Latest / The Flipped Story / The Retention Economy Flip: Building an Online Business Community with Dan Rodman
Transcript
- David: I'm David Gedarian, and I'd like to welcome everyone Dan: And I'd like to well David: back to the Flip Story. Today, we're talking about something every business claims they want, but very few actually understand: the flipped community. Our guest today has an incredibly rare blueprint for this. He went from the rigid objective world of Canadian Mountain Town, mechanical engineering, robotics, and professional soccer. We're gonna talk about all those. But really what we're talking about is he's built a system Dan: What we're talking about is useful to David: for human connection. He's the founder and CEO of Co Unity, Dan Rodman. Welcome to the show. Dan: Awesome. Thank you for the the great intro there, David. I think this is David: Yeah. Dan: gonna be a fun conversation. David: Absolutely, absolutely. Hopefully I got it all right. So Dan: Yeah, no. It sounds sounds great. And yeah, I can fill in some of the the pieces how one goes from one thing to the next like that and you know how I really believe a lot of this conversation around community is getting more and more present and more and more important for businesses and and for people as well to think about. So yeah, I know I'm excited to to get into all of that good stuff. David: All right. All right. So I think what I what I generally like to do, Dan, is is kind of start the episodes with a little bit of it now. maybe let's not go too deep on the business, but for those folks just tuning in who maybe don't know us, don't know you, don't know me, why don't we talk a little bit about what is co-unity and that'll kinda anchor the discussion the remaining the way through here. So back to you. Dan: Yeah, for sure. so Community is a agency that is focused very much on the value that comes from within your project, brand, and audience that's deeper within the funnel, you could say, right? Like it's around that element of loyalty building and the people who are being a part of your project, your brand, whatever it is. And they are leaning into it in different ways. They have a shared kind of passion and alignment around what's going on. And that's where we kind of have found some really interesting space. There's a lot of agencies, specifically where we jumped into was in blockchain industry, initially Web3 and a lot of the communities around token projects and everything that you know, do a lot of everything from A to Z. And we decide we're going to go very focused on just the kind of community part. so about four years ago, I was trying to figure out, you know, these different entrepreneurial ventures I was dabbling in. And I was doing a little bit of marketing in the web three space. I was helping NFT projects when NFTs were a big thing on some of their marketing. And ended up meeting someone who built Discord servers. And his name is Peter, he was one of our original co-founders, awesome guy. And, you know, very, very technical and detail oriented about the structure and the process with how you organize a Discord cleanly, right? And I thought it was fascinating and such a great product or in a way a great service of what he was able to do. and then my current business partner, Nick, we all kind of came together and ended up doubling down to this as a business. And slowly we got like our first client. And we all three of us just worked on that same client for a few months. And then we started to innovate consistently on what can we do for more engagement, for more loyalty, for more different ways of getting the community excited about this. The first one was a gaming project. And yeah, we just sharpened our teeth with it and got a couple more clients. And then I started going to conferences and meeting more people and having more discussions. And yeah, we've been growing ever since then. And it's just been a flow of the last four years of constantly trying to, you know, as I do with like, you know, the engineering background, problem solve and innovate in the most kind of creative way to think through how can we bring people closer to the center or closer to becoming an advocate, a leader around what you're doing with your brand. Right. So that's kind of a bit of the main consensus of it. Yeah. David: Alright, so that's awesome. So we'll we'll talk about currencies shortly. I'm kinda curious. That's still part of Dan: Sure. David: your anchor space or you guys kinda d diversify well beyond that. But all right, so let's get let's get into some of your background here. This is kind of interesting. Grew up in Canada, small town, mountain town. What does that mean, a mountain town? What's that what's what is that like Dan: Yeah. David: what does that signify as far as a town? Dan: I guess it's like, you know, when you're in the town, you you kinda have these big things over your shoulders. You know, you're down the valley and you can just look up and you've got a mountain up to your right and you know, up to up to your left. And yeah, there's about ten thousand people in my hometown. It's called Nelson. It's in an area in BC called the Kootenys. it's British Columbia. So it's about a seven or eight hour drive from Vancouver. Towards the next province over Alberta. So it is quite remote. I generally actually fly into Spokane, Washington, and then drive David: Okay. Dan: north up up through the border. a little fun fact about Canada, David: right. Yeah. Dan: about I think it's 93 or 94% of Canadians live within three hour drive of the border. All the big cities, you know, Toronto, Ottawa, Vancouver, Edmonton, you know, they're all not too far away from the border. Cause once you get to the north half of Canada. It's not as enjoyable, trust me. So David: Okay, that's fair. And what'd your folks do, if you don't mind me asking? Just kinda curious about your your your journey Dan: Yeah. Yeah. So my David: in the entrepreneurialism. Dan: For sure, my dad was a civil engineer. My grandpa was also a civil engineer, so a little bit of an engineering lineage. David: Okay. Okay. So you had you had engineering was gonna be like the next stop out of out of small town B C. Got it. Dan: Yeah, and I and I was lucky