends within our local area and our fields of membership?
- 2:23Um, there should be just some general economic information that's shared across
- 2:28the committee because they're gonna be determining tactics, strategies,
- 2:32and well, credit union should not make huge bets on the economy.
- 2:38They do have to take a position and make reasonable decisions on.
- 2:43How they're gonna operate their lending and investment programs, their deposit
- 2:48gathering programs, and that's going to be influenced by their local economic
- 2:53factors or their expectations of which direction the economy is gonna go.
- 2:57And you, you can't really manage any risk out within the organization
- 3:01unless you have some basic information about your financial statements
- 3:05and your budgets and how are you doing on budgets and comparisons.
- 3:09Along that line, they're the biggest ones that responsible.
- 3:13How do we address variances in our budgets?
- 3:16Do we need to change strategy?
- 3:18Do we need to change topics?
- 3:19Do we need to change pricing if things aren't going as the board expects?
- 3:24I'm a big believer in compliance dashboards.
- 3:28Um, and within this, there's lots of things.
- 3:30So there's key performance, syndicators, key risk indicators.
- 3:34NCA gives you an exam report.
- 3:36It has key ratios.
- 3:37I do think each board, as they lay out their business plans, they should lay out
- 3:42what are the key performance indicators and key risk indicators bring down.
- 3:47And that strategic plan, you can get really carried away with these, uh,
- 3:52and maybe overburden the community, but you also need to have enough what's
- 3:56going on with each of those risk areas in the organization and how the way to
- 4:01measure your performance against your strategic and business plans within
- 4:05those performance indicators and.
- 4:09I'm a big believer that especially concentration risk is important for
- 4:13most organizations, and I think a lot of organizations, they will have these
- 4:19types of ratios, but they're spread out.
- 4:21I really think to be effective with analco and even for boards of directors,
- 4:25and we've talked about board governance before, that these compliance numbers
- 4:31really need to be put in one spot where people can see them all in one place.
- 4:37Liquidity reports and there's different kinds of liquidity reports.
- 4:41A lot of people use historical measures for liquidity, and I think
- 4:46that's fine for compliance purposes.
- 4:49Uh, for an ALCO type, someone who's responsible for managing
- 4:53liquidity and interest rate risk, they need cash flow forecasts.
- 4:58And especially they need to be looking at them out there three to
- 5:01six months from now, how are we gonna be deploying the funds available
- 5:07to us into loans and investments?
- 5:09How are we gonna be gathering up those deposits?
- 5:11What's our risk of deposits losing what's going on with our borrowed money?
- 5:16Those become very important indicators Then.
- 5:19I'll just throw something else out here.
- 5:21Some alcoves, they will get reports like this from various places.
- 5:26Well, they might generate an in-house cashflow forecast.
- 5:30Their A LM vendor might give them another one.
- 5:32And you'll see some of this with interest rate risk reports too.
- 5:35They'll get 'em from multiple vendors.
- 5:38I'm a big believer there needs to be one version of the truth
- 5:40though in the organization.
- 5:42And which of these reports are you going to use?
- 5:44It's not, let's use this one today.
- 5:46This other one tomorrow, which everyone makes us look good.
- 5:50Let's lay out in policy, which of these reports is gonna
- 5:55be our decision making tool.
- 5:57We can use other reports as a model validation type thing,
- 6:01another source of information.
- 6:03But you do have to be careful that you have one version of the truth going on.
- 6:08We've seen clients written up for this, especially with in their loan portfolio,
- 6:13in their credit risk management.
- 6:15They have different systems giving them different versions of the truth.
- 6:20What does that say about your organization when you have
- 6:23different versions of the truth?
- 6:24It's not looks well, it doesn't necessarily look very well when
- 6:30you have different versions of the truth Inside the organization is
- 6:33cashflow Reports very important.
- 6:36Uh, interest rate risk reports.
- 6:38This is traditionally the role of the alco.
- 6:40How, what does our net interest income and what does our NAV numbers
- 6:44look like under various scenarios?
- 6:47Card unions typically don't do these every month unless you're really large.
- 6:52The quarterly is quite common along the lines with the interest rate
- 6:58risk report at the elco level.
- 7:01Elco members need to have a good general understanding of the model
- 7:04assumptions in those reports.
- 7:07Do they need to see all 2000 of 'em that are in a report?
