Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E063: Soft Sovereign Default with Peruvian Bull
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1974198792972000 and
- 0:18whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same thing
- 0:20over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell. Hey, OK, I say when we sell.
- 0:32Everyone welcome back to the last trade.
- 0:35Today I'm joined by Peruvian Bowl and of course my Co host
- 0:40Jesse Myers and Michael Tanguma. Good to see you all.
- 0:42How we doing? Doing good.
- 0:45Welcome back, Peruvian. Hey, thanks for having me back
- 0:48guys. I'm excited to be here.
- 0:51Yeah, last time you were on the show was fairly recently, but a
- 0:55lot has happened since then. And Marty was the host of this
- 0:58podcast. So we'll continue with the
- 1:00conversation that the three of you guys had just recently.
- 1:04But really want to touch on a lot of the changing
- 1:07macroeconomic landscape. You know, certainly a lot has
- 1:10happened with the Bank of Japan even in the past couple of
- 1:13weeks. So, you know, Peruvian Bowl,
- 1:17maybe you're the best place to start just given your
- 1:19background. You know, you're Peruvian,
- 1:21right? But you're an expert and known
- 1:23for your work in the Japanese markets, among many other things
- 1:27as well. But it's good to have you on.
- 1:29And maybe the best place to start would just be a recap.
- 1:32I know we've covered it on past episodes here and you've covered
- 1:35it on other shows as well. But really it's best to hear
- 1:38directly from you what's happening in Japan, what
- 1:41happened a couple of weeks ago in global financial markets, and
- 1:44then maybe what has happened since then in the past couple of
- 1:46weeks. Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:48So, you know, I think we've already talked but previously on
- 1:53the show about the the history of the Bank of Japan and, you
- 1:55know, the Japanese monetary experimentalism that they've
- 1:59been undertaking for the last 25 plus years.
- 2:02But to quickly recap, you know, Japan faced the bursting of a
- 2:05massive credit bubble in the early 90s, and they responded by
- 2:08starting to experiment with, you know, new forms of monetary
- 2:12policy. So that started with lowering
- 2:14the interest rate, the, you know, their target rate to 0% in
- 2:171999. And then in 2001, in March of
- 2:20that year, they started doing QE.
- 2:22And you know, a decade later they started doing QQE, which is
- 2:26qualitative quantitative easing, which just means QE for certain
- 2:29assets. And then they eventually started
- 2:32yield curve control in September of 2016.
- 2:35And all this served to essentially over leverage the
- 2:38Japanese economy and bring it to a bring it to a place where, you
- 2:46know, interest rates were pinned at the zero bound and the only
- 2:48way to achieve yields was to lever yourself up.
- 2:52And so this environment, you know, being so low interest rate
- 2:56was conducive to what are called carry trades.
- 2:59And carry trades are essentially where you borrow in one currency
- 3:03and you lend it another currency that has a higher interest rate
- 3:05so you can capture a spread between the two currencies.
- 3:10And so Japan became a major funding mechanism for the carry
- 3:14for these carry trades. They were carry trade funder for
- 3:18the AUDJPY pair. So there was a massive run in a
- 3:23UDJPY where the currency appreciated, appreciated.
- 3:26And that means the yen depreciated.
- 3:28And then during the 2008 financial crisis, this carry
- 3:31trade unwound and there was a whipsaw and all that leverage
- 3:34got wiped out. And we're talking, you know, 10s
- 3:37of 10s of billions of dollars, you know, every single day
- 3:41getting getting wiped out. So it was very destructive to
- 3:43any carry traders who had gone in long on that trade.
- 3:46And in, you know, in 2020 with the global, you know, central
- 3:52banking apparatus at 0, the carry trade was kind of on pause
- 3:57because there just wasn't enough spread to capture.
- 3:59But in starting in March of 2022 when the Feds started hiking,
- 4:04that spread started to grow again and the carry trade
- 4:07started to get put on again in earnest on JPYUSD.
- 4:12And So what that meant is that functionally, traders are
- 4:16shorting JPY and they're going along USD because they're
- 4:19borrowing again. And then they're buying dollars
- 4:22and lent, you know, to capture that interest rate spread.
- 4:25And the interest rate start or the exchange rate started to
- 4:28blow out starting at 100 or so in 2022, and it blew out all the
- 4:32way to 150 and 160 this year. And the Bank of Japan has been
- 4:35trying, you know, throwing everything, including the
- 4:38kitchen sink at this problem, doing massive interventions.
- 4:43They tried to move the bands of yield curve control.
- 4:46They tried to do, you know, a dozen different, you know,
- 4:50strategies to figure out how to deal with, you know, this, this
- 4:55blowing out currency and and essentially everything they did
- 4:58was not really fucked like working.
- 5:01It was, you know, let's say, pouring a little water on the
- 5:06fire, so to speak, like it was just, it wasn't enough.
- 5:08And so they finally realized that what was one of the things
- 5:13that was stopping or was, was helping the carry trades was the
- 5:16lack of volatility in the interest rates that they had
- 5:19domestically. And so starting in March of this
- 5:22year, they brought their target rate out of the negative bound
- 5:25and into the zero to 0.1% range. And then, you know, they've been
- 5:33doing intervention since then. And in late July and July 31st,
- 5:38they finally shocked the market with a surprise interest rate
- 5:41hike all the way to 25 basis points.
- 5:44And 25 basis points doesn't sound like much, right?
- 5:47And it isn't. But for an economy that's this
- 5:50indebted, right, we're talking 263% debt to GDP, 120% private
- 5:54debt to GDP, it's a lot. And all these carry trades
- 5:59immediately started to get unwound.
- 6:01And so we saw that weekend, on Friday, the Nikkei started
- 6:05falling, fell by 4% that day. The next Monday, it opened lower
- 6:09and crashed 13% in a single day, which was the worst day for
- 6:12Japanese equities since 1987. And for the next few days, it
- 6:17was very, very, there's very high amounts of volatility.
- 6:20And the Bank of Japan essentially had to walk back
- 6:23their policy statements. So they had said in the, in the
- 6:27way they had said in the meeting the previous week that they were
- 6:31they were essentially ready to, you know, they were ready to
- 6:36start a hiking cycle and more hikes were more seen as
- 6:39appropriate. And they wanted to bring the
- 6:43interest rate to what was called, you know, a normal rate
- 6:46for the economy. And he didn't specify what that
- 6:48was, but he just said it was higher than where we are now.
- 6:50And so that scared traders. And so on the next week in early
- 6:53August, he walked back these statements.
- 6:55He said, OK, like, calm down. We're not going to.
- 6:59We're going to pause those interest rate hikes.
- 7:00We're not going to do anything more.
- 7:01And he said we may even become accommodative if needed.
- 7:05And so that that wording helped to soften the impact on markets
- 7:11and I think you know, hold us where we've been for the for for
- 7:16now. So you know, USDJPY is around
- 7:181:45. A lot of the carry tried has
- 7:20been around. But if if Japan keeps hiking,
- 7:23you know, we could be seeing a real deflationary crisis start
- 7:26to emerge there. At Onramp, we believe that
- 7:29Bitcoin is the most important asset of the 21st century.
- 7:33The hard part is securing it right.
- 7:35There are shortcomings with keeping your coins on an
- 7:37exchange, but also with setting up your own self custody
- 7:40arrangement. On Ramp solves for these
- 7:43concerns. Our multi institution custody
- 7:45solution maximizes security and minimizes counterparty risk,
- 7:50ensuring that your Bitcoin remains securely in your
- 7:52possession and provides built in inheritance planning to ensure
- 7:56your family is protected as well.
- 7:58On Ramp provides Peace of Mind for your Bitcoin journey,
- 8:01whether for your whole stack or for part of it as a compliment
- 8:04to your existing self custody setup.
- 8:07For more information, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 8:11Yeah, Well, appreciate you walking us through that.
- 8:13I know you did that in even greater detail on on the last
- 8:17episode that we had you on. But it's important just to
- 8:19highlight the changes that have happened since then.
- 8:22And in particular, as you mentioned in July 31st and
- 8:24coming into August, just the systemic volatility that we saw
- 8:29across the board, right? Like it wasn't isolated to
- 8:31Japan, it it happened in US equities.