too, 'cause, you know, I got into remote control cars and remote control planes and drones and stuff and even real cars as well. Like my dad we got like a project minivan that had all the the brakes were all broken down and a few other pieces on the van weren't working as like a project and we took it apart in the garage and, you know, fixed it up and Then ended up reselling it, right? so really enjoyed the hands on side of things. We had a little small kind of farm. My mom got two horses. so grew up with a little bit of farm life kind of style as well. so yeah, super lucky to have David: Yeah. Dan: to have that for sure. Definitely different from a way what you're doing now, or something totally mysterious and totally easy to find. David: Parents understand what you're doing now, or is it just like totally mysterious? Dan, yeah, he's he's fine. I don't know what he does, but yeah. Dan: It's like I feel like we get a little further through the education every time I come home and visit, you know? It's like we we go to the next chapter and work our way through it a little bit more. It's a journey. David: I think that's fair. I mean I've been doing digital marketing for a long Forever, you know, my dad just no shot. Say, I I don't know what you do, I don't get it. He'd like purposefully mispronounce every social engineering or social network of Twixting, I think was one of my favorites. Spacebook was another one he had. just wasn't wasn't having it, just old school. Just like whatever, dude. I'm always kind of curious. Okay. Dan: Yeah. Yeah. David: Soccer. Dan: man, such a such a passion for me and it's brought me a lot of places and I still play. David: Okay. Dan: so when I was in that little small town, I ended up had a friend who went and did his second last year of high school in Vancouver. He had an spot on an academy, which was where you train every single day and also go to school. And I ended up trying out for the academy. And I made it on to the academy spot. So I ended up moving out when I was sixteen to Vancouver, seven, eight hours away, live with a homestay family and train in the academy every day. Got a lot better at soccer. David: Amazing. What what position you play? Dan: mostly on the wing. Yeah. So I David: Okay. Dan: was up and down the wing quite a bit. It's lots of running. And, David: Yep. The winger. Dan: you know, growing up in the mountain town, lots of hiking, you know, I used to do that a lot with the family. So, you know, you stay stayed pretty fit. But yeah, no, it was great. That got my skills up quite a bit. Then I did first year college in Vancouver and then I got a scholarship in the US to an engineering school in Memphis, Tennessee. So I played college there, had athletic scholarship there. and then right after college, I ended up trying out for a team that I made it on to where we were a touring team from the US and we went to Northern Europe and I played in Latvia, Lithuania, and Estonia for about two or three months. David: That sounds amazing. Dan: and yeah, it was very fun. I I s I enjoyed it a ton, training twice a day, playing professional clubs in northern Europe in their off season. and then had to choose between an offer for a team in Sweden and going back to the US to actually get some work as an engineer, which because I had my degree and keep my visa valid and whatnot. So I ended up keeping my visa valid for the US and went back to the US. Started working as an engineer and then signed a contract for a professional indoor team. It was called the n it was in the National Indoor Soccer League, the NISL. And I did two seasons with with them, which was really fun. Got to train in the morning at six AM and then go to the office the where I was working as an engineer. And yeah, managed to to balance a bit of both of those worlds, which was cool. David: Huh. That's awesome. Alright. So you're you're clearly you're you're constantly on the go. If I heard one thing out of all of that is that Dan's a guy who likes to run a lot. Dan: Yeah. Yeah. A lot of boundary pushing, I think. I think that's a a big thing for entrepreneurs David: Yeah. Dan: in in business in a certain sense. That's a common trait. Even when you see a lot of athletes who are entrepreneurs as well, there's like David: Mm-hmm. Dan: this I've I'm pretty competitive. I like to win, you know. David: Yep. Dan: and and you push yourself for that and you push your boundaries for that with your training, with just, you know, everything that you can kind of do to To get to that next level, right? and I think that same ethos translates quite well into business when it comes to sports, you know, this aspect of within business, we're all kind of there's almost elements of training within business where you're learning, you're studying stuff, you know, the marketing, the sales, the conversation, how do you handle your objections for something you're trying to sell within your clients and you practice that, right? And then game day is like a sales call, you know, you gotta. Crush your sales call, use the knowledge that you've been leaning into and what you've been practicing and put it all out there, to see if you can get the W and close the deal, right? David: No, I get that. And I I think I got a question for ya. As far as soccer Dan: Sure. David: to just as you as a player, are you a big tape guy or did y Dan: A big sorry? David: did you watch a lot of tape? Dan: Yeah, our college coach we did watch a lot of tape. mm. Definitely in the in the change room locker rooms. And then, you know, in in general overall, just, you know, watched Premier League and watched different other professional clubs, but we would watch specifically our own college games as well, David: Right. Dan: quite consistently. David: I if I find that, you know, athletes pro, semi pro athletes bring a bring a a very interesting kind of angle to to the world of work. it's kind of fascinating just talking about it. All right. So let's talk a little bit about community now, because we're gonna kind of shift here into we're gonna come back to soccer. I'm gonna come back to engineering too, because I think, you know. engineers definitely are not boundary pushers. They have different frameworks and sounds like you you