Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / 💳 Is PayPal Undervalued? A Deep Dive into PYPL’s Intrinsic Value
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to The Deep Dive.
- 0:01Today we're pulling back the curtain on PayPal.
- 0:05I mean, it's a company so ingrained in our daily lives,
- 0:08right? We hardly stop to think about
- 0:10how it actually works, financially speaking.
- 0:13It's everywhere. Exactly.
- 0:15Sending money on Venmo, checking out online.
- 0:17But you know, has this digital payment powerhouse kind of
- 0:21matured into this stable giant or are there still hidden growth
- 0:27engines or maybe even some thinking time bombs under the
- 0:30surface? Yeah, that's the big question.
- 0:32So we'll peel back the layers today, see what the numbers
- 0:34really tell us. Our source material is this
- 0:37comprehensive financial analysis of PayPal and our mission.
- 0:41Well, it's pretty simple. Let's extract the most important
- 0:43Nuggets of insight, help you understand their business model,
- 0:46their strengths, and, yeah, the challenges they face too.
- 0:49Right, turning complex data into something clear.
- 0:51Exactly. Clear, actionable understanding
- 0:53for you. And what's fascinating right
- 0:55from the start of this analysis we're looking at is the
- 0:57disclaimer it includes very explicit.
- 0:59Oh yeah, what does it say? It states very clearly you know
- 1:02this is for informational purposes only.
- 1:04It's not investment advice and importantly it reflects data as
- 1:09of mid 2025. OK, so context is key here.
- 1:12Absolutely. It really sets the tone for how
- 1:14we should approach any deep dive like this.
- 1:17Focus on understanding the data, the business itself, not jumping
- 1:21to conclusions or making immediate investment decisions.
- 1:23It really hammers home that point.
- 1:25Do your own due diligence. Absolutely a crucial point.
- 1:28So OK, let's start at the very beginning.
- 1:30What exactly is PayPal, you know, as a business beyond just
- 1:34the app we all use? And how does this massive
- 1:37platform, because it includes Venmo, Braintree, Zettle, how
- 1:42does it actually make its money? They're not selling physical
- 1:44stuff after all. Right.
- 1:45That's a great question because it's not immediately obvious.
- 1:47Our source breaks down the revenue mix.
- 1:49So in 2024, Paypal's total net revenue was around $31.8
- 1:52billion. 31.8 billion, OK. Yeah.
- 1:55And the vast majority that we're talking roughly 90, maybe 91%
- 1:59came directly from transaction. Fees, Yes, transaction fees.
- 2:02Yeah, these are the fees for processing, processing payments,
- 2:04PDP transfers, merchant services.
- 2:06To give you a sense of scale, that's almost $29 billion just
- 2:10from transactions in 2024. The rest, that remaining 9 to
- 2:1510% comes from what they call other value added services.
- 2:18OK, like what? Things like interest they earn
- 2:21on loans maybe from their BNPL programs, currency conversions
- 2:25when you pay internationally, and various subscriptions for
- 2:28merchants. And this mix, it's been pretty
- 2:31consistent, tells you their core business really is just enabling
- 2:34those payments. So when you look at those
- 2:36numbers, it's clear they're not just processing payments.
- 2:38They're almost like a a digital toll booth right on this massive
- 2:41global highway that keeps expanding.
- 2:43That's a good way to put it. But here's the kicker.
- 2:45Maybe How do they keep that trusted middleman status when
- 2:50everyone from tech giants to tiny startups is trying to build
- 2:52their own roads, You know? Competition is fierce.
- 2:55Yeah, what numbers really show just how ubiquitous PayPal is?
- 2:59Well, the scale is genuinely mind boggling when you dig in.
- 3:02Our source points out a few key figures. 1st FY20 24 PayPal had
- 3:07about 426,000,000 active accounts worldwide. 426,000,000.
- 3:12Yeah, think about it. That's like more than the entire
- 3:15population of the US plus Canada using their platform.
- 3:18It's split between roughly 390,000,000 consumers and
- 3:2235,000,000 merchants and across like 200 markets.
- 3:26Incredible reach. But the number that really
- 3:27captures the activity is their total payment volume, TPV.
- 3:32That's all the money flowing through their systems.
- 3:34In 2024, that hit an astonishing $1.65 trillion.
- 3:38Trillion with AT. With AT Yeah.
- 3:40And that came from about 25.5 billion individual transactions.
- 3:44So if you average it out, each active account made about 60
- 3:46transactions over the years. 60 transactions per account?
- 3:49Wow, $1.65 trillion. That number is, yeah, almost
- 3:54hard to wrap your head around. Isn't it makes you wonder about
- 3:56their server capacity? Right.