- 8:34Bitcoin, of course, sold off quite rapidly, just acting as a
- 8:37liquidity sponge and allowing people to shore up capital.
- 8:41But I mean it's remarkable, right There's like 20 plus years
- 8:44of central planning and manipulating interest rates and
- 8:48and really just to be accommodative to the debt burden
- 8:51that was growing in Japan. But now it's you say, if that's
- 8:55right, Peruvian like they're they're really just stuck in a
- 8:58black hole of their own making or something like that, right.
- 9:01I mean, there's, there's really no way way out of this mess.
- 9:03And we're seeing now just how much volatility could be
- 9:05introduced from what seems to be like such an such a little
- 9:10amount of interest rate increase from the Bank of Japan.
- 9:14But it's like ends up sending massive shock waves through the
- 9:17system. So really there's so much
- 9:19fragility that we need to be paying attention to as
- 9:22investors. One thing maybe to touch on,
- 9:27unless Michael or Jesse, you want to hop in, but I was really
- 9:29curious, like we have next month, the Federal Reserve may
- 9:34be lowering interest rates, right?
- 9:36So that of course, is going to start compressing the spread of
- 9:38the carry trade even further. And typically, you know, easing
- 9:43policy in the US would be accretive to the economy and for
- 9:49financial markets. But now there's kind of this
- 9:51dynamic where it could potentially unwind the carry
- 9:54trade even further, at least that's how I understand it.
- 9:56And then I think even today, the Bank of Japan came out one of
- 10:01the one of the policy makers there and said that they would
- 10:04potentially increase interest rates again if inflation remains
- 10:08to be a problem. So you kind of got us caught up
- 10:12in the past couple of weeks here.
- 10:14What do you think of the coming weeks and months in terms of
- 10:18like U.S. policy and and Bank of Japan policy and how that could
- 10:21impact markets? Sure.
- 10:24So, yeah, I think I mean, generally a, you know, rate cut
- 10:27in the US is, is stimulative to our equity markets.
- 10:30But I think you're right in I'm saying that the, the, the
- 10:34contradiction there is that for the carry traders, you know,
- 10:38they're spread, they're highly levered on this spread.
- 10:41And so if the spread moves, you know, the ones that are the most
- 10:44levered get liquidated first. And so if ironically, if we see
- 10:48the Fed hiking, we could see a temporary pull back in in
- 10:50markets across the board. And I'm talking crypto, you
- 10:54know, Japanese equities, US equities, even, you know,
- 10:58domestic corporate bonds. It could be, you know, almost a
- 11:02universal sell off because carrier traders have plowed long
- 11:05into almost every single asset class that they've, you know,
- 11:09been able to get their hands on. But, you know, in the long term,
- 11:14my base case is still that the US equity markets are going to
- 11:17continue to climb higher. And that's just because of the
- 11:20fundamental mechanisms of how, you know, our modern markets
- 11:25work, right? And I've kind of said this
- 11:27before, but you know, the, in my opinion, value investing is dead
- 11:32and it died in 2008. And now the entire market is
- 11:37just completely dependent on Fed liquidity.
- 11:39And so whenever Fed liquidity is coming, markets will rally.
- 11:43And if Fed liquidity is leaving, then the markets will fall.
- 11:46And there's that's just simply how things work now.
- 11:50The correlation between the Feds balance sheet and you know the
- 11:53S&P 500 is now like .89, so it's like almost 1:00 to 1:00.
- 11:57And it's extremely difficult to, you know, imagine a scenario in
- 12:02which lowering interest rates and the Fed continuing cutting
- 12:05cycle is not long term bullish for US equities.
- 12:09And again, I'm not saying that actually there's a fundamental
- 12:11value case for those equities. It's just that nominally they
- 12:15will go up because this is what we've seen in the past, this is
- 12:17how we've seen the system has changed and this is what is
- 12:20going to happen moving forward. Yeah, Michael, you're on mute.
- 12:27Sorry, that's such a great point.
- 12:29Because I think traditionally it's brought up around inflation
- 12:32and historically the past 30 years, you could argue what
- 12:36inflation was. But if you look at empty money
- 12:38supply, that's probably the closest proxy and it's generally
- 12:41been like roughly 7%, I believe year over year.
- 12:45And that's just like should be our benchmark moving forward
- 12:49about the amount of capital it needs to inject in the system to
- 12:51keep it from deleveraging. And it goes back to there's too
- 12:54much debt, not enough dollars and that only accelerates.
- 12:57So inflation only accelerates and the benchmarks in real terms
- 13:00only accelerate or decelerating like what a your, anybody's
- 13:04portfolio will return. And it just gets harder and
- 13:06harder to beat that. Sorry, the money supply is just
- 13:10a perfect proxy for where this is all ultimately headed.
- 13:14Yeah, I, I, I did a, a little analysis of, of that same
- 13:19question a couple years ago and just looked at the, the, the
- 13:23kegger on the M2 chart. And if you go back like a
- 13:27decade, the kegger was like 5% a year.
- 13:30And then it kind of there's a little bit of an inflection
- 13:33point jumped like 6% a year. And then but for the last, I
- 13:37don't know, half decade, we've been in a 7% a year kind of
- 13:41environment. So just kind of speaks to the
- 13:44ratcheting up of of monetary base growth and, and, and I
- 13:50agree with Michael that really is the the best proxy for true
- 13:53inflation is Mt expansion. Yeah, PBPB, just question on
- 14:01something less on the, it's more of the qualitative than the
- 14:03quantitative. You referenced the 236% debt to
- 14:07the GDP and we hear about, you know, Japan and the monetary
- 14:11policy and how it's an anomaly. And everybody references like
- 14:13they can get away with it and like all these things.
- 14:16But there's this notion of from a societal perspective, what has
- 14:19transpired and from the number of births to women working,
- 14:25older people dying, like everything.
- 14:27And you being a student, I feel like of that specific situation.
- 14:32I don't know if you could share insights into that and how it
- 14:35got there because I don't think that I even personally fully
- 14:37appreciate why the reference from less capital production
- 14:42equates to all the things that have effectively occurred.
- 14:46And that's kind of where we, I mainly think about or ask that
- 14:49question because this is a, it's a pre, pre cursor to where we're
- 14:53basically going in the US, if that makes sense.
- 14:57Yeah. No, I think, I think that that's
- 14:59accurate to a certain extent. Yeah, No, the the Japanese
- 15:02situation is really interesting, right, Because that 263% public
- 15:06debt GDP, they are, you know, easily the most over levered
- 15:10country in the entire world. And again, it really dates back
- 15:13to the 1980s and 1990s where if you read this book called
- 15:17Princess of the yen, which is a really great expose on the
- 15:22Japanese central bankers and their desire to essentially
- 15:26reorder the Japanese economy post World War 2, they began
- 15:31engaging in extreme forms of monetary policy.
- 15:34So, you know, in the 1970s and 80s, they were enforcing what
- 15:39were called window quotas for the banks.
- 15:41And So what that meant is they would call the bank, the
- 15:43commercial banks and give them a, you know, a nominal yen
- 15:47amount of loans they had to make every day.
- 15:50And so they were telling that they were calling, you know,
- 15:53loan books, mortgage offices, right?
- 15:55Like they're calling, you know, private consumer credit.
- 15:58They're saying, hey, we need to create ¥500 billion, you know,
- 16:03per day of, of credit. And that started to create this
- 16:09massive credit cycle that started to ramp up to the 70s
- 16:12and 80s and over inflate literally every single Japanese
- 16:16asset. And so, you know, they got to a
- 16:19certain point where the, the palace, the Imperial Palace in
- 16:23Tokyo, just the Polish grounds were worth the real estate was
- 16:28worth more than the entire than all the real estate in
- 16:30California. And you know, something like
- 16:33that is just purely indicative of a, of a complete and massive
- 16:36bubble, right? Japanese equities, Japanese
- 16:38stocks in the late 90s were worth more than several G7
- 16:42countries combined. It was just completely
- 16:44unsustainable. And so then in 1990, when the
- 16:48deflationary, when they stopped doing these window quotas and
- 16:51started restricting credit, the entire system started
- 16:54contracting heavily. So we saw Japanese equities fall
- 16:5760%, bonds fall 6070%, you know, certain types of real estate
- 17:01fall 75%, just a huge contraction across the board.