take a little bit of kind of the rules based kind of mentality Dan: Base kind of David: and some of the the athletics mentality of a competitor and looking to just overachieve relative to others. And I mean that is what competition really is, right? It has an endpoint that it's just a little bit ahead of the next. That gets you the W. so it's an interesting mix that you you kind of cut rolling in here. And so you get into to this space of I guess the last question Dan: Interesting things that you're So you get into this space of I guess David: on your background, you get into this space of you were playing in NFT at that point, or were you playing in community and you were like in technology? What was the what was what was happening at that like four and a half year ago moment? Dan: Sure. I mean, even like briefly taking it a step even further back from that, throughout David: Yeah. Dan: college and whatnot, I was constantly having all sorts of business ideas to optimize things, trying to design different things. I was in the YouTube work the YouTube rabbit holes of how do you make a million dollars in affiliate marketing. And I even, you know, got David: Okay. Yeah. Dan: pulled into the drop shipping trend. I started a company. David: Okay. What are you drop shipping? Dan: I was dropping drop shipping Game of Thrones jewelry when Game of Thrones was really popular. Right. David: That's fantastic. Okay. Dan: and like and yeah, I was I was well, it was funny. David: Did you make money doing that or was it just chaos? Dan: I did not make money. I made sales, but I spent more messing around with Facebook ads. And that was David: Yeah. Dan: right when Facebook ads started to get more expensive. But David: Right. Dan: I learned a lot, you know, and I was constantly just trying these different things. And in a way, there was a component to I started to realize the lesson of like a lot of this YouTube clickbait shortcuts to a million dollars are are not so much shortcuts. You know, there's there's not David: Right. Dan: a lot of these types of shortcuts in life and whatnot. so I was dabbling in all these different things. The one component that stayed a little bit steady was getting into trading. So I started to trade stocks a little bit. I learned about technical analysis, about reading charts. I started to trade options. And then the app that I was using, which was Robinhood at the time, they added like crypto on their app in like 2018, 2019. I was like, what's crypto? What's Bitcoin? What's Ethereum? And then I went down a big rabbit hole as an engineer reading the Bitcoin white paper and everything online. And I was like, wow, blockchain technology is really interesting. I could see myself doing something in this space. I don't know what. And so I was just kind of constantly following these different trends and components of what was going on with blockchain. And that was when NFT started to make a big kind of pump. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, for sure. Did I what? David: Yeah, did you just add a quick question here, did you build your own mind? You did you build your did you build your own mind? Dan: was I like mining Bitcoin with my own computer? David: Yeah. Dan: no, I didn't get into mining directly with Bitcoin. just because my laptop David: Yeah, I didn't either. I was Dan: at the time didn't have the didn't have the compute power for it. but I got into like there was an element David: That was one of my regrets. Dan: of ICOs and nodes and all sorts of different crypto things I was dabbling into. David: Yeah. Dan: but and then the NFTs was wild. It was like, You know, seeing the NFTs really take off. And I was following people, you know, on YouTube who were trading the NFTs and there was Axie Infinity. There's all these crazy things that happened in the space that were interesting, social dynamics of projects and tokens and all this money. And I was like, where does this money come from? You know, and how is there so much speculation? This is this is like the wild west of a frontier technology, and it felt kind of like remnants of what I've, you know. Heard a lot about with when the when the internet made the big boom in like the 1999, 2000, whatever, right? So I was like, this is fascinating. and that's why I wanted to position myself to do something in that space. And I had a friend at the time who was running a marketing agency and he opened up a element to his agency called agency box. It was a really smart business model, which was basically like a white label. partner program where they would build you your website for you. and then all you had to do was go out and get sales, and then you fulfilled your services through them. So they basically gave you a good rate. You could market up however you want. And then you could go from there. So I did, and they had really great PR connections and PR packages. So I ended up spinning up a website and selling PR in media to NFT projects that were wanting to get exposure. I was like, well, all these NFT projects are really hot right now. Maybe I can help them get positioned in these PR articles to my friend's agency, build a website, and do some business there. And that started actually, I started to generate that was probably one of my earlier, more successful business. I was like, wow, this is actually rolling. Like maybe I could quit my job. You know, it's like this David: Right. Dan: is this is an online business that seems to be working, right? and that was then when I met Peter, who is building the communities. And I learned about what he was doing. And I my I was also noticing how I didn't have a strong moat per se with you know selling PR services. and there was a lot of other agencies doing it, it was competitive. and it was sometimes it felt like a race at the bottom with certain components to that and you know, structuring yourself there. so when I heard about what he was doing and there wasn't many people seemingly to be doing that type of business. I was like, I wonder if we could have something here, you know, this is interesting. And so that's when the origins of it all kind of began. David: Okay, I love it. So let's talk about the the business now. So you got you were obviously Dan: Let's talk about the the business now. David: looking for opportunity. I think you found a good one in community. I mean I've been personally I've been playing in social from way back when I had hair to now. So that's does it you don't just lose all your hair in a day, I'll just say that. A lot a Dan: Yeah. David: lot of hard work hard earned forehead happening here, okay? And I've seen all kinds of communities. I was, you know, early in a professional sense work in my space. And then started getting into early Facebook apps, building that back when that was a thing, which was kind of way a long time ago. And so I've been on social kind of both personally and professionally for quite a while. And I I I like the space you're playing in. And I think you you kinda you talked about something earlier, and I think let's talk about let's maybe start here in this this concept of talked about this kind of gamification or whatever you want to call it of trying to spin up businesses fast and maybe a little bit soft and an understanding what buying mechanics look like and and I think it's an interesting opportunity to talk about community too and in particular around the metrics Dan: It's an interesting opportunity to talk about community two in particular around David: around a community and So what are you seeing in terms of how people maybe come to you with what they wanna measure versus what they should be measuring and how are you kinda guiding them in that Dan: How people maybe come you with what they want to measure versus what they should be measuring. David: kind of place of good, better, best? because I think a lot of folks tend to get this totally upside down because they're doing the same thing you were doing to kinda Dan: And it is all there's like now because David: start your journey of digital of like, let me get online and go watch the video and Yeah, that looks awesome. So we should be doing that. And it's you know, a little bit of smoke and mirrors, Fugazi, if you will. So kind of curious to get your take on that. Dan: Yeah, no, this really speaks nicely into a framework that we're pushing quite a bit, which I call like GTC, which is go-to-community strategy. And so like what does GTC go to community strategy? what is that compared to GTM go-to-market strategy? You know, and how do they go hand in hand? so a bit of a definition of that and how it kind of plays into this element you're you're speaking a bit about is, you know, go to market is all about. value capture. You know, it's about getting attention. Like good marketing. It's about putting the right fishing hooks out there and seeing what you can get to like bite. And that's like definitely, you know, there's a lot of strategy that goes into that. There's a lot of brilliant kind of components. You know, Seth Godin, the purple cow, all sorts of elements of differentiation, how you get people attracted into that attention layer. but that's also something I think that's you know, the attention economy is getting quite blown up when you think about AI generated content now and just how our attention spans are shortening so much around that. And so GTC is a concept of not value capture of capturing attention, but value creation. So it's about value exchange. And the, you know, analogy component to it is like designing a watering hole. Instead of going out and fishing, you're like building a space where when people come there, they get a lot of value. And there can be some great, you know element of telling their friends like, hey, you should come to this watering hole. It's great place to be, right? and the better your product, the better your brand is. you know, that's like the juice in the water that really attracts people. And the easier it is to form a community around a really great product. A great example is like Cursor. They spent zero dollars on marketing and in their first 12 months, They scale to a hundred million in annual revenue with zero dollars on marketing in that whole year. And it was all from just like this 10X type product that spread by word of mouth like wildfire, right? Through these different communities, through these different circles, you know? And so if you look at that and trying to like engineer, well, what's my what should my, you know, GTC strategy be then, Dan, if I need to do trying to think through value exchange and bring people together? I like to think of it as kind of first mapping out what is your minimum viable community, you know? And there's there's three main pillars. There's an aspect of the identity of like who is this really community for? There's elements of the experience of like what are we actually doing here together? Like, you know, what's the element David: Right. Dan: that we share here around this? And then there's the third element, which is then the structure, like where how where is this hosted? Is this IRL community? Is this an online? Is it a Telegram, Discord, WhatsApp? You know these things. But ultimately to pull all that kind of back to your closer to your kind of question, I really had this element of a message and a process that I'm pushing quite a bit, which is kind of tied into my background of like, you know, pushing boundaries and experimenting. I think experimentation in community is crucial. And you should really think about putting together small experiments and then tying in your analytics to measure those experiments to see how well they work. And then tweak and adjust them or double down on them, right? And the tighter you have that feedback loop, the quicker you're able to optimize and move into different experiences and different components that, you know, tie the community closer to the brand and everything, right? So looking at these elements of your engagement rate, the messaging information, the activation, looking at the cohorts that go through that experiment. thinking through even the stickiness ratio. This is like daily active users over monthly active users, really understanding, you know, how much time are they spending. and there's this one element of this other metric I would drop in that I really like, which is typically a SaaS metric called time to first value. When you have a great SaaS product, you'll like measure how