Latest / Replay Reviews / I Did NOT Want to See That 🫪 | Red Dead Redemption II | Part 3

Transcript

I Did NOT Want to See That 🫪 | Red Dead Redemption II | Part 3 · Replay Reviews

• 0:00
  Welcome back to Red Dead Redemption 2. Chapter
• 0:03
  2, Part 2. Episode 3, though. Too bad it wasn't
• 0:07
  Episode 2. Anyway, it's going to be a short episode
• 0:10
  today. Is there anything you want to say before
• 0:12
  we do the out -of -context summary? Nope. In
• 0:17
  this episode, we see an ever -elusive FBM. We're
• 0:22
  subject to 2 out of 3? 4 bodily fluids in this
• 0:27
  episode? How many are there? Oh, gosh. I don't
• 0:29
  know. At least four. Anyway, and that soup really
• 0:33
  offended Arthur. That might be the most upset
• 0:35
  that we've seen him. But that upset soup moment
• 0:39
  made me think of that would have been the same
• 0:42
  as John's reaction. I feel like John would have
• 0:45
  been like, man, it tastes like shit. It kind
• 0:48
  of would. Was it the taste or the temperature
• 0:51
  or both? We may never know. Thank you for coming
• 0:57
  back from our replay reviews. My name is Leah.
• 0:59
  And my name is Kathy. We are two friends who
• 1:01
  are here to replay, review, and analyze your
• 1:04
  favorite video games. And since Kathy has never
• 1:06
  seen the games before, it helps me view them
• 1:08
  through her fresh eyes, almost like I'm discovering
• 1:11
  them again for the first time. We hope it will
• 1:13
  be a similar experience for you. Alright, so
• 1:22
  we start out in the morning. Miss Grimshaw approaches
• 1:25
  Arthur, saying one of the girls saw Mary Gillis
• 1:28
  sniffing about, and she does not seem to be a
• 1:31
  fan of hers. Hosea then invites Arthur to go
• 1:35
  hunting for a bear. I don't know if you had any
• 1:39
  notes on their conversation. Yeah, my question
• 1:42
  is, we know John left, but under what circumstances?
• 1:46
  Was he kicked out of it temporarily because he
• 1:49
  did something wrong? Was he just pursuing something
• 1:51
  else? So the circumstances of why he left should
• 1:55
  be considered, even though we don't know what
• 1:57
  it is. All we just know is he's forgiven by everyone.
• 2:02
  Besides Arthur. I really want to know what John
• 2:05
  did for that year. Can we have a third game about
• 2:07
  that year, please? Arthur's line cracks me up
• 2:10
  where he's like, it's one thing to leave the
• 2:11
  boy, but to ditch us for a year? I'm like, Arthur,
• 2:15
  it is a big deal to leave your child. But also,
• 2:19
  how long ago was this? Exactly. I mean, we know
• 2:24
  that Jack was alive. I feel like it was pretty
• 2:26
  when Jack was pretty young and he's probably
• 2:28
  just freaked out. I mean, he's not old. John
• 2:32
  is a young man in this game. Not saying I condone
• 2:35
  it, but I kind of feel like that's probably what
• 2:37
  happened. But then it also seems like Arthur
• 2:39
  wasn't mad on behalf of Jack, though. I think
• 2:42
  it was more of a betrayal friendship, even though
• 2:45
  Dutch and Hosea have forgiven him. Yeah, I agree.
• 2:51
  We also hear mention of a woman named Bessie,
• 2:54
  who it sounds like was Hosea's wife? Common law
• 2:59
  wife? And they stayed together despite the gang.
• 3:02
  He says they made it work. But he also says you
• 3:06
  can't really get out of this life. I feel like
• 3:09
  that's kind of a big call back to the first game.
• 3:13
  Or is it a foreshadow to the first game? Yeah,
• 3:16
  what is it? I don't know. But it carries weight
• 3:18
  for the first game, for sure. So then they track
• 3:23
  the bear. They set a trap in the middle of the
• 3:26
  hole. Let's rearrange this trap. The bear comes
• 3:29
  out. immediately after setting that trap and
• 3:32
  hosea panics hosea the same man who says i was
• 3:36
  virtually weaned on bear meat and making it such
• 3:39
  a not a big deal to him until this moment happens
• 3:43
  and then he thanks arthur for saving his life
• 3:45
  because arthur shoots the bear but it also makes
• 3:47
  me feel like hosea probably realizes that he's
• 3:52
  not that young and quick on his feet anymore
• 3:56
  yeah I questioned him going to check the bait.
• 4:01
  That just seemed like a really bad idea. But
• 4:03
  yeah, Hosea decides to go back to camp while
• 4:05
  Arthur stays out to handle other business, which
• 4:08
  is going to find Reverend Swanson. Why is this
• 4:12
  Reverend getting so drunk? I think that's my
• 4:16
  only note about him. Fair. Yeah, Arthur finds
• 4:19
  him drunk and getting played at poker. Is this
• 4:23
  the first time we see Arthur be a little scary?
