Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Neo Nazis - (Chapter 4 - The Great Replacement)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. This is chapter four in our Deep dive on Neo
- 0:05Nazis. My name is doctor Kirk Honda. I'm a therapist and a professor.
- 0:09Who are you, Berta. My name is Umberto Castagne, and I
- 0:11design the little toothpicks that you find in restaurants. So I thought we would
- 0:16start the introduction to chapter four with discussing the Buffalo shooting that happened last year
- 0:24in twenty twenty two. We're recording this in the end of twenty twenty three.
- 0:28As always trigger warning because it doesn't go into graphic detail, and we're
- 0:32not going to describe it in graphic detail. But it's a very, very
- 0:35tough subject. I have learned the limits for myself when I was doing the
- 0:39deep dive, that there's only so much of this that I can cram it
- 0:42in my head at one time, So take care of yourself. So in
- 0:46twenty twenty two, there was a shooting at a supermarket in Buffalo and ten
- 0:52people, all of whom were black, were murdered and three were injured.
- 0:57The shooter was eighteen years old, white male. I won't mention his name
- 1:02because that's often why they do this sort of thing. He live streamed the
- 1:04attack on Twitch for a number of minutes before Twitch figured it out and took
- 1:10it down. His manifesto talked about ethnonationalism, white supremacy, and the great
- 1:15replacement, conspiracy theory, and white genocide, which we'll get into shortly afterwards.
- 1:22New York banned most semi automatic sales to people under twenty one and certain
- 1:26types of body armor. Woohoo. Definitely should do that. That's the minimum.
- 1:34Yeah, it's like most semi automatic sales are banned to people under twenty
- 1:41one and just certain types of body armor. So all right, And the
- 1:47shooter was sentenced to eleven consecutive life sentences without the possibility of parole. And
- 1:53the reason why we're talking about it is because there's strong evidence that the shooter
- 1:57was radicalized by online neo Nazi rhetoric. So let's watch a news clip on
- 2:06Vice. But what's often been missing from the discussion around this shooting is how
- 2:09it neatly fits into a pattern of white supremacist terror attacks directly inspired by the
- 2:15christ Church mosque massacres of twenty nineteen. This is how racist conspiracy theory and
- 2:22emerging tech platforms have combined to create the template for a chilling new form of
- 2:28gamified live streams far right terror. Yeah. So with out going into detail,
- 2:34and we might not have time to, there's a chilling trend of copycat
- 2:39shooters who will either target black people or Jewish people. And what he's talking
- 2:46about is the shooting in Buffalo. The eighteen year old white male who shot
- 2:52a bunch of black people in Buffalo, New York was seemingly following in the
- 2:57footsteps directly from shootings that were similar. And this morning we're getting an exclusive
- 3:02look at the moment the shooter was arrested and the warning signs that were missed.
- 3:07Investigators are going to be pouring through multiple online posts that this alleged shooter
- 3:12made before his attack. The Buffalo shooter released the manifesto on Discord, largely
- 3:16centered around the conspiracy theory known as the Great Replacement. So we'll watch more
- 3:23of this, but there seems to be a trend that Discord is where neo
- 3:25Nazis get together. Did you know that. Let me put it this way,
- 3:29it's where a lot of communities get together, and also a lot of
- 3:31video game communities. And there's a lot of video games that you know,
- 3:36young people play that those young people might then become radicalized and continue being on
- 3:39Discord. Yeah, and it's a good place to find those young young people
- 3:44that are right. Yeah, it just seems like it's a gamer place and
- 3:46of course other community. We used to have a Discord server ourselves. I
- 3:51don't know, it's just kind of interesting. In other words, it's not
- 3:53like there's there's three main Discord like services and we're wondering why are they choosing
- 3:59Discord. It's more like Discord is the service you would use for this for
- 4:03a group and a community. Yeah. Well there's a Slack which is very
- 4:09similar, but Slack is more used by teams working together. I mean,
- 4:13yeah, that's I think Discord grew in the idea of like, hey,
- 4:16create your community. Okay, So in create a community, it just happens
- 4:20to be a racist, white nationalist community. In May twenty twenty two,
- 4:25a domestic terrorist murdered ten black people at a supermarket in Buffalo, New York.
- 4:30The alleged shooter wearing full body armor and tactical gear. Targeting people of
- 4:34color. This is an absolute racist hate crime. They're reviewing a one hundred
- 4:41and eighty page manifesto reportedly written by the shooter, where he describes his perceptions
- 4:46about the dwindling size of the white population. The attack was followed by the
- 4:49depressingly familiar rounds of platitudes about thoughts and prayers, as well as the usual
- 4:55series of arguments and evasions around gun control in America. Yeah, it's it
- 5:00is so tragic that you would have access to military grade equipment so easily that
- 5:08you can go and you know, because the fact is three hundred and fifty
- 5:13million people, there's going to be people that lose their marbles and that want
- 5:16to go and kill or kill themselves or do harm. Absolutely, it's going
- 5:20to happen. If it's not white power, it's something else. And to
- 5:24be clear, by lose your marbles, you're including people who are indoctrinated into
- 5:28a discord cult of racism. You're not talking about mental health. Well,
- 5:31I'm definitely including mental health, like of course, yeah, but like typically
- 5:35the shooters are not suffering from a mental health condition that would cause the shooting
- 5:42of youth. You don't have disagreed about this in the past, Like I
- 5:44don't. I'm not saying they've been diagnosed or would be diagnosed. I'm just
- 5:46saying, you have a curve, purrito curve. People land in like the
- 5:50normal side, and day to day they don't go out and shoot people.
