Latest / The Line Podcast / On The Line: Should Canada just join America?
Transcript
- 0:00SPEAKER_00: Ladies and gentlemen of On The Line,
- 0:01SPEAKER_00: I'm Jen Gerson,
- 0:02SPEAKER_00: and I'm in Ottawa today to speak to Ross Douthat,
- 0:06New York Times colonist who has recently written a book about
- 0:08why we should all be
- 0:09SPEAKER_00: religious.
- 0:10SPEAKER_00: I don't know if he convinces me, but maybe he'll convince you.
- 0:13SPEAKER_00: That's today on On The Line.
- 0:26SPEAKER_00: Why, hello, Ross Douthat from the New York Times.
- 0:29SPEAKER_00: So nice to see you.
- 0:30SPEAKER_01: So nice to be here.
- 0:31SPEAKER_01: Thank you so much for having me.
- 0:32SPEAKER_00: No problem.
- 0:33SPEAKER_00: Well, welcome to On The Line.
- 0:35SPEAKER_00: Just wanted to have a discussion with you first.
- 0:38SPEAKER_00: You're here up in the great white north, Ottawa, the middle of November.
- 0:42SPEAKER_00: Bold, thank you for that.
- 0:44I know that you're here to talk about God,
- 0:46and we're going to get into that.
- 0:47But first,
- 0:49on behalf of the nation,
- 0:51I do feel the need to bring this one up.
- 0:53SPEAKER_00: Yep.
- 0:54SPEAKER_00: Oh, Canada, come join us January 2025.
- 0:57SPEAKER_00: Yes,
- 0:57I wrote a column making a gesture of friendly outreach to our
- 1:03cousins to the North
- 1:04SPEAKER_01: to,
- 1:05SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 1:06SPEAKER_01: lay claim to the North American birthright,
- 1:09SPEAKER_01: the shared North American birthright that should always have been ours.
- 1:14SPEAKER_01: What could have been controversial about that?
- 1:16I really feel like maybe that column failed to read the room a
- 1:20little bit.
- 1:20Like just in a moment when you have your president making
- 1:24overtures toward us to
- 1:25SPEAKER_00: become a 51st state or some kind of tributary thereof.
- 1:29SPEAKER_01: When we can all agree that certainly at least nine or 10 states could be
- 1:35SPEAKER_01: not just one in the context of- Well,
- 1:37SPEAKER_00: I'm just saying perhaps some ire,
- 1:41SPEAKER_00: some Canadian ire might have been expressed.
- 1:44SPEAKER_00: And I do think that the response to that column was grumpy.
- 1:46Was that fair to say that people were a bit grumpy with you
- 1:49about that one?
- 1:49SPEAKER_01: I mean, by Canadian standards, not to play into stereotypes, right?
- 1:53But the assumption that Americans make about Canadians is that
- 1:57it's a nation of
- 1:58SPEAKER_01: very polite people.
- 1:59SPEAKER_01: So that grumpiness by Canadian standards
- 2:02SPEAKER_01: is, you know, a sort of friendly umbrage by American standards.
- 2:06SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 2:06SPEAKER_00: So, I mean, enraged.
- 2:08SPEAKER_01: Enraged.
- 2:08SPEAKER_01: Enraged in a Canadian way, maybe.
- 2:11SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 2:12SPEAKER_01: the reality,
- 2:12SPEAKER_01: as you well know,
- 2:13of journalism is that you're looking for opportunities in which
- 2:17your arguments will
- 2:19SPEAKER_01: actually attract attention.
- 2:20SPEAKER_01: And Donald Trump behaving like Donald Trump created an opportunity for,
- 2:25SPEAKER_01: if I'd written a column about a North American union
- 2:28SPEAKER_01: five or ten years ago, no one would have read it.
- 2:31SPEAKER_01: In this case,
- 2:32SPEAKER_01: many people read it and became,
- 2:34SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 2:35SPEAKER_01: white hot or ice cold,
- 2:37SPEAKER_01: as the case may be with rage.
- 2:39SPEAKER_01: But still, at least some people read it.
- 2:42SPEAKER_00: I think you're right.
- 2:42SPEAKER_00: If you had written a column,
- 2:44a measured column about the prospect of an economic union with
- 2:46Canada five or six
- 2:47SPEAKER_00: years ago,
- 2:48there might have been even some people willing to consider that
- 2:50possibility.
- 2:51SPEAKER_01: Well, economic union is much too limited, though.
- 2:56SPEAKER_00: Oh, you want the whole thing, huh?
- 2:57SPEAKER_01: For my ambitions.
- 2:58SPEAKER_01: Well...
- 2:59SPEAKER_01: I think that as ridiculous as President Trump's 51st state posturing was,
- 3:09I did find something resonant in his complaints about the ugly
- 3:13line he's talking
- 3:15SPEAKER_01: about.
- 3:15SPEAKER_01: They just drew this line across the country.
- 3:17SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 3:19SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 3:19SPEAKER_01: And arbitrary order.
- 3:21SPEAKER_01: Arbitrary.
- 3:22SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 3:22SPEAKER_01: You know,
- 3:22there is there if you spend time in the Canadian West and the
- 3:27American West,
- 3:28SPEAKER_01: the Canadian Rockies or the American Rockies,
- 3:30SPEAKER_01: you may notice some similarities of topography and even personality.
- 3:35SPEAKER_01: Maybe that that, you know, it's it's a shame that these things are.
- 3:39SPEAKER_01: are impeded in their full flourishing.
- 3:43SPEAKER_01: The other reality is,
- 3:44SPEAKER_01: again,
- 3:45SPEAKER_01: not to sound too American,
- 3:46SPEAKER_01: but when you put together a population map of North America,
- 3:52SPEAKER_01: it quickly becomes noticeable.
- 3:55that almost all Canadians live within a pretty narrow range of
- 4:01miles or kilometers,
- 4:02SPEAKER_01: if you prefer,
- 4:02SPEAKER_01: even kilometre,
- 4:05SPEAKER_01: from the American border.
- 4:07SPEAKER_01: And that suggests to me that there is,
- 4:10SPEAKER_01: that the United States,
- 4:12SPEAKER_01: let me put it this way,
- 4:13SPEAKER_01: the United States is like,
- 4:14SPEAKER_01: a magnet, right?
- 4:16SPEAKER_01: Sometimes for good, sometimes for ill.
- 4:18But I feel like Canada and Canadians have ended up with a kind
- 4:21of worst of both
- 4:22worlds scenario in the last 10 or 15 years where it seems like
- 4:27Canada traditionally
- 4:28found a way to sort of define its own national identity against
- 4:32the United States,
- 4:33SPEAKER_01: right?
- 4:34You know,
- 4:35to be sort of Tory and respectable when America was
- 4:39revolutionary.
- 4:41SPEAKER_01: and to be sort of,
- 4:43SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 4:44SPEAKER_01: liberal and secular when America was a bunch of,
- 4:46SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 4:47SPEAKER_01: religious cowboys from Texas led by George W.
- 4:49SPEAKER_01: Bush.
- 4:50SPEAKER_01: But I feel like... So you missed those days, by the way.
- 4:52SPEAKER_01: Well, I feel like, and you can tell me I'm wrong about this, right?
- 4:55SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 4:55SPEAKER_01: That Canada,
- 4:56SPEAKER_01: especially in the Trudeau years,
- 4:58SPEAKER_01: has entered into its own kind of national identity crisis.
- 5:01It's not,
- 5:02you know,
- 5:02Trudeau talked about the post-national nation or something,
- 5:06you know.
- 5:07SPEAKER_01: And...
- 5:10even as it has become even more buffeted and influenced through
- 5:16changes in politics
- 5:18SPEAKER_01: and economics,
- 5:18SPEAKER_01: but also just through the internet by trends in the United States.
- 5:22So basically you're sort of prisoners of our politics without
- 5:25being able to vote,
- 5:26SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 5:26SPEAKER_01: to vote in our politics,
- 5:28SPEAKER_01: to shape our politics directly.
- 5:31SPEAKER_01: And you're also having a crisis of national identity.
- 5:34SPEAKER_01: And it seems like you could solve both problems.
- 5:37SPEAKER_01: By abandoning the national identity.
- 5:40SPEAKER_01: Through union.
- 5:41SPEAKER_01: Through union in a larger shared identity.
- 5:44SPEAKER_01: But, you know, I've read the polls.
- 5:47SPEAKER_01: I know this argument appeals to about 10% of Canadians,
- 5:51SPEAKER_01: slightly more Generation Z.
- 5:54SPEAKER_01: You know,
- 5:54SPEAKER_01: you get up to 15%,
- 5:54SPEAKER_01: 15%.
- 5:55SPEAKER_01: So I'm starting from a low foundation.
- 5:58SPEAKER_01: But I think of this as a, let's say, a 50 to 75 year plan for union.
- 6:02SPEAKER_00: I do respect the willingness to be provocative on this point.
- 6:05SPEAKER_00: And I will say,
- 6:05SPEAKER_00: as someone from Western Canada,
- 6:07SPEAKER_00: I'm under no obligation to be particularly nice to Ottawa.
- 6:09SPEAKER_00: I only come here when I have to.
- 6:11SPEAKER_00: Thank you for giving me the opportunity.
- 6:13I believe that Alberta is the Canadian province where support
- 6:17for union with the
- 6:18SPEAKER_01: United States pulls best.
- 6:20SPEAKER_00: It is, in fact.
- 6:21SPEAKER_00: It sometimes breaches 15%, maybe even 20%, depending on the poll.
- 6:27SPEAKER_00: Look,
- 6:27I think one of the reasons why Canadians got particularly fussy
- 6:29about that column
- 6:30and upset about that column is because you've correctly
- 6:32identified a problem.
- 6:34SPEAKER_00: And that is,
- 6:34SPEAKER_00: I do think that Canada lacks,
- 6:36SPEAKER_00: especially Anglo-Canada,
- 6:37SPEAKER_00: not so much French Canada,
- 6:39SPEAKER_00: does lack a cohesive national identity.
- 6:42And that becomes abundantly clear and a major problem when
- 6:45we're facing...
- 6:47SPEAKER_00: a potential cultural,
- 6:48SPEAKER_00: if not economic,
- 6:49SPEAKER_00: incursion by a much larger,
- 6:50SPEAKER_00: more powerful,
- 6:50SPEAKER_00: richer neighbor.
- 6:53I tend to agree that right now all we have as a national
- 6:56identity is that we're not America.
- 6:57SPEAKER_00: Which is what Trudeau, specifically, it was the first thing he said.
- 7:01SPEAKER_00: When Trudeau goes on CNN and says, what's the Canadian identity?
- 7:04SPEAKER_00: He's like, but we have a dental program.
- 7:07SPEAKER_00: That's pretty weak, right?
- 7:08SPEAKER_00: That's pretty weak as far as national identities go.
