Latest / It's Only In Trying / S2 Ep. 5 - Table Stakes & The Bubble
Transcript
- 0:04Tara: Okay, picture this.
- 0:06Tara: You're at a conference, listening to a presentation, and the suggestion is one of those things that sounds almost too easy.
- 0:12Tara: Before your team sends out a letter, run it through AI.
- 0:15Tara: Quick once over, it catches the mistakes and it makes the writing better.
- 0:19Tara: Done.
- 0:20Tara: Honestly, when I heard it, it barely even registered as advice.
- 0:24Tara: It felt like a given.
- 0:26Tara: And then a manager in the room brought up the catch.
- 0:30Tara: Her people are buried.
- 0:32Tara: A lot of them are new to the corporate world.
- 0:35Tara: And adding learn AI and use it regularly to a training list that's already huge is actually not a small task.
- 0:43Tara: And that's when I stopped and thought, oh, oh no, I think I might be in a bubble.
- 0:52Tara: This is its only in trying, a place to stop asking and start being.
- 0:58Tara: Let's go.
- 1:00Tara: So here's the thing.
- 1:02Tara: I use AI pretty regularly.
- 1:06Tara: I've spent years in rooms full of people who work and think a lot like I do.
- 1:11Tara: So when someone said just run it through AI, my brain filed it under table stakes.
- 1:16Tara: Obvious baseline, the thing everybody does, right?
- 1:21Tara: And a manager who's actually out there with the people doing the work just calmly said, it's not that easy.
- 1:28Tara: Not because people aren't capable, but because they're already carrying so much.
- 1:34Tara: And I realized I might be sitting in a bit of an ivory tower, walking around thinking a bunch of skills that are normal to me aren't normal to everyone else.
- 1:45Tara: Now I want to be really clear.
- 1:47Tara: I'm not telling you this to make you feel bad for me, and I definitely don't want anyone to feel small or bad about themselves.
- 1:53Tara: So this isn't a shame story.
- 1:54Tara: It's a, huh.
- 1:57Tara: I didn't know that story.
- 2:00Tara: So then I was actually the speaker in the very next presentation, and someone asked whether it would be helpful for reps to ask certain things on calls with customers.
- 2:10Tara: And I said, well, yeah, that would be helpful.
- 2:14Tara: But I've also heard from several managers at this conference that their people are buried.
- 2:19Tara: So I want us to be mindful of the expectations we're putting on our front line.
- 2:23Tara: And I think it's on us as leaders to be the example and give more proactive training.
- 2:31Tara: If I had not heard the other manager's perspective just before my own presentation, I don't think I would have answered so thoughtfully.
- 2:40Tara: Her simple statement changed my advice immediately.
- 2:44Tara: I don't have to wait a week to think about it.
- 2:47Tara: I just had to hear one person tell the truth from her corner of the world.
- 2:53Tara: Which brings me to the thing about bubbles.
- 2:57Tara: You can't see them from the inside.
- 3:00Tara: That's kind of the whole design.
- 3:02Tara: Everything in there just looks like the whole complete version of the world.
- 3:09Tara: So here's how the bubble hurts us and why we can't see it.
- 3:14Tara: There's this concept called the curse of knowledge.
- 3:17Tara: It was put on the map by economists Colin Kammerer, George Lowenstein, and Martin Weber.
- 3:23Tara: In their 1989 paper, the economists found that better informed agents do not fully appreciate the informational advantage they possess.
- 3:32Tara: Meaning, people who were better informed couldn't set aside what they knew, even when that additional information might work against them.
- 3:40Tara: Something I picked up as I read the paper is that the authors mention expert wine tasters as a way to compare their study to other real-world examples where the curse of knowledge may come into play.
- 3:52Tara: So, for example, a high-quality wine might end up being overpriced because the expert understands the full spectrum of good versus bad wine.