- 5:53Some people fall off that curve, whatever you want to call that. That
- 5:57happened to that person, And I'm saying that's going to happen, and in
- 6:00a big society, okay, but when it happens, and the thing that
- 6:03you can do is I mean, heck, grab a car, which is
- 6:06horrific enough, you're still there's still some natural limits to what you can do,
- 6:13or grab a knife and things like that. When you can grab full
- 6:15body armor and a weapon of mass killing and walk anywhere, it's just the
- 6:20casualties and the hurt is going to be exponentially greater. Yeah, yeah,
- 6:26yeah, absolutely. And you know the reason why I push back on words
- 6:31like I can't remember what you said, lose their marbles is because there's a
- 6:36right wing rhetoric talking point that, well, yeah, in any population,
- 6:41you're going to have some crazy people, people suffering from schizophrenia, delusions in
- 6:45this sort of thing. And yeah, occasionally individuals with schizophrenia or psychosis will
- 6:51commit a crime like this, but the vast majority of people who murder people
- 6:57and even mass shootings are not suffering from those those those disorders, and even
- 7:00if they were, that wasn't the cause necessarily, because when you look at
- 7:03statistics, the vast, vast majority of people who suffer from psychosis what we
- 7:10would call, you know, losing one's marbles or going crazy or whatever,
- 7:15then we see that there's one barely an increase in risk of that kind of
- 7:20behavior or cheminal behavior in general. But also when we have resources for those
- 7:27individuals that help them, that are humane and available and suited to the individual,
- 7:33then that signal goes away, meaning that the frustration of untreated disorders and
- 7:41the ostracization and your life going down the tubes, losing your job, losing
- 7:45your support system, losing your house can result in some people becoming desperate to
- 7:49take actions of crime or just so in despair that they've given up hope.
- 7:55And so we definitely want to disassociate these kinds of crimes with going crazy or
- 8:03with a mental disorder. The vast majority of people commit these crimes, it's
- 8:07not because they have some sort of mental condition that we have available to us
- 8:11in the DSM. You yourself can label them as there's something different about them,
- 8:16I suppose, but there's not science to back that up. Well,
- 8:20let me flip the script, though, because if our belief is that which
- 8:24is I know is not what you're saying. If our belief was that,
- 8:26like, look, there's really nothing we can do to help these people ahead
- 8:30of time, then we would be in a really worse situation. Whereas I
- 8:33believe, and I think you believe that absolutely early intervention with these individuals could
- 8:39help them and whatever that intervention is meant to do. Whatever label you want
- 8:43to give to the thing that was in their head, because it was in
- 8:46their head that the intervention could help, let's call that candy apple. They
- 8:50had candy apple. Yeah, so I'm hoping that so anyway, So my
- 8:56point was simply that there are folk with candy apple, and when you can
- 9:00identified early and maybe intervene, maybe you can help them. But if you
- 9:03can't and they have access to mass destruction weapons, then it's going to be
- 9:05worse forever. Well, the phrase I would put to it is that these
- 9:09individuals are suicidal and angry. Those are words we have available to us,
- 9:15and they often are suicidal and angry or and or very angry. You know,
- 9:20meaning just angry, not suicidal necessarily. I think that's what a lot
- 9:24of lay people, like myself, they'll consider mental health. It doesn't mean
- 9:28that they're diagnosed as this that. On the other thing, it just means
- 9:30that they have they need some help in the mental health department. Well,
- 9:33we all do, and so that's the thing, Like we all need mental
- 9:37health help. But we're not all about to go murder fifty people. Yeah,
- 9:41but we all have issues that would benefit by talking with a professional,
- 9:45and we all have issues that would benefit from more self awareness and emotional regulation.
- 9:48So to categorize these people as having some mental condition or candy apple or
- 9:56something, I think is philosophically dubious. It might be true, we don't
- 10:00have the technology to measure such things at this point, and there's some science
- 10:03that points in some directions. But I could give you the whole world rundown.
- 10:07But generally speaking, the consensus is that there's nothing that we can say
- 10:11about the profile or someone that does this that demonstrates they have some different mental
- 10:16condition or some different mental structure or But we can point to things like indoctrination,
- 10:22like despair, like trauma. These things we can point to that cause
- 10:28a lot of problems, including these problems you know, right, but there's
- 10:33a vast population that are being indoctrinated. I mean not maybe not in the
- 10:37millions, but it's certainly one hundred thousand probably like and they don't all go
- 10:41and do these things, right, So there's some additional factors there. Yeah,
- 10:45And there's also some randomness to it that when you have, say in
- 10:50Buffalo or near Buffalo, you have let's say a thousand people that fit the
- 10:56profile where they're in despair, they've been traumatized, they're isolated, that's often
- 11:01the case. They've been completely indoctrinated for whatever reason. Maybe they had some
- 11:05racist parents, or they had a bad experience. And we'll get into more
- 11:09of this than another chapter about what factors lead to neo Nazism and extreme behavior
- 11:15like this. But let's say you had like a thousand individuals near this supermarket
- 11:20who were thinking about doing something like this, and what's the difference, you
- 11:26know, and even that that's a small group of people, It's not like
- 11:28we're talking a million people. Were talking about a small group and all of
- 11:33them were capable, might maybe even had the body armor and the guns and
- 11:37a plan. What's difference between those ninety nine and the one guy that actually
- 11:41did it. Well, it could be some randomness like he just had a
- 11:46particularly bad week, or he had nothing to do that day. I mean
- 11:50literally things like because the only analogy in behavior which I think is analogous is
- 11:56suicide attempts, in that there's a lot of people who think about suicide.
