Latest / The Long for Truth Show / Proof Bethel's Christianity Is Reckless: A Discussion With Holly Pivec and Doug Geivett
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to the Long for Truth podcast. I'm Robin Long. Join my husband
- 0:06Dan and I as we explore the roots of the early Pentecostal and Charismatic movements,
- 0:11and we shine a light on false doctrines and false teachers in the modern
- 0:15church. Let's get started. And we've had gold dust appear in people's hands
- 0:23for years. I don't ever talk about it, but frequently during worship.
- 0:27We actually had it today. Ben and I both saw gold'll start falling during
- 0:31worship. Wow, wow, wow wow. Right now. I had a
- 0:54encounter with God many year ago. I've told many tories. I've told the
- 0:57story many times about the Lord walking into the bathroom and he said to me,
- 1:02you're going to be a prophet. The King's prime ministers, governors,
- 1:06And it would be about fifteen or maybe fourteen years ago, somewhere in that
- 1:10area. Fourteen years ago probably the feathers started disappearing and falling in meetings,
- 1:15and then they started falling in our homes and in restaurants and things like that,
- 1:19just unusual things. You know, there are signs that make you wonder.
- 1:26People say, where's that in the Bible. Well, they said,
- 1:27he'd cover you with his feathers. So sometimes our students, you know,
- 1:32in our congregation, we want people to take risks, and what do they
- 1:36do when they mess up? They do something that embarrasses us because that sort
- 1:38of happens. You know, We've come around the corner and they're in a
- 1:41pile and a holy ghost pile. Hey, but oh you want to head
- 1:48my two man? Hello everyone, welcome along for truth. My name is
- 2:04Daniel Long. Most of you that watch this show know of Bethel Church in
- 2:09Reading, California, so you know the names Bill Johnson and Chris Vallaton.
- 2:15But I wonder if you know just how much influence Bethel as a church has
- 2:22had worldwide. And that's because Bethel isn't just a church. Bethel is a
- 2:27movement. Now. There is a book that you need to get and that
- 2:32book is called Reckless Christianity, the destructive new teachings and practices of Bill Johnson,
- 2:40Bethel Church and the global Movement of Apostles and Prophets. And I have
- 2:46both the authors today, Holly Pivoc and Doug Guivett with me. Welcome guys,
- 2:52thank you so much for being on today. Holly, you've been here
- 2:55before. But Doug, this is your first time. Welcome. It is
- 3:00thank you, Daniel. Great to be here with you, Great to have
- 3:02you, guys, great to be here, good, good to have you.
- 3:06So let's get started by having each one of you tell us a little
- 3:09bit about yourselves and then especially why you wrote this book Reckless Christianity, which,
- 3:15by the way, I will make sure that I put a link to
- 3:19that book and your other books in the YouTube description. So tell us a
- 3:23little bit about yourselves and why you decided to write the book. We'll start
- 3:27with you, Holly. Okay, my name is Holly Pivic. I have
- 3:30a master's degree in Christian apologetics from Biola University, where I also worked for
- 3:38nearly a decade as the university editor there and the managing editor of Biola Magazine.
- 3:45And I've written four books about the New Apostolic Reformation movement now along with
- 3:52Doug. And I'm also a wife, a pastor's wife, and a mom.
- 3:59And and I have a blog where I've been blogging about this movement at
- 4:02holyypivot dot com for over twenty years now. So you know, we had
- 4:09already written three other books about the New Apostolic Reformation, but we hadn't written
- 4:15a book yet that took a deep dive into the teachings of Bethel Church and
- 4:20reading California, which is the most influential church in the New Apostolic Reformation movement
- 4:27today. As you said, it has a global influence. We received letters
- 4:31regularly from people and countries all around the world describing the way that Bethel Church
- 4:40teachings have made inroads into their churches and into the Christian ministries, and they're
- 4:44part of the world and caused a lot of damage and destruction and brought in
- 4:48a lot of Fall's teaching. And so we wanted to do a book that
- 4:53looked really closely at the teachings of Bethel Church and it's chief apostle, Bill
- 4:59Johnson and its chief profit Chris Vallatin, and really really go deeper. Our
- 5:06previous book, Counterfeit Kingdom, addressed Bethel Church, but Reckless Christianity goes even
- 5:12deeper in that it goes several layers into the argumentation. It's extremely heavily documented.
- 5:18Counterfeit Kingdom is documented heavily as well, but Reckless Christianity is very heavily
- 5:25documented. Because we want to take readers to the actual sources and really dive
- 5:31deeply into the teachings of Bethel Church. All right, Doug, what about
- 5:39you, Let's let's get your tell us a little bit about yourself and why
- 5:44you decided to write the book as well. Okay, sure, Daniel,
- 5:47thank you. I have been teaching for over forty years in higher education at
- 5:55several different places, and during the most recent twenty nine years before my recent
- 6:00retirement, I was at Biola University in the Talbot School of Theology, teaching
- 6:04philosophy. My education background is in Biblical studies, religious studies, theology,
- 6:13and philosophy. My PhD work was done at the University of Southern California in
- 6:17philosophy, and in my most recent teaching, I was teaching in a philosophy
- 6:21department in the seminary and also lecturing on Christian apologetics almost every semester, and
- 6:30I've traveled globally speaking in churches and universities and in other settings on issues that
- 6:40I write about and speak about on a regular basis. Many of them have
- 6:43to do with grounds for believing that Christianity is true. All the major doctrines
- 6:46that we agree on despite our denominational differences, and the intersection of faith and
- 6:55philosophies have been a big part of it. I've got a book on faith,
- 6:58film and philosophy, have written in the area of ethics with other Christian
- 7:02philosophers and collected them into an edited volume. So those are just some of
- 7:06the things that I've done. But with Holly, it's been a unique enterprise
- 7:11focusing on this movement called the New Apostolic Reformation. And as Holly pointed out,
- 7:16our most recent two books, one published in late twenty twenty two called
- 7:21Counterfeit Kingdom and the other one published more recently called Reckless Christianity, focus on
- 7:30more narrowly on some of the practices and theological aspects of the movement by its
- 7:35most influential dispensaries, you might say, and that especially includes Bethel Church and
- 7:43Reading, California. My interest in this most recently now is that there are
- 7:49many people who have been seduced by a mythology about the miraculous and about the
- 7:56possibility of obtaining supernatural power through activation exercises if they move towards Bethel and en
- 8:03role for example in their Bethel School of Supernatural Ministry, where they can get
- 8:09up to three years of training and activation in the manifestation of these spiritual dimensions
- 8:16of what they believe is the power of God. Second year BSSM Video curriculum
- 8:22builds on first year's curriculum. We focus on practical leadership principles, habostolic governmental
- 8:28structures, and deeper activations of a gift of the spirit. There is more
- 8:33in depth, and so that's one of my concerns is that the lure from
- 8:37a distance looks very promising, but the results you get on the ground don't
- 8:43really add up, and they don't fulfill the expectation that many people have.
- 8:48They come out of this movement disillusioned. Speaking of people who come out disillusioned
- 8:54now includes a young generation of adults who grew up in the movement. So
- 9:01the movement is old enough now even at Bethel for young people to be coming
- 9:05up through the ranks hearing this in their culture all these years and now having
- 9:11to sort out questions that they have and no resources within the movement to deal
- 9:16with them in a responsible way, and this is also causing some difficulty for
- 9:20them. And I believe that having more books out on the topic that seek
- 9:28to establish through careful biblical study and theological investigation and excess extreme documentation, so
- 9:37that we can't be accused of being irresponsible in our own expose of this movement.
