Latest / Quantum Potential / Psychologist David Yeager on What it Takes to Motivate Young People
Transcript
- 0:05Because a good mentor isn't just helping you in that moment, they're preparing you for future adversity, future challenges.
- 0:12Like, after you leave our care, are you prepared to continue to do things that are hard with resilience?
- 0:18And so they have to own the thinking.
- 0:20They have to be able to tell themselves the better story.
- 0:23And the more you care for someone who's suffering or vulnerable, the more tempted you are to tell them what to do.
- 0:43Welcome to "Quantum Potential," a podcast dedicated to curiosity and discovery.
- 0:48My name is Cybele Raver, and I serve as the provost of Vanderbilt University.
- 0:52As a leader in higher education and as a social scientist, I believe that we can transform higher education for the 21st century.
- 0:59At my core, I am wildly curious about other people's work, whether it's in science, the social sciences, the humanities or the arts.
- 1:08This podcast gives us the opportunity to break open new ideas through discovery and creative expression.
- 1:21Welcome, David.
- 1:22It's really exciting to have you.
- 1:24You're a renowned social scientist and thinker.
- 1:27You are a professor of psychology at the University of Texas at Austin and a co-founder of the Texas Behavioral Science and Policy Institute.
- 1:34You are best known, I think, for your work conducted with Carol Dweck and Angela Duckworth and Greg Walton on these incredibly short but powerful interventions— um, these mindset interventions that influence adolescent behaviors, whether it's in motivation, engagement, healthy eating, dealing with issues of bullying, stress, mental health and more.
- 1:54But I think what's also really cool is that you leverage that intellectual powerhouse knowledge in the private sector, in the corporate sector to really accelerate the way that those ideas are put into the world.
- 2:05You've partnered and consulted with Google, Microsoft, Disney and the World Bank— as well as with the White House and the government leadership in California, Texas and Norway.
- 2:16And apologies to Norway for pitching it in with states, but um, I just think it's really impressive to think about that.
- 2:23Texans think of Texas as a peer with nations.
- 2:25There you go.
- 2:26So.
- 2:27Your work has been featured in "The New York Times Magazine," "The New York Times," "The Wall Street Journal,""Scientific American," CNN, Fox News, "The Guardian," "The Atlantic." I think one of the benefits of that span of, uh, types of outlets is to show how incredibly appealing and engaging these ideas are to so many different constituencies across the political spectrum.
- 2:46Um, you have been ranked as the top point-one percent— that's one-tenth of 1%—uh, of most influential scientists in the world in the past decade.
- 2:57And, um, you've also been a middle school teacher and a basketball coach.
- 3:01And I love that you draw all of those strengths, including your training as, uh, Ph.D. and a master student at Stanford and your undergraduate degree, uh, and your master's in, uh, education from the University of Notre Dame— 55 You draw all of those strengths, um, for the work that you do.
- 3:21I really can't thank you enough for bringing that to all of us.
- 3:25Before we get into my talking about how much I love your work, I'd love you to read from the book, from "10 to 25," to give our audience a little snapshot of how great this framing is and how useful it might be for going forward.
- 3:42It seems like everywhere you turn, you hear older adults—Gen Xers, Millennials and Boomers—describing young people today in dark and despairing terms.
- 3:52In my 18 years as a developmental scientist and 13 years as a parent, I've heard it in the bleachers at my kids' games, in the boardrooms of major corporations I've consulted for and by the water coolers at schools I've visited:"They just don't care.
- 4:06They speak a different language.
- 4:08They're entitled.
- 4:09They're too sensitive." But imagine a world in which older adults interact with young people age 10 to 25 in ways that reliably leave the next generation feeling inspired, enthusiastic and ready to contribute— rather than disengaged, outraged, worried or overwhelmed.
- 4:29In this world, managers' work will be easier because their younger employees will be motivated and self-sufficient.
- 4:35Parents will be happier because they won't have to dread their children turning into teenagers.
- 4:40Educators will feel more successful and less burned out because they can reach a stressed-out or disengaged generation of young people.
- 4:48And all of us will be able to bridge the divide between the generations with confidence and without starting a war of words.
- 4:55I've seen this world in the lives of great managers, parents, educators and coaches.
- 5:00I've studied what they do and how they talk.
- 5:03I've used the scientific method: hypothesis, experiment, data, results, to understand why they're effective.
- 5:10I've used the scientific method: I wrote this book because I wanna share the secrets of what I've learned.
- 5:15I've used the scientific method: This book is for anyone who wants to experience this better world firsthand in their interactions with young people age 10 to 25.
- 5:22I've used the scientific method: It shows how to stop clashing with the next generation and start inspiring them.
- 5:31I've used the scientific method: I mean, there's so many ways that that speaks to me personally, that speaks to me as a leader, that speaks to our values in this institution at Vanderbilt.
- 5:39I've used the scientific method: And I just am so excited to dive into those strategies.
- 5:43I've used the scientific method: But first, I just wanna step back for a second, um, because one thing I love about your work is that you provide this incredibly compelling new way to think about the brain.
- 5:54I've used the scientific method: Um, and you give us this fresh take on, uh, the way that we think about adolescents' brain development.
- 5:59I've used the scientific method: And I have to say, you kind of call out those of us who are guilty of talking about, um, the way in which adolescents' brains might not be functioning the right way, right?
- 6:10I've used the scientific method: So, you know, the good old prefrontal cortex, executive function— the part of our brains that does decision making and remembering rules, which we really want kids to do, and using those rules to make good decisions and to ...
- 6:22I've used the scientific method: to wait before they, you know, look before they leap—all of those things.
- 6:26I've used the scientific method: We've had this problem where we've thought about that as less mature, um, which explains why adolescents and young adults can sometimes do things that we don't really want them to do.
- 6:37I've used the scientific method: But in many ways we've ended up telling a story of these sort of wild kids with these hyperactive amygdalas who are driven by their emotions.
- 6:44I've used the scientific method: Kind of this idea of, you know, a driver behind a fast car with all that acceleration and no brake.
- 6:50I've used the scientific method: And you totally reframe that by talking about this tiny, wonderful part of the brain called the nucleus accumbens and how sensitive the nucleus accumbens is to testosterone and other pubertal hormones.
- 7:02I've used the scientific method: So before we jump into mindsets, which I know is where we're gonna go, help us understand why this part of the brain in young adulthood and, uh, even in, you know, 10 year olds from 10 to 25 is, is so hyperactive or hypersensitive or so, uh, sort of alert to signals, um, that matter to those young adults and those kids.
- 7:22I've used the scientific method: Yeah.
- 7:22I've used the scientific method: I mean, I, I was amazed when I started looking into this literature how much the narrative has changed, really, in the last 15 years.
- 7:30I've used the scientific method: I mean, and I've so much respect for your work.
- 7:32I've used the scientific method: I, I was once asked if I could pick any colleague in any psychology department, who would it be?
- 7:37And the answer I told my chair: you.
- 7:40And the answer I told my chair: I've deep admiration for you and your work so thank you for having me on your show.
- 7:44And the answer I told my chair: Super kind.