- 12:01There's a lot of people. There's a you know, a smaller group of
- 12:05people who will plan to attempt. There's an even smaller group of people who
- 12:09actually attempt suicide, and there's a smaller group of people who who complete suicide.
- 12:13And there's a lot of those individuals as opposed to these individuals who there
- 12:18are very few of these individuals, you know, the people who actually shoot
- 12:20up in you know, the people who commit these kinds of hate crimes.
- 12:24But there's millions and millions of people, and we've been studying people with suicidal
- 12:28thoughts and behavior for many, many years, and in research and in interviews
- 12:33and in my own personal experience, there can be these very strange factors that
- 12:39can lead to someone attempting where, like I said, they have a day
- 12:41off where they're like, well, what do I do today. I don't,
- 12:45you know, there's nothing distracting me, or I'm bored, or today's
- 12:50today would be kind of a good day that the sun is out, so
- 12:54I don't have to walk in the rain to get to the place where I
- 12:58want to attempt. I mean literally, when you hear from people that attempt
- 13:01seriously and will survive and tell us why they chose that day, they will
- 13:07they will say sometimes like, I don't know, it just suddenly was overwhelming
- 13:11that day, and I just I just decided to do it. And so
- 13:16so similarly with these shootings in Buffalo, you know, similar to their shooting
- 13:22in Buffalo, the factors can be numerous that have nothing to do with one's
- 13:28neuronal structure. I will have to disagree, because it was his brain ultimately,
- 13:33and he had been planning it and he did go through with it,
- 13:37and so there was something out of the norm happening and that I believe could
- 13:41have been benefited from there. If all the folks that cynically say it's not
- 13:48the guns, it's mental health, if all of them actually then back that
- 13:50up with like, therefore, we're going to increase taxes on the wealthier of
- 13:54brackets and on corporations, and we're going to use that money to start a
- 13:58new mental health program out the country that's going to have hire a whole bunch
- 14:03of therapists and social workers and a school counselors, and we're going to have
- 14:07regular meetings and do education stuff. I would applaud that, and I would
- 14:11still say, and we also got to get rid of the gunts because because
- 14:16it's still so yeah, that's my thing. Well, I want to point
- 14:18out that literally nothing you said I disagree with. I know that's why I
- 14:22think that it's say, but you said we have to agree to it.
- 14:24Well, because you said that there's nothing with his neuron. I'm like,
- 14:26no, it is his brain. It's just that it's not diagnosed. It's
- 14:30not in a DSM diagnosis. But it'd be the same statement to say that
- 14:35you're wearing a purple shirt, therefore your brain is different because you chose a
- 14:39purple shirt. Yeah it is. I mean, well, it was configured
- 14:41in a way that made me choose this shirt today. Okay, Well,
- 14:45if it's that broad, then yeah, I suppose well, right, but
- 14:46then the consequences of my choice are not people dying, whereas the consequence of
- 14:50his choices are, so that doesn't matter that we can obviously, but the
- 14:54other it's the semantic and there's literally nothing I disagree with with what you're saying.
- 15:01And the solution is I think broader than just quote unquote mental health to
- 15:07And of course I'd be all in support of increasing the tax allocation and raising
- 15:16of taxes to pay for these services, not just therapists, but as you
- 15:20say, social workers and other kinds of helpers, parenting experts, also just
- 15:26economic help, which often does affect these things statistically, that occupational training,
- 15:33these kinds of things. So I'd be all for that, of course.
- 15:37But like with like with Sandy Hook, my conclusion on the individual who committed
- 15:43the horrendous crime of killing all those kids would have benefited from the family,
- 15:48would have benefited the mom because it was a single mom and her child,
- 15:52and at least by the time this crime happen. I don't know if there
- 15:56are other siblings, but I've worked with families in this situation where you because
- 16:00apparently he would just stay in his room all the time and play video games
- 16:03and would never leave and didn't seem like he was very happy, and the
- 16:07mom was trying different things, but it wasn't working. And I mean it
- 16:11was the mom or the grandma that he was of her grandma Okay, and
- 16:15I don't know where the mom was if she was around her, but I
- 16:18know it was his grandma was the person that he was right. Yeah,
- 16:22he killed first first. Yeah, and the father has been pretty involved with
- 16:29the media afterwards. Anyway, point is is that I've worked with a lot
- 16:33of families like that, and if you just assigned a therapist, that might
- 16:37not help, because you have to get the kid to go to therapy.
- 16:41You have to get the kid to participate in therapy the whole family. So
- 16:45what I was paid to do was I went to the home and I would
- 16:48sit outside the door of these secluded, isolated individuals and do everything I could.