- 4:02Tara: But the problem is that the wine taster may then compare the high-quality wine to a low-quality wine and might underprice the quote lower quality wine.
- 4:14Tara: Meaning if the curse applies, the fancy bottles get overpriced and the cheap stuff underpriced, because the expert's price reflects quality a regular buyer can't taste.
- 4:30Tara: So basically, once you know something, you can't really unknow it.
- 4:37Tara: And that makes it really hard to picture what it's like to not know it.
- 4:43Tara: That is my table stakes moment right there.
- 4:46Tara: The thought that everyone is using AI.
- 4:50Tara: And there's a real-world number that goes with it.
- 4:53Tara: In Pew's 2026 survey, about half of US adults said they use AI chatbots.
- 5:00Tara: Roughly a quarter use them every day, and about half don't use them at all.
- 5:05Tara: So if you're in that daily quarter like I am, it can feel like everyone's doing it.
- 5:11Tara: And really, they're just not.
- 5:15Tara: A couple caveats to what I just said.
- 5:17Tara: That 1989 study was business students in trading experiments, not workplaces.
- 5:24Tara: And it says nothing about education or privilege.
- 5:27Tara: The paper actually explains why a blind spot is invisible.
- 5:31Tara: Connecting it to my conference is me kind of connecting the dots.
- 5:36Tara: And that Pew number is people telling a survey just whether or not they use AI, not how well or how comfortably they use it.
- 5:45Tara: Okay, so the bubble hides things.
- 5:49Tara: But what actually happens when we open up?
- 5:52Tara: Sociologist Ronald Burt studied 673 supply chain managers at a large American electronics company.
- 6:00Tara: He asked them for the one thing they'd change, then had two senior leaders rate the ideas without knowing who wrote them.
- 6:09Tara: His hypothesis, right at the top of this article, is that people who stand near the gaps between groups are at higher risk of having good ideas.
- 6:19Tara: Like, that's a bad thing.
- 6:22Tara: His reasoning is that opinions and habits are more alike inside a group than between groups.
- 6:29Tara: So people connected across groups have seen more alternatives.
- 6:35Tara: And those managers were more likely to speak up, less likely to get dismissed, and more likely to have their ideas rated as valuable.
- 6:45Tara: So something totally ordinary in one group can be brand new and useful in another.
- 6:53Tara: That's exactly what happened in that room.
- 6:56Tara: To that manager, My People Are Buried was just Tuesday.
- 7:01Tara: To me, it was information I didn't have.
- 7:06Tara: Again, the real version is that this is correlation from one company.
- 7:12Tara: It doesn't prove that talking to more people makes you brilliant, but it anecdotally matches what I felt sitting there when that manager spoke her mind.
- 7:23Tara: So here's what I'm taking from that room.
- 7:31Tara: She just said what is true where she stands.
- 7:34Tara: And I was lucky enough to be listening.
- 7:37Tara: What feels like table stakes to me might be somebody else's, whoops! I didn't know there was a table there.
- 7:47Tara: So this week, here's my challenge.
- 7:50Tara: For you and for me, ask one person whose day looks nothing like yours a real question.
- 7:58Tara: Not small talk.
- 8:00Tara: Something like, what's the hardest part of your day that nobody sees?
- 8:04Tara: And then just listen.
- 8:07Tara: Writer David Sidaris does a version of this.
- 8:10Tara: He's never learned to drive, so buses, trains, and planes keep putting him next to real people he'd never planned to meet.
- 8:18Tara: And that's where a lot of his stories come from.
- 8:22Tara: You don't have to give up your car.
- 8:25Tara: You can just be a little more like that.
- 8:29Tara: And if you're the one at the front of the room setting the expectations, ask what's already on someone's plate before you add to it.
- 8:38Tara: You're not a bad person for having a bubble.
- 8:41Tara: Everyone has one.
- 8:42Tara: The win is noticing when you're in one.
- 8:48Tara: And just remember, you're doing better than you think about.