Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Effects of Vicarious Trauma on Trial Lawyers
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07The Effect of Vicarious Trauma on Trial Lawyers.
- 0:10I'm Alla Poli Castro, Director of Education and
- 0:13Professional Development at Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:14Association. I'm delighted to introduce our speaker
- 0:17for today's program, Christina Garcia. Christina
- 0:21is a trial attorney at Dolan Law Firm, where
- 0:24she specializes in representing child survivors
- 0:26of sexual abuse in schools, as well as individuals
- 0:29in cases involving personal injuries and wrongful
- 0:32death. She has been recognized as a super lawyer
- 0:36rising star, a best lawyer is one to watch, and
- 0:39received the Presidential Award of Merit from
- 0:42the Consumer Attorneys of California. She serves
- 0:45on the board of directors for both the Consumer
- 0:47Attorneys of California and the Latina Lawyers
- 0:49Bar Association. We're so excited to have her
- 0:52with us today. So I'm going to turn it over to
- 0:54her now. Thank you for that introduction. Good
- 0:59afternoon, everyone. And thank you for joining
- 1:01us today. As Leah mentioned, I'm a plaintiff
- 1:06side personal injury attorney with the Dolan
- 1:09law firm. And today we're going to be discussing
- 1:12the effects of vicarious trauma on trial lawyers.
- 1:18Next slide, please. So I handle a lot of sexual
- 1:23abuse cases in schools as well as catastrophic
- 1:26injury and wrongful death cases. As a personal
- 1:30injury attorney, I am constantly exposed to the
- 1:34survivor's or injured person's trauma, whether
- 1:37by listening to their stories, reviewing case
- 1:40material, preparing for depositions, or retelling
- 1:44the story to opposing counsel, mediators, or
- 1:48juries. Next slide. So in our legal profession,
- 1:56the exposure to trauma is not unique to one area
- 1:59of practice. I've listed a few other practices
- 2:03here in which lawyers are exposed to constant
- 2:06trauma. And of course, this is not an exhaustive
- 2:10list. For example, family law. Family law attorneys
- 2:15handle disputes between spouses over child custody,
- 2:19which can get vicious. There could also be domestic
- 2:23violence issues which add to the client's trauma.
- 2:27Immigration law. Immigration lawyers are dealing
- 2:31with very stressful and volatile circumstances,
- 2:35especially at this time. They're having to deal
- 2:38with unprecedented situations and rules that
- 2:41are constantly changing. Whereas for many of
- 2:45our practice, our rules remain the same. For
- 2:50immigration, right now, all of those rules are
- 2:54changing and it's a very stressful environment.
- 2:57Criminal law. Criminal lawyers are exposed to
- 3:02very heavy graphic content. particularly if they
- 3:07are assigned to the special victims unit or homicide
- 3:11cases. Personal injury, as I noted in this field,
- 3:16we have constant contact with clients whose lives
- 3:19have been altered or forever tamed by the loss
- 3:22of a loved one. And lastly, bankruptcy law. These
- 3:27are lawyers who are dealing with clients whose
- 3:30financial worlds have fallen apart. Next slide.
- 3:38So as attorneys, we are tasked not only with
- 3:41addressing the legal aspect of a case, but also
- 3:45with offering reassurance and support to our
- 3:47clients, which requires empathy and compassion.
- 3:52Therefore, it's not surprising that those representing
- 3:55traumatized individuals may themselves become
- 3:58physically and emotionally depleted. Next slide.
- 4:07I'm going to start with a couple of definitions,
- 4:11which although they may appear basic, I do think
- 4:14they're important to understand for the topic
- 4:17we will be discussing today. So trauma is defined
- 4:21as a psychological and emotional response to
- 4:25an event or an experience that is deeply distressing
- 4:29or disturbing. This event or experience overwhelms
- 4:33a person's ability to cope. Next. The American
- 4:40Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorder,
- 4:45fifth edition, which is also referred to as DSM
- 4:48-5, briefly describes trauma as exposure to actual
- 4:54or threatened death, serious injury, or sexual
- 4:58violence. Next. What is like curious trauma?
- 5:07So vicarious trauma is the experience of absorbing
- 5:12others pain and times of their distress so deeply
- 5:16that it affects your own well -being. And this
- 5:19is a result of repeated exposure to those traumatic
- 5:23experiences. Next. Recent research has found
- 5:31that there is a connection between post -traumatic
- 5:35stress disorder and secondary trauma. So PTSD
- 5:39is a mental health condition that is triggered
- 5:42by experiencing or witnessing a traumatic event.