- 16:56And I had to be experienced in that, and there's no training for
- 16:59that. Like in graduate school, we took a class on how to conduct
- 17:02therapy through a door with a very unwilling person. Yeah, So I had
- 17:07to cobble together and approach and have support around that and the leeway to do
- 17:12it. The government actually would pay me to do that kind of work.
- 17:17Now, it wasn't identified that this person's going to be a shooter eventually,
- 17:19but I'm guessing today they would be identified that way at least as a risk
- 17:23anyway, so that would have helped. But that's not like traditional therapy.
- 17:29Therapy. Also, if there was help for the grandma and the other caregivers
- 17:33when the shooter was five years old, you know, three years old,
- 17:37seven years old, because there were issues then too, But it's hard to
- 17:41get that kind of concentrated help. Often they're just going to their physician,
- 17:45and their physicians just like, I don't know, try this medication or something.
- 17:48And I think the reason in my mind why it's important to still have
- 17:51that conversation because once again the cynical claim by the right wing folks that always
- 17:59a pine after these things, saying, oh, it's too soon to talk
- 18:00to politicize, but if we're going to talk, we should only talk about
- 18:03mental health. It's a cynical take because first of all, they do nothing
- 18:07about mental health period. Also they ignore the obvious statistics, which are that
- 18:11this is the only country where these mass massacres happen constantly with guns, right
- 18:15like it's just so, of course, the first step, of course has
- 18:18to be to deal with the guns and it's a nearly intractable, intractable problem
- 18:22in this country because of the obsession with it. But then what I would
- 18:27contend is that even in Europe and other countries where they do have gun laws,
- 18:32there are still people that do go on these rampantes, they stab people.
- 18:34So all those interventions with families and stuff would still be helpful and also
- 18:38would be helpful in this country. So I think that it's not an either
- 18:41or in my mind, it's like, yeah, we should do both,
- 18:45and certainly start with the guns. Yeah, in terms of risk benefit,
- 18:48it's worth a shot. Yeah, excuse the pun. Okay, So let's
- 18:52take a break and we get back. Let's talk about the Great Replacement theory,
- 18:56Burdo. Let's do it all right. Back from the break, So
- 19:03let's watch more of this video from Vice that talks about the great Replacement theory,
- 19:08which I will say I kind of knew, but didn't really know until
- 19:12I did the steep dive. Did you yes, because yes, a lot
- 19:18of the channels I listened to talk about it denouncing it. Before his attack.
- 19:23The Buffalo Shooter released a manifesto on discord largely centered around a conspiracy theory
- 19:30known as the Great Replacement, a fantasist notion that there's a shadowy plot to
- 19:33replace white people in Europe and the US with non white immigrants, forced mass
- 19:38immigration, population replacement, diversity quotas, and lies about white privilege and how
- 19:45only white people can be racist, obvious truths about the ongoing program of genocide,
- 19:51and gets my race predictably. The people supposedly running this plot are the
- 19:55Jews. They're showing that clip we watched in a previous chapter of the Unite
- 20:03the Right rally in Charlottesville where they're saying Jews will not replace us, which
- 20:08also before this deep dive, I would have maybe taken a guess as to
- 20:14what they meant by that. But there's an elaborate philosophy and conspiracy theory and
- 20:19whole system of nonsense that is present here. So what is your understanding of
- 20:26the Great replacement? Hear? Well, Like with all of these things,
- 20:29it starts with a sliver of facts and then co opted. What are some
- 20:33of the facts. It is a fact that in western industrialized countries birth rates
- 20:38overall are lower nowadays than they used to be, and certainly compared to developing
- 20:44nations. It's even broader that countries economically that are doing well across the globe
- 20:48regardless of well and that's because more recently other parts of the world have been
- 20:52doing better economically. But Japan has one of the lowest end, has always
- 20:57had one of the lowest, and that's not in the Western world. So
- 21:00sure, that's absolutely true. Like it's correlated with the wealth. It's just
- 21:03that the Western world has been most of the wealth. Most of the rest
- 21:07of the world isn't wealthy, and therefore they have had higher birth rates and
- 21:11they still do. And so cause and causation or you know, correlation and
- 21:18causation are two different things, but those get thrown out the window, and
- 21:21essentially folks look at it and like, okay, let's do the math.
- 21:22In this country, the percentage of white population is decreasing as a percentage of
- 21:29total population, and we're seeing more and more immigration from other countries that are
- 21:33not white, and those countries are having more and more kids. So it
- 21:37does seem like the percentage of white people is going down. Okay, Then
- 21:41you add the conspiracies like, oh, why is this happening. It must
- 21:45be purposeful, It must be because they hate us, they hate the white
- 21:48people, and they're trying to replace us. Who is they? Someone's doing
- 21:52this, someone powerful enough. Jews are powerful. They run the world.
- 21:55They must be doing it. Why are they doing it, Well, they're
- 21:57doing it because they want to have global domination. And it's easier for them
- 22:02to enslave the lower class races than it is to enslave the white people,
- 22:07so they must. And these things get tacked onto each other, and then
- 22:11they get amalgamated with other conspiracy theories, and so then it becomes that this
- 22:15worldwide cabal, and they use the word on purpose, this worldwide cabal is
- 22:19purposely trying to eliminate, exterminate the white race. Yeah. I remember learning
- 22:26about this trend when I was young, maybe a teenager, and being kind
- 22:33of happy about it in a way, because growing up, I was one
- 22:37of the only mixed race as they call us kids in my community. And
- 22:41even in the country at large, there's an increasing number of what we would
- 22:47call mixed race kids and people, but when I was growing up, it
- 22:51was rare, and there were a shit ton of white people in my community
- 22:56and in the United States, and you know, white people people were the
- 23:00people who rounded up my family and put us in prisons in World War two.