- 7:10No, but they do need to have a good general understanding which assumptions
- 7:16move the numbers the most, and at least occasionally they need to have
- 7:21some good documentation of what those numbers and those assumptions look like.
- 7:25And that Alco should be actively involved in establishing change control
- 7:29procedures for those um, numbers.
- 7:32It's an important piece and examiners will criticize, uh, credit unions
- 7:38at the Elco level if they don't have a good handle around what
- 7:43those model assumptions might be.
- 7:45Investment portfolios in C'S regulation lays out here is required investment
- 7:51reports tickly those flow to Elco.
- 7:54It's pretty common for Elco to actually be the party that.
- 7:57Step's investment strategy inside that business plan.
- 8:01Based on other things that are going on.
- 8:03There should be some good reports related to that whole investment
- 8:06portfolio and their analysis.
- 8:08Another piece of this, and credit unions will hear this
- 8:11all the time from examiners.
- 8:13They want scenario and sensitivity testing of their models back
- 8:17testing of liquidity models.
- 8:19I think that scenario and sensitivity analysis is an important piece of this.
- 8:25Like I said, members of the Alco committee, they should know which
- 8:29variables will move these numbers the most and which ones they need to pay attention
- 8:34to in terms of their member behavior.
- 8:37The scenario analysis, it's really important for your capital planning
- 8:41and building your whole strategic plan.
- 8:45What does our results look like if A happens or if B happens?
- 8:51Do we wanna have our loan portfolio be 60% real estate and 40% consumer,
- 8:59or do we wanna be a business lender?
- 9:01We're it's 60% business loans and 20% consumer loans and
- 9:0620% residential real estate.
- 9:08Those things make a difference and credit union need to build
- 9:11those into scenario analysis.
- 9:14What happens if.
- 9:15What happens if all these CDs that we've gathered up in the last couple years walk
- 9:21back out the door, we can't replace them.
- 9:24What happens if our whole deposit structure changes?
- 9:28Those types of things should be laid out in scenario analysis, especially as
- 9:32we're building up our business plans.
- 9:34Increasingly, we're seeing, and the examiners ask credit ease to
- 9:38stress test their loan portfolios.
- 9:41This is a new thing.
- 9:43To credit unions, it's not a new thing.
- 9:44In fact, the first time I seen the stress test was way back in the 1990s.
- 9:48They had an egg lender where they had an in-house database where they could
- 9:51actually just change the price of commodities and it would spit out, here's
- 9:56all your farmers that were not gonna make money or make money under this.
- 10:01And that was way back in 1990.
- 10:04Um, so it's not a new thing, but it's new that examiners are increasingly.
- 10:10Asking credit unions to do these stressed and scenario analysis on their
- 10:16loan portfolio, especially if they have concentrations of number business
- 10:20loans, because everyone's reading that commercial real estate buildings
- 10:24are empty or less full than they used to be in certain markets though.
- 10:30But scenario type of testing and analysis, it informs your decision
- 10:35making in a very positive way.
- 10:38Another key part of Alco and sometimes Alco delegates this, but I think Elco
- 10:43really needs to stay on top of it, and that's your pricing decisions, support.
- 10:48How do we price our assets and how are and liabilities and what are we
- 10:53going to use to base that pricing on?
- 10:56Now just about he, Carine will have surveys, what a competitors
- 10:59have for loan and share rates, but.
- 11:02If you follow competitors, you're gonna get their results and
- 11:05their expenses and capital might be very different than yours.
- 11:09So I think you need just a little bit more than that, and it's where,
- 11:13here's an analysis of the yields and returns and our loan portfolio.
- 11:17Here's analysis of our cost of funds, here's our analysis of our
- 11:21borrowing and deposit structure.
- 11:24You don't see this very often, but I think it's very critical
- 11:26is what's our marginal cost.
- 11:29In marginal yields so many times as a problem, case officer and a director
- 11:35of special actions, you get into institutions that have earnings problems.
- 11:39And what you really find out is they've mispriced things, they price things to
- 11:44meet the competition, but it doesn't meet the needs of the institution.
- 11:48And if you go back to the last recession in 2008 before Covid hit.
- 11:53A lot of the folks had problems is because they followed the market in terms
- 11:57of pricing loans in the entire market.
- 11:59Underpriced for risk, and you wanna have control of that decision or not.