• 4:26
  Verbally wise, not in terms of like punching
• 4:29
  people. There's just something about the dialogue
• 4:32
  in this scene that hits different. I think so.
• 4:36
  I think it's more aggressive. Aggressive and
• 4:39
  protective, like threat. I don't know. Now, firstly,
• 4:42
  we ain't friends. Don't make no mistake on that
• 4:45
  subject. Now, secondly, he can't hardly see,
• 4:47
  let alone reason. Now, reasoning ain't never
• 4:50
  been one of my strong points neither, but seeing
• 4:52
  I do just fine. You want to step outside or do
• 4:55
  a business here? I liked the dialogue a lot in
• 4:58
  this scene, though. Speaking of dialogue, Arthur
• 5:01
  doing this big, tough paragraph, followed by
• 5:05
  Swanson going, can't we all just get along? And
• 5:11
  then him crawling away when Arthur sits down
• 5:13
  to beat them at poker. Yeah. Arthur did seem
• 5:19
  very enthusiastically happy that he won, though,
• 5:22
  when he was scooping in all that money. He did
• 5:25
  look very happy. I will say he makes that face
• 5:28
  every time he wins poker. This scene, though,
• 5:31
  he is like the most animated I've seen of him
• 5:34
  yet. I wonder if he's starting to just, I mean,
• 5:37
  like thaw out from the mountains. Not physically,
• 5:40
  but you know what I mean? Like life feels a little
• 5:43
  lighter now. Arthur loses track of Swanson after
• 5:47
  he crawls away and finds him on the train bridge
• 5:51
  with his foot stuck and manages to save them
• 5:54
  both just in time. Arthur must have been pissed.
• 5:58
  Moving on. We're back at camp. Uncle put that
• 6:06
  ass back under its flap. But FBM, full booty
• 6:11
  moment for those of you who are new here. And
• 6:14
  it's a nice square cutout showing his butt and
• 6:17
  crack. Very highlighted. But we had to call out
• 6:23
  Uncle shaking his ass like that. Arthur then
• 6:27
  checks in with Strauss who asks him to collect
• 6:29
  debt from people he's loaned money to. On the
• 6:32
  way out to the first one, he finds a blind man
• 6:35
  and gives him a dollar. That was kind of nice
• 6:39
  of Arthur to do so because I didn't think he
• 6:42
  would. And then the man immediately becomes a
• 6:44
  fortune teller. Yep. He says you're her. He says
• 6:50
  you're. Why can't I say that? Your whole. Wow,
• 6:58
  that is so hard for me to say. Your whole life,
• 7:00
  sir. Your whole life, sir. You have followed
• 7:03
  the wrong star. Whoa. That's a weird tongue twister.
• 7:09
  So he gets to Emerald Ranch where he's looking
• 7:12
  for the first debtor. And I ask some guy where
• 7:16
  she is. And he goes, uh -uh -uh. And that irritated
• 7:20
  me. You're not happy. It was so rude. The second
• 7:24
  guy at least went, oh, I don't know. Didn't completely
• 7:26
  just be a jackass and dismiss Arthur. Anyway,
• 7:29
  so I had to. antagonize him but he asked for
• 7:31
  it we do find her we collect the debt and then
• 7:36
  we collect the other two debts any notes on any
• 7:39
  of the debt collecting for you no i just have
• 7:42
  one which is uh the final guy the candle being
• 7:46
  lit and you noted it too oh yeah the detail of
• 7:49
  the candle getting blown out when he pushes the
• 7:51
  guy to the side is just crazy to me The fact
• 7:53
  that they even thought about that is nuts. They're
• 7:56
  also making horse poop, so the level of detail
• 7:59
  in this game is pretty on point. I might be making
• 8:03
  this up, but they might fart more when they're
• 8:05
  fat. Your horse can get fat. Really? Do you feed
• 8:08
  your horses? And too skinny. Yeah. Oh. So Arthur
• 8:13
  returns to camp where Grimshaw says that Hosea
• 8:16
  is waiting for him at Emerald Ranch when he has
• 8:18
  a chance. And when he returns the debt to the
• 8:22
  - Camp Cashbox, Strauss tells him there is one
• 8:25
  more debt to collect, Mr. Downs. Okay, final
• 8:30
  scene in the episode and maybe the best scene
• 8:34
  in the game. The most entertaining, I'll say.
• 8:38
  So Lenny rides into Camp Frantic and tells Dutch
• 8:41
  and Arthur that Micah has been arrested in Strawberry
• 8:43
  and there's talk of hanging him. Can we take
• 8:46
  a moment to discuss Arthur's reaction? I mean,
• 8:49
  I think he knew this was bound to happen. And
• 8:53
  I... I think Arthur was just also more pissed
• 8:56
  at the fact that Lenny almost got lynched. He's
• 8:59
  not having it. And I love it. They nearly lynched
• 9:02
  me. They got Micah and the sheriffs in Strawberry.
