Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Engineering Outlook 2025: Growth, Tariffs & the Workforce Crunch
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome to Engineering Influence Podcast from the American Council of Engineering Companies.
- 0:09We're here from our 2025 fall conference in now sunny San Diego.
- 0:14Cloud cover is burned off, and we are talking the state of the economy in engineering.
- 0:20And to do that, I'm very pleased to be joined by John Gray, Rockport Analytics.
- 0:25He is one of the authors of our newest economic forecast and really just the
- 0:31state of the engineering industry right now. John, thanks for pointing us.
- 0:36Well, thanks for having me. I'll do my best to keep the sunshine.
- 0:40I know, right? Not roll the clouds in. We're talking about economic forecast.
- 0:44I know, right? It's been interesting, to say the least.
- 0:48We've had a bunch of work done with the ACAC Research Institute on sentiment
- 0:54surveys, taking the snapshot in time. And we've been doing that on a quarterly basis.
- 0:59We're starting to do mid-quarter lightning goals. And now we've had those results,
- 1:04but now we have the greater picture of where the industry is and what people
- 1:10are thinking about five years down the line, right?
- 1:13So where are we?
- 1:16Big question. Where are we? Yeah, so this is the time of year that we always
- 1:21do that rehash and really look backward year and see kind of how we performed as an industry.
- 1:28As you mentioned, we're doing the sentiment studies a little bit more frequently.
- 1:31And what we saw, we're looking back at 2024, which is obviously the last full
- 1:37calendar year that we have data available for.
- 1:41And the industry is continuing to perform very well.
- 1:46$459 billion in the U.S.
- 1:49Was generated in revenue collectively among engineering and design services firms.
- 1:55That was up 5.3% over the previous year, so another strong year.
- 2:01We are seeing that growth start to moderate a little bit.
- 2:04We've got some headwinds that I'm sure we'll talk about. And some of those headwinds
- 2:09have started to set in last year.
- 2:12But by and large, just another really strong year. This is four years consecutive of growth.
- 2:18We've seen about 35% growth since the lows that we saw in 2020 of those COVID bottoms.
- 2:26And so it's been really a tremendous period for the industry in general.
- 2:30So we've seen growth in the amount of industry revenue. We're seeing the growth
- 2:34in the amount of contribution to GDP. we're seeing employment growth as well, right?
- 2:39The numbers there are going positive.
- 2:42Of course, there are headwinds there, and we will talk about those.
- 2:45And even the number of engineering establishments themselves.
- 2:48I mean, it seems like, you know, there has been a positive growth trend.
- 2:53But looking at some of those headwinds, you know, in the sentiment studies that we've done,
- 2:57there's always been a good high level of optimism from the feeling of my firm's
- 3:03doing pretty well personally, and then also general optimism on the macroeconomy.
- 3:09However, we have noticed a little bit of softening, right?
- 3:14And let's talk about that a little bit, especially the big guys,
- 3:18taxes, tariffs, to an extent workforce, right? So let's start with the taxes.
- 3:26IIJA, that is now old history. We're looking at a surface for authorization.
- 3:31How have tax policies impacted the industry?
- 3:36Yeah, I mean, that's been one really favorable area, right?
- 3:40We've seen certainly tailwinds through the tax plan that passed earlier this
- 3:47year. I think that was, you know, very business friendly and it was friendly
- 3:51to engineering and design services businesses.
- 3:54And so I think that certainly from a top line revenue standpoint has been a
- 4:00tailwind. And you mentioned IIJA.
- 4:03Yes, we're pretty far down the line now, almost five years, I think,
- 4:07since that bill was signed.
- 4:09And we were expecting a lot of this funding to hit the market.
- 4:13That's the question, right? It's like, yeah, the sugar high of passage,
- 4:16but it's a question of getting money out of the door.
- 4:19Yeah. You know, and how is that, you know, how does that impact,
- 4:24you know, how really firms are
- 4:26seeing themselves and then also just the general impact on our society?
- 4:30The work done to improve the economy or plug back into it
- 4:33yeah i think you know on the negative side of
- 4:36the ledger certainly the rollout has been fairly slow so that
- 4:39means we don't have infrastructure built to
- 4:42the degree we would like it to at this point you know if you want to look at
- 4:46you know that glass being half full if you will we still have years of additional
- 4:52stimulus that are coming down the line right and so and frankly you know a lot
- 4:58of these sort of longer tail projects,
- 5:01we talk about the update of the energy grid.