- 3:57So OK, what's the core take away here for someone trying to
- 4:00understand the business? Well, I think it means their
- 4:02success really hinges on being that trusted middleman for
- 4:06billions, literally billions of transactions.
- 4:09Right. Efficiency and security are
- 4:10paramount. Exactly.
- 4:11Their competitive advantage, their Moat.
- 4:13It isn't just the tech, it's the trust they've built and that
- 4:17huge network effect. Every new user, every merchant
- 4:20makes the platform more valuable.
- 4:23That classic network effect. Yeah, it's a self reinforcing
- 4:26loop and that's incredibly hard for competitors to just
- 4:28replicate overnight. OK, so that's the money machine
- 4:31and the sheer scale. But you know, no business sales
- 4:34smooth forever. Every big ship faces storms.
- 4:39Our analysis points to some pretty serious headwinds for
- 4:42PayPal. What are the biggest threats on
- 4:44their radar right now? Yeah, there are several.
- 4:46One of the big ones, maybe the biggest headache, comes from
- 4:48just the rules of the road. Everywhere they operate, we're
- 4:50talking about regulatory and political risks.
- 4:53The red tape. Exactly, PayPal is global right?
- 4:56So they're constantly navigating this incredibly complex web of
- 4:59financial regulations. You've got anti money laundering
- 5:02laws, consumer protection rules, new guidelines popping up for
- 5:05things like crypto or buy now, pay later.
- 5:08Right, BNPL is a big one now. Huge Add in global privacy laws
- 5:12like GDPR in Europe, political risks like sanctions, trade
- 5:15tensions. It's a constant tightrope walk,
- 5:18yeah. But some's exhausting.
- 5:19Then there's economic cyclicality.
- 5:21As a payment processor, their volume is directly tied to how
- 5:24much people are spending globally.
- 5:26Makes sense if the economy slows.
- 5:28Exactly. A recession, high inflation
- 5:30making people cut back that can significantly slow down their
- 5:34transaction volumes, and high interest rates.
- 5:36That's a double whammy. How so?
- 5:38Well, it increases Paypal's own funding costs, especially for
- 5:41potential losses on their BNPL loans, right?
- 5:44And it also tends to reduce overall consumer spending.
- 5:47Our source actually notes that profitability dipped back in
- 5:492022, partly because they had to set aside more for risk
- 5:52reserves. And don't forget over 40% of
- 5:55their revenue comes from outside the US, so fluctuating currency
- 5:59exchange rates that can hit their earnings too.
- 6:02Right. The currency risk, OK, what
- 6:04else? The competitive landscape, it's
- 6:05brutal out there in digital payments.
- 6:07I bet PayPal themselves acknowledge substantial and
- 6:10increasingly intense competition worldwide.
- 6:13You've got the big card networks, Visa, MasterCard,
- 6:17other huge fintechs like Stripe Block, which owns Square.
- 6:21And tech giants Apple Pay, Google Pay.
- 6:24Yep, plus emerging crypto platforms, even traditional
- 6:27banks trying to catch up. Merchant loyalty isn't
- 6:29guaranteed. They can switch if someone
- 6:31offers lower fees or you know, a slicker experience.
- 6:34So. They constantly have to defend
- 6:35their turf. Constantly, and you have big
- 6:37players like Visa actively trying to encroach on parts of
- 6:40Paypal's market. Then there's technology and
- 6:42cybersecurity, always a big one for.
- 6:44Oh yeah, massive target. Absolutely.
- 6:46Given the sheer volume and value of transactions, they're a prime
- 6:50target for cyber tax fraud, system outages, their own
- 6:54filings, one about IT breaches could mean loss of trust, huge
- 6:57legal costs, financial losses, reliability and security are
- 7:00just non negotiable. You can't afford downtime or
- 7:03breaches in that business. Not at all.
- 7:05And finally, there are operational and partner risks.
- 7:08PayPal doesn't operate in a vacuum.
- 7:11They rely heavily on 3rd party networks, banks, credit card
- 7:14networks and other partners. The infrastructure behind the
- 7:17scenes. Precisely if there are
- 7:18interruptions there, or if partners like Visa or MasterCard
- 7:22raise their interchange fees, that's the cut the bank gets on
- 7:24a card transaction. Yeah, those little fees add up.
- 7:27They really do. That could hike Paypal's cost
- 7:29significantly, or even limit the services they can offer.
- 7:32Even things like customer support issues can become a real
- 7:35reputational risk. Wow.
