Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Top Hat (1935)
Transcript
- 0:12Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And I've got rhythm. I've
- 0:24got music. I've got my pal. Who could ask for
- 0:27anything more? Well, look at you. I'm so sorry
- 0:30to ruin this for you. Do you have dance? No.
- 0:33No. No, you have rhythm. I know that. Yeah. Yeah.
- 0:36But very selective rhythm. Well, that's not true.
- 0:39You play guitar. Right. That's the selective
- 0:42nature of it. I can do that. These hips only
- 0:45lie. Oh, anti -Shakira. Anti -Shakira. Well,
- 0:48don't know. You're pro -Shakira. I'm pro -Shakira.
- 0:51You're just the, you're, you are the anti -Shakira
- 0:55is what I'm saying. Not that you are. I'm like
- 0:57when Scott Pilgrim fights Nega Scott. Yes. Shakira
- 0:59would fight me and just be like. When? Why don't
- 1:02you move? And I'm like. Waka waka. I'm like the
- 1:06Timmy. You're dead. Yeah. Yeah. I thought that
- 1:09was a Fozzie Bear reference. Anyway. Well, she
- 1:11does. Isn't that Waka Waka Africa? Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:14What is the song that I just sang? What is that
- 1:16from? The hip. What did you say? I've Got Rhythm.
- 1:19I've Got. Is that not from Top Hat? No. What
- 1:23are we doing? I just did a musical song. I thought
- 1:26you were doing the I Got Rhythm. Yes, I do. I
- 1:28Got Rhythm. How about you? Is that from Top Hat?
- 1:31No. Oh. That might be from. I don't know where
- 1:34it originated, but I was thinking bring it on.
- 1:35Is anything from Top Hat? And you know what?
- 1:38Can we really say where things came from? Is
- 1:40it strange that some things feel the same, almost
- 1:43down to the casting, down to the story, that
- 1:47things feel similar? Is that weird? I think,
- 1:49you know, you can say this was inspired by itself,
- 1:54which is the best way to be inspired, really,
- 1:56you know? And within. Exactly. You'd be inspired
- 1:58within. And the reason that we go off the rails
- 2:02so quickly is because today we're talking about
- 2:04something that is also a little off the rails.
- 2:06It's Top Hat, the second Ginger Rogers Fred Astaire
- 2:09musical that we've covered here on this iteration
- 2:11of the pod. Very excited to be talking more about
- 2:15this because we are pretty heavy into musical
- 2:18territory, man. We have a lot of musicals around
- 2:21us. Yeah. Because Naughty Marietta that we just
- 2:24covered a couple episodes ago, I didn't know
- 2:26that was a musical. Neither did I. Until I was
- 2:28watching it. And then we are recording a triple
- 2:32episode day. We got two musicals here as well
- 2:35with this and the Broadway melody. Do you think
- 2:37Alice Addams would have been better as a musical?
- 2:39I think it would have been better if a lot of
- 2:41things. Spoiler alert. Look forward to that episode
- 2:45on Friday. So with this one, we, of course, see
- 2:48the return of Ginger Rogers and Fred Astaire.
- 2:50But along with them, we see the return of pretty
- 2:52much a lot of people, like almost everyone from
- 2:55the previous film we saw of theirs, which was
- 2:58The Gay Divorcee. Not everyone, but a number
- 3:02of people. Going down that list, well, you know
- 3:05what? I'll let you cover that when we go over
- 3:06cast, because that's pretty much where we see
- 3:08a lot of people return. But with Top Hat, there
- 3:10were four nominations, and those nominations
- 3:12were as follows. For Dance Direction, this was
- 3:16Hermes Pan. We'll get there in a second. We definitely
- 3:19want to talk about that. Original song, Cheek
- 3:22to Cheek. And this is notable because A, very
- 3:25notable song, B, Irving Berlin. Did the songs
- 3:30for this, the score. So very neat. Art direction,
- 3:33Carol Clark and Van Nest Poliglossi. An outstanding
- 3:37production on behalf of RKO Radio. A question
- 3:41for you before we hop into cast. At this point,
- 3:44we stop seeing RKO Radio. Or we start seeing
- 3:47RKO and we see Radio Pictures is now the title
- 3:52when it comes on. Yeah. Was there a time where
- 3:55RKO, they dropped RKO together and they're just
- 3:58Radio Pictures? It may have been a merger somewhere.
- 4:01I'm not super familiar with the history. It's
- 4:04funny because it almost seems like a separation
- 4:06and not a merger because they just dropped RKO.
- 4:08Because remember, it was RKO Radio Pictures.
- 4:10Yeah. Where is it Radio Pictures? In front of
- 4:13a number of these films that we've talked about.
- 4:14For this iteration, no, not iteration, this week
- 4:17specifically. I've noticed it says Radio Pictures
- 4:20instead of RKO. Does it say RKO on the little
- 4:23electric tower that's going? I have to double
- 4:26check, but the tower is, that's the funny thing.
- 4:28The tower is there. The shot is exactly the same.
- 4:30They just changed the wording. And it doesn't
- 4:32say RKO. No, it starts saying radio. Ryan, I
- 4:36don't know if I've noticed that, and now you've
- 4:38got me questioning everything. So it's Bernstein,
- 4:41and not Bernstein Bears. Oh no, not this one.
- 4:46Yeah, I don't know. I'm looking up things, and
- 4:48I'm seeing everything in RKO Radio Pictures.
- 4:52Now I'm going to have to go back and watch every
- 4:55movie that RKO has done. After some research,
- 4:59it's clear that that is a real thing that has
- 5:01happened. It says A Radio Picture instead of
- 5:03RKO Radio Pictures. We're going to do some deep
- 5:06diving to see why exactly that might be. Because
- 5:08to your point, a merger is the first thing I
- 5:10thought of, but a merger wouldn't get rid of
- 5:12the words RKO. It would add something additional
- 5:15and not just drop RKO. So not sure what that
- 5:17was all about, but this was the studio formerly
- 5:20known as RKO Pictures representing themselves
- 5:23as a radio picture. Yeah. Can't wait to find
- 5:26out what that's all about. Do you think there's
- 5:27a chance that it is RKO Radio, but they're just
- 5:29labeling their movies as a radio picture now?
- 5:33I think it might just be. Wait, doesn't it open
- 5:37with... Yeah. What if the RKO is Morse code?
- 5:42That's really cool if it is, but still weird
- 5:44that they dropped it. Because it's... Well, it's
- 5:46radio, which is only an audio format. Yeah, but
- 5:50at that point, just have a black screen. Well,
- 5:52it's a picture. Of course. Come on, keep up,
- 5:58man. Of course. I'm going to look it up for the
- 6:00next RKO picture we cover, which actually is...
- 6:04It's going to be the next episode. We're going
- 6:06to figure it out and sleuth it up here at Once
- 6:09Upon a Time at the Oscars. What we do best. Sure,
- 6:12Ryan. Sure. So, as you mentioned, we have Fred
- 6:15Astaire and Ginger Rogers returning in Top Hat,
- 6:18playing Respectively. Respect? I do this all
- 6:21the time. I'm so glad that you caught this. Respectively.
- 6:24I think I've always been good at it until I met
- 6:27you. You're welcome for that. It's a curse. You
- 6:29have seven days. Respectively. Yeah. As Jerry
- 6:32Travers and Dale Tremont. Returning, though,
- 6:35a number of people. Edward Everett Horton as
- 6:38Horace Hardwick. Eric Rhodes as Alberto Bedini.
- 6:42And you'll remember both of them from The Gay
- 6:44Divorcee. Pretty much playing the exact same
- 6:46characters. Very, very similar. And I'll just
- 6:50come out and say, this movie as a whole is pretty
- 6:53similar to The Gay Divorcee. It's The Gay Divorcee
- 6:562, basically. Now, you don't have Alice Brady
- 6:58returning as... Horton's love interest. Instead,
- 7:02you have Helen Broderick playing his wife, Mage
- 7:05Hardwick. And then Eric Bloor, I don't believe,
- 7:09was in The Gay Divorcee. And he plays the butler
- 7:13character in this named Bates. The other cool
- 7:17name that shows up in this movie very briefly,
- 7:19she has two lines. Allow me to say them here.
- 7:23Well, what can he say, really? Lucille Ball,
- 7:28ladies and gentlemen. That's right. Lucille Ball's
- 7:30in the very beginning. She's the flower shop
- 7:31clerk. She has platinum blonde hair, so it's
- 7:34really, like, you can't tell that it's Lucille
- 7:37Ball. But I did not recognize her when I watched
- 7:40this. I don't think she ever turns and fully
- 7:42faces the camera. You only see her side profile.
- 7:44And really more of, like, her backside profile
- 7:47of her face. Yes. Yeah. But, yeah, I couldn't
- 7:52tell it was her either. I had to... Look up the
- 7:55trivia to know for sure. Thank God for the trivia.
- 7:58Yeah. Two more names that are returning to this.
- 8:00So Alan Scott was one of the screenplay writers.
- 8:04But another screenplay writer who returned from
- 8:06The Great Gay Divorcee, Dwight Taylor. Because
- 8:10The Gay Divorcee was based on a Dwight Taylor
- 8:13story. Came back for the screenplay in this one.
