Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Intentional Positivity
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I love you.
- 0:02Keep going podcast with George Hoss.
- 0:05For more information, please. Visit our website at
- 0:07www.medicare.gov work. That's www.mit.edu oup dot-org.
- 0:18The welcome everybody. This is I love you.
- 0:20Keep going. It is March 23rd 2023, 7:35 p.m.
- 0:27Pacific Daylight Time And I thought that we would talk a
- 0:30little bit about intentional positivity tonight.
- 0:36We've talked about Enlightenment a little bit in the for path
- 0:39model, but one of the things that's important to I think
- 0:44attend to in practice is the development of intentional
- 0:48positivity. Dan Brown famously said that the
- 0:55absence of the negative is not the addition of the positive so
- 1:00that it really is two systems. One is a kind of negative bias
- 1:04and the other is a positive capacity and you have to work to
- 1:11reduce the negativity. But then you also have to work
- 1:15to increase the positivity, you can work to Simply reduce the
- 1:19negativity and then There's an absence of the - but that
- 1:23doesn't in, then create the positive experience that you
- 1:29could use to counterbalance that are simply a place to inhabit.
- 1:36When I first met Dan, he said that his goal for practice was
- 1:40rainbow body. Rainbow body?
- 1:43Is it Tibetan practice? Where The body dissolves into
- 1:49pure light. And I asked him what it was that
- 1:53you needed in order to come into the state of rainbow body.
- 1:58And he said not a single negative thought, for a minimum
- 2:03period of 13 years, So, if we were to use that for map, how we
- 2:10doing the development of our intentional positivity,
- 2:15Christian? Might seem like a dumb question,
- 2:22but what would a negative thought mean in that contest?
- 2:30Well, an interesting idea. What is it - thought a thought
- 2:35that produces an afflictive experience might be a good way
- 2:39to think about it? So that that implies that you as
- 2:43you get more skillful, you'll understand which thoughts to
- 2:46think in which thoughts not to think, right?
- 2:50You'll suppress the habit of negative thoughts and replace it
- 2:54with the habit of positive thoughts.
- 2:59I was coming to mind for me is the my experience of going to
- 3:03the gym. You've probably heard this story
- 3:06before but I go to the gym, I have a body like everybody else
- 3:12and as the body ages you have to keep it up or it declines and
- 3:18the disadvantage of not keeping it up.
- 3:20Is that are you have less and less capacity to do things?
- 3:24And if you do, keep it up, you have more capacity to do.
- 3:28Things. And so one of the things that
- 3:32older bodies like is weight training, I know that that may
- 3:37sound barbaric, but you have to strengthen the body in order to
- 3:41keep the muscle. I can't find the word with the
- 3:50the volume of muscle that you have, so that doesn't wither.
- 3:54You, you do through weight training.
- 3:56So I go to the gym, twice a week and do weight training.
- 4:02But I used to go to the gym and I would say to myself, this is
- 4:04awful, I hate this experience. I have to do this to maintain my
- 4:07body but it's a miserable experience.
- 4:09I really wish that I didn't have to do this.
- 4:14And so I would do my workout and would take about an hour and
- 4:17then my friend who is in a much younger body who goes to the
- 4:22gym, so that he could look brilliant.
- 4:26Instead of just maintain said, well that seems like a bad way
- 4:30to work out. Why don't you just say to
- 4:36yourself I can totally do this. So, I went to the gym and I
- 4:41replaced all the negative thoughts about working out with,
- 4:44I can totally do this. Christian is pointed out, the
- 4:47word I was looking for was muscle mass, your muscle mass
- 4:50declines, and you need to keep it up.
- 4:55And then I discovered that I could do my same workout in a
- 4:58half an hour instead of an hour, which meant that a half, an hour
- 5:04of my workout was overcoming my own resistance to doing the
- 5:09workout. Which was happening in this
- 5:11process of thinking and simply moving it into the different
- 5:16thought. Patterns saved it.
- 5:20A lot of effort of just overcoming resistance.
- 5:25My trainer for a while. Was going what happened to the
- 5:28person who used to come workout? Because the constant spewing of
- 5:34negativity was replace. All right, what's next?
- 5:39That making sense. We do have agency in how we
- 5:45regulate our emotions, and all of these things are, really what
- 5:49we're really talking about is regulating emotion.
- 5:52We have a reaction to the conditions of the present
- 5:55moment. If there's an emotional response
- 5:57that exceeds the window of Tolerance that we have an
- 6:00emotional event that needs to be regulated and we typically
- 6:03regulate that through thinking. So we think a thought that has a
- 6:07regulating quality to it. It.