- 7:44And the answer I told my chair: Um, I spent a lot of time talking to my neuroscience friends, uh, Ron Dahl and Adriana Galvan, who, as you know, were a part of this movement to try to understand neuroscience and apply it originally in legal settings.
- 7:59And the answer I told my chair: So the dilemma about 20 years ago, 25 years ago, was that young people, when they would commit extreme crimes, would be either sentenced to death or life without parole.
- 8:10And the answer I told my chair: And, um, this disproportionately affected youth of color.
- 8:14And the answer I told my chair: So there's a whole social justice concern.
- 8:17And the answer I told my chair: And so the, the network of scholars said, "Let's take what we think we know about neuroscience, and then let's give an argument for why that shouldn't be the case.
- 8:27And the answer I told my chair: Why shouldn't we lock up a 16-year-old for the rest of their lives?" And the, the distillation of the science was that, kind of, they can't help themselves.
- 8:36And the answer I told my chair: Their prefrontal cortex isn't fully developed.
- 8:38And the answer I told my chair: They have no self-control.
- 8:39And the answer I told my chair: They're, and so they're committing a heinous crime, but it's not really them, and they'll grow out of it, so therefore there's no point in keeping them behind bars forever.
- 8:46And the answer I told my chair: That's a summary, but it's more or less the argument.
- 8:49And the answer I told my chair: And that had a ... a substantial effect.
- 8:52And the answer I told my chair: So there were three different Supreme Court cases that then outlawed a lot of these, um, extreme and irreversible sentences for youth criminal offenders.
- 9:00And the answer I told my chair: The issue is that that same argument could be applied to lots of other decisions.
- 9:05And the answer I told my chair: Well, if they can't control their actions, then maybe teenagers shouldn't have the right to birth control.
- 9:10And the answer I told my chair: Maybe they shouldn't be able to decide who they date.
- 9:13And the answer I told my chair: If their brains are still developing till 25, maybe they shouldn't be voting, maybe they shouldn't have a car.
- 9:18And the answer I told my chair: So there's kind of, like, this application of that logic that was kind of an issue.
- 9:22And the answer I told my chair: And so this, a lot of the scientists started saying, "Well, no, no, no, no.
- 9:26And the answer I told my chair: That's not really what we meant." And but around the same time, changes in technology allowed for different kinds of studies.
- 9:33And the answer I told my chair: So the original studies where you would just show activation in the prefrontal cortex, activation in, like, the nucleus accumbens, and then it seemed as though the activation was greater among adolescents or those high in testosterone, et cetera, in the nucleus accumbens.
- 9:50And the answer I told my chair: And so there was this mismatch between the appetitve part of the brain and the self-control part.
- 9:55And the answer I told my chair: But later studies were able to look at connectivity and how those two regions were talking to each other—not just whether they were lighting up or not.
- 10:03And the answer I told my chair: And this started in animals, and then the humans, and the connectivity studies revealed that the pathways went the exact opposite of what they thought.
- 10:11And the answer I told my chair: So the classic Greek idea, right— and you can read this in Plato and"The Phaedrus"—is that the rational, logical part of the brain makes kind of abstract plans and then tells the emotional part to cool it, Right. Top down, right?
- 10:24And the answer I told my chair: Yeah.
- 10:25And the answer I told my chair: Yeah.
- 10:25And the answer I told my chair: It's the top down, uh, control.
- 10:27And the answer I told my chair: Executive tells the worker.
- 10:28And the answer I told my chair: The executive tells the front-line associate, right?
- 10:30And the answer I told my chair: Right.
- 10:31And the answer I told my chair: And, um, that's ... that is, is not really the direction in adolescents.
- 10:37And the answer I told my chair: It's really more that the appetitive, desire part of the brain is telling the prefrontal cortex what it wants, and then the prefrontal cortex has to figure out how to get what it wants.
- 10:48And the answer I told my chair: Right.
- 10:49And the answer I told my chair: So the ... so what Adriana Galvan...
- 10:51And the answer I told my chair: I think you give the example of an adolescent who figures out how to sneak out of a window to be able to meet up with friends, even though the parents have said they do not want the ... that kid outside.
- 11:01And the answer I told my chair: Right.
- 11:01And the answer I told my chair: So, yeah, like, like Adriana Galvan always says that, that the prefrontal cortex is for goal-directed behavior.
- 11:06And the answer I told my chair: ...
- 11:07And the answer I told my chair: Teenagers are very good at goal-directed behaviors, it's just not the goals that adults often want them to be pursuing.
- 11:12And the answer I told my chair: Adults want them to be factoring worksheets of trinomials and balancing stoichiometric equations, and teenagers want to, like, look awesome in front of their friends. Right.
- 11:21And the answer I told my chair: And so like, it's not like they can't plan for the ... I mean, a teenager who makes an elaborate plan to impress someone that they have a crush on, right, they might stay up all night practicing guitar for months and months, right?
- 11:33And the answer I told my chair: That's a lot of self-control.
- 11:35And the answer I told my chair: That just basic insight suggests that this simple model of "they lack of prefrontal cortex, therefore they cannot make wise decisions about their future"—that is overly simplistic.
- 11:45And the answer I told my chair: Instead, it's "What are they motivated by and when do they marshal ...
- 11:49And the answer I told my chair: when do they, when do they start using that, that valuable resource of the prefrontal cortex in order to achieve goals?" And I didn't write about this in the book, but if you look at basic IQ tests like the Ravens, right, human intelligence peaks between 18 and 23.
- 12:04And the answer I told my chair: This is the smartest we'll ever be, right, on fluid intelligence tests.
- 12:08And the answer I told my chair: But how many people in this room are like, "I made the best decisions when I was in college"?
- 12:12And the answer I told my chair: Right.
- 12:13And the answer I told my chair: Right?
- 12:13And the answer I told my chair: Right.
- 12:14And the answer I told my chair: So, like, smartness is very different from judgment and decision-making, and it's because judgment and decision- making is in ... in reference to a goal that we have and something we wanna accomplish.
- 12:23And the answer I told my chair: Right.
- 12:23And the answer I told my chair: And I think the beauty of that moment in the book is that you then pivot to help me, both as a leader and a parent, see that what's really motivating a student is social prestige, status and a sense of respect, right, from me, the adult.
- 12:39And the answer I told my chair: So that when I put my kid in a high-stakes situation, I think I am navigating that in a thoughtful and regularly and normative way.
- 12:48And the answer I told my chair: But from the other, from the younger brain's perspective, it's a, it's a test as to whether I respect that kid, or whether I'm showing them enough recognition of their authority, right?
- 13:01And the answer I told my chair: So I'd just love you to talk about the nucleus accumbens in that regard, in terms of this notion of, of status and hierarchy.
- 13:07And the answer I told my chair: There's a certain kind of learning that that is driven by pubertal maturation— specifically around achieving social goals.
- 13:14And the answer I told my chair: And in a lot of the animal studies, they find that if you stop the pubertal process, ... you don't get this kind of extreme social learning.
- 13:22And the answer I told my chair: There's beautiful song, there's studies of songbirds that I really like.