- 17:06And this resulted in, you know, a sadly, a demographic crisis
- 17:12for the Japanese because rates of suicide and depression
- 17:15skyrocketed, especially among young men.
- 17:18And, you know, the ability of people to form families also
- 17:21felt because so many jobs got destroyed.
- 17:24And the Bank of Japan just kept going with these policies.
- 17:27And then in the late 90s, they decided they're like, OK, we
- 17:31want to reverse this and reorder the Japanese economy to again,
- 17:35be more financially vibrant, right?
- 17:38We want to reinvigorate the the financial markets because
- 17:41they've been falling for the last decade.
- 17:43So that's when they started to engage in this, you know, QE
- 17:46zerp policy, you know, QQE, yield curve control, all this
- 17:50stuff that they're doing. And what it essentially did is
- 17:55now, you know, their entire economy is built on over
- 17:59financialization. They have created a
- 18:01financialized monster, gargantuan monster that they
- 18:04can't back out of now. And the net effect of that is
- 18:08you have an economy that is, you know, needing constant and
- 18:13continuous QE and monetary stimulus of all forms.
- 18:17And so raising rates by any amount will will trigger this,
- 18:21this House of Cards to collapse. And the US has already been, you
- 18:25know, starting down that path. We had, you know, eight years of
- 18:28near zero rates after after the 2008 financial crisis.
- 18:32And then we finally started hiking and, you know, late 2016,
- 18:35early 2017. And then we had to pause hiking
- 18:37in late 2018 and then, you know, start cutting again in 2020.
- 18:42So we've we've already started to get trapped in this, in this
- 18:47bubble. But I think if time goes on, if
- 18:50we go back to 0 percentage rates, that will further trap us
- 18:53in this debt bubble. Because, you know, like I said
- 18:56in that that famous piece I wrote called financial gravity,
- 18:59if you bring it straight to the zero bound, it creates a dilemma
- 19:02where bad debt doesn't get extinguished from the economy.
- 19:05It just adds on more and more and more.
- 19:07And so each time you lower rates, it becomes harder to
- 19:09raise rates in the next cycle. So it's it's counterintuitive,
- 19:14but it lowering rates will just burden you with that even more,
- 19:18as the Japanese have found out. Yeah, and that's why the 25 bit
- 19:23rate hike after 20 years of 0 is, is a non starter.
- 19:28It completely breaks everything. So you know, I'm, I'm curious
- 19:32about, I think you know, that there's like the classic,
- 19:36classic Hirschman capital data point of 51 out of 52 times
- 19:41since 1800 that a, a country has reached 130% debt to GDP.
- 19:45They eventually defaulted softer, hard defaulted on their
- 19:48debt. And the one exception is Japan
- 19:52is, is present day Japan. And you, you know, you're sort
- 19:56of talking about how you know what the steps I took through
- 19:58the 90s and it feels like the US right now with our debt to GDP
- 20:04of, of like something like 125 right now, we would maybe be in,
- 20:09in the early 90s in terms of where Japan was then.
- 20:15And that I think for a lot of people would make them think,
- 20:18oh, we're fine, we've got 30 years of runway, right?
- 20:22But I think, and I think you think that it's a bit of an
- 20:26exception for Japan for a variety of reasons.
- 20:30And I'd love to hear your thoughts on like, does the US
- 20:33have 30 years, if Japan has been able to run this way for 30
- 20:38years without running into any problems?
- 20:40And if not, why? That's that's a really good
- 20:44question. That's a really good question.
- 20:46So I think there's a couple answers to that.
- 20:49First is right, the demographic issues in the US and the Japan
- 20:53are, are wildly different in scale.
- 20:55We we have our own demographic issues, but Japan is a unique
- 20:59outlier in the sense that they've had basically a falling
- 21:03birth rate for the last 25 years.
- 21:05And this started actually in the 90s with, you know, the birth
- 21:08rate going below replacement level and basically staying
- 21:12there for the last 25 something years.
- 21:14The amount of old people aging out of the workforce has been
- 21:17increasing steadily every single year to the point where, you
- 21:21know, in modern day Japan, more adult diapers are sold every
- 21:25year than baby diapers. So their their population is
- 21:28aging, you know, completely. And old people generally when
- 21:33they get stimulus checks or they get some form of, you know,
- 21:37asset price appreciation, they don't sell those assets
- 21:39immediately and spend them. They keep them there, hold them
- 21:43and save them for their grandkids or save them for their
- 21:46retirement or, you know, their, their later life care, right?
- 21:50So because of that, there won't be a huge, you know, those are
- 21:57some, some factors that will lower monetary velocity and
- 22:00reduce the likelihood of inflation arising in Japan just
- 22:02naturally. You also have to remember Japan
- 22:05is a large external creditor. So you know, most of their, a
- 22:08lot of their excess savings goes abroad and gets invested into,
- 22:12into US equities, into European equities, into US bonds,
- 22:15treasuries. So, you know, they have a
- 22:18positive current account, they're a trade, they have a
- 22:21trade surplus. So they're net exporter.
- 22:25So there's a lot of things going for Japan that helped to bolster
- 22:28it financially, despite the fact that they're building up all
- 22:31this debt. Now.
- 22:33To answer your question on the question of, you know, inflation
- 22:36and debt, you know, will you hard default, soft default?
- 22:40The part of the reason why Japan was able to get away with what
- 22:42they did is because they they matched monetary austerity in
- 22:46the 90s with fiscal austerity. So they didn't run large scale
- 22:50fiscal deficits from the federal government and they didn't
- 22:53launch massive spending programs to try to bail out the populace.
- 22:56They essentially just let the populace, they sit back and
- 22:59said, you know what, let's let, let's let things happen.
- 23:02Let's let the populace, let's let, let's see what happens, let
- 23:07what happens happened. And so they stood back and just
- 23:10let things go. And that is in, in sometimes
- 23:16it's bad for the endeline economy because fiscal stimulus,
- 23:19you know, despite the fact that a lot of Austrian economists
- 23:22think it's wrong, which it, you know, morally you can have a
- 23:24problem with it. But Keynesians are right that in
- 23:27a depression or recession, fiscal stimulus can help to, you
- 23:31know, push the economy out of a kind of stag stagnant scenario.
- 23:37But with the US, right, we are already running 7% deficit to
- 23:42GDP and that's only only projected to rise.
- 23:45And if you remember that deficits are, you know, I term
- 23:49it as like the release valve for the financial economy into the
- 23:53real. So the bigger the fiscal
- 23:56deficits, the more, you know, treasury bonds that get sold by
- 24:00their by their treasury. That means money is being
- 24:04transferred from the financial economy, right?
- 24:06Banks, brokers, commercial commercial banks, pension funds,
- 24:11central banks, all of them when they're conducting monetary
- 24:14easing. If the Fed, if the federal
- 24:16government of the country is also running large fiscal
- 24:19deficits, those bonds are being sold to the banks.
- 24:22The banks hand them over bank reserves.
- 24:24Those bank reserves go into a, into a, an account called the
- 24:26TGA. Those bank reserves magically
- 24:29switch into M2 money because you have to be, that has to be
- 24:34spendable, right? If the government's going to go
- 24:35out and buy tanks and planes and pay for Social Security and
- 24:39Medicare and Medicaid and build hospitals and, and real and
- 24:42infrastructure, that has to be spendable in the real economy.
- 24:45That can't be bank reserves because bank reserves are are
- 24:47only restricted to financial institutions.
- 24:49So once the government pairs the high level borrowing with a high
- 24:54level spending and monetary accommodation, that results in
- 24:58inflation, which is what we saw in 2020, right?
- 25:00We saw this massive wave of inflation because for the first
- 25:02time we were pairing a large fiscal deficit with monetary
- 25:05easing. In 2008 in the US, we didn't
- 25:07have inflation because we were pairing monetary easing with
- 25:11pretty small deficits and that mostly just counteracted the
- 25:15deflationary force of 2008 anyways.
- 25:17And so the reason why we don't have 30 years this time is
- 25:21because we can't run. We can't run and we're not
- 25:23running the Japanese playbook. We're not running 1% deficit GP.