- 8:16He's back as well. And then, of course, directed
- 8:18by Mark Sandrich, the same director as the Gay
- 8:21Divorcee. So across the board, there are many
- 8:24names returning for this one. And that kind of
- 8:29leads the witness here in terms of how we feel
- 8:31about it. But why don't you talk us through a
- 8:34little bit of the brief synopsis of Top Hat?
- 8:38Just go back and listen to our Gay Divorcee episode.
- 8:41No, credit. It's a humdinger. Fred Astaire is
- 8:45a famous dancer, of course, and Horace Hardwick
- 8:49is about to cast him again in one of his shows.
- 8:51He's a producer, right? Yes. Through a strange
- 8:55series of events, he meets Ginger Rogers characters,
- 8:58Dale Tremont. They kind of fall in love a little
- 9:03bit. Like, she's definitely interested, but...
- 9:06She'll tell you if she's not. And then there's
- 9:08a big misunderstanding as to who he really is,
- 9:11and it turns into this big, kind of confusing,
- 9:14just like the gay divorcee, of like, okay, who's
- 9:17he supposed to be? What's going on? But really,
- 9:19they fall in love in the end, and they have to
- 9:21deal with Eric Rhodes being Italian. Aggressively.
- 9:26Aggressively Italian. Yes, thank you. Yeah, a
- 9:29couple things. Meet Cutes change their... Their
- 9:35respective careers kind of change. The misunderstandings
- 9:41about each other, sort of different. Otherwise,
- 9:44this is the same movie. The biggest difference,
- 9:46I would say, Fred Astaire is pursuing her less
- 9:51aggressively. True. Because that was the issue
- 9:53you had with The Gay Divorce Day. It was. So
- 9:55that was very welcoming to me. Because it stressed
- 9:59me out. I was like, chill out, man. But in this,
- 10:02it does feel more mutual. She is more hesitant,
- 10:05but even her reason for being hesitant makes
- 10:07more sense and feels less like, no, you're being
- 10:11too aggressive and creepy, stop. And this is
- 10:14something weird's going on with you. Yeah, I
- 10:18clocked that as well. Now, he does still do some
- 10:22crazy things, such as stealing a carriage. That
- 10:26had me worried. Towards the beginning, he finds
- 10:29out that she's about to leave. And in order to
- 10:31get some time to talk with her, he ends up staging
- 10:34himself as the driver of the carriage. And it's
- 10:39a fun scene. But you do still have to understand
- 10:42that, like, I think the moment that for me became
- 10:45a little worrying was when she was like, how
- 10:47long have you had your license to drive one of
- 10:50these? He's like, oh, I don't. I was like, oh,
- 10:52no. Yeah. This has not been thought out. It's
- 10:55one of these things where you're like. is this
- 10:57grand theft auto it is yeah yeah no he stole
- 11:01a carriage like my concern is what happened to
- 11:03the guy before because there's never a guy that's
- 11:05like hey that's my carriage and he just like
- 11:07went to the bathroom or something this is like
- 11:09is he okay and is he alive he struggles so much
- 11:13to drive it he does get to where he's trying
- 11:16to go yeah does he get it back not not explained
- 11:19who knows i want that sequel now the reason that
- 11:23i'll give it a pass in that is i gotta think
- 11:25that if george clooney just like stole a car
- 11:28and then left it on the side of the road, I wouldn't
- 11:31be like, so George, how did that car get back?
- 11:33I'd be like, you're George Clooney. I mean...
- 11:34What if it was your car? I would have confidence
- 11:37it's coming back to me. If not, Nespresso would
- 11:39hear from me. Nespresso? Doesn't he have a partnership
- 11:42with Nespresso? Oh, he might. I don't know. Here's
- 11:46the problem. I miss my wife. And that's the kind
- 11:49of joke that Taylor would have been like... that's
- 11:52like she's listening right now she's like that
- 11:53was really funny oh okay my bad you just need
- 11:55to like try be married to me more sure if you
- 11:57can like lean into that and like absolve or not
- 12:00absolve but like try and fall into that character
- 12:02i thought i would appreciate with my intro for
- 12:05this episode you would have a little more respect
- 12:07now we sound married yeah there you go you just
- 12:11slipped right into it yeah see look at you you
- 12:13know you're doing um it's funny with how much
- 12:16we say that this is just the gay divorcee but
- 12:19with like some slight changes some good, some
- 12:22bad, that it sounds like a really negative thing.
- 12:25And you said something before we started recording
- 12:28that I think was really telling because we did
- 12:31some history or some research on the history
- 12:34of this movie. And there's a word that kind of
- 12:37came about and it was forgettable. There's a
- 12:40forgettable plot in this. And it's hard to kind
- 12:43of differentiate with a plot of Gay Divorcee
- 12:45versus something like Top Hat. But does that
- 12:48affect the movie? I don't think it does. Right.
- 12:53Because it's still good. It kind of does. Well,
- 12:56it brings it down a little bit for me because
- 12:59I'm like, oh, you did the same thing. But you
- 13:01brought up that the plot of these movies doesn't
- 13:04really matter. It doesn't, no. Because it's just
- 13:06about the dancing. It's just about the dancing.
- 13:08It's a little bit about the comedy. There are
- 13:11just constant jokes throughout these movies.
- 13:15But yeah, as far as the like... Hey, you're supposed
- 13:19to be married to my wife. And that's bad. Like,
- 13:22I don't really care. Yeah. And that's okay. Because
- 13:26in a couple minutes, Fred and Ginger are going
- 13:30to be tap dancing across the stage. And there
- 13:33are going to be super cool choreographed machine
- 13:37gun numbers. And I'm like, yeah, whatever. I
- 13:40don't care what's going on. I'm in. Keep it up,
- 13:42Fred. Yeah, I mean, the only thing I agree with
- 13:45you, the only real difference in the misunderstanding
- 13:47is that in a gay divorcee, she believes Fred
- 13:51Astaire's famous dancer persona to instead be
- 13:56a gigolo. Yeah. That is trying to like bed her.
- 13:59So she's not embracing him for that reason. And
- 14:02then in this one, she believes him to be the
- 14:06Edward Everett Horton character and that he is
- 14:10actually married. Right. So she is not accepting
- 14:14of his advances, but also when she does, she
- 14:16feels bad because she's really good friends with
- 14:19his wife. In this case, Edward, Everett Horton's
- 14:24wife. So that's the real difference here. I agree
- 14:28with you. I think the dancing and the singing
- 14:30does take your mind off of it. I will also say
- 14:33that while Gate of Orsay is the first movie we've
- 14:36seen, so it's easy to say, well, you're just
- 14:38copying the Gate of Orsay. Like, I'm not interested.
- 14:41I will say that I think I like, there's moments
- 14:43of this that I like better than Gate of War say.
- 14:46Some of the moments for me, they're meet cute
- 14:49is when Jerry Travers is above her hotel. He's
- 14:55in the hotel above her room. His room is above
- 14:57hers. That's the word I'm looking for. Let it
- 15:02be known that I have finished maybe a knuckle
- 15:05worth of my coffee. So I'm not doing good. His
- 15:10room is above hers in the hotel. And he starts
- 15:13dancing, tap dancing. Bothers the hell out of
- 15:16her. She calls the front desk. She tries to get
- 15:20him to stop. She begs him to stop. And then what
- 15:23he does, I thought was one of the most romantic
- 15:25things I've ever seen, which is where he grabs
- 15:28a pot. Actually, it's an ashtray. Yeah. And he
- 15:31grabs an ashtray and he starts spreading the
- 15:33ashes from the ashtray onto the floor that he
- 15:36was dancing on above her. And he acts as the
- 15:39Sandman. Yeah. And he starts dancing in a very
- 15:42light and elegant way across the sand to help
- 15:45her get to sleep. And it is one of the cutest
- 15:49things I've ever seen. It's very cute. And it's
- 15:51not like she knows and he's telling her, he's
- 15:53like, hey, did you know I do this? He's doing
- 15:54it for the symbolic purpose of like, I just met
- 15:57this angel. I'm obsessed with her. I'm sorry
- 16:00I bothered her. So now I need to do this. And
- 16:02it even puts Edward Ever Horton to sleep when
- 16:04he's like watching him do it. And then of course
- 16:06she falls down to sleep because there's someone
- 16:08above doing that. And she doesn't know that to
- 16:11me was like an all timer. Like it was very cool.
- 16:14I think of some like in for black and white,
- 16:16I think of like some moments, even outside of
- 16:19black and white, some moments in movie history
- 16:20that to me are like, you can believe in love
- 16:22again. It's a wonderful life. Do you want the
- 16:25moon? I'll throw a lasso around the moon for
- 16:27you. I love that line. Thank you, Capra. This
- 16:30was something that entered that iconography for
- 16:34me. I also think Tom Hanks at the end of You've
- 16:38Got Mail kind of revealing that he is who he
- 16:41is with Brinkley, with Somewhere Over the Rainbow
- 16:44playing. Why that song, I don't know, but it's
- 16:46very effective. There's a lot of moments for
- 16:49me where it's just like... the iconography of
- 16:51love yeah this is kind of like that entered it
- 16:53for me just watching that like big pan out like
- 16:56one take scene of him dancing very gingerly i
- 17:00don't mean that the way it sounds as a pun um
- 17:02on ashes beautiful yeah it's very cool and it's
- 17:08filmed really well too because the camera moves
- 17:11back and forth between the two floors at one
- 17:14point it's funny that you say that do you know
- 17:17what mark sandrich did before he was a director
- 17:19construction worker very close he was a physicist
- 17:22oh um no he was a physicist before he got into
- 17:26filmmaking he was a physicist and he cites that
- 17:30as the inspiration for how he would become a
- 17:32director because he built built blueprints So
- 17:36for all of his films that he was a director,
- 17:38he would build out a blueprint for every shot.