- 9:43I think people who are interested in the movement from the inside now are
- 9:50starting to have questions and pressing those questions with their leaders in ways that their
- 9:54leaders are not used to, and it's awkward for them. And we think
- 10:00it's helping people come to a clearer understanding of the nature of the Gospel,
- 10:05the person of Jesus, what prayer really consists in, and what the global
- 10:09movement of Christianity should look like, contrasting that with what Bethel calls revival Christianity.
- 10:18So that's very encouraging to me. And of course always there are those
- 10:22who for reasons of their own have left the movement found some of our research
- 10:28and found it to be reassuring to them and helpful. And we're comforted by
- 10:33that too, because so far we're uniformly receiving testimonies from people that our description
- 10:39of what's happening and the problems that exist are accurate and genuine, and so
- 10:45this just enlivens us to keep on going. And I want to thank you
- 10:48Daniel for hosting us for this program. Oh it is my pleasure, it
- 10:54really is So, speaking of research, guys, in your search for this
- 11:01book, what and each of you can answer this if you'd like, What
- 11:05was the most disturbing thing or some of the most disturbing things you found in
- 11:11in your research? Who who'd like to start with that one? I'll say
- 11:15one thing that for me, it was the way that Bethel leaders disparage and
- 11:22even demonize people who have questions about their teachings and their practices. They have
- 11:31very controversial teachings and practices, even by their own admission, uh, their
- 11:37teachings are are controversial and so. But then when people have questioned those teachings
- 11:43and brought really legitimate questions, legitimate concerns, have done so respectfully, those
- 11:50people are often met with accusations that that maybe they're operating under the influence of
- 11:58a demonic spirit for challenging the teachings and the practices and the leaders, or
- 12:05you know, they're accused of having an anti christ spirit or something like that
- 12:11and so and along with that is really a gas lighting that that they've done
- 12:18of when when they've when it's been shown that they've engaged in these controversial practices
- 12:26like grave sucking or grave soaking, when that's come to light, and there's
- 12:30a lot of evidence for that. Instead of you know, admitting what they
- 12:35had done and owning that, instead there's a lot of gas lighting and and
- 12:41telling people that actually saw these things with their own eyes that they didn't promote
- 12:46these teachings and they didn't promote these practices. So this idea of grave sucking
- 12:50as a practice was so it's just like almost a weird, demonic assault against
- 12:56this beautiful, hungry heart that it became. I was even just resentful.
- 13:01I'm not even gonna talk about that we didn't do graves sucking or anything.
- 13:03In that moment, I thought of a way that, oh no, I
- 13:18better not mention something that would do. Please don't do what I'm about to
- 13:22suggest. It's a joke. I thought we could build a new building by
- 13:28just selling grave sucking straws. But I'm not gonna do. And so that's
- 13:37also very concerning. Okay, the same with the same with their students also
- 13:43engaging in reading like Christianized versions of Tarot cards, destiny cards, and that's
- 13:50another example of something that you know clearly happened, but again denials that that
- 13:58those cards were being used Essentially like tarot cards. Yeah wow, Doug,
- 14:05how about you? Yeah, well, I agree. Disparagement is a very
- 14:09huge problem. They disparage their critics when they're not just ignoring them, and
- 14:13then they disparage those who have questions. Even sincere questions people in their own
- 14:20midst are ostracized and ultimately discouraged from participating in the movement with them because they
- 14:28ask penetrating questions. That's very disturbing to me. And that's not the way
- 14:31it is in the Church in general. Historically, when the Gospel has been
- 14:37preached, people have been encouraged to ask their questions. When Saint Paul arrived
- 14:43in Berea, as we're told in the Book of Acts, and these people
- 14:48who were Jews at the time, sincere godly believers and trusted the Hebrew Bible
- 14:54that they had at the time, we're hearing things from Paul that they'd never
- 14:58heard before. It says that they tested the scriptures to see if these things
- 15:01were so, and ultimately came to the conclusion that Paul's exposition of the Hebrew
- 15:07Bible was accurate and that's the way it's supposed to be. And Paul commends
- 15:11the Bereans for being especially honorable among the audiences that he traveled to and where
- 15:20he established churches. And so that's a very important thing to me, is
- 15:24that we have the freedom to talk to our leaders and ask our leaders very
- 15:31direct questions. That especially in the modern world where there are so many ideas
- 15:35swirling around and people have to find their bearings and latch onto the truth on
- 15:41the strength of good reasons and good evidence when so many things are competing for
- 15:46their attention. So the disparagement is a major issue for me. I think
- 15:50I'm seeing more evidence of deception. Now. Why I say that is not
- 15:56because I believe that they're necessarily knowingly deceiving people when they claim to have performed
- 16:04a miracle, for example, but sometimes, as Holly described, the way
- 16:11that they redescribe things that they've done using different categories when they've failed, I
- 16:17think is a form of deception. It's sleight of hand. When, for
- 16:22example, they were dealing with a family in their church where the wife was
- 16:29a member of the worship team at Bethel lost their two year old daughter,
- 16:34all of Heiligenthal and we can talk about this later, but in brief,
- 16:38what happened was she and along with the leaders of the Church decided to engage
- 16:45in prayer declarations for Olive's resurrection Jesus as act when Jesus Date feeling about should
- 17:00right out Jesus State in Jesus State. And there was a great social movement
- 17:19to this effect. It was all over the media, it was global,
- 17:22it went viral, and people from all over the world were participating in what
- 17:26are called prayer declarations. These are not petitions, but there are declarations to
- 17:32raise Olive from the dead. Well, it didn't happen. And after the
- 17:37fact, when it didn't happen, and there was a memorial service held for
- 17:40al of they released a press statement in which they redescribed what they had been
- 17:45doing as if it was petitionary prayer, which it was not, and did
- 17:49not consider it to be declaration prayer after the fact. So there's pastoral malpractice
- 17:56all over the place here from start to fill. And that's one of my
- 18:00great concerns as well. I'm very concerned that they pay lip service to orthodox
- 18:07Christian beliefs like the deity of Jesus, but then in their practice it seems
- 18:12like it cuts no ice. And we can talk about that as well.
- 18:15It's my personal conviction that Jesus didn't do any miracles as God. This has
- 18:22got me into a little bit of trouble. But just bear with me and
- 18:25take it or leave it. I'll just share with my heart with you.
- 18:29It's my conviction that Jesus didn't do any miracles as God. He did them
- 18:33as a man submitted to God. And the reason he did so was to
- 18:37give us an example that we could follow. If he performed all of his
- 18:42miracles as God. I'm still impressed, it's just I can't follow that.
- 18:48I'm reduced to an observer. I stand back and I say, oh,
- 18:52my goodness, he did it again. He parted the sea, he brought
- 18:55water out of a rock. Look at him. He's in the cloud of
- 18:57the presence. And I stand back and I in awe. But something happens
- 19:02when I find out that Jesus did what he did as a man. I'm
- 19:04no longer content to stay where I am. I must pursue the example that's
- 19:10been set for me. But another thing is that they affirm the inerrancy of
- 19:12scripture, the authority of Scripture as the inspired word of God, but in
- 19:17other ways they undermine its authority in the way that they used the Bible.
- 19:22So these are some of my concerns about the movement today. Yeah, you
- 19:26were talking about deception there. And I watched a clip earlier today with Justin
- 19:32Peters on the Wretched radio program, and he was talking about a church that
- 19:37I can't remember the name of the church. It was connected to Bill Johnson.