- 12:04And cost accounting systems come into this.
- 12:06It really depends on size and complexity, but in general, you need a good pricing
- 12:12decision, support set of reports, whatever that might be for your
- 12:16organization that you need to understand.
- 12:20'cause pricing decisions, even through the last little bit here,
- 12:24when interest rates shot up, a lot of card unions got into some earnings
- 12:29issues for us short period of time.
- 12:31Most of them adjusted pretty well and have adjusted today.
- 12:34But there are still some that are still having some challenging issues
- 12:38with earnings because they made poor pricing decisions in the past.
- 12:43Before that even hit.
- 12:45This isn't in all Alco, but I do think more and more it's becoming a big piece
- 12:50of Alco is they need a comprehensive set of credit risk management reports.
- 12:55Now, do they need to be having discussions at Alco about individual borrowers?
- 12:59No.
- 13:00Should they have a general idea of what's going on in their loan portfolios?
- 13:05Absolutely, yes.
- 13:08How do you build that out so you don't cross the line into getting
- 13:11into the weaves, so to speak?
- 13:14That becomes an individual credit union's kind of challenge, but I do think in
- 13:19general it's very hard for a credit union to manage liquidity and interest
- 13:24rate risk without assessing credit risk.
- 13:27I just don't see how you can manage those two without
- 13:30having a handle on credit risk.
- 13:32Are you worried about an NCUA exam and process or looming on the horizon?
- 13:36Don't face it alone.
- 13:37We're X-N-C-U-A insiders with decades of experience ready to guide you to success.
- 13:43Our team understands the intricacies of NCUA examinations from the inside out.
- 13:47Hire us and gain peace of mind during your exam process.
- 13:51Insider knowledge of NCUA procedures and expectations strategies
- 13:55to address potential issues before they become problems.
- 13:58Continuous access to our extensive subject matter expertise with our access retainer.
- 14:03You'll have on-demand support from former NCUA experts.
- 14:07We're here to ensure your credit union passes your exam with flying colors.
- 14:11Contact Credit Union Exam Solutions today to learn more about our services and how
- 14:17we can help your credit union succeed.
- 14:19But that's Todd Miller's take on Alco and that they need to have control of
- 14:25that credit risk assessment as well.
- 14:28Agendas and minutes are really a key thing.
- 14:32The way I would lay out, what does your agenda in minutes do
- 14:35and what should they accomplish?
- 14:37They should make it really transparent.
- 14:40What you're using to make decisions, the decisions you
- 14:42made, why decisions were made.
- 14:45And if you've got adverse trends, why are you not doing nothing about it?
- 14:51Some credit, ENC, things not going the way they're on.
- 14:54And I, okay, we'll just watch that for a while, but we're
- 14:56not gonna change anything.
- 14:58Your minutes should really be transparent that you.
- 15:01Made that decision intentionally and did so for specific reasons.
- 15:07Um, it, I think a lot of places miss this.
- 15:11They have their agenda.
- 15:12They don't put a thought into it.
- 15:14I think trend reporting is a big piece of this in getting it right.
- 15:19We have one, we have more than one client.
- 15:23They'll rate their risk categories and you should put that on the agenda.
- 15:27Liquidity risk this month, right on the agenda.
- 15:30Moderate, increasing, moderate, stable, high, increasing, high stable.
- 15:35Like really where you spend your time should get dictated by where your risk
- 15:40is at and where your risk is going.
- 15:43Uh, so those are critical things to me and a lot of times when you
- 15:48get issues with examiners question, questioning a credit union decision.
- 15:56It's because as they go through their exam process and they read your minutes
- 16:00and they look at your reports, it's not clear and transparent to them what
- 16:05decisions you made and why you made them.
- 16:08So it, it's critical that you lay out in your minutes, your alco minutes
- 16:14that we made these decisions for these reasons we weren't operating in a vacuum.
- 16:19You can avoid a lot of issues with your examiners.
- 16:22From a board governance perspective, it should be clear and transparent.
- 16:26So if your board picks up these minutes and looks through it,
- 16:29they should be able to understand why you did what you did with the
- 16:32authority they've given you as well.
- 16:34So you don't do it just for the examiners, you do it for the benefit
- 16:39of the organization, and it's the way you keep everyone on the same page.
- 16:45It's really unfortunate.