- 5:46So that could be reliving or re -experiencing
- 5:50nightmares, flashbacks, triggers. A person experiencing
- 5:58PTSD may also have symptoms of hyperarousal or
- 6:02being on guard. So they're always feeling jittery
- 6:07or they're overly alert. They're constantly in
- 6:11the fight or flight or freeze response. They
- 6:15have difficulty sleeping and concentrating. They
- 6:18feel angry and irritable. Next. Secondary trauma
- 6:28is a concept that has received significant scholarly
- 6:31attention in the recent years. Karen M. Seeley
- 6:36wrote a book that's called, Therapy After Terror
- 6:399 -11, Psychotherapists and Mental Health. What
- 6:43she did in this book is that she examined the
- 6:462001 World Trade Center attack from the perspectives
- 6:50of the New York City mental health professionals
- 6:53who treated patients affected by the attack.
- 6:57Next. So Celie, who is a licensed clinical social
- 7:04worker herself, she offered a comprehensive examination
- 7:08of the work and the experience of the psychotherapists
- 7:12in the aftermath of 9 -11. So in her book, she
- 7:17notices that these psychotherapists that are
- 7:19treating patients who were affected by 9 -11
- 7:22started displaying similar symptoms of PTSD due
- 7:27to the constant exposure that they had by hearing
- 7:31the stories of their patients. Next. So how is
- 7:45PTSD and secondary trauma related? So in 2013,
- 7:51the DSM -5 introduced an additional category
- 7:55of causation of PTSD. And in this, it stated
- 8:00that PTSD symptoms could be experienced by the
- 8:04repeated or extreme exposure to details of traumatic
- 8:08events. So the person developing these symptoms
- 8:12do so in the course of their professional duties.
- 8:16Similar to nurses and doctors, we as lawyers
- 8:21also constantly engage with this traumatic material,
- 8:25whether it's photographs of car accidents, injuries,
- 8:32wrongful deaths, and things like that. Next.
- 8:41So why does it matter? Vicarious trauma is an
- 8:47unavoidable occupational hazard for diligent
- 8:51and humane lawyers who care deeply for their
- 8:54clients. The intensity of this compassion and
- 8:58empathy over time leads to vicarious traumatization.
- 9:03A way to avoid vicarious trauma is to fail to
- 9:07engage compassionately or even empathetically
- 9:10with one's clients. But given that you're all
- 9:14here for this webinar, that tells me that you
- 9:17care for your clients and you want to empathize
- 9:19with them, but you also want to take care of
- 9:22your own well -being because in order to care
- 9:24for our clients, we need to care for ourselves
- 9:27first. Next. So although in the past, it seemed
- 9:36that the state bar was not too concerned with
- 9:39the emotional or mental health of lawyers, it
- 9:43appears that it has become a growing concern
- 9:46recently. So not too long ago, the state bar
- 9:50implemented a duty of competence, which is state
- 9:53bar of California rule 1 .1. And this rule provides
- 9:59that a lawyer shall not intentionally recklessly
- 10:04with gross negligence or repeatedly fail to perform
- 10:08legal services with competence. And under this
- 10:12rule, competence is in any legal service shall
- 10:19mean to apply the learning and skill and mental,
- 10:24emotional, and physical ability reasonably necessary
- 10:28for the performance of such service. So under
- 10:32this state bar rule, mental and emotional wellness
- 10:36is part of our duty of competence as lawyers.
- 10:48So I heard about the Raging River analogy a few
- 10:52years ago, and I thought it was a really good
- 10:55way to explain the secondary trauma that a lot
- 10:59of waters experience through their clients. Next.
- 11:10So for this analogy, imagine that your client
- 11:15lives at the center of a raging river. Their
- 11:20lawyer, which is you, stands at the edge of the
- 11:24river as a huge boulder is dropped just in front
- 11:27of your client. So your client is knocked down
- 11:32by the immediate towering waves that the boulder
- 11:35creates. The waves completely cover him, washing
- 11:40over him, soaking him. The impact of the rushing
- 11:45water topples him each time, and he struggles
- 11:49and continues to struggle to keep himself standing.
- 11:55Next. So the lawyer who's standing at the edge
- 12:02of the river is eventually also struck by those
- 12:05waves and ripples created by the boulder. The
- 12:08waves are different, however, similar in shape
- 12:12in character to the initial waves. So the lawyer
- 12:16also stands at the intersection of many such
- 12:20rivers receiving similar waves and ripples from
- 12:24many directions. So this raging river analogy
- 12:32provides an overall visual image for the concepts
- 12:36of vicarious trauma, secondary traumatic stress,
- 12:42and compassionate fatigue. The raging river is
- 12:46the day -to -day stressful condition the client
- 12:49lives in. The boulder represents a trauma occurring
- 12:54in the life of the client. And the towering waves
- 12:58represent the client's initial experience of
- 13:01that trauma. And the lesser waves and ripples
- 13:05represent the secondary trauma experienced by
- 13:08the lawyer. And as I mentioned, as the lawyer,
- 13:12We don't have one client, we have many clients.