- 13:26And the answer I told my chair: So, um, the most important thing to do as a teenager, if you're a songbird, like a cardinal or whatever, is to practice and perfect the song that will attract a mate.
- 13:35And the answer I told my chair: And so pubertal hormones cause this, like, obsessive, over-the-top practicing—like the teenager practicing guitar all night in order to impress somebody, right?
- 13:45And the answer I told my chair: And if you stop puberty, then they practice a little bit, but you don't get the obsessive kind of repetitive practice. And then they die alone, right?
- 13:53And the answer I told my chair: Wow.
- 13:53And the answer I told my chair: They never attract a mate.
- 13:55And the answer I told my chair: And then they, and then they're just not Evolution failed.
- 13:57And the answer I told my chair: Yeah.
- 13:57And the answer I told my chair: Right there.
- 13:57And the answer I told my chair: Yeah, exactly.
- 13:58And the answer I told my chair: Yeah.
- 13:58And the answer I told my chair: And so we, that ... there's a version of the story that's, like, we often characterize testosterone as this male dominance or sex or aggression or violence or whatever.
- 14:09And the answer I told my chair: But testosterone goes up in both men and women and ... along with other gonadal hormones like estradiol, and they sensitize the brain to social feelings like the, the thrill of getting admired or the pain of being humiliated.
- 14:44And the answer I told my chair: In all mammals, as puberty happens, you're hypersensitized to social information.
- 14:48And the answer I told my chair: And in humans, we have these more complex emotions like pride and shame and humiliation.
- 14:53And the answer I told my chair: That, that it's not just you're sensitive to them, you're sensitive to them because you're trying to learn how to be a socially successful person.
- 14:59And the answer I told my chair: And the rules for social success are subtle, and they're negotiated, and you have to and and there's no manual for being socially successful in your milieu.
- 15:09And the answer I told my chair: So you have to infer it from subtle clues that are not hyper-clear.
- 15:14And the answer I told my chair: And that is the job of adolescents, is they need to be able to walk in a room and like, "Who is at risk of humiliating me?" Like "Who is at risk of elevating me?" You know, "Where is social danger?
- 15:25And the answer I told my chair: Where is social support?" They have to be able to do that instantly, right?
- 15:30And the answer I told my chair: But what that means is they're overactive in searching for meaning in very subtle social cues.
- 15:36And the answer I told my chair: And that meaning that they derive as they observe the social world may not be what the people in power were intending, right?
- 15:43And the answer I told my chair: So an adult might, uh, like a teacher might have a very rigorous and regimented, disciplined seating arrangement, and they try to separate the kids that're gonna screw around or whatever.
- 15:52And the answer I told my chair: And the adult has the goal of helping everyone learn by avoiding the kids that are gonna goof off, right?
- 16:00And the answer I told my chair: So in their mind they're like, "I'm helping you in your future because of this." But from the kid's perspective, it might be, "This is, like, a totalitarian lunatic that is just yelling at ..." How dare you?
- 16:10And the answer I told my chair: ... you for no reason." Right?
- 16:11And the answer I told my chair: "And how dare you tell me where I should sit socially because now you're imposing your rules and values on what's a personal choice for me." Such a great example, you know?
- 16:20And the answer I told my chair: I mean, who in this room hasn't been in that moment where you're like, "I had no idea" right,"that the thing I just did or said or asked is being interpreted in this way that is triggering a very strong sense of being on opposite sides.
- 16:33And the answer I told my chair: Rather than I'm working together to achieve a, a shared goal," right?
- 16:37And the answer I told my chair: Yeah.
- 16:37And the answer I told my chair: And, and what's ... what's frustrating for adults is we often do have the best interest of the young person at heart.
- 16:44And the answer I told my chair: Uh, but we're not hyper transparent about it, and so we, we leave important things unsaid.
- 16:50And the answer I told my chair: But because they're ... young people are used to that status difference of us looking down on— or this parenting coach I interview, she always says, "yell, tell, blame and shame," that's like a default mode for many adults that are concerned about order and discipline, et cetera— kids will presume that that's what we're doing unless we're clear.
- 17:09And the answer I told my chair: And there's, I talk about this study that I love that my colleague Ron Dahl collaborated on. Jennifer Hill had an R1— she was studying maternal depression, so, moms and daughters.
- 17:20And the answer I told my chair: And as a part of this bigger study, they bring the moms and daughters in the lab and ... actually just bring the daughters. The moms prerecord themselves nagging the daughters.
- 17:30And the answer I told my chair: Okay, so they're doing the yell, tell, blame and shame.
- 17:33And the answer I told my chair: It's ... it's what I call "grown-splaining," and I'm now going to mansplain "grown-splaining" to you.
- 17:38And the answer I told my chair: Go for it.
- 17:38And the answer I told my chair: It's the idea that, like, you've pieced everything, all the good choices out in your mind with your smart adult brain, and then their dumb adolescent brain doesn't know anything.
- 17:49And the answer I told my chair: And we convince ourselves, "If only I could, like, share the contents of my smart brain and transmit it to yours, then you would make wise decisions.
- 17:57And the answer I told my chair: And the fact that you don't listen to me means you're recalcitrant, you're rebellious, you're entitled," or whatever it is.
- 18:04And the answer I told my chair: And so they brought the kids in the lab, and the moms were grown- splaining and nagging on audio.
- 18:11And the answer I told my chair: And then the teenage daughters are there, and there's a big magnet whirring around their heads, And then they've got the earphones on and the question is, "What happens in the brain when you're listening to your mom nag you?" Okay, so here's what happened zero percent of the time.
- 18:25And the answer I told my chair: What never happened was the daughter was, like,"You know, Mom, you have a point.
- 18:30And the answer I told my chair: It sounds like a ...
- 18:32And the answer I told my chair: ... uh, I'm really glad for this long list of personal flaws that you've, you've raised.
- 18:37And the answer I told my chair: Um, I've got some homework to do.
- 18:38And the answer I told my chair: I'm gonna make a plan, and I'll get back to you.
- 18:41And the answer I told my chair: So good chat." So that never happened once. Instead, what you see is this dramatic increase in regions of the brain associated with intense emotions, so the inference is that they're angry.
- 18:53And the answer I told my chair: A dramatic decrease in ... in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex region—associated with planning, how to change your behavior.
- 18:59And the answer I told my chair: Probably the most interesting is a decrease in the temporo-parietal junction.
- 19:03And the answer I told my chair: So this is the social cognition part of the brain.
- 19:05And the answer I told my chair: This is, like, basically, are they inferring the good intentions that the mom was bringing with all of the words?
- 19:13And the answer I told my chair: Or are they attending to the literal part of the words and assuming that it's just negative and harsh and all these other things?
- 19:20And the answer I told my chair: And then you see dramatic reduction in that, so the kids aren't sitting there saying,"What does my mom really want when she's telling me that my room is a mess and it's no good and I'm lazy?" Like, like they're not saying, "Oh, that means I should go proactively clean my room," right?
- 19:35And the answer I told my chair: That's an inference you have to make.
- 19:36And the answer I told my chair: The TPJ is shut off, they're not doing that.