- 5:04I mean, that's where, you know, we'll talk about AI, obviously, a big topic.
- 5:09And we're going to need the energy to support that. And a lot of those IIJA
- 5:14funds that are going to go into those projects to update the grid,
- 5:18they're going to take, you know, decades or longer.
- 5:21And so, yes, we do need this infrastructure now, But it's also a good thing
- 5:27that, you know, we're going to continue to see in terms of the performance in
- 5:31firms, these funds roll out.
- 5:34Because frankly, if all of these funds were hitting the market right now. Yeah.
- 5:38We'll talk about staffing. I just don't think the industry really has the capacity
- 5:43to be able to grow and use them adequately. Yeah, absolutely.
- 5:47Before we talk about workforce, let's talk about backlog.
- 5:52How are firms looking at backlog right now? How is that impacting the industry?
- 5:57And with all this work coming out on stages, the money flowing into the projects,
- 6:01how is that mix going? Yeah.
- 6:05And backlog, I know, is something that the Research Institute is measuring on
- 6:09a quarterly basis in sentiment.
- 6:11And, you know, I think we started to see, you know, smaller levels of backlog
- 6:17for a brief period of time. Yeah.
- 6:19And then that's crept back up. So we're again seeing that backlog pretty strong.
- 6:25You know, we are starting to see some headwinds that is impacting demand and
- 6:30may start to impact that backlog.
- 6:32But as of right now, it remains very strong. So let's talk about tariffs real quick.
- 6:38I mean, that's looking at the
- 6:39numbers from 2024, you know, it wasn't completely baked in, right? Yeah.
- 6:44You know, just putting on your normal economist hat, right?
- 6:48What do you think the impact of tariffs have been? I mean, I'm hearing everything
- 6:52from, yeah, there's still great uncertainty.
- 6:55Yes, there's going to be an issue, especially when it comes to,
- 6:57you know, input costs on project completion and what the, you know,
- 7:04contractors are actually buying and using, how that is going to impact the engineering
- 7:08sector. But then also that that.
- 7:11Built-in resilience over time of firm leaders realizing that just because there's
- 7:15a tariff announced doesn't mean it's actually going to take place.
- 7:18Where do you think this is all leaning right now? Is it a taco?
- 7:22Is it not? You know? Yeah.
- 7:24I mean, it's a really tough question to answer, right?
- 7:29And so that's kind of where all of us are thinking through kind of the economic impact of this, right?
- 7:36And so in 2024, And before, as you mentioned, you know, Trump got voted in office,
- 7:42I think we all looked around and said, there's a number of things that are likely
- 7:45to happen. We're probably going to have less regulation. Yeah.
- 7:48We're probably going to have lower taxes. And there's this whole tariff thing
- 7:52and where is it really going to go?
- 7:54And I don't think we really thought that it was going to elevate to the degree.
- 7:59I don't think anybody did. Then of the announcements that we saw on the so-called
- 8:03Liberation Day, those big boards coming out. Yeah.
- 8:07And everyone kind of went, oh, wow. And so clearly since then,
- 8:11we've seen rollback and, you know, a lot of this is clearly sort of negotiation
- 8:17tactics and... But at the end of the day...
- 8:20Trying to ask somebody what the tariff rate is going to be on a minimum's feel,
- 8:27on general goods and services, across all these different economies that we
- 8:32trade with, it's really tough to handicap.
- 8:35So I think, you know, and that's what's having a bit of an impact when we think
- 8:40about uncertainty is, you know, businesses have a hard time planning.
- 8:43And no matter what, we're going to see some costs go up. You mentioned input costs.
- 8:48I think that's, we already have, you know, interest rates that are restrictive
- 8:53and are slowing construction in certain segments.
- 8:57And now with the cost of materials, building materials going up again,
- 9:03there are going to be more project delays and things are going to be put off.
- 9:07Now, some of that might get made up when we get out and there's a little bit
- 9:11more clarity and we've got pent up demand and we see that.
- 9:15But until we really know what all of that's going to look like and how things
- 9:19are going to shake out, it's very difficult to handicap.
- 9:21Yeah, it's interesting to see exactly how the industry is going to react just
- 9:25psychologically. Because 99% of this to a point, psychological,
- 9:29so you just don't know what's going to happen until it does happen.
- 9:31But it's going to be interesting to see exactly how.