- 25:27We're running 7. And that's only going to get
- 25:29worse as time goes on with 10,000 baby boomers retiring
- 25:33every single day. And you know, interest expense
- 25:36already this year, you know, projected to be able one
- 25:39trillion again. You know, this, this train like
- 25:42Lenalden says, nothing stops the strain.
- 25:44And so as this continues, I think the deficits will
- 25:47increase, the monetary accommodation will have to
- 25:49increase and therefore inflation will continue to rise.
- 25:54Yeah, that was an excellent primer.
- 25:55And it really sounds like then we are in the early stages of a
- 26:00soft default and so is Japan as well, right?
- 26:02Because if you look at the US, just to use our country as an
- 26:06example, most people are fine with accepting a nominal return
- 26:11right now of 5%, right or thereabouts.
- 26:14With U.S. Treasuries, I think there's like
- 26:16$6 trillion or so parked in money market funds at the
- 26:20moment. Those people have effectively
- 26:24accepted, whether they realize it or not, that they're OK
- 26:28getting paid a negative real return because we know over the
- 26:30past couple of years that the rate of monetary expansion has
- 26:34been greater than a 5% nominal rate.
- 26:36So correct me if I'm wrong, but we're kind of already in those
- 26:39early stages of a soft default, are we not?
- 26:41Like we haven't gotten to the point yet where debt to GDP will
- 26:44start to decline, which I guess is what will need to happen to
- 26:47actually reset the monetary system.
- 26:49But we are at a point now where whether people are realizing it
- 26:53by purchasing these securities or they don't, they are kind of
- 26:57losing purchasing power year over year.
- 27:00And right now, I guess it's somewhat bearable, but it could
- 27:03become a point where that rate just happened so quickly and
- 27:06people are really just getting drained out of their savings,
- 27:08which presents all sorts of other demographic issues that
- 27:12you mentioned a bit about Japan. Yeah, absolutely.
- 27:16Yeah. I think we are in the early
- 27:17stages of in the US and globally, right, a soft default
- 27:20because this level of debt to GP cannot be maintained forever.
- 27:24And as we're seeing with the debt spiral, you know,
- 27:27accumulation like this, this thing isn't unfortunately an
- 27:31exponential process. And that's why the Fed is
- 27:34essentially has to step in, right?
- 27:36There's only so much capacity on on commercial bank balance
- 27:39sheets. It's only so much private credit
- 27:40that can buy treasuries even at these rates.
- 27:44And so that's why they need to find new sources of funding.
- 27:47And they already have submitted a letter that is that which is
- 27:51the Internet, the International Securities and Derivatives
- 27:54Association. They, I believe it's securities
- 27:58are, it might be something else, but they essentially submitted a
- 28:02letter to the Fed and the OCC asking for an SLR exemption for
- 28:06treasuries, basically allowing them to buy treasuries without
- 28:09putting capital against pledging capital against those treasuries
- 28:12in case of losses. So allowing infinite leverage.
- 28:16And you know, there's been other moves, of course, you know,
- 28:18there's been TGA reverse repo. The feds been trying to manage
- 28:22these accounts to draw them down to add liquidity to the system
- 28:25without blowing anything up though, without having to
- 28:27restart QE. But long term, my base case is
- 28:30that they're going to have to restart QE no matter what
- 28:32because just this debt issue is too bad.
- 28:34I mean, we saw in three days in August, we saw the debt go up by
- 28:38130 billion / a weekend and something like that is, you
- 28:43know, someone else did said that that was all the debt
- 28:46accumulated in the US up until World War, up until and past
- 28:50World War One, because World War One is like $85 billion or so.
- 28:53So they're like, imagine all of the debt, you know, borrowed by
- 28:58the US or the total debt level borrowed by the US up until
- 29:01World War One. And we did that in three days.
- 29:05Yeah, I remembering it might have been Luke Roman, he was
- 29:12making a point of of like the one of the key ingredients or
- 29:16somebody was one of the key ingredients for a soft default
- 29:22is basically what what has to happen is bond holders have to
- 29:25get screwed. You, you, you have to destroy
- 29:29bond value in real purchasing power terms by having inflation
- 29:35run higher than the yields on those bonds.
- 29:39And you know, he, he likes to point out that the one way to do
- 29:43that is, is what happened in Israel in the, in the 80s, I
- 29:47believe, where they allowed inflation to run at like 100%
- 29:53for like 2 years. And, and you basically have a
- 29:55reset on, on the real debt levels, you know, debt in real
- 30:02terms. That's one option.
- 30:06The other option is to, to run at A, at a small negative real
- 30:11return for many years. And, and the key ingredient
- 30:15there is to make it so that the bond holders don't realize that
- 30:19they're destroying value by holding bonds during that
- 30:21period. Because otherwise you sell the
- 30:23bonds and, and, and, and then they, they trade it, you know,
- 30:27they trade it below par and, and the market corrects itself.
- 30:34And, and that's kind of what we've been doing, right?
- 30:36Like if it's necessary for bondholders to not realize that
- 30:40they're losing value. And we exist in an environment
- 30:43where CPI is supposedly 3% and yet M2 is growing at 7% and
- 30:49bonds are yielding 5, four, 5%. That's, that's the, the
- 30:54ingredients right there. So I think it, I think it is we
- 30:58are, we are in the non urgent, non crisis mode stage of a soft
- 31:04default where, you know, they're trying to pull the levers.
- 31:07But the reality is that like things are not aligned where,
- 31:11you know, we, we should not be having expanding deficits if
- 31:14we're trying to get out of, if we're trying to, to soft default
- 31:20on our debt, we should not be adding to it at an increasing
- 31:22rate. So, you know, it's it not all
- 31:25decision makers are aligned on this on strategy because they
- 31:28don't realize that this is what is happening or, or needs to
- 31:31happen. So, you know, it's, you're never
- 31:34going to get it done If if lawmakers are spending at an
- 31:39increasing rate because they don't realize that this is a
- 31:41crisis and, and that the only way out is to sort of screw over
- 31:45bondholders. You know, So I think that I
- 31:50think that all speaks to like we are in the early stages of this
- 31:52and, and yet it's ineffectively being done.
- 31:56And so eventually we'll get to a point where they have to take
- 32:00more radical actions. I would imagine we can we can go
- 32:03back at least to 71, but definitely OA right in the soft
- 32:09default. And the the notion at which
- 32:11you're describing is like the 6040, right?
- 32:13Like the 6040 is the is the commitment to the soft default
- 32:17because it's just understood that I'm going to hold 40% of my
- 32:20wealth and bonds and I'm just going to yeah, I'm
- 32:23subconsciously accepting this, you know, negative real yielding
- 32:29return. And it's increasingly becoming
- 32:31greater. But that just like conversation
- 32:35at 64 days still embedded. And then it ties into the past
- 32:37year. We've had the multiple
- 32:38conversations of speed fed speak, right?
- 32:40Because the second you start to move past what the target
- 32:42inflation is, now you start to question all your returns.
- 32:45So you have to anchor them to this lower bound that we all
- 32:48know is not true, but we just accept and talk about.
- 32:50And then that's where the unemployment comes in and all
- 32:52the other like second and 3rd order derivatives of the
- 32:55monetary policy and how it's impacted.
- 32:57So that 6040 is just this like feels like a very key component
- 33:01that's intertwined in all of this because that's just the
- 33:03basis of all portfolio theory and how people manage their
- 33:05capital and people are anchored to that.
- 33:07So anything that moves from that is just a small deviation from
- 33:11how you're going to like accept your your ultimate default year
- 33:15over year in your return profile.
- 33:18Yeah, absolutely. The the unassailable wisdom is
- 33:21that 6040 is wise, right? Like and and and then of course
- 33:25that's that becomes your your attack vector to try to pull off
- 33:30some wealth destruction that's necessary here.
- 33:33Yeah, yeah. Exactly.
- 33:34And imagine this like we're we're at 7% debt or deficits to
- 33:38GDP without a formal recession, without, you know, the US being
- 33:43in a large scale war, although we are kind of funding to proxy
- 33:46wars and without a banking crisis, you know, And so it's
- 33:52like, if we're already here at 7%, what's going to happen if
- 33:56something really bad breaks out? What's going to happen if we
- 33:58have, you know, another commercial banking crisis or if
- 34:02there's another large scale war that opens up?