- 7:37So it's not just managing their their own tech, it's this whole
- 7:40ecosystem. They're navigating a global
- 7:42minefield of rules, economic shifts, fierce competitors,
- 7:46cyber threats, partner issues. It's incredibly complex.
- 7:49Yeah, that adds a layer most of us probably don't think about
- 7:51when we just click Pay with PayPal.
- 7:53Really shows how interconnected everything is.
- 7:56OK, so let's pivot a bit from those external pressures to
- 7:59what's happening inside the company.
- 8:02How does PayPal actually manage its own money?
- 8:05Our analysis gives us a peek into their cost structure.
- 8:09Where does most of the cash go? OK.
- 8:11Yeah, their biggest cost by far is something called payment
- 8:15transaction expenses, OK. Think of it like the toll PayPal
- 8:19pays to the credit card companies, the banks for every
- 8:22single transaction includes those interchange fees we just
- 8:24talked about. In 2023, these expenses were
- 8:27about $14.39 billion. That's roughly 58% of their
- 8:31total revenue, Avenue 58%. Wow, over half the revenue just
- 8:34goes out the door immediately. Pretty much.
- 8:36And crucially, these costs are mostly variable.
- 8:38They go up directly with transaction volume.
- 8:40Makes sense. More transactions, more fees
- 8:42paid out. Exactly.
- 8:44Another significant chunk is transaction and credit losses.
- 8:47This includes the money they have to set aside, you know,
- 8:50provisions for potential loan losses, especially from those
- 8:53BMPL programs. That was around $1.68 billion in
- 8:572023, so managing credit risk is definitely a notable expense.
- 9:02OK. So transaction costs and credit
- 9:04losses are big. What about other expenses like
- 9:06running the place, marketing? Right.
- 9:08Looking at their other big expenses, what's really
- 9:10interesting is how they're managing them.
- 9:12Take sales and marketing. That budget actually shrank by
- 9:14about 20% in 2023, compared to 20220.
- 9:18Interesting. Down 20%, yeah.
- 9:20That's a pretty strong signal, right?
- 9:21It suggests there may be moving out of that hyper growth spend,
- 9:25whatever it takes to acquire users mode and focusing more on
- 9:28profitable efficiency. Optimizing.
- 9:30Exactly. Then you have technology and
- 9:32development that covers platform upgrades, cyber security, R&D.
- 9:35It's substantial, about 10% of revenue, but it's also largely
- 9:38fixed costs like IT staff, general and admin.
- 9:41That's your overhead, about 7% of revenue, also mostly fixed.
- 9:45And interestingly, customer service and operations costs
- 9:48actually scaled down a bit in 2023.
- 9:51How they managed that? Seems like it was largely due to
- 9:53increased automation in their support functions.
- 9:56Smart. OK.
- 9:56So what's the main take away from their cost structure?
- 9:59I think it tells us they're really focused on tightening
- 10:03your belt, getting more efficient.
- 10:04Yeah, controlling what they can control.
- 10:06Exactly. And that's a crucial strategic
- 10:08move, especially if that top line revenue growth starts to
- 10:11slow down. It's about making sure they stay
- 10:12profitable even if transaction volume isn't exploding like it
- 10:16used to. Optimizing the engine they've
- 10:17built, right? Makes perfect sense.
- 10:19OK, so beyond the pure numbers, who's actually, you know,
- 10:23steering this massive ship and who owns it?
- 10:27Let's talk about the management, the governance, the big
- 10:29investors behind PayPal. Yeah, good question.
- 10:31There's actually been some significant leadership
- 10:33transition pretty recently, Alex.
- 10:35Chris He came over from Intuit, became CEO in September 2023.
- 10:39OK. New CEO.
- 10:40Yeah. And then Jamie Miller joined as
- 10:43the new CFO just a couple of months later in November 2023.
- 10:47The board itself, it's got a good miss of experienced finance
- 10:50and tech executives. Seems like they have a solid
- 10:52base of knowledge there. And what about management owning
- 10:55stock? Are they heavily invested
- 10:57themselves? Well, the company has strict
- 11:00guidelines requiring executives to hold a certain amount of
- 11:02stock. But the analysis notes that the
- 11:05personal stakes of the current top team were, let's say,
- 11:08relatively small as of early 2024.
- 11:12Interesting. Yeah.
- 11:12It's not necessarily a red flag or anything, but it is a data
- 11:15point. It contrasts a bit with, say,
- 11:17the former CEO, who had a much larger holding.
- 11:20Just something to note about how personally invested current
- 11:22leadership is in the stock price right now.