- 17:41Interesting. So what makes that very interesting
- 17:43to me is that, of course, he's got to work with
- 17:45cinematography on this, but that lends to what
- 17:47you're talking about, where he's like, well,
- 17:49this is where the camera needs to be, and then
- 17:51we put it here, and this is the next change.
- 17:53So it feels very clinical in a movie that otherwise...
- 17:57doesn't need to be so i felt that a lot it also
- 18:00makes sense that he would apply that to musicals
- 18:02because as we know fred astaire a bit of a perfectionist
- 18:05so he would want like you know the camera not
- 18:07to be very tied up on like um shoes or like faces
- 18:10or reactions it's got to be on the dancing like
- 18:13the whole body dancing so it makes sense that
- 18:17like you know that perfectionist nature would
- 18:19want a director who wants the entire shot in
- 18:22the uh scene you know yeah Or rather entire scene
- 18:25in the shot. I think it pays off really well
- 18:27in these Fred and Ginger musicals. Oh, it does.
- 18:29Yeah. Because I like that these have their own
- 18:32identity where it's not your Disraeli, put the
- 18:36camera in the audience, hit record. But it's
- 18:38also not like a Busby Berkeley. It has its own
- 18:41very clear identity. That's thanks, Mark, you
- 18:45know, because we need that. You don't want everything
- 18:47to feel like a Busby Berkeley. And I think that's
- 18:49a risk you run into. with how prolific those
- 18:53movies are. It's so interesting because you say
- 18:56identity, and I know what you mean, but we, again,
- 19:00this is so copy -paste The Gay Divorce Act. Right.
- 19:04Right, and it's not just these two movies. This
- 19:06is known that, to your point, it's about the
- 19:09dancing, so they just kind of provide whatever
- 19:10story they can and then just start shooting.
- 19:13So I agree with you. It's like the shell is exactly
- 19:18the same. But the heart of it is a bit different.
- 19:21And the soul feels pretty different. So I agree
- 19:24with you. I think the filmmaking on this is firing
- 19:26a bit better than it did in The Gay Divorcee.
- 19:28I think the writing is a bit better. I think
- 19:30the miscommunication is still very present. But
- 19:33it's kind of a little more believable. It makes
- 19:35the dialogue between some characters a little
- 19:37more fun of like, what do you mean you're okay
- 19:39that I've been seeing your husband? Yeah. Some
- 19:41great lines here and there. I think we could
- 19:43have done something with Bedini. But, you know,
- 19:46we'll get there. Yeah. we will get there i don't
- 19:49i don't want to talk about bedini just yet because
- 19:51i want to talk about some of the dancing too
- 19:52not only is fred astaire's opening number with
- 19:56no strings i'm fancy free fantastic but it does
- 20:00end in him slowing down with the dancing on the
- 20:03the sand from the the ashtray yes and the dance
- 20:07numbers in this i think are so so much more memorable
- 20:11than I think the Gay Divorcee. Definitely. Because
- 20:14in my mind, the one that stands out to me the
- 20:16most in the Gay Divorcee is actually Edward Everett
- 20:19Horton. Oh, that's so funny. I thought you would
- 20:21have said the Continental. Like I like the Continental,
- 20:24but I have the same issue with the Continental
- 20:26that I do with the Piccolino here in that it's
- 20:30less about Fred and Ginger and more about like
- 20:32the grand scale of the chorus lines and all of
- 20:36that. So instead you embrace the one that has
- 20:37absolutely nothing to do with Fred and Ginger.
- 20:40He's very, Edward Everett Horton's very funny
- 20:43in that. The only downside of this movie is that
- 20:45they don't give him a number like that. This
- 20:47is true. He does get a little moment to dance,
- 20:49which is very funny. He has to, Fred Astaire
- 20:51starts dancing to bring Bellini, no, Bedini back
- 20:56up to his room. And right before he comes up,
- 20:59he tells Hardwick, take over. I'm going to go
- 21:02talk to Dale. And Horton's just like. The worst
- 21:08tap dancing ever. It's so funny. I love him.
- 21:11I think he's one of the standouts in these movies.
- 21:14It'd be so easy to complain about the casting
- 21:16being the same if I didn't absolutely love Edward
- 21:19Ever Horton and Fred Astaire. It's funny because
- 21:21whenever like Ginger isn't on the screen and
- 21:24it's just Fred Astaire, you think you'd be like,
- 21:27where's Ginger at? But instead, Edward's there.
- 21:29And I'm like, yeah, let's go. My guy. And we've
- 21:32talked about some people that I think specifically
- 21:35are deserving of the I got to find a good name
- 21:39for it. I'm really happy with a Catherine Keener
- 21:41award that I gave a couple episodes ago. Yeah.
- 21:45I'm very happy with the naming of that. I got
- 21:46to find a good name for this one, too. But an
- 21:48award that I want to give to Ned Sparks and Edward
- 21:50Edward Horton of just like reactionary faces
- 21:53and not even just reactionary faces, but like.
- 21:57I'm going to say something, and then someone
- 21:58else is going to say something else where it
- 22:00points it back at me. And then I'm going to say
- 22:02five words, realize what they say, and then turn
- 22:04and look at the camera in a very mean way. And
- 22:07these guys, those two guys, are the kings of
- 22:09it. Ned Sparks, it's more just kind of his face,
- 22:12but Edward Everett Horton, I need that guy to
- 22:15have a less tongue -twisty name, is so good.
- 22:19So good at that. He knows his part, and he plays
- 22:22it extremely well. That's why it's hard to kind
- 22:25of say, oh, this is a bad movie because it's
- 22:27the same as Gay Divorcee. It works. Yeah. It
- 22:30works extremely well and everyone's playing the
- 22:32part they need to. We'll talk about Eric Rhodes.
- 22:35But I want to talk more about the dance direction
- 22:38that you mentioned. Yes. What is it? No Strings,
- 22:43Fancy Free. No strings, I'm fancy free. Right.
- 22:46That's the first number. That's the first one.
- 22:48The next one that really jumps out to me, not
- 22:50necessarily the next one specifically in canon,
- 22:52but the next one that jumps out to me, really
- 22:54excited to talk about it, Top Hat, White Tie,
- 22:56and Tails. Yeah. So this is one where we actually
- 22:59see him performing on a stage. So what he's singing
- 23:02and dancing is part of like a musical that he's
- 23:05in. And in this, there's a sequence that kind
- 23:09of took my breath away. And it's when there's
- 23:12a number of dancers behind him. And he grabs
- 23:14his cane that he has. And he mimics the cane
- 23:18as a machine gun. And he goes down the line and
- 23:22takes them out individually. And not even just
- 23:25from left all the way to the right. But they
- 23:27actually kind of like say, okay, you're going
- 23:28to do the 13th person. I'm going to do the 26th.
- 23:30You're going to do the 19th. And he uses his
- 23:33tap shoe as the sound of a gun. So whenever he
- 23:37like pulls the cane, he can tap and that kind
- 23:39of make it sound like a gunshot. And this scene
- 23:41goes on for like, I think two minutes. It's got
- 23:44some length to it. It's not quick. And it's really
- 23:47fun. My favorite part of all of this is when
- 23:50he, I think there's maybe like 10 people left
- 23:53after they don't fall down. They kind of just
- 23:55like bend the knee a little bit and kind of like
- 23:57lean over when they're shot. So the remaining
- 24:00people, he starts on the right, I think, and
- 24:03then goes left. And he just starts using his
- 24:05tap shoes to mimic like a machine gun sound.
- 24:08Because the first few people, it's like he has
- 24:10a rifle. So it's just like a bah, bah. A one
- 24:13shot. And then when he's finishing up, that's
- 24:16when he switches to machine gun mode. Yes. And
- 24:17you can hear like that da -da -da -da -da -da
- 24:19of his like tap shoes going down the line. It's
- 24:21so good. And this cane is even kind of like he's
- 24:23losing control of it a little bit. Yeah. The
- 24:25mimicking of that is so good. It's like the miming
- 24:28is very, very strong. It's fantastic. In that
- 24:31sequence. And then it's great at the end. There's
- 24:33one guy remaining and he goes to fire his quote
- 24:37unquote rifle at him. But the guy is kind of
- 24:40dodging the bullets. So he makes a bow out of
- 24:43his cane and then does like a silent like with
- 24:47his with his boot. Yeah. His boot. To kind of
- 24:49mimic the sound of like an arrow leaving a bow
- 24:51instead of like a bullet. Yeah. Instead of tapping
- 24:53the floor, he kind of like brushes his foot across
- 24:55the floor and the guy goes down. And then. Even
- 24:58after the dance number is over, I love when he
- 25:01looks back at the audience, points his cane at
- 25:04Hardwick in the audience, and mimics another
- 25:10gunshot, and everybody ducks in the audience.