- 6:09So another way you might think about this is using only
- 6:13positive strategies for regulating emotional
- 6:17experiences, that exceed your capacity, just to be with an
- 6:21emotional experience, an emotional experience that
- 6:25exceeds the window of Tolerance, window of Tolerance is a, it's a
- 6:29phrase that Dan Siegel invented in talking about emotional
- 6:33experience. If you have an emotional
- 6:35reaction to the present moment, which Falls within your
- 6:38tolerance for Kind of emotional experience that you don't have
- 6:42to regulate it. It just comes and goes you have
- 6:45a reaction to the present moment, which exceeds your
- 6:48capacity, for intensity of that emotion, that you have an
- 6:52emotional event that needs to be regulated.
- 6:54And then we typically have Associated already.
- 6:58Thought processes that regulate those kinds of experiences.
- 7:02So each kind of experience has a thought process that's already
- 7:06associated with it, which just Earns on to regulate the
- 7:11emotions. So that training of intentional
- 7:14positivity is meant to replace the negative thoughts that might
- 7:17be generated to regulate the experience of emotion with
- 7:21intentionally positive. Thoughts to regulate the same
- 7:24experience of emotion. But you have to train yourself
- 7:28to do in order for the body mind to just do that.
- 7:32Otherwise, you'll recognize that the negative thought has arisen
- 7:36in the context of emotional regulation, you'll need to
- 7:39suppress it in, replace it with something positive.
- 7:43And as you do that over time replacing more and more of the -
- 7:47strategies with positive strategies, the mind is less
- 7:51inclined to think a negative thought that making sense.
- 7:57Christian. Forgive my devil's advocacy.
- 8:03But it seems like this kind of practice could have a very avoid
- 8:08enough to be the devil canted piece of whatever.
- 8:19It seems obvious to me that in if you practice a certain way
- 8:23could have a very avoidant flavor, you know, like just you
- 8:26know like a good vibes only attitude like couldn't don't I
- 8:33don't like Supreme Court Pollyanna ISM.
- 8:37Right right? Where I'm I'm not going to like
- 8:42I'm going to hyper avoid negative thoughts because I
- 8:46guess I guess the idea behind that would be that they
- 8:52Contradict my world view or something like that but yeah.
- 8:56And we make a distinction between reaction to the present
- 8:59moment. And the regulating thought.
- 9:08So we're not suppressing from Consciousness, our reaction to
- 9:11the present moment when we have a reaction to the present
- 9:14moment, which exceeds the window of Tolerance were training, the
- 9:17mind to respond to that. In a positive strategy rather
- 9:21than in - or afflictive strategy, it doesn't mean that
- 9:26we're suppressing awareness of the reaction itself.
- 9:33Okay. Yeah, so so not so becoming
- 9:36aware of - narratives that you use to regulate emotions and not
- 9:42using those, right? Now, what do we begin then?
- 9:48To take apart the though, the reactive thought to the present
- 9:54moment, which is not a repetitive self-generated
- 9:58thought that's meant to be regulating.
- 10:02Why is it that you would have a negative response to conditions
- 10:06of the present moment and not frame it in some way that was
- 10:10positive or beneficial? Maybe we should switch to the
- 10:17word beneficial. They mean, different things of
- 10:20beneficial response to the conditions of the present
- 10:23moment. Instead of an effective response
- 10:25to the conditions of the present moment. then we would be talking
- 10:29about the database which we rely on to create our understanding
- 10:34of conceptual reality, which is what we experience as the cell
- 10:40and How might we develop the perceptual database in such a
- 10:49way that we could respond in a beneficial way to whatever the
- 10:53circumstances of the present moment are rather than in an
- 10:57afflictive way? Which is not in any way of
- 11:01avoiding the experience of the present moment, but training the
- 11:05mind to respond in a way that skillful and beneficial.
- 11:13What we mostly do as children, of course, is watch how the
- 11:18caregivers that we had respond to things and then that begins
- 11:23the basic structure of this database that we use.
- 11:27I'm using the word database Loosely this conditioned
- 11:34response that we have been, truly used to create the
- 11:38experience of conceptual reality, right?
- 11:41So we have the capacity to Something we have the object
- 11:46that can be sense, when there's contact consciousness of the
- 11:49sensing experience arises, that's not the self-conscious.
- 11:53It's an it's not known to the self experience.
- 11:57He had its unconscious using the question psychological term.
- 12:06It's evaluated for urgency. Does it need?