- 13:17So it's as if many rivers are coming at us in
- 13:21different direction, different waves and different
- 13:24shapes as we're absorbing all the different trauma
- 13:28from our different clients. The terms compassion
- 13:38fatigue. secondary traumatic stress, and vicarious
- 13:42trauma are related, but distinct concepts arising
- 13:47from secondary exposure to trauma. So this concept
- 13:50was originally studied in first responders, nurses,
- 13:54and doctors, but is now recognized as a risk
- 13:58for lawyers and other helping professions as
- 14:01well. Dr. Charles Fickley is the founder of the
- 14:11Traumatology Institute and the leading author
- 14:14in this field. He has a lot of work discussing
- 14:19compassion fatigue and discussing how people
- 14:24who are helping professionals such as nurses,
- 14:28doctors, lawyers, we experience compassion fatigue
- 14:33because we take in our clients' experience. We
- 14:37empathize with them. We want to make sure that
- 14:41they feel heard. But at some point after this
- 14:45constant exposure, our Gas tends to run on empty,
- 14:50right? And we're starting to feel that fatigue
- 14:53of caring so much for all of our clients. So
- 14:58his work has greatly contributed to the understanding
- 15:02of compassionate stress in professionals. Next.
- 15:12So he defined compassion fatigue in secondary
- 15:17traumatic stress as follows. Compassion fatigue
- 15:21is the emotional and physical exhaustion that
- 15:26can affect helping professionals over time. And
- 15:30secondary traumatic stress is described as the
- 15:33trauma experienced indirectly by hearing about
- 15:37traumatic events affecting others. He also referred
- 15:43to compassion fatigue as the result of the cost
- 15:47of caring. And this cost of caring can manifest
- 15:52symptoms similar to PTSD. So this constant secondary
- 16:02exposure that as lawyers we experience can definitely
- 16:06lead to vicarious trauma. Psychologists Lori
- 16:17A. Perlman and Kei Savitme coined the term vicarious
- 16:22trauma. And it is used to describe the profound
- 16:26shift in worldview that occurs in helping professionals
- 16:30when they work with clients who have experienced
- 16:32trauma. When someone is experiencing vicarious
- 16:44trauma, or I may refer to it as VT for short,
- 16:48their fundamental beliefs about the world are
- 16:51altered and possibly damaged by being repeatedly
- 16:55exposed to traumatic material. So they start
- 16:58believing that the world is a dangerous place
- 17:01and that all people are inherently bad. And VT
- 17:06is cumulative, so it happens over time. It's
- 17:11the constant exposure, the constant hearing of
- 17:16your client's stories, as well as repeating those
- 17:20stories to whether it's a judge or a mediator.
- 17:25And that can significantly impact an attorney's
- 17:28personal and professional life. So vicarious
- 17:37trauma is not just a concept. It's a real diagnosis
- 17:45and something that also manifests itself not
- 17:49only in physical symptoms but also emotional
- 17:53symptoms. So some of the physical symptoms are
- 18:04high levels of cortisol. So this is when your
- 18:08body is producing too much of the stress hormone,
- 18:11which is triggered by chronic stress. And this
- 18:14can lead to high blood pressure and high blood
- 18:17sugar. You may also be experiencing sleep disturbances.
- 18:23So you may find yourself tossing and turning
- 18:26in bed or constantly getting up because you're
- 18:29restless. You may experience hair loss, gastrointestinal
- 18:36problems. So common symptoms for this are abdominal
- 18:40pain and bloating. You may also experience weight
- 18:44gain. With the increased levels of cortisol,
- 18:48you may find that your appetite has increased.
- 18:51So you're feeling hungrier and more often. And
- 18:55a lot of the time your cravings are for sugary
- 18:59and fatty foods. You may also experience headaches.
- 19:03And this may be more noticeable if you're someone
- 19:07who would rarely suffer. from headaches and then
- 19:11recently you find yourself having constant headaches.
- 19:15Chronic fatigue is also a physical symptom. So
- 19:19this is when someone's feeling extremely tired
- 19:22all the time and that tiredness tends to sometime
- 19:25last more than six months. And even when they
- 19:28get a good night's rest, they still wake up feeling
- 19:32foggy minded and extremely fatigued. An impaired
- 19:38immune system is also a symptom. So people experiencing
- 19:44this will find themselves getting sick more often
- 19:48or they will find that they're having a hard
- 19:50time getting over a cold and infection or whatever
- 19:54illness it is that they have. And rapid pulse
- 20:00and breathing is also one of the symptoms. So
- 20:04this can happen when your brain activates the
- 20:08fight or flight response because it releases
- 20:11hormones like adrenaline and cortisol that quickens
- 20:15your heartbeat and causes shallow breathing.
- 20:21Next. as if physical symptoms weren't enough.