- 25:12Because that's how just in it everybody was.
- 25:16You believe it. It's very cool. And I think that's
- 25:19kind of the reason this movie is more memorable,
- 25:22because it has these really unique concepts that
- 25:26they use with the dancing. making a machine gun
- 25:28out of your shoes and a cane. That's awesome.
- 25:31Yeah. We're being more invent innovative. Yeah.
- 25:33And I'm very excited about musicals in its current
- 25:37state right now of 1935, because there is a lot
- 25:41going on where I think the inventive nature continues.
- 25:45Yeah. And I'm glad because in the gate of war
- 25:48say a lot of it really was look how well we can
- 25:50dance. And that's amazing, but we need some like.
- 25:54along with your dancing, we need some like memorable
- 25:56moments. And this one delivers on that. Yeah.
- 25:58Even in the first song, there's, there's a brief
- 26:01moment where he's dancing too close to like a
- 26:03statue or a vase kind of thing. And he knocks
- 26:07it over and then immediately starts dancing.
- 26:09And I do love when Ginger Rogers first makes
- 26:12it up to his room, busts open the door and he's
- 26:15like cradling this statue and just like really
- 26:18slinking around. I can't think of anything more
- 26:22embarrassing than somebody walking in and I'm
- 26:24like, look at me. First off, making that noise.
- 26:28I agree. I agree. That would be terrifying if
- 26:32Taylor walked in on me doing that. But in general,
- 26:36I think the staging, the props that they use,
- 26:40way more innovative in this one. I do want to
- 26:44point out that Top Hat White Tie and Tails segment,
- 26:48he had like, I can't remember the exact count,
- 26:52a number. I would even say an army of canes because
- 26:56he continued to break them. Really? I mean, if
- 26:58you look at that scene again, he's kind of like
- 27:00tapping on the ground, like flipping it around.
- 27:02Like he's tapping it very hard on the ground
- 27:05and he broke a number of them. Wow. And he was
- 27:08getting so frustrated. The take that is used
- 27:11in the film, because I believe the majority of
- 27:13that is one shot. Of course it is. The last take
- 27:17was the very last cane. Really? The take that
- 27:20is in the movie was their very last cane that
- 27:22they had. Wow. Because he was going through all
- 27:23the props. So he was getting pretty frustrated.
- 27:26I think he was pretty frustrated on this set
- 27:28specifically. We talked about it before, but
- 27:31he's, I mean, Astaire was a perfectionist. Like,
- 27:33he was adamant about how dance scenes should
- 27:35be filmed. I mentioned earlier, whole body, no
- 27:38cuts to faces or reactions from the audience
- 27:40watching. The only exception to this rule is
- 27:42in the very beginning and the very end. In the
- 27:45very beginning, the title card is actually Fred
- 27:48Astaire will enter the shot and you'll see his
- 27:50shoes at the top. At the bottom, it'll say Fred
- 27:53Astaire. And then Ginger Rogers comes in and
- 27:54says Ginger Rogers. And then it'll say Top Hat
- 27:57and the cast and everything. Yeah. And then the
- 27:59end of the movie, you'll see kind of like a close
- 28:01-up of their feet coming down the stairs. And
- 28:04then it'll pan out to show them. That's during
- 28:06the Piccolino, I think. And he wasn't. We'll
- 28:09talk about that. But the point is that he was
- 28:12a bit of a perfectionist. He lost his cool a
- 28:14little bit on this set. Whether that's something
- 28:16he does outside of this movie in general, I can't
- 28:20say just yet. But I read a good bit about this.
- 28:22So it's interesting to see the anger notated
- 28:26from him. Because on screen... He's extremely
- 28:29believable, and he's just lost in his dancing,
- 28:32which, again, there's no one like him. And the
- 28:35pairing of him and Ginger Rogers is so effective
- 28:38in this one. It really is. And the first time
- 28:41that you get to see them dance together, I think,
- 28:44is fantastic. And that's the number, Isn't This
- 28:47a Lovely Day, to be caught in the rain. This
- 28:51is the first moment where I said, This has to
- 28:55be a direct inspiration to La La Land. Oh, sure.
- 28:58Because that scene, this is when he steals the
- 29:00carriage and he takes her to the horse area,
- 29:05right? Isn't it like an equestrian thing? Horse
- 29:10area is how it will be known from now on in this
- 29:12pod. So yeah, it's a horse area. She's like going
- 29:14to ride horses. Are you trying to say ranch?
- 29:17It might be ranch. Yeah, I don't remember what
- 29:19that's called. But anyway, there's like a big
- 29:21pavilion that they seek shelter from the thunderstorm
- 29:24that just rolled in. Yes. And the way the dynamic
- 29:28here between them is very much like they're both
- 29:33into each other, but there is like a resistance
- 29:36and it mostly comes from her. But that's so similar
- 29:40to me to Lovely Night. From La La Land? Yes.
- 29:43Which is, you know, the most iconic song from
- 29:45that movie. That's the posters from that scene.
- 29:49Yes, exactly. And that's very much, you know,
- 29:51yeah, it's a really nice night, but we're probably
- 29:54going to waste it because that's not us. We aren't
- 29:58that couple. And this felt that way, too, because
- 30:00isn't this a lovely day? But then the rain is
- 30:03also happening. And I think this is another example
- 30:05where they utilize things other than just the
- 30:08dancing in the number itself. Because the thunder
- 30:11plays a role. She's terrified of the thunder.
- 30:15And what is it? He says, oh, you're not afraid
- 30:16of the thunder, are you? And she says, no, just
- 30:18the sound. Yeah. Girl. But anytime the thunder
- 30:22booms, she like falls into his arms. Right. So
- 30:26it's like an additional element that adds to
- 30:28their dance and kind of brings them closer together.
- 30:31It's just cool. And the dancing is fantastic.
- 30:35It's the first time you get to see them showcase
- 30:37it together in this movie. I don't know. It was
- 30:39one of my favorite sequences outside of the two
- 30:41that were part of the nomination for dance direction.
- 30:44I think it spoke a lot to their chemistry that
- 30:47they can have a moment like that. And it's really
- 30:49believable. I think that, I mean, that sequence
- 30:52is really great because it's choreographed really
- 30:55well to the thunder outside. Yeah. And you can
- 30:58see lightning happening a little bit and then
- 31:00the thunder follows right after. And you can
- 31:02almost see, again, great acting on their parts.
- 31:05Them noticing the lightning and almost timing
- 31:08when the thunder is going to hit. Yeah. So it
- 31:10can kind of be like a reactionary thing. That
- 31:13sequence was really great. Song was good too,
- 31:16but I felt like the sequence itself staged really
- 31:18well. I think that Ginger has more of an opportunity
- 31:22in this movie to show that you can keep up with
- 31:24Fred Astaire. I think in the Gate of War, say.
- 31:27There's a couple scenes where it's like, let's
- 31:28see Fred go crazy. And then Ginger's going to
- 31:30be very elegant. Yeah. In this one, she's definitely
- 31:33elegant. But you can see her kind of matching.
- 31:35At one point, I think he jumps off the platform
- 31:38and then like sits down on it like very quickly.
- 31:40And she does the same thing as he does. So there's
- 31:42a lot more of like an equality in this one. That's
- 31:45what's cool about this number is it starts out
- 31:47with like a mimicking of him. Yes. Almost like
- 31:49she's teasing him. But yeah, it does give her
- 31:51the opportunity to be like, look. We all know
- 31:54Fred can dance. You've seen what I can do, but
- 31:57really pay attention now. And I don't know, saying
- 32:01like she can keep up with them feels like an
- 32:04undersell of her because she's. she's ginger
- 32:07rogers 100 i think the reason i say that is he
- 32:11is just in gay divorcee he is going nuts yeah
- 32:14like he is just like arms flailing his legs are
- 32:16going all over like the tasmanian devil he is
- 32:18just spinning in circles around in that movie
- 32:20it's a good way to put it and with ginger rogers
- 32:22she's much more uh portrayed much more as like
- 32:25the gin i don't mean gingerly like that but the
- 32:28more elegant the graceful dancer yeah and in
- 32:32this one she is given the opportunity to do a
- 32:35bit more of the frantic that Fred Astaire is
- 32:38known for. Yeah. So you're right. I don't mean
- 32:40to say like, you know, one's a better dancer
- 32:42than the other. It's more Fred Astaire's frantic
- 32:44and she's a little bit more elegant. And those
- 32:47two kind of like merge to be a perfect romance.
- 32:49In this one, we see Astaire being more romantic
- 32:54with like, you know, the Ash sequence of being
- 32:56the Sandman. And with her, we get to see her
- 32:59be a little more frantic. So it's more exciting
- 33:01to kind of see those, them get out of their comfort
- 33:03zones. Yeah. So I enjoyed that. Even if the plot
- 33:07itself was just very similar to the previous
- 33:09movie, almost an exact copy, again, that's the
- 33:13shell. The soul of it, you can see in the dancing,
- 33:16and I like this a bit more. The big number that's
- 33:21worth talking about here, I mean, I know there's
- 33:22a few more that fall in between this, but if
- 33:26we talk about what the Gay Divorcee is known
- 33:29for, which is The Continental, you can say The
- 33:32Piccolino, and we will talk about that as the
- 33:34finale, but cheek to cheek. is really the big
- 33:37one here. Yeah. Now, correct me if I'm wrong,
- 33:40was this the origination of Cheat to Cheek? I
- 33:41believe so. I mean, obviously this is well known.