- 34:04Or if there's some sort of, you know, economic or, you know,
- 34:09natural disaster that just spurs a bunch of government spending.
- 34:12Another virus, right? Monkey pox, although I don't
- 34:15know if that one is really as viral as they say it is, but you
- 34:19know that if there's another crisis here, we're it's just
- 34:22going to send this system into OverDrive.
- 34:24I think that's the that's a real risk that people need to what,
- 34:27keep an eye out for. Does your Bitcoin custody setup
- 34:29keep you up at night? Maybe you still have coins
- 34:32sitting on an exchange worried about hackers.
- 34:35Or maybe you've set up your own self custody, but don't feel
- 34:37safe with your Bitcoin savings stashed on a little plastic
- 34:40device in your desk drawer. Gain Peace of Mind with On Ramp
- 34:44and our multi institution custody solution.
- 34:47Here's how it works. On Ramp creates a dedicated
- 34:50multi sig vault just for you. 3 separate institutions each hold
- 34:54a key on Ramp bit go and coin cover, but none can move funds
- 34:58unilaterally. Instead only you have control
- 35:01over your coins. With On Ramp's multi institution
- 35:05custody, you'll sleep better at night knowing your Bitcoin is
- 35:08stored with best in class security on chain with fault
- 35:11tolerant multi sig. If you believe your Bitcoin is
- 35:14going to be worth a lot someday, don't jeopardize that future by
- 35:18exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks
- 35:22in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 35:25you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 35:28custody set up. On ramps, Multi institution
- 35:31custody, eliminates single points of failure, reduces your
- 35:34personal attack surface and technical burden, and provides
- 35:38access to financial services that allow you to confidently
- 35:40secure your Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance
- 35:44backed warranties for all balances and transactions, low
- 35:47cost trading and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 35:51asset. Secure it right.
- 35:53Learn more at on rentbitcoin.com.
- 35:56Yeah. What continues to shock me is
- 35:58that we must be in an echo chamber because PB, one of the
- 36:02things you said earlier that I agree with is really after 2008
- 36:06fundamental and that fundamental value investing has died, right?
- 36:10So there was a world where all the best investors were were all
- 36:14value investors. They were able to, you know, do
- 36:17the channel checks, dig into the financials, understand total
- 36:21addressable markets and competitor landscape and they
- 36:23were able to allocate capital to undervalued companies and they
- 36:27were able to beat the market by doing so.
- 36:29But it seems like so obvious to the four of us that really any
- 36:33asset class, whether it's Bitcoin or it's real estate,
- 36:37precious metals, equities, what have you are really all proxies
- 36:42for global liquidity, right? So I feel like it's so obvious
- 36:47at this point just, and this is kind of a similar conclusion I
- 36:50came to in 2020 personally. And when I began to allocate
- 36:53more seriously to Bitcoin myself, first introduced it in
- 36:562017, but really in 2020 had a front row seat to Wall Street.
- 37:02I was doing hedge fund research and private asset research.
- 37:05And what was remarkable to me was all the people who made the
- 37:09most money in 2020 and 2021 were just long the market, right?
- 37:13Like there was not necessarily any.
- 37:16They were all really sharp people, much smarter than I was.
- 37:18And it was a privilege to be able to get to know these people
- 37:21and their investment strategies. But the thing was, if you were
- 37:24long when liquidity was expanding at like an
- 37:27astronomical rate, then obviously you're going to make
- 37:29money. And if you were, you know, more
- 37:31hedged or you were had a more of a neutral bias or short bias,
- 37:35then you kind of were left behind in that, in that massive
- 37:38run up. And and now like that's my
- 37:40personal framework for investing is and why I've ultimately come
- 37:43to Bitcoin as you know, the name of the show, right, the last
- 37:46trade. That's where I allocate my
- 37:48capital personally because I've came to this conclusion.
- 37:50But PB, I'm curious your thoughts, like is there anything
- 37:54that maybe we're missing or why is it so obvious to us?
- 37:58But maybe some of the other folks in our, you know, in the
- 38:00triad Phi space are continuing to struggle with maybe the
- 38:04realities of this like kind of fiscal dominance and global
- 38:07liquidity, you know, sloshing around and moving all the
- 38:09assets. I think it's, it's just hard for
- 38:13them to break from the, you know, mental mold that they've
- 38:16been using for the last 3540 years, right?
- 38:19Buying bonds has worked largely until the last four years, like
- 38:24buying, you know, junk grade, buying commercial grade, buying
- 38:28treasury bonds, right? There was a guy in I think I
- 38:32heard the story about a guy working in Salomon Brothers who
- 38:37to got a loan on on his house, like a lien against his house
- 38:40and bought a bunch of treasury 30 year notes or 30 year bonds
- 38:44in 1981 and retired. Like the interest was, you know,
- 38:4916% and he was able to retire completely and make millions of
- 38:52dollars just from just from interest and compounding math,
- 38:57right. So he was able to just continue
- 38:58to roll this paper forward and make a ton of money and a ton of
- 39:02traders did the same thing, right?
- 39:03You could go long bonds, he'd go long equities and everything
- 39:07would just make money. S the 6040 portfolio made
- 39:09complete sense. And if there was a risk of a
- 39:12recession, the Fed would ease and so the bonds would gain
- 39:15value and equities might sell off for a little bit, but then
- 39:17they'd recover pretty quickly. And then they come back to all
- 39:20time highs. And so that playbook, right, Has
- 39:24it worked in the, you know, the 1990s?
- 39:26It worked in the early 2000s. It worked after 2008.
- 39:29It worked out for 2020. And so it was really, it was up
- 39:34until 2022 that this was working really well.
- 39:37But once the Fed started hiking and interest rates globally
- 39:40started rising and bonds really started to get battered, that's
- 39:43when all this, you know, fear started into the market and
- 39:46people started to realize, holy crap, like, are we in a new
- 39:50paradigm? And I think for the majority of
- 39:53participants, they still haven't fully swallowed that pill yet.
- 39:56It's very hard because again, most, right, the median age of
- 40:00an asset manager in the US is what, like 67?
- 40:02So you know a lot of them, or I should say the, I think it's the
- 40:06average age. A lot of them are, you know,
- 40:09and, and the on the lower bound, it's around the 40 year old
- 40:12mark. And so we're we're dealing with
- 40:14the people who a class people who are between 40 and 6570
- 40:18years old, who have are generally the boomers or Gen.
- 40:22Xers who have managed money professionally for the last
- 40:2530-40 fifty years at in some cases.
- 40:28And their playbook has worked literally Florida State until
- 40:32the last two years. And so it's really hard to come
- 40:36and tell those people, oh, you're wrong.
- 40:39There's a new paradigm shift. Everything's going to change.
- 40:41You should be buying Bitcoin, you should be shorting bonds,
- 40:44you should be buying equities when they could just say, hey,
- 40:47like, what are you talking about?
- 40:48I've managed money professionally for this long and
- 40:51long bonds, long equities always works.
- 40:53And it's low risk and there's low variance.
- 40:55And all these models prove it out.
- 40:57And I don't want to do anything that the rest of the money,
- 41:00money managers are not doing it because of doing.
- 41:02Because if I do, then you know, something, then I could be an
- 41:05outlier and then I'll, I'll be wrong and I'll lose money.
- 41:08And so that bias, I think is crept in and taken hold and very
- 41:12hard to uproot. And, and that's the thing that's
- 41:15funny about this. I was looking for a quote and
- 41:18the quote that came up was a Chinese proverb that says if you
- 41:20want to know what the water's like, don't ask a fish and you
- 41:24reference the 67 year olds. If you want to know what money
- 41:28is or what economy is, don't ask somebody that's played in the
- 41:30financial system the past 70 years because it's, it's a
- 41:33similar thing that they've been living enough in an aberration
- 41:36and an anomaly outside of the past, call it 1000 years where
- 41:41you had sound money. And so they're just, they know
- 41:44what system and that's why it's hard to break from it.
- 41:47It's a fascinating thing because we have, we all have these
- 41:49conversations daily and it's one by one slowly.
- 41:52And I think 2020 was, that's what's interesting about being
- 41:55in this space that O eight O 9 satoshi, the white paper came
- 41:59about. But 2020 has been like the most
- 42:02instrumental that I've heard from individuals.