- 20:30There's also emotional symptoms that come along
- 20:33with it. So emotional numbness or feeling disconnected.
- 20:41So this is when your brain shuts off feelings
- 20:44like joy, sadness, or anger to survive trauma
- 20:50or a high stress situation. Feeling disillusioned
- 20:55by humanity. So this is heavy. It's a painful
- 21:00weight that often comes from emotional burnout.
- 21:04You're constantly seeing the bad behavior in
- 21:07the world, and it makes you feel like you've
- 21:09lost faith in humanity. Changes in the world
- 21:15view are considered inevitable. feelings of hopelessness.
- 21:21The person may feel despair, a lack of positive
- 21:24expectations for the future. They may also believe
- 21:28that nothing will ever improve. They can also
- 21:33experience cynicism. So they may adopt an attitude
- 21:37marked by deep distrust of human motives. So
- 21:43they believe that people act only out of selfishness.
- 21:48Pessimism. They're expecting the worst outcome.
- 21:52They're focusing on the negative side of life,
- 21:55and they believe that pain or evil is more common
- 21:59than good. And lastly, here we have hypervigilance.
- 22:06So people experiencing this symptom may feel
- 22:09as if danger is lurking in every corner. So they're
- 22:12always at the edge of their seat, keeping an
- 22:15eye out for danger. Next. So these effects may
- 22:28cause attorneys to withdraw or isolate themselves.
- 22:33They start to fail to find pleasure in activities
- 22:40that they once enjoyed. They also become detached
- 22:44from others, not just at work, but in their personal
- 22:47lives as well. So lawyers might feel that they
- 22:52have lost their compassion. Next. So when you're
- 23:08living in a state of vicarious trauma, it becomes
- 23:11harder to maintain a level of compassion. You
- 23:15start to notice that you're exhibiting little
- 23:18or no empathy or no sympathy for other people.
- 23:23Sometimes you may compare clients and this is
- 23:27the way that it manifests. For example, in personal
- 23:32injury you may have a client who unfortunately
- 23:36had to have their leg amputated and then you
- 23:40have a client who had a broken ankle and you
- 23:44might be on the phone with the client with a
- 23:46broken ankle who is just telling you how difficult
- 23:50life is and many things that they are unable
- 23:53to do in their daily activities. And in your
- 23:57mind, you're thinking, yes, it's bad, but it's
- 24:00not as bad as this person who had the amputated
- 24:03leg and they're doing their best to survive and
- 24:07to come out in front of this. And so all of that
- 24:12is part of that compassion fatigue. Right. It's
- 24:16not that you don't you care less about your client
- 24:20that has the broken ankle. It's just that you're
- 24:23tired of having all that empathy and in your
- 24:27brain you're starting to exhibit less empathy
- 24:30for some people than others by comparing you
- 24:34know who may have it worse if you can say it
- 24:38that way. So another thing that occurs is avoidance.
- 24:43So you may receive emails or phone calls from
- 24:48a client and you know that that client has a
- 24:53particularly traumatic story and you may not
- 24:57feel ready to quite jump into that conversation.
- 25:01So you kind of just put it aside and try to avoid
- 25:05it as long as you can. So all of this can leave
- 25:11you feeling like there's a sense that you have
- 25:14stopped caring for your clients. But in reality,
- 25:18the intensity of care and empathy for your clients
- 25:22is what led you to experience post -traumatic
- 25:25symptoms like numbness. Repeated exposure to
- 25:39client trauma can lead to substance abuse. And
- 25:43it's no secret that, unfortunately, in the legal
- 25:47profession, there is a history of alcohol and
- 25:51drug abuse. The chronic stress can negatively
- 25:55impact a person's impulse control, learning,
- 25:59and memory functions. And so as a result of that,
- 26:04a lot of lawyers may self -medicate with alcohol
- 26:09or drugs. And it's important to note that the
- 26:14majority of disciplinary matters handled by the
- 26:18state bar are due to lawyers dealing with mental
- 26:21health issues or alcohol and drug issues. Next.
- 26:37So how can we mitigate these vicarious trauma
- 26:43symptoms? So education is a big part of it, learning
- 26:49more about it and how it can affect us and the
- 26:53way that it manifests itself, not just physically,
- 26:57but emotionally as well. It's important to continue
- 27:02educating yourself on the topic. been a lot of
- 27:09research, a larger body of research that has
- 27:12been done in recent years regarding this concept.
- 27:17And now that it has been acknowledged that lawyers
- 27:20are at risk for this secondary trauma, not just
- 27:24doctors versus responders, there is larger resources
- 27:31and information out there about this. And it's
- 27:37important to educate ourselves, not just for
- 27:39ourselves, but also for our colleagues, right?
- 27:43For our other friends that are also in the profession.