- 19:39And the answer I told my chair: And what it suggests is that a lot of times adolescents are motivated for the status and respect, we communicate in ways that threaten it, and therefore we shut off --- we... we cause them to disengage.
- 19:52And the answer I told my chair: And I love that, right?
- 19:53And the answer I told my chair: That that, you know, often we inadvertently trigger an experience of threat when we meant to trigger an experience of collaboration, right?
- 20:03And the answer I told my chair: And so I'd love to pivot there and have you really then share the solution, right?
- 20:09And the answer I told my chair: This interesting, you know, you are just describing what you call the enforcer, sort of, approach to top-down management, right?
- 20:17And the answer I told my chair: Or alternately, the protector is never, you know, even venturing into the space of trying to shape or support your young person's, you know, activities and experiences because you, you are so afraid or so stressed out by the likelihood that they won't meet those expectations, right?
- 20:33And the answer I told my chair: And then you have this really beautiful mentor, uh, approach that's, you know, the sweet spot in the middle.
- 20:39And the answer I told my chair: So just give us a little bit of a color commentary on that to help us understand those three ways that, um, we as older adults are approaching working with, um, children and young adults that can really kind of provide more transparency and more support so that we don't activate all that threat.
- 20:55And the answer I told my chair: Yeah.
- 20:55And the answer I told my chair: So I'll ... I'll say the framework, then I just want to share how I came to it ...
- 20:59And the answer I told my chair: Great.
- 20:59And the answer I told my chair: ... in my process.
- 21:00And the answer I told my chair: So the framework is, basically, a lot of people think you have two choices, that you're either tough, high standards, demanding, expecting a lot—negative side effect, you're an authoritarian sadist, right?
- 21:14And the answer I told my chair: But that's the price of doing business if you have high standards.
- 21:17And the answer I told my chair: Or you're nice, caring, friendly, supportive—negative side effect, you're a wimp or a pushover.
- 21:23And the answer I told my chair: And so it feels like you have two bad options.
- 21:26And the answer I told my chair: Right?
- 21:26And the answer I told my chair: And you didn't prepare your child correctly for the world.
- 21:29And the answer I told my chair: Yeah.
- 21:29And the answer I told my chair: They're a student or your People living in a cocoon their whole life.
- 21:31And the answer I told my chair: Soft bigotry of low expectation.
- 21:33And the answer I told my chair: Right.
- 21:33And the answer I told my chair: Exactly.
- 21:34And the answer I told my chair: Right.
- 21:34And the answer I told my chair: Right.
- 21:34And the answer I told my chair: So there's that idea and, and it feels like we just have, uh, two tough choices, right?
- 21:40And the answer I told my chair: And you can look in our popular culture and you see these prototypes, right?
- 21:45And the answer I told my chair: You see the kindergarten teacher that loves and cares for every kid, even though if they can't hold a pencil.
- 21:50And the answer I told my chair: And then you have like the ... the high school principal roaming the hallways of the inner-city school with a baseball bat ... Right.
- 21:56And the answer I told my chair: ... threatening everybody.
- 21:57And the answer I told my chair: Yeah.
- 21:57And the answer I told my chair: And you talk a lot about movies that, that really reinforce that, that tough... Yeah ... tough love image, right?
- 22:03And the answer I told my chair: Those are the, those are our mental models that many people, if you're a teacher, you enter, I have to pick one of those.
- 22:08And the answer I told my chair: If you're a high school football coach, you know, which one am I going to be?
- 22:12And the answer I told my chair: Certainly as a parent, the parenting coach I interview
- 22:17calls it the "nice and nasty dance": That we're, like, we yell and tell and blame, and then we feel guilty, And then we're overly permissive, and then the kids act out and then we go back to the first one.
- 22:25calls it the "nice and nasty dance": And so what the ... the first basic principle that I'd argue is that there's not one axis with two poles.
- 22:33It's like two orthogonal axes: One is standards, one is support.
- 22:34It's like two orthogonal axes: And you can have very high standards and very high support, and that's what I call the mentor mindset.
- 22:42It's like two orthogonal axes: And you can also have different errors.
- 22:45It's like two orthogonal axes: So one error is exceptionally high standards but no support.
- 22:49It's like two orthogonal axes: And that's what I call the enforcer mindset.
- 22:51It's like two orthogonal axes: That's the idea that, for instance, the society is unruly, kids are a danger to themselves, they're about to get out of hand, that, you know, society's going to hell in a handbasket.
- 23:03It's like two orthogonal axes: Chaos is around the corner, and therefore I just have to enforce strict discipline and rules, and the way I can get kids to protect themselves from danger is extreme threats of punishment or maybe bribes.
- 23:16It's like two orthogonal axes: But I'm not, I don't have a presumption that there's any internalized motivation that can be unlocked in the young person, tt has to be external control.
- 23:23It's like two orthogonal axes: And what you end up seeing in enforcer world is a few people maybe meet the standard, but they're the kind of people who already had so many resources that they were going to be fine no matter what.
- 23:33It's like two orthogonal axes: So they succeed despite the leader or the mentor, not because of the leader or mentor.
- 23:38It's like two orthogonal axes: And so you see massive inequalities in enforcer-type classrooms or organizations.
- 23:43It's like two orthogonal axes: Protector is the opposite error—very low standards, very high support.
- 23:47It's like two orthogonal axes: So that's, I'm loving, I'm caring.
- 23:49It's like two orthogonal axes: And that we ... we learn comes from a belief that young people are, that they've experienced toxic stress.
- 23:57It's like two orthogonal axes: They've maybe gone through trauma.
- 23:59It's like two orthogonal axes: They have all the ACEs, or they just went through COVID or anxiety epidemic, their brains are addicted to screens.
- 24:05It's like two orthogonal axes: It's just, like, we pathologize them, and we conclude weakness.
- 24:10It's like two orthogonal axes: And because they're weak and feeble, it would be cruel for me to have high standards and expect something of them because they can never do it.
- 24:18It's like two orthogonal axes: And so I just resign myself to them knowing at least I care about them, right?
- 24:23It's like two orthogonal axes: They put their head on their pillow and know I love them, even though I've expected nothing of them.
- 24:27It's like two orthogonal axes: And I love that in the interviews that you have with students, students basically check out.
- 24:31It's like two orthogonal axes: They're like, since this is not gonna yield anything other than, you know, care.
- 24:36It's like two orthogonal axes: And since we don't even really believe this person believes in us, we're just going to take over the classroom and completely ignore the teacher, right?
- 24:43It's like two orthogonal axes: Yeah.
- 24:44It's like two orthogonal axes: Yeah.
- 24:44It's like two orthogonal axes: And the alternative to these is the mentor mindset, which is very high standards, very high support.
- 24:48It's like two orthogonal axes: And the way I tried to characterize that was I tried to find people who, through whatever metrics, they didn't have this dilemma of communicating with young people that I've described so far.
- 25:01It's like two orthogonal axes: That for whatever reason, when they walk in a room, they command respect and they give respect and young people feel taken seriously and so on.
- 25:09It's like two orthogonal axes: And so, uh, I found a lot of different exemplars.
- 25:12It's like two orthogonal axes: One was this guy who's Texas's best high school physics teacher.