- 42:05And there's like 2 components. There was amount of liquidity
- 42:07that was pushed in the system. But then the other part that
- 42:10doesn't get brought up a lot was that generally people have the
- 42:13rat race they're tied into, so they don't have the time to look
- 42:15at this stuff. And ultimately everybody was
- 42:17locked in a box in 2020. And so you literally had the
- 42:20time to be like, what is happening here?
- 42:22And then it's, it doesn't take, you know, it's generally we talk
- 42:25about it's not an IQ test, it's a common sense test.
- 42:27So if you have some time and you look at the problem, you're
- 42:29like, well, there's you know, and you look at Bitcoin, you're
- 42:31like, oh, that might actually all make sense.
- 42:33But it's historically people don't have that time afforded to
- 42:37them to just assess what's going on.
- 42:40Yeah, that's a great point. And PB, the other thing too, as
- 42:44you mentioned, it's, you know, people have confirmation bias
- 42:47and and really what we're talking about as it relates to
- 42:49traditional assets. You're right, it's worked in
- 42:52many different cycles and paradigms, right?
- 42:54Like it's sixty 40s arguably, arguably been a good way to
- 42:57allocate capital and preserve wealth really up until recently.
- 43:02And you mentioned 2022 as an inflection point just with like
- 43:04correlations breaking. I really think one of the big
- 43:07forcing functions for Bitcoin adoption will be when Bitcoin
- 43:12begins to be included in indices and active managers have to
- 43:20benchmark against these, right? So if the index holds some at
- 43:25like let's say it's a global macro index that has all these
- 43:27different equity exposures and or let's say it's a commodity
- 43:32commodity index, right? And has all these commodity
- 43:34exposures and AG and energy and what have you.
- 43:36And then there's an exposure to Bitcoin as a digital commodity
- 43:39as well. And if Bitcoin is driving
- 43:43positive returns and it's, you know, kind of punching far and
- 43:46to the right in terms of attribution, and managers who
- 43:48don't have exposure to Bitcoin are underperforming the
- 43:52benchmark because of that, then they're going to start getting a
- 43:54lot of calls from their investors asking, you know, why
- 43:58are you underperforming the benchmark?
- 44:00I'm paying you 2 and 20 or whatever it is at the fund, and
- 44:04I could be getting better returns in a passively managed
- 44:07vehicle where it's, you know, a fraction of the cost, right?
- 44:10So in my mind, and maybe that's just the world I was coming
- 44:13from, active managers will almost be forced to adopt
- 44:16Bitcoin at some point. Of course, there's the flip side
- 44:19of bear markets under weighting it relative to a benchmark would
- 44:23likely put you in a better position.
- 44:24But as we know, Bitcoin compounds quite nicely on an
- 44:29annual basis, and I really think that's how it'll get into a lot
- 44:32of portfolios and how active managers will have to adopt it
- 44:35just to, you know, continue to generate alpha and you'll
- 44:38provide value to their investors.
- 44:42Completely agree and I think that's what's going to change.
- 44:45All right. The change the paradigm is, is
- 44:49that FOMO once you start seeing massive institutional allocation
- 44:52to Bitcoin and once their portfolios, right?
- 44:54I mean, this has been done 1000 times, right?
- 44:56Sharp ratio improves total returns, approve risk adjusted
- 45:00returns improve like on every single metric you see an
- 45:02improvement in portfolio even if you just added one or 5%
- 45:05allocation to Bitcoin. And so it's going to be
- 45:08extremely hard to argue against that in the long term.
- 45:11But you know, right, in the short term, this is a battle of
- 45:14the minds. This is a battle of of bias and
- 45:16and that takes time to overcome. Yeah, totally agree with that.
- 45:20Maybe, you know, we could shift gears a little bit.
- 45:23One, one thing I did want to touch on was Wyoming, because
- 45:26Michael was out there last week hanging out with all the Federal
- 45:30Reserve policymakers and wanted to get Michael's thoughts just
- 45:34on what he saw. He was at the Salt Blockchain
- 45:37Symposium, which is a digital asset conference.
- 45:40Michael would love to hear you talk about that.
- 45:42And then PB, Jesse, whoever would love to juxtapose that
- 45:47against maybe what we heard coming out of the Fed in Jackson
- 45:50Hole last week as well. It sounds like, you know, rate
- 45:53cuts are projected to happen in September.
- 45:56And you know, PB, as you mentioned, we have probably
- 45:58global liquidity easing coming soon after a period of like kind
- 46:03of consolidation and tighter policy.
- 46:05So Michael, maybe you can catch us up on what happened in
- 46:08Wyoming first. Yeah, for sure.
- 46:10I think that there's a perfect dovetail from what PB was
- 46:13talking about in portfolio and portfolio theory or adding
- 46:17Bitcoin in the the results that we've talked about where I think
- 46:20on conversations like this, we've naturally, can you guys
- 46:25hear me OK, OK, randomly. So we're all positive of Bitcoin
- 46:34and where it sits in a portfolio in the math.
- 46:36But something just dawned on me that is I wanted to throw out it
- 46:39has to relate to the Wyoming conference that probably like
- 46:43anybody would expect. There was a lot of, you know,
- 46:46trad fi that's breaking into space and also digital asset
- 46:49crypto native folks. And there was a lot of
- 46:51discussion around real world assets, tokenization, crypto,
- 46:55you know, Solana was there. There's there's a lot of the
- 46:57things that you would naturally see in the market thinking about
- 47:01Bitcoin and crypto, completing them together, thinking about it
- 47:03as risk and you know, you want, you know, 1-2 percent of a
- 47:06portfolio allocation. And obviously we have a
- 47:10different message here. We talked to individuals that,
- 47:12you know, you want to isolate crypto versus Bitcoin crypto,
- 47:16You can think about it at best, if you have to play nice as as a
- 47:19venture bet and that it could go to zero and it could go to, you
- 47:23know, it can maybe in a short order outperform Bitcoin, But
- 47:26ultimately a lot of these things are, are not there or that
- 47:29they're not money. Bitcoin is money.
- 47:31It's a it's more of a gold two point OA bond and it should be
- 47:34thought of as a different asset. And so my personal thought has
- 47:38been like this will win over time, this conversation and it's
- 47:42part of our our thesis and our strategy.
- 47:45But something just dawned on me in the sense of because of the
- 47:49financialization over financialization of Wall Street
- 47:52and the need for, you know, increased revenue margins and
- 47:55all those things. And we saw this fee compression
- 47:57with the ETFs. What if the misalignment of
- 48:01incentives, alignment of incentives is you keep it
- 48:03conflated and then you show all these other products because you
- 48:07have higher margins and higher fees, right Solana ETF for these
- 48:11other things. And the, what we see and we come
- 48:15back daily is this notion of diversification, portfolio
- 48:19allocation that it's crazy for anybody to think about why you
- 48:23would put anything over a couple percentage points in a BTC.
- 48:26We're saying that and we obviously know we're right
- 48:28because we've been living through this, but the markets
- 48:31not say that and the market will increasingly not be incentivized
- 48:33to say that for a number of reasons.
- 48:36And so that just like dawned on me in this conversation, like
- 48:37I'm happy to talk more about Wyoming, but like there's this
- 48:40notion that maybe it's not as straightforward as a sharp ratio
- 48:43and putting it because you're going to, you're not
- 48:44incentivized to do that because there's other products that are
- 48:48in short order, maybe outperform, but on a long enough
- 48:51hot time horizon, you don't have the, you have the benefit of not
- 48:54having that quick, you know, return to show them.
- 48:58And so 3-4 years later, obviously the proof's there, but
- 49:00everybody can sell snake oil in short order.
- 49:03Like, Venture can return here all the things that are
- 49:05associated with something that's not in the best interest of the
- 49:09end client, if that makes sense. Yeah.
- 49:12I mean, that makes a lot of sense just because the Bitcoin
- 49:15ETFs, at least in the US, are very commoditized, right?
- 49:18They all practically use the same custodian.
- 49:20They're virtually the same product.
- 49:22It's just a different sponsor of that ETF.