- 27:47And you might notice these symptoms that they're
- 27:51displaying and they may need assistance with
- 27:55that. So it's important to acknowledge the trauma
- 27:59that you're dealing with. talk about it, normalize
- 28:04it, and don't allow it to have a stigma that
- 28:07you are weak for taking a proactive approach.
- 28:26So in the materials, I've included a vicarious
- 28:32trauma assessment and it's a pretty short assessment.
- 28:37It's two pages and it has about 30 questions
- 28:42and it's a pretty quick answer. It gives you
- 28:46numbers one through five as to whether you never
- 28:52experience this rarely, sometimes, often, or
- 28:57very often. Next. And I would encourage everyone
- 29:11to take the assessment. I know that a lot of
- 29:16you will have the intention to return to do this
- 29:20assessment to complete it, but life gets busy
- 29:24and you may never come back to it. So what I'm
- 29:28going to do is I'm just going to read the questions
- 29:31that appear on the first page. And as I read
- 29:36them, you should think whether this is something
- 29:40that you never feel, rarely, sometimes, often,
- 29:46or very often. So the first one is, I feel overwhelmed
- 29:54by the thought of going to work each day. The
- 30:03next one is, I feel exhausted from the moment
- 30:08I get to work. Three. I am unable to stop thinking
- 30:19about a particular situation I worked on. Four,
- 30:29I have little motivation when I am at work. Five,
- 30:40I have a difficult time not thinking about work
- 30:44when I'm at home. Six, I am startled easily by
- 30:55loud noises. Seven, I am easily irritated and
- 31:05have a harder time coming back to center once
- 31:08I am irritated. Eight, I feel like I have little
- 31:17to no control over my day -to -day life. Nine,
- 31:26I feel as though I am experiencing the trauma
- 31:29of someone else that I have helped. Ten, I am
- 31:38preoccupied with wanting to follow up with specific
- 31:42clients. 12. I feel overwhelmed by the system
- 31:52I work within. 12. I have a difficult time seeing
- 32:01any good in the work I have done. 13. I feel
- 32:10trapped by my work. and 14, I am having difficult
- 32:18time sleeping. We can go on to the next slide.
- 32:36So there is a second page with additional questions
- 32:42and Once you are done filling in the numbers
- 32:47that you're filling for each question, then you
- 32:50can go at the end here and it will show you a
- 32:54score. It ranges from 30 to 33, which is no signs
- 33:01of burnout, so you're doing great if you're in
- 33:04this section. 34 to 62, low risk of burnout unless
- 33:11some factors are particularly severe. And then
- 33:14on the right -hand column, it gives you more
- 33:17of a description of the classification. Then
- 33:23you have 62 to 75, which is high burnout risk.
- 33:30And so at this point, if you're scoring here,
- 33:34you may want to start checking in with yourself
- 33:39and really see how you're feeling if you're exhibiting
- 33:42any of the vicarious trauma symptoms that we
- 33:48discussed earlier. 75 to 90, that's burnout.
- 33:56And 90 to 150, this is vicarious trauma. Again,
- 34:05you know, it only takes a few minutes. I think
- 34:08it's a good way to check in with yourself to
- 34:12fill it out. And depending on where you land
- 34:15on the rubric, you may want to seek professional
- 34:19help or implement some of the strategies to mitigate
- 34:23that vicarious trauma that we'll be discussing
- 34:26in the following slides. So how do we mitigate
- 34:37these vicarious trauma symptoms? So a big one
- 34:43is support network. So you want to be able to
- 34:48join bar associations and go to events to create
- 34:54meaningful connections with others in your profession.
- 34:58And not just in your specific legal field, but
- 35:02across other fields. You may find that other
- 35:06lawyers have interests outside of the law that
- 35:10you may also share with them. Also engage in
- 35:16activities that you find meaningful. A lot of
- 35:19the time when we're suffering from the secondary
- 35:22trauma or this compassion fatigue, you just feel
- 35:27empty. you feel like you don't have any more
- 35:32empathy to give. And sometimes it's easy to lose
- 35:36sight as to why we're here. So as lawyers, I
- 35:40know the majority of us became lawyers because
- 35:44we're passionate about what we do, whether it's
- 35:48helping people. And that is the reason why we
- 35:53became lawyers and we're so passionate about
- 35:56it. But when you're experiencing compassion fatigue,
- 36:00this can be lost. You may start feeling, I'm
- 36:03not even sure why I'm in this profession. So
- 36:07doing things like mentoring can be meaningful
- 36:11and it can remind you why you chose to go into
- 36:14law, participating in professional development
- 36:19programs that can also assist you and reinvigorate
- 36:24that passion of yours, and social network outside
- 36:29of the law. I love my lawyer friends, but it's
- 36:33also nice to have friends that are not lawyers.