- 7:10And I think that that is a conversation that especially English
- 7:13Canada needs to
- 7:14SPEAKER_00: start having with itself because it's a problem.
- 7:17SPEAKER_00: So yeah,
- 7:18SPEAKER_00: look,
- 7:18there's nothing that makes people angrier at a columnist when a
- 7:21columnist is
- 7:22SPEAKER_00: correct about something.
- 7:23SPEAKER_00: That's just the worst.
- 7:26SPEAKER_00: But what I thought was really interesting about that column,
- 7:29SPEAKER_00: not to belabor something you wrote a year ago,
- 7:31was that at no point did you stop to consider whether or not
- 7:34America was a country
- 7:35SPEAKER_00: worth joining,
- 7:37SPEAKER_00: right?
- 7:37SPEAKER_01: That's true.
- 7:38SPEAKER_01: I did not.
- 7:39SPEAKER_00: which is a very American thing to do.
- 7:41SPEAKER_01: Absolutely, yes.
- 7:43I mean,
- 7:43you're never gonna convince someone to join you if you spend a
- 7:48lot of time
- 7:49SPEAKER_01: listing all the reasons someone might not join you.
- 7:52SPEAKER_01: A wooing,
- 7:52SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 7:53SPEAKER_01: no man romancing a woman would say,
- 7:55SPEAKER_01: well,
- 7:56SPEAKER_01: let me also offer you a list of my,
- 7:57SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 7:58SPEAKER_01: some men would actually,
- 7:59SPEAKER_01: I shouldn't say that.
- 7:59SPEAKER_01: It's a new generation.
- 8:00SPEAKER_00: It's a new generation, right?
- 8:01SPEAKER_00: It's very Gen Alpha.
- 8:02SPEAKER_01: But it's not ideal to say,
- 8:05SPEAKER_01: here's a list of the 15 reasons that you might not want to,
- 8:08SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 8:08SPEAKER_01: might not want to marry me or something.
- 8:10I just think that...
- 8:11I think it is,
- 8:12I don't think it's hard to come up with aspects of...
- 8:15SPEAKER_01: American life that someone might not want to participate in.
- 8:20But I am enough of an American chauvinist to suggest that
- 8:25looking ahead across the
- 8:26SPEAKER_01: sweep of the 21st century,
- 8:29SPEAKER_01: I think America is going to be one of the better places to be,
- 8:33SPEAKER_01: flaws and all.
- 8:34And I think that some of the things that Canadians find
- 8:39unpleasant or distasteful
- 8:40SPEAKER_01: about the United States
- 8:42maybe slightly exaggerated by the desire to sort of avoid the
- 8:48magnetic pull of the
- 8:50SPEAKER_01: richer and more obnoxious nation to the south.
- 8:52SPEAKER_00: Well, I'm not going to lie.
- 8:53SPEAKER_00: My group chats right now are filled with news of Olivia Nuzzi.
- 8:56SPEAKER_00: This is a thing that it's crossed the border.
- 8:59SPEAKER_01: Well, we'll see right there.
- 9:00SPEAKER_01: You're already trapped in our horrifying media vortex.
- 9:04SPEAKER_01: It's true.
- 9:05I would say the one other thing I'd say about this is that I
- 9:08think that...
- 9:10And again,
- 9:11I obviously don't expect Canada to join the United States
- 9:14anytime soon.
- 9:15SPEAKER_01: But I think that over the last 40 or 50 years,
- 9:18Canada was pretty comfortable with a kind of West in which
- 9:22Europe and America were
- 9:24SPEAKER_01: kind of equally balanced.
- 9:25SPEAKER_01: And Canada almost played a mediating role.
- 9:28SPEAKER_01: It was more European and old world in certain ways than the US,
- 9:32SPEAKER_01: more new world than Western Europe.
- 9:35SPEAKER_01: I suspect over the next 40 or 50 years,
- 9:38SPEAKER_01: European decline is going to be more and more of a stark fact.
- 9:43And Canada,
- 9:44and this is already true,
- 9:45Canada is going to sort of find itself in a world where
- 9:48SPEAKER_01: its southern neighbor is still extremely powerful.
- 9:51And the other major balancing forces in the world are places
- 9:56like the People's
- 9:56SPEAKER_01: Republic of China,
- 9:57SPEAKER_01: which obviously has made its own efforts to gain influence in Canada.
- 10:02SPEAKER_01: And I think,
- 10:02SPEAKER_01: again,
- 10:03SPEAKER_01: independent of the maybe slightly ridiculous,
- 10:07SPEAKER_01: should we actually literally join the U.S.
- 10:09question,
- 10:10there's just a question of,
- 10:12you know,
- 10:13what does Canada do in a 21st century where
- 10:17SPEAKER_01: It's no longer balancing between Western Europe and the United States.
- 10:23SPEAKER_01: And instead,
- 10:25the dynamic is more the United States on the one hand or
- 10:32authoritarian powers in
- 10:33SPEAKER_01: Asia on the other.
- 10:34SPEAKER_01: I think that's just a new dilemma for Canada.
- 10:36SPEAKER_00: Our recent budget does have us making a play for Eurovision.
- 10:39SPEAKER_00: That does count for something.
- 10:41SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 10:42I think it would be a big mistake for the Canadians to go hard
- 10:46on a kind of
- 10:48SPEAKER_01: European identity at this moment in history,
- 10:51SPEAKER_01: but we'll see.
- 10:52SPEAKER_00: Well, we'll see.
- 10:53SPEAKER_00: The only thing I'm saying,
- 10:54SPEAKER_00: as much as I think you've correctly identified the not-Canada,
- 10:57SPEAKER_00: or sorry,
- 10:57SPEAKER_00: the not-America national identity as being insufficient for the moment,
- 11:01SPEAKER_00: and I would agree with that,
- 11:03SPEAKER_00: not-America is doing a lot of work right now.
- 11:06SPEAKER_00: Yes.
- 11:07SPEAKER_00: pulling a lot of weight on that.
- 11:09SPEAKER_01: Absolutely.
- 11:10SPEAKER_01: And I think the nature of the phenomenon that is Donald Trump,
- 11:16SPEAKER_01: and this is not a phenomenon that is unique to US-Canadian relations,
- 11:20but Trump has an unparalleled ability to sort of put his finger
- 11:26on spots of trouble
- 11:29and change and issues that elites don't want to talk about and
- 11:34sort of bring those
- 11:35SPEAKER_01: issues to the fore.
- 11:36SPEAKER_01: And then
- 11:37SPEAKER_01: be totally unable to then do something productive.
- 11:42SPEAKER_01: Like the Epstein files.
- 11:44SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 11:45SPEAKER_01: Put things on a stable footing in any way.
- 11:48SPEAKER_01: Well, you just see this on practical issues, right?
- 11:51SPEAKER_01: Like,
- 11:52SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 11:53SPEAKER_01: in the US,
- 11:54it's debates about immigration and higher education and all of
- 11:57these things where
- 11:59Trump embodies a critique of conventional wisdom that has a
- 12:04tremendous amount of power.
- 12:06SPEAKER_01: And that's why he has been resilient and has been able to win.
- 12:09SPEAKER_01: But if you say, can Donald Trump put U.S.
- 12:13immigration policy on a stable footing for the next 25 years or
- 12:16put higher
- 12:17SPEAKER_01: education policy on a stable footing,
- 12:19SPEAKER_01: the answer is consistently and repeatedly going to be no.
- 12:23SPEAKER_01: And so just in the same way,
- 12:25SPEAKER_01: can Donald Trump put his finger on this sort of unstated,
- 12:30SPEAKER_01: difficult reality facing
- 12:32SPEAKER_01: Canada in the 21st century, yes, he absolutely can.
- 12:35SPEAKER_01: Can he make Canadians want to hang out with Americans?
- 12:39SPEAKER_01: Not really.
- 12:40SPEAKER_01: Except here in this safe space.
- 12:43SPEAKER_00: In a safe space, like I said.
- 12:44SPEAKER_00: You get much credit for coming to enemy territory.
- 12:48SPEAKER_01: It's not enemy territory.
- 12:49SPEAKER_00: In the midst of November, no less.
- 12:51SPEAKER_01: Yeah, there were some issues landing our plane at the Ottawa airport.
- 12:56SPEAKER_01: And there was actually a pretty stark division.
- 12:59SPEAKER_01: So we had to divert our plane to Syracuse because of fog in Ottawa.
- 13:03SPEAKER_01: And Syracuse is only three hours south.
- 13:05SPEAKER_01: But climactically,
- 13:07SPEAKER_01: it did feel like I was crossing some kind of really substantial frontier,
- 13:12SPEAKER_01: which maybe into the north,
- 13:14SPEAKER_01: which maybe I underestimated in my optimistic plans for,
- 13:20SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 13:20SPEAKER_00: Well,
- 13:21SPEAKER_00: let me say the role of climate and shaping Canadian identity is,
- 13:25SPEAKER_00: I think,
- 13:26SPEAKER_00: not quite as understood or necessarily explored as it ought to be.
- 13:29I do think it does change the way people approach even things
- 13:32like government
- 13:33SPEAKER_00: policy and creating civic institutions and neighbourly values.
- 13:37SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 13:37When you live in a very brutal climate where you have to
- 13:40potentially depend on your
- 13:42SPEAKER_00: neighbours in a way that you don't and warmer,
- 13:43SPEAKER_00: more...
- 13:45SPEAKER_00: In Florida.
- 13:46SPEAKER_00: Well,
- 13:46SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 13:46SPEAKER_00: it's not that you guys don't have climate issues,
- 13:48SPEAKER_00: but,
- 13:48SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 13:48I can tell you stories about getting stuck in the middle of
- 13:51snow banks in the
- 13:51middle of rural Alberta and having random trucks pull over in
- 13:54the middle of the
- 13:55SPEAKER_00: night and tow me out.
- 13:57SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 13:57And being able to trust in random strangers to be able to
- 14:01survive in that way.
- 14:02SPEAKER_00: It creates a different mentality a little bit.
- 14:05SPEAKER_00: Anyway, I'm working on creating a national identity.
- 14:07SPEAKER_00: I'll get to that.
- 14:08SPEAKER_00: Look, we want to talk about God.
- 14:11SPEAKER_00: You're here, you're delivering a lecture here in Ottawa.
- 14:14Tell me a little bit more about that and tell me a little bit
- 14:17more about what your
- 14:17SPEAKER_00: thesis is for that lecture.
- 14:20Well,
- 14:20I haven't given it yet,
- 14:21so to some degree it has yet to be discovered.
- 14:24SPEAKER_01: All talks sort of come to their full shape when they're actually given.
