Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Bill C-14 And What Bail Can Not Fix
Transcript
- 0:32Adam Stirling: What's the story?
- 0:34Michael Mulligan: So first of all, this piece of legislation, Bill C fourteen, uh just came into effect last week, and it makes a number of changes to uh provisions dealing with largely bail.
- 0:47Michael Mulligan: Um and as I spoke about before in some general terms, uh the issue of bail or judicial interim release has gotten sort of politically focused on uh as uh somehow an explanation for legitimate concerns about social disorder and crime, right?
- 1:03Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 1:03Michael Mulligan: Um and the the thing to understand about bail uh is that it it is really a function of the fact that we presume people to be innocent, right?
- 1:12Michael Mulligan: Most people would agree that's kind of the foundation of our justice system.
- 1:16Michael Mulligan: And when you presume people to be innocent, one of the consequences of that is that you can't just start punishing people uh that might have committed a crime, because you'll wind up punishing a bunch of people that didn't commit crimes.
- 1:27Michael Mulligan: Not everyone accused of a crime, of course, is is guilty, right?
- 1:31Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 1:31Michael Mulligan: And that basic principle is constitutionally enshrined along with the presumption of innocence.
- 1:38Michael Mulligan: And in 11E of the Charter, it guarantees the right to reasonable bail absent just cause.
- 1:43Michael Mulligan: And that's been interpreted, keeping in mind that just general principle I've just spoken about.
- 1:47Michael Mulligan: Well, um, there are, I should say, legitimate issues with the criminal justice system and things that could be done to improve it.
- 1:57Michael Mulligan: Um, you know, for example, one of the reasons why we're having this show at a special time today uh is because of uh just how busy it is in court.
- 2:05Michael Mulligan: Um I that's where I was uh at the regular time, court running uh over when it would usually run, and that's largely a function of things like uh an inadequ inadequate number of judges, for example.
- 2:16Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 2:17Michael Mulligan: We've got communities that grow quickly, and if you don't add uh resources, which means not just judges, but you also need court clerks and sheriffs and crown, and uh in fact, in many cases you also need to have legal aid funding.
- 2:28Michael Mulligan: If you don't have those things, you wind up with uh courts unable to manage things and cases take longer and longer, all of which is unsatisfactory.
- 2:36Michael Mulligan: And that's just one example of how there are legitimate issues, many of which involve resourcing, both on the judicial end, uh on the police end.
- 2:45Michael Mulligan: There are real and pressing things that could be done to help.
- 2:48Michael Mulligan: Uh but yeah, somebody who's in the system and sees it every day, one of the underlying problems is not generally how the bail system has been functioning.
- 2:58Michael Mulligan: Uh and so this piece of legislation that came in uh appears to be intended to politically address the critique that really that's somehow the problem.
- 3:09Michael Mulligan: If we could just start jailing people before their trial, somehow that would solve the problem.
- 3:15Michael Mulligan: Uh and the extent to which that those basic principles could be modified by legislative change is of course, not of course, but it is modest, because of course we have a constitutional right to be presumed innocent, not to deny uh bail without just cause.
- 3:31Michael Mulligan: Uh and so even if uh somebody thought it was wise legislatively to just say, well, we're just gonna forget about those, you know, messy trials that take so much time and just start holding people in jail, you know, for a year, whatever it takes now to get to trial, somehow that'll solve our problem.
- 3:47Michael Mulligan: That's not even constitutionally permissible.
- 3:51Michael Mulligan: So what we instead have is this piece of legislation which lists a bunch of things that I think the best analogy to the uh medical state of affairs would be like a bunch of admonitions directing doctors that they shall carefully wash their hands before performing surgery.
- 4:08Michael Mulligan: And if they don't wash them very carefully, they're to consider whether they should wash them carefully or maybe even wash them twice.
- 4:14Michael Mulligan: So, for example, when you look at this piece of legislation, it uh includes things like, for example, a direction that the judge or justice uh when determining whether to uh when conducting a bail hearing for somebody uh who has uh committed acts of random and unprovoked violence, uh is to consider whether the accused uh should be detained, taking that into account.