- 25:17It's like two orthogonal axes: His name is Sergio Estrada.
- 25:19It's like two orthogonal axes: Awesome.
- 25:19It's like two orthogonal axes: And we did a statistical analysis.
- 25:21It's like two orthogonal axes: There's a network of, of educators in Texas called On-Ramps.
- 25:24It's like two orthogonal axes: So this is dual enrollment, so it's high school teachers teaching the real UT physics classes, OK? So Mike Marder, a famous physicist, developed freshman physics at UT Austin.
- 25:36It's like two orthogonal axes: Yes, the real deal.
- 25:36It's like two orthogonal axes: Keivan Stassun ...
- 25:37It's like two orthogonal axes: Yeah.
- 25:37It's like two orthogonal axes: ... real-deal physics.
- 25:38It's like two orthogonal axes: It'd be like, it'd be like 500 high school teachers across Tennessee teaching Keivan's freshman physics class, right?
- 25:44It's like two orthogonal axes: And so, but what's nice is that their exams are graded by the UT professors in, uh, baseline in September and May.
- 25:50It's like two orthogonal axes: So we can calculate a value-added score for every single teacher in the network.
- 25:54It's like two orthogonal axes: And then also, kids complete surveys.
- 25:56It's like two orthogonal axes: So we triangulate both value-added— so do you, do your kids learn more than you would expect based on their demographics—
- 26:03and classroom culture: Do kids feel respected?
- 26:05and classroom culture: Are they motivated?
- 26:05and classroom culture: Are they engaged?
- 26:06and classroom culture: So you find those people.
- 26:08and classroom culture: And we found 20 of them, and we brought them to Austin, and we had a workshop facilitated by this Stassun-like calculus professor named Uri Treisman, who's a legendary MacArthur-winning calculus professor.
- 26:23and classroom culture: And so he had intuition about great teaching, so he helped us pull it out.
- 26:28and classroom culture: At any rate, among those 20, the best was this guy named Sergio Estrada.
- 26:32and classroom culture: It would be like if Buddha taught high school physics.
- 26:35and classroom culture: Like, everything he said was so wise and just calm and with this amazing and just, like, the most profound ...
- 26:42and classroom culture: Awesome.
- 26:42and classroom culture: ... insight into kids.
- 26:43and classroom culture: And so after that—this is March of, of February of 2020, so right before the pandemic hit.
- 26:49and classroom culture: And then for the first two years of the pandemic, Carol Dweck and I called him on Fridays on his off period.
- 26:55and classroom culture: And I, I know you've spent a lot of time in low- income urban public schools— in a lot of these schools, kids are just wandering around, all the time.
- 27:03and classroom culture: And the reason why is because after 15 and a half, they don't even have to go to school because truancy court, they all know, takes six months.
- 27:11and classroom culture: And so kids just stop going.
- 27:12and classroom culture: They're head ... they're headed on their way out anyway.
- 27:14and classroom culture: And so, so the school's happy to even have them at the school.
- 27:17and classroom culture: And so anyway, low-income, low-achieving kids in low-income high schools end up wandering into the only classroom where they feel safe because most adults are yelling at them all the time, or ignoring them.
- 27:29and classroom culture: And so Sergio would have, like, 30 kids, like, you know, parents from Mexico, like kids, you know...
- 27:36and classroom culture: Everybody, at random ...
- 27:37and classroom culture: All, all this stuff.
- 27:38and classroom culture: ... not assigned to AP physics, just happening to be.
- 27:41and classroom culture: They would just wander in his classroom.
- 27:42and classroom culture: Yeah.
- 27:42and classroom culture: And sometimes I would be like,"What, what does Mr. Estrada do?" And they would tell me these unbelievable stories.
- 27:48and classroom culture: And then I would start asking like,"Who's the opposite of Mr. Estrada?" And then I got some really good stories.
- 28:13and classroom culture: What are those strategies?
- 28:15and classroom culture: Particularly, I loved the portion of the book that you addressed issues of how to deal with kids when they're under high stress.
- 28:21and classroom culture: Because I think of myself as reasonably competent in being a good mentor parent rather than an enforcer parent or a, you know, overly permissive, um, you know, hyper-compassionate but low-standards parent, or leader for that matter.
- 28:36and classroom culture: Until things get really stressful— you know, my daughter calls because she's afraid of a big, um, you know, presentation at work.
- 28:45and classroom culture: Or, um, we're about to have to meet really high external standards or demands.
- 28:52and classroom culture: In that stressful situation, I resort to, um, the telling rather than the asking.
- 28:59and classroom culture: Right.
- 28:59and classroom culture: So talk a little bit about, um, this wonderful idea about, um, really collaborative troubleshooting and this opportunity that we have to actually ask questions when things get scary.
- 29:11and classroom culture: Yeah.
- 29:11and classroom culture: I love that story of Scarlett, your, your daughter, um, headed toward, uh, a really big performance.
- 29:18and classroom culture: And, you know, you ask a brilliant question in that moment rather than telling her how to manage her anxiety.
- 29:24and classroom culture: Yeah.
- 29:25and classroom culture: Oh, just overhear Sergio, working with students on physics, I was amazed.
- 29:30and classroom culture: I basically never heard him explain a physics concept. Ever.
- 29:34and classroom culture: Like, how is the best physics teacher not ever explaining physics?
- 29:37and classroom culture: All he did was ask questions.
- 29:39and classroom culture: He was like, "Huh, I see what you have there.
- 29:41and classroom culture: What would happen if you changed that?" And, and then it'd be like, it'd be silent for a long time and they'd be like.
- 29:47and classroom culture: "Oh, I get it now.
- 29:47and classroom culture: Okay.
- 29:48and classroom culture: Thanks, Mr. Estrada." And he was just doing that the whole time.
- 29:51and classroom culture: And, and he used this app called Remind.
- 29:53and classroom culture: It's like a secure texting app for, you know, keeps everybody safe, but you can still text your teacher.
- 29:59and classroom culture: And, uh, so there, I, I saw the timestamps, and he was, like, uh, one night on the couch watching Netflix with his wife or whatever, and a student said, "I'm so lost.
- 30:10and classroom culture: I'm so confused.
- 30:10and classroom culture: I'm crying.
- 30:11and classroom culture: I can't do this.
- 30:12and classroom culture: I'm overwhelmed." Uh, yada, yada, yada, right?
- 30:15and classroom culture: And like Sergio, he teaches at Riverside High School, 2 percent of kids are college-ready.
- 30:20and classroom culture: But in his class, 95 percent pass college physics every year.
- 30:24and classroom culture: He's a legend, right?
- 30:25and classroom culture: But his whole life mission is, like, promoting equity and ... and changing lives.
- 30:29and classroom culture: So this is a moment where he is got a student that's about to, you know, blow up, and I'm, like, I would've been so tempted to be a protector in that moment and say, "Don't worry about it.
- 30:39and classroom culture: We'll just do this problem tomorrow." Or "Who cares?
- 30:42and classroom culture: It's just ..." Pull the rip cord.
- 30:43and classroom culture: You're, you're exhausted.