- 14:30SPEAKER_01: But I'm going to talk a little bit about the sort of
- 14:35shape of debates about religion and arguments about religion in
- 14:40Western culture
- 14:41SPEAKER_01: right now,
- 14:41because I think there's been a really interesting shift over
- 14:44the last five years or
- 14:46SPEAKER_01: so where we went through a period of sort of accelerated secularization,
- 14:51SPEAKER_01: especially in the U.S.,
- 14:52SPEAKER_01: but in Europe,
- 14:54SPEAKER_01: secularization had already sort of reached a further limit.
- 14:58SPEAKER_01: Canada is somewhere in between.
- 14:59SPEAKER_01: But we went through this
- 15:01SPEAKER_01: this period of deepening secularization that sort of hit,
- 15:07SPEAKER_01: if not an endpoint,
- 15:08SPEAKER_01: at least a plateau three to five years ago.
- 15:12And now we're in a landscape where it's not that there's
- 15:15exactly a religious
- 15:16SPEAKER_01: revival,
- 15:17SPEAKER_01: but there is sort of
- 15:19Renewed interest in religion renewed interest in having
- 15:22arguments about religion
- 15:23There are some indicators of actual revival in the most secular
- 15:27parts of the West
- 15:28in France and the United Kingdom in the United States It's more
- 15:32that the number of
- 15:34SPEAKER_01: non-religious people has stopped going up for the moment,
- 15:37SPEAKER_01: but you do have
- 15:39a lot of anecdotal stories about conversions in college towns
- 15:45and people in the
- 15:47SPEAKER_01: most secular parts of the country,
- 15:50SPEAKER_01: people in the intelligentsia,
- 15:51SPEAKER_01: people in academia,
- 15:54either going back to church or being interested in talking
- 15:57about religion again.
- 15:59SPEAKER_01: So I'm interested in why that's happened, what has changed.
- 16:04SPEAKER_01: I think we have gone through a period in which there was a sort of
- 16:10a narrative of secular optimism that has obviously hit the
- 16:14rocks in pretty important ways.
- 16:17SPEAKER_01: And there were a set of intellectuals,
- 16:21SPEAKER_01: the new atheists,
- 16:22SPEAKER_01: these kind of arguers of 15 or 20 years ago who made some pretty concrete
- 16:26predictions about how the world was going to get better if it
- 16:29got less religious.
- 16:30And people look around in the 2020s and say,
- 16:32well,
- 16:32things got less religious and
- 16:35SPEAKER_01: you know, oops, it's not so great.
- 16:38SPEAKER_01: We're not less polarized.
- 16:39SPEAKER_01: We're not, you know, more neighborly to each other.
- 16:42SPEAKER_00: No ism without a schism.
- 16:43SPEAKER_01: That's right.
- 16:44SPEAKER_01: There's no, it's not that everyone believes in science now.
- 16:47SPEAKER_01: No, they believe in other weird or crazier things, right?
- 16:50SPEAKER_01: So there's that reality.
- 16:54SPEAKER_01: There's the extent to which I think life under digital conditions,
- 16:59SPEAKER_01: under internet conditions has sort of
- 17:01SPEAKER_01: thrown the younger generation into a profound existential funk in which
- 17:08many people who have been raised without any kind of religion
- 17:11are suddenly saying,
- 17:12SPEAKER_01: Hmm,
- 17:12SPEAKER_01: maybe I could use a community or a metaphysical horizon again.
- 17:17SPEAKER_01: Um,
- 17:17SPEAKER_01: so there's a number,
- 17:18SPEAKER_01: there's a number of things going on there,
- 17:21SPEAKER_01: but then the question is what happens next,
- 17:25SPEAKER_01: right?
- 17:25SPEAKER_01: Do you actually get a real religious revival out of this moment?
- 17:29SPEAKER_01: Or is it just sort of this temporary moment of reconsideration and
- 17:33SPEAKER_01: The argument that I make in my most recent book,
- 17:36SPEAKER_01: which is called Believe,
- 17:38SPEAKER_01: Why Everyone Should Be Religious,
- 17:41SPEAKER_01: which is sort of an aggressive sales pitch,
- 17:43SPEAKER_01: like my sales pitch to Canadians.
- 17:45SPEAKER_01: All my sales pitches are maybe overly aggressive.
- 17:47SPEAKER_01: But the argument there is that it is, in fact, much more...
- 17:53SPEAKER_01: not just intellectually serious,
- 17:54but maybe intellectually obligatory to take religious questions
- 17:59seriously,
- 17:59to take the possibility or likelihood that there is a God
- 18:03seriously than a lot of
- 18:07SPEAKER_01: secular people have been conditioned to think.
- 18:09So it's an argument that sort of made to people reconsidering
- 18:13religion and saying,
- 18:14SPEAKER_01: yes,
- 18:14SPEAKER_01: you should reconsider it.
- 18:16SPEAKER_01: You should take it seriously.
- 18:17There probably is a God joining going back to church is
- 18:21actually a very reasonable
- 18:23SPEAKER_01: thing to do,
- 18:23even if you haven't had flights of angels descending to tell
- 18:26you that you ought to
- 18:28SPEAKER_01: do it.
- 18:28SPEAKER_01: So.
- 18:31SPEAKER_01: But then the other point,
- 18:32SPEAKER_01: which is not in the book,
- 18:33but which I'm going to try and fold into the talk because they
- 18:37said they wanted
- 18:38SPEAKER_01: something about the whole world and the future.
- 18:41SPEAKER_00: No pressure.
- 18:42SPEAKER_01: No pressure.
- 18:43SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 18:43Is that I think the landscape of the 21st century is just going
- 18:48to be a landscape
- 18:49SPEAKER_01: that where what we're seeing now is only the beginning.
- 18:51There's just going to be tremendous pressure on the individual
- 18:56human being,
- 18:58SPEAKER_01: families,
- 18:58SPEAKER_01: communities,
- 19:00SPEAKER_01: nations to either have a strong self-definition,
- 19:05SPEAKER_01: a strong understanding of their place in the world or the cosmos,
- 19:09SPEAKER_01: a strong reason for existing and trying to continue to exist.
- 19:14Or there's going to be sort of obsolescence and disappearance
- 19:18of all kinds of human
- 19:19SPEAKER_01: things that the pressures of the Internet are sort of phase one of this.
- 19:24And then the pressures of artificial intelligence are going to
- 19:26be phase two.
- 19:27SPEAKER_00: Can you expand a little bit on that?
- 19:28What kind of human things do collapse in the absence of a
- 19:32strong unifying religious faith?
- 19:35SPEAKER_01: So, well, so what happens is
- 19:39SPEAKER_01: it's not just religion that collapses,
- 19:42SPEAKER_01: it's more that religion is a potential antidote to collapse.
- 19:45SPEAKER_01: So what you see already under digital conditions,
- 19:48SPEAKER_01: right,
- 19:49is the collapse of a lot of just sort of basic real world ways
- 19:54that human beings
- 19:55SPEAKER_01: related to one another for most of our history,
- 19:58SPEAKER_01: right?
- 20:00SPEAKER_01: You know,
- 20:00that sort of people who relate to and communicate with each
- 20:03other under digital
- 20:04SPEAKER_01: conditions don't do things in reality that used to
- 20:09build community and help men and women meet each other and get
- 20:13married,
- 20:14right?
- 20:14SPEAKER_01: And help families raise children, but also
- 20:18SPEAKER_01: You know,
- 20:18SPEAKER_01: it ranges from that to,
- 20:22SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 20:22SPEAKER_01: sort of institutions of high culture,
- 20:24SPEAKER_01: museums,
- 20:25SPEAKER_01: ballet,
- 20:26SPEAKER_01: all of these things suffer tremendously under digital conditions.
- 20:30SPEAKER_01: The movies have suffered tremendously.
- 20:32SPEAKER_00: Journalism.
- 20:33SPEAKER_01: Going great.
- 20:34I mean,
- 20:34you don't want you don't as a journalist,
- 20:36you don't want to start with journalism.
- 20:37SPEAKER_01: Journalism was, in fact, a leading example where the Internet destroyed
- 20:42SPEAKER_01: The economic base for a lot of journalistic enterprises first,
- 20:47SPEAKER_01: and it didn't do away with journalism,
- 20:49SPEAKER_01: but it reduced it.
- 20:51SPEAKER_01: And then it also reduced its connection to reality.
- 20:54SPEAKER_01: Like my wife was a newspaper reporter,
- 20:56SPEAKER_01: actually not that far from here in upstate New York in her 20s.
- 21:00SPEAKER_01: And her job was all about reality.
- 21:03She would go out into the Adirondack State Park and find
- 21:06stories and talk to people
- 21:08SPEAKER_01: and exist in the world.
- 21:10SPEAKER_01: And the journalism that has sort of replaced that kind of journalism,
- 21:14SPEAKER_01: because all the newspapers that used to hire people to do that,
- 21:17you know if they had 50 reporters once now they have 10 right
- 21:20so those jobs go away
- 21:21and in their place you have things um that are and this is you
- 21:26know maybe the wrong
- 21:26SPEAKER_01: thing to say on a video podcast right but it's people talking to screens
- 21:30interacting with each other in digital worlds that can be very
- 21:34interesting and
- 21:34there's good things about long-form podcasting i run a podcast
- 21:38myself right but it
- 21:40SPEAKER_01: is it is a reduced
- 21:43SPEAKER_01: form of engagement with reality.
- 21:45And I think you see that all over in all kinds of different
- 21:50aspects of life.
- 21:52SPEAKER_01: And one of the effects of that,
- 21:54SPEAKER_01: one of I think the clear effects is that people just sort of float
- 22:00through life in these kind of virtual worlds and it's very easy
- 22:05not to do things
- 22:07that people sort of took for granted for most of human history
- 22:11and again some of
- 22:12this is about art and institution building and culture some of
- 22:14it is just very
- 22:15basic people just get married less and have fewer kids at a
- 22:20pace that is going to
- 22:21SPEAKER_01: make
- 22:23SPEAKER_01: Again,
- 22:23SPEAKER_01: not just like a family or a region or a state,
- 22:28SPEAKER_01: but entire nations could just collapse from sort of,
- 22:36SPEAKER_01: in effect,
- 22:37SPEAKER_01: demographic suicide over the course of the next couple of generations.
- 22:41SPEAKER_01: In fact, this will happen in some places.
- 22:43SPEAKER_01: It's already built in.
- 22:45Something terrible is going to happen in South Korea over the
- 22:48next 50 years because
- 22:50SPEAKER_01: their fertility rate is 0.7.
- 22:53So there is no these things are sort of certain things are sort
- 22:56of already built in.
- 22:59SPEAKER_01: AI,
- 23:00SPEAKER_01: we'll see how far it goes,
- 23:01but it promises to go further and it doesn't just sort of offer
- 23:04a kind of way to
- 23:05SPEAKER_01: float digitally.