- 19:44Justine said, was friends with Bill Johnson and they were talking about the
- 19:48Glory Cloud and the Glitter. You guys know what I'm talking about that.
- 19:52But the Glory Cloud and the Glitter is a large church in Miami named El
- 19:56Ray Jesus King Jesus Church, pastored by a guy named Guillermo Maldonado. Now
- 20:03Guiermo Maldonado is the Bill Johnson of Miami. Okay, okay, and he
- 20:08and Bill Johnson are good friends. Long story short. There was a lady
- 20:14who came to the conference I was teaching. She came up to me,
- 20:17she introduced herself. She said I used to be in l Ray Jesus And
- 20:21I said, oh really, She said, oh yeah, she said I
- 20:23I was high up in it. She said, my husband is still in
- 20:26it. Maybe it's too much. Hope I won't get in trouble but her
- 20:30husband is still in it. She got saved, genuinely saved, converted,
- 20:36left it as you would expect a Christian to do, left the church.
- 20:40And I was talking about some of the manifestations in Maldonado's church. Bill Johnson.
- 20:45Anyway, she came up to me. She said, justin you know
- 20:47how Maldonado's church has the gold dust And I said yeah. She said that
- 20:52was my job, she said, I was tasked her and a friend of
- 20:56hers. We were told to go upstairs with canisters of you can't make this
- 21:03stuff up with canisters of finally, a real fine gold glitter of sorts and
- 21:11she said lobby glitter. Yeah, and she said it was our job to
- 21:15dump it into the ventilation system, and of course it blew out over the
- 21:21whole congregation. Let's talk about Bethel's mission, and that mission is to bring
- 21:27Heaven to Earth. Yes, so yeah, Bethel talks about bringing Heaven to
- 21:38Earth a lot. It's become like a tagline for the church. They put
- 21:42that in their promotional materials and there's like a banner at Bethel hanging up that
- 21:51says something like that, bringing Heaven to Earth. Bill Johnson, you know,
- 21:56has written books about this when Heaven invades Earth and what it is.
- 22:02In the New Epistolic Reformation, they think the Great Commission is actually a commission
- 22:07not to make disciples, just to make disciples of Jesus in all nations,
- 22:14to teach people to follow Jesus's teachings, that kind of thing. They think
- 22:18the Great Commission is actually to make disciples of nations, to take dominion,
- 22:25to take socio political control of the nations, and to bring God's physical kingdom
- 22:32to Earth prior to Christ's return. And so this is a Kingdom Now variety
- 22:40of dominionism. According to Kingdom Now theology, the way to take dominion of
- 22:45the earth is under the authority of apostles and prophets who are bringing new revelations
- 22:51and the church rising up and working these amazing miracles to bring God's Kingdom to
- 22:56earth. And so at Bethel, though they talk about setting up God's kingdom
- 23:00on earth, they referred to that as bringing Heaven to Earth, and they
- 23:03also talk about that it's the purpose of the church. The task of the
- 23:10Church is supposed to make Earth reflect Heaven, so that means that there's no
- 23:14sickness in Heaven. There should be no sickness on earth, there's no war
- 23:17in heaven, there's no pollution in heaven, there's no depression in heaven,
- 23:22there's no poverty in heaven. All these things also then should not be on
- 23:26earth either. And so that's their peculiar take on the Great Commission, is
- 23:34that it's the task of the Church to bring Heaven to Earth. And you
- 23:40can actually see that come up a lot in the music lyrics from Bethel Music,
- 23:44that that language comes up in their music. It really guides everything they
- 23:49do, and they base they a scripture passage they use for this is the
- 23:55Lord's Prayer. So they would say that the Lord's Prayer is actually like a
- 24:00battle plan for how to bring Heaven to Earth. They said, pray like
- 24:04this year will be done on earth as it is in heaven. He gave
- 24:12a very specific assignment that as you relearn now how to represent me and my
- 24:21world, my dominion, my lordship, I want you to make this place
- 24:27like that place. And they would say that the Lord's Prayer teaches the church
- 24:33to make prayer declarations. Like Doug mentioned earlier, that we can make verbal
- 24:40affirmations, we can have spoken words that create reality, that create health,
- 24:48or prosperity, or that bring revival. That God has given the authority to
- 24:52all believers to speak words that create reality. So that's very different than a
- 24:56biblical view of prayer, which, like Doug said, his petitionary that's when
- 25:02we ask God, if it's your will, God, will you please kill
- 25:04this person? Or will you please, you know, provide these finances or
- 25:10something like that. But that's very different. In Naar and at Bethel,
- 25:15they think the most powerful form of prayer, the most effective form of prayer,
- 25:18is prayer declarations, and that petitionary prayers actually reflects a lack of faith
- 25:22because you shouldn't be saying if it's God's will, will you do this or
- 25:26that? You You should know that it's God's will. We're gonna give tonight,
- 25:30but before we do that, we're firm believers here at Bethel, not
- 25:33just at Bethel, but in the Kingdom. Nothing happens till it's first to
- 25:36declarations. So we're gonna make a declaration together. Offering reading number one,
- 25:41and uh, let's say it with some faith. Amen. Here we go.
- 25:47As we receive today's offering, we are believing the Lord for job benefits,
- 25:56sales, and commissions, ter settlements, estates and inheritances, interests and
- 26:03income, rebatesend returns, sex in the mail, gifts and surprises, finding
- 26:11money gets paid off, expenses, decrease, blessing and increase. Thank you
- 26:18Lord for meeting all of my financial needs, that I may have more than
- 26:23enough to give into the Kingdom of God and promote the gospel of Jesus Christ,
- 26:29and so so, prayer declarations are a key for Bethel and bethel theology
- 26:34for how to bring Heaven to earth, how to make earth reflect Heaven.
- 26:40Yeah, and I'm guessing that they get this theology that they have because what
- 26:45you're describing, Holly isn't isn't in scripture that that's not prayer, And the
- 26:48Bible doesn't teach us that, you know, that the Lord's prayer has to
- 26:53do with warfare, prayer bringing heaven to earth. But I'm guessing, and
- 26:56we'll be talking about this a little bit later, they get this from what
- 27:02you guys call prophetic illumination in your book. Would that would that be correct?
- 27:07Yeah? So prophetic illumination in in our doctrine, and which Bethel also
- 27:14holds to, is is the belief that the apostles and prophets receive understandings of
- 27:19passages of scripture that no one has seen before, and so they get like
- 27:23these new understandings of scripture, and they would say that God has been giving
- 27:30new truth to the Church, which they'll often referred to as restored truths.
- 27:33They'll say these were truths that the early church had that were lost through the
- 27:37centuries and are now being restored. And so the view of the Lord's prayer
- 27:42as like this battle plan for bringing God's Kingdom to Earth through prayer declaration,
- 27:49that is, that would be in line with these new or restored truths that
- 27:55in our leaders are claiming to give to the church. Okay, all right,
- 28:00Doug, did you have anything you wanted to add to that. Yeah,
- 28:03there are a couple things I think would be worth mentioning as well in
- 28:06connection with this. First of all, this motto bringing Heaven to Earth is
- 28:12emblazoned on a banner that is posted above the stage in the maink sanctuary at
- 28:18Bethel Church. It's the model they live by, and as Holly said,
- 28:22it is rooted in a proof text from the New Testament, when Jesus trained
- 28:29his disciples about how to pray, and Jesus says, your Kingdom Come,
- 28:33your will be done on earth as it is in heaven. And I want
- 28:37to set the record straight here this passage, this clause that Jesus includes in
- 28:44the prayer. The prayer is longer than that is misinterpreted by these nar leaders.