quickly does someone getting value from this product. And the quicker David: Right. Dan: that happens, the longer the retention. so if you want to increase retention in your community, you should be thinking like time to first belonging. Like how do I get someone to have that moment of belonging and connection to my brand and feel that value exchange, that watering, you know, whole moment as quickly as possible so we get a higher retention as well. So that was a little bit of a a mixture of different elements that kind of wrapped around what you were what you were inferring to there. David: well no I get it because I and I think it it makes total sense just hearing you talk about it's a lot of fun because what it it sounds like you and your partners have have managed to capture is taking some best in breed concepts but then really doubling down on community as your value proposition and showcasing how to Explore community using some of those methodologies. I will tell you I'm gonna push back a little bit on your go-to-market definition. I think you're gonna like it, but I'm gonna Dan: Sure. Yeah. David: push back. I think that one of the elements of effective and modern GTM, in my view, is that often it's it's it's not a marketing concept, it's go to the market. And so it's what we're talking about, I think in a modern sense, is putting everybody in an organization, depending on kind of where that organization fits, maybe at the beginning they're still kind of discovering what their market is. So it's a lot more experimental, if you will. And then as they start to know what that market is, really unifying your sales, your customer success team, your marketing team, your product teams. all to start to get into some different types of motions that might be more in a traditional testing sense of you know now that we know what our kind of market is we might start to evolve how we test. Testing at the beginning might be headline tests or things of that nature. But at certain point you're now starting to test your cohorts in a little more elevated kind of things of that nature and within that you probably now that you're starting to have a a better rehearsed choreographed GTM, you might have a different view on community versus where you might be in the first phase of your kind of evolution and then certainly as you start to have depth and you're a fairly well established company. Your GTM is gonna evolve and so I would think your GTC would kinda continue to evolve with that. But perhaps I'm not thinking about it right, but anyways. Dan: I I think is interesting. Like overall, a really good topic of conversation is like where does community fit within the business? Like, where does it fit on the org chart? You know, it's David: Right. Dan: really interesting because sometimes with certain companies, it's closer to product. You know, it's closer to just product support, its elements. That's how it's thought of for the most part, product support, maybe product feedback. David: Yeah. Dan: with other communities, it's closer to marketing. Because it's like advocacy, there's ambassadors, there's content creator programs, right? and so it often gets thrown from organizational mapping, other absorbed into marketing or absorbed into product and kind of rarely owning its own space between the two as much. David: Right. Dan: but it's a fascinating element of of conversation when you ask people, you know, is community closer to product or is it closer to marketing? 'Cause it really can go both ways sometimes, which I think is interesting. David: I think the way you answer that impacts the math that you deploy against it. To be honest, I think if you're saying it's marketing, you're probably more focused on content and developing, you know, tentacles that go further. If you're talking about product, you're probably thinking about, you know, that that concept of time to value. And maybe you're even thinking about what's in it for your community of retention, things of that nature, that y often marketing is not gonna be tasked to to look at their universe that way. They just have a different go forward. And so and both are fine. So how do you guys discover that? What what's your process there of kind of answering that question? Because I imagine a lot of companies are totally disjointed when they come to you and they're like, Well you ask the question and they say, Well, damn, what do you think? And so I would imagine that there's you know, that's why they're coming to Dan: They come here and be like, Well, you ask the question and they say, Well, DM, what do you think? Yeah. David: you is 'cause they don't necessarily have community clarity quite yet. And so how do you guys go about kind of teasing that out? Dan: No, it's a great question. I think there's another scale that comes into this a bit, which is almost like the scale of community is at such a buzzword oftentimes, often being on this scale of like kind of kumbaya community. Like, you know, we all hold hands and it's like, yay, community. It's like good vibes, right? and that's like a component of somehow some people really like think like that's what comes into their mind with kind of Community. and then it's like for us a lot of time, especially when I'm talking to other ex like executive teams and whatnot, it's like, how do we get to the business value of community? Right. And so on the David: Yeah. Dan: marketing front, I'll speak the lingo of, well, if you're paying like KOLs, like key opinion leaders, influencers in the web three space, the average CPM starts at around two hundred dollars to even five hundred dollars for cost per million. Impressions, right? and when you look at running like ambassador and content creator programs, that's almost like micro influencer style of things, like we'll run and operate those programs for half of that CPM. So it's much more effective and efficient from a cost perspective. And you're also distributing to more regions, and you have a higher conversion on elements of the trust factor that. That plays into a the effect here because as a brand, if you put out lots of content and you're like, we're the best, you know, XYZ, buy our product, sign up here, here's the link. It's like, yeah, you read