- 23:06SPEAKER_01: It says an actually
- 23:08SPEAKER_01: all of the residual things that human beings still have to do,
- 23:11SPEAKER_01: we're going to replace those too,
- 23:13SPEAKER_01: right?
- 23:13SPEAKER_00: So if I'm going to wear my devil's advocate monstrous atheist hat,
- 23:18SPEAKER_00: which I occasionally put on for fun,
- 23:20SPEAKER_00: I would say,
- 23:21so your solution to these very real problems is the
- 23:25substitution of one kind of
- 23:27SPEAKER_00: fantasy reality with another.
- 23:28You're relying on this idea that people will resolve some of
- 23:32these tensions of the modern world
- 23:34by getting out of one digital fantasy reality and absorbing
- 23:39another kind of
- 23:40SPEAKER_00: unprovable metaphysical ethic.
- 23:43SPEAKER_00: How does that solve any of these problems?
- 23:46SPEAKER_00: And you can't really go back, right?
- 23:49You can't go back in time to the 1950s when everybody or the
- 23:531920s or whatever else
- 23:54SPEAKER_00: and say back to a time when everybody was an Orthodox Christian believer.
- 23:57SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 23:58Well,
- 23:58everyone was certainly not an Orthodox Christian believer in
- 24:00the 1950s.
- 24:01SPEAKER_00: I'm drawing a very generalized argument.
- 24:03SPEAKER_01: No, but I want to be clear.
- 24:06SPEAKER_01: There are two separate questions.
- 24:08SPEAKER_01: One question is,
- 24:10SPEAKER_01: is religion just a fantasy,
- 24:13SPEAKER_01: just a kind of metaphysical dress-up that has nothing to do with reality,
- 24:17SPEAKER_01: or does it accurately describe reality?
- 24:20SPEAKER_01: That's question one.
- 24:20SPEAKER_01: Sure.
- 24:21SPEAKER_01: Question two is...
- 24:24what is selected for by this kind of turn towards human
- 24:29obsolescence that we're experiencing.
- 24:32I think religion is likely to be selected for over the next few
- 24:36generations,
- 24:37SPEAKER_01: whether or not it is true.
- 24:39SPEAKER_01: So I'm not saying religion is the solution to this.
- 24:41SPEAKER_01: I'm saying whether you think religion is good or not,
- 24:45SPEAKER_01: it's going to be one of the places,
- 24:47SPEAKER_01: and you can already see this,
- 24:49SPEAKER_01: that one of the ways of being
- 24:53in the world that encourages human beings to still form
- 24:58families and communities
- 25:00and cultures under conditions that are really hostile to the
- 25:03basic continuity of
- 25:05SPEAKER_01: human things.
- 25:06SPEAKER_01: Doesn't mean it's true.
- 25:06I'm not saying you must be religious in order to survive this
- 25:11evolutionary bottleneck.
- 25:12SPEAKER_01: I'm just saying, and in fact, there are
- 25:17there will be people going through this period who turn to
- 25:21completely different
- 25:22SPEAKER_01: ideas as a means.
- 25:24SPEAKER_01: And if you look at people in Silicon Valley looking at these trends,
- 25:27SPEAKER_01: there are people in Silicon Valley who are ready to say,
- 25:30SPEAKER_01: yeah,
- 25:32it's really terrible that nobody's having kids anymore under
- 25:36the conditions that we
- 25:37SPEAKER_01: ourselves are creating.
- 25:39And so the solution is we're gonna figure out how to build
- 25:41artificial looms and large
- 25:44you know brave new world style hatcheries or something there
- 25:46will be a lot of that
- 25:47there will be people who are seeking technological solutions
- 25:51technological ways for
- 25:52human beings to continue there will be people who are perfectly
- 25:55happy with a lot of
- 25:56the human race becoming obsolete as long as they can sort of
- 25:59rule over what remains
- 26:00SPEAKER_01: so there's going to be a lot of different forces in play but
- 26:05religion is likely to be one of the more powerful forces
- 26:10because religion offers an
- 26:11SPEAKER_01: account of why the individual human being is valuable.
- 26:15SPEAKER_01: It offers an account of,
- 26:17SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 26:17why it actually matters what you do with your life in reality
- 26:21that right now more
- 26:23SPEAKER_01: secular sort of thought forms are not offering.
- 26:27SPEAKER_01: Now, it's also helpful that it's true.
- 26:30SPEAKER_01: That's the answer to your question, is it just metaphysical dress-up?
- 26:36SPEAKER_01: No, the answer is no.
- 26:38SPEAKER_01: God is real.
- 26:39You will probably meet him or her or them when you die and you
- 26:42should be prepared for that.
- 26:44And these things are true regardless of whatever is happening
- 26:48in larger world conditions.
- 26:49SPEAKER_01: I'm just saying,
- 26:50SPEAKER_01: if you look at larger world conditions,
- 26:52there are reasons to think that we've kind of hit a certain
- 26:56limit on secularization
- 26:58SPEAKER_01: and the decline of religion.
- 26:59So essentially,
- 26:59there's two different arguments here,
- 27:00and I'll summarize here.
- 27:02SPEAKER_00: One is, even if it's not true, it's necessary.
- 27:05And your position is,
- 27:06in addition to that,
- 27:06it's also,
- 27:07in your opinion,
- 27:08true.
- 27:08Yes,
- 27:09but I'm not urging,
- 27:10I wouldn't urge people to be religious because it's necessary.
- 27:13SPEAKER_01: I'm making a prediction.
- 27:16I'm saying it is a form through which human beings are more
- 27:25likely to resist their
- 27:27own obsolescence and therefore it is likely to flourish under
- 27:31the difficult
- 27:31SPEAKER_01: conditions ahead.
- 27:33SPEAKER_01: And also it's true.
- 27:34healthy religious communities are much more likely to survive
- 27:37and create healthy
- 27:38SPEAKER_00: families than secular communities or non-healthy religious communities.
- 27:43SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 27:43SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 27:43SPEAKER_01: generally communities,
- 27:44and this connects to our lovely discussion about the Canadian
- 27:47American future.
- 27:48SPEAKER_01: Sure.
- 27:49SPEAKER_01: Communities that have a sense of what they're for,
- 27:54SPEAKER_01: that they have some kind of meaningful purpose going forward,
- 27:58SPEAKER_01: and that they are custodians of something valuable from the past,
- 28:02are more likely to survive than communities that don't have
- 28:05those feelings.
- 28:07SPEAKER_01: This is true of nations,
- 28:08SPEAKER_01: a nation that has a sense of who it is,
- 28:12SPEAKER_01: why it wants its own traditions to persist,
- 28:15SPEAKER_01: is more likely to survive the 21st century than one that doesn't.
- 28:19SPEAKER_01: And similarly,
- 28:21SPEAKER_01: a community that has,
- 28:23SPEAKER_01: that thinks that human beings are put in the world for a reason,
- 28:27SPEAKER_01: that it's worth struggling through life,
- 28:30SPEAKER_01: even,
- 28:30SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 28:32SPEAKER_01: Even if you can't see the overall plan because there is an overall plan,
- 28:35SPEAKER_01: it's worth being fruitful and multiplying all these things.
- 28:38SPEAKER_01: That kind of community is also more likely to persist.
- 28:41SPEAKER_01: You don't have to be religious to persist in this environment,
- 28:44SPEAKER_01: but you have to have a sense of purpose and continuity.
- 28:50that religion is pretty good at granting people relative to
- 28:54other worldviews right now.
- 28:56SPEAKER_00: Well,
- 28:56SPEAKER_00: that brings me to the question about American religious revival,
- 29:00SPEAKER_00: because granted,
- 29:00SPEAKER_00: I don't go there.
- 29:01SPEAKER_00: It's not my high school.
- 29:02SPEAKER_00: But it does seem to me that America is going through a religious revival.
- 29:07that religious revival seems to be a particularly strange
- 29:12hybrid of evangelical
- 29:13SPEAKER_00: Christianity and nationalism,
- 29:15SPEAKER_00: essentially a Christian nationalist revival.
- 29:18SPEAKER_00: Again, this is from afar, that's what it looks like to me.
- 29:21SPEAKER_00: And I look at that revival and I'm like,
- 29:23that sort of presents the most toxic elements of Christianity
- 29:26and the most toxic
- 29:27SPEAKER_00: elements of nationalism in one beautiful,
- 29:30SPEAKER_00: perfectly toxic package.
- 29:32So,
- 29:32I mean,
- 29:32would that be a counter argument to the position that you're
- 29:36making?
- 29:38I mean,
- 29:38first,
- 29:38I don't think America is going through a religious revival at
- 29:41the moment.
- 29:42I think America is considering whether to have a religious
- 29:46revival is the better
- 29:47SPEAKER_01: way of putting it.
- 29:48SPEAKER_01: But you don't yet see sort of stark increases in church attendance.
- 29:55SPEAKER_01: You know,
- 29:55SPEAKER_01: the stuff that actually,
- 29:56SPEAKER_01: if you're going to describe something as a revival,
- 29:59SPEAKER_01: more people need to be going to church.
- 30:01SPEAKER_01: You need to see commitment.
- 30:01SPEAKER_01: You need to see commitment.
- 30:03SPEAKER_01: And to the extent that
- 30:04SPEAKER_01: there's a kind of pseudo-religious revival that is performative,
- 30:08SPEAKER_01: where people go on the internet and talk about,
- 30:11SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 30:12SPEAKER_01: sort of God and country and don't actually do anything in reality,
- 30:16SPEAKER_01: then that's not one that's just sort of bad in and of itself,
- 30:22SPEAKER_01: because if there is a God,
- 30:24he probably wants you to go to church and not just shitpost on
- 30:28the internet about
- 30:28SPEAKER_01: Jesus or whatever,
- 30:29SPEAKER_01: pardon my language.
- 30:30SPEAKER_00: All of us are called in our own special ways.
- 30:32SPEAKER_00: They are.
- 30:32SPEAKER_01: I mean, look, I post on the Internet.
- 30:35SPEAKER_00: Some of us were meant to be on Twitter.
- 30:37SPEAKER_01: Let he who is without tweets cast the first stone, as a wise man said.
- 30:42SPEAKER_01: But yes,
- 30:43for a religious revival that doesn't revive any actual
- 30:48religious practices and that
- 30:51SPEAKER_01: is mostly just subsumed into politics is both bad in and of itself.
- 30:56SPEAKER_01: And it's not going to do the kinds of things that I think
- 31:00SPEAKER_01: actual religion does for people in the world or in eternity.
- 31:07That said,
- 31:08I also think that,
- 31:10you know,
- 31:11the way media works,
- 31:12the way sort of our attention works
- 31:16SPEAKER_01: politics draws in everything.
- 31:20SPEAKER_01: So people,
- 31:21SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 31:21you read sociological trends through the lens of politics
- 31:26because that's what gets
- 31:27SPEAKER_01: all the attention,
- 31:28SPEAKER_01: right?