- 12:09Immediate attention, is that neutral, does it not matter
- 12:12whether it gets attention is It Pleasant and is there time for a
- 12:18pleasant experience? We know from mapping brain time
- 12:21that things that are deemed urgent process in 3/8 of a
- 12:25second. Go to the head of the line for
- 12:28processing. And require half the intensity
- 12:32of something that's Pleasant. So twice, the intensity.
- 12:36And the duration for something pleasant is a half a second, not
- 12:403/8 of a second. So, Almost twice as long twice
- 12:46as intense in order for it to enter into a conscious
- 12:49awareness, which is the self experience witness again.
- 12:55Then it's compared to the perceptual database and if
- 12:58there's experience that's already in the database are
- 13:02conditioning and matches closely enough, that meaning is attached
- 13:06to the undifferentiated, Ultimate Reality rolls out into
- 13:12conceptual Actual reality. So that that experience of
- 13:17what's already happened that we've already responded to
- 13:20informed the experience of the present moment.
- 13:25And then part of that process is the intention for an action in
- 13:28response to how we've made up our experience of the present
- 13:32moment. And once we take the action and
- 13:37track the outcome of, taking that action, that's all
- 13:40remembered and stored in the database.
- 13:43For the next time, it might be activated by the conditions of
- 13:47the present moment. That's the building of our
- 13:50experience and what to do in response to that.
- 13:56Or experiences that unfold Revenge that unfold.
- 13:59Is that making sense? If you're not mindful it, just
- 14:06rolls unconsciously, automatically respond, based on
- 14:09how you've created the meaning of the moment based on the
- 14:15experiences that you've already already had in those types of
- 14:20conditions. if you hit a novel condition where there aren't any
- 14:27entries in the database, then the imagination kicks in and
- 14:31decides what what it really means and how to respond to it,
- 14:35and that attracts the outcome of that, and that's stored in the
- 14:39database that perceptual database of our conditioning
- 14:45Still making sense. If you grow up in a household
- 14:55where the automatic response to thumb some things was an
- 14:59expression of anger, you might say that that was an effective
- 15:03response that you could then train yourself out of an
- 15:08automatic anger response into something different.
- 15:12The quantum is response or an inquiry response.
- 15:15The Curiosity response instead of an anger response.
- 15:21The reason that the the training is necessary is because it
- 15:26happens so fast. That whole process, usually
- 15:32happens before it enters into Consciousness.
- 15:35So the unconscious mind that Christian is or that Jaden has
- 15:41or that Joanna in is form. The response and it rolls into
- 15:48action. And just as you're about to take
- 15:50the action, it enters into Consciousness and you have shins
- 15:55and used to say, 3/8 of a second before the terrorists, take over
- 15:59the body. If you're already in the action
- 16:02and if you're not perfectly Mindful and evaluate what the
- 16:05action is, you're already in the action by the time you recognize
- 16:09it's happening. And if the mind is conditioned
- 16:13to respond and afflictive way, you're already into an Afflicted
- 16:17response by the time, it enters Consciousness and you have to
- 16:21squash it or you create the karmic thread.
- 16:24That is attached attaches to that - afflictive response, even
- 16:32though it's a conditioned response even though that's what
- 16:35your family system trained you to do, because that's how your
- 16:40family system understood. What an appropriate response
- 16:44would be. That all making sense so far.
- 16:49Christian. So there's like there's a couple
- 16:53threads of kind of going at once and so, if you're measuring, The
- 17:03quality of your response to something.
- 17:06I think you only have either your emotion that comes up or
- 17:11you have the conscious response, you're going to make that comes
- 17:14up. But you can't understand like
- 17:17the karma of it, the consequence until you've actually chosen the
- 17:21response or not. Right?
- 17:24And so if there is an afflictive or a beneficial action that you
- 17:29take How do you actually know if you're not, you're not truly
- 17:34going to know the effect of the thing.
- 17:35Like sometimes, sometimes it'll be obvious if you're going to
- 17:38say something that would just be a faux pas but like or works,
- 17:43right? And and I, you know, I certainly
- 17:46wish I had this skill and my time machine.
- 17:50But how are you actually? Like where are you looking at
- 17:56your experience to understand what is beneficial right?
- 18:04Are you looking at your emotional response or are you
- 18:07trying to predict the karmic outcome of it?
- 18:12How do you actually judge like what's the feedback loop to
- 18:15learn the correct lesson? So then we're really talking
- 18:20about is the development of the Brahma of a horror as the heart
- 18:24practices. Is and we're looking at the far
- 18:27enemy of the cultivation of these intentional positive
- 18:34States and think of them as the afflictive responses.