- 30:44and classroom culture: Right?
- 30:45and classroom culture: Yeah.
- 30:45and classroom culture: Or you know, or the enforcer would've been like, "Suck it up," right?
- 30:49and classroom culture: "Stop whining." Things are hard.
- 30:51and classroom culture: Yeah.
- 30:51and classroom culture: They're gonna be even harder in real life.
- 30:52and classroom culture: Supposed to be hard.
- 30:52and classroom culture: Keep going.
- 30:53and classroom culture: Yeah.
- 30:53and classroom culture: And Sergio instead was like, "All right, show me what you have." And then he is, like, "I noticed you already have this and this.
- 30:59and classroom culture: What would happen if you changed that?" And then he, like, you know, presses play on "Bridgerton" again and puts the phone down or whatever he is doing on the couch.
- 31:07and classroom culture: And then 20 minutes go by and then the phone lights up again.
- 31:10and classroom culture: He picks it up and it's like, "Oh, I see it now, Mr. Estrada, I can do it.
- 31:14and classroom culture: I'm not crying.
- 31:15and classroom culture: I feel confident.
- 31:15and classroom culture: I'll see you tomorrow." And I was like, "Sergio, how did you have the self-control to not, like, be the protector in that moment?" And he's like, he looked at me like I had two heads.
- 31:26and classroom culture: Like he was like, "I would never deprive a student of the chance to know that they could understand physics." So beautiful, right""I would never deprive person whomever from discovering that they're capable of figuring it out," right?
- 31:38and classroom culture: I just love that, that Yeah.
- 31:40and classroom culture: But it, the level of self-control that it takes for us as the, the other side of the student mindset is that our mindsets have to change, right?
- 31:50and classroom culture: Yeah.
- 31:50and classroom culture: You know, and I, I love the opportunity that you give to us, um, through this idea of the do-over, right?
- 31:56and classroom culture: That sometimes we don't get it exactly right.
- 31:58and classroom culture: That we, too, have to have a growth mindset about ourselves, right?
- 32:02and classroom culture: I love that When you, you're driving your daughter Scarlett, instead of saying, "This is how to handle the stressful performance that you're about to play," um, you say,"What do you think I'm going to say?" Yeah.
- 32:13and classroom culture: Yeah.
- 32:14and classroom culture: Scarlett got in the, so Scarlett got in the car, this is like two years ago.
- 32:17and classroom culture: She's a freshman now, she's in seventh grade at the time, and she's like ... it's April so it was time for auditions for the next year's orchestra. And it was first chair.
- 32:27and classroom culture: And I don't, don't ask me what first chair is.
- 32:29and classroom culture: I don't, Sounds really scary and important.
- 32:30and classroom culture: But according to her it's a big deal.
- 32:32and classroom culture: And, uh, she's like,"Daddy, I'm so nervous.
- 32:35and classroom culture: I have butterflies in my stomach.
- 32:37and classroom culture: I don't think I can do it." And again, the enforcer is, "Suck it up, like, stop whining," right?
- 32:44and classroom culture: And the protector would be, "I'll call the school and tell them you're sick.
- 32:48and classroom culture: And you don't have to go," right?
- 32:49and classroom culture: A lot of parents do this— like, this is a very common thing, I hear this all the time— And, um, you know, protect them from the stress and anxiety and failure.
- 32:58and classroom culture: And I was writing a book, and I knew that if teenage girls do anything, it's find hypocrisy in their parents.
- 33:05and classroom culture: And I was, like, I can't write a book about what you're supposed to do and then not do it myself.
- 33:09and classroom culture: Cause she'll throw it in my face for the rest of my life.
- 33:11and classroom culture: Yes, indeed.
- 33:12and classroom culture: And so I was, like, "All right, Scarlett, what do you think I'm gonna say?" And she was, like, "Oh, well you're gonna say that the fact that my, I have butterflies in my stomach means I really care about doing a good job.
- 33:23and classroom culture: But it's actually really hard because it's really important to be first chair.
- 33:27and classroom culture: And so I'm nervous about it because it matters to me and it's truly, like, courageous.
- 33:32and classroom culture: And the fact that my heart's racing and my palms are sweaty is just getting cooler oxygenated blood to my brain and my muscles so I can perform at the level of my preparation." And I was, like,"Scarlett, how did you know that that's exactly what I was gonna say?" And she's like, "Oh, well, two years earlier..." And then she reminded me that two years earlier, we were in a lake in Wisconsin, just north of Chicago and the Lake Geneva, and she, uh, she was gonna water ski for the first time.
- 33:57and classroom culture: And I'm holding the skis behind her, and Uncle Luke has the boat and Uncle Luke's about to say"hit it" and, like, rev the engine.
- 34:03and classroom culture: And she's super nervous about it.
- 34:05and classroom culture: And she's, like, "Daddy, I'm nervous.
- 34:07and classroom culture: I have butterflies in my stomach." And I was, like, "Oh, Scarlett," And at that moment I was like, I've been preparing this...
- 34:11and classroom culture: I'm a famous neuroscientist...my entire life.
- 34:12and classroom culture: Yeah.
- 34:12and classroom culture: I'm not a neuroscientist, but I, we, we had just published a paper in "Nature" on this topic.
- 34:17and classroom culture: And so I was like, "Aw, this is great.
- 34:18and classroom culture: I ... I know one thing about parenting and I'm gonna do it right now. And, um, so I was like—well, Scarlett, the ...
- 34:23and classroom culture: the fact that you're nervous means you're doing something kind of awesome.
- 34:27and classroom culture: Because you're gonna, you're about to be on top of water.
- 34:30and classroom culture: Like, it's unbelievable that the physics work, that you can just glide on water right behind an enormous engine.
- 34:37and classroom culture: And you're gonna just be, like, wind buzzing through your hair, it's gonna be amazing.
- 34:41and classroom culture: But in order to do it, you have to be strong enough to hold onto the rope.
- 34:44and classroom culture: And so your body knows that that's what's gonna happen, and so you're getting oxygenated blood to your muscles.
- 34:50and classroom culture: to make you strong. And then when you pop up, then you're gonna have so much fun and you're never gonna forget it.
- 34:54and classroom culture: And she was like, "OK." And then she popped right up— she weighed like 70 pounds at the time, so all she had to do was go like this—and then she...
- 35:01and classroom culture: Could, so, so see that.
- 35:02and classroom culture: ...she skied for like 20 minutes, and I just sat there bobbing in the water alone, kind of bored, but it was this moment where it, it could have gone either way.
- 35:11and classroom culture: There, it's, it's the, the psychologists, as you know, call it undifferentiated arousal.
- 35:16and classroom culture: That you, there's this a feeling of arousal.
- 35:18and classroom culture: You don't know what to name it, right?
- 35:20and classroom culture: This is the Schachter theory.
- 35:22and classroom culture: And then, but a mentor at a moment where they have it—undifferentiated arousal, and they could name it this or that— allowed Scarlett to name it something as "my body preparing to do well," and then it actually became true.
- 35:37and classroom culture: And then from then on, she didn't need me to tell her hypothetically what her body is doing.
- 35:42and classroom culture: She had proof from her own experience.