- 31:29SPEAKER_01: So I think there is also kind of an impulse to sort of
- 31:33find the most absurd politicized form of religion in America or
- 31:37anywhere else and
- 31:38SPEAKER_01: say,
- 31:39SPEAKER_01: ah,
- 31:39SPEAKER_01: this is what,
- 31:40SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 31:40SPEAKER_01: if there's a religious revival,
- 31:41SPEAKER_01: it must mean this guy talking about Christian nationalism on YouTube.
- 31:46SPEAKER_01: But then you go and like actually poll Americans and you're like,
- 31:49SPEAKER_01: all right,
- 31:49SPEAKER_01: what is Christian nationalism?
- 31:50SPEAKER_01: Let's ask five questions that capture Christian nationalism.
- 31:54SPEAKER_01: And first of all, most conservative Americans
- 31:57SPEAKER_01: don't know what Christian nationalism means.
- 31:59It's really hard to sort of assemble a set of questions that
- 32:02makes it a definable term.
- 32:05It's a term that's very useful to a set of people who are
- 32:09trying to build their own
- 32:10SPEAKER_01: brands as would-be leaders.
- 32:12And it's very useful to people who want to be scared about
- 32:15something frightening
- 32:16SPEAKER_01: that's happening way out to their right.
- 32:18SPEAKER_01: So there's a kind of feedback loop, right?
- 32:20A kind of mutual reinforcement of would-be Christian
- 32:22nationalist influencers
- 32:24SPEAKER_01: and people who think the U.S.
- 32:25SPEAKER_01: is about to be plunged into theocratic darkness.
- 32:28I don't think either of those things accurately describe most
- 32:32of what happens in
- 32:34SPEAKER_01: American religion right now.
- 32:36SPEAKER_01: And to the extent that there is sort of stirrings of actual revival,
- 32:42SPEAKER_01: I think it's not primarily political at all.
- 32:46SPEAKER_01: But...
- 32:51SPEAKER_01: It also is because it sort of influx what shape it would actually take.
- 32:55SPEAKER_01: It could be pulled in a lot of different directions.
- 32:57SPEAKER_01: I don't want to say in 20 years,
- 32:59SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 32:59SPEAKER_01: we won't look back and say,
- 33:00SPEAKER_01: oh,
- 33:00SPEAKER_01: this was pulled in a bad direction.
- 33:04But you don't want to sort of freeze something in certainty
- 33:07based on political
- 33:08categories that are partially only important for understanding
- 33:11debates on YouTube.
- 33:12SPEAKER_00: Well, I mean, fair enough.
- 33:13SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 33:13SPEAKER_00: I'm only seeing this from a distance,
- 33:15but I looked at the Charlie Kirk Memorial and it strikes me
- 33:19that if there is
- 33:20something resembling a Christian or a religious revival in the
- 33:23United States,
- 33:24SPEAKER_00: it's probably going to look a lot like that and a lot less like the
- 33:28SPEAKER_00: wholesome,
- 33:30SPEAKER_00: family-focused,
- 33:31community-focused Christianity that I think that you would
- 33:34probably espouse.
- 33:35SPEAKER_01: Well, but the Kirk Memorial had its own sort of internal duality, right?
- 33:39Where there was a set of speakers who were there who wanted to
- 33:42recruit Charlie Kirk
- 33:43SPEAKER_01: to a kind of Trumpist nationalist narrative of smiting liberal enemies.
- 33:48SPEAKER_01: And then there was also a narrative,
- 33:50SPEAKER_01: including from Kirk's own wife,
- 33:52SPEAKER_01: Erica,
- 33:53SPEAKER_01: that was about sort of
- 33:55SPEAKER_01: taking Kirk,
- 33:56SPEAKER_01: who had been a political operative for most of his life,
- 34:00SPEAKER_01: and framing him primarily as a father,
- 34:03SPEAKER_01: a role model for young men,
- 34:05SPEAKER_01: and an evangelist for Christianity.
- 34:07SPEAKER_01: And both of those were just mixed up together, right?
- 34:10SPEAKER_00: Or mixed up,
- 34:10or another way of saying it is that Christians wanting to have
- 34:12their cake and eat
- 34:13SPEAKER_00: it too.
- 34:14SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 34:14SPEAKER_01: or Christians who,
- 34:16SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 34:17Christians wanting to be engaged in politics is not necessarily
- 34:20wanting to have
- 34:21SPEAKER_01: their cake and eat it too.
- 34:22SPEAKER_01: But I think you could go speaker by speaker at that event and see,
- 34:26SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 34:27SPEAKER_01: the culmination was Erica Kirk standing up and saying,
- 34:30it's really important as Christians to forgive our enemies and
- 34:33Donald Trump
- 34:34SPEAKER_01: standing up
- 34:36SPEAKER_01: Donald Trump,
- 34:36SPEAKER_01: not a Christian,
- 34:38SPEAKER_01: at least in any sort of practical meaning of the term,
- 34:41SPEAKER_01: standing up and saying,
- 34:41SPEAKER_01: sorry,
- 34:42SPEAKER_01: Erica,
- 34:43SPEAKER_01: but I hate my enemies.
- 34:44SPEAKER_01: So it literally...
- 34:45Lots of self-described Christians talking about being clothed
- 34:48in the armor of God
- 34:49in order to pursue the enemies of Christ as defined as liberals
- 34:52and Democrats.
- 34:55SPEAKER_01: I mean, again, yes, but there's...
- 35:02SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 35:03SPEAKER_01: fundamentally,
- 35:04SPEAKER_01: there's a version of religion and religious language that,
- 35:09SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 35:10SPEAKER_01: is inherently in conflict with not all,
- 35:13SPEAKER_01: but certain forms of secularism and liberalism.
- 35:16And that is sort of a reality that is just sort of,
- 35:23I mean,
- 35:23again,
- 35:27I,
- 35:29how should I put this?
- 35:31I spent a lot of time reading and debating and arguing with
- 35:38people who were sort of
- 35:39SPEAKER_01: in the secular new atheist camp.
- 35:44SPEAKER_01: And,
- 35:44SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 35:45SPEAKER_01: the way that those writers and thinkers,
- 35:47SPEAKER_01: and this does not apply to all liberals or all atheists,
- 35:50but the way that they wrote and thought about religion was
- 35:53itself a kind of battle
- 35:54SPEAKER_01: to the death with the forces of dark medieval reaction and obscurantism,
- 35:59SPEAKER_01: right?
- 35:59SPEAKER_01: And,
- 36:00SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 36:00SPEAKER_01: there's a whole segment of kind of secular culture that watches sort of,
- 36:07SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 36:07pornographic fantasies like The Handmaid's Tale and tells
- 36:11themselves that this is
- 36:11SPEAKER_01: what's going on.
- 36:12They are locked in a battle with the Republic of Gilead that's
- 36:17about to be
- 36:18established tomorrow and ban female literacy and all these
- 36:21things that are not,
- 36:22SPEAKER_01: in fact,
- 36:22SPEAKER_01: going to happen in any plausible way.
- 36:25SPEAKER_01: reality that I inhabit.
- 36:27SPEAKER_01: So I think it shows up on both sides, right?
- 36:30SPEAKER_01: That,
- 36:31SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 36:31and that the narratives of conflict and battle and struggle
- 36:38exist in secular
- 36:39SPEAKER_01: liberal arenas as well as in religious conservative arenas.
- 36:43SPEAKER_01: And people on one side listen to the other side's narratives and say,
- 36:46SPEAKER_01: oh,
- 36:46SPEAKER_01: that's,
- 36:47SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 36:47SPEAKER_01: that's so terrifying.
- 36:48SPEAKER_01: They want to destroy us.
- 36:50SPEAKER_01: They want to kill us.
- 36:51SPEAKER_01: and so on.
- 36:52SPEAKER_01: But they don't hear how their own narratives fall and land.
- 36:56SPEAKER_00: But to be fair,
- 36:57I don't necessarily want to fall into the camp of reflexively
- 37:00defending a Richard
- 37:01SPEAKER_00: Dawkins or a Sam Harris or Hitchens back in the day.
- 37:04SPEAKER_00: But those guys were polemicists writing, you know, rhetorically
- 37:10SPEAKER_00: sexy books about their beliefs.
- 37:12SPEAKER_00: They weren't running US administrations.
- 37:15SPEAKER_00: They weren't influential in terms of actually setting policy.
- 37:19SPEAKER_00: And nor do I recall any of those people, you know...
- 37:22SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 37:22SPEAKER_01: the people who actually set policy,
- 37:26SPEAKER_01: for instance,
- 37:27in the last two liberal democratic administrations in the
- 37:31United States thought
- 37:33that it was extremely important to attempt to sue orders of
- 37:38Catholic nuns into
- 37:40oblivion for failing to cooperate with government mandates in
- 37:44health care.
- 37:45SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 37:45SPEAKER_01: I mean, the.
- 37:46SPEAKER_00: Which government mandates in healthcare?
- 37:49SPEAKER_00: I mean, I'm not familiar with this case.
- 37:50SPEAKER_01: Which government mandates in healthcare?
- 37:53This is the famous case was an order of nuns called the Little
- 37:57Sisters of the Poor
- 37:58that objected to requirements to supply contraceptive and
- 38:04abortifacent and
- 38:05sterilization procedures or to cover them under a particular
- 38:09healthcare plan,
- 38:10SPEAKER_01: which is
- 38:10a very different kind of health care debate than you have in
- 38:13Canada because we
- 38:14SPEAKER_01: don't have single payer and so on.
- 38:15SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 38:16So you get these sort of particular privatized systems that
- 38:19raise issues around
- 38:21SPEAKER_01: religious liberty.
- 38:23SPEAKER_01: But generally, I mean, I think the the people in
- 38:28SPEAKER_01: power in sort of liberal systems and orders are very,
- 38:36very comfortable doing things and taking steps that are fairly
- 38:46radical in their
- 38:48SPEAKER_01: implications and that are not,
- 38:50SPEAKER_01: again,
- 38:51SPEAKER_01: are not framed in the language of the armor of God or anything like that.
- 38:55SPEAKER_01: But, you know, if you had rolled back
- 38:58SPEAKER_01: I mean, since we are in Canada, right?
- 39:00If you had rolled back the clock on debates about euthanasia to
- 39:0825 years ago,
- 39:09and you had described the system of euthanasia that Canada has
- 39:13established in the
- 39:14SPEAKER_01: last five or 10 years,
- 39:15SPEAKER_01: If I had described it as a religious conservative,
- 39:18I would have been accused by my secular and liberal friends of
- 39:22sort of telling
- 39:22fantastic horror stories the way I just accused liberals of
- 39:26using The Handmaid's
- 39:26SPEAKER_01: Tale,
- 39:27SPEAKER_01: right,
- 39:27SPEAKER_01: as a fantastic horror story.