- 18:39So in loving, kindness practice, the fire enemies, anger hatred,
- 18:45in compassion practice. The far enemy is cruelty in the
- 18:51practice of sympathetic Joy. The far enemy is Envy or
- 18:54jealousy. Elysee and in the practice of
- 18:57equanimity, the far enemy is craving a version or
- 19:00unconsciousness. And so, you'll notice as you're
- 19:04tracking these states, as they arise, if it pulls into any one
- 19:08of those, then we're looking at an Afflicted State and then we
- 19:12have the antidote to those afflictive states which is the
- 19:16attentional development of the positive alternative.
- 19:22Positive opposite. You might say, So, I guess
- 19:26embedded in the idea of the realm of the hores is that all
- 19:30of them contain some kind of inherent wisdom, right?
- 19:34But you're not building like a positive delusion by doing them,
- 19:37but that actually, you'll be operating more skillfully from
- 19:41these So if you look at say, loving kindness practice the
- 19:49Folly word for that is meta. You're cultivating a view, which
- 19:57I like to call kind open-hearted curious because it's inclining
- 20:03towards something. And so you're holding a view of
- 20:06that. You notice anger rising and you
- 20:08push the anger of you out and replace it with the
- 20:11loving-kindness view that you can examine the conditions of
- 20:16the present moment with a kind of open kind curiosity, rather
- 20:21than with your hatred. The near enemy of loving
- 20:29kindness is sentimentality, which is what you're talking
- 20:32about, the pollyannaish a distortion of experience or
- 20:38events without actually examining them.
- 20:42Whereas in the active state of loving-kindness, you're open to
- 20:46the experience of what's happening in your able to
- 20:48examine it without the mind being clouded with by anger.
- 20:57You know, the Buddha said, one expression of anger could
- 21:01annihilate a thousand years of kindness?
- 21:05So you can inquire kindly about something that's bothering you
- 21:09or disturbing you and that that it appears difficult to you,
- 21:13where if you respond with anger, you could damage the
- 21:17relationship in such a way that it's not repairable.
- 21:22With compassion, of course, your opening to The Suffering
- 21:25experience of other people, not repelling it through an
- 21:31expression of Cruelty. One of the.
- 21:37Couples. Therapist we worked with gauged,
- 21:47How likely it would be. That a couple's relationship
- 21:51could be salvaged in therapy based by the expressions of
- 21:55contempt. Contempt, is a kind of cold
- 21:59devaluing anger. That one person in the
- 22:02relationship, expressed the other because it's almost
- 22:07impossible for somebody to recover from.
- 22:10Contempt where you're being judged by somebody as morally
- 22:14unfit? Making sense.
- 22:20So that cruelty that comes from, that kind of expression.
- 22:28Whereas with compassion, of course, your opening to The
- 22:31Suffering experience of somebody else, helping them to
- 22:35emotionally regulate. And in the process of them,
- 22:38emotionally regulating hopefully, that their, their
- 22:41cognitive mind will come back online, and they can be
- 22:44collaborative in solving the problem that you're facing,
- 22:48whereas, if the if they're overwhelmed by emotion,
- 22:51overwhelmed, by the impulse for cruelty, then the Good advice.
- 22:59And it's likely offline. They're just responding from
- 23:02conditioning. Far enemy of sympathetic Joy is
- 23:08Envy or jealousy. What happens when you find that
- 23:12you're envious of somebody's material.
- 23:15Possessions or social position or jealous of their personal
- 23:18relationships and have distorting of your reality?
- 23:22Is that whereas if you can come into a place of joyfulness, In
- 23:29our culture, which is so goal. Oriented, and so
- 23:34materialistically oriented, most of the celebrations that we do
- 23:38are around achieving some kind of social position or status and
- 23:47It's less often. I find that people are
- 23:50celebratory of discovery of something meaningful.
- 23:55So much of the inside path is really organized around the
- 23:59insights of understanding the nature of the human condition.
- 24:04And It's unusual that those kinds of things are celebrated
- 24:10as opposed to a promotion or a new place to live or whatever it
- 24:16is. You know, I grew up in a
- 24:24household where every year, my dad got it was every year or
- 24:29every other year, he got a new car, I was part of the status.
- 24:38Declaration. The new car smell would wear
- 24:45off. And then the desire for another
- 24:47car would come on. And it really did appear that he
- 24:53was driving around. It is new car shopping for the
- 24:55next new car rather than inhabiting the, the car that he
- 25:00was in so, Being joyful for people achieving the things that
- 25:13have meaning to them. When we talk, when we used to
- 25:16talk about this 20 years ago, it was only being joyful for
- 25:21people's spiritual attainments and not for material to humans,
- 25:25but I find we should be joyful for people pursuing the things
- 25:30that have meaning to them. And not imposing on them are
- 25:34structure of what would be meaningful or what would be
- 25:36meaningful. They are pursuing the things
- 25:39that they need to Define. And out what they need to know
- 25:42and that's what we're celebrating for them.