- 4:39Michael Mulligan: Now, can you imagine many judges that are not taking that into account uh already without the admonition?
- 4:46Michael Mulligan: Uh or for example, uh when uh you have, for example, a person who is repeatedly committed convicted has previously been convicted of serious offenses involving, you know, break and enter, for example, to take that into account when sentencing the person for a subsequent breaking and entering.
- 5:03Michael Mulligan: So really, was that a problem?
- 5:04Michael Mulligan: Were they failing to do that?
- 5:06Michael Mulligan: Um, or for example, uh admonitions to require the court to consider the uh denunciation and deterrence of repeat motor vehicle theft offenses, or offenses committed for criminal uh organizations.
- 5:20Michael Mulligan: Is that really a problem?
- 5:22Michael Mulligan: Was there a failure to take that into account?
- 5:24Michael Mulligan: Uh other uh exam uh and it just goes on and on in that way.
- 5:28Michael Mulligan: Other things like, for example, uh it includes a requirement for a judge to uh impose a firearms prohibition unless the judge concludes that it's not in the interest of justice for various offenses, including terrorism offenses or extortion or intimidation of justice system participants.
- 5:47Michael Mulligan: Was it really a raging problem that judges who are dealing with people for a bail hearings charge with terrorism were not considering whether it would be a desirable condition to impose on the ought to have firearms?
- 5:57Michael Mulligan: Was that something we needed to correct?
- 5:59Michael Mulligan: And on and on it goes.
- 6:09Michael Mulligan: And there have been a number of those for a long time in the criminal code, like for example, for serious offenses like murder, um, it would be the accused who would have the burden of establishing that they should be released rather than the reverse.
- 6:22Michael Mulligan: The constitutional principle that you're presumed to be innocent and as well that you are not to be denied bail absent just cause is unaffected.
- 6:31Michael Mulligan: It's a matter of who would have the sort of evidentiary and persuasive burden, bearing in mind those unshifting principles, like we don't just presume people who are charged with a serious offense to be guilty of the offense because the allegation is a serious one.
- 6:45Michael Mulligan: We maintain the presumption of innocence and maintain the principles that uh inform the you know how that principle informs uh bail.
- 6:53Michael Mulligan: Uh and so uh there are uh a number of other serious offenses where that uh would be the case, but uh really uh bearing in mind first of all that isn't really the outstanding core of any particular problem in the criminal justice system, and bearing in mind those basic principles that are not and cannot be modified by legislation, it is very unlikely that those things are going to have a meaningful impact.
- 7:18Michael Mulligan: Uh the other thing about all of this, as you mentioned in the uh opening there, yeah, um, is that you know, and again, all of these things are of course at their core political.
- 7:27Michael Mulligan: Um, and so one of the things which the Attorney General's office has done is they've drafted up a preform submission, which they then ordered all Crown Counsel to file in every case where they're are having a bail hearing.
- 7:40Michael Mulligan: Uh and it it uh it's amusing on several respects.
- 7:43Michael Mulligan: First of all, it uh is probably the uh uh most use of underlining I think I've ever seen in a uh recently at least in a uh a submission in court.
- 7:52Michael Mulligan: And it includes various things like, for example, I mentioned to you what that section of the charter requires, like section 11E says the charter guarantees the right to reasonable bail absent just cause.
- 8:03Michael Mulligan: And so what they've done is they've underlined absent just cause, uh, or various other things uh that they've uh sort of emphasized by various underlines, uh, pointing out uh that uh you know some of the uh uh captain obvious things like the hand washing for doctors, they've also taken care to point out things like uh it is significant to clarify the principle of restraint does not require the accused to be released with an underline.
- 8:30Michael Mulligan: That's an interesting thing.
- 8:31Michael Mulligan: You may have heard that commented on that principle of restraint.
- 8:34Michael Mulligan: Uh and that's uh a principle that the Supreme Court of Canada uh has uh outlined in interpreting what uh it's meant by uh not denying bail absent just cause.
- 8:45Michael Mulligan: Uh and that principle of restraint essentially means that uh when you're the starting point would be you don't detain an innocent person unless there's a reason to do that relating to bail.
