Latest / The So What? / Local Government Elections - The Second Round
Transcript
- 0:05Hello, and welcome to the So What podcast, in
- 0:08which political economic analyst J .P. Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of
- 0:13South Africans. You can find a written version
- 0:16of this content on J .P.'s website, jplandman
- 0:19.co .za. I am Ruda Landman, and I am your host.
- 0:26This episode is dated the 12th of November, 2026.
- 0:31And it's, of course, about the local government
- 0:33elections. JP, you call it the critical second
- 0:37round. Why? In my view, the first round was on
- 0:40the 4th of November when we all went out to vote
- 0:42and got those results. But those results did
- 0:46not give us clear -cut winners. In a large number
- 0:49of municipalities and metros, we will now have
- 0:51to form coalition governments. And that's this
- 0:55process of forming coalition governments is going
- 0:57on now. There's a period of 14 days in which
- 1:00it can be done. And I call that a critical round
- 1:03because that will really determine, that will
- 1:05really determine who governs which municipalities
- 1:08and which cities. So it's not the first round
- 1:12in which you voted. It's a second round and it's
- 1:14a critical round. And that's why I call it a
- 1:16critical second round. In how many of our municipalities
- 1:20does that have to happen? We have a total of
- 1:24what, 257? In 65 % of municipalities, and in
- 1:51the case of metros, seven out of eight metros,
- 1:54coalition governments now need to be formed.
- 1:57So it's a large number. Will those decisions
- 2:00be made centrally, do you think? It looks like
- 2:03it. All the major parties have indicated that
- 2:05they appointed what they call negotiation teams.
- 2:08These teams will conduct the negotiations between
- 2:10the various parties, and it will be done at national
- 2:13level. So the possible benefit of that, and I
- 2:17think that's why parties are doing it, is to
- 2:19have a uniform approach across the country. And
- 2:22we must see how that pans out. Will local leaders
- 2:27adhere to that? That's the big question. That's
- 2:30the big question. And we know specifically in
- 2:32the case of the ANC that there are important
- 2:34factions inside the party who do not want to
- 2:37be in coalitions with, for example, the DA. And
- 2:41so we'll have to see whether the party discipline
- 2:44can hold on whatever the central decision is
- 2:46that is taken. What are the main possibilities?
- 2:53Broadly speaking, there are two main coalition
- 2:56options. The first one is that you carry on with
- 2:58the government of national unity that we have
- 3:00at the national level, and that the parties who
- 3:02participate in the GNU will then also form local
- 3:07government coalitions of... local unity, so to
- 3:12speak. And that will give you a continuation
- 3:15more or less of the middle of the road moderate
- 3:17approach that we currently have at the national
- 3:19level. That excludes the EFF and MK. And ATM.
- 3:24And it also excludes Action SA in the sense that
- 3:28Action SA has chosen not to join the GNU. They
- 3:32regard themselves as independent. So that's the
- 3:34one big grouping. Then you've got Action SA,
- 3:37we're independent. And then there is what you
- 3:40can call on the left, a grouping of progressive
- 3:45parties of the left, as some people call it,
- 3:47or black political parties, as other people call
- 3:51it. or parties of the national liberation struggle,
- 3:53as a third group of people call it. So it depends
- 3:56who you talk to, but those terms are used interchangeably
- 4:00to basically denote the same thing, and that
- 4:03is that ANC, MK, EFF, and other smaller parties
- 4:07must come together and form local governments
- 4:10of unity. So those are the two big ones, a continuation
- 4:13of the GNU and parties of the progressive left
- 4:16or parties of the black political parties. Now,
- 4:21we all know how well that has served us in the
- 4:25past. So in my personal view is that we need
- 4:29parties that will strengthen the middle. We need
- 4:31parties that will bring together the middle.
- 4:33It's interesting if you look at the results,
- 4:35the parties that participate in the GNU. got
- 4:3965 % of the votes in this local government election.
- 4:42This was not a national election. It was a local
- 4:45election. And yet they garnered 65, almost two
- 4:48thirds of all the votes in the country. So I
- 4:51think it gives you a clear indication of where
- 4:53the majority of South Africans stand. They do
- 4:55not want parties of the extreme on either side.
- 4:59They would prefer to have a stronger middle and
- 5:02for the middle to govern the country. What about
- 5:05Action SA? They only got a small percentage of
- 5:10the national vote, but they're very strong in
- 5:13Gauteng and specifically the three metros. Yes,
- 5:17indeed. Nationally, their vote came to less than
- 5:196%. But in Johannesburg, in Zwane and in Ekoroleni,
- 5:24the three metros in Gauteng, they are very strong.