- 33:44This is a song that Louis Armstrong had. Forgive
- 33:47me, I forget the partnership that he had in that
- 33:49song. But many other people have sang Cheat to
- 33:52Cheek, great song. And this was another one where
- 33:55it's a dance that they're doing together and
- 33:57Fred sings it to Ginger and back and forth. What'd
- 34:00you think about this sequence? It's cool because
- 34:03you're getting a different type of dance here.
- 34:06This is more of like a ballad, a romantic kind
- 34:08of showcase of their dancing. Sure. There's not
- 34:11a lot of tap here. So it was exciting to see
- 34:15that. And I think it goes well with the music
- 34:17itself. My struggle here was La La Land. Sure.
- 34:22As weird as that sounds. I adore La La Land.
- 34:26It's one of my favorite movies ever. And there's
- 34:29like a motif here that feels like a direct pull
- 34:32from this movie into La La Land. And it's it's
- 34:35the and my heart beats so that I can hardly speak
- 34:38in lovely night. It's a silver sky that stretches
- 34:44to the sea. It's like the same thing. And I couldn't
- 34:47get that out of my mind. This has to be like
- 34:51exactly what Justin Horvitz pulled for La La
- 34:55Land. Well, it's interesting because we already
- 34:57know that Damien Chazelle. was a big fan of seventh
- 35:02heaven yeah so we know that he's watching movies
- 35:04from like the 20s it's not hard to imagine he's
- 35:07doing the same thing from the 30s and he's calling
- 35:09back with la la land like a style of filmmaking
- 35:12and a style of movie that just isn't made anymore
- 35:14right so it's probably fair to say and honestly
- 35:18that whole sequence of lovely night like the
- 35:20dance sequence of that screams ginger rogers
- 35:22for to stare to me absolutely so i think it's
- 35:25fair to say that they are pulling from that like
- 35:29inspiration from whether it be the dance scenes
- 35:31or the writing of the songs and the, the lyrical
- 35:35rhythms. I think it has to be. Yeah. I don't
- 35:39have any proof behind that, but I think just
- 35:41the way that we've heard Damien Chazelle talk
- 35:44about some of those movies, it makes sense. I
- 35:47would love to see him and Justin Hurwitz with
- 35:50like a top 10 movies that inspired La La Land.
- 35:53And I feel like I could name at least five of
- 35:56them. I feel like a top hat more than Gate of
- 35:58Orsay has to be it. Yeah, definitely, definitely.
- 36:01But that little motif, like, it screamed out
- 36:04to me. Because I'll listen to the La La Land
- 36:06soundtrack just on my way to set or something.
- 36:09But just to clarify, it's not the, you don't
- 36:13hold it against a top hat that it reminds you
- 36:17of La La Land. No, no, no. I think it's great.
- 36:19Yeah. Because what La La Land is, is this, like,
- 36:23love letter to... old hollywood and musicals
- 36:27and stuff so i think it's perfect um it's it's
- 36:30not like he stole it or anything like that no
- 36:32you can just see the clear inspiration yeah yeah
- 36:34it's very cool but cheek to cheek it where does
- 36:38this sit in in your enjoyment of the the musical
- 36:41numbers it's very quiet uh it's not as loud as
- 36:44the other ones i like that too this definitely
- 36:46takes the i forget the name of the song but is
- 36:49it day and night in gate of orsay where they're
- 36:51in like that little gazebo I think so. That sounds
- 36:54familiar. It takes the place of that, where it's
- 36:57just a very slow, very intimate moment. And it's
- 37:01very beautiful. I mean, they start the song and
- 37:03dance by them being in a room, a dance room with
- 37:07everyone else, a lot of other couples. And then
- 37:09they eventually break off. And when they break
- 37:11off, they go into a separate room where it's
- 37:13just them. And they're allowed to dance a little
- 37:15more extravagantly, but still very beautifully.
- 37:20I did read here that Mark Sandrich, and it's
- 37:24so hard not to say sandwich, and Fred Astaire
- 37:27suggested that, even recommended, that Ginger
- 37:32Rogers wear the same nightgown dress that she
- 37:35wore at the end of The Gay Divorcee. And she
- 37:39was dead set on wearing this very large feathery
- 37:43dress. And they were like, look. We're dancing
- 37:46a lot in this. You're moving around a lot. It
- 37:48is going to cause, like, there's going to be
- 37:50some feathers and everything that, like, fall
- 37:52off. We can't really do this. She was really
- 37:54upset. So they actually ended up doing it anyways
- 37:58and having her dancing in that dress. And you
- 38:01can see there are specific, like, scenes where
- 38:04you can see feathers laying around. Now that
- 38:07I'm thinking about this, it might be the piccolino.
- 38:09I'm forgetting which one is which. She definitely
- 38:12wears a feathery dress that's very noticeable
- 38:14on camera. And you can see some feathers laying
- 38:17around in the final takes that made it to the
- 38:20film. Interesting. So they were right. The feathers
- 38:22just keep falling off. But, I mean, she looked
- 38:25beautiful in the movie. The dancing itself, it
- 38:27felt very tender, which is supposed to match
- 38:29their relationship at the time. So this was great.
- 38:32It's not extravagant. It's not something that
- 38:35kind of takes your breath away. It's just very
- 38:37pretty. But, I mean, you can't deny the power
- 38:40of a song like Cheat to Cheek. Yeah, I think
- 38:43it has more lasting power than anything in the
- 38:46Gay Divorcee. Oh, yeah. And yeah, I don't know.
- 38:48It almost feels like Gay Divorcee was the proof
- 38:51of concept leading up to this. And this is just
- 38:55the masterpiece. Now, I will say Cheek to Cheek
- 38:58is the first song once the story has moved to
- 39:01Italy. The Lido. Yeah. Yeah. In Italy. That's
- 39:05correct. Is that what it's called? The Lido?
- 39:07Yeah. Oh, I don't know what that is. Is that
- 39:09the city? Sure. Oh, I don't know, but they just
- 39:12keep, uh, so Eric Rhodes, uh, plays Bedina or
- 39:16Bedino. Nope. Bedini. Bedini. My God. I went
- 39:18through every vowel, but, um, he plays, uh, Alberto
- 39:22Bedini and he is a fashion, uh, costume like
- 39:27designer. Um, and he designs dresses just for
- 39:31ginger rogers character dale tremont and she
- 39:34is uh he kind of believes it's a relationship
- 39:37she thinks it's a partnership right and he is
- 39:40begging her to go to italy with him and it's
- 39:42not until um she decides to go to italy and bring
- 39:45him that they go to the lido he keeps talking
- 39:48about going to the lido are we going to lido
- 39:49and i think the lido might be that city or that
- 39:52specific location they're staying in like the
- 39:54hotel hotel yeah because the lido is a beautiful
- 39:58set Just a little precursor to what you're about
- 40:01to say here. It's a beautiful set. It is extremely
- 40:04white. Like, just the white walls, white structures,
- 40:07everything is just pale white. And this was a
- 40:11problem on set. Oh. Right? For the contrast,
- 40:13when it comes to, like, the way they filmed,
- 40:15the water just looks really weird. So they ended
- 40:18up, because it is, like, on a canal, basically.
- 40:20So they ended up dyeing the water in the canal
- 40:22black. So then the contrast of the water would
- 40:26match the contrast of the, or the color of the
- 40:29set. So the set was just so white that they actually
- 40:32had to change the color of the canal. It's wild.
- 40:35Which I thought was really interesting. Yeah.
- 40:37Not something you would have expected, especially
- 40:39later on when you see like there are scenes of
- 40:41them writing in those. Gondolas. Thank you so
- 40:45much. The gondolas. And you'll see them like
- 40:48paddling through and I'll kind of be checking
- 40:50the consistency of the water. died and you can't
- 40:53tell but uh is it chocolate pudding made me think
- 40:57of uh willy wonka of like just going through
- 40:59the chocolate river but anyways uh to your point
- 41:02they were at the lino in italy yeah and i think
- 41:05that this is where the production design takes
- 41:08like this massive leap and the movie's been gorgeous
- 41:11leading up to this point the the gazebo or whatever
- 41:15where they dance to isn't this a lovely day in
- 41:18the horse area yeah in the horse area exactly
- 41:20thank you and You know, the bedroom sets in the
- 41:23opening sequence of No Strings, I'm Fancy Free.
- 41:27But like Italy is just worlds beyond that. And
- 41:31the set is massive. It's one of those, just like
- 41:35with The Continental, where you see in the very
- 41:37deep background, like people sitting there at
- 41:40their little tables and you're like, wow, that's
- 41:42crazy green screen. Nope. They're back there.
- 41:44They're there. They're there hanging out. There's
- 41:46certainly some screens behind them in this movie.