- 23:03White people were the people who discriminated against us and me and would ask
- 23:08me where are you from, and would attack my family and would bully my
- 23:15dad in school and call him names. Not that I had a problem in
- 23:18general with white people, but I had a feeling of like, well,
- 23:23with more diversity and a balancing of the scales, it might be better for
- 23:30everybody. I don't know if that's true necessarily, because it's not like non
- 23:33white people can't be evil. That's ridiculous, but it was a thought I
- 23:37had. The racism part is deflated a little bit if you don't look so
- 23:44different from each other. Yeah, and just more people like me, you
- 23:48know. I would meet half black kids and feel like we had a kinship
- 23:53because we were just mixed. And when you're alone and you're looking for other
- 24:00people like yourself, it's you know, it feels good to meet other people.
- 24:03And so when I went to Hawaii for the first time, when I
- 24:07was I don't know, maybe thirty thirty five years old or something, for
- 24:11the very first time in my life, I felt like I fit in.
- 24:14It was the weirdest thing because like ninety five percent of people in Hawaii are
- 24:19mixed Asian or happa you know, and they looked like me and talked like
- 24:26me, and ate the same food as me. Like a lot of Japanese
- 24:29American culture food wise and otherwise is very similar to just general Hawaiian culture,
- 24:34because there were a lot of Japanese Americans on Hawaii, particularly in the beginning,
- 24:41proportionally. And so when I heard about the stat of you see the
- 24:45trend lines of more brown people and more mixed people and fewer white people.
- 24:51Like for myself, since it was all white people generally speaking around me,
- 24:56I tended to date white people. Yeah, And so I thought, uh,
- 25:02you know, it's just a matter of who's around you. My dad,
- 25:06being Japanese American and Spokane with mostly white people, he fell in love
- 25:10with a white person because you know, it's it's uh, it's what's in
- 25:14front of you around Yeah. And so it's stood a reason that over time,
- 25:18in diverse multicultural society that we aspire to be in the United States,
- 25:26as we always have, that there would be eventually everyone would be some version
- 25:30of mixed, right, And I thought that would that would be a good
- 25:34thing, at least I would fit in in that future. I'm I'm a
- 25:40a harbinger of things to come. And and you know, there's jokes about
- 25:45how when you enter when you interbreed a dog species or a human family,
- 25:52you know, you get the habspurg chin and the and the blunted cognitive ability,
- 25:59whereas if you breed diverse represent representatives from the gene pool, then you
- 26:06have a you have more robust as you get the immune system of both,
- 26:10you get the survivability of both. At least that's my understanding of how it
- 26:15generally works. I'm sure it doesn't always work out that way, but well
- 26:18that at the very least, you're less likely to have the same recessive negative
- 26:22genes. You know, you might, but it's less likely, right.
- 26:26So I would joke around with my purebred white friends that I was stronger and
- 26:33you know, more resilient because I'm a mixed person, and they were some
- 26:37sort of you know, just you know, race jokes when you're a kid,
- 26:41and so, yeah, it's just always the best. And so I
- 26:45remember feeling like, yeah, bring it on. Not that I want to
- 26:51get rid of white people, but it's just a matter of time, you
- 26:53know, especially when you just think of the whole world like a thousand years
- 26:57from now, there's probably not going to be anyone that's purely white. There
- 27:03might not even be anyone who's quote unquote purely white right now. I mean
- 27:06it depends. First of all, I'm mixed. I'm mixed, and I'm
- 27:10mixed on the whole thing because I love the fact that the world looks different
- 27:17and unique in different places, and that it mixes as well, Like,
- 27:19right, I love the United colors of Benetton, you know, I love
- 27:25all of it. Right. I also think that it's gonna be physiologically odd
- 27:30if people that live in the Northern hemisphere, even people that started with dark
- 27:34skin that move there and have children in mixture that have over time, they
- 27:37still don't tend towards lighter skin because of the mechanics of why they have lighter
- 27:44skin in the first place, and that people that live closer to warmer,
- 27:48hotter areas that get more sunlight wouldn't continue to have darker skin, because again,
- 27:53I just don't think that just interbreeding alone is going to get rid of
- 27:56the physical, physical realities of that. Right well, I would imagine that
- 28:00you'd have to have a population in a region of lots of sun or little
- 28:07sun for certain. I think it's what they would say as certain alleles or
- 28:12versions of DNA that will manifest in melanin amount in one's skin to be selected
- 28:19for over time. So you know, I imagine in the future that if
- 28:23we're still around, that mobility will be as such, that mean moving around,
- 28:29that it will be an odd circumstance that will result in a certain group
- 28:33of people living in somewhere like Norway for five thousand years such that the light
- 28:40skin will start to select itself for that or opposite. I imagine that in
- 28:45my world of the future, the Star Trek version of the future, people
- 28:48are moving around all over the place. Plus there are medical interventions. All
- 28:52you have to do is take a vitamin D supplement and everything's fine, and
- 28:56there's sunscreen, you know what I mean. So I as a mixed person,
- 29:00and you're a mixed person. You're part White Spanish and part Native Colombian
- 29:07and what else? A part Asian basically, and what else are you?