- 25:47And then hopefully it's a mutual relationship where they then
- 25:52celebrate those things for you. So you have that sense of
- 25:56acknowledgement that that you've pursued something and found it
- 26:01out. And then Equanimity, is this
- 26:05this basis of evenness. The near enemy of equanimity is
- 26:15Detachment. And so what we understand about
- 26:17Equanimity of the senses it's fully engaged, it's Lively and
- 26:21energetic and it's perfectly balanced.
- 26:25It's not cut off and detached and flat and unfeeling.
- 26:31Well, the image I always liked, is the surfer, right?
- 26:35Have you ever watch those films or videos of the guys or gals
- 26:41that go out and surf a 60 foot wave?
- 26:44It's like this giant wall of water and there's a little
- 26:46surfboard sticking out. And it's really super dangerous.
- 26:53But you see this sense of totally locked into the
- 26:56experience of these tiny little movements to contain the
- 27:00balance. And there's this Roar of energy,
- 27:02that's kind of the way that I think about equity.
- 27:07And then of course the the far enemy of equities, getting swept
- 27:11up in craving a version and unconscious.
- 27:14The unruly mind which is a place of often great suffering.
- 27:26One of the things that you may have noticed about life, even in
- 27:30the, the relative affluence of most of us in the west who
- 27:37practice. Or even the outright effluence,
- 27:44is that life is still hard and still challenging, we still can
- 27:50get rocked into quite negative points of view and the suffering
- 27:55around that can be quite intense.
- 27:59And so we want to really understand that we are in charge
- 28:05of the thoughts that we allow the mind to think and that we
- 28:07can we can shift out of negative thoughts that are regulating and
- 28:17negative reactions the conditions of the present moment
- 28:21of the construction of conceptual realities which are
- 28:25afflictive. And that's a matter of practice
- 28:30in doing that. So, recognizing mines dates, and
- 28:34then developing agency to hold the Mind state that you want to
- 28:39hold represents a skillfulness in how you participate in the
- 28:46experience of the present moment as it unfolds.
- 28:54I like to practice this around mine States.
- 28:59So we have a discussion of what met wet hard practices and dry
- 29:04hard practices. In wet hard practices were
- 29:08intentionally developing a positive emotional experience
- 29:14that that's in the body. So we're in the body and we're
- 29:17generating through thought processes intentionally
- 29:22enjoyable or Pleasant. Emotional state.
- 29:28Which we can use, then to regulate.
- 29:30So a training of regulating the experience of the present moment
- 29:34when we need to by generating positive emotional states, I'm
- 29:39trying that it's more concentration oriented and more
- 29:43around the exploration of view. So, I think that this is
- 29:49important and is productive in the pursuit of Enlightenment
- 29:54because view is one of the things that you need to really
- 29:57understand. If you're going to go into that
- 29:59end of practice. What view are you holding?
- 30:04Is the mind to Quantum is so that there's no Distortion.
- 30:07The views of the data that you're collecting is then
- 30:10transformed into a fairly accurate reflection of what's
- 30:16Happening. painting or can you recognize when the mind is in
- 30:21Anger, viewers sadness, viewer, fearful view or excited viewer,
- 30:27loving view or whatever the view is We also do a lot of
- 30:32attachment work around here, so it's we like to also understand
- 30:36when your attachment view is active.
- 30:40So attached review, shuts down the exploration capacity and
- 30:46creates the sense of urgency around, seeking proximity to
- 30:51somebody, who will protect you, somebody who will help you feel
- 30:56safe. but then we could also talk about the loving, kindness
- 31:03view, the compassion view the sympathetic, Joy View and the
- 31:08Equanimity of you and how that changes things, how that if you
- 31:15think about it, Ultimate Reality is the raw data that you take in
- 31:20and then you process that and and flip it into conceptual
- 31:25reality. In between Ultimate Reality and
- 31:30conceptual realities where the view goes, it's like wearing the
- 31:35metaphor I like is when we were kids and we would go skiing, we
- 31:39would put on these goggles that bright orange or a bright yellow
- 31:45filter on them and you put them on and immediately be aware that
- 31:49the whole color field shifted. But then you'd skilled at skiing
- 31:53down a couple of hills and you'd forget that that was what the
- 31:56view was and you would be operating as if that was how the
- 32:00world look. It wasn't, until you took them
- 32:03off at you recognized that you had been in a distortion of what
- 32:08was actually there. Now, the purpose of the that was
- 32:11to create contrast in the snow so that you could see the Moguls
- 32:15easier. But it did color shift
- 32:20everything in the mind, went to correct it.