- 41:49Like the carriage scene obviously has to be pretty
- 41:51heavily provided in the background. But it really
- 41:56is once they land in Italy that you start seeing
- 41:58like the camera almost, not to say that it's
- 42:01very close up for most of the movie. Again, in
- 42:03the classic stair style, his full. Body is in
- 42:07the frame whenever he's dancing. But the camera
- 42:09does get the opportunity to pull back here. And
- 42:12you do get to see the entirety of the set with
- 42:14background actors walking around in the background.
- 42:17And everything is just busy. And it's very, very
- 42:20fun. It looks like the second half of this movie
- 42:23takes place on It's a Small World. That's such
- 42:26a good point. Oh, my God, it does. With the way
- 42:30the boats are going through, it almost looks
- 42:32like just a dark ride. At Disney. Like kind of
- 42:35the Mexico ride in Epcot where there's a restaurant
- 42:39right there and then the boats go by. Or I guess
- 42:41Pirates of the Caribbean at Disneyland. And you
- 42:44know what? It really is a world of laughter and
- 42:47a world of tears in this movie. That's exactly
- 42:50what I'm saying. Well, I can't sing it. We're
- 42:53going to get DMCA'd so bad. Disney's going to
- 42:55be like, I'm sorry, what? You haven't covered
- 42:58Snow White yet. It's a what world? And you know
- 43:01what? What a tiny planet it is. At the end of
- 43:05the day. Yeah. Did I skate that one? I think
- 43:07I skated that one pretty well. Yeah. It's a tiny
- 43:10planet. It's a tiny world. No, can't say that.
- 43:13Anyways. We tried. Lost our minds. We tried.
- 43:16It's this sequence where the rest of the, or
- 43:18this location where the rest of the movie takes
- 43:19place. Yeah. We see everyone checking into their
- 43:22hotels and Horace Hardwick, Edward Horton. His
- 43:26wife is already staying with Dale. They're staying
- 43:29in the same room. So it is up to Horace and Jerry
- 43:32to share a room. And wouldn't you know it, the
- 43:34only room available at the time is the bridal
- 43:36suite. Yeah. And I got to tell you. It's huge.
- 43:39I got to tell you, man. Look, if you and I and
- 43:43Ziggy and Taylor are going out. Well, hold on.
- 43:46Don't worry. You'll get excited again. Okay.
- 43:47The four of us are going to Toledo. And we get
- 43:50there. And Ziggy and Taylor are like, hey, we
- 43:53have this room already. There's only one room
- 43:55left, and it's the bridal suite. And I get into
- 43:57that bridal suite, and it looks like that. Brother,
- 44:00I'm having the best vacation. That room, that
- 44:04is a house. That's bigger than a house. I love
- 44:07that it's bigger than a house, but it's also
- 44:08one room. Okay, but there's, like, attachments.
- 44:12Yeah, like, there's little things. But just the
- 44:14idea of, like, you stand in that corner, and
- 44:16I stand in the other one, and I'm like, what?
- 44:19And the bed is a heart? I was like, this is dope.
- 44:22It's pretty crazy. Because, of course, in 1935
- 44:25at the time, Fred Astaire and Edward Edward Horton
- 44:28kind of have to play it like, oh, no. Everyone's
- 44:31going to think we're the newlyweds. And I do
- 44:33appreciate Fred Astaire's at least being like,
- 44:35you know, we're going to have a great night or
- 44:36something like that. The newlyweds are going
- 44:37to have a good night. I appreciate that. And
- 44:39it's him kind of playing with it a little bit.
- 44:41I know at the time, Hays Code and everything,
- 44:43they were very strict about what could come across
- 44:46as depicting any kind of homosexuality. And I'm
- 44:50happy that this at least stayed in because reading
- 44:53about how strict it was, and there was a good
- 44:55bit of it. Bedini, they had to make sure it wasn't
- 44:58coming across that he was interested in men in
- 45:00any way. So I appreciated the at least attempts
- 45:03at alluring you into thinking that. But they
- 45:07were definitely like, oh, man, only the bridal
- 45:09suite. I'd be like, hell yeah, the bridal suite.
- 45:11Let's go. But at the same time, and I am saying
- 45:15this mostly because I know that my partner is
- 45:17listening. I am well aware that if I'm checking
- 45:20into a hotel and they're like, I'm so sorry,
- 45:22ma 'am, your room is good to go. Sir, we only
- 45:24have the bridal suite. She'd be like, no, no,
- 45:26his room is available. Yeah. And I have the bridal
- 45:30suite, which is 100 % true. But I just want to
- 45:33point out that if you and I ended up going to
- 45:35Toledo and staying in a newlywed suite or the
- 45:38bridal suite, pretty good weekend, man. It'd
- 45:40be pretty awesome. Pretty cool weekend. You can
- 45:43have the hard bed. I'll... take the pole out.
- 45:46But you gotta think, if the bed is a heart, right,
- 45:49and then the top has, like, the two rounded parts
- 45:51and it comes down to a dip, you just get that
- 45:54head, and then I get the other one, and then
- 45:56our feet just touch. And we're gonna Grandpa
- 45:58Joe. Yeah, of course. Who cares? Why not? I mean,
- 46:02I assume there was a couch there. I don't know
- 46:04if we saw it, but I assume there was. I do love,
- 46:06there's a moment where Eric Rhodes, like, storms
- 46:09out of the room, and he's like, I'm gonna go
- 46:10talk to the front desk about this. And it, like,
- 46:13Takes him some time to get from the bed to the
- 46:16door. Like it's a journey. It's pretty funny.
- 46:19Half his journey is just getting out of the actual
- 46:21suite. Yeah. Yeah. I love that. They definitely
- 46:24took the notes that I had from Gay Divorcee of
- 46:27like, hey, this suite that they're in is pretty
- 46:28small. They're like, bet. Watch this. So, but
- 46:32I say we make it to Italy and just the production
- 46:36design like explodes and it just becomes this
- 46:39massive, beautiful. element of the movie the
- 46:43plot however i think takes a massive dive sure
- 46:46and this is kind of where it just becomes this
- 46:49mess where i i don't really care at this point
- 46:52dale is married to badini she yes they believe
- 46:57they are right cool i don't really care and jerry
- 47:02is still you know being accused but i don't know
- 47:06there's this weird thing where ginger knows that
- 47:08fred isn't married to uh edward everett horton's
- 47:11wife but everyone else thinks they are like it
- 47:14gets really kind of convoluted as to what's really
- 47:16going on but again i don't think it really matters
- 47:19well she finds out after she's married yeah so
- 47:23she gets married to bedini that she believes
- 47:25but then finds out oh you actually aren't already
- 47:30married to uh you aren't edward edward horton
- 47:33and you are not married So that changes things
- 47:36for me a little bit. And he's like, I won't give
- 47:38you the, you know, divorce or whatever. But Dini
- 47:40says, I won't give you the divorce. Yeah. So
- 47:43that plot comes into play. And that goes pretty
- 47:45quick. I think it's like five, maybe 10 minutes
- 47:47of like, they're getting married and then they
- 47:50find out about this. But I agree through this
- 47:52movie is like maybe 10, 15 minutes too long.
- 47:54Oh yeah. I don't even think that it's long. I
- 47:56think that the, the, the cliche of like, hey,
- 48:01I think you're somebody else and that's going
- 48:02to cause this entire movie to occur, really.
- 48:08I just don't really care. It's kind of an overused
- 48:12story beat already this early on in the Academy
- 48:15years. Do you think that it is a plot development
- 48:18that is introduced that you're like, oh, I'm
- 48:20not interested? Or do you think that it is the
- 48:22plot of the movie that has just worn out its
- 48:24welcome? I think it's one that I'm just not really
- 48:27interested in. I think that it's just overused.
- 48:30Interesting. I think for me, it's not that that
- 48:32part bothered me because that's kind of like
- 48:35the rest of the movie, but that's why I said
- 48:38it was too long is I thought it went longer.
- 48:40So they had to kind of introduce another step
- 48:42of it, which was like, okay, like now I'm starting
- 48:45to see the cracks in the foundation of that story.
- 48:48But I mean, To be fair, I was already seeing
- 48:50the cracks because, again, it's just like the
- 48:52gay divorcee in terms of the setup and misunderstanding.
- 48:55But, yeah, you know, to me, it was the songs
- 48:58and the dancing that kept me invested. Right.
- 49:01And when I say, like, oh, I don't care about
- 49:03what's going on, I'm not sitting here like, ugh,
- 49:06come on, move on. It's more just like the complications
- 49:11that arise of, okay, does she know he's Horace
- 49:15yet or not Horace? And I'm just like, I'm kind
- 49:18of tuning out. until somebody either tells a
- 49:21joke or starts dancing. Right. I think that's
- 49:23really what I'm getting at. Yeah, that makes
- 49:25sense. You know, we've gone pretty much this
- 49:27entire episode, and I know we're about to wrap
- 49:30up here, but we've gone this whole episode without
- 49:31saying it. But, you know, the dancing, a very
- 49:34big part of this. Hermes Pan was the dance director
- 49:37for a number of songs and parts, pieces of this
- 49:42movie. Those two being the Piccolino, which is
- 49:44the final musical number of the movie, and Top
- 49:47Hat, White Tie, and Tail. He, of course, did
- 49:50he win this award for Dan Turchin? He did not.