- 35:44and classroom culture: Yeah.
- 35:44and classroom culture: It's super exciting.
- 35:45and classroom culture: Right?
- 35:46and classroom culture: And you're like, preparing them for future difficulty.
- 35:48and classroom culture: And to be honest, this, when I interviewed Keivan's, um, former graduate students, they have these moments where it's like, I, I, I have my like exam coming up to figure out if I'm gonna stay in the Ph.D. program and they don't know what to name that.
- 36:01and classroom culture: And a good mentor like Keivan steps in and is, like, "This means you are doing something at the frontiers of your field.
- 36:08and classroom culture: You're preparing to change physics, and we need you and your skills, and by the way, you're prepared.
- 36:13and classroom culture: So use that as fuel to help you to do well." It's amazing, and it's that combination that you describe of high transparency, right?
- 36:21and classroom culture: You're not sugarcoating it.
- 36:22and classroom culture: You're not pretending like it's no big deal.
- 36:24and classroom culture: You're being really clear.
- 36:25and classroom culture: This is a fulcrum, this is a key moment.
- 36:28and classroom culture: Right.
- 36:28and classroom culture: You are experiencing high arousal because it is super, super intense, right?
- 36:32and classroom culture: And I have complete confidence in what's gonna happen next, in the fact that you are ready, right?
- 36:39and classroom culture: Or that you... Right.
- 36:40and classroom culture: ...even though it feels not great, you're gonna figure it out.
- 36:43and classroom culture: I have confidence in you figuring it out.
- 36:44and classroom culture: Right?
- 36:44and classroom culture: And think about the implicit message of the protector move.
- 36:46and classroom culture: Like, I didn't say "Let's inner tube instead of water ski." You know, if you, if that's what I would've done, then the lesson is when it's hard, you should reduce your expectations and standards and remove the stressor.
- 37:00and classroom culture: Right.
- 37:00and classroom culture: That's great.
- 37:01and classroom culture: And it would imply that I didn't believe that she could do it.
- 37:03and classroom culture: Yeah.
- 37:04and classroom culture: Right.
- 37:04and classroom culture: And that you leave room for that collaborative troubleshooting, like, "What do you think is a good solution in this moment?" right?
- 37:09and classroom culture: Yeah.
- 37:10and classroom culture: That the question-asking kind of breaks it open.
- 37:12and classroom culture: Well, yeah.
- 37:13and classroom culture: I want her to own the thinking because a good mentor isn't just helping you in that moment.
- 37:17and classroom culture: They're preparing you for future adversity, future challenges.
- 37:22and classroom culture: Like, after you leave our care, are you prepared to continue to do things hard that are hard with resilience?
- 37:29and classroom culture: Absolutely.
- 37:30and classroom culture: And, and so they have to own the thinking.
- 37:32and classroom culture: They have to be able to tell themselves the better story.
- 37:34and classroom culture: And, and what I write about in the book is that it, the, the more you care for someone who's suffering or vulnerable, the more tempted you are to tell them what to do.
- 37:45and classroom culture: We want to transmit our expertise.
- 37:47and classroom culture: It's like if, if somebody was lost on the street in your neighborhood, and they rolled down the window, like, "Where do I go?" It would be weird to be like, "I don't know.
- 37:54and classroom culture: Where do you think you should go?" How do you feel about that?
- 37:56and classroom culture: Right.
- 37:56and classroom culture: Like, like it's the, the polite thing to do is to give them information when they're in need.
- 38:01and classroom culture: And so we apply that same conversational heuristic when we're talking to our children in need.
- 38:06and classroom culture: But the problem is that we haven't asked them to own the idea.
- 38:10and classroom culture: So we have to overcome that compulsion to tell and instead engage in this routine I call collaborative troubleshooting.
- 38:17and classroom culture: Where it's your little curiosity like, huh, why is this error here?
- 38:20and classroom culture: Like, that's interesting.
- 38:22and classroom culture: Like, what do you think about it?
- 38:23and classroom culture: And then, but still you're positioning yourself as a resource to continue to tinker and troubleshoot until you fix it.
- 38:28and classroom culture: Yeah.
- 38:28and classroom culture: I mean, so aligned with, you know, my own interest in and excitement around curiosity, uh, around the counterfactual: What would be true if what I'm thinking is not true and another option might be open, right?
- 38:42and classroom culture: It gives so much more oxygen and so much more room for that kind of creative problem-solving, but also so exciting in terms of the values that I think we hold really strongly here at Vanderbilt in terms of, um, supporting and, and, um, and framing students to be prepared for really high challenge.
- 38:59and classroom culture: But also a really strong sense of purpose and a really strong sense of belonging.
- 39:03and classroom culture: You have two whole chapters on that that are just really exciting and inspiring.
- 39:07and classroom culture: And I guess as we close, you know, this is all great and the examples that we've used are Sergio as a teacher in his classroom.
- 39:14and classroom culture: Or your experience, or my experience working with, um, you know, young adults in our own households or in leadership.
- 39:20and classroom culture: But I think what's really incredibly powerful is to think about how you've now taken that as a nationwide intervention to dramatically shift how teachers teach in schools across this country.
- 39:33and classroom culture: Yeah.
- 39:34and classroom culture: So do you wanna just close with a little bit of, um, of the sort of evidence that bears this out in terms of that randomized control trial?
- 39:40and classroom culture: Yeah, I mean, I, we're, we're very hard-nosed about the research.
- 39:44and classroom culture: And as you know, like, I, I don't have a lot of patience for nonsense research, especially if it's gonna be used...
- 39:50and classroom culture: Right.
- 39:50and classroom culture: You say you hate parenting advice books ...
- 39:51and classroom culture: ...to influence,...which I just love.
- 39:53and classroom culture: Yeah.
- 39:53and classroom culture: Just so many parenting books.
- 39:54and classroom culture: So worthless.
- 39:55and classroom culture: And I mean, they're earnest and they're wonderful people, I'm sure.
- 39:59and classroom culture: But they're not...
- 39:59and classroom culture: But like, I, I didn't wanna write a book where it's like, "How To Deal With Your Idiot Teenager," because your teenager's gonna see that book, like, "What are you doing, Mom?" Um, so, but, so it was important to me that the book operated as an actual intervention, or at least that I had confidence that the ideas in it, if truly adopted, would have a positive impact on the person who read it.
- 40:21and classroom culture: And, and for me as a scientist, the only way I could know that is if I did a randomized trial.
- 40:25and classroom culture: And so we, before I published the book, we took the content of mainly Chapter 1, but also a little bit of Chapter 5 and 6, and we randomized hundreds of teachers across Texas to get that content and interact with it and answer questions in a double-blind design.
- 40:41and classroom culture: And then we tracked the students' performance over time.
- 40:43and classroom culture: This is with Chris Brian and Cameron Hecht, my collaborators.
- 40:46and classroom culture: And we found that students were more likely to, to pass the course at the end of the year— especially low-income students, students who might otherwise have experienced that enforcer or protector, um, and who might have doubted that they're taken seriously or respected— and we published that in "PNAS" last year.
- 41:05and classroom culture: Um, and then...