• 9:07
  And there's talk of hanging them. Here's hoping.
• 9:10
  Arthur. What? He does not want to go rescue Micah,
• 9:13
  but Dutch tells him that he has to, basically.
• 9:16
  And he says, kind of along the lines of, okay,
• 9:18
  I'll do it, but when I feel like it. But then
• 9:21
  Dutch also tells... arthur to take lenny to get
• 9:24
  drunk which is like if you're really in that
• 9:27
  much of a rush why would you offer to get someone
• 9:31
  drunk knowing they can't immediately rescue michael
• 9:34
  then i wonder if there's a little bit of like
• 9:36
  we're gonna let you sit there a minute so you
• 9:40
  don't do something stupid again but i think arthur
• 9:43
  let him sit forever yeah i noted dutch said get
• 9:47
  him drunk and also and no crazy business Isn't
• 9:51
  that a little bit of an oxymoron, Dutch? Doesn't
• 9:54
  Dutch know better to send them to get drunk?
• 9:59
  This scene is insane. I absolutely love it. I
• 10:02
  love the we're going to fight turning into we're
• 10:05
  doing the can -can. I don't like Lenny's face
• 10:08
  on the prostitute. Or on everyone else's face.
• 10:14
  It's so funny. I had to obviously blur that,
• 10:18
  so I showed you the... The unedited version so
• 10:23
  you can see how disturbing it is. Yeah. But Arthur's
• 10:26
  scream is just priceless. So good. Well, that
• 10:30
  was also right after he was peeing, right? Or
• 10:34
  right before. Yeah. Yeah. Our eyes were assaulted
• 10:37
  in this episode between Uncle's ass and prostitute
• 10:41
  Lenny hybrid. Same with Arthur. True. True. Well,
• 10:47
  on that note. Wait, I would also want to say
• 10:49
  the transitions. during this entire scene is
• 10:51
  insane it's like wild because one second they're
• 10:55
  slapping each other and then then they're drinking
• 10:58
  again and then they're waterboarding a man and
• 11:01
  then they're back to having like a jolly good
• 11:03
  time it's just whiplash then running from the
• 11:07
  cops yeah it's insane throwing up i will say
• 11:09
  i'm very nervous about what's gonna happen because
• 11:12
  we don't see lenny in the end it makes me very
• 11:15
  nervous because we know this game is about redemption
• 11:18
  and so far i don't quite know exactly what he
• 11:21
  needs to redeem himself from so my theory in
• 11:24
  this moment until i see lenny is lenny's gonna
• 11:26
  die and then arthur is going to need to redeem
• 11:30
  himself to get some redemption for letting lenny
• 11:33
  die so that's my theory very nervous i hope he
• 11:36
  doesn't die and i hope my theory is wrong yeah
• 11:39
  lenny gets tackled by the cops so arthur's taking
• 11:41
  a pp and he just runs for it which i feel like
• 11:45
  that's what lenny would want him to do But yeah,
• 11:48
  what's going to happen to Lenny? I'm very nervous
• 11:51
  about that. Young Leonard. But also, how frequent
• 11:54
  is Arthur getting drunk to the point of being
• 11:56
  just like blackout drunk? Because he says, not
• 11:58
  again. I don't really know how to wrap that scene
• 12:04
  up. But it happened. And it's glorious. Yeah.
• 12:08
  I hope you enjoyed it. It's like a fever dream
• 12:10
  for Arthur. Any more notes from you in Chapter
• 12:16
  2, Part 2? No, but I'm going to be nervous about
• 12:20
  what happens to Lenny until we can watch the
• 12:23
  next part. Agreed. We'll be back next week for
• 12:28
  the next part of Chapter 2. Audacity on one.
• 12:33
  Wait, wait, okay. Audacity on one. Three, two,
• 12:37
  one. Thank you for listening, and don't forget
• 12:39
  to send in any questions, comments, or game suggestions.
• 12:42
  You can find all our contact info on our website,
• 12:45
  replayreviewspod .com. or contact us directly
• 12:47
  through our site. Did we completely miss something?
• 12:50
  Are we way off the mark? Or do you just want
• 12:52
  us to take a deeper look at anything from the
• 12:54
  game? We'll tackle any topics you all want to
• 12:56
  hear in our season wrap -up episode. We also
• 12:58
  have a Reddit where we discuss anything we're
• 13:00
  curious about. Go take a look and let us know
• 13:02
  what you're thinking. Our theme music is Condemned
• 13:05
  by Eggie Toast. They'll play you out, and we'll
• 13:07
  be back next week.