- 49:26So Michael, your point makes a lot of sense just in terms of
- 49:28trying to find edges for these other companies to get into like
- 49:31more exotic crypto products. Or they can actually maybe be
- 49:35one of the only people to offer this or the only firm to offer
- 49:38it. And then also just get a lot of
- 49:40revenue tied to that and care less about the Bitcoin product
- 49:43because it's just vanilla and it's all the same, right, as
- 49:46everything else. And then I think the other, you
- 49:48know, important point you mentioned too is most of the
- 49:52market kind of like, you know, the four of us and people listen
- 49:56to this, are kind of in the minority as relates to how we
- 49:57think about Bitcoin. Like we view it as typically a
- 50:00risk off asset. But if you're conflating Bitcoin
- 50:03with the broader crypto space and at best it's a 123 percent
- 50:07allocation of your portfolio and it's viewed as something that's
- 50:09either going, you know, zero or to the moon, right?
- 50:12Like a typical just like all the retail crypto shilling out there
- 50:16then. Yeah.
- 50:17I mean, we're kind of like in a totally different league, just
- 50:21like how we think about this and how does it, how does Bitcoin
- 50:24actually fit into all the themes that we're talking about from a
- 50:26risk off perspective, not from let's just throw something at
- 50:30the wall and see if it sticks and see if we can make some
- 50:32money on it in the in the process.
- 50:35Yeah, yeah. And, and, and I think, you know,
- 50:37there's another theme in there too, of I think we too quickly
- 50:42jump from, you know, oh, Wall Street's here.
- 50:48They're the smartest people in the room.
- 50:49They're going to get it, they're going to understand, they're
- 50:52going to, they're going to point their clients towards Bitcoin
- 50:55rather than crypto. And the reality is, like every
- 51:00time any new cohort shows up to Bitcoin and crypto, that cohort
- 51:05goes through the learning process of making the same
- 51:09mistakes. Every, every person ends up
- 51:12making the same mistakes when they first arrive.
- 51:15And, and that that has meant going through the path of
- 51:19altcoins and making that error only to later realize that all
- 51:27that is House of Cards and the only thing that you really want
- 51:32to own is Bitcoin. And so Wall Street and, you
- 51:35know, ETF providers and wealth managers, they're all going to
- 51:40make that mistake and they're going to shepherd,
- 51:43unfortunately, they're going to shepherd their clients into
- 51:46making that mistake as well. And eventually they will learn.
- 51:49So I think, you know, people who are in the Bitcoin space
- 51:53already, who are already understand the value proposition
- 51:56of Bitcoin, I think we have to brace ourselves for that and
- 52:00prepare for our friends and our family telling us that their
- 52:05wealth manager said that the, you know, the Solana ETF is a
- 52:08good idea to balance out your Bitcoin exposure.
- 52:11You know, like, like that's coming.
- 52:13And we, we just have to just have to accept that that
- 52:15everyone is going to make the same mistake.
- 52:18It's just part of the process of learning here.
- 52:20And we have to, you know, be patient and also help guide
- 52:26those folks towards what they will eventually learn the hard
- 52:30way or the easy way that bitcoins the only thing they
- 52:32want to have. Yeah, and there's there's a
- 52:35really important part in all of this that doesn't get discussed
- 52:39enough. And it's that kind of like loose
- 52:41monetary policy. I hate using this term, but you
- 52:44know, Fiat because it's charged that you throw it at everything.
- 52:46But this notion of too much liquidity drowns out unit
- 52:49economics. And so the idea of compression
- 52:52around custody exists in the traditional finance world into
- 52:55it ported over to the Bitcoin and digital asset world.
- 52:59And so when these asset managers look at the space, they all sit
- 53:03in a room and I know this first hand and they're all trying to
- 53:05figure out how do you make money from a market that's telling you
- 53:07you can't make money from a market?
- 53:09Like you can't custody, you can't do anything.
- 53:10It's a race to 0. And that's absolutely false.
- 53:14It's a fallacy baked into the market because ultimately nobody
- 53:17holds Bitcoin very long because nobody gets educated on what it
- 53:19is. So their exit liquidity or their
- 53:21custodian gets hacked and they lose it.
- 53:24And so this is natural education that we provide or, and what we,
- 53:28we, it's taking time to become proud of because anybody
- 53:31listening to this is like, oh, it's easy.
- 53:32You buy it and you hold it. But everybody that's gone
- 53:34through multiple cycles knows it's not easy because there's
- 53:36always somebody trying to steal your Bitcoin and there's always
- 53:38some counterparty trying to steal your Bitcoin, whether it's
- 53:41an exchange or somebody trying to break in your house or
- 53:42whatever increasingly becomes more treacherous waters.
- 53:46And so there's real value to be delivered in what we think about
- 53:49in this notion of multi institution custody, different
- 53:52institutions getting involved because as the asset
- 53:54appreciates, you can take fees on that financial services
- 53:57around it. But then ultimately the
- 53:59education about why it's Bitcoin versus this other stuff, because
- 54:03you can play the game in short order and pushing to like
- 54:05crypto, but on a long enough time frame, like kind of the
- 54:08tide goes out and you find out who's swimming naked and who was
- 54:10pitching you the snake oil. And that's just an interesting
- 54:14dynamic because it's it's some probably male intent that's
- 54:17built into the market somewhere. But a lot of it's just
- 54:19misalignment of incentives of not knowing that you can't make
- 54:22money here. And then now you have to
- 54:24naturally go out to further out on the risk curve and you end up
- 54:26rugging your clients. So it's just a very interesting
- 54:31aspect. And like, to Jesse's point, Wall
- 54:33Street comes in and no notion of any of that because this is
- 54:35just, well, it looks like a stock or a bond.
- 54:38It's just completely different. It's a fascinating place to be
- 54:42in. And that's kind of ties into
- 54:44Jackson, the Wyoming event, because there were some of the
- 54:47most reputable firms there and, and everybody, you know, Brian
- 54:52had a really great recap. He was there as well and in a
- 54:54weekly newsletter. And in paraphrasing him, it's
- 54:58like everybody's talking about these use cases, but they're
- 55:01trying to, they're hinting at they're trying to find a use
- 55:03case and they're also afraid to say that there's no use case.
- 55:09But behind closed doors, most people will tell you like they
- 55:12don't know what this what's happening behind the stuff other
- 55:14than Bitcoin and then stable coins.
- 55:16But when you really breakdown stable coins or any
- 55:18tokenization, it doesn't get talked about enough.
- 55:20But it's basically there's three layers of counterparty risks
- 55:23that exist and they ultimately have to net settle.
- 55:25Where does the underline? And you don't necessarily need a
- 55:27blockchain, but nobody has these conversations because they're
- 55:31not incentivized to somebody. Just like it's like, oh, I think
- 55:33there's a use case because we can, you know, build a solution,
- 55:35we can raise money on it, we can do it.
- 55:37So it's just an interesting period and to I think to
- 55:40Justin's core point, because Bitcoin's so emergent, we lived
- 55:44through this on micro examples with individuals and smaller
- 55:46companies. And now we're just going to live
- 55:47through this at the larger scale.
- 55:49And it's effectively why we exist because people are going
- 55:51to get rugged and we just want to lower that magnitude of
- 55:54rugging ultimately to a lot of the things we're developing are
- 55:56just standards in the market. Yeah, the best use case is a
- 56:01savings technology that's globally accessible and can be
- 56:04sent anywhere in the world instantly and for near zero
- 56:07fees. So I think that's a good use
- 56:10case to focus on personally. And yet somehow the world
- 56:14doesn't know that yet. When Michael was talking, I was
- 56:16reminded that, you know, that I was at at Bain before getting
- 56:21into falling down the rabbit hole.
- 56:23And there's a a macro trends group at Bain.
- 56:27And all they do is study macro and put out their perspective,
- 56:30you know, so that the partners can talk about that with their
- 56:32clients. And you know, it's part of the
- 56:34value proposition of yeah, engaging with Bain and the macro
- 56:40trend guy has for a long time referred to Bitcoin as a as a
- 56:50hammer looking for a nail, which is to say it's a great
- 56:53technology, but it doesn't have any use case in the application.
- 56:55There's no there's no reason for it to be.
- 56:59And that is still the the official position.