- 41:06and classroom culture: That's, sorry, for everyone else, that's the "Proceedings of the National Academy of Science." Very, very big deal in our world, so congratulations.
- 41:13and classroom culture: Amazing.
- 41:14and classroom culture: So it was a great paper.
- 41:15and classroom culture: We're very excited about it.
- 41:16and classroom culture: But we, we actually tested the content of this.
- 41:18and classroom culture: And then we said, "Well, let's do more than a one-time message.
- 41:23and classroom culture: Let's actually support people over time to do the mentor mindset practices." And then in the book we have, there's this gray section that's all scripts that I wrote with educators and educator trainers.
- 41:34and classroom culture: And so we basically took that kind of content and we created a model of what we call a fellowship.
- 41:40and classroom culture: I love this part.
- 41:41and classroom culture: And the idea is that conventional teacher professional development is like any teacher's worst day of the year.
- 41:48and classroom culture: And it's also the parent's worst day because your kids are home from school for no reason.
- 41:52and classroom culture: That's right, in-service! Yeah.
- 41:54and classroom culture: For those of us who have gone through in-service...
- 41:56and classroom culture: This happened to me on Tuesday—I had, I had, this is not important for the story, but I had Ronan home, my 5-year-old, for his in-service.
- 42:02and classroom culture: And I'm on a work call, and he runs in screaming at the top of his lungs because he has gotten a Lego stuck up his nose.
- 42:09and classroom culture: And I'm like on a call, tweezers, Lego— because Margot's a nurse, so she's at work.
- 42:14and classroom culture: And so, like, that's one reason why in-services are not my favorite, because, like, I get Lego nose problems.
- 42:20and classroom culture: Uh, but also teachers hate it because it's so didactic, right?
- 42:24and classroom culture: It's a bunch of ivory tower experts telling you what to do.
- 42:27and classroom culture: Okay?
- 42:27and classroom culture: And when I was a middle school teacher, the, on most PD days, you look and you see the best teachers grading papers in the back because they know it's a waste of time, right?
- 42:36and classroom culture: So I was like, how do we not, how do we take good content or what we believe to be good content, and actually have people adopt it.
- 42:42and classroom culture: And what we found is that teachers are a lot like teenagers in the sense that they're constantly in the status disparity where society says you're in a low-status profession, you're underpaid.
- 42:54and classroom culture: Parents are constantly yelling at you for ruining their kids' future, right?
- 42:58and classroom culture: Every single school board election is run on how terrible the math scores are and how terrible the ... so it's just constant blame and underpaying for teachers.
- 43:08and classroom culture: So to come in and say, "Here's a long list of a million ways that you need to be more attentive to your students' feelings.
- 43:14and classroom culture: And, and the way you're talking to them is screwing them up," like, that's not.
- 43:18and classroom culture: Not gonna work, right?
- 43:19and classroom culture: So instead we said,"Hey, here's some science.
- 43:22and classroom culture: It's new and interesting.
- 43:23and classroom culture: A lot of people don't know it.
- 43:24and classroom culture: They think this wrong thing about the adolescent brain.
- 43:27and classroom culture: We're giving you the new stuff." Some new, some new, right.
- 43:29and classroom culture: "But we don't know what it's like in your classroom.
- 43:32and classroom culture: You are the expert on sixth to ninth grade math in public schools in Texas, not us.
- 43:36and classroom culture: So what we want you to do is to take the science and then at the end of the year, present in a showcase how you applied the Sergio tactics: How did you do collaborative troubleshooting?
- 43:47and classroom culture: How did you be transparent?" Awesome.
- 43:49and classroom culture: You get social status among your teacher colleagues.
- 43:52and classroom culture: You get.
- 43:52and classroom culture: They get an invitation from their principal and superintendent, naming them as a fellow, and we give them custom Yetis because I like to have as many Yetis personally as I can.
- 44:02and classroom culture: Um, and the, and, and we give them a stipend.
- 44:06and classroom culture: And so it's, it's an honorific thing.
- 44:08and classroom culture: It's not remedial.
- 44:09and classroom culture: It's not like we're fixing your bad teaching.
- 44:11and classroom culture: We're valuing you and your expertise and your professionalism.
- 44:15and classroom culture: And, um, and then they work in a network, and monthly they meet with our virtual coaches— and I hired Sergio Estrada as one of the coaches.
- 44:24and classroom culture: Awesome.
- 44:25and classroom culture: And two other people that are ...
- 44:26and classroom culture: Passing it forward in this amazing way.
- 44:27and classroom culture: ...two other people who are just as good and they're amazing: Charles and Christian.
- 44:31and classroom culture: And, um, so they meet with our amazing facilitators and then they create their own mentor mindset practices and share them out, and they become a part of the legacy of, of so future fellows come and see what you tried. And what we're finding is that, uh, students' math test scores in these classrooms are up by 0.4 standard deviations.
- 44:51and classroom culture: Which, who knows if that's the effect size as it continues to scale.
- 44:54and classroom culture: Right?
- 44:54and classroom culture: So that's how many months of instruction?
- 44:56and classroom culture: I mean, for high school, that's two years of learning.
- 44:58and classroom culture: So, so they, you accelerated kids' learning by two years by helping teachers to really, really not only adopt but own and creatively move forward with that kind of a, a mindset change.
- 45:11and classroom culture: Yeah.
- 45:11and classroom culture: That, that, right.
- 45:12and classroom culture: That's if you believe that the translation of standard deviation effects size.
- 45:16and classroom culture: Yeah.
- 45:16and classroom culture: But just for the, that's the purposes.
- 45:17and classroom culture: That's absolutely what, how people would interpret it.
- 45:20and classroom culture: And, but for me, as important as that is, we survey the students and say how much they feel respected.
- 45:25and classroom culture: Awesome.
- 45:26and classroom culture: And that goes up, especially students of color.
- 45:29and classroom culture: We found a 50% reduction in the Black- white achievement gap for the math test.
- 45:34and classroom culture: And then last, once this teachers have these engaged classrooms where students feel respected, their lives are better.
- 45:41and classroom culture: It's, like, they don't have ... it's not pulling teeth trying to get kids to factor trinomials.
- 45:46and classroom culture: They're, they're willing and eager...
- 45:46and classroom culture: Everybody's working, yeah, a well-oiled machine.
- 45:49and classroom culture: And so we see teacher burnout go down 50% and attrition go down 50%.
- 45:53and classroom culture: Amazing.
- 45:55and classroom culture: Thanks to our listeners for tuning in.
- 45:58and classroom culture: Remember to stay curious and keep exploring new ideas.
- 46:01and classroom culture: We'll be back next time with another guest who's pushing the boundaries of discovery.
- 46:04and classroom culture: Until then, I'm Cybele Raver, and this is Quantum Potential.
- 46:17and classroom culture: The "Quantum Potential" podcast comes from Vanderbilt University.
- 46:22and classroom culture: Your host is C. Cybele Raver Production by Matriarch Digital Media.
- 46:30and classroom culture: For more information about Quantum Potential, go to vanderbilt.edu/quantum potential.
- 46:40and classroom culture: Stay curious.