- 5:28And they could be, if the ANC and the DA do not
- 5:31come to an agreement, they could be the kingmakers.
- 5:34If the ANC and the DA do come to an agreement,
- 5:37and the agreement is carried through at the local
- 5:40level, then Action SA would not be a kingmaker.
- 5:43So we'll have to see how that one plays out.
- 5:46And what about KwaZulu -Natal? Because their
- 5:49MK got the majority in at least the metro, Etiqueni.
- 5:54They did. They did worse than what they thought.
- 5:57Mr. Zuma was very confident that they will. capture
- 6:00Equitini, but they didn't. With an absolute majority.
- 6:03With an absolute majority, yes. They did not.
- 6:05They got, I think, 38 .5 % of the vote there.
- 6:11The second biggest party in that metro is the
- 6:14DA. Now, here is the thing. The DA and the ANC
- 6:17both have accepted and stated publicly that the
- 6:22leading party in a metro or a municipality must
- 6:25have the mayorship. must carry the mayoral chain.
- 6:28In other words, the party who received the most
- 6:31votes. Yeah. Now, in the case of Etoquini, that
- 6:34means MK. And if you now extend that principle,
- 6:38then the mayorship in Etoquini must go to MK.
- 6:44There is a problem, and the problem is the following.
- 6:47MK is in favor of changing the current constitution.
- 6:50They want to go back to the parliamentary democracy
- 6:53that we had before 1994. not the constitutional
- 6:57democracy that we've had for the last three and
- 7:00a half decades. So that's quite a radical departure
- 7:04from where we are. And therefore, if you look
- 7:07at what's happening in countries in Europe, the
- 7:09Netherlands, for example, Germany, where a group
- 7:12of parties at the middle decide that they do
- 7:14not want to work with a radical party and exclude
- 7:17that party, although it is, from a voter's point
- 7:19of view, quite strong. If that approach is followed
- 7:22here, then you can find that the three parties
- 7:24that currently govern the province of KZN, which
- 7:28is the IFP, the ANC, and the DA, that they can
- 7:32club together and also take over the government
- 7:34in Etiquini. Now, the MK people would be very
- 7:37upset and so on, but as long as it's based on
- 7:41solid principles, and the principle being that
- 7:43those parties who do not accept the current constitution,
- 7:47who wants to change the current constitution
- 7:49in a radical way, are excluded, then I think
- 7:52one can make that case to the public. But that
- 7:54will be an interesting case to see how it plays
- 7:56out as well. The GNU is based on respect for
- 8:02the Constitution. That's an agreement between
- 8:04those parties. Yes, the founding statement of
- 8:06the GNU, which was signed in 2024, two and a
- 8:09half years ago, in Clause 8 .1, clearly states
- 8:13that respect for the Constitution, rule of law,
- 8:15and for the country to be a united country. is
- 8:19a basic principle of the GNU. And if that principle
- 8:22is enforced also at the local level, then on
- 8:26the basis of that one can exclude a party like
- 8:28MK, for example. So what? Your so what's this
- 8:34time are not a mere summary of what went before,
- 8:40but you make a very specific point that the election
- 8:42was a success. No doubt. I mean, just think about
- 8:46it for a moment. Nobody is fleeing the country
- 8:50like Bolsonaro did in Brazil. Nobody is bitching
- 8:53that the election was stolen like Netanyahu in
- 8:55Israel or Trump in the United States. No mob
- 9:00stormed the results center of the IEC and demanded
- 9:05a different outcome. Even in litigious South
- 9:09Africa, where we like going to the courts, nobody
- 9:11went to the court to challenge the results. So
- 9:14I think it's a very solid victory for good administration,
- 9:19good management of the election. All the more
- 9:21so, you must think that 28 million ballot papers
- 9:24had to be reprinted after the Constitutional
- 9:27Court decision on that matter. So I think the
- 9:31election was really a success. There's no question
- 9:33about that. I think the second so what is that
- 9:36we've moved quite decisively from a political
- 9:39terrain where one party dominated. to a terrain
- 9:44where nobody particularly dominates, where you've
- 9:47got to form a coalition. So we've moved very
- 9:49decisively into coalition territory. And why
- 9:55the second round of coalition forming is so critical
- 9:57is what kind of coalition will it be? No question
- 10:01there will be a coalition in 65 % of the country's
- 10:05municipalities. But what kind of coalition? One
- 10:07of the middle or one of the... more radical left.