that as a consumer, you're like, Of course you're gonna say that, you know, it takes lots of touches for you to kind of maybe build that trust and maybe click on the link or whatever. But if you have your friend, yeah, yeah. David: It's also unauthentic. Right. Dan: And if you but if you have your friend like Joe's, like, yo, Dan. There's this awesome app I'm using. I'm getting like, you know, cash back or whatever body blah. It's like you should use my link to sign up. It's pretty cool. Check it out. Like I'm I'm I'm enjoying it. I'll be like, hell yeah, Joe. Like let me let me check that thing out. Right. So like conversions already way higher, right? So designing that type of system, you know, hits like marketing metrics and components that gets the attention of the exec team on like, whoa, that's cool. Let's let's scale that, right? so that's on the marketing side. I could touch on the the product one, but I'm not sure if you wanted to if you had any thoughts David: Yeah, let's do it. Dan: on that. David: No, I well, I mean, I have a totally different thought. So why don't you go on the the product side? 'Cause I'm kind of curious Dan: Yeah. Sure. I guess. David: to see what what that answer is of you know, you got a strong product leader, they've owned community, they're gonna hold on to community no matter what. That's their that's their thing. They're they feel the affinity to the users because they're making the product for them. all right, go ahead. How does that work? Dan: Yeah, I mean a lot of time I find with product though too, there's a lot of product teams who the community is also sometimes a bit of to them feels like often a bit of a distraction. Like they want to put their head down the product and work on the product and kind of envision what they have for that. but when people are using the product and they have issues, you know, there's often components where people create tickets, right? They create their support tickets, hey, I have an issue, blah, blah, blah. And I think where community can really add a lot of value is in support ticket deflection, as in you can ask questions about what you were maybe gonna put through on a ticket and the community will lean in and help help each other out, right? There was actually a brilliant case study around this with this consultancy group called Feverbee. His name is Richard Millington, and one of his clients, which he doesn't disclose, but they Allowed him to basically run this test. I don't know how they allowed him do it, but basically they turned the community off completely. So you couldn't chat in the community. And then David: Okay. Dan: they measured and tracked the increase in support ticket volume on the the support side of the business. And it David: Through the roof. Dan: and it went through the roof and the company was like, my goodness, what's happening? Open the community back up. But just that component of that time period and all that extra additional burden on the company to have to answer those questions was like millions of dollars for this company, right? For them to take David: Yeah, of course. Dan: their engineer time and and focus on answering those questions. So again, it's like there's an element where you don't even realize how much of a burden your kind of community and these people who are passionate about your product, their power users, can actually, you know, help. And oftentimes it's just for a component of status and more intrinsic motivators and quality kind of components that they feel like an extension of the team that, you know, enables you to empower them around this, right? And gives so much value both ways then. but yeah, so that's some elements of the of the product side, some some quick thoughts. But happy to happy to jump into the to whatever tangent you were thinking earlier. David: Alright, so new space, new space, very modern. We kinda you kinda teased on this a minute ago in terms of content creation of, you know, anybody anywhere all the time. They can AI content. are you finding that there's greater urgency from your your customers, your clients to have a community to to to really help forge their identity and what's I think insanely noisy kind of time period for for us. Are you finding that I guess on the other side that are you using any tools to try to limit AI content within your communities to to really kind of deflect that and keep the value of the the community. I I guess I find that overall, not talking specifically your business, but overall what I'm seeing, my observation is People are concerned about losing their voice in an AI world. And there there seems to be a an appetite for for a little bit more humanity in in kind of the digital space. So I was just kind of curious to get your take on kind of that that whole I think there were probably twelve questions in there, Dan. So you can pick that however, it kind of works, but Dan: No. It's a it's a fascinating topic right now. Obviously, it's moving so fast. The technology, it's getting s like leaps and bounds and exponentially better with every new model. And I think we are really kind of trying to approach our positioning with it. as like, you know, people say barbell strategy, right? Like we are really leaning into innovation and AI. And we're using a lot of our team is using Cloud Code to build like custom bots and campaigns and graphics and things that are, you know, would normally cost tens of thousands of dollars to to build just to make a really great experience around a community campaign that's now much more efficient for us. But then the whole goal of using that technology and you know leaning into that is then on the other side of the barbell, like to to forge more human connection and to ha have people go through experiences that get them excited and go, wow, this is cool, you know, and potentially allow them to collide with other similar people more easily, like matching aspects and these types of things. So I think it's interesting how we really can leverage a lot of this amazing technology to still bring about more human connection. but that being said, also I think that if you you know think about like a lot of brands and companies right now, creating organic content used to be, you