- 11:24OK. And who are the big owners, the
- 11:25top shareholders? It's overwhelmingly
- 11:27institutional investors, absolutely dominates the
- 11:30ownership structure. You've got the giants like
- 11:32Vanguard, BlackRock, they each hold significant chunks like
- 11:368.35% for Vanguard, 6.7% for BlackRock.
- 11:39State Street, Fidelity are up there, too.
- 11:42So the big index funds and asset manager.
- 11:44Exactly. And these large funds typically
- 11:47tend to vote with management on those things.
- 11:48Like at the 2020 Tree annual meeting, the director nominees
- 11:52were all reelected pretty easily.
- 11:54But I sense a but. Well, there was one interesting
- 11:57vote, the Say on pay proposal, which is about executive
- 12:01compensation. It passed but only got about 78%
- 12:04support. 78%, yeah, that's not overwhelming.
- 12:07Right. It's still a clear majority, but
- 12:09it does suggest maybe some level of investor concern or
- 12:12disagreement on the pay packages.
- 12:14Not enough to force a change, but maybe a signal.
- 12:17No major activist campaigns noted, though.
- 12:19Gotcha. And what about share buybacks,
- 12:21so returning cash to shareholders?
- 12:22Oh yeah, big time. PayPal has a consistent history
- 12:26of share buyback programs. They finished a $10 billion
- 12:29authorization in early 2023 and then started a new $15 billion
- 12:33one in mid 2022. 15 billion. Yeah.
- 12:36And they still had almost $11 billion left on that at the end
- 12:39of 2023. They've been really aggressive
- 12:41with buybacks, especially in 2022 and 2023 when the share
- 12:43price was, well, lower. Buying back stock when it's
- 12:46cheaper makes sense. Exactly.
- 12:47In total, our source says PayPal returns something like 19 to $20
- 12:51billion to shareholders through buybacks just between 2015 and
- 12:552024. And these buybacks have made a
- 12:58real dent in the number of shares out there, cut the share
- 13:00count by about 27% since 2015. 27% reduction, that's
- 13:05significant. It really is a boost earnings
- 13:07per share, obviously. So it's fascinating to see who's
- 13:10in charge, the big institutions owning most of it, and this huge
- 13:13commitment to buy backs. That feels like a pretty clear
- 13:16signal of confidence in the company's long term value, even
- 13:19if maybe the current execs haven't built up massive
- 13:22personal stakes yet. It certainly suggests management
- 13:25believes the shares are undervalued, or at least a good
- 13:27use of capital. OK, let's pull it all together.
- 13:29Now the big picture numbers. How does PayPal stack up when we
- 13:32look at its intrinsic value and its performance over, say, the
- 13:37last decade? This is where the rubber meets
- 13:39the road, right? Precisely.
- 13:41So the analysis we have uses what people often call the
- 13:44Buffett method for intrinsic value, you know, focusing on
- 13:46owners earnings. Which is basically free cash
- 13:48flow. Essentially, yeah.
- 13:50The real cash the business generates that's available to
- 13:52shareholders after all the expenses and necessary
- 13:55investments are paid for. Paypal's trailing 12 month free
- 13:58cash flow as of the analysis was about $6.77 billion.
- 14:03OK, $6.77 billion in free cash. Right.
- 14:06So the analysis runs an example. If you assume, say a modest 3%
- 14:10terminal growth rate forever and you use a 12% discount rate,
- 14:14which is like the annual return you'd require.
- 14:16The calculated intrinsic equity value comes out to roughly $73
- 14:20billion, which interestingly was very close to Paypal's actual
- 14:24market cap at the time of the analysis, around 72 point $6
- 14:27billion. So the market price was pretty
- 14:28much reflecting that calculated value.
- 14:30Based on those assumptions, yes, it implies that to justify the
- 14:33price then you'd need to expect about a 12% return.
- 14:35It suggests the stock wasn't, you know, deeply undervalued
- 14:38using that method, especially if you wanted a significant margin
- 14:40of safety like 3050. Percent.
- 14:42No obvious huge discount there. And consensus estimates for
- 14:45future free cash flow growth were also pretty modest, around
- 14:485-6 percent. Not exactly stellar growth baked
- 14:51in. OK.
- 14:52What about more recent performance like the latest
- 14:54quarterly results? Yeah.
- 14:55Let's look quickly at Q1 2024. They continued to show modest
- 15:00growth and some margin expansion.
- 15:01Net revenue was up 9% year over year.
- 15:04Earnings per share saw healthy double digit jumps.
- 15:07OK. Solid growth there.
- 15:08Total payment volume TPV rose a strong 14% year over year, and
- 15:13TPV per active account was also up double digits, which is a
- 15:16good sign of engagement. Even if total accounts dipped
- 15:19slightly. Yeah.