- 29:11Oh my full dyn anything? Yeah, Oh, I'm two percent Ashkenazi Jew,
- 29:14I'm I've got East Asian, I've got how much African? How much?
- 29:19I don't know, like, uh, probably five percent or I don't
- 29:23know, meaning that one of your great great great No, no, meaning
- 29:27that the Native Americans have descendants their ancestors are from Asia. Right, Sorry,
- 29:36the thing with remember the melanin develops on your skin with the stimulus from
- 29:41the sun. So yes, you're born with a certain amount already predisposed genetically,
- 29:45but if the sunlight doesn't hit it, you don't get That's why you
- 29:48get tanned, right, that's why. And so anyways, who knows,
- 29:52I'm you're right, I'm probably wrong, and you you bring up excellent points.
- 29:56But what I was trying to get at was that I don't need I
- 30:00don't need everyone to look identical in the world for me to be happy.
- 30:03And yet I do wonder if people weren't so dramatically different in some cases,
- 30:10you know, visually, if that would reduce some of this nonsense, and
- 30:14it hopefully would. Yeah, I mean it's interesting to think about this because
- 30:18you know, scientifically, and if things continue down this road, everyone will
- 30:23be some version of mid brown, right, if we just average the skin
- 30:30tone and the other kinds of indicators of ethnicity, you know, eye shape,
- 30:36you know, there's as an Asian. People will look at me sometimes
- 30:40and say, oh, your eyes look Asian, or they'll say your eyes
- 30:44don't look Asian enough or whatever. You know, there's a certain look,
- 30:45and that as those things average out, that not only will white people quote
- 30:52unquote white people never exist, but other sorts of groups that are distinct will
- 30:56also potentially not exist anymore. So what is that? What is yeah?
- 31:02What does that mean? You know? Yeah, it could take literally like
- 31:04a million years, who knows, but ort to very least still be fewer
- 31:07of them, you know, I mean, so you're one hundred percent correct
- 31:11to an end degree because like it's already happened, right, like clearly the
- 31:15US is in fact one of the great examples of this, because when you
- 31:19look at a city like New York, you see all of the stuff,
- 31:22and you see a lot of people in the middle and see people where you
- 31:25you can't quite tell what they are, and that's great, right, But
- 31:30if you go to the more, then you go to pocket areas, and
- 31:32then you're still like, Okay, well that's fully white or that's fully black,
- 31:34or that's fully Asian or that's fully whatever, and that you know,
- 31:38that's going to last longer because it takes longer for those pockets to get great
- 31:41replaced. Yeah. But the difference again, it's the thing we were talking
- 31:47about in the other episode. There's observing a fact and then there's what's your
- 31:49agenda behind observing that fact. Yeah. Yeah, and my agenda is I,
- 31:56at least in the short term, I want more people like me.
- 32:00But but you're so therefore you're controlling the world and you're trying to you know,
- 32:04exterminate the white No, that's the part that gets layered onto this,
- 32:07that's that I just want everyone to accept that I like spam musubi. I'm
- 32:10just looking for more justification for them. Yeah. By the way, we
- 32:15had a party, Oh, at the Christmas party that I have every year,
- 32:22someone suggested that I make because there's one thing that I make and it's
- 32:25spammusubi. And someone suggested maybe it's even stacy, And I was like,
- 32:30I don't think regular people, you know, non Asians, because we have
- 32:35some Asian friends, but most of our friends are not Asian. There's you
- 32:37know, white people, black people's, Spanish people, but not a lot
- 32:40of Asians. And I was like, and the Asians that I do know,
- 32:44they're not Japanese. So and even if they were Japanese. Really the
- 32:47only people who like spam musubi like the way it's like soul food to us
- 32:52is Japanese Americans and Hawaiians by extension, because they're so influenced by that.
- 32:59And there's various reasons I spam became a thing. One of the main reasons
- 33:01is that during World War Two, because white people FDR locked us up into
- 33:07prisons, they had to feed us, and one of the ways that they
- 33:10fed us was what was army rations. And spam was an army ration because
- 33:16it is in a tin can and it keeps. And so the Japanese Americans
- 33:22citizens, by the way, people born in this country, relatives of mine,
- 33:28had to make do with what they had, and so they're used to
- 33:30making sushi and other kind of rice things in their four meals, and so
- 33:37they're like, well, you know, we don't have fish, so we'll
- 33:39go with the spam, and so they just started making spam hand rolls or
- 33:44musubi. That eventually evolved into what we have today. And you know,
- 33:47spam is disgusting. It's particularly in the past when it had that sort of
- 33:52gelatin stuff around it. It does what do you mean, it doesn't know
- 33:54it doesn't now, No, it's completely What was the gelatin with fat to
- 33:59preserve it? I guess I don't know, maybe maybe just part of the
- 34:02manufacturing process. It also made it easier for it to come out of the
- 34:07can, right, So how does it now? It's it's hard you really
- 34:10cut up? Oh so it's just it in the tin? Yeah, you're
- 34:14sure, but you know, and I get it. I only remember because
- 34:17I probably only had spam when I was a kid, and I remember it
- 34:21with a fat. Yeah, we had a lot of that gel stuff and
- 34:23it's not very pleasant. But to me, it's a taste of home,
- 34:29a taste of you know, family get togethers. There were special events when
- 34:34spam musubi was around, and you know, I like it. So now,
- 34:39if it wasn't part of my family, if it was just like something
- 34:43that someone served to me, I'd be like, yeah, that's fine.