- 28:49It's one of the abuses of scripture that I was alluding to earlier.
- 28:52And they suppose that what it means is that we're to replicate, we are
- 28:59to replicate the conditions of Heaven on earth. Holly made that point, but
- 29:06that's not what the prayer is teaching. First of all, thy Kingdom Come,
- 29:10Thy will be done, is appealing to God to make those changes on
- 29:15the earth with our cooperation, so we're not making these things happen. Second,
- 29:22and more important, is that when they say when they interpret the words
- 29:27as it is in Heaven, they get it wrong. They think that what
- 29:32you're doing is you're looking at heaven as a blueprint for the way it ought
- 29:36to be on earth, the physical conditions where there is no illness. Of
- 29:40course, there's no agent up there that could become sick or ill, so
- 29:44the conditions can't be replicated exactly because there's no healing that takes place in heaven.
- 29:49But that's what they're talking about here. Come and do what only you
- 29:52can do, Oh Kingdom of God, Oh Kingdom of God, in this
- 30:00place on earth as it is in heaven, on earth as it is in
- 30:04heaven. Would you awaken your bride to reality of the kingdom that cannot be
- 30:11shaken, so that we could walk not just in purity, but in demonstrations
- 30:15of a holy power. No, this is not about replicating a blueprint that's
- 30:19already actualized in heaven. No, it's about realizing the will of God for
- 30:26the earth in the same way that the will of God is realized in heaven.
- 30:32But the will of God for Earth is not the same as the will
- 30:36of God in Heaven, which is perfectly realized for the time being. So
- 30:40God has a will and a plan that He's revealed for us for our conduct
- 30:44in His kingdom here and now. When Jesus presented the Sermon on the Mount,
- 30:49for example, begins with the beatitudes, which are behavioral, and he
- 30:55pronounces blessings on people who engage in those practices, the persecuted, those who
- 31:02share the word the merciful. And I want to key in on the merciful
- 31:06here for a moment. Merciful refers to those who have special compassion on people
- 31:12who are suffering. This is also I believe the significance of the gift of
- 31:17mercy in the New Testament. And there would not be a call for a
- 31:22spiritual gift of mercy if people did not suffer in this world. And that
- 31:27includes physical suffering, mental torment, psychological damage, or what have you,
- 31:33spiritual anguish. All of these are forms of suffering that God has gifted some
- 31:40to be especially merciful in dealing with That's a gift that presupposes that there's evil
- 31:45that has not yet been crushed in the world, and that God does not
- 31:49plan to completely eliminate until a future time that is spoken of in revelation about
- 31:57the end times. And so they've got it wrong. There is no call
- 32:01for mercy, for example, in heaven, where Christ reigns at the right
- 32:07hand of God. Now, when I say the Kingdom of God here and
- 32:10now, I'm not speaking of kingdom now theology, because the expression of the
- 32:19Kingdom on the earth is one of implementation of God's design for the world,
- 32:23not full realization, because that can't happen until he performs various supernatural acts associated
- 32:31with the second Coming of Jesus Christ and then sets up his own kingdom.
- 32:37And that's the full realization of the kingdom. So I want to make that
- 32:39clear. Another point I wanted to make about this is that the details of
- 32:47this battle plan. You know, Holly said that they use the Lord's Prayer
- 32:52to launch the plan, but the details of the plan cannot be discerned from
- 32:58the Lord's Prayer or any place else in the New Testament. So they take
- 33:01this one slice of the Lord's prayer, they completely discord distort what it means,
- 33:07and then they have to devise the details of a battle plan that depend
- 33:10on special revelation or new truths being revealed, as she described. So this
- 33:17bringing heaven to Earth concept is very foreign to scripture, and yet it is
- 33:24the trademark or the hallmark of Bethel Church and the Bethel Movement. Let's move
- 33:37on then and talk about Randy Clark. What kind of influence has Randy Clark
- 33:43had on Bethel Church. Well, according to Bill Johnson, Randy Clark is
- 33:49John Wimber. He would say, and Randy Clark are the two most influential
- 33:53individuals on his own views in his own ministry, and he would say particularly
- 34:00Randy Clark has had a very significant influence on his ministry at Bethel Church.
- 34:07Randy Clark. We mentioned this in the book, but Randy Clark came and
- 34:12visited the church at one point. And after Randy Clark's visit, according to
- 34:17Bill Johnson, according to Randy Clark, the miracles just started happening regularly at
- 34:23Bethel Church, whereas they weren't before his visit. And so Bill Johnson credits
- 34:30Randy Clarke with being a major influence on Bethel Church. Yeah, and I've
- 34:37got a quote here from Bill Johnson, this is directly out of your book.
- 34:40Here says, Randy has been the largest contributor to my understanding and experience
- 34:45of the miracle lifestyle. Before he came to reading, we saw miracles weekly.
- 34:51After a few days with Randy, we saw the miracles multiply and they
- 34:53became daily happenings. So do you any of you guys, either of you
- 35:05guys want to address the miracles. I look at the miracles from the folks
- 35:12in the nar and comparing them to Scripture, they are absolutely nothing like what
- 35:16we see in the Bible either, you want to address that for a moment.
- 35:21Yeah, let me speak to that, because I said earlier in our
- 35:24interview here that there's this great mythology about the miraculous that has sprung up around
- 35:30the Bethel movement, and that's intentional, that's their narrative. And that was
- 35:37the point of Bill Johnson's ministry when he became the pastor and the apostle at
- 35:43Writing Church in Bethel Church in Reading, California, because they had to agree
- 35:47that they would be a church where they would experiment in the supernatural as the
- 35:52hallmark of their ministry before he would agree to serve there in leadership. And
- 35:57so that's what it's become. Of course, they're advertising this message in varieties
- 36:04of ways that we can talk about, including through their music, but also
- 36:07through their books and their teachings and other campaigns that they have going. So
- 36:15miracles are central to their program, their whole movement, and without miracles they
- 36:23would be utterly diminished, or at least without the perception that legitimate miracles of
- 36:29God are being worked on a regular basis. This cannot be periodic, it
- 36:32cannot be infrequent. It has to be pretty much ongoing. Constant, and
- 36:37if it's global, then there shouldn't be a day that passes when there isn't
- 36:42some dramatic miracle that is taking place, given the large population of the world
- 36:45these days and the great global influence of Beth Church. So what about that?
- 36:51Well, they believe that, And Johnson says this explicitly in his writings.
- 36:57He said it from his pulpit that when Jesus said to his disciples in
- 37:00the Upper room. We have this recorded in John chapter fourteen, the key
- 37:05verses, verse twelve, where Jesus said to them, the works that I
- 37:09have done, you will do also, and greater works than these will you
- 37:14do. And that word works there in our English Bibles is the translation of
- 37:20a Greek word for believe it or not works. So that's why responsible translators
- 37:30have consistently uniformly used the word works to translate the word the Greek word er
- 37:37gone in John fourteen twelve. Well, Jesus is the one who came and
- 37:40said, greater works than these will you do. So here's the one who
- 37:45has just set a high water mark for the miraculous, beyond anything we've ever
- 37:51seen before. And then he makes this announcement and he invites us into a
- 37:55discipleship process where he teaches his own disciples raise the dead, cast out devils,
- 38:01cleansed lepers. He imparts that he includes that in the Great Commission.