- 10:10That's the issue that will be decided in the
- 10:13next 10 days or so. And then I want to add two
- 10:18questions. You have a PS in your note. And the
- 10:23first one that I want to ask, which is not covered
- 10:27really in your note, is what is this whole thing
- 10:31called an overhang? And how does it work? And
- 10:33how did it play out? Yeah, it's very, very interesting.
- 10:37At the municipal level, we've got a hybrid system.
- 10:4050 % of councillors are elected in wards by the
- 10:44voters from that ward. 50 % of councillors are
- 10:47elected onto a proportional list, which is a
- 10:51party political list. So you had two votes on
- 10:54the 4th of November, one for your ward councillor
- 10:56and one for the party that you want to support.
- 11:00Now, what happens is if a party wins a number
- 11:04of votes with less than 50%, of that ward votes.
- 11:08Then the parties still get the vote. That person
- 11:12that stood there as a candidate, he gets the
- 11:15ward. You can't take that away from him. You
- 11:17can't disqualify him. But now, this has happened
- 11:22in about seven municipalities. The parties who
- 11:24got a majority of wards got a minority of votes
- 11:28because they took no ward for 50%. They took
- 11:32it for 40 % or 35 % or 30%. So they got the ward.
- 11:37but they didn't get enough votes to make up the
- 11:40proportion of votes that they captured. And what
- 11:43then happens, the proportional side of the council
- 11:46must then be adjusted to make sure that all parties
- 11:50are proportionally represented. Proportionally
- 11:53simply means if you got 20 % of the vote, then
- 11:56you must have 20 % of council seats. Now, and
- 11:59if you got 30 % of the vote, you must have 30
- 12:02% of council seats. Now, where you win wards
- 12:05with less than 50%, your ward tally runs up and
- 12:09now you have more wards than what you are proportionally
- 12:12entitled to. So you can have, say, in a council
- 12:17of 100 members, you can have, say, 55 wards.
- 12:21You could have won, say, 40 or 50 wards. Remember,
- 12:25the 100 divides 50 -50. So you've got 50 wards.
- 12:29Let's say your winning party captured 40 of those
- 12:32wards. But they only did so with about 30 % of
- 12:35the vote. Total vote. Total vote. Now you've
- 12:38got to reduce their proportional allocation of
- 12:42proportional seats. And that's where the overhang
- 12:45comes in. It's a bit technical and it sounds
- 12:49unfair, which to some extent it is. But it's
- 12:52only, first of all, it only affects about seven
- 12:54councils, according to my knowledge, in the country,
- 12:58which is not a big deal. And also you must look
- 13:00at the alternative. How do you fix that problem?
- 13:03Well, the only way you can fix it is to allow
- 13:06the council to get bigger, to give people, all
- 13:09the parties, a proportional space. And you can
- 13:12end up with a lot of extra councillors, which
- 13:16is not what we want. So it's a compromise, and
- 13:19I think one must live with that compromise. You
- 13:21know, maybe somebody tests us in court. Let's
- 13:24see what happens. But I think it will stand.
- 13:28And what would have happened if we did not have
- 13:32the proportional vote as part of this picture?
- 13:35If it was constitutions only? We must thank the
- 13:39heavens we've got a proportional system. Just
- 13:41look at the UK, where the party that gets 34
- 13:44% of the vote end up with more than 50, sometimes
- 13:48more than 60 % of members of parliament. So you
- 13:51basically have an unrepresentative government.
- 13:54The essence of democracy is that every vote counts
- 13:57the same. Now, if 34 % of the people can determine
- 14:0160 % of the composition of parliament, and that
- 14:03parliament then takes decisions on the basis
- 14:06of that 60%, well, that's how we got apartheid.
- 14:09Let's just remember in 1948, the National Party
- 14:12had a majority of seats, but a minority of votes.
- 14:16You know, a constituency system is really not
- 14:20a good system. And we must thank our founding
- 14:24fathers that we went for a proportional system
- 14:26because in that every vote counts the same. Small
- 14:29parties get access and nobody can run away because
- 14:32they've captured a large number of seats. Thank
- 14:35you very much. We will come back to the audience,
- 14:39I think, after the next two weeks and we're all
- 14:43holding our breath. Absolutely. Thank you. Thank
- 14:47you for listening to the So What Podcast. If
- 14:50you enjoy this content, please don't forget to
- 14:53leave a review and a rating, and please consider
- 14:55subscribing so you don't miss any future episodes.
- 14:58Also, tell your friends. Remember, you can find
- 15:02a written version of all JP's content at jplandman
- 15:05.co .za.