- 36:36So join groups, organizations that are not law
- 36:40related, but are of interest to you. Next. So
- 36:50self -care is central to the capacity to care
- 36:54for others. And by self -care, I don't mean purchasing
- 36:59nice candles or treating yourself to a massage,
- 37:03although you should still do that if you enjoy
- 37:05that. But I am talking about self -care as something
- 37:10that is more intentional and a practice that
- 37:14you can engage in regularly. So with coping with
- 37:28vicarious trauma, you want to position yourself
- 37:31as a conduit rather than a sponge. So you don't
- 37:35want to be absorbing all of that trauma and keeping
- 37:40it within yourself, right? You want to find ways
- 37:44to allow others' pain to just flow through you
- 37:49rather than you soaking it in. So our client's
- 37:54trauma deserves our attention and it can alert
- 37:58us to bad situations, but it doesn't do any good
- 38:02for us to carry that trauma of those events.
- 38:14So coping with vicarious trauma, this self -care
- 38:20is going to look different for everyone, right,
- 38:23because everybody has different interests. But
- 38:27it's important to find hobbies that you find
- 38:31fun that are engaging, such as gardening. That
- 38:38is one thing that I tried to take up, but was
- 38:43very bad at. So that that quickly fizzled out
- 38:50for me. But you can try hiking, baking, journaling,
- 38:57painting, camping, cycling, bird watching. Next.
- 39:09And maybe you might try golf. So a few years
- 39:15ago, I started playing golf. I had never touched
- 39:21a golf club in my life, but my husband started
- 39:24getting into golf and invited me to come along.
- 39:28I will be honest, I was not interested at all.
- 39:32But he convinced me by telling me it was a nice
- 39:36scenery, it was nice to get outside. He also
- 39:41said I would be able to drive the golf cart and
- 39:45have my snacks and drinks with me. So I said,
- 39:48all right, after he asked several times, I figured,
- 39:53why don't we give it a try? So it turns out that
- 39:57I really enjoyed it. Being out in the fresh air,
- 40:02seeing the trees, the geese, the ponds, it really
- 40:07helped me relaxed. And for a moment, I was truly
- 40:12disconnected from work. I don't know if any of
- 40:16you have played golf, but it's really hard to
- 40:20try to concentrate on hitting that ball and thinking
- 40:25about something else. especially when you're
- 40:28starting out. I definitely missed that ball several
- 40:31times. But one thing that golf is also great
- 40:35at is teaching you positive self -talk. So you
- 40:42may have gone on to the first hole and done a
- 40:46terrible shot, right? And you just can't seem
- 40:51to get that ball on the green, but you know,
- 40:56you have to tell yourself that's okay, you know,
- 41:00this shot is a new shot. And the same thing when
- 41:03you move on to the next hole, right? The first
- 41:06hole was a bad hole. That's fine, leave it in
- 41:08the past. You move on to the second hole, you
- 41:11put your best foot forward. And I think that
- 41:17that positive talk is really important, especially
- 41:20for us as lawyers when we're feeling overwhelmed
- 41:24and we're experiencing that. compassion fatigue,
- 41:31the way that we talk to ourselves is really important
- 41:34because we really do internalize those feelings.
- 41:38Even if we don't mean them, our brain is processing
- 41:42that. So it's really important to practice positive
- 41:47self -talk. So a few other strategies that you
- 42:02can also implement in order to mitigate that
- 42:09vicarious trauma is by practicing grounding techniques.
- 42:15So grounding techniques are simple practices
- 42:18that help shift your focus away from intense
- 42:23anxiety, panic. or overwhelming emotions and
- 42:28back to the present moment. So there is a particularly
- 42:33grabbing technique that's pretty popular and
- 42:37it's called five four three two one and what
- 42:45you do in that technique is that first you think
- 42:50of five things that you can see four things that
- 42:55you can touch, three things that you can hear,
- 43:00two things that you can smell, and one thing
- 43:03that you can taste. So for purposes of our webinar
- 43:09here today, I want us to go through that technique.
- 43:14You will think about those five things to yourself
- 43:17and I will. think of those five things for myself
- 43:22as well, but I just want you to practice that
- 43:26technique. So first, let's think of five things
- 43:31that you can see. All right, so now think about
- 43:48four things that you can touch. Now think about
- 44:01three things you can hear. Two things that you
- 44:11can smell. And one thing that you can taste.
- 44:23So what this does is that in the last few seconds
- 44:29that we were thinking about these things, your
- 44:33brain was disengaging from any other thoughts
- 44:36that you may have had. So when you're at work
- 44:40and you're feeling overwhelmed or anxious about
- 44:44something that you're doing, try this technique.
- 44:49quick, but it also helps your brain to just relax
- 44:54and bring yourself back to the present moment.
- 45:00And another technique that you can try is mindfulness.
- 45:06So mindfulness is the simple practice of being
- 45:10fully aware of the present moment without judging
- 45:14your thoughts or your feelings. So this helps
- 45:19lower stress, improve focus, and calm your mind.