- 15:20Active accounts ticked down just 1% year over year, basically
- 15:23flat from the previous quarter. But importantly, operating
- 15:26margins expanded thanks to that disciplined spending we talked
- 15:28about. The cost control paying off.
- 15:30Seems so. Free cash flow for just that
- 15:33quarter was strong, about $1.8 billion and they kept buying
- 15:36back shares, returned another $1.5 billion to shareholders in
- 15:40Q1. The CEO, Alex Chris, basically
- 15:43framed 2024 as a transition year, focusing on strategy and
- 15:46efficiency. OK, a transition year.
- 15:48Got it. Now let's zoom way out the 10
- 15:50year financial trends. What does the longer picture
- 15:52look like? Well, over the past decade,
- 15:54Paypal's growth has been really impressive.
- 15:56Historically speaking, revenue grew from about $6.7 billion
- 15:59back in 2013 to around $31.8 billion in 2024.
- 16:04Wow, that's huge growth. Yeah, that's about an 18%
- 16:07compound annual growth rate. COGR profitability also expanded
- 16:11significantly over that time. Gross profit tripled, operating
- 16:14income quadrupled. They are a very strong cash
- 16:17generator. Free cash flow averaged around 4
- 16:20to $5 billion annually in recent years and then jumped
- 16:22significantly in 2024. So historically a growth
- 16:25machine, now a cash machine. Yeah.
- 16:27From a valuation and profitability perspective now it
- 16:30trades at well moderate multiples relative to its
- 16:33earnings in book value around 1718 X trailing earnings based
- 16:36on 2024 EPS. OK.
- 16:38But it's returns are really strong.
- 16:39Return on equity consistently high over 20% recently, return
- 16:43on invested capital usually above 15%.
- 16:45Those numbers tell you it's incredibly good at turning
- 16:48investments into profit. It suggests a highly profitable
- 16:51pretty capital light business. Model high returns, that's key.
- 16:53Definitely. And in terms of liquidity and
- 16:55leverage, very strong position, loads of cash, about $18 billion
- 17:00in cash and marketable securities, moderate long term
- 17:03debt around $10 billion. So financially pretty solid.
- 17:07So the big picture is grew incredibly fast.
- 17:09Now growth is slowing, but it's highly profitable, generating
- 17:13tons of cash buying back stock and as a strong balance sheet.
- 17:16That sums it up pretty well. It's a company that's clearly
- 17:18maturing. It's a very different story than
- 17:21maybe five years ago when it was all about hyper growth.
- 17:24Yeah, the narrative is definitely shifted.
- 17:25It's now more about efficiency, steady cash flow and returning
- 17:29value to shareholders rather than just pure rapid expansion.
- 17:33OK. Well, we've certainly covered a
- 17:34lot today from PayPal Score business model, that incredible
- 17:37scale to the pretty complex risks it faces.
- 17:42Headwinds. Yeah, those headwinds, it's
- 17:43strategic cost cutting, the leadership changes, and then
- 17:45wrapping up with its overall financial health and valuation.
- 17:48It's a really fascinating snapshot of a company that, like
- 17:50we said, touches so many of our lives.
- 17:52Absolutely. And if we connect this all back
- 17:54to the bigger picture, you know, this deep dive drawing from this
- 17:57detailed financial analysis, it really reminds us that
- 18:00understanding a company means digging into the data,
- 18:03appreciating it, but always, always with that caveat, just
- 18:08like our source highlighted right at the beginning.
- 18:09Right, the disclaimer. Exactly.
- 18:11This isn't a recommendation to buy or sell.
- 18:14It truly underlines how important it is to do your own
- 18:16homework, your own due diligence.
- 18:18And hey, for more insights like this, remember to like and
- 18:21subscribe to The Deep Dive on Apple, Spotify, Podcasts, or our
- 18:25YouTube channel. And don't forget, you can find
- 18:27that list of valuable investing books we mentioned right there
- 18:29in the episode description. Great reminder.
- 18:32So what does this all mean for you, the curious learner
- 18:35listening in? Knowing all this about PayPal
- 18:38now, what do you think is the next big challenge they'll have
- 18:41to overcome? Something maybe not even
- 18:43explicitly on this list of risks we discussed.
- 18:47Interesting question. Maybe it's the rise of central
- 18:50bank digital currencies, or perhaps some massive shift in
- 18:53consumer behavior that moves beyond digital wallets entirely.
- 18:56Something for you to ponder as you continue your own deep dives
- 18:59into the world around you.