- 8:55Michael Mulligan: Uh and then as well uh when you're imposing conditions of release on somebody who is being is being released by a judge, the judge is required to only impose conditions that would be necessary to address whatever the particular concern is on bail.
- 9:11Michael Mulligan: Like, for example, if there was a concern that somebody needed to be protected, you could impose whatever conditions that would be necessary to make sure that a person is kept safe.
- 9:20Michael Mulligan: Or if there was a concern uh that if a person was released they wouldn't attend court.
- 9:24Michael Mulligan: You could impose conditions in order to address that uh concern.
- 9:28Michael Mulligan: That's what it really amounts to.
- 9:30Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh it does not allow conditions to be imposed for other reasons.
- 9:35Michael Mulligan: Like, for example, a judge at a bail hearing could not impose conditions intending to punish the accused before they've had a trial.
- 9:42Michael Mulligan: Or indeed, you couldn't impose conditions even if you thought they may be rehabilitative, right?
- 9:47Michael Mulligan: If they weren't being imposed to protect public or make sure somebody's gonna show up, you know, the other things that are part of bail.
- 9:52Michael Mulligan: Uh and that's what's meant by the principle of restraint.
- 9:56Michael Mulligan: Uh and there is no one uh in the criminal justice system who would have believed that the principle of restraint required accused people to be released.
- 10:04Michael Mulligan: That would be nonsensical.
- 10:06Michael Mulligan: And so you've got now this document that they are ordering Crown Council to file that has things like underlining, the principle of restraint underlined, does not require the accused to be released.
- 10:16Michael Mulligan: Um again, it's uh uh a bit much.
- 10:20Michael Mulligan: Uh and so uh that's what has come into effect, um, and that's one of the ways in which the uh the AG provincial is dealing with it, is to uh order Crown to file this uh submission with a bunch of underlines uh with all the judges every time they're conducting a bail hearing.
- 10:39Michael Mulligan: Uh and so uh that's sort of where we've landed.
- 10:43Michael Mulligan: Uh I I don't uh have any doubt if the uh members of the public had concerns about things which are in fact legitimate concerns, for example, about you know social disorder that people have seen uh in downtown Victoria.
- 10:58Michael Mulligan: That is real.
- 10:59Michael Mulligan: If people uh don't think that's real, they are simply mistake it.
- 11:02Michael Mulligan: It it's real.
- 11:03Michael Mulligan: Uh but uh if there was somehow uh an expectation that uh this bill or bunch of underlining is going to address the you know underlying serious issues we have with drug addiction and mental illness and um lack of uh police and uh court resources and all of the things that uh might legitimately have an impact on those serious problems, uh I think they're going to be uh seriously disappointed uh because the underlying problem was not one with bail.
- 11:34Michael Mulligan: Uh and so uh things like this, uh which are uh intended to sort of sound tough by pointing out uh that judges should consider things like whether you should prohibit a terror alleged terrorist from having a firearm, uh, or whether you should consider it an aggravating circumstance that the person's been repeatedly committed, convicted in the past of serious offenses, uh, I think are going to be quite disappointed to learn that we have a judiciary that is perfectly capable of assessing uh those things already.
- 12:02Michael Mulligan: They were assessing them already, and there wasn't some uh complete failure to take into account uh the uh obvious in terms of uh what would be important considerations on bail.
- 12:14Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that's what's happened uh as a result of uh those political machinations.
- 12:19Michael Mulligan: We've got Bill C 14, uh, and we've got uh the uh Crown Council uh being ordered to uh hand up uh a uh submission pointing these various things out with a bunch of underlines, uh, as if somehow uh that's going to address the uh the legitimate concerns people have uh about uh the criminal justice system.
- 12:39Michael Mulligan: So that's latest on Bill C 14.
- 12:41Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh what came into effect last week?
- 12:44Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense.
- 12:46Adam Stirling: Legally speaking, we'll continue right after this.
- 12:49Adam Stirling: Legally speaking, fact Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense, Michael, before the break we were talking about latest in terms of bail provision.
- 12:57Adam Stirling: Moving on to the next topic that you and I have on our agenda today.
- 13:00Adam Stirling: A missed trial application is uh here of witnesses violating court orders to not discuss evidence.