- 16:46There's a few times.
- 16:48We've been involved with credit unions that end up in court and with the vendor.
- 16:52They end up in court because of a qo.
- 16:54They end up in court because of some investment.
- 16:57Broker did something to them and you start deposing people and it's, they don't
- 17:01remember why and they look at their own minutes and it's, why did you do that?
- 17:04I don't remember.
- 17:06I don't know.
- 17:06That's really not a good place to be in as an organization when you don't understand
- 17:12why you made the decisions you made.
- 17:15So that kind of covers the reporting.
- 17:17I just wanna talk about model risk a little bit in line with the reporting,
- 17:21because a lot of what Alco has done, does and bases their decision on are
- 17:27based on forward-looking models, be that capital forecast, interest rate,
- 17:31risk models, all this scenario stuff we talked about in sensitivity testing.
- 17:36Those are all done as part of forward looking models, credit
- 17:39stresses on your loan portfolio.
- 17:41That's all models.
- 17:43Model risk is something that is a challenge for everyone.
- 17:47I do think for Alco committees, committee members need a general understanding of
- 17:53key assumptions In all of these models, if they're basing decisions on them,
- 17:58they should have a basic understanding.
- 18:00Do they need to be an expert on the model and know everything?
- 18:03No, but they should have a good general understanding.
- 18:07Um, the second piece of this is model validations.
- 18:10And this happens in different places in different size credit unions on
- 18:14some really large credit unions.
- 18:16It's a whole separate function of internal audit and the ERM process.
- 18:22In smaller credit unions, it actually falls a lot of times to the Alco
- 18:26committee itself to validate their own models, and sometimes it's even
- 18:30down to the finance department to just validate their own cash flow forecast.
- 18:35It doesn't really.
- 18:38There's right, there's different answers to who handles model validation
- 18:43in a different size organization.
- 18:45The point I wanna make is community members should be comfortable with
- 18:48efforts made to validate their models.
- 18:51How frequently do we do it within an organization?
- 18:54From a governance perspectives, it can be happening in different departments and be
- 18:59driven by different people, but at the end of the day, the folks using those models
- 19:03to make decisions should be comfortable.
- 19:07With what their organization has done to validate those critical models
- 19:11and make sure they're accurate.
- 19:13That covers most of what I have to say.
- 19:15I think that gives people a good general understanding of things.
- 19:19Maybe any one of these days, you can get another person to do a
- 19:22podcast just on the whole credit risk reporting piece of it, because it
- 19:26can be as big as the other pieces.
- 19:28And I think it's an ever-growing important piece and we see more and more examiners.
- 19:34Want justification for concentration risks, whether that's in your
- 19:38investment portfolio, loan portfolio.
- 19:41NCUA hasn't really talked about liability concentrations, but I guarantee you
- 19:46it will be coming in the future on their part as they get comfortable with
- 19:51their whole concentration risk on the asset side of the balance sheet today.
- 19:57Todd, as you're talking through that, I'm envisioning a couple d, you know,
- 20:01different listeners, not specific people, but someone out for a walk listening
- 20:05to this on their iPhone versus someone sitting at their laptop versus someone
- 20:10driving in their car and they're you.
- 20:13You had so much information packed in there.
- 20:16I know that some of the listeners are gonna go, when I get to my
- 20:18laptop, I need to re-listen to this and I need to take some notes.
- 20:22And when I get to my laptop, I need to forward this episode
- 20:25just to my committee, et cetera.
- 20:27'cause there was just tons of information there.
- 20:29I wrote a lot of different things down.
- 20:31And the listeners can't see this, but you might not even be, if
- 20:34I hold it here, you can see it.
- 20:35I got two different pins.
- 20:37I got a, a black one and a red one.
- 20:38And.
- 20:39As you were talking on some things that I wanted to, I didn't wanna interrupt
- 20:43you 'cause I didn't wanna break your flow 'cause that was fabulous.
- 20:46But I wrote a couple different things down that linked to
- 20:49things that it triggered for me.
- 20:51I'm gonna walk through some of those.
- 20:53I'm gonna ramble with some of those and then you can pivot and see
- 20:56if there's anything that I said that that you wanna respond to.
- 21:00So you talked about stress testing and everybody's hearing
- 21:03that there's empty buildings.