know, quite something to invest into because you had to like think about a marketing team, you had to create the content, you had to write it. But with like agents and AI and you know, we're in this era, yeah, there's definitely a lot of AI slop there, but I think it won't be too long where it's not as much AI slop. It's maybe high it's quite high quality, very similar to human written content. It'd be very hard to differentiate between the two. And I think that's where when there starts to become a flood of so much of that type of content and everything going for our eyeballs, community becomes more of a moat because this is where like there's connection. There's more of a, you know, closer degree to your to your business, to to your organization. And so that's definitely something I think that's you know I think powerful and and helpful around it. David: But I think it's fascinating what is happening in AI and I think I I like that concept that you mentioned of a community moat. That that that feels very very protected. Are you are you finding that you're getting on any bots, AI bots in your communities, or had that hasn't happened yet? Dan: Well, again, we've had to definitely innovate into, you know, using the best and newest CAPTCHA technologies and things like that, because bots are even solving CAPTCHAS, right? So typically one of our kind of general processes, it's been like a a standard thing in the web three space, which is being almost unfortunate with community as like a buzzword in itself in its own way, where projects basically were told, hey, you need to have a community of about a hundred thousand members in your Discord in order for you to launch a token on a centralized exchange. The centralized exchanges that list tokens go, how big's your community, you know, and they go, Okay, you've got a hundred thousand members in your community. Great. You check the box, boom, you can list a token. they're they're getting much more wise to that. But unfortunately what that really triggered was people doing a lot of these questing Airdrop kind of elements where they're like, hey, come join our community. We're gonna give like an airdrop. And then people would create multiple social accounts because they think maybe if I'm in the community, I can get more like a reward here. And they'd share it in other groups, and you'd get just like a huge amount of low quality kind of community members who aren't there at all really. For supporting the brand, but more extracting from your brand, extracting from your company to see like, hey, can I get some rewards here and then bounce, you know? David: Treasure hunters. Dan: exactly. So, you know, we've we've had to lean in to fix that problem to front. With one project we did was like the CEO told me, Dan, I'm gonna do this anyway. And I was like, Okay, well, if you're gonna do it anyway, what we'll have is a community structure that we're gonna design for you an architecture, we're gonna engineer the space where There's a shallow end of the pool, which is like anyone can kind of join. It's less friction, right? And then if you want to actually qualify to the deeper area where you want to spend time and nurture those members, we build custom verification systems that connect to your product. So we actually know, okay, this person's actually someone who's using your product. and even up to a certain amount, we've validated it with the API that you kind of gave us in the bot that we built. and now David: It's touching your C RM and you can see it. Yeah. Dan: We can unlock, yeah. That's that. David: makes sense. That's fascinating. Dan: I just David: There's a lot, a lot of a lot of things happening here. You guys are obviously doing a ton of stuff and it's a pretty fast moving space. It's definitely got some social to it. It's got some 3.0. It's got some friction. I think that you know often it's got some old kind of probably outdated metrics that people want to bring into to community that maybe are counterproductive. Not saying that your client was right or wrong in that instance, but You know, there there's definitely I could see very quickly why the people feel like it's a number, it's a volumetric number game when in fact perhaps maybe there's more to community than just having a lot of folks that are low low engagement rate, not seeing the value, that N N R kinda journey, if you will. So this has been awesome. I g Dan: Yeah, you know like the Thousand True Fans, you know, you know that essay? David: Right. No, I don't. What's that? What's that one all about? Dan: it's a really fantastic popular essay. I'll have to I'll have to drop the name for the author of it afterwards or in the notes or something. But there's this little essay called 1000 True Fans. And David: Yep. Dan: it's just all about this ethos of that, like to really scale a business or a company or a project or whatever you really have, you really only need that 1,000 true fans. You know, you don't need 10,000 or 100,000 people in your community. I would way rather take one thousand true fans, someone really passionate about what you're doing and about your project, over a hundred thousand just vanity metric numbers, as you say, right? David: Huh. Yeah, that makes total sense too. I mean if you you know, that's where you get the the journey, that's where you get a lot of the retention. That's where you those folks are the ones who are gonna see the value probably the quickest. They've experienced it. And they're yeah, you're absolutely right, likely to be your your best advocates. One more time. Dan: Kevin Kelly, that's his name. One thousand true one thousand true fans by Kevin Kelly. It's a good resource to check David: Alright. I'll I'll drop a link in Dan: out. David: in the in the show notes for sure. All right. I got a few more questions here. This is a weird one, but okay, so you are Dan. You work at this company that does community. You've been a sports player, so you know team really well. you're Building these communities for others, I I think the word I I kinda used on this is do you feel like you're like a samurai kind of living this the these missions for others, or do you feel like you're fulfilling your own mission and your your own kind of you you