- 34:45But to me, you know, it's anyway. So I was like,
- 34:46I'm not going to make it for my friends because they're going to think it's
- 34:52disgusting and it's and it you know, you don't make food for people,
- 34:55but at least not very often. But if you ever, you like at
- 35:00a party where it's buffet stop and your dish is the one thing that no
- 35:04one tests, you know what I mean? And yeah, humiliating and plus
- 35:09just the amount of time the potato salad, No, I'm okay, and
- 35:12I'm like, well, this one's really good. Why do you have me?
- 35:15Why are you so invested in me? Especially something like spam with sube
- 35:19because you can easily just grab it. You're not committing the way you would
- 35:22be to a potato salad. You know, it's just like snack feet And
- 35:25I make them in the little bite size, small enough like you know,
- 35:29normally a spamis sweet, was a whole thing, but I make like four
- 35:32what fourths you know that you could just pop in your mouth, and so
- 35:37they looked very good. I had the salmon, right, so I made
- 35:39salmon ones as well, but the spam ones actually raced off the plate as
- 35:45the salmon ones did, and I but faster than the salmon because there was
- 35:51still salmon left after the spam was gone. And I didn't know. And
- 35:54I made twice as much as the spam ones, and so I would is
- 36:00very surprised. I mean, I will say I make a very good version
- 36:02of it, because I don't make this. If it was anywhere like your
- 36:05salmon one, it must have been delicious, because the salmon was great.
- 36:08Yeah. Yeah, I use special sauce and special FOODI kaka, and I
- 36:12use cream cheese, and I use a special kind of nody. But anyway,
- 36:15point is is that it felt good, you know, to have that
- 36:19acceptance. You know, I'm fifty three years old and I still feel like
- 36:22an outsider in my own fucking town because it's not just this sort of stuff,
- 36:28but it's been my whole life. And so for me to have at
- 36:30least some more mixed people in the mix is enjoyable to me. Like I
- 36:37said earlier, I claim all mixed people like I claim I claim you to
- 36:40some extent, you know what I mean. So for myself it's just a
- 36:45win. But for other people, you know, I could see it'd be
- 36:49like my people you know that have been on this planet for millennia, there
- 36:55won't be anyone that will look like me anymore. And I get it,
- 36:59well, look, act have the same culture and customs. Listen it is
- 37:04it is the reason it's so existential to them is because they look at it
- 37:07as like remember the nostalgia thing. They're like, but I looked around,
- 37:12like my mom, my, uncles, my cousins. We all look like
- 37:15us, and we all celebrate Christmas with Christian specific kinds of Christian values,
- 37:22and we go to the same kind of church, and we have the same
- 37:27holidays and the same celebrations. We eat the same kind of foods, we
- 37:30talk the same way, we like the same kind of music. All of
- 37:35that is being challenged. That is not just the skin color, it is
- 37:38their identity, is who they are, it's their whole history, and they
- 37:43feel like it's all being taken away. Yeah, and its yeah, yeah,
- 37:47it's malevolent and the only solution is to fight and exterminate and to segregate.
- 37:54But anyway, Berto, let's just take a quick break. What do
- 37:58you say, Let's do it. Okay, we're back from the break,
- 38:05you know. I can. Actually, it's so weird how these deep dives
- 38:08and then talking about it with you causes me to make these very strange connections.
- 38:13So I have started to notice that even Japanese Americans, not mixed,
- 38:17but just Japanese Americans are on the way out. Because there was this initial
- 38:23wave of immigration from Japan to the United States in the early late nineteenth early
- 38:30twentieth century. That you know, the main bulk of Japanese Americans came over
- 38:36when my ancestors came over, which was around nineteen hundred, and there were
- 38:40Chinese people here because of work in the railroad and this kind of thing.
- 38:45But the Japanese wave was was pretty sizable because of economic and economic problems and
- 38:52famine and that sort of thing. Then the Japanese economy started to do better
- 38:59through the twentieth century and there were fewer there was less of a need for
- 39:04Japanese people to leave, and so there were far fewer immigrants from Japan.
- 39:09But there were a lot more Vietnamese people during during the war and otherwise.
- 39:15And then Filipinos have been coming over for a long time because opportunities in the
- 39:22Philippines and political strife has been ongoing now with the tech growth, at least
- 39:25in a lot of the areas like here, lots of Indian, right,
- 39:30yeah, right, So the category of Asian American used to when I was
- 39:37a kid, people would assume you're either Japanese or your Chinese. And of
- 39:42course Koreans were starting to come over as well in the seventies, eighties,
- 39:46nineties, whereas today if someone says they're Asian. Japanese would not be the
- 39:52assumption, and it shouldn't be because there's there's not many of us proportionally.