- 9:35I don't know, built in a lot of the anticipation of the tariff announcements
- 9:38that are going to be moving forward in 2025 when we do your next assessment
- 9:41is going to be how volatile was that to industry performance?
- 9:46Yeah, I mean, look, let's hope this time next year we have a lot more clarity
- 9:50and we can look back and say, OK, this was a disruption, but here's what we are moving forward.
- 9:56I think just having that footing will give us all the confidence because let's
- 10:01face it, we're an economy that's performing very well. The industry has been performing very well.
- 10:07You know, we just need a little bit of structure to be able to know how to move forward. Absolutely.
- 10:13Now, let's go back to that point. It's like if all the money came out not once,
- 10:16we wouldn't have people to do the work.
- 10:19Workforce major issue always will be for us. What are you seeing right now in
- 10:24engineering workforce?
- 10:25The rate of employment, hiring and what the industry really needs.
- 10:30Yeah, it's tough. I mean, I would say it's the biggest challenge that is facing the industry now.
- 10:36I think obviously we talked about the uncertainty around tariffs,
- 10:40but just not having the people that are needed to support the demand if it's there.
- 10:48We've seen it, we saw it spike really 22, 23, and we have seen a little of the
- 10:55pressure ease as demand has waned a little bit.
- 10:59And so as we've seen interest rates rise, and as I mentioned,
- 11:03some of these projects get stalled or slow down, that has taken a little bit of the edge off.
- 11:09But I think the bigger challenge, the longer term challenge is more structural,
- 11:14and that's on the supply side of labor.
- 11:17It's really thinking about demographics and where we are, right?
- 11:23We've got a lot of the workforce in the industry nearing those retirement years.
- 11:32And so over the next 10 years, we're going to see a lot of, in particular,
- 11:37senior level people leaving the workforce. Yeah.
- 11:40And we don't have enough engineering talent to really fill in those gaps, right?
- 11:45And so it's a big problem that as an industry, we're going to have this all.
- 11:50Yeah, and that's why our focus is so much on workforce now, next gen,
- 11:56firm of the future. It all ties together.
- 11:58The immigration debate, of
- 12:00course, is something which wasn't in your forecast because it's brand new.
- 12:04The restriction on H-1Bs, I think the public debate on that,
- 12:08you know, the administration says, you know, the jobs should go to Americans first.
- 12:14We're not an industry that has that challenge, right? It's not a question of
- 12:17that. It's a question of we don't have enough people. There aren't the people. Yeah.
- 12:21So we need those visas issued to be able to fill in that gap because,
- 12:27you know, I thought it was interesting watching the keynote at lunch today and
- 12:32thinking about, you know, this competition that we're in, you know, nationally.
- 12:38And certainly our leadership, you know, political leadership sees that.
- 12:42But, you know, you've got to see the details underneath this.
- 12:47And I think there's a lot of unintended consequences that can come from these
- 12:51policies that can put us behind as a nation.
- 12:54I mean, you're looking at an industry that's actually doing pretty well on the
- 12:58numbers, right? We're growing.
- 12:59We're generating more tax revenue. We're putting more into the GDP.
- 13:03We are hiring more people as much as possible. So we're an industry that's doing
- 13:07really well. that's essential to accomplishing most of the national policies
- 13:12that we're trying to put out there, right?
- 13:14But then you have an immigration policy that could cut us off at the knees,
- 13:18right? And that's something to consider.
- 13:21Exactly. It's one big key that could unlock a lot of economic potential in the industry.
- 13:29Yeah, that's going to be.
- 13:32An issue we're advocating on you guys provide us with the information and then,
- 13:36we we we take it to the people that power you do
- 13:39the hard work yeah you know
- 13:41so what's what's what's next up for
- 13:45you guys in the institute so you do i mean you are
- 13:47a powerhouse when it comes to that the nice thing is
- 13:50you know and i'm so happy when we started doing this is that you know at the
- 13:55earlier stages we didn't own the data we didn't we weren't able to say here's
- 13:59the size scale scope of the engineering industry and its component parts sector
- 14:04impact everything like that now we actually had a tangible data through the
- 14:08sentiment stuff and all that we now have actual.
- 14:11Data that we just started doing trend analysis so now we have this economic
- 14:15wealth of information how are you looking to build on that what what comes next
- 14:19yeah i think just building year after year like you said having this longer
- 14:23time series of data allows us to do a lot more allows us to understand a lot more.