are community fulfilled in in kind of living through these folks? Dan: What a great, interesting question. I think for me, there's an ethos of just from a business running, you know, running an agency. I I really thrive on problem solving. Well, I feel like when you go through college and engineering, it's like all you're doing is just constantly solving these different random hypothetical problems from economics to thermodynamics to fluids to all sorts of different, you know, questions David: Yep. Dan: that are Testing your brain and you know, making sure you can kind of walk walk through and figure them out. And a lot of time figuring them out comes through a process of like, well, what are the constants and what are the variables and how do we kind of work the equation out to kind of solve the problem? And ultimately I really find a lot of marketing, a lot of community problems and clients come in a sort of way like this, where I just have to really think through, okay, well. What do we have to work with here that's kind of a constant? What do we have to work with here that's more variable? What are things that we've done in the past that have gotten great results? And I think I truly enjoy bringing different ideas and solutions and then seeing them put into effect and bring results, right? And being able to repeat this with multiple different clients is a is one I feel like I grow and develop. way faster than if I was just working at a single company. You know, if I was working just at a single company, there would be a handful of different pro like problems and things that I have to solve and whatnot. And I think that was part of what also I struggled with working as an engineer at two different companies. Like I kind of felt like I hit the ceiling very quickly. I was like, okay, so this is what life's gonna be like every day, you know. sure there's some different things that'll happen each day and and whatnot, but for the most part this is kind of the flow. Whereas I love the fact that working in the agency and having different like prospect calls, sales call, client calls, I never know what crazy news is gonna drop, what's gonna happen. It's like, and like one of our account managers goes, Dan, there's something going on with this client and this is happening. And I'll be like, All right, let's check it out, you know, let's figure it out. and yeah, and I think there's a degree that even the sports side of that, you know, when it comes to stress, you know, juggling, doing athletic sports out of out of college while doing engineering and just being used to like, the exams tomorrow, haven't studied yet. It's like, all right, I guess I'll have to study tonight, you know, just like being David: Right. Dan: able to deal last minute with things and and deal with pressure and whatnot. I don't know. It just becomes more routine, I guess, and in a certain sort of way, when you when you pull out that W at the last minute with the little bit of prep and whatnot, it it also feels like, You know, rewarding W, I guess you could say. David: Love it. Alright. So I want to ask you something, kind of final question of our episode here. So we have or I have one of the signature elements of the flip story is the flip story recipe book. And so I invite all the guests to to kind of share their own recipe. It could be a how-to, it could be a series of ingredients, could be a method. or even a framework. And the idea is to to give something to the audience that they can kind of look at that recipe and say, I have this challenge. Let me go use that recipe to to either kind of flip that moment or even to flip their their wider aperture, if you will. So Dan, I'd love to get your take on on a recipe for our show. Dan: Yeah. Man, there's so many different recipes. I feel like we touched on one earlier. That is a really important one, I think, for all different kind of business owners and whatnot. And even from a personal growth perspective, can even apply, which is that kind of component of kind of taking risks and and putting experiments out there, you know, and basically taking action on something. And putting the right things in place to be able to track and measure that and and then being able to make a decision on, you know, whether you want to adjust that, drop that, or double down on it, right? That component of let me put together a campaign of some sort and let me think about the ways that I can track that and how tight can I make that feedback loop where I can put that experiment out and get that quick feedback. Maybe I've got a specific area of my business or a group that I'm able to do this with. And then the insights that you can get from that can really drive your strategy, right? Because I think at the end the day, strategy is all about prioritization. You know, good strategy is great prioritization. and in order to make those great strategic decisions, you need to kind of be working with something. And so to be working with something, you need to be tracking it and you need to test things and put them out there and see where it goes from there. So an element of experimental loops with tracking and leaning into that leaning into those areas. David: Well told. All right. Well, Dan, this has been awesome. how how do people find you? Just as we kind of wrap out. Dan: Yeah, for sure. you can find me on actually all social platforms. My handle is the same. It's T-H-E the Dan Rodman. so the Dan Rodman, just like Dennis Rodman, but no relation. and mostly active on on X and on LinkedIn. And yeah, no, definitely feel free to reach out to me on LinkedIn or X if you've got any questions about community or if you're curious about any of it and always happy to, you know, hop on a call or connect you with the team and yeah, go from there. David: Alright, amazing. Well Dan, it's been it's been a lot of fun having you on the show. It's I learned a lot. I loved kinda getting into flip community and getting your perspective as an expert practitioner in the space. So really neat. You guys are doing some neat stuff and really just loved having ya. So Dan: Yeah. Thanks for having me, David. Great questions and enjoyed the time. David: my pleasure. All right folks. Well we'll see you on the next one.