- 38:07But the point is that if you believe that the works that Jesus referred to
- 38:12were miracles and miracles and more miracles and only miracles, then you have already
- 38:19interpreted the passage to mean that it's not transparent from the use of the Greek
- 38:24word ergone. And there's a translation so called of the Bible that serves the
- 38:30purposes of the Bethel Movement, especially called the Passion Translation produced by Brian Simmons,
- 38:38where he translates I put that in quotation marks the word ergone into the
- 38:45English word miracles, which is utterly irresponsible for any translator to do, but
- 38:52so it is, and so it helps to foster the impression already existing in
- 38:57the minds of many that when Jesus spoke to his disciples in this way,
- 39:00he was talking about miracles. Now, notice it wasn't just the miracles that
- 39:05Jesus did without exception, you would think, but it's also greater miracles than
- 39:09the ones that he did. So they have to be greater in some sense,
- 39:14whether it's quantity or quality or some other thing. There has to be
- 39:17some real difference between the miracles that they perform and the miracles that Jesus performed,
- 39:23And not only a difference between himself and his disciples, but between himself
- 39:29and all who believe on him through their witness, because Jesus says that this
- 39:35promise holds for those who believe in Me, and not just for the disciples
- 39:39who believed in him. So you see quickly, now we have some tests
- 39:44for the accuracy of the Bethel Movement interpretation of John fourteen twelve. First of
- 39:50all, we have to look at the disciples. What works did they perform
- 39:54that were equal to or greater than the works of Jesus. We look for
- 39:59the facts in the Book of Acts. The Acts the Apostles gives us a
- 40:04record of the works that they did on this earth during their life in fulfillment
- 40:08of this promise that Jesus gave. And yes, we see that miracles occurred.
- 40:14What we don't see are any miracles that would outstrip the miracles of Jesus.
- 40:19So no greater miracles per se and I can't think of anyone who's come
- 40:22up with examples of miracles that were performed by Paul, Peter, Philip,
- 40:28any of the evangelists during the Early Church period recorded in acts that were different
- 40:34in kind or in magnitude than anything that Jesus did, and that would seem
- 40:39to be quite difficult to do anyway, in principle, since Jesus foretold his
- 40:45resurrection and said he would raise himself from the dead, and then that happened,
- 40:51and so he takes responsibility for divine agency in bringing about his own return
- 40:55to life. That certainly was never replicated. And I don't know what would
- 41:00be more impressive of a miracle than that. So what works do we find
- 41:06them performing in the Book of Acts, That's got to be the question.
- 41:09Then that can become a lesson for us about what believers, all believers are
- 41:15capable of doing in fulfillment of jesus promise. And what they did was they
- 41:20preached the gospel to a broader cross section of humanity and through a larger,
- 41:28much larger geographical region. Jesus ministry was confined to Judah and Galilee, to
- 41:34the Palestinian area, to Samaria. That's a small region, but by authorizing
- 41:39and commissioning and empowering twelve individuals, and then later adding Paul to the mix.
- 41:46He was able to shake the world up in a way that never been
- 41:50done before. And it says in the Book of Acts, sometimes in positive
- 41:54language, that they turned the world upside down, and sometimes their critics put
- 41:59it in more negative terms, that they are there disturbing the world with their
- 42:07teachings. And so it was one way or the other. They were making
- 42:12a difference on a grandiose scale. And that difference was that the gospel that
- 42:16Jesus was preaching reached many, many, hundreds of thousands of people, more
- 42:23than anything that he was able to accomplish during his own ministry. It was
- 42:28actually a more complete gospel because now it included the message of the resurrection of
- 42:31Jesus from the dead and stronger evidence of the truths of Jesus claims himself.
- 42:37So this is another thing that's a greater work than the work that Jesus did.
- 42:43And then finally it included the gentiles. Jesus ministry was to the House
- 42:46of Israel. When he commissioned his apostles, his intention was to feel phil
- 42:53fulfill not only his own promises, but the prophecies of the Hebrew prophets that
- 42:59God would be gracious towards the Gentiles. And so it was especially through Paul,
- 43:05whose ministry dominates the second half of the Book of Acts, and so
- 43:09he's always referring to the way that God has now provided salvation and spiritual life
- 43:20to both Jews and Gentiles. It's why he opens his book to the Romans,
- 43:24who are Gentiles for the most part, but also Jews who had converted
- 43:30and lived in Rome, and says in verse sixteen, this gospel is the
- 43:36power of God for salvation to everyone who believes, including both Jews and Gentiles.
- 43:40To the Jews first, yes, but also to the Gentiles. So
- 43:45if you want to understand what works Jesus referred to, you must look at
- 43:50the complete the totality of the works of the apostles in the Gospels. And
- 43:58though they perform mayors, they were never the centerpiece of their ministry as it
- 44:02has become at Bethel Church. So that's a serious misunderstanding. Now, Jesus
- 44:10himself, I said, use the word works elsewhere in the Gospel of John,
- 44:15and oftentimes it refers to him giving the word to people, which in
- 44:20chapter seventeen in prayer before his father, he says he's now going to hand
- 44:25the baton off to his disciples, and they will carry the same word to
- 44:30the rest of the world. So I don't think it's difficult if you have
- 44:34the patience and use a little common sense to sort out what Jesus is referring
- 44:38to in John fourteen twelve. And it's not what Bill Johnson says it is.
- 44:44Now, what about the actual miracles that are supposed to pass for being
- 44:49a similar to or greater than those of Jesus. That's another question altogether.
- 44:53And Daniel, you're right, there is no comparison. There is no comparison.
- 45:00I was recalling yesterday that many of the miracles of Jesus, many many,
- 45:05many of the miracles of Jesus were healing of blind people, sometimes among
- 45:10individuals, sometimes in groups of people. This had never been done in the
- 45:15nation of Israel. There is no account of the healing of a blind person
- 45:20in the Hebrew Bible, in the Old Testament, and we don't see it
- 45:23much in the Book of Acts. I don't think we see it at all
- 45:29in the Book of Acts. Jesus accomplished something that had never been done and
- 45:34is not, as a rule being done. People blind from birth can't see
- 45:37a single thing or receive their side. And this is partly because Jesus exercised
- 45:45divine power when he did it, and he did it as a symbol of
- 45:52his role in enlightening human beings as the unique son of God who was the
- 46:00perfect revealer of the Father, bringing to light these truths. And so that's
- 46:07another difference. So how do you compare healing a paralytic or a blind man
- 46:13with a gold dust falling from the ceiling. There's no comparison. Wow.
- 46:36Wow. In all the cases when Jesus healed, there was always a spiritual
- 46:51component, and it was obvious to the people who received the healing. Jesus
- 46:55even commended them for their faith because it was a spiritual exercise. The really
- 47:00interesting, noteworthy example of this, for multiple reasons is the case of healing
- 47:06of the paralytic in Mark chapter two, where he doesn't heal the man first
- 47:10though that's why he is there is to be healed, and everybody expects a
- 47:15miracle now that they've seen Jesus doing miracles, but instead of working a miracle
- 47:19first, he addresses the man's more fundamental need, and what was that the
- 47:24condition of his soul and his need for salvation through forgiveness. And he says
- 47:29to the son, your sins are forgiven. Now that's quite a declaration.