- 45:24A lot of the focus is on your breath. And you're
- 45:28doing a body scan to pay attention to how each
- 45:32part of your body feels from your head to your
- 45:35toes. So when you're practicing mindfulness,
- 45:40you're first focusing on your breathing. And
- 45:44the important part of this is what it means by
- 45:49without judgment or other feelings is that if
- 45:55you're trying to focus on your breathing and
- 45:57you suddenly find yourself thinking about work,
- 46:01about the kids, about your partner, about a host
- 46:05of other problems that you may have going on,
- 46:11don't talk negatively to yourself, right? Don't
- 46:16say, oh geez, I couldn't even keep it together
- 46:20for one minute. That's the whole part of the
- 46:24mindfulness part. Do not have negative talk.
- 46:27If you lost your thought and your thought went
- 46:30somewhere else other than your breath, it's okay.
- 46:32Just bring it back and continue to breathe and
- 46:37exhale and continue to scan your body from your
- 46:41head to your toes. The first few times that you
- 46:44do it, it's going to be hard and it's going to
- 46:47be distracting, but as you practice it, you will
- 46:52get better at it. Regular exercise is also helpful.
- 47:00And while it would be great, if you can get an
- 47:04hour of exercise a day or every other day, we
- 47:08know that as lawyers sometimes that's not possible,
- 47:12especially if you're in trial or have back -to
- 47:15-back depositions. But you can still incorporate
- 47:20some exercise into your daily routine. So it
- 47:25can be as simple as getting up from your desk
- 47:28to take a quick 10 to 15 minute walk. I know
- 47:33that oftentimes we may be working on a brief,
- 47:37on trial documents, or preparing for depositions,
- 47:41and we feel like we are in the zone. We don't
- 47:45want to get up because we just feel like our
- 47:48thoughts are firing up and we are typing away.
- 47:52However, if you've been there for a few hours,
- 47:55you really should try to get up and just do a
- 48:00quick 10 minute walk. It's just 10 minutes and
- 48:03you will definitely feel more refreshed when
- 48:06you return to your desk. Meditation is also a
- 48:13really good strategy. tried meditating before,
- 48:19there are plenty of self -guided meditation videos
- 48:23on YouTube that you can access. And I would suggest,
- 48:28if you're trying it out for the first time, just
- 48:32do a short video just so that you can get a feel
- 48:36for it. And then once you develop a practice,
- 48:40you can increase the amount of time that you
- 48:43are meditating for. Vacations. So taking regular
- 48:49vacations is really important. You know, as lawyers,
- 48:55we sometimes use it as a badge of honor that
- 48:58we have. hundreds of hours of PTO because we
- 49:03work so hard and we're not taking any time off.
- 49:07But we really do need to take some time off to
- 49:10avoid that burnout and that compassion fatigue.
- 49:15And it doesn't have to be, you know, an elaborate
- 49:20plan. It can even be something as simple as a
- 49:24staycation, right? Maybe you just take a Thursday
- 49:27and Friday off and you have, you know. those
- 49:31four days to stay within your city, but explore
- 49:35areas or locations you haven't gone to. There
- 49:39might be museums, there might be music festivals,
- 49:44going to the beach, all of those things can be
- 49:48very relaxing. taken a part in doing a staycation
- 49:58before moving to LA. I lived in the Bay Area
- 50:04and I worked in San Francisco, but I didn't live
- 50:08in San Francisco. So I commuted to San Francisco
- 50:11every day for about an hour and 30 minutes. And
- 50:15so while I was in San Francisco every day, I
- 50:20never really took the time to explore San Francisco
- 50:24because I was just in a hurry to get to the park
- 50:27station and try to get home. You know, one of
- 50:32those weekends, me and my husband said, let's
- 50:34just make it a four day weekend and pretend we're
- 50:37tourists. And we did. We took the ferry. We visited
- 50:41Alcatraz. We went to the pier. And for years,
- 50:46I've been going in and out of San Francisco and
- 50:48I hadn't done several of the things that we did
- 50:51that day. So I think, you know, staycations are
- 50:56things that are simple to do and it will definitely
- 51:00give your brain a little bit of a mental break.
- 51:08Next. So healthy sleep hygiene. I know that we
- 51:14all know this, but how many of you are actually
- 51:19getting enough sleep? Probably not many, myself
- 51:24included. I'm guilty of this too. According to
- 51:28the Academy of Sleep Medicine, adults should
- 51:31try to get seven or more hours of sleep. And
- 51:35we all know that sleep is important for cognitive
- 51:38functioning, our mood, mental health, and for
- 51:43our heart health. And so, Try to do your best
- 51:48to get rest. One of the things that is recommended
- 51:53is having a dedicated space for sleep. depending
- 51:59on your living situation, and especially after
- 52:03COVID with a lot of people working remote, people
- 52:07tended to have their desks in their bedroom.