- 39:29SPEAKER_01: And yet,
- 39:29SPEAKER_01: not just in Canada,
- 39:30SPEAKER_01: but all over the Western world,
- 39:33SPEAKER_01: sort of a regime around euthanasia,
- 39:35assisted suicide that even liberals would have been opposed to
- 39:39a generation ago has
- 39:40SPEAKER_01: become very rapidly...
- 39:42normalized right as just sort of a normal part of what a good a
- 39:47good secular
- 39:48liberal is is supposed to support it's not clear to me why
- 39:52religious conservatives
- 39:53looking at that landscape need to step back and say ah you know
- 39:58our you know we're
- 39:59SPEAKER_01: we're fanatics and extremists and our enemies are moderate
- 40:02SPEAKER_01: and reasonable.
- 40:03SPEAKER_01: I think there's plenty of sort of utopian fanaticism.
- 40:06SPEAKER_01: And I mean,
- 40:07SPEAKER_01: honestly,
- 40:08I don't actually think the push for euthanasia flows from
- 40:12utopian fanaticism.
- 40:13SPEAKER_01: I don't want to overstate that.
- 40:14I think it actually flows from an ideology of post-religious
- 40:17despair,
- 40:17which is a bit different.
- 40:19SPEAKER_00: Also,
- 40:19it actually flowed from a lot of people wanting to have more
- 40:23control over their
- 40:24SPEAKER_00: ends in the face of terminal cancer diagnosis.
- 40:27Which is not to say that the criticisms of our current
- 40:29euthanasia regime are ungrounded.
- 40:32SPEAKER_00: There absolutely have been some fairly horrific examples and excesses.
- 40:36But one thing that I do think is worth noting here is that
- 40:39Canada oftentimes for
- 40:40SPEAKER_00: America serves as a kind of cartoonish...
- 40:45SPEAKER_00: example of the best and the worst of secular liberal policies.
- 40:49I go and I listen to Joe Rogan's version of Canada and I get a
- 40:53kind of un-nuanced
- 40:54SPEAKER_00: cartoonish idea of,
- 40:56SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 40:57mass censorship and mass debanking and all of everybody's being
- 41:00oppressed.
- 41:02SPEAKER_01: Only a little debanking.
- 41:03SPEAKER_00: Well, only a tiny little.
- 41:04SPEAKER_00: Well,
- 41:04SPEAKER_00: I'm not defending the debanking either,
- 41:06SPEAKER_00: but neither did people who actually did inquiries into that subject.
- 41:09SPEAKER_01: No, there's a lot.
- 41:10SPEAKER_01: I think it is fair to say
- 41:14SPEAKER_01: that there's a general tendency towards caricature.
- 41:18I'm just offering this because I feel like the narrative of
- 41:22Christian nationalism
- 41:23SPEAKER_01: in America as a set of,
- 41:25SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 41:26SPEAKER_01: a sort of politics of,
- 41:27SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 41:28SPEAKER_01: here's the other thing about Christian nationalism in the U.S.,
- 41:31SPEAKER_01: such as it is.
- 41:32SPEAKER_01: The Trump administration is,
- 41:34SPEAKER_01: all of its sort of primary policy interests have very little to do with
- 41:39with the sort of traditional agenda of religious and social
- 41:43conservatives in the United States.
- 41:45The centerpieces of Trump administration policy making are
- 41:50around immigration,
- 41:51SPEAKER_01: which is an issue where they've ended up in conflict.
- 41:54And not so much with conservative evangelicals,
- 41:58but certainly with the U.S.
- 42:00SPEAKER_01: Catholic bishops and other religious groups.
- 42:02SPEAKER_01: Immigration enforcement is a big issue on the political right.
- 42:04SPEAKER_01: It's not a big issue for religious conservatives.
- 42:07SPEAKER_01: Historically,
- 42:08SPEAKER_01: religious conservatives,
- 42:09SPEAKER_01: big issues are issues like abortion,
- 42:11where the Trump administration has done very little and has
- 42:14basically attempted to
- 42:16SPEAKER_01: avoid
- 42:17doing anything substantially pro-life at a national scale
- 42:20because it doesn't want
- 42:21SPEAKER_01: to touch the issue.
- 42:23SPEAKER_01: Issues around transgenderism and debates related to that,
- 42:28where the Trump administration has done things that religious
- 42:31conservatives
- 42:32SPEAKER_01: support,
- 42:32but that reflect basically a sort of rollback of a very extreme
- 42:39set of policies
- 42:40SPEAKER_01: embraced by the Biden administration.
- 42:42SPEAKER_01: I just think
- 42:43The Trump administration includes within its ranks people like
- 42:48Pete Hegseth,
- 42:49SPEAKER_01: the Secretary of Defense,
- 42:51SPEAKER_01: who are very comfortable with a kind of chest-thumping,
- 42:53SPEAKER_01: rah-rah religious rhetoric about politics.
- 42:56But I think you misunderstand Trumpism if you see it as
- 43:02primarily driven by
- 43:06specific religious conservative concerns taking over the
- 43:10policy-making apparatus.
- 43:12SPEAKER_01: I don't think that's what's happening really at all.
- 43:14My read on the Trump administration is that the religious
- 43:16conservatives and
- 43:17SPEAKER_00: Christian nationalists are a faction of power within a wider coalition.
- 43:22SPEAKER_00: Right,
- 43:23SPEAKER_00: but if you roll back...
- 43:24SPEAKER_00: You could also just roll back Roe versus Wade,
- 43:26SPEAKER_00: largely in the result of Trump administration judicial appointees,
- 43:32SPEAKER_00: thanks to a lot of that.
- 43:35I don't think that a lot of these factions are without power or
- 43:39influence either.
- 43:41SPEAKER_01: No, I wouldn't say that they're without power or influence.
- 43:44SPEAKER_01: But if you said, do religious conservatives...
- 43:49SPEAKER_01: The conservative victory in Roe v.
- 43:52Wade was something that was built up sort of generationally
- 43:55over decades and
- 43:56SPEAKER_01: decades of argument and judicial appointments and so on.
- 43:59And as soon as it happened,
- 44:01the national leaders of the Republican Party ran away from
- 44:07SPEAKER_01: any kind of implications for national policy very quickly.
- 44:10So that should tell you something about the relative power of
- 44:13different groups.
- 44:14SPEAKER_01: Also,
- 44:15SPEAKER_01: if you go back to George W.
- 44:18SPEAKER_01: Bush administration,
- 44:20SPEAKER_01: the period when we were- The beautiful era.
- 44:22SPEAKER_00: The beautiful days of the cowboy.
- 44:25George W.
- 44:25Bush talked about religion in public way more than Donald
- 44:28Trump.
- 44:29His administration on multiple levels was more informed,
- 44:33I think,
- 44:34by a very specifically
- 44:36evangelical religious perspective on the world than the Trump
- 44:40administration is.
- 44:41And if you if you took these polls of like who is a Christian
- 44:45nationalist,
- 44:45it's no question that more Americans were technically were
- 44:49Christian nationalists
- 44:51SPEAKER_01: as technically defined in 2003 than are in 2025.
- 44:56SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 44:57We have,
- 44:57in fact,
- 44:58we have to go back to where I started,
- 45:00we have lived through a
- 45:02SPEAKER_01: a period of sustained secularization in the United States.
- 45:06The country is less religious now than it was a generation ago
- 45:10in that environment.
- 45:12SPEAKER_01: as people look around and say,
- 45:14SPEAKER_01: hmm,
- 45:14SPEAKER_01: maybe we miss religion,
- 45:15SPEAKER_01: maybe we need it after all,
- 45:16SPEAKER_01: there's a lot of forces out there,
- 45:18SPEAKER_01: Christian nationalism,
- 45:19SPEAKER_01: one of them,
- 45:20that are sort of contending for influence that are in different
- 45:23ways maybe weirder
- 45:24SPEAKER_01: and wackier and more extreme than the normie Christianity of 1999.
- 45:30SPEAKER_01: But that's why the moment is interesting, right?
- 45:33SPEAKER_01: And there are forces also that,
- 45:34SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 45:36one thing worth stressing too about this moment is it's not a
- 45:39binary between
- 45:40SPEAKER_01: Christianity and secularism.
- 45:42There's a way in which the culture right now is in a kind of
- 45:451970s zone where
- 45:47SPEAKER_01: there's lots of people who can't get all the way to a belief in
- 45:51you know,
- 45:51a father God who's way up there who made the whole universe,
- 45:54right?
- 45:55SPEAKER_01: But who can get all,
- 45:57SPEAKER_01: who are interested in like spiritual powers that might,
- 46:00SPEAKER_01: intermediate powers that might be out there,
- 46:02SPEAKER_01: right?
- 46:02SPEAKER_01: So you get interest in witchcraft and neo-paganism,
- 46:06SPEAKER_01: you get interest in UFOs,
- 46:08SPEAKER_01: you get interest in psychedelic mediated spiritual experiences.
- 46:13SPEAKER_01: And then the AI stuff has a religious edge and element too, right?
- 46:18SPEAKER_01: They talk about,
- 46:19SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 46:20SPEAKER_01: are we inventing consciousness in a laboratory somewhere,
- 46:23SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 46:23SPEAKER_01: somewhere in Northern California?
- 46:25SPEAKER_01: So that's also part of what makes this moment striking.
- 46:30SPEAKER_01: But also why I wanna sort of push against
- 46:34SPEAKER_01: too much of a narrative that says,
- 46:36SPEAKER_01: well,
- 46:37religion means Christian nationalism and so you have Christian
- 46:40nationalism here or
- 46:41SPEAKER_01: secular liberalism over there.
- 46:42So much politics sort of flattens realities that in terms of
- 46:49people's actual
- 46:49SPEAKER_01: beliefs are more complex and interesting and dangerous too,
- 46:54SPEAKER_01: right?
- 46:54I think that that is definitely something that when I talk to
- 46:57people who are more
- 46:58SPEAKER_00: secular,
- 46:58that there's a mistake that if you say you're religious or
- 47:01you're Christian,
- 47:01SPEAKER_00: they put thought you into a belief that,
- 47:03SPEAKER_00: oh,
- 47:03SPEAKER_00: therefore you must be a conservative nationalist,
- 47:05SPEAKER_00: blah,
- 47:06SPEAKER_00: blah,
- 47:06SPEAKER_00: blah,
- 47:06SPEAKER_00: blah,
- 47:06SPEAKER_00: blah.
- 47:06SPEAKER_00: And that's just not true.
- 47:08SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 47:09SPEAKER_01: I mean, it's more... It is true that...
- 47:12Most,
- 47:12you know,
- 47:13there's more conservative people are religious right now than
- 47:18liberal people.
- 47:19SPEAKER_01: But these all stand.