- 47:35It's not a prayer, it's a declaration. And Jesus is arrogating to himself
- 47:40the authority due only to God, a prerogative that is God's alone, to
- 47:45heal this man's sins. And it caused a unanimous gasp in the audience,
- 47:53as everybody looked to the leaders of the House of Israel, the Pharisees and
- 47:59Sadducees, who were gathered and sitting on the front row, who must who
- 48:01were thinking. Jesus said that this was impossible, because only God can forgive
- 48:07sins, and it looked impossible even after he did it, because there's no
- 48:10way to test it. And so to demonstrate his authority, he then turned
- 48:15to the man and said, rise, take up your palate, and go
- 48:17home. And he did. Now that is the work of Jesus, to
- 48:24forgive men of their sins, and to demonstrate his authority to do it through
- 48:30the healing of the paralytic gold dust feathers flying. None of that comes even
- 48:37close in character to the sort of miracles that Jesus did. Now, if
- 48:42the disciples did it, they did it in the name of Jesus, right,
- 48:45So there's clearly a difference between the production of a miracle by Jesus himself,
- 48:52who didn't do it in his name, he did it in his strength,
- 48:57and an apostle who did it in his name, also in the strength
- 49:01of Jesus. Thank you for that, Doug. That was a really really
- 49:06good and solid discussion on the miracles of Bethel versus the actual miracles that Christ
- 49:13and the apostles did. Let's transition out to Bethel School of Supernatural Ministry.
- 49:17Let's talk about that a minute. What is it and what kind of impact
- 49:30does it have on the church globally. So, Bethel School Supernatural Ministry is
- 49:37a full time, three year, full time program where students can enroll and
- 49:43they basically enrolled to learn to become miracle workers. And Bethel School Supernatural Ministry
- 49:49has a curriculum that they've put together that other churches and organizations purchase, and
- 49:54so churches throughout the United States even around the world are starting their own of
- 50:00supernatural ministry using Bethel's curriculum. Or many in our churches actually have developed their
- 50:06own curriculum with their own supernatural schools the ministry. But the idea is that
- 50:09they're activating people. That's a nar buzzword. They're activating people in the miraculous
- 50:16and so activation is essentially the idea that spiritual gifts that people have that they
- 50:23might not be using miraculous gifts like prophecy or healing and working miracles, these
- 50:30gifts need to be like triggered in order for them to start using them.
- 50:36And so so at these schools the supernatural ministry, they promote promote activation exercises,
- 50:43things like Bethel has promoted things like having two people get together and one
- 50:47of the people's blindfold. One of those people is blindfolded and they're supposed to
- 50:52say whatever pops into their head as a prophetic word, word of revelation from
- 50:58God for the other person. And so this is the way they teach students
- 51:01to prophesy. Or they promote things like playing prophetic Uno. So if you
- 51:07know the Uno card game that a lot of people know, they'll tell their
- 51:13students to get like a deck of cards, and I'm getting a group like
- 51:16of you know, it says six to eight students, and as you can
- 51:21see there, it says, you know, they draw a card, So
- 51:23if they draw a red card, they're supposed to give a prophetic word to
- 51:27the person on their left about their financial situation. If they draw a green
- 51:30card, they give a prophetic word to the person on their right about their
- 51:34relationship with someone close to them. If you draw a blue card, you
- 51:37give a prophetic word to the person opposite about something that concerns them, you
- 51:42know, and it just goes on. If you choose a wild card,
- 51:45you choose, you know what what I The screen isn't up there anymore,
- 51:49but you basically choose whether you want to prophesy it this way or that way.
- 51:52And the idea is they're teaching students who have never prophesied before how to
- 51:55prophesy by just saying what pops into their heads, right from God for someone
- 52:00else. And they're instructed not to filter those words. That's a big key
- 52:05for this is not to filter what the thoughts that pop into your head,
- 52:07but just to go with them and sam as long as they're positive and they're
- 52:12affirming, and so this kind of prophetic activation. You know, we talked
- 52:15about this in our book Counterfeit Kingdom, we have a whole chapter on how
- 52:19New Age practices are entering the Church through nar and this is an example.
- 52:23These prophetic type activation exercises have more in common with like new Age or occult
- 52:29practices like activation exercises people might engage in to learn to become psychics, for
- 52:34example. But the core teaching in nor is that apostles and prophets must govern
- 52:42the church. And the reason for that is because they would say that apostles
- 52:46and prophets alone are authorized by God to bring critical new revelation that will enable
- 52:52the global church to rise up as this end time miracle working army and bring
- 52:57God's Kingdom to Earth. In order to raise up this INtime miracle working army,
- 53:01they're starting these supernatural schools of ministry where students go and learn to become
- 53:08activated in the miraculous so they can become part of this INtime miracle working army
- 53:14that will cause this great INtime revival to occur. They call it the Billion
- 53:16Soul Harvest, when over a billion people will convert to belief in Christ and
- 53:22God's Kingdom will be brought to earth and their teaching and so it's really important
- 53:28to realize that the apostles and prophets governing the church is the critical teaching in
- 53:32our because without the apostles and prophets giving the new revelations, people won't be
- 53:37enabled to learn to work to develop these miraculous powers. And they would say,
- 53:43every Christian should be operating in every miraculous gift. Every Christian should be
- 53:46healing the sick, every Christian should be prophesying, every Christian should be raising
- 53:51the dead. And so that's why they have these schools of ministry, and
- 53:57they also have books and courses and other curriculum and things that are designed as
- 54:04well to teach people to learn to start operating in the miraculous I want to
- 54:08read a quote if I can, from Chris Vallatin. This is taken out
- 54:13of your book, and this is what it says. This is what Chris
- 54:15says. I was lying on the floor and praying one morning when the Lord
- 54:20spoke to me so clearly that it stunned me. He said, there is
- 54:23a new epoch season season emerging in this hour. Much like the Protestant Reformation,
- 54:30there is another reformation coming that will unearth the very foundation. That's a
- 54:37wow listen to that quote. That will unearth the very foundation of Christianity.
- 54:44This move of the spirit will absolutely redefine your ideologies and philosophies concerning what the
- 54:51church is and how she should function. I asked him. He asked God,
- 54:55what will this transition look like? He said, my church is moving
- 55:00from denominationalism to apostleships. Yeah. Right, So in our teaching and in
- 55:09Bethel teaching, the idea is that all churches must be governed by apostles and
- 55:15and so churches that are currently pastor led, churches that are part of denominations,
- 55:23they are outside of God's will for church government if they don't have apostles
- 55:29over them, because God's designed for church government is apostles at the top with
- 55:36all others, including pastors. Uh, they must be submitted to them.
- 55:40They must come under their spiritual covering to use a nar buzzphrase. And if
- 55:45they don't come under their spiritual covering, they won't have the benefits that come
- 55:49from being under their covering. So that means that they the miracles, the
- 55:52healings, the financial prosperity, the protection from demonic attack, all of these
- 55:58things will not be available for churches and pastors that do not come under the
- 56:04spiritual covering and authority of an apostle. And that means that all Christians should
- 56:08be seeking to find a church to attend that is is governed by an apostle,
- 56:13and if if their church doesn't have its own apostle, then they should
- 56:16join a church that has joined an apostolic network like the Bethel Leaders Network is
- 56:22an apostolic network led by the apostle of Bill Johnson and the prophet Chris Valentin.
- 56:27Bethyl Leaders Network exists for you to belong, be impowered, and bring
- 56:32Heaven to Earth. Together, we can take the Kingdom feather then they ever
- 56:37thought it possible? Are you ready for more? Where you have senior leaders
- 56:49of churches will join this network so they can come under the spiritual covering of
- 56:52Bill Johnson and Chris Vellatin and receive all of these supernatural blessings that will come
- 56:59from being under they're covering. Yeah, here's another quote from Vallatin about the
- 57:04Bethel Leaders Network. I woke up in the middle of the night with a
- 57:08decree from the Lord. He said, create a place where leaders can be
- 57:14long. I came to our team and shared the word with them through my
- 57:19tears, I said, we must find a way to create a culture where
- 57:22leaders feel at home, welcomed, honored, celebrated and known. Everyone was
- 57:28immediately on board. We realized that we needed to build a completely new structure
- 57:34to accommodate this divine mandate. After many more months of dreaming, the Bethel
- 57:40Leaders Network BLN was born. So that then leads to this question, and
- 57:49either one of you can answer this as well. About the Bethel Leaders Network,
- 57:53you guys mentioned, you know, there are other Apostolic networks out there,
- 57:58but you guys mentioned it something like a pyramid scheme, if I recall
- 58:01correctly in your book? Is that kind of maybe not a pyramid scheme?