- 49:53No, he did not. He did get the nomination for
- 49:54it. You pointed out some particularities around
- 49:58his nomination for this. Yeah, because when it's
- 50:03listed on Letterboxd in their Academy Award thing,
- 50:06it shows the two numbers. So I thought that he
- 50:10was nominated twice, but I had to look up what
- 50:12the rules were. in regards to this, and I will
- 50:15read verbatim here. Each dance director may nominate
- 50:19two dance numbers for whose direction he was
- 50:22responsible. These are not required to be from
- 50:25the same picture, but shall be considered together
- 50:27as one nomination. So, this is one nomination
- 50:30for him, which just happened to both be from
- 50:33Top Hat. But I guess they could be from two movies.
- 50:36Look, unless you did another Ginger Rogers Fred
- 50:38Astaire musical, I think that's the way to do
- 50:40it. Yeah. Like, you gotta point out the ones
- 50:42that have heavy dancing in it. Yeah, and, you
- 50:44know, I will say Top Hat White Tie and Tails,
- 50:47fantastic. Great. The Piccolino, however, this
- 50:50is the finale of the movie, and it's kind of
- 50:53like The Continental. I alluded to it earlier,
- 50:56where the focus kind of removes itself from Fred
- 50:59and Ginger. They're definitely dancing in it,
- 51:01and their dance number is spectacular. And I
- 51:03think this is the one where the feathers are
- 51:05coming off the dress, too. Right. But there's
- 51:07also a lot of it that just relies on the chorus
- 51:11line. doing their their dance there's a little
- 51:13bit of that like pulled back geometrical pattern
- 51:16busby berkeley thing well just like the continental
- 51:18like you know the staircase of the um hotel that
- 51:22they're staying at at the time that's kind of
- 51:24the set for this it's a very large scale very
- 51:26many background dancers and the attention is
- 51:29off of a stare in rogers which to me just doesn't
- 51:33make it as interesting yeah so it's a great comp
- 51:36not just to be in the final song of the movie
- 51:38but her final dance but piccolino has a lot in
- 51:40common with the continental to me yeah where
- 51:42it's just kind of like hey this is impressive
- 51:44i really just want to see rogers in a stare doing
- 51:47more yeah now you do get to hear uh ginger sing
- 51:49here you do which is cool same thing as the continental
- 51:53i believe like that's kind of her song so it's
- 51:56it's weird that they reserve her for the finale
- 52:00in these movies i think that's by chance uh i
- 52:03know that in this one the piccolino was the only
- 52:06song that they did or dance and song that they
- 52:09did where fred astaire just wasn't that interested
- 52:11oh yeah he was like this just isn't really like
- 52:13i'm not i'm not a big fan of it so instead of
- 52:15like scrapping it he was like well if you take
- 52:17the lead on the song i'm probably okay with that
- 52:20so she ended up taking the lead on the piccolino
- 52:23and I mean, all the better for it. I think it
- 52:26would have like the style of song doesn't sound
- 52:28like something that would go into Fred Astaire's
- 52:29register. So I'm on board with that. I, maybe
- 52:33it's something I'll have to see a third with
- 52:35other swing time or shall we dance in that collection
- 52:37that we have, but to really like cement that.
- 52:40But my first thought is it's just kind of happenstance.
- 52:43Interesting. Cause it sounds like he was up for
- 52:45doing it or they were trying to get him to do
- 52:47it, but he was just not interested. I need to
- 52:50read more on Fred Astaire. Because all these
- 52:51little things are kind of making me feel like,
- 52:54hey, man, I don't know if you know this, but
- 52:56you're kind of getting paid for this. Sure. Very
- 52:59interesting. Heck of a time for us to be talking
- 53:02about this. Tom Holland, right off of the Odyssey.
- 53:04Yeah. It was just announced that he will actually
- 53:07be starring as Fred Astaire in a biopic about
- 53:10his life. Man. And this is a man who's been dancing
- 53:13for a pretty long time. Listen. So. My favorite
- 53:17thing in the world is. when anybody says really
- 53:22tom holland's gonna play fred astaire and then
- 53:25i immediately just show them him doing umbrella
- 53:27yeah for what was it the celebrity lip sync or
- 53:30something like that yeah yeah and i'm just like
- 53:32what go ahead and argue yep go ahead he's perfect
- 53:37he was doing gene kelly uh not gene kelly i'm
- 53:40so sorry he was doing um no wasn't he doing gene
- 53:42kelly singing in the rain for that Because the
- 53:45opening of that for Umbrella, he was doing Singing
- 53:47in the Rain, wasn't he? Right. Yeah. He comes
- 53:48out in the full suit and he's doing a little
- 53:50bit of Singing in the Rain. And then he ditches
- 53:52the overcoat or whatever. Yeah. And he's wearing
- 53:55the Rihanna of it all and everything. Incredible.
- 53:57I think he's going to do really well. I think
- 53:59so, too. I think that's what he needs, is he
- 54:01needs a star vehicle that he can really show
- 54:03off his acting chops and dance and not just,
- 54:06you know, I'm Spider -Man. So we'll see how that
- 54:07goes. The other thing I want to mention here,
- 54:10along with Dance Direction, these songs are all
- 54:12done by Irving Berlin, a name that is going to
- 54:15be known for a long time when it comes to musicals.
- 54:18Bing Crosby is a name that I think about when
- 54:20I think of Irving Berlin, White Christmas, Holiday
- 54:23Inn. There's a lot to come. I think that this
- 54:26movie thrives as much as it does. Because of
- 54:29a number of partnerships. And I think Irving
- 54:31Berlin is a very big part of that. Yeah. So I
- 54:34just want to point out a lot of these songs,
- 54:36I think a little catchier than some things in
- 54:38The Gay Divorcee. And I cannot imagine it's a
- 54:41coincidence that Irving Berlin takes over. That
- 54:43makes sense to me. We need to get into ratings,
- 54:47but I have to bring up just my favorite comedic
- 54:50line from this movie. And it's when... Edward
- 54:54Everett Horton is speaking to Bates, the butler
- 54:57character played by Eric Bloor. My favorite character.
- 55:00And they bring up a hornet's nest. And Bates
- 55:05says something like, oh, my sister. He sounds
- 55:08so weird, too. He's almost like Igor. Yes. But
- 55:10he's like, my sister got stung by hornets once.
- 55:13And she rubbed butter all over her body. And
- 55:17he's like, well, we're not rubbing butter on
- 55:20anybody. That doesn't make sense. He's like.
- 55:22Well, my sister did it. And then off screen,
- 55:24Horton like loses his mind. And he's like, well,
- 55:28then you did it wrong. You should have used mud.
- 55:31And it comes out of nowhere. But the level of
- 55:35anger he has in that scene is so funny. Eric
- 55:39Bloor is doing some insane things in this movie.
- 55:42Mostly the idea of like a butler that is just
- 55:44like, I think maybe have split personality. Like
- 55:48he refers to himself as we. Yeah. Well, that's
- 55:51a running joke throughout the movie, too. Yeah.
- 55:53He's saying like, oh, we just got here. Who?
- 55:56We. He's talking about just him. So I think Eric
- 56:00Bloor is doing some really great stuff in this.
- 56:02Him. being a spy and following ginger Rogers
- 56:06for the majority of this movie has been fantastic
- 56:09of seeing him as like the gondola like operator
- 56:11or like he ends up being the officiant and he's
- 56:14not actually an officiant. Right. So they're
- 56:16not really married. He just took his collar and
- 56:19turned it backwards, which makes it look like
- 56:20he's an officiant, which ends up being like the
- 56:22silliest little, Oh, okay. Well, I guess we can
- 56:26be together then. Cause we never got married.
- 56:27It's like, okay. And they kick the Dini out and
- 56:29they're like, Hey, how much get out of here?
- 56:30Yeah. Um, I did like him with the police officer
- 56:33as well. Yes. Where he's just spouting insults
- 56:37at this police officer who only speaks French
- 56:39until he doesn't. And it's a great little plot
- 56:43twist. It's worth noting, too, that Mel Brooks,
- 56:45this is one of his favorite movies. Oh, okay.
- 56:47And I think Eric Bloor, you can see it. Yeah.
- 56:50Like, the whole Eric Bloor of it, you're like,
- 56:52oh, this screams Mel Brooks to me. Yeah. So,
- 56:55I mean, maybe just in the... the Igor that you
- 56:58mentioned, but the humor of Mel Brooks is pretty
- 57:01apparent in the Eric Bloor Bates character. I
- 57:04like it. Yeah, that makes complete sense to me.
- 57:07Let's move into ratings now. I'd love to hear
- 57:09yours. I actually don't know yours. So I watch
- 57:12these movies out of sequence, the three we're
- 57:13covering today. So I watched this yesterday.
- 57:16And I didn't rate it until like two in the morning
- 57:18today. So I gave it three and a half stars. That's
- 57:22where I'm at. I gave it three and a half stars
- 57:24too. But the more that we talk about it, I think
- 57:27I withheld some of my, I reserved some of my
- 57:31enthusiasm for this movie because it was so similar
- 57:34for gay divorcee. Yeah. But in our conversation,
- 57:37this always happens. It becomes clear to me that
- 57:40that doesn't matter. Like it is the vehicle.