- 21:05And that's a type of commercial load risk and that you need to have better
- 21:08tools that are doing stress testing.
- 21:11And I believe we've given guidance and or NCUA has criticized credit unions that
- 21:18when you're doing that stress testing, you don't wanna just stress commercial
- 21:22over here and then stress real estate, residential real estate over here
- 21:27and then stress your visa over here.
- 21:29Then stress your deposits over here.
- 21:32There needs to be some sort of cascading effect where you might, you might
- 21:38stress two factors or three factors.
- 21:40That was one thing I wanted to mention.
- 21:42And there we, I also wanna mention that we have a separate, you
- 21:46and I did a separate podcast.
- 21:48With the sole topic of model risk.
- 21:52And so if someone is listening and you wanna hear more about what Todd said
- 21:57relative to model risk, I think we probably have a 20 or 30 minute podcast
- 22:01that we did specifically on model risk scenario and sensitivity analysis.
- 22:08I think if I'm linking this right to some of our conversations.
- 22:13We've had situations where a documented resolution or an examiner finding was
- 22:17given to a credit union where they said that you need to update those and you
- 22:21need to be reevaluating those things and careful what you ask for in CA is
- 22:26what we've seen because people have come through this cycle and they have.
- 22:32Reevaluate, uh, what the reality is and then projecting that forward.
- 22:37And I'm gonna get some of this wrong, but I think you're gonna get
- 22:39the point I've trying to make here.
- 22:40But when NCA asked you to do some back testing, that back testing sometimes
- 22:45will actually work the opposite of what NCA thought and your assumptions might.
- 22:49Show that your deposits are more sticky.
- 22:52So that's something that I wanted to throw out there to governance.
- 22:56Many of these things, if any, NCA, you hit on governance at a
- 22:59covered couple different points.
- 23:01We have a separate podcast on governance.
- 23:03We are seeing NCA almost link every examiner fighting.
- 23:07Maybe not examiner fighting, but document resolution If NCA
- 23:09is unhappy about something that happened since the last exam.
- 23:13They seem to always now link it back to corporate governance, which
- 23:17makes some sense in most instances.
- 23:18But it just impresses upon me that the corporate governance is even
- 23:23more important that it's ever been.
- 23:25I've said in another podcast, it almost seems like it's done training
- 23:28on a national level or pointed out that they need to do this 'cause
- 23:31we're seeing it so consistently.
- 23:33And then here's my last comment and then I'll let you respond to any of
- 23:36these that you might might want to What?
- 23:39Going back to what I was actually doing, exams, you go in and.
- 23:42NSU A doesn't do an audit.
- 23:44There's the supervisor committee or the CPA audit, but you'd have
- 23:47your regular trial balance and you'd loans totaled up to $15.24179
- 23:53million, and you'd compare that to the regular loan trial balance.
- 23:58Then you'd have the visa trial balance, which was different.
- 24:01Then you'd have the commercial loan trial balance, which might have been different.
- 24:04Then you might have the real estate loan trial balance, and then on
- 24:08top of that, you've got these.
- 24:10Big systems that credit Union seems to have some time where they, where they're
- 24:15doing analysis and loss analysis, and I don't wanna name particular companies,
- 24:19but there are other vendors out there that will provide these other analysis.
- 24:23And we saw in some situations where an examiner said, Hey, you have all this a
- 24:27LM stuff that says that this loan type is X at the end of March and it's off by.
- 24:35$4,000 on a multimillion dollar program because its purpose
- 24:39isn't to be that trial balance.
- 24:41And in, in that instance, we gave some guidance to this credit union that they
- 24:46might wanna get those a LM reports as of April instead of as, as of March,
- 24:51so that the examiner doesn't try and link it back to their call report.
- 24:54And there's no requirement that those a LM reports be linked.
- 24:58I think you might have said, even you've seen some situations, so there's a lot
- 25:02of workload tied to that for that vendor.
- 25:05The vendor might give you a discount.
- 25:07Not only do you have the avid advantage of NCA, not trying to link
- 25:10it to something that it shouldn't, and that doesn't happen that often.
- 25:13That was really more of a one-off, but all right.
- 25:16Those are the brain dump of what I wrote and read on different things I wanted to
- 25:20mention relative to the notes I have here.
- 25:22Did that any of that trigger any, uh, clarification or follow ups from what I
- 25:26said that you might want to add there?