- 52:11And so this can be disruptive for your sleep,
- 52:15even though you may not realize it. So to the
- 52:19extent that you're able to avoid this and separate
- 52:23your sleeping space from your workspace, that's
- 52:27a more ideal situation. And when you go to sleep,
- 52:33try to place your phone on do not disturb, silence
- 52:39the notifications. And that will help with the
- 52:44quality of sleep that you get. For a long time,
- 52:49I actually didn't silence my email notifications
- 52:52on my phone. And it was just a constant pinging
- 52:56throughout the night for every email that would
- 52:58come in. And at one point I said, I really don't
- 53:03need to be hearing this constant pinging. And
- 53:07so I finally placed it on silent and that small
- 53:10change made a world of a difference. One of the
- 53:14things that is recommended is to Try to keep
- 53:19your phone away from you when you sleep, possibly
- 53:23across the room instead of right next to you
- 53:27on your nightstand. I'm still guilty of this.
- 53:31I have not gotten to the point where I can just
- 53:34leave my phone across the room. I do still keep
- 53:38it on my nightstand. having those notifications
- 53:44on silent definitely helps. And one of the things
- 53:50that I would tend to do is that sometimes in
- 53:54the middle of the night, I would wake up with
- 53:57thoughts about a case or an argument that I wanted
- 54:01to add to a brief. And so what I would do is
- 54:04that I would open my phone and type in quick
- 54:07notes for myself. But then that would lead me
- 54:11to my calendar or sometimes to my email. So I
- 54:15would become completely awake and then just have
- 54:19trouble falling back asleep. But I then started
- 54:24implementing a technique that I got from a colleague,
- 54:28which is just place a notepad in a pad next to
- 54:32your nightstand. That way, if you know you have
- 54:35an urging thought that you just have to write
- 54:38down and just wake up, scribble it on the notepad
- 54:42and put it right back and go back to sleep. And
- 54:46then you avoid the danger of potentially scrolling
- 54:49over to your email or to your calendar. And then
- 54:53it's two in the morning and you're just not getting
- 54:56the sleep that you need. So taking care of yourself
- 55:19is really important. We deal with a lot of individuals
- 55:26that have been traumatized due to different circumstances
- 55:32in life. And it's important to get good sleep,
- 55:39try to eat healthy. get some exercise. I know
- 55:43it's a lot of things that many of us know that
- 55:46we should do, but we don't. So I think, you know,
- 55:52hopefully you can take some of these strategies
- 55:56that I shared with you so that you can implement
- 56:03them when you're having anxiety, you're feeling
- 56:08overwhelmed, you're feeling compassion fatigue,
- 56:14or you're feeling like you're running out of
- 56:16empathy, hopefully a few of those things will
- 56:19help you. It's also really important for your
- 56:23personal life, right? So outside of... Although
- 56:27being an attorney is a big part of our life,
- 56:32we are also people outside of being attorneys.
- 56:35We're sisters, we're brothers, nieces. We have
- 56:42a life outside of that. And also, how we're feeling
- 56:46at work, we bring that home with us. So our spouses,
- 56:52our family, They see what's going on with us,
- 56:57and they see whether we are actually present
- 57:00when we're at the dinner table with them, when
- 57:04we're engaging in activities. So in reality,
- 57:10taking care of yourself is not just so that you
- 57:12can be a competent attorney and continue to represent
- 57:17your clients cellously, but also so that you
- 57:21can have a good, healthy, know, rich personal
- 57:26life. So if you take anything from today is that
- 57:34we all need to take care of ourselves and try
- 57:38to implement even if it's just the smallest.
- 57:42strategy of many that I listed here today. So
- 57:47that hopefully you can mitigate any vicarious
- 57:50trauma symptoms, avoid ending up with compassion
- 57:54fatigue. And again, you know, if you are finding
- 57:59yourself that you are feeling depressed or in
- 58:04a situation where it's hard to pull yourself
- 58:06out, you should seek therapy, right? And an ideal
- 58:12world we should all have a therapist because
- 58:14we all deal with a lot of trauma that we absorb
- 58:19and need to learn how to let go. So thank you
- 58:25all today for attending and here is my email
- 58:30in case you have questions about any other resources
- 58:35I did provide in my materials. article that I
- 58:40wrote for the advocate. I also did write one
- 58:44for the Daily Journal, but also, as I mentioned,
- 58:48that my curious trauma assessment, as well as
- 58:51other articles that elaborate on some of the
- 58:55topics that I discussed with you all here today.
- 59:01This concludes today's presentation. Thank you
- 59:03so much, Christina, for taking the time to educate
- 59:05our audience, and thank you so much to everyone
- 59:08joining us today. Have a great day everybody.