- 32:23Then then lost track of it. And you were just operating in
- 32:26this distorted perception and that's what these these views or
- 32:32these mind states do and if you can't recognize them you wander
- 32:37around as if conceptual reality were unfiltered and that that
- 32:40was actually what was happening. so that if you, if you Never had
- 32:47an issue with anger. Anger was one of my early
- 32:51challenges and the anger view is there.
- 32:54Everything would be problematic. but it wouldn't appear as if I
- 32:59were angry to myself, it would just appear as if everything
- 33:03were problematic And then, so the begin this process of being
- 33:08able to recognize what a few is there.
- 33:10That's the advantage. I think of practicing the dry
- 33:17Divine. Abodes Christian.
- 33:23What if this is your experience? I have this hunch that like the
- 33:29idea of like a viewer about Wednesday is a little tough but
- 33:33I've been punched that. It's not that easy to see a view
- 33:38or a mind state if you're not used to it, if you're just in
- 33:41that but that you can see it more clearly and shifting
- 33:44between views. So like the arising of anger or
- 33:48the diminishing of Banger and the contrast of that.
- 33:51But if you're just in Anger, all the Time.
- 33:54Like, you know, you'd be like the fish and water or like, was
- 33:57that your experience in becoming aware of that?
- 34:00Well I wouldn't be angry all the time and when I began to pay
- 34:06attention to what view is present.
- 34:11So part of this is also going to be related to your conditioning
- 34:19your and in particular, your attachment conditioning, one of
- 34:23the things about Out secure people is that when they were
- 34:27children, their caregivers ask them over and over again.
- 34:31What was going on with them? What were they feeling?
- 34:34What were they thinking? How are they viewing things?
- 34:37And so that they would have to learn to understand what was
- 34:42happening. So parent might say, I can't
- 34:44figure out what's going on with you.
- 34:46You seem angry, are you angry? And then the child would have to
- 34:50investigate whether or not they thought they were angry or not.
- 34:53You seem Really sad. Are you sad?
- 34:55And then the child would have to investigate, you seem really
- 34:58happy what's going on with making you so happy so that a
- 35:02child would have to investigate what that was, right?
- 35:06What was the expression that they were making in that moment?
- 35:10That somebody else could interpret as happy?
- 35:12And how did they know that that was happening?
- 35:15And if that happened enough, you would have already learned how
- 35:18to do this. If that didn't happen enough for
- 35:22you, then you wouldn't necessarily Sara Lee know, or be
- 35:26able to distinguish one from another.
- 35:29So if you did have that experience from your caregivers
- 35:33and you can do it, then we begin to just train in different kinds
- 35:38of Mind States, so that you have a wide arrange of capacity to
- 35:43track them. But if that didn't happen for
- 35:46you, then you begin to ask these questions of your experience.
- 35:50Now, what am I feeling? How is that affecting the way
- 35:55that I experienced this? If I'm angry, is it distorting?
- 35:59My perception of what's happening?
- 36:02If I'm happy, is that destroying my perception of what's
- 36:05Happening? We tend to be more pliable, more
- 36:10gullible when we are happy. So that somebody who can create
- 36:14a sense of happiness in us, has a better chance of manipulating
- 36:18us and somebody who makes us angry at making sense, or maybe
- 36:23anger is a good way to do it. Can you track your emotions?
- 36:28Well, enough? And do you have good Clarity
- 36:30between the your emotional reaction to the present moment?
- 36:34The self-generated emotion, that's meant to regulate that
- 36:38the somatosensation emotional experience.
- 36:40If you have that and also the empathetic experience of other
- 36:44people and can you track all of those in real time so that you
- 36:48can really pull this whole thing apart and see the pieces
- 36:52including what mine State you're in.
- 36:55And then do you have agency, you develop the capacity for
- 36:59compassion. So that when you notice the Mind
- 37:03inclining toward a cruel, mind that you can immediately replace
- 37:06that with a compassionate or anger with loving-kindness,
- 37:13making sense and being jealousy with sympathetic Joy or Craving
- 37:19aversion and unconsciousness with equanimity.