- 13:08Adam Stirling: What happened?
- 13:10Michael Mulligan: Well, the this case involved uh a very commonly made order in criminal cases, and it's an order which uh would uh uh require witnesses who are under cross-examination not to discuss their evidence uh with anyone uh until the cross-examination is finished.
- 13:28Michael Mulligan: Uh and it's one of those sort of routine orders that's uh made along with uh another common order in a criminal case, which would require witnesses to remain outside of the courtroom until after they've had a chance to testify.
- 13:40Michael Mulligan: And both of those common orders are intended to uh uh assist in getting the best evidence we can from witnesses, right?
- 13:48Michael Mulligan: You don't want, in terms of witnesses sitting in the courtroom, somebody to just sit there, listen to what the last three people had to say and then say in you know, consciously or subconsciously the same thing, right?
- 13:57Michael Mulligan: That's how it would work.
- 13:59Michael Mulligan: And also, when a witness is being cross-examined and questioned about what they had to say, you don't want them going off and talking to others to get some tips on how they might uh solve whatever uh problem there might be with their evidence, right?
- 14:12Michael Mulligan: And this was a case uh in uh the provincial court in BC, uh and it was an impaired driving case, it wasn't anything particularly remarkable, but it was a circumstance where a police officer was testifying, uh, and as sometimes happens, because we generally have a lack of uh judicial resources, court time, uh it didn't finish.
- 14:32Michael Mulligan: The case didn't finish.
- 14:33Michael Mulligan: The officer had testified in chief, like the crown had called him to ask what happened and then what did you do?
- 14:38Michael Mulligan: And then he was being cross-examined by the defense, and they ran out of time for the day.
- 14:42Michael Mulligan: And so the case had to be adjourned, and the judge gave that common direction to the police officer that you're not to discuss your evidence with anyone uh because you're under cross-examination.
- 14:53Michael Mulligan: Case had adjourned, they came back, uh, and defense counsel uh asked her to ask a few questions about well, did you talk to anyone uh uh over the uh you know past few days after the case was adjourned?
- 15:04Michael Mulligan: And the officer, oh yes, uh the officer agreed he spoke to various people at his detachment and spoke to a recruit that was there and discussed various things about his evidence, including some central parts of it.
- 15:15Michael Mulligan: Uh and in breach of that court order.
- 15:18Michael Mulligan: And the application then came from the defense for a mistrial, arguing that, hey, the officer breached this obligation, he discussed evidence uh that was uh central uh in the cross-examination with uh others uh before coming back to continue being asked questions about those things.
- 15:35Michael Mulligan: And so it led to the judge needing to assess is that an appropriate case where you need to declare a mistrial?
- 15:41Michael Mulligan: Um and that brings us to that law surrounding mistrials.
- 15:46Michael Mulligan: Uh and the the basic uh principle of that is that a judge should declare a mistrial, like canceling it, so go do over, right?
- 15:54Michael Mulligan: Uh, but should do that only if there's no other remedy that would adequately preserve the right to a fair trial.
- 16:00Michael Mulligan: That's really the the North Star, right?
- 16:02Michael Mulligan: Yes.
- 16:02Michael Mulligan: Uh and when deciding whether some kind of a problem like this one, the uh police officer speaking to others during cross-examination, contrary to a court order, should result in a mistrial.
- 16:13Michael Mulligan: One of the judge things the judge has to think about is is there anything else that could save this?
- 16:18Michael Mulligan: Because uh you don't want to declare a mistrial if that can be avoided, because it means doing the whole thing over again, and other things can result from that.
- 16:26Michael Mulligan: The trial might not be done in a reasonable period of time, or you know, it uh require twice as much court time, gotta do it all over again.
- 16:34Michael Mulligan: Um and here the judge found on this particular fact pattern, because of exactly what was discussed and so on, that it wasn't necessary to declare a mistrial because other potential remedies were available, including, the judge suggested, there could be a request by the defense to uh come to the conclusion with respect to this officer's testimony that it lacked credibility, that it was unreliable, uh, that little weight should be attached to it, or even potentially that the evidence was so tainted by the discussions had with others during the cross-examination that the court should accept none of the officer's evidence.