- 57:43It is, it is a Camaro just because, uh, or it's
- 57:48a Camaro the same way that gay divorcee was Camaro.
- 57:50Yeah. But this one's souped up. It is. This one
- 57:53got pimped out by exhibit and this one, is better
- 57:57because of those changes, because of Mark Sandrich
- 58:01being more deliberate with his direction style,
- 58:03because of Fred Astaire using more props in his,
- 58:07not even just him, but everyone using more props
- 58:09in the musical numbers, Irving Berlin being tapped
- 58:12in to do the music. All of these things, Eric
- 58:15Bloor being introduced as like, you know, what
- 58:17is this guy on in this movie? Yeah. All of this
- 58:21enhances what was there before that was already
- 58:23doing really well. I'm leaning towards four.
- 58:26And I'll probably end up changing it to four
- 58:28because I did enjoy this a lot. But my initial
- 58:31thought was three and a half. Yeah. It's somewhere
- 58:33in between there. I think what it is, I have
- 58:36to rewatch all of the Fred and Ginger movies
- 58:39and watch the ones I haven't seen yet and just
- 58:41kind of accept that these aren't here for the
- 58:44plot. Right. And I need to just have fun while
- 58:47I'm watching them. Because I agree. On a rewatch,
- 58:49I think this would be one of maybe my favorite
- 58:51musicals. The biggest way to tell this is if
- 58:54you watch the special features on this, which
- 58:56you did not. How embarrassing. All right. There's
- 59:01a trailer that you can watch of this. And in
- 59:04the trailer, there's never a, look at the miscommunication
- 59:07between these two. Guess what kind of crazy antics
- 59:09they get into. It is more, look. They're going
- 59:12to dance. Yeah. They're going to sing. It's going
- 59:14to be these two. And they're going to be on screen
- 59:16the whole time. You should come see them. It
- 59:17is about them. It is about the dancing. It is
- 59:20about the singing. And they enhance the dancing.
- 59:22They enhance the singing. I mean, their chemistry
- 59:25is the same as it ever was. So, to me, if that's
- 59:29the scale of success, you crushed it. But I just
- 59:32withheld myself a little bit from it because
- 59:34of the similarities in the casting, in the plot,
- 59:38in the way it turns out. To your point, that's
- 59:40by design. So it's hard to kind of rate against
- 59:42it. So I'm probably at four, but I think even
- 59:45with our median scale, that still brings it to
- 59:47three and a half. Yeah, yeah, it does. And I
- 59:49think that's fair. I think that's right. Yeah.
- 59:52You mentioned the DVD extras. We've mentioned
- 59:56it during the Gay Divorcee episode. We both have
- 59:58the Turner Classic Movies Greatest Films Collection,
- 1:00:01where it is for Fred and Ginger movies, the Gay
- 1:00:04Divorcee. Top Hat, Shall We Dance, and Swing
- 1:00:08Time. Yep. So the one thing that neither one
- 1:00:11of us watched, Ryan, was the commentary track
- 1:00:14on Top Hat, which I really want to check out.
- 1:00:17It's a film historian, but also Fred Astaire's
- 1:00:19daughter doing a commentary track for Top Hat.
- 1:00:22So I'm definitely going to go back and watch
- 1:00:24that because that sounds awesome. Yeah, very,
- 1:00:26very interested in that. I did watch everything
- 1:00:28else. There was a Bob Hope short titled Watch
- 1:00:31the Birdie, about 18 minutes long. There was
- 1:00:33an animated short that I believe was attached
- 1:00:36to Top Hat in theaters. A couple great special
- 1:00:41features along with the trailer, so definitely
- 1:00:43worth seeking out. But I have to watch the commentary.
- 1:00:45Yeah. Or experience the commentary, however.
- 1:00:48Double features. Yeah, so with Gay Divorcee,
- 1:00:52I... Went with Swing Time. I just went with another
- 1:00:55Fred and Ginger musical. Sure. I did the same
- 1:00:58here. I think you should just round out your
- 1:01:00Turner Classic Movies Greatest Film Collection.
- 1:01:03Finish up the fourth movie, Shall We Dance? Kind
- 1:01:06of uninspired, but I think that the only thing
- 1:01:09that can really match the level of grace and
- 1:01:12skill of Fred and Ginger is Fred and Ginger.
- 1:01:15So, Shall We Dance? That sounds about right.
- 1:01:17I'm going to try and do something that doesn't
- 1:01:19do that. Cool. That sounds about right. You know,
- 1:01:23for The Gay Divorce, I did The Producers 2005.
- 1:01:25Yeah. And I mentioned there was some like Mel
- 1:01:27Brooks style humor in that. Kind of wish I would
- 1:01:29have reserved that because there's more Mel Brooks
- 1:01:31in this with Eric Bloor alone. So I wish I would
- 1:01:35have held on to that. But for this one, I did
- 1:01:37something a bit differently. I focused a little
- 1:01:39bit more on the plot of this. The plot being
- 1:01:41that Ginger Rogers believes Fred Astaire is married
- 1:01:45and she is mistaking his identity. Something
- 1:01:49that's pretty popular in these movies. And she's
- 1:01:52determining whether she wants to stay with him
- 1:01:54despite him being married. Is this wrong? Should
- 1:01:57I pursue that? Even though his wife knows about
- 1:01:59it, is that a bad thing? And I went with an all
- 1:02:02-time steric classic. This is a movie that has
- 1:02:04been watched in my household no less than 50
- 1:02:07times. And it is the 1993 Thomas Schlame movie,
- 1:02:12So I Married an Axe Murderer. This stars Mike
- 1:02:15Myers and... Nancy Travis. I knew I had that
- 1:02:19name in my head. I was just waiting for it to
- 1:02:20come out. Have you seen this movie? No, I have
- 1:02:23not. This is one of my favorite comedies of all
- 1:02:26time. Mike Myers plays a poet, a musician, and
- 1:02:30he meets Nancy Travis and falls in love with
- 1:02:33her, and they get married. And after they get
- 1:02:35married, he realizes, because his best friend
- 1:02:38is a detective, his best friend, I forgot the
- 1:02:40actor's name, he's doing a great Edward Horton
- 1:02:42stand -in for this, finds that he's a reporter,
- 1:02:45a police officer. rather and he finds out that
- 1:02:49uh there is an axe murderer and it could be his
- 1:02:52wife and the more that he does some research
- 1:02:54into it his wife is the most likely culprit of
- 1:02:57being this axe murderer and she kills all of
- 1:03:00her husbands so now he's concerned that he's
- 1:03:03going to be killed but he's still in love with
- 1:03:05her and this like comedy around mistaken identity
- 1:03:09granted a little darker and something like uh
- 1:03:11so he made an axe murderer than it is in top
- 1:03:13hat but i thought that was a nice pairing of
- 1:03:16the uh theme within top hat yeah yeah but also
- 1:03:20just an incredible comedy like seek it out i
- 1:03:23i will i have it on blu -ray you can borrow it
- 1:03:25it's so good i like mike myers i think i say
- 1:03:28can i say something only because i like wayne's
- 1:03:30world but go ahead oh dang i love wayne's world
- 1:03:34i think you just complicated what i was going
- 1:03:36to say i was going to say i think it's his best
- 1:03:39movie oh but wayne's world wayne's world might
- 1:03:41be definitely his best movie yeah it's it's up
- 1:03:44there though I think it's better than Wayne's
- 1:03:45World 2. Okay. But yeah, good call. Thank you
- 1:03:49for saying Wayne's World because I probably would
- 1:03:50have made a complete fool of myself. Anytime
- 1:03:53you need me to say Wayne's World, I'm here for
- 1:03:55you. Well, you know what that makes me? Not worthy.
- 1:03:59I love Wayne's World. It's so good. Oh, man,
- 1:04:01it's so good. But that's going to do it for our
- 1:04:03episode on Top Hat. Hope you guys enjoyed it.
- 1:04:06If you have thoughts on Top Hat or any of the
- 1:04:09Fred and Ginger musicals, if you have thoughts
- 1:04:11on how this is a direct inspiration for La La
- 1:04:14Land, let me push up my glasses, and the motif
- 1:04:16is undeniable, shoot us an email at outaopodcast
- 1:04:22at gmail .com. Stay tuned for our Patreon -exclusive
- 1:04:27bonus show. Every 13th, we put out Horror of
- 1:04:30the Overlooked, and we'll be talking about all
- 1:04:33of the films that were released in 1935 that
- 1:04:35the Academy said, yeah, no, we're good. That
- 1:04:39aren't Bride of Frankenstein. Yeah. I mean, we'll
- 1:04:41still probably throw its name out there, but
- 1:04:43yeah. There's many others. We'll talk about them.
- 1:04:45So many others. Looking at you, Claude. But stay
- 1:04:49tuned for that. Check out patreon .com slash
- 1:04:52O -U -T -A -O podcast. I think I said that twice
- 1:04:54now, but now you have two reasons to go check
- 1:04:56it out. And next episode, we will be covering
- 1:04:59the return of Catherine Hepburn in Alice Adams.
- 1:05:03That's right. Until then, I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan.
- 1:05:08And we'll see you at the movies.