- 47:19These things also cut across lines of ethnicity and class and
- 47:24really interested,
- 47:24like the Democratic Party in the United States has a lot of
- 47:27very religious members.
- 47:28SPEAKER_01: They're just African-American and Hispanic.
- 47:31SPEAKER_01: Democratic Party is the party of very secular white people.
- 47:35SPEAKER_01: and more religious minorities.
- 47:38SPEAKER_01: And then Canada is,
- 47:42SPEAKER_01: because your patterns of immigration are different from ours,
- 47:45SPEAKER_01: non-Western religions,
- 47:47SPEAKER_01: Islam,
- 47:48but also actual non-Abrahamic religions are likely to play a
- 47:52much bigger role in
- 47:53SPEAKER_01: Canadian
- 47:55SPEAKER_01: in the next 30 or 40 years than is the case in the U.S.
- 47:59SPEAKER_00: Interestingly,
- 47:59Cardes recently did a study and found that the religious sort
- 48:02of breakdown of
- 48:03conservatives in Canada more or less matches the religious
- 48:05breakdown of Democrats
- 48:06SPEAKER_00: in the United States.
- 48:08SPEAKER_01: Well, that's, yeah.
- 48:09SPEAKER_00: Just kind of...
- 48:10I want to quickly talk about tradcasts because I think this is
- 48:15a really interesting
- 48:15SPEAKER_00: phenomenon is that I keep on reading about a lot of conversion,
- 48:19SPEAKER_00: not just to evangelical Christianity in the United States,
- 48:22but there's also seemingly a growth of conversion to
- 48:26traditional Catholicism in the
- 48:28SPEAKER_00: United States.
- 48:28SPEAKER_00: There's a movement, particularly among young people.
- 48:30SPEAKER_00: You're a well-known Catholic writer at the New York Times.
- 48:35SPEAKER_00: What I find really fascinating, I was raised Catholic myself.
- 48:38What I find really fascinating about a lot of the growth of
- 48:42traditional Catholics,
- 48:42SPEAKER_00: particularly from the conservative side,
- 48:44is they seem to be increasingly at odds with some of the
- 48:48traditional teachings of
- 48:48SPEAKER_00: the Catholic Church around social welfare and immigration,
- 48:52SPEAKER_00: for example.
- 48:53SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 48:53one thing that I find deeply hilarious now is when I go onto
- 48:55Twitter and click on
- 48:56SPEAKER_00: Pope Leo,
- 48:57SPEAKER_00: there's now a giant collection of reply guys who are,
- 49:01SPEAKER_00: you can just tell,
- 49:02SPEAKER_00: recently converted Catholics.
- 49:04SPEAKER_00: who disagree with his positions.
- 49:06SPEAKER_01: Or are converted to...
- 49:10SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 49:11SPEAKER_01: the challenge with reply guys,
- 49:12SPEAKER_01: right,
- 49:13SPEAKER_01: is knowing,
- 49:14SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 49:15SPEAKER_01: are these guys actual converts to Catholicism?
- 49:17SPEAKER_01: Are they playing it on the internet?
- 49:20But even if they're just playing it on the internet,
- 49:21it's an interesting phenomena,
- 49:23right?
- 49:23SPEAKER_00: I mean, I sort of see J.D.
- 49:24Vance as falling into the recent convert reply guy TradCath
- 49:29category,
- 49:30right?
- 49:30SPEAKER_00: It's a different... There's a weird sort of internal...
- 49:33movement in Catholicism right now,
- 49:36at least as far as I can see from where I am.
- 49:38SPEAKER_00: And I'm wondering if you can speak a little bit to that tension between
- 49:42SPEAKER_00: conventional or traditional Catholicism and the teachings of the church,
- 49:45SPEAKER_00: which increasingly seem to be coming up at odds with MAGA-ism,
- 49:49SPEAKER_00: the Trump administration,
- 49:50SPEAKER_00: particularly on issues of refugees,
- 49:53SPEAKER_00: immigration,
- 49:54SPEAKER_00: social welfare.
- 49:54SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I think there is a sort of sustained tension that is sharp
- 50:02SPEAKER_01: right now with Trump,
- 50:04SPEAKER_01: but exists in a substantial way in Western Europe,
- 50:08SPEAKER_01: all of Europe for a while now,
- 50:10between what conservative Catholics think about immigration and
- 50:18what the sort of
- 50:20SPEAKER_01: bishops and the Pope tend to say about immigration.
- 50:27SPEAKER_01: But that also reflects this kind of, it's not just a matter of
- 50:32People who are politically conservative and Catholic are
- 50:36putting their politics
- 50:37SPEAKER_01: before their faith.
- 50:39SPEAKER_01: There's also generational issues where
- 50:42the people in the Catholic Church is a gerontocracy in the
- 50:45sense that quite
- 50:48SPEAKER_01: literally archbishops and cardinals and the Pope tend to be quite,
- 50:53SPEAKER_01: quite old.
- 50:53SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 50:54SPEAKER_01: And there is a,
- 50:56SPEAKER_01: I think,
- 50:56a generational difference in views about immigration that shows
- 51:02up in the Catholic
- 51:03SPEAKER_01: Church,
- 51:03SPEAKER_01: too.
- 51:04SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 51:04SPEAKER_01: Where there's yeah, there's sort of an older generation of
- 51:10sort of you could call them liberal universalist optimists and
- 51:16a younger generation
- 51:18that sees sort of mass immigration as this kind of incredibly
- 51:23destabilizing force.
- 51:25SPEAKER_01: And in Catholic terms, what the tension then becomes
- 51:29SPEAKER_01: Again,
- 51:29I think it's historically been sharper in Europe than in the US
- 51:34because in the US
- 51:35SPEAKER_01: for a long time,
- 51:37SPEAKER_01: most immigrants were coming from Catholic countries,
- 51:39SPEAKER_01: right?
- 51:39SPEAKER_01: Whereas in Western Europe, this was not the case.
- 51:42SPEAKER_01: Western Europe,
- 51:43you have a dynamic of a Christian teaching about the need to
- 51:51welcome the stranger
- 51:52SPEAKER_01: and welcome the refugee.
- 51:54SPEAKER_01: being understood by a lot of Catholics as being used to basically sort of
- 52:00SPEAKER_01: Islamicize Western Europe.
- 52:02That's the tension in the mind of the Western European
- 52:05Catholic,
- 52:06conservative especially,
- 52:07right?
- 52:07SPEAKER_01: That yes, you have this religious obligation to treat migrants well.
- 52:14But if the effect of mass immigration policy is to take
- 52:18formerly Catholic countries
- 52:20SPEAKER_01: and make them increasingly non-Catholic,
- 52:23SPEAKER_01: then
- 52:25SPEAKER_01: Isn't there some tension there?
- 52:26SPEAKER_01: I guess that's what a lot of people in Europe would say.
- 52:32SPEAKER_01: And the church is effectively trying to navigate those tensions.
- 52:36SPEAKER_01: But I think in the U.S., you know, I think the...
- 52:46There's also the weirdness of the Biden administration had a
- 52:49particular immigration
- 52:51policy that was entered into somewhat accidentally that became
- 52:54a kind of total open
- 52:56SPEAKER_01: door to mass migration for about three years.
- 52:59SPEAKER_01: It was tremendously unpopular.
- 53:02And the Trump administration was elected in part with a pretty
- 53:05clear mandate to do
- 53:07SPEAKER_01: something about that.
- 53:08And there was sort of an initial popularity to the Trump
- 53:12administration's measures.
- 53:13And now we're a year in and we've moved from securing the
- 53:15border to actually trying
- 53:16SPEAKER_01: to do mass deportations.
- 53:18SPEAKER_01: And in practice,
- 53:19there's just a lot of people who are for a secure border and
- 53:23don't like what you
- 53:24SPEAKER_01: have to do to do mass deportations.
- 53:26And that's not a religious question exactly,
- 53:30but that's sort of the politics of the thing.
- 53:35You have to understand these things in terms of what did the
- 53:39previous administration do?
- 53:42SPEAKER_01: The public is always conflicted on immigration.
- 53:45SPEAKER_01: There's always a sense of like,
- 53:47SPEAKER_01: well,
- 53:47SPEAKER_01: immigration is good and we should be welcoming,
- 53:49SPEAKER_01: but if you do it too fast,
- 53:51SPEAKER_01: it turns into chaos.
- 53:52SPEAKER_01: And so you had what felt like chaos that led to support for restriction,
- 53:57SPEAKER_01: but now at a certain point,
- 53:58SPEAKER_01: restriction comes to seem cruel and then the pendulum swings back.
- 54:01SPEAKER_01: I'm taking us away from religion.
- 54:02SPEAKER_01: Let me pull back to religion.
- 54:04SPEAKER_01: With traditional Catholicism, I think,
- 54:10SPEAKER_01: you have a pattern that's, that affects Catholicism.
- 54:16SPEAKER_01: It affects conversions to Eastern Orthodoxy,
- 54:19SPEAKER_01: which a colleague of mine at the times just wrote a story about.
- 54:22SPEAKER_01: Um, but among, especially I think highly educated,
- 54:29SPEAKER_01: highly educated Americans,
- 54:31SPEAKER_01: but it's true in other Western countries too,
- 54:34there's a really strong appetite right now for what seem like
- 54:39demanding liturgical
- 54:40SPEAKER_01: forms of religious faith.
- 54:43SPEAKER_01: But
- 54:45it's not clear how big that demand is and how far it extends
- 54:49outside a kind of
- 54:51SPEAKER_01: self-conscious would-be elites.
- 54:54SPEAKER_01: So it seems like there's a weird inversion with Catholicism in the U.S.
- 55:00SPEAKER_01: where historically Catholicism was the mass religion,
- 55:05SPEAKER_01: the religion of the working class,
- 55:06SPEAKER_01: working class immigrants,
- 55:07SPEAKER_01: and then the elites were all Protestant.
- 55:10SPEAKER_01: But if you look at certainly in conservative politics right now.
- 55:13SPEAKER_00: My husband really misses that era.
- 55:14SPEAKER_01: Yeah, so now, I mean, Charlie Kirk was sort of an outlier.
- 55:24Many of the leaders,
- 55:26many of sort of the conservative elites in America are
- 55:29Catholics.
- 55:30SPEAKER_01: Some are cradle Catholics, many are converts to Catholicism.
- 55:34Catholicism is stronger in elite America in certain ways than
- 55:37it's ever been before.
- 55:39SPEAKER_01: But the church as a whole in the U.S.
- 55:41is still losing members,
- 55:44is losing members to Pentecostalists and evangelicals.
- 55:47SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 55:48SPEAKER_01: And it's becoming weaker as a mass religion,
- 55:51SPEAKER_01: even as it becomes more influential as an elite religion.