- 58:07But how does all that work? How does how do churches get involved with
- 58:12that? What's what do they have to do if they want to, you
- 58:15know, be a part of the Bethel Leaders Network. Well, one of
- 58:20the things you have to do is open your wallet and pay them twenty seven
- 58:23hundred dollars per year to participate in the network. And I was just reading
- 58:30recently the updated information packet I think was updated last month March of twenty four
- 58:38for their Bethel Leaders Network with I don't know twenty two pages of information about
- 58:44what they provide, what is expected, and the goal there is to attract
- 58:50churches into the shadow of Bethyl and to come under the covering of the Bethel
- 58:55leaders themselves, so that all these churches will allegedly receive the blessings that can
- 59:02only come in this fashion. I believe it is an effort to actually dominate
- 59:09the church globally and from central headquarters at the Heavenly Portal there in Reading,
- 59:17California, at Bethel Church. I think that Bill Johnson believes that he is
- 59:23a reformer for this generation. Notice that the first quotation you put up there
- 59:29by Chris Vallaton compares what they're doing with the Reformation of Martin Luther, John
- 59:36Calvin's Wingley and the others. This is he says, it's much like the
- 59:40Protestant Reformation. It is not in the least like Protestant Reformation. It's a
- 59:46reformation, all right, but it is in diametric contrast to the Protestant Reformation,
- 59:52which did not bring new truths to light, did not depend on new
- 59:57revelation. It was a Bible based by Bible believing movement to bring the church
- 1:00:01back to what it had believed even as recently as the Middle Ages, and
- 1:00:07the Roman Church of which they were a part at the time, was being
- 1:00:12reformed by them to bring it back to its original parameters. And Martin Luther
- 1:00:17was quoting scripture and translated the scriptures into the vernacular Germans so that people could
- 1:00:23see these things for themselves. This is all this new movement is unlike that
- 1:00:29in that it is proffering new doctrines, new revelations that are going to shake
- 1:00:34up the Church, and through the church, the Church shake up the world.
- 1:00:37And we've already received the revelation of God's plan for shaking up the world
- 1:00:43by establishing the church as it is. The next event on God's revelatory calendar
- 1:00:47is the coming of Jesus Christ, as John says at the end of the
- 1:00:52Book of Revelation. Even so, come Lord Jesus, that's the thing that
- 1:00:57we await. So they need new revelations, unlike existing revelation, to launch
- 1:01:06their new reformation, and we're supposed to believe them and take their word for
- 1:01:09it. But Martin Luther and others were not alone. They worked over a
- 1:01:15period of time and solidarity with each other to restore faith in the scriptures and
- 1:01:20get the ship back on course the way it had been. So there's nothing
- 1:01:24like the Protestant Reformation going on here, though it is a deliberate reformation.
- 1:01:30And they believe that they have this special word from God. These prophets who
- 1:01:36you know, have made prophecy again literally prophetic uno. But it's a game
- 1:01:42with them because it's not it's not a serious enterprise along God's design plan.
- 1:01:47You can get it wrong. You don't even have to be accurate to play
- 1:01:51this game and still see your vision come to pass. Well, they can
- 1:01:54see their vision come to pass, but it's not God's vision. If they're
- 1:01:59not trustworthy profits today. If you round the board playing the you know,
- 1:02:04the prophetic game, you don't go to jail if you get it wrong.
- 1:02:07You don't. You certainly don't suffer capital punishment, which was the punishment the
- 1:02:12penalty for getting it wrong if you were a Hebrew prophet. We teach folks
- 1:02:15to clian at their mass to take responsibility for a bad prophetic word or something
- 1:02:19like that, if they give one, there's one more piece I want.
- 1:02:22I don't know if you're going there. But we also teach our people who
- 1:02:25receive word prophetic words like you know, hey, if you get a bad
- 1:02:29word, flesh man, you know, your body has a way to deal
- 1:02:32with to eliminate, to eliminate waste. You know, it's like your spiritual
- 1:02:37body needs to have a way eliminate waste. So it's like, you know,
- 1:02:39I got a word fifteen years ago and it destroyed my life. Oh
- 1:02:43oh please stop. You know, it's like just flesh it and go on.
- 1:02:46And so I don't know why these people claim to be performing greater works
- 1:02:50than Jesus did if neither Jesus nor any of apostles, and certainly not the
- 1:02:54prophets of God in the Hebrew Bible ever made a mistake. Yeah, so
- 1:03:00you're talking about prophecy here, And we had mentioned earlier about prophetic illumination,
- 1:03:07how they kind of take passages of scripture and they interpret it in a new
- 1:03:15way. Do you want to talk about that or talk about an example of
- 1:03:22that, or give an example of a way that they actually do that.
- 1:03:28Well, I can give a personal example from visiting Bethel Church and reading with
- 1:03:34my wife a couple of years ago and Bill Johnson was there. He happened
- 1:03:38to be preaching. I guess you could call it that he hadn't come with
- 1:03:44a text that he took the people through. He brought a text, and
- 1:03:47he launched from that into something that wasn't really rooted in the text. And
- 1:03:52I presume that he did that through what they call prophetic illumination. If you're
- 1:03:57an apostle or a prophet, you have this means of access to God for
- 1:04:01new revelation, for the church, for prophetic revelation, predicted prophecy, but
- 1:04:08also for illumination into the meaning of a text. It might be something that
- 1:04:12has special application to your particular audience at the time. And there he was
- 1:04:15in the Old Testament, and he was claiming that what the passage was saying
- 1:04:24would be realized in the experience of those people. And then I think he
- 1:04:29not only distorted what it was saying to the original audience, but then his
- 1:04:31application of it to the contemporary audience was all rooted in some special insight,
- 1:04:38presumably only he had received the night before in the middle of the night,
- 1:04:42as part of this preparation for the sermon. That's the kind of thing that
- 1:04:46is done. So scripture gets distorted in multiple ways. Here, one is
- 1:04:53through just casual interpretation of making mistakes. I think the way that John fourteenth
- 1:05:00well is handled is just poor exegesis. It's not even attempt at serious exegesus.
- 1:05:05There's no comparison with other passages. There's no consideration of alternative possibilities.
- 1:05:11They just dogmatically declared that they know what it means, and then they might
- 1:05:15not even presume to know it based on prophetic illumination because Paul sorry Bill Johnson
- 1:05:19says that in that case, it's obvious to anybody who just reads it and
- 1:05:25has his eyes open, he's got to know that that's a reference to miracles.
- 1:05:29But I've already spoken to that. So that's just abuse of scripture without
- 1:05:33taking responsible measures to try to get it right, not even trying really to
- 1:05:39get it right. And then the second is through prophetic illumination that we're talking
- 1:05:44about now, where they believe that as they read the scriptures privately and because
- 1:05:49they are Apostolic, the Holy Spirit breathes on the pages and illuminates their minds
- 1:05:56with new understanding of what these passages mean. Yeah, I got an example
- 1:06:00of that that I want to play for you. This is the same example
- 1:06:03that you mentioned in your book. This is Bill Johnson on said, wrath
- 1:06:10watch this. I was reading Isaiah sixty, Verse one, Ray shine,
- 1:06:14for your light has come. The glory of the Lord has risen upon you.