- 25:27I think I'll respond to all of them just briefly and we will do the last one first.
- 25:33Balancing reports, and this is back to my one version of the truth type thing.
- 25:37You do need within your organization processes to reconcile reports.
- 25:42Now, you might run credit risk, things that might be done at a
- 25:45mid bunt or not a quarter end.
- 25:48You built this workflow in there and most organizations
- 25:52now have large data warehouses.
- 25:54Information is lodged in a couple different places.
- 25:56It might be off a little bit for ER accounting.
- 26:00Reports, and it's probably okay for them to be off a little bit, but examiners
- 26:06just wanna reconcile things to the penny.
- 26:10I mean, that's just a waste of their time when you're in a one or
- 26:15two or a $5 billion organization or even a $500 million organization.
- 26:20But Freddy and themselves should have internal controls to reconcile
- 26:24these different reports and make sure they're appropriate.
- 26:27A LM reports your a LM people capital markets.
- 26:31Who's ever looking at a LM?
- 26:33Uh, I always looked at them and tied them to a balance sheet.
- 26:36The, these roughly look good.
- 26:38Okay.
- 26:39Within, and this happens almost all the time within your loan type codes
- 26:44in your vendors, a LM type codes.
- 26:47Sometimes things just don't map exactly.
- 26:50Small errors never bothered me.
- 26:53Simple things were investment securities where you know exactly what
- 26:57the balance is on exactly that day.
- 27:00Those should tie exactly every time, and it didn't happen often
- 27:04in my career, but it, it did happen once or twice where there were
- 27:08material errors in an A LM model.
- 27:11In some of this was intentional on the part of the card, not giving their vendor
- 27:16actually accurate information about certain items on their balance sheet.
- 27:21NCUA tends to wanna reconcile this stuff to the penny because even though
- 27:26they don't catch very much fraud, it's usually caught other ways by internal
- 27:30audit or an employee writing out another employee or caught by accident.
- 27:35But a lot of times when NCUA does catch fraud, it is because
- 27:39these reports don't reconcile.
- 27:41Or they'll see strange things as they get their share loan download, and that's not
- 27:46tying with a general ledger or there's a.
- 27:49Funky account within that trial balance that's been used to hide errors.
- 27:53So that's why MCUA is sensitive to that issue is because the frauds they have
- 28:00caught, it's been caught for that reason, not the point of our thing here today.
- 28:05We'll go back to sensitivity scenario analysis.
- 28:09You see this a lot in exam reports.
- 28:11They want you to beep up sensitivity scenario analysis.
- 28:14As an Elko though, you need to keep in mind those are two totally separate
- 28:19things, even though examiners often use the words interchangeably.
- 28:26Sensitivity analysis is about determining which factors move
- 28:31those model results the most and which assumptions move it the most.
- 28:35Scenario analysis, you're trying to figure out what could or might
- 28:38happen under different conditions.
- 28:40It's not related to you.
- 28:42Those core basic assumptions at all two very different purposes.
- 28:46We go back to this credit modeling and you mentioned where we stress
- 28:50this credit portfolio, real estate, differently from the consumer, differently
- 28:56from the residential real estate.
- 28:59And yeah, they're done differently, but more and more years theme
- 29:07for credit unions to really justify their capital adequacy.
- 29:11They're almost going down to a capital planning path.
- 29:14And so you get into the ones credit unions and they're over 10 billion.
- 29:18They're required to do this combined stress test and the Federal Reserve even
- 29:22sets the conditions for those stress.
- 29:24And here's what the interest rate scenario's gonna look like.
- 29:27Here's what the economy's gonna look like.
- 29:30Um, those are very technical and very precise, but I think for a lot of
- 29:35credit unions, the scenario analysis and different conation levels.
- 29:39They can do that on a less precise way and probably need to do a combined
- 29:45analysis of some of these stresses to determine if their capital is adequate.
- 29:51You have regulatorily required capital levels.
- 29:55The reality is in many marketplaces, and depending on the way your
- 29:58balance sheet structured is those regulatory capital levels are
- 30:02probably not sufficient for you.
- 30:05To be competitive and optimal.
- 30:07You serve your members, you're gonna need more capital than that
- 30:10regulatory capital in the real world.
- 30:13And as your competitors have more capital, you're gonna need more
- 30:16capital to keep up with them.