- 37:25So then we practice the bottom of a hair has, or the Divine
- 37:31abodes to develop capacity. Not only to recognize the Mind
- 37:36state, but then to have agency to monitor what's happening and
- 37:40replace afflictive states with beneficial States in real time
- 37:44all day long, as we're moving around taking care of the
- 37:48day-to-day that making sense. We usually start practice with
- 38:02an easy person. So if you're talking about
- 38:07loving kindness, practice and easy person, and loving kindness
- 38:11practice, is somebody who wouldn't you think of them?
- 38:13The Mind naturally inclines toward this.
- 38:19Particular View. Sad.
- 38:24I indicate used to call say that.
- 38:26It was always cool. Always kind.
- 38:30Open Friendly, curious. Always cool means there's an
- 38:37absence of the heat of anger. There is an absence of the heat
- 38:42of Desire. So desire for whatever it is
- 38:54that you're craving and then the anger that arises in frustration
- 39:03around trying to get the things that you want craving of things.
- 39:10And that anger is the far enemy. Always cool, always kind.
- 39:21Open Friendly and because it is inclining towards something.
- 39:25I like to use the word curious for that.
- 39:27Now, in my family system, curiosity is cool.
- 39:32It's not, it's not hot, but I have had people come to me and
- 39:36say that in their family systems curiosity was hot and so that
- 39:42wouldn't be really what I mean. But it's an inclining towards
- 39:45something and said, it's a, it's a desire to explore.
- 39:53Figure something out. Without heat. so, and then The
- 40:02second category is practicing for self.
- 40:07We have a working model of self each time, the sense of self
- 40:10arises, this working model of self activates.
- 40:15And the way that we recognize the pattern of self is because
- 40:19all of these little gists that are associated, with the working
- 40:21model of self activate, if you have a working model of self
- 40:27that's filled with a lot of negative states in the way that
- 40:30you recognize yourself is through, a lot of negative
- 40:33States self-consciousness, an aversive reaction to the sense
- 40:38of self, That is the seed of self-hatred because each time
- 40:43the sense of self arises. You find yourself in a negative
- 40:47State and then to the aversion to being constantly in a
- 40:51negative state, begins to arise. And then when the sense of self
- 40:54arises, there's a strong aversive response to it.
- 40:59The way into self-love or is to Simply load up working model of
- 41:05self with tons of positive States.
- 41:08So that when the sense of self arises, it's a pleasant
- 41:11experience at a new Joy. You enjoy having the experience
- 41:16of love yourself. So we tend to work in the
- 41:19beginning, touching into an easy person to establish the Mind
- 41:24State and then work with the self when we were on retreat, in
- 41:29Myanmar, we spent three days on the easy person.
- 41:34So three days of sitting and the recommendation was that we spent
- 41:39an hour on each person that we know to see whether or not they
- 41:44were reliable and causing the Mind state to Arise and we were
- 41:49systematically who suggested to us to systematically.
- 41:54Go through everyone we knew and just sat with them for an hour
- 41:59to see whether the Mind inclined toward this loving, kindness
- 42:03place or didn't and then to create a short list of people
- 42:07that were reliable and causing the mind to inclined toward
- 42:11loving kindness. Once you have the short list,
- 42:16when you want to generate the mindset of of the kindness, you
- 42:19just have to think of them because the working model of
- 42:21themselves will cause that mind-state to rise in the
- 42:25creation of the experience of. So that's where you begin to
- 42:29develop a sense of agency, then activating the easy person than
- 42:35activating the sense of self so that you can begin to associate
- 42:39through the process of memory, the positive states with the And
- 42:44self and do that practice enough until when the sense of self,
- 42:49arises almost all of the time or all of the time, it's a pleasant
- 42:55experience to have your sense of self or Rising.
- 43:02So why don't we do a little bit of practice tonight with the
- 43:06easy person and then shifting to the sense of self?
- 43:11So go ahead and settle in. Ringing the bell.
- 43:17So any comments or questions about that, Christian So in
- 43:24Buddhism, there's like six senses, right?
- 43:26There's the five senses and the mind if I understand that.
- 43:30So how do we so we have to be able to understand a view
- 43:35through? Any of those six senses but
- 43:39you're saying it's not, it doesn't reside within those or
- 43:42like. How does that?
- 43:44How does that work? Well, you explore the appearance
- 43:52of conceptual reality. so the men of a positive sense you use
- 43:57for passing her to deconstruct the appearance of conceptual
- 44:02reality and you could explore that in any of the sense, Gates,
- 44:09So it's kind of mediated through the sense of mind.
- 44:14Right. How do you know something is
- 44:21something? How do you know you're having
- 44:24the experience that you're having?
- 44:25That's the investigation? And is the reflection of
- 44:34Ultimate Reality in conceptual reality.
