Latest / Ego and Other Things / Knowledge Without Proof (Attempt 2)
Transcript
- William: So I want take another shot at that question I did the other day. What can you know that something is true without being able to explain it or explain why? And I want to take another shot because I think the first time I kind of just missed maybe the actual purpose of that question. I got into this conversation around justified true belief and what counts as knowledge and I got into public and private knowledge, and I'm not really sure that's where that wasn't the spirit of the question. I think the more I reflected on it, the more I I came to realize that what seems to be the spirit of the question is something like does instinct count as knowledge, right? you know, somebody who has a lifetime of experience doing something. But like technically I guess you could say, but not maybe a lot of I don't know, explicit knowledge about what's going on. Does that kind d do they have a kind of knowledge? Like I almost wanna think of you know, farmers. Farmers before the invention of agricultural science, before really before science itself, didn't they have a kind of knowledge even though it wasn't scientific? and I think this gets us into the whole question of functional knowledge, which is actually the kind of knowledge that we live off of and on a day-to-day experience, because w or to to one degree or another, because we don't have total knowledge of the world. We don't have every explicit detail, every explicit causal mechanism that goes into everything that we're doing. We have to rely kinda on these shorthands, on pattern recognition, on I guess individual moments of experience or testimony or anecdote, right? Or tradition. And the thing about maybe tradition, so maybe maybe you're a farmer and you've got a traditional way of going about growing your crops, maybe tied to some religious tradition, what you do is you don't farm the same field every day but you you give up the farm. you give up farming one year out of five in order to please God. Right. and you you do this just out of tradition. You do that you do this just because this is what your father did and his grandfather did and and on and on. You don't do it because you you understand that allowing the field to rest helps to to keep the the crops going or helps the soil recover so that you can continue to get a similar yield over time. You just do this out of tradition, you just do this out of out of piety, so to speak. In fact, I think this is a rule that is within the Old Testament that was given to the Jews. And there's other kinds of rules in there, like don't eat pork. And today, from the scientific perspective, we can kind of look at those rules and say, well, you know, these rules seem to serve a kind of a purpose that helped these people to stay alive, right? Either help them with the crop rotation, help them not get disease, whatever. You have another example would be like maybe you have a doctor who has been practicing surgery their whole life and they've studied and studied and they're in a surgery and something goes wrong. And in that moment, they have this split-second intuition of what the problem is. And it's not like they know it for sure, they know it explicitly, it's just this instinct that has grown out of being a doctor. And they find they find the problem that insolvent or a baseball player who makes the right move because they've played years and years and they just sort of know on an intuitive level or a functional level, how what needs to be done. many of us I mean, I'm driving a car right now, I have no idea how the car actually works, mechanically or from a physics level. I mean, this car has broken down before and I don't know. I haven't known how to fix it. I know how to drive it, right? I know about the car what I need to know about the car in order for it to work. It's kind of the same relationship that we have with ourselves. I know what I need to know about myself in order to act for the sake of what I value. And so there's all kinds of knowledge that can't be rationally explained, and to that extent, it's just kind of pragmatic knowledge. It is functional knowledge. It is a question of to what degree is this useful to me to know further. Now, we used to be limited in our ability to gain explicit knowledge of the world before the development of the scientific method, before more rigorous logic. And so we had to rely on that kind of on these different forms of knowledge, this traditional knowledge or intuitive knowledge, mostly because we didn't have another option, right? That that was what was available to us until we developed these these further kinds of explicit forms of knowledge. And so if you ask me, you know, is it possible to know something without being able to explain why, you'd have to say absolutely, because for thousands of years people were able to operate on a non-explicit version of knowledge and were able to at least survive, at least able to to get along in the world to accumulate not enough resources so that somebody could develop more explicit forms of knowledge. You might say, you know, there's different layers, right? There's different layers to knowledge. There's there and there's and different layers reveal different aspects of the thing that you're you're encountering, That help you to understand it on a deeper level and therefore help you to control and manipulate it on a diff on a different level. Again, the car is another example here. You know, I know it on a very pragmatic functional level. I know that I press the gas pedal, car goes forward, I turn the wheel, car turns. You know, I know how to drive the car, but I don't know how the car works. I don't know what the physics are involved in making an engine. I know nothing about the combustion. I I know nothing about that. And In fact, I don't need to know anything about that until the car breaks down and I can't find anybody else who fix it. Then I have to try and use my reason, use my deductive skills, use my inductive reasoning to kind of figure out, okay, how do I fix the car? So the actual the genuine driver in human life towards more deeper explicit forms of knowledge. Is the fact that something is broken or doesn't work or is causing us pain and suffering. And at again in history there was a limit to that until we developed more explicit forms of knowledge. In fact, the the development of more explicit forms of knowledge like s like science and logic came about because people were were coming up up against that limit to solve their problems, and they said, We need new tools, we need new thinking tools to solve these kinds of problems that. Or figure out. I mean this is another example of how meaning precedes knowledge, purpose precedes knowledge, who you are precedes knowledge, what you value precedes knowledge, and how all of that, the values and the purpose and the meaning, actually determines and defines How you seek after knowledge and what knowledge you seek. The the fact that we don't seek knowledge indiscriminately, but we seek knowledge based on what we value and what we want out of things. And in that way we we seek knowledge at multiple different kinds of levels. I don't need to understand how the car works because if the car breaks down, I can get it brought somewhere else, and somebody who does know how to fix it will fix it, right? Now, philosophical knowledge is generally explicit knowledge. It's again molded like any other kind of knowledge by by values. So in my own philosophical method, I don't try to investigate, you know, any kind of of topic related to to to f that philosophy could investigate. I investigate based on what my interests are and I sort of I I start with the center of interest and I expand out as deep as I I sort of deem necessary. And that is necessarily a a value-laden process, a pragmatically laden process that sort of contours or contains the entire investigation. But within that, the knowledge that I'm I'm aiming for here is explicit knowledge, or at least conceptually explicit knowledge, as far as is useful. And it's a perfectly valid form of knowledge, and instinctual knowledge is valid insofar as it works, and functional knowledge is is valid insofar as it as it actually functions. And so there really is a a layer of pragmatic evaluation to knowledge. But both pragmatic and explicit knowledge both relate to the truth, right? Explicit knowledge is just the detailed truth. The pragmatic knowledge is this knowled is just it's true enough to work, right? And so they're both related to truth. They're both related to what is the case, meaning what is the case of what will actually work here and achieve such value, and it's just what is the case about given object or given phenomena and its details as far as we can explore it. So these are both valid forms of of truth related to that that central idea of what is the case. So yeah, I just wanted to give this a second shot because I feel like I kind of missed the point perhaps of the first question, and I just wanted to give it another go. So we're gonna end it here.