- 30:18Yeah.
- 30:19And capital planning is a necessary part of every organization.
- 30:25And.
- 30:26I can see a day where these required tests for 10 billion getting moved
- 30:30down to credit unions at 5 billion, and examiners are gonna start wanting
- 30:34people at 1 billion to do it, even though the reg might not require it.
- 30:38It's just an evolution that examiners go through where best practices, they tend
- 30:44to filter it down to smaller and smaller organizations, and I don't necessarily
- 30:49see that as a bad thing in many ways.
- 30:53It's a good thing.
- 30:54And I just started out the whole thing.
- 30:55Large organizations have committee charters and small organizations put
- 30:59it in policy, and I said, even these small organizations, you should think
- 31:02about having committee charters.
- 31:04So it's just a natural evolution of things.
- 31:07So I think more and more you're gonna see examiners push organizations of
- 31:12all size to go to a comprehensive capital planning type, and we
- 31:17help people out with some of that.
- 31:19You see it consistently in exam reports.
- 31:22They want support for concentration risk, which is really another way to say,
- 31:26prove you have enough capital to do this, which is the, uh, other side of the coin.
- 31:30Which words do you use?
- 31:32Prove you have enough capital or prove you can support your concentration risk?
- 31:35It's the same question, just different sides to it.
- 31:39Did I hit all the points you had written down there and you did.
- 31:45You did fabulous.
- 31:46Yeah.
- 31:46You hit 'em all.
- 31:47I have different color pens too and I have notes and I always say I'm gonna check
- 31:51off on my notes when I address something.
- 31:53But I get talking and I never do.
- 31:55So I make and then I just don't really look at very much star he are podcast
- 32:01that, that just makes me smile too.
- 32:03'cause it reminds me of my dad.
- 32:05I used to go to a lot of race horse races with my dad.
- 32:09He had the daily racing form and he had four different colored highlighters
- 32:12and he had three different colored pens and everyone meant something.
- 32:16And then you'd get there, you'd do all your handicapping, which is
- 32:19almost as fun as going to the race.
- 32:21And then you'd get there and you'd see the odds and you'd do something different.
- 32:25Then you'd go back and you'd look at in blue, he, he said he wanted blue as his
- 32:30top horse, for example, in each race.
- 32:32And then you only went with that like half the time.
- 32:34You'd go home and you'd do the debrief of the, all that color coding and,
- 32:38and you'd realize that you were onto something you just needed to
- 32:41follow with your convictions and the assumptions you had going in.
- 32:43So that's a total sack word to this.
- 32:46But all that color code made me think of that.
- 32:48So that made my heart smile.
- 32:49Alright, Todd, so what else as we wrap this up, is there any final
- 32:53thoughts you wanna make relative to, to what we've discussed here?
- 32:56No, I think we'll just go reiterate something at the beginning.
- 32:59There's no one right answer for all of this that you're trying to
- 33:03accomplish the same general things, but really you make all this fit in
- 33:07work within your corporate culture.
- 33:09It's all part of your corporate culture.
- 33:12You build this around the knowledge, skills, and abilities of your staff and.
- 33:16A good reason to do this and have this in a very formal way is it
- 33:21improves the knowledge, skills, and abilities of the rest of your staff.
- 33:25And I guess that kind of leads to one thing that examiners do bring this
- 33:28up occasionally, is it's important to continue the training of all your staff.
- 33:33That they have ongoing training and various areas that they're responsible for
- 33:38listening to our podcast as part of that.
- 33:40But um, that's right.
- 33:41That's right.
- 33:42That is an important piece for and be members, and it's an important piece
- 33:46for any organization that you dedicate resources to improving those knowledge,
- 33:52skills, abilities of your staff members.
- 33:54Fantastic.
- 33:55This is gonna be an instant classic episode.
- 33:57I got a feeling that, uh, that people are again, gonna wanna
- 34:00listen to this more than once.
- 34:01There's a lot of really good advice and counsel in this and I, I wanna
- 34:06thank you for your time today, Todd.
- 34:07It was my pleasure, mark.
- 34:08I enjoyed doing these.
- 34:10These are fun.
- 34:11These are very fun and listeners, I want to thank you for listening.
- 34:14I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 34:16This is Mark TriCal signing off with Flying Colors.