- 1:06:17From the whole darkness will cover the earth, deep darkness to people,
- 1:06:20But his light will appear upon you. His glory will be seen upon you.
- 1:06:26Kings will come to your light, and nations to the brightness of your
- 1:06:29rising. I was reading that's the first three verses. But I was reading
- 1:06:31through Isaiah, and you know what it's like. It's like when you read
- 1:06:35something and God just breathes on it. It just seems to leap off the
- 1:06:40page. Even though I couldn't have explained it to anyone. I couldn't.
- 1:06:43I didn't have the insight to explain. Yet I knew that this was life
- 1:06:46to me. I could feel the breath of God on those verses. So
- 1:06:51I took that verse. I shared it to our church on Sunday. I
- 1:06:56said, I feel like this is the word force right now and the same
- 1:06:59thing up into the entire room. I shared it another meeting other leaders,
- 1:07:03where there they said God has been saying the same word for us, that
- 1:07:08this is a present day word that the people of God are to rise because
- 1:07:12the glory of God will be seen upon us. Many people wait to rise
- 1:07:16if I can use that place of faith or a place of confidence. Many
- 1:07:19people wait to rise until that glory is manifested. He is saying, you
- 1:07:26rise and the glory will be seen. I will answer your posture with Heaven's
- 1:07:30invasion. I'll put my sign of presence upon you if you'll take your right
- 1:07:34place. So that is, that's the exact quote that you mentioned in your
- 1:07:42book, and I just wanted to I wanted to show you guys that,
- 1:07:44and either of you guys can comment on that. Well, I would add
- 1:07:47that you know, when he says to sid Roth, who's interviewing him there
- 1:07:56in front of a live audience, obviously you know what it's like. Well,
- 1:08:00I suspect that sid Roth does probably know what it's like to experience that
- 1:08:03I don't, And I thank God for protecting me from that delusion that we
- 1:08:11can receive that kind of knowledge of what a passage means. In that way,
- 1:08:15we see both sorts of distortions. It's a distortion of the original intended
- 1:08:18meaning he has no concern with what the author of that book, Isaiah originally
- 1:08:26intended and what it meant in its original context. And so the second distortion
- 1:08:31in is I can make this mean whatever I think it means, or feel
- 1:08:35it means, or want it to mean, now that I lead this global
- 1:08:40movement as an apostle from the ready in California. And so he applies it
- 1:08:45in a way and then thinks that he can appeal to a consensus among other
- 1:08:50nar prophets and apostles who have been getting the same urge within themselves that this
- 1:08:57is the message of God. Guys, thank you so much. I want
- 1:09:02to close with an appeal to people who may be caught up in this movement.
- 1:09:09What words would you words of encouragement or warning would you have for them?
- 1:09:15Personally, somebody who might be watching this video that might be caught up.
- 1:09:18Either of you can or both of you could could speak to that.
- 1:09:24One thing I'll say is that if there are people listening and if they felt
- 1:09:30like something was off at their church or the teaching that they're hearing from somewhere,
- 1:09:38not to be afraid to question teachings, you know, especially if they're
- 1:09:44in a context where people are claiming to be apostles and prophets, they may
- 1:09:46be afraid to question the apostles and prophets because they've been maybe taught that questioning
- 1:09:53the apostles and prophets might bring judgment from God, or it might mean they
- 1:09:56have a demonic spirit influencing them, or something like that. But we know
- 1:10:00from Acts Acts seventeen eleven we learned about the Briands and how when the Apostle
- 1:10:06Paul brought new teachings to them, And this was the apostle Paul, when
- 1:10:12he brought new teachings to them, they didn't just accept what he said without
- 1:10:15question, but they searched the scriptures intently to see if the teachings he was
- 1:10:21bringing were so and were true. And the scriptures they searched would have been
- 1:10:27the Old Testament scriptures that they had at that time. And so if even
- 1:10:30the Apostle Paul, if his teachings needed to be questioned to make sure that
- 1:10:38they lined up with scripture, how much more so is that true of any
- 1:10:42leader today, a teacher, someone claiming to be an apostle prophet, that
- 1:10:45we should uphold their teachings to scripture and search the scriptures to see if their
- 1:10:50teachings find support there. Okay, that, yeah, read your Bibles.
- 1:11:00We're hearing from so many people who said, if I had only been reading
- 1:11:04my Bible for myself, I would have come awakened to these things much earlier
- 1:11:11on. And some have said, I've repented of my naive acceptance of the
- 1:11:17authority these people without testing it against scripture, and now having left the movement,
- 1:11:25I'm discovering what almost seems like a completely different Jesus in a different Gospel
- 1:11:30than what I was raised in or what I was hearing and believing at the
- 1:11:32time. These are dramatic testimonies, and I think that they should be testimonies
- 1:11:39that give people in the movement hope, because I think that within the movement
- 1:11:43there's also a great deal of disillusionment and concern, a disconnect between what they
- 1:11:50believe they're observing among those around them, but they know that they're not experiencing
- 1:11:56in their own personal lives. And this is the first source, the first
- 1:12:00simulus I think to really take a close look and see, look under the
- 1:12:03hood, and test these things for yourself. There are all sorts of tools
- 1:12:08out there that can help you do this, but it begins with reading your
- 1:12:12own Bible for yourself and holding them accountable. But you've got to go to
- 1:12:15them with their questions, ask if anybody has ever proven their apostleship as Paul.
- 1:12:25Did you know the apostle Paul was that took great pains to establish and
- 1:12:30prove his apostleship so that he could be trusted, and we know how he
- 1:12:34went about it. I don't know of any place where Bill Johnson has effectively
- 1:12:41defended his own apostleship. That's something he needs to do, and people surrounding
- 1:12:45him need to ask him to do it. There should be no embarrassment if
- 1:12:49it's genuine, there should be no reluctance because he has the best example he
- 1:12:55could possibly have in the form of the original apostles in Paul himself. So
- 1:13:00let's follow the example of Scripture in our own behavior, and let's call for
- 1:13:03others in leadership over us to do the same. That would be my primary
- 1:13:11sort of practical application here. You said, if there are people watching who
- 1:13:15are involved in this movement. Clearly from the clip that we saw last at
- 1:13:20the sid Roth interview with Bill Johnson with flashes to the audience, you could
- 1:13:26see how people were eating it up and believing it just on the strength of
- 1:13:30Bill Johnson's word that's what we need to be careful of. And it's not
- 1:13:34just Bill Johnson who's responsible for what he teaches, but anybody who believes his
- 1:13:39message is responsible for believing it. Amen, guys, I am so thankful
- 1:13:45that you took time out of your busy schedules to join me today and talk
- 1:13:48about this. And I'd be honest with you, we could sit if if
- 1:13:54it were possible, we could sit and talk for two more hours about this,
- 1:13:58because we just kind of scratch the surface here, you know what I
- 1:14:01mean, We didn't, you know, but so I would love to have
- 1:14:04both of you guys on again. Folks, this is the book you need
- 1:14:09to get right here. You need to buy this book. I'm going to
- 1:14:12put a link to it down in the YouTube description, as I said,
- 1:14:15but it is so well researched and so well done and you are not going
- 1:14:19to be able to put it down, I promise you. Folks, thank
- 1:14:23you so much for watching, and Lord Willing, we will see you next week