- 39:57The assumption today in Seattle would be Filipino, Chinese, Korean. Yeah,
- 40:04I guess that. And of course, you know there's Indonesians, you know,
- 40:06and I don't want to leave anyone out oceans among people, Thai people,
- 40:10Taiwanese people, Gabanians, and the Japanese side is certainly not as prominent,
- 40:16right because there's just fewer of us, and a lot of us have
- 40:21married white people or other ethnic groups, you know, black people, Hispanic
- 40:27people, and so the descendants of those Japanese people are either half quarter or
- 40:32eighth and so my people, you know, it's Japanese people, but that's
- 40:39very different from Japanese American people and my people Japanese American people. In fifty
- 40:46years there might not be very meant in a one hundred years, there might
- 40:50not be hardly any of us. Now, there always be a trickle of
- 40:53immigration from Japan, but not like it was not a large community. Yeah,
- 41:00you know, we had a whole town in Seattle, Japantown that was
- 41:04you know, destroyed by internment. You can look at that and be like,
- 41:08man, that's kind of sad. Yeah, right, but and it
- 41:12is. It does bump me out because the Japanese community was very close and
- 41:16it's very particular, and it's not anything like Chinese culture, not like it's
- 41:22better, it's just it's just a very different, yeah culture. And of
- 41:25course Japan has many cultures, just even within its borders. And you know,
- 41:31the Japanese community within Seattle is important. You know Wa Jamaya and japan
- 41:37Town, and different parks are named after Japanese people. There's different festivals,
- 41:43the obone festival with the type bone it's like Summer June festival. It will
- 41:50be gone. And when I go to these events now, it's a lot
- 41:52of white people because or half people or quarter people or spouses or just the
- 42:00seattleites you were interested. When I was a kid, it was all Japanese
- 42:02people. You know. It's like it's it's losing it's it's cohesion and it's
- 42:07and its existence. And it does bum me out. But I'm not about
- 42:12to say to Japanese people, stop interbreeding with the the the dirty white people.
- 42:20Well and even worse, stop falling for the conspiracy of such and such
- 42:24cabals that are trying to get us Japanese Americans to disappear from the face of
- 42:29the Yeah, yeah, yeah. And some people might say, well,
- 42:32the difference is with white people, they have been taught that they're the best,
- 42:37that there's something special about them. Well, newsflasts. Japanese are the
- 42:40same way. Japanese people believe they are special and better than everyone else on
- 42:47the planet, particularly the other Asian countries, almost every community. And I'm
- 42:52not saying it's good. I'm just saying it's true, but it's particular to
- 42:57white people and Japanese people. Hence World War Two and the genocide that Germans
- 43:02and Japanese people committed upon all sorts of people. My people were in the
- 43:07States not doing those things. We were just being discriminated against. I'm'll tell
- 43:12you, I think there's just much more power there. But like, I
- 43:15grew up in a country that looks identical to the countries around it, and
- 43:17we believe we were superior to every country and that as a people, we
- 43:22are superior, and the other countries believe the same. Let alone, if
- 43:27you go to Argentina. But I wonder how I wonder, I mean,
- 43:32you could tell me that Colombia has a particular vibe to it or something.
- 43:38Well, I guess anyway, point is is that and yet there are only
- 43:43some countries that invaded and considered it their manifest destiny to rule the world.
- 43:52Well, I mean, if you want to talk great replacement, what about
- 43:54the Native Americans in this country that were greatly replaced out of all their land
- 44:00into little conclaves. And honestly, if it had been up to the the
- 44:06white people in charge, it's an interesting thing because part of them didn't want
- 44:09to intermix, but a lot of them did intermix. And so because remember
- 44:15the whole thing like, hey, if you come to our country, you
- 44:15got to adapt to our culture. You hear that all the time. And
- 44:20I don't think there's anything particularly wrong with the benign version of that. Hey,
- 44:24if you're gonna be here, you gotta follow our rules, you gotta
- 44:28like, you know, try to integrate, you know. But where it
- 44:31gets malignant is when it's like, I don't like, you have your little
- 44:36community there, What is that? What is that you're not speaking our language?
- 44:38What is that? What is that? Right? But isn't it ironic?
- 44:42Like it's these knives that they have cut six ways because they're like,
- 44:46you can't have your own community. Bad, stop speaking in that other language.
- 44:51Oh, stop mixing with us, like they want both. Interesting.
- 44:55You can't have your own community, but you should be in your own community.
- 44:59Oh, don't be in your own community and talk your own language.
- 45:00But you should not mix with us. Yeah, but you should integrate like
- 45:04what And we're immigrants as well because we came from Europe. But no,
- 45:08no, no, we had a divine right to the land. Yeah.
- 45:10Yeah, Well, let's take a break and when we get back, it'll
- 45:15just be for patrons. So if you want to listen to the rest of
- 45:16this, become a patron of the podcast. Also know that when you become
- 45:21a patron, you are literally making it possible for us to make episodes of
- 45:27any sorts, particularly these deep dives, because it takes a lot of time.
- 45:30Also know that a certain portion of your pledge goes to various charities that
- 45:35we support and scholarships and scholarships as well, and occasional art funds as well.
- 45:39So do that now. Otherwise, please take care of yourself. Join
- 45:45us next time when we continue talking about this. Take care of yourself because
- 45:49you deserve it