- 55:54And it used to be that in America you would have a pattern
- 55:57where someone would be raised
- 55:59SPEAKER_01: raised Southern Baptist or non-denominational or Pentecostalist,
- 56:04and they would go to college and they would sort of make a kind
- 56:06of almost like
- 56:07SPEAKER_01: class-based conversion to Presbyterianism or Episcopalianism,
- 56:12SPEAKER_00: right?
- 56:12SPEAKER_01: That that was sort of the hierarchy.
- 56:14And now you get very,
- 56:16very few conversions to mainline or high church Protestantism.
- 56:21SPEAKER_01: Those traditions,
- 56:23SPEAKER_01: if you're like on a college campus or something,
- 56:25SPEAKER_01: those often feel sort of liberalized to the point of irrelevance.
- 56:31And so there's a stereotype of like the young evangelical who
- 56:34goes to an Ivy League
- 56:35SPEAKER_01: school and becomes a trad calf.
- 56:38That's like a that's and it's not that's a that's a real
- 56:41pattern and but it is a
- 56:46SPEAKER_01: pattern that is concentrated in
- 56:50elite professional class circles and is not what you would find
- 56:53in the suburbs of
- 56:56SPEAKER_01: Iowa or something like that.
- 56:57There is no mass stampede of people out of non-denominational
- 57:01churches into
- 57:02Catholicism or Eastern Orthodoxy in Oklahoma or Iowa or any of
- 57:07these places.
- 57:08SPEAKER_01: If anything, the trend is still somewhat the reverse.
- 57:11SPEAKER_00: It's an interesting question because it makes me wonder,
- 57:13SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 57:14SPEAKER_00: do people who operate in elite circles of society,
- 57:17SPEAKER_00: people who operate in highly intellectual fields,
- 57:21SPEAKER_00: are their religious needs fundamentally different than somebody who is,
- 57:25SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 57:26having a perfectly happy family life in Iowa or Idaho or
- 57:29someplace like that?
- 57:30SPEAKER_01: I think that there's a need.
- 57:31SPEAKER_01: There's both of what you would call...
- 57:35well,
- 57:35we'll just call it like good and bad needs that people feel in
- 57:39those circles.
- 57:39SPEAKER_01: I think there's a good need which is for,
- 57:43SPEAKER_01: robust intellectual grounding for your faith,
- 57:46where you feel like you can defend it and take it seriously
- 57:49when you're surrounded
- 57:50SPEAKER_01: by secular people who wear the atheist hat and think it's all nonsense,
- 57:55SPEAKER_01: right?
- 57:56SPEAKER_01: And the old liturgical religious traditions often just have more of that
- 58:02SPEAKER_01: philosophical ground,
- 58:03SPEAKER_01: like Roman Catholicism,
- 58:04SPEAKER_01: whatever else it has going for it,
- 58:06SPEAKER_01: It's got a lot of philosophers.
- 58:08It's got a lot of philosophers in its back pocket in the way
- 58:11that your evangelical
- 58:13SPEAKER_01: megachurch probably does not.
- 58:15SPEAKER_01: So that's a positive attraction.
- 58:18SPEAKER_01: There's also, though, yeah, probably a certain kind of
- 58:23SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 58:23SPEAKER_01: sort of snobbery,
- 58:25SPEAKER_01: right,
- 58:25SPEAKER_01: that you get at the elite level where it's like Catholicism is,
- 58:29SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 58:30ancient and serious and has pretty architecture and the
- 58:33megachurch seems a little
- 58:34SPEAKER_01: embarrassing.
- 58:35SPEAKER_01: And so it's,
- 58:35SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 58:36SPEAKER_01: again,
- 58:36it's similar to why someone who was a Baptist in 1930 would
- 58:40become an Episcopalian
- 58:41SPEAKER_01: when they went to Harvard or something,
- 58:43SPEAKER_01: right?
- 58:43SPEAKER_01: So both those kind of things are in play.
- 58:49SPEAKER_00: Catholics have much better churches, just architectural art.
- 58:52SPEAKER_00: Well, not everywhere.
- 58:53SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 58:53SPEAKER_01: not,
- 58:54SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 58:54SPEAKER_01: the post-Vatican II churches,
- 58:55SPEAKER_01: and I'm sure Canada,
- 58:58there are a lot of suburban churches built in North America in
- 59:03the 1970s that I do
- 59:04not think are an advertisement for the riches and depth of the
- 59:07Catholic tradition.
- 59:09SPEAKER_01: But...
- 59:11SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 59:12SPEAKER_01: Apart from that unfortunate,
- 59:14the great unfortunate period in Catholic architecture is better
- 59:19than megachurch
- 59:20SPEAKER_01: architecture.
- 59:20SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 59:21SPEAKER_00: I'm saying even post-Vatican two churches don't look like malls.
- 59:24SPEAKER_00: I'm just saying.
- 59:25SPEAKER_01: There's some that look like, you know, suburban gymnasiums and dungeons.
- 59:29SPEAKER_01: But yes, generally, I don't know.
- 59:33SPEAKER_01: But you also have to give, there is clearly a way in which
- 59:38SPEAKER_01: people in elite circles,
- 59:40intellectual circles and professional circles can underestimate
- 59:44the resilience and
- 59:46SPEAKER_01: adaptability of sort of the suburban megachurch,
- 59:50SPEAKER_01: right?
- 59:50SPEAKER_01: Like one reason,
- 59:53one thing I think that you saw a bit of at the Charlie Kirk
- 59:56Memorial too was,
- 59:58SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 59:59SPEAKER_01: Evangelical Christianity, it just exists outside the elite.
- 1:00:04SPEAKER_01: It's always been disdained by the elite.
- 1:00:07SPEAKER_01: And there's always this expectation in the elite that it will sort of,
- 1:00:11SPEAKER_01: either it will take over in some terrifying Handmaid's Tale style way,
- 1:00:15or it will just retreat back into backwoods revivalism and sort
- 1:00:20of disappear as a
- 1:00:22SPEAKER_01: cultural force.
- 1:00:22SPEAKER_01: And in a way, what you saw at the Charlie Kirk
- 1:00:25SPEAKER_01: Memorial was people saying like, no, we're we're still here.
- 1:00:28We are not that evangelicalism is booming,
- 1:00:31but it is a profoundly resilient part.
- 1:00:35SPEAKER_01: It's the most resilient part of Christianity in an age of secularization.
- 1:00:40SPEAKER_01: And those of us who are not part of it,
- 1:00:41SPEAKER_01: who are going to liturgical churches with smells and bells and ancient
- 1:00:46SPEAKER_01: philosophical traditions,
- 1:00:47we have to give some credit to the suburban megachurch for
- 1:00:51being a resilient source
- 1:00:54SPEAKER_01: of
- 1:00:55SPEAKER_01: serious religious practice in a more secularized age.
- 1:01:00And also a place that is not just sort of a font of political
- 1:01:04partisanship,
- 1:01:05but is in fact a zone of religious community and social
- 1:01:10outreach and all of those
- 1:01:11SPEAKER_01: things.
- 1:01:11SPEAKER_01: Like,
- 1:01:12SPEAKER_01: again,
- 1:01:12the average suburban non-denominational church in America is
- 1:01:17not especially
- 1:01:18SPEAKER_01: political,
- 1:01:18SPEAKER_01: right?
- 1:01:19It's not what you would think from,
- 1:01:21like,
- 1:01:22the guys who call themselves Christian nationalists,
- 1:01:25SPEAKER_01: Like I would just urge any viewers,
- 1:01:27SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 1:01:28SPEAKER_01: if you go,
- 1:01:30SPEAKER_01: there's two kinds of Christian nationalism,
- 1:01:32SPEAKER_01: right?
- 1:01:32SPEAKER_01: There's sort of a traditional kind,
- 1:01:34SPEAKER_01: which is a megachurch pastor who's got the American flag behind him and,
- 1:01:39SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 1:01:39SPEAKER_01: has a kind of narrative of how God loves the USA.
- 1:01:42probably really strongly supports israel for you know sort of a
- 1:01:46mix of theological
- 1:01:47and political reasons right that's real that's a that's like a
- 1:01:51big been a big part
- 1:01:51of american life for my entire lifetime then there's also the
- 1:01:55sort of podcast bro
- 1:01:57right who's got a beard much bigger than mine who's here to
- 1:01:59tell you about why
- 1:02:00SPEAKER_01: women shouldn't vote and you know like
- 1:02:04That is interesting and important in a context where everything
- 1:02:09is up for grabs,
- 1:02:10but like is not the defining reality of religious faith in the
- 1:02:16American heartland
- 1:02:17SPEAKER_01: or anywhere else.
- 1:02:19SPEAKER_00: Well, I hope that that's true.
- 1:02:21SPEAKER_00: That's true.
- 1:02:21It continues to be so as a woman who likes to vote,
- 1:02:25but is nonetheless not an American.
- 1:02:26SPEAKER_00: Yeah,
- 1:02:26SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 1:02:26SPEAKER_01: if you,
- 1:02:27SPEAKER_01: like,
- 1:02:27SPEAKER_01: there's evangelical Christianity in the United States is filled with,
- 1:02:34SPEAKER_01: like,
- 1:02:34SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 1:02:35SPEAKER_01: dad...
- 1:02:36SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 1:02:37SPEAKER_01: it's just suburban.
- 1:02:37SPEAKER_01: It's like suburban America.
- 1:02:39SPEAKER_01: It's dads who are really into girls' basketball.
- 1:02:41SPEAKER_01: It's like, it's... You shouldn't let the...
- 1:02:47Dads are into girls basketball and who would never dream of
- 1:02:50repealing the 19th
- 1:02:52SPEAKER_01: amendment,
- 1:02:52SPEAKER_01: let's put it that way.
- 1:02:54SPEAKER_01: And maybe that will change.
- 1:02:55SPEAKER_01: And again,
- 1:02:56SPEAKER_01: I think it is a,
- 1:02:57it's a moment of deep instability all over and religious
- 1:03:02instability is part of
- 1:03:03SPEAKER_01: that.
- 1:03:05But you wanna recognize how much of even religious culture in
- 1:03:10America and Canada is
- 1:03:12SPEAKER_01: still pretty normy and normal.
- 1:03:15SPEAKER_00: God, let's keep it that way.
- 1:03:17Ross Staudet,
- 1:03:17thank you so much for taking some time to chat with me on the
- 1:03:20line.
- 1:03:20SPEAKER_01: You're very welcome.
- 1:03:20SPEAKER_01: I feel like we covered all of the most fraught issues in North America.
- 1:03:25SPEAKER_00: We solved it all.
- 1:03:26SPEAKER_01: In this wonderful Continental Union of ours.
- 1:03:29SPEAKER_00: Wonderful.
- 1:03:29SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 1:03:30SPEAKER_00: Well, thank you so much for your time.
- 1:03:30SPEAKER_00: You're very welcome.
- 1:03:31SPEAKER_00: Cheers.