- 44:37Without distortion The metaphor that the Buddha used was the
- 44:45mirror, so the bowl of 2600 years ago.
- 44:48The mirror was a dark glazed bowl that was filled with water.
- 44:54He said if the Mind were equanimous is as if the water
- 44:58were still in clear. So the reflection off the
- 45:01surface of the water that's conceptual.
- 45:03Reality is a an accurate representation of what the
- 45:07sensing experience is. But if the Mind were filled with
- 45:12lust, it was as if the water were dyed a bright color that
- 45:17when you see the reflection off the surface of the water, it
- 45:20seems Vivid and filled with color that is in.
- 45:23Actually what's happening? It's because the mind is that
- 45:26way that the mind is filled with anger, it says the water were
- 45:31boiling so that the just the perception on the surface, the
- 45:35reflection of what is coming in off the surface of the mind is
- 45:39very Thwarted, the mind is restless and agitated.
- 45:43It says, if a breeze were blowing across the surface of
- 45:46the water causing ripples, if the mine were filled with Sloth
- 45:50and torpor zazz. If it were overgrown with algae,
- 45:53if the mind was filled with skeptical doubt, it says, if the
- 45:56water were muddied, So that the the reflective surface of the
- 46:02bind depending on whether it's a Quantum is or whether it's
- 46:06distorted by a particular view or mine State changes.
- 46:11The way that Ultimate Reality appears in when it's made into
- 46:17conceptual reality Now we often think of visuals for that if
- 46:22you're seeing person we really rely on how the world appears to
- 46:28us in that visual Town below that we create.
- 46:32But also understand there's auditory happening and there's a
- 46:34felt sense of the body that's happening that creates the
- 46:38realness of it and without all three of them coming together
- 46:42that the appearance of reality is not as substantial.
- 46:47That making sense. So, when the mind is angry,
- 46:53distorts the visual, it distorts the auditory and also there's
- 46:57feeling behind it in the body which creates a vividness of it.
- 47:05So we want to explore that and understand how we know something
- 47:08appears to be real to us, and it's going to be some
- 47:12combination of visual auditory and the felt sense of the body.
- 47:22So there's a guy lives on my block and he has a car which has
- 47:27a car alarm. and, You can hear them turn it on.
- 47:35But almost all of the time when he turns it on, it just goes off
- 47:38and starts honking that he turns it off and then he slams the
- 47:43door of the car again and then he turns out again and then it
- 47:46just goes off and this can go on for 20 minutes until he finally
- 47:50gets the car settled enough that it doesn't go off.
- 47:54But then a car drives by and it goes off. it becomes
- 47:59increasingly annoying, even though it's the same horn,
- 48:03honking Right. So anger creates comes in and
- 48:11distorts the the outrage of it, when it's actually just a horn
- 48:23that makes sense. You could hear it just as the
- 48:27horn. And it's just the horn, but when
- 48:32the view comes in and you, you add to that moral outrage, that
- 48:35disperse, it is subjecting the entire neighborhood, this car
- 48:39horn, becomes something else. So Saturday is the fourth of the
- 48:51level one that we were doing in Pacific Time. 92. 115 on April
- 48:591st, we're starting a level one in Central European Time.
- 49:05So, it's 2 p.m. in Europe. We're doing it from 2 p.m. to
- 49:146:15 p.m. for four Saturdays. If you know, somebody in Europe
- 49:19or you're in that time or actually, or on the east coast
- 49:23and want to do it in the morning, you could do that.
- 49:26Or if you're a real early bird, it starts at five in the morning
- 49:29here in Pacific time. Then we have a level-two
- 49:35starting in April if you want to take that on.
- 49:41And then in June, I'm doing afford a level one in person, in
- 49:45Utrecht in the Netherlands. If you want to come to that,
- 49:49that should be I think a fun thing to do and then in July
- 49:55we're going to start a level 2 that's in Central European Time.
- 50:01So 7:30 to 9:30 Central in time, p.m. if you want to do a level 2
- 50:07in that time zone, That's what's coming up for the next part of
- 50:12your. Take a look at it.
- 50:13Most of that's on the website. I offer this class on it.
- 50:21Donna base is done, is the Pali word for generosity.
- 50:24So I offer the cat class feeling but I do hope that if your
- 50:27resource that you can make a donation that you do, there's a
- 50:30link on the website to do that. Any amount is appreciated, it
- 50:35helps support me. And also the work that a group
- 50:37is doing really appreciate your practice.
- 50:39Thanks for coming, it's good to see you and we'll see you soon.
- 50:44I know. I know.