- 57:02Well, I guess his unofficial position of his perspective
- 57:05about what, what what bitcoins value is, which is to say that,
- 57:08you know, people whose entire job is to study macro and you
- 57:14know, at a place like Bain, still don't think that Bitcoin
- 57:18has any, any use case, any, any, any value proposition.
- 57:24So if you just, you know, listen to Jackson recap what the, what
- 57:28the value proposition of Bitcoin is as a savings technology,
- 57:32you're, you're ahead of the curve.
- 57:34You're ahead of what the information that's being
- 57:37disseminated by like the experts at at Bain and Company with
- 57:42regard to what Bitcoin is and where it fits in the macro
- 57:45landscape. Yeah.
- 57:47And and maybe to tie it back into just kind of like looking
- 57:50ahead now, so it's the end of August, got a handful more
- 57:54months of the year and then we're looking into 2025.
- 57:59Ultimately, we've described the use case of Bitcoin as just a
- 58:02better form of money and saving savings technology.
- 58:05And you know, the important thing behind that all that is
- 58:10the ability to protect purchasing power, right?
- 58:12So it's like fundamentally Bitcoin exists within the
- 58:14context of not having to trust centralized entities that issue
- 58:19a currency, that manipulate currencies, that sensor
- 58:21transactions, etcetera. So the reason why we've kind of
- 58:25coalesced around this technology is to protect our purchasing
- 58:28power from the continued debasement of the dollar and
- 58:31other Fiat currencies. So like PB, maybe you could just
- 58:34like let us know what you're paying attention to now through
- 58:37the end of the year in the next. What are you seeing in turn,
- 58:40like what are the most significant things to pay
- 58:42attention to from a macro lens? And maybe we can we can wrap it
- 58:47there. Sure.
- 58:49So, yeah, I'm looking at several key indicators.
- 58:52Indicators, You know, one is, you know, Fed liquidity.
- 58:55Also looking at global net liquidity.
- 58:58You know, with the Bank of Japan still continuing with monetary
- 59:01easing and with the Fed deciding to start the pivot, it looks
- 59:05like there's going to be a breakout in global liquidity,
- 59:08which is going to be, like I said, bullish for risk assets,
- 59:12including Bitcoin. You know, Michael Howell of
- 59:15Liquidity Wars does a lot of great work on this.
- 59:17And he has pointed out that, you know, for every one unit of
- 59:21liquidity added, gold goes up by, you know, 1.5 X and Bitcoin
- 59:26goes up by like 5X. So it goes up by multiples of
- 59:30the liquidity that's added. So Bitcoin is hypersensitive to
- 59:34liquidity. And if there's going to be a
- 59:35long term, you know, global cutting cycle beginning in the
- 59:41next, you know, let's say 12 to 18 months, we're going to be
- 59:44seeing in my opinion, a price appreciation of Bitcoin and a
- 59:48break out of this of this zone. Of course, the other main
- 59:52indicator I'm looking at is the USD JPY, right?
- 59:56Like every time we're getting back to the one 5160 level the
- 59:59Bank of Japan is. Deciding to do something crazy,
- 1:00:02whether that is the interventions or that is hiking
- 1:00:05interest rates or changing yield curve control bands, you know,
- 1:00:08doing whatever they can to figure out how to stop the hurds
- 1:00:11from currency from depreciating. That's like a very big driver
- 1:00:17here because Japan as the largest global sovereign
- 1:00:21creditor, you know, they own a trillion dollars of U.S.
- 1:00:25Treasuries and they own, you know, well in excess of a
- 1:00:29trillion dollars of US equities, several trillion dollars
- 1:00:32actually. And they're the largest external
- 1:00:35like foreign holder of, of both commercial and junk bonds in the
- 1:00:40US as well as just bonds generally.
- 1:00:42Like they own a large chunk of bonds in the, in the entire, you
- 1:00:47know, global ecosystem. And so if their economy is
- 1:00:50forced to deliver, we could be seeing a bond route globally.
- 1:00:54Now, I'm not saying that's going to happen.
- 1:00:55I think the most likely scenarios that the Bank of Japan
- 1:00:59and the Ministry of Finance are going to have to swallow the
- 1:01:00hard pill that their currency is going to have to be the release
- 1:01:03valve for the pressure that's built up in their financial
- 1:01:06system. So they're going to have to say,
- 1:01:07look, we can't, we clearly can't hike rates because that causes
- 1:01:10a, you know, 1990s style deflation in our own equity and
- 1:01:15bond markets. We can't really continue to do
- 1:01:18interventions because that's just throwing money into the
- 1:01:20fire. Just wait.
- 1:01:21It's buying time, so we're just going to have to let this thing
- 1:01:25ride. And so that means the Japanese
- 1:01:28yen is going to devalue significantly and carry trades
- 1:01:32can continue to add, you know, add leverage to the Japanese
- 1:01:36economy while feeding liquidity to the US because carry trade
- 1:01:40is, you know, borrowing with one currency and lending to another.
- 1:01:43So it will add liquidity to U.S. market and further bolster U.S.
- 1:01:48markets into the end of the year.
- 1:01:49So I think that section is really key to watch what
- 1:01:52happened in Japan will determine, will help determine
- 1:01:55what happens in the rest of the world.
- 1:01:57But I would say those are my two main indicators I'm looking at.
- 1:02:03All said, when when you mentioned PB earlier the
- 1:02:06Princess of yen book, I just had this realization of like this
- 1:02:09island far off with some guys determining monetary policy and
- 1:02:13like, well, what if they have friends that they want to, you
- 1:02:16know, it was just like more visceral of like this isn't the
- 1:02:19US and this isn't central bankers here, but it's just
- 1:02:22these guys and why would and it's obviously all the same, but
- 1:02:24it's just going to make a lot more in a future state where
- 1:02:26like, wait, people created the monetary policy before it wasn't
- 1:02:29just like fixed and just ran. It's just a very funny thing
- 1:02:33that just to look back at is everything you described is just
- 1:02:37a product of human nature at the end of the day and we shouldn't
- 1:02:40be able to control the numbers on the screen or what like sets
- 1:02:45the cost of capital, but we just accept it and.
- 1:02:47And, and all of the carry trades in the world, basically when,
- 1:02:50when they're between currencies are, are people finding
- 1:02:54arbitrage opportunities between different, you know, shaman
- 1:02:58groups and what they have said. So you know, that that's what so
- 1:03:03much of the financialized economy is based on is, is
- 1:03:06people exploiting the differences in, in what
- 1:03:08different groups of shamans have said about what the price of
- 1:03:12money should be today and going forward.
- 1:03:14It's all so ridiculous when you, you know, when you zoom out to
- 1:03:17that level. And of course a a monetary
- 1:03:21standard that cannot be changed and nobody controls will win out
- 1:03:25over such an inefficient system of of different shamans on
- 1:03:28different islands all over the world.
- 1:03:34Well said. They're all.
- 1:03:35Said yeah, Peruvian bowl, Really good to have you on, as always,
- 1:03:40Great catching up with you. And maybe before we just hang up
- 1:03:43here, where could the folks who don't know you find you online?
- 1:03:47Where would you like to hand them off to?
- 1:03:49Sure. So I have a Twitter which is
- 1:03:51Peruvian under score under score bowl.
- 1:03:54I have the sub SAC which is dollar end game.subsac.com.
- 1:03:59I also have a website called the Dollar End Game where where all
- 1:04:01my old writings from 2022 and earlier are are located and I
- 1:04:06have a YouTube under Peruvian bowl as well.
- 1:04:08So if you want to find any of my video or written content you can
- 1:04:10check me out there. I have a noster that's also I've
- 1:04:13been posting more on. You can find that end pub in my
- 1:04:17expanded bio on Twitter. Awesome.
- 1:04:19Yeah, I got to protect that free speech.
- 1:04:21Well, thank. Thanks again for making time,
- 1:04:23PB. Always great to have you on.
- 1:04:25And yeah, for anyone who's not following him already, certainly
- 1:04:28go check out his work. It's it's phenomenal.
- 1:04:31Awesome. Thanks so much guys.
- 1:04:32Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:04:35If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:04:37episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:04:40app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:04:41today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:04:44Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Ramp Media is
- 1:04:47for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:04:49nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:04:53Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:04:55to hear from you. Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact
- 1:04:59to schedule a consultation with one of our private Client
- 1:05:01advisors.