- 14:28We can start to see doing the sentiment analysis, what those correlations are
- 14:33between a lot of the economic forecast that we're doing.
- 14:37And then obviously, the work that the Institute is doing with Affirmative Futures,
- 14:41as I mentioned, is just critical for the industry right now.
- 14:45And I think looking at these factors that are going to unlock that next wave
- 14:52of growth, whether it's, you know, the demand for the industry or,
- 14:57like we're talking about, labor challenges.
- 14:59I think workforce, thinking about AI, obviously, is the top of the list.
- 15:05Yeah, I mean, you know, the speaker we had at Lund, Mike Wall,
- 15:10futurist, really, I think, I didn't even think about this, the whole idea of
- 15:14sovereign AI, of moving, it's so...
- 15:17Dissociated across, you know, the entire economy. You have all these companies
- 15:22doing things, but countries have to make a determination.
- 15:26What is the national AI strategy and how do you build out the infrastructure
- 15:29to support that? And how do you actually get it done?
- 15:32You know, that's a whole new area that I don't think anybody's really delved
- 15:38into about what do we need to do to accomplish a national sovereign AI strategy?
- 15:43Yeah, I think it's going to move, as he said, very quickly, And so it's getting
- 15:48in front of it now and understanding what needs to be done to unlock that, because it is critical.
- 15:55And if you look at productivity in our industry, it is lagged.
- 16:01Productivity has grown over the last seven or eight years in engineering and
- 16:06design services at about half the rate, actually less than half the rate of
- 16:10the national average. And I think there's a lot of reasons for that.
- 16:14I mean, you think about the complexity of the industry, you think about how
- 16:19much regulation, how localized it is, and what sort of local knowledge our firms
- 16:25have to have to be able to do the work.
- 16:27It's not very easy to automate a lot of those things, but as we start to work
- 16:34technologies, AI in particular, and the workflows and tools are built,
- 16:40that is rapidly going to change, right?
- 16:42And so I think it really speaks to the upside that we have as an industry.
- 16:48In terms of unlocking that additional productivity. Yeah, it's going to be a
- 16:53it's going to be a double edged sword, right?
- 16:55Because you got the productivity question, the AI can unlock,
- 16:57it can automate a lot of the task takes away from the work that would otherwise
- 17:02be going into the actual projects.
- 17:03At the same time, we can't lose that essence of what we do and why it separates
- 17:09ourselves from a product service kind of a thing, right?
- 17:13It's the fighting against commoditization, but at the same time,
- 17:15embracing technology to create more efficient workflows.
- 17:18How do we balance that? It's going to be an ongoing conversation.
- 17:23Yeah, very true. And again, the speaker this afternoon talking to.
- 17:28You know, it's really having the intellectual capital that you can add to these
- 17:36systems that are being built through artificial intelligence, right?
- 17:40So it's not commoditizing and just building something that is going to get pushed
- 17:45out in a box. It's having the foresight to know how to use them and structure it.
- 17:50And so I think the work that the Institute is doing now to really understand
- 17:54that and unlock that is very important.
- 17:57And it's also people, I mean, he had a great example of Klarna,
- 18:02you know, the financial services company that fired 7,000 people because they
- 18:06thought technology could work, realized that it couldn't, had to hire them back in. In a second.
- 18:11Yeah, right. Somebody that's going to train these things. Yeah,
- 18:14but it's going to be people plus technology. It's going to be turning one person
- 18:17into five, but still keeping that one person in.
- 18:22By giving them ai agents to kind of multiply
- 18:25their work it's we're just always
- 18:28going to need people we're going to need to train to license people to do the
- 18:31work and we just need more of them to just grow the economy and grow the market
- 18:36yeah absolutely yeah so that's the key to fix everything we're there we got
- 18:41it we got it let's just get it done all right we've solved the world's problems.
- 18:46So yes, the new economic assessment and forecast is out.
- 18:51ACEC Research Institute has it up on their website.
- 18:56Definitely recommend everybody to go out and get it. And we'll be talking about
- 19:00it throughout the conference.
- 19:02This is huge. I think the people in the audience this morning really enjoyed hearing.
- 19:07I know they really are eager to get more information. So we're We're always
- 19:11happy to have you guys put it out there and we can use it.
- 19:14Yeah, always great. John Gray, Rockport Analytics.
- 19:17And this has been Engineering Influence Podcast for the American Council of
- 19:22Engineering Companies. And we're going to see you next time.