- 17:10Michael Mulligan: And so rather than declaring the mistrial, the judge pointed out those are a potential ways it could be dealt with, and so the mistrial was avoided.
- 17:16Michael Mulligan: The case will continue, but there will be a real question about whether uh the uh court accepts what the officer had to say, given that they failed to follow that common direction in terms of uh what's to be done when you're under cross-examination.
- 17:30Michael Mulligan: So I thought it was a worthwhile case, both for that general principle that when you're being asked questions in court, if there's an adjournment, be it the lunch break or over to another day, if you're in the process of being cross-examined, you can't just go and discuss your evidence with others to get a bunch of tips on how you might better answer the uh awkward questions you're being asked in cross-examination, and when that doesn't happen, how a judge is uh required to deal with the uh with the fallout.
- 17:54Adam Stirling: And three minutes left in our segment today.
- 17:56Adam Stirling: A reasonable pret expectation of privacy for a suspect in a murder trial.
- 18:02Adam Stirling: What happened?
- 18:03Michael Mulligan: Well, this is a case involving a murder trial where there was an issue, I think, about who did it, right?
- 18:09Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh part of the evidence that the crown was relying upon uh was in the form of video, s security video, that the police seized from a neighbor.
- 18:18Michael Mulligan: Uh and a neighbor of the uh residence in which the accused lived um turned over this video to the police, uh, but the police didn't obtain a uh warrant or judicial authorization to get the video.
- 18:31Michael Mulligan: They just got it from the neighbor.
- 18:33Michael Mulligan: Uh and the video included video footage of the front door of the accused house, showing the accused coming and going and other people coming and going from the home.
- 18:42Michael Mulligan: And the accused challenged that on the basis that uh the police didn't get uh judicial authorization to seize the video, and arguing that he had a reasonable expectation of privacy, which would require the police to get a warrant for the thing being seized.
- 18:58Michael Mulligan: That raised to the judge that fundamental issue, which is uh whether you have a reasonable expectation of privacy over video footage of your front door, which I think for many people may be a live issue even if you're not charged with murder.
- 19:11Michael Mulligan: And the arguments on each side of it included uh the accused saying, well, hold on, this isn't somebody just s looking out and seeing me standing at the front door or not seeing me there, it's a fifteen-hour recording of my front door.
- 19:24Michael Mulligan: And you can well imagine how that could be viewed as a different thing in our modern reality, because while it's true that you you know, anyone could potentially see you either not standing at or standing at your front door, it could be a very different thing if you have a camera pointed at your front door such that you could go back and forth and figure out when does this person come and go, who are they coming and going with, uh, and so on.
- 19:46Michael Mulligan: And that might be something in which you would have a reasonable expectation of privacy.
- 19:50Michael Mulligan: At least that was the argument here.
- 19:52Michael Mulligan: Ultimately, the judge agreed with the crown and found that there was no reasonable expectation of privacy in terms of the video of the front door of the accused person, uh, which is you know, on one level that's understandable, right?
- 20:03Michael Mulligan: It's a public place, you can kind of see the front door.
- 20:06Michael Mulligan: But on the other hand, you need to think about well, what are the implications of that?
- 20:10Michael Mulligan: What if, for example, the police decide to just set up a surveillance camera watching you in your front door at all times?
- 20:15Michael Mulligan: Does that interfere with your reason do you have a reasonable expectation of privacy that's being breached there, for example?
- 20:21Michael Mulligan: And so I thought it was just an interesting case for people to be aware of.
- 20:24Michael Mulligan: That was the outcome here, uh, but for people just to think about, you know, whether that is something in the modern world of uh security cameras, whether that should impact on whether you've got uh an expectation of privacy over uh images or video of you over an extended time at your home, and whether that's any different from uh the fact that you could just see the person if you happen to drive by at a particular time.
- 20:47Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking, during the second half of our second hour, but it was an hour three today, right here on C Facts and Wells.
- 20:55Adam Stirling: Michael, thank you so much.
- 20:56Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 20:57Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 20:58Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.
- 20:58Adam Stirling: All right, quick break news is next.